Upload
giang-dang
View
218
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
1/35
GOVERNANCEINEDUCATIONINVIETNAM
DangHoang-GiangDangNgoc-Dinh
PhungThanhXuanNguyenVanPhu
CenterforCommunitySupportandDevelopmentStudies
(CECODES)
April2013
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
2/35
TableofContents
1. INTRODUCTION.......................................................................................................................32. OVERVIEW................................................................................................................................4
3. THESCHOOLNETWORK.......................................................................................................6
4. FINANCIALMANAGEMENT..................................................................................................84.1. STATEFUNDING............................................................................................................................8 4.2. TUITIONANDFEES....................................................................................................................11
5. PERSONNELMANAGEMENT..............................................................................................145.1. TEACHERSRERUITMENT.......................................................................................................14 5.2. PRINCIPALSASSIGNMENT......................................................................................................18
6. STAKEHOLDERSINASCHOOL..........................................................................................197. QUALITYASSURANCE..........................................................................................................21
8. CONTENT.................................................................................................................................26
9. CONCLUSION..........................................................................................................................27
10. ANNEXES...............................................................................................................................31ANNEX1:GRAPHICOFKEYRESONSIBILITIESANDACCOUNTABILITYLINKAGES..........31ANNEX2:REGULATIONSFORPRIVATESCHOOLS...................... .................. .................. ............32ANNEX3:LISTOFINTERVIEWS.................. ................. .................. .................. .................. ...............34
11. REFERENCES........................................................................................................................35
ThisreportwaspreparedwithsupportfromtheWorldBank.Thefindings,interpretations,andconclusionsexpressedhereinarethoseoftherauthorsanddonotnecessarilyreflecttheviewsoftheWorldBank.TheWorldBankdoesnotguaranteetheaccuracyofthedataandinformationincludedinthiswork.
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
3/35
1.INTRODUCTION
InthepastdecadesVietnamhasachievedtremendousprogressintermofschooleducation.From2001to2010,thenetenrollmentratesofprimaryeducationcontinuedtogrowfromanimpressive94%to97%.Itgrewfrom70%to83%forlowersecondaryeducation,andfrom33%to50%foruppersecondaryeducation.Thecountryhasestablishedanextensivenetworkofeducationinstitutions,allowingrelativelyeasyaccesstoschooleducationforthewholepopulation,withoneprimaryschoolineachcommune,onelowersecondaryschoolperoneortwocommunes,andatleastoneuppersecondaryschoolineverydistrict.Thebudgetallocatedforeducationnowaccountstoapprox.20%ofthetotalnationalbudget,ahighlevelininternationalcomparison,withmoreresourcesmobilizedfromthesocietythroughtheso-called
socializationprocess.Vietnamhasbasicallysucceededineradicatingilliteracy,achievingnationalcompulsoryprimaryeducationuniversalization,andmovingtowardsdoingthesameforpreschoolandlowersecondaryeducation.Whiletheachievementsareimpressiveandwellacknowledged,ontheotherhand,seriousconcernshavebeenincreasinglyraisedthatVietnamseducationisnotwellpositionedfortheageofglobalizationandinternationalcompetition.Giventhehighlevelofinvestment,theeducationqualityandefficacyclearlyneedimprovement.Curriculum,teachingmethodsandmanagementstructuresareconsideredtobenotadequateforthedevelopmentofsoftskills,creativeandcriticalthinking,andpracticalskillsforpupils,whicharecriticallyrequiredforahighqualitylaborforceneededfor
thecountrysindustrialization.The2011-2020VietnamDevelopmentStrategymakeitaclearprioritytofundamentallyreformthenationaleducationsystem.Someofthekeychallengeslieinthegovernancestructuresofthesector.Asinanyotherpublicsector,deliveringqualitypublicservicesineducationrequirescleardefinitionofresponsibilityforpolicymakingandimplementation,aswellaswell-definedaccountabilityfortheirresults.Efficientpolicyformulationandimplementation,inturn,requirestimelyanddetailedinformationoninputssuchasfinance,humanresources,etc.andoutcomes(e.g.enrollments,attendance,etc.).Intermofaccountability,itisimportanttoconsiderbothdownwardandupwardaccountabilitylinkagesbetweenserviceprovidersanddifferentlevelsofstateagencies,aswellashorizontalaccountabilitiestowardscitizens.However,itappearsthatoverall,theallocationofresponsibilityacrosstheeducationsysteminVietnamatpresentisdiffuse,anditisnotclearwhoisaccountableforwhichresultsinpractice.Lackoftimely,comprehensiveanddetailedinformationoninputsandoutcomepresentschallengesforpolicymakingandfurtherweakensaccountabilityforresultstobothgovernmentandnon-governmentstakeholders.Againstthisbackground,thisreportcontributestotheunderstandingofthecurrentgovernancearrangementsintheschooleducationsystembydescribingcurrent
functionsandresponsibilitiesofthekeystakeholders.Itdoessoby(1)reviewingandsummarizingrelevantlegaldocuments,and(2)gatheringinformationthroughdesk
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
4/35
researchandin-depthinterviewswithvariousrelevantgovernmentagenciesandstakeholdersatthecentrallevel,aswellasintwoprovinces,HaNoiandThanhHoa.Combiningthedejureframeworkandevidencegatheredfromthefieldwork,thereportaimstopointoutmaincriticalgovernanceissueswhichimpacttheperformanceofthesector.Inotherwords,itaimstoanswerthequestion:whatarethechallengesofthe
currentsetupthathinderthesystemfromdeliveringqualityineducationservices.Whilethereportlooksatgovernanceaspectsofthesector(whichareexpressedthroughfunctionsandresponsibilitiesofactorsandtheiraccountabilitylinkages),itdoesnotlookatpedagogicalconcern,suchasqualityoftextbooksorthesuitabilityofthecurriculum.Thereportisstructuredasfollowing:Chapter2ofthereportgivesanoverviewofthenationaleducationsystem.Chapter3coversthemanagementoftheschoolnetwork,includingestablishingnewschools,andmergingandclosingofschools.Chapter4dealswiththefinancialmanagementofschools,lookingathowstatefundingisallocatedandused,aswellasattuitionsandfees,parentalcontributionsandothersourcesofschoolsincome.Chapter5looksatpersonnelmanagement,includinghiringandtransferofteachers,principalsassignment,andissuesrelatedtotheirqualificationandin-servicetraining.
Chapter6coversSchoolCouncilandParentsCouncilthatare,besideschoolmanagementandteachers,keystakeholdersinschools.Chapter7looksataspectsofqualityassurance,includingperformanceassessmentofteachersandprincipals,theaccreditationofschools,andtheNationalStandard.Chapter8coversgovernanceissuesrelatedtocontent,e.g.curriculumandtextbooks.Finally,chapter9providesaconcludinganalysisofgovernanceissuesandtheirimpactonthesystemsperformance.Whilethereportfocusesonpublicschoolsasprovidersofpublicservices,Annex1givessomebasicoverviewontherelevantregulationsforprivateschools.
2.OVERVIEWTherearetwoformsofeducationalinstitutions:publicandprivate.Forkindergartens,thereisathirdform,calledpeople-founded(dnlp),whicharefundedbylocalcommunities,andnotfinancedfromthestatebudget.Accordingtothecircular
11/2009/TT-BGDT,fortheprimaryandsecondarylevel,people-foundedschoolshave
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
5/35
tobetransformedintoeitherthepublicorprivateform.Thetransformationisunderwayandissupposedtobefinishedin2013.Figure1showsthestructureofthenationaleducationsystem.
(Source:Dr.VuDinhChuan,DirectorGeneral,SecondaryEducationDepartment,MinistryofEducationandTraining,TheDevelopmentofBasicEducationinVietnamduringtheintegration,2011)
Earlychildhoodeducation(ECE):ECEisforchildrenfrom3monthsto6yearsold.ECEinstitutionsinclude:(1)Crches:forchildrenfrom3monthsto3yearsold;(2)Kindergarten:36yearsold;(3)Mmnon:combinationoftheprevioustwo(3months6yearsold).PublicECEinstitutionsareunderthemanagementofdistrict
government;privateECEinstitutionsareunderthemanagementofcommunegovernment.Primaryschool:Durationofprimaryschoolsis5years(1stto5thgrade).Theentryis6yearsold.Primaryschoolsareunderthemanagementofthedistrictgovernment.Secondaryschool:Lowersecondaryschoolsarefrom6thto9thgrade(4years).Entryis11yearsold.Lowersecondarylevelhasanexaminationatgrade9.Uppersecondaryschoolsarefrom10thto12thgrade(3years).Entryis15yearsold.Uppersecondarylevelhasanentranceandexitexam.
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
6/35
Thealternativetotheuppersecondarytrackisthevocationaltrainingtrack,whichlastsfrom6monthsto3years.Similarly,aftergraduationfromuppersecondarylevel,vocationaltrainingcanbetakenasanalternativetohighereducation.LowersecondaryschoolsareunderthemanagementofthedistrictPeoplesCommittee
(government).UppersecondaryschoolsareunderthemanagementoftheprovincialPeoplesCommittee.ThecentralMinistryofEducationandTraining(MOET)isinchargeofsettingthecurriculum,publishingthetextbooks,issuingregulationsonteachingandassessments,andonthesystemofdegreesandcertificates.ThevastmajorityofVietnamsschoolsarepublicschools(evenattertiarylevel,themostprivatizedlevel,privatehighereducationinstitutionsaccounttoonly11%ofallstudents).
TheprovincialPeopleCommittee(PC)issupportedandadvisedbytheDepartmentofEducationandTraining(DOET)inmanagingtheireducationsector,thedistrictPCissupportedandadvisedbyBureauofEducationandTraining(BOET).DOETandBOETgiveoutinstructionsintermofcontent,programandpoliciesasissuedbyMOET,andareinchargeofinspectingpolicyimplementationandactivitiesandqualityoftheschools.DOETandBOETaresubjecttodirectionandmanagementofthePeoplesCommitteesintermsoforganizationalstructure,staffsizeandtasks;whileintechnicalandprofessionaltermstheyaresubjecttotheMOETsdirection,guidanceandsupervision.
3.THESCHOOLNETWORKThischapterprovidesanunderstandingaboutrolesandresponsibilitiesindevelopingandmanagingtheschoolnetwork.Itdealswithaspectssuchasopeninganewschool,mergingorclosingschoolsandrelatedgovernanceissues.Establishingnewschools
Foreachoftheschoollevels(ECE,primary,loweranduppersecondary),MOETdefinesminimalrequirements(e.g.aboutsizeandqualificationofhumanresources,infrastructure,etc.)foranewschooltobeestablished.
