18
General Breaker Questions 1. Heaters. On the 1 st SF6 Dead Tank I’ve put a GeneralAsset instance with .kind=.breakerHeater attached to the mechansim. On the 2 nd SF6 Dead Tank I have put a Asset instance w/ .kind=breakerHeater attached to each SF6 Dead Tank tank. Need to talk about which approach makes more sense and identify exactly those components we should hang heater instances off of. 2. CTs. What about modeling CTs as GeneralAssets now and save CTInfo until later… or maybe put just a .ratio attribute in CTInfo? (Would have one instance GeneralAsset w/ .kind= CT of every ratio for every model) Need to have a discussion about what different kinds of CTs are worth modeling. 3. Do we need to model compressors on breakers? (Paul B says TVA tracks them) 4. Interrupters appear not to have nameplates and make up an integral part of a breaker’s design, so they probably don’t merit creation of an InterrupterUnitInfo class. Are there, however, interrupter characteristics that merit attributes in SwitchInfo, perhaps (since all interrupters on a breaker would be the same)? Like type: · arc-assist (or arc-assisted) · self-blast (same thing as self-pressuring?) · puffer (double-nozzle quenching is variant, right?) · self-compression (2 moving contacts) · rotating arc · double pressure Or material: · porcelain · composite · silicon rubber · Brown/Grey · fiberglass Note on use of AssetPosition: The AssetPosition class is intended to support utility-specific standardized definition of relative positions of similar asset components within an asset (or positions of assets among collections of assets). In the asset health domain, two main drivers for defining position exist: - for unambiguous identification of a specific asset component (among many like components) by humans - for unambiguous identification of a specific asset component (among many like components) by systems that are not asset component “MRID” aware In the CIM standard asset templates, where an association between an asset component and an AssetPosition instance is shown, the association from the asset component to some AssetPosition instance is required, though it need not be to an AssetPosition instance with the .position value shown in the template. Utilities are free to utilize their own position numbering conventions and to associate asset components to appropriate AssetPosition instances. The fundamental assumption is simply that when there are multiple similar asset components within an asset, each asset component will be associated with a unique AssetPosition instance to enable unambiguous identification. In addition to the required AssetPosition instance associations, any Asset or Asset child instance can have an AssetPosition instance associated with it.

General Breaker Questions Dead Tank I’ve put a ...cimug.ucaiug.org/Focus_Comms/AssetHealth/Public Documents/Modeli… · On the 1st SF6 Dead Tank I’ve put a GeneralAsset instance

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

General Breaker Questions1. Heaters. On the 1st SF6 Dead Tank I’ve put a GeneralAsset instance with .kind=.breakerHeater attached to the mechansim. On the 2nd SF6 Dead Tank I have put a Asset instance w/ .kind=breakerHeater attached to each SF6 Dead Tank tank. Need to talk about which approach makes more sense and identify exactly those components we should hang heater instances off of. 2. CTs. What about modeling CTs as GeneralAssets now and save CTInfo until later… or maybe put just a .ratio attribute in CTInfo? (Would have one instance GeneralAsset w/ .kind= CT of every ratio for every model) Need to have a discussion about what different kinds of CTs are worth modeling.3. Do we need to model compressors on breakers? (Paul B says TVA tracks them)4. Interrupters appear not to have nameplates and make up an integral part of a breaker’s design, so they probably don’t merit creation of an InterrupterUnitInfo class. Are there, however, interrupter characteristics that merit attributes in SwitchInfo, perhaps (since all interrupters on a breaker would be the same)? Like type:· arc-assist (or arc-assisted)· self-blast (same thing as self-pressuring?)· puffer (double-nozzle quenching is variant, right?)· self-compression (2 moving contacts)· rotating arc· double pressureOr material:· porcelain· composite· silicon rubber· Brown/Grey· fiberglass

Note on use of AssetPosition:The AssetPosition class is intended to support utility-specific standardized definition of relative positions of similar asset components within an asset (or positions of assets among collections of assets).

In the asset health domain, two main drivers for defining position exist: - for unambiguous identification of a specific asset component (among many like components) by humans - for unambiguous identification of a specific asset component (among many like components) by systems that are not asset component “MRID” aware

In the CIM standard asset templates, where an association between an asset component and an AssetPosition instance is shown, the association from the asset component to some AssetPosition instance is required, though it need not be to an AssetPosition instance with the .position value shown in the template. Utilities are free to utilize their own position numbering conventions and to associate asset components to appropriate AssetPosition instances. The fundamental assumption is simply that when there are multiple similar asset components within an asset, each asset component will be associated with a unique AssetPosition instance to enable unambiguous identification.

In addition to the required AssetPosition instance associations, any Asset or Asset child instance can have an AssetPosition instance associated with it.

SF6 Dead Tank Breaker · 15.5 kV – 800+ kV· SF6 gas used for both insulation and arc-

extinguishment · SF6-filled insulated (grounded) tank containing

interrupter(s) with connections made via bushings.

