42
“Th M i fH Fl “Th M i fH Fl Introduction to Flavour Physics Introduction to Flavour Physics “Th M i fH Fl “Th M i fH Fl or or “The Magic of Heavy Flavours“The Magic of Heavy Flavoursor or “The Magic of Heavy Flavours“The Magic of Heavy Flavourswith flav flavour… Outline : Importance of flavour physics and its main players Probing New Physics with heavy flavours (a biased selection of “hot” topics) O tl k& l i Outlook & conclusions Moriond QCD and High Energy Interactions, 10-17 March 2012 Andreas Schopper

Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Introduction to Flavour PhysicsIntroduction to Flavour PhysicsIntroduction to Flavour PhysicsIntroduction to Flavour PhysicsIntroduction to Flavour PhysicsIntroduction to Flavour Physics“Th M i f H Fl ”“Th M i f H Fl ”

Introduction to Flavour PhysicsIntroduction to Flavour Physics“Th M i f H Fl ”“Th M i f H Fl ”or or “The Magic of Heavy Flavours”“The Magic of Heavy Flavours”or or “The Magic of Heavy Flavours”“The Magic of Heavy Flavours”

with flavflavour…

Outline: Importance of flavour physics and its main playersp p y p y Probing New Physics with heavy flavours

(a biased selection of “hot” topics) O tl k & l i Outlook & conclusions

Moriond QCD and High Energy Interactions, 10-17 March 2012

Andreas Schopper

Page 2: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Importance of Importance of FlavourFlavour PhysicsPhysicsImportance of Importance of FlavourFlavour PhysicsPhysics

While the Standard Model (SM) describes flavour physics very accurately

The origin of flavour is one of the big, unsolved mysteries of fundamental physics!

While the Standard Model (SM) describes flavour physics very accurately, it does not explain its mysteries: Why are there 3 generations in nature? What determines the extreme hierarchy of fermion masses? What determines the extreme hierarchy of fermion masses? What determines the elements of the CKM matrix? What is the origin of the matter-antimatter asymmetry (CP violation)?

The SM CP-violation is insufficient to explain the matter/antimatter asymmetry progress in flavour physics may help understand open questions in cosmology

History has shown that flavour physics often gives first evidence for new discoveries: Kaon mixing, BR(K0

L→μμ) & GIM prediction of charm Kaon mixing, BR(K L→μμ) & GIM prediction of charm CP violation prediction of third quark family B mixing mass of top is very heavy rare B decays SUSY parameter space constrained

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 1

rare B-decays SUSY parameter space constrained

Page 3: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

FlavourFlavour Physics as a probe for New PhysicsPhysics as a probe for New PhysicsFlavourFlavour Physics as a probe for New PhysicsPhysics as a probe for New Physics

The Standard Model cannot be the ultimate theory !SM could be a low-energy effective theory of a

f d l h hi h lmore fundamental theory at a higher energy scale, introducing new particles, dynamics and/or symmetriesat a higher E-scale (in theory perfect)at a higher E scale ( y p )

Andreas Schopper12 March 2Moriond QCD 2012

Page 4: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

FlavourFlavour Physics as a probe for New PhysicsPhysics as a probe for New PhysicsFlavourFlavour Physics as a probe for New PhysicsPhysics as a probe for New Physics

The Standard Model cannot be the ultimate theory !SM could be a low-energy effective theory of a

f d l h hi h lmore fundamental theory at a higher energy scale, introducing new particles, dynamics and/or symmetriesat a higher E-scale (in theory perfect)at a higher E scale

How can New Physics (NP) be discovered and studied ?

( y p )

Energy frontier:New particles produced and observed as real particles at energy frontier machines (e g LHC)at energy frontier machines (e.g. LHC)

“hit as hard as you can to catch the real particles”

Andreas Schopper12 March 3Moriond QCD 2012

Page 5: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

FlavourFlavour Physics as a probe for New PhysicsPhysics as a probe for New PhysicsFlavourFlavour Physics as a probe for New PhysicsPhysics as a probe for New Physics

The Standard Model cannot be the ultimate theory !SM could be a low-energy effective theory of a

f d l h hi h lmore fundamental theory at a higher energy scale, pintroducing new particles, dynamics and/or symmetriesat a higher E-scale (in theory perfect)at a higher E scale

I t it f ti

How can New Physics (NP) be discovered and studied ?

