Upload
apoapoajo
View
216
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/13/2019 How Indonesia Got It Right
1/3
How Indonesia got it rightJANUARY 07, 2014
Datuk Zaid Ibrahimfounded Malaysia's
largest law partnership
before focusing onpolitics. He was a
minister in the Abdullah
administration, was in
Umno, PKR and last inKITA as its president.
Indonesia is the most populous Muslim country in the world, which probably led the late Abdurrahman
Wahid (Gus Dur)the former Indonesian president and an enlightened ulamato predict confidently that
his country would shape and determine the future global Muslim agenda.
According to him, other Muslim countries, even those in the Middle East, would not be as capable as
Indonesia in this area and its no exaggeration to say that Islamic discourse, whether in politics, theology,
or cultural practices, is gaining widespread currency throughout the world.
In Indonesia, just as in Malaysia, there are many groups and organisations spreading their views and
trying to determine and shape the future of Islam in the respective countries.
In Indonesia, these groups range from liberals (such as the Jaringan Islam Liberal) to ultra-conservative
Salafis.
Some say that the smiling face of Islam is no longer present in todays Indonesia. This refers to the rise
of attacks against liberals and so-called deviationists such as the Ahmadiyya movement and Shias.
The city of Solo is a hotbed of conservatism, as is South Sulawesi. Committees for overcoming threats of
apostasy are sprouting like mushrooms. Even the Muhammadiyah, long regarded as a bastion of
moderate Islam, is changing its face and is becoming increasingly like the Wahabbis of a certain desert
country.
Former Muhamadiyah leader Dr Amien Rais tried to give more traction to the development of political
Islam by declaring that the Pancasila should not be the sole Weltanschauungor worldview for Indonesia,
nor should it constitute the founding principles of the nation.
He didnt gain much support for this view and, like all opportunists, he slowly faded away from the scene.
Today, despite the apparent growth of conservative Islam, the Indonesian government has not faltered
and still strenuously advocates the need for a secular democratic system with Islam as its guiding
principle.
http://www.themalaysianinsider.com/opinion/columnist/zaid-ibrahim/8/13/2019 How Indonesia Got It Right
2/3
Democracy is alive in Indonesia and gains strength each day. The freedom of the press is there for all to
see. Political parties with strong religious elements are allowed to participate and campaign on whatever
platform suits them.
They can seek popular support for their opinions and there is a multitude of viewpoints from which to
choose.
These organisations are not above the law of the land. Not surprisingly, the religious parties are not
frontrunners in this years general election and I doubt that they will do well at the polls.
Whatever the case, I hope that Gus Durs liberal aspirations will come to the fore again.
In Malaysia, however, the Islamisation process involves not just non-governmental organisations or
social and religious activists but the very core of the government as well, and the ongoing attacks on the
Christian use of the word Allah give credence to the view held by political experts that, at the next
general election, the contest will be about who can play the Islamic game better.
Political Islam is gaining a momentum in Malaysia at a rate unheard of before. This means that
democracy and the rule of law in Malaysia grows increasingly fragile while authoritarian rule lurks aroundthe corner.
I hope that the leaders of political parties in Malaysia, especially those in the Barisan Nasional, will take
this development seriously. I exclude Umno from this because it is probably already too late to expect
anything progressive from that quarter.
The unwillingness of Umno leaders to find a peaceful solution to the Allah issue, for example, is a clear
sign of the march towards authoritarian rule.
Invoking the name God is just a ruse to gain support for a new dictatorship.
PAS, I hope, will be the last bastion preventing the death of democracy in this country. Who could have
imagined such a thing 20 years ago? But the way the PAS president has formulated his principle with
regard to the issue of Allah is exemplary.
He said that as long as the word Allah is not abused but used in prayers and in holy books, PAS has no
objection at all.
This is not merely correct, in principle, it is an excellent practical solution.
If the government has any sense left, it should know that it is impossible to continue confiscating Bibles
and the Guru Granth Sahib. And if anyone insists that non-Muslims are barred from using Allah in any
context, then surely that insistence includes the singing of state anthems containing the word Allah.
Such a ban is patently ridiculous and impossible to implement. Furthermore, barring someone fromsaying or singing Allah lanjutkan usia Tuanku (God grant long life to his highness), for example, can be
interpreted as an act of treason.
As such, the government should not renege on the 2010 cabinet decision and should instead explain that
decision carefully and clearly so everyone understands it.
I shall leave it to them to find the courage to do so.
8/13/2019 How Indonesia Got It Right
3/3
Meanwhile, troublemakers have had all the attention and, in the process, the government is now stuck
with a ban it cant possibly enforce.
Why do I say that Indonesia got it right? The institutions of state must be preserved and protected by the
founding principles of that nation. Indonesia has steadfastly held on to this.
Operating in a democracy, the Indonesian government continues to allow the various political andreligious aspirations of the nation to be aired and canvassed with all the enthusiasm adherents can
muster. At the same time, no one is ever allowed to transgress the defining parameters of the
Constitution.
In Malaysia, we think we are smarter. We think we can redefine and reformulate the founding principles
of our nationor even violate the Constitution outrightjust because the government or some privileged
interest group feels it is politically expedient to do so.
Weve got it all wrong. January 7, 2014.
* This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of
The Malaysian Insider.