Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
n1srnuawan1~'irns1:GGaya~duan"uu~u1nua~~u3~1ilun1sti~~aion1s Y
e c" 6 ' c " c " asulu%uiiduu n1unkuzuadiu3~1sr~a:a101au a ~ n a n a ~ i n u ~ $ u a ~ $ a W n w ~ nslu
a13aAnw1 n c j u n ~ n ~ ~ d a $~i~! i '~ i i l~auan~ui i~~u&ud
nautf I n~sirns~:GGayar~uan"unn~un~wua;lflanuauunaunlu
nautf 2 n1s'irnn:Gunu1nua~~u3~1slun1sd~~~3~n1s4Culu.a"~17u~ 6 ' c " c " n1uGfiu:us~~u3~1sr~a:a101su n ~ n a n a ~ i n u l K u a l B a I n w ~ n m a ~ B a Wnw~ ncju
n l n bMd9 6'- c" naud 3 n1s?rnn:G~~uu~~uu~fiu:"ua~~u3~1s~ra:a1~1su a ~ n n n a d
,=id 8 i n u ~ $ u a l l a W n l * ~ n s u n B a d n w ~ nc jon ln~ada nunaunu1nua~iu3~1slun1sddra3lu
nlsi$'u~u&iiduu 4n~unn1udi1rr~rid~ J I ~ ncjuf a l i a a u ~ P n ~ s W n w ~ uazds:nun~sd n ~ s q ~ m u
o i n n i s i r 2 wuii n4uGao i i r C l ~ ~ u ~ u ~ ~ i s i i i u a u 73 nu $?Pn isdnwi
1J5qqin'T 41uau 42 nu RRLBU%IURL 57.5 frni iGqqi& 4 i u a u 31 nu RniIlu ioua: 42.5 a iad~~Gds : f iun i~&nis i i r iuu inn i? 19 9 i i u a u 42 nu Rn~Uu~oua: ~ ~ . ~ T O J B O ~ ~ I S ~ M ~ ~ J 10-19 3 4 1 ~ 2 ~ 26 R U WRLU~~OLIA: 35.6 ~ ? ~ n $ l l ~ ' l B d l ~ d L i l ~ o i o i s 6 G i i u a u 147 nu n o u n $ u h i ~ i G q i i u a u 72 nu R~LUU?EILIR:. 49 ua:ntju?vi B w i i u a u 75 nu ~ R L O U $ U Q L 51 aiau'b~@!~Fijnis~n~is~6uGqqin'T 4 i u a u 89 nu Rn~gu?oun: 60.5 ~~n:Gds~arunis&ni3$iriuuinnj7 19 9 4 i u a u 63 nu 8 n ~ h ? o u a : 42.9 ~ o r a r u i $ o s : ~ i i r 10-19 3 i i u a u 58 nu Sn~Uufoua: 39.5
(n = 73)
2.86 0.81 d1una7~ 2.61 0.75 d' luna7~
(n = 147)
sr Ku dau?
- X
- X S.D. S.D.
3 ~ 6 U
dau3
nisi3 4 ~ i ~ a d u ~ 1 ~ ~ F i i ~ d u ~ ~ ~ u u i ~ ~ ~ i u ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ n u i n ~ o ~ ~ u ~ ~ i d u n 1 ~ k ~ ~ i i i m 5
? k ~ u & ~ ~ r u u munkw:uaa$u?uinis $iunisk~~3ul6~iliinn3iu h ~ i s v o ~ ~ i u POI
aouluZu~?uu
1 S.D. 1 dfjfl8
s i n n i x i d 6 w u i i $ 1 ~ ~ 1 3 ~ U ~ U I ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ Z ~ J L ~ B J ~ I ~ ~ C ~ I M . ~ " M L ~ ~ ~ Giunix CI U C I
~ v i n ~ i u r i i ~ ~ ~ ~ n ~ ~ ~ ~ u ~ u . a " P . s ~ ~ u u h u m w ~ ~ ~ d ~ ~ n o ~ ~ ~ ~ : 6 ~ l d i ~ n a i d (X = 3.21) CI Gsisnn~ilunuGo w u i i d~unuy luse6ud iunm u'uddfiuZiuingn~s ~i~~a5ulvin2
