FACTORIAL CAUSATION ANALYSIS: HOW TO RESOLVE SAFEGUARDS PARADOX IN WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION DISPUTE SETTLEMENT

8/14/2019 FACTORIAL CAUSATION ANALYSIS: HOW TO RESOLVE SAFEGUARDS PARADOX IN WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION DISP

1/27

Xfm

SXI flu ufisj nxumdg xi `m l u}eemuug}d njxmpjlxnijld ipcljnzlxnij$ ljh flu rdl~mh l epnxneld pidm

=Uncjlxipnmu xi xfm CLXX)SXI lcpmmamjxu lpm pmgmppmh xi nj xfm lcpmmamjxu lu Ama`mpu xi pmurmex xfm uiwmpmncjx~ ig xfm

jlxniju pmrpmumjxmh*7

Alj~ dmlhnjc r}`dnelxniju urme}dlxmh l`i}x xfm riuun`ndnx~ ig l xplhm slp? Njwmuxipu @}unjmuu Hlnd~$Lampnelu XnpmhRpixmexnijnua$ Umrxma`mp ; Alj}glex}pnjc ' Xmefjidic~ Jmsu$ Efnjl Xnpm Elum Pmu}dxu nj Jms Gpmm Xplhm Di``~ $Umrxma`mp $ wid}am


4/27

8

nj plnunjc uxljhlphu ig dnwnjc sipdhsnhm*


5/27

=

xfm aiux mggnenmjx dielxnij*


6/27

7

eiux xplhm$ sfmpm l`uid}xmd~ ldd xlpnggu ljh xplhm `lppnmpu lpm mdnanjlxmh* Xfm cdi`ld xplhnjc

mjwnpijamjx$ snxf nxu cpmlx hnwmpunx~ ig uienmxnmu ljh xfmnp wlpni}u rpnjenrdmu ig ciwmpjljem ljh

lrrpilefmu xi meijianeu$ nu unard~ xii eiardmv gip xflx* Xfm


7/27

3

alpkmx meijianmu sndd dnkmd~ ldui flwm xi `m eijwnjemh `~ mvxmpjld glexniju xi aiwm xislph l

alpkmx u~uxma*05 Xfmum eiddmexnwm rpmuu}pmu gipa l rpiemuu xflx nu eiaaijd~ kjisj lu

cdi`ldnzlxnij*

Xfm SXI slu hmuncjmh xi fmdr aljlcm xfm cdi`ldnzlxniju rpiemuu* Xfm SXI glendnxlxmu

njxmpjlxnijld xplhm ljh rpiwnhmu l uxp}ex}pmh rpiemuu xi pmuidwm hnur}xmu lpnunjc xfmpmnj* Xfm

uxp}ex}pmu$ rpiemuumu$ ljh lcpmmamjxu pmrpmumjx l eijempxmh mggipx xi pmdlv xfm xmjunij `mxsmmj

uxlxm uiwmpmncjx~ ljh gpmm xplhm* Xfm SXI u~uxma nu jix xfm gnpux$ `}x xfm e}danjlxnij ig

pmrmlxmh lxxmarxu xi ipcljnzm jlxniju xi sipk xislphu gpmm xplhm* Ijm ig xfm hmgnjnjc

eflplexmpnuxneu ig xfm SXI nu xflx nx flu mwidwmh ipcljneldd~$ dlpcmd~ aixnwlxmh xfpi}cf glnd}pmu

ig mvnuxnjc u~uxmau$ nj l rplexneld glufnij xi ammx xfm aiux }pcmjx jmmhu ig nxu ama`mpu* Xfmpm

flu `mmj ji ipcljnznjc xfmip~ ip `d}mrpnjx ixfmp xflj xfm rpnjenrdmu ig gpmm xplhm ljh xfm

iòmexnwm ig riwmpx~ pmh}exnij*08 Xfm SXI slu ìpj i}x ig xfm jmlp glnd}pm0= ig xfm Cmjmpld

05

Umm Gpljk O* Clpenl$Nu Gpmm Xplhm Gpmm9 Nu Nx Mwmj Xplhm9 Irrpmuunij ljh Eijumjx nj Fmanurfmpne Xplhm Lcpmmamjxu*Umlxxdm Oi}pjld gip Uienld O}uxnem$ Urpnjc)U}aamp 0223* Clpenl lpc}mu cmjmpldd~ lclnjux xfm eijwmjxnijld wnms xflx xfmnardnelxnij ig gpmm nj gpmm xplhm amlju gpmmhia gpia lj~ hnuxipxnjc ciwmpjamjxld njxp}unij }rij xfm alpkmxrdlem* FismwmpClpenlu eijed}unij gie}umu ij eijumju}u!`}ndhnjc lu l rpnalp~ lurmex ig xplhm!glendnxlxnjc ipcljnzlxniju &nj xfnu elum$ ELGXL.*Ng xplhm lcpmmamjxu hi jix glendnxlxm eijumju}ld meijiane mvefljcmu$ ljh lpm jix xfmaumdwmu xfm pmu}dx ig eijumju}ldjmcixnlxniju$ xfm~ `meiam irrpmuunwm* Ijm sl~ xi mjwnunij xfm pidm ig xplhm njuxnx}xniju nu xflx ig l rdl~cpi}jh aijnxip eflpcmhsnxf alnjxlnjnjc l `mjmgnenld rpiemuu ig njxmplexnij$ `}x lddisnjc l cpmlx hmld ig dlxnx}hm xi xfm rlpxnenrljxu nj muxl`dnufnjc xfmnpisj pmdlxnijufnru ljh eijh}exnjc xfmnp isj xpljulexniju* Lu snxf rdl~cpi}jh clamu$ xfmpm sndd `m xpljunxip~ snjjmpu ljh diumpu$

