Upload
others
View
5
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
JUVENILEJUSTICE
COUNCIL
HOWMIGHTWEIMPROVETHEEXPERIENCESANDOUTCOMESOFYOUNGPEOPLEINJUVENILECOURT?
JuvenileJusticeCouncil SUMMER!"#$
1|J J C R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s
Table of contexts
• Cover Page….. • Table of Contents….. 1 • Authors…… 2 • Executive Summary….. 3 & 4 • Preparation….. 5
o Recommendation One….. 5 o Recommendation Two….. 6 o Recommendation Three….. 7
• Language….. 8 o Recommendation Four….. 8 o Recommendation Five….. 9 o Recommendation Six….. 10
• Diversion….. 11 o Recommendation Seven….. 11 o Recommendation Eight….. 12 o Recommendation Nine….. 13 o Recommendation Ten…..14
JuvenileJusticeCouncil SUMMER!"#$
2|J J C R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s
Authors
BeaEusebio
KeondreJones
NatalieGastevich
XitlaliAvila
CarolinaLobodeCastro
GiltonioFlowers
MarkelEllis
MarthaZuniga
MuzamilChaudhry
TierraRichardson
CapriseWilliiams
DarcyPalder
EnriqueCarapia
StephonDemus
EstefaniaVillasenor
AdrianMunoz
DennisNeely
RobertHolloway
VickyYamilarRomero
IrisGonzalez
MikaylaJones
HardieFleming
YulissaMarTnez
MiracleBurrows
DiamondDavenport
ArrialDavis
BrianaJackson
JuvenileJusticeCouncil SUMMER!"#$
3|J J C R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s
ExecutiveSummaryTheMikvaChallengeJuvenileJusticeCouncil(JJC)isagroupofCookCountyyouthadvocateswho
worktoimprovethejuvenilejusticesystem.Thissummerwefocusedoureffortsonthecourtprocessandhavecreatedaseriesofrecommendationsthatanswerthefollowingquestion:
Howmightweimprovetheexperiencesandoutcomesofyoungpeopleinjuvenilecourt?
WefocusedlargelyontheconceptofProceduralJustice,whichpromotestheideathatifthecourtprocessisfairandunderstoodbytheyouth,theiropinionofandcompliancewiththeiroutcomewillimprove.Wehopetheserecommendationswillassistyouthinnavigatingtheircourtprocessandprovidethemwithabetterexperienceinordertoimprovetheiroutcome.
Weeducatedourselvesonmultipleaspectsofthecourtprocessincluding(a)preparation,(b)understandingthecourtlanguage,and(c)thediversionprogramsavailable.Conductingourresearchwithvideos,pamphlets,documentsandguestspeakerswewereabletoformaholisticperspectiveoftheyouth’sjourneythroughthecourtandinturnwereabletocraftrecommendationsthatareinformedandrelevantforthecurrentCookCountyjuvenilejusticesystem.
Eachoftherecommendationsaddressesadifferentaspectoftheyouth’sjourneythroughthecourtprocess.Theyaimtoprovidenotonlyshorttermsolutionstotheproblem,buttoaidtheindividualinthelongtermaswell.Ourfinalproductsincludetenrecommendations,achecklistforcourtpersonnel,anda3Ddesignofjuvenilecourtroomandwaitingroom.Thefollowingaresummariesofwhatwillappearlaterinthereport:
Fromasurveywecreated,whichreceivedover450responsesfromyouthalloverthecity,wediscoveredthatmorethan80%ofsurveyorshad“littletonoidea”aboutthejuvenilecourtprocess.Aftermuchexplorationandanalysisofalternatesolutions,wecreatedarecommendationthatsuggeststhecreationofawebsiteandappthatwillexplainthejuvenilecourtprocessstepbystep,coveringthemomentofarresttothefinaldispositionhearing.AccordingtoasurveybytheUSNationalLibraryofMedicine82.9%ofyouthwereeither“somewhatlikely”or“verylikely”touseaninformation-basedwebsite“iftheyweregoingthroughadifficulttime”suchascourt.Basedonthisinformationandsimilarstudies,wehopethatinformationonthewebwillreachagreateramountofyouththananypamphletwilldo.Intermsoftheamountofyouththatwillabsorbtheinformationofthewebsite,wehavereasonedthatbecauseasiteismoreinteractivethananypamphletorflyer,itwillthereforebecomemoreengagingfortheeveractiveyouth.
