労働政策研究報告書No.188『壮年非正規雇用労働者 …...1984 º _ c15. 3># [ 6 W S b _ P K 1990 º _ c20. 2># 2000 º _ c26. 0># 2010 º _ c 33. 7># 2016 º _ c37

労働政策研究報告書 No.188

独立行政法人労働政策研究・研修機構（JILPT）

JILPT 3 2012 2016

2010 40

35 44

5 34

5

JILPT No.126 JILPT 2013aNo.164 JILPT 2014

JILPT No.143 JILPTJILPT 2015b No.180

JILPT 2015a JILPT No.160JILPT 5 JILPT 2016a 5

5 2

JILPT 2014 1 1

2012a 5



1984 15. 3 1990 20. 2 2000 26. 0 2010

33. 7 2016 37. 6

1

2014

65. 5 42. 6

2 2015

10

32 1, 100 1 1, 958

20 5, 100 1 1, 258

1 1, 059

3

JILPT

54. 9 40. 5

2015 OFF-JT

44. 1 20. 9

2016 2942011

2013 2015

1984 1990 2000 2 2010 2016 1 31984 1990 2000 2010 2016

1 1 1

JILPT 2010 8, 000 21

JILPT 2011a JILPT 2011a



1

2007

2014

2 2012

5

3

2012

2015

2016

12 16

20

34

2016 2014

JILPT 2013b 2016b http://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/shingi 2 /0000146057.html http://www.kantei.go.jp/jp/singi/hatarakikata/



2000 1990

2015

3415 34

5 1991

15 34 2003

1992 11'92

2000 20012001 2008 2009 2005 JILPT 2006 2010 2012 2013c 2009

2007 2009 2010 2011 2011 2011 2012

2003 2012b 2012



40

25 34

35 44

100

90

2010

2007

2000 2010



2013

2002 2012

1

2

3

JILPT 2010

3

20 44. 8 30 53. 4

30 36. 2 40 36. 5 3



20 46. 8 30 50. 4 30 28. 8 40

26. 7 JILPT 2011b

4

2015

25 34 39. 2 35 44 41. 1 45 54

43. 1

5

JILPT

3



1

2

3

JILPT 2012 2016

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

S No.126

No.164

S No.143

No.180

S No.160

164180

2012 15

10

JILPT No.126 JILPT

2013a

2013



No.164 JILPT 2014

No.180 JILPT

2015a

2015 5

3

JILPT 2013a 2014 2015a

30

JILPT No.143 JILPT 2015b JILPT No.160 JILPT 2016a



JILPT 2013a 2016a

1

1 2 3

4 6

5



JILPT 2014 2015a

JILPT 2015b

2013 7 8

25 34 3, 000 35 44 7, 000

4, 970 49. 7

5

2 5

30 39 5

5

5

a

b c 2015 12 11

22

5 6 JILPT 2015b 3



a b c 3

a b

JILPT 2016a

35 45

5 2010 12

a 1, 500

b 5 2010 12 1, 500

c 5 2010 12 1, 500

5 30 39 5

=35 44 5

1 35

44

2

35 44

30

44

1 2

2



5 6 29 30

1

30

1 JILPT 2016a

5 5

5

2 5

3

5

4

5



5

2

1

2 5

3 2

3 5

4



2009

3

3

ATE ATT

ATE ATT

4

5

3 treatment

3 ATE ATT 2



5 30 39

1

2

3

4

5

4 30

1 20 30



2 20

30

30

3 30

30

6

1 5

1

1

2

3



6

2015

9 1 pp.147-172

2013 No.633 pp.26-29

2001



2008

No.580 pp.61-77

2009

No.586 pp.34-48

2012a http://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/houdou/2r98520

000025zr0-att/2r98520000026fpp.pdf

2012b http://

www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/houdou/2r9852000002rlop.html

