Human Rights Project for BHRC

8/18/2019 Human Rights Project for BHRC

1/32

PROJECT ON

HUMAN RIGHTS

ALISHA ANAND.

1ST YEAR (2013-2018)

C.N.L.U. PATNA.

1


2/32

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

I am highly la!" !# $#%& #' my %#*! !#i* +HU,AN RIHTS /'"% !h g/i"a'*

# ,%. N%a /ma% %ma L.D.C. 4iha% H/ma' Righ!5 C#mmi55i#' Pa!'a. I am %y

g%a!/l !# him #% hi5 %#% g/i"a'*. Al5# I $#/l" li& !# !ha'& ,%. A'a'"6a%"ha'

Si'ha IAS S*%!a%y(4HRC) #% %#i"i'g /5 */%%'! ali*a!i#' # !h %#g%amm5 %/'

7y 4.H.R.C a'" "i*!a!i'g /5 "i%'! 5*!i#' # Th P%#!*!i#' # H/ma' Righ!5 A*!.

I 5i'*%ly a*&'#$l"g !h hl # H#'7l 9/5!i* S.N.9ha #%m% Chai%%5#'

H#'7l 9/5!i* Ra'"%a P%a5a" #%m% ,m7% (4HRC) ,%. Nlma'i IPS A*!i'g

*hai%%5#' (4HRC) D%. Ni%mal /ma% A:a". I. (4HRC) $h# 7y %'"%" m hl i'

l#*a!i'g a%#%ia! %5#/%*5 !# *#ll*! ma!%ial5 a'" ma&i'g m a*;/ai'!" !# !him#%!a'* # H/ma' %igh!5 C#mmi55i#' i' !h 7!!%m'! # 5#*i!y. I $#/l" li& !#

'ligh!' my %a"%5 $i!h my #%!5 a'" /5! h# !ha! I ha !%i" my 75! #% 7%i'gi'g

l/mi'#5i!y !# !hi5 !#i*.

I $#/l" ' li& !# !ha'& my %i'"5 #% *#ll*!i'g $ "a!a #% m $hi*h $% %y

/5/l i' *#ml!i'g !h %5a%*h $#%&. I am ' !ha'&/l !# my *#llg Cha'a&ya

Na!i#'al La$ U'i%5i!y Pa!'a 5*ial %ga%" !# li7%a%ia' $h# ma" %la'! #%!

%ga%"i'g !# %#i" !h %la'! ma!%ial !# my %#*! !#i*. A! la5! 7/! '#! !h la5! I

UNI6ERSITY.

INTERN AT 4HRC (3RD 9AN-23RD 9AN 201?)

2


3/32

HUMAN RIGHTS

H/ma' Righ!5 a% !h#5 %igh!5 !ha! 7l#'g5 !# %y i'"ii"/al @ma' #% $#m' 7#y #% a gi%l

i'a'! #% l"% %i*h #% ##% ma5!% #% 5%a'!-5imly 7*a/5 h #% 5h i5 a h/ma' 7i'g.H/ma' Righ!5 may 7 "i'" a5 +!h %igh! a'" %"#m5 !ha! %y %5#' #' a%!h i5 '!i!l" !#

'#y li& %igh! !# 5#*ial 5*/%i!y %igh! !# ;/ali!y %igh! !# li %igh! !# li7%!y a'" 5*/%i!y # %5#'5 !*. $i!h#/! "i5!i'*!i#' #' 7a5i5 # %a* 5


4/32

*aa7l # "i%*!ly a*!i'g #/% m#5! im#%!a'! i'!%5!5. Th "#*!%i' # h/ma' %igh!5 a5i%5 !#

%#i" !h *#'!m#%a%y allg"ly #5!-i"#l#gi*al g#-#li!i*al #%"% $i!h a *#mm#'

%am$#%& #% "!%mi'i'g !h 7a5i* *#'#mi* #li!i*al a'" 5#*ial *#'"i!i#'5 %;/i%" #% alli'"ii"/al5 !# la" a mi'imally g##" li. >hil !h %a*!i*al i*a*y # %#m#!i'g a'"

%#!*!i'g h/ma' %igh!5 i5 5ig'ii*a'!ly ai"" 7y i'"ii"/al 'a!i#'-5!a!5 lgally %*#g'i5i'g !h

"#*!%i' !h /l!ima! ali"i!y # h/ma' %igh!5 i5 *ha%a*!%i5!i*ally !h#/gh! # a5 '#! *#'"i!i#'al/#' 5/*h %*#g'i!i#'. Th/5 !h "#*!%i' # h/ma' %igh!5 i5 i"ally la*" !# %#i" i'"ii"/al5

$i!h a #$%/l ma'5 #% m#%ally a/"i!i'g !h lgi!ima*y # !h#5 *#'!m#%a%y 'a!i#'al a'"

i'!%'a!i#'al #%m5 # #li!i*al a'" *#'#mi* a/!h#%i!y $hi*h *#'%#'! !hm a'" $hi*h *laim /%i5"i*!i#' #% !hm.

Th *#'*! # H/ma' Righ!5 7ga' "/%i'g !h %'ai55a'* i' !h a%ly m#"%' %i#". Th

m%g'* # li7%ali5m a'" h/ma' %igh!5 !%a* i!5 #%igi' %#m !h E/%#a' $a%5 # %ligi#' a'"

*iil $a%5 # 1B!h *'!/%y. Th '" # h/ma' %igh!5 $a5 l! a'" i! 7*am a ma#% *#'*%' i'

18!h *'!/%y !h Ag # E'ligh!'m'!. Th *#% i"a # h/ma' %igh!5 *am i'!# hil %#m Am%i*a'

R#l/!i#' *#'*! # "m#*%a*y a%#5 $hil !h *#'*! # Li7%!y E;/ali!y a'" %a!%'i!y

*am %#m %'*h %#l/!i#'. La!% !h *#'*! # U'i%5al D*la%a!i#' # H/ma' %igh!5 *am

"/%i'g !h >#%l" >a%5. Th#/gh #5! $a% !h *#'*! # mi'i5m a'" *iil %igh!5 5!a%!"

m%gi'g i' A%i*a' a'" Am%i*a' *#/'!%i5. D/ !# !h 5/%ag # m' $#m' a'" *hil"%'

a!% !h $a%5 a '" #% a m*ha'i5m $hi*h *#/l" %#!*! !hm %#m 5#*ial *!5 # !h $a%

$a5 l!. Thi5 m*ha'i5m $a5 #/'" i' !h #%m # h/ma' %igh!5. Si'* !h' i'"ii"/al5 a'"

g%#/5 *#'!i'/ !# l m#$%" 7y !h la'g/ag # h/ma' %igh!5 # h/ma' %igh!5 a'" 7y !h

%am$#%& !ha! ha5 g%#$' / !# "l# 5#li"a%i!y i' '5/%i'g %5*! #% !h5 %igh!5. Th

h/ma' %igh!5 m#m'! i5 '#$ *#'*%'" $i!h gl#7al 5#*ial /5!i*. H/ma' %igh!5 a% i7%a'!

'#! 5!a!i* a'" i5 g%#$i'g.

4


5/32

NATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION

Th I'"ia' g#%'m'! !h%#/gh !h %#!*!i#' # !h H/ma' Righ!5 P%#!*!i#' A*!5 13

5!a7li5h" a '$ Na!i#'al H/ma' Righ!5 i'5!i!/!i#' *all" +THE NATI=NAL HU,ANRIHTS C=,,ISSI=N I' =*!#7% 13. Th Na!i#'al H/ma' Righ!5 C#mmi55i#' (NHRC)

# I'"ia i5 a' a/!#'#m#/5 /7li* 7#"y *#'5!i!/!" #' 12 =*!#7% 13 /'"% !h P%#!*!i#' #

H/ma' Righ!5 =%"i'a'* # 28 S!m7% 13.I! $a5 gi' a 5!a!/!#%y 7a5i5 7y !h P%#!*!i#'

# H/ma' Righ!5 A*! 13 (TPHRA). Th NHRC i5 !h 'a!i#'al h/ma' %igh!5 i'5!i!/!i#'

%5#'5i7l #% !h %#!*!i#' a'" %#m#!i#' # h/ma' %igh!5 "i'" 7y !h A*! a5 F%igh!5

%la!i'g !# li li7%!y ;/ali!y a'" "ig'i!y # !h i'"ii"/al g/a%a'!" 7y !h C#'5!i!/!i#' #%

m7#"i" i' !h I'!%'a!i#'al C#'a'!5F. A**#%"i'g !# 5*!i#' 2(1)(") H/ma' Righ!5 ma'

!h Righ! %la!i'g !# Li Li7%!y E;/ali!y a'" Dig'i!y # i'"ii"/al.. Th a*! 5ay5 !ha! !h

*#mmi55i#' *a' /!ili: !h 5%i*5 # a'y #i*% #% i'5!iga!i'g ag'*y # !h *'!%al #% 5!a!

g#%'m'!. I! ha5 a 5&l!#' ma*hi'%y # i!5 #$' #% i'5!iga!i#'. Th 5!a! g#%'m'! 5hall

ha !# 5!a7li5h 5!a! h/ma' %igh!5 *#mmi55i#'.