SeeingastheJuvenileJusticeSystemonlyappliestothoseundertheageof18andunlikelytoownavehicle,wealsolookedintoyouthtransportationmethodstocourt.AccordingtoasurveybyMikvaChallenge’sMayoralYouthCommissionin2015,44%ofrespondentssaidthemainreasontheymissed
JuvenileJusticeCouncil SUMMER!"#$
4|J J C R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s
schoolwasbecausethey“can’taffordtransportation”.Ourcounciltookthistomeanthatmostyouthdonothavethefinancialabilitytogettocourteither.Basedonthesurveyreport,werecommendedafreeride-sharingforallyouthwithacourtdate.Inthiswayyouthabsenceandresultingcourtcancellationswouldbecomelessfrequent.Inturntheefficiencyofthejuvenilejusticesystemwouldincrease.
Asaculminatingproject,ourcouncilworkedwithLatentDesigntocreateayouthdesignedcourtroom.AccordingtoasurveybyModelsforChangemostyouthareonlyabletorecallathirdofwhattheyweresentencedtoaftertheirhearing,duelargelytotheconfusingdialectusedincourt.Basedonthesamereport,thetemplateforwhichmostjudgesspeaktoyouthiswrittenata12.9gradelevelwhiletheaveragereadinglevelforbothadultsandyouthisbetween7thand8thgrade(Readability).Inordertobetterprepareyouthforthecourtroomlanguage,thedifferentrolesoftheadultsandthepossibleoutcomes,werecommendedthecreationofapreparationroomconnectedtothecourtwaitingroom.Thepurposeofthisseparateroomwouldbetoprovideinteractivewaystoteachyouthaboutthecourtroom,including:videos,informationalpamphlets,comicsfocusedoncourtandvocabdefiningposters.Expandingontherecommendation,inordertomakesureallquestionsareanswered,acosteffectivelawinternshouldbestationedintheroom.Wealsoworkedtoredesignthecourtroomitself,utilizingtheconceptofhumancentereddesign,inordertocreateaspatiallayoutthatwouldbenefittheyouth.Thesesuggestionsrangedfromalteringthelanguageusedincourttoreflectyouthdialecttoaddingmorecolorinordertomaketheroommoreyouthfriendly.Thefollowingrecommendationssuggestthatspaceandarchitecturaldesigncanandshouldbeusedasatooltoaidtheyouthduringtheircourtprocess.
Throughanextensivesixweeksofresearch,wehavecompiledtheserecommendationstoimprovethecurrentCookCountyjuvenilejusticesystem.Wehaveconsideredboththeindividualandthethousandsthattravelthroughthejuvenilejusticesystem.Itmustbenotedonemoretimethatweareagroupofyouthandthereforeprovideauniqueperspectivethatwillseldombefoundanywhereelse.Weinviteyoutoreadandstronglyconsiderwhatwehavetosay,webelieveitwillbetterthelivesofyouthinthesystem.
Sources:
Peralta,Rose,andGeorgeYeannakis."InnovationBrief:JudicialColloquies:CommunicatingwithKidsinCourt."—ModelsforChange:SystemsReforminJuvenileJustice.ModelsforChange,12Dec.2013.Web.7Aug.2015.
JuvenileJusticeCouncil SUMMER!"#$
5|J J C R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s
"Readability-ClearLanguageGroup."ClearLanguageGroup.Readability.Web.10Aug.2015.
Sources:
Cardenas,Edward."UberOffersRidesForSpringCleaningDonations."CBSDetroit.CBSDetroit,30Apr.2015.Web.10Aug.2015.<http://detroit.cbslocal.com/2015/04/30/uber-offers-rides-for-spring-cleaning-donations/>.
Goudie,Chuck."I-Team:ViolenceonCTAWidespread."ABC7Chicago.ABC7Chicago,20Feb.2013.Web.10Aug.2015.
