1
T ~ **5 lewis m. grist, proprietor, j Jn Jnkpcnbtnf Jamiln fUto'spaptr: Jfor % ^romofira of % political, jJotial, ^jrfnillnral anb Commercial Interests of tjie ^ont^. |terms--$3.oo a tear, in advance. VOL. 25. YOEKYILLE, S. C., THURSDAY, JULY 3, 1879.' NO. 27. fleeted foetrg. NO TIME FOR HATING. Begone with feud ! away with strife ; Our human hearts unmating; Let us be friends again ! This life I&all too short for hating ; So dull the day, so dim the way, So rough the road we're faring. Far better weal with faithful friend, Than stalk along unbearing. The barren fig, the withered vine, Are types of selfish living ; But souls that give, like mine and thine, Renew their life by giving. While cypress waves o'er earthly graves On all the ways we're going, Far better plant where seed is scant, Than tread on fruit that's growing. Away with scorn ! Since die we mtist. And rest on one low pillow; There are no rivals in tne dust. No foes beneath the willow ; So dry the bowers, so few the flowers, Our earthly way discloses, Far better stoop where daisies droop, Than tramp o'er broken roses! Oh! what are all the joys we hold, Compared to joys above us, And wnat are ranic and power and gold Compared to hearts that love as ? So fleet our years, so fall of tears, So closely "death is waiting, God give us space for loving grace But leave no time for hating. JU Original Jdartf. Written for the Yorkville Enquirer. RACHEL RAY'S SECRET. CHAPTER XVII. All yet seems well; and, if it end so meet, The bitter past, more welcome is the sweet. Shakspeare. "Tell me all about Rachel, mother," said Magdalen Gray, as she sat in the cottage parlor on the evening of her return from the country. "Your letters have not been very satisfactory, somehow. They have only given me a general idea of her affairs.how strangely everything seems to have come round!" "Yes, indeed," rejoined Mrs. Gray. "Who could have supposed that our quiet little reserved Rachel had such a romantic history? I have seen very little of her since her hus. band's return. Her time has, of course, oeen entirely occupied with nursing the brother, and so on." "The brother.that is, Mr. Vivian's brother?" asked Magdalen, in a constrained voice. "Yes; the unfortunate gentleman, you know, who flung himself out of the window. I wrote you about him." "I forget what you said his name was.his Christian name, I mean," said Magdalen, in the same constrained manner. "I don't think I mentioned, dear. I am not sure that I ever heard. If I did, I do not remember it now," answered the widow. "All I know about him is that he has long been insane,'and is now." "Long been insane.why, I thought quite differently. I am sure you mentioned it only as a temporary thing," interrupted Magdalen, in a quick, impatient sort of way. "And he is quite well, quite sane again, you wrote." "Yes, dear, I believe so," answered the mother, a little wondering, a little troubled at Magdalen's tone. The girl rose from her seat and walked to the window, stood there a minute or two, nervously plucking at the white fringe of the curtain, then came back and threw herself in her chair again, with a long, tremulous, half-suppressed sigh. "Are you uuwell, love?" asked Mrs. Gray, Tt ca nniionn ] fr\ ona hor miXIUUSIJTf It TVOC OKI UUUOUM1 WW uvv *JV» daughter restless or impatient. "No, only tired." "Tired from your journey, no doubt. You must go to bed early, dear." "Perhaps so. Mother, is Rachel.does she seem very, very happy ?" "Her face looked like a sunbeam, in the brief glimpses I have caught of it lately. Notwithstanding her illness, she is wonderfully changed for the better, in her outward aspect. But, as I said, I have seen her but seldom, for some time past." "I am so glad she is happy," said Magdalen, abstractedly. "I wonder how she could bear such a grief as she did, and not betray it." ' "Yes, she must have wonderful self-command." While they were yet talking, there was a light tap at the door, and Rachel herself entered. Magdalen actually started at the transformation in her appearance. No more sombre draperies and melancholy looks robbed her of her youthfulness and clouded the sunny brightness of her face. In a light muslin dress, adorned with blue ribbons, and the greater adornment of smiles, and a happy blush mantling her still delicate check, she looked like a girl of sixteen. She threw her arms around her friend, and kissed her again and again. "I knew you were come home," she said, "and I was too anxious to see you to wait un- til to-morrow. So Murrell.Mr. Vivian, that is.brought me round, and will come back for me after a while." "Why did he not come in, dear? We should Tiave been so pleased to see him," said Mrs. Gray. "He will come, very soon. But just now "he is so busy attending to his brother, who .still requires constant nursing," Rachel answered, with a furtive glance at Magdalen as she spoke. She saw that the latter shrank a little, and hurriedly looked away. She had not yet spoken a word, and it was easy to perceive that she was restless and discomposed. Rachel was longing to talk to her alone, but! there was no opportunity for that yet. Good Mrs. Gray had twenty questions to ask, and would not be satisfied without a full and par-! ticular account of many things which had not yet been explained to her. Then Jem came in, and the conversation became more general. Magdalen roused herself by degrees to speak more cheerfully and like her own self; but Rachel saw that it was an effort, and, knowing her secret, had no difficulty in guessing the subject of her thoughts. The evening wore on, and feeling sure at last that it would not be long before her hus-; band would come for her, Rachel made a bold stroke to gain the opportunity she desired. "Magdalen, have you finished unpacking?" she asked. "Because, if not, won't you let me help you before I go home ?" She gave her a look full of meaning as she spoke. The other met and understood it. A crimson flush mounted to her face, as, murmuring some rather incoherent reply, she immediately rose and left the parlor, Rachel following her, and they were soon alone in the little chamber where her trunk stood half emptied of its contents. "Magdalen, dear," Rachel began, too eager to unburden herself to make any preliminary < speeches, "if I ask you a question, will you i give me a sincere answer ?" "What question is it Rachel ?" asked Mag- £ dalen, her breath coming quick and fast. < She was very much excited, it was easy to < see, though she tried not to betray it. i "Do you remember," her friend went on, sinking her voice to a whisper, as she put her { arms about the other's trembling form, "some t time back.the last day I was with you here. t oKnminn ma a niMnrp?" i suv""u6 ** r"~v Magdalen nodded. She could not control herself sufficiently to make any other rdply. "You know, dear.don't you?.that the original of that picture is very near you. that he is ray husband's brother," Rachel continued. "I see that you do. Now this is the question I want to ask you.do you love hira still ?" Magdalen trembled more than ever. She looked with piteous entreaty into Rachel's eyes. "You would not ask me that," she faltered s presently, "unless you had some reason. Oh ! $ Rachel," she cried, suddenly breaking through t her enforced self-restraint, and clasping her [ hands, as if in supplication, as she spoke, \ "for pity's sake tell me all you know at once. 1 Has he spoken to you ? Has he explained ?". a "Dear, he cannot explain," Rachel answer- i ed gently. "Remember, bis mind has been a 1 blank so long. But he has spoken to me.of f you. He loves you as much as ever. He p never, I am sure, intentionally, did you any i wrong. It is plain to me that he was not v master of his own actions when he left you, e as you say he did, so suddenly." 3 "Vnn moan. woa inaanp " said Mafrda- len, tfith a shudder. "Oh! Rachel, is it not r a fearful thiDg?" r "Yes, it is a terrible misfortune; but Mag- s dalen, the doctors think his reason will not p leave him again. This last shock, caused by I his severe fall, seems to have revolutionized c him. They think he is lastingly cured." "And he loves'me still," said Magdalen, I below her breath. Her eyes looked far away, s her bosom rising and falling with a suppress- c ed agitation, a beatific smile, yet tremulous with scarcely restrained tears, playing upon h her lips. Rachel almost feared she had said too much. c "You know, dear Magdalen," she went on, to cautiously, "the doctors cannot be quite sure. It may be, of course, that he will have some n return, some temporary spells of his dis- b ease." s "What do I care for that?" impetuously a interrupted Magdalen. "That is not the v question. I would not give that a thought. to but the thing is, are you quite sure of what t you told me just now.oh ! Rachel.it may be I all a mistake. I dare not believe it." ii "Come and see him, if you don't believe il it," rejoined Rachel. "He talked to me about you for an hour yesterday. I believe the i< sight of you would cure him at once." h "I could not go, you kuoW.that would be p impossible. Besides.there is mother; it would all seem dreadful to her. She never h kuew.you remember I told you. And Ra- v chel," continued Magdalen, with returning d doubt, "if he really meant it.then, long ago, s, I mean.why did he persuade me not to tell ? v Could he not have spoken, if he was siucere? & You have not explained that." c "It was, I suppose, merely a caprice.some- c thing which he could not now account for. With the shadow of his approaching afflic- v tion clouding his mind, who can tell what h fancies may have possessed him ?" v t "Ah ! Rachel, and with his mind so cloud- j] ed, how could he know if he really loved me f d That may have been a fancy, too," said Mag- t dalen, despondeutly. "I know I am wrong t to build any hopes upon what you have told ]( me." t "Unbelieving girl! Listen, and I will con- fl vince you that I have good reason for every word that I have uttered," rejoined Rachel; d and, forthwith, she entered into the details of ? the conversation between her brother-in-law t and herself, to which she had alluded, and e which proved sufficiently convincing to assure t her listener that, whatever else was forgotten c or indistinct in Maurice's mind, the remera- ? brance of her and of his love for her, and the c existence* of that love, in all its ardor, at the t present time, were indubitable. _ j "If mother can only be brought round to listen to it," she said, at length, when her own t doubts and arguments were fully laid at rest, t "But that will be a harder task than you im- c agine." "Leave that to me," replied Rachel, hope- r fully. "I'll bring in a verdict of a council of 8 physicians to satisfy her on the score of Mau- e rice's health." t "At all events," said Magdalen, with a long t drawn sierh. "if nothiner more ever comes of it, s it is an inexpressible comfort to know that he g did not wilfully deceive me. That will be a r happiness to me all my life." t "I knew you would feel so dear. I know I so well what it is to have the burden of a terrible, consuming doubt lifted from the heart, t after bearing it so long," said Rachel, almost c in a whisper. Magdalen kissed her cheek. c "You have said not one^ word of yourself, t Rachel; and I meant to tell you how I re- a joiced in your happiness, only my selfish f thoughts put it out of my head. How pa- c tiently you bore your trouble, and how much you had to bear !" a "Don't let us speak of it now," said Rachel r tremulously. "I want to put the memory of g that dreadful time far away from me, like a ^ nightmare, or a horrid dream. Indeed, it e seems to me now like a dream. But you f don't know, Magdalen.you could not guess. j that almost the worst part of it all was see- ( ing that picture of Maurice, and taking it for ] his." 1 "Why, are they so much alike?" ( "Almost exactly alike, only that illness has \ altered him ; but at the time that was paint- \ ed, it might easily have been taken for my husband's likeness. Oh, I felt as if you had f struck me a mortal blow when you showed it j tn mp T thought, then, vou had been the vv **"v' " O"*' ' Jcause of all my suffering." s "And I never knew.you never betrayed j your thoughts! Poor Rachel!.how you ( must have hated me," cried Magdaleu. "I , could so easily have explained.have told you his Christian name." "Yes.it could have been explaiued ; but I could not ask a question. I felt as if I were j s turned into stone. It was my bewilderment ! that made nie get run over as I was going J home, I suppose. I was too blind and giddy I' to find my way. However, that was just the ( best thing that could happen to. me, for ( through it I came to know Maurice's physi- < r jian, Dr. Snow; and how wonderfully all its results were brought about?" Here their conference was interrupted by a lumraons from Mrs. Gray. "Mr. Vivian has :ome for you, Rachel. I have coaxed him to ;ome in for a few minutes, and he is waiting n the parlor." "Now you will see him,"*said Rachel, in a jlad whisper, as she and her friend descended he stairs; "but remember what I told you ibout the resemblance, and don't be as started as I was." Although she was thus prepared, Magdaen's heart beat painfully at the sight of the loble, handsome face, so wonderful in its likeless to the one indellibly impressed upon her ecollection; far more like it,, indeed, than vas the original of that cherished remerant. the nresent time. Murrell thanked >oth her and her mother, in his own way. vhich was beyond comparison, as Rachel hought, with anybody's way in the whole vdrld besides.for their share in comforting ind helping his wife at a time when she so orely needed friends. It was a subject too ender for many words to be spoken on it, >ut he expressed all that he mearit to, and vas fully understood. He pressed Magdaen's hand kindly as he bid her good-night, md she fancied she read a certain meaning n his eyes; nor was she mistaken. Rachel : tad, of course, told him' all about her, and tad quite won him over as an ally to her dans. They talked about her all the way tome. Rachel was charmed to find that he ras favorably impressed with her, and was ager to have the love-affair brought to a atisfactory conclusion at once. < "My dear child," Murrell said, with gentle 1 emonstrance, "you must not be in such un- ( easonable haste. Remember, it must be ometime yet, ere Maurice, poor fellow, can < resent himself in the character of a wooer, j Jesides, there are certain drawbacks to be f onsidered and overcome." } "You mean her mother's objections," said 1 lacbel. "But, after all, we don't know that f he will have objections. And, if she has, we ] an persuade her out of them." j "1 am not sure that we can," rejoined her usband. 