20
Multihousing Investment Advisors INDIANA APARTMENT MARKET 2018

INDIANA APARTMENT Overview Brochure 2018 WEB.pdf · • World Headquarters of Eli Lilly, Simon Property Group and Anthem all located downtown • Over 135,000 workers downtown with

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • Multihousing Investment Advisors

    INDIANA

    APARTMENTMARKET

    2018

  • 2 3Multihousing Investment Advisors

    National Employment and Apartment Market Statistics

    National Employment Data• US unemployment rate at lowest in 49 years - 3.7% in October 2018• Manufacturing jobs growing at highest rate in 23 years• Labor participation rate is steady in spite of Baby Boomers retiring at the

    rate of 10,000 per day• Job growth averaging over 210,000 per month in 2018 - higher than five

    of the last seven years• Average wages up 3.1% over last year

    National Multifamily Fundamentals• Apartment Occupancy - 95.8% at end of 3Q18 - highest since 2001 peak • Apartment Rents - up 2.9% year over year • 233,000 new units delivered through 3Q18 - Est. 300,000+ for full-year • Apartment construction expected to slow slightly in 2019 due to

    increasing interest rates, higher construction costs and tightened lending standards

    • Demand for apartments will continue to spur strong occupancy as an estimated 1.53M new households will form in 2019, up from 1.23M in 2018

    National Apartment Sales • Cap rates averaging 5.6% throughout first three quarters of 2018, not yet

    impacted by rising interest rates • Multifamily investment sales on pace to break record of $159.6 Billion

    set in 2016

    Indiana Economic Overview

    Continued Strong Employment • State unemployment stands at 3.0% in September, compared with 4.1%

    nationally• State continues to set employment records in 2018 with 2,710,900

    Hoosiers employed in the private sector at the end of September 2018, up from 2,691,600 one year ago

    • 20,700 jobs added in the last 12 months

    Indiana – A State that Works for BusinessNational Rankings• Top 5 US States for Business (Chief Executive 2018)• 1st in the US for Manufacturing Workforce (Business Facilities 2017)• 2nd Best Business Infrastructure (CNBC Top States for Business 2018)• 2nd Best Property Tax Index (Tax Foundation 2018)• 5th Best Cost of Doing Business (CNBC’s Top States for Business 2018) • 8th Best for State Business Tax (Tax Foundation 2018)• Purdue University 15th worldwide for university-issued patents (2018)• 5th Most New Tech Jobs (Forbes 2017)• 2nd Best Cost of Living (CNBC 2017)

    Fiscally Sound• AAA Bond Rate – Standard & Poor’s, Fitch and Moody’s• Tax cuts scheduled every year through 2021• Balanced budgets and “rainy day” reserves

    Strong Job Creation throughout StateIndianapolis | Infosys, a global consulting and technology services company, will establish a U.S. Education Center to train workers and will increase its workforce in Indiana by 3,000 by the end of 2023. The company will expand into a $245 million, 141-acre campus.

    Carmel | GEICO, one of the country’s fastest-growing auto insurers, plans to expand its operations in central Indiana, creating up to 1,474 new jobs by the end of 2022.

    Ft. Wayne | Sweetwater, the country’s largest on-line retailer of audio gear, and music instruments, plans a major expansion and will add 1,009 new jobs.

    Jeffersonville | United Collection Bureau Inc., a business process outsourcing and accounts receivable management firm, will build a new call center in Clark County, creating up to 621 new jobs by 2022.

    Indianapolis | Republic Airways will establish a flight training academy to train hundreds of students and aviation professionals. The company plans to add more than 600 new, full-time jobs here.

    Hobart | Illinois based Daifuku Wynright picks Hobart for manufacturing of high-tech materials handling system and will add 582 new jobs.

    Mishawaka | California-based electric vehicle company, SF Motors, will establish a manufacturing facility, acquiring AM General’s commercial plant and creating up to 467 new jobs by 2020.

    Whitestown | Rockwell Automation, a publicly traded industrial automation firm, is relocating from Illinois and Tennessee to Indiana and will create up to 231 new jobs.

    Diverse Economy Aerospace and Aviation• GE Aviation is building a $100 million jet engine manufacturing facility in

    Lafayette, the largest manufacturing facility for Rolls-Royce civil aero jet engines outside the U.K.

    • Recent expansions by Raytheon and Alcoa Advanced Manufacturing• Leading the nation in manufacturing job growth • Elkhart – Goshen area (RV Capital of the World) ranks 3rd in nation for

    job growth in 2018• Home to the second largest automotive industry in the nation• Home to auto assembly plants for Honda, Subaru and Toyota (only state

    in US to have all three)• Indiana is the US largest steel producerAgribusiness• Indiana contributes roughly $31.2 billion to the GDP annually• Over 107,500 Hoosier jobs in agricultural production, processing and

    related businesses• Leading producer of corn, soybeans, hogs, poultry, popcorn, and tomato

    productsInformation Technology• Indy Ranked 5th among “Cities Creating the Most Tech Jobs” (Forbes)• 21 Indiana tech firms made Inc. 5000’s Fastest Growing Companies List • Ziprecruiter, a job search engine, includes Indianapolis among the 6 US

    cities where start-ups are thriving

    Economic Overview

  • 3Please visit www.TAmulti.com for more information

    Life Sciences• 2nd largest exporter of life science products • Orthopedics capital of the world (50% of US orthopedics)• Home to the world’s largest private medical device manufacturerLogistics• Shortest distance to median center of US Population• 1st in number of pass-through highways• Home to the 2nd largest FedEx air hub worldwide• 3rd in total freight railroads• 7th in waterborne shipping Motorsports• With more than 2,100 motorsports companies, Indianapolis and Indiana

    are well-known as the Racing Capital of the World

    Indianapolis Economic Overview

    National Recognition• Carmel – 2018 Best City to Live in America – CNN Money Magazine• Fishers – 2017 Best City to Live in America – CNN Money Magazine• Indianapolis – 2018 Best Airport in America – Conde Nast Traveler• Indianapolis – 2018 #1 Convention City in the US – USA Today• Indianapolis – 2017 America’s 20 Favorite Food Cities – Food and Wine

    Strong Employment and Continuing Job Growth • 15,000 new jobs added in the last 12 months • Unemployment rate at 2.9%

    Vibrant Downtown• Home to city’s pro football, basketball, baseball and soccer• Outstanding theaters featuring Broadway shows, Indianapolis Symphony

    and world class entertainment• Nationally recognized for its wide variety of fine dining options• Outstanding walkability score of 96 - “Walkers Paradice”• Home to 30,000 student Indiana University Purdue University

    Indianapolis, including IU law school, medical school and dental school• World Headquarters of Eli Lilly, Simon Property Group and Anthem all

    located downtown• Over 135,000 workers downtown with 7,270 new jobs added last year• The Number of market rate apartment units downtown have more than

    doubled since 2010• More than $5B invested in downtown CBD in last 8 years

    Brisk New Downtown DevelopmentPlanned• Indy will add 235,000 sqft to the convention center in extensive expansion• Kite Realty to build Hilton 38-story tower with 600 hotel rooms next to

    convention center• National design firm selected to plan best utilization of the more than 58

    miles of the White River running through IndianapolisOpen or Under Construction• 360 Market Square opened a 28-story, 292-unit Class A+ property with a

    42,000 sqft Whole Foods Grocery• Penrose on Mass nearing completion of $45M mixed use project

    including 236 Class A+ apartments and 40,000 sqft of retail shops and restaurants

    • Construction commenced on 15-story, 316 room Hyatt Hotel

    • Construction under way of 402-unit CityWay 2.0, Class A+ apartments and 29,000 sqft of commercial space

    • Construction beginning on the 12-acre, $300M Bottleworks District mixed use development

    Job GrowthState of Indiana – Number of New Jobs

    (180,000)

    (160,000)

    (140,000)

    (120,000)

    (100,000)

    (80,000)

    (60,000)

    (40,000)

    (20,000)

    0

    20,000

    40,000

    60,000

    80,000

    2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018(T-12)

    Chan

    ge in

    Em

    ploy

    men

    t (Jo

    bs)

    Total Establishment Employment -State of Indiana 9/18 = 3,167,700 Jobs

    Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics

    2018 Done

    Job GrowthIndianapolis MSA – Number of New Jobs

    (45,000)

    (40,000)

    (35,000)

    (30,000)

    (25,000)

    (20,000)

    (15,000)

    (10,000)

    (5,000)

    0

    5,000

    10,000

    15,000

    20,000

    25,000

    30,000

    35,000

    40,000

    45,000

    2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018(T-12)

    Chan

    ge in

    Em

    ploy

    men

    t (Jo

    bs)

    Total Establishment Employment -Indianapolis MSA 9/18 = 1,089,700 Jobs

    Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics

    2018 Done

    Unemployment RateIndiana & Indianapolis MSA

    4.6%

    5.9%

    10.3% 10.4%

    9.1%8.3%

    7.7%

    6.0%

    4.8%4.4%

    3.5%3.0%4.2%

    5.2%

    8.8%

    9.6%

    8.7%8.1%

    7.4%

    5.7%

    4.5%4.1%

    3.3%2.9%

    0.0%

    1.0%

    2.0%

    3.0%

    4.0%

    5.0%

    6.0%

    7.0%

    8.0%

    9.0%

    10.0%

    11.0%

    12.0%

    2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018(9/18)

    Une

    mpl

    oym

    ent R

    ate

    Indiana Indianapolis MSA Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics

    2018 Done

    Economic Overview

  • 4 5Multihousing Investment Advisors

    V���������$1,036 / $1.14 / 95.0%

    M�����������$933 / $1.01 / 88.6%

    C���� P����$910 / $1.04 / 96.3%

    S���� B���$871 / $1.00 / 94.5%

    M��������$754 / $0.90 / 97.2%

    E������$726 / $0.85 / 96.3%

    F�. W����$704 / $0.82 / 95.5%

    M�����$589 / $0.68 / 81.4%

    M�����$803 / $0.87 / 93.7%

    A�������$667 / $0.72 / 94.7%

    K�����$653 / $0.78 / 96.2%L��������

    $737 / $0.90 / 95.8%

    W��� L��������$1,065 / $1.09 / 96.9%

    I�����������$858 / $0.95 / 93.7%

    T���� H����$843 / $0.89 / 96.5%

    C�������$932 / $1.02 / 95.6%B����������

    $1,019 / $1.12 / 94.5%

    R�������$917 / $0.72

    E���������$711 / $0.83 / 93.8%

    N�� A�����$717 / $0.70 / 96.5%

    J�������������$745 / $0.82 / 95.1%

    M������� C���$647 / $0.84 / 94.0%

    69

    C����������$722 / $0.76 / 94.7%

    3731

    37

    31

    70

    465

    74

    65

    70

    74

    65

    9480

    64

    164

    469

    P������$823 / $0.92 / 96.7%

    Indiana Average Rent and Occupancy(Avg Rent / Avg Rent per sqft / Avg Occupancy)