A**#%"i'g !# S*!i#' 12 !h /'*!i#'5 # Na!i#'al H/ma' Righ!5 C#mmi55i#' a% +!# ';/i%

i!h% 5/# m#!# #% #' a !i!i#' i'!# h/ma' %igh!5 i#la!i#' i'!%' i' *#/%! %#*"i'g5 i5i!

ail5 #% #!h% la*5 # */5!#"y %i$ h/ma' %igh!5 5ag/a%"5 a'" ma& %*#mm'"a!i#'5

%i$ a*!#%5 i'*l/"i'g !%%#%i5! i'hi7i!i'g !h '#ym'! # h/ma' %igh!5 5!/"y i'!%'a!i#'al

i'5!%/m'!5 #' h/ma' %igh!5 /'"%!a& a'" %#m#! %5a%*h 5%a" h/ma' %igh! li!%a*y a'"

a$a%'55 # 5ag/a%"5 am#'g !h ma555 '*#/%ag N=5 a'" i'5!i!/!i#'5 $#%&i'g i' !h

il" # h/ma' %igh!5 a'" %#%m a'y #!h% /'*!i#'5 !ha! h/ma' %igh!5 *#mmi55i#' may "m

'*55a%y #% %#m#!i#' # h/ma' %igh!5. Th *#mmi55i#' $#/l" 5!%i*!ly #75% !h %i'*il5# a/!#'#my a'" !%a'5a%'*y. I!5 %#%!5 a'" h/ma' %igh!5 '$5l!!%5 5& !# /lill 7#!h 7y

%#%!i'g !h a*!ii!i5 # h/ma' %igh!5 *#mmi55i#'.

Th Na!i#'al H/ma' Righ!5 C#mmi55i#' ha5 5# a% gi' %i#%i!y !# *iil li7%!i5-*/5!#"ia'

"a!h5 S!a! i#l'* agai'5! *iilia'5 !#%!/% a'" #!h% *%/l i'h/ma' #% "g%a"i'g !%a!m'!

*/5!#"ia' %a "i5aa%a'* %#m */5!#"y a!%#*i!i5 agai'5! /l'%a7l 5*!i#'5 # !h 5#*i!y

5/*h a5 $#m' *hil"%' a'" "i5a7l" (i'*l/"i'g "#$%y "a!h5 7#'"" a'" *hil" la7#/%) a'"

%#m#!i#' # h/ma' %igh!5 "/*a!i#' a'" !%ai'i'g !h i55/ # %i5#' %#%m5 a'" /'"% !%ial5.

N#'-g#%'m'! #%ga'i:a!i#' # i'!%'a!i#'al h/ma' %igh!5 li& GAm'5!y I'!%'a!i#'al a'" i!5

Am%i*a' *#/'!%a%! GA5ia $a!*h i'i!ially *#'i'" !hi% #*/5 !# !h h/ma' %igh!5 5i!/a!i#' i'I'"ia !# P/'a7 a'" 9amm/ a'" a5hmi% "/%i'g #%a!i#'5 7y !h P#li*. Th% i5 GP#l5

U'i#' #% Ciil Li7%!i5 /5" !# i'!%a*! $i!h !h Na!i#'al H/ma' Righ!5 C#mmi55i#'. Th%

a% a '/m7% # '#' g#%'m'! #%ga'i5a!i#'5 # h/ma' %igh!5 i!h% #%ga'i5" #% 5/#%!" 7y

"i%'! #li!i*al a%!i5 i' I'"ia.

5


6/32

Th NHRC *#'5i5!5 #

A Chai%%5#'

=' ,m7% $h# i5 #% ha5 7' a 9/"g # !h S/%m C#/%! # I'"ia

=' ,m7% $h# i5 #% ha5 7' !h Chi 9/5!i* # a High C#/%!

T$# ,m7%5 !# 7 a#i'!" %#m am#'g %5#'5 hai'g &'#$l"g # #% %a*!i*al


7/32

J Ri$ - 5ag/a%"5 /'"% !h C#'5!i!/!i#'Ka'y la$ - #% %#!*!i#' # h/ma' %igh!5 -

%*#mm'" ma5/%5 - *!i imlm'!a!i#'.

J Ri$ - a*!#%5 - al5# a*!5 # !%%#%i5m - i'hi7i! !h '#ym'! # h/ma' %igh!5 - %*#mm'"

a%#%ia! %m"ial ma5/%5.

J S!/"y !%a!i5Ki'!%'a!i#'al i'5!%/m'!5 #' h/ma' %igh!5 - ma& %*#mm'"a!i#'5 #% *!i

imlm'!a!i#'.

J U'"%!a& a'" %#m#! %5a%*h i' !h il" # h/ma' %igh!5.

J S%a" h/ma' %igh!5 li!%a*y - %#m#! a$a%'55 # 5ag/a%"5 aaila7l #% %#!*!i#' -

/7li*a!i#'5 m"ia 5mi'a%5 a'" #!h% ma'5.

J E'*#/%ag #%!5 # '#'-g#%'m'!al #%ga'i5a!i#'5Ki'5!i!/!i#'5 $#%&i'g i' !h il" #

h/ma' %igh!5.

J =!h% /'*!i#'5 *#'5i"%" '*55a%y #% %#m#!i#' # h/ma' %igh!5.

J R5#'5i7ili!y # #%'m'! a/!h#%i!y.

J Th C'!%al #%'m'!KS!a! #%'m'!KA/!h#%i!y ha5 !# i'"i*a! i!5 *#mm'!5 i'*l/"i'g

a*!i#' !a&' #' !h %#%!K%*#mm'"a!i#'5 # !h C#mmi55i#' $i!hi' a %i#" # #' m#'!h i'

%5*! # *#mlai'!5 agai'5! /7li* 5%a'!5 #!h% !ha' mm7%5 # !h a%m" #%*5.

J I' %5*! # *#mlai'!5 agai'5! mm7%5 # !h a%m" #%*5 !h C'!%al #%'m'! ha5 !#i'"i*a! a*!i#' !a&' #' !h %*#mm'"a!i#'5 $i!hi' !h% m#'!h5 !# !h C#mmi55i#'.

J I55/ # !h #'-ya% limi!a!i#' %i#".

J P/%#5 - '#! !# ha a'#!h% /"i*ial 7#"y - a' i'5!i!/!i#' $hi*h $ill gi 5ha%% #*/5 #' !h

allga!i#' # i#la!i#' # h/ma' %igh!5 a'" %#i" ;/i*&% %"%55al - #!h% %"%55al m*ha'i5m

- Di5!%i*! C#/%!5 !# !h S/%m C#/%! - al$ay5 aaila7l !# !h #l - C#mmi55i#'5 %#l '#!

!# %la* !h5 m*ha'i5m5.

7


8/32

BIHAR HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION

Th P%#!*!i#' # H/ma' Righ!5 A*! 13 a' A*! # !h Pa%liam'! %#i"5 #% 5!a7li5hm'!

# !h Na!i#'al H/ma' Righ!5 C#mmi55i#' a! !h 'a!i#'al ll a'" S!a! H/ma' Righ!5

C#mmi55i#'5 a! !h 5!a! ll.

I' !h S!a! # 4iha% !h S!a! H/ma' Righ!5 C#mmi55i#' $a5 5!a7li5h" #' 3%"-9a'-2000 i"

N#!ii*a!i#' N#. 20B. H#$% !h C#mmi55i#' $a5 #%mally *#'5!i!/!" i" '#!ii*a!i#' '#.

8 #' 2M..2008 $h' Sh%i 9/5!i* S.N. 9ha a #%m% Chi 9/5!i* # !h 9amm/ a5hmi%

a'" Raa5!ha' High C#/%!5 $a5 a#i'!" a5 Chai%%5#' a'" Sh%i 9/5!i* Ra'"%a P%a5a" a#%m% 9/"g # !h Pa!'a High C#/%! a'" Sh%i R.R. P%a5a" a #%m% Di%*!#% '%al # P#li*

4iha% $% a#i'!" a5 mm7%5. A!% !h 5/""' "mi5 # Sh%i R. R. P%a5a" Sh%i Nlma'i

#%m% Di%*!#% '%al # P#li* 4iha% $a5 a#i'!" a5 mm7% 4HRC #' 15! D*m7%

2011. H#'7l 9/5!i* Ra'"%a P%a5a" *#ml!" hi5 !'/% #' 2!h 9/' 2013 a'" H#'7l

Chai%%5#' 9/5!i* S. N. 9ha *#ml!" hi5 !'/% #' 3%" N#m7% 2013.

C=,P=SITI=N

Sri Neelmani, Acin! C"air#er$%n &BHRC'

,%. Nlma'i !##& #% a5 ,m7% 4iha% H/ma' Righ!5 C#mmi55i#' #' 15! D*m7% 2011

a!% 5/%a''/a!i#' %#m !h #5! # D.. P#li* 4iha%. A' I.P.S. =i*% # 1BM 7a!*h.S'

R5a%*h P/7li*a!i#'5 i' S#li" S!a! Phy5i*5 i'*l/"i'g #/% i' Am%i*a' Phy5i*al Ri$ a% !#

hi5 *%"i!. H $#%&" a5 L*!/%% i' Phy5i*5 a! 4.H.U. #% #' ya%. A %*ii'! # P#li* ,"al

#% ,%i!#%i#/5 S%i*5 a'" Di5!i'g/i5h" S%i* ,"al5 h 5%" a5 S/%i'!'"'! #

P#li* # 6ai5hali Da%7ha'ga Sa%a' 4hagal/% a'" ,a"h/7a'i "i5!%i*!5 $#%&" a5 Ra'g

D.I.. Sa%a' Shaha7a" a'" ,aga"h. H hl" all im#%!a'! a'" *%i!i*al a55ig'm'!5 i' 4iha%

i'*l/"i'g I.. Pa!'a O#' I.. =%a!i#' Rail$ay5 I..KA.D.. H";5. A.D.. 6igila'*

4/%a/ a'" ha"" 4iha% P#li* a5 D..P. %#m ,a%*h 2010 !# 315! A/g/5! 2011 7#% 7i'g

la!" !# 4.H.R.C.

