Fracking and Health: facts vs. fiction

8/12/2019 Fracking and Health: facts vs. fiction

1/35


2/35

!"#$%&'( #'* +,#-.+!"#$% '%( !)#$)*+

, -./0)#"$)*+ *! $12

!"#$$%& ()

3)00)"4 5.#26)27

*+,%- .& + (../ +0$1."%- ()

812*9*:2 ;( 8124< =>< =?< @1>< =@A< ;,BCD=


3/35

!"#$%&'( #'* +,#-./0 !#$.1 213 !&$.&4'

!

!"#$%&'( #'* +,#-./0 !#$.1 213 !&$.&4'3 !"#$%&'() + ,-./ 0$ 123%&456 !"764&8

"6 94&3643 56: ;358)(< 188 %&'()= %3=3%>3:< ?" #5%) "@ )(&= 0""A 25$ 03 7=3: "%

%3#%":743: &6 56$ 25))3% B(5)="3>3% B&)("7) B%&))36 #3%2&==&"6 3C43#) &6 )(3 45=3 "@

0%&3@ D7")5)&"6= 320":&3: &6 4%&)&458 5%)&483= 56: %3>&3B=< E"% 2"%3 &6@"%25)&"6F 4"6)54)G

123%&456 !"764&8 "6 94&3643 56: ;358)(

.HHI J%"5:B5$F 97&)3 ,-,

?3B K"%AF ?3B K"%A .--,LMINO-P38< Q,.,R LO,MS-//< E5C Q,.,R LO,M/H.H

TUVG ())#GWWBBB=< E&4)&"6

Z%&43G [O


4/35

!"#$%&'( *+,(&%- +( .&%#( '(/ 0#'-12

"

#$%% '($)*'+, -./0/1=="4&5)3 a&%34)"% "@ )(3 9"7)(B3=)Z366=$8>56&5 X6>&%"6236)58 ;358)( Z%"_34)

!"!#$$%&' )*

1$2.3)% .4%%350, 10, 6321+, 6324)1,632)-P"C&4"8"'&=) 5) b836 E588= ;"=#&)58

+,-. /%,,0' 12

357.45+ #/ 8($--4, 10, 1-.1=="4&5)3 Z($=&4&56F 934)&"6 "@c447#5)&"658 d3:&4&63F b7)(%&3

!8&6&4F V):3= :%&88&6' 5 >3%)&458 ("83 :"B6 )" =3>3%58

(76:%3: @33) 50">3 )(3 )5%'3) %3=3%>"&%F B(&4( &= '363%588$ ,F--- )" HF--- @33) 038"B )(3

=7%@543F )(36 )7%6&6' )(3 :%&88 0&) )(%"7'( 56 5%4 76)&8 &) &= :%&88&6' 3==36)&588$ ("%&^"6)58M

"% :&=%7#)F )(3 %"4A B(&83 5 #%"##56) Q)$#&4588$ D75%)^ =56: '%5&6=R 45%%&3: &6 )(3

* B$8BB%.= 60 % C%=-$6%, =5%= D6,, E--B %. 6.7$?) *>113(+


9/35

!"#$%&'( #'* +,#-./0 !#$.1 213 !&$.&4'

@

%3#"%)= 854A 4%&)&458 5658$=3= 56: :&=47==&"6= "@ :"=3M%3=#"6=3 %385)&"6=(=F B(&4( 5%3

4%74&58 )" 76:3%=)56:&6' )"C&4&)$ 5%'7236)=3 &6D7&%$ 56: &6>3=)&'5M

B5= @"76:F 56: 588 5>5&85083 :5)5 =7''3=) )(3 #%"43== &= 4"2#83)38$ =5@3 &6 )3%2= "@

%385)3: 5:>3%=3 (7256M(358)( &2#54) &6 8"458 %3=&:36)=< P(&= &= 6") )" =5$ )(5) )(3

(358)(M%385)3: "7)4"23= &= %3D7&%3:


10/35

!"#$%&'( *+,(&%- +( .&%#( '(/ 0#'-12

A

`64%35=3: 5B5%363== 50"7) 7=&6' 5 (&'(8$ )34(6&458 #%"43== 45883: ($:%578&4 @%54)7%&6'

)" %34">3% 65)7%58 '5= )%5##3: :33# B&)(&6 =(583 :3#"=&)= (5= 4%35)3: D73=)&"6= 50"7)

%385)3: (7256M(358)( 56: 36>&%"6236)58 &2#54)=< 1=="4&5)3: 5%'7236)=F 0")( #%" 56:

d5%43887= 9(583 Z85$ =1,, >#?@ >ABC@ ?#(, 66D5)&"6= 6"B 5%3 36508&6' )(3 :3>38"#236) 56: 3C#8"&)5)&"6 "@ 76:3%'%"76:

%3=3%>3= "643 4"6=&:3%3: 76%34">3%5083< a"23=)&4 ="7%43= "@ =(583 '5= 8"6' (5>3 0336

A6"B6 )" 3C&=)5)3: 0$ (56: )" 5 :3#)( "@ ,S @33)F )(3 B388 =7##8&3: '5= )" )(3 )"B6 @"% &8872&65M

9)5)3= Q!7%)&=F ,--,R3 )34(6&D73= B3%3 &6)%":743: )" 36(5643 3C&=)&6' @%54)7%3=

&6 )(3 =(583 56: 58=" )" 4%35)3 63B "63=< \(&83 )(3 )34(6&D73= B"%A3:F )(3 %3=78)=

B3%36e) 36)&%38$ =5)&=@54)"%$F 56: 0$ )(3 .HI-= 76:3%'%"76: 3C#8"=&>3= 03'56 )" 03

%3#8543: B&)( 5 63B #%"43== A6"B6 5= f($:%5@%54Fg &6 B(&4( 8&D7&:= 56: #%"##56)=

B3%3 #72#3: 76:3% (&'( #%3==7%3 &6)" =3834)&>3 =(583 ^"63= @"% @%54)7%3 36(5643236)&883MJ"==&3% =(583 :7%&6' )(3 h7%5==&4 #3%&": Q5##%"C&M

25)38$ .I- 2&88&"6 $35%= 5'"R< `@ )(3 >"8723 "@ "%'56&4 25)3%&58 4"6)5&63: B&)(&6 )(3

=70_34)3: )" (&'( (35) 56: #%3==7%3 ">3% 2&88&"6= "@ $35%=3%8&3 )(3 =(583 :3#"=&)G ]36)74A$F d5%$856:F ?3B h3%=3$F ?3B K"%AF c(&"F

85$3%= "@ )(3 d5%43887= 9(583 %56'3 @%"2 83== )(56 I @33) )(&4A )" 2"%3 )(56 ,I- @33)

7.) 13(2)%%>* *.3%)


15/35

!"#$%&'( #'* +,#-./0 !#$.1 213 !&$.&4'

