67
Immune Modulation for Prevention Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

  • View
    218

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Immune Modulation for Prevention of Immune Modulation for Prevention of

Type 1 DiabetesType 1 Diabetes

Peter A. Gottlieb, MDBarbara Davis Center

University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Page 2: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Main PointsMain Points

• Type 1 diabetes is an autoimmune disease• It is a predictable disease with different

phases• Approaches to prevention and cure are

possible.• New insulins, medications and devices will

improve therapy in the coming decade.

Page 3: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

NKNK

BB

Th1Th1

MOMO

Tc1Tc1

TargetTarget

Effector CellsEffector CellsCD4CD25CD4CD25

Th2Th2

NKTNKT

Th3Th3

Tr1Tr1

Regulatory CellsRegulatory Cells

Cellular Mechanics of Autoimmune Type 1 DiabetesCellular Mechanics of Autoimmune Type 1 Diabetes

Page 4: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

0

20

40

60

80

100

0 2.5 5 7.5 10 12.5 15

3 Abs

2 Abs

1 Ab

Progression to Diabetes vs Number of AutoantibodiesProgression to Diabetes vs Number of Autoantibodies(GAD, ICA512, Insulin)(GAD, ICA512, Insulin)Percent not Diabetic

Years of Follow-up

3 Ab n = 41 17 8 1 2 Abs n = 44 27 15 4 2 11 Abs n = 93 23 14 10 6 4

Verge et al, Diabetes 45:926-933, 1996 BDC

Page 5: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

The Major Histocompatibility Complex

Human

Mouse

DP DQ DR B C A

K I-A I-E D L

Chromosome 6

Chromosome 17

Class II Class III Class I

Class II Class III Class IClass I

Complement Proteins

Cytokines Class I-like genesand pseduogenes

Antigen Processing Genes

Page 6: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Type 1a Diabetes: An Autoimmune Type 1a Diabetes: An Autoimmune DisorderDisorder

• Autoantibodies to islet proteins: insulin, Autoantibodies to islet proteins: insulin, GAD 65, IA-2 (ICA512)GAD 65, IA-2 (ICA512)

• T cell responses to islet proteinsT cell responses to islet proteins• HLA associationHLA association• Immunosuppressive drugs can ameliorate Immunosuppressive drugs can ameliorate

the disorder – ex. Cyclosporinethe disorder – ex. Cyclosporine• Recurrence of autoimmunity in pancreas Recurrence of autoimmunity in pancreas

transplants between monozygotic twinstransplants between monozygotic twins

Page 7: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Prevention of Type 1 diabetesPrevention of Type 1 diabetes

Primary:Primary: 1a1autoimmunityutoimmunity 1b1b-cell loss-cell loss

1c1clinical diabeteslinical diabetes

Geneticsusceptibility

Autoimmunity

No autoimmunity

Clinicaldiabetes

Complications

Clinicalremission

1c

Secondary1a

1b -cell loss

Tertiary

?

Page 8: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Secondary PreventionSecondary Prevention

Goal - induction of diabetes remission and preservation of C-peptide

non-antigen-specific interventions

antigen specific interventions

Page 9: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

EDIC: Long Term Benefit of EDIC: Long Term Benefit of Intensive TreatmentIntensive Treatment

-The Diabetes Control and Complications Trial/Epidemiology of Diabetes Interventions and Complications Research Group. N Engl J Med 2000;342:381-9.

Page 10: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

EDIC: Long Term Benefit of EDIC: Long Term Benefit of Intensive TreatmentIntensive Treatment

-The Diabetes Control and Complications Trial/Epidemiology of Diabetes Interventions and Complications Research Group. N Engl J Med 2000;342:381-9.