( y p )

Intensity frontier:New particles appear as virtual particles in e.g. loop processes, leading to observable deviations p p , gfrom the pure SM expectations in flavour physics and CP violation

“shake as hard as you can to feel the virtual particles”

Andreas Schopper12 March 4Moriond QCD 2012

f p

Page 6: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

New Physics manifestations in Heavy New Physics manifestations in Heavy FlavoursFlavoursNew Physics manifestations in Heavy New Physics manifestations in Heavy FlavoursFlavours

Search for deviations from Standard Model predictions due to virtual contributions of new heavy particles in loop processes

b st,c,uW

Penguin diagramt,c,ub s,d

Box diagram

?0B

K 0

b

sd

ss

t,c,u

tcu

W W

sd b

0B 0B? New Physics

,K ss,d s,d

B + “ h l i ”

t,c,us,d b

measure: CP violating phases in mixing and decay

Bs μ+μ- s-channel penguin”g p g y

Rare Decays of heavy quarks compare: to very precise predictions of the SM to very precise predictions of the SM

discovery potential for New Physics extending to mass scales far in excess

?

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 5

of the LHC centre-of-mass energy

Page 7: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Example of search for New Physics: Example of search for New Physics: BBd,sd,sμμ++μμ--Example of search for New Physics: Example of search for New Physics: BBd,sd,sμμ++μμ--

f d l f β M l in SM: B(BSμ+μ-) = (3.2 ± 0.2)·10–9

sensitive to many NP modelspreferred values of tanβ vs MA plane

jetsjet + μJ t +MSSM: Jet + eMSSM:

NUHM1: (Non-Universal Higgs Mass) b fi i β M l best fit contours in tanβ vs MA plane

[O. Buchmuller et al, arXiv:0907.5568]

CMS direct search (5σ) contours 30 or 60 fb-1

H A→ τ+ τ- [ Xi 0704 0619]H,A → τ+ τ [arXiv:0704.0619]

indirect limit from BR(Bsμ+μ-) very discriminative

distinguish between different models by measuring ratio B(Bdμ+μ-)/B(Bsμ+μ-)

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 6

SM uncertainty ~5%

Page 8: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Probing New Physics with Probing New Physics with HeavyHeavy FlavoursFlavours

Probing New Physics with Probing New Physics with HeavyHeavy FlavoursFlavoursHeavy Heavy FlavoursFlavoursHeavy Heavy FlavoursFlavours

Where do we stand today?Where do we stand today?Are there signs of new physics at the horizon?

L ’ “ h k h d” d h h f l f bi N Ph iLet’s “shake hard” and go through a few examples for probing New Physics, by looking at the:

Status of Standard Model picture of quark couplings (CKM metrology) CP violation in mixing and decays of heavy flavours Rare heavy flavour decays y y

First a quick look at the main players…First a quick look at the main players…

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 7

Page 9: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

BB--FactoriesFactoriesBB--FactoriesFactories

772M & 467M BB events accumulated!772M & 467M BB events accumulated!

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 8

Page 10: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

TevatronTevatronTevatronTevatron

12 fb-1 delivered to each experiment!

2.5 fb-1/year6-8 inter./xing

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 9

Page 11: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

LHC(b)LHC(b)LHC(b)LHC(b)1 2 fb-1 d li d t LHCb!1.2 fb-1 delivered to LHCb!5.6 fb-1 delivered to ATLAS&CMS!

