Green Engineering PC General Meeting – Aviation 2015 - Dallas June 24, 2015 Marty Bradley Program Committee Chair [email protected]

Green Engineering PC General Meeting – Aviation 2015 - Dallas

June 24, 2015

Marty BradleyProgram Committee [email protected]

What is Green Engineering?

Biofuels RenewableEnergy

Energy ConversionEfficiency

Airframe EfficiencyAIAA Conferences & Literature

RecyclingOperations

Climate Monitoring

GE.comBoeing.com

Enviro.aero

Enviro.aero

Wikipedia.org

GEPC Charter

The purpose of the Green Engineering Program Committee

(GEPC) is to promote a holistic, systems approach to improved

energy efficiency, sustainability, renewable energy and ‘cradle-to-

cradle’ design. GEPC serves as the AIAA focal point for all “green”

aerospace-related programs and technologies, and works

synergistically with the appropriate technical committees to assure

that the AIAA membership is adequately informed about all aspects

of this critical aerospace activity.

GEPC General Meeting – Aviation Forum - June 2015

• Introduction & Introductions – Org Chart• Aircraft Electric Propulsion Meeting• Conference Status• Subcommittee Leads – Around the room

Public Policy Initiative & Discussion Communications – Twitter, Facebook, Website, Newsletter Education, Awards, Liaison

• Action Items• Open discussion• More details on future AIAA Conference Forums (optional if

time is available)

4





time is available)

5

Attendance – GEPC Aviation General Meeting June 24, 2015

1. Marty Bradley2. Xxx3. Yyy4. zzz

6

Dani Soban – record information

Green Engineering Program Committee

Publication / Communications

Tayo Ladeinde

Awards Essam Khalil

EducationTarek Abdel-Salam

MembershipDanielle Soban

Service Subcommittee RepresentativesService Subcommittee Representatives

Technical Subcommittee RepresentativesTechnical Subcommittee Representatives

ChairMarty Bradley

Vice Chair (Future Chair)Ruben Del Rosario

Past ChairJason Slagle

ConferencesFranz-Josef Kahlen

Liaison xxx

Green Aviation - xxxLarry Leavitt – ERA

Marty Bradley et al.– Electric Aircraft

Green Energy - xxxNicole Mendoza – Tethered Wind Turbines

Jeremy Straub – Space Solar PowerGeorge Miley/Michael Houts - Advanced Nuclear

Noel Bahktian – Energy HarvestingMarty Bradley – Geo-Engineering

Standardsxxx

Public Policy Katherine Bradley

June 8, 2015

GEPC Meetings – Summer 2015

GEPC General Meeting - Telecon/Webex – June 16th at 8 AM PDT

Aviation 2015 – Dallas June 22-25th– Aircraft Electric Propulsion Path Forward - Coordination Meeting - Monday 12-

2 PM - Cooper Room– GEPC Meeting – Wednesday June 24th 5:30-6:30 PM – Malta Room

P&E 2015 – Orlando July 27-29th

– GEPC Leadership & ConferenceTeam Meeting» Monday, 27 July 2015 5:00-7:00 pm

– GEPC Meeting» Tuesday, 28 July 2015 5:00-7:30 pm

Space 2015 – Pasadena Aug 13th - September 2nd– Space Based Solar Power Session (Jeremy Straub)

8


• Introduction & Introductions – Org Chart• Aircraft Electric Propulsion Meeting Separate Briefing• Conference Status• Subcommittee Leads – Around the room



time is available)

9





time is available)

10

GEPC General Meeting – Conference Status

• Aviation 2015 (Andy Gibson) See separate slide

• P&E 2015 (Valerie Lyons) See separate slide

• Space 2015 Space Based Solar Power Session (Jeremy Straub)

• SciTech 2016 (Chris Hughes) Call for Papers - Abstracts due June 2, 2015 ERA Special Session (Larry Leavitt) Geoengineering F360 Session (Marty) – waiting to hear from F360 Chair “Supercritical Transformational Energy Production” – Roger Herdy looking to submit

or find a home for his paper “I just have the session slots reserved. Right now, I only have ERA and the papers

that came in through the GE call. I have not heard from Transformational Flight yet, and you are still thinking about one for AATT. I have one oral presentation on Hybrid Electric from Armstrong proposed for GE. I don’t have any other information yet.” – Chris 11