3Poles/Structure, 1Pole/Tank, 1Pole/Mech, 1Break 345 kVhttp://www05.abb.com/global/scot/scot245.nsf/veritydisplay/a147af5683d7462cc12579d00056e326/$file/242pmi90_2gnm110092.pdf

Mechanism is disk spring - hydraulic

1 Pole/Structure3 Poles /Structure

1 Pole/Tank (w/ Shared or Separate SF6)3 Poles/Tank 1 Pole/Tank3 Poles/Tank

1 Pole/Mechanism3 Poles/Mechanism 1 Pole/Mechanism3 Poles/Mechanism 1 Pole/Mechanism3 Poles/Mechanism

Single Break Double Break Single Break Double BreakSingle Break Double Break Single Break Double Break

SF6 Dead Tank Breaker Variants

3Poles/Structure, 1Pole/Tank, 3?Poles/Mech, 1Break145 kVhttp://www.alstom.com/Global/Grid/Resources/Circuit%20Breakers/Documents/DT1%20Dead%20tank%20circuit%20breakers%20from%20123%20kV%20to%20145%20kV%20Brochure%20GB.pdf

Mechanism is “low energy FK3-1 spring-operated”

1Pole/Structure, 1Pole/Tank, 1Pole/Mech, 2?Break550 kVhttp://www.alstom.com/Global/Grid/Resources/Circuit%20Breakers/Documents/DT2-550%20F3%20Dead%20tank%20SF6%20circuit%20breaker%20550%20kV%20Brochure%20GB.pdf

mechanism can be spring or low pressure hydraulic

SF6 Dead Tank Examples (of types different from sample templates)

Example templates provided

3Poles/Structure, 1Pole/Tank, 3?Poles/Mech, 1Break72.5 kVhttp://www.alstom.com/Global/Grid/Resources/Circuit%20Breakers/Documents/DT1-72.5%20Dead%20tank%20circuit%20breaker%20for%2072.5kV.pdf

Mechanism is “low energy FK spring-operated”

3 Break

Carey:I found product references to early SF6 dead tank 500kV breakers with 3 breaks. In an older textbook there was mention of “three or four (or more) series breaks”. Does AEP have some older 765 kV SF6 dead tanks? I’m thinking saying “n” make sense here.

n Break...

3Poles/Structure, 1Pole/Tank, 3?Poles/Mech, 1Break230 kVHVB (High Voltage Breakers, Inc.) HVB 242 31500 http://www.westcoastswitchgear.com/Inventory/Breaker/Details/SB5189?t=Substation%20Breaker&v=230000&p=0

3Poles/Structure, 1Pole/Tank, 3?Poles/Mech, 1Break145 kVMitsubishi 120-SFMT-40EManufactured 1999 http://www.westcoastswitchgear.com/Inventory/Breaker/Details/SB5600?t=Substation%20Breaker&v=145000&p=0

3Poles/Structure, 1Poles/Tank, 3Poles/Mech, 1Break48 kV

Siemens SP-48.3-40-3, manufactured 1991

http://www.westcoastswitchgear.com/Inventory/Breaker/Details/SB1698?t=Substation%20Breaker&v=48000&p=0

kind = sF6

tank medium:Mediumkind = breakerTankAssembly

tank assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerSF6DeadTankBreaker

whole SF6 dead tank breaker:AssetContainer

bushing 2:Bushing bushing 5:Bushing bushing 6:Bushing

position = 1

position 1:AssetPosition

position = 2

position 2:AssetPosition

position = 3

position 3:AssetPosition

position = 4

position 4:AssetPosition

position = 5

position 5:AssetPosition

position = 6

position 6:AssetPosition

+MovingContact +MovingContact +MovingContact +FixedContact+FixedContact+FixedContact

This Template3Poles/Structure3Poles/Tank3Poles/MechanismSingle Break

3Poles/Structure, 3Poles/Tank, 3Poles/Mech, 1Break 15 kV - 38 kVhttp://www.hss-ltd.com/products/outdoor-switchgear/139/Hawker Siddeley Switchgear, “Horizon”Bushing – silicon rubber mechanism:OperatingMechanism

kind = breakerStructure

base:AssetContainer

bushing 1:Bushing bushing 3:Bushing bushing 4:Bushing

3Poles/Structure, 3Poles/Tank, 3Poles/Mech, 1Break ?? kVGowri

3Poles/Structure, 3Poles/Tank, 3Poles/Mech, 1Break ?? kVGowri

pole 1 interrupter:InterrupterUnit pole 2 interrupter:InterrupterUnit pole 3 interrupter:InterrupterUnit

AnalogtripCoilCurrentheaterCurrentheaterTemperatureDiscreteheaterState

Proposed changes on this page: - model heaters and CTs as “general asset components” - in other words model-specific instances not asset-specific instances- indicate measurementType of common or useful Measurrements associated with each asset component - indicate types of ProcedureDataSets that could be associated with each asset component**NOTE** breaker templates are probably not where we want to illustrate measurementType and ProcedureData set associations to asset components over the long run, but are useful here for now.

These are just samples, need to identify real types of measurements

FactoryTestDataSetPowerFactorTestDataSetBushingInspectionDataSet

CT model:GeneralAsset

kind = bushingCT

heater model:GeneralAsset

kind = breakerTankHeater

kind = sF6

pole 1 tank medium:Medium

kind = breakerTankAssembly

pole 1 tank assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerTankAssembly

pole 2 tank assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerTankAssembly

pole 3 tank assembly:AssetContainer

kind = sF6

pole 2 tank medium:Medium

kind = sF6

pole 3 tank medium:Medium

bushing 1:Bushing bushing 2:Bushing bushing 5:Bushingbushing 3:Bushing bushing 4:Bushing bushing 6:Bushing

position = 1

position 1:AssetPosition

position = 2

position 2:AssetPosition

position = 3

position 3:AssetPosition

position = 4

position 4:AssetPosition

position = 5

position 5:AssetPosition

position = 6

position 6:AssetPosition

pole 1 interrupter:InterrupterUnit pole 2 interrupter:InterrupterUnit pole 3 interrupter:InterrupterUnit