Recommenda0on1
Youthshouldreceiveafreerideshare(Uber/Taxi/Lyft)toandfromcourt,toensurethattheyouthwon’tbelateormisstheircourtdatebecausetheydonothavetransportation.Courtpersonnelprovideyouthwithbuscards,butyouthmaybetemptedtousethebusfareforotherthingsthatcomeupduringthetimeofwaitingforcourt,thereforeprovidingarideshareforyouthwillbemoreuseful.
Research***MostYouthdonothavethejinancestotraveltocourt***AccordingtoasurveybyMikvaChallenge’sMayoralYouthCommissionTransportationIncentivesProgram,44%ofrespondentsanswered“Can’taffordtransportation”asthereasontheydon’tgotoschool.***ThepopularrideshareprogramUberisknowntodonatetheirservices,inspring2015,aspartofaGoodwillpromotion,theyofferedfreeridestothosewillingtodonatebetween10am-3pmSaturday
HowwillthishelpCourtattendancebyyouthhasalwaysbeenscattered,duelargelytotheirinabilitytogettocourtbecauseoftheirjinancialsituation.Youth’sattendancehasalsobeenknowntonegativelyaffectthecourtscheduleanddecreasetheefjiciencyofthecourt.Thisrecommendationisaimedtoprovideyouthwithasafe,easyridetocourtinhopesthatitwillimprovetheyouth’scourtexperienceandthecourt’sefjiciency.
JuvenileJusticeCouncil SUMMER!"#$
6|J J C R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s
Recommenda0on2
Youthshouldbeprovidedwithinformationalpamphlets,courtvocabularydeFiningposters,interactivevideos,andcourtspecialistsbeforetheyenterthecourtroom.Thesesupplementalmaterialscouldbeprovidedinaroomthatyouthtravelthroughbeforetheyenterthecourtroom.
Research***MostYouthareconfusedbythechallenginglanguageusedincourt***AccordingtoasurveybyModelsforChangemostyouthareonlyabletorecallathirdofwhattheyweresentencedtoaftertheirhearing,duelargelytotheconfusingdialectusedincourt.***Itwouldbestronglyadvisedthatpublicdefenders,prosecutorsandjudgeswentthroughtheroomandtoadjustthelanguagetheyuseincourttorejlectthepreparationrooms.
Howwillthishelp
Asmostyouth’stimeincourtcausestheirexperiencetoworsen,duetotheirconfusionofproceedings,thepreparationroomwouldactasaplacewhereyouthandtheirfamilycanreceiveatutorialofcourtproceedings.
Sources:
Peralta,Rose,andGeorgeYeannakis."InnovationBrief:JudicialColloquies:CommunicatingwithKidsinCourt."—ModelsforChange:SystemsReforminJuvenileJustice.ModelsforChange,12Dec.2013.Web.7Aug.2015.
JuvenileJusticeCouncil SUMMER!"#$
7|J J C R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s
Recommenda0on3
Inordertohelpyouthbetterprepareforthecourtprocess,thepublicdefender’sofFiceshouldvisittheyouth’sschooland/orhome.
Research***Youthwhohavenotbeenthroughthecourtprocessalready,feltthatayouthshouldtalktotheirlawyerorpublicdefender2to3timesbeforetheircase.***ThcouldbelinkedtothehighcaseloadsexperiencedbyCookCountypublicdefenders.TheNationalAdvisoryCommissiononCriminalJusticeStandardsandGoalssetthecaseloadlimitforafulltimepublicdefenderat200juvenilesayear,butthecaseloadofaCookCountypublicdefenderis160%morethanthenationalstandard(that’s320juvenilesayear).
HowwillthishelpThisrecommendationwillhelpyouthbecomemoreeducatedonthecourtprocessandtheoccurrencesthathappenthroughout.Itwillalsoincreasetheamountoftimepublicdefendersspendfamiliarizingthemselvestotheyouth’scaseandtheoptionsthatareintheyouth’sbestinterest.Itissuggestedthatbydecreasingthecaseloadofpublicdefenderstheywillhavemoretimetounderstandtheyouth’scaseinordertomakethecourtprocesslessstressful.