GEPC General Meeting – Conference Status

• Aviation 2016 (TBD )

• P&E 2016 (Tarek Abdel-Salam)

• SciTech 2017 (TBD)

• Other topics (conference sessions not scheduled yet)

1. Airborne Wind Turbines (Nicole Mendoza) – possible presentation to GEPC at SciTech 2016

2. Energy Harvesting (Noel Bahktian) – possible presentation to GEPC at SciTech 2016

3. Advanced Nuclear (George Miley/Michael Houts) – presentation on state of the art at P&E 2015

12

Aviation 2015 Report – Andy Gibson

Number of papers (submitted / accepted) 4 Technical Papers submitted, 2 accepted. 6 Oral Presentations Invited, 6 accepted and sessioned.Number of sessions (regular and invited) One; GEPC-01 Overview of NASA Advanced Air Vehicles Program. Two accepted Papers passed off to other sessions. "Selected Array of Technology and Systems Options for Ecologically Responsible Aviation“ moved to ATIO-07 Systems Engineering and Analysis. "Landscape Analysis Framework for Low Carbon Energy" moved to ATIO-06 Fleet and Route Planning.Duration and schedule of sessions GEPC-01, Thursday June 25th, 2 - 5pm.Highlights / topical areas of your sessions Decided upon single technical session; focus to introduce the projects in the Advanced Air Vehicles Program.Any other pertinent information Not at this time; it seems that SciTech might be GEPC's focus, but P&E received good returns as well, which

could be because it's P&E, or because Valerie wanted to re-write the CfP. We decided not to re-write the CfP for AVIATION specifically to see how it would compare to SciTech, and that question was answered.

Forum 360 Panel Session – Challenges of Green Aviation – Wednesday 2:00-4:30 pmGEPC Meeting – Wednesday June 24th 5:30-6:30 PM – Malta Room

13

Valerie Lyons P&E 2015 Status

Number of papers (submitted / accepted) = 6 · Number of sessions = 1 (regular paper session)· Duration and schedule of sessions = 6x30 min = 3 hrs -· Highlights / topical areas of your sessions = wide variety of

"green" engineering topics - from liquid propellants to aeronautics.

Plenary Program“Technology Development and Trends in Propulsion and Energy”

Forum 360“Aircraft Electric Propulsion”“Role of Bio-fuels in Future Aviation” Still looking for speakers!

Continuing Education“The Application of Green Propulsion for Future Space”

GEPC Leadership/Conference/General Meetings 14



Tayo Ladeinde

Awards Essam Khalil





ChairMarty Bradley




Liaison xxx






Standardsxxx


June 8, 2015





time is available)

16

What is a Policy Position Paper?

• A policy position paper is the form in which a policy issue is presented to Congress.

• It is a brief, 1-page paper summarizing a key issue and what Congress should do to fix the problem.

17

Types of Position Papers (From AIAA website)

• AIAA Information Paper – The least formal of the policy papers, an Information Paper provides information only on a particular key issue but does not make any formal policy recommendations. Information papers are subject to approval at the Section, Technical and/or Program Committees’ level.More Info

• AIAA Member/Group Position Paper – A statement that provides an objective and balanced analysis of an issue that represents the views of the authoring group or committee, but not necessarily the views of AIAA as a whole. The Member/Group Position Paper may include formal recommendations of government action on the particular issue.

• AIAA Position Paper – A paper that provides an objective and balanced study with a clear AIAA position on the best course of action by government to address issues of interest or concern to AIAA members.More Info

18

http://www.aiaa.org/Secondary.aspx?id=405

http://www.aiaa.org/secondary.aspx?id=3422

2014 Information Papers

• Long-Term Investment in Technology and Transition: An AIAA Information Paper

• Assuring the Viability of the U.S. Aerospace and Defense Industrial Base: An AIAA Information Paper

• Developing a Seamless National Cybersecurity Policy: An AIAA Information Paper

19

http://www.aiaa.org/uploadedFiles/Issues_and_Advocacy/Aeronautics/Technology%20Transition%20Final%20022814.pdf



http://www.aiaa.org/uploadedFiles/Issues_and_Advocacy/Policy_Papers/Information_Papers/2014_Information_Papers/Sustaining%20the%20Industrial%20Base%20Information%20Paper%20Final%20030314.pdf



http://www.aiaa.org/uploadedFiles/Issues_and_Advocacy/Policy_Papers/Information_Papers/2014_Information_Papers/Cyber%20Security%20Policy%20Information%20Paper%20Final%20030314.pdf