1 % i *.i 1 "You can, if you try," said itacnei, wun onfidence. "You can do whatever you please o." "With you, my darling.that I know. But fty influence with others may not be so unfunded," was his reply. "Nor do I think uch objections as we anticipate would be at 11 unreasonable or surprising. I know too rail my own horror of that dreadful disease, o feel desirous of persuading any one to run he risk of having it entailed upon others. Sven if Maurice should escape a return of the [lfliction, how do we know that his children, f he had any, would prove exempt?" "Well, I suppose we must leave it to Province," said Rachel with a sigh. "But I did ope that now everything would come hapily round!" "I hope so, too, my love. But I think we ad better now remain passive for a little diile, having done what it seemed right to o, and wait for time to develop farther reults," answered Murrell. And 'Rachel, to rhom he was now, as ever, an oracle, submited to his judgment, and, for the present, deided not to make any farther efforts in the ause which she had so much at heart. Not the less, however, did she eagerly /atch the progress of events; nor did she feel lerself at all bound to check the confidences ?hich Maurice was continually ready to pour nto her ear. He was most eager to see Maglalen, and to learn from her own lips that he former tie between them was still rememlered by her; and Dr. Snow, to whom at ength she spoke of this desire, undertook to : 3 ^ rttAAr* Arrt ^ le a meuium ui uuiuiuuuikiiuuii uc^nccu mtui, ,nd, still better, a mediator with Mrs. Gray. The old lady was greatly overcome by the j lisclosures made to her, and for some time it < pas doubtful whether her consent to a union tetween Maurice and her daughter could . ver be won. But Magdaleu, when she found 1 hat her mother knew all, plead her own ause with an earnestuess that was hard to withstand. Mrs. Gray was astonished at the oncentrated passion of the girl's nature, for he first time revealed to her in this outpour- ng of her long hidden love and grief, her lopes and fears; she had never dreamed of he intensity of feeling that had lain bidden >eneath that unusually placid and even heerful exterior. At last she consented to go and see Mau- ice, who was still far too weak to come and ee her. The interview between them, if not ; xactly a conclusive one, proved favorable o the lovers' hopes. It was arranged that no >ar to their intercourse should be offered; md if no promise was asked or given, it eeired, nevertheless, an understood thing that natters should be allowed, without opposition, o arrange themselves as circumstances might test dictate. As soon as the invalid was strong enough, he family party removed to Woodstock, the ild Virginia home. Mrs. Gray and her chilIren were urged to come, too; but this iuvitaion she declined. At some future day, she md Magdalen might pay Rachel a visit, but or the present they must continue in tKe [uiet pursuit of their usual duties at home. Letters passed frequently between Maurice md Magdalen, the former writing more and nore hopefully, and telling her always of teadily improving health. At last his letters vere followed by a visit from himself, looking, sxcept for his gray hair, like the Maurice of '/ifmorJavt Ho hnrl mmi> now Vip snirl tr» V/l UIVI UMJ Ul v W>MV V .. | ..v dead in earnest for a favorable hearing. jould it not be definitely settled whether Vlagdalen was to marry him, and if so, when? Mrs Gray hesitated, doubted, and finally gave ;onsent, which, indeed, she had already given n her heart. Only, it was the hardest thing u the world for her to let Magdalen go. "Never mind, mother," said Jem. "You ind I'll keep house together, and be as hapiy as the day is long." "Better, than that," said Maurice. "You shall both come and live with me, and there leed not be any partings at all." And so, to everybody's satisfaction, it was finally arranged. [conclusion next week.] It was the Duke of Wellington who mid "great nations cannot wage little wars," ind England will be apt to realize the force o 1 diis remark when she gets through with this Zulu business. Twenty-five hundred Englishlien have already perished in that war, 2(y 300 regulars are now in the field, and the cost if the war is 82,500,000 a week. Nothing ?ould be worse than this statement. (Etouft of \ i TRIAL f OF j , JAMES P. OASTON ; FOR THE MURDER OF 1 CHURCHILL L. WIM.IF0RD. < In the Court of General Sessions, June Term, 1879. jj BY OUR OWN REPORTER. .t No trial in the sessions court of York coun- * ty, for many years past, if ever, has created c such general public interest as the case of the * State vs. James P. Caston, indicted for the 1 murder of Churchill L. Williford, in Hock 1 Hill, oik the 2nd day of last month. On the < morning of that day, the deceased, a young J man who had barely attained his majority.of ' respectable family, of gay and lively tempera- r ment, frank and open-heartedj but of combat- c ive temperament, perhaps, when under the ^ baneful influence of strong drink.left York- £ ville in the exuberance of youthful health and t the bright anticipations of a new life, which t he expressed to liis companion on the road, as 8 his determination talead, a/id ere the noon- e day sun had ci\388exivthe iqfcridian the start- 8 ling intylligenceWi& conveyed here by tele- 8 graph that he wqs dead.tie victim of a pis- F tol in the hands of James E. Caston, likewise 1; a young man, but little the} senior of his vie- t tim.a man of rerairkably qniet, peaceable dis- 8 position.a merchant, a consistent member of a Christian denomination, and whose general deportment had even been rdgarded as a model t for even those of mkturer wars. The slayer was committed to tlife jail of York county on o the afternoon of the* occurrence, and on the \ following day the mortal remains of his victim ji were consigned to thel earth! t At that time it wap difficult to obtain all I the facts which led to tbe unfortunate occur- n rence; nor, indeed, di 1 weJ deem it prudent,' r in view of the early ap proaching term of the s: sourt, to publish any (f t^ie many versions of- s the affair, preferring U await the legal inves- a tigation and lay before th£ public the facts as y elicited in the court of justice. f< On Monday afternoo i of last week the pris- a Dner was arraigned bii'ore Judge Thomson^ ^ md entered his plea off npt guilty, the State o aeing represented by Mr.TSolicitor Gaston, as- a listed by Giles J. PattCrapn, Esq., of the Ches- y ;er bar, and Messrs. Wilson & Wilson, of the e Yorkville bar. The prisoner was represented a uy an array of equally eminent counsel, con- y listing of Messrs. Wifhtrspoon & Spencer, J. y P. Gage, Esq., and J.J 0. Witlierspoon, Esq., y )f the Yorkvillebar, Jrim J. D. Wylie, Esq., of t* the Lancaster bar. J / tl After the arraignment and pleading, al- k thoueh the prisoner Ms entitled by the prac- si iice in this State, to Aree days' notice from n :he date of the bill q# indictment, which was ri returned in court oniMonday, yet his counsel o waived the right, andf, by consent, the trial was j\ jet for Wednesday morning at 10 o'clock. h The court-room w/is filled with eager specta- e: :ors long before the hour appointed, and so h )ppressive was the heat in the overcrowded b room, that the sheriff found it necessary to h lend for a carpenter to remove the entire sash from the windows in order to admit proper ^ ventilation. g At 10 o'clock, the prisoner, cleanly shaven 0 md neatly and faultlessly attired in a suit of 0 ilack, was led into the court room, and seated aj learhis counsels 0 The regularpanel, consisting of thirty-six y_ lames, was as follows: Wm. Whyte, W. N. ^ Jackson, W. W. Castles, J. P. Hutchison, H. gl] 1 Strauss, W. S. Creighton, Frank Edwards, V W. M. McGill, Wm. Borders, J. A. Carroll, ^ D. J. Goode, Wm. Choate, G. R. Boleyn, John t( Ltattaree, W. J. Martin, John B. Lowry, Jef- 01 ferson Ellis, J. Frank Workman, L. R. Wil- $ iams, J. C. McCully, Greene Bratton, T. S t]Tefferys, Samuel Brown, J. H. Crawford, A. ^ J. Davinney, Joseph Black, L. R. Pierce. L. p, L. Smith, Oscar Chambers, Allen Hall, S. N {J Love, W. II. Herndon, Iredell Jones, Thomas j, R. Martin, John M. Jackson, S. J. Kimbrell. t( Mr. Workman, of the original panel, was ex- ^ ;used on account of sickness, and L. R. Wil- ^ iams, who was among those summoned by J ipecial venire on the previous day, to complete ^ ;he panel, was excused on account of the of- ^ ice he holds as school-trustee.J* Counsel for ^ lefence pressed their right fSr a full panel, ^ md, accordingly, his Honor granted an order h for a special venire of two jurorsXo supply the $ vacancies. Under supervision of Jury Com- ^ missioner D. C. McKinney, the names of John 0 It. Ferguson and George A. Wilkerson w ere ^ Irawn. Mr. Ferguson resides in YorkviHe, 0 jut Mr. Wilkerson lives in the country, ^ "-wo miles from the court house. He was at a liis home, and over an hour intervened before j., lie could be summoned and make his appearmce in the court-room. ^Arriving, and the panel being complete, the drawing of the P iury was proceeded with, after the request by P [. D. Witherspoon, Esq., of counsel for defence, V that each juror be put upon his voir dire. No £ abjection being made by State's counsel, his Honor so ordered. n The names of the jurors were drawn in the a following order, and the panel exhausted be- ( fore the tenth juror was obtained, the State ^ (laving the right to two peremptory chal- , lenges: Wm. Whyte, accepted ; W. N. Jack- ^ son, rejected; W. W. Castles, accepted ; John G. Ferguson, rejected on his voir dire* H. C. , Strauss, same; James P. Hutchison,"accepted ; W. S. Creighton, peremptorily challenged ^ by the State; Franklin Edwards, rejected; ^ George A. Wilkerson, rejected; W. M. McGrill, accepted ; Wm. Borders, accepted ; J. A. T Carroll, rejected on his voir dire; D. J. Goode, * accepted; Wm. Choate, rejected; G. R. Bo- £ leyn, rejected ; John Rittaree, answered that he is a relative of deceived; W. J. Martin, re- ® jected; John B. Low::y, accepted; Jefferson ji Ellis, rejected; J. C. McCully, rejected ; ^ Greene Bratton, rejected; T. S. Jefferys, re- J jected on his voir dire; A. J. Davinney, rejected; Joseph Black, rejected ; L. R. Pierce, ? rejected on his voir din; L. L. Smith, accept- ^ ed; Oscar Chambers, rejected ; Allen Hall, rejected; S. M. Love, rejected on his voir dire; W. H. Henidon, same; Iredell Jonetr same; ^ Thomas Martin, rejected; John M. Jacksqn, f accepted; S. J. Kimbi.