+MovingContact +MovingContact +MovingContact +FixedContact+FixedContact+FixedContact

3Poles/Structure, 1Pole/Tank, 3Poles/Mech, 1Break38 kV - 72.5 kVhttp://www05.abb.com/global/scot/scot245.nsf/veritydisplay/4c285e8eabeedd1d852574f30044cfbf/$file/72pm_2gnm110001_new.pdf

Interrupter is self-blastMechanism is “low powered motor-charged spring”

3Poles/Structure, 1Pole/Tank, 3Poles/Mech, 1Break38 kV - 72.5 kVhttp://www.energy.siemens.com/us/en/power-transmission/high-voltage-products/circuit-breaker/sf6-high-voltage-power-circuit-breakers-dead-tank.htm#content=Details

Bushing – either porcelain or compositeInterrupter – arc-assist (identical to live tank)Mechanisim “spring-spring mechanism” (identical to live tank)

kind = breakerSF6DeadTankBreaker

whole SF6 dead tank breaker:AssetContainer

kind = breakerStructure

base:AssetContainer

This Template3 Poles/Structure1 Pole/Tank, Separate SF6

3 Poles/MechanismSingle Break

mechanism:OperatingMechanism

3Poles/Structure, 1Pole/Tank, 3Poles/Mech, 1Break?? kVPaul

kind = breakerHeater

pole 2 tank heater:Asset

kind = breakerHeater

pole 1 tank heater:Asset

kind = breakerHeater

pole 3 tank heater:Asset

kind = breakerSF6DeadTankBreaker

whole SF6 single pole dead tank breaker:AssetContainer

position = 1

position 1:AssetPosition

pole 2 interrupter 1:InterrupterUnit

pole 2 mechanism:OperatingMechanism

+MovingContact +FixedContact

pole 2 interrupter 2:InterrupterUnit

1Pole/Structure, 1Pole/Tank, 1Pole/Mech, 2Break800 kVhttp://www.hitachi.com/products/power/TandD/gcb/

1Pole/Structure, 1Pole/Tank, 1Pole/Mech, 2Break550 kVhttp://www.mvtech.com.au/catalogues/MVT%20Siemens%20HVCB.pdfhttp://www.hitachi.com/products/power/TandD/gcb/

kind = breakerStructure

pole 2 base:AssetContainer

kind = breakerTankAssembly

pole 1 tank assembly:AssetContainer

position = 2

position 2:AssetPosition

pole 1 interrupter 1:InterrupterUnit

pole 1 mechanism:OperatingMechanism

+MovingContact +FixedContact

pole 1 interrupter 2:InterrupterUnit

kind = breakerTankAssembly

pole 3 tank assembly:AssetContainer

pole 3 interrupter 1:InterrupterUnit

pole 3 mechanism:OperatingMechanism

+MovingContact +FixedContact

pole 3 interrupter 2:InterrupterUnit

kind = breakerStructure

pole 1 base:AssetContainer

This Template1 Pole/Structure1 Pole/Tank1 Pole/MechanismDouble Break

kind = breakerStructure

pole 3 base:AssetContainer

kind = sF6

pole 1 tank medium:Medium

kind = sF6

pole 2 tank medium:Medium

kind = sF6

pole 3 tank medium:Mediumkind = breakerTankAssembly

pole 2 tank assembly:AssetContainerkind = breakerHeater

pole 1 tank heater:Asset

kind = breakerHeater

pole 2 tank heater:Asset

kind = breakerHeater

pole 3 tank heater:Asset

position = 3

position 3:AssetPosition

position = 4

position 4:AssetPosition

position = 5

position 5:AssetPosition

position = 6

position 6:AssetPosition

Do interrupters need position designation or is fixed contact to moving contact sufficient to identify which interrupter is which?If numbering interrupters are they 3 sets of 1 & 2 or are they 1 thru 6?

pole 2 bushing 1:Bushing pole 2 bushing 2:Bushingpole 1 bushing 1:Bushing pole 1 bushing 2:Bushing pole 3 bushing 1:Bushing pole 3 bushing 2:Bushing

SF6 Live Tank Examples (of types different from sample templates)

Example templates provided

SF6 Live Tank Breaker· 36 kV – 800 kV· Insulator stacks provide electrical

isolation, SF6 provides arc-extinguishment

· 1 or 2 SF6-filled interrupter chamber(s) in top insulator(s) of insulator column, where one to four insulator columns can be used per pole, with interrupters in series.

SF6 Live Tank Questions1. Are there heaters on SF6 live tank breakers? Should they be modeled off each interrupterUnit if they exist?2. Does it makes sense to model Medium on these breakers? Some of what I’ve read indicates that some models are essentially sealed at manufacture. If we use Medium, does it associate with the InterrupterUnit or the insulating stack assembly? <there is perhaps a larger discussion about when modeling of Medium should be done… when it’s makeup or condition is a factor in health, when it can be replaced.. what else?>3. Is breakerInsulatingStackAssembly or insulatingColumnAssembly a better .type? (same question for air blast circuit breaker and minimum oil)4.There are never more than 2 breaks on an insulating stack, right?5. There is no reason (or place) to model a relationship on SF6 live tank breakers that reflects the moving / fixed contact, right?6. What is the maximum number of insulating stacks?