BE

)(&4AF B&)( )(3 5##%"C&25)3 :3#)( )" )(3 05=3 %56'&6' @%"2 50"7) ,F--- @33) )" HF---

@33) 038"B '%"76: =7%@543< 1) '%35)3% :3#)(=F )(3 ">3%8$&6' %"4A= 457=3 '%35)3% #%3==7%3

&6 )(3 d5%43887= @"%25)&"6 B(&4( 456 %3=78) &6 (&'(3% #%":74)&"6 %5)3= &@ #%"#3%8$

=)&2785)3:< `6 '363%58F B&)( '%35)3% :3#)(F )(3 65)7%58 '5= 4"6)5&6= (&'(3% #%"#"%)&"6="@ 23)(563 56: 83== #%"#563F 07)563F 56: 3)(563 QZ366 9)5)3 d!cUF ,-./R3%3:F )34(6&4588$ %34">3%508365)7%58 '5= 56: L3%5083 65)7%58

'5= 8&D7&:=F 544"%:&6' )" 56 5==3==236) 0$ )(3 T< 9< b3"8"'&458 97%>3$ QT9b9R< P(3

9(583 &6 )(3 1##5854(&56 J5=&6 &6 ,--,< P(3 &64%35=3 &6 76:&=4">3%3:F )34(6&4588$

%34">3%5083 %3="7%43 &= :73 )" 63B '3"8"'&4 &6@"%25)&"6 56: 36'&633%&6' :5)5F 5= )34(6"M

85=) :345:338"#236)= &6 :%&88&6' )34(6"8"'$F 58"6' B&)( (&'(3% B388(35: #%&43=F (5>3

25:3 )(3 d5%43887= 9(583 56 &2#"%)56) 65)7%58 '5= %3="7%43 Q9"3:3% 56: ]5##38F

,--HR< P(3 d5%43887= &= 4(5%54)3%&^3: 5= 5 f)&'()g =(583F B&)( >3%)&458 @%54)7%3= Q"%

f_"&6)=gR )(5) 5%3 @3B 56: 65)7%588$ "447%%&6'< P(&= 6343==&)5)3= )(3 5##8&45)&"6 "@

("%&^"6)58F =70=7%@543 :%&88&6' )34(6&D73=F B&)( 36'&633%&6' #%"43:7%3= )(5) &6>"A3

!"#$"%"&

'(")

*+%%,-./&%"&

0+1

2+#,+-

0+14)#5

6-.&%7

50 50

100

100200

200

200

200

150

100

50

250

150

100

50

250

300

350

50150

100

100

150

50

150

50

!"#$%&&'( *+"&% ,+-$./%((

89 :8 ;3%3: @%"2 )(3 B388 56: :&=#"=3: "@

P(3 '3"8"'&4 4%"== =34)&"6 Q038"BR :3#&4)= )(3 3C)36) 56: :3#)( "@ )(3 d5%43887= 9(583

&6 6"%)(35=)3%6 56: 436)%58 Z366=$8>56&5F )(3 d5%43887= E"%25)&"6 '363%588$ 034"23=

=(588"B3% 5) :3#)(= "@ ,F--- @33) )"B5%: 6"%)(B3=) Z366=$8>56&5< P(3 d5%43887= 9(583

76:3%8&3= 635%8$ SI #3%436) "@ Z366=$8>56&5 QZ366 9)5)3 d!cUF ,-./R38"#236) QT9b9

)(3 .HN-= )(5) )(3 )34(6"8"'$ B5= &2#%">3: 36"7'( )" 034"23 5 =)56:5%: &6:7=)%$

#%54)&43< P(3 )34(6"8"'$ &6>"8>3= :%&88&6' 5 >3%)&458 ("83 )" =3>3%58 (76:%3: @33)

50">3 )(3 )5%'3) %3=3%>"&%F )(36 :&%34)&6' )(3 :%&88 0&) )(%"7'( 56 5%4 76)&8 &) &= :%&88&6'

3==36)&588$ ("%&^"6)588$ Q;5%#3%F ,--NR< P(3 5:>56)5'3= "@ ("%&^"6)58 B388= &6487:3&64%35=3= &6 )(3 52"76) "@ %3=3%>"&% #363)%5)3: @%"2 #"==&08$ (76:%3:= "@ @33) )" ">3%

IF--- @33)F 56: &64%35=3= &6 )(3 67203% "@ >3%)&458 "% =70M>3%)&458 @%54)7%3= &6)3%=34)3:

Q9)3>36= 56: ]77=A%55F ,--HF T9b9 ,-.LR5%&"7= :3#)(=F 278)')(= "@ =)338 45=&6' 5%3 43236)3: &6 #8543 )" #%")34) =7%@543 B5)3%F '%"76:B5)3%F

"% B5)3% =7##8$ B388= @%"2 )(3 #")36)&58 2&'%5)&"6 "@ 65)7%58 '5= &6 )(3 :%&883: B3883%=38$ &2#54)&6' B5)3% %3="7%43= QZ366 9)5)3 d!cUF ,-./R )-.. 3=%=- !4YZ' UVW[

2(4**J*)27$45 46 7+-$23% .4($I4573% 13(2)%%>* 9)%%


20/35

!"#$%&'( *+,(&%- +( .&%#( '(/ 0#'-12

BA

%3D7&%3= )(3 7=3 "@ L )" O 2&88&"6 '588"6= "@ B5)3% #3% B388< `6 )(3 d5%43887=F %"7'(8$

B5)3%3% )(3 8&@3 "@ )(3 B388F 5::&)&"658 >"8723= "@ )(3 B5)3% B&88 03 #%":743:36'3%=F 4%"==8&6A3%=F 485$ &6(&0&)"%=F 485$ =)50&8&^3%=F '388&6' 5'36)=F

=7%@54)56)=F 56: ")(3%=< 9"23 "@ )(3=3 @"%2785)&"6= %325&6 #%"#%&3)5%$i ="23 (5>3

0336 25:3 #708&4< U3#%3=36)5)&>3F 4"6)%&07)"%$ @%54)&"6= )" )(3 278)&4(32&458 4"6)36)

05=3: "6 :5)5 @%"2 d5%43887= 9(583 :3>38"#236) &6 Z366=$8>56&5< J3)B336 N/ 56:

&= #%"##56)i )(3 %325&6:3%F )$#&4588$ 83== )(56 . #3%436) 4"6=&=)= "@ 4(32&458 5::&)&>3=