Page 11: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

-Cell Function and Complications in the-Cell Function and Complications in theDiabetes Control and Complications TrialDiabetes Control and Complications Trial

- Steffes MW, et al. Diabetes Care 26:832–836, 2003

Page 12: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

-Cell Function and Hypoglycemia in the-Cell Function and Hypoglycemia in theDiabetes Control and Complications TrialDiabetes Control and Complications Trial

- Steffes MW, et al. Diabetes Care 26:832–836, 2003

Page 13: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Past Trials in New Onset Type 1 DMPast Trials in New Onset Type 1 DM

• Cyclosporine A - no lasting effect• Imuran - no lasting effect• Corticosteroids - no lasting effect• Plasmapheresis- no lasting effect• BCG (Denver) - no effect• Nicotinamide (DENIS) - no effect (At risk)

• Gluten-free diet (Italy) - no effect• Q fever vaccine s.c. - no effect• Nicotinamide and Vitamin E - no effect

Page 14: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Metabolic Effects of AZA and Prednisone Metabolic Effects of AZA and Prednisone at 1 year in New Onset T1DMat 1 year in New Onset T1DM

Treated Control Significance

HbA1c 7.2 (20) 8.6 (20) NS

Total Ins. 0.42+0.27 0.66+0.24 P<0.001

Ins. Indep. 15% 0% NS

C-peptide 0.52nmol/L

0.26nmol/L

P<0.03

Responder (HbA1c<6.8)

50% 15% NS

- Silverstein, et al. NEJM 1988, 319:599-604- Silverstein, et al. NEJM 1988, 319:599-604

Page 15: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Accelerated Loss of C-Peptide Accelerated Loss of C-Peptide with BCG Vaccination at Onsetwith BCG Vaccination at Onset

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

00.20.40.60.8

11.21.4

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

00.20.40.60.8

11.21.4

0 5 10 15 20 25 300

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

< 12

>=12

AgeFasting C-Peptide Stimulated C-Peptide

Adapted from Allen, et al, Diabetes Care 1999, 22:1703-07

Page 16: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Ongoing and Proposed Non-antigen Specific Ongoing and Proposed Non-antigen Specific Immunotherapy Trials in New Onset Type 1 DMImmunotherapy Trials in New Onset Type 1 DM

• MMF and DZB - Peter Gottlieb, TrialNet

• Multidose anti-CD3 hOKT3 - Kevan Herold, NY; Lucienne Chatenoud, France

• HSP 65 p277 s.c. - (Peptor) – Jerry Palmer, Seattle

• Multi-dose DZB - Henry Rodriguez, Indiana

• Exanitide and Rapamycin – David Harlan, NIH

• Oral hIFN-alpha - Staley Brod, Texas

• Anti-CD20 – Mark Peskovitz, Indiana, TrialNet

• ATG (Sandostat) – Steve Gitelman, UCSF, ITN, TrialNet

• Rapamycin and IL-2, Alex Rabinovitch, Canada

• Fish oil - A-G Ziegler, Germany

• Diazoxide - E Bjork+A Karlsson,

Sweden

• Lisofylline i.v. - S Kirk, Virginia

• Vitamin E+nicotinamide - P Pozzilli,

Italy

Page 17: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Preservation of Pancreatic Production Preservation of Pancreatic Production of Insulin (POPPI) Participating of Insulin (POPPI) Participating

CentersCenters

• The Barbara Davis Center

• Indiana University• Stanford University• University of Florida• University of

Minnesota• Virginia Mason

(Washington)

• Joslin Diabetes Center• Columbia University• UCSF• Children’s Hospital of

Los Angeles• Toronto, Canada• Milan, Italy and

Munich, Germany

New CentersExisting Centers

Page 18: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Preservation of Pancreatic Production of Preservation of Pancreatic Production of Insulin (POPPI) studyInsulin (POPPI) study

(Mycophenolate Mofetil and Zenapax)(Mycophenolate Mofetil and Zenapax)• MMF protects BB rats from developing DM and is effective in islet

allograft transplantation in mice• MMF effective in a number of autoimmune conditions and in

transplantation• DZB effective as part of Edmonton protocol and in other

transplantation regimens• Anti-IL2R Ab protects BB rat, but not NOD islet grafts• IL2-Receptor + Cells increased at diagnosis of DM• IL-2R+, CD4hi population harbors autoreactive T cells (mouse and

man)• Relative known toxicities of drugs are low

Page 19: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Mycophenolate Mofetil (MMF)Mycophenolate Mofetil (MMF)