R i t n i i ~ i n a i u j I ~ i 7 d ~ ~ u d s r ~ u a ~ ~ o n i x w " w u i n i s ~ u u n i s w o u (F = 3.44) ssdadui A o CnlGinisausu~~onisw"wuinaiu~ n 3 1 u u i 1 l ~ l ~ n : f l n w : l ~ n 1 ~ i 1 ^ a C ~ l ~ . a " ~ Z ~ ~ ( j 7 = 3.38) L L a : ~ o & ~ f i f i t i ~ o u ~ $ ~ o GI W ~ ~ I S T C ~ I U . ~ " ~ P T U U \ ~ I . ~ " L ~ ~ ~ I J L L W U R I M U ~ u luu ie rvos~n iu8n~ i (F = 2.75)
8. ~ J L ~ ~ ~ ~ I G G I wanis^a~u~P.s.a"u~uu!dw"wuinix$uu
- x S.D. dfifi;
o i n n i s i d 7 wuii i u 5 u i s i j u n u i n ~ ~ n i ~ ~ r l ~ a ~ ~ n i ~ ~ ~ u ~ u $ u f i u ~ Giun i s a W A ~ G n a i u u a u i u ~ ~ a n ~ ~ i i i C u ~ u k i i u u ~muniws~ud~unu~lus:6udiunai~
a '44- (Z = 2.74) ~ d a ~ o i s r u n ~ u n u ~ a wuii d.guma$usr6udiunaid ~addfiu%uinym~a ~i~~a5ulG~~riiwa~1unis6iiCu1u~ufi~u!d~sminisn"u^aa1~u ( j7 = 2.93) sa~sduiWa
l d n i s u n i a;lau~ao~~rin~d~waaiunis$i~
e i n n i s i a 8 wuii (u3~13 ~ ~ U ~ U I ~ Z U ~ I S ~ ~ J I ~ ~ ~ ~ I S ~ < ~ I U ~ M G U M A u n i s 4 -4
d a 1 ~ 3 u n a i u r i i a ~ ~ i l u i i ~ ~ ~ ~ a n i ~ a i u ~ o ~ ~ = j ~ i i ? < u ~ u . a " u P s u u Imun iwsaud l~una$Lu 4 -4 ~t6udiunaia (E = 2.74) ~ d o G e i s m i ~ ~ u ~ i u ~ o wuii ~ J J U R J ~ ~ ~ U ~ : ~ U ~ I U ~ ~ ~ I J 6 0 i
daduingnn o d ~ ~ a ~ u ~ r i n ~ i ~ ~ i l a i u n i s ? < u ~ u ~ u ~ u ~ < n i i b ~ u ~ a a i u n i a ? " ~ ~ i n i s ~ i a
u a ~ $ o u d i ~ ~ ~ r i a (x = 2.86) saaaauiWo ariu~~u~vin~dii~a~,unis?
6iuni~d~~n5ul99"~i im~aiuf i i~~0ua~~iu^aCulu
-
X S.D.
d i u n a i a u ' a d i r i i ~ a i u p ~ n 8 o iiuluu~u~?aujii~~um~ian~ua~un~s~~?
6 d - sinniriJ I I wuii oisiru u n ~ u r d a u n u i n u a ~ ~ u 5 u i M 1 h n 1 ~ d ~ 1 ~ 3 u m r _ ~~UIW&APSUW - ~ i u n 1 d ~ n ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ 1 6 ~ ~ u n 1 ~ " a ~ u l u . a " u 1 i u u ~RU~IW~-JUS$WS:&J d i una i~ (K = 2.98) ~ d a ~ s i r m i ~ i l u s i u ~ a wui i i i f l ~ u r a ~ I . u r c ~ u ~ i u n a i ~ ~ a d i ~ i l t d u ~ ~ ~ n c v Cnlriiinisauru t~uniswiuuin2lui n~iutuilslmm~nw:lunir.iii^a~u
~u.a"uisuu (i? = 3.24) ra~a~u+io id~~a^~u~
6 d . U s i n a i s i J 12 nu i i oisi-iu unnu:dounuinua~~u5iidunisii~~a5unis
A -mu~ui?ufiuu .U fiunis1vin~iuusuiuriu6on~$p;ii?