Q?K9aX! ,-..R< P(3 %385)&>38$ =2588 52"76)= "@ 5::&)&>3= '363%588$ 4"6=&=) "@ @%&4)&"6

%3:743%=F 0&"4&:3= )" #%3>36) 054)3%&58 :3>38"#236)F 56: =4583 &6(&0&)"%=3= 5

56: #%"##56)= )" 03 #72#3: )" )(3 )5%'3) ^"63 5) 5 (&'(3% %5)3 56: 8"B3% #%3==7%3 )(56

&@ B5)3% 58"63 B3%3 7=3:&%"6236)58 56: (7256M(358)(

#708&=(3: %3#"%)= 5%3 854A&6' 4%&)&458 5658$=3= 56: :&=47==&"6= "@ :"=3M%3=#"6=3 %385)&"6M

6") )" #"=3 5 %358&=)&4 (358)( 4"643%636)3%=F #%3==7%3

=36="%=F 56: 256$ 4"2#83C =3%&3= "@ 4"6)%"8 >58>3= 56: 256&@"8:=< !(32&458M

4(32&458=< \388 =&)3 =7%@543M=5@3)$ 4"6)%"8= %3D7&%3 4"6)%"883: 5443==W=347%&)$F 4(32&458

&="85)&"6W#%")34)&"6F 56: #3%="658 #%")34)&>3 3D7) QZZXR @"% 635%0$ B"%A3%=3%)&458 4"2#"636) "@ )(3 B388 =(5@)=Ri 08"B"7)

)("7=56:= "@ @33) 5= 5 %783< a3=#&)3 )(3=3 6723%"7= =5@3'75%:=F )(3%3 %325&6= 5 '%35)

M

=7%@543 B5)3%


22/35

!"#$%&'( *+,(&%- +( .&%#( '(/ 0#'-12

!B

P(3 "%&'&658 =)7:$ 7#"6 B(&4( )(&= >3%=&"6 &= 05=3: B5= 56 "0=3%>5)&"658

4"2#36:&72 "@ "0_34)&>3 :5)5F B("=3 '"58 B5= )" 4(5%54)3%&^3 56: D756)&@$ 56$ 56:

(7256 (358)( &6 )(3 :&=)%&07)&"6 "@ 65)7%58M'5= :%&88&6' 56: #%":74)&"6 54)&>&)&3= &6 )(3

d5%43887=< P(&= =)7:$ &= %3=)%&4)3: )" )(3 54)758 ($:%"@%54)7%&6' #%"43== &)=38@< `) :"3=

6") 4">3% )(3 =7%@543 "% =70=7%@543 54)&>&)&3= "@ :%&88&6'F )(3 07&8:&6' "@ %385)3: %"5:= "%

%.&

B388 @"% %.%#"=3< ?"% :" B3 5::%3== 5&% D758&)$36)= %385)3: )" )(5) 54)&>&)$F 3>36 B&)( (76:%3:= "@ B388= 58%35:$ (5>&6'

)(3 d5%43887= 9(583F B&)( %"7'(8$ .-F--- B388= :%&883: )(3%3 @%"2 ,--N )" :5)3F (5=

3C#3%&3643: %"7'(8$ /- %385)3: 36>&%"6236)58 &64&:36)= Qf=#&88= &6)" 65>&'5083 B5)3%=gR

&6 B(&4( )(3 T&%"6236)58 Z%")34)&"6 1'364$ QT9 XZ1R 034523 &6>"8>3: >&5 &)=

3>36)=< P(3 T9 XZ1 (5= 034"23 320%"&83: &6 256$ 45=3= "@ =7=#34)3:F d5%43887=M

%385)3: 36>&%"6236)58 :&=%7#)&"6F &6487:&6' )(3 &6@52"7= "63 "@ 5883'3:F B&:3=#%35:

'%"76:B5)3% 4"6)52&65)&"6 "@ :"23=)&4 B388= 0$ 2&'%5)&6' 23)(563 &6 a&2"4AF Z366M

=$8>56&5 Q9)5% b5^3))3F ,--HF V7=)'5%)36F ,--HR< ;"B3>3%F )(3 T9 XZ1 48"=3: &)= &6>3=M

M

256$ ")(3% =)5)3=W=(583 #85$= QX6)&63F ,-.LR&%"6236)58 &6@%54)&"6= B3%3 ="7%43: @%"2 )(3 T9 XZ1 U3'&"6 Le= >3%058

%3#%3=36)5)&"6= "@ 5##%"C&25)38$ /- &64&:36)= "@ f=#&88= &6)" 65>&'5083 B5)3%=g )(5) (5:

.+0(46(327>($58 350 .>135 .)3%7.


23/35


24/35

!"#$%&'( *+,(&%- +( .&%#( '(/ 0#'-12

!"

P" :5)3F )(3%3 (5= 0336 6" d5%43887= 9(583 (&'(M>"8723 ($:%"@%54)7%&6' 54)&>&)$

0336 6" %385)3: (7256M(358)( &2#54)< `6 ?3B K"%A 9)5)3F B(&4( ">3%8&3= )(3 d5%43887=

56: 3C#3%&3643: (&=)"%&458 ($:%"@%54)7%&6' 54)&>&)$ =&643 )(3 .HN-=F )(3%3 &= 56

@%"2 )("=3 54)&>&)&3=< V&A3B&=3F `6)3%63) =35%4(3= @5&83: )" #%":743 56$ "0_34)&>3F

)%5435083 :5)5 "6 5:>3%=3 (7256M(358)( &2#54)= E7%)(3%2"%3F '&>36 )(3 50=3643

=74( &2#54)=< 9&2&85%8$F U3'&"6 , "@ )(3 T9 XZ1F B(&4( ">3%=33= ?3B K"%AF :&: 6")

#%">&:3 %3D73=)3: :5)5 "6 56$ =74( &64&:36)=< `) &=F "643 5'5&6F 8&A38$ )(5) )(3%3 5%3 6"

%3=#"6=&>3 :"47236)= @%"2 )("=3 ="7%43= 56: )(5) )(3%3 &= 5 - #3%436) %385)3: &64&:3643

P(3 #%3=3643 "@ 23)(563 &6 5##%34&5083F &@ 6") %323:&58M83>38F 52"76)= &6 .I #3%436)

38=3B(3%3 &6 )(3 d5%43887= :&=)%&07)&"6F 56: )("=3 =&)75)&"6= =("78: 03 "0_34)&>38$

5::%3==3: &6 )3%2= "@ )(3&% 78)&25)3 ="7%43=< U3=78)56) A6"B83:'3 =("78: 03 &6)3'%5)3:

5 4"8834)&>3 &64&:3643 "@ =)5)3M83>38 36>&%"6236)58 45=3= "% 485&2= "@ %"7'(8$ .- #3%436)

L 56: I "@ )(3 T9 XZ1 (5>3 354( 5##5%36)8$ 3C#3%&3643: 5 - #3%436) &64&:3643 "@

5= f6" :5)5 %3=#"6=&>33 0336 6723%"7= 45=3= "@ 5:>3%=3 36>&%"6M

2452%>*$45*


25/35

!"#$%&'( #'* +,#-./0 !#$.1 213 !&$.&4'

!E

236)58 &2#54) &6 Z366=$8>56&5F 5##5%36)8$ @%"2 =7%@543 54)&>&)&3=F )(3%3 (5= 0336 5 -

#3%436) &64&:3643 "@ 5=="4&5)3: :"47236)3:F 5:>3%=3 (7256M(358)( &2#54) #1

&671> )6$$,)& &%(&> &3 =(&,> (2&6(+ FGFH ?#&%#1 &%, (2, C(72,++6) D31,)