Sources:“TooManyClients,TooLittleTime:HowStatesAreForcingPublicDefenderstoViolateTheirEthical
Obligations."FederalSentencingReporter:91-102.JuvenileJusticeCouncil2015Survey
JuvenileJusticeCouncil SUMMER!"#$
8|J J C R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s
Sources:
“WhyBostonStudentsCreatedA'KnowYourRights'App."Learninglab.N.p.,16June2015.Web.10Aug.2015.
"UnderstandtheProblem.",WrongfulConvictionsofYouth:BluhmLegalClinic,NorthwesternUniversitySchoolofLaw.Web.10Aug.2015.<http://www.law.northwestern.edu/legalclinic/wrongfulconvictionsyouth/understandproblem/>.
"CaseStudy:DevelopingJudicialColloquies."(n.d.):9.Print.
http://learninglab.wbur.org/2015/06/16/why-boston-students-created-a-know-your-rights-app/
Recommenda0on4
CreateawebappthatexplainsthecourtprocessstepbystepandalsodeFinessentencingtermsinmultiplelanguages.Thewebappwillsimplifyterms,breakthemintocrimecategoriesandaddressthepossibleoutcomes.Someexampletabswouldbe,“Knowyourrights,”“Court,”and“Arrest.
Research***AccordingtotheBluhmLegalClinicatNorthwestern,“youthfuldefendantsmayhaveparticulardifjicultyunderstandingcriminalproceedingsoractivelyparticipatingintheprocess.”***StudentsinBostoncreatedasimilarwebsiteandappcalled,“BostonStudentRights.”Theirsuccessshowsthatasimilarappaboutlegaltermswouldbejustassuccessful.***ThisrecommendationstronglyagreeswithAyomide,astudentwhohelpedcreatetheBostonappwhosaid,“Youcan’tdefendyourselfanywhereifyoudon'tknowthetypeofrightsyouhave."
Howwillthishelp
Awebappwouldbehelpfulsinceitiscommonforyouthandtheirfamiliestonotknowwhotoaskforinformationorwheretogetinformation.Awebappcanbeaccessed24/7andwouldbeuser-friendly.It
wouldbeveryhelpfultoboththeyouthandparent/guardianbeforeenteringthecourtprocess.
JuvenileJusticeCouncil SUMMER!"#$
9|J J C R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s
Source:
"BenefitsofPeerMentoring."BenefitsofMentoring.N.p.,n.d.Web.10Aug.2015.
Recommenda0on5Haveeachcalendaradministerasurveyonlinetoyouthwhohave
recentlybeenthroughcourtaskingwhattheyunderstoodthroughouttheexperience.Usethefeedbacktoinstructjudgeson
howtosimplifyandexplainwhatisgoingonincourt.(Samplequestionsbelow):
• Doyouknowtherolesofthateachindividualplayedinyourcase?• Didyoufeelthatyouwerebeingtreatedfairly?Whyorwhynot?
Research
***AccordingtoAGuideforCommunicationandUnderstandinginJuvenileCourt,formsandlanguageusedinthejuvenilecourtare,“...writtenata12.9gradereadinglevel,usingtheFlesh-Kincaidreadinggradeleveltestandhasaverylowreadabilityscore(i.e.difjiculttoreadandbestunderstoodbyuniversitygraduates)...”***AccordingtotheJusticeJuvenileCouncilSurvey2015,46.4%youthdidnotunderstandcourtlanguage.***Havingatranslatorincourt,likeamentor,“...canprovidevaluablesupportforstudentsatcriticalpointsintheirstudentlife..."
Howwillthishelp
.
Manyyouthinthesystemdon’treallyknowwhat’sgoingonduetothecomplicatedlanguageincourtroomswhichusuallyleavesthemblindlysaying“yes”withoutunderstandingwhat’shappening.Havingayouthtranslatorwouldbenejitthecourt-involvedyouthbecausetheywillbemoreengagedbefore,during,andafterthehearingsincetheynowunderstandthelanguagethatisbeingused.Havinganinternwoulddecreasetheamount(46.4%)ofyouththatdon’tunderstandthecourtlanguage.
JuvenileJusticeCouncil SUMMER!"#$
10|J J C R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s
Sources:"Diversion|LawFacts."Diversion|LawFacts.LawFacts.Web.10Aug.2015.