A( )( Sin"a, IAS, Secrear* &BHRC'

C#m!i'g i' !h %y i%5! a!!m! i' 1B8 S%i A.6.Si'ha IAS ha5 #**/i" 5%al im#%!a'!

#5!5 i' 4iha% % 5i'* i'*l/"i'g A""i!i#'al 6igila'* C#mmi55i#'% C#mmi55i#'% #%

Da%!m'! i';/i%i5 A""i!i#'al ,m7% 4#a%" # R'/ a5 $ll a5 ,m7% (La!% A"i5#%)

8


9/32

i' 4iha% S!a! Pla''i'g 4#a%". H i5 S*%!a%y 4iha% H/ma' Righ!5 C#mmi55i#' 5i'* 12!h

,a%*h 2013. S%i Si'ha ha5 a/!h#%i5" ma'y 7##&5 i' 5#*ially */l!/%ally %la'! !#i*5.

Dr( Nirmal K+mar Aa-, IPS, I(G( &BHRC'

H ha5 7' a$a%"" Ph.D i' 2008. Di" ,a5!%5 i' S#*ial S*i'* %#m 9.N.U. 9#i'" I'"ia'P#li* S%i* i' 1?. Si'* ,a%*h 2012 h i5 #5!" a5 I.. (I'5!iga!i#') $i!h 4iha% H/ma'

Righ!5 C#mmi55i#'.

UNCTI=NS = 4IHAR HU,AN RIHTS C=,,ISSI=N

Th C#mmi55i#' may

(a) E';/i% #' i!5 #$' i'i!ia!i #% #' a !i!i#' %5'!" !# i! 7y a i*!im #% a'y #!h% %5#'

#' hi5Kh% 7hal i'!# *#mlai'! #

1. i#la!i#' # h/ma' %igh!5 #% a7!m'! #%

2. 'glig'* i' !h %'!i#' # 5/*h i#la!i#'5 7y a /7li* 5%a'!

(7) I'!%' i' a'y %#*"i'g i'#li'g a'y allga!i#' #% i#la!i#' # h/ma' %igh! '"i'g

7#% a *#/%! !# !h a%#al # !ha! *#/%!

(*) 6i5i! a'y ail #% a'y #!h% i'5!i!/!i#' /'"% !h *#'!%#l # !h S!a! #%'m'! $h% %5#'5 a% "!ai'" #% l#"g" #% /%#55 # !%a!m'! %#%ma!i#' #% %#!*!i#' #% !h

5!/"y # lii'g *#'"i!i#'5 # !h i'ma!5

(") Ri$ !h 5ag/a%"5 %#i"" 7y #% /'"% !h *#'5!i!/!i#' #% a'y #!h% la$ #% !h !im

7i'g i' #%* #% !h %#!*!i#' # h/ma' %igh!5

() Ri$ !h a*!#%5 !ha! i'hi7i! !h '#ym'! # h/ma' %igh!5

() U'"%!a& a'" %#m#! %5a%*h i' !h il" # h/ma' %igh!

(g) S%a" h/ma' %igh! li!%a*y a'" %#m#! a$a%'55 # !h 5ag/a%"5 aaila7l #%

%#!*!i#' # !h5 %igh!5 !h%#/gh /7li*a!i#'5 m"i*al 5mi'a%5 a'" #!h% aaila7l ma'5

(h) E'*#/%ag !h #%!5 # N#'-#%'m'! =%ga'i:a!i#'5 (N=5) a'"

(i) P%#%m 5/*h #!h% /'*!i#'5 a5 i! may *#'5i"% '*55a%y #% !h %#m#!i#' # h/ma'

%igh!5.

9


10/32

P=>ERS = THE C=,,ISSI=N

>hil ';/i%i'g i'!# !h *#mlai'! !h C#mmi55i#' i5 5!" $i!h all !h #$%5 # a *iil *#/%!

i' !h ma!!% # !%ial # a 5/i! /'"% !h C#" # Ciil P%#*"/% 108. I' a%!i*/la% i! ha5 #$% !# -

1. 5/mm#' a'" '#%* !h a!!'"a'* # $i!'555 a'"

m#!/) %#i"" !h Na!i#'al H/ma' Righ!5 C#mmi55i#' #% !h S!a! H/ma' Righ!5 C#mmi55i#'# !h *#'*%'" S!a! ($h% i#la!i#' #% 'glig'*K ail/% !# %'! !h i#la!i#' ha" !a&'

la*) ha5 '#! i'i!ia!" a'y %#*"i'g $i!h %5*! !# 5/*h i#la!i#' #% 'glig'*K ail/% !#

%'! i!.

10


11/32

CASE STUD.

CASE /0

CASE NUMBER0 4HRCKC#m- 80K12

COMPLAINANT0 Ya"/'a'"a' Si'gh.

ISSUE0 Th%a!'i'g 7y amily mm7%5.

4'*h # H#'7l 9/5!i* S(N(JHA(

FACTS

Th *#mlai'a'! Ya"/'a'"a' Si'gh i5 !h a!h% # La! Cha'"%a 4ha5&a% $h# $a5 a'

ml#y # I'"ia' Rail$ay5 a'" $a5 #5!" a! /"%a %#a" i' =%i55a 5!a! a5 a' a55i5!a'!

L#*# Pil#!. H ha5 l! 7hi'" him a 5#' a'" hi5 $i"#$ Ni%ma Di. Sh ha5 ali" #%

a#i'!m'! #' *#ma55i#'a! g%#/'" #% !h #7 i' la! # hi5 la! h/57a'". Th

ali*a'! 5!a!5 !ha! Ni%ma Di ha5 "l#" %la!i#'5hi $i!h a'#!h% ma' a'" $a'!5

him !# all#$ h% !# ma%%y him. I' !h *i%*/m5!a'*5 ali*a'! $a'!5 !ha! 7'i! #

*#ma55i#'a! a#i'!m'! #% 7'i!5 li& g%a!/i!y #% '5i#' !* 5h#/l"'! 7 %#i""

!# Ni%ma Di.

JUDGEMENT

A**#%"i'g !# %#%! # C#mmi55i#' i! i5 lai' !ha! !h *#mlai'! # !h ali*a'! i5

agai'5! hi5 "a/gh!%-i'-la$ Ni%ma Di. I' #!h% $#%"5 !h *#mlia'! li5 i' !h %alm #

%ia! %5#'al "i5/!. Th C#mmi55i#' "#5'! i'!%' i' *a55 %la!" !# %5#'al

11


12/32

"i5/!5. C#mmi55i#'5 i' i!5 %#%! 5!a!5 !ha! i! i5 #' !# !h ali*a'! !# a%#a*h !h

#i*ial5 *#'*%'" !# !h Rail$ay5 a'" 5& %#% i'!%'!i#' i'!# !h ma!!%.

CASE 1

CASE NUMBER0 4HRCKC#m-B2MK12

COMPLAINANT0 Uma Di.

ISSUE0 P%ima%y *a5 !# 7 il".

4'*h # H#'7l 9/5!i* NEELMANI(

FACTS

Uma Di $h# i5 !h *#mlai'a'! i5 !h $i # Sh%i Um5h Rai. Sh %5i"5 $i!h h% h/57a'". $ "ay5 7a*& "a*#i!y !##& la* i' h% h/57a'"5 5h# "/ !# $hi*h h

5/%" i'a'*ial *%i5i5. Si'g !h *%i5i5 ali*a'!5 a!h% ga 5#m i'a'*ial

a55i5!a'* !# him 5# !ha! h *#/l" 5!a%! hi5 7/5i'55 agai' a'" 5!ay a*/lly $i!h hi5

"a/gh!%. A!% $ "ay5 ali*a'!5 7%#!h%-i'-la$ $h#5 'am i5 S#'/ /ma% $a5

a%%5!" i' a *a5 # "a*#i!y. N#$ *#mlai'a'!5 h/57a'" a'" hi5 %la!i5 a% #%*i'g h%

a!h% !# ay !h am#/'! #% !h 7ail # S#'/ /ma%. E' $h' ali*a'!5 a!h% a'"

7%#!h% $'! !# m! h% h% i' la$5 "i"'! all#$ !hm !# m! h% a'" ' mi57ha"

$i!h !hm. Thy ha ' *a/5" g%i#/5 h/%! !# !hm. C#mlai'a'! la"" !h

C#mmi55i#' !# l##& i'!# !h ma!!% a'" !a& 5!%i*! a*!i#' agai'5! !h a**/5".

JUDGEMENT

C#mmi55i#' hl" !ha! !h ma!!% %la!5 !# !h i'5!iga!i#' # a %*'!ly i'5!i!/!" *a5.