%() E,,1> #1 4,7/ )#@.+, &,7@)> I

(=4,7),> %6@(1A%,(+&% #@.(2&)BP(&= &= 6") )" =5$ )(5) )(3 4&)3: 854A "@ 47%%36)F

d5%43887=< 974( 23:&458 =7%>3&885643 &= 5 4"22"6M=36=3 25))3% 56: B"78: #%">&:3 )(3

f>&:3"g #3%=#34)&>3 &6 )(&= 25))3%F B(&4( 25$ #%">3 =7#3%&"% )" )(3 #%3=36) f=65#=(")g

#708&=(3:F )%5435083 =)56:5%:= 56: 23)(":"8"'&3= @"% =74( 457=5)&"6 :3)3%2&65)&"6=

=("78: 03 3=)508&=(3: 56: 4"6=&=)36)8$ 5##8&3: &@ 56$ =36=3 &= )" 03 25:3F "% 4"6487=&"6=

:%5B6F @%"2 =74( 5 :5)505=3


26/35


27/35

!"#$%&'( #'* +,#-./0 !#$.1 213 !&$.&4'

!H

)(3 T6&)3: 9)5)3=F ,-.,G T38"#236)F &6 ;&88F aW::=W::=M-OHW::=M-OHM^W38"#236) 54)&>&)&3= 56: (&'(M>"8723 ($:%578&4 @%54)7%&6'F

Q93#)3203% ,-..R ())#GWWBBB"6&5636M#85$=M:"2&65)3M6"%)(M523%&45M54)&>&)$W@"%345=)=W53"3H3@ G/3H3@ H3N$3 =+4'D

;"=#&)58 @"% !(&8:%36

R&(,- Q#"%@ >3H3

1803%) X&6=)3&6 !"883'3 "@ d3:&4&63

5-&O#K,./ >3 S/,-#'@ N$3H3@ >3G3+3

Z%3=&:36)F 1!9;

R4"F#' 53 Q4"-#T(@ G/3H3

Q.H./M,--HR

QK35%= "@ 93%>&43 )" 1!9;G .HSNM,--HR

E5)(3% "@ )(3 fb%336 U3>"87)&"6g

?"038 V57%35)3

!",*"&$% E3 N.#",@ >3H3@ G/3H3

Q.H.-M,--,R

QK35%= "@ 93%>&43 )" 1!9;G .HSNM,--,R

E"76:3%F ;5%>5%: a3#5%)236) "@ ?7)%&)&"6

E41/ Q-44F@ G/3H3a&%34)"% "@ !(32&458 56: Z(5%25437)&M

458 94&3643=

CT./ U#2#@ G/3H3@ C3H3936&"% E388"B &6 ?7)%&)&"6

5"&% M&,V

a&%34)"% "@ !"2276&45)&"6=

W'# >#"$,-4

XC347)&>3 1==&=)56) )" )(3 Z%3=&:36)

A/,"X- >#".&'1=="4&5)3 a&%34)"% 56: a&%34)"%

"@ a3>38"#236)

S&--F >$A#&'a3>38"#236) 1=="4&5)3

J&-K,". C411@ >3H3

XC347)&>3 56: d3:&458 a&%34)"%

W"&,- N#2"#'1%X

1=="4&5)3 a&%34)"% "@ Z708&4 ;358)(

W'# N&F421%#

C&$/#"* S,,%1@ AGW

144"76)56)

5-&O#K,./ >3 S/,-#'@ N$3H3@ >3G3+3Z%3=&:36)F 1!9;


30/35

KLMNO LP SVWTUQWPWV MUO \LXWV] MO[WSLNS5"',1. M3 WK,-@ G/3H3

!3%=&)$ "@ b3"%'&5

G,.," A3 W-K,"1,'@ >3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !"6634)&47)

ET-&, W3 W-K",$/.@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?30%5=A5F V&64"86

G/&-&? W-$#K,1@ G/3H3;76)3% !"883'3F !T?K

E#F,1 53 W-$4$%@ G/3H3

b836:"6 !"883'3FK"%A T6&>3%=&)$ Q!565:5R

I/4F#1 N3 W--,F1@ >3H3@ >3G3+3956 E%564&=4"F !1

C&$/#"* J3 W--&14'@ G/3H3E3:3%5)&"6 "@ 123%&456 9"4&3)&3= @"%

XC#3%&236)58 J&"8"'$

E4/' Q3 W--",*@ G/3H3c(&" 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

U#"- 53 W'*,"14'@ >3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ P3C5=F d3:&458 J%564(

E,"4F, A3 W"',.@ E"3@ >3H3

H,''&1 I3 W2,"X;7:="6 `6=)&)7)3

C4'#-* Q#$/F#'@ >3H3

]5&=3% Z3%25636)3 d3:&458 !36)3%

C4K,". N3 Q#"#.O@ H3H3N3@ G/3H3@ >3H3`6)3%65)&"658 d3:&458 !"6=78)5)&"6

93%>&43=

N.,?/,' Q#"",..@ >3H3Z&))=0"%"F ?!

I/4F#1 J3 Q#TF(#".',"@

G/#"F3H3@ >35*3!"6=78)56) Z(5%254&=)= "@ 123%&45

S3 M#P",'$, Q,,14'@ H"3G3+3

V"25 V&6:5 T6&>3%=&)$

5-&11# G3 Q,',*,%@ >3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ d&4(&'56 d3:&458 94(""8

N&" A4-&' Q,""X@ H3N$3@ G/3H3@ >3H3

Z5)("8"'&458 6=)&)7)3F U"$58 V"6:"6

;"=#&)58 QT6&)3: ]&6':"2RS&--F N3 Q&$%,-@ G/3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ 1%&^"65

N.,2,' Q-#$%@ >3H3!&64&665)& !(&8:%36e= ;358)(

d3:&458 !36)3%

Q-#&', M3 Q-#*@ G/3H3

]56"=(F TP

+&'"&$/ M3 Q4/'@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ 1%&^"65

Q,' Q4-$/@ G/3H3

U(":3= !"883'3

E41,?/ !3 Q4"O,--,$#@ G/3H3

>&$/#,- U3 Q4..1@ 51Y3

J,4"(, W3 Q"#X@ >3H3

Z366&6')"6 J&"23:&458 U3=35%4( !36)3%

C4'#-* S3 Q",$/,"@ G/3H3@ A3A/,F3@

HWQI@ ZGCWdPXWb8"058P"C Q!565:5R

W--#' Q",..@ >3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ 9"7)( !5%"8&65

U,'',./ J3 Q"4P'@ G/3H3]0&64

A/"&1.&', >3 Q"T/'@ G/3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5

J#-, W3 QT$/#'#'@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ b3"%'&5

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F J3%A383$

J,4"(, >3 QT"*&..@ E3H3J388F J"$: p V8"$: VV!