Mont Blanc

Geneva airportlake

jet d‘eau

CERN

LHC Tunnel

Andreas Schopper12 March 10Moriond QCD 2012

Page 12: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Probing New Physics with Probing New Physics with HeavyHeavy FlavoursFlavours

Probing New Physics with Probing New Physics with HeavyHeavy FlavoursFlavours

A highly biased selection of a few exciting topics:

Heavy Heavy FlavoursFlavoursHeavy Heavy FlavoursFlavours

Based on summer conferences:

CKM metrology: the tension between sin(2) and B τν

g y g p Based on summer conferences:LP2011, EPS2011, HCP2011…

the need for improved measurement of angle γ Direct CP violation:

first evidence for direct CP violation in B Kπ first evidence for direct CP violation in Bs Kπ B0K+ π− and B+K+π0 CP asymmetry puzzle

Mixing induced CP violation: dimuon charge asymmetry Asl

weak phase Фs

Rare decays: Rare decays: AFB in Bd K*μμ Bs μμ (and D0 μμ)

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 11

A charming surprise…

Page 13: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Probing New Physics with Probing New Physics with HeavyHeavy FlavoursFlavours

Probing New Physics with Probing New Physics with HeavyHeavy FlavoursFlavours

A highly biased selection of a few exciting topics:

Heavy Heavy FlavoursFlavoursHeavy Heavy FlavoursFlavours

CKM metrology: the tension between sin(2) and B τν

g y g p

the need for improved measurement of angle γ Direct CP violation:

first evidence for direct CP violation in B Kπ first evidence for direct CP violation in Bs Kπ B0K+ π− and B+K+π0 CP asymmetry puzzle

Mixing induced CP violation: dimuon charge asymmetry Asl

weak phase Фs

Rare decays: Rare decays: AFB in Bd K*μμ Bs μμ (and D0 μμ)

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 12

A charming surprise…

Page 14: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

The CKM metrology The CKM metrology The CKM metrology The CKM metrology Flavour states CKM matrix Mass states

Improve the measurements of the CKM matrix elements t e C at e e e ts any inconsistency in the CKM picture will be a sign of NP!

Spectacular confirmation of the CKM model as the dominant source of flavour

B t

and CP violation(legacy of BaBar, Belle, CDF, D0)

But: some tension in sin(2)

versus B τ ν still missing precise determination

Bd mixing phase: d = 2β = –arg(Vtd2)

B mixing phase: = – 2β = –arg(Vt2)

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 13

still missing precise determination of angle γ

Bs mixing phase: s 2βs arg(Vts )weak decay phase: γ = –arg(Vub)

Page 15: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

sin(2sin(2) versus ) versus B B ττ ννsin(2sin(2) versus ) versus B B ττ νν

tension between observed values of sin(2) and BF(B → τ ν)with predictions from CKM fit (~3σ effect)

BF(B → τ ν) is too high or sin(2) too low

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 14

Page 16: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

sin(2sin(2) versus ) versus B B ττ ννsin(2sin(2) versus ) versus B B ττ νν

tension between observed values of sin(2) and BF(B → τ ν)with predictions from CKM fit (~3σ effect)

BF(B → τ ν) is too high or sin(2) too low BF t i t t b t B B & B ll d t f i d l i ! BF measurements consistent between BaBar & Belle update of improved analysis soon! BF enhancement cannot be explained by Bd decay constant fBd (10% LQCD calculations)

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 15

Page 17: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

sin(2sin(2) versus ) versus B B ττ ννsin(2sin(2) versus ) versus B B ττ νν

tension between observed values of sin(2) and BF(B → τ ν)with predictions from CKM fit (~3σ effect)

BF(B → τ ν) is too high or sin(2) too low BF t i t t b t B B & B ll d t f i d l i ! BF measurements consistent between BaBar & Belle update of improved analysis soon! BF enhancement cannot be explained by Bd decay constant fBd (10% LQCD calculations) charged Higgs contribution (sensitive to H-b-u)? l 1 8 i B D(*) (H b ) th St d d M d l di ti

Andreas Schopper12 March

also 1.8 σ excess seen in B→ D(*) τ ν (H-b-c) over the Standard Model prediction… apart from this, tension in exclusive versus inclusive determination of |Vub|…

Moriond QCD 2012 16

Page 18: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Measurement of angle Measurement of angle γγMeasurement of angle Measurement of angle γγ

angle γ = (68+10-11)° is still the least constraining (despite heroic efforts by BaBar & Belle)

important to compare meas rements from tree important to compare γ measurements from tree-decays only with those involving loop decays (NP)