1Pole/Structure, 1Stack/Pole, 1Pole/Mech, 2Break300 kVhttp://www.mvtech.com.au/catalogues/MVT%20Siemens%20HVCB.pdf

Interrupter: double-nozzle quenching (puffer, I think)Insulator: solid porcelainMechanism: hydraulic operated

1Pole/Structure, 1Stack/Pole, 1Pole/Mech, 1Break??? kVhttp://www.mvtech.com.au/catalogues/MVT%20Siemens%20HVCB.pdf

1Pole/Structure, 1Stack/Pole, 1Pole/Mech, 2Break400 kVhttp://www.skm-eleksys.com/2012/02/sf6-circuit-breaker-working.html

1Pole/Structure, 1Stack/Pole, 1Pole/Mech, 2Break420 kVhttp://tdworld.com/sponsored-articles/world-high-voltage-power

1Pole/Structure, 4Stacks/Pole, 1Pole/Mech, 4Break800 kVAlstom FXPower System Analysis and DesignBy J. Duncan Glover, Mulukutla Sarma, Thomas Overbye

Mechanism: hydraulic (or maybe spring if actually FXT)

1Pole/Structure, 1Stack/Pole, 1Pole/Mech, 1Break245 kVToshiba GSPF 245 HP??

Interrupter: pufferMechanism: spring

1 Pole/Structure3 Poles/Structure

1 Stack/Pole 2 Stacks/Pole1 Stack/Pole

1 Pole/Mechanism (rare)

3 Poles/Mechanism 1 Pole/Mechanism

Single Break

Double Break

4 Break(2 Breaks/

Stack)

1 Pole/Mechanism

n Stacks/Pole

1 Pole/Mechanism

n*2 Break(2 Breaks/Stack)

(n+1)-(n*2-1) Break (1 Break/Stack for some

Stacks2 Breaks/Stack for other

Stacks)

n Break (1 Break/Stack)

3 Stacks/Pole

1 Pole/Mechanism

6 Break(2 Breaks/Stack)

4-5 Break (1 Break/Stack for some Stacks2 Breaks/Stack

for other Stacks)

3 Break (1 Break/Stack)

3 Break (1 Break/Stack for one Stack

2 Breaks/Stack other Stack)

...

SF6 Live Tank Breaker Variants

Single Break

Double Break

Single Break

Double Break

2 Break(1 Break/

Stack)

Are thereSF6 live tank breakers where all 3 poles are on one structure that have double breaks?

Are SF6 live tanks ever configured with combinations of single and double break stack assemblies such that there are an odd number of breaks/pole?

Are SF6 live tanks ever configured with combinations of single and double break stack assemblies such that there are an odd number of breaks/pole?

Are SF6 live tanks ever configured with combinations of single and double break stack assemblies such that there are an odd number of breaks/pole?

kind = sF6

pole 1 interrupter medium:Medium

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 1 insulating stack assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 2 insulating stack assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 3 insulating stack assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerSF6LiveTankBreaker

whole SF6 live tank breaker:AssetContainer

position = 1

position 1:AssetPosition

position = 2

position 2:AssetPosition

position = 3

position 3:AssetPosition

pole 3 interrupter:InterrupterUnit

mechanism:OperatingMechanism

pole 2 interrupter:InterrupterUnit

3Poles/Structure, 1Stack/Pole, 3Poles/Mech, 1Break72.5 kV – 145 kV

http://www.energy.siemens.com/us/en/power-transmission/high-voltage-products/circuit-breaker/3ap1-fg-live-tank-circuit-breaker.htm

Interrupter: arc-assistedInsulator: porcelain or compositeMechanism – stored-energy spring

3Poles/Structure, 1Stack/Pole, 3Poles/Mech, 1Break36 kV – 84 kV

http://www.energy.siemens.com/us/en/power-transmission/high-voltage-products/circuit-breaker/sf6-hv-circuitbreaker-livetank.htm

Insulators – “Brown/Grey” or silicon rubberMechanism – motor charged spring operating mechanism (1 or 3)

This Template3 Poles/Structure1 Stack/Pole3 Poles/MechanismSingle Break

kind = breakerStructure

base:AssetContainer

pole 1 interrupter:InterrupterUnit

kind = sF6

pole 2 interrupter medium:Medium

kind = sF6

pole 3 interrupter medium:Medium

3Poles/Structure, 1?Poles/Tank, 3Poles/Mech, 1Break40.5 kVXian Electrichttp://www.openelectrical.org/wiki/index.php?title=Circuit_breakers andhttp://www.xianelectric.com/dzyb/download/gcb.pdf

kind = breakerStructure

pole 1 base:AssetContainer

kind = breakerSF6LiveTankBreaker

whole SF6 live tank breaker:AssetContainer

position = 1

position 1:AssetPosition

position = 2

position 2:AssetPosition

pole 2 interrupter 2:InterrupterUnit

pole 2 mechanism:OperatingMechanism

pole 2 interrupter 1:InterrupterUnit

kind = sF6

pole 2 interrupter 2 medium:Medium

1Pole/Structure, 2Stacks/Pole, 1Pole/Mech, 4Break800 kVhttp://www.mvtech.com.au/catalogues/MVT%20Siemens%20HVCB.pdf