5*P#"* 53 QT"'1@ G/3H3P3C5= 1pd T6&>3%=&)$

!"#'$&1 !3 QT1.#@ G/3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ d&663=")5

5-P44* !3 A#-*P,--@ G/3H3@ >3Q3W3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ d&663=")5

[,"-, M3 A#"?,'.,"@ G/3H3P3C5= 1pd T6&>3%=&)$ 9$=)32

C4K,". J3 A#11,'1@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ \&=4"6=&6F d5:&="6

5"$4-, M3 A#2#-&,"&@ H3N$3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?30%5=A5 d3:&458 !36)3%

CT11,-- R3 W3 A,$&-@ >3H3@ G/3H3

18056$ d3:&458 !"883'3

C&'4 A,"&4@ >3H3J5%)= 56: P(3 V"6:"6 ;"=#&)58 `6=)&)7)3

"@ Z5)("8"'$ QT6&)3: ]&6':"2R

N#F U3 A3 A/#'(@ G/3H3d&==&==#& 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

Q"T$, >3 A/#11X@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ `88&6"&=F T%0565M!(52#5&'6

H#2&* W3 A/"&1.4?/,"@ G/3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ;5B5&& 5) dq6"5

5F&- S&--F A/X''@ >3H3

!3 >3 A-X*,1*#-,@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ d5==54(7=3))=

H4'#-* J3 A4$/"#'@ G/3H3

!"%6388 T6&>3%=&)$

E4/' E3 A4/"11,'@ 51Y3

J,"#-* !3 A4FK1@ E"3@ G/3H3

T9a1 b%56: E"%A= ;7256

?7)%&)&"6 !36)3%

J",(4"X A4'%4@ E3H3!"2#3)&)&>3 X6)3%#%&=3 `6=)&)7)3

>&$/#,- H3 A4"K,..@ G/3H3c25(5F ?X

>4".4' A4"'@ G/3H3

h"(6= ;"#A&6= T6&>3%=&)$

R#'$X A4.T('#@ H"3G/3@ C3H3@ A3H3R3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ a385B5%3

+3 CT11,-- A"411@ G/3H3P3C5= 1pd T6&>3%=&)$

S&--F E3 A"4P-,X@ E"3@ >3H3@ >3Q3W39#&43B"":F Pr

E#F,1 S3 AT""#'@ >3H3@ >3G3+3U"88&6= 94(""8 "@ Z708&4 ;358)(F X2"%$

T6&>3%=&)$

A/#"-,1 C3 AT".&1@ G/3H3c(&" 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

I#&P4 U3 H#'F4-#@ A3G3W3

X%6=) p K"76'

L-,', C3 H#'1,@ >3H3J"8&65=F !1

N/,""&-- H#2&14'@ \3>3H3@ >3H3@ >3Q3W3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ Z366=$8>56&5

G,.," A3 H,*4'@ >3H3@ G/3H3

d5==54(7=3))= 6=)&)7)3 "@ P34(6"8"'$

I/4F#1 C3 H,J",(4"&@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ;"7=)"6

5-2&"# J3 *, >,]@ G/3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ `88&6"&=F T%0565M!(52#5&'6

>,"-, M3 HF4'*@ >3H3a&52"6: ;35:54(3 !8&6&4

N,XF4T" HF4'*@ >3H3a&52"6: ;35:54(3 !8&6&4

H4'#-* A3 H&$%14'@ >3N35353

b&803%)F 1n

C#-?/ H&..F#'@ >3H3@ >3G3+3;"7=)"6F Pr


31/35

E4/' 53 H4*,1@ H3H3N3?5)&"658 !"764&8 1'5&6=) ;358)( E%57:

E4/' H4T--@ >3H3@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ]56=5=

I/,"4' S3 H4P',1@ G/3H3

936345F 9!

>&$/#,- G3 H4X-,@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ b3"%'&5

W*#F H",P'4P1%&@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ \5=(&6')"6

>&$/#,- W3 HTK&$%@ G/3H3T3%=&)$ "@ `88&6"&=

N.,?/,' U3 5?1.,&'@ >3H3@

>3G3G3@ !WA5GJ3)( =%538 a354"63== d3:&458 !36)3%

I,""X H3 5./,".4'@ G/3H3Z366=$8>56&5 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

C3 J",(4"X 52#'1@ G/3H3@ >3G3+39)< V"7&= T6&>3%=&)$ !36)3% @"% )(3 9)7:$

"@ J&")3%%"%&=2 56: X23%'&6' `6@34)&"6=

H#'&,- !3 !#"%#1@ G/3H3@ >3N3@ G353

c%3'"6 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

C&$/#"* N3 !#P$,..@ G/3H3;7C83$F 1

!",*,"&$% M3 !,""&1 LLL@ >3H3?5)&"658 X$3 `6=)&)7)3

H#2&* R3 !,""4@ G/3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ d5==54(7=3))=

>#*,-4' M3 !&'%,-@ G/3H3!"%6388 T6&>3%=&)$ d3:&458 !"883'3

M,4'#"* I3 !-X''@ G/3H3@ >3Q3W3d"%'56>&883F ?h

S&--F +3 !4,(,@ >3H3@ >3G3+3

935))83F \1

A/"&1.4?/," +3 !4",F#'@ E"3@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ d5%$856:

N/#P' R3 !"#1,"@ G/3H3

1)(505=45 T6&>3%=&)$ Q!565:5R

J-,'' S3 !"4'&'(@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?30%5=A5F V&64"86

\&'$,'. W3 !T-(&'&.&@ >3H3P74="6F 1n

C4K,". N3 J#K-,@ 5*3H3@ G/3H3@ E3H3

!85%32"6) b%5:75)3 T6&>3%=&)$

N/#X', A3 J#*@ G/3H3@ H3W3Q3I3@ W3I3N3b5: !"6=78)&6' 93%>&43=

S&--F J3 J#&',1@ E"3@ >3H3@ >3G3+394")) p \(&)3 !8&6&4

E3 Q,"'#"* M3 J,,@ >3H3

K583 T6&>3%=&)$ 94(""8 "@ d3:&4&63

U3 +3 J&'O,-@ >3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ 1%A56=5= @"%

d3:&458 94&3643=

S&--F G#T- J-,O,'@ >3H3J5$8"% !"883'3 "@ d3:&4&63

E#X W3 J4-*@ >3H3@ E3H3@ >3G3+3

d3:&458 !"883'3 "@ \&=4"6=&6

C4(," 53 J4-*@ G/3H3P3C5= 1pd T6&>3%=&)$

C,',^ >3 J44*"&$/@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ E8"%&:5

!",*,"&$% U3 J44*P&'@ >3H3P(3 b3"%'3 \5=(&6')"6 T6&>3%=&)$

d3:&458 !36)3%

I&F4./X R3 J4"1%&@ >3H3@ !3W3A3B3J3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?"%)( P3C5=

C4'#-* 53 J4.1@ >3H3@ G/3H3

`6)3%65)&"658 !36)3% @"% P"C&4"8"'$

56: d3:&4&63

+,'"X J3 J"#K4P1%&@ G/3H3

a7A3 T6&>3%=&)$

E#F,1 L#' J"#X@ G/3H3d&4(&'56 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