• Inhibits inosine monophosphate dehydrogenase (IMPDH)

• Inhibits de novo pathway of guanosine nucleotide synthesis

– T and B cells need de novo pathway (other cell types use salvage pathway)

Page 20: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

APCAPC

T cellT cell

MHC

TCR

IL-2

• Blocking of activated T and B cell proliferation and antibody formation

• Does not block IL-1, IL-2 production

MMF: Mode of action

Greenbaum, CBenaroya Research InstituteSeattle, WA

Page 21: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

MMF (CellCept)MMF (CellCept)

• An immunosuppressive medication that is most commonly used to prevent transplant rejection.

• Capsules, taken by mouth, twice a day for two years.

• Most common side effects: Diarrhea, vomiting, nausea, decreased white blood cells.

Page 22: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

MMF ToxicitiesMMF Toxicities

• LeukopeniaLeukopenia

• Gastrointestinal Gastrointestinal

• Increased rate of viral infectionsIncreased rate of viral infections

• Lymphoproliferative disorder? No Lymphoproliferative disorder? No increase in multidrug regimens. No increase in multidrug regimens. No increase in single drug use increase in single drug use (Psoriasis). (Psoriasis).

• Cancer? (Psoriasis data – No).Cancer? (Psoriasis data – No).

Page 23: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Daclizumab (Zenapax)Daclizumab (Zenapax)

Humanized IgG monoclonal antibody that binds to the alpha subunit (CD25, p55alpha, Tac) of IL-2 receptor on the surface of activated lymphocytes

Greenbaum, CBenaroya Research InstituteSeattle, WA

Page 24: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Activated T cell

α γ

IL-2

ß

Activated T cell

α γ

IL-2

ß

DZB

DZB: Mode of action

Inhibit IL-2 mediated activation of lymphocytes

Greenbaum, C;Benaroya Research Institute; Seattle, WA

Page 25: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

DACLIZUMAB (DZB)DACLIZUMAB (DZB)

• An immunosuppressive medication, commonly used in patients receiving kidney transplants.

• IV infusion, twice during the study (Baseline and Week 2).

• Most common side effects: Diarrhea, vomiting, nausea, decreased white blood cells.

Page 26: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

No increase in most frequently reported AEs in No increase in most frequently reported AEs in Zenapax-treated patients*Zenapax-treated patients*

% of Patients with Adverse Event% of Patients with Adverse Event

Safety ResultsSafety Results

00 2020 4040 6060 8080 100100

TremorTremor

HeadacheHeadache

Pain PosttraumaticPain Posttraumatic

Wound HealingWound Healing

InsomniaInsomnia

Musculoskeletal PainMusculoskeletal Pain

* Pooled data.* Pooled data.

PlaceboPlacebo (n=293) (n=293)

ZenapaxZenapax (n=336) (n=336)

Page 27: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

POPPI StudyPOPPI Study• 3 arm study: MMF alone, MMF and 2 doses of DZB 3 arm study: MMF alone, MMF and 2 doses of DZB

and placeboand placebo• 60 subjects per arm, 180 total, through TrialNet 60 subjects per arm, 180 total, through TrialNet

centers (6 initially)centers (6 initially)• Type 1 diabetes (autoantibodies) within 12 weeks Type 1 diabetes (autoantibodies) within 12 weeks

of diagnosisof diagnosis• Ages 12-35, without significant other diseaseAges 12-35, without significant other disease• Outcomes: HbA1c, C-peptide, hypoglycemia, T Outcomes: HbA1c, C-peptide, hypoglycemia, T

cell assayscell assays• Start Date: July 27, 2005. 23 patients enrolled.Start Date: July 27, 2005. 23 patients enrolled.