Interrupter: self-compression (2 moveable contacts)Mechanism: spring drive

This Template1 Pole/Structure2 Stacks/Pole1 Pole/Mechanism4 Break

Is position designation (within insulating stack assembly) for InterrupterUnits sufficient that the connection (fixed contact to moving contact) between interrupers isn’t necessary?(Same situation exists for air blast circuits breakers)

kind = sF6

pole 2 interrupter 3 medium:Medium

position = 3

position 3:AssetPositionposition = 4

position 4:AssetPosition

pole 2 interrupter 4:InterrupterUnitpole 2 interrupter 3:InterrupterUnit

kind = sF6

pole 2 interrupter 4 medium:Medium

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 1 insulating stack assembly 1:AssetContainer

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 1 insulating stack assembly 2:AssetContainer

kind = breakerStructure

pole 3 base:AssetContainer

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 3 insulating stack assembly 2:AssetContainer

Assume all interrupters on same pole have same mechanism, regardless of insulating stack?

kind = sF6

pole 1 interrupter 1 medium:Medium

pole 1 interrupter 2:InterrupterUnitpole 1 interrupter 1:InterrupterUnit

kind = sF6

pole 1 interrupter 2 medium:Medium

pole 1 interrupter 4:InterrupterUnit

kind = sF6

pole 1 interrupter 4 medium:Medium

kind = sF6

pole 3 interrupter 1 medium:Medium

pole 3 interrupter 1:InterrupterUnit

kind = sF6

pole 3 interrupter 3 medium:Medium

pole 3 interrupter 4:InterrupterUnitpole 3 interrupter 3:InterrupterUnit

kind = sF6

pole 3 interrupter 4 medium:Medium

pole 1 mechanism:OperatingMechanism pole 3 mechanism:OperatingMechanism

kind = sF6

pole 2 interrupter 1 medium:Medium

kind = breakerStructure

pole 2 base:AssetContainer

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 2 insulating stack assembly 1:AssetContainer

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 2 insulating stack assembly 2:AssetContainer

pole 3 interrupter 2:InterrupterUnit

kind = sF6

pole 3 interrupter 2 medium:Medium

kind = sF6

pole 1 interrupter 3 medium:Medium

pole 1 interrupter 3:InterrupterUnit

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 3 insulating stack assembly 1:AssetContainer

Bulk Oil General Questions1. Is structure superfluous on Bulk Oil or does it make sense to match other types of breakers?

Bulk Oil· 11 kV – 330 kV· Mineral oil used for both insulation and arc-

extinguishment · Mineral oil-filled insulated (grounded) tank

containing interrupter(s) with connections made via bushings.

1 Pole/Tank3 Poles/Tank

3 Poles/Mechanism 1 Pole/Mechanism3 Poles/Mechanism

Bulk Oil Breaker Variants

Example templates provided

3 Poles /Structure

Note on double- and single-break bulk oil breakers:Double-break bulk oil breakers have 2 fixed contacts.Single-break bulk oil breakers have one fixed and one moving contact.

Example templates are for double-break bulk oil breakers.

Double-break bulk oil breakerhttp://www.openelectrical.org/wiki/index.php?title=Circuit_breakers

Single-break bulk oil breakerhttp://www.openelectrical.org/wiki/index.php?title=Circuit_breakers

Single Break Double Break Single Break Double Break Single Break Double Break

kind = mineralOil

tank medium:Medium

kind = breakerTankAssembly

tank assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerBulkOilBreaker

whole bulk oil breaker:AssetContainer

bushing 2:Bushing bushing 5:Bushing bushing 6:Bushing

position = 1

position 1:AssetPosition

position = 2

position 2:AssetPosition

position = 3

position 3:AssetPosition

position = 4

position 4:AssetPosition

position = 5

position 5:AssetPosition

position = 6

position 6:AssetPosition

pole 1 interrupter:InterrupterUnit pole 2 interrupter:InterrupterUnit pole 3 interrupter:InterrupterUnit

+FixedContact +FixedContact +FixedContact +FixedContact+FixedContact+FixedContact

This Template3Poles/Structure3Poles/Tank3Poles/Mechanism

mechanism:OperatingMechanism

kind = breakerStructure

base:AssetContainer

3Poles/Structure, 3Poles/Tank, 3Poles/Mech66 kVhttp://www.openelectrical.org/wiki/index.php?title=Circuit_breakershttp://industrialtests.com/sf6-circuit-breaker-testing-maintenance/

3Poles/Structure, 3Poles/Tank, 3Poles/Mech27 kVGE FKD-25.8-11000-4http://www.westcoastswitchgear.com/Inventory/Breaker/Details/SB3006Manufactured 1971

bushing 3:Bushing bushing 4:Bushingbushing 1:Bushing

kind = mineralOil

pole 1 tank medium:Medium

kind = breakerTankAssembly

pole 1 tank assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerTankAssembly

pole 2 tank assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerTankAssembly

pole 3 tank assembly:AssetContainer

kind = mineralOil

pole 2 tank medium:Medium

kind = mineralOil

pole 3 tank medium:Medium

bushing 1:Bushing bushing 2:Bushing bushing 5:Bushingbushing 3:Bushing bushing 4:Bushing bushing 6:Bushing

position = 1

position 1:AssetPosition

position = 2

position 2:AssetPosition

position = 3

position 3:AssetPosition

position = 4

position 4:AssetPosition

position = 5

position 5:AssetPosition

position = 6

position 6:AssetPosition

pole 1 interrupter:InterrupterUnit pole 2 interrupter:InterrupterUnit pole 3 interrupter:InterrupterUnit