Theestablishingofanewschoolofanylevelrequirestwolicenses:- Licensetofoundaschool(giyphpthnhlptrng)- Licensetoconducteducationalactivities(giyphphotnggio
dc)
Licensetofoundaschool:ThecommunePeoplesCommittee(PC)isinchargeofcreatingtheproposaltofoundapublickindergarten,aprimaryschooloralowersecondaryschool.Inthiscase,theproposalisforthedistrictPCtoapprove.
Foruppersecondaryschools,thedistrictPCisinchargeofcreatingtheproposal,whichistobeapprovedbyChairmanoftheprovincesPC.
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
7/35
Forkindergartens,primaryandlowersecondaryschools,thedirectorofBOETgrantsthelicensetoconducteducationalactivities.Foruppersecondaryschools,thedirectorofDOETgrantsthelicense.
Whiletheformerlicenseisgrantedwhentheauthorityinchargeseestheproposalasfittingtotheneedsanddevelopmentplanofthecommunity,thelatterlicenseisonlygrantedwhenthenewschoolcanactuallyshowtherequiredconditionsintermofinfrastructureandhumanresources.Theauthoritytograntthelicenseisalsotheauthoritytoevokethelicense.AlthoughMOETprescribesindetailstherequirementstobemetforaschooltobefounded,itisunderstandablethatmanyschools,especiallythoseinpoorerareas,cannotmeettheminimalrequirements.Inthe1990s,thenationalgoalwastohaveallchildrenaged614tocompleteprimaryeducation.Asaresult,thenetworkofprimaryschoolsexpandedrapidlyandreachedallcommunesinthecountry.Oftenviasatelliteschoolsitwasensuredthatnocommuneswerewithoutaprimaryschoolandnovillageswerewithoutprimaryclasses.Thesesatelliteschoolsareoftenrudimentaryintermsofbothphysicalconditionsandhumanresources.1Whileschoolsinruralareasmaylackbothhumanresourcesandinfrastructure,manyschoolsindenselypopulatedurbanareas,suchasHanoi,suffershortagesofspace.
Closing/mer
gingschools
Decisionstosplit,mergeorcloseECE,primaryandlowersecondary
schoolsarewiththechairmanofthedistrictPC.Decisionsofsplitting,mergingandclosinguppersecondaryschoolsarewiththechairmanoftheprovincialPC.Thesedecisionscanbeofhighlypoliticalnature,asseeninthecaseofThanhHoabelow.
CasestudyThanhHoa
Asaconsequenceofcontinuinglydecreasingbirthrates,country-widethenumberofprimaryandlowersecondarypupilshasbeengoingdown.(Inthesametime,thenumberofECEpupilsandofuppersecondarypupilshasbeenslightlyincreasingorremainingthesameduetohigherratesofenrollmentattheselevels.)ThissituationisstronglyexperiencedinThanhHoa.Accordingtoaninformantintheprovincesleadership,inagivenyear,thedeclineofprimarypupilsmayequalto600classes,oflowersecondarypupilsequalingto400classes.Tenyearsago,thetotalnumberofpupilsintheprovincewere1.1millions,comparedto.75millionsnow.In1995,therewere0.5millionsprimarypupilsand0.4millionslowersecondarypupils,comparedto0.2millionsand0.2millionsnow.
1
Forexample,InHaTinh,aprimaryschoolhas4classesbutonly2classroomsandoneteacherintotal(http://vietnamnet.vn/vn/giao-duc/92987/truong-co-duy-nhat-mot-giao-vien.html)
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
8/35
Asaresulttheprovincesleadershiphasfacedtheneedtore-organizetheschoolnetwork.Schoolswithlessthen6classesaresupposedtobemergedwithanotherone;satellitesaretobemovedtothemainschool.Forexample,inHauLoc,thedistrictwevisited,thereare6schoolswith
justonly4or5classeseach.Thedistrictplanstoreducethenumberoflowersecondaryschoolsfromcurrently28to22.Therearetwodifferentwaysofmerging:horizontal(mergingschoolofthesamelevel,e.g.primary,ofdifferentcommunesintoone);andvertical(mergingschoolsofdifferentlevels,e.g.primaryandlowersecondary,ofthesamecommunityintoone).AccordingtotheThanhHoaexperience,whichislikelytobesimilarinanyotherprovince,horizontalmergingpresentsanumberofspecificdifficulties:typically,communesdonotwanttoloosetheirschool,butwanttokeepitasaprestige.Thereisalsoresistancefromthepopulationtosendtheirkidtoaschoolinanothercommune.Thedistrict/provincesgovernmentprobablywouldhavefewerproblemswithclosingormergingschools,asunlikecommunes,aschoolisnotaobjectofprestigeforthem.Oneoftheissuesofverticalmergingisthatinsubjectswithashortageofteachers(e.g.Englishorarts),theseteacherswillendupteachingawiderangeofclassesfromprimarytosecondarylevel.Redundancyofstaff,includingnon-teachingstaff,suchasaccountantsorlibrarians,
and,seeminglyhardertodealwith,principals,isanotherissue.Duetopersonalconnectionsofprincipalstouppergovernmentlevelsanddifferentcommunesinfluenceonthedistrict,amergingdecisionmaybebasedlessonconsiderationsofoptimizingqualityandcostoftheservices.
4.FINANCIALMANAGEMENT4.1.STATEFUNDING
Allocationofstatebudget
Accordingtodecentralizedresponsibilityassignedtogovernmentlevels,publickindergartens,primaryandlowersecondaryschoolsarefundedbythedistrictsbudget.Statefundingforuppersecondaryschoolscomesfromtheprovincesbudget.Districtsplantheireducationbudgetbasedoninputsfromschoolsintheirterritory.Inturn,provincesplantheireducationbudgetbasedoninputsfromtheirdistricts.Apparentlythereisnegotiationattheprovinciallevelwhenitcomestoallocatingfundingtothedistricts,as
wellasatthedistrictlevel,whenitcomestoallocatingfundingtothecommunes.Asdiscussedbelow,thequalityofdatareportedupthe
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
9/35
hierarchyisquestionable,bothduetolackofreportingcapacity,lackofproperITtools,andalsoduetovulnerabilitytointentionalmanipulation,e.g.ofnumberofstudentsorteachers.Thisissueishardtobringundercontrolwithaweaksystemofinspectionandcontrolfromhigherlevelsofgovernment.
Themechanismsusedtoplanandallocateeducationfundingcouldbe:
- Basedonteachersheadcount- Basedonpupilsheadcount- Basedonclassroomsnumber- Amixoftheabove.
Thestatefundingcoversthesalarybudgetandoperationalbudget,butnocapitalinvestment.Higherschoolleveltypicallyreceivedhigherperheadamount.Perheadamountsalsovarydependingonsocio-economicregionwithinaprovinces,andarehigherinpoorerregions.InThanhHoaandHaNoi,theprovincestheteamvisitedforfieldwork,itseemsthatthecommonmechanismforbudgetallocationfromprovincetodistrictsistheonebasedonpupilsheadcount,althoughdistrictscandeployquitedifferentmechanismstoallocatefundingtoschools.
CasestudyThanhHoa
InThanhHoa,budgetamountsperpupilvaryfromschoolleveltolevelandfromregiontoregion.Thereare4typesofregion:urbanruralmidlandhighland.Theperheadamountislowestforurban,and
highestforhighlandregion.Forkindergartens,statebudgetrangesfrom1.3millionsVND/pupil(urban)to2.1millionsVND/pupil(highland).Forprimarylevel,theamountperpupilvariesfrom2.8millionsVND(urban)to4.8millionsVND(highland).Forlowersecondary,theperpupilamountrangesfrom3.8millionsVND(urban)to5.3millionsVND(highland).Therangeforuppersecondaryisfrom4.3millionsVND(urban)to5.9millionsVND(highland).(Forcomparison,incentralHanoi,theperpupilamountatprimarylevelis3.0millions,lowersecondary3.7millionsanduppersecondarylevel4.0millions.)Theserangesaredefinedforevery5years,thecurrentonesbeingappliedfrom20112015.Whiletheserangesseemtobeusedforprovincetodistributefundingtothedistricts,thedistrictsmaywanttoadjust,makeexceptionorusedifferentmechanismwhenallocatingbudgettoschools.Forexample,aruralschoolveryclosetoanurban
areamaystillgettheurbanrate,butnotthehigherruralrate.AlowersecondaryschoolinThanhHoastatedthattheirannualoperational
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
10/35
budgetiscalculatedasfollow:50000VNDperpupilperyear,plus2millionsVNDperclassperyear,plus15millionsontopofthat,whichisquitedifferentthantheperheadmechanismdescribedbyofficialsattheprovinciallevel.Ingeneral,schoolswithtoofewpupilsmayreceiveadditionalfunding,althoughthereseemstobenoclearlydefined
flooringlevel.Teachersalary
Teachersarepaidaccordingtothepublicemployeeschemeappliedinthepublicsector.Themechanismregardingteacherpaymentvaries.Insomecasesschoolspayteachersdirectly,whileinothercasesthedistrictgovernmentconductsthepayment.Inbothcases,anewcentrallyissuedregulationrequiresthatpaymenthastobedonethroughabank.Whilethebenefitofthisregulationisunclear,itleadstotheissuethatteachersinremoteschoolshavetotravelday(s)togettoabankoranATMinthedistrictforacashwithdraw.2Oneissuewiththefundingallocationmechanismbasedonpupilsheadcountisthatthepartforteacherssalarycouldrepresentaverydifferentshareinthetotalschoolbudget.Schoolswithmoreseniorteachers(whoreceivehighersalariesandsocialbenefits)willenduppayingoverproportionallyforsalary,thusleftwithsmallerbudgetsharefortheiroperation.Thesameproblemisfacedbyschoolswithdecreasingpupilnumber(andgrowingteacher-studentratio),astheydonthavetoautonomytoadjustdowntheirteachingbody.