S&--F S3 J",#2,1@ >3H3@ >3N3G3+3

d3:&458 !"883'3 "@ \&=4"6=&6

M#T"# A3 J",,'@ G/3H3@ H3W3Q3I3!520%&:'3 X6>&%"6236)58F 643H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !"8"%5:"

H#2&* E3 +#'14'@ G/3H39)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?3B K"%AF Z")=:52

I,""X- E3 +#".F#'@ G/3H3@ >3G3+3@ C3H3

Z366=$8>56&5 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

A-#", >3 +#1-,"@ G/3H3

P(3 U"03%) d"6:5>& `6=)&)7)3 "@\&63 56: E"": 94&3643F T6&>3%=&)$ "@

!58&@"%6&5F a5>&=

\&"(&- S3 +#X1@ G/3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ]36)74A$

A-#"% S3 +,#./@ E"3@ >3H3123%&456 !5643% 9"4&3)$

HP&(/. Q3 +,#./@ G/3H3

J%"B6 T6&>3%=&)$

C4K,". +,&F,"@ G/3H3K583 94(""8 "@ Z708&4 ;358)(

C4K,". Q3 +,-F1@ G/3H3123%&456 X6)3%#%&=3 `6=)&)7)3

[#', C3 +,-1,-@ G/3H3

U7)'3%= T6&>3%=&)$F !""A !"883'3

KLMNO LP SVWTUQWPWV MUO \LXWV] MO[WSLNSFVLUQWURTOG


32/35


E#F,1 H3 +,"K,".@ G/3H3a%3C38 T6&>3%=&)$

I/,4*4", C3 +4-V4"*@ G/3H3K583 T6&>3%=&)$ 94(""8 "@ d3:&4&63

C4K,". >3 +4--&'(P4"./@ G/3H3

d&4(&'56 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

5*P#"* N3 +4".4'@ >3H3h"=8&6 a&503)3= !36)3%W;5%>5%: d3:&458

94(""8

E41,?/ +3 +4.$/%&11@ G/3H3!"%6388 T6&>3%=&)$

d32"%&58 98"56M]3))3%&6' !5643% !36)3%

G,.," Q#".4' +T..@ 51Y3

!">&6')"6 p J7%8&6'F VVZ

NT1#'', M3 +T..',"@ G/3H3]X 9D75%3:

MT$&,' C3 E#$4K1@ >3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F V"= 16'383=

W-,]#'*"4 C3 E#*#*@ >3H3@ H3G/&-3@!3C3A3G3A3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ P"%"6)" Q!565:5R

CT*4-?/ E3 E#,(,"@ G/3H3X6>&%"6236)58 d3:&4&63F `643%=&)$

>&$/,-, E#X_CT11,--@ H3\3>3@

>3G3\3>3@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F a5>&=

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ `88&6"&=F T%0565M!(52#5&'6

1803%) X&6=)3&6 !"883'3 "@ d3:&4&63

>&$/#,- U#F"&'@ G/3H3

d&4(&'56 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

E4/' Q3 U#',,',@ G/3H3@ >3G3+3@ H3\3>3d&4(&'56 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

G3 W'*",P U#"#F@ G/3H3@ A+Gdh\ !"%#"%5)&"6

>#"% W3 U#.$/,'@ >3N3@ >3Q3W3@ A3L3+3

P(3 Z($825% b%"7#

U#./"X' 53 U,--X@ H"3G3+3a38)5 P"C&4"8"'$

C4K,". H3 U,"'1@ G/3H3

K583 T6&>3%=&)$ 94(""8 "@ d3:&4&63

J,4"(, C3 U,""@ >3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ P3C5=F ;"7=)"6

J,4"(, W3 U,XP4"./ LL@ G/3H3!5%238F !1

>&$/#,- U&"1$/@ >3H3

;&'(856: ;3&'()=F c;

E4/' A3 U&"1$/F#'@ G/3H318836)"B6F Z1

S&--F >3 G3 U-,&'@ G/3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ Z&))=07%'(

C4'#-* 53 U-,&'F#'@ >3H3d5==54(7=3))= b363%58 ;"=#&)58W;5%>5%:

d3:&458 94(""8

M,1-&, >3 U-,2#X@ >3H3@ N3H3 &' +X(3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?"%)( a5A")5 94(""8 "@

d3:&4&63 56: ;358)( 94&3643=

H#2&* >3 U-T"V,-*@ G/3H3T3H@ >3G3+3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ d&4(&'56 94(""8 "@

Z708&4 ;358)(

W-#' C3 U"&1.#-@ H"3G3+3E%3: ;7)4(&6="6 !5643% U3=35%4( !36)3%

>&.O& C3 U"4$%42,"@ >3H399J 9"87)&"6=

>#'V",* U"4(,"@ G/3H3

Z366=$8>56&5 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

N#'V4"* !3 UT2&'@ >3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ d&52& 94(""8 "@ d3:&4&63W

;30%3B T6&>3%=&)$ "@ h3%7=5832A#"4-X' E3 M#$%,X@ G/3H3@ C3H3

?"%)( !5%"8&65 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

E3 A-#XKT"' M#!4"$,@ G/3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F V"= 16'383=

C4K,". J3 M#/&.#@ >3H3@ G/3H3d"76) 9&65& 94(""8 "@ d3:&4&63

E#F,1 A3 M#FK@ L\@ G/3H3@ E3H3XC#"636)

M#P",'$, 53 M#FK@ >3H3

956 16)"6&"F Pr

S&--F 53 >3 M#'*1@ G/3H3!"883'3 Z5%AF da

Q"' W3 M#"%&'1@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ 1%&^"65

M#""X M#T*#'@ G/3H3?5)&"658 17)"6"2"7= T6&>3%=&)$ "@

d3C&4" Qd3C&4"R

I4F Q3 M,#F4'@ G/3H3V&03%)$ d7)758 `6=7%5643 !"2#56$

E#X +3 M,/"@ G/3H3

X6>&%"6236)58 X:745)&"6 X6)3%#%&=3=F `643%=&)$

!-4X M&--,X@ E3H3E3%656:&65 J354(F EV

G#T- E3 M&4X@ G/3H3Tda?hMU"03%) \"": h"(6="6

d3:&458 94(""8

S&--F >3 M4'*4'@ 5*3H3@ >3G3+3!58&@"%6&5 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$F V"= 16'383=

S&--F >3 MT'$/@ G/3H3

c%3'"6 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

H#"X- MT'*@ G/3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ \&=4"6=&6F d5:&="6

E4/' MT?&,'@ >3N$3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ d5==54(7=3))=

+4P#"* H3 >#$$#K,,@ G/3H3@ >3H3

1852"F !1

E#',. 53 >#$/,-,*.@ >3H3@ >3N3@ >3G3+3;"7=)"6F Pr

+,'"X J3 >#'',@ E3N3H3

b3"%'3 d5="6 T6&>3%=&)$ V5B 94(""8

U#"- >#"#F4"41$/@ G/3H3

U7)'3%= T6&>3%=&)$F !""A !"883'3

ET*&./ W3 >#"-,..@ G/3H3@ C3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ \&=4"6=&6F d5:&="6