Th *#mlai'a'! *a' a%#a*h !h high% #li* a/!h#%i!i5 #% /%!h% i'!%'!i#' i' !h

12


13/32

ma!!% a5 !h *a5 "#5'! *#m5 /'"% !h i#la!i#' # h/ma' %igh!5 $i!h $hi*h !h

C#mmi55i#' "al5. Th !i!i#' $a5 /%!h% 5'" !# !h I #% !h "i5#5al # !h ma!!%

a'" !# i'#%m !h *#mlai'a'! a**#%"i'gly.

CASE 2

CASE NUMBER0 4HRCKC#m-3?1?K11

COMPLAINANT0 /m/" Ra'a' Si'gh.

ISSUE0 Da*#i!y i' a' #%ga'i:a!i#' #i* # ,aga"h Sama alya' P%a!i5!ha' a'" !h%a!

# &illi'g.

4'*h # H#'7l 9/5!i* RAJENDRA PRASAD.

FACTS

Th *#mlai'a'! /m/" Ra'a' Si'gh $#%&5 i' ,aga"h Sama alya' P%a!i5!ha' $hi*h

i5 a' N= %/' /'"% 4a*ha' 4a*ha# Aa'"#la'. A**#%"i'g !# him #' 2..2011 a%#/'"

12M m a%#/'" i !# 5i< #l $h#m h *#/l" i"'!iy i h 55 !hm agai' *am !#

hi5 #i* a'" !h%a!'" him !# &ill him. Th#5 #l 5!a%!" 5a%*hi'g #% 5#m!hi'g i'

!h ma'$hil !hy !h%$ a%!i*l5 %5'! i' !h #i* a'" ' "amag" !hm. Th#5

#l a5&" #% m#'y %#m him a'" ' !##& a$ay al/a7l5 %#m !h #i*. >h'

!h ali*a'! %/5" !# gi m#'y !hy ' *a/5 h/%! !# him. C#mlai'a'! 5!a!" !ha!

!h5 a% i'l/'!ial #l a'" !hy ' !h%a!' him !# ay m#'y l5 !hy $#/l" &ill

him. C#mlai'a'! la"" !h C#mmi55i#' !# l##& i'!# !h ma!!% a'" !a& a*!i#' a'" %#!*! hi5 li $hi*h i5 hi5 /'"am'!al %igh!.

JUDGEMENT

13


14/32

C#mmi55i#' a!% ha%i'g !h *#/'*il a5&" #% !h %#%! %#m SSP Nala'"a. SSP 5'! a

%#%! $h% i! $a5 5!a!" !ha! i'5!iga!i#' ha5 7' "#' i' !h ma!!% a'" !h

allga!i#' ma" 7y !h *#mlai'a'! i5 !%/. 4/! a5 !h ma!!% $a5 # *iil 'a!/% $hi*h

"#5 '#! *#m5 /'"% i#la!i#' # h/ma' %igh!5 5# i! $a5 '#! mai'!ai'a7l 7y !h

C#mmi55i#'. Th/5 !h C#mmi55i#' "i5#5" # !h ma!!% a'" !h 5am i'#%ma!i#' $a5gi' !# !h *#mlai'a'!.

CASE 3

CASE NUMBER0 4HRCKC#m-108K11

COMPLAINANT0 6i%'"%a Sha%ma.

ISSUE0 P%#!*!i#' # H/ma' li a'" %#%!y.


FACTS

Th C#mlai'a'! 6i%'"%a Sha%ma i5 a %5i"'! # Naga'#/5a a'" i5 a ha'"i*a"

%5#'. H ha5 !$# *hil"%' a'" a $i. A**#%"i'g !# !h *#mlai'a'! hi5 U'*l a'"

#!h% %la!i5 ha" 5#m %#%!y "i5/! $i!h him a'" 7*a/5 # i! !hy a% !h%a!'i'g

him !# gi / !h %#%!y. Thy a% i'l/'!ial #l a'" !hy *#/l" *a/5 ha%m !# him

al#'g $i!h hi5 amily mm7%5 a'" hi5 %#%!y !##. 4/! *#mlai'aa'! i5 ha'"i*a"

a'" ' "#5'! ha '#/gh 5#/%*5 !# li hi5 li a'" 5% hi5 amily %#%ly. H

/%!h% 5!a!" !ha! hi5 U'*l a'" %la!i5 ha ' il" al5 *#mlai'! agai'5! him i'

!h #li* 5!a!i#'. Th *#mlai'a'! la"" !h C#mmi55i#' !ha! %#!*!i#' 5h#/l" 7

gi' !# hi5 li a'" %#%!y a5 i! i5 al5# a /'"am'!al %igh! # a ha'"i*a" %5#' !# 7 %#!*!".

JUDGEMENT

14


15/32

C#mmi55i#' a5&" SSP !# i';/i% i'!# !h ma!!% a'" 5/7mi! %#%! # i!. SSP i' hi5

%#%! 5!a!" !ha! a!% !h i';/i%y i! $a5 #/'" !ha! !h% $a5 a %#%!y "i5/! a'" !h

*ha%g5 ma" 7y !h *#mlai'a'! $a5 '#! *#%%*! a'" hi5 %la!i5 a% i''#*'!. E' !h

%#%!y "i5/! $a5 al%a"y 5#l" a'" *#m%#mi5". Th 'a!/% # allga!i#' i5 #

%#%!y "i5/! a'" !h %#*"i'g $a5 "i5#5" # a5 *l#5" 7y.

CASE 4

CASE NUMBER0 4HRCKC#m-21?2K12

COMPLAINANT0 A$"h5h /ma%.

ISSUE0 D/mi'g # "a" 7#"y m/%"%.

4'*h # H#'7l J+$ice RAJENDRA PRASAD(

FACTS

Th C#mlai'a'! A$"h5h /ma% Si'gh i5 a %5i"'! # Cha&&a' 4igha Na/7a!/%

P#li* S!a!i#' Pa!'a. H ha" a "a/gh!% $h#5 'am $a5 A'5h/ &/ma%a a'" h% ag $a5

1? ya%5. A**#%"i'g !# !h *#mlai'a'! hi5 "a/gh!% $a5 m/%"%" a'" !h%#$' i' !h

$ll $hi*h i5 'a% !# hi5 h#/5. H 5!a!5 !ha! Ra"hi&a "i a'" hi5 !$# 5#'5 A'im5h

a'" La&5hma' &/ma% 5i'gh ha m/%"%" hi5 "a/gh!% a'" !h%#$' h% "a" 7#"y i' !h

$ll a5 !h% $a5 a %#%!y "i5/! am#'g !hm. E' a!% !hi5 i'*i"'! Ra"hi&a "i

a'" hi5 5#'5 a% !h%a!'i'g him a'" hi5 amily !# !a& 7a*& !h *a5. >h' *a5 $a5 7i'g i'5!iga!" 7y !h #li* !hy "i"'! all#$ !# i'5!iga! i' !hi% h#/5 a'" i'5!a"

5!a! !ha! *#mlai'a'!5 "a/gh!% $a5 a *ha%a*!%l55 gi%l a'" m/5! ha 7i'g &ill" 7y

a'y %5#' $h# m/5! ha ha" a' aai% $i!h h%.

JUDGEMENT

15


16/32

Th *#mlai'a'! A$"h5h /ma% Si'gh $a5 ha%" a'" !h %#%! %*i" %#m SSP $a5

%5/". I! aa%5 %#m SSP5 %#%! a'" 5!a!m'! !a&' 7y !h #li* !ha! i'5!iga!i#'

ha5 7' "#' a'" ma!!% i5 '"i'g i' !h *#/%! a'" a5 5/*h 5/7-/"i*. I' !h %5/l! !hi5

ma!!% $a5 #%"%" !# 7 "i5#5" # a5 *l#5" 7i'g 5/7-/"i* a'" a5 5/*h '#!

mai'!ai'a7l $i!h li7%!y !# *#mlai'a'! !# 5& %m"y i' !h *#/%! i!5l $h% *a5 i5 7'"i'g #% "i5#5al.

CASE 5

CASE NUMBER0 4HRCKC#m-2M18K12

COMPLAINANT0 Sha5hi La!a Si'gh.

ISSUE0 T#%!/% 7y h/57a'" a'" hi5

4'*h # H#'7l 9/5!i* NEELMANI.

FACT

Th *#mlai'a'! ha5 !h *#mlai'! agai'5! hi5 h/57a'" Sha5hi 7h/5ha' 5i'gh. A**#%"i'g

!# h% hi5 h/57a'" i5 a 7/5i'55ma' $h# '"5 !# g# #/! #!' #% hi5 $#%&. >h' 5h

a5&5 him $h% h g#5 #/! h gi5 hi5


17/32

I'5!iga!i#' $a5 "#' 7y !h C#mmi55i#' a'" %#%! $a5 5'" 7y !h SSP Pa!'a !# !h

*#mlai'a'! #% 5'"i'g !h %5#'5 a'" $a5 al5# i'#%m" !ha! i h% %5#'5 i5 '#!

%*i" 7y !h "/ "a! !h ma!!% $#/l" 7 *l#5". Th *#mlai'a'! ha" '#! 5'! !h

%5#'5 5# a% !h/5 !h C#mmi55i#' "i5#55 # !h ma!!% a5 *l#5".