-ell, peremptorily chal- f lenged by the State. f This exhausted the panel, leaving three* ju- \ rors yet to be drawn. On motion of Solicitor t, Gaston, his Honor granted an order for a spe- J cial venire of twelve to be drawn immediately from the jury box, which was done as follows: . W. C. Latimer, J. B. Thomasson. Wm. Rawls, c J. B. Scott, W. R. Bell, T. B. Barnett, A. F. e, McConnell, Solomon Harshaw, J. C. Kuyken- J dal, T. M. Dobson, J. R. Witherspoon, Nelson Davies. c After the names were drawn and the venire issued, court adjourned until 4o'clock, P. M., the jurors qualified to serve in the case being placed under charge of a constable, and admonished to have no communication with any person on the subject of the trial now progressing. Court convened promptly at 4 o'clock P. M., and all of the special venire answered to their names except wm. Rawls, Solomon Harshaw and Nelson Davies, of whom the latter could not be found. From this list only one juror was obtained, the names being drawn with the following result: J. B. Thomasson, excused 011 his voir dire; J. C. Kuykendal, same; Joseph It. Witherspoon, same; W. C. Latimer, rejected; J. B. Scott, excused on his voir dire; T. M. Dobson, same; W. R. Bell, rejected ; T. B. Barnett, accepted ; A. F. McConnell, excused on his voir dire. This exhausted the list, and a venire was ordered for twenty jurors, who were drawn from the box as follows: Hamilton Thomasson. R. Frank Clark, L. B. Sherer, Wm. M. Corkill, J. A. Ratchford, J. F. Carson, W. F. Gardner, J. M. Templeton, S. T. Ferguson, M, L. Thomasson, R. L. Brown, Henry Jackson, M. H. Jackson, A. Sylvanus Wallace, James Fitchett, Samuel Staraes, W. L. McLeave, J. A. Erwin, Knox Williams, Robert M. Lindsay. While the drawing was progressing, Win. Rawls and Solomon Harshaw appeared in Court, and were notified to lie in attendance at 10 o'clock on Thursday morning, when court adjourned to that hour. OrTthe convening of the court on Thursday morning, all the jurors of the second sj>ecial venire, as also Nelson Davies of the first, answered to their mimes. Those of the first venire, who were absent on Wednesday.Wm. Rawls, Nelson Davies and Solomon Harshaw. were placed in the box and drawn before using the names of the second venire. The name of William Rawls was drawn first and he was accepted. The names of Nelson Davies and Sol- toon Harshaw were then drawn respectively, ai md both rejected. The second venire was then tl )laced in the box, and the first name drawn I' vas that of It. L. Brown, who was accepted, r< md he completed the jury, which is as follows: bl (Vim. Whyte, W. M. Castles, James P. Hutch- p] son, W. M. McGill, Wm. Borders, D. J. Good, p] rohn B. Lowry, L. L. Smith, John M. Jack- p< ion, T. B. Barnett, William Rawls and R. L. tl Efcwn. a * The jury then retired to their room and tl sleeted L. L. Smith as foreman, and after re- tx luraimf their seats, the indictment was read ir )y fcfie clerk, when Mr. Solicitor Gaston opened c< -jre case by saying.J pi May it please the Court: It is customary in sases of this magnitude to outline to the jury C he proof by which the State expects to estab- Ik ish the allegations of the indictment. I will tc - . - » mi n >riet!y comply w;tn tins custom, rue estate v/ ixpects to prove that 011 the second day of se Tune, 1879, the deceased, having been absent ir or several days from pis home in Rock Hill, h< eturned there; that 1 e took a seat in front b; >f a store in that tow 1, at a place which he tl tras accustomed to o< cupy when at leisure; ai hat he sat with his < hair thrown back and m lis leg elevated in an kttitude of repose; ahd di hat while the deceased sat quietly in this po- si ition, with his head turned away, the prison- H r came to the door of his own.an adjoining w tore.and extending his body forward, with oi pistol in Ills left hand, shot the deceased, in- w licting a mortal wound, of which he almost ti; ostantly died! We iexpect"to prove further w hat the prisoner, before this occurrence, had si tated that he wouldf shoot the deceased; I testimony/for tiie state. / hi The State then introduced its testimony for he prosecution. // Y II. P. Haslam, sworn. Was in Rock Hill w n the 2nd day of .June. Knew Churchill L. ri Villiford; he is depul. He died from an in- h< ury received at Rdck Hill, in this county^ on le he 2nd day of jiine. 1 was standing near ^ lagans' store, on the street.Railroad street. <f ear where the shqoting occurred. The street 4 uns parallel with the railroad oh the west P1 T maa afonrllnrr nn fctiA OOflt. Sldft flf tllfi Jh( troet, in front Tf Hagans' fltore, leaning jfei gainst a sign pott. Churchill L. Willifordi pi raji sitting in front of Howe's bar-room, about* W arty feet from where I was /Standing. I ha<| ro jclear "view of htoi: there were no obstruci i'o ions between us.jL When I first saw the pri» ner, he was standing in his own store dooi, di bout twenty feet from where the deceased oj ras sitting. Hope's store adjoins the prisonr's store. The deceased was leaning ba£k ai gainst the building, his feet crossed, and ihe w ras on the side or lie door farthest from W there the prisoner was standings Thedeceaped I ras sitting talkmg t<* the bar-tender, hislat- he ention directed into Howe's house. I eaw at tie prisoner copm tq^his door, and as soonas [1 e came to the doo/, he fired at deceased.Mas A Don as Williford was shot, he exclaimed* v'0 H ly God I" and ripi or reeled into Howe'l bar- 11 Dom. Caston remained in his door a ^cond pc r so after shooting. After the shooting, I bi imped into tbe street and Caston went into a is store, and I went to the store wherh I am bi ogaged. Caston shot with a pistol, field in wi is left hand. I h4ve known Caston tWo years, pi ut do not know whether or not h^ is left- an anded. ~ / to Cross-examined by Mr. Wylie..I sfco. a na- a: ive of New Jersey. I was in tlie United Pf tates Army, a,nd was discharged od the 9th Pj f January, 1876. My employment at the time h j f the shooting was that of a baiker. The hi ign post against which I was leaning stands m; n the outer edge of the guttering of the street? sp deceased was sittiDg on the south side of w; [owe's bar-room door, occupying/ a common pi alit-bottom chair, X think, but am not posi- in ive. The face of deceased was tprned to the A: ist, his face iaartly!in the direction of Cas- di m's store. He could have seen Caston if his fa ra had been turned in the direction of his ril oor.^The chair in Which Willjftard was siting wns leaning ag^inst'.the Muse.Howe's pli ar-room. I cannot i^ay whether or not both fo osts were against the building. Williford's th ody was turned in the chair, facin&the build- tei lg. The chair was (Jverturned.overturned th )ward the front. I flaw pail; of Caston's al; ody. Was prevented from seeing all his body rh y an obstruction between two stores.a tin wi uttering enclosed in jvood? six inches from or le building. This guttering prevented me th ;om seeing the whole of his^body. Caston ras in his door when h|e fired.fljHe fired with te is left hand. He was standinglon the step of hi is door. The lower stfep projects a little in w] ront of the building. The step is the same it eight as the pavement.even,with the surface pr f pavement. From the sign-post the distance ih o the line of buildings; is seven or eight feet, pa n the same side of the street. The next ed uilding north is Howe*s; the next is Caston's, Ca 11 in same block. I was about sixty feet dis- W( ant from the scene of the firing. Redirect..Mr. Williford wis talking to some rij erson in Howe's store.! His face was looking th ato the store.the side of his face next to el( !aston's, and the front towards Howe's store, if 'risoner was on his own step when he fired, .'here is no lower graded step than the floor; J. o difference in the grade between the step be nd the floor of the building. Ik To Mr. Wylie, by permission of Solicitor.. \Y Jannot say how long Williford had been sit- to ing there. I stated to the coroner that I went w own street on business. I saw him sitting F here two or three minutes.' ju To the Solicitor..The question proposed to M ie put to the witness was the introduction of st tew matter, which was objected to by the bj efence. and objection sustained by the court, di Witness was then withdrawn. h< Charles Patton, sworn. I was in Rock ti lill on the 2n(T~0f--31mt£,-aml-flaw the occur- ti ence. At the time, I was workinjhacross the treet, in the depot sliedj about eighty feet ni listant. There was no obstruction between y( ae and the place where the shooting occurred, tc was working across the street, dressing a r lank, and as I turned in'that direction, duing my work, I saw Ckston step to the door i nd shoot at Williford-with a pistol. As Cas- r on shot, Williford was leaning against the tl vail, sitting in a chaiiuLWben shot, Williford ai aised from the chair reeled into the door. jn Ls he went into the door,; Caston cocked his 0i »istol. I saw him take it down, and think b le cocked it from the fact that he raised it, as ^ f to shoot again. Wlien he fired, hexwas lean- n< ng forward out of the door, standing on the fa loor-sill. After firing, he( made a second at- Ce empt to shoot, and then turned and went in- ti o his store. Williford was in my view. There uj vas no obstruction. Williford had no weapon ix Irawn or exposed. Williford's head was turn- n, d "towards Howe's' doorj in the direction of m Gaston's house. Caston'adoor was to Williord's right. Williford could not see Gaston's fr loor on account of an obstruction. hi Crnss^xuminedJjtfMr^ Wjilie..I was work- in n^iirftock-HtlTaiul resided there at the time, tl dy parents live in Charlotte. I am nineteen ct rears of age. I had been living in Rock Hill st or one \veek prior to the 2nd of June. I left m lock Hill on the WedneMay night following T he shooting on Monday..' I returned to Rock I lill last Friday, because I was summoned to fc ittend here as a witness." I was summoned in h< loach's store on the day after the occurrence, k< aid gave bond for pay appearance here. My tr loss turned me off because I went to a picnic ai vithout his consent. The picnic or excursion di vas by the Pioneer Fire Company from Char- g< otte to Winnsboro. I went down, and re- d< urned 011 thtfsame evening, and continued on w 0 Charlotte. /^The reason why I returned to oc lock Hill, Fhday, was because I was summon- bj d to be here 011 the fourth Monday, and I c? bought I had better come in time. I did not el vant to confer with anybody. I stopped at hi dr. Roach's, where I Ifoarded before. I have ti lad 110 conversation In Rock Hill with any cs sidy since Friday as td the nature of my tes- In imony. Mr. Gjiston (the Solicitor) lias con- ni f.rrpfi with nifi.Gl I was workinc 011 a tempo- bt ary bench 80 oij?Rl fetjit from the shooting. I ec mow the distance by having stepped it, which w did day before yesterday. It is '27 steps or in ards. I stepped it in company with Mr. IIol- II er, who stepped it also, We did not talk ai ,lx)ut the homicide. iFrom where I was work- I ng at the time of the shooting, the distance nc s 64 feet by measurement. I measured the at listances at the suggestion of some one. I ca liink Mr. Thompson, a carpenter in Rock sli fill, suggested tlie measurement. in Calvin G. Parish, sworn.. On the morn- hi irg-nf the2ntf of June! was in Rock Hill. M Vent from Yorkville? and left between 7 and m o'clock in the morning. Churchill L. Willi- hi old went with me. He had been in Yorkville "VV ince the Friday previous. We went over on hi Monday morning. When we arrived at Rock or 1111, we first went to his father's livery stable, ad from there to his father's house. From lere we went to Gordon's hotel- and next to vy's store. Then, I think, to Hagans' barx>m to play billiards; but not liking his tale, we went to Howe's and commenced to lay, when Williford asked Howe to take his lace andjulay with me. Williford then step3d out^TVVhile we were playing, and before le ganl| was finished, I heard the report of pistol.' I thought I heard him talking at le door before the pistol fired.. I thmk he had 3en out ten or fifteen minutes before the firig. I heard Williford's voice in ordinary jnversation. On hearing the report of the istol, I started fort the front dodr and met /"illiiord, who fait to me, "I am shot; Jim aston has killed i le." I spok/ to him, but 3 made no reply. [ soon gJterwards stepped > the back door of he same building and saw aston twenty step i distant, / suppose. He lemed to be look ng in, mid held a gun i his hands. I tolf Mrs H^ve to look out. 3 might be shot; And Howe stepped 10 me ick door and told Cast<m not to shoot in lere. Caston held he g\p\ in both his hands id was looking tov ards/Howe's-rtK was a usket; I think a ree^i-loader.TjVVilliford ed in about 10 or .5 minutes aftpr he was lot. He was taken ,o /is father's residence, e died in this coui if. During the time f as with him that day/he was not in company ' the prisoner. He wus absent from me only bile 5 was playing billiards.while he was at. le ffont door of the same house in which I as playing. To the best of my knowledge the looting was between 11 and 12 o'clock, A. M. was to have taken dinner with Williford at s father's house that day.jT* Cfoss-examined by ifr^Wylie..I reside in oikville. I saw Caston making across toards Gordon's hotel. There was a pile of lpbish lying near the way he was going, but v liad passed that, I would suppose, to his rt, before I saw him. He made no demonration to ffre while in rear of Howe's. I ) not know the fact that Mr. "Williford had pistoljtn his person, though I know he had le here on Saturday,, I saw no pistol after 3 was shot. Williford did not leave mypresice that day, only during the time I was aying billiards; he was with me all the time, re drove to the livery stable, west of the railad, and rather north-west rrom Howe's barom. Hedirect..I cannot say positively about the rection of the stables; but they are on the iposite side of the railroad. «t M. Howe, sworn.. I reside in Rock" Hill, ia hill pWpnetor of the store spoken of. I as there on the 2nd of June. Parish and rilliford stepped into my house.. Parish and commenced playing billiards. Williford said > wanted to see Mr. Gordon, and returned in (out ten minutes and looked at our game,; ?his statement was objected to by defence, dmitted by the Court, and exception noted.] e then went to the front door of the house, aeard him say nothing before I heard the re»rt of the pistol. I could not see from the lliard tabte to the front door, on account of screenll t met "VVilliford coming toward the lliard tiple after he was shot. He said he as shot. I asked liim by whom, and he reied, by Jim Caston. I took down his pants id thought it was only a flesh wound, and so Id him. He sat down in a chair and died in few minutes. On taking down his pants, a stol fell out of his pants pocket. It was eked up by Mr. Roach. I have often noticed m witli a pistol when playing billiards with s coat off. He spent much of his time about y store, and often sat in front of it. He ent a portion of his time with me, and it is no unusual thing for him to sit in front of y house. I saw him on the day of the shootg, and from his actions I think he was sober, fter the shooting I saw the prisoner, some stance.15 or 20 feet.from my back door, cing