    Source: US Census Bureauthrough ESRI

    2018 Estimates

    Source: Tikijian Associates

    PopulationStatisticsIndiana 6,746,700

    Cities Indianapolis MSA: 2,053,700

    Indianapolis: 864,500

    Fort Wayne MSA: 440,000Fort Wayne: 264,200

    Evansville MSA: 320,500Evansville: 122,000

    South Bend MSA: 325,900South Bend: 103,800

    Fishers: 97,400

    Carmel: 92,100

    Bloomington: 85,200

    Hammond: 78,500

    Lafayette: 75,400

    Gary: 74,700

    Muncie: 69,100

    Noblesville: 64,400

    Terre Haute: 61,900

    Anderson: 55,000

    Elkhart: 52,300

  • 5Please visit www.TAmulti.com for more information

    30

    33 469

    69

    930

    2724

    30101

    124

    14

    COLISEUM BLVD

    ST JOE CENTER ROAD

    MAPLE CREST RO

    AD

    CLIN

    TON

    STRE

    ET

    COLD

    WAT

    ER R

    OAD

    WASHINGTON CENTER ROADCR

    ESEN

    T AVE

    GOSHEN RD

    LAKE AVENUE

    WASHINGTON BLVD

    JEFFER

    SON B

    LVD

    ADAMS CEN

    TER RD

    LEESBURG RD

    FORT WAYNE

    NEW HAVEN

    3

    PAULDING RD

    MAIN ST

    MOLLER RD

    PONTIAC ST

    RUDISILL BLVD

    ILLINOIS RD

    T�� L������(34 - MR)S������� L����(72 - MR)

    C�������� F����(163 - MR)S������ T����

    (124 - MR)

    P�������� H������S������ H����

    (44 - AF)

    B����� W���� L����(31 - AF)

    B�������(221 - MR)

    Indiana UniversityPurdue University

    Fort Wayne 37

    327 2

    1

    7

    3

    45

    6

    27

    930

    STELLHORN RD

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    DOWNTOWNNORTH EASTEASTSOUTH EASTSOUTH WESTWEST

    7 NORTH WEST

    DEVELOPMENT STAGEP������

    U���� C�����������

    R������� C��������

    A������� R����

    R����� S���

    A���������

    M����� R���

    (AF)

    (MR)

    41 N����(268 - S�����)

    E������� W���� I(170- MR)

    A������ A���������(54 U����)

    S�. J�� P����(144 U����)

    R����’� E���(56 - AF)

    S����� P�����(43 - AF)

    T������� P���(68 - MR)

    A�� S����� H����(60 - S�����)

    Fort Wayne

    80 5 20 12 11 13 11 818,758 666 6,141 1,754 2,194 2,967 2,938 2,09895.5% 95.5% 96.2% 94.1% 90.6% 97.5% 97.2% 94.8%

    $702 $645 $794 $621 $503 $587 $765 $803$.82 $.89 $.88 $.81 $.61 $.67 $.90 $.95

    Avg. Rent $516 $521 $479 $590 $390 $435 $439 $584Avg. $ / SF $1.12 $1.01 $1.21 $1.15 $1.35 $1.09 $1.52 $1.12Avg. Rent $596 $642 $668 $529 $513 $511 $657 $660Avg. $ / SF $.90 $.89 $.92 $.90 $.71 $.76 $1.00 $1.02Avg. Rent $685 $789 $786 $666 $536 $602 $775 $751Avg. $ / SF $.75 $.87 $.85 $.73 $.58 $.63 $.80 $.94Avg. Rent $851 $981 $873 $778 $571 $653 $861 $1,112Avg. $ / SF $.81 $.71 $.83 $.81 $.56 $.66 $.86 $.92Avg. Rent $970 $1,164 $1,164 $841 $643 $779 $1,035 $1,157Avg. $ / SF $.77 $.68 $.91 $.70 $.57 $.60 $.82 $.84Avg. Rent $725 N/A N/A N/A $628 $1,020 $1,142 N/AAvg. $ / SF $.55 $.49 $.63 $.73

    2 Bd/ 2 Ba

    3 Bed

    4 Bed

    Average RentAvg Rent / Sq. Ft.

    Studio

    1 Bed

    2 Bd/ 1 Ba

    7-No

    rth W

    est

    Total PropertiesTotal Units

    Occupancy Rate

    1-Do

    wnt

    own

    2-No

    rth Ea

    st

    3-Ea

    st

    RENTS

    4-So

    uth

    East

    5-So

    uth

    Wes

    t

    6-W

    est

    Entir

    e M

    arke

    t

    Property Developer Type Status Units

    41 North RealAmerica Senior Planned 268

    Bonterra Domo Development Market Under Construction 221

    Electric Works Ph I Cross Street / Green Street / Biggs Market Planned 170

    Skyline Tower Ash / Great Lakes Capital Market Complete 124

    Superior Lofts RealAmerica Market Under Construction 72

    Triangle Park BND Development Market Under Construction 68

    Ash Senior Homes ASH Holding Senior Planned 60

    River's Edge UP Development Affordable / Specialty Planned 56

    Prosperity Heights - Scholar House BWI Affordable Complete 44

    Slocum Pointe Keller Development Affordable Planned 43

    The Landing The Model Group Market Under Construction 34

    Bottle Works Lofts Miller-Valentine Affordable Under Construction 31

    Totals 1,191

    New Construction

    Recent SalesProperty Buyer UnitsSt. Joe Place Sundance Real Estate Advisors 144

    Anthony Apartments Private Investment 54

    Totals 198

    2.7%

    0%

    1%

    2%

    3%

    4%

    5%

    6%

    7%

    8%

    9%

    10%

    11%

    12%

    (15,000)

    (10,000)

    (5,000)

    0

    5,000

    10,000

    2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018(T-12)

    Une

    mpl

    oym

    ent R

    ate

    Chan

    ge in

    Em

    ploy

    men

    t (Jo

    bs)

    Annual Change in EmploymentUnemployment Rate

    Total Establishment Employment -Ft. Wayne MSA 9/18 = 230,000 Jobs

    Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics

    Job Growth / Unemployment RateFort Wayne MSA – Number of New Jobs

    90.7%90.1%

    91.2%

    92.4% 92.5%

    93.7%93.2%

    95.7%95.2%

    94.3%

    95.5%

    86%

    88%

    90%

    92%

    94%

    96%

    98%

    100%

    2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

    Ft. Wayne Historical Occupancy

    Source: Tikijian Associates

    2018 Done

    Top EmployersCompany # EmployeesParkview Health Systems 4,710

    Lutheran Health Network 4,301

    Fort Wayne Community Schools 4,230

    General Motors (SUVs / Trucks) 3,909

    Lincoln Financial Group 1,970

    City of Fort Wayne 1,814

    Allen County Government 1,605

    BFGoodrich (Tire Manufacturing) 1,580

  • 6 7Multihousing Investment Advisors

    EVANSVILLE

    MELODY HILL

    NEWBURGH

    HIGHLAND

    University ofSouthern Indiana

    University ofEvansville

    66

    62 66

    261

    62

    57

    66

    65

    62

    41

    662

    66

    69

    69

    4

    3

    1

    2

    41

    66

    41

    1

    2

    3

    4

    NORTH EASTSOUTH EASTWESTCENTRAL

    DEVELOPMENT STAGEP������

    U���� C�����������

    R������� C��������

    A������� R����

    R����� S���

    A���������

    M����� R���

    (AF)

    (MR)

    W������ T����(348 - MR)

    C�������� C����(45 - AF)

    G����� L����(27 - AF)

    E���� V������(128 U����)

    M�C���� B�������(100 - MR)

    R������� P���(175 - S�����)

    P��� H����(144 - MR)

    R�������(58 U����)

    C������ L����(62 - AF)

    Evansville

    72 16 31 13 1212,203 3,367 5,088 2,074 1,67493.9% 94.1% 93.3% 96.1% 92.3%

    $712 $740 $685 $786 $643$.82 $.85 $.79 $.89 $.78

    Avg. Rent $500 N/A $501 N/A $350Avg. $ / SF $1.07 $1.08 $.67Avg. Rent $604 $619 $607 $609 $563Avg. $ / SF $.87 $.91 $.86 $.84 $.84Avg. Rent $709 $741 $689 $750 $699Avg. $ / SF $.79 $.82 $.76 $.82 $.81Avg. Rent $872 $905 $840 $942 $692Avg. $ / SF $.77 $.84 $.71 $.81 $.61Avg. Rent $971 $1,046 $936 $1,090 $785Avg. $ / SF $.77 $.80 $.78 $.84 $.62Avg. Rent $1,463 $881 $896 $1,700 $659Avg. $ / SF $1.31 $.63 $.63 $1.70 $.44

    2 Bd/ 2 Ba

    3 Bed

    4 Bed

    Average RentAvg Rent / Sq. Ft.

    Studio

    1 Bed

    2 Bd/ 1 Ba

    Occupancy Rate

    Entir

    e M

    arke

    t

    4-Ce

    ntra

    l

    1-No

    rth Ea

    st

    3-W

    est

    Total PropertiesTotal Units

    2-So

    uth

    EastRENTS

    Property Developer Type Status Units

    Warrick Trail Chandler Real Estate Market Under Construction 348

    Richmond Park Spurling Development Senior Under Construction 175

    Post House Scannel Properties Market Planned 144

    McCurdy Building Kunkel Group Market Complete 100

    Central Lofts AP Development Affordable Under Construction 62

    Carpenter Court Pioneer Development Affordable Complete 45

    Garvin Lofts ECHO Housing Corp. Affordable Complete 27

    Totals 901

    New Construction

    Recent SalesProperty Buyer UnitsEagle Village (Student) Kahuna Investments 128

    Rathbone Fetter Properties 58

    Totals 186

    2.9%

    0%

    1%

    2%

    3%

    4%

    5%

    6%

    7%

    8%

    9%

    10%

    (8,000)

    (6,000)

    (4,000)

    (2,000)

    0

    2,000

    4,000

    2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018(T-12)

    Une

    mpl

    oym

    ent R

    ate

    Chan

    ge in

    Em

    ploy

    men

    t (Jo

    bs)

    Annual Change in Employment

    Unemployment Rate

    Total Establishment Employment -Evansville MSA 9/18 = 164,300 Jobs

    Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics

    Job Growth / Unemployment RateEvansville MSA – Number of New Jobs

    92.4%

    91.2%91.8%

    93.1% 92.7%93.3% 93.3%

    94.4% 94.6%93.7% 93.9%

    86%

    88%

    90%

    92%

    94%

    96%

    98%

    100%

    2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

    Evansville Historical Occupancy

    Source: Tikijian Associates

    2018 Done

    Top EmployersCompany # EmployeesDeaconess Hospital 5,600

    Toyota Motor Manufacturing (SUV / Trucks) 5,000

    St. Mary's Medical Center 3,638

    Evansville Vanderburgh School Corp. 3,214

    University of Southern Indiana (Enrollment 10,820) 2,895

    Berry Plastics (Injection-molded Plastics) 2,699

    SKANSKA (Commercial / Industrial Contractors) 2,425

    T.J.Maxx (Distribution) 1,500

    Koch Enterprises, Inc. (Auto Parts Manufacturing) 1,409

    Vectren Corporation (Utilities) 1,200

    Old National Bank Corp. 1,160

    EVANSVILLE

    MELODY HILL

    NEWBURGH

    HIGHLAND

    University ofSouthern Indiana

    University ofEvansville

    66

    62 66

    261

    62

    57

    66

    65

    62

    41

    662

    66

    69

    69

    4

    3

    1

    2

    41

    66

    41

    1

    2

    3

    4

    NORTH EASTSOUTH EASTWESTCENTRAL

    DEVELOPMENT STAGEP������

    U���� C�����������

    R������� C��������

    A������� R����

    R����� S���

    A���������

    M����� R���

    (AF)