CASE 6

CASE NUMBER0 4HRCKC#m- 2B1MK10

COMPLAINANT0 4imal /ma% Sh%ia5!a.

ISSUE0 C#mlai'! #% !h "/ 5ala%y.

4'*h # H#'7l 9/5!i* S(N(JHA.

FACT

Th *#mlai'a'! 4imal /ma% Sh%ia5!a ha" #i'" H/ma' R5#/%* Dl#m'! a5 a

*#m/!% #%a!#% #% !h /%#5 # Da!a E'!%y. 4/! 5##' a!% #i'i'g hi5 #7 h $a5

a5&" !# %5ig' %#m !h #7. Th %a5#' 5!a!" !# him 7y !h "a%!m'! $a5 !ha! "/ !#

l55 $#%& l#a" !h% i5 '# '" #% him #% !h #7 a'" hi5 5ala%y #% #% !$# m#'!h5 i..

%#m A%il !# ,ay $a5 '#! ai" !# him.

S# !h *#mlai'a'! la"" !h C#mmi55i#' !# "i%*! !h "a%!m'! !# ay hi5 "/

5ala%y $hi*h $h' *al*/la!" *am !# a5 R5. 111M0#% 7#!h !h m#'!h5.

I' hi5 a'#!h% ali*a!i#' !# 4HRC h !%i" !# 5& !h a!!'!i#' # !h C#mmi55i#'

!#$a%"5 hi5 m'!al 5#*ial a'" *#'#mi* 5/%i'g5 a'" $a5!ag # hi5 !im. H $a'!"

!ha! hi5 !%mi'a!i#' %#m hi5 #7 5h#/l" 7 *all" # a5 i! $a5 '#! /5!ii". H "ma'""

*#m'5a!i#' #% !h ha%a55m'! $hi*h h ha" 5/%" "/ !# hi5 !%mi'a!i#' # #7.

17


18/32

JUDGEMENT

C#mmi55i#' a5&" #% !h %#%! a!% i'5!iga!i#' i' !h *a5 %#m !h H/ma' R5#/%*

Dl#m'! ,i'i5!%y $i!hi' #/% $&5 #' !h *#mlai'! # !h *#mlai'a'!. I' !hi5

%#%! !h am#/'! # "/ 5ala%y $a5 *al*/la!" !# 7 a%#/'" R5. 11M10 #% !h m#'!h5 #

A%il a'" ,ay. E' a!% 5%al %mi'"%5 !h *#mlai'a'! "i" '#! %5#'" a'" 5# !h

*a5 $a5 *l#5". Th il $a5 %#'" #' !h "ma'" # !h *#mlai'a'! a'" !h

aym'! # "/ 5ala%y $a5 *la%" 7y !h H/ma' R5#/%* Dl#m'!. 4/! !h

"ma'" #% !h !%mi'a!i#' !# 7 *all" # $a5 '#! !a&' i'!# *#'5i"%a!i#'.

CASE 7

CASE NUMBER0 4HRCKC#m-13? K11

COMPLAINANT0 6I9AY U,AR YADA6.

ISSUE0 RAUDULANTLY TAIN = ,=NEY.

4'*h # H#'7l 9/5!i* S(N(JHA.

FACT

Th *#mlai'a'! 6iay /ma% Ya"a il" a *#mlai'! i' !h 4HRC $h% h 5!a!" !ha!

h $a5 a %!i%" a%my #i*% a'" */%%'!ly h i5 $#%&i'g a5 a a%m% i' hi5 illag a!

,a'%. /%!h% h 5!a!" !ha! a %5#' 'am" a5 ,#ha 4haga! *am !# him #% !h 5al #

hi5 l#! $hi*h $a5 l#*a!" a! ,a/a Sa%ai ,a'% a!% !h 'g#!ia!i#' a'" ag%m'!

7!$' !hm !hy i


19/32

!h C#mmi55i#' !# l##& i'!# !h ma!!% a'" !a& a*!i#' a'" hl him !# %*i hi5

am#/'! 7a*&.

JUDGEMENT

Th *#mlai'a'! $a5 %5'! #% !h %5#'5 $h% h 5!a!" !ha! h $a5 !ha'&/l !# !hC#mmi55i#' !ha! i! l##&" i'!# !h ma!!% 7/! h ha" al%a"y *#m%#mi5" $i!h !h

##5i! a%!y $i!h !h i'!%'!i#' # !h l#*al Pa'*haya!. H /%!h% 5!a!" !ha! ##5i!

a%!y ha5 %!/%'" !h am#/'! R5. ?00000 $hi*h h ai" !# !h #!h% a%!y a5 !h

*#'5i"%a!i#' #% !h 5al # !h la'". /%!h% !h *#mlai'a'! 5!a!" !ha! '#$ h "#5'!

$a'!5 !# %#*" i'!# !h ma!!% !h/5 !h ma!!% $a5 *l#5" 7y !h C#mmmi55i#'.

CASE 8

CASE NUMBER0 4HRCKC#m-313? K12

COMPLAINANT0 A6INASH RAI HANNA.

ISSUE0 QUITIN = STUDIES 4Y IRLS DUE T= E6E TEASIN.


FACT

Th *#mlai'a'! Ai'a5h /ma% ha''a il" a *#mlai'! i' #%"% !# 7%i'g i'!# !h *a5

i' !h y5 # !h C#mmi55i#' $h%i' i' h 5!a!" !ha! a '$5 i!m $a5 /7li5h" i' Th

Tlg%ah #' 20K08K2012 i' $hi*h i! $a5 /7li5h" !ha! !h% ha5 7' !a5i'g "#'

!# !h 5*h##l g#i'g gi%l5 $h# !%al !# !hi% 5*h##l5 !h%#/gh *y*l5. A'" "/ !# %a!"

!a5i'g !hy $% #%*" !# "%# #/! # !hi% 5*h##l5 a'" la !hi% 5!/"y.

C#mlai'a'! 5!a!" !ha! !hi5 i5 a *a5 # i#la!i#' # h/ma' %igh!5 # !h gi%l5 a'" i! i5

al5# agai'5! !h $la% # !h 5#*i!y.

19


20/32

JUDGEMENT

Th C#mmi55i#' #%"%" !h %5*!i *#m!'! a/!h#%i!y !# !a& '*55a%y a*!i#'

agai'5! !h m'!i#' ma!!% a'" "i%*!" !hm !# 5'" !h %#%! # !h a*!i#' !# !h

*#mlai'a'!.

CASE /9

CASE NUMBER0 4HRCKC#m-2B K11

COMPLAINANT0 SA6ITA DE6I.

ISSUE0 ASSAULT AND STEALIN = 9E>ELLERY.


FACTS

Th *#mlai'a'! Sai!a Di i5 a %5i"'! # Ni:am/% illag D"a%ga' Pa!'a a'" i5

$i # ,%. 6iay Si'gh. Sh ha" *#mlai'" !ha! !$# #l 'am" a5 T/''/ Si'gh a'"

4ia! Si'gh ha" a55a/l!" h% a'" !hy 5!#l a$ay h% $ll%y a!% 7%a&i'g i'!# !h

h#/5.

Sh /%!h% m'!i#'5 !ha! T/''/ Si'gh a'" 4ia! Si'gh 7%#& i'!# h% h#/5 #'

1?K10K2011 a%#/'" m $h' 5h $a5 a5l a'5 5!a!" a7/5i'g h%. Sh allg5 !ha!

!hy *a $i!h $a#'5 li& i5!#l5 5$#%" a'" 5!i*&5 a'" !hy ' 7a!" h% / a!%

20


21/32

a7/5i'g h%. Sh m'!i#'5 !ha! !hy !%i" !# hi! h% 7y !h 5$#%" 7/! 5h %#!*!" h%5l

5#mh#$.

Sh al5#m'!i#'5 !ha! !h a**/5" !##& h% $ll%y $hi*h 5h $a5 $a%i'g a! !ha! !im

$hi*h i'*l/"" a *hai' # a%#/'" 20 g%am5 # g#l" a'" 10 g%am5 # g#l" a%%i'g5.

JUDGEMENT

Th C#mmi55i#' a5&" #% !h %#%! a!% i'5!iga!i'g !h ma!!% %#m !h SSP $i!hi'

#/% $&5. Th %#%! 5!a!" !ha! i'5!iga!i#' $a5 "#' a'" !h allga!i#' # !h

*#mlai'a'! $a5 '#! *#%%*! a'" !h/5 !h ma!!% $a5 "i5#5" # 7y !h *#mmi55i#'.

CASE //

CASE NUMBER0 4HRCKC#m-120 K11

COMPLAINANT0 AASHA DE6I.

ISSUE0 THREAT CAUSED 4Y THE C=USIN =R CAPTURIN THE PR=PERTY.

4'*h # H#'7l 9/5!i* S(N(JHA.