1 x 1 S.D. I x S.D. 1 1
Sig
b d " pinmis i r 14 w u i i ~ G ~ i s u n : s i s i s u un~u~iaunuinusoiu5~idunis P P d i i r~i isunis5Culu$ufiuu lnuniwsauailrsiu61u~~mnd1rn"usei1riiGu51Ky~1ranm~
s:Ku .os unriuniuni~iir~a5unaiun"ia~Gi1u~i~~~Grnisriuvarn~~ii^a~u1u~uEuu
1a.i ~ ~ m n i i r i Y u
n i s i s 15 ~d~uu~Guunkutuso~u5uimsua:ai~isd di i s i ounu inuas~u~~ i s Iun~s
ddL6unisi
6 d u uinmisid 15 W U ~ I ~u5~1s~an:iliinsu iln~1u:daunuin~101~u5uiMidunis
d~aa5ilnis4Qulu+ua5uu T ~ U ~ I V I s a a u m n r i i ~ ~ u u r i i ~ i ~ ~ + i ~ ~ ~ i ~ a ~ ~ ~ s : ~ u .05 ads~~ismi~ilusiuuj wuii iKm:
P a d u ad., ~ ~ m n r i i ~ n i t s rildd~u+i~i~nida61m63:~u .05 ndunil nGuarjunis
6 d ' L I a i n m i s i d I 6 w u i i ~U~MITLLB~UI~I~U u n ~ ~ ~ i i l ~ n ~ i n v a ~ ~ ~ l 7 ~ 1 s I u n i s i i~m5unis i4 'uIu.a"uisuu niunisinaiuiufinrauian~~.iii^a4'ulu~ufiuu i n u n i w s a u
.05 ~ d s f i ' a i s m ' l ~ ~ u s i u $ a w u j i cnku~
u JLI b b m n i i d n i r o r i i d i i ~ u 8 7 ~ ~ ~ 1 1 d a f i ~ i s r ~ u .05 mduno i~auiaulunisbmroauruat u v u d rfreisnr~aauaaou~wvdiud~~nisfiuuni3nsu uaririauiadunisGmaiwi~~~on
uinnssu~ilu~~unisfiuunisneu~Asn~s^a
$9
6-dU
ainn i - i ia 17 wuii ~ u 5 m i s ~ ~ a r o i a i s u unpl~ziounu~nuoa$u5~14Iuni4
iJLir^~uniiiiulu$u~suu h u n ~ d v i n ~ ~ u h K ~ r i u n i ~ ^ a i ~ ~ u i ~ f i ~ ~ i n u n i w s a u ~ ~ n n s i i a
h o d i a d r i u d i @ n i ~ n 8 R $ s t 6 u .05 ~ 6 a f l a i s n o ~ i l u n u $ a wuii d~plu:~mndlah nd d d
adia i i td in iynwn8R$s:
S.D. S.D.
< c r u s i n m i s i r 19 w u i i c u ? ~ i s ~ ~ a : a i s i s u u n ~ l u : d a u n u i n ~ a r ~ u ? ~ i s ~ u n i s
d r L a ~ u n l s ^ a < u ~ u h f i u ~ 6 l ~ ~ l ~ d ~ l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ f i ~ l l ~ l ~ ~ ~ l b b M ~ 9 n l ~ 9 l ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ; ~ ~ l ~ ~ ~
l u h f i u u inuniws3uamnii~6uadir!lizcuh6qniraaW ~ ~ a ~ s i ~ ~ i ~ ~ u ~ i u f i ' a wu srad u A'&
ii i in l~u :amn i i r ~ua~ i r i i r i ~~~~n1 ran~ I1s :~u .05 mruna E ~ J L ~ ~ U Z G ~ ~ ~ J W R J I ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ $ ~ P ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ L ~ ~ U ~ ~ I ~ ~ I ~ ^ ~ " I I I ~ ~ ~ L ~ ~ ~ ~ L$~M~PI'ILL.V'I~~ &IU.'$a~u7 !ii!,Rndl~
/El t Sig
Sig
P,
.a"ufiuu
i & a u i a u l u n i ~ ~ ~ a a ~ v i W I J L ! ~ ~
'Lvi 7 ~ u n i s ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ v i d ~ i ~ ~ d ~ ~ i ~ a POI aoulu.a"u6uu
i~au5au~uni~~aua~~u:~~ar~aiss lb7
~ a G a i < u ~ d a d ? u d ~ ~ n i s 6 u u
ni4aau
~ l ~ i n ~ ~ C l ~ i i u n l s ~ < u l u . a " u ~ u u Ld a;Jlon21Gi13GJ i&au iau lun i2Znv i~ i~~5an
u?nn~~u~fiuan"Prnisfiuunisaau
Ldani2^a
Go
I
I.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
u n u i n u a ~ ~ u 5 ' s ~ i i l u n i s d ~ i ~ 5 u nisT
X 1 S.D.
I (n=42) ( n = 31)
u'u u n u m u s ~ $ u ? ~ ~ d u n ~ s i i ~ ~ r i s u
n~s^a
P
Sig
1 S.D. Sig
F Sig
0.'15 0.85
0.19 0.82
0.39 0.67
0.09 0.91
0.19 0.82
6 i u n i s d d ~ ~ ~ u ~ $ ~ ~ a n a i u 8 i ~ ~ a v a d d i u ? ~ u SS
0.890
60.589
61.479
0.445
67.473
67.918
0.143
70.597
70.740
0.771
79.256
80.027
0.91 3
75.718
76.630
0.694
68.320
69.014
0.425
62.918
63.342
0.243
69.072
69.315
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
1u;ufiuu
dduuiur r~a~f i i r ru , ,ds 5:rriidniu aCuayunis~i iCu~u~uGuu niulunip
sa a~ 3 dstgua~~q~unuinuadn2id srrr i i~niu
i a n i s i i i ~ l u $ u f i u u ~ d a niulundu d?ud~~nisduunisaau sa u
aCuayunisCarri~uds~a~im s:rrii~n+u
~~a:orr6o~u~u~6snisiCuIu niuluntju Y
.a"ufiuu sa a~ aCuayul$iinm:nssa~nis strrii~nt+
6&nwi1unisii%'u1u niuluniu V
.a"ul'suu sa a~
l$$a;nriua6uurr6dnaia~j srrr i i~niu
~ t a i f i n w i d i u ~ ~ u muluniu
sa a~ ~ a r r i~dns&r r?a~n~a~da s:rriimia~
i i a 7 idaiiuasnaiuataan niuluniu
~unisi i?~u~u$ul 'suu sa ~l
C a ~ i ~ a n a i s i i s i aisais ' Z E M ~ I ~ J ~ ~ ~ B J a=. '4 nisGinwi~~a:~iuaqu~~a niuluniu
~ u n ~ i i ~ < u ~ u $ u f i u u sa a~
l$nsiidau$aulunis~aua s:rriisni~l uluuiuaamisai~owunis niulundu
u3~1~~1ui~u1u$ufiuu sa u
df
2
70
72
2
70
72
2
70
72
2
70
72
2
70
72
2
70
72
2
70
72
2
70
72
MS
0.44
0.86
0.22
0.96
0.07
i .oo
0.38
1.13
0.45
1.08
0.34
0.97
0.21
0.89
0.12
0.98
F
0.51
0.23
0.07
0.34
0.42
0.35
0.23
0.12
Sig
0.60
0.79
0.93
0.71
0.65
0.70
0.79
0.88
6 iun i s~db~~u 'b$~ i imnrn~ ib?0"~o~~ iu?~u
lu.auL?uu SS
0.922
61.051
61.973
0.21 8
47.978
48.197
9.
