Upload
addison
View
33
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Optimization and Co-Generation of Energy from Steel Making Process CDM Methodologies Process Approval. Guilherme Corrêa Abreu Luiz Antônio Rossi Tsutomu Morimoto. Responsible Work Team. Companhia Siderúrgica de Tubarão (coordination). (Technical support in the project development). - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Citation preview
Pow
er
Gri
ds a
nd
C
DM
Meth
od
olo
gie
s
Dec
emb
er 8
th,
Bu
eno
s A
ires
, A
rge
nti
na
Guilherme Corrêa AbreuLuiz Antônio RossiTsutomu Morimoto
Optimization and Co-Generation of Energy from Steel Making
Process
CDM Methodologies Process Approval
Pow
er
Gri
ds a
nd
C
DM
Meth
od
olo
gie
s
Dec
emb
er 8
th,
Bu
eno
s A
ires
, A
rge
nti
na
Responsible Work Team
Companhia Siderúrgica de Tubarão
(coordination)
(Technical support in the project development)
(Validation Process)
Pow
er
Gri
ds a
nd
C
DM
Meth
od
olo
gie
s
Dec
emb
er 8
th,
Bu
eno
s A
ires
, A
rge
nti
na
The CDM Projects
SludgeSludgePumpsPumps
VenturiVenturiPumpsPumps
Steel Making Gas (LDG) recovery for electric energy generation => Increasing the generation.
Electric energy consumption reduction at Steel Making Plant => Reduction of the consumption.
Total of 330.000 tCO2 in 07 years.
Electric energy consumption reduction
LD gas recovery / Power Plant #4
Pow
er
Gri
ds a
nd
C
DM
Meth
od
olo
gie
s
Dec
emb
er 8
th,
Bu
eno
s A
ires
, A
rge
nti
na
The Proposed Methodologies Baseline Scenario: The future thermal participation on the grid expansions. The hydrologic conditions for hydro energy generations.
Validation Process initiated at September 2003 (DNV). New Methodologies: NM0059: Energy co-generation from steel making gas recovery at Brazil. NM0064: Electric energy consumption reduction in steel making process at Brazil.
Submission for Meth Panel: June 24, 2004. Public comments: Jul 16 until August 05. Meth Panel recommendation: Nov. 08~10.
Pow
er
Gri
ds a
nd
C
DM
Meth
od
olo
gie
s
Dec
emb
er 8
th,
Bu
eno
s A
ires
, A
rge
nti
na
Meth Panel Considerations Final Recommendation (NM0059 and NM0064): Not to approve the
proposed methodologies. Additionality not clear and not rigorously supported (additionality test). Proposed threshold (<50%) too high to establish “non common practice in
the sector”. Necessary an Investment Analysis to support additionality through Barriers
Analysis. Necessary to use the energy operating margin AND built margin. Baseline Scenario not well defined (only one baseline scenario is
considered). Necessary of leakages expansion assessment.
Pow
er
Gri
ds a
nd
C
DM
Meth
od
olo
gie
s
Dec
emb
er 8
th,
Bu
eno
s A
ires
, A
rge
nti
na
Project Participants Comments
Technical questions and procedures questions have arose after Final Recommendation.
Additionality test, that has been asked for, was published by Meth Panel on 11th meeting July 09, 2004, therefore after the submission.
Even being published after the project submission, it is not clear in the additionality test (MP 11th meeting) that it is necessary an Investment Analysis AND Barriers Analysis.
The whole project including proposed methodologies and the additionality had been evaluated by DNV during the Validation Process, and was considered in accordance with Kyoto Protocol demands.
Pow
er
Gri
ds a
nd
C
DM
Meth
od
olo
gie
s
Dec
emb
er 8
th,
Bu
eno
s A
ires
, A
rge
nti
na
Project Participants Comments
Differences of individual analysis by experts on several points (ex. NM0059 with controversial positions between the experts related to the baseline establishment).
No possibility for any clarifications by project participants, even this phase is foreseen on Meth Panel procedures. Most of the technical aspects pointed by the experts could be clarified in case of explanations by project participants.
No support on the establishment why the “proposed threshold is too high”.
Participation of an expert (Ricardo Esparta) not in accordance with Meth Panel procedures regarding the total impartiality on the process.
Pow
er
Gri
ds a
nd
C
DM
Meth
od
olo
gie
s
Dec
emb
er 8
th,
Bu
eno
s A
ires
, A
rge
nti
na
Thank you for your attention !!
www.cst.com.br
Guilherme Corrêa Abreu
Environmental Specialist