Budgetforschooloperation
Basedoninterviewsanddesk-research,itseemsthattypicallyabout90%ofstatefundingisusedforsalaries,whiletheremaining10%isusedforschoolsoperation.However,inthedistrictwevisitedinThanhHoa,onlyabout7%ofschoolbudgetisavailableforschoolsoperation.Wearetoldthatinsomeotherdistricts,thesalarypartaccountsupto97%.InaprimaryschoolinThanhHoa,theoperationbudgetisaslittleas40000VND/pupil/year.TheDOETtypicallywillkeepsome%ofthenon-salarypartoftheschoolstofinancetheirownactivities,suchastraining,interschoolmeetings,organizingcampaigns(thidua),etc.,furthermorereducing
theschoolsbudgetforoperation.IncaseofThanhHoaandHanoi,60%ofcollectedtuitionscanbeusedforschoolsoperation,theremaining40%topupitssalarybudget.SchoolshavetosubmittheirmonthlyfinancialplantotheStateTreasurytobeapproved,whichcreatesunnecessarybureaucracy.HanoisschoolshavetoseekStateTreasurysapprovalfortheirfinancialplanonlyonceatthebeginningoftheyear.
2Seeforexampleamediareport:http://m.vietnamnet.vn/vn/giao-duc/96196/giao-vien-meo-mat-nhan-luong-qua-the.html
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
11/35
Capitalinvestment
Elitepublicschool(trngim)
Poorerprovincescomplainaboutthelackofstatefundingforcapitalinvestmentforlargerrepair,extensionorre-constructionofschools.Theoperationalshareof10%andlessoftotalbudgetistoosmallforlargerinvestment.Ifavailable,fundingforcapitalinvestmenttypicallycomefromnationalprograms,ODAordevelopmentprojects.
Asresourcesarelimited,localgovernmentshavetheincentivetoinvestinafewschoolsforshowcase,e.g.togetthemtheNationalStandardCertificate(seealsoElitepublicschoolbelow).Whencapitalinvestmentisconducted,schoolsarejustbeneficiaries,andaretypicallynotinvolvedinthedesign,contractingandconstructionprocess,whichisinthehandofthestateagenciescontrollingthefinancialresources(e.g.district/provincialgovernmentorthedepartmentmanagingtheODAproject).Thiscanresultinamismatchofactualschoolsneedsandtheinvestmentdecision.Forexample,theprincipalofaHanoilowersecondaryschoolaskedthedistrictgovernmenttoplantshadegivingtreesintheschoolyardwhenherschoolwasbeingconstructed,butinsteadtheyplantedtreesshootingintoheight,givinghardlyanyshadingeven5yearslater.Inanothercase,thetoiletwasbuiltforadultsize,andneededtoberebuiltlaterbytheschoolitself.NotallschoolsinVietnamreceiveequaltreatment,butinvestmentsoftengointoselectiveschools,calledtrngim.Theseelite
schoolstendtohavebetterqualifiedteachersandperformaboveaverage(e.g.reflectedbynumberofstudentsgettingintowell-knownuniversitiesorgettinghighscoresinprovincialandnationalcompetitions).Theyareoftenfavoritechoicesforlocalpoliticianstosendtheirchildrento,andasaresult,oftenreceivingover-proportionallyattentionandcapitalinvestment.Thisrepresentsaself-repeatingcycle:betterschoolsattractchildrenofhigh-rankingpublicofficials,thereforereceivingfavorabletreatmentintermofhumanresourcesandfinance,whichinturnwidensthequalitygapbetweenthemandtherest.Forbothteachersandpupils,aplaceinaneliteschoolishighlydesirable,leadingtoparentsandteacherstopayconsiderableinformalpaymentstobeacceptedbytheschool.AccordingtoaninformantinHanoi,parentspayupto1,500USDfortheirkidstogetaplaceinareputablelowersecondaryschool,atthesametimeacceptingcrowdedclasseswithupto50pupilsduetohighdemand.
4.2.TUITIONANDFEES
Useoftuitionand PrimaryschoolsinVietnamarefreeoftuition.Forkindergartenandsecondaryschools,thetuitionframe(minandmax)issetbythe
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
12/35
fees Vietnamesegovernment.Itshouldnotexceed5%ofaveragedincomeofthefamily.Theaveragedincomelevelsaredefinedbythecentralgovernmentnationallyforthreeregions:urban,ruralandmountainousandsubjecttobeadjustedannuallywithinflation.Accordingtodecree49/2010/N-CP,fortheschoolyear2010-11,thetuitionlevelsfor
kindergartensandsecondaryschoolsrangefrom40K-200K/pupil/monthforurban,from20K-80K/pupil/monthforruralandfrom5K-40K/pupil/monthformountainousareas.Withinthisframework,tuitionsaresuggestedbythelocalgovernmentinchargeofmanagingtheschoollevel,andformallyapprovedbythePeopleCouncil.Schoolscankeeptuitionsandentryfeespaidbytheirpupils.MOET,MOFandMOLISAtogetherdefinepoliciesforreducingorwaivingtuitionsforthepoor.Therevenuelossduetoreductionandwaivingarere-fundedbythedistrict/provincetotheschool.InbothThanhHoaandHanoi,40%ofthetuitionissupposedtogotoschoolssalarybudget.Theremainingpartisusedforschoolsoperation.Decree49/2010/N-CPallowsschoolsthatofferhigh-qualitycontenttorequesthighertuition.Thehighertuitionlevelsaretobeapprovedbytheprovincialgovernment.HoChiMinhCityhasbeenpilotingthismodelandgrantingpermissiontosomeschoolsaskingfortuitionlevels
significantlyhigherthanthecitysstandards.Forexample,110KVND/pupil/monthischargedatuppersecondaryschoolNguyenThaiBinh.Inexchangeofqualityofinternationalstandard,uppersecondaryschoolLeQuyDonasksfor890.000VND/pupil/month.Theseschoolsusethetuitionstoofferfull-dayschooling,moreclasses(andhencehavinglowerpupilnumberperclass),upgradeinfrastructure,labsandITequipment,andgiveteacherssalarieshigherthanthenationalstandards.Thereisacontroversialdebatearoundtheseschoolsastheystillreceivefullpublicfundinglikeothers,representingahiddenformofstatesubsidyfortherich.
Extraclasses Extraclasseshavebecomeamajorissueinschooleducationthathas
receivedheavycriticismfromthepublicandmedia.theyarepredominantlyanurbanphenomenon.Whatstartedoutasafterschoolsupportforunderperformingpupilshasbecameafullfletchedindustrywherealmostallstudents,notjustweakones,andalreadyatprimarylevel,goforseveraltimesafterschoolandatweekendtoextraclasses.Themajorityofextraclassesarenowmeansforteacherstogetextraincome,andstudentsgoingtherewouldeitherlearnthesamecontenttheyhadinthemorning,oradditionalacademiccontentwhichaddsuptotheirheavyscheduleandleavingnotimeforphysicalandcreative
activities.
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
13/35
ThesituationhasbecomesocriticalthatMOETissuedacircularinMay2012(17/2012/TT-BGDT),requiringallextraclassestoapplyforalicensefromBOETorDOET.Thelicenseissupposedtoregulatethatextraclassesarereallybasedonstudentsneedsanddonotbecomeexcessive.RecentlyDOETsandBOETsofsomeprovinceshave
conductedinspectiontoclosedownextraclassesandhandoutdisciplinarywarningtoteachers.However,itisunlikelythattheseactionswouldbesuccessfulinthelongterm,asitdoesnotsolvetherootissues,whichareteachersalariesandparentsfearoftheirkidsreceivingunfavorabletreatmentiftheystayawayfromtheextraclasses.
Parentscontribu-tion,extrafees,andotherrevenues
Whilecontributionsmobilizedfromparentsarenegligibleinruralareas,itcanbesignificantsourcesofrevenueforschoolsinurban,better-offareas.Parentswouldcontributetoraiseteachersincome,toimproveinfrastructureandteachingequipment,tosettletheschoolsbills,etc.Whileingeneralitisapositivetrendtomobilizesocietysresourcesforeducation,itcanalsohaveseveralnegativeconsequences.Oneisinequality,asschoolswithpupilsfromwealthyfamilieswillbelikelytogetmorecontribution,thussettingthemselvesfurtherapartfromotherpublicschools.Eveninsideaschool,discriminatingstandardsexistasparentstargettheirinvestmentjustintotheirclass(calledVIPclasses).Thereisahighcompetitionforwealthyparentstomakeinfromalpaymentstotheschooltogettheirchildrenintotheseeliteclasses,whichwereoriginallydesignedfortalentedstudents.3Inmanycases,pupilswithhigherparentscontributionsarereportedto
betreatedfavorablybyteachers.
Someschoolsaskfornon-voluntaryparentscontributioninformofextrafeesthatareinprincipleillegal.Thefeesmaybefortheelectricitybill,salaryofcleanersandguards,kitchenstools,etc.Inmanycases,thiscreateshighpressuretonotwell-offfamilies.Furthermore,alackofbothtransparentbookkeepingandparentsinvolvementinvitemisusebyschools.Currentlytheissueisdrawingmuchcriticismfromthemediaandpublic.
Decree43/2006/N-CPenablesschoolstohavefinancialautonomy
(tchtichnh),meaningtheycouldmobilizeexternalresourcesbesidesthestatefunding.Schoolsmaybeabletofindcompanyssponsorships,Englishtrainingfreeofchargefortheirteachers,orsummercampsforpupils.Schoolsinurbanareasmayusetheirfacilitiesforrentforothereducationalactivitiesfromoutsideofschool,ornon-educationalactivitiessuchasweddingparties,etc.Ortheyorganizefundraisingactivitiesthroughculturalandsportactivities.Ingeneral,successwilldependonsocio-economicconditionsofthelocalityandentrepreneurshipofschoolsmanagement.Hence,inrural
3TudaythemtoilopVIP,VietnamNet,24Oct2012(http://tuanvietnam.vietnamnet.vn/2012-10-23-su-tha-hoa-cua-giao-duc-tu-day-them-toi-lop-vip)
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
14/35
areas,thechallengestomobilizeexternalresourcesaremuchbigger.Additionally,schoolmanagementintheseareasistypicallymuchlessdynamicandcapableoffindingalternativesourceofincomeandsponsorship.
Capacityinfinancialmanagement
Lackingskillsoffinancialmanagementisoneapparentissue,whichcouldespeciallybeobservedwiththeschoolmanagementoflowerlevelsandinpoorerregions.Principalsusuallycomepurelyfromateachingbackgroundandareusedtoonlyimplementinstructions,andlacktheabilitytoorganizeanddeveloptheschool.Mostlackmanagerialandentrepreneurialskills.Inanumberofourinterviews,theprincipalsdidnotevenknowmostbasicfinancialdetailsofhis/herschool,suchastheschemeusedforfundingallocation,andhadtorelyontheaccountant.Ontopofthat,insomecasesthereisalackofresourcesinaccounting,hinderingschoolscapacity.WearetoldthatinThanhHoa,severalschoolsmayshareoneaccountant,asduetolimitedbudget,theyarenotabletorecruitmore.