niun~~ i in~ iu iu i inaoudon~~f i i^aCu~ '~b~u~uu
~ i ~ ~ R m a i u ~ ~ ~ a n i s r i i % x w h n d u ~ u f i ~ u r [ ~ ~ ~ u ~ f ~ a i u ~ ~ e ~ u niulundu
33 81
~ i 1 1 1 $ 1 i u ? ~ ~ u ~ u ~ u u sa u / 76.110 7 2 1 1
ss 0.281
55.473
55.753
0.921
69.819
70.740
0.444
75.665
I.
2.
3.
df
2
70
72
2
70
72
s r ~ i i ~ n i u 3-2 U muluncju
sa u
lricii&nwiluni~rii~Culu sr~ii~ncju
&~fiuu niuluni-ju sa u
~ r i n a i u ~ a u ~ ~ i i o n ~ ~ u n i 5 1 m ' s f ~ i l ~ n i u firu~iAdwanzrnudnnis niuluncju ii ~ftunia~~~u=i?u~f uu sa u d&auiau~uni3uwa~~inid 3 : ~ i i ~ n q u 6onlMBj lunisu6fiqnifi niulunqu
df
2
70
72
2
70
72
2
70
MS
0.46
0.87
0.10
0.68
MS
0.14
0.79
0.46
0.99
0.22
1.08
F
0.52
0.15
Sig
0.59
0.85
F
0.17
0.46
0.20
sig
0.83
0.63
0.81
fiunisiin3iuiuf m~ouion3$fli^aC~~u.a"ufiu ss 0.397
68.973
69.370
0.447
74.430
74.877
0.102
70.392
70.493
0.314
57.185
57.499
4.
5.
6.
iiii?ui? ulunir~nua~~ut~~at s : ~ h ~ n + u fioiarui~i~ai~u~i;ad~ud~s niuIun+u nisfiuunis~ou 33 LI CmIss"ins~6161unis^aCulu sraiisnqu ifufiuu~w ol?sIon;l
niuni;lCn~iuuauiuGud0n~~~i5Culu~uGuu ss 0.33
88.597
88.630
1.226
94.034
95.260
0.109
72.138
72.247
1.
2.
3.