2010

2011

2005

No.535 pp.29-41

2011

No.608 pp.88-102

2003 http://www.kantei.go.jp/jp/singi/index/wakamo

no/

2016 11

2009

2012 http://www5.cao.go.jp/keizai 1 /wakamono/wakamono.html

2003 15

2011 62 3 4 pp.3-23

2000 97

2001

2009 3

10 2 pp.18-34

2007

2012 No.619

pp.45-53

2011

pp.80-124

1991 3



JILPT 2006

No.72 JILPT

JILPT 2010

No.117 JILPT

JILPT 2011a 21 1 2

JILPT No.89 JILPT

JILPT 2011b / JILPT

No.86 JILPT

JILPT 2012 3

No.148 JILPT

JILPT 2013a JILPT

No.126 JILPT

JILPT 2013b

JILPT

No.122 JILPT

JILPT 2013c 2

No.152 JILPT

JILPT 2014

No.164 JILPT

JILPT 2015a

No.180 JILPT

JILPT 2015b JILPT

JILPT No.143 JILPT

JILPT 2016a JILPT 5

JILPT No.160 JILPT

JILPT 2016b /

JILPT

No.151 JILPT



JILPT 2014 JILPT 2016

2005 2008 2010

2011 2011

5 30

2

3 30

4

3

5

6

JILPT

JILPT 2015 JILPT 2016





0 1

5 30 39 30



5

4, 500 572 12. 7

A

300 20. 0 5

179 11. 9 5 93 6. 2

B

5

262 17. 5 165 11. 0

87 5. 8

B

5 5

5

1

2 5

558

5 101 - 3 - 3



3

4

19

5 5

6 5

7 5

19



1

5

2 5

3

5

4

5 5

6 5

5

JILPT 2016 1



5

1 5

2 5

3 5

4 5

5

6

3









3

3

1

5

5

5

5

5

5

5 5

5



1 5

2

5 5

3

5



3

3



7. 5

25. 0 13. 3

26. 5

8. 3 16. 8 9. 6

18. 8

3

3

442 272



3

5

2

1

5

5

2 5

5

3 5

5

4 5

1, 000





3

5

2



3



3

35. 0

56. 9

102

2



1 2

1

5 5

2 5



3 5

4

5

5

5

5

5

6

1

5 5

3



2

5

3

4

5

6

JILPT 2014

JILPT No.164

JILPT 2015 JILPT

JILPT 2016 1

4 2



JILPT No.143

JILPT 2016 JILPT 5

JILPT No.160

2008

No.580 pp.61-77

2010 2 JILPT

JILPT No.117 pp.40-82

2005

No.535 pp.29-41

2011

No.608 pp.88-102

2011

pp.80-124



2008a 2008b 2009

2008a

2008b

2009



JILPT

2016

JILPT

2015

2016

2009

2015

2009

5

2

2009

JILPT 20142014b

2010, 2014a 2013



3 4

5

6 7

JILPT 2015 12 5

5 2010 12 4, 500

1, 500 5 1, 500 5

1, 500

5

1



17. 5

11. 0 5. 8 1

p>0. 05 3

5

5

5

5





1

5

2

5

4



5

66. 5 24. 1

3 1

4 1



5

5

100 1, 000

99

29

1

5





5

5

5

1 2 5



5

5 2

2

1

5

5

1 2 5



5

5

1

5

2

3

5

1, 000

5 99

5



5

1, 000

5

99

2



1

2 5

3 2

3 5

4



2009

2008a

No.580 61-77

2008b 59 4 340-356

2009

No.586 34-48

2015

No.180 207-234

2016

JILPT No.185

53-88

2010

JILPT No.65

2014a

JILPT No.137

2014b

JILPT No.134



2015a

3

2 3

4 5

1990

Rees 1966 Granovetter 1973 Lin et al 1981

Marsden & Gorman 2001; Ioannides & Loury

2004; Mouw 2006; Topa 2011 2012

1991 1998 2009

2002 2002 2004 2005 2005

2007 2012 2015b



2007 18 29 2

2015b

JILPT 2013 15 44

3

1

2

3

5

2015 12 35 45 5 2010 12

5

1

Treatment

Average Treatment Effect

Caliendo & Kopeinig 2008 2014

Potential Outcome Approach

D i i 1 0 Y i D i i



1

2 Y i 1 Y i 0

Y i D iY i 1 1 D i Y i 0 Average

Treatment Effect: ATE

2

ATE

Average