Page 28: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Potential Benefits of the StudyPotential Benefits of the Study

• Patient will be the most important part of a research team that is attempting to learn more about type 1 diabetes.

• Diabetes may be easier to manage.

• Less chance for long-term complications of diabetes.

Page 29: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Anti-CD3 Monoclonal Antibody in Anti-CD3 Monoclonal Antibody in New-Onset Type 1 Diabetes MellitusNew-Onset Type 1 Diabetes Mellitus

Kevan C. Herold, MD; William Hagopian, MD, PhD;

Julie A. Auger, BA; Ena Poumian-Ruiz, BS;

Lesley Taylor, BA, David Donaldson, MD;

Stephen E. Gitelman, MD, David M. Harlan, MD;

Danlin Xu, PhD; Robert A. Zivin, PhD;

& Jeffrey A. Bluestone, PhD

Herold K. et al., N Engl J Med 2002; 346:1692-8.

Page 30: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

hOKT3hOKT31(Ala-Ala)1(Ala-Ala)

Ala-A

la

Binds to CD3hOKT3hOKT31(Ala-Ala) is a monoclonal1(Ala-Ala) is a monoclonalantibody that binds to the CD3antibody that binds to the CD3(T cell receptor) on human T cells. (T cell receptor) on human T cells. The drug is a “humanized” antibodyThe drug is a “humanized” antibodywith a mutation in the Fc chain towith a mutation in the Fc chain toprevent binding to the Fc receptor.prevent binding to the Fc receptor.Binding to the Fc receptor and Binding to the Fc receptor and crosslinking of the CD3 moleculecrosslinking of the CD3 moleculeis thought to activate T cells, is thought to activate T cells, cause release of cytokines, and cause release of cytokines, and account for the toxicity of OKT3.account for the toxicity of OKT3.

Page 31: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Changes from Study Entry to 12 Months in the Total C-Peptide Response to Mixed-Meal Tolerance Testing

Herold K. et al., N Engl J Med 2002; 346:1692-8.

To

tal

Are

a u

nd

er t

he

C-P

epti

de

Res

po

nse

Cu

rve

(nm

ol/

l/4

hr)

Monoclonal-Antibody Group

To

tal

Are

a u

nd

er t

he

C-P

epti

de

Res

po

nse

Cu

rve

(nm

ol/

l/4

hr)

Control Group

Page 32: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

A single course of h(Ala-Ala) at dx of diabetes improves insulin secretion for over 2

years

Month

0 6 12 18 24

AU

C (

pm

ol/m

l/2

40

min

)

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

DrugControl ** ** **

(p<0.0001(p<0.0001**p<0.02)**p<0.02)

Page 33: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Hemoglobin A1c levels in Drug treated and Control Subjects

P<0.0001 by RPANOVAP<0.0001 by RPANOVA

4.5

5.5

6.5

7.5

8.5

9.5

0 6 12 18 24

Month

He

mo

glo

bin

A1

c (

%)

Drug treated

Control

****

** p<0.01, * p<0.1** p<0.01, * p<0.1

**

Page 34: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Before treatment 1 wk after treatment

Induction of IL-10+CD4+ cells in vivo following Treatment with hOKT3g1(Ala-Ala)

IL-10+, IFN-g-CD45RO+CTLA-4-Some TGF-b+CCR4+

Page 35: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

CFSE

hOKT3g1(Ala-Ala) induces proliferation of CD8+T cells in vitro

CD4CD8

PHA

hOKT3(Ala-Ala)5 ug/ml

Page 36: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

CD25

CD25

CD3 engagementand signaling

Postulated Induction of CD8+ regulatory T cells by hOKT3γ1(Ala-Ala)

CD8

CD8 CD8

CD8

CD8

CD8

CD4

CD8+ T cell proliferation

Inhibition of antigen-reactiveCD4+ cells

Page 37: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Antigen Specific TherapyAntigen Specific Therapy