5.PERSONNELMANAGEMENT5.1.TEACHERSRERUITMENT
Teachersrecruitment
Policiesregardingteachersrecruitmentcanvaryfromprovincetoprovince,evenfromdistricttodistrict.Themostcommonapproachis
thattheprovincesPCisinchargeofhiringforuppersecondaryschools,anddistrictsPCforalllowerschoollevels,althoughinsomeprovinces(e.g.Hanoi),uppersecondaryschoolshavetheautonomytohireteachersthemselves.Detailsofhiringprocedures,suchaswhositsintheselectioncommittee,alsochangefromdistrict/provinceschairmantochairmanandoftenreflectspowerplaybetweendepartmentsofthelocalgovernment.Inmostcases,theprocessisledbyDOHA/BOHA.Annually,schoolssendtheirhumanresourcesdemandtoBOET/DOET,whichworksoutahumanresourceplan(slngbinch)withDOHA.TheplanistobeapprovedbyPCoftheappropriatelevel(provincialforuppersecondaryanddistrictforallschoolsoflowerlevels).Hiringisacompetitiveprocessbasedonanexamandaninterview(thituyn).Inruralandremoteareas,wheretherearemuchfewerapplicationstofillthedemand,theprocesscanbebasedonevaluationofuniversitygraduationresults(xttuyn).Thereareregulationsontheratioofteachersperclass,althoughthisseemsdifferfromMOETto
DOETlevel.Forexample,inThanhHoawearetoldthatMOETsettheteachersperclassratiotobe2.25(e.g.aschoolwith20classesshould
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
15/35
have45teachers),whiletheratiosetbyThanhHoaDOETis1.98.Thelackofschoolsautonomyinhiringtheirteachersisoneoftheissuesmostcriticizedbyourinformants.TheofficialreasoningfromDOHAandBOHAisthatschoolsdonthavetherightcompetencyto
hire.Thecurrentselectionprocessopensthedoortorentseekingopportunities,asitisintransparentandwithlimitedaccountability,leadingtolackingmeritocracyandmismatchesbetweendemandforteachersandactualhiring.Oneinterviewedprincipalcomplainedthatwhilesheneededateacherinmath,shereceivedtwoforsport,sentfromabove.AnecdotalevidencesuggeststhatinbigcitiessuchasHanoi,briberiesofupto100millionstolandateachingjobarepaidtothosewhoorganizeandsitintheselectioncommittee.Thecommonviewisthatteachersofmathematics,VietnameseandEnglishhaveagoodchancetorecoverthecosts(throughincomecomingfromextraclasses),whileitismuchharderforteachersofothersubjectstodoso.Accordingtosomeinformants,corruptioncangoasfarasthatthesupervisorinawrittenexamwouldimprovetheworkofthecandidatesofchoice,beforeputtingitintotheenvelopandsealit.
CasestudyThanhHoa
Duetodecreasingbirthrateanddecliningpupilnumber(seealsoChapterTheSchoolNetwork),ThanhHoahasbeenfacingtheissueofteachersurplus.Accordingtoaninformant,currentlyThanhHoahasasurplusof3500teachers.Theprovincehasbeencopingwithitby
sendingteachersintoearlyretirement(whichpresentsanextrafinancialburdenfortheprovincialbudgetandisnotpopularbyteachersastheirretirementwagesinthesecasesarelower),orbyaskingthemtoworkaslaboratoryorlibrarystaff,ortoteachothersubjectswherethereisalackofteachers,mostnotablyinEnglishorIT.Despitetheteachersurplus,districtgovernmentscontinuetohire..Asaresponse,in2011ThanhHoasPeopleCommitteeissuedastrictprovince-widebanofnewrecruitment.Beforetheban,teachersofkindergartens,primaryandlowersecondaryschoolswererecruitedbythedistrict-levelBOHA.UppersecondaryteacherswererecruitedbyDOET.(Notethisisdifferenttomostotherprovincesweknow,whereuppersecondaryteachersarerecruitedbyeitherDOHAorbyschoolsthemselveslikethecaseofHanoi.)Thebanissupposedtobeinplaceuntil2015.Ontheotherhand,insomelocationsthereisashortageofteachersforcertainschoollevels,e.g.kindergarten,whereduetohigherenrollmentrates,thenumberofpupilshasbeenontherise.InHauLocdistrictwheretheteamvisited,thereisashortageof120teachersforkindergartensthatthedistricthasnopermissiontofill.
HaTinhhasasimilarsituationwithasurplusof700teachersofall
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
16/35
CasestudyHaNoi
levels,butisexperiencinglocalshortagesinsomesubjects,suchasEnglish,sportandtechnology.4Inadistrict,12Englishteachershavetocover31primaryschools,sothateachoftheteachershastoteachin2-3schools.
Atthesametime,schoolsinremoteareasstillfacegeneralshortageofteachers,evenwithincentivesinplace.(InThanhHoa,teacherssalaryinremoteareascanbethreetimeshigherthantheurbanlevel.)Since2006,Hanoiallowsuppersecondaryschoolstorecruitteachersthemselves.DOETpublisheshiringannouncement,collectsapplications,andforwardthemtohiringschools,whichsetuptheirownselectioncommittees.Asschoolspopularityvaries,someschoolsmayhavefewornoapplications,whileinothersthenumberofapplicationsbyfaroutweighsthenumberofpositions.Thelevelofattractivenessarisesfromtheworkingenvironmentandqualityoftheschoolsmanagement,butalsosignificantlyfromitslocation.Schoolsinpoorerandmoreruralareaswillreceivefewerandlowerqualityapplications.Agreatchallengeallschoolsfaceistorecruitnon-academicstaff,suchaslibraryorlaboratorystaff,asontopoftheirlowwages,thesepositionshavenosourcesofadditionalincomes(suchasthroughextraclasses).Forallschoolsbelowuppersecondarylevel,thedistrictgovernment
(viaBOHA)isinchargeofrecruitment.Accordingtosomeinformants,somedistrictsinHanoinowallowtheprincipalofthereceivingschooltositintheselectioncommittee,whileingeneralthisisnotthecase.Aninterviewedprincipalcomplainedthatalthoughshewastotallysatisfiedwithateacherwhohasworkedforyearsundercontract(hpng),thatteacherfailedtherecruitmentexamtobecomeapublicemployeeandwasreplacedbyanewone.
Teacherstransfer
Whileregulationsregardingteachertransferdifferfromprovincetoprovince,orevendistricttodistrict,ingeneralschoolsmanagethetransferbetweeneachother.Iftheschoolsareofdifferentdistrictsthenthedistrictgovernmentshavetoapprove.Inter-provincialtransfersneedDOETsapproval.InThanhHoasince2012eventransfersbetweentwodistrictsoftheprovincehavetobeapprovedbyDOET.Thisistocutintouncontrolledhiringandtransferringdonebythedistrictgovernmentsseekingrents.Accordingtoanecdotalevidence,acommonstrategyforteacherstogetintothesystemistobehiredandassignedtoaschoolinaremotearea,
4BihaigiaovientiengAnhdaytheducVietnamNet,6Nov2012(http://vietnamnet.vn/vn/giao-duc/95348/bi-hai-chuyen-giao-vien-tieng-anh-day-the-duc.html)
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
17/35
andthentobribetobetransferredtoaschoolinamorefavorablearea.Thisrepresentsanextrachallengeforschoolsinremoteareas,whichspentefforttotrainnew,youngteachersbutonlytosystematicallyloosethemafewyearslater.
Teachersqualification
Teacherqualityandqualificationwasamainconcernofallinterviewedinformants.Inthe1980sand1990s,asVietnamexpandedtheeducationsystem,teachersweremassivelyrecruitedintothesystem,oftenwithqualitybeingcompromised.TodayVietnamnolongerfacesteachershortage,butcurrentrecruitmentqualityisstillmorethanquestionable,duetothenatureoftherecruitmentprocess.
Furthermore,theteacherseducationinpedagogicalcollegesanduniversitiesismostlyoutdated,asfutureteachersarestillmainlytrainedtojustmechanicallypassonfactsandknowledge,lackingkeyskills,suchaspresentationskillsorabilitytodealwithdiversesituationsandtoestablishrelationshipwithpupils.Overthelastdecade,inthewakeofcommercializationofhighereducation,manyteacher-traininginstitutionshaveabandonedtheirmissionofteachertrainingandupgradedintomultidisciplinarycollegesanduniversitiesinordertoattractmorestudents,seekingmoreprofit.Thenumberofprovidersislarge(morethan70),andmanywatereddowntrainingqualitybyloweringentryrequirementsinordertogetenoughenrollment.Vietnamhasnosystemforaccreditationofformalteachertraining,althoughtheneedforonehasbeenarticulatedforyears.
Thereisneitherpressurenorincentiveforteacherstoperformwell,ortoupdatetheirteachingmethodsandmaterials.Thesystemisnotdesignedtorewardorpunishteachers;thereisnomechanismtodisciplineorfireunder-performingteachers(whichisonlypossibleifteacherisabsentorhashadillegalbehavior).Annually,theaverageteacherwillattendsomein-servicetrainings,whichareusuallyorganizedbyDOETduringthesummerbreak.Thetrainingscanlastfromafewdaystoafewweeks,andcanhappenin-house,withguestspeakerscomingintoschool,orinlargecitiessuchasHanoiorHoChiMinhCity.Mostofourinformantscomplainthatsuch
trainingsaremereformality,andlackingrelevance,asthetrainingcontentisdrivenfromDOET,perceivedtobeverytheoreticalandnotpractice-oriented,anddoesnotmatchteachersneeds.Asaresult,teachersmotivationtoattendsuchtrainingsisusuallyverylow,anddrop-outratesarehigh.Schoolshavetopartlyfinancetheirteachersin-servicetrainingfromtheiroperationalbudget,whichisalreadyverylimited.5Finally,asmentionedabove,therearecasesteachersareaskedtoteach
5Formoreinformationontheissuesrelatedtoin-servicetrainingforteachers,seehttp://dantri.com.vn/giao-duc/can-doi-moi-cach-tap-huan-boi-duong-giao-vien-414834.htm
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
18/35
asubjectdifferentthantheirtraining.Forexample,countrywide,DOETsarenowfocusingonEnglish,reducingFrench.ThiscausesFrenchteacherstomovetoteachsports,citizenseducationorEnglish.