2014 Information Papers (Continued)

• Access for Unmanned Aerial Vehicles in the National Aerospace System: An AIAA Information Paper

• Ensuring a Robust U.S. Human Spaceflight Program: An AIAA Information Paper

• Addressing the Growing Threat of Orbital Debris: An AIAA Information Paper

• Building Our Competitive Foundation: Supporting K-12 STEM Education: An AIAA Information Paper

20

http://www.aiaa.org/uploadedFiles/Issues_and_Advocacy/Policy_Papers/Information_Papers/2014_Information_Papers/UAVs%20in%20the%20NAS%20Final%20022814.pdf

http://www.aiaa.org/uploadedFiles/Issues_and_Advocacy/Policy_Papers/Information_Papers/2014_Information_Papers/UAVs%20in%20the%20NAS%20Final%20022814.pdf

http://www.aiaa.org/uploadedFiles/Issues_and_Advocacy/Policy_Papers/Information_Papers/2014_Information_Papers/Ensuring%20a%20Robust%20US%20Human%20Spaceflight%20Program%20White%20Paper%20Final%20030314.pdf

http://www.aiaa.org/uploadedFiles/Issues_and_Advocacy/Policy_Papers/Information_Papers/2014_Information_Papers/Ensuring%20a%20Robust%20US%20Human%20Spaceflight%20Program%20White%20Paper%20Final%20030314.pdf

http://www.aiaa.org/uploadedFiles/Issues_and_Advocacy/Policy_Papers/Information_Papers/2014_Information_Papers/Addressing%20the%20Growing%20Threat%20of%20Orbital%20Debris%20White%20Paper%20Final%20030314.pdf

http://www.aiaa.org/uploadedFiles/Issues_and_Advocacy/Policy_Papers/Information_Papers/2014_Information_Papers/Addressing%20the%20Growing%20Threat%20of%20Orbital%20Debris%20White%20Paper%20Final%20030314.pdf

http://www.aiaa.org/uploadedFiles/Issues_and_Advocacy/Policy_Papers/Information_Papers/2014_Information_Papers/EmphasizingTechnology%20and%20Engineering%20Education%20Information%20Paper%20Final%20030114.pdf

http://www.aiaa.org/uploadedFiles/Issues_and_Advocacy/Policy_Papers/Information_Papers/2014_Information_Papers/EmphasizingTechnology%20and%20Engineering%20Education%20Information%20Paper%20Final%20030114.pdf

Existing Environment Position Statements

• February 2009Aviation’s Role in Minimizing Environmental Impacts

• January 2010Essential Capabilities for Operational Climate Change Monitoring

• May 2010• Energy and the “Greening” of Aviation• May 2010• Understanding, Mitigating, and Adapting to Climate Change• February 2011

A National Strategy is Required to Address Obstacles to Sustainable Alternative Aviation Fuels

21

http://www.aiaa.org/uploadedFiles/Issues_and_Advocacy/Energy_and_Environment/EnvironmentWhitePaper030309v03.pdf

http://www.aiaa.org/uploadedFiles/Issues_and_Advocacy/Energy_and_Environment/ClimateMonitoringWhitePaper022409v01PW.pdf

http://www.aiaa.org/uploadedFiles/Issues_and_Advocacy/Energy_and_Environment/Energy%20Information%20Paper%20030111%20v02.pdf

http://www.aiaa.org/uploadedFiles/Issues_and_Advocacy/Energy_and_Environment/Energy%20Information%20Paper%20030111%20v02.pdf

How to get a Policy Position Paper Developed

• AIAA Public Policy is picking a few (3-5) broad, key policy issues to promote to Congress.

• The other issues will be referred to local Public Policy representatives who will try to fix the issues on the local level.

• The goal: Identify green engineering policy issues both large-scale and local to promote to AIAA Public Policy.