    (MR)

    W������ T����(348 - MR)

    C�������� C����(45 - AF)

    G����� L����(27 - AF)

    E���� V������(128 U����)

    M�C���� B�������(100 - MR)

    R������� P���(175 - S�����)

    P��� H����(144 - MR)

    R�������(58 U����)

    C������ L����(62 - AF)

  • 7Please visit www.TAmulti.com for more information

    South Bend

    SOUTH BEND

    MISHAWAKA

    GRANGER

    OSCEOLA

    South BendRegional Airport University of

    Notre Dame

    Saint Mary'sCollege

    Bethel College

    Holy CrossCollege

    20

    90

    90

    23933

    31

    312

    123

    331

    223

    123

    23

    23

    23

    331

    31

    20

    20

    202031

    31

    219

    933

    M��� �� I��������(232 - MR)

    B����� F����(120 - MR)

    L� S����(67 - MR)

    L������ T����(83 - MR)

    C������� C�����(140 - MR)

    East

    23

    5

    3

    4

    2

    1

    6

    933

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    NORTHFAR EASTEASTWESTCAMPUSDOWNTOWN

    DEVELOPMENT STAGEP������

    U���� C�����������

    R������� C��������

    A������� R����

    R����� S���

    A���������

    M����� R���

    (AF)

    (MR)

    V����� �� F��(390 - MR)

    H������� S����� L�����(136 - S�����)

    E��� S�����C������ P� II

    (407 - MR)

    U��������� V������(252 - MR)

    G����� O��(80 U����)

    G���������(200 U����)

    46 8 17 4 7 6 412,955 2,840 5,516 1,185 2,072 944 39895.5% 93.9% 98.1% 84.5% 95.6% 98.0% 96.6%

    $834 $882 $738 $685 $706 $1,625 $1,069$.97 $.97 $.91 $.80 $.79 $1.72 $1.20

    Avg. Rent $546 N/A $460 N/A N/A $787 $497Avg. $ / SF $1.21 $.95 $2.30 $.97Avg. Rent $695 $751 $627 $620 $641 $1,245 $901Avg. $ / SF $1.00 $.98 $.94 $.93 $.92 $1.95 $1.28Avg. Rent $792 $884 $737 $695 $733 $1,416 $977Avg. $ / SF $.87 $.86 $.87 $.78 $.82 $1.36 $.99Avg. Rent $1,053 $1,153 $930 $832 $735 $1,593 $1,446Avg. $ / SF $1.04 $1.14 $.91 $.82 $.74 $1.66 $1.30Avg. Rent $1,245 $1,269 $1,225 $820 $748 $2,187 N/AAvg. $ / SF $1.02 $1.02 $.99 $.65 $.61 $1.87Avg. Rent $1,625 N/A $1,296 N/A $765 $2,700 N/AAvg. $ / SF $1.10 $.86 $.56 $1.74

    2 Bd/ 2 Ba

    3 Bed

    4 Bed

    Average RentAvg Rent / Sq. Ft.

    Studio

    1 Bed

    2 Bd/ 1 Ba

    Occupancy Rate

    Entir

    e M

    arke

    t

    6-Do

    wnt

    own

    1-No

    rth

    5-Ca

    mpu

    s

    4-W

    est

    2-Fa

    r Eas

    t

    Total PropertiesTotal Units

    3-Ea

    st

    RENTS

    Property Developer Type Stage Units

    Eddy Street Commons Ph II Kite Realty Market Under Construction 407

    Villas on Fir Watermark Residential Market Under Construction 390

    University Village Redevelopment

    Notre Dame / Holladay Properties Market Planned 252

    Mill at Ironworks Flaherty & Collins Market Under Construction 232

    Commerce Center Matthews Market Planned 140

    Hellenic Senior Living AHEPA Management Company Senior Under Construction 136

    Berlin Flats TWG / Berlin Market Under Construction 120

    Liberty Tower Washington Square Realty Market Under Construction 83

    La Salle RealAmerica Market Complete 67

    Totals 1,827

    New Construction

    Recent SalesProperty Buyer UnitsCarriage House (Elkhart) Piterman Real Estate 230

    Williamsburg on the Lake (Elkhart) Piterman Real Estate 190

    Georgetown Legacy Varin Property Management 200

    Woodwind (Elkhart) Brown Capital Group 95

    Golden Oak Village Preinceton Enterprises 80

    Greenleaf Hunters Pond (Elkhart) Brown Capital Group 76

    Totals 871 3.2%

    0%

    1%

    2%

    3%

    4%

    5%

    6%

    7%

    8%

    9%

    10%

    11%

    12%

    13%

    (10,000)

    (8,000)

    (6,000)

    (4,000)

    (2,000)

    0

    2,000

    4,000

    2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018(T-12)

    Une

    mpl

    oym

    ent R

    ate

    Chan

    ge in

    Em

    ploy

    men

    t (Jo

    bs)

    Annual Change in EmploymentUnemployment Rate

    Total Establishment Employment -South Bend MSA 9/18 = 144,000 Jobs

    Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics

    2018 D

    Job Growth Unemployment RateSouth Bend MSA – Number of New Jobs

    91.6%

    89.5%

    85.7%

    87.9% 88.1%

    90.4%

    91.8%92.9%

    92.3%

    94.0%

    95.5%

    84%

    86%

    88%

    90%

    92%

    94%

    96%

    98%

    100%

    2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

    South Bend Historical Occupancy

    Source: Tikijian Associates

    2018 Done

    Top EmployersCompany # EmployeesBeacon Health System 6,913

    University of Notre Dame (Enrollment 12,124) 5,590

    South Bend Community School Corporation 3,489

    AM General (National Headquarters) 2,858

    Trinity Health / Saint Joseph Regional Medical Center 2,534

    Roman Catholic Diocese of Fort Wayne - South Bend 1,698

    Indiana University South Bend (Enrollment 7,574) 1,489

    St. Joseph County 1,132

  • 8 9Multihousing Investment Advisors

    Bloomington

    Monroe CountyAirport

    GriffyReservoir

    University Lk

    37

    46

    37

    46

    45

    446

    48

    45

    10TH STREET

    WA

    LNU

    T STREET

    3RD STREETATWATER AVENUE

    COLLEG

    E AVENU

    E

    N RO

    GERS STREET

    VERNAL PIKE

    3RD STREET

    WA

    LNU

    T STREET

    S HEN

    DERSO

    N STREET

    S COLLEG

    E MA

    LL ROA

    D

    SARE

    ROAD

    WINSLOW ROAD

    S HIG

    H STREET

    ARLINGTON ROADPATTERSON DRIVE

    ROCK

    PORT

    ROAD

    DU

    NN

    STREET

    SMITH

    ROA

    D

    CURRY PIKE

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    NORTHEASTSOUTHWESTDOWNTOWNCAMPUS

    4645

    45

    DEVELOPMENT STAGEP������

    U���� C�����������

    R������� C��������

    A�������� R����

    R����� S���

    A���������

    M����� R���

    (AF)

    (MR) T�� L���� L�����(148 - MR)

    E�����(279 - MR)

    P��� �� M�����(152 U����)

    17TH STREET

    BLOOMINGTON

    A���� V������ II(140 - MR)

    S�������� H���(92 U����)

    U���� S������ P� II(60 - MR)

    T�� A����(54 - MR)A���� W����

    (33 - MR)

    U���� �� C�������(149 - AF)

    E����(180 - MR)

    P��� S����(41 - MR)

    H�������(153 U����)

    S�������� �� C������(233 U����)

    C���S���(64 - MR)

    B-L��� H������(34 - AF)

    H������ C����(139 U����)

    R������ C����(125 U����)

    Top Employers

    92 14 24 29 9 9 711,563 1,430 3,822 3,933 1,188 690 50094.5% 98.9% 92.1% 94.5% 96.0% 96.8% 94.4%

    $1,019 $989 $986 $892 $1,010 $1,590 $1,590$1.12 $1.11 $1.14 $.99 $1.00 $1.67 $1.43

    Avg. Rent $683 $567 $675 $850 N/A $631 $635Avg. $ / SF $1.68 $1.94 $1.69 $1.57 $1.68 $1.49Avg. Rent $802 $729 $794 $791 $731 $1,113 $859Avg. $ / SF $1.21 $1.23 $1.19 $1.16 $1.14 $1.65 $1.34Avg. Rent $826 $1,047 $792 $754 $699 $1,355 $1,038Avg. $ / SF $.97 $1.22 $.97 $.85 $.86 $1.67 $1.01Avg. Rent $1,189 $954 $1,204 $1,159 $937 $1,609 $1,838Avg. $ / SF $1.16 $.98 $1.20 $1.06 $.96 $1.65 $1.63Avg. Rent $1,328 $1,302 $1,361 $1,049 $1,173 $2,244 $2,191Avg. $ / SF $1.02 $.91 $1.14 $.80 $.91 $1.80 $1.47Avg. Rent $2,125 $1,932 $1,727 $1,371 $2,051 $2,503 $3,124Avg. $ / SF $1.36 $1.36 $1.39 $.73 $1.21 $1.63 $1.68

    3 Bed

    4 Bed

    Average RentAvg Rent / Sq. Ft.

    Studio

    1 Bed

    2 Bd/ 1 Ba

    Total UnitsOccupancy Rate

    1-No

    rth

    2-Ea

    st

    2 Bd/ 2 Ba

    RENTS

    3-So

    uth

    4-W

    est

    5-Do

    wnt

    own

    Total Properties

    Entir

    e M

    arke

    t

    6-Ca

    mpu

    s

    Property Developer Type Stage Units

    Evolve CA Ventures Student Complete 279

    Ethos HM Mac Student Under Construction 180

    Union on Crescent Annex Affordable Affordable Planned 149

    The Lakes Luxury Renaissance Rentals Market Under Construction 148

    Adams Village Ph II Regency Multifamily Market Under Construction 140

    CitySide Cedarview Market Complete 64

    Urban Station Ph II HM Mac Student Planned 60

    The Annex Annex Student Living Market Planned 54

    Park South Dwellings Market Under Construction 41

    B-Line Heights Pedcor Affordable Planned 34

    Alley Works David Howard Market Planned 33

    Totals 1,182

    New Construction

    Recent SalesProperty Buyer Units

    Smallwood on College The Pierce Company 233

    Heritage Apartments Hunter Management 153

    The Park On Morton The Preiss Company / TH Real Estate 152

    Hoosier Court Hunter Management 139

    Regency Court Hunter Management 125

    Sassafras Hill Hunter Management 92

    Totals 894

    3.2%

    0%

    1%

    2%

    3%

    4%

    5%

    6%

    7%

    8%

    9%

    (2,000)

    (1,500)

    (1,000)

    (500)

    0

    500

    1,000

    1,500

    2,000

    2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018(T-12)

    Une

    mpl

    oym

    ent R

    ate

    Chan

    ge in

    Em

    ploy

    men

    t (Jo

    bs)