• Magic bullet Approach

• Targets autoreactive cells

• Generates protective cells

• Spares rest of immune system

• Minimal Toxicity

• Timing may be critical to efficacy

Page 38: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

InsulinInsulin• Beta Cell Specific

• Predominant T-cell reactivity islets NOD

• Insulin expressed lymphoid tissue by dendritic and macrophage-like cells

• Thymic messenger RNA for insulin related to “protective” insulin allele

• Proinsulin expression in thymus prevents NOD diabetes

Page 39: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Effect of Insulin Injections on Effect of Insulin Injections on Diabetes & InsulitisDiabetes & Insulitis

0

10

2030

40

50

60

7080

90

100

Placebo Insulin

% D

iab

etes

Female NOD MiceFemale NOD Mice

Atkinson, Diabetes 1991Atkinson, Diabetes 1991

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

Placebo Insulin

Insu

liti

s S

core

Page 40: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Prevention of Diabetes with B:9-23 Prevention of Diabetes with B:9-23 Peptide “Immunization” Peptide “Immunization”

0 10 20 30 40 50 60

0

20

40

60

80

100

Age in Weeks

Pe

rce

nt

No

t D

iab

eti

c

Tetanus control

B:9-23 peptide

D.Daniel ,D.Wegmann . PNAS,1996D.Daniel ,D.Wegmann . PNAS,1996

Page 41: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Altered Peptide LigandAPCAPC

T cellT cell

MH

CT

CR

IFNγ

APCAPC

T cellT cell

MH

CT

CR

IL-4

Greenbaum, C;Benaroya Research Institute; Seattle, WA

Page 42: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

NBI 6024-003 New Onset TrialNBI 6024-003 New Onset TrialAltered Peptide Ligand B:9-23Altered Peptide Ligand B:9-23

• Double-blind Phase I/II trial to test safety and Double-blind Phase I/II trial to test safety and efficacy of an altered insulin peptide ligand efficacy of an altered insulin peptide ligand

• Forty Patients (12-40) were randomized to receive 5 Forty Patients (12-40) were randomized to receive 5 doses of NBI-6024 (0.1mg, 1.0 mg, or 5.0mg) or doses of NBI-6024 (0.1mg, 1.0 mg, or 5.0mg) or placebo biweekly and monthly. placebo biweekly and monthly.

• No side effects. No obvious benefit to subjects, but No side effects. No obvious benefit to subjects, but study was primarily a safety study. study was primarily a safety study.

• Evidence of immunologic effect on T cells was Evidence of immunologic effect on T cells was observed in a dose dependent fashion in adolescent observed in a dose dependent fashion in adolescent groups particularly.groups particularly.

Page 43: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

ELISPOT analysis of Th1 and Th2 Responses to ELISPOT analysis of Th1 and Th2 Responses to Insulin B(9-23)Insulin B(9-23) ((▲);); NBI-6024 (NBI-6024 () or Medium only () or Medium only ( ); ); 0.1 mg Adolescent0.1 mg Adolescent Tx’ed Patients from NBI- Tx’ed Patients from NBI-

6024-00036024-0003

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

Weeks After Initiation

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

Weeks After Initiation

IFN-

IL-5

Patient #O

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

Weeks After Initiation

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

500

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

Weeks After Initiation

Patient #PIFN-

IL-5

IFNIFN IFNIFN

IL-5IL-5IL-5IL-5

Page 44: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Recent and Ongoing Antigen-specific Recent and Ongoing Antigen-specific Immunotherapy Trials in T1DMImmunotherapy Trials in T1DM

• Joslin Parenteral Insulin: “Delay”• Schwabing Parenteral Insulin: “Delay”• DPT-1 Parenteral: No Effect• DIPP (intranasal): ?• Melbourne (intranasal): ?• DPT-1 Oral Insulin: Possible for subgroup• Italy/France Oral Insulin: No Effect• Maclaren Oral Insulin: ?• NBI 6024-0003 - Neurocrine, BDC No effect• B chain – Orban, Joslin ?• hGAD s.c. in alum (Diamyd) 20ug dose only• Peptor Heat Shock Protein ?