FACTS

Th *#mlai'a'! Aa5ha Di 5!a!" i' h% *#mlai'! !ha! h% la! m#!h% ha" &! 5#m

m#'y a'" $ll%y #% h% g%a'"a%'! $hi*h 5h 5#l" $h' 5h $a5 "yi'g. >h' h% *#/5i' *am !# &'#$ a7#/! !h %#%!y h "i"'! all#$ h% !# '!% i'!# h#/5 a'" $h'

5h #%*i7ly !%i" !# '!% !h' h% *#/5i' a'" hi5 $i 7a!" h% 7a"ly a'" !h%a!'"

h% !ha! i 5h *#mlai'" a7#/! !hi5 i'*i"'! !# !h Pa'*haya! !h' !hy $#/l" &ill h%

a'" h% *hil"%'. H% *#/5i' ha" $%#'gly m'!i#'" #' !h 5#/%* # m#'y !ha! h ha"

!a&' ? la&h5 %#m h% m#!h% $hi*h $a5 "/ a'" #' !h 7a5i5 # !ha! h ha" "#'

%gi5!%y # !h la'" #' hi5 'am %a/"ly. Sh la5!ly m'!i#'" !ha! #' h% /%!h%

21


22/32

*#mlai'! h% *#/5i' !h%a!'" h% !ha! h% h/57a'" a'" h% *hil"%' $#/l" 7 &ill" i

5h il" a'y *a5 i' !h *#/%! agai'5! him. I' h% *#mlai'! 5h m'!i#'" a7#/! !h ai'

a'" ag#'y *a/5" !# h% 7y h% *#/5i'. Sh ha" la"" !h C#mmi55i#' !ha! '*55a%y

a*!i#' m/5! 7 !a&' agai'5! h% *#/5i' a5 h ha" i'#l" him5l i'!# *%imi'al

a*!ii!i5.

JUDGEMENT

Th C#mmi55i#' i' i!5 %#%! 5!a!5 !ha! !h *#mlai'! li" i' !h %alm #

%ia!K%#%!y "i5/!. Th C#mmi55i#' "#5 '#! i'!%' i' 5/*h *a55 a'" $#/l"

!h%#% '#! /%5/ !h ma!!% /%!h%. Th *#mlai'a'! $a5 i'#%m" a7#/! !h "*i5i#'.

CASE /1

CASE NUMBER0 4HRCKC#m- 2?32K12

COMPLAINANT0 RANI DE6I

ISSUE0 =R ENQUIRY IN THE RAPE CASE.

4'*h # H#'7l 9/5!i* NEELMANI.

FACT

Th *#mlai'a'! Ra'i Di i5 $i # Sh%i. A'/ Da5 illag Chama/% 4a&h!iya%/%

Pa!'a. Sh 5!a!" !ha! h% h/57a'" i5 $#%&i'g a5 a la7#/% i' Ha%ya'a a'" 5h i5 '#! a7l

!# m! h% '"5. P%5'!ly 5h i5 5!ayi'g i' Pa!'a al#'g $i!h h% !h% *hil"%'.

Sh allg5 !ha! h% 'igh7#/% 9ay P%a&a5h alia5 Ch#!/ Da5 $h# $#%&" a5 a !a*h% i' a

%ima%y 5*h##l i' Sim%i illag *am !# h% h#/5 #' 1B!h 7%/a%y 2012 a! a%#/'" B m

a'" !%i" !# %a h%. Sh 5!a!5 i' h% *#mlai'! !ha! h !#% # h% *l#!h5 a'" !%i" !#

%a h%. 4/! 5h 5!a%!" 5h#/!i'g #% hl 7*a/5 # $hi*h #l 5!ayi'g 'a%7y *am

!# h% %5*/ 7/! !h a**/5" %a' a$ay.

22


23/32

Sh ha5 ' m'!i#'" !ha! 5h $'! !# %gi5!% a' .I.R i' !h #li* 5!a!i#' a! a%#/'"

m #' !h 5am "ay 7/! 5/%%i5i'gly '# a*!i#' $a5 !a&' agai'5! !h a**/5". Sh 5!a!5

!ha! Ra5h "a5 al#'g $i!h ,ah5h "a5 Sh%aa' "a5 a'" ,a'i5h "a5 ma'ha'"l"

Rama5h%ay "a5. Thy 7%#& hi5 ha'" a'" hi5 ha" $a5 5%i#/5ly i'/%". Sh ha" '

a!!a*h" '*55a%y m"i*al *%!ii*a! a'" h% *#y # 5!a!m'!. Sh la"" !hC#mmi55i#' #% high% ll # i';/i%y i' h% *a5.

JUDGEMENT

Th *#mlai'a'! ha" m'!i#'" !ha! !h% ha5 7' i'a*!i'55 #' !h a%! # !h #li*

i' h% *#mlai'. S# *#mmi55i#' "i%*!" !h SSP Pa!'a !# 5'" hi5 %#%! !# !h

C#mmi55i#' a!% i'5!iga!i'g i' !h ma!!% $i!hi' #/% $&5 $h% i'5!iga!i#' m/5!

'#! 7 "#' 7y a'y #i*% 7l#$ !h %a'& # D/!y SP a'" 5/7mi! !h %#%!. SSP i' hi5

%#%! m'!i#'" !ha! a*!i#' ha5 7' !a&' agai'5! !h a**/5" 7/! !hy a% #/! #' 7ail.

Th %5#'5 gi' 7y !h *#mlai'a'! $a5 '#! a%#%ia! a'" !h C#mmi55i#' "i" '#!i'" a'y m#% %a5#'5 !# & !h *a5 #' 5# !h *a5 $a5 *l#5".

CASE /2


COMPLAINANT0 RA,DAS RA9A

ISSUE0 CASE = HARASS,ENT AAINST S=N-IN-LA>


FACT

Th *#mlai'a'! Ram"a5 %aa& 5K# La! Laga' Raa& i5 a %5i"'! # illag a!a%i

Ni5a%/% Pa!'a. H g#! h% "a/gh!% P%amila Di ma%%i" !# Pa/ Raa& alia5 Rah/l.

Thy ha !$# *hil"%'. P%amila Di l! h% h/57a'"5 h#/5 "/ !# *%!ai' "i%'*5a'" *am !# li $i!h him. Ram"a5 %aa& i' hi5 *#mlai'! allg5 !ha! hi5 5#'-i'-la$

Pa/ Raa& *#m5 !# hi5 h#/5 i' a!a%i $h% h% "a/gh!% i5 al#' a! h#m a'"

a7/55 h% %7ally a'" hy5i*ally. H allg5 !ha! hi5 5#'-i'-la$ i5 "ma'"i'g "#$%y.

H 5!a!5 !ha! hi5 5#'-i'-la$ i5 "ma'"i'g R5. ?0000 a'" g#l" # $#%!h R5. ?000 a'"

5il% # $#%!h R5. 2000. H la"" !h C#mmi55i#' !# 5!%i*! a*!i#' a'" %#!*! hi5 a'"

hi5 "a/gh!%5 h/ma' %igh!5.

23


24/32

JUDGEMENT

Th C#mmi55i#' a5&" !h SSP !# i'5!iga! !h ma!!% a'" gi %#%! $i!hi' ? $&5.

SSP 5/7mi!!" !h %#%! a!% i'5!iga!i'g !h ma!!% $h%i' i! $a5 m'!i#'" !ha! !h*ha%g5 ma" 7y !h *#mlai'a'! a% al5. Th *#mlai'a'! $a5 a5&" !# gi hi5

%5#'5 7/! h "i"'!. Th/5 !h C#mmi55i#' "i5#5" # !h ma!!% a5 *l#5".

CASE /3


COMPLAINANT0 HANSYA, SHAR,A

ISSUE0 REARDIN CANCELLATI=N = TRANSER =RDER.


FACT

Th *#mlai'a'! ha'5hyam Sha%ma i5 a %5i"'! # Pa!'a *i!y Pa!'a. Th *#mlai'a'!

ha" il" !h *#mlai'! %ga%"i'g *a'*lla!i#' # !%a'5% #%"% # C#'5!a7l A5h#&

/ma% Si'gh $hi*h $a5 i55/" 7y SSP Pa!'a. I' hi5 *#mlai'! h ha5 5!a!" !ha! i! $a5

al5ly /7li5h" i' '$5a% !ha! A5h#& /ma% Si'gh $a5 #5!" a! !h 5am la*

5i'* la5! i a'" a hal ya%5. Al#'g $i!h !h *#mlai'! l!!% h ' a!!a*h" %#<

*#y # !%a'5% #%"% i55/" #' 2MK0K12 $a5 al5# a!!a*h" !# i! $hi*h m'!i#'" !ha!

C#'5!a7l A5h#& /ma% Si'gh $a5 !%a'5%%" !# ,al5alami #li* 5!a!i#' %#m

,a%/ga' =.P. S# i! $a5 '#$ *la% !ha! !h '$5a% %#%! $a5 al5 a'" h $a5

#5!" i' ,al5alami #li* 5!a!i#' 5i'* la5! #' ya% a'" !$# m#'!h5.

24


25/32

JUDGEMENT

A!% l##&i'g i'!# !h *#mlai'! !h C#mmi55i#' a5&" SSP !# i'5!iga! i'!# !h ma!!%

a'" %5'! i!5 %#%! $i!hi' #/% $&5. Th %#%! 5!a!" !ha! ,a%/ga' 5!a!i#' i5 al5#/'"% ,al5alami #li* 5!a!i#' 5# h ha5 *#ml!" hi5 !'/% # !$# ya%5. S# !h %#%!

$a5 5'! !# !h *#mlai'a'! #% hi5 %5#'5 7/! a!% 5%al %mi'"%5 h "i"'!