22

Potential Green Engineering Related Policy Issues

1. EPA and airplane emissions2. Funding cuts for AFRL fuels lab that was

providing significant help for biofuel certification activities

3. Your ideas4. Xxx

23

EPA Takes Step Toward Regulating Airplane Emissions

The New York Times (6/11, Mouawad, Davenport, Subscription Publication) reports that in “the latest” of President Obama’s “major initiatives to combat global warming,” the EPA said yesterday that “it would take the first step toward regulating greenhouse gas emissions from airplanes.” The Washington Post (6/11, Mooney) indicates, however, that “rather than moving ahead on its own, the agency plans to continue to work on with the United Nations’ International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO).” Christopher Grundler, who heads the EPA’s Office of Transportation and Air Quality, “defended the international approach,” observing that “an international standard would cover far more aircraft than simply a domestic standard, and would cover far more greenhouse gas reduction.”

The Huffington Post (6/10, Sheppard) reports that the EPA “did not announce actual regulations at this point,” but “rather...its intent to reach an endangerment finding, which would trigger regulations under the Clean Air Act.” On its website, US News & World Report (6/11, Neuhauser) notes that the EPA, under the current administration, “made a similar finding in 2009 that led to new emissions standards for motor vehicles, and has pushed to harness the Clean Air Act to reduce carbon emissions from power plants.” US News added that “such moves have been vigorously opposed and portrayed as federal overreach by industry and conservative lawmakers, but have been upheld in court.”

The AP (6/10, Lowy) notes that the ICAO “has been working for five years on developing global aircraft emissions standards for the first time. Final agreement on those standards is expected in February of next year.” However, “a final US decision on adoption of international standards is likely to be left to the next presidential administration,” as “EPA officials said the earliest the agency is likely to propose adoption of ICAO standards would be in 2017.”

Bloomberg News (6/11, Snyder) says that “environmental groups welcomed the EPA action they have sought since 2007, though some cautioned about the tie to the ICAO.” Vera Pardee, “a senior attorney at the Center for Biological Diversity,” said yesterday, “It’s an important first step, but too little too late. ... EPA is punting responsibility.” In fact, “Pardee said the ICAO may delay significant reductions until 2030 or later.”

Reuters (6/10, Volcovici) reports that Paul Steele, senior vice president at the International Air Transport Association, said, “If you’re a big airline and you’re flying to 100 countries a day, then complying with all those different regimes is an administrative nightmare.”

The Wall Street Journal (6/10, Ostrower, Harder, Subscription Publication) reports that Nancy Young, vice president for Environmental Affairs at Airlines for America, a trade association representing U.S. airlines and air cargo carriers, similarly said, “Aviation is a global industry, making it critical that aircraft emission standards continue to be agreed upon at the international level.”

24A good discussion topic for Aviation and P&E GEPC Meetings

http://mailview.bulletinmedia.com/mailview.aspx?m=2015061101aiaa&r=5649333-46c2&l=002-4fd&t=c

http://mailview.bulletinmedia.com/mailview.aspx?m=2015061101aiaa&r=5649333-46c2&l=003-1e2&t=c

http://mailview.bulletinmedia.com/mailview.aspx?m=2015061101aiaa&r=5649333-46c2&l=004-e99&t=c

http://mailview.bulletinmedia.com/mailview.aspx?m=2015061101aiaa&r=5649333-46c2&l=005-871&t=c

http://mailview.bulletinmedia.com/mailview.aspx?m=2015061101aiaa&r=5649333-46c2&l=006-fda&t=c

http://mailview.bulletinmedia.com/mailview.aspx?m=2015061101aiaa&r=5649333-46c2&l=007-bf6&t=c

http://mailview.bulletinmedia.com/mailview.aspx?m=2015061101aiaa&r=5649333-46c2&l=008-06f&t=c

http://mailview.bulletinmedia.com/mailview.aspx?m=2015061101aiaa&r=5649333-46c2&l=009-9c6&t=c

https://twitter.com/aiaaGEPC

25

GEPC Newsletter

26

GEPC Newsletter

27



Tayo Ladeinde

Awards Essam Khalil





ChairMarty Bradley




Liaison xxx






Standardsxxx


June 8, 2015





time is available)

29

Actions:

63. Schedule follow-on IMECHE workshop – Ruben Del Rosario66. Advanced Nuclear presentation for GEPC Meeting at P&E 2015 – Michael Houts67. Energy Harvesting and/or Energy Water Nexus presentation for SciTech 2016 – Noel

Bahktian68. Airborne Wind Turbine presentation for SciTech 2016 – Nicole Mendoza69. Find new Subcommittee Lead for Liaison - Marty & Leadership Team70. Valerie needs speakers for F360 panel “Role of Bio-fuels in Future Aviation” at

P&E . Gary Dale to check on getting an LNG speaker (maybe change session name to “Role of Alternative Fuels in Future Aviation”). Marty to check with Boeing contacts.