Measure angle γ using various methods:Processes involving large penguin contributions are sensitive to New Physics Bd +– & Bs K+K– (U-spin approach)d s ( p pp ) Bd K+ π-

Bd Ks π+π- & Bd K+π-π0

Tree-level processes allow clean extraction of γ access interference effects involving the phase between Vub and Vcb

B D(*)K with• D CP eigenstate (GLW)• D(*) suppressed states (ADS)

D multi body states (GGSZ)

combining all tree-level modes expect to soon improve σ(γ) significantly with new data

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 17

• D multi-body states (GGSZ) Bs DsK (time dependent analysis!)

significantly with new data

Page 19: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Example: angleExample: angle in trees from in trees from BB±± D(D(ππK)K)KK±±Example: angleExample: angle in trees from in trees from BB±± D(D(ππK)K)KK±±

Atwood-Dunietz-Soni method [Phys Rev Lett 78 3257 (1997)] Atwood Dunietz Soni method [Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 3257 (1997)]

measure relative rates of B- → D(Kπ) K- and B+ → D(Kπ) K+

two interfering tree B-diagrams, one colour-suppressed two interfering tree D-diagrams, one Double Cabibbo-suppressed

u

b

usc u

B–

D 0

K–u ub c

u s

B– D0K–g g , pp

Weak phase diff.: Magnitude ratio: rB

VubVcb

u u colour-suppressed

u u colour-allowed

Magnitude ratio: rDK

Strong phase diff.: B

}D0{c

uds

}K

D0{c

usd g D

Strong phase diff.: DK}K

Cabibbo-favouredD0{c

u su }

Double Cabibbo-suppressedD0{c

u du

NF-

2011

-044 (LHCb

4σ significance)

LHC

b-C

ON

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 18

ADS suppressed modes now clearly established (BaBar, Belle, CDF, LHCb)...

Page 20: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Probing New Physics with Probing New Physics with HeavyHeavy FlavoursFlavours

Probing New Physics with Probing New Physics with HeavyHeavy FlavoursFlavours

A highly biased selection of a few exciting topics:

Heavy Heavy FlavoursFlavoursHeavy Heavy FlavoursFlavours

CKM metrology: the tension between sin(2) and B τν

g y g p

the need for improved measurement of angle γ Direct CP violation:

first evidence for direct CP violation in B Kπ first evidence for direct CP violation in Bs Kπ B0K+ π− and B+K+π0 CP asymmetry puzzle

Mixing induced CP violation: dimuon charge asymmetry Asl

weak phase Фs

Rare decays: Rare decays: AFB in Bd K*μμ Bs μμ (and D0 μμ)

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 19

A charming surprise…

Page 21: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Direct CP violation inDirect CP violation in BB00ss K K ππ and and BB00

dd K K ππDirect CP violation inDirect CP violation in BB00ss K K ππ and and BB00

dd K K ππBs

0/Bd0 yield = (10.7±2.0)%,

ACP(B 0) = (27 ± 8 ± 2)%

CPV in decay:A(B0→f) ≠ A(B0→f)

Bd0 K π &

Bs0 K π

ACP(Bs ) (27 ± 8 ± 2)%

first evidence of direct CPV in B deca ss

[LHCb-CONF-2011-011]B(s)0 B(s)

0

in Bs decays

(s) B(s)

Bs0 π+ K- Bs

0 π- K+s s

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 20

Page 22: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Direct CP violation inDirect CP violation in BB00ss K K ππ and and BB00

dd K K ππDirect CP violation inDirect CP violation in BB00ss K K ππ and and BB00

dd K K ππBs

0/Bd0 yield = (10.7±2.0)%,

ACP(Bd0) = (-8 8 ± 1 1 ± 0 8)%

CPV in decay:A(B0→f) ≠ A(B0→f) ACP(Bd ) ( 8.8 ± 1.1 ± 0.8)%

first observation (5σ) of direct CPV in B decays

Bd0 K π &

Bs0 K π

[LHCb-CONF-2011-011]

yat hadron machine

B(s)0 B(s)

0

s

(s) B(s)

Bd0 K+ π- Bd

0 K- π+

Bs0

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 21

Page 23: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Direct CP violation andDirect CP violation and thethe B B KKππ puzzle puzzle Direct CP violation andDirect CP violation and thethe B B KKππ puzzle puzzle

Compare direct CP asymmetry in B0→K+π - and B+→K+π0

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 22

Page 24: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Direct CP violation and Direct CP violation and thethe B B KKππ puzzle puzzle Direct CP violation and Direct CP violation and thethe B B KKππ puzzle puzzle Would expect naively direct CP asymmetry in B0→K+π – to be identical to B+→K+π0

too large colour suppressed tree amplitude? new phase in electroweak penguin? new phase in electroweak penguin?