I r in isunr in~aurru~~r in~d~ s m i i ~ n i u wn~ium~ii^a~u~u.a"ufiuu niulundu 6odd~r;u~nuii'uae: TI u d d wouy 1 ~ ~ ~ u s ~ ~ n s ~ + o s i 4 ~ n ~ ~ r i n ; i ~ : ~ i i 4 n d u iiwa4lunisvil3~iu1u.a"u~uu niulundu
41 IJ
~wu~~w~w~~iunis^aCuIu s:~ii.sn$u .a"ufiuuua~n$G;nnaiu~t~ niuluntju
; u a ul6fCn sa u
df
2
70
72
2
70
72
2
70
72
MS
0.01
i .26
0.61
1.34
0.05
1.03
F
0.01
0.45
0.05
Sig
0.98
0.63
0.94
sinnisi4 30 wuii ~ u ~ ~ i s d i i ~ s ~ m n i s n i n i ~ i i ~ i u ~ i n j i 10 B 10-19 B oeruinnii 19 3 ii~~urdaunuin~u~~u5~is~uni3~i~~~unisiCu1u.a"u~uu 6iunis '~vinaiuuauiuCuiian;~iiiCulu$ufiuu h u m w s a n u a t s i u b r ~ ~ n i i ~ i i u a e i i ~ 1 i d C u
fi16~Yl19R%i
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
ss
1.136
74.618
75.753
0.936
75.749
76.685
1.650
74.404
76.055
1.345
78.573
79.918
0.297
80.361
80.658
0.173
67.185
67.357
niunidvinaiuu~uiuCu~~n~ci~^aCul~.a"~G~u
Iv inZ~~aninuan~~iuunaiu srnii~n$u
Rn~iiuniunaiui~~ar niuluntju 6 W d dsmunisnmur-p~unisii sau
e w aoulu$ufiuu
ii~~a5u1fin~fiiinnuinaiu s r ~ i i ~ n i u
muisnniunis'iCuiu.a"ufiuu n i uluntju riluinuinsriiunsnnaini sau
IGiiu na
a~ua~uI f in~d i ina iu sr~i isn$u
muisnniunis~~uIu$ufiuu n i uluntju
~ilun~dr$u~Iunisii i~u"u04 san
kra iu ' l~n~f id wa~iunis^a~u stni i~n$u
~u.a"ufiou~unisbwu~~w=i niuluniu
w a~iulM'~iludsduaJ~~rin; sau
nL?? 1d ii4ia5ulll'n;rii w a ~ i u n ~ s i i srnii~ntju
i~ulu$ufiuu~d~sruinisiiu n i ulun:u ia idu sa n
s t ~ i i ~ n t j u
sa n niutun$u
3-2 sJ
df
2
70
72
2
70
72
2
70
72
2
70
72
2
70
72
2
70
72
MS
0.56
1.06
0.46
i .08
0.82
1.06
0.67
~ , 1 2
0.14
1.14
0.08
0.96
F
0.53
0.43
0.77
0.59
0.12
0.09
Sig
0.58
0.65
0.46
0.55
0.87
0.91
a s
ag +
a
C 2,
5 ac- C
aE 2 ;z3
lo?
-
G
P 9
C
ca
s 2
+ C
g a@ " a
ax? 3
g 5
F' F
s
"@
5
5 s C
s
Og
- c-
C
12 aE z
-" c
lo
c- C
2°C
(lo z
a
a
a$ E aza ,
lo
g -g a
Fa
lo
?
'5
$$
C
'B a&
5
~ a
C
2 s
q a
a &aa 3
'J5
3 ,. ag
I
0)
a
d
al
LO
N
.- a
C9 k
C9 0
0
0
0
2
k
2
CD
N
CO
Q)
LL 7
n!
r
0
2 0
0
0
a
T
2 0
CD
C
D r
b
Q)
m
T
T
7
m
* 7
'y y
I
0
4
0 r
0
4
0 r
0 r
NO
NN
ON
N
ON
NO
NN
ON
s b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
b
-Q
)o
oo
o
rN
mr
or
0N
N
CO
bC
Dr
Nm
z:
Q)
Q)
rn
Nb
dT
a a
T*
n!
o
cv
mS
Z$
a
a
m
a
oc
vZ
X2
g
cn a
TX
-TT
co
8
9
ca 2
2
z
2
z
F' -(.- -g-
-(.- -g-
-(.- -2-
-(.- -g-
-(.* -$
?
6 s C
C
C
9
lo
$ s -F
+
c
s
-c- +
-c-
+
7 s
-c- 5
7 s
-c- <
C
C
ax
sa
z
az
z
* z
5 C
&Z
gg
is
cc
~&
i~
&
;E
-2 5 2
s
a
a
Ca
5
a (a
lo
(a
"C ac-
s
s lo
lo
s
ag + %g 7
"a"
C
C C
; 'E-
lo C
,, s
sp
s
zg
s
lo
C C s-qs
as , ,
CC
C
aE C
g -uz 'CCFS
5 a
:
a$ c
2 P -zk-P
aE ap ac-
c
3
gq
ua
a, 3 c
5 3
a~ ag
cis r%
u C
ca F
O
S
(J
p -lE3 E -ag
2 !" &
&
C a37
lo
z
c- l
oa
c 5
aE 6
" .; lE,E
3
c- A
s a5
a:
s 3
lo
" " &a= s E
z
P
c
GP
a
sa
c
aE A
z
2 '5 ale z q
-2 -paap u
i z a
5 7
1%
-2 3 "5
5 .as
a$ 5 a 5
'E '5
ca -"$
lo
C
F -9 s ; & 'g
:F .z
.g "2 ~
JP G
r% p
P
C
C
s a&
7
4
cj 4
. .
(.
~a g 2
9 C
c- s
-F ap
F
Cs
E
CS a
-'@
a, 6
3
ac- I-
$!
2
OE
z qC
;
US
-g 3 a
E E
2"
a s aC
7 isa
a
s Ea
uz alo
a
9
-" J"3"
C 9
so
?(
@
alo
3
as
Za
6
a,?