<http://lawfacts.ca/criminal/diversion>.1,Chapter."MakingtheCaseforProgramEvaluation."MakingtheCaseforProgramEvaluation(n.d.):n.pag.Web.
10Aug.2015.
Recommenda0on6
Asurveyshouldbeadministeredtoyouththatwouldevaluatecourtpersonnel(state’sattorney,publicdefender,etc.)makingsuretheyareperformingtheirjobeffectivelyandmeetingtheneedsoftheyoungpeopleincourt.Thissurveywouldfocusonproceduraljustice.
Research***Evaluationsincreaseperformancebypinpointingtheweaknessessothattheycanworkonthemandimprovetheirworkethicandhowtheyhandlecases.Themainfocusoftheevaluationistoensurethatthecourtpersonnelarehandlingcasesinajustandfairmanner.Itwillmakesurethattheyouthontrialhavecourtpersonnelthatarewellversedinallaspectsoftheircasesuchasfairsentencing,alternativestojail,etc.***Evaluationsareimportanttomakesureyouthhaveafairexperienceincourt.Havinganevaluationwouldprovide“unlimitedpotentialforimprovingservices.Itcanhelptoclarifyanddevelopthekindsofservicesthatrecipientsneed.Italsocanhelptoidentifyand/oradjustservicesthatarenotbeingdeliveredtomoreeffectivelyservetheappropriatepeople.”
Howwillthishelp
Thiswouldhelptheyouthasitwouldensurethatthecourtpersonnelareperformingtheirjobfairlyandadequatelyatalltimes.Theyouthaftercompletingtheevaluation,willbeassuredthattheircasematteredtothegovernmentandwillhaveagreateropinionoftheirexperienceandoutcomeincourt.Theyouthwillfeelthattheyhavea"voice"inthecourtthatwillbetransmittedthroughtheevaluationtheycomplete.
JuvenileJusticeCouncil SUMMER!"#$
11|J J C R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s
Sources:"Readability-ClearLanguageGroup."ClearLanguageGroup.Readibility.Web.10Aug.2015.
"RedeployIllinois."DHS:.IllinoisDepartmentofHumanServices.Web.10Aug.2015.
RedeployIllinois:AnnualReporttotheGovernorandtheGeneralAssembly(2012-2013)
Recommenda0on7
RedeployIllinoisshouldbeadoptedinCookCounty.RedeployIllinoisisaprogramthatprovidesprogramsforhigh-riskyouthtopreventthemfromenteringthejuvenilejusticesystem.
Research***RedeployIllinoishasbeenimplementedinMaconCounty,PeoriaCounty,St.ClairCounty,LeeCounty,McLeanCounty,andMadisonCounty.Asof2012,eachcountysavedatleast$1millionsincestartingRedeployIllinois.***Together,thesixcountieshavesaved$59,632,711.***ThesesavingscomefromkeepingyouthoutofaJTDCandputtingthemintodiversionprograms,whichismuchlessexpensive.Onaverage,itcosts$31,000ayeartoimprisonsomeone,yetitcosts$350-$450toputsomeonethroughadiversionprogram.***IthasalsosavedIllinoistaxpayers$11.7million.***Currently,inthecountiesitexistsin,Redeployhas54%lessyouthbeingincarcerated(outofthosewhowereeligibletobeincarcerated).***Intangiblenumbers,eachcountysaved40youthfrombeingsenttoaJTDCthroughRedeployIllinois
Howwillthishelp
RedeployIllinoisshouldbeimplementedinCookCountybecauseitwillsavethecountymoneyinadditiontopreventyouthfromenteringtheJuvenileTemporaryDetentionCenter.Thisbenejitsboththecountyandtheyouth,whichisraretojindinaprogram.
JuvenileJusticeCouncil SUMMER!"#$
12|J J C R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s
“TheJumpstartprogramkeptmeeducateduntilIgotbackintoschool.IfIwould’vereceivedcreditsforschoolwhileintheJumpstartprogramIprobablywould’vegraduatedsooner.”