Need measurement in other channels: asymmetry in B K0 π0 to check

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 23

complementary measurements in B ρK , B → K*π

Page 25: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Probing New Physics with Probing New Physics with HeavyHeavy FlavoursFlavours

Probing New Physics with Probing New Physics with HeavyHeavy FlavoursFlavours

A highly biased selection of a few exciting topics:

Heavy Heavy FlavoursFlavoursHeavy Heavy FlavoursFlavours

CKM metrology: the tension between sin(2) and B τν

g y g p

the need for improved measurement of angle γ Direct CP violation:

first evidence for direct CP violation in B Kπ first evidence for direct CP violation in Bs Kπ B0K+ π− and B+K+π0 CP asymmetry puzzle

Mixing induced CP violation: dimuon charge asymmetry Asl

weak phase Фs

Rare decays: Rare decays: AFB in Bd K*μμ Bs μμ (and D0 μμ)

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 24

A charming surprise…

Page 26: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

MixingMixing induced CPV in induced CPV in dimuondimuon charge asymmetrycharge asymmetryMixingMixing induced CPV in induced CPV in dimuondimuon charge asymmetrycharge asymmetrydi C ( 0 0) ( 0 0)B0 B0 B0B0

Measure like-sign dimuon charge asymmetry:

Indirect CPV: Γ(B0→B0) ≠ Γ(B0→B0)

X + XCP

)()( 00 XBXB qq

)()()()(

00 XBXBa

qq

qqqSl

b bb bbSl

N NA

d s

d Sl SlC a C a Slbb bb

AN N d Sl s SlC a C a

( 0 787 0 172( ) 0 093( ))%bA stat syst ( 0.787 0.172( ) 0.093( ))%SlA stat syst 0.0050.006( ) ( 0.028 )%b

SlA SM

V.M.Abazov, et al. (D0 Collab), FERMILAB-PUB-11-307-E

3.9 σ discrepancy large new phase in Bs mixing?

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 25

g p s g

Page 27: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

MixingMixing induced CP violation: weak phase induced CP violation: weak phase ФФssMixingMixing induced CP violation: weak phase induced CP violation: weak phase ФФss

≈0

+NP?

t,c,u

W W

b

Bs0 Bs

0

s

≈0+NP?

t,c,u b+NP?

s

s

analogue of 2 (phase of B0 mixing), with which BaBar & Belle validated the CKM model

ηf = +, - 1 CP eigenstates

mixing phase very precisely known in Standard Model: s = – 2βs = –0.0363±0.0017

sensitive to New Physics effects s = s(SM) + s(NP)

B J/Ψ Ф i i CP dd d CP i Bs → J/Ψ Ф requires separating out CP-odd and CP-even eigenstates tagged, time-dependent angular analysis

other states like e.g. Bs→J/Ψ f0(980) and Bs→J/Ψ η(`) have lower BR,

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 26

but are essentially pure CP eigenstates (odd and even, respectively) no angular analysis required

Page 28: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

MixingMixing induced CP violation in induced CP violation in BBs s J/J/ΨΨ ФФMixingMixing induced CP violation in induced CP violation in BBs s J/J/ΨΨ ФФ≈0

+NP?

t,c,u

W W

b

Bs0 Bs

0

s

≈0+NP?

t,c,u b+NP?

s

s

Intriguing results by Tevatron (with 5-6 fb-1)

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 27

(note: s = – 2βs)

Page 29: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

MixingMixing induced CP violation in induced CP violation in BBs s J/J/ΨΨ ФФMixingMixing induced CP violation in induced CP violation in BBs s J/J/ΨΨ ФФ≈0