it. He had a breech-loading Remington le in his hands, holding it in front of him^ Dr. R. H. Ho^e , sworn. I am a practicing ysician by profession. I saw C. L. Willird an hour and a half ^after he was shot, on e 2nd of June. I was'present at a post morn examination. The ball entered his right igh, ranging inward and upward, producing most instant death from internal hemor-j age. The evidence of internal hemorrhage is, on opening the abdomen, when between le-half and a gallon of blood w^s found in e cavity. Cross-examined by Mr. Wylie..The ball enred two and a half or three inches from the p joint. The course of the ball was sometiat superficial until it entered the abdomen, did not strike a bone. On probing, the obe made an angle with the thigh* a straight le with the thigh. Tlje course of a ball in -ssing through musales is likely to be deflect.. I think there was a little deflection in this se. near the entrance of the ball. The probe snt straight but a short distancev Redirect..I think the deceased was witn nis ajht side to the pistol. The muscles of the igh, with a man sitting down and his leg svated, contract, rendering them as hard as he was standing in an ordinary position. J. C. Hooper, sworn. I know the prisoner, F. Caston. I had a conversation with him sfore the shooting. I passed his door, and i called me in and asked me if I had heard rilliford make any threats about him, and I Id him, No. He then said if Church fooled ith him, he would shoot him. This was on riday before the shooting. There is a trial stice residing in Rock Hill. His office is on ain street, in the building of Friedheim's ore. A person could easily get to his office j the back way from Caston's store. The stance is about as far as from the court >use to Rose's hotel. There is no obstrucon on the way. Mr. Fewell is the trial jusce and attends regularly at his office. Cross-examined by Mr. Wylie..My Christian ime is John. #I first came to Rock Hill, six >ars ago; lived"there two years and then went > Virginia. I returned from Virginia to ock Hill. Done business for Bob Morrison* re did not get along very well; had a fight, remained in Virginia until I returned to ock Hill about a year ago. My business is ;at of bar-keeper. I followed it in Virginia id in Charlotte. Kept bar for Mr. Morrison Rock Hill. Also, for Roach; quit Roach le or two months ago.N Last employed in odenheimer's bar. Bodenheimer lives in orth Carolina. I quit him because he would )t pay me. He did not claim to me that I ,iled to properly account for money I relived. Ilis reason to me for closing was that mes are hard, and he would suspend business atil Fall. My conversation with Caston was itween 9 ami 10 o'clock in the forenoon.the jxt morning after the picnic on the 29th of Ay at Iredell Jones'. The conversation was the rear of Caston's store, He called me om the street front door to the back end of s store. As I passed up street, he wasstandig in his front door, and he took me back trough the store. I saw no one else until I ime out. I met Mr. Keistler as I left the WLIIa »»ta rtnr>Tiovflinr» fUaro uraa UIC. YY 1111C nc WIITC10U15 vitviv nwu ) one else in. The clerk was 011 the outside, he conversation lasted three or four minutes, did not do/business for Smith & Roach, but ir Roach. I was dismissed by him" because 3 said he could not pay my price. I have ?pt bar in Chester, for Nicholson. Had no ouble with him. I left Chester immediately !ter I quit Nicholson. I left that place after irk, but 011 the cars for Charlotte. Did not ?t off at Smith's Turnout. Got 011 at the ?pot in Chester. I have a family.a wife. I10 lives in Kernersville, N. C. I go home :ca8ionally. I have no children. Have had it very little law business.never but one ise. Why I know about Trial Justice Fewl's office hours, is by having observed him in s office. He goes to his dinner, and somemes leaves his office before night. I had a ise before Trial Justice Feweli with Boden;imer. I sued him for my pay. Do not reember the defence of Bodenheimer as to emblement of money by me, though lie claimI that the liquors did not hold out, which as because it was a new bar, and much treatg was done in order to attract customers, e complained that the whisky was short. I II sometimes about Williford's livery stable, generally knock around the bar-rooms, Aui >t doing anything now. Have employment White Sulphur Springs, Va., as soon as I ,11 leave to go there, I sleep in Johnson's iop at Rock Hill. Mr. Keistler has a room the same house. I sleep 011 quilts and ankets 011 the floor, in the harness shop of r. Johnson. When the conversation conienced in the store with Caston, I did not tell m in that conversation that the old man illiford, Church and Wade, were all cursing 111, prior to that conversation; but I did hear 1 Saturday. [Objection made by State to bringing out declaration of parties made at another time. Objection not sustained.] Q. Did you hear Church, his father, or Wade Williford, cursing prisoner on Saturday morning ? A. Church was not present when his father was talking-^-no one talking but Church's father. The way I came to speak to Caston. was tliat I happened to be passing. I haa started to Frew's.. When passing Caston's, he called me in. I came from Mitchell's barroom. I never did business for Mitchell. I was not discharged from a bar-room in Salisbury, N. C., but kept one there of my own. I was not on intimate,, but on friendly terms, . with Caston. At our interview, or conversation, in his store, he asked me in, as I passed by from the direction of the livery stables, or the bar-room near the stables. I boarded with Mrs. Octavia Owens; but I now buy provisions and have them cooked. I reported the conversation with Caston. He said he had understood they.the Willifords.had been talking about him, and if he fooled with him he would shoot him. Upon my oath I say that Caston said if Church had been talking about him or threatening him.I am not positive which word he used-«Jie would shoot him. I don't recollect whom I told it to, I related the circumstance of the conversation after Church was dead, speaking to a crowd, but don't remember who composed the crowd, nor what part of town we were in. but think ' it was on Monday evening of-the snooting. I am hot positive that Caston said that Church htfd threatened him. He said if Church fooled about him he would shoot him.. J. L. Walker, sworn. I was at a picnic attended by deceased and prisoner on the 29th of last May. I was present at an unpleasantness that occurred between same parties. Church stepped up to the buggy in which a young lady and Caston were seated, and said to the lady: "I think you have done me a dirty, mean triok." Mr. Caston then alighted from the buggy. I do not know what was next said by either party;but Churcb remarked to Caston, soon after, "If you take it up, you are a d.d s.n of a b.h_" Mr. Frew stepped ih between Caston and Church and led Church off. Soon after, Williford went to town and returned to the picnic grounds about 4 o'clock, P. M, The first difficulty occurred about 11 o'clock, A. M. I heard'the conversation between Williford and Caston. Williford stepped up to Caston, about 4 o'clock, P. M. Williford said, "I understand you want satisfaction to-morrow. I will give it to you at any time, or in 4ny shape that you want it. I will give you a fair fight," Williford was drink- ing in the morning, f ( Cross examinetTB^Mr. Wylie..My relations with the family of the deceased are friendly. of an intimate character. I was accompanied to the pichic on Thursday preceding the shooting by a young lady.. Can give her name if the Court directs. [Court decided the question competent.] Witness resumed. I was accompanied to the picnic by Miss Williford. sister of the deceased. I was a bosom friend of C. L. Williford; .but my feelings towards him or his family would not prevent me from telling the truth on this trial I remember a ; conversation in Ivy's store, and the remarks, I made -on a certain occasion since the homicide. I did not say that in the event of acquittal it would cause a difficulty; but that in such event I believed it would, and illustrated" my remark by a similar occurrence in Laurens county. I did not tell Bird Campbell, a witness iq this case, that he had better be careful how he testified. I may have spoken to him on the subject of the trial; but I did not know on which side he was summoned. I do not now remember when or where the ^nnvursoHfln n/>/>nTTWl Marshall Rattaree, sworn. I know the ' prisoner. He is left-handed. I was at the picnic on the 29th of May. I heard a conversation between the prisoner and Frew- It was after 1 ^rclock in the afternoon. Frew "was crying. Caston told him to preserve his coolness; that he had done so; this was not the time or place to have satisfaction. Crow-examined by Mr. Wylie..I am a first cousin of the deceased. I understood from the conversation that Frew was crying on account of a difficulty he had had with Williford, the deceased. Frew remarked that he regretted the row; but I do not know whether or not Caston was present. Williford apologized to Frew that afternoon. I did not speak to Caston that day after he left the buggy. I saw Williford and Frew go off and sit down. I,. did not see Williford and Caston together. After the homicide on Monday, I went to Frew and asked him if he^ heard Caston make that remark in reference to preserving his ooolness. . > that that was not the time or place for a difficulty. He replied that he was so excited at the time that he could not remember. I do not know whether or not Williford had a pistol the day of the picnic. I was not near the dis- . turbance at the picnic. Caston seemed excited when he approached me and Frew, and- < said he intended to have satisfaction. Caston came from toward Iredell Jones' house, when he approached the buggy. In our conversation at the buggy, my left side was next to Jones'house. I. am seventeen years of age, and son of John Rattareev State here rested. testimony for the defence. Mr. Wylie, of counsel for the defence, addressing the court and jury, remarked that while contrary to the general rule to make a statement in advance of the introduction of testimony, yet as the 8tate had told the jury what they expected to prove> he would depart from that rule, and outline what the defence proposed to prove ; and in doing so, would promise to prove nothing they could not,, From the line of our cross examination, our defence may already be conceived. We propose to show that this man has done no murder. That he has committed a homicide we do not propose to attempt to disprove. We do not stand here to deny that he has unfortunately deprived a fellow being of his life.not as a murderer, but, unfortunately, the cause of the death of a fellow man for justifiable reasons, and that he is not here as a cold-blooded mtiF"* derer, as the indictment proclaims him to have been ; but to the contrary, a man whose mind had been tortured and worked upon by the threats of ^desperate man. until he scarcely possessed peace of mind% We expect to prove that the best men, warned him that his life was in danger, and that they advised him to. arm himself and take care that his desperate pursuer should not get undue' advantage of him. We expect to prove the character of the deceased; not that we would throw dust on the grave of the dead, nor go farther in this direction than is absolutely necessary by our duty to the prisoner at the bar,. Than this we will go no farther; but we will go as far as we can under the law to prove that the deceased carried deadly weapons and made threats against the unfortunate prisoner; and when we conclude, we expect to show you that the prisoner stands before you, not as the malicious murderer, as charged in the indict-, ment, but one forced to commit the deed in order to save himself from bodily harm or to protect his own life. John R. London, sworn. I resjde in Rock Hill and am intendant of the town. I have lived there ten years. I am in business there. T lrtinw the nrisnner and have known him eisrbt or ten years. His general reputation as a peaceable, quiet, orderly man is good.as good as any man in the county. He is a member of the Episcopal church, I knew the deceased.. Knew him a good many years. He grew up there. Am acquainted with his general reputation as a turbulent man. Objected to by Mr. "Wilson, Sen.. of counsel for State, who argued before the court, denying the right of the defence, under the law, to attack the character of the deceased, unless it can be shown that he committed an overt act at the time of the occurrence. Counsel cited authorities to sustain his position that unless there was some overt act indicating^yiolence, evidence on the subject is irrelevant. Counsel proceeded to argue that the law gives no ri£ht to shoot down a dangerous man without his committing an overt act, and the defence lias no right to introduce testimony to attack character, unless an overt act is connected with the occurrence, Mr, Witherspoon^flfi the part of the defence, argued in support of the admissibility of the testimony, and cited authorities in support of his position. xne position 01 tne ueience was auauuncu by the Court, and witness resumed. Deceased was generally regarded as a dangerous man. His public reputation was that of a dangerous man. It was his habit to carry deadly weapons. He was looked upon as a man who carried a pistol, and his reputation v was that he was apt to use it. [continued on second page.]

