Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
From Vision to Reality
The Architectural Journey that Ensures a Customized Design for Your Ministry
Aubrey Garrison LIVE Design Group Birmingham, AL
Craig Krawczyk LIVE Design Group Birmingham, AL
Eric Partin Shoreline Church Destin, FL
Share Two Things:
Innovation in the Design of Churches Evolution of Design & Construction process
Share Two Things:
Innovation in the Design of Churches Evolution of Design & Construction process
DEMONSTRATE THIS DESIGN PROCESS CONCEPT FOR WORSHIP ROOM DESIGN
Innovation in the Design of Churches Evolution of Design & Construction process
Demonstrate: Collect Design Requirements for Demonstration
#2 How many seats? 800 – 2,000 #3 Percentage of flat floor to stadium seating?
#1 Site size acres? 4 – 30 acres
#4 Seating Layout? Narrow or Wide Fan #5 Stage layout? Depth and Width
Demonstrate: Collect Design Requirements for Demonstration
#7 Control Booth location? #8 Video Screen locations? #9 Catwalk? Yes or No #10 Exposed Structure or Ceiling Clouds?
#6 Proscenium? Yes or No
Vision to Reality: Change Perception of God / Change Perception of Church
Experience Community That’s Authentic & Comfortable
A Church That is Attractive to the Community
A Desirable Place to Be Any Time of the Week
A Building that would Cultivate Creativity
A Passion to Share the Experience with Others
at Shoreline Church
ABSOLUTES of church design process: God has a plan for the Church
Church & design team seeking God’s plan together All things happen within God’s timing Vision and the Dream The church’s staff knows the DNA Dream vs Budget Dream Big – Don’t follow formulas
Launched in 2001 with attendance of 400
Relocated to 2,400 seat campus with 5,300 per weekend in 2007
Growth Formulas would have projected approximately 12,000 per weekend for 2016
Actual weekend attendance in 2016 is 42,000 +/- at 14 locations
What is the Mindset of the Architect / Design Team
How does Church–Architect–Contractor Team Function
Level of Design Involvement by the Church Team
Level of Collaboration
Level of Immersion and Understanding by Church
EVOLUTION of CHANGE?
Architecture Historically: Architects designed Historic Churches with hand drawn plans
In mid-1900’s, still drawn by hand, but larger offices & employees
Construction technology progressed over time
Design technology plateaued until CADD
Experience with design firms? How many have worked with an architect on a new building project?
What was your experience?
POSITIVE?
NEUTRAL?
NEGATIVE?
Did the Architect listen?
All by design team without church involvement
Design team’s decisions arrived here
Church wanted to be here
Option 1: Modify design team’s concept to get to here
Options 2: To get to here. Start over? Option 3: hire new
design team?
$$$ More design fees
And, more time
What is the mindset of the architect?
an ART FORM?
“I agreed to design Cortlandt for the purpose of seeing it erected as I designed it and for no other reason.
Howard Roark Mindset? Architect’s self percep.on vastly different than the public’s percep.on
“Even when you like what the architect came up with, you hate to admit it just because you don’t want the architect to be right” -‐ Mellissa from New Life Bap2st
Practical Example
Architect 1 – adamant against the arches
Architect 2 – changed the design of arches
Architect 3 – didn’t want to be told what to do
McDonald brothers wanted arches on their first building
Mindset of the Architect / Design Team team oriented / extreme collaboration serve the church / selflessness attitude
Integration of Church–Architect–Contractor Team
Involve the Church Team in the Design Process Collaboration: high level of communication & transparency
Technology that supports emersion into process
We believe there is a BETTER WAY:
IMAGINE ?
with no back and forth
create a new form of design synergy
working together - Unified
with church, design team & contractor
based on real-time communication mutual ownership of ideas church understands of every design decision
IMAGINE ? A way to design a church that insures Vision & DNA integrated into design image and concept.
IMAGINE ?
Achieving this goal IS the design process
it was possible to get all the input contributors together in one room….
….testing multiple solutions
….making multiple compounding decisions simultaneously
IMAGINE ?
it were possible to get all the input contributors together in one room….