5.2.PRINCIPALSASSIGNMENTAssignmentofprincipal
Theprincipalofakindergarten,aprimaryoralowersecondaryschoolisassignedbythedistrictchairman.Theprincipalofanuppersecondaryschoolisassignedbytheprovinceschairman.TheassignmentfollowstherecommendationoftheselectioncommitteeorganizedbyBOHA(forlowersecondarylevelandbelow)orDOHA(foruppersecondarylevel).Aprincipalstermis5years.Intheory,aprincipalcanonlyholdthepositioninthesameschoolfortwoterms,althoughitcandifferinpractice.Theprincipalisaccountabletothegovernmentlevelthatassignedhim(viaBOHAorDOHA).Parentshavelittleweightinassessingtheprincipalsperformance,influencingtheschoolsoperationandholdingtheschoolsmanagementaccountable.BeingaPartymemberisakeycriteriontobeselectedasprincipal,andthePartyrepresentativeisonecorememberoftheselectioncommittee.Accordingtoaninformant,thecommitteesprocedureisinmanycasesnottransparent,asvotingresultsarenotexposedtocommitteemembers.Theprocessisalsovulnerabletonepotismand
corruptionandpossiblyatanevenhigherscalethanintheteacherrecruitmentprocess,astherentopportunityishigher.Themorewellknowntheschool,themoredesirableisitsprincipalposition(asitwouldattractmorefundingandpupils).Moreover,selectioncriteriafortheprincipalspositionareoftenformulatedinawaythatthepreferredcandidateistheonlyonefulfillingtherequirements.Asaresult,differentsetofrequirementsmayapplyforsimilarschools.Forexample,inonecase,theDOETrequiredcandidatestobeatleast5yearsyoungerthantheretirementage,whileinanothercaseitwasonly3years.Therehavebeencases
wherecadresofYouthUnionorthePartywithoutpedagogicalandteachingbackgroundwereassignedtobeprincipals.
Principalqualification
MOEThasissueddifferentqualitystandardsforprincipals(chunhiutrng)foreachoftheschoollevels.Thesestandardscover4areas:morals,politicalattitude,pedagogicalandmanagementcapabilities.Inpractice,therearedoubtsonwhetherthesestandardsareanappropriatetooltomeasureandassessquality.Mostprincipalsarepromotedfrombeingteachersandhavenoproper
traininginfinancialandpersonnelmanagement.TheAcademyofEducationManagement,aunitofMOET,holdstraininginmanagement
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
19/35
fornewprincipalsandvice-principals(aswellasforofficialsofDOETsandBOETs).Thetraining,however,maybeinsufficienttoadequatelyprepareprincipalsfortheirresponsibilities.Principalsonlyvisitcourses,whichlastfromfewweekstofewmonths,aftertheyareassigned.Therearenoexittestsorexams.Eachyeartheacademyonly
trainsseveralthousandsofprincipals,andasitsbudgetislimited,ittendstorunlargecourseswithupto100participantsinaclasstosaveexpensesonlecturers.Moreover,itisdifficultfortheacademytopaycompetitiveratestohirelecturerexperiencedinmanagementtoholdthetrainings.Thecoursecontents,accordingtoacademysmanagement,areoutdatedandnotpractice-oriented.TheexpensesforprincipalstoattendtrainingcoursesattheacademyarecoveredbytheirDOETs.Thismeansthatprincipalsatremoteareastypicallyhavelesschancetoattendthecourses,eventhoughtheyaretheoneswhohavethebiggesttrainingneeds.Limitedautonomyoftheprincipalindecision-makingonfinancialandpersonnelmanagementmayunderminethemotivationforlearningastheycannotapplymuchofthelearnedknowledge.Inafewofourinterviews,principalsdidntevenknowkeyfinancialfiguresoftheirschools.
6.STAKEHOLDERSINASCHOOL
Besidetheschoolsmanagement,teachersandstudents,theothermainstakeholdersaretheschoolcouncilandtheparentscouncilwhointheorycanplayanimportantroleinschoolgovernance.BelowissomeanalysisabouttheirroleandfunctionsbasedondejureregulationsanddefactosituationencounteredduringfieldworkinHanoiandThanhHoa.
Schoolcouncil Accordingtolegalregulations,thehighestauthorityinmanagingapublicschoolistheschoolcouncil.Theschoolcouncilisinchargeofsettingthegoals,strategy,developmentplansandtheregulationsoftheschool.Itisalsoresponsibleforapprovingtheuseoffinancialresources,monitoringtheschoolsoperationaswellasprincipals
performance.TheschoolcouncilofapublicschoolconsistsofschoolsPartyChairman,theprincipalandvice-principals,andrepresentativesofteachersandnon-academicstaff.ThecompositionoftheschoolcouncilissuggestedbytheprincipaltoDOET(foruppersecondarylevel)orBOET(foralllowerlevels)tobeapproved.Itdoesnotruleoutthepossibilitythattheprincipalcanbethecouncilchairatthesametime.Theschoolcouncilmayinviterepresentativesofthelocalgovernmentandmassorganizationstoattenditsmeetingswhen
deemednecessary.
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
20/35
Thissetupwillcertainlynotallowtheschoolcounciltofulfillitsmandate,whichistogiveoutdirectiontotheschoolsmanagementandmonitortheirperformance,astheprincipalformsthecouncilcompositionhim/herselfandisoneofitsmember,whileothermembersarepeoplewhoworkunderprincipalssupervision.
Furthermore,whileinprincipletheprincipalhastheresponsibilitytoimplementdecisionsmadebytheschoolcouncil,incasesofdisagreementwiththecouncil,theprincipalcanbringuptheissuestothemanagingauthority,whichisDOET/BOET,forsettlement.Thisunderminesfurtherthecouncilsauthority,andlocatestheactualdecisionmakingatDOET/BOET.Inpractice,noschoolwevisitedhadaschoolcouncil.Itmaybeexplainedthattheregulationaboutestablishingtheschoolcouncilanditsroleandfunctionswasonlyissuedin2010forprimaryschools,and2011forsecondaryschools,andisstilltoonewtobeimplementedinpractice.
Parentscouncil
Aparentscounciliscanbeestablishedforeachclassandfortheschoolasawhole.Theparentscouncilfortheclasschannelsparentsfeedbackstoteachersoneducationalissues.Theparentscouncilfortheschoolbringsparentsvoicetotheschoolsprincipalregardingeducationalactivitiesandmanagementoftheschool.Thedejuresetupgivesparentscouncilverylimitedweighton
influencingtheoperationandmonitoringtheperformanceofapublicschool.Legalregulationsdonotexplicitlygivetheparentscouncilanyrighttobeinvolvedinmanagingtheschool,suchasparticipatinginprojectformulation,supervisinginvestmentsandprocurement,selectingcateringproviders,etc.Schoolcouncilsdonothavetoincludeparentsasmembers.Inpractice,theroleoftheparentscouncilisoftenreducedtocollectingthevoluntarycontributions.Incasesofdissatisfaction,theonlywayforparentstobeheardisgoingtotheDOET/OOET,accordingtotheLawonComplaints.
Transparency Oneregulationthat,atleastintheory,canhelptoincreasetheschoolsaccountabilitytowardsparentsasserviceusersisthecircularontransparencyofschooloperation(09/2009/TT-BGDT).Itrequiresschoolstoexposetothepublicallinformationoftheiroperationincludingfinancialdetails.Ifimplementedrigorously,thisregulationcanbeausefultoolforthepublictoproperlymonitortheschools.Inpractice,however,accordingtoseveralinformants,financialfigures,ifdisclosed,aremostlyarbitraryandatthediscretionoftheschool.Thereisnoindependentaudit,andparentshavenomeanstoverifythepublishedfigures.Eventeachersaremostlynotinformed
abouttheschoolsfinancialsituationeither.
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
21/35
7.QUALITYASSURANCELearningoutputs
Amajorpartofupwardaccountabilitywithinthestateagenciesintheeducationsectorisexpressedinoutputssuchasenrollmentanddropoutrates,or%ofpupilswithexcellentgrades,etc.Goodstatisticsmaketheschool,andwithititslocalgovernment,lookinggoodinthecompetition(thidua).Ontheotherhand,achievementsfeedintothelegitimacyofthepoliticalsystem.Atthesametime,horizontalaccountabilitytowardscommunityandparentsare,asseenabove,extremelyweak.Thisleadstothesituationthatschoolandlocalauthoritieshaveanincentivetobeautifystatistics,astheirperformanceassessmentdependsmostlyonthesenumbers,whileactualqualityofteachingandlearningcansufferfromthedistortion.Afewexamplesbelowillustratethesituation:
Achieving100%coverageofprimarylevel(phcpgiodctiuhc)isoneofthemaintargetsofVietnam,andschoolsandlocalauthoritiesdeployanumberoftrickstoachieveit.AccordingtoaninformantwhoworkedforaDOET,somepeoplemaybeclassifiedasdisabledinordertobemovedoutofthelist.Orlocalauthoritiesmaythreatennottoissuemarriagecertificatestotheminthefutureiftheywouldnotgotoclass.Studentswillbehelpedwhensittinginexams.Figures,suchasdropoutrate,ortestresults,canbemodifiedtoo.Thereareanecdotesthatparentsasktheschooltolettheirchildrepeattheclassbutthepupilisforcedtomoveup,inordernottodamageschoolsstatistics.Also,schoolsareknowntohandout
beautifiedstudentbooks(hcb)forfamiliesapplyingforscholarshipsabroadinexchangeofbribes.6
Enrollment
Whileinruralareasmostpupilswouldsimplyenrollintheclosestschool(typicallylocatedintheircommuneordistrict),thesituationiscomplicatedinurbanareassuchasHanoi,wheretherearemorechoiceswithinsmalldistances,andpeoplechoosetosendtheirchildrentoaspecificschoolbasedonvariousconsiderations.Ingeneral,inordertoachieveareasonableloaddistribution,basedonsomebasicstatisticsofhouseholdregistration,theDOET/BOETwillannuallydefinethepupilsfromtheresidentialareasthatwillhavethe
righttoenrollinwhatschoolinthedistrict.Schoolsaresupposedtogiveprioritytopupilswiththeregistrationfromtherightareas,andonlyenrollpupilsfromotherareasiftherearestillplaces.Asincasesofmismatchbetweendemandandsupply,andoflackingcontrol,malpracticesarecommon.Peoplemayfaketheirhouseholdregistration,orofferbriberytogetintotheschoolofchoice,(whichisnotintheirresidentialareas,butmayhaveabetterreputationorisclosertowhereaparentworks).Ontheotherhand,schoolsmay
6
Formorefirsthandinformation,seethisletterofalowersecondaryteachertoanewspaper,mentioningseveralpracticestoimproveschoolsteachingstatistics,oftenunderschoolsmanagementspressure:http://vnexpress.net/gl/ban-doc-viet/xa-hoi/2009/05/3ba0f5f8/
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
22/35
Nationalstandard
illegallyreserveplacesforparentsfromotherareasinexchangesoflucrativeinformalpayments.Theissueishardtoberesolvedaslongassignificantqualitydifferencesbetweenschoolsexist,combinedwiththelackoffunctioningcityplanningandcorrespondingdevelopmentoftheschoolnetwork.
