35
Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor (IAA)

Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

Khirbet QeiyafaAn Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah

Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor (IAA)

Page 2: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

V. Guerin: 1869C.R. Conder & H.H. Kitchener: 1883

Y. Dagan: 1992Z. Greenhut: 2001

Yosef Garfinkel & Saar Ganor 2007-2008

History of Research

Thanks

J.B. SilverBerman Center for Biblical Archaeology

Foundation StoneCurtis and Mary Brenan Foundation

Page 3: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

Azekah

Socoh

Qeiyafa

Page 4: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

View from Qeiyafa to the Elah valley

Page 5: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor
Page 6: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

The city wall

Page 7: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

Area: 2.3 hectares

City wall:700 m long

Site map

Page 8: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

Area B

Page 9: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

Schematic plan of Area B (Iron Age)

12

3

45

Page 10: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

Casemate city wall

200,000 tons of stones

Page 11: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

A fourchamber

gate

Page 12: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor
Page 13: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

Two buildings (dwellings?)

Page 14: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

Stone MassebahUpside down in wall

Page 15: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

Steps leading into Building 2

Page 16: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor
Page 17: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

Ostracon

Page 18: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

1. The longest Proto-CanaaniteInscription ever found

2. The earliest Hebrew inscriptionKnown to date

3. A letter

Page 19: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

The pottery

A complete absence of late Philistine bichromepottery, that is known at Qasile X (see plate) or Miqne IV.

When the citywas built?

Page 20: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

The characteristic

pottery of Khirbet Qeiyafa:

Early AshdodWare

Page 21: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

Complete absence of Late Philistine Decorated Ware (Tell Safi)

Page 22: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

4 samples&

4 samples

Collecting olive pitsfor C14dating

Page 23: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

C14: Four Calibrated Olive pits (Oxford)

* Please note 2 standard deviations: lower as 969 BC at 77.8%

Page 24: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

Low chronology is now officially dead and buriedLow chronology is now officially

dead and buried

Page 25: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

The methodological problems of the “Low Chronology”

Samples taken from Northern sites. No Samples from Judah.

Samples from Late Iron I, and from later phases of the Iron IIa. No samples from early Iron IIa. No samples from Megiddo Vb.

2. Stratigraphy 1. Geography

Page 26: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

Implications for understanding the 10th century BC

1. Chronology: Iron IIa started at ca. 1000 BC

2. Settlement pattern: fortified city

3. Political organization: centralized

4. Biblical narrative: “Between Socoh and Azekah”

5. Paleography: spread of alphabetic writing; literacy in Judah in early 10th century BC.

Page 27: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

Historical Identification ?

Adataim? (Y. Dagan)

Azekah? (S. Ganor)

Sha'arayim? (D. Adams, A. Rainey)

Efes Damim? (Todd Bolen)

Gov? (N. Naaman)

And the answer is ……. ????

Page 28: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

Area C

Area C

Two working days In November 6th

& November 7th

Page 29: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

A second gate in Area C, facing Jerusalem

Page 30: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor
Page 31: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor
Page 32: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

Khirbet Qeiyafa: the only known city in Judah or Israel with two gates

Page 33: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

An Iron Age City with two gates??

שערים

1. In the city list of Judah's tribal inheritance Sha'arayimappears after Socoh and Azekah (Jos 15, 36).

2. After David killed Goliath the Philistines run awaythrough the “way to Sha'arayim " (1 Sam 17:52).

3. In the city list of the tribe of Simeon, Sha'arayim is mentioned as one of the cities “unto the reign of David" (1 Chr 4:31)*.

*A scribal error: Sha'arayim (1 Chr 4:31) = Shilhim (Jos 15:32) = Sharuhen (Jos 19:6)

Sha'arayim

Page 34: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

A. General Arguments:1. Geographical location in Judah2. Sha'arayim: mentioned in Judah's city list 3. Fortified field cities are known only in Judah4. Casemate city walls are known only in Judah5. Main entrance facing Jerusalem

B. Material Culture:6. No pig bones7. Aren Maier: Gath pottery is different8. Petrographic analysis: local Elah valley pottery9. Hebrew inscription

Why the city is Judean

Page 35: Khirbet Qeiyafaqeiyafa.huji.ac.il/qdb/ASOR_2parts.pdf · 2008-12-07 · Khirbet Qeiyafa An Early Iron IIa Fortified City in Judah Yosef Garfinkel (Hebrew University) & Saar Ganor

Thank You