8/6/2019 How to Tackle Journal Reviewers- Jayed.M.H
1/6
Scientific Bangladesh
?
Jayed M.H.
TF0608C073(01)
8/10/2011
8/6/2019 How to Tackle Journal Reviewers- Jayed.M.H
2/6
Page 2 of6
?
Bornmanm
& Daniel (1993), Liesegang et al. (2007), Ray et al.
(2000)
8/6/2019 How to Tackle Journal Reviewers- Jayed.M.H
3/6
Page 3 of6
Elsevier Elsevier English Language Editing Service
Publication.Easy
,
...
...
8/6/2019 How to Tackle Journal Reviewers- Jayed.M.H
4/6
Page 4 of6
8/6/2019 How to Tackle Journal Reviewers- Jayed.M.H
5/6
Page 5 of6
DDD .
The
reviewer have pointed out a very unique research aspect. But
unfortunately current research article
is focused in KKK only. We hope to shade more light in future
research endeavor."
*
8/6/2019 How to Tackle Journal Reviewers- Jayed.M.H
6/6
Page 6 of6
1. Does the subject fall within the general scope of the
journal?/ Is the topic of themanuscript appropriate for the
Journal?
2. Is this a new and original contribution?1. Is the information
of significant interest to the readers?
Is the title accurate and sufficiently descriptive of the
content?
2. Is the abstract sufficiently informative, especially when
read in isolation?3. Are appropriate keywords given?
Are the statistical methods used correct and adequate?
4. Is the organisation of the article satisfactory?5. Does the
content justify the length?6. Are the methods appropriate and
scientifically sound?7. Are the conclusions supported by the data
presented?8. Are the tables and figures well designed and add to
understanding of the text?9. Is information in the tables and
figures redundant?10. Are the references cited the most appropriate
to support the manuscript?11. Should the manuscript be
shortened?