Vietnamusestwodifferentstandardstomeasureandclassifyschoolquality:thenationalstandard(chunqucgia)andtheaccreditationstandard.Thenationalstandardisbetterknownbythepublicandseemstobemoreprestigiousthantheaccreditationstandard(discussedbelow).Theshareofschoolscertifiednationalstandardareakeynumberfrequentlyusedbyprovincialgovernmentsasevidencefortheirachievementineducation.MOETdefinesasetofindicatorsusedforthenationalstandardofeachschoollevel(32/2005/Q-BGDT).Thesequalityindicatorsarepartlythesamebutpartlydifferenttotheonesusedintheaccreditationstandard,andmeasuretheinfrastructure,quantityandqualificationofteachingbodyandstaff,andlearningoutput.Therearetwolevelsofthenationalstandard,levelIIbeingmoredemanding.Thecertificatesforbothlevelsarevalidfor5years,afterwhichare-assessmentisinorder.WhiletheassessmentoftheaccreditationstandardisorganizedbyDOET,thecommitteeofthenationalstandardissetupbytheprovincialPCchairman.(Forkindergartensandprimaryschools,apre-assessmentconductedbyadistrictcommitteeisrequiredbefore
theprovincialassessment.)ThecommitteetypicallyconsistsofrepresentativesfromDOET,TradeUnionofEducation,DOHA,DPI,DOF,DOH,etc.,aswellassomeprincipalsfromotherschools.However,itdoesnotincluderepresentativefromschoolscommunityorparents.Asthenationalstandardisofpoliticalimportancefortheprovincesleadership,ittypicallyinvestsinanumberofeliteschools(seealsoabove)tocertifyandshowcasethem.Keychallengesforschoolsinruralareasarebothlackofinfrastructureandteacherqualification.InlargecitiessuchasHanoi,theschoolsterritoryisoftennotlargeenoughtohavetherequired6-10m2/student.ActuallyHanoiissuggestingtakingintoaccountfloorsurfaceandnotlandsurfaceasanindicator.
Accreditationstandard
Comparedtothenationalstandarddiscussedabove,whichhasbeenappliedforover10years,theaccreditationstandard(chunkimnh)isrelativelynewandwasintroduced4-5yearsago.Theevaluationindicatorsfordifferentschoollevelswerejustre-issuedin2011and2012.
Similartothecriteriaofthenationalstandard,thecriteriaoftheaccreditationstandardareissuedbyMOETandlookatareassuchas
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
23/35
infrastructure,quantityandqualificationofhumanresources,learningoutputs,etc.Therearethreelevelsofaccreditation,basedontheshareofindicatorspassingtherequiredmarks.E.g.level3,thehighestlevel,isgrantediftheschoolpassesatleast80%oftheindicators,whilelevel1requiresjust50%oftheindicatorstobe
passed.Thecertificateisvalidfor5yearsforkindergartenandprimaryschools,and4yearsforsecondaryschools.Ifonetakesintoaccountthat,foranewschooltobeopened,ithasalsotofulfillasetofqualitycriteria,thentherearethreedifferentqualitystandardsinplaceatthesametime,whichgivesaconfusingpicture.AccordingtoaninformantfromMOET,thenationalstandardaimsataperfectsituation,onlyfitfortopschools,whiletheaccreditationstandardrepresentsalevelwhichideallyshouldbereachedbyallschools.Thisstilldoesnotanswerthequestionwhyoneneedsanaccreditationstandardbesidethestandardrequiredtoestablishanewschool.Inallourinterviews,schoolmanagementcouldnottellapartthepurposesofthenationalstandardandaccreditationstandard.OneorganizationaldifferenceisthattheassessmentofnationalstandardisorganizedbytheprovincesPC,whiletheassessmentoftheaccreditationstandardisorganizedbyDOET.Therearetwodifferentkindofassessmentofaccreditationstandards:self-assessmentandexternalassessment.AccordingtoaMOETofficial,asof2012,13provinceshaveconductedself-assessmentto
100%oftheirschools.Intheremainingprovinces,ithasbetween50%and80%.Schoolshavetocovertheexpensesforself-assessmentfromtheirannualoperationalbudget.Giventhelimitationoftheirstatebudgetallocationandthelackofverification,itistobeassumedthatself-assessmentisonlyaformalexercise.Furthermore,schoolshavelimitedabilityintryingtoimprovetheirinfrastructureandqualificationofhumanresources,asthesemattersarenotintheircontrol.ExternalassessmentsareconductedbyDOET,usingDOETsbudget,butonlywhentheschoolappliestobeexternallyaccredited.Reliablenumbersofschoolsalreadyexternallyaccreditedcouldnotbeobtained.Becausetheaccreditationstandarddoesnotbringprestigelikethenationalone,schoolsviewtheassessmentasaburdenwhichrequireslotsofpaperwork,andisoverwhelmingforschoolmanagementduetolackofcapabilityandtime.Interestingly,theaccreditationstandardispartoftheEducationLaw,whilethenationalstandardisnot.Apartfromtheissuesofhavingmanystandards,anothercomplaint
heardfromtheinterviewswithMOETisthatwhileMOETdefinesqualitystandards(e.g.buildingcodes),financingandbuildingschools
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
24/35
areinthehandoflocalPCs,withouttheDOETsinvolvement,resultinginbadimplementation(e.g.innarrowcorridors,toofewandsmallstaircases,toofewrestrooms,etc.).AccordingtoMOETsDepartmentofAccreditation(CucKhaothiva
Kiemdinhchatluong),MOETisworkingonunifyingthe3levelsofaccreditationstandardsand2levelsofnationalstandardsintoonesystem,e.g.equalingthe3rdaccreditationlevelwiththe2ndlevelofthenationalstandard.SomealsocallforanaccreditingbodyindependentfromMOET/DOETtoallowmoreobjectivity.Accordingtoaninformant,thisisbeingdiscussedinthecontextofthenewHigherEducationLaw.7Inothercountries,theseindependentbodiesissuetheaccreditationstandards,butinVietnam,itismorelikelythatMOETstillowntheaccreditationcriteria,eveniftheassessmentisdonebyanindependentorganization.Financingisstillanunclearissue.Accordingtothesameinformant,anotherconsiderationofMOETistohavedifferentqualitystandardsfordifferentsocio-economicconditions,aseachregionneedsastandardmoreappropriatetoitsdevelopmentlevel,anditdoesnotreallymakesensetohaveonestandardappliedacrosswealthyurbanandpoorremoteareas.
Performanceassessmentofhuman
resources
Asmentionedabove,MOETissuedastandardforprincipals(chunhiutrng)foreachschoollevel.Thesearetypicallyalistofindicatorscoveringmoral,politicalattitude,managementcapability
andpedagogicalcapability.Forprincipals,theannualperformanceassessmenthasthreesteps:aself-assessment,anassessmentbytheschoolsstaffcollectiveorganizedbytheParty,andfinallyanassessmentbytheprincipalssupervisoratBOET/DOETbasedontheprevioustwo.Parentsarenotinvolvedinanywayintheassessmentprocess.Itiscommonthataprincipalsperformanceassessmentismostlyaformality,whereaspersonalconnection,especiallyintheParty,woulddeterminetheprincipalscareer.
Similartoprincipalsstandard,MOETalsoissuedateachersstandard(chungiovin)foreachschoollevel.Thestandardscoverareassuchaspoliticalattitude,morale,knowledgeandpedagogicalskill.Theannualassessmentprocesshasthreesteps:aself-assessment,anassessmentbycolleaguesandfinallyanassessmentbytheprincipal.Intheory,ifinateacherdisagreeswiththeprincipalsassessment,he/shecanbringittotheschoolcouncil.Inreality,thecouncilrarelyexists,orifitdoes,itisheadbytheprincipal.
7Article52ofthenewHigherEducationLawpassedin2012statesthatanaccreditingbodywill
haveitsownlegalstatusandwillbeestablishedwhenaproposalexistswhichfittotheoverallplanoftheaccreditationnetwork,butitdoesnotexplicitlymentionifthisaccreditingbodyistobeindependenttoMOETornot.
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
25/35
Inspectorate Accordingtothesectoralinspectoratesystem,thereisinspectorateat
MOETlevelandatDOETlevel,inchargeofalllevelsofschooleducation.Thereisnoinspectorateatthedistrict(BOET)level.Schoolsaretobeinspectedonfinance,teachersdeployment,assets,
infrastructure,andimplementationofsocialpolicies,etc.Teachersaretobeinspectedonteachingquality.Accordingtoaninformant,MOETrequires20-25%ofbothschoolsandteacherstobeinspectedperyear.Duetoseriousunderstaffingofinspectors,inreality,thenumberiscloseto10%,andconcentratingmostlyonuppersecondaryschools.Thereareanumberofissuesrelatedtoqualityofinspection.Tostartwith:lowsalarymakestheworkunattractive.Mostinspectorsareilltrainedandyoung,whichmakeitharderforthemtoworkwitholderschoolsmanagement.Schoolsmaydealwithinspectionvisitsbyputtingthebestoftheirstudentsintotheclassthatisinspected.Ortheyusetheirpersonalconnectiontoinfluenceinspectorsandpre-settheinspectionreport.
ReportingandusageofIT
Everyyear,MOETissuesinstructionsforDOETstoreportaboutcompletededucationalactivitiesforallschoollevelsintheirprovinces.Theseincludeinformationontheschoolnetwork,numberofpupilsandtheirshareofthepopulation,cadretraining,thedevelopmentofteachingbodyandmanagement,financialdata,etc.