%5#'"" 5# !h *#mmi55i#' hl" !ha! !h *#mlai'a'! i5 '#! i'!%5!" i' *a%%yi'g

#%$a%" !h ma!!% 5# !h *a5 i5 *l#5".

CASE /4

CASE NUMBER0 4HRCKC#m- 10MK11

COMPLAINANT0 SA9DA PAR6EEN

ISSUE0 PHYSICAL T=RTURE AND HARASS,ENT 4Y HUS4AND


FACT

Th *#mlai'a'! Sa"a Pa%' $a5 ma%%i" !# Pa%$ A'/m #' 08K03K18B. Th

*#mlai'a'! i' h% *#mlai'! 5!a!" !ha! !ill 5#m !im a!% h% ma%%iag %y!hi'g $a5

'#%mal 7!$' h% h/57a'" a'" h%. I' !h ma'$hil 5h ga 7i%!h !# a 5#'. I' "/

*#/%5 h% h/57a'" 5!a%!" 7a!i'g h% a'" !#%!/%i'g h%. Sh l#5! h% a!i'* $h' h%

h/57a'" 5!a%!" ' !# !#%!/% h% 5#'. S# 5h l! h% h#/5 a'" $'! !# h% a!h%5

h#/5 i' P/%'a $h% 5h ' il" a *a5 # !#%!/% agai'5! h% h/57a'". 4/! h%

h/57a'" *am !# h% h#/5 a'" %;/5!" h% !# !a& 7a*& !h *a5 $hi*h !h

*#mlai'a'! a**!" a'" *am al#'g $i!h h% h/57a'" !# Pa!'a. 4/! !# h% 5/%%i5 h%

h/57a'" agai' 5!a%!" 7hai'g i' ill ma''% $i!h h% a'" ' 5!#" gii'g h% !h

7a5i* am'i!i5. I' %#!5! !# i! !h *#mlai'a'! 5!a%!" a 7a/!y a%l#/% i' a 5mall %##m

25


26/32

7/! h% h/57a'" /5" !# ill !%a! !h */5!#m%5 !##. La!% h% h/57a'" ' !%i" !# &ill h%

al#'g $i!h h% 5#'. S# 5h il" a *a5 7#% Chi 9/"i*ial ,agi5!%a!. 4/! '# a*!i#'

$a5 !a&' 5# 5h la"" !h C#mmi55i#' !# l##& i'!# !h ma!!% a'" %#!*! h% li

$hi*h i5 h% /'"am'!al %igh! al5#.

JUDGEMENT

A!% l##&i'g i'!# !h *#mlai'! !h C#mmi55i#' a5&" !h SSP !# i'5!iga! i'!# !h

ma!!% a'" %5'! i!5 %#%! $i!hi' #/% $&5. Th *#mlai'a'! $a5 a5&" !# 7 %5'!

#% !h ha%i'g 7/! a!% la5! %;/5! !h C#mmi55i#' a55/m" !ha! !h *#mlai'a'! i5 '#!

i'!%5!" i' *a%%yi'g #%$a%" !h ma!!% 5# i! "i5#5" # !h *a5.

CASE /5


COMPLAINANT0 RA9NISH A,AL

ISSUE0 A,ILY DISPUTE

4'*h # H#'7l 9/5!i* S(N(JHA.

FACT

Th *#mlai'a'! i5 a' a%!i5! a'" i5 */%%'!ly $#%&i'g $i!h C=L=RS CHANNEL

,/m7ai. H $a5 ma%%i" !# Ra5hmi amal i' !h ya% 200M. A**#%"i'g !# !h

*#mlai'a'! hi5 $i ha5 /'/5/al 7hai#% !#$a%"5 him a'" 5h ' "#5'! %5*! hi5

$#%& a'" !%i5 !# 5!# him %#m g#i'g #/! # !h h#/5. E' 5h ha5

$i!h 5#m /'&'#$' #l a'" "/ !# !hi5 !hy ha igh! alm#5! %y "ay. Hi5 a!h%

a'" 7%#!h%-i'-la$ al5# !h%a!' him !# il a *a5 # "#$%y agai'5! him. Thy ha !h%

*hil"%' $h# a% al5# 7i'g a*!" 7y all !hi5. Th *#mlai'a'! la"" !h

C#mmi55i#' !# *all hi5 $i a'" hi5 a!h% a'" 7%#!h%-i'-la$ !# a"i* a'" #%"% !hm

26


27/32

7ha $ll $i!h him a'" %5% hi5 h/ma' %igh!5 # m#i'g a'y$h% a'" !# li $i!h

"ig'i!y.

JUDGEMENT

I! i5 a *a5 # amily ma!!% !h/5 !h C#mmi55i#' "#5'! '!%!ai'5 5/*h *#mlai'!5. S#

!h ma!!% $a5 "i5#5" # a'" *l#5" a'" a %#%! %ga%"i'g !h "*i5i#' $a5 5'! !# !h

*#mlai'a'!.

CASE /6

CASE NUMBER0 4HRCKC#m- 11?BK11

COMPLAINANT0 RA6ENDRA PAS>AN

ISSUE0 ,ARRIAE 4Y RAUD


FACT

Th *#mlai'a'! ma%%i" h% "a/gh!% !# U"ay Pa5$a' $h# $#%&" i' li i'5/%a'*

C#ma'y. H ha" 5'! a l#! i' !h ma%%iag *%m#'y # hi5 "a/gh!%. H 5ay5 !ha! 7#% !h ma%%iag h ha" "#' /ll i';/i%y a7#/! !h *ha%a*!% a'" *#'"/*! # !h

7%i"g%##m. D/%i'g !hi5 !h %la!i5 a'" *#-illag%5 # !h 7%i"g%##m 5ai" !ha! h $a5

/'ma%%i" a'" $a5 # g##" *#'"/*! a'" *ha%a*!% !h/5 a!% !hi5 *#mlai'a'! $a5 a55/%"

# ma%%yi'g hi5 "a/gh!% !# him. A!% !h ma%%iag $h' hi5 "a/gh!% $'! !# h% i'-

la$5 h#/5 5h *am !# &'#$ !ha! h% h/57a'" $a5 ma%%i" !h%i* a'" ha5 !h% *hil"%'

27


28/32

%#m !hm a'" '#$ 5h $a5 !h #/%!h $i # him. A!% !h ma%%iag *#mlai'a'!5 5#'-

i'-la$ $a5 "ma'"i'g #% R5 10000 7/! h %/5" !# ay. Th g%##m i5 5ai" !# ha

ma%%i" a'" &ill" all !h $i5 #% i'5/%a'* m#'y a'" !h *#mlai'a'! ha5 a "#/7!

!ha! h may "# !h 5am !hi'g $i!h hi5 "a/gh!%. Th *#mlai'a'! la"" !h

C#mmi55i#' !# l##& i'!# !h ma!!% a'" !a& a*!i#'.

JUDGEMENT

Th ma!!% $a5 %5#l" 7y !h m/!/al *#'5'! a'" !h *a5 $a5 $i!h"%a$' 7y !h

*#mlai'a'!.

CASE /7

CASE NUMBER 4HRCKC=,P- 2B3K10

COMPLAINANT SHA4ANA PAR>EEN

ISSUE0 RELATED T= C=,PENSATI=N = L=SS = ACADE,IC YEAR.

FACTS

A**#%"i'g !# !h ali*a'! 5h *#/l" '#! ill !h


29/32

i'!%m"ia! *#/%5 a'" i5 %#5*/!i'g /%!h% 5!/"i5. Sh 7l#'g5 !# 4PL amily $i!h#/!

a'y a%'!al 5/#%!.

JUDGEMENT

I' !h a*!5 a'" *i%*/m5!a'*5 !h C#mmi55i#' i5 # !h i$ !ha! i! $#/l" 7 i' !h '"5

# /5!i* !# g%a'! h% a !#&' m#'!a%y *#m'5a!i#' # R5.10000 (%/5 !' !h#/5a'")

$hi*h may 7 %*#%" %#m !h 5ala%y # !h Ha"mi5!%55 # !h 5*h##l *#'*%'".

Th ma!!% i5 !h/5 "i5#5" #.

CASE /8

CASE NUMBER0 4HRCKC#m-1B3 K11

COMPLAINANT0 PRADEEP U,AR

ISSUE0 C=,PLAINT AAINST REULAR LIE THREAT RECEI6ED.

4'*h # H#'7l 9/5!i* S(N(JHA.