    Annual Change in EmploymentUnemployment Rate

    Total Establishment Employment -Bloomington MSA 9/18 = 76,900 Jobs

    Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics

    2018 Done

    Job Growth / Unemployment RateBloomington MSA – Number of New Jobs

    94.7% 95.1%

    93.0%

    94.3%

    95.5%96.0%

    94.8%94.2% 94.4%

    95.6% 96.0%

    94.5%

    86%

    88%

    90%

    92%

    94%

    96%

    98%

    100%

    2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

    Bloomington Historical Occupancy

    Source: Tikijian Associates

    2018 Done

    Company # EmployeesIndiana University - Bloomington (Enrollment 43,200) 7,000

    Cook Group (Pharmaceuticals) 3,300

    Indiana University Health - Bloomington 2,246

    Monroe County School Corporation 1,182

    Baxter Healthcare Pharmaceuticals 1,100

    City of Bloomington 690

    General Electric (Refrigeration Plant) 650

  • 9Please visit www.TAmulti.com for more information

    Lafayette / West Lafayette

    LAFAYETTE

    WEST LAFAYETTE

    SHADELANDDAYTON

    Zoo

    PurdueUniversity

    26

    65

    38

    38

    26

    25

    26

    25

    231

    231

    52

    25

    26

    52

    526443

    43

    231

    O������� F����(262 - MR)

    W����� L������ P� II(115 - MR)

    MARQ(99 - MR)

    T�� P����(54 - MR)R��� �� C�������

    (300 - MR)

    C������� �� L�������(193 U����)

    H� V���(73 - MR)

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    EASTCENTRALSOUTHW. LAFAYETTECAMPUS

    4

    2

    1

    3

    5

    52

    DEVELOPMENT STAGEP������

    U���� C�����������

    R������� C��������

    A������� R����

    R����� S���

    A���������

    M����� R���

    (AF)

    (MR)

    A����� ��D�������� P���

    (375 - MR)

    T�� H�� P���(260- MR)

    T�� H��(300 - MR)

    T���� S��� F���� P� II(132 - MR)

    S��� C��� C�������(76 - MR)

    Top Employers

    71 15 10 12 25 911,577 2,595 1,173 2,245 4,210 1,35496.4% 95.4% 96.8% 95.8% 97.0% 96.7%

    $894 $758 $740 $710 $1,125 $876$1.00 $.87 $.93 $.91 $1.06 $1.28

    Avg. Rent $618 $420 $471 $604 $677 $691Avg. $ / SF $1.48 $1.40 $1.09 $1.30 $1.76 $1.64Avg. Rent $688 $668 $658 $634 $776 $717Avg. $ / SF $1.03 $.98 $.92 $1.00 $1.14 $1.16Avg. Rent $800 $785 $912 $705 $809 $1,049Avg. $ / SF $.90 $.84 $.88 $.86 $.88 $1.43Avg. Rent $969 $881 $889 $889 $1,080 $1,019Avg. $ / SF $.97 $.81 $.95 $.84 $1.06 $1.15Avg. Rent $1,245 $938 $960 $1,030 $1,364 $1,319Avg. $ / SF $.95 $.74 $.84 $.85 $1.01 $1.27Avg. Rent $1,824 $985 N/A N/A $1,826 N/AAvg. $ / SF $1.18 $.90 $1.18

    4 Bed

    Avg RentAvg Rent / Sq. Ft.

    Studio

    1 Bed

    2 Bd/ 1 Ba

    3 Bed

    Total Units

    3-So

    uth

    4-W

    est L

    af.

    2 Bd/ 2 Ba

    1-Ea

    st

    Occupancy Rate

    Entir

    e M

    arke

    t

    5-Ca

    mpu

    s

    2-Ce

    ntra

    l

    Total Properties

    RENTS

    Property Developer Type Stage Units

    Aspire at Discovery Park Balfour Beatty Student Under Construction 375

    The Hub Core Spaces / Campus Up Student Complete 300

    Rise at Chauncey CA Ventures Student Under Construction 300

    Overture Flats Domo Development Market Complete 262

    The Hub Plus Core Spaces / Campus Up Student Under Construction 260

    Trail Side Flats Ph II Van Rooy Market Compete 132

    Wabash Landing Ph II Sheehan Company Market Under Construction 115

    MARQ Deylen Realty Market Complete 99

    Star City Crossing Milakis Homes Market Under Construction 76

    Hi Vine Weida Apartments Student Under Construction 73

    The Press Weinstein / Nelson Market Complete 54

    Totals 2,046

    New Construction

    Recent SalesProperty Buyer UnitsOverture Flats Regency Multifamily 262

    The Cottages on Lindberg Horizon Realty Advisors 193

    Totals 455

    2.6%

    0%

    1%

    2%

    3%

    4%

    5%

    6%

    7%

    8%

    9%

    10%

    (5,000)

    (4,000)

    (3,000)

    (2,000)

    (1,000)

    0

    1,000

    2,000

    3,000

    4,000

    2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018(T-12)

    Une

    mpl

    oym

    ent R

    ate

    Chan

    ge in

    Em

    ploy

    men

    t (Jo

    bs)

    Annual Change in EmploymentUnemployment Rate

    Total Establishment Employment -Lafayette MSA 9/18 = 109,700 JobsSource: Bureau of Labor Statistics

    Job Growth / Unemployment RateLafayette / West Lafayette MSA – Number of New Jobs

    93.0%

    90.7%

    92.6% 92.9%93.1% 93.0% 93.3%

    94.3% 94.5%

    95.9%96.4%

    86%

    88%

    90%

    92%

    94%

    96%

    98%

    100%

    2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

    Lafayette Historical Occupancy

    Source: Tikijian Associates

    2018 Done

    Company # EmployeesPurdue University (Enrollment 40,451) 15,304

    Suburu of Indiana (Outback / Legacy Lines) 3,300

    Caterpillar Large Engine Center 1,800

    IU Health Arnett 1,699

    Wabash National (Corporate Headquarters) 1,500

    Franciscan St. Elizabeth Hospital 1,235

    Oerlikon Fairfield (USA Headquarters) 1,233

    Alcoa / Lafayette Operations 1,000

    State Farm Insurance 700

  • 10 11Multihousing Investment Advisors

    CARMEL

    FISHERSZIONSVILLE

    GREENWOOD

    PLAINFIELD

    AVON

    BROWNSBURG

    GREENFIELD

    WESTFIELD

    31

    136

    3640

    52

    36

    LAFAYETTE RD

    32

    238

    38

    32

    267

    NOBLESVILLE38

    421

    9

    40

    13531

    13

    134DANVILLE

    39

    431

    37

    67

    267

    132

    32

    37

    69

    70

    465

    70

    465

    74

    70

    65

    65 74

    Northwest Indiana

    HAMMOND

    GARY

    IL

    CALUMET CITY

    PORTAGE

    MERRILLVILLE

    VALPARAISO

    MICHIGAN CITY

    EAST CHICAGO

    SCHERERVILLE

    HOBART

    CROWN POINT

    LA PORTE

    GRIFFITH

    CHESTERTON

    WESTVILLESOUTH HAVEN

    WHITING

    WINFIELD

    NEW CHICAGO

    KINGSFOD HEIGHT

    WANATAH

    KINGSBURY

    HIGHLAND

    Indiana DunesNational

    Lakeshore

    Indiana DunesState Park

    Kingsbury Fishand Wildlife Area

    Calumet PrairieNature Preserve

    130

    41

    DEVELOPMENT STAGEP������

    U���� C�����������

    R������� C��������

    A������� R����

    R����� S���

    A���������

    M����� R���

    (AF)

    (MR)

    90

    94

    65

    90

    80

    20

    12

    12421

    41

    30

    30

    30

    35

    6

    6

    20

    20

    12

    20

    35

    35

    41

    231

    421

    51149

    4939

    42

    2

    39212

    249

    53

    55

    53

    152

    912

    312

    2

    L��� P��� (95 - S�����)

    P�������� ��F������� S�����

    (304 - MR)

    E���� C�������(170 - MR)

    L���� �� V���������(407 - MR)

    G����� E������ W���(171 U����)

    A���� C�������(138 U����)

    S����P���� �� C���������(160 - S�����)

    A���� L���(100 U����)

    C����� D�����(83 U����)

    M�������(52 U����)ANCO R������������

    (+/-350 - MR)

    R��������� ��C����� C����

    (110 - S�����)

    N��P���� L������(200 - MR)

    65

    Top Employers

    53 30 7 1613,568 9,141 1,408 3,01993.3% 92.3% 94.0% 96.0%

    $867 $886 $647 $909$.98 $.99 $.84 $1.01

    Avg. Rent $553 $596 $461 $559Avg. $ / SF $1.19 $1.30 $.98 $1.19Avg. Rent $765 $817 $574 $752Avg. $ / SF $1.05 $1.08 $.89 $1.09Avg. Rent $842 $861 $671 $839Avg. $ / SF $.94 $.97 $.78 $.90Avg. Rent $1,056 $1,039 $836 $1,181Avg. $ / SF $.99 $.97 $.81 $1.11Avg. Rent $1,119 $1,064 $1,018 $1,283Avg. $ / SF $.94 $.91 $.78 $1.06Avg. Rent $1,135 $890 N/A $2,839Avg. $ / SF $.87 $.70 $1.77

    Avg Rent

    RENTS

    Entir

    e M

    arke

    t

    Lake

    Co

    LaPo

    rte C

    o

    Porte

    r Co

    Total PropertiesTotal Units

    Occupancy Rate

    4 Bed

    Avg Rent / Sq. Ft.

    Studio

    1 Bed

    2 Bd/ 1 Ba

    2 Bd/ 2 Ba

    3 Bed

    Property Developer Type Stage Units

    Lakes of Valparaiso Weiss Entities Market Complete 407

    ANCO Redevelopment Flaherty & Collins Market Planned 350

    Promenade at Founders Square Holladay Properties Market Under Construction 304

    NewPorte Landing Flaherty & Collins Market Planned 200

    Eagle Crossing In Good Company Market Under Construction 170

    StoryPoint of Chesterton StoryPoint Senior Under Construction 160

    Residences at Coffee Creek

    Residences Senior Living Senior Under Construction 110

    Lake Park Senior RealAmerica Senior Under Construction 95

    Totals 1,796

    New Construction

    Recent SalesProperty Buyer UnitsGolden Estates West BLVD Capital 171

    Arbor Crossing MGM Management 138

    Abbey Lane Crown Properties 100

    Canden Damada Pinnacle Group 83

    Mayfield Private Investor 52

    Totals 544

    4.1%

    0%

    1%

    2%

    3%

    4%

    5%

    6%

    7%

    8%

    9%

    10%

    11%

    12%

    (20,000)

    (18,000)

    (16,000)

    (14,000)

    (12,000)

    (10,000)

    (8,000)

    (6,000)

    (4,000)

    (2,000)

    0

    2,000

    4,000

    6,000

    8,000

    10,000

    2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018(T-12)

    Une

    mpl

    oym

    ent R

    ate

    Chan

    ge in

    Em

    ploy

    men

    t (Jo

    bs)

    Annual Change in EmploymentUnemployment Rate

    Total Establishment Employment -Northwest Indiana Region 9/18 = 282,200 Jobs

    Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics

    Job Growth / Unemployment RateNorthwest Indiana Region – Number of New Jobs

    96.9%96.0%

    94.6% 95.0%95.4%

    94.7%

    92.6% 92.5%93.4%

    92.8%93.3%

    86%

    88%

    90%

    92%

    94%

    96%

    98%

    100%

    2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018Source: Tikijian Associates