+NP?

t,c,u

W W

b

Bs0 Bs

0

s

≈0+NP?

t,c,u b+NP?

s

s

2010 d tFirst result by LHCb with

2010 data (36 pb-1)[LHCb CONF 2011 006]

2010 data36/pb

SM

2010 data

[LHCb-CONF-2011-006] SM

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 28

Page 30: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

MixingMixing induced CP violation in induced CP violation in BBs s J/J/ΨΨ ФФMixingMixing induced CP violation in induced CP violation in BBs s J/J/ΨΨ ФФ

LHCb (337/fb)( )

LHCb with part of 2011 data (337 pb-1)combining with J/Ψ f0

i l t i t f single most precise measurement of s

fully consistent with SM at current level of precision! LHCb: ~3 times more data on tape watch out new results!

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 29

Page 31: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Probing New Physics with Probing New Physics with HeavyHeavy FlavoursFlavours

Probing New Physics with Probing New Physics with HeavyHeavy FlavoursFlavours

A highly biased selection of a few exciting topics:

Heavy Heavy FlavoursFlavoursHeavy Heavy FlavoursFlavours

CKM metrology: the tension between sin(2) and B τν

g y g p

the need for improved measurement of angle γ Direct CP violation:

first evidence for direct CP violation in B Kπ first evidence for direct CP violation in Bs Kπ B0K+ π− and B+K+π0 CP asymmetry puzzle

Mixing induced CP violation: dimuon charge asymmetry Asl

weak phase Фs

Rare decays: Rare decays: AFB in Bd K*μμ Bs μμ (and D0 μμ)

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 30

A charming surprise…

Page 32: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Rare decays: Rare decays: AAFBFB for for BB00K*K*00μμ++μμ--Rare decays: Rare decays: AAFBFB for for BB00K*K*00μμ++μμ--

Flavour changing neutral current decay CKM suppressed Flavour changing neutral current decay, CKM suppressed in the Standard Model: BR(B0K*l+l-) = (3.3±1.0)10–6

forward-backward asymmetry AFB(s) in the rest-frame i i i b f N Ph i

+NP?

is a sensitive probe of New Physics [A.Ali et al., Phys. Lett. B273,505 (1991)]

zero point can be predicted at LO with no hadronict i ti k t 5% l l i SM iti t NPuncertainties, known at 5% level in SM, sensitive to NP

via non-standard values of Wilson coefficients

hint of peculiar pbehaviour at low q2 ?

Andreas Schopper

q2 [GeV2/c4]

12 March Moriond QCD 2012 31

Page 33: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Rare decays: Rare decays: AAFBFB for for BB00K*K*00μμ++μμ--Rare decays: Rare decays: AAFBFB for for BB00K*K*00μμ++μμ--

Flavour changing neutral current decay CKM suppressed Flavour changing neutral current decay, CKM suppressed in the Standard Model: BR(B0K*l+l-) = (3.3±1.0)10–6

forward-backward asymmetry AFB(s) in the rest-frame i i i b f N Ph i

+NP?

is a sensitive probe of New Physics [A.Ali et al., Phys. Lett. B273,505 (1991)]

zero point can be predicted at LO with no hadronict i ti k t 5% l l i SM iti t NPuncertainties, known at 5% level in SM, sensitive to NP

via non-standard values of Wilson coefficients[LHCb-CONF-2011-038]

data in excellent agreement with SM data in excellent agreement with SM predictions at current level of precision

measure precisely zero-crossing point add other observables such as AT

(2) add other observables such as ATsensitive to RH currents

add other modes like BK*νν expect new results from BaBar & Belle!

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 32

Theory predictions from C.Bobeth et al., arXiv:1105.0376v2

p update from LHCb with more data!

Page 34: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Very Very rare decays:rare decays: search for search for BBd,sd,s μμ μμVery Very rare decays:rare decays: search for search for BBd,sd,s μμ μμSM

In Standard Model:

MSSM+NP?