C
-& 2
-g i
a a
za s
(J
5 a"
r
E I7
C
m s
-5 9 =+as
'
1z 'S
a
12
-2
@ ~a
C
F %
C
z aE -a
cz(J
-p C
s
C
g ac
C
9
a$ -6
55
c
5 , -z
2
~ ~ u I w Y ~ J ~ u ~ M I ~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ L ~ ~ u (n=72) (n = 75)
nis^aGulu~u~%u - - X S.D. X S.D.
1. G iun is is~~5ulPs"~ i inna iu5-1~ is~a~~iu
Sig
S.D.
0.78
S.D.
Sig
Sig
Sig
Sig
ilinnisio 35 wu i i a i i l i s 6 ~ ~ a u n ~ i ~ i LLBA~IQW iinkutia unuinuaoQu5uirridunisio~~5aJnis^aCu'bui?uGuu AuniilM'Raiu h & g ; ~ n l ~ ^ a C ~ l ~
k f iou ~ n u n i w r a u a n n ~ i o ~ a e i i o ' b i ~ ~ u ~ i ~ ~ n i o ~ ~ ~ ~iiaiilismisiuGa wu i i ii - 24 G~ue~~ani ion"pdaei io i~uGiQiy~io~AG~stKu .05 mouna b~y^anuinsussuiub~~aJnaiaJ
$~aonisi
t Sig
0.03 0.97
0.1 3 0.89
0.54 0.59
1.54 0.12
1.99' 0.04
2.20* 0.02
1.25 0.21
0.99 0.32
1 1.23 0.22
I. &iunisis~a5u~G~iia~aiu~i~i0uo~~iu
^a
-
X S.D. I
- Sig
X S.D.
f l f l w ainnisid 40 wuii u i ~ i s 6 ~ i 2 6 f i r u q i n ? ~~e :pn i i f i ryy i r s unnurds
unuinvm (uiMidunis k ~ a i u n ~ ~ ^ a C ~ ~ ~ . a " p a ~ % u $i?unisdnaiuiuijnaaud vn;@i P W a~ulu.a"ufiuu b n u m w s a ~ ~ ~ n n h ~ n i ( s [ i i ~ ~ i ~ ~ u i i 6 q n i ~ L ~ O ~ P I ~ ~ U I L ~ U ~ I U ~ B
OI A & wuii i K n u r u n n d i ~ K u e d i ~ ~ ~ u ~ i Q T ~ n i ~ n ~ G d s r 6 u .05 n ~ k s ddaui?uIunisAn~i
ni~~'ianuinnssu~iua~unisfiuunis~au~isnis~Cu~u.a"ufiuu idu d s ~ i o ~ d n s n i n i s
fiuunisnou ~ a u d s ' s u ~ ! i u n n d i ~ h
&iunisl~naiu~iQi~n"Plnis^aCuIu .a"ufiuu
$6insr@1rin;~~nnisdiud~~
ns:uaunisfiuunisasubnuI%n~s POI
~ P U L ~ U ~ U ; I U 2.91 0.96 2.91 1.01 -0.02 0.98
d ~ ~ ~ i 3 u I r i ~ ; i n i s r i i ^ a C ~ I ~ ~ ~ f i ~ ~
~ ~ a d i u d ~ ~ n i s f i u u n i s a a u 3.08 1 0.96 3.17 0.99 -0.56 0.57
dd ~a?ullin;n'un
f l f l u
ainnisir 41 w v i i aiais6~i24pi5yyin? va :~rn i i f i yy ins unnu:da
unuinuarfiu5~iilunisrir~fi~unis^aCerlu.a"ufieru 61unisl~n~iuEii6yn"unis?Gerlu k f i u u h u n i w s ~ u u m n d i ~ n " u a e i i r ~ B j i C ~ ~ i ~ y ~ i ~ f i A ~ ~ d a f i a i ~ ~ ~ ~ i l u ~ l u u ' a wu i i
u A'd i i n l ~ l u ~ o m n d i ~ ~ u a e i i r d C u d i 6 ~ ~ i ~ f i A ~ ~ a : 6 u .05 nruno CnlGiinis8nausli
nau f i3~na i~dan i~ l~na i : f iQa;~~~a:n is i ri?uQadu7 I a i ~ ~ n n i i ~ n i r
a
7.
unuinua~{u5~islunisrir~fi5u nis^aCerlu.a"ufiw
CnlGinis8nausunauf ia~mai~da
(n=89)
-
X S.D.
(n = 58) t
- X
Sig
S.D.