    2018 Done

    Northwest Region Historical Occupancy

    HAMMOND

    GARY

    IL

    CALUMET CITY

    PORTAGE

    MERRILLVILLE

    VALPARAISO

    MICHIGAN CITY

    EAST CHICAGO

    SCHERERVILLE

    HOBART

    CROWN POINT

    LA PORTE

    GRIFFITH

    CHESTERTON

    WESTVILLESOUTH HAVEN

    WHITING

    WINFIELD

    NEW CHICAGO

    KINGSFOD HEIGHT

    WANATAH

    KINGSBURY

    HIGHLAND

    Indiana DunesNational

    Lakeshore

    Indiana DunesState Park

    Kingsbury Fishand Wildlife Area

    Calumet PrairieNature Preserve

    130

    41

    DEVELOPMENT STAGEP������

    U���� C�����������

    R������� C��������

    A������� R����

    R����� S���

    A���������

    M����� R���

    (AF)

    (MR)

    90

    94

    65

    90

    80

    20

    12

    12421

    41

    30

    30

    30

    35

    6

    6

    20

    20

    12

    20

    35

    35

    41

    231

    421

    51149

    4939

    42

    2

    39212

    249

    53

    55

    53

    152

    912

    312

    2

    L��� P��� (95 - S�����)

    P�������� ��F������� S�����

    (304 - MR)

    E���� C�������(170 - MR)

    L���� �� V���������(407 - MR)

    G����� E������ W���(171 U����)

    A���� C�������(138 U����)

    S����P���� �� C���������(160 - S�����)

    A���� L���(100 U����)

    C����� D�����(83 U����)

    M�������(52 U����)ANCO R������������

    (+/-350 - MR)

    R��������� ��C����� C����

    (110 - S�����)

    N��P���� L������(200 - MR)

    65

    La Porte

    Company # EmployeesArcelorMittal (Steel / Manufacturing) 8,539

    Franciscan St. Margaret Health 5,347

    Community Hospital 5,100

    US Steel Corp (Steel / Manufacturing) 5,000

    NIPSCO (Utility) 4,600

    Methodist Northlake 4,385

    White Lodging (Hospitality) 2,012

  • 11Please visit www.TAmulti.com for more information

    Indianapolis Data Snapshot

    CARMEL

    FISHERSZIONSVILLE

    GREENWOOD

    PLAINFIELD

    AVON

    BROWNSBURG

    GREENFIELD

    WESTFIELD

    31

    136

    3640

    52

    36

    LAFAYETTE RD

    32

    238

    38

    32

    267

    NOBLESVILLE38

    421

    9

    40

    13531

    13

    134DANVILLE

    39

    431

    37

    67

    267

    132

    32

    37

    69

    70

    465

    70

    465

    74

    70

    65

    65 74

    93.7%

    Indianapolis Average Rent

    Indianapolis Average Occupancy

    4.5% from 2017

    $942 AVG RENT

    $0.99 RENT/SQFT

    93.5% OCC

    $770 AVG RENT

    $0.87 RENT/SQFT

    93.9% OCC

    $1,198 AVG RENT

    $1.46 RENT/SQFT

    93.2% OCC

    $677 AVG RENT

    $0.78 RENT/SQFT

    93.0% OCC

    $781 AVG RENT

    $0.88 RENT/SQFT

    94.3% OCC

    NORTHIndianapolis Average Rent

    $858

    0$1.43/SQFT

    $641

    1$1.09/SQFT

    $767

    2

    1 Ba

    $0.85/SQFT $737

    3$0.81/SQFT

    $1,054

    4$0.94/SQFT

    $1,362

    $1.16Avg. Rent/SQFT

    -94.4%

    Occupancy

    WestDowntown

    East

    South

    Clas

    s

    Clas

    s

    Clas

    s$0.90Avg. Rent/SQFT-

    94.5%Occupancy

    $0.81Avg. Rent/SQFT

    -91.8%

    Occupancy

    2$0.92/SQFT

    $993

    2 B

    a

  • 12 13Multihousing Investment Advisors

    Indianapolis Rental Market StatisticsTotal Apartment Base (units) 152,700Number of Communities (all) 820Number of Communities (> 200 units) 350Average Community Size (units) 186Average Occupancy Rate (2018) 93.7%Median Occupancy Rate (2018) 95.1%Rent Growth Rate (2017 to 2018) 4.5%Annual Rent Growth (2013 to 2018) 3.5%"Same Store" Annual Rent Growth (2017 to 2018) 2.8%"Same Store" Annual Rent Growth (2013 to 2018) 2.6%"Same Store" Annual Rent Growth (2008 to 2018) 2.2%* Total Apartment Base in units (152,700) and communities (820) equals all properties in the metro area, including properties still under construction, fully subsidized properties, and smaller properties not part of the Tikijian Associates Annual Rent Survey. The total units (142,255) and properties (729) shown in the occupancy and rent chart, below, are properties which are included in the Tikijian Associates Annual Rent Survey.

    Indpls Dwntwn North South East West Indy Indy IndyMetro Indpls Metro Metro Metro Metro Class Class Class

    Area Area Area Area Area Area A B CTotal Properties 729 126 214 133 111 145 163 322 244

    Total Units 142,255 11,463 52,314 25,886 18,081 34,511 35,650 64,423 42,182Occupancy Rate 93.7% 93.2% 93.5% 94.3% 93.0% 93.9% 94.4% 94.5% 91.8%

    4.5% 5.9% 4.3% 3.3% 4.0% 4.1% 3.4% 7.2% 5.2%Average Rent $858 $1,198 $942 $781 $677 $770 $1,136 $815 $688

    Average Rent / Sq. Ft. $.95 $1.46 $.99 $.88 $.78 $.87 $1.16 $.90 $.81Avg. Rent $641 $855 $619 $558 $500 $521 $1,110 $643 $535

    Avg. $ / SF $1.43 $1.77 $1.33 $1.39 $1.21 $1.24 $1.97 $1.33 $1.35Avg. Sq. Ft. 447 484 466 402 412 419 564 483 396Total Units 4,306 1,173 1,200 498 598 837 492 1,581 2,233

    Avg. Rent $767 $1,049 $825 $696 $605 $663 $1,000 $719 $625Avg. $ / SF $1.09 $1.50 $1.12 $.99 $.91 $.97 $1.32 $1.03 $.94

    Avg. Sq. Ft. 706 701 737 699 668 682 759 700 665Total Units 53,861 6,194 20,079 9,159 5,668 12,761 14,378 24,244 15,239

    Avg. Rent $737 $954 $822 $726 $642 $724 $951 $764 $666Avg. $ / SF $.85 $1.10 $.91 $.83 $.75 $.86 $1.03 $.87 $.79

    Avg. Sq. Ft. 867 863 900 872 854 846 926 877 846Total Units 26,284 768 6,165 6,469 5,577 7,305 2,480 11,786 12,018

    Avg. Rent $993 $1,546 $1,056 $885 $762 $883 $1,221 $918 $770Avg. $ / SF $.92 $1.40 $.95 $.84 $.73 $.83 $1.09 $.86 $.73

    Avg. Sq. Ft. 1,084 1,101 1,114 1,052 1,041 1,058 1,119 1,069 1,057Total Units 43,815 2,810 19,926 7,181 4,205 9,693 14,870 20,527 8,418

    Avg. Rent $1,054 $1,947 $1,183 $972 $840 $974 $1,383 $991 $886Avg. $ / SF $.81 $1.46 $.86 $.78 $.68 $.76 $1.03 $.77 $.69

    Avg. Sq. Ft. 1,302 1,335 1,369 1,254 1,239 1,276 1,338 1,292 1,289Total Units 12,930 294 4,764 2,382 1,840 3,650 3,147 5,753 4,030

    Avg. Rent $1,362 $2,581 $1,278 $992 $943 $968 $2,435 $946 $1,025Avg. $ / SF $.94 $1.80 $.83 $.73 $.64 $.68 $1.66 $.68 $.67

    Avg. Sq. Ft. 1,443 1,430 1,541 1,363 1,465 1,428 1,469 1,389 1,528Total Units 1,058 224 180 196 193 265 283 531 244

    Overall Rent Growth (2017 - 2018)

    3 Bedroom

    4 Bedroom

    Studio

    1 Bedroom

    2 Bedroom/ 1 Bath

    2 Bedroom/ 2 Bath

    *

  • 13Please visit www.TAmulti.com for more information

    Same Store Rent GrowthIndianapolis Metro Area

    2.8%2.6%

    2.2% 2.1%

    3.1%

    0.0%

    0.5%

    1.0%

    1.5%

    2.0%

    2.5%

    3.0%

    3.5%

    4.0%

    1-Year 5-Year 10-Year 20-Year 30-Year

    1-Year Annual Growth

    10-Year Annual Growth

    20-Year Annual Growth

    5-Year Annual Growth

    30-Year Annual Growth

    Source: Tikijian Associates

    2018 Done

    Indianapolis Rental Market Statistics

    2018 marked the 33rd consecutive year of year-over-year rent growth in the Indianapolis Metro. Although market rates have consistently grown, the early 2000’s saw “Effective Rents” (rents after concessions) actually decrease due to a boom in single-family home buying. Due to market strength and the increasing use of revenue management software, in recent years, concessions are now used less often.

    Rent in the Indianapolis Metro grew at a robust 4.5% rate in 2018.

    Average Rent per Square Footby Year Built & by Class – Indianapolis Metro Area

    $1.16

    $0.90

    $0.81

    $0.65

    $0.70

    $0.75

    $0.80

    $0.85

    $0.90

    $0.95

    $1.00

    $1.05

    $1.10

    $1.15

    $1.20

    $1.25

    Class A Class B Class C

    $1.23

    $0.95$0.98 $0.97

    $0.83 $0.83

    $0.97

    $0.65

    $0.70

    $0.75

    $0.80

    $0.85

    $0.90

    $0.95

    $1.00

    $1.05

    $1.10

    $1.15

    $1.20

    $1.25

    2010's 2000's 1990's 1980's 1970's 1960's Prior to1960's

    Includes some downtown

    rehabsSource: Tikijian Associates

    By Year Built By Class

    2018 Done

    Historical Average Rent Growth RateIndianapolis Metro Area

    4.5%

    1.1%

    4.5% 4.6%

    4.1%

    3.7%

    1.8%

    2.7%

    3.9%

    2.9%

    5.6%

    2.3%

    1.7%

    3.3%

    2.5%

    3.3%

    1.7% 1.2%

    0.5% 0.5%

    1.3%1.8%

    3.0%

    0.9% 0.8%

    2.7% 2.5%

    2.1%

    2.8%

    2.2%

    5.8%

    2.9%

    4.5%

    0.0%

    1.0%

    2.0%

    3.0%

    4.0%

    5.0%

    6.0%

    7.0%

    Aver

    age

    Rent

    Gro

    wth

    Rat

    e

    Source: Tikijian Associates

    2018 Done

    2.7%32 Yr. Avg.