+FixedContact +FixedContact +FixedContact +FixedContact+FixedContact+FixedContact

kind = breakerBulkOilBreaker

whole bulk oil breaker:AssetContainer

kind = breakerStructure

base:AssetContainer

This Template3 Poles/Structure1 Pole/Tank3 Poles/Mechanism

mechanism:OperatingMechanism

3Poles/Structure, 1Pole/Tank, 3Poles/Mech ?? kVhttp://www.inl.gov/featurestories/2003-03-25.shtml

3Poles/Structure, 1Pole/Tank, 3Poles/Mech?? kVPaul B

3Poles/Structure, 1Pole/Tank, 3Poles/Mech41 kVhttp://emadrlc.blogspot.com/2007/10/oil-circuit-breakers.html

3Poles/Structure, 1Pole/Tank, 3Poles/Mech 230 kV (in 138kV application)http://electrical-engineering-portal.com/oil-circuit-breaker-how-does-it-interrupt-the-arc

3Poles/Structure, 1Pole/Tank, 3Poles/Mech?? kVhttp://electrical-engineering-portal.com/circuit-breakers-classified-by-interrupting-medium

3Poles/Structure, 1Pole/Tank, 3Poles/Mech ?? kVSiemensGowri

Minimum OIl Examples (of types different from sample templates) Example templates provided

Minimum Oil (Live Tank) Breaker· 38 kV – 765 kV· Insulator stacks provide electrical

isolation, mineral oil provides arc-extinguishment

· 1 or 2 oil-filled interrupter chamber(s) in top insulator(s) of insulator column, where one or more insulator columns can be used per pole, with interrupters in series.

Minimum Oil Questions1.Are there fundamental differences between how SF6 live tank, air blast and minimum oil are configured or does the template end up basically being the same?

1 Pole/Structure3 Poles/Structure

2+ Stacks/Pole1 Stack/Pole 2 Stacks/Pole1 Stack/Pole

1 Pole/Mechanism (rare)3 Poles/Mechanism 1 Pole/Mechanism3 Poles/Mechanism

Single Break Double Break 2 Break (1 Break/Stack)

4 Break(2 Breaks/Stack)

Single Break Double Break

1 Pole/Mechanism3 Poles/Mechanism

Single Break Double Break

n Stacks/Pole

1 Pole/Mechanism3 Poles/Mechanism

n*2 Break(2 Breaks/Stack)

(n+1)-(n*2-1) Break (1 Break/Stack for some

Stacks2 Breaks/Stack for other

Stacks)

n Break (1 Break/Stack)

3 Stacks/Pole

1 Pole/Mechanism3 Poles/Mechanism

6 Break(2 Breaks/Stack)

4-5 Break (1 Break/Stack

for some Stacks2 Breaks/Stack

for other Stacks)

3 Break (1 Break/Stack)

3 Break (1 Break/Stack for one Stack

2 Breaks/Stack other Stack)

...

SF6 Live Tank Breaker Variants

I could only find textbook references to “breaks in series” (no pictures) for minimum oil breakers. Do they use more than one stack per pole?

3Poles/Structure, 1Stack/Pole, 3Poles/Mech, 2Breakhttp://www.eeh.ee.ethz.ch/uploads/tx_ethstudies/eps_st_lec6.pdf

kind = mineralOil

pole 1 interrupter medium:Medium

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 1 insulating stack assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 2 insulating stack assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 3 insulating stack assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerMinimumOilBreaker

whole SF6 live tank breaker:AssetContainer

position = 1

position 1:AssetPosition

position = 2

position 2:AssetPosition

position = 3

position 3:AssetPosition

pole 3 interrupter:InterrupterUnit

mechanism:OperatingMechanism

pole 2 interrupter:InterrupterUnit

This Template3 Poles/Structure1 Stack/Pole3 Poles/MechanismSingle Break

kind = breakerStructure

base:AssetContainer

pole 1 interrupter:InterrupterUnit

kind = mineralOil

pole 2 interrupter medium:Medium

kind = mineralOil

pole 3 interrupter medium:Medium

3Poles/Structure, 1Stack/Pole, 3Poles/Mech, 1Breakhttp://www.openelectrical.org/wiki/index.php?title=Circuit_breakers

3Poles/Structure, 1Stack/Pole, 3Poles/Mech, 1Breakhttp://yourelectrichome.blogspot.com/2011/03/minimum-oil-circuit-breaker-mocb.html

3Poles/Structure, 1Stack/Pole, 3Poles/Mech, 1Break132 kV(at Energy Austraia)http://emadrlc.blogspot.com/2012/06/132kv-mineral-oil-circuit-breakers.html

3Poles/Structure, 1Stack/Pole, 3Poles/Mech, 1Breakhttp://www.bhel.com/product_services/power/switch/hlc.htm

Same question about what Medium should be attached to...

1 Pole/Structure3 Poles/Structure

2+ Stacks/Pole1 Stack/Pole 2 Stacks/Pole1 Stack/Pole

1 Pole/Mechanism3 Poles/Mechanism 1 Pole/Mechanism3 Poles/Mechanism

Single Break Double Break 2 Break (1 Break/Stack)

4 Break(2 Breaks/Stack)

Air Blast Circuit Breaker Variants

Air Blast Examples (of types different from sample templates) Example templates provided

Air Blast Circuit Breaker· 132 kV –700 kV· Insulator stacks provide electrical

isolation, pressurized air provides arc-extinguishment

· 1 or 2 air-filled interrupter chamber(s) in top insulator(s) of insulator column, where one to ten insulator columns can be used per pole, with interrupters in series.