Jn Jnkpcnbtnf Jamiln Jfor Commercial Interests |terms--$3 ... · PDF file"Tell me all aboutRachel, mother," said ... daughter restless orimpatient. "No, only tired." ... blush mantling

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

T ~ **5

lewis m. grist, proprietor, j Jn Jnkpcnbtnf Jamiln fUto'spaptr: Jfor % ^romofira of % political, jJotial, ^jrfnillnral anb Commercial Interests of tjie ^ont^. |terms--$3.oo a tear, in advance.

VOL. 25.YOEKYILLE, S. C., THURSDAY, JULY 3, 1879.' NO. 27.

fleeted foetrg.NO TIME FOR HATING.

Begone with feud ! away with strife ;Our human hearts unmating;

Let us be friends again ! This lifeI&all too short for hating ;

So dull the day, so dim the way,So rough the road we're faring.

Far better weal with faithful friend,Than stalk along unbearing.

The barren fig, the withered vine,Are types of selfish living ;

But souls that give, like mine and thine,Renew their life by giving.

While cypress waves o'er earthly gravesOn all the ways we're going,

Far better plant where seed is scant,Than tread on fruit that's growing.

Away with scorn ! Since die we mtist.And rest on one low pillow;

There are no rivals in tne dust.Nofoes beneath the willow ;

So dry the bowers, so few the flowers,Our earthly way discloses,

Far better stoop where daisies droop,Than tramp o'er broken roses!

Oh! what are all the joys we hold,Compared to joys above us,

And wnat are ranic and power and goldCompared to hearts that love as ?

So fleet our years, so fall of tears,So closely"death is waiting,

God give us space for loving graceBut leave no time for hating.

JU Original Jdartf.Written for the Yorkville Enquirer.

RACHEL RAY'S SECRET.CHAPTER XVII.

All yet seems well; and, if it end so meet,The bitter past, more welcome is the sweet.

Shakspeare."Tell me all about Rachel, mother," said

Magdalen Gray, as she sat in the cottage parloron the evening of her return from thecountry. "Your letters have not been verysatisfactory, somehow. They have only givenme a general idea of her affairs.howstrangely everything seems to have come

round!""Yes, indeed," rejoined Mrs. Gray. "Who

could have supposed that our quiet little reservedRachel had such a romantic history?I have seen very little of her since her hus.band's return. Her time has, of course, oeen

entirely occupied with nursing the brother,and so on.""The brother.that is, Mr. Vivian's brother?"asked Magdalen, in a constrained voice."Yes; the unfortunate gentleman, you

know, who flung himself out of the window.I wrote you about him."

"I forget what you said his name was.hisChristian name, I mean," said Magdalen, inthe same constrained manner.

"I don't think I mentioned, dear. I am

not sure that I ever heard. If I did, I do notremember it now," answered the widow. "AllI know about him is that he has long beeninsane,'and is now."

"Long been insane.why, I thought quitedifferently. I am sure you mentioned it onlyas a temporary thing," interrupted Magdalen,in a quick, impatient sort of way. "And heis quite well, quite sane again, you wrote."

"Yes, dear, I believe so," answered themother, a little wondering, a little troubled at

Magdalen's tone. The girl rose from herseat and walked to the window, stood there a

minute or two, nervously plucking at thewhite fringe of the curtain, then came backand threw herself in her chair again, with a

long, tremulous, half-suppressed sigh."Are you uuwell, love?" asked Mrs. Gray,

Tt ca nniionn ] fr\ ona hormiXIUUSIJTf It TVOC OKI UUUOUM1 WW uvv *JV»

daughter restless or impatient."No, only tired.""Tired from your journey, no doubt. You

must go to bed early, dear.""Perhaps so. Mother, is Rachel.does she

seem very, very happy ?""Her face looked like a sunbeam, in the

brief glimpses I have caught of it lately.Notwithstanding her illness, she is wonderfully

changed for the better, in her outward aspect.But, as I said, I have seen her but seldom,for some time past."

"I am so glad she is happy," said Magdalen,abstractedly. "I wonder how she couldbear such a grief as she did, and not betrayit." '

"Yes, she must have wonderful self-command."While they were yet talking, there was a

light tap at the door, and Rachel herself entered.Magdalen actually started at thetransformation in her appearance. No more

sombre draperies and melancholy looks robbedher of her youthfulness and clouded thesunny brightness of her face. In a light muslindress, adorned with blue ribbons, and thegreater adornment of smiles, and a happyblush mantling her still delicate check, shelooked like a girl of sixteen. She threw herarms around her friend, and kissed her againand again.

"I knew you were come home," she said,"and I was too anxious to see you to wait un-

til to-morrow. So Murrell.Mr. Vivian, thatis.brought me round, and will come backfor me after a while.""Why did he not come in, dear? We should

Tiave been so pleased to see him," said Mrs.Gray."He will come, very soon. But just now

"he is so busy attending to his brother, who.still requires constant nursing," Rachel answered,with a furtive glance at Magdalen as

she spoke. She saw that the latter shrank a

little, and hurriedly looked away. She hadnot yet spoken a word, and it was easy to perceivethat she was restless and discomposed.Rachel was longing to talk to her alone, but!there was no opportunity for that yet. GoodMrs. Gray had twenty questions to ask, andwould not be satisfied without a full and par-!ticular account of many things which had not

yet been explained to her. Then Jem came

in, and the conversation became more general.Magdalen roused herself by degrees to speakmore cheerfully and like her own self; butRachel saw that it was an effort, and, knowingher secret, had no difficulty in guessing thesubject of her thoughts.

The evening wore on, and feeling sure at

last that it would not be long before her hus-;band would come for her, Rachel made a

bold stroke to gain the opportunity she desired."Magdalen, have you finished unpacking?"

she asked. "Because, if not, won't you letme help you before I go home ?"She gave her a look full of meaning as she

spoke. The other met and understood it.A crimson flush mounted to her face, as,murmuring some rather incoherent reply, sheimmediately rose and left the parlor, Rachelfollowing her, and they were soon alone inthe little chamber where her trunk stoodhalf emptied of its contents.

"Magdalen, dear," Rachel began, too eager

to unburden herself to make any preliminary <

speeches, "if I ask you a question, will you i

give me a sincere answer ?""What question is it Rachel ?" asked Mag- £

dalen, her breath coming quick and fast. <

She was very much excited, it was easy to <

see, though she tried not to betray it. i"Do you remember," her friend went on,

sinking her voice to a whisper, as she put her {arms about the other's trembling form, "some t

time back.the last day I was with you here. t

oKnminn ma a niMnrp?" isuv""u6 ** r"~v

Magdalen nodded. She could not controlherself sufficiently to make any other rdply."You know, dear.don't you?.that the

original of that picture is very near you.that he is ray husband's brother," Rachelcontinued. "I see that you do. Now this isthe question I want to ask you.do you lovehira still ?"Magdalen trembled more than ever. She

looked with piteous entreaty into Rachel'seyes."You would not ask me that," she faltered s

presently, "unless you had some reason. Oh ! $

Rachel," she cried, suddenly breaking through ther enforced self-restraint, and clasping her [hands, as if in supplication, as she spoke, \

"for pity's sake tell me all you know at once. 1Has he spoken to you ? Has he explained ?". a

"Dear, he cannot explain," Rachel answer- ied gently. "Remember, bis mind has been a 1blank so long. But he has spoken to me.of fyou. He loves you as much as ever. He pnever, I am sure, intentionally, did you any iwrong. It is plain to me that he was not v

master of his own actions when he left you, e

as you say he did, so suddenly." 3"Vnn moan. woa inaanp " said Mafrda-

len, tfith a shudder. "Oh! Rachel, is it not r

a fearful thiDg?" r

"Yes, it is a terrible misfortune; but Mag- s

dalen, the doctors think his reason will not pleave him again. This last shock, caused by Ihis severe fall, seems to have revolutionized c

him. They think he is lastingly cured.""And he loves'me still," said Magdalen, I

below her breath. Her eyes looked far away, s

her bosom rising and falling with a suppress- c

ed agitation, a beatific smile, yet tremulouswith scarcely restrained tears, playing upon hher lips. Rachel almost feared she had saidtoo much. c

"You know, dear Magdalen," she went on, to

cautiously, "the doctors cannot be quite sure.

It may be, of course, that he will have some n

return, some temporary spells of his dis- bease."s"What do I care for that?" impetuously a

interrupted Magdalen. "That is not the v

question. I would not give that a thought. to

but the thing is, are you quite sure of what t

you told me just now.oh ! Rachel.it may be Iall a mistake. I dare not believe it."ii"Come and see him, if you don't believe il

it," rejoined Rachel. "He talked to me aboutyou for an hour yesterday. I believe the i<

sight of you would cure him at once." h"I could not go, you kuoW.that would be p

impossible. Besides.there is mother; itwould all seem dreadful to her. She never hkuew.you remember I told you. And Ra- v

chel," continued Magdalen, with returning ddoubt, "if he really meant it.then, long ago, s,

I mean.why did he persuade me not to tell ? v

Could he not have spoken, if he was siucere? &You have not explained that." c

"It was, I suppose, merely a caprice.some- c

thing which he could not now account for.With the shadow of his approaching afflic- v

tion clouding his mind, who can tell what hfancies may have possessed him ?" v

t "Ah ! Rachel, and with his mind so cloud- j]ed, how could he know if he really loved me f dThat may have been a fancy, too," said Mag- tdalen, despondeutly. "I know I am wrong tto build any hopes upon what you have told ](me." t

"Unbelieving girl! Listen, and I will con- fl

vince you that I have good reason for everyword that I have uttered," rejoined Rachel; dand, forthwith, she entered into the details of ?

the conversation between her brother-in-law tand herself, to which she had alluded, and e

which proved sufficiently convincing to assure ther listener that, whatever else was forgotten c

or indistinct in Maurice's mind, the remera- ?

brance of her and of his love for her, and the cexistence* of that love, in all its ardor, at the t

present time, were indubitable. _j"If mother can only be brought round to

listen to it," she said, at length, when her own tdoubts and arguments were fully laid at rest, t"But that will be a harder task than you im- c

agine.""Leave that to me," replied Rachel, hope- r

fully. "I'll bring in a verdict of a council of 8

physicians to satisfy her on the score of Mau- e

rice's health." t"At all events," said Magdalen, with a long t

drawn sierh. "if nothiner more ever comes of it, s

it is an inexpressible comfort to know that he g

did not wilfully deceive me. That will be a r

happiness to me all my life." t"I knew you would feel so dear. I know I

so well what it is to have the burden of a terrible,consuming doubt lifted from the heart, tafter bearing it so long," said Rachel, almost cin a whisper. Magdalen kissed her cheek. c

"You have said not one^ word of yourself, tRachel; and I meant to tell you how I re- a

joiced in your happiness, only my selfish fthoughts put it out of my head. How pa- c

tiently you bore your trouble, and how muchyou had to bear !" a

"Don't let us speak of it now," said Rachel r

tremulously. "I want to put the memory of g

that dreadful time far away from me, like a ^

nightmare, or a horrid dream. Indeed, it e

seems to me now like a dream. But you fdon't know, Magdalen.you could not guess. jthat almost the worst part of it all was see- (

ing that picture of Maurice, and taking it for ]his." 1"Why, are they so much alike?"("Almost exactly alike, only that illness has \

altered him ; but at the time that was paint- \ed, it might easily have been taken for myhusband's likeness. Oh, I felt as if you had f

struck me a mortal blow when you showed it jtn mp T thought, then, vou had been thevv **"v' " O"*' 'Jcauseof all my suffering." s

"And I never knew.you never betrayed j

your thoughts! Poor Rachel!.how you (

must have hated me," cried Magdaleu. "I ,

could so easily have explained.have told

you his Christian name.""Yes.it could have been explaiued ; but

I could not ask a question. I felt as if I were j s

turned into stone. It was my bewilderment !

that made nie get run over as I was going Jhome, I suppose. I was too blind and giddy I'to find my way. However, that was just the (best thing that could happen to. me, for (

through it I came to know Maurice's physi- <

r

jian, Dr. Snow; and how wonderfully all itsresults were brought about?"Here their conference was interrupted by a

lumraons from Mrs. Gray. "Mr. Vivian has:ome for you, Rachel. I have coaxed him to

;ome in for a few minutes, and he is waitingn the parlor.""Now you will see him,"*said Rachel, in a

jlad whisper, as she and her friend descendedhe stairs; "but remember what I told youibout the resemblance, and don't be as started

as I was."Although she was thus prepared, Magdaen'sheart beat painfully at the sight of the

loble, handsome face, so wonderful in its likelessto the one indellibly impressed upon her

ecollection; far more like it,, indeed, thanvas the original of that cherished remerant.the nresent time. Murrell thanked>oth her and her mother, in his own way.vhich was beyond comparison, as Rachelhought, with anybody's way in the wholevdrld besides.for their share in comfortingind helping his wife at a time when she so

orely needed friends. It was a subject too

ender for many words to be spoken on it,>ut he expressed all that he mearit to, andvas fully understood. He pressed Magdaen'shand kindly as he bid her good-night,md she fancied she read a certain meaningn his eyes; nor was she mistaken. Rachel :

tad, of course, told him' all about her, andtad quite won him over as an ally to herdans. They talked about her all the waytome. Rachel was charmed to find that heras favorably impressed with her, and was

ager to have the love-affair brought to a

atisfactory conclusion at once. <

"My dear child," Murrell said, with gentle 1

emonstrance, "you must not be in such un- (

easonable haste. Remember, it must beometime yet, ere Maurice, poor fellow, can <

resent himself in the character of a wooer, jJesides, there are certain drawbacks to be f

onsidered and overcome." }"You mean her mother's objections," said 1

lacbel. "But, after all, we don't know that f

he will have objections. And, if she has, we ]an persuade her out of them." j"1 am not sure that we can," rejoined herusband. 1