Pre

diab

ete

Pre

diab

ete

ssN

ew O

nset

New

Ons

et

Page 45: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

PREVENTIONPREVENTION

Page 46: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Primary PreventionPrimary Prevention

autoantibodies or diabetes as the endpoint

avoidance of environmental agents ?

induction of autoantigen tolerance ?

Rewers-BDC

Page 47: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Natural History of Type 1 DiabetesNatural History of Type 1 Diabetes

CELLULAR (T CELL) AUTOIMMUNITYCELLULAR (T CELL) AUTOIMMUNITY

LOSS OF FIRST PHASE LOSS OF FIRST PHASE INSULIN RESPONSEINSULIN RESPONSE

(IVGTT)(IVGTT)

GLUCOSE INTOLERANCEGLUCOSE INTOLERANCE(OGTT)(OGTT)

HUMORAL AUTOANTIBODIESHUMORAL AUTOANTIBODIES(ICA, IAA, Anti-GAD(ICA, IAA, Anti-GAD6565, IA, IA22Ab, etc.) Ab, etc.)

PUTATIVEPUTATIVEENVIRONMENTALENVIRONMENTAL

TRIGGERTRIGGER

CLINICALCLINICALONSETONSET

TIMETIME

BE

TA

CE

LL

MA

SS

BE

TA

CE

LL

MA

SS

DIABETES

“PRE”-DIABETES

GENETICPREDISPOSITION

INSULITISBETA CELL INJURY

Page 48: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Primary Prevention TrialsPrimary Prevention Trials• DPT-1 - Parenteral - Ineffective

- Oral Insulin – May be effective in subgroup

• DIPP - Nasal Insulin• INIT - IntraNasal Insulin Trial

• ENDIT - Nicotinamide - Ineffective

• TRIGR - Casein Hydrolysate (Cow’s Milk Elimination)

• NIP - Nutritional Intervention to Prevent T1DM

Page 49: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

DPT-1 Parenteral Study – Time to DiabetesDPT-1 Parenteral Study – Time to DiabetesBy TreatmentBy Treatment

1.01.0

0.90.9

0.80.8

0.70.7

0.60.6

0.50.5

0.40.4

0.30.3

0.20.2

0.10.1

0.00.0

169169170170

144144131131

9696101101

69696969

39394040

13131414 11

Number at RiskNumber at Risk

Su

rviv

al D

istr

ibu

tio

n F

un

ctio

nS

urv

ival

Dis

trib

uti

on

Fu

nct

ion

P- Value= 0.796P- Value= 0.796(Log Rank Test)(Log Rank Test)

InterventionInterventionObservationObservation

00 11 22 33 44 55 66 77

Years FollowedYears Followed

STRATA:STRATA: InterventionIntervention ObservationObservation

ControlControl

TreatedTreated

New Engl J Med 2002; 346:1679

Page 50: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

ENDIT: Kaplan-Meier failure curveENDIT: Kaplan-Meier failure curve

- European Nicotinamide Diabetes Intervention Trial (ENDIT) Group Lancet 2004; 363: 925–31

Page 51: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Rationale for Oral InsulinRationale for Oral Insulin

TH1Cell

s

IFN-, IL-2

DestructiveCytokines

TH2Cells

IL-4, IL-5, IL-10 TGF-

TH3Cells

ProtectiveCytokines

Page 52: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Oral Antigen ProtocolOral Antigen Protocol

• Initial results appeared to suggest no effect of oral insulinInitial results appeared to suggest no effect of oral insulin• Secondary analysis suggests that for original cohort Secondary analysis suggests that for original cohort

there is delay in onset compared to placebo treated there is delay in onset compared to placebo treated patiens.patiens.