Treatment Effect on the Treated: ATT

3

ATE ATT

Austin 2011 1

ATT

ATE

ATE ATT

E Y 0 |D 1 E Y 0 |D 1

E Y 0 |D 0

4

E Y 0 |D 1 E Y 0 |D 0

ATT E Y 0 |D 1

E Y 0 |D 0 0

2

1 5

2 6

1

selection on observables conditional independence assumption CIA



2

common support ATT

1 7

2 8

1 1

P D 1|X P X Propensity score

Rosenbaum & Rubin 1983

1

ATT

9

Nearest Neighbor Matching NN

2

Diaz 2012 Krug & Rebien 2012

2 5

3 1

2



32. 8

19. 4 17. 6

22. 9

25. 1 30. 4









3

ATE Raw

Matched

10

12

6

2015b



276

470 286

ATE

ATE

3

ATT



3

ATT Treated obs Control

obs

t 2 p<0. 05

ATT

ATE 17

ATE 12 341 ATE 470 ATE

ATT

ATE

ATE

ATT

ATT ATE 1

2

3 3

ATT

p>chi2 2

Standardized Bias Standardized Bias

10 11

10

11



Mean Bias Standardized Bias

Standardized Bias 10

Austin 2011 3 5

Caliendo and Koepeing 2008 10

1

2

3



3 1 1

U

Hidden Bias

Social homophily

ATT

Rosenbaum 2002 Sensitivity Analysis

Becker &

Caliendo 2007

x i u i

x i u i

12

i j i P i / 1 P i j

P j / 1 P j

13

exp x i u i /exp x j u j exp{ u i u j }

u i u j 0 0 1

0

2 mhbounds Becker &

Caliendo 2007 rbounds DiPrete & Gangl 2004

STATA

exp{ u i u j }

ATT

ATT

ATT

ATT



Qmh Qmh pmh

Qmh p mh 2

1. 2 5

2 1. 2

ATT

ATT

2. 3 2. 3

ATT

1

2

3

ATT 3



1 2

35 45 5

ATE ATT 1

2

3

3 1 2

Austin, Peter C. 2011 An Introduction to Propensity Score Methods for Reducing the

Effects of Confounding in Observational Studies, Multivariate Behavioral Research, 46:

pp.399-424.

Becker, Sascha O. and Marco Caliendo 2007 Sensitivity Analysis for Average Treatment

Effects, The Stata Journal , 7 1 : pp.71-83.

Caliendo, Marco and Sabine Kopeinig 2008 Some Practical Guidance for the Implementation

of Propensity Score Matching, Journal of Economic Surveys, 22 1 : pp.31-72.

2002 506

pp.38-49



Diaz, Ana Maria 2012 Informal Referrals, Employment, and Wages: Seeking Causal

Relationships, Labour, 26 1 : pp.1-30.

DiPrete, Thomas A. and Markus Gangl 2004 Assesing Bias in the Estimation of Causal

Effects: Rosenbaum Bounds on Matching Estimators and Instrumental Variables

Estimation with Imperfect Instruments, Sociological Methodology, 34 1 : pp.271-310.

2015a

66 1 pp.73-88

2015b

No.180 pp.247-276

Granovetter, Mark S. 1973 The Strength of Weak Ties, American Journal of Sociology,

78 6 : pp.1360-80.

2007

pp.101-127

2012

No.148 pp.57-86

Ioannides, Yennis M and Linda Datcher Loury 2004 Job Information Networks,

Neighborhood Effects, and Inequality, Journal of Economic Literature , Vol. XLII:

pp.1056-1093.

2012

61 1 pp.1-20

2009

60 2 pp.279-296

2005

pp87-143

Krug, Gerhard and Martina Rebien 2012 Network-Based Job Search: An Analysis of

Monetary and Non-Monetary Labor Market Outcomes for the Low-Status Unemployed,

Zelischrift fur Soziologie, 41 4 : pp.316-333.