FACT

Th *#mlai'a'! P%a" i5 B? ya%5 #l" $h# i5 5K# La! P/%a'a Cha'"%a Cha&%a7#%!y

ha" /%*ha5" a la'" a'" 7/il! a h#m !h%#' a'" ha" 7' %5i"i'g !h% 5i'* 2? ya%5

$i!h hi5 amily mm7%5. H 5!a!5 !ha! h i5 #l" a'" /5/ally %mai'5 ill. H 5!a!" !ha! 1-

2 ya%5 7a*& h ha" 7' i'!'"i'g !# 5ll hi5 %#%!y a'" i' !hi5 %ga%" h ha" 7'

a%#a*h" 7y !$# !h% 7%#&%5. =/! # !hm #' 7%#&% Sh%i Dha%m'"%a /ma% 9ha

ha" %;/i%" him !# %#i" a h#!#*#y # #$'%5hi "" # hi5 %#%!y. Thi5 7%#&%

29


30/32

i'#%m" him !ha! Sh%i 4ha%a! Tha&/% $a'!" !# !al& !# him %ga%"i'g !hi5 %#%!y. 4/!

a5 h $a5 '#! $illi'g !# 5ll !h %#%!y h *la%ly %/5". Th' all # a 5/""' #' 8 !h

9a'/a%y 2011 #' Sh%i a'haya P%a5a" $h# *laim" h !# 7 C#mmi55i#'% a'" Sh%i

4ha%a! Tha&/% *am !# hi5 h#/5 a'" a5&" !# 5ll !hi5 %#%!y !# him 7/! !h

*#mlai'a'! %/5" i!. 4/! #' %/5al !hy !h%a!'" him # "i% *#'5;/'*5 a'" la!% 5'! a lgal '#!i* #' 1MK01K2011 5!a!i'g !ha! !h% $a5 a *#'!%a*! #% 5al # %#%!y #

$#%!h R5. 3M la&h5 a'" R5. 1M0000 ha" al%a"y 7' ai". Th *#mlai'a'! 5!a!5 !ha! i!

i5 al5 a7%i*a!" a'" '# ag%m'! ha" 7' ma". H la"" !h C#mmi55i#' !ha! h

7l#'g5 !# 4'gali mi'#%i!y *#mm/'i!y a'" h a'" hi5 amily mm7%5 a% 7i'g

ha%a55" #' !h ha'"5 # la'" maia. S# h %;/5!" !h C#mmi55i#' !# !a& a*!i#' a'"

%#!*! hi5 %#%!y a'" amily mm7%5.

JUDGEMENT

Th C#mmi55i#' a5&" !h SSP Pa!'a !# i'5!iga! !h ma!!% a'" %5'! 7#% i! !h%5#'5 $i!hi' ? $&5. Th i'5!iga!i#' $a5 "#' a'" a %5#'5 $a5 a5&" %#m !h

*#mlai'a'! $h% h 5!a!" !ha! 5i'* h il" hi5 *#mlai'! #' 18K01K2011 !ill !#"ay i..

12K03K2012h ha5'! %*i" a'y !h%a! a'" '#$ "/ !# #%! # !h C#mmi55i#' !h

ma!!% i5 '#%mal a'" h ' %ai5 C#mmi55i#' a'" SSP #% !hi5 #%!5. S# i' !h i$

# %5#'5 # !h *#mlai'a'! !h ma!!% i5 *l#5" a'" *#mlai'a'! $a5 al5# i'#%m".

CASE 19


COMPLAINANT0 EETA DE6I

ISSUE0 C=,PLAINANT REARDIN PR=PER IN6ESTIATI=N IN A CASE

4'*h # H#'7l 9/5!i* S(N(JHA.

FACT

Th *#mlai'a'! il" !h *#mlai'! !ha! h% "a/gh!% Aa%!i Di $a5 *all" 7y /'!iDi #' 01K01K2012 a! a%#/'" ?00 m !# h% h#/5. Th% 5h 5%" my "a/gh!% !a

$hi*h *#'!ai'" 5#m a""i*!i 5/75!a'* "/ !# $hi*h 5h l! /'*#'5*i#/5. A!% 5#m

!im !$# #l 'am" Pa%m5h$a% Rai a'" Sa!y'"%a /ma% *am a'" #%*i7ly !##&

h% i'!# !h %##m a'" $h' *#mlai'a'!5 "a/gh!% %5i5!" /'!i Di 5ai" !ha! !#"ay i5

15! 9a'/a%y a'" y#/ ha !# 5'" 'igh! $i!h !hm. N


31/32

#l $'! !h% a'" %5*/" h%. Th' *#mlai'a'!5 h/57a'" $'! !# il *#mlai'! i'

!h #li* 5!a!i#' 7/! 5i'g h% *#'"i!i#' 5h $a5 %%%" !# P.,.C.H $h% 5h "i" #'

13K01K2012. =' 02K01K2012 #li* i'5*!#% ha" g#! 5ig'" #' a 7la'& a% 7y !h

*#mlai'a'!5 "a/gh!% a'" la!% #' h $%#! 5#m al5 5!a!m'!. La!% #' !h a**/5"

!h%a!'" *#mlai'a'!5 h/57a'" a'" ' 7a!" him a'" il" al5 *a5 agai'5! him.Th *#mlai'a'! la"" !h C#mmi55i#' !# !a& a*!i#' agai'5! !h a**/5" a'" %#!*!

h% amily.

JUDGEMENT

Th i'5!iga!i#' $a5 "#' 7y !h SSP $h% h 5!a!" !ha! !h% i5 !$# %5i#' # *a5

$hil a5 % !h *#mlai'a'! !h "*a5" $a5 5! #' i% 7y /'!i Di a5 % #!h%

%5i#' $hi*h #li* ha5 #/'" !# 7 !%/ i5 !ha! !h "*a5" #/%" &%#5' #il #' h%

7#"y a'" 5! h%5l ai% a!% 7i'g %7/&" 7y !h amily mm7%5 #% i5i!i'g /'!i

Di5 h#/5 agai'5! !hi% $i5h5. Th *#mmi55i#' $'! i'-"!h !# 5 $h!h% !h%ha5 7' a'y 5h#%!*#mi'g i' !h i'5!iga!i#' 7y !h #li* 7/! i! "i"'! i'" a'y 5/*h

!hi'g. Th *#mmi55i#' i5 i'*li'" !# !hi'& !ha! !h *#mlai'a'! ha5 '#! %al" !h

$h#l 5!#%y. C#/%!5 #% ;/a5i /"i*ial 7#"i5 *a' i'!%' $h% i! #/'" i'*#ml! #%

"i5h#'5! #% illgal 7/! '#!hi'g # &i'" ha5 7' 7%#/gh! !# '#!i*. Th C#mmi55i#'

$#/l" a**#%"i'gly "*li' !# /%5/ !h ma!!%.

CONCLUSION

Th %5a%*h% ha5 "#' !h i'!%'5hi /'"% 4IHAR HU,AN RIHTS C=,,ISSI=N

$h% !h %5a%*h% ha5 g#' !h%#/gh !h hi5!#%y # h/ma' %igh!5 al#'g $i!h !h $#%&

"#' 7y !h HU,AN RIHTS C=,,ISSI=N. Th h/ma' %igh!5 a% +!h %igh! a'"

%"#m5 !ha! %y %5#' #' a%!h i5 '!i!l" !# '#y li& %igh! !# 5#*ial 5*/%i!y %igh!

!# ;/ali!y %igh! !# li %igh! !# li7%!y a'" 5*/%i!y # %5#'5 !*. $i!h#/! "i5!i'*!i#' #'

7a5i5 # %a* 5


32/32

Th %5a%*h% *am a*%#55 a%i#/5 *a55 $hil g#i'g !h%#/gh !h il5 # 4HRC "/%i'g

!h i'!%'5hi a'" *am !# !h *#'*l/5i#' !ha! C#mmi55i#' i5 a %y i*i'! m*ha'i5m

!h%#/gh $hi*h !h h/ma' %igh!5 # !h #l i5 7i'g %#!*!" a'" %5%". Th

C#mmi55i#' 7a5" #' !h *#mlai'! i'#l5 a ai% "g% # i'5!iga!i#' 7y !h

i*i'! a'" a/!h#%i:" a/!h#%i!y a'" 7a5" #' !h %#%! %#i"5 ai% %li !# !h*#mlai'a'!. Th *#mlai'!5 a% 5%" i' a ;/i*& 555i#' a'" !h *#mlai'a'!5 a% gi'

%li5. ,a'y # !h *a55 $% *l#5" a5 % !h %i'*il # !h C#mmi55i#'. Th

%5a%*h% *am a*%#55 ma'y *a55 al5# $h% !h *a55 il" $% al5 "/ !# $hi*h

!h% $a5 $a5! # !im #' !h a%! # !h C#mmi55i#'. Th %5a%*h% ha5 gi' a'

a**#/'! # !h *a55 g#' !h%#/gh "/%i'g !h i'!%'5hi.

I' a %*'! %#%! /7li5h" i' TI,ES = INDIA 4HRC ha5 7' %a'&" am#'g !h

!# m#5! 5!a!5 #% i!5 5"y !%ial i' ya% 2013. Th '/m7% # *a55 7i'g il" i' !h

C#mmi55i#' ha5 al5# i'*%a5" $hi*h i'"i*a!5 a #5i!i 5ig' !ha! !h !%/5! am#'g

#l #% 4HRC ha5 i'*%a5" !%m'"#/5ly. Th% $% a%i#/5 %#g%amm5

*#'"/*!" 7y !h 4HRC #% !h i'!%'5 $h% immi''! %5#'5 # a%i#/5 il"5 *am !#

"i5*/55 a%i#/5 *#'*!5 a'" !#i*5 %la!" !# !h h/ma' %igh!5. Thi5 i'i!ia!i # !h

C#mmi55i#' i5 *#mm'"a7l a5 i! hl" !h i'!%'5 !# gai' !h#%!i*al a5 $ll a5

%a*!i*al &'#$l"g. Th i'!%'5hi !a&' /'"% !h 4HRC ha5 7' a' '%i*hi'g a'"

&'#$l"g 5&i'g

Documents

Human Rights Project for BHRC