Air Blast Questions1. Does it makes sense to model Medium on these breakers? If we use Medium, does it associate with the InterrupterUnit or the base or a reservoir?

Single Break Double Break

1 Pole/Mechanism3 Poles/Mechanism

Single Break Double Break

1Pole/Structure, 2Stack/Pole, 1Pole/Mech, 4Break500 kVhttp://www.openelectrical.org/wiki/index.php?title=File:Air_CB_500_KV.gif

1Pole/Structure, 4Stack/Pole, 1Pole?/Mech, 8Break300 kVHigh-Voltage Engineering: Theory and Practice, Second Edition, Revised and ...By Mazen Abdel-Salam

3 Stacks/Pole

1 Pole/Mechanism3 Poles/Mechanism

6 Break(2 Breaks/Stack)

4-5 Break (1 Break/Stack

for some Stacks2 Breaks/Stack

for other Stacks)

3 Break (1 Break/Stack)

3 Break (1 Break/Stack for one Stack

2 Breaks/Stack other Stack)

3Poles/Structure, 1Stack/Pole, 3Poles/Mech, 1Break71 kV - 84 kVhttp://www.fujielectric.com/company/tech_archives/pdf/11-04/FER-11-04-104-1965.pdf

...

1Poles/Structure, 5Stacks/Pole, 1Poles/Mech, 10Break420kVhttp://tdworld.com/sponsored-articles/world-high-voltage-power

1Pole/Structure, 2Stack/Pole, 1Pole/Mech, 4Break?? kVAlstom PKhttp://www.alstom.com/Global/Grid/Resources/Documents/Service/Alstom%20Grid%20-%20Circuit%20breaker%20lifecycle%20management.pdf

n Stacks/Pole

1 Pole/Mechanism3 Poles/Mechanism

n*2 Break(2 Breaks/Stack)

(n+1)-(n*2-1) Break (1 Break/Stack for some

Stacks2 Breaks/Stack for other

Stacks)

n Break (1 Break/Stack)

It seems that air blast breakers with multiple stack assemblies/pole don’t have only one interrupter on the stack. Is this true?

kind = air

medium:Medium

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 1 insulating stack assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 2 insulating stack assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 3 insulating stack assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerAirBlastBreaker

whole air blast breaker:AssetContainer

position = 1

position 1:AssetPosition

position = 2

position 2:AssetPosition

position = 3

position 3:AssetPosition

mechanism:OperatingMechanism

This Template3 Poles/Structure1 Stack/Pole3 Poles/MechanismSingle Break

kind = breakerStructure

base:AssetContainer

3Poles/Structure, 1Stack/Pole, 3?Poles/Mech, 2Break??kVPaul B

pole 1 interrupter 2:InterrupterUnitpole 1 interrupter 1:InterrupterUnit pole 3 interrupter 2:InterrupterUnitpole 3 interrupter 1:InterrupterUnitpole 2 interrupter 2:InterrupterUnitpole 2 interrupter 1:InterrupterUnit

Should this type be .breakerReservoir not .breakerStructure?Should we model a reservoir off the base?(Same thing with other air blast breaker template)

kind = breakerStructure

pole 1 base:AssetContainer

kind = breakerAirBlastBreaker

whole air blast breaker:AssetContainer

position = 1

position 1:AssetPosition

pole 2 interrupter 2:InterrupterUnit

pole 2 mechanism:OperatingMechanism

pole 2 interrupter 1:InterrupterUnit

This Template1 Pole/Structure3 Stacks/Pole1 Pole/Mechanism6 Break

Are assuming here that the namplate applies to a set of all 3 single pole assemblies. Correct?

position = 3

position 3:AssetPosition

position = 4

position 4:AssetPosition

pole 2 interrupter 4:InterrupterUnitpole 2 interrupter 3:InterrupterUnit

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 1 insulating stack assembly 1:AssetContainer

kind = breakerStructure

pole 3 base:AssetContainer

kind = air

pole 1 medium:Medium

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 3 insulating stack assembly 1:AssetContainer

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 3 insulating stack assembly 2:AssetContainer

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 2 insulating stack assembly 1:AssetContainer

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 2 insulating stack assembly 2:AssetContainer

Assume all interrupters on same pole have same mechanism, regardless of insulating stack?

1Pole/Structure, 3Stack/Pole, 3?Poles/Mech, 6Break?? kVPaul B

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 1 insulating stack assembly 3:AssetContainer

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 3 insulating stack assembly 3:AssetContainer

kind = air

pole 3 medium:Medium

pole 2 interrupter 6:InterrupterUnitpole 2 interrupter 5:InterrupterUnit

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 2 insulating stack assembly 3:AssetContainer

position = 5

position 5:AssetPosition

position = 6

position 6:AssetPosition

Does this particular breaker have one mechanism for each pole or one for the whole breaker?