AnnualreportsaretobedoneaccordingtolistsandtemplatesdefinedbyMOET.TheannualreportistobesenttoMOETandGeneralStatisticsOffice(GSO)attheendoftheyear.Additionally,ad-hocreportsmayberequested,butonlybyMOEToranagencythatisgrantedpermissionfromMOETsMinister.MOETisinchargeofpublishingandprovidingstatisticaldatatoallagenciesinandoutsidetheeducationsector,aswellasofunifyingthedatawithGSO.Provincesareinchargeofpublishingtheirowndata,inaccordancewithdatareportedtoMOET.
Thebiggestchallengeintermofreportingisthatalliscurrentlydonemanually,withoutanyintegratedITsystem.ReportsaresentfromschoolstoBOETtoDOET,whichinturnsendtheirreportstoMOET,mostlyasrudimentaryWorddocuments,notevenasanExcelfile,whichmakesaggregatingdatadifficult.Also,inreality,verticalreportinglinesarenotclear;hencedifferentdepartmentsinMOEThavedifferentdataonthesamematters,whichareinturndifferenttoGSOsdata.
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
26/35
8.CONTENT
Learningprogramandtextbooks
Thelearningprogramisunifiedcountrywideandislegallybinding(tnhphplnh).Intheory,MOETallowsabout15%ofthelearningprogramtobelocallyspecific.Theselocalcontentsmaycoverlocalhistory,localcustomsormusic.MOETaimsataratioof70%unifiedcontentand30%localcontentinfuture.Inpractice,however,thecurrentspaceof15%israrelyused,asprovincesdonotwanttotakeontheextraworkofcreatingthelocalcontent,andtheriskofbeingcriticizedabouttheappropriatenessandcorrectnessoftheextracontent.Accordingtooneinformant,onlybraveprovinceswillengageinthis.MOETdefinesaminimallevelofknowledgetobeattained,while
schoolsarefreetoteachextracontentontopofthisminimallevel,dependingonstudentscapabilities.Forexample,theminimallevelmayrequiresstudentstomastermultiplicationwith2digit,whiletheschoolmaywanttoteachtheirpupilsmultiplicationwith3digits.Classesspecializedinmath,English,orFrenchwillhaveamuchmoreintensiveprogramonthesesubjects.Typicallyschoolsinurbanareaswilltrytoaddmorecontentthroughextraclasses,inordertogettheirstudentsaheadoftherace.Formostoftheruralareas,itsachallengealreadytoachievetheminimalknowledgelevel.Thelearningprogramisoperationalizedthroughthetextbooks,whichareissuedbyMOET.Textbooksareguidelinesforteachersandstudents,butarenotlegallybinding.Forboththeminimalknowledgelevelandtheadd-on,teachersarefreetousematerialsoutsideoftheMOETtextbooks.Onthebookmarketthereisawealthofadditionalteachingmaterial(schthamkho),whicharenotissuedandcontrolledbyMOET.However,accordingtoaninformant,annuallyMOETdoesrecommendcertainteachingmaterialsofferedonthemarket.
Non-
mandatoryandspecialprograms
Theofferingofnon-mandatorysubjectsisbynaturelimitedbythe
availabilityofteachersintheschool.BesidethecountrywideunifiedlearningprogramdefinedbyMOET,inspecialcasesschools,orrathercertainclassesinaschool,mayapplyalternativeprograms.Oneexamplehasbeenthebi-lingualVietnameseFrenchprogramfundedbytheFrenchEmbassyandintroducedtoanumberofprimaryandlowersecondaryschoolsinHanoi.TheprogramcontentwasdesignedbytheFrenchsideandapprovedbyMOET.TeachersdeployedintheprogramwerepaidbytheFrenchEmbassy.Aftertheprojectended,schoolscoulddecidetocontinuetheprogram,withFrenchteacherssolelypaidbyparents
contribution.
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
27/35
9.CONCLUSIONThischapterprovidesasummaryandconcludinganalysisofgovernanceaspectsofthesector.Byidentifyingcurrentchallengeshinderingthesystemtoperform,itaimstoanswerthequestionIstheeducationsystemsetuptoprovidewhatthecountryneedsforitsdevelopment?.Theunderstandingisthatwhatthecountryneedsisbothexpandedquantity,definedbyequalandbroadaccesstoeducation,andimprovedqualityofeducationservices.Lackofworkingaccountabilitylinkages
Theeducationsystemisprimarilyfocusedonupwardaccountability,whiledownwardaccountabilityisseriouslylacking.Responsibilitiesarelocatedatthelocalgovernments(provinceordistrict),withoutappropriatehumanandfinancialresourcesgivingtothemtomeetdemands.Thesystemissetupinawaythatitisriskaverse.Officialshavenoincentivetolookforinnovationandproactivity,butjustfulfill
theminimalrequirements.8Asserviceusersarenotinvolvedinmeasuringschoolperformance,thesystemfavorsformalityoveractualquality.Inrespondingtopoliticalpressuretodeliver,schoolshaveanincentivetowaterdownqualityandreportupcookedstatistics.
Intheory,citizenshavetwowaystoinfluenceeducationserviceproviders:clientvoice(longrouteofaccountability),andclientpower(shortrouteofaccountability).Viathelongroute,citizensgivevoicetothecentralgovernment,whichthensetoutpoliciesandgoalsforserviceprovidersastorespondtocitizensneeds.Theshortrouteisrepresentedbydirectfeedbacktoserviceproviders,co-managementofserviceusers,andchoiceofservices.
TheAccountabilityFramework
8Foramoredetaileddiscussionondevolution,excessupwardaccountability,shortageofdownwardaccountability,seeWorldBanksVietnamDevelopmentReport2010,ModernInstitutions.
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
28/35
Source:WorldBank(2003)
Intheory,decentralizationissupposedtoshortenthelongroutebymovingresponsibilitiesfromcentralgovernmentdowntoprovincialanddistrictgovernment.Theunderlyingassumptionisthatauthoritiesknowmoreaboutrealneedsandcanbemoreaccountableiftheyareclosertothepeople,asithelpstoincreasepeoplesparticipationindecisionmakingandmonitoringgovernmentsactivities.Inreality,asVietnamhasasinglepoliticalpartywithaconstitutionalrole,thelongrouteaccountabilityisextremelylong,aselectionshavenocompetitionandcitizenscannotvotepoliticiansoutofpower.Inthepastdecades,thissystemseemedstilltobeeffectivetodeliveraccessandfightilliteracy,whichitsettobeitspoliticaltask,
butnowaspopulationgrowthisdecliningandthechallengesshifttodeliveringqualitytomoredemandingpeople,itdoesntseemtofunctionaswell.Thisgoeshandinhandwiththefactthattheshortrouteisweak,aswiththecurrentsetup,parentshavenomeansofinvolvementinschoolmanagement,orofsanctionorthreatofsanctionincaseofpoorperformanceofschools.(Foravisualpresentationofthekeystateactorsandtheiraccountabilitylinkages,seeAnnex1.)
Inthiscontext,moreschoolautonomydoesnotautomaticallymeanbetterserviceefficiencyandquality,aslongasparentsdonothavearoleinmonitoringteacherbehaviorandtheallocationofschoolfunds.Clientpowercanonlyberaisedthroughmoreparentparticipation.Accountabilityrelationshipcanbestrengthenedbytheintroductionofschoolcouncilsthathavesubstantialresponsibilitiesinservicedelivery(e.g.responsibilitiesinthehiring,firingandmonitoringofteachers).
Ineffectiveoversightandpower
struggle
Besidessettingthebroadpolicyframework,MOETsroleistoensurequalityofpolicyimplementation,whichisdoesinaverylimitedway.Asmentionedabove,MOETsinspectionlackresourcesanddonthave
realpoweronotherministriesandthelocalgovernments.MOETisthestateauthoritytoensureeducationsquality,butitdoesntmanage
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
29/35
personnelandfinance,whiletakingtheresponsibilityfortheoutcomes.AccordingtoaMOETsofficial,MOETonlymanages5%oftotalbudgetforeducation(includinghighereducation).Otherministriesmanage21%,about74%aremanagedbytheprovinces.Inhiswords,MOETcanonlyissueregulationsthattheschoolhasto
havearestroom,butitisuptotheprovincesPCtobuilditornot.
Thecurrentdecentralizationisnotsetuptoproduceefficiency,asitismarredbypowerstrugglebetweendifferentlevelsofgovernmentanddifferentadministrativebodiesateachlevel,asseeninthecaseofThanhHoaintermofadaptingtheschoolnetworktorespondtodecreasingpupilsnumberandsurplusofteachers.Ascanbeobservedinpreviouschapters,theChairofPC,bothatprovinciallevel(foruppersecondarylevel),andatdistrictlevel(forlowersecondarylevelandlower)hassignificantpower,e.g.tocreate,closeormergeschools.Moreover,theyaretheoneswhocanchangekeyregulations,suchastheonesrelatedtorecruitmentprocess(e.gthebodyhavingthehiringresponsibility,thecompositionofthemembersoftheselectionofcommittee,etc.)Concentratedpowerisvulnerabletobemisused.Infact,inmorethanonecasesinformantscomplainthatregulationswerechangedbackandforthasadistrictChaircameandwent.
Lackofincentivesforteachersand
schoolmanagement
Teachersandschoolmanagementhavenoincentivestogivetheirbestandworkwithcommitmentandmotivation.Oneofthekeyreasonsforthelackofteachersmotivationisthattheirsalaryisnotlinkedto
levelofcompetency,ascurrentremunerationforteachersissolelybasedoneducationlevelandexperience(measuredasnumberofin-serviceyears).Althoughtextbooksarenotlegallybinding,andteachershaveroomtodesigntheirteachingmaterialsandthewaytheydeliver,thisspaceisrarelyused.Thus,theintensivedebateandcriticsabouttextbooksinthecurrentmediaispartlymissingthemark,asthecauseforthelackofcreativityandflexibilityisnotwiththetextbookscontent.Aperformance-basedsalaryschemecanbedoneonlyifteachermanagement,intheformofhiring,firingandpromotion,isinthe
handofschoolsmanagementandnotinthehandoflocalgovernment.
