8/17/2019 Lembar Daftar Tilik Critical Apraisal - Copy
1/2
CRITICAL APRAISAL WORKSHEETNo 1 2 3
Can You Find This in thepape
Is the !a" this !as done apo#$e%
&oes the po#$e%theaten the 'a$idit"o( thestud"
1 What is the esea)h*uestion and+ oh"pothesis
It is )on)ened !ith thei%pa)t on an inte'ention,)ausa$it", o
dete%inin-the %a-nitude o( a hea$thpo#$e%.
2 What is the studi t"pe. Is the stud" t"peappopiate to the
esea)h*uestion.
I( not, ho! use(u$ ae theesu$t podu)ed #" thistipe o( the
stud".
3 What is the e(een)epopu$ation. What aethe sa%p$in- (a%e
andsa%p$in- %ethode.
Is the sa%p$in- (a%eappopiate (o thee(een)e popu$ation.Is thee
se$e)tion #ias
&oes these theaten thee/tena$ 'a$idit" o( thestud"
0 Is an e/pei%enta$stud", hoe !ee su#e)tsassi-ned to -oups,. In
a$on-itudina$ stud" ho!%an" ea)hed na$(o$$o! up.
Has #ias #een intodu)ed. &oes these theaten theintena$
'a$idit" o( thestud"
What ae the stud"(a)tos and ho! ae the"%easued
Is thee %easue%ent eo Is %easue%ent eo ani%potant sou)e o(
#ias.
4 What ae the out)o%e(a)tos and ho! ae the"
%easued
15 Ae a$$ e$e'antout)o%es assessed
25 Is thee %easue%enteo.
16 ho! i%potant aeo%%ited out)o%es.
26 Is %easue%ent eoan i%potant sou)e o(#ias
7 What i%potantpotentia$ )oun(oundesae )onsideed.
Ae i%potant )on(ounde)onto$$ed
Is )on(oundin- ani%potant sou)e o( #ias
8 Ae statisti)a$ test)onsideed
Wee the tests appopiate(o the data. Ae)onden)e inte'a$ -i'en.Is
the po!e -i'en.
9 Ae the esu$t )$ini)a$$"+so)ia$$" i%potant
Was the sa%p$e si:esu;)ient to dete)t a
)$ini)a$$"+so)ia$$" si-ni)antesu$t.
Is the stud" use(u$ o isthe esu$t in)on)$usi'e
1< Wh" )on)$usions did theauthos ea)h a#out theesea)h
*uestion. &idthe" -eneate ne!h"potheses. &o "oua-ee !ith
the)on)$usion
&o the esu$t app$" to thepopu$ation in !hi)h "ou!ou$d #e
inteested.
&o "ou a))ept the esu$to( this stud".
Note =Out)o%e o#at > e?asi, sa(et", a))epta#i$it",
)o%p$ian)e6@a-ai%ana apa #isa diap$i?asi?an .. #ias #o$eh tapi
%ini%a$ tetapi tida? #o$eh ada
)on(oundeen-hi$an-?an pen--an--u den-an pen-a%#i$an sa%pe$55
%isa$ den-an stati?asi dan