&iunislflnaiuuou?uGuflonsfi$i n o r
aoulu$uPsuu
lrinisundvraurauarin~6ijwa~iu
n ~ ~ ~ ~ ^ a < ~ l u t ~ f i ~ u d ~ i d ~ : ~ ~ l ~ n --muiij,~~a:dSu~
l $ L f i U3~fiGl3Ujll?'~a3lJa"~ bbfinS$lfJ~~ ~iunis$i^aG~lu$ufiuu
L W U L L W ~ W a~iunis~~ului?ufiuuuo~
~ ~ I ~ ~ n n a Q u ~ % ~ u a u I ~ i < n
~ v i n ~ i j ~ o n i a u a n ~ d ~ u u n a i u ~ m ~ ~ ; i u 6 u plei
Giun~iu~~~a:dsrnunisnmu y oulu nisGî a
~ i n m i s i ~ 42 w u i i a i ~ i s ~ d i i ? f i n i s W n w i f i q q i m ~ i i a z p n j i f i y y i m ~
~ 6 ~ u r d a u n u i n u a ~ ~ u ~ ~ i ~ ~ n i ~ k i n ~ u n i s ~ < u ~ u ~ u f i u u 6 i u n i s ~ ~ m a i u u a u ? u
riuiiansejrii5
a d & o i n n i s i ~ 43 wuii o i o i s 6 i i 2 ~ ~ q 1 ? i n i ~ a t ~ r l n i i f i q q i n s unnutdo
unu inua~ ~~)7~1slun1si~~n3unis^a~ulu.a"~5uu hunis i~~~5una1un"ia~Ci lu di~mri~nis~iuuo~n~~fl~?
~inmis19 45 wuii a i ~ i s 6 i ~ s : ~ u n i s d n i ~ f l i 9 1 u ~ i n i i i o WO-19 3 d 4 - ~ ~ e t u l n n i i i 9 d un~u:inunuinua~~u5~1s~unis~~~~5~~n1s^a
uinn-di 19 0 iin41 10 9 10-19 9
i i n 4 i 10 9 uinn-di 19 0
pinnina 47 n u i i oins~6iidrrauni~dnis.iii~iud1ni1 10 3 rYuni~is5 ~iids:nunisdnisriim 10-19 9 oi~isdii i~s:aumssib"nis~~~~u i 0-19 j~ i ~ u
d do, o~~~sd~iids:~unisdniaii~iuuinnii 19 d unautZuld3od iii
6iwni~~n~iuiu~maoudon~$i1^aCu~w.a"~Zuu ss
4.137
104.856
108.993
5.690
90.579
96.269
6. dri7ui?ulwni~Rm~ini t s : ~ i i t n i u ~ ! o n u ~ n n s s u ~ i u a ~ u n 1 3 n iu luntu ~ ~ u u n l ~ n o u ~ $ o n 1 3 ^ a ~ u ~ u sau .a"u~uw law B e v ~ ~ o ~ d n s n i nisZuuni3nou
df
2
144
146
2
144
146
3:wiitniu 33 u n iu luniu
33 U
MS
2.06
0.72
2.84
0.62
F
2.84
4.52*
Sig
0.06
0.01
da:auniadnia$idiu u i n n i i I 9 'I d i n i i 10 3 10-1 9 'I - X 2.62 2.58 2.16
u i n n i i I 9 9 2.62 0.04 0.46* i i n i i I o YI 2.58 0.42 10-19 3 2.16
da:auni~&nia$idiu
Gin i i 10 3 u i n n j i I 9 3 10-19 9
din41 10 'I u i n n i i I 9 'I 10-19 3 - X
2.81
2.59
2.17
2.81 2.59 2.1 7
0.22 0.64*
0.41*
e i n m i n o 50 wuii o i o i s ~ i i d s r ~ u n i s & n i s d i ~ i u ~ ~ n i ~ i o 73 5u sir7siiC/iids:aunis&nisiidiu 10-19 TI oiois6dii~s:aunis~nis.iii~iu 10-19 9
d do, 5uoins6fiiidsr~unis&ni3vlinnii 19 d unnududojl~n~~ud~ub'~93onsIu
n ~ s u C ~ ~ ~ ~ A i i w a n s : ~ u ~ o n i ~ ~ i ~ f i u n i i i b l u u amndid5uori i~i i~u$iQTywi~ d dW
a ~ ~ $ s : t ~ u .05 1nusieis6dii~~:rmnisrjnis~i~1ui1ni1 10 II unnur Iusmcupn i i n7ois6fi~dsraunis&n7sdidiu 10-19 9 bb~roiois6fi~ds:aunis&nisdi~i~u~nn3i
4 do,
19 d unnur1u~:~u~dnii~iois6fii ids: ~ ~ n l ~ i d i 10-19 73
o i n m i s i ~ 51 wuii o io is6di i~s:auniss ib"n is~i~ i~ 10-19 9 i ruo io is6d d do,
iids:aunis&nisiidiu~~innii 19 I I unnu:Iudo~ i i i ~ u j ~ u I u n i s ~ ~ ~ ~ s ~ i w i ~ ~ ~ o n
IM J q ~ u n ~ s o ~ ~ ~ i d f i ~ d ~ ~ i u ~ ~ ~ I ~ . a " u f i u ~ u n n r i i ~ n i t o r i i ~ i i ~ u ~ i ~ ~ ~ i ~ a ~ ~ f i s:Ku .05 I n u s ~ ~ i s ~ d i j ~ s : ~ ~ n i S n i n i s ~ i ~ i u u i n n ~ i 19 9 i i G ~ ~ : I u s : ~ u ~ ~ n i i o i~is6di ids:aunis&ni~~"i~iu 10-19 3
Sig
0.09
0.16
0.53
6iunislvin2iu h@n"unis^a~u'bu~u~uu SS
4.55
135.292
139.850
3.486
I 35.548
139.034
1.083
123.747
( ~wuinisisuunlsauu 33u 1 124.830 1 146
I.