• A new trial to confirm these observations is being A new trial to confirm these observations is being planned by TrialNetplanned by TrialNet

• Additional arms including intranasal insulin are being Additional arms including intranasal insulin are being consideredconsidered

Page 53: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Nutritional Intervention to Prevent Type 1 Diabetes (NIP – Diabetes)

Plan: Use of an omega 3 fatty acid (Docosahexanoic acid or DHA) to prevent the initial autoimmune process.

DHA supplementation will begin in:

• the last trimester of pregnancy

• the first 6 months after birth

It will be continued in medium or high risk infants for 3 years.

Page 54: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Dietary Intake – Western DietsDietary Intake – Western Diets

The Ratio of n-6 to n-3 Fatty Acids in our diet:

1800’s = 1 or 2 (n-6) to 1 (n-3)

Present = 20 or 30 (n-6) to 1 (n-3)

High n-3: anti-inflammatory anti-thrombotic hypolipidemic vasodilatory

(High n-6 has the opposite effect)(Am J. Clin Nutr. 70, 560-569, 1999)

Page 55: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

III) Mechanisms of Action of Omega 3 Fatty Acids

Decrease AA in cell membranes alters PGE 1 and 2 production (inflammatory prostaglandins)

Decrease pro-inflammatory cytokines TNF, IL-1 and IL6 ( efficacy of IL4 and IL10)

Decrease ICAM-1 on monocyte surfaces in humans fed 3g fish oil/dx 21 days ( chronic inflammation)

DHA and /or vit D may have important immune modulating effects in babies at risk for developing

T1DM

Page 56: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Mechanistic Studies

Biomarker: Omega-3 FA will be measured

Reduction of inflammation

• CRP (with DHA) (Am J Cardiol 88:1139,2001)

• inflammatory PGs: PGE-1 and 2

• Inflammatory cytokines: IL-1 and IL-6

Islet cell antibodies

Page 57: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO
Page 58: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

TrialNet Sites

Page 59: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

TrialNet International SitesTrialNet International Sites

• AustraliaAustralia

• United KingdomUnited Kingdom

• FinlandFinland

• Italy & GermanyItaly & Germany

Page 60: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

NIDDK NIAID NICHD NCRR

ADA JDRF

SponsorsSponsors

Page 61: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Type 1 Diabetes TrialNet Protocol Development Procedure

Stage 1: Concept Proposal

Stage 2: Draft Protocol

Stage 3: Full Protocol

Prioritization & Implementation 

Page 62: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Types of Trials

• Phase 1 – Safety and/or Proof of Concept

• Phase 2 – New-Onset Diabetes

• Phase 2 – Prevention of Diabetes

• Natural History & Epidemiology

Page 63: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

TrialNet Interventions• New-Onset Diabetes

– Anti-CD3 (via ITN collaboration)– Mycophenolate Mofetil +/- Anti-CD25– Anti-CD20– IL-2 plus Sirolimus – Phase 1 Safety Study

• Relatives At Risk– Natural History– Oral Insulin– Beta Cell Preservation (exenatide) – pilot study

• Newborns– Nutritional : Omega-3-Fatty Acids

Page 64: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Other TrialNet Studies

• Comparison of Mixed Meal Tolerance Test and Glucagon Stimulation Test for Stimulation of C-Peptide

• Reproducibility and Validation of T-Cell Assays for Monitoring of Diabetes Intervention Trials

• Collaboration with Type 1 Diabetes Genetics Consortium (T1DGC)

Page 65: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

Key Elements of Successful Clinical Trials

• Prospective

• Randomized

• Controlled

• Statistical power

• Objective endpoints

• Risk/benefit to individual

• Cost benefit to society

Page 66: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

What We Need

• Proven biomarkers for disease progression or improvement

• Better mechanistic assays

• Better rationale for moving potential interventions to RCTs

• The courage to study interventions with potential adverse side effects

Page 67: Immune Modulation for Prevention of Type 1 Diabetes Peter A. Gottlieb, MD Barbara Davis Center University of Colorado Health Sciences Center Denver, CO

1-800-HALT-DM1 (1-800 – 425-8361)www.diabetestrialnet.org