kind = breakerStructure

pole 2 base:AssetContainer

pole 1 interrupter 2:InterrupterUnitpole 1 interrupter 1:InterrupterUnit pole 1 interrupter 3:InterrupterUnit pole 3 interrupter 4:InterrupterUnitpole 3 interrupter 3:InterrupterUnit

pole 3 mechanism:OperatingMechanism

pole 1 interrupter 6:InterrupterUnitpole 1 interrupter 5:InterrupterUnit pole 3 interrupter 6:InterrupterUnitpole 3 interrupter 5:InterrupterUnit

kind = air

pole 2 medium:Medium

position = 2

position 2:AssetPosition

pole 3 interrupter 1:InterrupterUnit

pole 1 mechanism:OperatingMechanism

pole 1 interrupter 4:InterrupterUnit pole 3 interrupter 2:InterrupterUnit

kind = breakerInsulatingStackAssembly

pole 1 insulating stack assembly 2:AssetContainer

position = 4

position 1:AssetPosition

kind = bushing

bushing O Plus C position 4:GeneralAsset

position = 3

position 1:AssetPosition

kind = bushing

bushing O Plus C position 3:GeneralAsset

position = 2

position 1:AssetPosition

kind = bushing

bushing O Plus C position 2:GeneralAsset

position = 1

position 1:AssetPosition

kind = bushing

bushing O Plus C position 1:GeneralAsset

position = 6

position 1:AssetPosition

kind = bushing

bushing O Plus C position 6:GeneralAsset

position = 5

position 1:AssetPosition

kind = bushing

bushing O Plus C position 5:GeneralAsset

kind = sF6

tank medium:Mediumkind = breakerTankAssembly

tank assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerSF6DeadTankBreaker

whole SF6 dead tank breaker:AssetContainer

kind = breakerStructure

base:AssetContainer

heater model:GeneralAsset

kind = breakerTankHeater

Bushings & heater as GeneralAssets (no interrupters or mechanism)

kind = sF6

tank medium:Mediumkind = breakerTankAssembly

tank assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerSF6DeadTankBreaker

whole SF6 dead tank breaker:AssetContainer

bushing 2:Bushing bushing 5:Bushing bushing 6:Bushing

position = 1

position 1:AssetPosition

position = 2

position 2:AssetPosition

position = 3

position 3:AssetPosition

position = 4

position 4:AssetPosition

position = 5

position 5:AssetPosition

position = 6

position 6:AssetPosition

kind = breakerStructure

base:AssetContainer

bushing 1:Bushing bushing 3:Bushing bushing 4:Bushing

CT model:GeneralAsset

kind = bushingCT

heater model:GeneralAsset

kind = breakerTankHeater

kind = sF6

tank medium:Mediumkind = breakerTankAssembly

tank assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerSF6DeadTankBreaker

whole SF6 dead tank breaker:AssetContainer

bushing 2:Bushing bushing 5:Bushing bushing 6:Bushing

position = 1

position 1:AssetPosition

position = 2

position 2:AssetPosition

position = 3

position 3:AssetPosition

position = 4

position 4:AssetPosition

position = 5

position 5:AssetPosition

position = 6

position 6:AssetPosition

+MovingContact +MovingContact +MovingContact +FixedContact+FixedContact+FixedContact

mechanism:OperatingMechanism

kind = breakerStructure

base:AssetContainer

bushing 1:Bushing bushing 3:Bushing bushing 4:Bushing

pole 1 interrupter:InterrupterUnit pole 2 interrupter:InterrupterUnit pole 3 interrupter:InterrupterUnit

CT model:GeneralAsset

kind = bushingCT

heater model:GeneralAsset

kind = breakerTankHeater

interrupter model:GeneralAsset

kind = breakerInterrupterUnit

+MovingContact +FixedContact +MovingContact +FixedContact +MovingContact +FixedContact

Interrupter, CT & heater as GeneralAssets (no mechanism)

kind = sF6

tank medium:Mediumkind = breakerTankAssembly

tank assembly:AssetContainer

kind = breakerSF6DeadTankBreaker

whole SF6 dead tank breaker:AssetContainer

bushing 2:Bushing bushing 5:Bushing bushing 6:Bushing

position = 1

position 1:AssetPosition

position = 2

position 2:AssetPosition

position = 3

position 3:AssetPosition

position = 4

position 4:AssetPosition

position = 5

position 5:AssetPosition

position = 6

position 6:AssetPosition

+MovingContact +MovingContact +MovingContact +FixedContact+FixedContact+FixedContact

kind = breakerStructure

base:AssetContainer

bushing 1:Bushing bushing 3:Bushing bushing 4:Bushing

pole 1 interrupter:InterrupterUnit pole 2 interrupter:InterrupterUnit pole 3 interrupter:InterrupterUnit

CT model:GeneralAsset

kind = bushingCT

heater model:GeneralAsset

kind = breakerTankHeater

Mechanism, CT & heater as GeneralAssets (must create multi-pole mechansm GeneralAsset instance for this type of breaker

and 3 individual pole mechanism GeneralAsset instances for breakers w/ 1 mechanism per pole)

3-pole mechanism model:GeneralAsset

kind = breakerOperatingMechanism

CT & heater as GeneralAssets

Whole breaker as GeneralAsset (no components)

kind = breakerSF6DeadTankBreaker

whole SF6 dead tank breaker:GeneralAsset

name = <manufacturer name>

manufacturer:Manufacturer

Relationships that might “make sense” in defining any GeneralAsset instance

kind = <general asset kind>

instance of general asset:GeneralAsset

styleNumber = <style number>modelNumber = <model number>modelVersion = <version number>

model:ProductAssetModel

position = <position>

position:AssetPosition

model nameplate:AssetInfo child

general asset nameplate:AssetInfo child

Share = <percent share>

ownership:Ownership

equipment instance:PowerSystemResourcephysical asset:AssetContainer or child