-HardieFleming,CurrentMemberoftheJJC
Recommenda0on8
Alldiversionprograms,shoulduponayouth’scompletion,dismissallchargesagainsttheyouthandprovideotherincentives.YouthshouldreceiveschoolcreditsindiversionprogramslikeJumpstart.Jumpstartisaprogramforyouththatareonprobationtorefocusthemontheireducation.
Research***Researchhasshownthatstudentswhomissorfailacademiccoursesareatgreaterriskofdroppingoutofschoolthantheirpeers.Tore-engagethesestudentsresearchersrecommendthatschoolsprovideextraacademicsupport(Dynarskietal.,2008).Datareportedbyschoolssuggeststhatcredit-recoveryprogramsmayhavepositiveeffectsonearningcreditstowardgraduation,attendancerates,andpassingratesonstatestandardizedtests.
Howwillthishelp
Youthshouldreceivecreditfromdiversionprogramsbecauseitwouldnotonlymotivatedthemtoattend,butalsobebenejicialfortheiracademic,employmentandrehabilitationsuccess.Thecreditfromdiversionprogramsshouldbeimplementedbecauseitwouldbeawaythattheyouthcouldinteractwithotheryouths.
JuvenileJusticeCouncil SUMMER!"#$
13|J J C R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s
Sources:
Kaba,Mariame."JuvenileJusticeinIllinois:ADataSnapshot."1Apr.2014.Web.10Aug.2015.<https://chiyouthjustice.files.wordpress.com/2014/04/juvenile_justice_in_illinois.pdf>.
"Diversion|LawFacts."Diversion|LawFacts.LawFacts.Web.10Aug.2015.<http://lawfacts.ca/criminal/diversion>.
Recommenda0on9
Thereshouldbeanincreasednumberofdiversionprogramsinneighborhoodsthathavehighinstancesofyoutharrests.
Research***Generallyspeaking,completingdiversionmeansthatyouwon’thaveacriminalrecord,eitherbecausethechargeiswithdrawn,orbecausetheone-yearperiodhaspassedwithoutincidentafteryourchargehasbeenstayed.***Avoidingapossiblecriminalrecordisoftenthemainreasonwhyaccusedpersonschoosetocompletediversion.***In2012,therewereabout46,800juvenilearrestsinIllinois.Themajorityofarrestswereformisdemeanoroffenses(59%)andtwenty-jive(25%)werefelonies.
Howwillthishelp
IncentivesandAccessibilityforDiversionProgramsshouldbeimplementedbecauseitwouldgivetheyouthareasontocomeandsuccessfullycompletetheprogram.Also,theyouthwouldnothavetotravelfortocometothediversionprogramsothatmightincreaseattendance.
JuvenileJusticeCouncil SUMMER!"#$
14|J J C R e c o m m e n d a t i o n s
Sources:
Goudie,Chuck."I-Team:ViolenceonCTAWidespread."ABC7Chicago.ABC7Chicago,20Feb.2013.Web.10Aug.2015.
http://policy.dcfs.lacounty.gov/content/Transportation_Requests.htm
Recommenda0on10
Sincecourtroomsarealreadyseparatedbydistrict,juvenilecourtshouldbeheldatafacilityneartheyouth’spolicedistrict.Bymovingthecalendarclosertotheyouth,itwouldmakeiteasierforthemtoattend.
Research***AccordingtoasurveybyMikvaChallenge’sMayoralYouthCommissionTransportationIncentivesProgram,44%ofrespondentsanswered“Can’taffordtransportation”asthereasontheydon’tgotoschool.***CountyofLosAngeleshasmentionedthatinthestatethatsomeyouthhavetroublegoingtotheircourthearingssotheyprovidetransportationforthosewhoneedit.
HowwillthishelpThisrequestwouldmakeiteasierfortheyouthasitdecreasestheamoutnoftransportationfromtheircurrentdestinationtothecourtroom.Youthwillbemorelikelytocometocourtifitismoreaccessibletogetto,.Furthermore,itwillhelpincreasetheamountofinformationpassedabouttheyouthbetweenthepoliceandthecourt.Thebettercommunicationwillensurethatthesentenceisfairbecauseeverythingabouttheyouthhasbeenfullyconsidered.