2005

pp.163-186

Lin, Nan, Walter M. Ensel and John C. Vaughn 1981 Social Resources and Strength of Ties:

Structural Factors in Occupational Status Attainment, American Sociological Review,

46 4 : pp.393-405.

Marsden Peter V. and Gorman Elizabeth H. 2001 Social Networks, Job Changes, and



Recruitment, Berg, Ivar and Arne L. Kalleberg eds., Sourcebook of Labor Markets:

Evolving Structures and Processes , New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers:

pp.467–502.

Mouw, Ted 2006 Estimating the Causal Effect of Social Capital: A Review of Recent

Research, Annual Review of Sociology, 32: pp.79-102.

2002 506

pp.26-37

2014

No.79

Rees, Albert 1966 Information Networks in Labor Markets, The American Economic

Review, 56 1 / 2 : pp.559-566.

Rosenbaum, Paul R. 2002 Observational Studies, New York: Springer.

Rosenbaum, Paul R. and Donald Rubin B. 1983 The Central Role of the Propensity Score in

Observational Studies for Causal Effects, Biometrika, 70 1 : pp.41-50.

Topa, Giorgio 2011 Labor Markets and Referrals, Handbook of Social Economics, Volume

1 B: pp.1193-1221.

2004

ESRI Discussion Paper Series No.106

1991 42 1

pp.2-16



5

1995 2003

3

2012

2014 2016

2014 18. 1 2020 10

2016

2015

25 54 25

54

JILPT 2013

25 44

2

2006 1

131



JILPT 2015 5 35

44 5

2011



2014

2011

2015

JILPT 2015 5

5 2010 12 30 39

30

2

5 5

3

5

4

5

6

25 34 35 44 JILPT



5

53. 3 22. 7 30. 6

54. 3 31. 2 23. 1

5



5 5

5 5

1, 000

5

1

1

1

5





5

5

1

2

3

30. 623. 1



5

5

5

5

5

5

5 5

30 39

1

1







5

5

126 72. 8

49 55. 1

5

116 67. 1

44 49. 4





5

49 92 29 28. 3 53. 2 16. 8

23 35 28 25. 8

39. 3 31. 5



5

5

D.I. 27. 0 72. 3 5

D.I. 27. 0 43. 0



5

5

D.I. 51. 7 69. 4 5

D.I. 51. 7

67. 6 5

D.I. 17. 7 49. 1

5

5

D.I. 27. 0

24. 3 5

5

D.I. 126. 2 75. 9 5



D.I.

1



2

3

4

5

6

30

30

2012

http://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/houdou/2r9852000002gqwx.html