….testing multiple solutions
….making multiple compounding decisions simultaneously
IMAGINE ?
IMAGINE ? watching the creation of your design while you participate?
IMAGINE ? providing real-time input for each design decision
IMAGINE ? advising in the location of the control booth or catwalk
IMAGINE ? understanding every decision related to your design
ONE EXAMPLE….
seating configuration
The SIMPLEST of Decisions Are truly complex....
EVERY PROJECT HAS Hundreds of Long Term Decision Paths....
MINDSET of Design & Construction Industry
is rapidly changing
reality
After 20 year plateau of CADD, now BIM is changing design & construction
Architects & contractors on sharp curve upward
BIM is a Big “C” change
Founded in 1768
Encyclopedia Britannica
1991
Britannica revenue of $650 Million
Big “C” Change
Founded in 1768
Encyclopedia Britannica
1991 1993
$650 Million
1980’s
Microsoft asked Britannica to collaborate in digital version but was rejected
Microsoft launches Encarta with Funk & Wagnall
Big “C” Change
Founded in 1768
Encyclopedia Britannica
1991 1993
$650 Million
1980’s
Microsoft asked Britannica to collaborate in digital version
Microsoft launches Encarta with Funk & Wagnall
1996
Britannica files for bankruptcy
Big “C” Change
parametric data
BIM
material specifications component quantities
Building Information Modeling
BIM Building Information Modeling
3D Visualiza2ons 3D Building Systems
traditional project team organization
engineering consultants
sub-contractors
traditional project team organization
removes connection of architect with church architect accountable to only contractor
innovative project team organization
traditional project team organization
new project team organization
consultants team with sub=contractors
consultants engineer, sub=contractors build BIM models
everyone collaborates
BIM Building Information Modeling
Design Team
Church
Construction Team
COLLABORATION
Eliminates architects working in a vacuum without the church
Church participates in all initial decisions
enter desired seat count
3D program mass objects re-size automatically
Cost summary based on average $/SF adjust for programming areas as seat count changes
3D design assist program, custom developed for church concept development
Design components change automatically as “sliders” are adjusted
Components include: seating section angles; depth of flat floor and stadium seating; distance from stage; screen location.
innovative team communications
Watoto Church Kampala, Uganda
one team in Africa with church
one team in Birmingham, AL on Go-To Meeting
innovative team communications
Watoto Church Kampala, Uganda
all communication with church now utilizes internet meeting technology
BIM Building Information Modeling
systems clash detection
BIM Building Information Modeling
4D scheduling capability
Systems and material quantiles take-offs
Innovators vs Early Adaptors
Innovators vs Early Adaptors
Innovate, or be Left Behind
Innovate, or be Left Behind
Innovate, or be Left Behind
Slide rule vs calculator
Innovate, or be Left Behind
BLOCKBUSTER $6 Billon - 2004
BLOCKBUSTER Bankrupt - 2010
Innovate, or be Left Behind
Technology is creating the CHASM. Early Majority has to be sold
Consumption curves with technology are getting steeper with time.
Virtual Reality Visualization
Inserts the viewer into the virtual 3D model.
Virtual Reality Visualization watch your project created around you.
Workstation surrounded with flat screen image of project.
Room surrounded with flat screen image of project.
Total immersion with virtual technology.
How far will this technology evolve?
Visualize a dome or sphere with total immersion into your project.
parametric data
BIM
material specs component quantities
Building Information Modeling
All this data can be utilized in so many ways
Buildings & Building Components
Imagine 3D Printing
Infrastructure
3D Printing
Like this bridge over a canal in Amsterdam
affordable = small & slow
3D Printing
consumer use?
In your house, printing daily supplies
3D Printing UNLIMITED opportunities Applications getting faster and with greater capabilities
3D Printing UNLIMITED
Even replacement parts for various health issues.
3D Printing UNLIMITED Cars and housing that connect to each other for power source.
off planet
3D Printing
Construction automated with BIM and 3D printing
From Vision to Reality
A different perspective and an introduction to alternate approach to designing churches
design demonstration
status
QUESTIONS?