M#P",'$, E3@ >#"',..@ G/3H3

E#F,1 C3 >#"1/#--@ G/3H3U"=B388 Z5%A !5643% `6=)&)7)3

C4(," B3 >$A-,--#'@ H3\3>3@ >3>3N3@

H3W3Q3I3@ H3W3Q3\3I3@ !3W3I3N31807D73%D73F ?d

>#"X +3 >$J"#./@ >3H3@ >3G3+3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F 956 E%564&=4"

W-#' J3 >$+T(/,'@ H3G/&-3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F U&>3%=&:3


33/35

E#F,1 H3 >$U,#'@ H3\3>3@ E3H3`"B5 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

E41,?/ G3 >$>,'#F&'@ >3H3@ E3H3d4b7&%3\"":=F VVZ

G#."&$% E3 >&$/#,-1@ G/3H3

!5)" `6=)&)7)3

I/4F#1 +3 >&-KX@ >3H3@ >3G3+3J"&=3F `a

E41,?/ >3 >&--,"@ >3H3@ >3G3+3a7%(52F ?;

C&$/#"* W3 >&--,"@ >3H3Z%&64&5 J&"#(5%25F `643%=&)$ "@ U"4(3=)3%

S&--F E3 >&--,"@ G/3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ b3"%'&5

W3 W-#' >4(/&11&@ G/3H3`6=)&)7)3 @"% U3'785)"%$ 94&3643

J"#$, G3 >4'#$4@ E3H3d3:&458 !5%3 c207:=256 Z%"'%52

Q"' 53 >4'*,--@ >3H3J58)&2"%3 ;35:54(3 `6=)&)7)3

E4/' S3 >4"(#'@ H"3G3+3!58&@"%6&5 !5643% U3'&=)%$

N.,?/,' E3 >411@ H3H3N3@ >3N3?3B K"%A T6&>3%=&)$ !"883'3 "@ a36)&=)%$

Q"44%, I3 >411F#'@ G/3H3

"@ d3:&4&63

W--&14' W3 >T--,"@ G/#"F3H3

`6=)&)7)3 @"% !"6)&67&6'

;358)(45%3 X:745)&"6

+#""&1 >3 R#(-,"@ >3H3J3)( `=%538 d3:&458 !36)3%W1803%)

X&6=)3&6 !"883'3 "@ d3:&4&63

H#'&,- E3 R$#X&X#'#@ >3H3J36'7385 ;358)( Q9"7)( 1@%&45R

G/&-&? 53 R,-14'@ G/3H3Z7%:73 T6&>3%=&)$

E4X$, W3 R,..-,.4'@ H3N$3@ C3H3

a36>3%F !c

E4/' N3 R,TK,"(,"@ H"3G3+3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ]56=5= 94(""8 "@ d3:&4&63

I/4F#1 R&$/4-14'@ G/3H3@ >3G3+3

\3=)3%6 ]36)74A$ T6&>3%=&)$

W-K,". J3 R&$%,-V$"6;35%) Q%3)3%=&)$

E4/' G#."&$% B`J"#*X@ >3H3P7@)= T6&>3%=&)$ 94(""8 "@ d3:&4&63

c%3'"6 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

N.#'-,X I3 BF#X,@ G/3H3@ !3W3I3N3@!3WAR@ A3R3N3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?3>5:5F U36"

>&$/#,- I3 B1.,"/4-F@ G/3H3@ >3G3+3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ d&663=")5

>&$/#,- S3 G#"&O#@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ \&=4"6=&6F d5:&="6

N.T#". G#..4'@ G/3H3

Z366=$8>56&5 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

E#F,1 >#"$ G,""&'@ >3H3d5== b363%58 ;"=#&)58 @"% !(&8:%36

E#X G/,-#'@ >3H3

\$83 `6)3'%5)3: 94&3643 56:

X6'&633%&6' b%"7#

I&F4./X HT%,1 G/&--&?1@ G/3H3

P3C5= 1pd T6&>3%=&)$

H#2&* C3 G&%,@ G/3H3!(52#5&'6F `V

N.,2,' G&'%,"@ G/3H3;5%>5%: T6&>3%=&)$

+,'"X A3 G&.4.@ >3H3@ G/3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ \&=4"6=&6F d5:&="6

I/4F#1 I3 G4-,F#'@ G/3H3!"%6388 T6&>3%=&)$

J#"X G3 G41',"@ >3H3

Z856) !&)$F EV

E4/' E3 G4P,"1@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ b3"%'&5

S&--F H3 G4P"&,@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ J%&)&=( !"8720&5 Q!565:5R

A3N3 G"#%#1/@ G/3H3

P7=A3'33 T6&>3%=&)$

>#"2&' G3 G"&..1@ G/3H3!"%6388 T6&>3%=&)$

H#'&,- E3 C#&.,'@ G/3H3?5)&"658 `6=)&)7)3= "@ ;358)(

H#2&* S3 C#F,X@ H3\3>3

U523$ XD7&63 b%"7#

C3I3 C#2,'/4-.@ >3H3@ >3G3+3Z"#785)&"6 ;358)( 2#3%5)&>3=

CT11,- E3 C,&.,"@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ P3C5=F 956 16)"6&"

S&--F C,2&--,@ G/3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ !"883'3 !"%A Q`%3856:R

H4'#-* C3 C4K,".1@ G/3H3P(3 T6&@"%23: 93%>&43= T6&>3%=&)$ "@

)(3 ;358)( 94&3643=

E3 H3 C4K&'14'@ >3H3b3"%'3)"B6 T6&>3%=&)$ 94(""8 "@ d3:&4&63

Q"#* C4*T@ H3H3N3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ V"7&=>&883

Q&-- H3 C4,KT$%@ G/3H3@ H3W3Q3I3a5%)2"7)( d3:&458 94(""8

H#2&* Q3 C4--@ G/3H3!"883$>&883F Pr

H#-, C3 C4F141@ G/3H3

d&4(&'56 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

E41,?/ H3 C41,'@ G/3H3!""A !"883'3F U7)'3%= T6&>3%=&)$

N.,2,' I3 C41,'@ >3H3

?"%)(B3=)3%6 T6&>3%=&)$ d3:&458 94(""8

N.#'-,X C4./F#'@ G/3H392&)( !"883'3

N.,?/,' +3 N#V,@ H3G/&-3P3C5= 1pd T6&>3%=&)$

S#--#$, L3 N#F?14'@ >3H3

9)56@"%: T6&>3%=&)$ 94(""8 "@ d3:&4&63

>#"% aE#14'b N#'*,"1@ >3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ P3C5= d3:&458 94(""8

+#"4-* +3 N#'*1.,#*@ >3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ P3C5= d3:&458 J%564(