    Historical Average RentIndianapolis Metro Area

    $356 $3

    72$3

    76 $393 $4

    11 $428 $4

    44$4

    52 $464 $4

    82 $496 $

    524

    $536

    $545 $5

    63 $577 $5

    96 $606

    $613

    $616

    $619

    $627 $6

    38 $657

    $663

    $668 $6

    86 $703 $7

    18 $738 $7

    54$7

    98 $821 $

    858

    $300

    $350

    $400

    $450

    $500

    $550

    $600

    $650

    $700

    $750

    $800

    $850

    $900

    Aver

    age

    Rent

    Source: Tikijian Associates

    2018 DoneAverage rents at newer properties and Class A properties greatly exceed rent at older Class B and C properties. The wide gap is primarily due to the facts that (a) developers must charge higher rents due to increasing land acquisition and construction costs; and (b) almost all new construction is at the very highest end of the market with expensive unit finishes and community amenities.

    “Same Store Rent Growth” is the rent growth of properties that have been in existence during an entire respective survey period. Properties built within that study period are not included in that period. The periods for which annual growth is the lowest include the years in which home-buying reached its peak in Indianapolis.

  • 14 15Multihousing Investment Advisors

    Indianapolis Rental Market Statistics

    2.9%

    3.5%

    2.7%

    4.1%

    -1.4%

    1.5%

    4.9%

    3.4%

    2.7%

    1.4%

    2.2% 2.1% 2.3% 2.1%

    -2.0%

    -1.0%

    0.0%

    1.0%

    2.0%

    3.0%

    4.0%

    5.0%

    6.0%

    Annual Rental Revenue Growth30 Property Sample – Class A & B – Well Managed

    2013-2018Average

    2.0%

    Source: Tikijian Associates

    In 2018:Properties with rent revenue growth = 25Properties with rent revenue declines = 5

    2018 Done

    Overall Market Vacancy RateIndianapolis Metro Area

    5%

    6%

    7%

    8%

    9%

    10%

    11%

    12%

    13%

    14%

    2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019Proj.

    Vaca

    ncy

    Rate

    • 2019 vacancy rate forecast assumes 3,400 units absorbed as compared to 3,400 units actually absorbed in 2018 • We are projecting 3,600 units will be delivered in 2018, hence the projected vacancy increases to 6.7%.• Average annual absorption has been 3,400 units since 2010 and 2,150 since 1984.

    Source: Tikijian Associates

    2018 Done

    Occupancy continues to be supported by strong demand attributed to steady job growth, individuals who prefer the rental lifestyle and those who are unable to buy a home. Student debt as well as a shortage of available houses and higher prices for those on the market are common reasons one might not be able to purchase.

    New Apartment Units (% of Base) vs. Market Vacancy Rate

    Indianapolis Metro Area

    7.1%

    9.7%

    11.2%

    9.4%

    7.7%

    8.8%8.1%

    7.1%

    6.2%

    6.8%

    8.1%

    6.4%

    8.9%

    9.2%

    9.2%

    9.3%

    10.4%

    12.0% 12.2%

    11.0% 10.4%

    9.9%

    9.2%

    10.7%

    9.2%

    8.6%8.3%

    7.9%

    8.0%

    7.2%

    6.9%

    6.8% 6.3%

    0%

    1%

    2%

    3%

    4%

    5%

    6%

    7%

    8%

    9%

    10%

    11%

    12%

    13%

    1986

    1987

    1988

    1989

    1990

    1991

    1992

    1993

    1994

    1995

    1996

    1997

    1998

    1999

    2000

    2001

    2002

    2003

    2004

    2005

    2006

    2007

    2008

    2009

    2010

    2011

    2012

    2013

    2014

    2015

    2016

    2017

    2018

    New Units as a % of Base Vacancy RateSource: Tikijian Associates

    2018 Done

    Occupancy Rate by ClassIndianapolis Metro Area

    85%86%87%88%89%90%91%92%93%94%95%96%97%98%99%

    100%

    Class A Class B Class C

    2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

    Source: Tikijian Associates

    2018 Done

    Tikijian Associates conducts an annual rental revenue study of 30 Class A and B well-managed properties. Rental revenue growth for this sample group has been consistent at 2.1%-2.3% for the past 4 years. The reason this is lower than the Indy Metro average rent growth is the larger market includes the very high rents commanded by the newest properties while the sample reflects more “same store” rent growth.

    This shows a growing demand for lower cost properties and a rising affordable housing shortage. It should be noted that the C Class of properties often reflects more significant occupancy movements due to greater occupancy declines when older properties become distressed and greater increases when older properties are purchased and rehabbed.

    This chart shows the number of new apartment units completed in a given year as a percentage of the overall inventory. The 2018 vacancy rate is the lowest since 1994, in spite of the delivery of new units. While new construction is active, many of the new projects are smaller than 1980’s and 1990’s construction due to more dense urban-oriented development.

  • 15Please visit www.TAmulti.com for more information

    Total Residential Building PermitsState of Indiana

    Source: US Census Bureau, Residential Construction Branch (includes condos, senior housing, etc.)

    10 yr. Avg. = 16,100 (total)

    5 yr. Avg. = 18,450 (total)

    2018 Done

    to 9/18

    33,8

    38

    26,0

    37

    20,4

    92

    12,3

    04

    10,0

    39

    10,5

    50

    9,83

    5

    11,0

    89

    12,6

    39

    12,6

    99

    13,4

    61

    14,8

    03

    16,5

    97

    16,6

    98

    0

    5,000

    10,000

    15,000

    20,000

    25,000

    30,000

    35,000

    40,000

    2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018(T-12)

    Num

    ber o

    f Ann

    ual P

    erm

    its

    Single Family (1 - 4 units) Multifamily (5+ units)

    Total Residential Building PermitsIndianapolis Metro Area

    Source: US Census Bureau, Residential Construction Branch (includes condos, senior housing, etc.)

    5 yr. Avg. = 8,500 (total)

    2018 Done

    to 9/18

    13,2

    32

    9,99

    2

    7,55

    4

    4,56

    1

    3,73

    2

    4,08

    8

    3,77

    7

    4,14

    4

    5,19

    1

    5,21

    6

    5,22

    3

    6,14

    2

    6,37

    2

    7,16

    1

    0

    2,000

    4,000

    6,000

    8,000

    10,000

    12,000

    14,000

    16,000

    2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018(T-12)

    Num

    ber o

    f Ann

    ual P

    erm

    its

    Single Family (1 - 4 units) Multifamily (5+ units)

    10 yr. Avg. = 7,200 (total)

    Multifamily Building Permitsas a % of Total Housing Permits

    15%12%

    9%

    31%29%

    23% 23%

    14%

    34%36%

    41%

    22%

    15% 16%

    12% 11%14%

    23%

    14%15%

    19% 20%

    28% 27%29%

    19%17%

    20%

    17%

    20%

    25%

    32%

    20% 21%

    29%

    33% 34%36%

    38%

    33% 32% 32%

    0%

    5%

    10%

    15%

    20%

    25%

    30%

    35%

    40%

    45%

    2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

    Indy MSA Indiana National

    to 9/18

    Source: US Census Bureau, Residential Construction Branch

    2018 Done

    New Apartment DevelopmentIndianapolis Metro Area

    1,09

    9

    2,52

    6

    2,48

    4

    1,75

    2

    2,83

    9

    1,93

    9

    3,52

    3 3,81

    5

    3,13

    8

    2,54

    7

    1,71

    2

    3,60

    0

    2,42

    1

    1,86

    8

    1,73

    6

    1,48

    2

    800

    2,88

    0

    2,79

    0

    3,47

    8

    1,63

    1

    1,74

    2

    0

    500

    1,000

    1,500

    2,000

    2,500

    3,000

    3,500

    4,000

    4,500

    2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018T-12

    2019Proj.

    Num

    ber o

    f Uni

    ts

    Placed in Service (Tikijian Associates) Building Permits (US Government)

    Source: Tikijian Associates survey of developers & US Census Bureau, Residential Construction Branch

    2018 Done

    to 9/18

    New ConstructionNorthside Apartment Development

    Indy North, Carmel, Fishers, Noblesville, Westfield & Zionsville

    0200400600800

    1,0001,2001,4001,6001,8002,0002,2002,4002,6002,8003,000

    Num

    ber o

    f Uni

    ts

    Indy North Carmel Fishers Noblesville Westfield Zionsville

    1,202

    878774

    455

    184344 400

    735

    1,096935 795

    1,021

    1,733 1,732 1,781

    700

    1,2821,068

    901

    New Units Delivered

    Source: Tikijian Associates survey of developers

    551

    2018 Done

    1,621

    Downtown Apartment DevelopmentIndianapolis Downtown

    124 88 133163

    83 680

    90

    236165

    406509

    991

    516

    1,369

    911

    510

    1,009

    613

    1,245

    667

    0

    200

    400

    600

    800

    1,000

    1,200

    1,400

    1,600

    1,800

    2,000

    Num

    ber o

    f Uni

    ts

    New Units Delivered

    Source: Tikijian Associates survey of developers

    2018 Done

  • 16 17Multihousing Investment Advisors

    Indianapolis Apartment Development

    CARMEL

    FISHERS

    ZIONSVILLE

    GREENWOOD

    PLAINFIELD

    AVON

    BROWNSBURG

    GREENFIELD

    WESTFIELD

    31

    86TH ST

    MERI

    DIAN

    ST465

    136

    36

    40

    52

    36

    71ST ST

    62ND ST

    56TH ST

    46TH ST

    38TH ST

    30TH ST

    79TH ST79TH ST

    KESSLER BLVD56TH ST

    46TH ST

    96TH ST

    106TH ST

    116TH ST

    131ST ST

    146TH ST

    KEYSTONE AVE

    MICHIGAN RD

    COLLEGE AVE

    16TH ST10TH ST

    RAYMOND STWASHINGTO

    N ST

    THOMPSON AVE

    EDGEWOOD AVE

    SOUTHPORT RD

    STOP 11 RD

    CO. LINE RD

    MANN

    RD

    MOOR

    ESVIL

    LE R

    D

    SHELBYVILLE RD

    ARLINGTON AVE

    EMERSON AVE

    FRANKLIN ROADPOST RD

    GERMAN CHURCH RD

    21ST ST

    79TH ST

    86TH ST

    126TH ST

    OLIO RD

    HAGUE RD

    CUMBERLAND RD

    MOORE RDLAFAYETTE RD ZIONSVILLE RD

    32

    238

    38

    MOORESVILLE

    267

    NOBLESVILLE

    38

    65

    74

    70

    74

    70

    69

    421

    9

    70

    INDIANAPOLISINT’L AIRPORT

    40

    135

    31

    WHITELAND RD

    SPRING MILL RDHA

    ZEL D

    ELL R

    D

    13

    134

    DAN JONES RD

    DANVILLE

    LEBANON

    39

    W 200 S

    ALLIS

    ONVI

    LLE

    RDBIN

    FORD

    BLVD

    431

    3767

    267

    144

    132

    32

    GRAY

    RD

    T�� C���(151 - MR)

    E������(126 - MR)

    T�� W��������(93 - MR)

    T�� Q������� R���� N����

    (196 - MR)

    37

    D����� C���� F����(240 - MR)

    S������� D���� II(160 - MR)

    OAK ST

    T������ ��C����� L���

    (210 - MR)

    E�������� S�����A���������

    (65 - AF)

    P��� 66 F����(108 - MR)

    S HIGH SCHOOL RD

    AMERIPLEX PKWY

    LYNHURST DR

    RONALD REAGAN PKWY

    SHERMAN DR

    LAFAYETTE RD

    SEE DOWNTOWNDEVELOPMENT MAP

    M�����(236- MR)