Bd,s μμ the super rare loop decay CKM and helicity suppressed

B(Bd μ μ) = (0.10 ± 0.01)10–9

B(Bs μ μ) = (3.2 ± 0.2)10–9

[A.J.Buras: arXiv:1012.1447][ ]

sensitive to New Physics, can be strongly enhanced in SUSY with scalar Higgs exchange sensitive probe for MSSM with large tanβ: B(BSμ+μ-) ~ tanβ 6 / MA

4

B(d s) μμ is the good way to constrain (d,s) μμ g ythe parameters of the extended Higgs sector in MSSM, fully complementary to direct searches

entering interesting regime with limits of B(Bs μ μ) < 10-8

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 33

Page 35: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

VeryVery rare decays:rare decays: search for search for BBd,sd,s μμ μμVeryVery rare decays:rare decays: search for search for BBd,sd,s μμ μμSM

In Standard Model:

MSSM+NP?

Bd,s μμ the super rare loop decay CKM and helicity suppressed

B(Bd μ μ) = (0.10 ± 0.01)10–9

B(Bs μ μ) = (3.2 ± 0.2)10–9

[A.J.Buras: arXiv:1012.1447][ ]

Data set Limit

2011 published Bsμμ limits @ 95% CL

CDF 3.7 fb-1 4.3 x 10-8

D0 6.1 fb-1 5.1 x 10-8

LHCb 0.036 fb-1 5.6 x 10-8

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 34

L [pb-1]

Page 36: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Exciting new CDF result on Exciting new CDF result on BBs s μμ μμ in Julyin JulyExciting new CDF result on Exciting new CDF result on BBs s μμ μμ in Julyin July new result based on 7 fb-1 , improved muon acceptance and Neural Network

Mμμ distribution in Bs search window for different NN bins

barrel-barrel

signal =

barrel-endcapbackground

s g a5.6 x SM

0.46 · 10-8 < BR < 3.9 · 10-8 @ 90% CL or BR=(1.8+1.1-0.9) · 10-8

f B

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012

excess of Bs μμ probability of 1.9% to be produced by SM + backgrd.

35

Page 37: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Updated measurements by CMS & LHCbUpdated measurements by CMS & LHCbUpdated measurements by CMS & LHCbUpdated measurements by CMS & LHCbLHCb CONF 2011 037CMS-BPH-11-002 LHCb-CONF-2011-037CMS-BPH-11-002

data

LHCb-CONF-2011-044 & CMS-PAS-BPH-11-019signal with SM BRcombinatorial

background

BR(Bs μμ) < 1.1 · 10-8 @ 95% CL CDF excess not confirmed but: limit still factor 3 4 above SM value but: limit still factor 3.4 above SM value watch-out new results with increased statistics

by ATLAS, CMS, LHCb! also: BR(D0μμ) < 1.4 ·10-7 @ 90% CL (Belle)

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 36

also: BR(D μμ) 1.4 10 @ 90% CL (Belle) major improvements expected (e.g. LHCb)

Page 38: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Probing New Physics with Probing New Physics with HeavyHeavy FlavoursFlavours

Probing New Physics with Probing New Physics with HeavyHeavy FlavoursFlavours

A highly biased selection of a few exciting topics:

Heavy Heavy FlavoursFlavoursHeavy Heavy FlavoursFlavours

CKM metrology: the tension between sin(2) and B τν

g y g p

the need for improved measurement of angle γ Direct CP violation:

first evidence for direct CP violation in B Kπ first evidence for direct CP violation in Bs Kπ B0K+ π− and B+K+π0 CP asymmetry puzzle

Mixing induced CP violation: dimuon charge asymmetry Asl

weak phase Фs

Rare decays: Rare decays: Afb in Bd K*μμ Bs μμ (and D0 μμ)

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 37

A charming surprise…

Page 39: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

AA charmingcharming surprise… surprise… AA charmingcharming surprise… surprise… Mixing in the D system has been established!