Similarissuesexistforschoolmanagement.Thecurrentsetupdoesnotencourageprincipalstobeentrepreneurialandcreativeanddoesnotawardthosewhoare.Thiscreatesaviciouscycle:localgovernmentagenciesrefusetohandoverpowerandautonomytoschoolswiththeargumentationthatschoolslackcapacitytomakedecisionsintermofpersonnelandfinancialmanagement.Thiskeepsschoolsinthetrapofbeingjustpassiveimplementersandnotactivemanagers,astheyneverlearnhowtodothejob.
Inequality
Vietnamfacespersistentinequalitiesintermofenrollment,attendanceandcompletionbetweenincomegroupsandethnic
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
30/35
Corruption
minorities.Disadvantagedpopulationgroupshavelowercompletionratesinprimaryeducation,whichfeedsintothewideninggapofbothattendanceandcompletioninsecondaryeducation.
Butinequalitydoesnotjustexistbetweenruralandurbanareas,but
alsobetweenschoolsinurbanareas,aseliteschoolstendtoreceivemoreresources.Poorparentsarelessabletobeheard,comparedtobetteroffparentswhocancontributemoretotheschool.
Theongoingdecentralizationprocessandsocializationisnotdrivenbyapursuitofidealsofdecentralizedgovernment,buttheresultsofmarketization,whichproducehighpotentialforinformalizationandcorruption.AccordingtoaWorldBanksurveyin2012,32%ofcitizensthathadsomeinteractionswithschoolsmadeunofficialpayments.9
AlthoughVietnamsspendingoneducationishighcomparedtoEastAsiancountries,bothintermofshareofGDPandperpupilexpenditure,corruptioncancausesignificantwastesofresource,andtogetherwithproblematicgovernancestructures,threatenstheefficacyofthesystem.
9WorldBank-GovernmentInspectorate,CorruptionfromthePespectiveofCitizens,Firms,and
PublicOfficials,Referencebook,NationalPoliticalPublishingHouse,HaNoi,2012
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
31/35
10. ANNEXESANNEX1:GRAPHICOFKEYRESONSIBILITIESANDACCOUNTABILITYLINKAGES
MOET
ProvincesPC
DistrictsPC
Principal
TeacherParentCouncil
Weakhorizontalaccountabilityasparentsnotinvolvedinschoolsdecesionmakingandmanagement.Parentsrolereducedtoconsent
tosendchildrentoschool(inruralareas),
andtocontribute
financially(inurbanareas)
Inchargeofprovincesperformanceofthesector;managinguppersecondary
schools(incl.financial
decisionmakingandhiringandfiring)
Mostlywithoutauthorityforhiringandfiring,andforfinancialdecisions.Performance
evaluatedwithoutclientsinvolvement
Managinglevelsbelowuppersecondary(incl.
financialdecisionmakingandhiringandfiring)
Downwardaccountabilitylimitedaslocal
governmentfailsto
providenecessaryconditions(finances,
infrastructure)forschoolstoperform
Definescurriculum,publishestextbooks,issuesregulationsonteachingandassessments,
degressandcertificates
MOEThandsdowninstructionsandguidancetoDOET/BOETbutthose
aresubjecttolocalPCsdirectionandmanagementintermsoforg.structure,
staffsizeandtasks
Upwardaccountabilitydistortedaspressureto
produceoutputmeasuredsolelyinstatisticswithout
monitoringinvitesmanipulation
Weaklongrouteaccountabilityascitizenscantvote
officialsoutofoffice
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
32/35
ANNEX2:REGULATIONSFORPRIVATESCHOOLS
Operatingasabusinessentity,aprivateschoolhasautonomyinallitsoperationsuchashiringandfiring,assignmentofschoolmanagement,decisionsoninvestmentandfinancing,determiningoftuitionlevelsetc.Ithasadirectaccountabilitytoitscustomers
inthesensethattheycouldwalkawayandchooseanotherserviceprovidersiftheyarenotsatisfiedwiththeschoolsperformance.Thissectionoffersanoverviewoflegalregulationsforprivateschoolswhereitsrelevantforgovernanceissues.Founding/closing
Theminimumrequirementsintermofinfrastructure,sizeandqualificationofhumanresources,whichMOETdefinesforalllevelsofpublicschoolsalsoapplyfortheestablishmentofanewprivateschool.
Foraprivateschooltobeestablished,theproposalowneralsoneedstwolicenses:licensetofoundaschool(giyphpthnhlptrng),andlicensetoconducteducationalactivities(giyphphotnggiodc),whicharetobeapprovedbythesamestateagencieswhichapproveapublicschoolsofthesamelevel(provincesPCforuppersecondary,anddistrictPCforalllevelsbelow).
Thestateagencyinchargeofgrantinglicenseforprivateschoolsinalsoinchargeofrevokingthelicense.
Assignmentofprincipal
TheprincipalofaprivateschoolisappointedbytheschoolsBoard.Theappointmentissubsequentlytoberecognized(cngnhn)by
therespectivestateagencies(DOETforuppersecondary,BOETforalllevelsbelow).
Teacherrecruitment
Asbusinessentities,privateschoolshavetotalauthorityinhiringandfiringdecisionsrelatedtotheiracademicandnon-academicstaff.Intheory,theyhavetocomplywithrequirementsregardtoquantityandqualificationoftheirhumanresources.Also,theprivateschoolhastoprovidetotheteachersthesameworkingconditionsintermofworkinghours,vacations,etc.asappliedinthepublicschools.
Financing,
tuition&fees
Asbusinesses,privateschoolsarefinancedtotallybyprivatesources
andschoolsrevenues.Theyoperateonthefreemarketandhavenoconstraintsintermofsettingtheirtuitionsandfeelevels.Infact,privateschoolsmayhavetuitionlevelshundredtimeshigherthantheaveragedlevelofpublicschools.
Teachingprogram&Curriculum
PrivateschoolshavetofollowthesameteachingprogramandteachingplanasdefinedbyMOETforpublicschools.Ontopofthat,privateschoolsareallowedtoaddonupto4weeksofextrateachingtimeperyear(13/2011/TT-BGDT).
Inspectorate Likepublicschools,privateschoolsareundertheinspectionofthe
stateagenciesmanagingthem.Aswithpublicschools,onecanexpectthatinspectionofprivateschoolsarenowaycomprehensiveand
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
33/35
sufficient.However,itdoeshappenthatprivateschoolsareclosedortheiroperationsuspendedduetoviolationsofregulations.10
Nationalstandard&
Accreditation
TheNationalStandardcanbeappliedforbothpublicandprivateschools,andinfactsomeprivateschoolsdoseektoapplyforthe
standard,althoughgenerallyforthemthepoliticsofitisdoesnotplayaprominentrolelikeforpublicschools.
Inregardtoaccreditationstandards,thelegalregulationsdonotmakeadistinctionbetweenpublicandprivateschools.However,noinformationhasbeenfoundthatprivateschoolshavebeenalsoaccredited.Itseemsthatuptonowaccreditationhasonlybeenappliedforpublicschools.
BoardofDirectors/
ParentCouncil
TheprivateschoolsequivalentofapublicschoolsSchoolCouncilistheBoardofDirectors,whichoverseestheworkingoftheschools
management.TheBoardistobeestablishedbytheowneroftheprivateschoolandoperatesunderthesamelegalregulationastheSchoolCouncilofapublicschool.
RelatedtoestablishmentandoperationoftheParentCouncil,decree55/2011/TT-BGDTprovidesthesameregulationforbothpublicandprivateschools.
10ForacaseinHoChiMinhcityin2012,seehttp://www.baomoi.com/Dinh-chi-hoat-dong-Truong-THPT-tu-thuc-Phuong-Nam/59/8777297.epi
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
34/35
ANNEX3:LISTOFINTERVIEWS
MOET
1. Management,DepartmentofECE(VuMamnon),MOET2. Management,ProjectSupportReforminEducationManagement,MOET3. Management,DepartmentofAccreditation(CucKhaothivaKiemdinhchatluong)4. Formermanager,EducationInspectorate(ThanhtraBo),MOET5. Management,DepartmentofPrimaryEducation(VuTieuhoc),MOET6. Management,DepartmentofSecondaryEducation(VuTrunghoc),MOET7. Management,AcademyforEducationManagement(Hocvienquanlygiaoduc)THANHHOA
8. Vice-ChairmanofProvincialPC9. Manager,OfficeofFinance,Dep.ofEducationandTraining(DOET)10.Manager,OfficeofPersonnel,DOET11.Official,DepartmentofFinance(DOF)12.Vice-ChairmanofDistrictPC13.District-levelBureauofEducation(BOET)14.ManagementofaPrimaryschool15.ManagementofaLowerSecondaryschool16.ManagementofaUpperSecondaryschoolHANOI
17.ManagementofaPrimaryschool18.ManagementofaUpperSecondaryschool19.ManagementofaLowerSecondaryschool20.Auppersecondaryteacher21.Alowersecondaryteacher22.ManagementofDepartmentofHomeAffairs(DOHA)MISC
23.Ms.NguyenThiHongNet,programofficer,Oxfam,Hanoi24.Dr.LuongVanThang,UniversityofEconomics(ConsultantforOxfam)25.Formermanager,DOETYenBai
7/27/2019 Governance in Education in Vietnam-Giang Dang_CECODES
35/35
11. REFERENCESVuDinhChuan,ThedevelopmentofbasiceducationofVietnamintheintegrationprocess,SecondaryEducationDepartment,MinistryofEducationandTraining,unknowndateLoveEdquist,DecentralizationofEducationalManagementinVietnam,MastersThesisinPoliticalScience,JnkpingJune2005
AdamFforde,TngquanvcngtcxhihogiodccaTPHChMinh,2010AdamFforde,nhgimtsbinphpthchinxhihogiodctithnhphHChMinh,2010OxfamUK,PhncpqunlgiodcVitNam,HNi,2010
TowardsTransparency,FormsandeffectsofcorruptiononeducationsectorinVietnam,2009TranThiKimThuan,ReportonthedecentralizationorientededucationalmanagementsysteminVietnam,NationalInstituteforEducationalSciences,Vietnam,unknowndateUNICEF,SecondaryEducation:RegionalInformationBase:CountryProfileVietnam,2007
WorldBank,Whatisschool-basedmanagement,HumanDevelopmentNetwork,2007
WorldBank-GovernmentInspectorate,CorruptionfromthePespectiveofCitizens,Firms,andPublicOfficials,Referencebook,NationalPoliticalPublishingHouse,HaNoi,2012
WorldBank,ModernInstitutions,VietnamDevelopmentReport,HaNoi,2010
WorldBank,WorldDevelopment2004:MakingServicesWorkforPoorPeople,2003