71. Send slide and talking points for discussion on Aircraft Electric Propulsion – Brien Seeley. Marty to use in AEP coordination meeting at Aviation on June 22nd.

72. Send sample of Aircraft Design Newsletter to Marty & Tayo – Hernando Jimenez73. Xxx74. Yyy75. zzz

30

Green = complete

Actions:

52. Investigate Speaker / Session on Geo-Engineering - Marty53. Investigate Speaker / Session on Energy Harvesting – Noel Bakhtian

54. Use other AIAA Facebook groups and pages to publicize GEPC Page – Marty

55. Find leader for Standards. - Marty & Leadership team56. Have them explain process to do a standard for AIAA. Have them identify other

current non-AIAA standards related to green aviation of energy – Standards Leader

35. Help find new Green Energy leader – John Blanton37. Outreach to student chapter – Tayo to get email POC’s for student chapters from

Betty Guille

31

Actions:

21. Standing up a new Major Award Nominations Committee – Contact Wayne Hurwitz [action GEPC Awards – Essam Khalil]

25. GEPC Awards – Figure out possible award nominations for Green Engineering related people or projects (RCEE, ERA, SUGAR, MIT Double Bubble D8, ???) – Essam Khalil

26. Identify SciTech16, Aviation 16, and P&E 16 GEPC Technical Chairs – Ruben Del Rosario – Franz-Josef

27. Develop process for Green Engineering Best Presentation Award – Essam and Conference Subcommittee

28. Publish 1st Newsletter – Tayo Ladeinde (Marty to send intro paragraph)29. Figure out status of Engine Design Competition & GEPC Role – Ian Halliwell, Jeff

Hamstra, Tarek Abdel-Salam

30. Send out email to enable/energize liaison activities – TBD31. Find new lead for Green Aviation – Marty & Leadership Team

32





time is available)

33





time is available)

34

Update on Forums

Briefing to Technical Activities Committee6 May 2015

Dates & Venues

• SciTech 4-8 January 2016, Manchester Grand Hyatt, San Diego,

CA 9-13 January 2017, Gaylord Texan, Grapevine, TX 8-12 January 2018, Gaylord Palms, Orlando, FL

• DEFENSE 8-10 March 2016, Applied Physics Lab/Johns Hopkins

University, Laurel, MD– Date available spring 2016 (not under contract)

36

Dates & Venues (continued)

• AVIATION 13-17 June 2016, Washington Hilton, Washington, DC 5-9 June 2017, Sheraton Downtown Denver, Denver,

CO• Propulsion & Energy

25-27 July 2016, Salt Palace Convention Center, Salt Lake City, Utah

10-12 July 2017, Hyatt Regency, Atlanta, Georgia

37


• SPACE 12-15 September 2016, Long Beach Convention

Center, Long Beach, California Out year options being explored based on suggested

cities and RFP responses:– Orlando, 12-16 September 2017– New Orleans, 2018 dates TBD (focused on early to mid

September)

38


• Staff exploring multi-year contract with Hyatt SPACE 2017 (Orlando) SPACE 2018 (New Orleans) SciTech 2019 (7-11 January, San Diego) SciTech 2020 (dates TDB, Orlando)

• Deal would include concessions leading to cost savings for all four forums

39


• AVIATION and P&E 2018 options being explored based on cities suggested and RFP responses AVIATION 2018

– Chicago: 11-15 June or 18-22 June– Atlanta: 25-29 June or 18-23 June (AV14 in Atlanta)– Honolulu: 25-29 June