D1,2 = p|D0> ± q|D 0> ; ;

No-mixing excluded at 10σ level

Reminder: three types of CP violation: mixing: Γ(D0→D0) ≠ Γ(D0→D0) decay: A(D0→f) ≠A(D0→f)

indirect CPVat 10σ leveldecay: A(D →f) ≠ A(D →f)

interference of the two direct CPV

CP violation in mixing is expected to be very small in SM and universal between CP violation in mixing is expected to be very small in SM and universal between CP eigenstates: O(10−5) for observables like

Γ(D0→K+K-) − Γ(D0→K+K-) Γ(D0→K+K-) + Γ(D0→K+K-)

AΓ =

LHCb Preliminary, 2010 data A = ( -5.9 ± 5.9 ± 2.1)·10-3

Watch out results with 2011 data!

Direct CP violation in charm can be larger in SM, very dependent on final state: negligible in Cabibbo-favoured modes (SM tree dominates everything) in singly-Cabibbo-suppressed modes up to O(10−4 →10−3) plausible

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 38

in singly Cabibbo suppressed modes up to O(10 →10 ) plausible Both can be enhanced by NP, in principle up to O(%)

Page 40: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Direct CP violation in charm: Direct CP violation in charm: ΔΔAACPCPDirect CP violation in charm: Direct CP violation in charm: ΔΔAACPCP

Measure direct CP violation in D0 → K+K− and D0 → π+π−

Expectations from U-spin symmetry: AdirCP := Adir (KK) = −Adir (ππ)

ΔA = Adir (KK) Adir (ππ) = 2·Adir Δ ACP = Adir (KK) −Adir (ππ) = 2·AdirCP

ΔACP=[-0.82 ± 0.21(stat) ± 0.11(sys)]% , LHCb @ HCP2011 3.5 σ significance for direct CP violation in charm decays

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 39

g y improve precision (CDF, LHCb full data-set) & look at other decays!

Page 41: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Outlook & ConclusionsOutlook & ConclusionsOutlook & ConclusionsOutlook & Conclusions

Belle’06 5ab-1 50ab-1

upgraded

(~0.5ab-1)

S(K0) 0.22 0.073 0.029

S(’K0) 0.11 0.038 0.020

S(KSKSKS) 0.33 0.105 0.037( S S S)

S(KS0) 0.32 0.10 0.03

Br(Xs) 13%

ACP(Xs) 0.058 0.01 0.005

C [A (K*ll)] 11% 4%C9 [AFB(K*ll)] --- 11% 4%

C10 [AFB(K*ll)] --- 13% 4%

Br(B+ → K+) <9Br(SM) 33ab-1 for 5 discovery

Br(B+ →) 3.5 10% 3%

Br(B+ →) <2.4Br(SM) 4.3ab-1 for 5 discovery

Br(B+ → D) --- 7.9% 2.5%

Br(→) <45 <30 <8

Br(→) <65 <20 <4Br(→) <65 <20 <4

Br(→ 3) <209 <10 <1

sin21 0.026 0.016 0.012

2 () 68°ー95° 3° 1°

complementary measurements by B-factories and LHCb at hadron machine

both will provide ultimate measurements d h

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 40

3( Dalitz) 20° 7° 2.5°

Vub (incl.) 7.3% 6.6% 6.1%

down to theory error !

Page 42: Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The ...moriond.in2p3.fr/QCD/2012/MondayAfternoon/Schopper.pdf · Introduction to Flavour Physics or “Th M i f H Fl ”“The

Fl Ph i i i t l t b N Ph i !

Outlook & ConclusionsOutlook & ConclusionsOutlook & ConclusionsOutlook & Conclusions Flavour Physics is a magic tool to probe New Physics! so far no clear manifestation of New Physics

(neither at the intensity nor at the energy frontier) several “tensions” with the Standard Model have been resolved recently

but some discrepancies still around most recent and upcoming analysis of heavy flavour decays (in particular at most recent and upcoming analysis of heavy flavour decays (in particular at

LHC) are testing the Standard Model predictions to an unprecedented precision with future facilities (Belle II, Super B, LHCb upgrade) an ultimate precision

d t th t i SM th b hi ddown to the most precise SM theory errors can be achieved the Standard Model will be breaking down; sooner or later… let’s go on and make it happen a.s.a.p.! let s go on and make it happen a.s.a.p.!

Andreas Schopper12 March Moriond QCD 2012 41