    161ST ST

    BODE

    N RD

    T�� W������(90 - MR)

    U���� G����(172 - MR)

    FIVE POINTS ROAD

    HICKORY ROAD

    MAIN STREET

    65

    SHERMAN DRIVE

    MCFARLAND ROAD

    MADISON AVENUE

    LONDON ROAD

    HURR

    ICAN

    E RO

    AD

    CLARK SCHOOL ROAD

    KENTUC

    KY AVE

    MOUNT COMFORT ROAD

    FRANKLIN ROAD

    T�� MK(99 - MR)

    C������ G���(93 - MR)

    T�� G�����(274 - MR)

    SMITH VALLEY ROADMORGANTOWN ROAD

    S����� C������(68 - AF)

    R���� H����(86 - MR)

    S���������� F����(25 - MR)

    C����� O���(205 - MR)

    S����� F����(269 - MR)

    T�� L��� U���� F����(128 - MR)

    M����� H������� C�����(64 - AF)

    N���� �� N���(186 - MR)

    RONALD REAGAN PKWY

    T�� A�������(208 - MR)

    E��� P��� ��P���� C�������

    (274 - MR)

    B������� F����(54 - AF)

    R���������� ��B�������� II

    (42- MR)

    C�� C���� ��R����� C�������

    (120 - MR)

    S���� R�� L����(32 - MR)

    A��� L������(280 - MR)

    E������ �� G�������� S������

    (180 - MR)

    S�������� S�����(132 - MR)

    G����� C����� S�����(60 - AF)

    H������� I�������� F����

    (32 - MR)

    E��� � M��� F����(117 - MR)

    MONON TRAILSEE NORTHSIDE

    DEVELOPMENT MAP

    INDIANAPOLIS

    K������ C����(64 - AF)T�� A�����(303 - MR)

    W������� T�������� D�������

    (66 - MR)

    Pendleton

    865

    465

    32

    69465

    65

    32

    238

    37

    1938

    421

    31

    WESTFIELD

    CARMEL

    NOBLESVILLE

    ZIONSVILLE

    FISHERS

    INDIANAPOLIS

    WHITESTOWN

    MCCORDSVILLE

    FORTVILLE

    KEYSTONE AVE

    116TH ST

    MAIN ST

    CARMEL DR

    SPRING MILL RD

    SMOKEY ROW RD136TH ST

    146TH ST

    TOWNE RD

    SHELBOURNE RD

    FORD RD

    ZIONSVILLE RD

    PLEASANT VALLEY RD

    OAK ST

    106TH STHAZEL DELL PKW

    Y

    GRAY RD

    OAK RIDGE RD

    CAREY RD

    161ST ST

    116TH ST

    96TH ST

    CUMBERLAND RD146TH ST

    GREENFIELD AVE

    SOUTHEASTERN PKWY

    ALLIS

    ONVIL

    LE R

    D

    OLIO RD

    106TH ST

    126TH ST

    131ST STO����� �� M���(203 - MR)

    F���� �� 146(368 - MR)

    B���� V���� II(134 - MR)

    W������� R����(136 - MR)

    T�������� R����(122 - MR)

    T�� F������ S�����

    (102 - MR)

    H������(257 - MR)

    A����(303 - MR)

    M�������� �� N���������� II(334 - MR)

    O�� O�� S�� II(81 - MR)

    S��������� S������(192 - MR)

    B������ C�������(24 - MR)

    S������ �� ��� M����(256 - MR)

    T�� P���������(237 - MR)

    32 | U���� �� N����������(210 - MR)

    S����(211 - MR)

    T�� R������� �� M������(208 - MR)

    C����� M������ F����(209 - MR)

    P��������(300 - MR)

    A��� �� Z���������(218 - MR)

    M��� �� Y��� ��F������ D�������

    (260 - MR)

    T�� L�������(83 - MR)

    T�� K����� C��� C�����

    (81 - MR)

    B���������� II(66 - MR)

    MONON TRAIL

    Northside New Development

    D���������� S����

    P������

    U���� C�����������

    R������� C��������

    S����� H������

    N����� �� U����

    A���������

    M����� R���

    (123)(AF)(MR)

  • 17Please visit www.TAmulti.com for more information

    Indianapolis Downtown Development

    2017 Starts Units 2018 Expected Starts Units 2019 Expected Starts UnitsMarket Rate Market Rate Market RateCityWay 2.0 - Buckingham 402 Promenade - Justus 300 Avon Landing - CityScape Residential/Hageman 280The Gables - Herman & Kittle 274 The Yard at Fishers District - Watermark 260 Aria of Zionsville - CityScape Residential 218Echo Park at Perry Crossing - Sila Capital 274 Harmony - J.C. Hart 257 Polk Dairy 16th/Monon - TWG Development 188Satori Pointe - CRG Residential 269 The Proscenium - AndersonBirkla 237 Harrison College Site - Milhaus 175Mosaic - Herman & Kittle 236 9 on Canal II - IPA 219 Point at Block 400 - Haven Campus / F&C 172Penrose on Mass - J.C. Hart 236 Spark - Hageman Group / Envoy 211 Samaritan Seniors @ Binford - Samaritan Cos. 13232 Union - TWG Development 210 Railyard at Midtown - Barrett & Stokely 208 Avant II - Edward Rose of Indiana 130Carmel Midtown Flats - J.C. Hart / Old Town Dev. 209 Riverview - Strategic Capital Partners / Goodwill 208 The Ardmore - Deylen / Gershman 126The Arbuckle - Flaherty & Collins 208 Notch at Nora - TWG Development 186 East & Main Flats - Rebar Development 117Union Green - Scannell Properties 172 Echelon at Greenwood Springs - Garrett Cos. 180 City's End - J.C. Hart / Jackson Development 103The MK - Milhaus Development 100 Southern Dunes II - Sheehan 160 The Levinson - Rebar Development 83The Wilshaw - Scannell & Loftus Robinson 90 The Assembly - TWG Development 132 Wren North & South at City Center - Pedcor 75River House - JTM Commerical 86 The Line Urban Flats - J.C. Hart 128 Woodland Terrace of Danville - Justus 66Roberts School Flats - Core Redevelopment 32 Cox Creek at Reagan Crossing - Freeman Development 120 Holland Playfair at City Center - Pedcor 60The E'laan - Sheikh 24 Edge - Milhaus 118 Totals - market rate 1,925Totals - market rate 2,822 The Kent at City Center - Pedcor 83

    918 Ft. Wayne Ave - Citadel / Rubicon 80 2019 Expected Starts Units2017 Starts Units Historic Irvington Flats - Core Redeveloopment 32 AffordableAffordable Slate Run Lofts - Muesing Management 32 German Church Senior Apartments - TWG / T&H 60Stokes Commons - Hoosier Housing Partners 68 Totals - market rate 3,151 Totals - affordable 60Minnie Hartmann Center- TWG / Near East 64 Totals - all 2019 1,985Totals - affordable 132 2018 Expected Starts UnitsTotals - all 2017 2,954 Affordable

    Kinnley Court - Keller Development 64Broadway Flats - Development Services 54Oxford Place II - TWG 39Totals - affordable 157Totals - all 2018 3,308

    Indianapolis Metro Area Construction Starts - 2018

    2018

    VIRGINIA AVE

    INDIANA AVE

    MASSAC

    HUSETT

    S AVE

    MERI

    DIAN

    ST

    NEW YORK ST

    10TH ST

    16TH ST

    ILLIN

    OIS

    STRE

    ET

    22ND ST

    OHIO ST

    CAPI

    TOL A

    VE

    DELA

    WAR

    E ST

    WASHINGTON ST

    EAST

    ST

    COLLEGE AVE

    31

    31

    4040

    P�������� M���

    (236 - MR)

    65 70

    70

    70

    65

    MICHIGAN ST

    WES

    T ST

    10TH ST

    MICHIGAN ST

    S HA

    RDIN

    G ST

    BELM

    ONT A

    VE

    E RI

    VERS

    IDE

    DR

    30TH ST

    LAFAYETTE RD

    T�� W��� (334 - MR)

    360 M����� S�����(292 - MR)

    O����� P���� II(39 - AF)

    747 C������(39- MR)

    V��(248 - MR)

    F����(64 - MR)

    C������� ��L������ S�����

    (111 - MR)

    A���� �� T����(107 U���� / 256 B���)

    9 �� C���� II(219 - MR)

    MLK

    JR S

    T

    C���W�� 2.0(402 - MR)

    SHELBY ST

    PROSPECT ST

    PENN

    SYLV

    ANIA

    ST

    SOUTH ST

    PENN

    SYLV

    ANIA

    ST

    COLLEGE AVE

    21ST ST

    P�����(77 - MR)

    M���� L����(142 - MR/AF)

    L���� �� P������ S�����

    (145 - MR)

    F������� F�� S�����(73 - AF)

    918 F��� W���� A��.(80 - MR)

    10TH ST

    CENTRAL AVE

    16TH ST

    10TH ST

    RURA

    L STR

    EET

    KEYS

    TONE

    AVE

    NUE HOYT AVENUE

    WASHINTON STREET

    SOUTHEASTERN AVENUE

    STAT

    E AV

    ENUE

    PLEASANT

    RUN PKW

    Y

    NEW YORK ST

    632 MLK(30 - MR)

    R��������� �� B���� 20(65 - MR)

    C���’� E��(105 - MR)

    YANDES ST

    R������ S����� F����(32 - MR)

    T�� A������(132 - MR)

    T�� A�������(132 - MR)

    946 MLK(20 - MR)

    R��������(208 - MR/AF)

    CAPI

    TOL A

    VE

    FALL C

    REEK P

    KWY D

    R

    ILLIN

    OIS

    ST

    28ND ST

    29TH ST

    25TH ST

    BURTON AVE

    TALB

    OTT S

    TT�� E’����(24 - MR)

    H������� C������S���

    (175 - MR)421

    K���� F������ L����(304 - MR)

    E��� (118 - MR)

    MONON TRAIL

    B����������(157- MR)

    P��� D����(188 - MR/AF)

    D���������� S����

    P������

    U���� C�����������

    R������� C��������

    S����� H������

    N����� �� U����

    A���������

    M����� R���

    (123)(AF)(MR)

    2017 Starts Units 2018 Expected Starts Units 2019 Expected Starts UnitsMarket Rate Market Rate Market RateCityWay 2.0 - Buckingham 402 Promenade - Justus 300 Avon Landing - CityScape Residential/Hageman 280The Gables - Herman & Kittle 274 The Yard at Fishers District - Watermark 260 Aria of Zionsville - CityScape Residential 218Echo Park at Perry Crossing - Sila Capital 274 Harmony - J.C. Hart 257 Polk Dairy 16th/Monon - TWG Development 188Satori Pointe - CRG Residential 269 The Proscenium - AndersonBirkla 237 Harrison College Site - Milhaus 175Mosaic - Herman & Kittle 236 9 on Canal II - IPA 219 Point at Block 400 - Haven Campus / F&C 172Penrose on Mass - J.C. Hart 236 Spark - Hageman Group / Envoy 211 Samaritan Seniors @ Binford - Samaritan Cos. 13232 Union - TWG Development 210 Railyard at Midtown - Barrett & Stokely 208 Avant II - Edward Rose of Indiana 130Carmel Midtown Flats - J.C. Hart / Old Town Dev. 209 Riverview - Strategic Capital Partners / Goodwill 208 The Ardmore - Deylen / Gershman 126The Arbuckle - Flaherty & Collins 208 Notch at Nora - TWG Development 186 East & Main Flats - Rebar Development 117Union Green - Scannell Properties 172 Echelon at Greenwood Springs - Garrett Cos. 180 City's End - J.C. Hart / Jackson Development 103The MK - Milhaus Development 100 Southern Dunes II - Sheehan 160 The Levinson - Rebar Development 83The Wilshaw - Scannell & Loftus Robinson 90 The Assembly - TWG Development 132 Wren North & South at City Center - Pedcor 75River House - JTM Commerical 86 The Line Urban Flats - J.C. Hart 128 Woodland Terrace of Danville - Justus 66Roberts School Flats - Core Redevelopment 32 Cox Creek at Reagan Crossing - Freeman Development 120 Holland Playfair at City Center - Pedcor 60The E'laan - Sheikh 24 Edge - Milhaus 118 Totals - market rate 1,925Totals - market rate 2,822 The Kent at City Center - Pedcor 83

