15
Presented to Presented to USAEE USAEE June 12, 2008 June 12, 2008 How Companies Inadvertently How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value During Destroy Shareholder Value During Deals Deals and what can be done about it? and what can be done about it?

How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value ... · 3 EHS Issues in Deals Brief History 1960s – Environmentalism launched with Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” 1970s

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value ... · 3 EHS Issues in Deals Brief History 1960s – Environmentalism launched with Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” 1970s

Presented toPresented toUSAEEUSAEE

June 12, 2008June 12, 2008

How Companies Inadvertently How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value During Destroy Shareholder Value During

Deals Deals

……and what can be done about it?and what can be done about it?

Page 2: How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value ... · 3 EHS Issues in Deals Brief History 1960s – Environmentalism launched with Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” 1970s

2

TopicsTopics

EHS issues in Energy Deals

Destroying Value and Creating Value

Remote Sensing®

The Three BucketsSM

© 2008 Pilko & Associates, LP

Page 3: How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value ... · 3 EHS Issues in Deals Brief History 1960s – Environmentalism launched with Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” 1970s

3

EHS Issues in DealsEHS Issues in DealsBrief HistoryBrief History

1960s – Environmentalism launched with Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring”

1970s - The first Earth Day and Love Canal becomes known

1980s - Buyers avoid getting the liabilities with the assets, largely CERCLA-driven (Superfund)

1990s - Sellers seek to understand their liabilities as a defense against buyer’s DD

2000s - Use DD as a proactive strategy to obtain competitive advantage and create value

Page 4: How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value ... · 3 EHS Issues in Deals Brief History 1960s – Environmentalism launched with Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” 1970s

4

EHS Issues in DealsEHS Issues in DealsWhat are TodayWhat are Today’’s EHS Drivers?s EHS Drivers?

Operations Excellence / Process Safety

Climate Change

REACH in Europe(Registration, Evaluation, Authorization and Restriction of Chemicals)

Page 5: How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value ... · 3 EHS Issues in Deals Brief History 1960s – Environmentalism launched with Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” 1970s

5Big Spring, TX RefineryExplosion – February 2008

Page 6: How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value ... · 3 EHS Issues in Deals Brief History 1960s – Environmentalism launched with Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” 1970s

6

Page 7: How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value ... · 3 EHS Issues in Deals Brief History 1960s – Environmentalism launched with Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” 1970s

7

EHS Issues in DealsEHS Issues in DealsImportanceImportance

These issues typically represent 5% to 30% of selling price in energy deals

Usually among the Top 3 issues to negotiate during a transaction

Often the longest section of the Purchase and Sale Agreement

Most Deal Leaders are ill-equipped to negotiate these issues well

Page 8: How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value ... · 3 EHS Issues in Deals Brief History 1960s – Environmentalism launched with Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” 1970s

8

Common MistakesCommon MistakesLead to Value Creating OpportunitiesLead to Value Creating Opportunities

Deal Leaders who don’t understand the EHS issues facing the business

Failure to understand the difference between Operational Issues and Transactional Issues

EHS Advisors who are technocrats and are operating in functional silos

Taking a narrow view of EHS

Page 9: How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value ... · 3 EHS Issues in Deals Brief History 1960s – Environmentalism launched with Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” 1970s

9

Stages of EHS Activities in DealsStages of EHS Activities in DealsD

ata

Roo

m O

pens

RemoteSensing®

Used in Gaining Negotiating Leverage

Sign

ed A

gree

men

tClaims

Planning

Transition Planning

Clo

sing

ClaimsManagement

Transition Implemen-

tation

Page 10: How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value ... · 3 EHS Issues in Deals Brief History 1960s – Environmentalism launched with Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” 1970s

1010

Remote SensingRemote Sensing®®

What is it?What is it?

Identify major risks and liabilities and other key information about the target company before the Data Room opens

Value is created by generating actionable intelligence

Performed without the knowledge of the target

Key is to know where to look and what to ask for

Page 11: How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value ... · 3 EHS Issues in Deals Brief History 1960s – Environmentalism launched with Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” 1970s

1111

Remote SensingRemote Sensing®®

How is it used?How is it used?

Remote Sensing® is used to assist Deal Leaders to credibly communicate EHS issues with the Board when the following situations arise:

In advance of large corporate acquisitions

Deals involving JV partners and the partner is concerned about confidentiality

Need for confidentiality within the acquiring organization.

Page 12: How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value ... · 3 EHS Issues in Deals Brief History 1960s – Environmentalism launched with Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” 1970s

12

Three BucketsThree BucketsEach Can Dramatically Impact ValueEach Can Dramatically Impact Value

Page 13: How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value ... · 3 EHS Issues in Deals Brief History 1960s – Environmentalism launched with Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” 1970s

13

Key Take AwayKey Take Away

For Energy Deals, EHS issues can be a strategic weapon for companies who recognize the value of:

Remote Sensing®

Three BucketsSM

Page 14: How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value ... · 3 EHS Issues in Deals Brief History 1960s – Environmentalism launched with Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” 1970s

14

Pilko & AssociatesPilko & AssociatesBusiness Driven EHS Advisors to Executives Business Driven EHS Advisors to Executives & Boards& Boards

Management Consultants specializing in EHS matters in the Chemical and Energy SectorsConsultants have an average of 27 years experienceAdvisor to Boards and Senior ManagementSpecialize in three major practice areas:

Large transactions, advising on $425+ billion in transactions in 48 countriesGovernance and Board Issues

Industry leader in strategic positioning of EHS matters in Acquisitions and DivestituresOrganized 23 Client Roundtables since 2000 to benchmark Best Practices in global chemical and energy transactions

Page 15: How Companies Inadvertently Destroy Shareholder Value ... · 3 EHS Issues in Deals Brief History 1960s – Environmentalism launched with Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” 1970s

15

Contact PilkoContact Pilko

Eric Dietert713-357-1000 office713-299-3691 [email protected]