A/#"-,1 C3 N#'.,"",@ G/3H3

Z7%:73 T6&>3%=&)$

M4P,-- H3 N#..,"-,,@ G/3H3

>#"% \3 N#T,"@ >3H3

!"8720&5 T6&>3%=&)$



34/35

P3C5= 1pd T6&>3%=&)$

>#"2&' E3 N$/&11,-@ H3H3N3U"=8$6 ;3&'()=F ?K

H#2&* N$/4..,'V,-*@ >3H3@ >3N$3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ d&4(&'56

E4,- >3 N$/P#".O@ >3N3U35="6 Z708&4 Z"8&4$ `6=)&)7)3

H#2&* 53 N,&*,F#''@ G/3H3J%""A8$6 !"883'3WK583 T6&>3%=&)$

H#2&* W3 N/#XP&.O@ >3H3@ G/3H3P(3%5>5643F 643%=&)$ "@ `88&6"&=F T%0565M!(52#5&'6

>#"$ U3 N&,(,-@ >3H3?3B K"%A T6&>3%=&)$ 94(""8 "@ d3:&4&63

>&$/#,- N&,(,-@ >3H3@ >3G3+3J"=)"6 T6&>3%=&)$ 94(""8 "@ Z70&4 ;358)(

M,, >3 N&-2,"@ G/3H3Z%&643)"6 T6&>3%=&)$

>&$/#,- N3 N&F4'@ >3H3@ >3G3+3

\5$63 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

N3 !",* N&'(,"@ G/3H394&3643 p X6>&%"6236)58 Z"8&4$ Z%"_34)

Z(&85:38#(&5F Z1

W'', >3 NF&./@ G/3H3@ C3H3@ M3H3c(&" 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

J#"X A3 NF&./@ G/3H3!"8"%5:" 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

E4/' R3 N4V41@ G/3H3

!"8"%5:" 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

M#1O-4 G N4F4(X&@ G/3H39U` `6)3%65)&"658 Q%3)3%=&)$

C4K,". W3 NYT&",@ H3\3>3@ G/3H3h"(6= ;"#A&6= T6&>3%=&)$

C4'#-* I3 N.#'%4@ >3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ Z&))=07%'( d3:&458 !36)3%

E#F,1 +3 N.,,-,@ H3\3>3@ >3G3+3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ P3C5=F ;"7=)"6

C4K,". H3 N.,,-,@ G/3H3Z366=$8>56&5 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

ET*&./ N3 N.,"'@ N$3H3@ C3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F a5>&=

N.,?/,' N3 N.,"'K,"(@ >3H3d32"%&58 98"56M]3))3%&6' !5643% !36)3%

C4'#-* H3 N.,P#".@ B3A3@ >3H3@ !CAGAa58("7=&3 T6&>3%=&)$ Q!565:5R

>#"./# Q#"',1 N.4',@ G/3H3

!"8"%5:" 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

E4' W3 N.4"X@ G/3H3Z7%:73 T6&>3%=&)$

N&.# C3 I#.&'&@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ d&663=")5

H&$% I#2,"',;"7=3 "@ V"%:=F T6&)3: ]&6':"2

N.,2, M3 I#X-4"@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?30%5=A5F V&64"86

M4""#&', I/,-'

]3)4(72F 643Q3W3P7@)= T6&>3%=&)$

H&F&."&41 I"&$/4?4T-41@ >3H3;5%>5%: 94(""8 "@ Z708&4 ;358)(

C4K,". G3 c?$/T"$/@ G/3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ 1%&^"65

>#"% E3 c.,--@ >3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ U"4(3=)3% d3:&458 !36)3%

N/#1/& Q3 \,"F#@ G/3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?30%5=A5F V&64"86

S&--#"* E3 \&1,%@ >3H3@ G/3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ `88&6"&= !"883'3 "@ d3:&4&63

MX'' S#&1/P,--@ G/3H3@ A+5NT6&>3%=&)$ "@ d3:&4&63 56: a36)&=)%$ "@

?3B h3%=3$F 94(""8 "@ Z708&4 ;358)(

Q"' S#'1&'%@ G/3H3!"%6388 T6&>3%=&)$

>&-,1 S,&'K,"(,"@ >3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ `"B5 ;"=#&)58= 56: !8&6&4=

E4/' S,&1KT"(,"@ G/3H3?3B K"%A d3:&458 !"883'3

E#',. N3 S,&11@ >3H3

P(3 P"Ca"4

N&F4' S,11,-X@ >3H3@ !CAG]&6'e= !"883'3 V"6:"6 56: `6=)&)7)3 "@

Z=$4(&5)%$ QT6&)3: ]&6':"2R

N.,2,' H3 S,d',"@ >3H3!83>3856: !8&6&4 E8"%&:5

E4,- 5--&4. S/&.,@ >3H3@ !3W3A3C3a56>&883F !1

E4/' N3 S/&.,@ G/3H3

\(&)3 P34(6&458 U3=35%4(

U,'',./ M3 S/&.,@ G/3H3

T)5( 9)5)3 T6&>3%=&)$

C4K,". E3 S/&.,@ >3H3@ G/3H39(5A3% ;3&'()=F c;

A#"4- S/&.-4$%@ G/3H3@ C3H3

U"4(3=)3% `6=)&)7)3 "@ P34(6"8"'$

A/"&1.4?/," !3 S&-%&'14'@ G/3H3\&82&6')"6F ?!

>#"% M3 S&--,'K"&'(@ >3H3

95&6) Z578< d?

A#"- U3 S&'.,"@ G/3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F a5>&=

E#F,1 E3 S4"F#'@ G/3H3U"4(3=)3% `6=)&)7)3 "@ P34(6"8"'$

CT11,-- N3 S4""#--@ B3H3

T6&>3%=&)$ "@ !58&@"%6&5F J3%A383$

N3 N.#'-,X e4T'(@ G/3H3?5)&"658 `6=)&)7)3 "@ 9)5)&=)&458 94&3643

N.,2,' +3 [,&1,-@ >3H3@ G/3H3

P(3 T6&>3%=&)$ "@ ?"%)( !5%"8&65

>&$/#,- Q3 [,F,-@ G/3H3

?7)%&)&"6 6=)&)7)3F T6&>3%=&)$ "@ P3663==33

5%/#"* 53 [&,(-,"@ >3H3T6&>3%=&)$ "@ `"B5


P(3 "#&6&"6= 3C#%3==3: &6 1!9; #708&45)&"6= :" 6") 6343==5%&8$ %3#%3=36) )(3 >&3B= "@ 588 23203%= "@

B&)("7) 4"2#36=5)&"6


35/35

3/4'(), 5+$,('& +, 6('/,(/ ),7 8/)&*.9::; ? 6$'*/ @A@B/= C+4D? B/= C+4D 9AA@EF;GG@H/&2 I@9@J EK@FLAMM N)O I@9@J EK@FM:9:PQRS .**#STT===2)(0.2+4U V3)'&S )(0.W)(0.2+4U

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

Documents

Fracking and Health: facts vs. fiction