2.
3.
I I
&iinsr+1~n~~~nnis3~iu sr~i1~ni .u d~mru7unisfiuwnisasw niulun4u ~n uIiYnisi-ju r9u6uziu sa u r i~~s~ulr in~i inis~i"aCu9u c m i i ~ n i u $~isuuLdsdiud~~nis~uu m uIuniu
fll3H110U 33 U
r i~~s?u~~n~6uiun
ac
;
a5 "
GI
s
YT
"ap
~3 "
zz
z
J$ $
$ ag
E 'lz
""
2
J c
6? a$
JG
n!
(a
05 T a;: C
P k JZ
&Guu (F = 3.67) u s r G n ~ $ i n i ~ d ~ n ~ u d ~ s ~ " G n i ~ ^ a G u ~ u $ u ~ u u ~ ~ a w i u u i m i u f n ~ ~ u
aiui~nd3:aums&uan (F = 3.37) huu'u;u7 !rionndionit
~6alvin~1ui1a1q~~66iid3:aun1~dn13i1d1~d1dn"~l~i ln6iw"~~~~~~3ii~l
unuinua~~u~~lilunl3~dba~unl3^a~u~u$ufiuu 91 &unidM'n3iu8iKyn"uni3^aGulu
k f i u u u a n d i ~ h B ~ ~ i u ~ r d u u ~ G u u r i l u 3 i u ~ l n u i 8 u a ~ ~ r r l ~ r l (Scheffe) ds inpk lu
Wl31-3 54-55
niunis2tinaiuuauiu~u~an~~di?C~2~.a"u~uu ss 2.97
149.73
152.707
6.875
179.547
186.422
2.942
143.725
146.667
1.
2.
3.
I~nisen dn~au~aeari~~id sttliianqu ~ e ~ ~ u n ~ s ~ l ' i < u ~ u . a " ' ~ b f i ~ ~ mulunqu ~adLIs:~ulu?nui ~ L L R : ~ n u $u7 1 ~ i ~ ~ u s t ~ n s f i a s 1 ~ 7 " e ~ ~ r i n ; $ ~ L M ~ I J ~ ~ U
ii wadiuni~$i?~~~u.a"ufiuu nlulunqu sa u
bNfJbb~fN~Jl~n'l3?
niuni~llin~ia~unuiuCuton~~iiSCulw$uE~~ ss 5.028
107.585
112.612
4.234
141.657
145.891
5.772
152.977
158.748
3.472
146.895
150.367
4.279
156.089
160.367
4.051
108.884
112.935
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
lvinadloninuanudiuunai~ x w i i ~ n q u finrriuniun2iu$ra:IJ~:nu niuluntju n i ~ d K u $ u l w n i 3 i i S j u l u n u $ufiuu i i ~ u ~ i ~ ? $ n ~ d d n 2 i ~ f n a i a ~ ~ x - h ~ n i u niaJi~nniwni~'iju~u$u~uu mulunqn ri luinuin~riiunonn~ia~$G 470
Kun; a r i u a u u I ~ n ; d i n ~ i u x ~ i i s n q a ~ aiui3nniuni3'i~u1u.a"uu4uu mulunqu u i l u n ; d u t ~ ~ w n i ~ i i i ~ u " u a ~ n u
n3 d ~ ~ f i u l ~ n ; d d w a ~ i u n i 3 i j u ~ z ~ i i ~ n q u luzu~~uduni lrwurrwiwp nlulwniu ~iw?Guiluds: luabrin~ 42 a~ n"?l !IJ k~ri3ulGn$i wa~iun13rii 4 z ~ i i ~ n q ~ e ~~ulu$ufiuw!IJ~~ruini~Ku - n i u l u n i u iai$u 42 a~
df
2
144
146
2
144
146
2
144
146
2
144
146
2
144
146
2
144
146
4 ~ M ~ l J n ~ a J 42 u m u l u n i u
42 U
MS
2.51
0.74
2.11
0.98
2.88
I .06
1.73
1.02
2.13
I ,OB
2.02
0.75
F
3.65*
2.15
2.71
1.70
1.97
2.67
Sig
0.03
0.12
0.06
0.18
0.14
0 07
IJs:aunia&nisi ia iu
din-di 10 3 u inni i 19 3 10-19 9
d i n i i 10 9 uinni i 19 9 10-19 9 - X
2.65
2.60
2.24
2.65 2.60 2.24
0.05 0.41"
0.36"