2014

http://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/

houdou/0000036753.html



2016 http://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/houdou/

0000110955.html

2011 Vol.26 No.2, pp.287-

302

2014

13 pp.77-83

2015

No.180 pp.43-62

1995 No.28 pp.162-184

2011 RIETI

Discussion Paper Series 11-J-052

2006

No.72

2003

No.158 pp.76-103



2007

2002 2007

2005 2006

2013

2002

2012 20 44

2009

2005



2008

2005

10

2010

1

2008

2009 2015 2015 2010

2 3

4

2008 2009 2015

2

20-34 1

0



2 3

4

5

2013 7 8

25 44 10, 000 4, 970

49. 7

2014

30 44 1

71. 7

41. 7

10, 0007, 000 35 44 3, 000 25 34



30 44

20

30 35

20 2009

2015 30

1, 303

3

70. 7

9. 8

19. 5

5 20 3. 0 21-

23 4. 5 24-26 4. 5 27-29 3. 1 30 4. 3

20 1 20



2

3

1 30. 8

50 46. 9 50

45. 0 8. 1 3

1 24. 6

3

71. 0 29. 0

59. 7

40. 3 4

14. 0

52. 7 25. 1 8. 1

3

8

6 25. 8

20 78. 0

20 7 20 20

5 30 28. 6

20 5

20 30

3

20

4. 345 4. 3454. 345 12



3

1



30 44

33. 0 27. 7

20. 8

20

20 20

20 40

20 20

3 7

30 20



50

48. 5 39. 8

30. 5 20

61. 5 50

30



20 38. 5 30

32. 1 31. 3

20



20

20

40 30

20

20 30 40

20 20

20

30



4 3

1

2

3 4

2



1

0. 1

2 20

0. 1 30

20

20 10

20 21 23

3 4

20 20



50

50

20 20

20 30

40 44 20

40 20

4 5 8

5 9

8

3530



5

6 20

20

7 8

9 20

20

10 20

30

8



30

35 3030



3

7

20

20 30

30 40

20 30

30 40

30



4

5 4 10 13

5 14 13

14 13

10

11

20

30

12 11 30

5

13

30

14

13 30

30

20

12 14 1

35 35



20 5



3

20

20

20

30

20 20

20

20

20

30

30

30

30

20

20

2008 2009 2015



20

20

30

40

1

30 44 35 44

10 11 12

2005 No.535



pp.16-28

2007

10

pp.217-238

2007 Vol.58 No.1, pp.31-46

2008

No.580 pp.62-77

2009

19

No.61 pp.60-147

2010

No.602 pp.50-59

2008 2005 SSM

8 2005 SSM pp.95-110

2005

No.535 pp.29-41

2012

No.620 pp.93-106

2015

No.180 pp.277-285

2002 Vol.58 No.2,

pp.22-35

2009

No.29

2010

pp.147-184

2006

Vol.22 23 pp.167-176

2013 No.638, pp.33-42

2015

No.180 pp.207-234

2014

No.164



1990

2010 2005

25 3

31. 9 3

3

2008 1982 2002

15 54

2015

1984 15. 3 1995 20. 9

2005 32. 6 2015 37. 5 1984 1995 2 2005 2015

25 20 24 92. 8

11



47. 9 18. 6

15. 0 59. 4

14. 8 8. 5

2013

6

4

2015

2015 JILPT

15 44

15 29 30 44

300 1, 000

2015



15 44

2015

2015

3 1

0 0

3

3

5

26

1

9

18 1

7 25 10

9 18



1 9 18

1

11 12 24

1

1

2

15 44 15 29 30 44

1

9 18 7

NPO POSSE

25 9

80 2013





1

2

29

1999

29

30

5





15 29

12 1

0 0

12

12

1000 5

29 1990 1991 1994 18. 1 16. 7 19901995 1999 17. 2 16. 5 2000 2000 2004 19. 0 17. 3 2000

2005 2009 15. 9 15. 2 2010 2010 2014 13. 8 14. 5





2

3

1







2008

5 101 2 pp.33-63

2015

No.180 pp.154-169

2005 76 pp.41-57

2010

2013

8

2013 24

2015



No.180 pp.170-186

2013

JILPT No.126



2012 2016 5

1

5 5

5

1

2 5

1

JILPT 2013 JILPT No.126 JILPTJILPT 2016 JILPT 5

JILPT No.160 JILPT JILPT 2016

1 2



3

5

1

3

1 3

4

5

1

2

5

4

6

5

7

2009No.586, pp.34-48

1



6

1

2

3

JILPT 2016 6 1 5

1 1 - 4 - 3 JILPT 2014 WEB JILPTNo.129 JILPT



4

3

5

6

7

1 1 - 4 - 3 http://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/houdou/0000110955.html



1

30 5 30

1 5

30 39 5

17. 5

1

2 2012

JILPT

50

6 5

25 34 64. 7 35 44 68. 9 2016 12 16

20

JILPT 2016 /

JILPT No.151 JILPT http://muki.mhlw.go.jp/

2016 JILPTJILPT No.185 JILPT pp.89-112



3

1

4

http://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/houdou/ 0000052513.html

http://tayou-jinkatsu.mhlw.go.jp/ JILPT 2016 3 1 4

2014http://www.mhlw.go.jp/stf/houdou/0000056282.html



Documents

労働政策研究報告書No.188『壮年非正規雇用労働者 …...1984 º _ c15. 3># [ 6 W S b _ P K 1990 º _ c20. 2># 2000 º _ c26. 0># 2010 º _ c 33. 7># 2016 º _ c37