% i *.i 1"You can, if you try," said itacnei, wun

onfidence. "You can do whatever you pleaseo.""With you, my darling.that I know. But

fty influence with others may not be so unfunded,"was his reply. "Nor do I thinkuch objections as we anticipate would be at11 unreasonable or surprising. I know too

rail my own horror of that dreadful disease,o feel desirous of persuading any one to run

he risk of having it entailed upon others.Sven if Maurice should escape a return of the[lfliction, how do we know that his children,f he had any, would prove exempt?""Well, I suppose we must leave it to Province,"said Rachel with a sigh. "But I did

ope that now everything would come hapilyround!""I hope so, too, my love. But I think we

ad better now remain passive for a littlediile, having done what it seemed right to

o, and wait for time to develop farther reults,"answered Murrell. And 'Rachel, torhom he was now, as ever, an oracle, submitedto his judgment, and, for the present, deidednot to make any farther efforts in theause which she had so much at heart.Not the less, however, did she eagerly

/atch the progress of events; nor did she feellerself at all bound to check the confidences?hich Maurice was continually ready to pournto her ear. He was most eager to see Maglalen,and to learn from her own lips thathe former tie between them was still rememleredby her; and Dr. Snow, to whom at

ength she spoke of this desire, undertook to :3 ^ rttAAr* V» Arrt ^

le a meuium ui uuiuiuuuikiiuuii uc^nccu mtui,

,nd, still better, a mediator with Mrs. Gray.The old lady was greatly overcome by the j

lisclosures made to her, and for some time it <

pas doubtful whether her consent to a uniontetween Maurice and her daughter could .

ver be won. But Magdaleu, when she found 1hat her mother knew all, plead her own

ause with an earnestuess that was hard towithstand. Mrs. Gray was astonished at theoncentrated passion of the girl's nature, forhe first time revealed to her in this outpour-ng of her long hidden love and grief, herlopes and fears; she had never dreamed ofhe intensity of feeling that had lain bidden>eneath that unusually placid and even

heerful exterior.At last she consented to go and see Mau-

ice, who was still far too weak to come andee her. The interview between them, if not ;

xactly a conclusive one, proved favorableo the lovers' hopes. It was arranged that no

>ar to their intercourse should be offered;md if no promise was asked or given, iteeired, nevertheless, an understood thing thatnatters should be allowed, without opposition,o arrange themselves as circumstances mighttest dictate.As soon as the invalid was strong enough,

he family party removed to Woodstock, theild Virginia home. Mrs. Gray and her chilIrenwere urged to come, too; but this iuvitaionshe declined. At some future day, shemd Magdalen might pay Rachel a visit, butor the present they must continue in tKe[uiet pursuit of their usual duties at home.Letters passed frequently between Maurice

md Magdalen, the former writing more andnore hopefully, and telling her always ofteadily improving health. At last his lettersvere followed by a visit from himself, looking,sxcept for his gray hair, like the Maurice of'/ifmorJavt Ho hnrl mmi> now Vip snirl tr»V/l UIVI UMJ Ul v W>MV V .. | ..v

dead in earnest for a favorable hearing.jould it not be definitely settled whetherVlagdalen was to marry him, and if so, when?Mrs Gray hesitated, doubted, and finally gave;onsent, which, indeed, she had already givenn her heart. Only, it was the hardest thingu the world for her to let Magdalen go."Never mind, mother," said Jem. "You

ind I'll keep house together, and be as hapiyas the day is long."

"Better, than that," said Maurice. "Youshall both come and live with me, and thereleed not be any partings at all." And so, to

everybody's satisfaction, it was finally arranged.[conclusion next week.]

It was the Duke of Wellington whomid "great nations cannot wage little wars,"ind England will be apt to realize the force o 1

diis remark when she gets through with thisZulu business. Twenty-five hundred Englishlienhave already perished in that war, 2(y300 regulars are now in the field, and the costif the war is 82,500,000 a week. Nothing?ould be worse than this statement.

(Etouft of \i

TRIAL f

OF j

, JAMES P. OASTON ;FOR THE MURDER OF 1

CHURCHILL L. WIM.IF0RD. <

In the Courtof General Sessions, June Term, 1879. jjBY OUR OWN REPORTER. .t

No trial in the sessions court of York coun- *

ty, for many years past, if ever, has created c

such general public interest as the case of the *State vs. James P. Caston, indicted for the 1murder of Churchill L. Williford, in Hock 1

Hill, oik the 2nd day of last month. On the <

morning of that day, the deceased, a young Jman who had barely attained his majority.of '

respectable family, of gay and lively tempera- r

ment, frank and open-heartedj but of combat- c

ive temperament, perhaps, when under the ^

baneful influence of strong drink.left York- £ville in the exuberance of youthful health and tthe bright anticipations of a new life, which the expressed to liis companion on the road, as 8

his determination talead, a/id ere the noon- e

day sun had ci\388exivthe iqfcridian the start- 8

ling intylligenceWi& conveyed here by tele- 8

graph that he wqs dead.tie victim of a pis- Ftol in the hands of James E. Caston, likewise 1;

a young man, but little the} senior of his vie- ttim.a man of rerairkably qniet, peaceable dis- 8

position.a merchant, a consistent member ofa Christian denomination, and whose generaldeportment had even been rdgarded as a model tfor even those of mkturer wars. The slayerwas committed to tlife jail of York county on othe afternoon of the* occurrence, and on the \following day the mortal remains of his victim jiwere consigned to thel earth! tAt that time it wap difficult to obtain all I

the facts which led to tbe unfortunate occur- nrence; nor, indeed, di 1 weJ deem it prudent,' rin view of the early ap proaching term of the s:sourt, to publish any (f t^ie many versions of- sthe affair, preferring U await the legal inves- atigation and lay before th£ public the facts as yelicited in the court of justice. f<On Monday afternoo i of last week the pris- a

Dner was arraigned bii'ore Judge Thomson^ ^md entered his plea off npt guilty, the State oaeing represented by Mr.TSolicitor Gaston, as- alisted by Giles J. PattCrapn, Esq., of the Ches- y;er bar, and Messrs. Wilson & Wilson, of the eYorkville bar. The prisoner was represented auy an array of equally eminent counsel, con- y

listing of Messrs. Wifhtrspoon & Spencer, J. yP. Gage, Esq., and J.J 0. Witlierspoon, Esq., y)f the Yorkvillebar, Jrim J. D. Wylie, Esq., of t*the Lancaster bar. J / tlAfter the arraignment and pleading, al- k

thoueh the prisoner Ms entitled by the prac- siiice in this State, to Aree days' notice from n:he date of the bill q# indictment, which was rireturned in court oniMonday, yet his counsel owaived the right, andf, by consent, the trial was j\jet for Wednesday morning at 10 o'clock. hThe court-room w/is filled with eager specta- e:

:ors long before the hour appointed, and so h)ppressive was the heat in the overcrowded broom, that the sheriff found it necessary to hlend for a carpenter to remove the entire sashfrom the windows in order to admit proper ^ventilation. gAt 10 o'clock, the prisoner, cleanly shaven 0md neatly and faultlessly attired in a suit of 0ilack, was led into the court room, and seated ajlearhis counsels 0The regularpanel, consisting of thirty-six y_

lames, was as follows: Wm. Whyte, W. N. ^Jackson, W. W. Castles, J. P. Hutchison, H. gl]1 Strauss, W. S. Creighton, Frank Edwards, VW. M. McGill, Wm. Borders, J. A. Carroll, ^D. J. Goode, Wm. Choate, G. R. Boleyn, John t(Ltattaree, W. J. Martin, John B. Lowry, Jef- 01ferson Ellis, J. Frank Workman, L. R. Wil- $iams, J. C. McCully, Greene Bratton, T. S t]Tefferys,Samuel Brown, J. H. Crawford, A. ^J. Davinney, Joseph Black, L. R. Pierce. L. p,L. Smith, Oscar Chambers, Allen Hall, S. N {JLove, W. II. Herndon, Iredell Jones, Thomas j,R. Martin, John M. Jackson, S. J. Kimbrell. t(Mr. Workman, of the original panel, was ex- ^;used on account of sickness, and L. R. Wil- ^iams, who was among those summoned by J

ipecial venire on the previous day, to complete ^;he panel, was excused on account of the of- ^ice he holds as school-trustee.J* Counsel for ^lefence pressed their right fSr a full panel, ^md, accordingly, his Honor granted an order hfor a special venire of two jurorsXo supply the $vacancies. Under supervision of Jury Com- ^missioner D. C. McKinney, the names of John 0It. Ferguson and George A. Wilkerson w ere ^Irawn. Mr. Ferguson resides in YorkviHe, 0jut Mr. Wilkerson lives in the country, ^"-wo miles from the court house. He was at aliis home, and over an hour intervened before j.,lie could be summoned and make his appearmcein the court-room. ^Arriving, and thepanel being complete, the drawing of the Piury was proceeded with, after the request by P[. D. Witherspoon, Esq., of counsel for defence, Vthat each juror be put upon his voir dire. No £abjection being made by State's counsel, hisHonor so ordered. n

The names of the jurors were drawn in the a

following order, and the panel exhausted be- (fore the tenth juror was obtained, the State ^(laving the right to two peremptory chal- ,

lenges: Wm. Whyte, accepted ; W. N. Jack- ^son, rejected; W. W. Castles, accepted ; JohnG. Ferguson, rejected on his voir dire* H. C. ,

Strauss, same; James P. Hutchison,"accepted; W. S. Creighton, peremptorily challenged ^by the State; Franklin Edwards, rejected; ^George A. Wilkerson, rejected; W. M. McGrill,accepted ; Wm. Borders, accepted ; J. A. TCarroll, rejected on his voir dire; D. J. Goode, *

accepted; Wm. Choate, rejected; G. R. Bo- £leyn, rejected ; John Rittaree, answered thathe is a relative of deceived; W. J. Martin, re- ®

jected; John B. Low::y, accepted; Jefferson jiEllis, rejected; J. C. McCully, rejected ; ^Greene Bratton, rejected; T. S. Jefferys, re- Jjected on his voir dire; A. J. Davinney, rejected;Joseph Black, rejected ; L. R. Pierce, ?rejected on his voir din; L. L. Smith, accept- ^ed; Oscar Chambers, rejected ; Allen Hall, rejected;S. M. Love, rejected on his voir dire;W. H. Henidon, same; Iredell Jonetr same; ^Thomas Martin, rejected; John M. Jacksqn, faccepted; S. J. Kimbi.-ell, peremptorily chal- flenged by the State. fThis exhausted the panel, leaving three* ju- \

rors yet to be drawn. On motion of Solicitor t,Gaston, his Honor granted an order for a spe- Jcial venire of twelve to be drawn immediatelyfrom the jury box, which was done as follows: .