    918 Ft. Wayne Ave - Citadel / Rubicon 80 2019 Expected Starts Units2017 Starts Units Historic Irvington Flats - Core Redeveloopment 32 AffordableAffordable Slate Run Lofts - Muesing Management 32 German Church Senior Apartments - TWG / T&H 60Stokes Commons - Hoosier Housing Partners 68 Totals - market rate 3,151 Totals - affordable 60Minnie Hartmann Center- TWG / Near East 64 Totals - all 2019 1,985Totals - affordable 132 2018 Expected Starts UnitsTotals - all 2017 2,954 Affordable

    Kinnley Court - Keller Development 64Broadway Flats - Development Services 54Oxford Place II - TWG 39Totals - affordable 157Totals - all 2018 3,308

    Indianapolis Metro Area Construction Starts - 2018

    2018

    2017 Starts Units 2018 Expected Starts Units 2019 Expected Starts UnitsMarket Rate Market Rate Market RateCityWay 2.0 - Buckingham 402 Promenade - Justus 300 Avon Landing - CityScape Residential/Hageman 280The Gables - Herman & Kittle 274 The Yard at Fishers District - Watermark 260 Aria of Zionsville - CityScape Residential 218Echo Park at Perry Crossing - Sila Capital 274 Harmony - J.C. Hart 257 Polk Dairy 16th/Monon - TWG Development 188Satori Pointe - CRG Residential 269 The Proscenium - AndersonBirkla 237 Harrison College Site - Milhaus 175Mosaic - Herman & Kittle 236 9 on Canal II - IPA 219 Point at Block 400 - Haven Campus / F&C 172Penrose on Mass - J.C. Hart 236 Spark - Hageman Group / Envoy 211 Samaritan Seniors @ Binford - Samaritan Cos. 13232 Union - TWG Development 210 Railyard at Midtown - Barrett & Stokely 208 Avant II - Edward Rose of Indiana 130Carmel Midtown Flats - J.C. Hart / Old Town Dev. 209 Riverview - Strategic Capital Partners / Goodwill 208 The Ardmore - Deylen / Gershman 126The Arbuckle - Flaherty & Collins 208 Notch at Nora - TWG Development 186 East & Main Flats - Rebar Development 117Union Green - Scannell Properties 172 Echelon at Greenwood Springs - Garrett Cos. 180 City's End - J.C. Hart / Jackson Development 103The MK - Milhaus Development 100 Southern Dunes II - Sheehan 160 The Levinson - Rebar Development 83The Wilshaw - Scannell & Loftus Robinson 90 The Assembly - TWG Development 132 Wren North & South at City Center - Pedcor 75River House - JTM Commerical 86 The Line Urban Flats - J.C. Hart 128 Woodland Terrace of Danville - Justus 66Roberts School Flats - Core Redevelopment 32 Cox Creek at Reagan Crossing - Freeman Development 120 Holland Playfair at City Center - Pedcor 60The E'laan - Sheikh 24 Edge - Milhaus 118 Totals - market rate 1,925Totals - market rate 2,822 The Kent at City Center - Pedcor 83

    918 Ft. Wayne Ave - Citadel / Rubicon 80 2019 Expected Starts Units2017 Starts Units Historic Irvington Flats - Core Redeveloopment 32 AffordableAffordable Slate Run Lofts - Muesing Management 32 German Church Senior Apartments - TWG / T&H 60Stokes Commons - Hoosier Housing Partners 68 Totals - market rate 3,151 Totals - affordable 60Minnie Hartmann Center- TWG / Near East 64 Totals - all 2019 1,985Totals - affordable 132 2018 Expected Starts UnitsTotals - all 2017 2,954 Affordable

    Kinnley Court - Keller Development 64Broadway Flats - Development Services 54Oxford Place II - TWG 39Totals - affordable 157Totals - all 2018 3,308

    Indianapolis Metro Area Construction Starts - 2018

    2018

  • 18 19Multihousing Investment Advisors

    2018 was another very active year for apartment sales. More than 12,900 apartment units will have changed hands in the Greater Indianapolis market by the end of the year, up 3.8% over 2017. The total dollar volume of sales increased by 11.7% to $878,000,000 in 2018 (up from $786,000,000 in 2017).

    Actual cap rates for B and better properties dropped again in 2018 falling to 5.5% from 5.6% last year. Forecast cap rates (based on buyers’ forecast net operating income) also fell in 2018 dropping to 6.4% from 6.7% in 2017. The drop evidences willingness of buyers to accept lower yields. Sale prices of Class B or better properties in the Indianapolis Metro increased from 2017 due to overall strong competition and the sale of several Class A properties this year.

    The universe of apartment investors interested in Indiana continues to expand. The increase in prospective buyers is the result of a combination of factors. First, a huge amount of capital from virtually all over the world continues to flow into the US seeking investment in real estate, and multifamily is generally viewed as the most attractive class of real estate. Secondly, steady and strong apartment fundamentals (rents and occupancies) in the Midwest offer higher current yields than available in many other markets. Finally, soaring prices in core markets and larger high-growth areas have driven many investors toward the more “reasonably priced” assets in secondary and tertiary markets.

    The most sought-after property type continues to be “value-add” properties, especially value-add properties in B or better locations. These properties offer buyers the best opportunity to significantly enhance rents through upgrades of units and amenities. The underwriting of increased rental income has allowed buyers to stretch to reach the higher prices commanded in this highly competitive market.

    Interest rate increases in 2018 have not negatively impacted sale prices or cap rates. Lenders have narrowed loan spreads somewhat to dampen the full impact of the Fed’s rate increases. Due to strong (and increasing) demand for apartment investments, buyers have accepted lower yields and/or adjusted their forecast post-sale rents to win deals.

    The most active buyer type continues to be private equity. This includes equity syndicators with small investors, larger networks of high net worth individuals, real estate funds and family offices. Institutional investors are also more actively looking in Indianapolis, generally through funds or with a joint venture partner.

    There has been no shortage of debt financing in 2018 to close acquisitions. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have been active in Indiana and the fact that Indiana remains a “pre-review” state has been no real impediment to financing, as waivers of the pre-review restrictions seem to be easily obtained. Many buyers are striving to achieve “green” status through environmental improvements - not only to benefit the planet but also to reduce their interest rate. To finance their value-add rehabs, many buyers are closing purchases with bridge loans and putting a permanent HUD or agency loan in place after renovations. HUD is still a viable financing option here but some buyers who have used HUD loans in the past have recently favored agency loans that offer periods of interest only payments in order to increase current yield.

    Apartment Sales TransactionsAll Indianapolis Metro Properties

    8,900

    6,100

    4,800

    13,100

    9,000 9,300

    6,800

    8,800

    11,800 12,400 12,900

    $878

    $0

    $100

    $200

    $300

    $400

    $500

    $600

    $700

    $800

    $900

    $1,000

    0

    2,000

    4,000

    6,000

    8,000

    10,000

    12,000

    14,000

    2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

    Mill

    ions

    of D

    olla

    rs

    Num

    ber o

    f Uni

    ts

    Units Sold Total Consideration (millions)

    Source: Tikijian Associates

    Done 2018

    Average Sale Cap RatesIndianapolis Metro Area - Class B or Better

    6.6%

    8.6%

    6.7%

    7.2%

    6.6% 6.5% 6.4%6.0%

    5.8% 5.6%5.5%

    8.2%

    9.6%

    8.8%8.6%

    7.2% 7.2%

    6.7%6.4%

    6.6% 6.7%6.4%

    5.0%

    5.5%

    6.0%

    6.5%

    7.0%

    7.5%

    8.0%

    8.5%

    9.0%

    9.5%

    10.0%

    10.5%

    11.0%

    Cap

    Rat

    e

    Actual Cap Rate Forecast Cap RateSource: Tikijian Associates

    2018 Done

    Average Price per UnitClass B or Better, Over 100 Units

    Indianapolis Metro Area

    $45,800

    $40,600

    $55,800

    $44,900

    $77,100

    $88,600 $88,000

    $97,400

    $106,500

    $97,600

    $104,000

    $56

    $41

    $56$49

    $77

    $92 $92

    $93

    $111$110 $110

    $40$45$50$55$60$65$70$75$80$85$90$95$100$105$110$115$120

    $40,000$45,000$50,000$55,000$60,000$65,000$70,000$75,000$80,000$85,000$90,000$95,000

    $100,000$105,000$110,000$115,000$120,000

    2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

    Pric

    e pe

    r Squ

    are

    Foot

    Pric

    e pe

    r Uni

    t

    Price per Unit Price per Sq. Ft.Source: Tikijian Associates

    2018 Done

    Sales Activity

  • 19Please visit www.TAmulti.com for more information

    Cottages of Fall Creek 753 UnitsIndianapolisDouble Creek Flats 240 UnitsPlainfield

    Fountain Parc 240 UnitsIndianapolis

    Overture Flats 262 UnitsLafayette

    The Win 24 UnitsIndianapolisSmallwood228 Units

    Bloomington

    Flats at Switch 102 UnitsFishers

    Westlake 1,381 UnitsIndianapolis

    Indy Portfolio 602 UnitsIndianapolis

    Salem on 56th &Retreat Northwest

    724 UnitsIndianapolis

    NW Indy Portfolio 1,427 UnitsIndianapolis

    Overlook at Valley Ridge & Summerwood on Towne

    624 UnitsIndianapolis

    Selected 2018 Indiana Apartment Sales

  • Multihousing Investment Advisors

    WWW.TAMULTI.COM

    FIND US ON:

    3755 E. 82nd St., Suite 265, Indianapolis, IN 46240 - P(317) 578-0088 - F(317) 570-3677

    George Tikijian III, CCIMSenior Managing Director

    [email protected]

    Hannah Ott, CCIMSenior Managing Director

    [email protected]

    Duke HardySenior Managing Director

    [email protected]

    Cameron BenzAnalyst

    [email protected]

    Kimberly FetzerManaging Director

    [email protected]

    John BakerDirector

    [email protected]

    Christine NealisMarketing Director

    [email protected]

    TIKIJIAN ASSOCIATES2018 MARKET SHARE

    #1 MARKET SHAREINDIANAPOLIS 2018-YTD

    6,920TOTAL UNITS

    54% BY

    NUM

    BER

    OF

    UNIT

    S51% BY DOLL

    AR

    VOLU

    ME