55
,IMRVMGL ,IMRI (IYXWGLPERH )MR ;MRXIVQmVGLIR -Q XVEYVMKIR 1SREX 2SZIQFIV [EVW (MI 8EKI [YVHIR XVFIV (IV ;MRH VM ZSR HIR &mYQIR HEW 0EYF (E VIMWX MGL REGL (IYXWGLPERH LMRFIV 9RH EPW MGL ER HMI +VIR^I OEQ (E JLPX MGL IMR WXmVOIVIW /PSTJIR -R QIMRIV &VYWX MGL KPEYFI WSKEV (MI %YKIR FIKYRRIR ^Y XVSTJIR 9RH EPW MGL HMI HIYXWGLI 7TVEGLI ZIVRELQ (E [EVH QMV WIPXWEQ ^YQYXI -GL QIMRXI RMGLX ERHIVW EPW SF HEW ,IV^ 6IGLX ERKIRILQ ZIVFPYXI )MR OPIMRIW ,EVJIRQmHGLIR WERK 7MI WERK QMX [ELVIQ +IJLPI 9RH JEPWGLIV 7XMQQI HSGL [EVH MGL WILV +IVLVIX ZSR MLVIQ 7TMIPI 7MI WERK ZSR 0MIFI YRH 0MIFIWKVEQ %YJSTJVYRK YRH ;MIHIVJMRHIR (SVX SFIR MR NIRIV FIWWIVIR ;IPX ;S EPPI 0IMHIR WGL[MRHIR 7MI WERK ZSQ MVHMWGLIR .EQQIVXEP :SR *VIYHIR HMI FEPH ^IVVSRRIR :SQ .IRWIMXW [S HMI 7IIPI WGL[IPKX :IVOPmVX MR I[KIR ;SRRIR 7MI WERK HEW EPXI )RXWEKYRKWPMIH (EW )METSTIME ZSQ ,MQQIP ;SQMX QER IMRPYPPX [IRR IW KVIMRX (EW :SPO HIR KVSIR 0QQIP -GL OIRRI HMI ;IMWI MGL OIRRI HIR 8I\X -GL OIRR EYGL HMI ,IVVIR :IVJEWWIV -GL [IM WMI XVEROIR LIMQPMGL ;IMR 9RH TVIHMKXIR }JJIRXPMGL ;EWWIV )MR RIYIW 0MIH IMR FIWWIVIW 0MIH 3 *VIYRHI [MPP MGL IYGL HMGLXIR ;MV [SPPIR LMIV EYJ )VHIR WGLSR (EW ,MQQIPVIMGL IVVMGLXIR

,IMRVMGL,IMRI (IYXWGLPERH )MR;MRXIVQmVGLIR · ,imrvmgl,imri (iyxwglperh )mr;mrxivqmvglir-qxveyvmkir1srex2sziqfiv[ ev w (mi8eki[yvhirxv‡fiv (iv;mrhvm−zsrhir&myqirh ew0eyf (evimwxmglregl(iyxwglperhlmr‡fiv

  • Upload
    phamnhi

  • View
    223

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

,IMRVMGL�,IMRI

(IYXWGLPERH��)MR�;MRXIVQmVGLIR

-Q�XVEYVMKIR�1SREX�2SZIQFIV�[EV�W�(MI�8EKI�[YVHIR�XV�FIV�(IV�;MRH�VM��ZSR�HIR�&mYQIR�HEW�0EYF�(E�VIMWX�MGL�REGL�(IYXWGLPERH�LMR�FIV�

9RH�EPW�MGL�ER�HMI�+VIR^I�OEQ�(E�J�LPX�MGL�IMR�WXmVOIVIW�/PSTJIR-R�QIMRIV�&VYWX��MGL�KPEYFI�WSKEV(MI�%YKIR�FIKYRRIR�^Y�XVSTJIR�

9RH�EPW�MGL�HMI�HIYXWGLI�7TVEGLI�ZIVRELQ�(E�[EVH�QMV�WIPXWEQ�^YQYXI�-GL�QIMRXI�RMGLX�ERHIVW��EPW�SF�HEW�,IV^6IGLX�ERKIRILQ�ZIVFPYXI�

)MR�OPIMRIW�,EVJIRQmHGLIR�WERK�7MI�WERK�QMX�[ELVIQ�+IJ�LPI9RH�JEPWGLIV�7XMQQI��HSGL�[EVH�MGL�WILV+IV�LVIX�ZSR�MLVIQ�7TMIPI�

7MI�WERK�ZSR�0MIFI�YRH�0MIFIWKVEQ�%YJSTJVYRK�YRH�;MIHIVJMRHIR(SVX�SFIR��MR�NIRIV�FIWWIVIR�;IPX�;S�EPPI�0IMHIR�WGL[MRHIR�

7MI�WERK�ZSQ�MVHMWGLIR�.EQQIVXEP�:SR�*VIYHIR��HMI�FEPH�^IVVSRRIR�:SQ�.IRWIMXW��[S�HMI�7IIPI�WGL[IPKX:IVOPmVX�MR�I[�KIR�;SRRIR�

7MI�WERK�HEW�EPXI�)RXWEKYRKWPMIH�(EW�)METSTIME�ZSQ�,MQQIP�;SQMX�QER�IMRPYPPX��[IRR�IW�KVIMRX�(EW�:SPO��HIR�KVS�IR�0�QQIP�

-GL�OIRRI�HMI�;IMWI��MGL�OIRRI�HIR�8I\X�-GL�OIRR�EYGL�HMI�,IVVIR�:IVJEWWIV�-GL�[IM���WMI�XVEROIR�LIMQPMGL�;IMR9RH�TVIHMKXIR�}JJIRXPMGL�;EWWIV�

)MR�RIYIW�0MIH��IMR�FIWWIVIW�0MIH�3�*VIYRHI��[MPP�MGL�IYGL�HMGLXIR�;MV�[SPPIR�LMIV�EYJ�)VHIR�WGLSR(EW�,MQQIPVIMGL�IVVMGLXIR�

;MV�[SPPIR�EYJ�)VHIR�KP�GOPMGL�WIMR�9RH�[SPPIR�RMGLX�QILV�HEVFIR�:IVWGLPIQQIR�WSPP�RMGLX�HIV�JEYPI�&EYGL�;EW�JPIM�MKI�,mRHI�IV[EVFIR�

)W�[mGLWX�LMIRMIHIR�&VSX�KIRYK*�V�EPPI�1IRWGLIROMRHIV�%YGL�6SWIR�YRH�1]VXIR��7GL}RLIMX�YRH�0YWX�9RH�>YGOIVIVFWIR�RMGLX�QMRHIV�

.E��>YGOIVIVFWIR�J�V�NIHIVQERR�7SFEPH�HMI�7GLSXIR�TPEX̂ IR�(IR�,MQQIP��FIVPEWWIR�[MV(IR�)RKIPR�YRH�HIR�7TEX^IR�

9RH�[EGLWIR�YRW�*P�KIP�REGL�HIQ�8SH�7S�[SPPIR�[MV�IYGL�FIWYGLIR(SVX�SFIR��YRH�[MV��[MV�IWWIR�QMX�IYGL(MI�WIPMKWXIR�8SVXIR�YRH�/YGLIR�

)MR�RIYIW�0MIH��IMR�FIWWIVIW�0MIH�)W�OPMRKX�[MI�*P}XIR�YRH�+IMKIR�(EW�1MWIVIVI�MWX�ZSVFIM�(MI�7XIVFIKPSGOIR�WGL[IMKIR�

(MI�.YRKJIV�)YVSTE�MWX�ZIVPSFX1MX�HIQ�WGL}RIR�+IRMYWWI(IV�*VIMLIMX��WMI�PMIKIR�IMRERHIV�MQ�%VQ�7MI�WGL[IPKIR�MQ�IVWXIR�/YWWI�

9RH�JILPX�HIV�4JEJJIRWIKIR�HEFIM�(MI�)LI�[MVH�K�PXMK�RMGLX�QMRHIV��)W�PIFI�&VmYXMKEQ�YRH�&VEYX�9RH�MLVI�^YO�RJXMKIR�/MRHIV�

)MR�,SGL^IMXOEVQIR�MWX�QIMR�0MIH�(EW�FIWWIVI��HEW�RIYI�-R�QIMRIV�7IIPI�KILIR�EYJ(MI�7XIVRI�HIV�L}GLWXIR�;IMLI��

&IKIMWXIVXI�7XIVRI��WMI�PSHIVR�[MPH�>IVJPMI�IR�MR�*PEQQIRFmGLIR��-GL�J�LPI�QMGL�[YRHIVFEV�IVWXEVOX�-GL�O}RRXI�)MGLIR�^IVFVIGLIR�

7IMX�MGL�EYJ�HIYXWGLI�)VHI�XVEX�(YVGLWXV}QIR�QMGL�>EYFIVWmJXI��(IV�6MIWI�LEX�[MIHIV�HMI�1YXXIV�FIV�LVX�

9RH�IW�[YGLWIR�MLQ�RIY�HMI�/VmJXI�

'%498�--

;mLVIRH�HMI�/PIMRI�ZSR�,MQQIPWPYWX+IXVMPPIVX�YRH�QYWM^MIVIX�;EVH�ZSR�HIR�TVIY�MWGLIR�(SYERMIVW1IMR�/SJJIV�ZMWMXMIVIX�

&IWGLR�JJIPXIR�EPPIW��OVEQXIR�LIVYQ-R�,IQHIR��,SWIR��7GLRYTJX�GLIVR�7MI�WYGLXIR�REGL�7TMX^IR��REGL�&MNSYXIVMIR�%YGL�REGL�ZIVFSXIRIR�&�GLIVR�

-LV�8SVIR��HMI�MLV�MQ�/SJJIV�WYGLX�,MIV�[IVHIX�MLV�RMGLXW�IRXHIGOIR�(MI�/SRXIVFERHI��HMI�QMX�QMV�VIMWX�(MI�LEF�MGL�MQ�/STJI�WXIGOIR�

,MIV�LEF�MGL�7TMX^IR��HMI�JIMRIV�WMRH%PW�HMI�ZSR�&V�WWIP�YRH�1IGLIPR�9RH�TEGO�MGL�IMRWX�QIMRI�7TMX^IR�EYW�7MI�[IVHIR�IYGL�WXMGLIPR�YRH�LIGLIPR�

-Q�/STJI�XVEKI�MGL�&MNSYXIVMIR�(IV�>YOYRJX�/VSRHMEQERXIR�(MI�8IQTIPOPIMRSHMIR�HIW�RIYIR�+SXXW�(IW�KVS�IR�9RFIOERRXIR�

9RH�ZMIPI�&�GLIV�XVEK�MGL�MQ�/STJ�-GL�HEVJ�IW�IYGL�ZIVWMGLIVR�1IMR�/STJ�MWX�IMR�^[MXWGLIVRHIW�:SKIPRIWX:SR�OSRJMW^MIVPMGLIR�&�GLIVR�

+PEYFX�QMV��MR�7EXERW�&MFPMSXLIO/ERR�IW�RMGLX�WGLPMQQIVI�KIFIR�7MI�WMRH�KIJmLVPMGLIV�RSGL�EPW�HMI:SR�,SJJQERR�ZSR�*EPPIVWPIFIR���

)MR�4EWWEKMIV��HIV�RIFIR�QMV�WXERH�&IQIVOXI�QMV��MGL�LmXXI.IX̂ X�ZSV�QMV�HIR�TVIY�MWGLIR�>SPPZIVIMR�(MI�KVS�I�(SYERIROIXXI�

«(IV�>SPPZIVIMRª���FIQIVOXI�IV��«;MVH�YRWIV�:SPOWXYQ�FIKV�RHIR�)V�[MVH�HEW�^IVWTPMXXIVXI�:EXIVPERH

>Y�IMRIQ�+ER^IR�ZIVFMRHIR�

)V�KMFX�HMI�mY�IVI�)MRLIMX�YRW�(MI�WSKIRERRX�QEXIVMIPPI�(MI�KIMWXMKI�)MRLIMX�KMFX�YRW�HMI�>IRWYV�(MI�[ELVLEJX�MHIIPPI��

7MI�KMFX�HMI�MRRIVI�)MRLIMX�YRW�(MI�)MRLIMX�MQ�(IROIR�YRH�7MRRIR�)MR�IMRMKIW�(IYXWGLPERH�XYX�YRW�RSX�)MRMK�REGL�EY�IR�YRH�MRRIR�ª

'%498�---

>Y�%EGLIR��MQ�EPXIR�(SQI��PMIKX'EVSPYW�1EKRYW�FIKVEFIR��1ER�QY��MLR�RMGLX�ZIV[IGLWIPR�QMX�/EVP1E]IV��HIV�PIFX�MR�7GL[EFIR�

-GL�Q}GLXI�RMGLX�XSX�YRH�FIKVEFIR�WIMR%PW�/EMWIV�^Y�%EGLIR�MQ�(SQI�;IMX�PMIFIV�PIFX��MGL�EPW�OPIMRWXIV�4SIX>Y�7XYOOIVX�EQ�2IGOEVWXVSQI�

>Y�%EGLIR�PERK[IMPIR�WMGL�EYJ�HIV�7XVE��(MI�,YRHI��WMI�JPILR�YRXIVXmRMK�«+MF�YRW�IMRIR�*Y�XVMXX��S�*VIQHPMRK��HEW�[MVH:MIPPIMGLX�YRW�̂ IVWXVIYIR�IMR�[IRMK�ª

-GL�FMR�MR�HMIWIQ�PERK[IMP�KIR�2IWX)MR�7X�RHGLIR�LIVYQKIWGLPIRHIVX�7EL�[MIHIV�TVIY�MWGLIW�1MPMXmV�,EX�WMGL�RMGLX�WILV�ZIVmRHIVX�

)W�WMRH�HMI�KVEYIR�1mRXIP�RSGL1MX�HIQ�LSLIR��VSXIR�/VEKIR���(EW�6SX�FIHIYXIX�*VER^SWIRFPYX�7ERK�/}VRIV�MR�JV�LIVIR�8EKIR�

2SGL�MQQIV�HEW�L}P̂ IVR�TIHERXMWGLI�:SPO�2SGL�MQQIV�IMR�VIGLXIV�;MROIP-R�NIHIV�&I[IKYRK��YRH�MQ�+IWMGLX(IV�IMRKIJVSVIRI�(�ROIP�

7MI�WXIP̂ IR�RSGL�MQQIV�WS�WXIMJ�LIVYQ�7S�OIV^IRKIVEHI�KIWGLRMIKIPX�%PW�LmXXIR�WMI�ZIVWGLPYGOX�HIR�7XSGO�

;SQMX�QER�WMI�IMRWX�KITV�KIPX�

.E��KER^�ZIVWGL[ERH�HMI�*YGLXIP�RMI�7MI�XVEKIR�WMI�NIX^X�MQ�-RRIVR�(EW�XVEYPMGLI�(Y�[MVH�MQQIV�RSGL%R�HEW�EPXI�)V�IVMRRIVR�

(IV�PERKI�7GLRYVVFEVX�MWX�IMKIRXPMGL�RYV(IW�>STJXYQW�RIYIVI�4LEWI�(IV�>STJ��HIV�ILQEPW�LMRXIR�LMRK�(IV�LmRKX�NIX̂ X�YRXIV�HIV�2EWI�

2MGLX��FIP�KIJMIP�QMV�HEW�RIYI�/SWX�Q(IV�6IYXIV��HEW�QY��MGL�PSFIR�&IWSRHIVW�HMI�4MGOIPLEYFI��HIR�,IPQ1MX�HIV�WXmLPIVRIR�7TMX^I�REGL�SFIR�

(EW�MWX�WS�VMXXIVX�QPMGL�YRH�QELRX%R�HIV�:SV^IMX�LSPHI�6SQERXMO�%R�HMI�&YVKJVEY�.SLERRE�ZSR�1SRXJEYGSR�%R�HIR�*VIMLIVVR�*SYUYq��9LPERH��8MIGO�

(EW�QELRX�ER�HEW�1MXXIPEPXIV�WS�WGL}R�%R�)HIPORIGLXI�YRH�/RETTIR�(MI�MR�HIQ�,IV^IR�KIXVEKIR�HMI�8VIY9RH�EYJ�HIQ�,MRXIVR�IMR�;ETTIR�

(EW�QELRX�ER�/VIY^^YK�YRH�8YVRIM�%R�1MRRI�YRH�JVSQQIW�(MIRIR�%R�HMI�YRKIHVYGOXI�+PEYFIRW^IMX�;S�RSGL�OIMRI�>IMXYRK�IVWGLMIRIR�

.E��NE��HIV�,IPQ�KIJmPPX�QMV��IV�^IYKX:SQ�EPPIVL}GLWXIR�;MX̂ I�)MR�O}RMKPMGLIV�)MRJEPP�[EV�W�)W�JILPX�RMGLX�HMI�4SMRXI��HMI�7TMX^I�

2YV�J�VGLX�MGL��[IRR�IMR�+I[MXXIV�IRXWXILX�>MILX�PIMGLX�WS�IMRI�7TMX̂ I,IVEF�EYJ�IYIV�VSQERXMWGLIW�,EYTX(IW�,MQQIPW�QSHIVRWXI�&PMX̂ I�����

>Y�%EGLIR��EYJ�HIQ�4SWXLEYWWGLMPH�7EL�MGL�HIR�:SKIP�[MIHIV�(IV�QMV�WS�XMIJ�ZIVLE�X��:SPP�+MJX7GLEYXI�IV�EYJ�QMGL�RMIHIV�

(Y�Lm�PMGLIV�:SKIP��[MVWX�HY�IMRWX1MV�MR�HMI�,mRHI�JEPPIR�

7S�VYTJI�MGL�HMV�HMI�*IHIVR�EYW9RH�LEGOI�HMV�EF�HMI�/VEPPIR�

(Y�WSPPWX�QMV�HERR��MR�PYJX�KIV�,}L��%YJ�IMRIV�7XERKI�WMX^IR�9RH�MGL�VYJI�^YQ�PYWXMKIR�7GLMI�IR�LIVFIM(MI�VLIMRMWGLIR�:SKIPWGL�X^IR�

;IV�QMV�HIR�:SKIP�LIVYRXIVWGLMI�X�1MX�>ITXIV�YRH�/VSRI�FIPILR�MGL(IR�[EGOIVR�1ERR��;MV�FPEWIR�8YWGL9RH�VYJIR��«)W�PIFI�HIV�/}RMK�ª

'%498�-:

>Y�/}PPIR�OEQ�MGL�WTmXEFIRHW�ER�(E�L}VXI�MGL�VEYWGLIR�HIR�6LIMRJPY��(E�JmGLIPXI�QMGL�WGLSR�HIYXWGLI�0YJX�(E�J�LPX�MGL�MLVIR�)MRJPY���

%YJ�QIMRIR�%TTIXMX��-GL�E�(SVX�)MIVOYGLIR�QMX�7GLMROIR�9RH�HE�IV�WILV�KIWEP^IR�[EV�1Y�X�MGL�EYGL�6LIMR[IMR�XVMROIR�

(IV�6LIMR[IMR�KPmR^X�RSGL�MQQIV�[MI�+SPH-Q�KV�RIR�6}QIVKPEWI�9RH�XVMROWX�HY�IX[IPGLI�7GLSTTIR�^YZMIP�7S�WXIMKX�IV�HMV�MR�HMI�2EWI�

-R�HMI�2EWI�WXIMKX�IMR�4VMGOIPR�WS�W���1ER�OERR�WMGL�ZSV�;SRRI�RMGLX�PEWWIR�)W�XVMIF�QMGL�LMREYW�MR�HMI�HmQQIVRHI�2EGLX�-R�HMI�[MHIVLEPPIRHIR�+EWWIR�

(MI�WXIMRIVRIR�,mYWIV�WGLEYXIR�QMGL�ER�%PW�[SPPXIR�WMI�QMV�FIVMGLXIR0IKIRHIR�EYW�EPXZIVWGLSPPIRIV�>IMX�(IV�LIMP�KIR�7XEHX�/}PPIR�+IWGLMGLXIR�

.E��LMIV�LEX�IMRWX�HMI�/PIVMWIM-LV�JVSQQIW�;IWIR�KIXVMIFIR�,MIV�LEFIR�HMI�(YROIPQmRRIV�KILIVVWGLX�(MI�9PVMGL�ZSR�,YXXIR�FIWGLVMIFIR�

(IV�'ERGER�HIW�1MXXIPEPXIVW�[EVH�LMIV+IXER^X�ZSR�2SRRIR�YRH�1}RGLIR�

,MIV�WGLVMIF�,SGLWXVEEXIR��HIV�1IR^IP�ZSR�/}PR�(MI�KMJX�KIR�(IRYR^MEXM}RGLIR�

(MI�*PEQQI�HIW�7GLIMXIVLEYJIRW�LEX�LMIV&�GLIV�YRH�1IRWGLIR�ZIVWGLPYRKIR�(MI�+PSGOIR�[YVHIR�KIPmYXIX�HEFIM9RH�/]VMI�IPIMWSR�KIWYRKIR�

(YQQLIMX�YRH�&SWLIMX�FYLPXIR�LMIV+PIMGL�,YRHIR�EYJ�JVIMIV�+EWWI�(MI�)ROIPFVYX�IVOIRRX�QER�RSGL�LIYX%R�MLVIQ�+PEYFIRWLEWWI���

(SGL�WMILI��HSVX�MQ�1SRHIRWGLIMR(IR�OSPSWWEPIR�+IWIPPIR�)V�VEKX�ZIVXIYJIPX�WGL[EV^�IQTSV�(EW�MWX�HIV�(SQ�ZSR�/}PPIR�

)V�WSPPXI�HIW�+IMWXIW�&EWXMPPI�WIMR�9RH�HMI�PMWXMKIR�6}QPMRKI�HEGLXIR�-R�HMIWIQ�6MIWIROIVOIV�[MVH(MI�HIYXWGLI�:IVRYRJX�ZIVWGLQEGLXIR�

(E�OEQ�HIV�0YXLIV��YRH�IV�LEX7IMR�KVS�IW�«,EPX�ª�KIWTVSGLIR��7IMX�NIRIQ�8EKI�FPMIF�HIV�&EY(IW�(SQIW�YRXIVFVSGLIR�

)V�[EVH�RMGLX�ZSPPIRHIX���YRH�HEW�MWX�KYX�(IRR�IFIR�HMI�2MGLXZSPPIRHYRK1EGLX�MLR�^YQ�(IROQEP�ZSR�(IYXWGLPERHW�/VEJX9RH�TVSXIWXERXMWGLIV�7IRHYRK�

-LV�EVQIR�7GLIPQI�ZSQ�(SQZIVIMR�-LV�[SPPX�QMX�WGL[EGLIR�,mRHIR*SVXWIX^IR�HEW�YRXIVFVSGLIRI�;IVO�9RH�HMI�EPXI�>[MRKFYVK�ZSPPIRHIR�

3�X}VMGLXIV�;ELR��:IVKIFIRW�[MVH+IWGL�XXIPX�HIV�/PMRKIPFIYXIP�+IFIXXIPX�FIM�/IX^IVR�YRH�.YHIR�WSKEV�-WX�EPPIW�JVYGLXPSW�YRH�IMXIP�

:IVKIFIRW�[MVH�HIV�KVS�I�*VER^�0MW^X>YQ�&IWXIR�HIW�(SQW�QYWM̂ MIVIR�9RH�IMR�XEPIRXZSPPIV�/}RMK�[MVH:IVKIFIRW�HIOPEQMIVIR�

)V�[MVH�RMGLX�ZSPPIRHIX��HIV�/}PRIV�(SQ�

3FKPIMGL�HMI�2EVVIR�MR�7GL[EFIR>Y�WIMRIQ�*SVXFEY�IMR�KER^IW�7GLMJJ:SPP�7XIMRI�KIWIRHIX�LEFIR�

)V�[MVH�RMGLX�ZSPPIRHIX��XVSX^�EPPIQ�+IWGLVIM(IV�6EFIR�YRH�HIV�)YPIR�(MI��EPXIVX�QPMGL�KIWMRRX��WS�KIVR-R�LSLIR�/MVGLX�VQIR�[IMPIR�

.E��OSQQIR�[MVH�HMI�>IMX�WSKEV�;S�QER��WXEXX�MLR�^Y�ZSPPIRHIR�(MI�MRRIVIR�6mYQI�^Y�IMRIQ�7XEPP*�V�4JIVHI�[MVH�ZIV[IRHIR�

«9RH�[MVH�HIV�(SQ�IMR�4JIVHIWXEPP�;EW�WSPPIR�[MV�HERR�FIKMRRIR1MX�HIR�,IMP�KIR�(VIM�/}R�KIR��HMI�HE�VYLR-Q�8EFIVREOIP�HE�HVMRRIR#ª

7S�L}VI�MGL�JVEKIR��(SGL�FVEYGLIR�[MV�YRW-R�YRWIVIV�>IMX�^Y�KIRMIVIR#(MI�,IMP�KIR�(VIM�/}R�KI�EYW�1SVKIRPERH�7MI�O}RRIR�[SERHIVW�PSKMIVIR�

*SPKX�QIMRIQ�6EX�YRH�WXIGOX�WMI�LMRIMR-R�NIRI�HVIM�/}VFI�ZSR�)MWIR�(MI�LSGL�^Y�1�RWXIV�LmRKIR�EQ�8YVQ�(IV�7EROX�0EQFIVXM�KILIM�IR�

(IV�7GLRIMHIVO}RMK�WE��HEVMR1MX�WIMRIR�FIMHIR�6mXIR�;MV�EFIV�FIRYX^IR�HMI�/}VFI�NIX̂ X*�V�ERHVI�1ENIWXmXIR�

>YV�6IGLXIR�WSPP�,IVV�&EPXLEWEV�>YV�0MROIR�,IVV�1IPGLMSV�WGL[IFIR�-R�HIV�1MXXI�,IVV�+EWTEV���+SXX�[IM���[MI�IMRWX(MI�HVIM�KILEYWX�MQ�0IFIR�

(MI�,IMP�KI�%PPMER^�HIW�1SVKIRPERHW�(MI�NIX^X�OERSRMWMIVIX�7MI�LEX�ZMIPPIMGLX�RMGLX�MQQIV�WGL}R9RH�JVSQQ�WMGL�EYJKIJ�LVIX�

(IV�&EPXLEWEV�YRH�HIV�1IPGLMSV�(EW�[EVIR�ZMIPPIMGLX�^[IM�+mYGLI�(MI�MR�HIV�2SX�IMRI�/SRWXMXYXMSR:IVWTVSGLIR�MLVIQ�6IMGLI�

9RH�WTmXIV�RMGLX�;SVX�KILEPXIR���)W�LEX,IVV�+EWTEV��HIV�/}RMK�HIV�1SLVIR�:MIPPIMGLX�QMX�WGL[EV^IQ�9RHERO�WSKEV&IPSLRX�WIMR�:SPO��HMI�8SVIR�

'%498�:

9RH�EPW�MGL�ER�HMI�6LIMRFV�GO��OEQ�;SLP�ER�HMI�,EJIRWGLER^I�(E�WEL�MGL�JPMI�IR�HIR�:EXIV�6LIMR-Q�WXMPPIR�1SRHIRKPER^I�

«7IM�QMV�KIKV��X��QIMR�:EXIV�6LIMR�;MI�MWX�IW�HMV�IVKERKIR#-GL�LEFI�SJX�ER�HMGL�KIHEGLX1MX�7ILRWYGLX�YRH�:IVPERKIR�ª

7S�WTVEGL�MGL��HE�L}VX�MGL�MQ�;EWWIV�XMIJ+EV�WIPXWEQ�KVmQPMGLI�8}RI�;MI�,�WXIPR�IMRIW�EPXIR�1ERRW�)MR�&V�QQIPR�YRH�[IMGLIW�+IWX}LRI�

«;MPPOSQQIR��QIMR�.YRKI��HEW�MWX�QMV�PMIF�(E��HY�QMGL�RMGLX�ZIVKIWWIR�7IMX�HVIM^ILR�.ELVIR�WEL�MGL�HMGL�RMGLX�1MV�KMRK�IW�WGLPIGLX�YRXIVHIWWIR�

>Y�&MFIVMGL�LEF�MGL�7XIMRI�ZIVWGLPYGOX�;ELVLEJXMK��WMI�WGLQIGOXIR�RMGLX�PIGOIV�(SGL�WGL[IVIV�PMIKIR�MQ�1EKIR�QMV(MI�:IVWI�ZSR�2MOPEW�&IGOIV�

)V�LEX�QMGL�FIWYRKIR��EPW�SF�MGL�RSGL(MI�VIMRWXI�.YRKJIV�[mVI�(MI�WMGL�ZSR�RMIQERH�VEYFIR�Pm�X(EW�/VmR^PIMR�MLVIV�)LVI�

;IRR�MGL�IW�L}VI��HEW�HYQQI�0MIH�(ERR�Q}GLX�MGL�QMV�^IVVEYJIR(IR�[IM�IR�&EVX��MGL�Q}GLXI�J�V[ELV1MGL�MR�QMV�WIPFWX�IVWEYJIR�

(E��MGL�OIMRI�VIMRI�.YRKJIV�FMR�(MI�*VER^SWIR�[MWWIR�IW�FIWWIV�7MI�LEFIR�QMX�QIMRIQ�;EWWIV�WS�SJX:IVQMWGLX�MLV�7MIKIVKI[mWWIV�

(EW�HYQQI�0MIH�YRH�HIV�HYQQI�/IVP�)V�LEX�QMGL�WGLQmLPMGL�FPEQMIVIX�+I[MWWIVQE�IR�LEX�IV�QMGL�EYGL4SPMXMWGL�OSQTVSQMXXMIVIX�

(IRR�OILVIR�NIX^X�HMI�*VER^SWIR�̂ YV�GO�7S�QY��MGL�ZSV�MLRIR�IVV}XIR�-GL��HIV�YQ�MLVI�6�GOOILV�WS�SJX1MX�8VmRIR�^YQ�,MQQIP�KIFIXIR�

-GL�LEFI�WMI�MQQIV�WS�PMIFKILEFX�(MI�PMIFIR�OPIMRIR�*VER^}WGLIR��7MRKIR�YRH�WTVMRKIR�WMI�RSGL�[MI�WSRWX#8VEKIR�RSGL�[IM�I�,}WGLIR#

-GL�Q}GLXI�WMI�KIVRI�[MIHIVWILR�(SGL�J�VGLX�MGL�HMI�4IVWMJPEKI�:SR�[IKIR�HIW�ZIV[�RWGLXIR�0MIHW�:SR�[IKIR�HIV�&PEQEKI�

(IV�%PJVIH�HI�1YWWIX��HIV�+EWWIRFYF��(IV�OSQQX�ER�MLVIV�7TMX^I:MIPPIMGLX�EPW�8EQFSYV��YRH�XVSQQIPX�QMV�ZSV%PP�WIMRI�WGLPIGLXIR�;MX^I�ª

7S�OPEKXI�HIV�EVQI�:EXIV�6LIMR�/SRRX�WMGL�RMGLX�^YJVMIHIRKIFIR�-GL�WTVEGL�^Y�MLQ�QERGL�XV}WXIRHIW�;SVX�9Q�MLQ�HEW�,IV^�^Y�LIFIR�

«3�J�VGLXI�RMGLX��QIMR�:EXIV�6LIMR�(IR�WT}XXIPRHIR�7GLIV^�HIV�*VER^SWIR�7MI�WMRH�HMI�EPXIR�*VER^SWIR�RMGLX�QILV�%YGL�XVEKIR�WMI�ERHIVI�,SWIR�

(MI�,SWIR�WMRH�VSX�YRH�RMGLX�QILV�[IM��7MI�LEFIR�EYGL�ERHIVI�/R}TJI�7MI�WMRKIR�RMGLX�QILV��WMI�WTVMRKIR�RMGLX�QILV�7MI�WIROIR�REGLHIROPMGL�HMI�/}TJI�

7MI�TLMPSWSTLMIVIR�YRH�WTVIGLIR�NIX̂ X:SR�/ERX��ZSR�*MGLXI�YRH�,IKIP�7MI�VEYGLIR�8EFEO��WMI�XVMROIR�&MIV�9RH�QERGLI�WGLMIFIR�EYGL�/IKIP�

7MI�[IVHIR�4LMPMWXIV�KER^�[MI�[MV�9RH�XVIMFIR�IW�IRHPMGL�RSGL�mVKIV�7MI�WMRH�OIMRI�:SPXEMVMERIV�QILV�7MI�[IVHIR�,IRKWXIRFIVKIV�

(IV�%PJVIH�HI�1YWWIX��HEW�MWX�[ELV�-WX�RSGL�IMR�+EWWIRNYRKI�(SGL�J�VGLXI�RMGLXW��[MV�JIWWIPR�MLQ(MI�WGLmRHPMGLI�7T}XXIV^YRKI�

9RH�XVSQQIPX�IV�HMV�IMRIR�WGLPIGLXIR�;MX^�7S�TJIMJIR�[MV�MLQ�IMRIR�WGLPMQQIVR�;MV�TJIMJIR�MLQ�ZSV��[EW�MLQ�TEWWMIVX&IM�WGL}RIR�*VEYIR^MQQIVR�

+MF�HMGL�̂ YJVMIHIR��:EXIV�6LIMR�(IRO�RMGLX�ER�WGLPIGLXI�0MIHIV�)MR�FIWWIVIW�0MIH�ZIVRMQQWX�HY�FEPH��0IF�[SLP��[MV�WILIR�YRW�[MIHIV�ª

'%498�:-

(IR�4EKERMRM�FIKPIMXIXI�WXIXW)MR�7TMVMXYW�JEQMPMEVMW�1ERGLQEP�EPW�,YRH��QERGLQEP�MR�+IWXEPX(IW�WIPMKIR�+ISVK�,EVV]W�

2ETSPISR�WEL�IMRIR�VSXIR�1ERR:SV�NIHIQ�[MGLX�KIR�)VIMKRMW�7SOVEXIW�LEXXI�WIMRIR�(mQSR�(EW�[EV�OIMR�,MVRIV^IYKRMW�

-GL�WIPFWX��[IRR�MGL�EQ�7GLVIMFXMWGL�WE�(IW�2EGLXW��LEF�MGL�KIWILIR>Y[IMPIR�IMRIR�ZIVQYQQXIR�+EWX9RLIMQPMGL�LMRXIV�QMV�WXILIR�

9RXIV�HIQ�1ERXIP�LMIPX�IV�IX[EW:IVFSVKIR��HEW�WIPXWEQ�FPMROXI�;IRR�IW�̂ YQ�:SVWGLIMR�OEQ��YRH�IMR�&IMP�)MR�6MGLXFIMP��^Y�WIMR�QMV�H�ROXI�

)V�WGLMIR�ZSR�YRXIVWIX^XIV�7XEXYV�(MI�%YKIR�[MI�^[IM�7XIVRI�)V�WX}VXI�QMGL�MQ�7GLVIMFIR�RMI�&PMIF�VYLMK�WXILR�MR�HIV�*IVRI�

7IMX�.ELVIR�LEXXI�MGL�RMGLX�KIWILR(IR�WSRHIVFEVIR�+IWIPPIR�(E�JERH�MGL�MLR�TP}X^PMGL�[MIHIV�LMIV-R�HIV�WXMPPIR�1SRHREGLX�̂ Y�/}PPIR�

-GL�WGLPIRHIVXI�WMRRIRH�HMI�7XVE�IR�IRXPERK�(E�WEL�MGL�MLR�LMRXIV�QMV�KILIR�%PW�SF�IV�QIMR�7GLEXXIR�[mVI��YRH�WXERH-GL�WXMPP��WS�FPMIF�IV�WXILIR�

&PMIF�WXILIR��EPW�[EVXIXI�IV�EYJ�[EW�9RH�J}VHIVXI�MGL�HMI�7GLVMXXI�(ERR�JSPKXI�IV�[MIHIV��7S�OEQIR�[MV&MW�EYJ�HIW�(SQTPEX^��1MXXI�

)W�[EVH�QMV�YRPIMHPMGL��MGL�HVILXI�QMGL�YQ9RH�WTVEGL��«.IX^X�WXIL�QMV�6IHI�;EW�JSPKWX�HY�QMV�EYJ�;IK�YRH�7XIK,MIV�MR�HIV�RmGLXPMGLIR�hHI#

-GL�XVIJJI�HMGL�MQQIV�MR�HIV�7XYRH��;S�;IPXKIJ�LPI�WTVMI�IR-R�QIMRIV�&VYWX�YRH�HYVGL�HEW�,MVR(MI�+IMWXIWFPMX^I�WGLMI�IR�

(Y�WMILWX�QMGL�ER�WS�WXMIV�YRH�JIWX��7XIL�6IHI��;EW�ZIVL�PPWX�HY,MIV�YRXIV�HIQ�1ERXIP��HEW�LIMQPMGL�FPMROX#;IV�FMWX�HY�YRH�[EW�[MPPWX�HY#ª

(SGL�NIRIV�IV[MHIVXI�XVSGOIRIR�8SRW�7SKEV�IMR�FM�GLIR�TLPIKQEXMWGL�«-GL�FMXXI�HMGL��I\SV^MIVI�QMGL�RMGLX�9RH�[IVHI�RYV�RMGLX�IQTLEXMWGL�

-GL�FMR�OIMR�+IWTIRWX�HIV�:IVKERKIRLIMX�/IMR�KVEFIRXWXMIKIRIV�7XVSL[MWGL�9RH�ZSR�6LIXSVMO�FMR�MGL�OIMR�*VIYRH�&MR�EYGL�RMGLX�WILV�TLMPSWSTLMWGL�

-GL�FMR�ZSR�TVEOXMWGLIV�2EXYV�9RH�MQQIV�WGL[IMKWEQ�YRH�VYLMK�(SGL�[MWWI��[EW�HY�IVWSRRIR�MQ�+IMWX�(EW�J�LV�MGL�EYW��HEW�XY�MGL�

9RH�KILR�EYGL�.ELVI�HV�FIV�LMR�-GL�VEWXI�RMGLX��FMW�MGL�ZIV[ERHPI-R�;MVOPMGLOIMX��[EW�HY�KIHEGLX�(Y�HIROWX��YRH�MGL��MGL�LERHPI�

(Y�FMWX�HIV�6MGLXIV��HIV�&�XXIP�FMR�MGL�9RH�QMX�HIQ�+ILSVWEQ�HIW�/RIGLXIW:SPPWXVIGO��MGL�HEW�9VXIMP��HEW�HY�KIJmPPX�

9RH�WIM�IW�IMR�YRKIVIGLXIW�

(IQ�/SRWYP�XVYK�QER�IMR�&IMP�ZSVER>Y�6SQ��MR�EPXIR�8EKIR�%YGL�HY�LEWX�HIMRIR�0MOXSV��HSGL�[MVH(EW�&IMP�HMV�REGLKIXVEKIR�

-GL�FMR�HIMR�0MOXSV��YRH�MGL�KIL&IWXmRHMK�QMX�HIQ�FPEROIR6MGLXFIMPI�LMRXIV�HMV���MGL�FMR(MI�8EX�ZSR�HIMRIQ�+IHEROIR�ª

'%498�:--

-GL�KMRK�REGL�,EYW�YRH�WGLPMIJ��EPW�SF(MI�)RKIP�KI[MIKX�QMGL�LmXXIR�1ER�VYLX�MR�HIYXWGLIR�&IXXIR�WS�[IMGL�(IRR�HEW�WMRH�*IHIVFIXXIR�

;MI�WILRX�MGL�QMGL�SJX�REGL�HIV�7��MKOIMX(IW�ZEXIVPmRHMWGLIR�4J�LPIW�;IRR�MGL�EYJ�LEVXIR�1EXVEX^IR�PEK�-R�HIV�WGLPEJPSWIR�2EGLX�HIW�)\MPIW�

1ER�WGLPmJX�WILV�KYX�YRH�XVmYQX�EYGL�KYX-R�YRWIVIR�*IHIVFIXXIR�,MIV�J�LPX�HMI�HIYXWGLI�7IIPI�WMGL�JVIM:SR�EPPIR�)VHIROIXXIR�

7MI�J�LPX�WMGL�JVIM�YRH�WGL[MRKX�WMGL�IQTSV>Y�HIR�L}GLWXIR�,MQQIPWVmYQIR�3�HIYXWGLI�7IIPI��[MI�WXSP^�MWX�HIMR�*PYK-R�HIMRIR�RmGLXPMGLIR�8VmYQIR�

(MI�+}XXIV�IVFPIMGLIR��[IRR�HY�RELWX�(Y�LEWX�EYJ�HIMRIR�;IKIR+EV�QERGLIW�7XIVRPIMR�EYWKITYX^X1MX�HIMRIR�*P�KIPWGLPmKIR�

*VER^SWIR�YRH�6YWWIR�KIL}VX�HEW�0ERH�(EW�1IIV�KIL}VX�HIR�&VMXIR�;MV�EFIV�FIWMX̂ IR�MQ�0YJXVIMGL�HIW�8VEYQW(MI�,IVVWGLEJX�YRFIWXVMXXIR�

,MIV��FIR�[MV�HMI�,IKIQSRMI�,MIV�WMRH�[MV�YR^IVWX�GOIPX�(MI�ERHIVR�:}POIV�LEFIR�WMGL

%YJ�TPEXXIV�)VHI�IRX[MGOIPX�����

9RH�EPW�MGL�IMRWGLPMIJ��HE�XVmYQXI�QMV�-GL�WGLPIRHIVXI�[MIHIV�MQ�LIPPIR1SRHWGLIMR�HMI�LEPPIRHIR�7XVE�IR�IRXPERK�-R�HIQ�EPXIVX�QPMGLIR�/}PPIR�

9RH�LMRXIV�QMV�KMRK�[MIHIV�IMRLIV1IMR�WGL[EV^IV��ZIVQYQQXIV�&IKPIMXIV�-GL�[EV�WS�Q�HI��QMV�FVEGLIR�HMI�/RMI�(SGL�MQQIV�KMRKIR�[MV�[IMXIV�

;MV�KMRKIR�[IMXIV��1IMR�,IV^�MR�HIV�&VYWX;EV�OPEJJIRH�EYJKIWGLRMXXIR�9RH�EYW�HIV�,IV^IRW[YRHI�LIVZSV(MI�VSXIR�8VSTJIR�KPMXXIR�

-GL�XEYGLXI�QERGLQEP�HMI�*MRKIV�LMRIMR�9RH�QERGLQEP�MWX�IW�KIWGLILIR�(E��MGL�HMI�,EYWX�VTJSWXIR�FIWXVMGL1MX�HIQ�&PYX�MQ�:SV�FIVKILIR�

9RH�NIHIWQEP��[IRR�MGL�IMR�,EYW&I^IMGLRIX�MR�WSPGLIV�;IMWI�)MR�7XIVFIKP}GOGLIR�IVWGLSPP�JIVRLIV�;ILQ�XMK�[MQQIVRH�YRH�PIMWI�

%Q�,MQQIP�EFIV�IVFPMGL�HIV�1SRH�)V�[YVHI�MQQIV�XV�FIV�+PIMGL�WGL[EV^IR�6SWWIR�NEKXIR�ER�MLQ(MI�[MPHIR�;SPOIR�ZSV�FIV�

9RH�MQQIV�KMRK�LMRXIV�QMV�IMRLIV1MX�WIMRIQ�ZIVFSVKIRIR�&IMPI(MI�HYROPI�+IWXEPX���WS�[ERHIVXIR�[MV;SLP�IMRI�KYXI�;IMPI�

;MV�KILIR�YRH�KILIR��FMW�[MV�^YPIX^X;MIHIV�^YQ�(SQTPEX^�KIPERKIR�;IMX�SJJIR�WXERHIR�HMI�4JSVXIR�HSVX�;MV�WMRH�LMRIMRKIKERKIR�

)W�LIVVWGLXI�MQ�YRKILIYVIR�6EYQ2YV�8SH�YRH�2EGLX�YRH�7GL[IMKIR�)W�FVERRXIR�%QTIPR�LMI�YRH�HE�9Q�HMI�(YROIPLIMX�VIGLX�^Y�^IMKIR�

-GL�[ERHIPXI�PERKI�HIR�4JIMPIVR�IRXPERK9RH�L}VXI�RYV�HMI�8VMXXI

:SR�QIMRIQ�&IKPIMXIV��IV�JSPKXI�QMV%YGL�LMIV�FIM�NIHIQ�7GLVMXXI�

;MV�OEQIR�IRHPMGL�̂ Y�IMRIQ�3VX�;S�JYROIPRHI�/IV^IRLIPPI9RH�FPMX^IRHIW�+SPH�YRH�)HIPWXIMR�(EW�[EV�HMI�(VIM�/}RMKW�/ETIPPI�

(MI�,IMP�KIR�(VIM�/}RMKI�NIHSGL�(MI�WSRWX�WS�WXMPP�HSVX�PEKIR�3�;YRHIV��WMI�WE�IR�EYJVIGLX�NIX^X%YJ�MLVIR�7EVOSTLEKIR�

(VIM�8SXIRKIVMTTI��TLERXEWXMWGL�KITYX^X�1MX�/VSRIR�EYJ�HIR�IPIRHIR:IVKMPFXIR�7GLmHIPR��WMI�XVYKIR�EYGL(EW�>ITXIV�MR�OR}GLIVRIR�,mRHIR�

;MI�,EQTIPQmRRIV�FI[IKXIR�WMI(MI�PmRKWXZIVWXSVFIRIR�/RSGLIR�(MI�LEFIR�REGL�1SHIV�YRH�^YKPIMGL2EGL�;IMLVEYGLHYJX�KIVSGLIR�

(IV�IMRI�FI[IKXI�WSKEV�HIR�1YRH9RH�LMIPX�IMRI�6IHI��WILV�PERKI�)V�WIX^XI�QMV�EYWIMRERHIV��[EVYQ)V�QIMRIR�6IWTIOX�ZIVPERKI�

>YIVWX�[IMP�IV�IMR�8SXIV�WIM�9RH�^[IMXIRW�[IMP�IV�IMR�/}RMK�9RH�HVMXXIRW�[IMP�IV�IMR�,IMP�KIV�WIM��(EW�EPPIW�V�LVXI�QMGL�[IRMK�

-GL�KEF�MLQ�^YV�%RX[SVX�PEGLIRHIR�1YXW�«:IVKIFIRW�MWX�HIMRI�&IQ�LYRK�-GL�WILI��HE��HY�HIV�:IVKERKIRLIMX+IL}VWX�MR�NIHIV�&I^MILYRK�

*SVX��JSVX�ZSR�LMIV��MQ�XMIJIR�+VEF-WX�IYVI�REX�VPMGLI�7XIPPI�(EW�0IFIR�RMQQX�NIX̂ X�MR�&IWGLPEK(MI�7GLmX^I�HMIWIV�/ETIPPI�

(IV�>YOYRJX�JV}LPMGLI�/EZEPPIVMI7SPP�LMIV�MQ�(SQI�LEYWIR�9RH�[IMGLX�MLV�RMGLX�[MPPMK��WS�FVEYGL�MGL�+I[EPX9RH�PE��IYGL�QMX�/SPFIR�PEYWIR�ª

7S�WTVEGL�MGL��YRH�MGL�HVILXI�QMGL�YQ�

(E�WEL�MGL�JYVGLXFEV�FPMROIR(IW�WXYQQIR�&IKPIMXIVW�JYVGLXFEVIW�&IMP��9RH�IV�ZIVWXERH�QIMR�;MROIR�

)V�RELXI�WMGL��YRH�QMX�HIQ�&IMP>IVWGLQIXXIVXI�IV�HMI�EVQIR7OIPIXXI�HIW�%FIVKPEYFIRW��IV�WGLPYK7MI�RMIHIV�SLR��)VFEVQIR�

)W�HV}LRXI�HIV�,MIFI�;MHIVLEPP%YW�EPPIR�+I[}PFIR��IRXWIX̂ PMGL���&PYXWXV}QI�WGLSWWIR�EYW�QIMRIV�&VYWX�9RH�MGL�IV[EGLXI�TP}X^PMGL�

'%498�:---

:SR�/}PPIR�FMW�,EKIR�OSWXIX�HMI�4SWX*�RJ�8EPIV�WIGLW�+VSWGLIR�TVIY�MWGL�(MI�(MPMKIRGI�[EV�PIMHIV�FIWIX^X�9RH�MGL�OEQ�MR�HMI�SJJIRI�&IMGLEMW��

)MR�7TmXLIVFWXQSVKIR��JIYGLX�YRH�KVEY�-Q�7GLPEQQI�OIYGLXI�HIV�;EKIR�(SGL�XVSX^�HIW�WGLPIGLXIR�;IXXIVW�YRH�;IKW(YVGLWXV}QXI�QMGL�W��IW�&ILEKIR�

(EW�MWX�NE�QIMRI�,IMQEXPYJX�(MI�KP�LIRHI�;ERKI�IQTJERH�IW�9RH�HMIWIV�0ERHWXVE�IROSX��IV�MWX(IV�(VIGO�QIMRIW�:EXIVPERHIW�

(MI�4JIVHI�[IHIPXIR�QMX�HIQ�7GL[ER^7S�XVEYPMGL�[MI�EPXI�&IOERRXI�9RH�MLVI�1MWXO�GLPIMR�H�ROXIR�QMV�WGL}R;MI�HMI�cTJIP�HIV�%XEPERXI�

;MV�JYLVIR�HYVGL�1�LPLIMQ��(MI�7XEHX�MWX�RIXX�(MI�1IRWGLIR�WXMPP�YRH�JPIM�MK�;EV�HSVX�^YPIX^X�MQ�1SREX�1EM(IW�.ELVIW�IMRYRHHVIM�MK�

(EQEPW�WXERH�EPPIW�MQ�&P�XIRWGLQYGO�9RH�HMI�7SRRIRPMGLXIV�PEGLXIR�(MI�:}KIP�WERKIR�WILRWYGLXZSPP�9RH�HMI�1IRWGLIR�LSJJXIR�YRH�HEGLXIR��

7MI�HEGLXIR���(MI�QEKIVI�6MXXIVWGLEJX

;MVH�FEPH�ZSR�LMRRIR�VIMWIR�9RH�HIV�%FWGLMIHWXVYRO�[MVH�MLRIR�OVIHIR^X%YW�PERKIR�*PEWGLIR�ZSR�)MWIR�

9RH�HMI�*VIMLIMX�OSQQX�QMX�7TMIP�YRH�8ER^�1MX�HIV�*ELRI��HIV�[IM�FPEYVSXIR�:MIPPIMGLX�LSPX�WMI�WSKEV�EYW�HIQ�+VEF(IR�&SRETEVXI��HIR�8SXIR��

%GL�+SXX��HMI�6MXXIV�WMRH�MQQIV�RSGL�LMIV�9RH�QERGLI�HMIWIV�+mYGLI�(MI�WTMRHIPH�VVI�KIOSQQIR�MRW�0ERH�(MI�LEFIR�NIX^X�HMGOI�&mYGLI�

(MI�FPEWWIR�/EREMPPIR��HMI�EYWKIWILR;MI�0MIFI��+PEYFIR�YRH�,SJJIR�7MI�LEFIR�WIMXHIQ�MR�YRWIVQ�;IMR7MGL�VSXI�2EWIR�KIWSJJIR������

9RH�HMI�*VIMLIMX�LEX�WMGL�HIR�*Y��ZIVVIROX�/ERR�RMGLX�QILV�WTVMRKIR�YRH�WX�VQIR�(MI�8VMOSPSVI�MR�4EVMW7GLEYX�XVEYVMK�LIVEF�ZSR�HIR�8�VQIR�

(IV�/EMWIV�MWX�EYJIVWXERHIR�WIMXHIQ�(SGL�HMI�IRKPMWGLIR�;�VQIV�LEFIR%YW�MLQ�IMRIR�WXMPPIR�1ERR�KIQEGLX�9RH�IV�PMI��WMGL�[MIHIV�FIKVEFIR�

,EF�WIPFIV�WIMR�0IMGLIRFIKmRKRMW�KIWILR�-GL�WEL�HIR�KSPHIRIR�;EKIR9RH�HMI�KSPHIRIR�7MIKIWK}XXMRRIR�HVEYJ�(MI�HIR�KSPHIRIR�7EVK�KIXVEKIR�

(IR�)P]WmMWGLIR�*IPHIVR�IRXPERK�(YVGL�HIW�8VMYQTLIW�&SKIR�;SLP�HYVGL�HIR�2IFIP��[SLP��FIV�HIR�7GLRII/EQ�PERKWEQ�HIV�>YK�KI^SKIR�

1M�X}RIRH�WGLEYIVPMGL�[EV�HMI�1YWMO�(MI�1YWMOERXIR�WXEVVXIR:SV�/mPXI��;ILQ�XMK�KV��XIR�QMGL(MI�%HPIV�HIV�7XERHEVXIR�

(MI�1IRWGLIR�WGLEYXIR�WS�KIMWXIVLEJX-R�EPXIV�)VMRRVYRK�ZIVPSVIR��(IV�MQTIVMEPI�1mVGLIRXVEYQ;EV�[MIHIV�LIVEYJFIWGL[SVIR�

-GL�[IMRXI�ER�NIRIQ�8EK��1MV�WMRH(MI�8VmRIR�MRW�%YKI�KIOSQQIR�%PW�MGL�HIR�ZIVWGLSPPIRIR�0MIFIWVYJ�(EW�«:MZI�P�)QTIVIYV�ª��ZIVRSQQIR�

'%498�-<

:SR�/}PPIR�[EV�MGL�HVIM�:MIVXIP�EYJ�EGLX(IW�1SVKIRW�JSVXKIVIMWIX�;MV�OEQIR�REGL�,EKIR�WGLSR�KIKIR�HVIM�(E�[MVH�^Y�1MXXEK�KIWTIMWIX�

(IV�8MWGL�[EV�KIHIGOX��,MIV�JERH�MGL�KER^(MI�EPXKIVQERMWGLI�/�GLI�7IM�QMV�KIKV��X��QIMR�7EYIVOVEYX�,SPHWIPMK�WMRH�HIMRI�+IV�GLI�

+IWXSZXI�/EWXERMIR�MQ�KV�RIR�/SLP�7S�E��MGL�WMI�IMRWX�FIM�HIV�1YXXIV�-LV�LIMQMWGLIR�7XSGOJMWGLI��WIMH�QMV�KIKV��X�;MI�WGL[MQQX�MLV�OPYK�MR�HIV�&YXXIV�

.IH[IHIQ�J�LPIRHIR�,IV^IR�FPIMFX(EW�:EXIVPERH�I[MK�XIYIV��-GL�PMIFI�EYGL�VIGLX�FVEYR�KIWGLQSVX(MI�&�GOPMRKI�YRH�)MIV�

;MI�NEYGL^XIR�HMI�;�VWXI�MQ�WTVMX^IPRHIR�*IXX�(MI�/VEQQIXWZ}KIP��HMI�JVSQQIR+IFVEXIRIR�)RKPIMR�QMX�%TJIPQYW�7MI�^[MXWGLIVXIR�QMV��«;MPPOSQQIR�ª

«;MPPOSQQIR��0ERHWQERRª���̂ [MXWGLIVXIR�WMI��«&MWX�PERKI�EYWKIFPMIFIR�,EWX�HMGL�QMX�JVIQHIQ�+IZ}KIP�WS�PERK-R�HIV�*VIQHI�LIVYQKIXVMIFIR�ª

)W�WXERH�EYJ�HIQ�8MWGLI�IMRI�+ERW�)MR�WXMPPIW��KIQ�XPMGLIW�;IWIR�7MI�LEX�ZMIPPIMGLX�QMGL�IMRWX�KIPMIFX�%PW�[MV�FIMHI�RSGL�NYRK�KI[IWIR�

7MI�FPMGOXI�QMGL�ER�WS�FIHIYXYRKWZSPP�7S�MRRMK��WS�XVIY��WS�[ILI�&IWE��IMRI�WGL}RI�7IIPI�KI[M��(SGL�[EV�HEW�*PIMWGL�WILV�^mLI�

%YGL�IMRIR�7GL[IMRWOSTJ�XVYK�QER�EYJ-R�IMRIV�^MRRIVRIR�7GL�WWIP�2SGL�MQQIV�WGLQ�GOX�QER�HIR�7GL[IMRIR�FIM�YRW1MX�0SVFIIVFPmXXIVR�HIR�6�WWIP�

'%498�<

(MGLX�LMRXIV�,EKIR�[EVH�IW�2EGLX�9RH�MGL�J�LPXI�MR�HIR�+IHmVQIR)MR�WIPXWEQIW�*V}WXIPR��-GL�OSRRXI�QMGL�IVWX>Y�9RRE��MQ�;MVXWLEYW��IV[mVQIR�

)MR�L�FWGLIW�1mHGLIR�JERH�MGL�HSVX�(MI�WGLIROXI�QMV�JVIYRHPMGL�HIR�4YRWGL�IMR�;MI�KIPFI�7IMHI�HEW�0SGOIRLEEV�(MI�%YKIR�WERJX�[MI�1SRHWGLIMR�

(IR�PMWTIPRH�[IWXJmPMWGLIR�%O^IRX:IVRELQ�MGL�QMX�;SPPYWX�[MIHIV�:MIP�W��I�)VMRRIVYRK�HEQTJXI�HIV�4YRWGL�-GL�HEGLXI�HIV�PMIFIR�&V�HIV�

(IV�PMIFIR�;IWXJEPIR��[SQMX�MGL�WS�SJX-R�+}XXMRKIR�KIXVYROIR�&MW�[MV�KIV�LVX�IMRERHIV�ERW�,IV^9RH�YRXIV�HMI�8MWGLI�KIWYROIR�

-GL�LEFI�WMI�MQQIV�WS�PMIFKILEFX�(MI�PMIFIR��KYXIR�;IWXJEPIR�)MR�:SPO��WS�JIWX��WS�WMGLIV��WS�XVIY�+ER^�SLRI�+PIM�IR�YRH�4VELPIR�

;MI�WXERHIR�WMI�TVmGLXMK�EYJ�HIV�1IRWYV1MX�MLVIR�0}[IRLIV^IR�)W�JMIPIR�WS�KVEHI��WS�ILVPMGL�KIQIMRX�(MI�5YEVXIR�YRH�HMI�8IV^IR�

7MI�JIGLXIR�KYX��WMI�XVMROIR�KYX�9RH�[IRR�WMI�HMI�,ERH�HMV�VIMGLIR>YQ�*VIYRHWGLEJXWF�RHRMW��HERR�[IMRIR�WMI�7MRH�WIRXMQIRXEPI�)MGLIR�

(IV�,MQQIP�IVLEPXI�HMGL��[EGOVIW�:SPO�)V�WIKRI�HIMRI�7EEXIR�&I[ELVI�HMGL�ZSV�/VMIK�YRH�6YLQ�:SV�,IPHIR�YRH�,IPHIRXEXIR�

)V�WGLIROI�HIMRIR�7}LRIR�WXIXW)MR�WILV�KIPMRHIW�)\EQIR�9RH�HIMRI�8}GLXIV�FVMRKI�IV�L�FWGL9RXIV�HMI�,EYFI���%QIR�

'%498�<-

(EW�MWX�HIV�8IYXSFYVKIV�;EPH�(IR�8EGMXYW�FIWGLVMIFIR�(EW�MWX�HIV�OPEWWMWGLI�1SVEWX�;S�:EVYW�WXIGOIRKIFPMIFIR�

,MIV�WGLPYK�MLR�HIV�'LIVYWOIVJ�VWX�(IV�,IVQERR��HIV�IHPI�6IGOI�(MI�HIYXWGLI�2EXMSREPMXmX�(MI�WMIKXI�MR�HMIWIQ�(VIGOI�

;IRR�,IVQERR�RMGLX�HMI�7GLPEGLX�KI[ERR�1MX�WIMRIR�FPSRHIR�,SVHIR�7S�KmF�IW�HIYXWGLI�*VIMLIMX�RMGLX�QILV�;MV�[mVIR�V}QMWGL�KI[SVHIR�

-R�YRWIVIQ�:EXIVPERH�LIVVWGLXIR�NIX̂ X2YV�V}QMWGLI�7TVEGLI�YRH�7MXXIR�:IWXEPIR�KmF�IW�MR�1�RGLIR�WSKEV�(MI�7GL[EFIR�LMI�IR�5YMVMXIR�

(IV�,IRKWXIRFIVK�[mV�IMR�,EVYWTI\9RH�KV�FIPXI�MR�HIR�+IHmVQIR:SR�3GLWIR��2IERHIV�[mV�IMR�%YKYV9RH�WGLEYXI�REGL�:}KIPWGL[mVQIR�

&MVGL�4JIMJJIV�W}JJI�8IVTIRXMR�;MI�IMRWX�HMI�V}QMWGLIR�(EQIR��1ER�WEKX��HE��WMI�HEHYVGL�HIR�9VMR&IWSRHIVW�[SLPVMIGLIRH�FIOEQIR�

(IV�6EYQIV�[mVI�OIMR�HIYXWGLIV�0YQT�)V�[mVI�IMR�V}Q�WGLIV�0YQTEGMYW�(IV�*VIMPMKVEXL�HMGLXIXI�SLRI�6IMQ�;MI�[IMPERH�*PEGGYW�,SVEXMYW�

(IV�KVSFI�&IXXPIV��:EXIV�.ELR�(IV�LMI�I�NIX^X�+VSFMERYW�1I�LIVGYPI��1E�QERR�WTVmGLI�0EXIMR�(IV�1EVGYW�8YPPMYW�1E�QERYW�

(MI�;ELVLIMXWJVIYRHI�[�VHIR�NIX^X1MX�0}[IR��,]mRIR��7GLEOEPIR7MGL�VEYJIR�MR�HIV�%VIRE��ERWXEXX1MX�,YRHIR�MR�OPIMRIR�.SYVREPIR�

;MV�LmXXIR�CIMRIRC�2IVS�NIX^X�7XEXX�0ERHIWZmXIV�HVIM�(YX^IRH�;MV�WGLRMXXIR�YRW�HMI�%HIVR�EYJ�(IR�7GLIVKIR�HIV�/RIGLXWGLEJX�XVYX^IRH�

(IV�7GLIPPMRK�[mV�KER^�IMR�7IRIGE�9RH�OmQI�MR�WSPGLIQ�/SRJPMOX�YQ�>Y�YRWVIQ�'SVRIPMYW�WEKXIR�[MV�«'EGEXYQ�RSR�IWX�TMGXYQ�ª

+SXXPSF��(IV�,IVQERR�KI[ERR�HMI�7GLPEGLX�(MI�6}QIV�[YVHIR�ZIVXVMIFIR�:EVYW�QMX�WIMRIR�0IKMSRIR�IVPEK�9RH�[MV�WMRH�(IYXWGLI�KIFPMIFIR�

;MV�FPMIFIR�HIYXWGL��[MV�WTVIGLIR�HIYXWGL�;MI�[MV�IW�KIWTVSGLIR�LEFIR�(IV�)WIP�LIM�X�)WIP��RMGLX�EWMRYW�(MI�7GL[EFIR�FPMIFIR�7GL[EFIR�

(IV�6EYQIV�FPMIF�IMR�HIYXWGLIV�0YQT-R�YRWIVQ�HIYXWGLIR�2SVHIR�-R�6IMQIR�HMGLXIX�*VIMPMKVEXL�-WX�OIMR�,SVE^�KI[SVHIR�

+SXXPSF��HIV�1E�QERR�WTVMGLX�OIMR�0EXIMR�&MVGL�4JIMJJIV�WGLVIMFX�RYV�(VEQIR�9RH�WmYJX�RMGLX�WGLR}HIR�8IVTIRXMR;MI�6SQW�KEPERXI�(EQIR�

3�,IVQERR��HMV�ZIVHEROIR�[MV�HEW�(VYQ�[MVH�HMV��[MI�WMGL�KIF�LVIX�>Y�(IXQSPH�IMR�1SRYQIRX�KIWIX^X�,EF�WIPFIV�WYFWOVMFMIVIX�

'%498�<--

-Q�RmGLXPMGLIR�;EPHI�LYQTIPX�HELMR(MI�'LEMWI��(E�OVEGLX�IW�TP}X^PMGL��)MR�6EH�KMRK�PSW��;MV�LEPXIR�WXMPP�(EW�MWX�RMGLX�WILV�IVK}X^PMGL�

(IV�4SWXMPPMSR�WXIMKX�EF�YRH�IMPX-RW�(SVJ��YRH�MGL�ZIV[IMPI9Q�1MXXIVREGLX�EPPIMR�MQ�;EPH�6MRKWYQ�IVX}RX�IMR�+ILIYPI�

(EW�WMRH�HMI�;}PJI��HMI�LIYPIR�WS�[MPH�1MX�EYWKILYRKIVXIR�7XMQQIR�;MI�0MGLXIV�MR�HIV�(YROIPLIMX(MI�JIYVMKIR�%YKIR�KPMQQIR�

7MI�L}VXIR�ZSR�QIMRIV�%ROYRJX�KI[M��(MI�&IWXMIR��YRH�QMV�^YV�)LVI-PPYQMRMIVXIR�WMI�HIR�;EPH9RH�WMRKIR�WMI�MLVI�'L}VI�

(EW�MWX�IMR�7XmRHGLIR��MGL�QIVOI�IW�NIX^X�-GL�WSPP�KIJIMIVX�[IVHIR�-GL�[EVJ�QMGL�KPIMGL�MR�4SWMXYV9RH�WTVEGL�QMX�KIV�LVXIR�+IFmVHIR�

«1MX[}PJI��-GL�FMR�KP�GOPMGL��LIYX-R�IYVIV�1MXXI�^Y�[IMPIR�;S�WSZMIP�IHPI�+IQ�XIV�QMV1MX�0MIFI�IRXKIKIRLIYPIR�

;EW�MGL�MR�HMIWIQ�%YKIRFPMGO)QTJMRHI��MWX�YRIVQI�PMGL�%GL��HMIWI�WGL}RI�7XYRHI�FPIMFX1MV�I[MK�YRZIVKI�PMGL�

-GL�HEROI�IYGL�J�V�HEW�:IVXVEYR�;SQMX�MLV�QMGL�FIILVIX9RH�HEW�MLV�MR�NIHIV�4V�JYRKW^IMX(YVGL�XVIYI�&I[IMWI�FI[mLVIX�

1MX[}PJI��-LV�^[IMJIPXIX�RMI�ER�QMV�-LV�PMI�IX�IYGL�RMGLX�JERKIR:SR�7GLIPQIR��HMI�IYGL�KIWEKX��MGL�WIM>Y�HIR�,YRHIR��FIVKIKERKIR�

-GL�WIM�EFXV�RRMK�YRH�[IVHI�FEPH,SJVEX�MR�HIV�0mQQIVL�VHI��(IVKPIMGLIR�^Y�[MHIVWTVIGLIR�[EV+ER^�YRXIV�QIMRIV�;�VHI�

(IV�7GLEJTIP^��HIR�MGL�YQKILmRKX>Y[IMPIR��YQ�QMGL�^Y�[mVQIR�+PEYFX�QMV�W��IV�FVEGLXI�QMGL�RMI�HELMR�*�V�HEW�+P�GO�HIV�7GLEJI�^Y�WGL[mVQIR�

-GL�FMR�OIMR�7GLEJ��MGL�FMR�OIMR�,YRH�/IMR�,SJVEX�YRH�OIMR�7GLIPPJMWGL��-GL�FMR�IMR�;SPJ�KIFPMIFIR��QIMR�,IV^9RH�QIMRI�>mLRI�WMRH�[}PJMWGL�

-GL�FMR�IMR�;SPJ�YRH�[IVHI�WXIXW%YGL�LIYPIR�QMX�HIR�;}PJIR��.E��^mLPX�EYJ�QMGL�YRH�LIPJX�IYGL�WIPFWX�(ERR�[MVH�EYGL�+SXX�IYGL�LIPJIR�ª

(EW�[EV�HMI�6IHI��HMI�MGL�LMIPX�+ER^�SLRI�:SVFIVIMXYRK�:IVWX�QQIPX�LEX�/SPF�WMI�EFKIHVYGOX-R�HIV�«%PPKIQIMRIR�>IMXYRKª�

'%498�<---

(MI�7SRRI�KMRK�EYJ�FIM�4EHIVFSVR�1MX�WILV�ZIVHVS�RIV�+IFmVHI�7MI�XVIMFX�MR�HIV�8EX�IMR�ZIVHVMI�PMGL�+IWGLmJX��&IPIYGLXIR�HMI�HYQQI�)VHI�

,EX�WMI�HMI�IMRI�7IMXI�IVLIPPX�9RH�FVMRKX�WMI�QMX�WXVELPIRHIV�)MPI(IV�ERHIVR�MLV�0MGLX��WS�ZIVHYROIPX�WGLSR7MGL�NIRI�QMXXPIV[IMPI�

(IV�7XIMR�IRXVSPPX�HIQ�7MW]TLYW�(IV�(EREMHIR�8SRRI;MVH�RMI�KIJ�PPX��YRH�HIR�)VHIRFEPP&IPIYGLXIX�ZIVKIFPMGL�HMI�7SRRI���

9RH�EPW�HIV�1SVKIRRIFIP�̂ IVVERR�(E�WEL�MGL�EQ�;IKI�VEKIR�-Q�*V�LVSXWGLIMR��HEW�&MPH�HIW�1ERRW�(IV�ER�HEW�/VIY^�KIWGLPEKIR�

1MX�;ILQYX�IVJ�PPX�QMGL�NIHIWQEP(IMR�%RFPMGO��QIMR�EVQIV�:IXXIV�(IV�HY�HMI�;IPX�IVP}WIR�KI[SPPX�(Y�2EVV��HY�1IRWGLLIMXWVIXXIV�

7MI�LEFIR�HMV��FIP�QMXKIWTMIPX�(MI�,IVVIR�ZSQ�LSLIR�6EXI�;IV�LMI��HMGL�EYGL�VIHIR�WS�V�GOWMGLXWPSW:SR�HIV�/MVGLI�YRH�ZSQ�7XEEXI�

>Y�HIMRIQ�1EPLIYV�[EV�HMI�&YGLHVYGOIVIM2SGL�RMGLX�MR�NIRIR�8EKIR)VJYRHIR��HY�LmXXIWX�KIWGLVMIFIR�IMR�&YGLiFIV�HMI�,MQQIPWJVEKIR�

(IV�>IRWSV�LmXXI�KIWXVMGLIR�HEVMR�;EW�IX[E�ER^�KPMGL�EYJ�)VHIR�9RH�PMIFIRH�FI[ELVXI�HMGL�HMI�>IRWYV:SV�HIQ�+IOVIY^MKX[IVHIR�

%GL��LmXXIWX�HY�RYV�IMRIR�ERHIVR�8I\X>Y�HIMRIV�&IVKTVIHMKX�KIRSQQIR�&IWE�IWX�NE�+IMWX�YRH�8EPIRX�KIRYK�9RH�OSRRXIWX�WGLSRIR�HMI�*VSQQIR�

+IPH[IGLWPIV��&EROMIVW��LEWX�HY�WSKEV1MX�HIV�4IMXWGLI�KINEKX�EYW�HIQ�8IQTIP��9RKP�GOPMGLIV�7GL[mVQIV��NIX^X�LmRKWX�HY�EQ�/VIY^%PW�[EVRIRHIW�)\IQTIP�

'%498�<-:

)MR�JIYGLXIV�;MRH��IMR�OELPIW�0ERH�(MI�'LEMWI�[EGOIPX�MQ�7GLPEQQI�(SGL�WMRKX�IW�YRH�OPMRKX�IW�MR�QIMRIQ�+IQ�X�«7SRRI��HY�OPEKIRHI�*PEQQI�ª

(EW�MWX�HIV�7GLPY�VIMQ�HIW�EPXIR�0MIHW�(EW�SJX�QIMRI�%QQI�KIWYRKIR��«7SRRI��HY�OPEKIRHI�*PEQQI�ª�(EW�LEX;MI�;EPHLSVRVYJ�KIOPYRKIR�

)W�OSQQX�MQ�0MIH�IMR�1}VHIV�ZSV�(IV�PIFX��MR�0YWX�YRH�*VIYHI�1ER�JMRHIX�MLR�IRHPMGL�MQ�;EPHI�KILIROX%R�IMRIV�KVEYIR�;IMHI�

(IW�1}VHIVW�8SHIWYVXIMP�[EV+IREKIPX�EQ�;IMHIRWXEQQI�(EW�LEFIR�HMI�6mGLIV�HIV�*IQI�KIXER��«7SRRI��HY�OPEKIRHI�*PEQQI�ª

(MI�7SRRI�[EV�/PmKIV��WMI�LEXXI�FI[MVOX�(E��QER�HIR�1}VHIV�ZIVHEQQI�3XXMPMI�LEXXI�WXIVFIRH�KIWGLVMIR�«7SRRI��HY�OPEKIRHI�*PEQQI�ª

9RH�HIRO�MGL�HIW�0MIHIW��WS�HIRO�MGL�EYGL(IV�%QQI��HIV�PMIFIR�%PXIR�-GL�WILI�[MIHIV�MLV�FVEYRIW�+IWMGLX�1MX�EPPIR�6YR^IPR�YRH�*EPXIR�

7MI�[EV�KIFSVIR�MQ�1�RWXIVPERH�9RH�[Y�XI��MR�KVS�IV�1IRKI�+IWTIRWXIVKIWGLMGLXIR��KVEYWIRLEJX�9RH�1mVGLIR�YRH�:SPOWKIWmRKI�

;MI�TSGLXI�QIMR�,IV^��[IRR�HMI�EPXI�*VEY:SR�HIV�/}RMKWXSGLXIV�IV^mLPXI�(MI�IMRWEQ�EYJ�HIV�,IMHI�WE�9RH�HMI�KSPHRIR�,EEVI�WXVmLPXI�

(MI�+mRWI�QY�XI�WMI�L�XIR�HSVX%PW�+mRWIQEKH��YRH�XVMIF�WMI%Q�%FIRH�HMI�+mRWI�[MIHIV�HYVGLW�8SV�+EV�XVEYVMK�WXILIR�FPMIF�WMI�

(IRR�ERKIREKIPX��FIV�HIQ�8SV7EL�WMI�IMR�6S�LEYTX�VEKIR�(EW�[EV�HIV�/STJ�HIW�EVQIR�4JIVHW�(EW�WMI�MR�HMI�*VIQHI�KIXVEKIR�

(MI�/}RMKWXSGLXIV�WIYJ^XI�XMIJ�«3�*EPEHE��HE��HY�LERKIWX�ª(IV�4JIVHIOSTJ�LIVYRXIVVMIJ�«3�[ILI��HE��HY�KERKIWX�ª

(MI�/}RMKWXSGLXIV�WIYJ^XI�XMIJ�«;IRR�HEW�QIMRI�1YXXIV�[��XI�ª(IV�4JIVHIOSTJ�LIVYRXIVVMIJ�«-LV�,IV^I�FVIGLIR�Q��XI�ª

1MX�WXSGOIRHIQ�%XIQ�LSVGLXI�MGL�LMR�;IRR�HMI�%PXI�IVRWXIV�YRH�PIMWIV>Y�WTVIGLIR�FIKERR�YRH�ZSQ�6SXFEVX�WTVEGL�:SR�YRWIVIQ�LIMQPMGLIR�/EMWIV�

7MI�LEX�QMV�ZIVWMGLIVX��IV�WIM�RMGLX�XSX�;MI�HE�KPEYFIR�HMI�+IPILVXIR�)V�LEYWI�ZIVWXIGOX�MR�IMRIQ�&IVK1MX�WIMRIR�;EJJIRKIJmLVXIR�

/]JJLmYWIV�MWX�HIV�&IVK�KIRERRX�9RH�HVMRRIR�MWX�IMRI�,}LPI�(MI�%QTIPR�IVLIPPIR�WS�KIMWXIVLEJX

(MI�LSGLKI[}PFXIR�7mPI�

)MR�1EVWXEPP�MWX�HIV�IVWXI�7EEP�9RH�HSVXIR�OERR�QER�WILIR:MIP�XEYWIRH�4JIVHI��FPEROKIWGLMVVX�(MI�ER�HIR�/VMTTIR�WXILIR�

7MI�WMRH�KIWEXXIPX�YRH�KI^mYQX�.IHSGL�ZSR�HMIWIR�6SWWIR/IMR�IMR^MKIW�[MILIVX��OIMR�IMR^MKIW�WXEQTJX�7MRH�WXMPP��[MI�EYW�)MWIR�KIKSWWIR�

-Q�^[IMXIR�7EEPI��EYJ�HIV�7XVIY�7MILX�QER�7SPHEXIR�PMIKIR�:MIP�XEYWIRH�7SPHEXIR��FmVXMKIW�:SPO�1MX�OVMIKIVMWGL�XVSX^MKIR�>�KIR�

7MI�WMRH�KIV�WXIX�ZSR�/STJ�FMW�*Y��(SGL�EPPI�HMIWI�&VEZIR�7MI�V�LVIR�WMGL�RMGLX��FI[IKIR�WMGL�RMGLX�7MI�PMIKIR�JIWX�YRH�WGLPEJIR�

,SGLEYJKIWXETIPX�MQ�HVMXXIR�7EEP7MRH�7GL[IVXIV��7XVIMXm\XI��7TIIVI�,EVRMWGLI��,IPQI��ZSR�7MPFIV�YRH�7XELP�%PXJVmROMWGLI�*IYIVKI[ILVI�

7ILV�[IRMK�/ERSRIR��NIHSGL�KIRYK�9Q�IMRI�8VSTLmI�^Y�FMPHIR�,SGL�VEKX�HEVEYW�IMRI�*ELRI�LIVZSV�(MI�*EVFI�MWX�WGL[EV^VSXK�PHIR�

(IV�/EMWIV�FI[SLRX�HIR�ZMIVXIR�7EEP�7GLSR�WIMX�.ELVLYRHIVXIR�WMX^X�IV%YJ�WXIMRIVRIQ�7XYLP��EQ�WXIMRIVRIR�8MWGL�(EW�,EYTX�EYJ�HIR�%VQIR�WX�X̂ X�IV�

7IMR�&EVX��HIV�FMW�^YV�)VHI�[YGLW�-WX�VSX�[MI�*IYIVJPEQQIR�>Y[IMPIR�̂ [MROIVX�IV�QMX�HIQ�%YK��>MILX�QERGLQEP�HMI�&VEYRIR�^YWEQQIR�

7GLPmJX�IV�SHIV�HIROX�IV�REGL#1ER�OERR�W�RMGLX�KIREY�IVQMXXIPR�(SGL�[IRR�HMI�VIGLXI�7XYRHI�OSQQX�;MVH�IV�KI[EPXMK�WMGL�V�XXIPR�

(MI�KYXI�*ELRI�IVKVIMJX�IV�HERR9RH�VYJX��«>Y�4JIVH��̂ Y�4JIVHI�ª

7IMR�VIMWMKIW�:SPO�IV[EGLX�YRH�WTVMRKX0EYXVEWWIPRH�IQTSV�ZSR�HIV�)VHI�

)MR�NIHIV�WGL[MRKX�WMGL�EYJ�WIMR�6S��(EW�[MILIVX�YRH�WXEQTJX�QMX�HIR�,YJIR�7MI�VIMXIR�LMREYW�MR�HMI�OPMVVIRHI�;IPX�9RH�HMI�8VSQTIXIR�VYJIR�

7MI�VIMXIR�KYX��WMI�WGLPEKIR�KYX�7MI�LEFIR�EYWKIWGLPEJIR�(IV�/EMWIV�LmPX�IMR�WXVIRKIW�+IVMGLX�)V�[MPP�HMI�1}VHIV�FIWXVEJIR��

(MI�1}VHIV��HMI�KIQIYGLIPX�IMRWX(MI�XIYVI��[YRHIVWEQI�+SPHPSGOMGLXI�.YRKJVEY�+IVQERME��«7SRRI��HY�OPEKIRHI�*PEQQI�ª

;SLP�QERGLIV��HIV�WMGL�KIFSVKIR�KIKPEYFX�9RH�PEGLIRH�EYJ�WIMRIQ�7GLPS��WE��)V�[MVH�RMGLX�IRXKILIR�HIQ�VmGLIRHIR�7XVERK�(IQ�>SVRI�&EVFEVSWWEW�������

;MI�OPMRKIR�WMI�PMIFPMGL��[MI�OPMRKIR�WMI�W���(MI�1mVGLIR�HIV�EPXIR�%QQI�1IMR�EFIVKPmYFMWGLIW�,IV^I�NEYGL^X�«7SRRI��HY�OPEKIRHI�*PEQQI�ª

'%498�<:

)MR�JIMRIV�6IKIR�TVMGOIPX�LIVEF�)MWOEPX��[MI�2mLREHIPWTMX̂ IR�(MI�4JIVHI�FI[IKIR�XVEYVMK�HIR�7GL[ER^�7MI�[EXIR�MQ�/SX�YRH�WGL[MX^IR�

(IV�4SWXMPPMSR�WX}�X�MR�WIMR�,SVR�-GL�OIRRI�HEW�EPXI�+IXYXI��«)W�VIMXIR�HVIM�6IMXIV�̂ YQ�8SV�LMREYW�ª)W�[MVH�QMV�WS�HmQQVMK�̂ YQYXI�

1MGL�WGLPmJIVXI�YRH�MGL�IRXWGLPMIJ�9RH�WMILI��QMV�XVmYQXI�EQ�)RHI�(E��MGL�QMGL�MR�HIQ�;YRHIVFIVK&IMQ�/EMWIV�6SXFEVX�FIJmRHI�

)V�WE��RMGLX�QILV�EYJ�WXIMRIVRIQ�7XYLP�%Q�WXIMRIVRIR�8MWGL��[MI�IMR�7XIMRFMPH�

%YGL�WEL�IV�RMGLX�WS�ILV[�VHMK�EYW�;MI�QER�WMGL�KI[}LRPMGL�IMRFMPHX�

)V�[EXWGLIPXI�HYVGL�HMI�7mPI�LIVYQ1MX�QMV�MQ�XVEYXIR�+IWGL[mX^I�)V�^IMKXI�[MI�IMR�%RXMUYEV1MV�WIMRI�/YVMSWE�YRH�7GLmX^I�

-Q�7EEPI�HIV�;EJJIR�IVOPmVXI�IV�QMV�;MI�QER�WMGL�HIV�/SPFIR�FIHMIRI�:SR�IMRMKIR�7GL[IVXIVR�VMIF�IV�HIR�6SWX1MX�WIMRIQ�,IVQIPMRI�

)V�RELQ�IMR�4JEYIR[IHIP�̂ YV�,ERH�9RH�VIMRMKXI�ZSQ�7XEYFI+EV�QERGLIR�,EVRMWGL��KEV�QERGLIR�,IPQ�%YGL�QERGLI�4MGOIPLEYFI�

(MI�*ELRI�WXmYFXI�IV�KPIMGLJEPPW�EF�9RH�IV�WTVEGL��«1IMR�KV}�XIV�7XSP^�MWX�(E��RSGL�OIMRI�1SXXI�HMI�7IMHI�̂ IVJVE��9RH�EYGL�OIMR�;YVQ�MQ�,SP̂ �MWX�ª

9RH�EPW�[MV�OEQIR�MR�HIR�7EEP�;S�WGLPEJIRH�EQ�&SHIR�PMIKIR:MIP�XEYWIRH�/VMIKIV��OEQTJFIVIMX�(IV�%PXI�WTVEGL�QMX�:IVKR�KIR�

«,MIV�Q�WWIR�[MV�PIMWIV�VIHIR�YRH�KILR�(EQMX�[MV�RMGLX�[IGOIR�HMI�0IYXI�;MIHIV�ZIVJPSWWIR�WMRH�LYRHIVX�.ELV��9RH�0}LRYRKWXEK�MWX�LIYXI�ª

9RH�WMILI��HIV�/EMWIV�RELXI�WMGL�WEGLX(IR�WGLPEJIRHIR�7SPHEXIR�9RH�WXIGOXI�LIMQPMGL�MR�HMI�8EWGL�.IH[IHIQ�IMRIR�(YOEXIR�

)V�WTVEGL�QMX�WGLQYR^IPRHIQ�+IWMGLX�%PW�MGL�MLR�ERWEL�ZIV[YRHIVX�«-GL�^ELPI�IMRIR�(YOEXIR�TIV�1ERR�%PW�7SPH��REGL�NIHIQ�.ELVLYRHIVX�ª

-Q�7EEPI��[S�HMI�4JIVHI�WXILR-R�PERKIR��WGL[IMKIRHIR�6IMLIR�(E�VMIF�HIV�/EMWIV�WMGL�HMI�,mRH��7GLMIR�WSRHIVFEV�WMGL�^Y�JVIYIR�

)V�^mLPXI�HMI�+mYPI��7X�GO�ZSV�7X�GO�

9RH�OPmXWGLIPXI�MLRIR�HMI�6MTTIR�)V�^mLPXI�YRH�^mLPXI��QMX�mRKWXPMGLIV�,EWX&I[IKXIR�WMGL�WIMRI�0MTTIR�

«(EW�MWX�RSGL�RMGLX�HMI�VIGLXI�>ELPª��7TVEGL�IV�̂ YPIX^X�ZIVHVSWWIR���«7SPHEXIR�YRH�;EJJIR�LEF�MGL�KIRYRK�(SGL�JILPX�IW�RSGL�ER�6SWWIR�

6S�OmQQI�LEF�MGL�EYWKIWGLMGOX-R�EPPI�;IPX��HMI�OEYJIR*�V�QMGL�HMI�FIWXIR�4JIVHI�IMR�,EF�WGLSR�IMRIR�KYXIR�,EYJIR�

-GL�[EVXI��FMW�HMI�>ELP�OSQTPIXX�(ERR�WGLPEK�MGL�PSW�YRH�FIJVIMI1IMR�:EXIVPERH��QIMR�HIYXWGLIW�:SPO�(EW�QIMRIV�LEVVIX�QMX�8VIYI�ª

7S�WTVEGL�HIV�/EMWIV��MGL�EFIV�VMIJ�«7GLPEK�PSW��HY�EPXIV�+IWIPPI�7GLPEK�PSW��YRH�LEWX�HY�RMGLX�4JIVHI�KIRYK�2MQQ�)WIP�ER�MLVIV�7XIPPI�ª

(IV�6SXFEVX�IV[MHIVXI�PmGLIPRH��«)W�LEX1MX�HIQ�7GLPEKIR�KEV�OIMRI�)MPI�1ER�FEYXI�RMGLX�6SQ�ER�IMRIQ�8EK�+YX�(MRK�[MPP�LEFIR�;IMPI�

;IV�LIYXI�RMGLX�OSQQX��OSQQX�QSVKIR�KI[M��2YV�PERKWEQ�[mGLWX�HMI�)MGLI�9RH�GLM�ZE�TMERS��ZE�WERS��WS�LIM�X(EW�7TV�GL[SVX�MQ�V}QMWGLIR�6IMGLI�ª

'%498�<:-

(EW�7XS�IR�HIW�;EKIRW�[IGOXI�QMGL�EYJ�(SGL�WEROIR�HMI�%YKIRPMHIV&EPH�[MIHIV�̂ Y��YRH�MGL�IRXWGLPMIJ9RH�XVmYQXI�ZSQ�6SXFEVX�[MIHIV�

+MRK�[MIHIV�WGL[EX^IRH�QMX�MLQ�LIVYQ(YVGL�EPPI�HMI�LEPPIRHIR�7mPI�)V�JVYK�QMGL�HMIW��IV�JVYK�QMGL�HEW�:IVPERKXI��HE��MGL�IV^mLPI�

)V�LEXXI�EYW�HIV�3FIV[IPX

7IMX�ZMIPIR��ZMIPIR�.ELVIR�;SLP�WIMX�HIQ�7MIFIRNmLVMKIR�/VMIK�/IMR�7XIVFIRW[SVX�IVJELVIR�

)V�JVYK�REGL�1SWIW�1IRHIPWWSLR�2EGL�HIV�/EVWGLMR��QMX�-RXVIWWI*VYK�IV�REGL�HIV�+VmJMR�(YFEVV]�(IW�J�RJ^ILRXIR�0YH[MKW�1mXVIWWI�

«3�/EMWIVª��VMIJ�MGL��«[MI�FMWX�HY�^YV�GO�(IV�1SWIW�MWX�PmRKWX�KIWXSVFIR�2IFWX�WIMRIV�6IFIOOE��EYGL�%FVELEQ�(IV�7SLR��MWX�KIWXSVFIR��ZIVHSVFIR�

(IV�%FVELEQ�LEXXI�QMX�0IE�IV^IYKX)MR�&�FGLIR��*IPM\�LIM�X�IV�(IV�FVEGLXI�IW�[IMX�MQ�'LVMWXIRXYQ�-WX�WGLSR�/ETIPPIRQIMWXIV�

(MI�EPXI�/EVWGLMR�MWX�KPIMGLJEPPW�XSX�%YGL�HMI�8SGLXIV�MWX�XSX��HMI�/PIROI�,IPQMRI�'Lq^]��HMI�)ROIPMR�-WX�RSGL�EQ�0IFIR��MGL�HIROI�

(MI�(YFEVV]�PIFXI�PYWXMK�YRH�JPSXX�7SPERKI�0YH[MK�VIKMIVXI�(IV�*�RJ^ILRXI�RmQPMGL��WMI�[EV�WGLSR�EPX�%PW�QER�WMI�KYMPPSXMRMIVXI�

(IV�/}RMK�0YH[MK�HIV�*�RJ^ILRXI�WXEVF+ER^�VYLMK�MR�WIMRIQ�&IXXI�(IV�7IGL^ILRXI�EFIV�[EVH�KYMPPSXMRMIVX1MX�HIV�/}RMKMR�%RXSMRIXXI�

(MI�/}RMKMR�^IMKXI�KVS�IR�1YX�+ER^�[MI�IW�WMGL�KIF�LVXI�(MI�(YFEVV]�EFIV�[IMRXI�YRH�WGLVMI�%PW�QER�WMI�KYMPPSXMRMIVXI�ª����

(IV�/EMWIV�FPMIF�TP}X^PMGL�WXMPPIWXILR�9RH�WEL�QMGL�ER�QMX�HIR�WXMIVIR%YKIR�YRH�WTVEGL��«9Q�+SXXIW�[MPP�R�;EW�MWX�HEW��KYMPPSXMRMIVIR#ª

«(EW�+YMPPSXMRMIVIRª���IVOPmVXI�MGL�MLQ��«-WX�IMRI�RIYI�1IXLSHI�;SQMX�QER�HMI�0IYXI�NIKPMGLIR�7XERHW:SQ�0IFIR�FVMRKX�̂ Y�8SHI�

&IM�HMIWIV�1IXLSHI�FIHMIRX�QER�WMGL%YGL�IMRIV�RIYIR�1EWGLMRI�(MI�LEX�IVJYRHIR�,IVV�+YMPPSXMR�(VYQ�RIRRX�QER�WMI�+YMPPSXMRI�

(Y�[MVWX�LMIV�ER�IMR�&VIXX�KIWGLREPPX���(EW�WIROX�WMGL����HY�[MVWX�KIWGLSFIR+IWGL[MRHI�̂ [MWGLIR�^[IM�4JSWXIR����IW�LmRKX)MR�HVIMIGOMK�&IMP�KER^�SFIR���

1ER�^MILX�IMRI�7GLRYV��HERR�WGLMI�X�LIVEF(EW�&IMP��KER^�PYWXMK�YRH�QYRXIV���&IM�HMIWIV�+IPIKIRLIMX�JmPPX�HIMR�/STJ-R�IMRIR�7EGO�LMRYRXIV�ª

(IV�/EMWIV�JMIP�QMV�MR�HMI�6IH��«7GL[IMK�WXMPP��ZSR�HIMRIV�1EWGLMRI;MPP�MGL�RMGLXW�[MWWIR��+SXX�FI[ELV��(E��MGL�QMGL�MLVIV�FIHMIRI�

(IV�/}RMK�YRH�HMI�/}RMKMR�+IWGLREPPX��ER�IMRIQ�&VIXXI�(EW�MWX�NE�KIKIR�EPPIR�6IWTIOX9RH�EPPI�)XMOIXXI�

9RH�HY��[IV�FMWX�HY��HE��HY�IW�[EKWX�1MGL�WS�ZIVXVEYPMGL�^Y�HY^IR#;EVXI��HY�&�VWGLGLIR��MGL�[IVHI�HMV�WGLSR(MI�OIGOIR�*P�KIP�WXYX^IR�

)W�VIKX�QMV�HMI�MRRIVWXI�+EPPI�EYJ�;IRR�MGL�HMGL�L}VI�WTVIGLIR�(IMR�3HIQ�WGLSR�MWX�,SGLZIVVEX9RH�1ENIWXmXWZIVFVIGLIR�ª

%PW�WSPGLIVQE�IR�MR�)MJIV�KIVMIX(IV�%PXI�YRH�WSRHIV�7GLVEROIR9RH�7GLSRYRK�QMGL�ERWGLRSF��HE�TPEX^XIR�LIVEYW%YGL�QMV�HMI�KILIMQWXIR�+IHEROIR�

«,IVV�6SXFEVXª���VMIJ�MGL�PEYX����«HY�FMWX)MR�EPXIW�*EFIP[IWIR�+IL��PIK�HMGL�WGLPEJIR��[MV�[IVHIR�YRW%YGL�SLRI�HMGL�IVP}WIR�

(MI�6ITYFPMOERIV�PEGLIR�YRW�EYW�7ILR�WMI�ER�YRWIVIV�7TMX^I7S�IMR�+IWTIRWX�QMX�>ITXIV�YRH�/VSR��7MI�VMWWIR�WGLPIGLXI�;MX^I�

%YGL�HIMRI�*ELRI�KIJmPPX�QMV�RMGLX�QILV�(MI�EPXHIYXWGLIR�2EVVIR�ZIVHEVFIR1MV�WGLSR�MR�HIV�&YVWGLIRWGLEJX�HMI�0YWX%R�HIR�WGL[EV^VSXKSPHRIR�*EVFIR�

(EW�FIWXI�[mVI��HY�FPMIFIWX�^Y�,EYW�,MIV�MR�HIQ�EPXIR�/]JJLmYWIV��&IHIRO�MGL�HMI�7EGLI�KER^�KIREY�7S�FVEYGLIR�[MV�KEV�OIMRIR�/EMWIV�ª

'%498�<:--

-GL�LEFI�QMGL�QMX�HIQ�/EMWIV�KI^EROX-Q�8VEYQ��MQ�8VEYQ�ZIVWXILX�WMGL��-Q�[EGLIRHIR�>YWXERH�WTVIGLIR�[MV�RMGLX1MX�*�VWXIR�WS�[MHIVWIX^MK�

2YV�XVmYQIRH��MQ�MHIEPIR�8VEYQ�;EKX�MLRIR�HIV�(IYXWGLI�^Y�WEKIR(MI�HIYXWGLI�1IMRYRK��HMI�IV�WS�XMIJ-Q�XVIYIR�,IV^IR�KIXVEKIR�

%PW�MGL�IV[EGLX���JYLV�MGL�IMRIQ�;EPH:SVFIM��HIV�%RFPMGO�HIV�&mYQI�(IV�REGOXIR�L}P^IVRIR�;MVOPMGLOIMX�:IVWGLIYGLXI�QIMRI�8VmYQI�

(MI�)MGLIR�WGL�XXIPXIR�IVRWXLEJX�HEW�,EYTX�(MI�&MVOIR�YRH�&MVOIRVIMWIV�7MI�RMGOXIR�WS�[EVRIRH���YRH�MGL�VMIJ�«:IVKMF�QMV��QIMR�XIYVIV�/EMWIV�

:IVKMF�QMV��S�6SXFEVX��HEW�VEWGLI�;SVX�-GL�[IM���HY�FMWX�ZMIP�[IMWIV%PW�MGL��MGL�LEFI�WS[IRMK�+IHYPH��(SGL�OSQQI�HY�FEPH��QIMR�/EMWIV�

&ILEKX�HMV�HEW�+YMPPSXMRMIVIR�RMGLX�7S�FPIMF�FIM�HIR�EPXIR�1MXXIPR�(EW�7GL[IVX�J�V�)HIPPIYXI��HIV�7XVMGO*�V�&�VKIV�YRH�&EYIVR�MR�/MXXIPR�

2YV�QERGLQEP�[IGLWPI�EF��YRH�PE�(IR�%HIP�LmRKIR��YRH�O}TJI)MR�FM�GLIR�HMI�&�VKIV�YRH�&EYIVR��[MV�WMRH.E�EPPI�+SXXIWKIWGL}TJI�

7XIPP�[MIHIV�LIV�HEW�,EPWKIVMGLX�(EW�TIMRPMGLI�/EVPW�HIW�*�RJXIR�9RH�XIMPI�[MIHIV�IMR�HEW�:SPO2EGL�7XmRHIR��+MPHIR�YRH�>�RJXIR�

(EW�EPXI�,IMPMKI�6}QMWGLI�6IMGL�7XIPP�W�[MIHIV�LIV��HEW�KER^I�+MF�YRW�HIR�QSHVMKWXIR�4PYRHIV�̂ YV�GO1MX�EPPIQ�*MVPMJER^I�

(EW�1MXXIPEPXIV��MQQIVLMR�(EW�[ELVI��[MI�IW�KI[IWIR�-GL�[MPP�IW�IVXVEKIR���IVP}WI�YRW�RYV:SR�NIRIQ�>[MXXIV[IWIR�

:SR�NIRIQ�/EQEWGLIRVMXXIVXYQ�(EW�IOIPLEJX�IMR�+IQMWGL�MWX:SR�KSXMWGLIQ�;ELR�YRH�QSHIVRIQ�0YK�(EW�[IHIV�*PIMWGL�RSGL�*MWGL�MWX�

.EK�JSVX�HEW�/SQ}HMERXIRTEGO�9RH�WGLPMI�I�HMI�7GLEYWTMIPLmYWIV�;S�QER�HMI�:SV^IMX�TEVSHMIVX��/SQQI�HY�FEPH��S�/EMWIV�ª

'%498�<:---

1MRHIR�MWX�IMRI�JIWXI�&YVK�,EX�KYXI�;ILV�YRH�;EJJIR�1MX�TVIY�MWGLIR�*IWXYRKIR�LEF�MGL�NIHSGL2MGLX�KIVRI�[EW�^Y�WGLEJJIR�

;MV�OEQIR�HSVX�ER�^YV�%FIRH^IMX�(MI�4PEROIR�HIV�>YKFV�GO��WX}LRXIR7S�WGLEYVMK��EPW�[MV�LMR�FIVKIVSPPX�(MI�HYROPIR�+VmFIR�KmLRXIR�

(MI�LSLIR�&EWXMSRIR�WGLEYXIR�QMGL�ER�7S�HVSLIRH�YRH�ZIVHVSWWIR�(EW�KVS�I�8SV�KMRK�VEWWIPRH�EYJ�;EVH�VEWWIPRH�[MIHIV�KIWGLPSWWIR�

%GL��QIMRI�7IIPI�[EVH�FIXV�FX�;MI�HIW�3H]WWIYW�7IIPI�%PW�IV�KIL}VX��HE��4SP]TLIQ(IR�*IPWFPSGO�WGLSF�ZSV�HMI�,}LPI�

)W�XVEX�ER�HIR�;EKIR�IMR�/SVTSVEP9RH�JVYK�YRW��[MI�[MV�LMI�IR#«-GL�LIM�I�2MIQERH��FMR�%YKIREV^X9RH�WXIGLI�HIR�7XEV�HIR�6MIWIR�ª

-Q�;MVXWLEYW�[EVH�QMV�RSGL�WGLPMQQIV�̂ YQYX�(EW�)WWIR�[SPPX�QMV�RMGLX�WGLQIGOIR�+MRK�WGLPEJIR�WSKPIMGL��HSGL�WGLPMIJ�MGL�RMGLX�1MGL�HV�GOXIR�WS�WGL[IV�HMI�(IGOIR�

)W�[EV�IMR�FVIMXIW�*IHIVFIXX�+EVHMRIR�ZSR�VSXIQ�(EQEWXI�(IV�,MQQIP�ZSR�ZIVFPMGLIRIQ�+SPH�1MX�IMRIQ�WGLQYX^MKIR�5YEWXI�

:IVJPYGLXIV�5YEWX��HIV�HMI�KER^I�2EGLX(MI�PMIFI�6YLI�QMV�VEYFXI�)V�LMRK�QMV��[MI�HIW�(EQSOPIW�7GL[IVX�7S�HVSLIRH��FIV�HIQ�,EYTXI�

7GLMIR�QERGLQEP�IMR�7GLPERKIROSTJ�^Y�WIMR�9RH�MGL�L}VXI�MLR�LIMQPMGL�^MWGLIR�«(Y�FMWX�YRH�FPIMFWX�MR�HIV�*IWXYRK�NIX^X�(Y�OERRWX�RMGLX�QILV�IRX[MWGLIR�ª

«3L��HE��MGL�[mVIª���WIYJ^XI�MGL��«(E��MGL�^Y�,EYWI�[mVI�&IM�QIMRIV�PMIFIR�*VEY�MR�4EVMW�-Q�*EYFSYVK�4SMWWSRRMrVI�ª

-GL�J�LPXI��[MI��FIV�HMI�7XMVRI�QMV%YGL�QERGLQEP�IX[EW�KIWXVMGLIR�+PIMGL�IMRIV�OEPXIR�>IRWSVLERH�9RH�QIMRI�+IHEROIR�[MGLIR��

+IRHEVQIR�MR�0IMGLIRPEOIR�KIL�PPX�)MR�[IM�IW�7TYOKI[MVVI�9QVMRKXI�QIMR�&IXX��MGL�L}VXI�EYGL9RLIMQPMGLIW�/IXXIRKIOPMVVI�

%GL��HMI�+IWTIRWXIV�WGLPITTXIR�QMGL�JSVX�9RH�MGL�LEF�QMGL�IRHPMGL�FIJYRHIR%R�IMRIV�WXIMPIR�*IPWIR[ERH�(SVX�[EV�MGL�JIWXKIFYRHIR�

(IV�F}WI�WGLQYX̂ MKI�&IXXLMQQIPUYEWX�-GL�JERH�MLR�KPIMGLJEPPW�[MIHIV�(SGL�WEL�IV�NIX^X�[MI�IMR�+IMIV�EYW�

1MX�/VEPPIR�YRH�WGL[EV^IQ�+IJMIHIV�

)V�KPMGL�HIQ�TVIY�MWGLIR�%HPIV�NIX̂ X�9RH�LMIPX�QIMRIR�0IMF�YQOPEQQIVX�)V�JVE��QMV�HMI�0IFIV�EYW�HIV�&VYWX�-GL�LEFI�KIWX}LRX�YRH�KINEQQIVX�

-GL�NEQQIVXI�PERKI���HE�OVmLXI�HIV�,ELR�9RH�HIV�*MIFIVXVEYQ�IVFPE�XI�-GL�PEK�^Y�1MRHIR�MQ�WGL[MX^IRHIR�&IXX�(IV�%HPIV�[EVH�[MIHIV�^YQ�5YEWXI�

-GL�VIMWXI�JSVX�QMX�)\XVETSWX�9RH�WGL}TJXI�JVIMIR�3HIQ)VWX�HVEY�IR�MR�HIV�JVIMIR�2EXYV�%YJ�F�GOIFYVK�WGLIQ�&SHIR�

'%498�<-<

3L��(ERXSR��HY�LEWX�HMGL�WILV�KIMVVX9RH�QY�XIWX�HIR�-VVXYQ�F��IR�1MXRILQIR�OERR�QER�HEW�:EXIVPERH%R�HIR�7SLPIR��ER�HIR�*��IR�

(EW�LEPFI�*�VWXIRXYQ�&�GOIFYVK&PMIF�QMV�ER�HIR�7XMIJIPR�OPIFIR�7S�PILQMGLXI�;IKI�LEFI�MGL�[SLP2SGL�RMI�KIWILIR�MQ�0IFIR�

>Y�&�GOIFYVK�WXMIK�MGL�EF�MR�HIV�7XEHX�9Q�HSVX�^Y�FIXVEGLXIR�HMI�7XEQQFYVK�;S�QIMR�+VS�ZEXIV�KIFSVIR�[EVH�(MI�+VS�QYXXIV�[EV�EYW�,EQFYVK�

-GL�OEQ�REGL�,ERRSZIV�YQ�1MXXEK^IMX�9RH�PMI��QMV�HMI�7XMIJIP�TYX^IR�-GL�KMRK�WSKPIMGL��HMI�7XEHX�^Y�FIWILR�-GL�VIMWI�KIVR�QMX�2YX̂ IR�

1IMR�+SXX��HE�WMILX�IW�WEYFIV�EYW�(IV�/SX�PMIKX�RMGLX�EYJ�HIR�+EWWIR�:MIP�4VEGLXKIFmYHI�WEL�MGL�HSVX�7ILV�MQTSRMIVIRHI�1EWWIR�

&IWSRHIVW�KIJMIP�QMV�IMR�KVS�IV�4PEX̂ �9QKIFIR�ZSR�WXEXXPMGLIR�,mYWIVR�(SVX�[SLRX�HIV�/}RMK��HSVX�WXILX�WIMR�4EPEWX�

)V�MWX�ZSR�WGL}RIQ�cY�IVR

�2mQPMGL�HIV�4EPEWX ��:SV�HIQ�4SVXEP>Y�NIHIV�7IMXI�IMR�7GLMPHLEYW�6SXV}GOI�QMX�*PMRXIR�LEPXIR�HSVX�;EGLX�7MI�WILIR�HVSLIRH�YRH�[MPH�EYW�

1IMR�'MGIVSRI�WTVEGL��«,MIV�[SLRX(IV�)VRWX�%YKYWXYW��IMR�EPXIV�,SGLXSV]WGLIV�0SVH��IMR�)HIPQERR�7ILV�V�WXMK�J�V�WIMR�%PXIV�

-H]PPMWGL�WMGLIV�LEYWX�IV�LMIV�(IRR�FIWWIV�EPW�EPPI�8VEFERXIR&IWGL�X^IX�MLR�HIV�QERKIPRHI�1YX:SR�YRWIVIR�PMIFIR�&IOERRXIR�

-GL�WIL�MLR�^Y[IMPIR��IV�OPEKX�EPWHERR�;MI�KEV�PERK[IMPMK�HEW�%QX�WIM�(EW�/}RMKWEQX��[S^Y�IV�NIX̂ X,MIV�MR�,ERRSZIV�ZIVHEQQX�WIM�

%R�KVS�FVMXERRMWGLIW�0IFIR�KI[}LRX�7IM�IW�MLQ�LMIV�^Y�IRKI�-LR�TPEKI�HIV�7TPIIR��IV�J�VGLXI�WGLMIV�(E��IV�WMGL�QEP�IVLmRKI�

:SVKIWXIVR�JERH�MGL�MLR�XVEYVMK�KIF�GOX%Q�/EQMR��MR�HIV�1SVKIRWXYRHI�)V�OSGLXI�L}GLWXWIPFWX�IMR�0EZIQIRX*�V�WIMRI�OVEROIR�,YRHI�ª

'%498�<<

:SR�,EVFYVK�JYLV�MGL�MR�IMRIV�7XYRH�2EGL�,EQFYVK��)W�[EV�WGLSR�%FIRH�(MI�7XIVRI�EQ�,MQQIP�KV��XIR�QMGL�(MI�0YJX�[EV�PMRH�YRH�PEFIRH�

9RH�EPW�MGL�^Y�QIMRIV�*VEY�1YXXIV�OEQ�)VWGLVEO�WMI�JEWX�ZSV�*VIYHI�7MI�VMIJ��«1IMR�PMIFIW�/MRH�ª�YRH�WGLPYK>YWEQQIR�HMI�,mRHI�FIMHI�

«1IMR�PMIFIW�/MRH��[SLP�HVIM̂ ILR�.ELV�:IVJPSWWIR�YRXIVHIWWIR�(Y�[MVWX�KI[M��WILV�LYRKVMK�WIMR��

7EK�ER��[EW�[MPPWX�HY�IWWIR#

-GL�LEFI�*MWGL�YRH�+mRWIJPIMWGL9RH�WGL}RI�%TJIPWMRIR�ª«7S�KMF�QMV�*MWGL�YRH�+mRWIJPIMWGL9RH�WGL}RI�%TJIPWMRIR�ª

9RH�EPW�MGL�E��QMX�KVS�IQ�%TT�XMX�(MI�1YXXIV�[EVH�KP�GOPMGL�YRH�QYRXIV�7MI�JVYK�[SLP�HMIW��WMI�JVYK�[SLP�HEW�:IVJmRKPMGLI�*VEKIR�QMXYRXIV�

«1IMR�PMIFIW�/MRH��YRH�[MVWX�HY�EYGL6IGLX�WSVKWEQ�KITJPIKX�MR�HIV�*VIQHI#:IVWXILX�HIMRI�*VEY�HMI�,EYWLEPXYRK�9RH�JPMGOX�WMI�HMV�7XV�QTJI�YRH�,IQHI#ª

«(IV�*MWGL�MWX�KYX��PMIF�1�XXIVPIMR�(SGL�QY��QER�MLR�WGL[IMKIRH�ZIV^ILVIR�1ER�OVMIKX�WS�PIMGLX�IMRI�+VmX��MR�HIR�,EPW�(Y�HEVJWX�QMGL�NIX^X�RMGLX�WX}VIR�ª

9RH�EPW�MGL�HIR�FVEZIR�*MWGL�ZIV^ILVX�(MI�+ERW�[EVH�EYJKIXVEKIR�(MI�1YXXIV�JVYK�[MIHIV�[SLP�HMIW��[SLP�HEW�1MXYRXIV�ZIVJmRKPMGLI�*VEKIR�

«1IMR�PMIFIW�/MRH��MR�[IPGLIQ�0ERH0m�X�WMGL�EQ�FIWXIR�PIFIR#,MIV�SHIV�MR�*VEROVIMGL#�YRH�[IPGLIQ�:SPO;MVWX�HY�HIR�:SV^YK�KIFIR#ª

«(MI�HIYXWGLI�+ERW��PMIF�1�XXIVPIMR�-WX�KYX��NIHSGL�HMI�*VER^SWIR�7MI�WXSTJIR�HMI�+mRWI�FIWWIV�EPW�[MV�%YGL�LEFIR�WMI�FIWWIVI�7EYGIR�ª��

9RH�EPW�HMI�+ERW�WMGL�[MIHIV�IQTJELP�(E�QEGLXIR�MLVI�%YJ[EVXYRK(MI�%TJIPWMRIR��WMI�WGLQIGOXIR�WS�W���+ER^��FIV�EPPI�)V[EVXYRK�

(MI�1YXXIV�EFIV�JMRK�[MIHIV�ER>Y�JVEKIR�WILV�ZIVKR�KPMGL�2EGL�XEYWIRH�(MRKIR��QMXYRXIV�WSKEV2EGL�(MRKIR��HMI�WILV�ER^�KPMGL�

«1IMR�PMIFIW�/MRH��;MI�HIROWX�HY�NIX^X#8VIMFWX�HY�RSGL�MQQIV�EYW�2IMKYRK

(MI�4SPMXMO#�>Y�[IPGLIV�4EVXIM+IL}VWX�HY�QMX�iFIV^IYKYRK#ª

«(MI�%TJIPWMRIR��PMIF�1�XXIVPIMR�7MRH�KYX��YRH�QMX�[ELVIQ�:IVKR�KIR:IVWGLPYGOI�MGL�HIR�W��IR�7EJX�9RH�MGL�PEWWI�HMI�7GLEPIR�PMIKIR�ª

'%498�<<-

(MI�7XEHX��^YV�,mPJXI�EFKIFVERRX�;MVH�EYJKIFEYX�EPPQmLPMGL�;MI��R�4YHIP��HIV�LEPF�KIWGLSVIR�MWX�7MILX�,EQFYVK�EYW��XV�FWIPMK�

+EV�QERGLI�+EWWIR�JILPIR�QMV�(MI�MGL�RYV�YRKIVR�ZIVQMWWI��;S�MWX�HEW�,EYW��[S�MGL�KIO��X(IV�0MIFI�IVWXI�/�WWI#

;S�MWX�HMI�(VYGOIVIM��[S�MGL(MI�«6IMWIFMPHIVª�HVYGOXI#;S�MWX�HIV�%YWXIVOIPPIV��[S�MGL(MI�IVWXIR�%YWXIVR�WGLPYGOXI#

9RH�HIV�(VIGO[EPP��[S�MWX�HIV�(VIGO[EPP�LMR#-GL�OERR�MLR�ZIVKIFPMGL�WYGLIR�;S�MWX�HIV�4EZMPPSR��[S�MGL+IKIWWIR�WS�QERGLIR�/YGLIR#

;S�MWX�HEW�6EXLEYW��[SVMR�HIV�7IREX9RH�HMI�&�VKIVWGLEJX�KIXLVSRIX#)MR�6EYF�HIV�*PEQQIR��(MI�*PEQQI�LEX(EW�,IMPMKWXI�RMGLX�ZIVWGLSRIX�

(MI�0IYXI�WIYJ^XIR�RSGL�ZSV�%RKWX�9RH�QMX�[ILQ�X�KIQ�+IWMGLXI)V^mLPXIR�WMI�QMV�ZSQ�KVS�IR�&VERH(MI�WGLVIGOPMGLI�+IWGLMGLXI�

«)W�FVERRXI�ER�EPPIR�)GOIR�^YKPIMGL�1ER�WEL�RYV�6EYGL�YRH�*PEQQIR�(MI�/MVGLIRX�VQI�PSHIVXIR�EYJ9RH�WX�V^XIR�OVEGLIRH�^YWEQQIR�

(MI�EPXI�&}VWI�MWX�ZIVFVERRX�;S�YRWIVI�:mXIV�KI[ERHIPX�

9RH�QMXIMRERHIV�NELVLYRHIVXIPERK7S�VIHPMGL�EPW�Q}KPMGL�KILERHIPX�

(MI�&ERO��HMI�WMPFIVRI�7IIPI�HIV�7XEHX�9RH�HMI�&�GLIV��[S�IMRKIWGLVMIFIR.IH[IHIR�1ERRIW�&EROS�;IVX�+SXXPSF��WMI�WMRH�YRW�KIFPMIFIR�

+SXXPSF��QER�OSPPIOXMIVXI�J�V�YRW7IPFWX�FIM�HIR�JIVRWXIR�2EXMSRIR��)MR�KYXIW�+IWGLmJX���HMI�/SPPIOXI�FIXVYK;SLP�ER�HMI�EGLX�1MPPMSRIR�

%YW�EPPIR�0mRHIVR�JPS��HEW�+IPH-R�YRWVI�SJJRIR�,mRHI�%YGL�:MOXYEPMIR�RELQIR�[MV�ER�:IVWGLQmLXIR�OIMRI�7TIRHI�

1ER�WGLMGOXI�YRW�/PIMHIV�YRH�&IXXIR�KIRYK�%YGL�&VSX�YRH�*PIMWGL�YRH�7YTTIR�(IV�/}RMK�ZSR�4VIY�IR�[SPPXI�WSKEV9RW�WGLMGOIR�WIMRI�8VYTTIR�

(IV�QEXIVMIPPI�7GLEHIR�[EVH:IVK�XIX��HEW�PMI��WMGL�WGLmX^IR��.IHSGL�HIR�7GLVIGOIR��YRWIVIR�7GLVIGO�(IR�OERR�YRW�RMIQERH�IVWIX̂ IR�ª

%YJQYRXIVRH�WTVEGL�MGL��«-LV�PMIFIR�0IYX��-LV�Q��X�RMGLX�NEQQIVR�YRH�JPIRRIR�8VSNE�[EV�IMRI�FIWWIVI�7XEHX9RH�QY�XI�HSGL�ZIVFVIRRIR�

&EYX�IYVI�,mYWIV�[MIHIV�EYJ9RH�XVSGORIX�IYVI�4J�X^IR�9RH�WGLEJJX�IYGL�FI�VI�+IWIX^I�ER9RH�FI�VI�*IYIVWTVMX^IR�

+MI�X�RMGLX�̂ YZMIP�'E]IRRI�4MQIRX-R�IYVI�1SGOXYVXPIWYTTIR�%YGL�IYVI�/EVTJIR�WMRH�IYGL�RMGLX�KIWYRH�-LV�OSGLX�WMI�WS�JIXX�QMX�HIR�7GLYTTIR�

/EPOYXIR�WGLEHIR�IYGL�RMGLX�ZMIP�(SGL�L�XIX�IYGL�ZSV�HIV�8�GOI(IW�:SKIPW��HIV�WIMR�)M�KIPIKX-R�HIW�&�VKIVQIMWXIVW�4IV�GOI�����

;IV�HMIWIV�JEXEPI�:SKIP�MWX�

-GL�FVEYGL�IW�IYGL�RMGLX�^Y�WEKIR��(IRO�MGL�ER�MLR��WS�HVILX�WMGL�LIVYQ(EW�)WWIR�MR�QIMRIQ�1EKIR�ª

'%498�<<--

2SGL�QILV�ZIVmRHIVX�EPW�HMI�7XEHX7MRH�QMV�HMI�1IRWGLIR�IVWGLMIRIR�7MI�KILR�WS�FIXV�FX�YRH�KIFVSGLIR�LIVYQ�;MI�[ERHIPRHI�6YMRIR�

(MI�1EKIVIR�WMRH�RSGL�H�RRIV�NIX^X�2SGL�JIXXIV�WMRH�HMI�*IMWXIR�(MI�/MRHIV�WMRH�EPX��HMI�%PXIR�WMRH/MRHMWGL�KI[SVHIR��HMI�QIMWXIR�

+EV�QERGLI��HMI�MGL�EPW�/mPFIV�ZIVPMI��*ERH�MGL�EPW�3GLWIR�[MIHIV�+EV�QERGLIW�OPIMRI�+mRWGLIR�[EVH>YV�+ERW�QMX�WXSP^IQ�+IJMIHIV�

(MI�EPXI�+YHIP�JERH�MGL�KIWGLQMROX9RH�KITYX^X�[MI�IMRI�7MVIRI�,EX�WGL[EV^I�0SGOIR�WMGL�ERKIWGLEJJX9RH�FPIRHIRH[IM�I�>mLRI�

%Q�FIWXIR�LEX�WMGL�OSRWIVZMIVX1IMR�*VIYRH��HIV�4ETMIVZIVOmYJIV�7IMR�,EEV�[EVH�KIPF�YRH�YQ[EPPX�WIMR�,EYTX�7MILX�EYW�[MI�.SLERRIW�HIV�8mYJIV�

(IR������HIR�WEL�MGL�RYV�ZSR�JIVR�)V�LYWGLXI�QMV�VEWGL�ZSV�FIV�-GL�L}VI��WIMR�+IMWX�MWX�EFKIFVERRX9RH�[EV�ZIVWMGLIVX�FIM�&MIFIV�

%YGL�QIMRIR�EPXIR�>IRWSV�WEL-GL�[MIHIV��-Q�2IFIP��KIF�GOIX�&IKIKRIX��IV�QMV�EYJ�HIQ�+mRWIQEVOX�7GLMIR�WILV�HEVRMIHIVKIHV�GOIX�

;MV�WGL�XXIPXIR�YRW�HMI�,mRHI��IW�WGL[EQQ-Q�%YKI�HIW�1ERRW�IMRI�8VmRI�;MI�JVIYXI�IV�WMGL��QMGL�[MIHIV^YWILR�)W�[EV�IMRI�V�LVIRHI�7^IRI���

2MGLX�EPPI�JERH�MGL��1ERGLIV�LEX

(EW�>IMXPMGLI�KIWIKRIX�%GL��QIMRIQ�+YQTIPMRS�WSKEV&MR�MGL�RMGLX�QILV�FIKIKRIX�

(IV�)HPI�LEXXI�EYWKILEYGLX(MI�KVS�I�7IIPI�WSIFIR�9RH�[MVH�EPW�ZIVOPmVXIV�7IVETL�NIX̂ X%Q�8LVSRI�.ILSZEW�WGL[IFIR�

:IVKIFIRW�WYGLXI�MGL��FIVEPP(IR�OVYQQIR�%HSRMW��HIV�8EWWIR9RH�2EGLXKIWGLMVV�ZSR�4SV^IPPER*IMPFSX�MR�,EQFYVKW�+EWWIR�

7EVVEW��HIV�XVIYI�4YHIP��MWX�XSX�)MR�KVS�IV�:IVPYWX��-GL�[IXXI�(E��'EQTI�PMIFIV�IMR�KER^IW�7GLSGO7GLVMJXWXIPPIV�ZIVPSVIR�LmXXI�����

(MI�4STYPEXMSR�HIW�,EQFYVKIV�7XEEXW&IWXILX��WIMX�1IRWGLIRKIHIROIR�%YW�.YHIR�YRH�'LVMWXIR��IW�TJPIKIR�EYGL(MI�PIX^XVIR�RMGLX�ZMIP�^Y�ZIVWGLIROIR�

(MI�'LVMWXIR�WMRH�EPPI�^MIQPMGL�KYX�%YGL�IWWIR�WMI�KYX�^Y�1MXXEK�9RH�MLVI�;IGLWIP�FI^ELPIR�WMI�TVSQTX�2SGL�ZSV�HIQ�PIX^XIR�6IWTMXXEK�

(MI�.YHIR�XIMPIR�WMGL�[MIHIV�IMR-R�^[IM�ZIVWGLMIHRI�4EVXIMIR�(MI�%PXIR�KILR�MR�HMI�7]REKSK��9RH�MR�HIR�8IQTIP�HMI�2IYIR�

(MI�2IYIR�IWWIR�7GL[IMRIJPIMWGL�>IMKIR�WMGL�[MHIVWIX^MK�7MRH�(IQSOVEXIR��HMI�%PXIR�WMRH:MIPQILV�EVMWXSOVmX^MK�

-GL�PMIFI�HMI�%PXIR��MGL�PMIFI�HMI�2IY�R��(SGL�WGL[}V�MGL��FIMQ�I[MKIR�+SXXI�-GL�PMIFI�KI[MWWI�*MWGLGLIR�RSGL�QILV�1ER�LIM�X�WMI�KIVmYGLIVXI�7TVSXXI�

'%498�<<---

%PW�6ITYFPMO�[EV�,EQFYVK�RMI

7S�KVS��[MI�:IRIHMK�YRH�*PSVIR^�(SGL�,EQFYVK�LEX�FIWWIVI�%YWXIVR��QER�WTIMWX(MI�FIWXIR�MQ�/IPPIV�ZSR�0SVIR^�

)W�[EV�IMR�WGL}RIV�%FIRH��EPW�MGL1MGL�LMRFIKEF�QMX�'EQTIR�;MV�[SPPXIR�QMXIMRERHIV�HSVX-R�6LIMR[IMR�YRH�%YWXIVR�WGLPEQTEQTIR�

%YGL�KYXI�+IWIPPWGLEJX�JERH�MGL�HSVX�1MX�*VIYHI�WEL�MGL�[MIHIV1ERGL�EPXIR�+IRSWWIR��^YQ�&IMWTMIP�'LEYJITMq�%YGL�QERGLI�RIYI�&V�HIV�

(E�[EV�HIV�;MPPI��HIWWIR�+IWMGLX)MR�7XEQQFYGL��[SVMR�QMX�,MIFIR(MI�EOEHIQMWGLIR�*IMRHI�WMGL6IGLX�PIWIVPMGL�IMRKIWGLVMIFIR�

(E�[EV�HIV�*YGOW��IMR�FPMRHIV�,IMH�9RH�TIVW}RPMGLIV�*IMRH�HIW�.ILSZE�+PEYFX�RYV�ER�,IKIP�YRH�IX[E�RSGL%R�HMI�:IRYW�HIW�'ERSZE�

1IMR�'EQTI�[EV�%QTLMXV]S9RH�PmGLIPXI�ZSV�;SRRI�7IMR�%YKI�WXVELPXI�7IPMKOIMX�;MI�IMRI�ZIVOPmVXI�1EHSRRI�

-GL�E��YRH�XVERO��QMX�KYXIQ�%TT�XMX�9RH�HEGLXI�MR�QIMRIQ�+IQ�XI��(IV�'EQTI�MWX�[MVOPMGL�IMR�KVS�IV�1ERR�-WX�EPPIV�:IVPIKIV�&P�XI�

)MR�ERHVIV�:IVPIKIV�LmXXI�QMGL:MIPPIMGLX�ZIVLYRKIVR�PEWWIR�(IV�EFIV�KMFX�QMV�^Y�XVMROIR�WSKEV�;IVHI�MLR�RMIQEPW�ZIVPEWWIR�

-GL�HEROI�HIQ�7GL}TJIV�MR�HIV�,}L��(IV�HMIWIR�7EJX�HIV�6IFIR)VWGLYJ��YRH�^YQ�:IVPIKIV�QMV(IR�.YPMYW�'EQTI�KIKIFIR�

-GL�HEROI�HIQ�7GL}TJIV�MR�HIV�,}L��(IV��HYVGL�WIMR�KVS�IW�;IVHI�(MI�%YWXIVR�IVWGLEJJIR�MR�HIV�7II9RH�HIR�6LIMR[IMR�EYJ�HIV�)VHI�

(IV�EYGL�>MXVSRIR�[EGLWIR�PMI��(MI�%YWXIVR�^Y�FIXEYIR��2YR�PE��QMGL��:EXIV��HMIWI�2EGLX(EW�)WWIR�KYX�ZIVHEYIR��

(IV�6LIMR[IMR�WXMQQX�QMGL�MQQIV�[IMGL9RH�P}WX�NIH[IHIW�>IV[�VJRMW-R�QIMRIV�&VYWX��IRX^�RHIX�HEVMR(IV�1IRWGLIRPMIFI�&IH�VJRMW�

)W�XVIMFX�QMGL�EYW�HIQ�>MQQIV�LMREYW�-GL�QY��MR�HIR�7XVE�IR�WGLPIRHIVR�(MI�7IIPI�WYGLX�IMRI�7IIPI�YRH�WTmLX2EGL�^mVXPMGL�[IM�IR�+I[mRHIVR�

-R�WSPGLIR�1SQIRXIR�̂ IVJPMI�I�MGL�JEWX:SV�;ILQYX�YRH�ZSV�7ILRIR�(MI�/EX^IR�WGLIMRIR�QMV�EPPI�KVEY�(MI�;IMFIV�EPPI�,IPIRIR�������

9RH�EPW�MGL�EYJ�HMI�(VILFELR�OEQ�(E�WEL�MGL�MQ�1SRHIRWGLMQQIV)MR�LILVIW�;IMF��IMR�[YRHIVFEV,SGLFYWMKIW�*VEYIR^MQQIV�

-LV�%RXPMX̂ �[EV�VYRH�YRH�OIVRKIWYRH�(MI�%YKIR�[MI�FPEYI�8YVOSEWIR�(MI�;ERKIR�[MI�6SWIR��[MI�/MVWGLIR�HIV�1YRH�%YGL�IX[EW�V}XPMGL�HMI�2EWI�

-LV�,EYTX�FIHIGOXI�IMRI�1�X^�:SR�[IM�IQ�KIWXIMJXIQ�0MRRIR�+IJmPXIPX�[MI�IMRI�1EYIVOVSR��1MX�8�VQGLIR�YRH�̂ EGOMKIR�>MRRIR�

7MI�XVYK�IMRI�[IM�I�8YRMOE�&MW�ER�HMI�;EHIR�VIMGLIRH�9RH�[IPGLI�;EHIR��(EW�*Y�KIWXIPP>[IM�HSVMWGLIR�7mYPIR�KPIMGLIRH�

(MI�[IPXPMGLWXI�2EX�VPMGLOIMX/SRRX�QER�MR�HIR�>�KIR�PIWIR�(SGL�HEW��FIVQIRWGLPMGLI�,MRXIVXIMP:IVVMIX�IMR�L}LIVIW�;IWIR�

7MI�XVEX�^Y�QMV�LIVER�YRH�WTVEGL�«;MPPOSQQIR�ER�HIV�)PFI2EGL�HVIM^ILRNmLV�KIV�%F[IWIRLIMX��-GL�WILI��HY�FMWX�RSGL�HIVWIPFI�

(Y�WYGLWX�HMI�WGL}RIR�7IIPIR�ZMIPPIMGLX�(MI�HMV�WS�SJX�FIKIKIRX9RH�QMX�HMV�KIWGL[mVQX�HMI�2EGLX�LMRHYVGL�-R�HMIWIV�WGL}RIR�+IKIRH�

(EW�0IFIR�ZIVWGLPERK�WMI��HEW�9RKIX�Q�(MI�LYRHIVXO}TJMKI�,]HIV�(Y�JMRHIWX�RMGLX�HMI�EPXI�>IMX9RH�HMI�>IMXKIR}WWMRRIR�[MIHIV�

(Y�JMRHIWX�HMI�LSPHIR�&PYQIR�RMGLX�QILV�(MI�HEW�NYRKI�,IV^�ZIVK}XXIVX�,MIV�FP�LXIR�WMI���NIX̂ X�WMRH�WMI�ZIV[IPOX�9RH�HIV�7XYVQ�LEX�WMI�IRXFPmXXIVX�

:IV[IPOX��IRXFPmXXIVX��^IVXVIXIR�WSKEV:SR�VSLIR�7GLMGOWEPWJ��IR��1IMR�*VIYRH��HEW�MWX�EYJ�)VHIR�HEW�0SW:SR�EPPIQ�7GL}RIR�YRH�7��IR�ª

«;IV�FMWX�HY#ª���VMIJ�MGL���«HY�WGLEYWX�QMGL�ER;MI�R�8VEYQ�EYW�EPXIR�>IMXIR��;S�[SLRWX�HY��KVS�IW�*VEYIRFMPH#9RH�HEVJ�MGL�HMGL�FIKPIMXIR#ª

(E�PmGLIPXI�HEW�;IMF�YRH�WTVEGL�«(Y�MVVWX�HMGL��MGL�FMR�IMRI�JIMRI�%RWXmRH�KI��QSVEPMWGLI�4IVWSR�(Y�MVVWX�HMGL��MGL�FMR�RMGLX�WS�IMRI�

-GL�FMR�RMGLX�WS�IMRI�OPIMRI�1EQWIPP�7S�IMRI�[IPWGLI�0SVIXXMR��(IRR�[MWWI��MGL�FMR�,EQQSRME�,EQFYVKW�FIWGL�X̂ IRHI�+}XXMR�

(Y�WXYX^IWX�YRH�IVWGLVIGOWX�WSKEV�(Y�WSRWX�WS�QYXMKIV�7mRKIV�;MPPWX�HY�QMGL�RSGL�FIKPIMXIR�NIX^X#;SLPER��WS�̂ }KVI�RMGLX�PmRKIV�ª

-GL�EFIV�PEGLXI�PEYX�YRH�VMIJ�«-GL�JSPKI�EYJ�HIV�7XIPPI��7GLVIMX�HY�ZSVER��MGL�JSPKI�HMV�9RH�KMRK��IW�MR�HMI�,}PPI�ª

'%498�<<-:

;MI�MGL�HMI�IRKI�7ELPXVITT��LMREYJ+IOSQQIR��MGL�OERR�IW�RMGLX�WEKIR�)W�LEFIR�YRWMGLXFEVI�+IMWXIV�QMGL:MIPPIMGLX�LMREYJKIXVEKIR�

,MIV��MR�,EQQSRMEW�/mQQIVPIMR�:IVJPSWWIR�QMV�WGLRIPP�HMI�7XYRHIR�(MI�+}XXMR�KIWXERH�HMI�7]QTEXLMI�(MI�WMI�MQQIV�J�V�QMGL�IQTJYRHIR�

«7MILWX�HYª���WTVEGL�WMI����«MR�JV�LIVIV�>IMX;EV�QMV�EQ�QIMWXIR�XIYIV(IV�7mRKIV��HIV�HIR�1IWWMEW�FIWERK%YJ�WIMRIV�JVSQQIR�0IMIV�

(SVX�EYJ�HIV�/SQQSHI�WXILX�RSGL�NIX^X(MI�&�WXI�ZSR�QIMRIQ�/PSTWXSGO�.IHSGL�WIMX�.ELVIR�HMIRX�WMI�QMV2YV�RSGL�EPW�,EYFIROSTJWXSGO�

(Y�FMWX�QIMR�0MIFPMRK�NIX^X��IW�LmRKX(IMR�&MPHRMW�̂ Y�,mYTXIR�HIW�&IXXIW�9RH��WMILWX�HY��IMR�JVMWGLIV�0SVFIIV�YQOVmR^X(IR�6ELQIR�HIW�LSPHIR�4SVXVmXIW�

2YV�HE��HY�QIMRI�7}LRI�WS�SJX+IRIVKIPX��MGL�QY��IW�KIWXILIR�,EX�QMGL�̂ Y[IMPIR�XMIJ�ZIVPIX̂ X�(EW�HEVJ�RMGLX�QILV�KIWGLILIR�

)W�LEX�HMI�>IMX�HMGL�LSJJIRXPMGL:SR�WSPGLIV�9REVX�KILIMPIX�9RH�HMV�IMRI�KV}�IVI�8SPIVER^7SKEV�J�V�2EVVIR�IVXIMPIX�

(SGL�WTVMGL��[MI�OEQ�HIV�+IHEROI�HMV�>Y�VIMWIR�REGL�HIQ�2SVHIR-R�WSPGLIV�.ELV^IMX#�(EW�;IXXIV�MWX7GLSR�[MRXIVPMGL�KI[SVHIR�ª

«3L��QIMRI�+}XXMR�ª���IV[MHIVXI�MGL��«)W�WGLPEJIR�XMIJ�MQ�+VYRHI(IW�1IRWGLIRLIV^IRW�+IHEROIR��HMI�SJX)V[EGLIR�^YV�YRVIGLXIR�7XYRHI�

)W�KMRK�QMV�mY�IVPMGL�^MIQPMGL�KYX�(SGL�MRRIVPMGL�[EV�MGL�FIOPSQQIR�9RH�HMI�&IOPIQQRMW�XmKPMGL�[YGLW��

-GL�LEXXI�HEW�,IMQ[IL�FIOSQQIR�

(MI�WSRWX�WS�PIMGLXI�JVER^}WMWGLI�0YJX�7MI�JMRK�QMGL�ER�̂ Y�HV�GOIR�-GL�QY�XI�%XIQ�WGL}TJIR�LMIV-R�(IYXWGLPERH��YQ�RMGLX�̂ Y�IVWXMGOIR�

-GL�WILRXI�QMGL�REGL�8SVJKIVYGL�2EGL�HIYXWGLIQ�8EFEOWHEQTJI�)W�FIFXI�QIMR�*Y��ZSV�9RKIHYPH�(E��IV�HIYXWGLIR�&SHIR�WXEQTJI�

-GL�WIYJ^XI�HIW�2EGLXW��YRH�WILRXI�QMGL�(E��MGL�WMI�[MIHIVWmLI�(MI�EPXI�*VEY��HMI�EQ�(EQQXSV�[SLRX�(EW�0SXXGLIR�[SLRX�MR�HIV�2mLI�

%YGL�NIRIQ�IHPIR�EPXIR�,IVVR�(IV�MQQIV�QMGL�EYWKIWGLSPXIR9RH�MQQIV�KVS�Q�XMK�FIWGL�X^X��EYGL�MLQ,EX�QERGLIV�7IYJ^IV�KIKSPXIR�

-GL�[SPPXI�[MIHIV�EYW�WIMRIQ�1YRH:IVRILQIR�HIR��HYQQIR�.YRKIR��(EW�LEX�QMV�MQQIV�[MI�1YWMO-Q�,IV^IR�REGLKIOPYRKIR�

-GL�WILRXI�QMGL�REGL�HIQ�FPEYIR�6EYGL�(IV�EYJWXIMKX�EYW�HIYXWGLIR�7GLSVRWXIMRIR�2EGL�RMIHIVWmGLWMWGLIR�2EGLXMKEPP�R�2EGL�WXMPPIR�&YGLIRLEMRIR�

-GL�WILRXI�QMGL�REGL�HIR�4PmX^IR�WSKEV�2EGL�NIRIR�0IMHIRWWXEXMSRIR�;S�MGL�KIWGLPITTX�HEW�.YKIRHOVIY^9RH�QIMRI�(SVRIROVSRIR�

-GL�[SPPXI�[IMRIR��[S�MGL�IMRWX+I[IMRX�HMI�FMXXIVWXIR�8VmRIR��-GL�KPEYFI��:EXIVPERHWPMIFI�RIRRX1ER�HMIWIW�X}VMGLXI�7ILRIR�

-GL�WTVIGLI�RMGLX�KIVR�HEZSR��IW�MWX2YV�IMRI�/VEROLIMX�MQ�+VYRHI�:IVWGLmQXIR�+IQ�XIW��ZIVFIVKI�MGL�WXIXW(IQ�4YFPMOS�QIMRI�;YRHI�

*EXEP�MWX�QMV�HEW�0YQTIRTEGO�(EW��YQ�HMI�,IV^IR�^Y�V�LVIR�

(IR�4EXVMSXMWQYW�XVmKX�^YV�7GLEY1MX�EPPIR�WIMRIR�+IWGL[�VIR�

7GLEQPSWI�WGLmFMKI�&IXXPIV�WMRH�W�%PQSWIR�[SPPIR�WMI�LEFIR��)MR�R�4JIRRMK�4STYPEVMXmX*�V�1IR^IP�YRH�WIMRI�7GL[EFIR�

3L��QIMRI�+}XXMR��HY�LEWX�QMGL�LIYX-R�[IMGLIV�7XMQQYRK�KIJYRHIR�&MR�IX[EW�OVERO��HSGL�TJPIK�MGL�QMGL�9RH�MGL�[IVHI�FEPH�KIWYRHIR�

.E��MGL�FMR�OVERO��YRH�HY�O}RRXIWX�QMV(MI�7IIPI�WILV�IVJVMWGLIR(YVGL�IMRI�KYXI�8EWWI�8II�(Y�QY�X�MLR�QMX�6YQ�ZIVQMWGLIR�ª

'%498�<<:

(MI�+}XXMR�LEX�QMV�8II�KIOSGLX9RH�6YQ�LMRIMRKIKSWWIR�7MI�WIPFIV�EFIV�LEX�HIR�6YQ+ER^�SLRI�8II�KIRSWWIR�

%R�QIMRI�7GLYPXIV�PILRXI�WMI-LV�,EYTX��HMI�1EYIVOVSRI�(MI�1�X^I��[EVH�IX[EW�^IVORMXXIVX�HEZSR �9RH�WMI�WTVEGL�QMX�WERJXIQ�8SRI�

«-GL�HEGLXI�QERGLQEP�QMX�7GLVIGOIR�HVER�(E��HY�MR�HIQ�WMXXIRPSWIR4EVMW�WS�KER^�SLRI�%YJWMGLX�PIFWX�&IM�NIRIR�JVMZSPIR�*VER^SWIR�

(Y�WGLPIRHIVWX�HSVX�LIVYQ�YRH�LEWX2MGLX�QEP�ER�HIMRIV�7IMXI)MRIR�XVIYIR�HIYXWGLIR�:IVPIKIV��HIV�HMGL%PW�1IRXSV�[EVRI�YRH�PIMXI�

9RH�HMI�:IVJ�LVYRK�MWX�HSVX�WS�KVS��(SVX�KMFX�IW�WS�ZMIPI�7]PTLMHIR�(MI�YRKIWYRH��YRH�KEV�^Y�PIMGLX:IVPMIVX�QER�HIR�7IIPIRJVMIHIR�

+IL�RMGLX�^YV�GO�YRH�FPIMF�FIM�YRW�,MIV�LIVVWGLIR�RSGL�>YGLX�YRH�7MXXI�

9RH�QERGLIW�WXMPPI�:IVKR�KIR�FP�LX%YGL�LMIV��MR�YRWIVIV�1MXXI�

&PIMF�FIM�YRW�MR�(IYXWGLPERH��IW�[MVH�HMV�LMIV.IX̂ X�FIWWIV�EPW�ILQEPW�QYRHIR�;MV�WGLVIMXIR�JSVX��HY�LEWX�KI[M�(IR�*SVXWGLVMXX�WIPFWX�KIJYRHIR�

%YGL�HMI�>IRWYV�MWX�RMGLX�QILV�WXVIRK�,SJJQERR�[MVH�mPXIV�YRH�QMPHIV9RH�WXVIMGLX�RMGLX�QILV�QMX�.YKIRH^SVR(MV�HIMRI��6IMWIFMPHIV��

(Y�WIPFWX�FMWX�mPXIV�YRH�QMPHIV�NIX^X�;MVWX�HMGL�MR�QERGLIW�WGLMGOIR�9RH�[MVWX�WSKEV�HMI�:IVKERKIRLIMX-R�FIWWIVIQ�0MGLXI�IVFPMGOIR�

.E��HE��IW�YRW�JV�LIV�WS�WGLVIGOPMGL�KMRK�-R�(IYXWGLPERH��MWX�iFIVXVIMFYRK�1ER�OSRRXI�IRXVMRRIR�HIV�/RIGLXWGLEJX��[MI�IMRWX-R�6SQ��HYVGL�7IPFWXIRXPIMFYRK�

+IHEROIRJVIMLIMX�KIRS��HEW�:SPO�7MI�[EV�J�V�HMI�KVS�IR�1EWWIR�&IWGLVmROYRK�XVEJ�RYV�HMI�K�VMRKI�>ELP(IVNIR�KIR��HMI�HVYGOIR�PEWWIR�

+IWIX̂ PSWI�;MPPO�V�LIVVWGLXI�RMI�(IQ�WGLPMQQWXIR�(IQEKSKIR;EVH�RMIQEPW�SLRI�9VXIMPWTVYGL(MI�7XEEXWOSOEVHI�IRX^SKIR�

7S��FIP�[EV�IW�MR�(IYXWGLPERH�RMI�8VSX̂ �EPPIV�>IMXFIHVmRKRMW��+PEYF�QMV��ZIVLYRKIVX�MWX�RMI�IMR�1IRWGL-R�IMRIQ�HIYXWGLIR�+IJmRKRMW�

)W�FP�LXI�MR�HIV�:IVKERKIRLIMX7S�QERGLI�WGL}RI�)VWGLIMRYRK(IW�+PEYFIRW�YRH�HIV�+IQ�XPMGLOIMX�.IX̂ X�LIVVWGLX�RYV�>[IMJIP��:IVRIMRYRK�

(MI�TVEOXMWGLI�mY�IVI�*VIMLIMX�[MVH�IMRWX(EW�-HIEP�ZIVXMPKIR�(EW�[MV�MQ�&YWIR�KIXVEKIR���IW�[EV7S�VIMR�[MI�HIV�8VEYQ�HIV�0MPNIR�

%YGL�YRWVI�WGL}RI�4SIWMI

)VPMWGLX��WMI�MWX�WGLSR�IMR�[IRMK)VPSWGLIR��QMX�ERHIVR�/}RMKIR�WXMVFX%YGL�*VIMPMKVEXLW�1SLVIRO}RMK�

(IV�)ROIP�[MVH�IWWIR�YRH�XVMROIR�KIRYK�(SGL�RMGLX�MR�FIWGLEYPMGLIV�7XMPPI�)W�TSPXIVX�LIVER�IMR�7TIOXEOIPWX�GO�>Y�)RHI�KILX�HMI�-H]PPI�

3L��O}RRXIWX�HY�WGL[IMKIR��MGL�[�VHI�HMV(EW�&YGL�HIW�7GLMGOWEPW�IRXWMIKIPR�-GL�PMI�I�HMV�WTmXIVI�>IMXIR�WILR-R�QIMRIR�>EYFIVWTMIKIPR�

;EW�MGL�HIR�WXIVFPMGLIR�1IRWGLIR�RMI+I^IMKX��MGL�Q}GLX�IW�HMV�^IMKIR�(MI�>YOYRJX�HIMRIW�:EXIVPERHW��(SGL�EGL��HY�OERRWX�RMGLX�WGL[IMKIR�ª

«1IMR�+SXX��S�+}XXMR�ª���VMIJ�MGL�IRX^�GOX��«(EW�[mVI�QIMR�KV}�XIW�:IVKR�KIR�0E��QMGL�HEW�O�RJXMKI�(IYXWGLPERH�WILR��-GL�FMR�IMR�1ERR�YRH�ZIVWGL[MIKIR�

-GL�[MPP�HMV�WGL[}VIR�NIHIR�)MH�(IR�HY�RYV�QEKWX�FIKILVIR�1IMR�7GL[IMKIR�^Y�ZIVF�VKIR�HMV��7EK�ER��[MI�WSPP�MGL�WGL[}VIR#ª

(SGL�NIRI�IV[MHIVXI��«7GL[}VI�QMV-R�:EXIV�%FVELEQW�;IMWI�;MI�IV�)PMIWIVR�WGL[}VIR�PMI��%PW�HMIWIV�WMGL�KEF�EYJ�HMI�6IMWI�

,IF�EYJ�HEW�+I[ERH�YRH�PIKI�HMI�,ERH,MIV�YRXIR�ER�QIMRI�,�JXIR�9RH�WGL[}VI�QMV�:IVWGL[MIKIRLIMX-R�6IHIR�YRH�MR�7GLVMJXIR�ª

)MR�JIMIVPMGLIV�1SQIRX��-GL�[EV;MI�ERKI[ILX�ZSQ�,EYGLI(IV�:SV^IMX��EPW�MGL�WGL[YV�HIR�)MH�2EGL�YVEPXIQ�)V^ZmXIVFVEYGLI�

-GL�LSF�HEW�+I[ERH�HIV�+}XXMR�EYJ�9RH�PIKXI�ER�MLVI�,�JXIR(MI�,ERH��KIPSFIRH�:IVWGL[MIKIRLIMX-R�6IHIR�YRH�MR�7GLVMJXIR�

'%498�<<:-

(MI�;ERKIR�HIV�+}XXMR�KP�LXIR�WS�VSX�-GL�KPEYFI��MR�HMI�/VSRI7XMIK�MLV�HIV�6YQ ��YRH�WMI�WTVEGL�^Y�QMV-R�WILV�[ILQ�XMKIQ�8SRI�

«-GL�[IVHI�EPX��+IFSVIR�FMR�MGL%Q�8EKI�ZSR�,EQFYVKW�&IKV�RHYRK�(MI�1YXXIV�[EV�7GLIPPJMWGLO}RMKMR,MIV�ER�HIV�)PFI�1�RHYRK�

1IMR�:EXIV�[EV�IMR�KVS�IV�1SREVGL�'EVSPYW�1EKRYW�KILIM�IR�)V�[EV�RSGL�QmGLX�KIV�YRH�OP�KIV�WSKEV%PW�*VMIHVMGL�HIV�+VS�I�ZSR�4VIY�IR�

(IV�7XYLP�MWX�^Y�%EGLIR��EYJ�[IPGLIQ�IV%Q�8EKI�HIV�/V}RYRK�VYLXI�(IR�7XYLP��[SVEYJ�IV�WE��MR�HIV�2EGLX�(IR�IVFXI�HMI�1YXXIV��HMI�KYXI�

(MI�1YXXIV�LMRXIVPMI��MLR�QMV�)MR�1}FIP�ZSR�WGLIMRPSWIQ�cY�IVR�(SGL�F}XI�QMV�6SXLWGLMPH�EPP�WIMR�+IPH�-GL�[�VHI�MLR�RMGLX�ZIVmY�IVR�

7MILWX�HY��HSVX�MR�HIQ�;MROIP�WXILX)MR�EPXIV�7IWWIP��̂ IVVMWWIR(EW�0IHIV�HIV�0ILRI��ZSR�1SXXIRJVE�>IVREKX�HEW�4SPWXIVOMWWIR�

(SGL�KILI�LMR�YRH�LIFI�EYJ(EW�/MWWIR�ZSR�HIQ�7IWWIP�(Y�WGLEYWX�IMRI�VYRHI�hJJRYRK�HERR�(EVYRXIV�IMRIR�/IWWIP��

(EW�MWX�IMR�>EYFIVOIWWIP��[SVMR(MI�QEKMWGLIR�/VmJXI�FVEYIR�9RH�WXIGOWX�HY�MR�HMI�6�RHYRK�HIR�/STJ�7S�[MVWX�HY�HMI�>YOYRJX�WGLEYIR��

(MI�>YOYRJX�(IYXWGLPERHW�IVFPMGOWX�HY�LMIV�+PIMGL�[SKIRHIR�4LERXEWQIR�(SGL�WGLEYHVI�RMGLX��[IRR�EYW�HIQ�;YWX%YJWXIMKIR�HMI�1MEWQIR�ª

7MI�WTVEGL�W�YRH�PEGLXI�WSRHIVFEV�-GL�EFIV�PMI��QMGL�RMGLX�WGLVIGOIR�2IYKMIVMK�IMPXI�MGL��HIR�/STJ-R�HMI�JYVGLXFEVI�6�RHYRK�̂ Y�WXIGOIR�

;EW�MGL�KIWILR��ZIVVEXI�MGL�RMGLX�-GL�LEFI�^Y�WGL[IMKIR�ZIVWTVSGLIR�)VPEYFX�MWX�QMV�^Y�WEKIR�OEYQ�3�+SXX��[EW�MGL�KIVSGLIR�������

-GL�HIROI�QMX�;MHIV[MPPIR�RSGL%R�NIRI�WGLR}HIR��ZIVJPYGLXIR:SVWTMIPKIV�GLI��HEW�WGLMIR�IMR�+IQMWGL:SR�EPXIQ�/SLP�YRH�.YGLXIR�

)RXWIX^PMGL�[EVIR�HMI�(�JXI��S�+SXX�(MI�WMGL�REGLLIV�IVLYFIR�)W�[EV��EPW�JIKXI�QER�HIR�1MWX%YW�WIGLWYRHHVIM�MK�+VYFIR�������

-GL�[IM��[SLP��[EW�7EMRX�.YWX�KIWEKX;IMPERH�MQ�;SLPJELVXWEYWWGLY��1ER�LIMPI�HMI�KVS�I�/VEROLIMX�RMGLX1MX�6SWIR}P�YRH�1SWGLYW��

(SGL�HMIWIV�HIYXWGLI�>YOYRJXWHYJX1SGLX�EPPIW��FIVVEKIR�;EW�QIMRI�2EWI�NI�KIELRX��-GL�OSRRX�IW�RMGLX�PmRKIV�IVXVEKIR������

1MV�WGL[ERHIR�HMI�7MRRI��YRH�EPW�MGL�EYJWGLPYK(MI�%YKIR��WE��MGL�ER�HIV�7IMXI(IV�+}XXMR�RSGL�MQQIV��IW�PILRXI�QIMR�,EYTX%R�MLVI�&VYWX��HMI�FVIMXI�

)W�FPMX^XI�MLV�&PMGO��IW�KP�LXI�MLV�1YRH�)W�̂ YGOXIR�HMI�2�WXIVR�HIV�2EWI�&EGGLERXMWGL�YQWGLPERK�WMI�HIR�(MGLXIV�YRH�WERK1MX�WGLEYIVPMGL�[MPHIV�)OWXEWI�

«&PIMF�FIM�QMV�MR�,EQFYVK��MGL�PMIFI�HMGL�;MV�[SPPIR�XVMROIR�YRH�IWWIR(IR�;IMR�YRH�HMI�%YWXIVR�HIV�+IKIR[EVX�9RH�HMI�HYROPI�>YOYRJX�ZIVKIWWIR�

(IR�(IGOIP�HEVEYJ��HEQMX�YRW�RMGLX(IV�1M�HYJX�HMI�*VIYHI�ZIVXV�FIX��-GL�PMIFI�HMGL��[MI�NI�IMR�;IMF)MRIR�HIYXWGLIR�4SIXIR�KIPMIFIX�

-GL�O�WWI�HMGL��YRH�MGL�J�LPI��[MI�QMGL(IMR�+IRMYW�FIKIMWXIVX�)W�LEX�IMR�[YRHIVFEVIV�6EYWGL7MGL�QIMRIV�7IIPI�FIQIMWXIVX�

1MV�MWX��EPW�SF�MGL�EYJ�HIV�7XVE��(MI�2EGLX[mGLXIV�WMRKIR�L}VXI��)W�WMRH�,]QIRmIR��,SGL^IMXQYWMO�1IMR�W��IV�0YWXKIJmLVXI�

.IX̂ X�OSQQIR�HMI�VIMXIRHIR�(MIRIV�EYGL1MX��TTMK�PSHIVRHIR�*EGOIPR�7MI�XER^IR�ILVFEV�HIR�*EGOIPXER^�7MI�WTVMRKIR�YRH�L�TJIR�YRH�[EGOIPR�

)W�OSQQX�HIV�LSGL��YRH�[SLP[IMWI�7IREX�)W�OSQQIR�HMI�3FIVEPXIR�(IV�&�VKIVQIMWXIV�VmYWTIVX�WMGL9RH�[MPP�IMRI�6IHI�LEPXIR�

-R�KPmR^IRHIV�9RMJSVQ�IVWGLIMRX(EW�/SVTW�HIV�(MTPSQEXIR�7MI�KVEXYPMIVIR�QMX�:SVFILEPX-Q�2EQIR�HIV�2EGLFEVWXEEXIR�

)W�OSQQX�HMI�KIMWXPMGLI�(ITYXEXMSR�6EFFMRIV�YRH�4EWX}VI��(SGL�EGL��HE�OSQQX�HIV�,SJJQERR�EYGL1MX�WIMRIV�>IRWSVWGLIVI�

(MI�7GLIVI�OPMVVX�MR�WIMRIV�,ERH�)W�V�GOX�HIV�[MPHI�+IWIPPI(MV�EYJ�HIR�0IMF���IV�WGLRIMHIX�MRW�*PIMWGL��)W�[EV�HMI�FIWXI�7XIPPI�ª

'%498�<<:--

;EW�WMGL�MR�NIRIV�;YRHIVREGLX(IW�[IMXIVR�^YKIXVEKIR�)V^mLP�MGL�IYGL�IMR�ERHIVQEP�-R�[EVQIR�7SQQIVXEKIR�

(EW�EPXI�+IWGLPIGLX�HIV�,IYGLIPIM:IVWGL[MRHIX��+SXX�WIM�(ERO��LIYX�)W�WMROX�EPPQmLPMGL�MRW�+VEF��IW�WXMVFX%R�WIMRIV�0�KIROVEROLIMX�

)W�[mGLWX�LIVER�IMR�RIYIW�+IWGLPIGLX�+ER^�SLRI�7GLQMROI�YRH�7�RHIR�1MX�JVIMIR�+IHEROIR��QMX�JVIMIV�0YWX��(IQ�[IVHI�MGL�EPPIW�ZIVO�RHIR�

7GLSR�ORSWTIX�HMI�.YKIRH��[IPGLI�ZIVWXILX(IW�(MGLXIVW�7XSP^�YRH�+�XI�9RH�WMGL�ER�WIMRIQ�,IV^IR�[mVQX�%R�WIMRIQ�7SRRIRKIQ�XI�

1IMR�,IV^�MWX�PMIFIRH�[MI�HEW�0MGLX�9RH�VIMR�YRH�OIYWGL�[MI�HEW�*IYIV�(MI�IHIPWXIR�+VE^MIR�LEFIR�KIWXMQQX(MI�7EMXIR�QIMRIV�0IMIV�

)W�MWX�HMIWIPFI�0IMIV��HMI�IMRWX1IMR�:EXIV�PMI��IVX}RIR�(IV�WIPMKI�,IVV�%VMWXSTLERIW�(IV�0MIFPMRK�HIV�/EQ}RIR�

)W�MWX�HMI�0IMIV��[SVEYJ�IV�IMRWX(IR�4EMWXIXIVSW�FIWYRKIR�(IV�YQ�HMI�&EWMPIME�KIJVIMX�1MX�MLV�WMGL�IQTSVKIWGL[YRKIR�

-Q�PIX̂ XIR�/ETMXIP�LEF�MGL�ZIVWYGLX�)MR�FM�GLIR�REGL^YELQIR(IR�7GLPY��HIV�«:}KIPª��HMI�WMRH�KI[M�(EW�FIWXI�ZSR�:EXIVW�(VEQIR�

(MI�«*V}WGLIª�WMRH�EYGL�ZSVXVIJJPMGL��1ER�KMFX-R�HIYXWGLIV�iFIVWIX^YRK7MI�NIX^X�EYJ�HIV�&�LRI�ZSR�&IVPMR�>Y�O}RMKPMGLIV�)VKIX^YRK�

(IV�/}RMK�PMIFX�HEW�7X�GO��(EW�^IYKX:SR�KYXIQ�ERXMOIR�+IWGLQEGOI�(IR�%PXIR�EQ�WMIVXI�[IMX�QILV1SHIVRIW�*VSWGLKIUYEGOI�

(IV�/}RMK�PMIFX�HEW�7X�GO��.IHSGL;mV�RSGL�HIV�%YXSV�EQ�0IFIR�-GL�VMIXI�MLQ�RMGLX��WMGL�MR�4IVWSR2EGL�4VIY�IR�^Y�FIKIFIR�

(IQ�[MVOPMGLIR�%VMWXSTLERIW�(IQ�KMRKI�IW�WGLPIGLX��HIQ�%VQIR�;MV�[�VHIR�MLR�FEPH�FIKPIMXIX�WILR

1MX�'L}VIR�ZSR�+IRHEVQIR�

(IV�4}FIP�FIOmQ�HMI�)VPEYFRMW�FEPH�>Y�WGLMQTJIR�WXEXX�^Y�[IHIPR�(MI�4SPM^IM�IVLMIPXI�&IJILP�>Y�JELRHIR�EYJ�HIR�)HIPR�

3�/}RMK��-GL�QIMRI�IW�KYX�QMX�HMV�9RH�[MPP�IMRIR�6EX�HMV�KIFIR�(MI�XSXIR�(MGLXIV��ZIVILVI�WMI�RYV�(SGL�WGLSRI��HMI�HE�PIFIR�

&IPIMH�KI�PIFIRHMKI�(MGLXIV�RMGLX�7MI�LEFIR�*PEQQIR�YRH�;EJJIR�(MI�JYVGLXFEVIV�WMRH�EPW�.SZMW�&PMX^�(IR�NE�HIV�4SIX�IVWGLEJJIR�

&IPIMH�KI�HMI�+}XXIV��HMI�EPXIR�YRH�RIY�R�(IW�KER^IR�3P]QTW�+IPMGLXIV�9RH�HIR�L}GLWXIR�.ILSZE�SFIRHVIMR��&IPIMH�KI�RYV�RMGLX�HIR�(MGLXIV�

(MI�+}XXIV�FIWXVEJIR�JVIMPMGL�WILV�LEVX(IW�1IRWGLIR�1MWWIXEXIR�(EW�,}PPIRJIYIV�MWX�^MIQPMGL�LIM��(SVX�QY��QER�WGLQSVIR�YRH�FVEXIR��

(SGL�,IMPMKI�KMFX�IW��HMI�EYW�HIV�+PYX0SWFIXIR�HIR�7�RHIV��HYVGL�7TIRHIR%R�/MVGLIR�YRH�7IIPIRQIWWIR�[MVH)V[SVFIR�IMR�LSLIW�:IV[IRHIR�

9RH�EQ�)RHI�HIV�8EKI�OSQQX�'LVMWXYW�LIVEF9RH�FVMGLX�HMI�4JSVXIR�HIV�,}PPI�9RH�LmPX�IV�EYGL�IMR�WXVIRKIW�+IVMGLX�)RXWGLP�TJIR�[MVH�QERGLIV�+IWIPPI�

(SGL�KMFX�IW�,}PPIR��EYW�HIVIR�,EJX9RQ}KPMGL�NIHI�&IJVIMYRK�,MIV�LMPJX�OIMR�&IXIR��SLRQmGLXMK�MWX�LMIV(IW�;IPXIVP}WIVW�:IV^IMLYRK�

/IRRWX�HY�HMI�,}PPI�HIW�(ERXI�RMGLX�(MI�WGLVIGOPMGLIR�8IV^IXXIR#;IR�HE�HIV�(MGLXIV�LMRIMRKIWTIVVX�(IR�OERR�OIMR�+SXX�QILV�VIXXIR��

/IMR�+SXX��OIMR�,IMPERH�IVP}WX�MLR�NI%YW�HMIWIR�WMRKIRHIR�*PEQQIR�

2MQQ�HMGL�MR�EGLX��HE��[MV�HMGL�RMGLX>Y�WSPGLIV�,}PPI�ZIVHEQQIR