W. C. Latimer, J. B. Thomasson. Wm. Rawls, c

J. B. Scott, W. R. Bell, T. B. Barnett, A. F. e,McConnell, Solomon Harshaw, J. C. Kuyken- Jdal, T. M. Dobson, J. R. Witherspoon, NelsonDavies.

c

After the names were drawn and the venire

issued, court adjourned until 4o'clock, P. M.,the jurors qualified to serve in the case beingplaced under charge of a constable, and admonishedto have no communication with anyperson on the subject of the trial now progressing.Court convened promptly at 4 o'clock P. M.,

and all of the special venire answered to theirnames except wm. Rawls, Solomon Harshawand Nelson Davies, of whom the latter couldnot be found. From this list only one jurorwas obtained, the names being drawn withthe following result: J. B. Thomasson, excused011 his voir dire; J. C. Kuykendal, same;Joseph It. Witherspoon, same; W. C. Latimer,rejected; J. B. Scott, excused on hisvoir dire; T. M. Dobson, same; W. R. Bell,rejected ; T. B. Barnett, accepted ; A. F. McConnell,excused on his voir dire.This exhausted the list, and a venire was

ordered for twenty jurors, who were drawnfrom the box as follows: Hamilton Thomasson.R. Frank Clark, L. B. Sherer, Wm. M.Corkill, J. A. Ratchford, J. F. Carson, W. F.Gardner, J. M. Templeton, S. T. Ferguson,M, L. Thomasson, R. L. Brown, Henry Jackson,M. H. Jackson, A. Sylvanus Wallace,James Fitchett, Samuel Staraes, W. L. McLeave,J. A. Erwin, Knox Williams, RobertM. Lindsay. While the drawing was progressing,Win. Rawls and Solomon Harshaw appearedin Court, and were notified to lie in attendanceat 10 o'clock on Thursday morning,when court adjourned to that hour.OrTthe convening of the court on Thursday

morning, all the jurors of the second sj>ecialvenire, as also Nelson Davies of the first, answeredto their mimes. Those of the firstvenire, who were absent on Wednesday.Wm.Rawls, Nelson Davies and Solomon Harshaw.were placed in the box and drawn before usingthe names of the second venire. The name ofWilliam Rawls was drawn first and he was accepted.The names of Nelson Davies and Sol-

toon Harshaw were then drawn respectively, aimd both rejected. The second venire was then tl)laced in the box, and the first name drawn I'vas that of It. L. Brown, who was accepted, r<md he completed the jury, which is as follows: bl(Vim. Whyte, W. M. Castles, James P. Hutch- p]son, W. M. McGill, Wm. Borders, D. J. Good, p]rohn B. Lowry, L. L. Smith, John M. Jack- p<ion, T. B. Barnett, William Rawls and R. L. tlEfcwn. a*

The jury then retired to their room and tlsleeted L. L. Smith as foreman, and after re- txluraimf their seats, the indictment was read ir)y fcfie clerk, when Mr. Solicitor Gaston opened c<

-jre case by saying.JpiMay it please the Court: It is customary in

sases of this magnitude to outline to the jury Che proof by which the State expects to estab- Ikish the allegations of the indictment. I will tc

- . - » mi n

>riet!y comply w;tn tins custom, rue estate v/

ixpects to prove that 011 the second day of se

Tune, 1879, the deceased, having been absent iror several days from pis home in Rock Hill, h<eturned there; that 1 e took a seat in front b;>f a store in that tow 1, at a place which he tltras accustomed to o< cupy when at leisure; aihat he sat with his < hair thrown back and mlis leg elevated in an kttitude of repose; ahd dihat while the deceased sat quietly in this po- siition, with his head turned away, the prison- Hr came to the door of his own.an adjoining w

tore.and extending his body forward, with oipistol in Ills left hand, shot the deceased, in- w

licting a mortal wound, of which he almost ti;ostantly died! We iexpect"to prove further what the prisoner, before this occurrence, had sitated that he wouldf shoot the deceased; I

testimony/for tiie state. / hiThe State then introduced its testimony for

he prosecution. // YII. P. Haslam, sworn. Was in Rock Hill w

n the 2nd day of .June. Knew Churchill L. ri

Villiford; he is depul. He died from an in- h<ury received at Rdck Hill, in this county^ on lehe 2nd day of jiine. 1 was standing near ^lagans' store, on the street.Railroad street. <fear where the shqoting occurred. The street 4uns parallel with the railroad oh the west P1

T maa afonrllnrr nn fctiA OOflt. Sldft flf tllfi Jh(troet, in front Tf Hagans' fltore, leaning jfeigainst a sign pott. Churchill L. Willifordi piraji sitting in front of Howe's bar-room, about* Warty feet from where I was /Standing. I ha<| ro

jclear "view of htoi: there were no obstruci i'o

ions between us.jL When I first saw the pri»ner, he was standing in his own store dooi, dibout twenty feet from where the deceased ojras sitting. Hope's store adjoins the prisonr'sstore. The deceased was leaning ba£k ai

gainst the building, his feet crossed, and ihe wras on the side or lie door farthest from Wthere the prisonerwas standings Thedeceaped Iras sitting talkmg t<* the bar-tender, hislat- heention directed into Howe's house. I eaw attie prisoner copm tq^his door, and as soonas [1e came to the doo/, he fired at deceased.Mas ADon as Williford was shot, he exclaimed* v'0 Hly God I" and ripi or reeled into Howe'l bar- 11Dom. Caston remained in his door a ^cond pcr so after shooting. After the shooting, I biimped into tbe street and Caston went into ais store, and I went to the store wherh I am biogaged. Caston shot with a pistol, field in wiis left hand. I h4ve known Caston tWo years, piut do not know whether or not h^ is left- an

anded.~/ to

Cross-examined by Mr. Wylie..I sfco. a na- a:

ive of New Jersey. I was in tlie United Pftates Army, a,nd was discharged od the 9th Pjf January, 1876. My employment at the time hjf the shooting was that of a baiker. The hiign post against which I was leaning stands m;n the outeredge ofthe guttering of the street? spdeceased was sittiDg on the south side of w;

[owe's bar-room door, occupying/ a common pialit-bottom chair, X think, but am not posi- inive. The face of deceased was tprned to the A:ist, his face iaartly!in the direction of Cas- dim's store. He could have seen Caston if his fara had been turned in the direction of his ril

oor.^The chair in Which Willjftard was sitingwns leaning ag^inst'.the Muse.Howe's pliar-room. I cannot i^ay whether or not both foosts were against the building. Williford's thody was turned in the chair, facin&the build- tei

lg. The chair was (Jverturned.overturned th)ward the front. I flaw pail; of Caston's al;ody. Was prevented from seeing all his body rhy an obstruction between two stores.a tin wi

uttering enclosed in jvood? six inches from or

le building. This guttering prevented me th;om seeing the whole of his^body. Castonras in his door when h|e fired.fljHe fired with teis left hand. He was standinglon the step of hiis door. The lower stfep projects a little in w]ront of the building. The step is the same iteight as the pavement.even,with the surface prf pavement. From the sign-post the distance iho the line of buildings; is seven or eight feet, pan the same side of the street. The next eduilding north is Howe*s; the next is Caston's, Ca11 in same block. I was about sixty feet dis- W(ant from the scene of the firing.Redirect..Mr. Williford wis talking to some rijerson in Howe's store.! His face was looking thato the store.the side of his face next to el(!aston's, and the front towards Howe's store, if'risoner was on his own step when he fired,.'here is no lower graded step than the floor; J.o difference in the grade between the step bend the floor of the building. IkTo Mr. Wylie, by permission of Solicitor.. \Y

Jannot say how long Williford had been sit- toing there. I stated tothe coroner that I went w

own street on business. I saw him sitting Fhere two or three minutes.' juTo the Solicitor..The question proposed to M

ie put to the witness was the introduction of sttew matter, which was objected to by the bjefence. and objection sustained by the court, diWitness was then withdrawn. h<Charles Patton, sworn. I was in Rock ti

lill on the 2n(T~0f--31mt£,-aml-flaw the occur- tience. At the time, I was workinjhacross thetreet, in the depot sliedj about eighty feet nilistant. There was no obstruction between y(ae and the place where the shooting occurred, tcwas working across the street, dressing a r

lank, and as I turned in'that direction, duingmy work, I saw Ckston step to the door ind shoot at Williford-with a pistol. As Cas- ron shot, Williford was leaning against the tlvail, sitting in a chaiiuLWben shot, Williford aiaised from the chair reeled into the door. jnLs he went into the door,; Caston cocked his 0i»istol. I saw him take it down, and think ble cocked it from the fact that he raised it, as ^f to shoot again. Wlien he fired, hexwas lean- n<

ng forward out of the door, standing on the faloor-sill. After firing, he( made a second at- Ce

empt to shoot, and then turned and went in- tio his store. Williford was in my view. There ujvas no obstruction. Williford had no weapon ixIrawn or exposed. Williford's head was turn- n,d "towards Howe's' doorj in the direction of mGaston's house. Caston'adoor was to Williord'sright. Williford could not see Gaston's frloor on account of an obstruction. hiCrnss^xuminedJjtfMr^ Wjilie..I was work- in

n^iirftock-HtlTaiul resided there at the time, tldy parents live in Charlotte. I am nineteen ctrears of age. I had been living in Rock Hill stor one \veek prior to the 2nd of June. I left m

lock Hill on the WedneMay night following The shooting on Monday..' I returned to Rock Ilill last Friday, because I was summoned to fcittend here as a witness." I was summoned in h<loach's store on the day after the occurrence, k<aid gave bond for pay appearance here. My trloss turned me off because I went to a picnic aivithout his consent. The picnic or excursion divas by the Pioneer FireCompany from Char- g<otte to Winnsboro. I went down, and re- d<urned 011 thtfsame evening, and continued on w

0 Charlotte. /^The reason why I returned to oc

lock Hill, Fhday, was because I was summon- bjd to be here 011 the fourth Monday, and I c?

bought I had better come in time. I did not elvant to confer with anybody. I stopped at hidr. Roach's, where I Ifoarded before. I have tilad 110 conversation In Rock Hill with any cs

sidy since Friday as td the nature of my tes- Inimony. Mr. Gjiston (the Solicitor) lias con- nif.rrpfi with nifi.Gl I was workinc 011 a tempo- btary bench 80 oij?Rl fetjit from the shooting. I ec

mow the distance by having stepped it, which w

did day before yesterday. It is '27 steps or inards. I stepped it in company with Mr. IIol- IIer, who stepped it also, We did not talk ai

,lx)ut the homicide. iFrom where I was work- Ing at the time of the shooting, the distance nc

s 64 feet by measurement. I measured the atlistances at the suggestion of some one. I ca

liink Mr. Thompson, a carpenter in Rock slifill, suggested tlie measurement. inCalvin G. Parish, sworn.. On the morn- hi

irg-nf the2ntf of June! was in Rock Hill. MVent from Yorkville? and left between 7 and m

o'clock in the morning. Churchill L. Willi- hiold went with me. He had been in Yorkville "VVince the Friday previous. We went over on hiMonday morning. When we arrived at Rock or

1111, we first went to his father's livery stable,

ad from there to his father's house. Fromlere we went to Gordon's hotel- and next tovy's store. Then, I think, to Hagans' barx>mto play billiards; but not liking his tale,we went to Howe's and commenced tolay, when Williford asked Howe to take hislace andjulay with me. Williford then step3dout^TVVhile we were playing, and beforele ganl| was finished, I heard the report ofpistol.' I thought I heard him talking at

le door before the pistol fired.. Ithmk he had3en out ten or fifteen minutes before the firig.I heard Williford's voice in ordinaryjnversation. On hearing the report of theistol, I started fort the front dodr and met/"illiiord, who fait to me, "I am shot; Jimaston has killed i le." I spok/ to him, but3 made no reply. [ soon gJterwards stepped> the back door of he same building and sawaston twenty step i distant, / suppose. Helemed to be look ng in, mid held a guni his hands. I tolf Mrs H^ve to look out.3 might be shot; And Howe stepped 10 meick door and told Cast<m not to shoot inlere. Caston held he g\p\ in both his handsid was looking tov ards/Howe's-rtK was a

usket; I think a ree^i-loader.TjVVilliforded in about 10 or .5 minutes aftpr he waslot. He was taken ,o /is father's residence,e died in this coui if. During the time fas with him that day/he was not in company' the prisoner. He wus absent from me onlybile5 was playing billiards.while he was at.le ffont door of the same house in which Ias playing. To the best of my knowledge thelooting was between 11 and 12 o'clock, A. M.was to have taken dinner with Williford ats father's house that day.jT*Cfoss-examined by ifr^Wylie..I reside inoikville. I saw Caston making across toardsGordon's hotel. There was a pile oflpbish lying near the way he was going, butv liad passed that, I would suppose, to hisrt, before I saw him. He made no demonrationto ffre while in rear of Howe's. I) not know the fact that Mr. "Williford hadpistoljtn his person, though I know he hadle here on Saturday,, I saw no pistol after3 was shot. Williford did not leave mypresicethat day, only during the time I was