P&E 2018– Cincinnati: 23-25 July– New Orleans: 9-11 July (incomplete bid; staff requesting more

information)– Also looked at Indianapolis but not available

40

Organizers: SciTech 2016

• Executive Steering Committee Robie Samanta Roy, Lockheed Martin Corporation Richard Christiansen, Sierra Lobo, Inc. John Tracy, The Boeing Company George Lesieutre, The Pennsylvania State University General Chair: Mason Peck, Cornell University

• Forum 360 Chair: Ann Zulkosky, Lockheed Martin Corporation• Forum Technical Chairs:

Brad Burchett (ASG), Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology Jeanette Domber (ADSG), Ball Aerospace Misty Davies (ISG), NASA Ames

41

Organizers: AVIATION 2016

• Executive Steering Committee Tom Edwards, NASA Ames Research Center Todd Zarfos, The Boeing Company Michael Bragg, University of Washington General Chair: Robert Gregg, The Boeing Company

• Forum 360 Chair: Samantha Magill, Honda Aircraft Company• Forum Technical Chairs:

Cees Bil (AASG), RMIT University LaTunia Melton (ASG), NASA Langley Research Center

42

Organizers: P&E 2016

• Executive Steering Committee Michael Heil, Ohio Aerospace Institute Robert Hwang, Sandia National Laboratory Alton Romig, Lockheed Martin Aeronautics Julie Van Kleeck, Aerojet Rocketdyne General Chair: Daniel Dumbacher, Purdue University

• Forum 360 Chair: John Horack, Teledyne Brown Engineering

• Forum Technical Chair: Justin Locke, United Technologies

43

Organizers: SPACE 2016

• Staff identified candidates based on approach to SPACE 2015 and developed proposed list Young professionals serving as primary organizers Some suggested candidates are carryovers from 2015,

some are new• Will need a Forum Technical Chair to be identified

soon

44

Organizers: SPACE 2016 (proposed)

• General Chair Ariane Cornell, Business Development & Strategy, Blue Origin

• Forum 360 Co-chairs Aaron Parness, NASA JPL [Carryover] Brad Steinfeldt, Georgia Tech

• Other Members Kate Stambaugh, JHU/APL [Carryover] Justin Kugler, Center for the Advancement of Science in Space [Carryover] Tim Hinerman, Blue Origin A.C. Charani, Virgin Galactic Kristen Bloshock, Lockheed Martin

45

Organizers: General

• Staff compiled suggested candidates for General and Forum 360 Chairs for SciTech, AVIATION, and P&E 2017 and developed short list

• Targeting to confirm candidates by mid- to late- June

46

Organizers: SciTech 2017 Short List

• General Chair Werner Dahm, Foundation Professor of Aerospace &

Mechanical Engineering, Arizona State University Juan Alonso, Associate Professor, Department of

Aeronautics and Astronautics, Stanford University • Forum 360 Chair

Robbie Robertson, Air Force Research Laboratory

47

Organizers: AVIATION 2017 Short List

• General Chair Fay Collier, Project Manager of the Environmentally

Responsible Aviation Project, Aeronautics Research Mission Directorate

Pres Henne, Gulfstream (Retired)• Forum 360 Chair

Ed Waggoner, Program Director, Integrated Aviation Systems, NASA ARMD

Ella Atkins, Associate Professor, Aerospace Engineering, University of Michigan

48

Organizers: P&E 2017 Short List

• General Chair Meyer “Mike” Benzakein, Professor, Mechanical &

Aerospace Engineering, Ohio State University (Retired GE)

Lourdes Maurice, Executive Director for Environment and Energy, FAA

• Forum 360 Chair Ruben Del Rosario, Manager of the Fixed Wing

Project, Fundamental Aeronautics Program, NASA John Olson, Vice President, Sierra Nevada

49

Organizers: Expanding the Pool

• Process for identifying chair candidates solicits feedback from stakeholder groups Board of Directors, Corporate Member Committee

• Not receiving enough suggestions to build a large pool of candidates

• Suggestions we receive are usually limited to AIAA members, volunteers from TAC structure Need to broaden the net to provide new ideas, fresh approaches Individuals outside of our community help us expand programmatically

and increase relevance Opportunity to engage potential individuals who should be AIAA

members but are not50





time is available)

52

Documents

Green Engineering PC General Meeting – Aviation 2015 - Dallas June 24, 2015 Marty Bradley Program Committee Chair [email protected]