aying billiards; he was with me all the time,re drove to the livery stable, west of the railad,and rather north-west rrom Howe's barom.Hedirect..I cannot say positively about therection of the stables; but they are on theiposite side of the railroad.«t M. Howe, sworn.. I reside in Rock" Hill,ia hill pWpnetor of the store spoken of. Ias there on the 2nd of June. Parish andrilliford stepped into my house.. Parish andcommenced playing billiards. Williford said> wanted to see Mr. Gordon, and returned in(out ten minutes and looked at our game,;?his statement was objected to by defence,dmitted by the Court, and exception noted.]e then went to the front door of the house,aeard him say nothing before I heard the re»rtof the pistol. I could not see from thelliard tabte to the front door, on account ofscreenll t met "VVilliford coming toward thelliard tiple after he was shot. He said heas shot. I asked liim by whom, and he reied,by Jim Caston. I took down his pantsid thought it was only a flesh wound, and soId him. He sat down in a chair and died infew minutes. On taking down his pants, astol fell out of his pants pocket. It waseked up by Mr. Roach. I have often noticedm witli a pistol when playing billiards withs coat off. He spent much of his time abouty store, and often sat in front of it. Heent a portion of his time with me, and itis no unusual thing for him to sit in front ofy house. I saw him on the day of the shootg,and from his actions I think he was sober,fter the shooting I saw the prisoner, somestance.15 or 20 feet.from my back door,cing it. He had a breech-loading Remingtonle in his hands, holding it in front of him^Dr. R. H. Ho^e , sworn. I am a practicingysician by profession. I saw C. L. Willirdan hour and a half^after he was shot, one 2nd of June. I was'present at a post mornexamination. The ball entered his rightigh, ranging inward and upward, producingmost instant death from internal hemor-jage. The evidence of internal hemorrhageis, on opening the abdomen, when betweenle-half and a gallon of blood w^s found ine cavity.Cross-examined by Mr. Wylie..The ball enredtwo and a half or three inches from thep joint. The course of the ball was sometiatsuperficial until it entered the abdomen,did not strike a bone. On probing, the

obe made an angle with the thigh* a straightle with the thigh. Tlje course of a ball in-ssing through musales is likely to be deflect..I think there was a little deflection in thisse. near the entrance of the ball. The probesnt straight but a short distancevRedirect..I think the deceased was witn nis

ajht side to the pistol. The muscles of theigh, with a man sitting down and his legsvated, contract, rendering them as hard ashe was standing in an ordinary position.J. C. Hooper, sworn. I know the prisoner,F. Caston. I had a conversation with himsfore the shooting. I passed his door, andi called me in and asked me if I had heardrilliford make any threats about him, and IId him, No. He then said if Church fooledith him, he would shoot him. This was on

riday before the shooting. There is a trialstice residing in Rock Hill. His office is onain street, in the building of Friedheim'sore. A person could easily get to his officej the back way from Caston's store. Thestance is about as far as from the court>use to Rose's hotel. There is no obstruconon the way. Mr. Fewell is the trial jusceand attends regularly at his office.Cross-examined by Mr. Wylie..My Christianime is John. #I first came to Rock Hill, six>ars ago; lived"there two years and then went> Virginia. I returned from Virginia toock Hill. Done business for Bob Morrison*re did not get along very well; had a fight,remained in Virginia until I returned toock Hill about a year ago. My business is;at of bar-keeper. I followed it in Virginiaid in Charlotte. Kept bar for Mr. MorrisonRock Hill. Also, for Roach; quit Roach

le or two months ago.N Last employed inodenheimer's bar. Bodenheimer lives inorth Carolina. I quit him because he would)t pay me. He did not claim to me that I,iled to properly account for money I relived.Ilis reason to me for closing was thatmes are hard, and he would suspend businessatil Fall. My conversation with Caston wasitween 9 ami 10 o'clock in the forenoon.thejxt morning after the picnic on the 29th ofAy at Iredell Jones'. The conversation wasthe rear of Caston's store, He called meom the street front door to the back end ofs store. As I passed up street, he wasstandigin his front door, and he took me backtrough the store. I saw no one else until Iime out. I met Mr. Keistler as I left the

WLIIa »»ta rtnr>Tiovflinr» fUaro uraaUIC. YY 1111C nc WIITC10U15 vitviv nwu

) one else in. The clerk was 011 the outside,he conversation lasted three or four minutes,did not do/business for Smith & Roach, butir Roach. I was dismissed by him" because3 said he could not pay my price. I have?pt bar in Chester, for Nicholson. Had noouble with him. I left Chester immediately!ter I quit Nicholson. I left that place afterirk, but 011 the cars for Charlotte. Did not?t off at Smith's Turnout. Got 011 at the?pot in Chester. I have a family.a wife.I10 lives in Kernersville, N. C. I go home:ca8ionally. I have no children. Have hadit very little law business.never but one

ise. Why I know about Trial Justice Fewl'soffice hours, is by having observed him ins office. He goes to his dinner, and somemesleaves his office before night. I had a

ise before Trial Justice Feweli with Boden;imer.I sued him for my pay. Do not reemberthe defence of Bodenheimer as to emblementof money by me, though lie claimIthat the liquors did not hold out, whichas because it was a new bar, and much treatgwas done in order to attract customers,e complained that the whisky was short. III sometimes about Williford's livery stable,generally knock around the bar-rooms, Aui>t doing anything now. Have employmentWhite Sulphur Springs, Va., as soon as I

,11 leave to go there, I sleep in Johnson'siop at Rock Hill. Mr. Keistler has a roomthe same house. I sleep 011 quilts and

ankets 011 the floor, in the harness shop ofr. Johnson. When the conversation coniencedin the store with Caston, I did not tellm in that conversation that the old man

illiford, Church and Wade, were all cursing111, prior to that conversation; but I did hear1 Saturday.[Objection made by State to bringing out

declaration of parties made at another time.Objection not sustained.]Q. Did you hear Church, his father, or Wade

Williford, cursing prisoner on Saturday morning? A. Church was not present when hisfather was talking-^-noone talkingbutChurch'sfather. The way I came to speak to Caston.was tliat I happened to be passing. I haastarted to Frew's.. When passing Caston's,he called me in. I came from Mitchell's barroom.I never did business for Mitchell. Iwas not discharged from a bar-room in Salisbury,N. C., but kept one there of my own. Iwas not on intimate,, but on friendly terms, .

with Caston. At our interview, or conversation,in his store, he asked me in, as I passedby from the direction of the livery stables, orthe bar-room near the stables. I boarded withMrs. Octavia Owens; but I now buy provisionsand have them cooked. I reported theconversation with Caston. He said he hadunderstood they.the Willifords.had beentalking about him, and if he fooled withhim he would shoot him. Upon my oath Isay that Caston said if Church had been talkingabout him or threatening him.I am notpositive which word he used-«Jie would shoothim. I don't recollect whom I told it to, Irelated the circumstance of the conversationafter Church was dead, speaking to a crowd,but don't remember who composed the crowd,nor what part of town we were in. but think '

it was on Monday evening of-the snooting. Iam hot positive that Caston said that Churchhtfd threatened him. He said if Church fooledabout him he would shoot him..

J. L. Walker, sworn. I was at a picnicattended by deceased and prisoner on the 29thof last May. I was present at an unpleasantnessthat occurred between same parties.Church stepped up to the buggy in which ayoung lady and Caston were seated, and saidto the lady: "I think you have done me a

dirty, mean triok." Mr. Caston then alightedfrom the buggy. I do not know what wasnext said by either party;but Churcb remarkedto Caston, soon after, "If you take it up, youare a d.d s.n of a b.h_" Mr. Frew steppedih between Caston and Church and led Churchoff. Soon after, Williford went to town andreturned to the picnic grounds about 4 o'clock,P. M, The first difficulty occurred about 11o'clock, A. M. I heard'the conversation betweenWilliford and Caston. Williford steppedup to Caston, about 4 o'clock, P. M. Willifordsaid, "I understand you want satisfactionto-morrow. I will give it to you at anytime, or in 4ny shape that youwant it. I willgive you a fair fight," Williford was drink-ing in the morning,f (

Cross examinetTB^Mr. Wylie..My relationswith the family of the deceased are friendly.of an intimate character. I was accompaniedto the pichic on Thursdaypreceding the shootingby a young lady.. Can give her name ifthe Court directs. [Court decided the questioncompetent.] Witness resumed. I was accompaniedto the picnic by Miss Williford.sister of the deceased. I was a bosom friendof C. L. Williford; .but my feelings towardshim or his family would not prevent me fromtelling the truth on this trial I remember a ;conversation in Ivy's store, and the remarks,I made -on a certain occasion since the homicide.I did not say that in the event of acquittalit would cause a difficulty; but that insuch event I believed it would, and illustrated"my remark by a similar occurrence in Laurenscounty. I did not tell Bird Campbell, awitness iq this case, that he had better becareful how he testified. I may have spokento him on the subject of the trial; but I didnot know on which side he was summoned.I do not now remember when or where the^nnvursoHfln n/>/>nTTWlMarshall Rattaree, sworn. I know the '

prisoner. He is left-handed. I was at the picnicon the 29th ofMay. I heard a conversationbetween the prisoner and Frew- It was after 1^rclock in the afternoon. Frew "was crying.Caston told him to preserve his coolness; thathe had done so; this was not the time or placeto have satisfaction.

Crow-examined by Mr. Wylie..I am a firstcousin of the deceased. I understood from theconversation that Frew was crying on accountof a difficulty he had had with Williford, thedeceased. Frew remarked that he regrettedthe row; but I do not know whether or notCaston was present. Williford apologized toFrew that afternoon. I did not speak to Castonthat day after he left the buggy. I sawWilliford and Frew go off and sit down. I,.did not see Williford and Caston together.After thehomicide on Monday, Iwent to Frewand asked him if he^heard Caston make thatremark in reference to preservinghis ooolness. .

>

that that was not the time or place for a difficulty.He replied that he was so excited atthe time that he could not remember. I donot knowwhether or not Williford hada pistolthe day of the picnic. I was not near the dis- .turbance at the picnic. Caston seemed excitedwhen he approached me and Frew, and- <

said he intended to have satisfaction. Castoncame from toward Iredell Jones' house, whenhe approached the buggy. In our conversationat the buggy, my left side was next toJones'house. I. am seventeen years of age,and son of John Rattareev

State here rested.testimony for the defence.

Mr. Wylie, of counsel for the defence, addressingthe court and jury, remarked thatwhile contrary to the general rule to make astatement in advance of the introduction oftestimony, yet as the 8tate had told the jury

whatthey expected to prove> he would departfrom that rule, and outline what the defenceproposed to prove ; and in doing so, wouldpromise to prove nothing they could not,,From the line of our cross examination, ourdefence may already be conceived. We proposeto show that this man has done no murder.That he has committed a homicide wedo not propose to attempt to disprove. We donot stand here to deny that he has unfortunatelydeprived a fellow being of his life.notas a murderer, but, unfortunately, the cause ofthe death of a fellowman forjustifiable reasons,and that he is not here as a cold-blooded mtiF"*derer, as the indictment proclaims him to havebeen ; but to the contrary, a man whose mindhad been tortured and worked upon by thethreats of^desperate man. until he scarcelypossessed peace of mind% We expect to provethat the best men, warned him that his lifewas in danger, and that they advised him to.arm himself and take care that his desperatepursuer should not get undue' advantage ofhim. We expect to prove the character of thedeceased; not that we would throw dust onthe grave of the dead, nor go farther in thisdirection than is absolutely necessary by ourduty to the prisoner at the bar,. Than this wewill go no farther; but we will go as far aswe can under the law to prove that the deceasedcarried deadly weapons and madethreats against the unfortunate prisoner; andwhen we conclude, we expect to show youthat the prisoner stands before you, not as themalicious murderer, as charged in the indict-,ment, but one forced to commit the deed inorder to save himself from bodily harm or toprotect his own life.John R. London, sworn. I resjde in Rock

Hill and am intendant of the town. I havelived there ten years. I am in business there.T lrtinw the nrisnner and have known him eisrbtor ten years. His general reputation as a

peaceable, quiet, orderly man is good.asgood as any man in the county. He is a memberof the Episcopal church, I knew the deceased..Knew him a good many years. Hegrew up there. Am acquainted with his generalreputation as a turbulent man.Objected to by Mr. "Wilson, Sen.. of counsel

for State, who argued before the court, denyingthe right of the defence, under the law, toattack the character of the deceased, unless itcan be shown that he committed an overt actat the time of the occurrence. Counsel citedauthorities to sustain his position that unlessthere was some overt act indicating^yiolence,evidence on the subject is irrelevant. Counselproceeded to argue that the law gives no

ri£ht to shoot down a dangerous man withouthis committing an overt act, and the defencelias no right to introduce testimony to attackcharacter, unless an overt act is connectedwith the occurrence,Mr, Witherspoon^flfi the part of the defence,

argued in support of the admissibility of thetestimony, and cited authorities in support ofhis position.xne position 01 tne ueience was auauuncu

by the Court, and witness resumed.Deceased was generally regarded as a dangerousman. His public reputation was that

of a dangerous man. It was his habit to carrydeadly weapons. He was looked upon as aman who carried a pistol, and his reputation v

was that he was apt to use it.[continued on second page.]