`}x xfm aijnxip#u pidm nu xi slxef i}x gip }dd~njc* = Umlxxdm O* gip Uie* O}ux* =2=$ =00 &*0223.* Xfnu nu l wldnh rpiriunxnij nj xfnuL}xfipu wnms$ `}x himu jix ci glp mji}cf xi mju}pm l dmcld gplamsipk xflx mju}pmu xflx xfm rlpxnmu flwm leemuu xi l hnur}xmumxxdmamjx hmwnem xflx sndd mju}pm xfm~ elj glnpd~ lhhpmuu xfmnp lddmcmh `}dd~njc cpnmwljemu*08

Xfm SXI#u gi}jhnjc ljh c}nhnjc rpnjenrdmu pmalnj xfm r}pu}nx ig irmj ìphmpu$ xfm c}lpljxmm ig aiux!glwi}pmh!jlxnijrpnjenrdm ljh jij!hnuepnanjlxip~ xpmlxamjx `~ ljh laijc ama`mpu$ ljh l eiaanxamjx xi xpljurlpmje~ nj xfm eijh}ex ig nxulexnwnxnmu* Xfm irmjnjc ig jlxnijld alpkmxu xi njxmpjlxnijld xplhm$ snxf o}uxngnl`dm mvemrxniju ip snxf lhm|}lxm gdmvn`ndnxnmu$ sndd

mjei}plcm ljh eijxpn`}xm xi u}uxlnjl`dm hmwmdiramjx$ plnum rmirdm#u smdglpm$ pmh}em riwmpx~$ ljh giuxmp rmlem ljh uxl`ndnx~* Lx xfm

ulam xnam$ u}ef alpkmx irmjnjc a}ux `m leeiarljnmh `~ ui}jh hiamuxne ljh njxmpjlxnijld ridnenmu xflx eijxpn`}xm xi meijianecpisxf ljh hmwmdiramjx leeiphnjc xi mlef ama`mp#u jmmhu ljh lurnplxniju* Xfm SXI smùnxm*[fxxr?))sss*sxi*ipc)mjcdnuf)xfmsxiYm)sflxnuYm)sxiYhcYuxlxYm*fxa*Q Pmxpnmwmh *0=

@mgipm xfm SXI slu gipamh$ xfm a}dxndlxmpld xplhnjc u~uxma ig sfnef CLXX nu xfm dmcld gi}jhlxnij nu umpni}ud~ mjhljcmpmh$hmedlpmh xfm eijxplexnjc rlpxnmu* &Anjnuxmpnld hmedlplxnij lhirxmh ij Umrx* lx > &65.*Gpia Hmema`mp 66 xi xfm gnjld eijed}unij ig xfm Gnjld Lex ig ]p}}c}l~ Pi}jh ij 8$ xfm ]p}c}l~ Pi}jhjmcixnlxnij uls alj~ }ru ljh hisju njed}hnjc xfm eiarpmfmjunwm gnjld hplgx &Xfm H}jkmd Hplgx >5$ nx flh `meiam empxlnj lu r}x nj siphu ~ Rmxmp U}xfmpdljh$ xfm xfmj HnpmexipCmjmpld ig CLXX xflx xfm sipdh flu efiumj irmjjmuu ljh eiirmplxnij njuxmlh ig }jempxlnjx~ ljh eijgdnex naripxljx jms lpmluig sipdh meijia~ flwm `mmj `pi}cfx }jhmp a}dxndlxmpld hnuenrdnjmu$ ljh lhhmh xicmxfmp$ xfm lefnmwmamjxu lai}jx xi l aloip


8/27

6

Lcpmmamjx ij Xlpnggu ljh Xplhm &CLXX. gplamsipk xflx slu xfm SXIu rpmhmemuuip*07 Xfm

CLXX nj x}pj slu xfm pmu}dx ig xfm glnd}pm ig xfm Njxmpjlxnijld Xplhm Ipcljnzlxnij &NXI. xi

lefnmwm plxngnelxnij `~ nxu ama`mpu* Xfm CLXX)SXI gplamsipk flu mmj dlpcmd~ u}eemuug}d

xf}u glp$ uiam elddnjc xfm SXI xfm aiux u}eemuug}d njxmpjlxnijld ipcljnzlxnij mwmp epmlxmh*03 Nx

flu `mmj xi lefnmwm nxu iòmexnwmu sfmpm ixfmpu flwm glndmh `mel}um nx flu ìxf dmcnudlxnwm ljh

lho}hnelxnwm g}jexniju* Xfm SXI aljlcmu xfm a}dxndlxmpld xplhm lcpmmamjxu rpiemuu$

lhanjnuxmpu xfm ldpmlh~!lcpmmh xpmlxnmu$ ljh rpiwnhmu l uxp}ex}pmh gip}a gip pmuidwnjc xplhm

hnur}xmu*06 Xfm SXI flu edmlpd~ rdl~mh l dmlhnjc pidm nj xfm uxip~ ig cdi`ldnzlxnij$ lu nxu

Ama`mpu njxmjhmh*

0>

Xfmum g}jhlamjxld cildu lpm xfm aiux wldnh ljh xp}m xi xfm ipncnjld

pmjmsld ig xfm sipdh xplhnjc u~uxma* C}nhm xi xfm SXI ljh CLXX$ Meijianeu$ Dls$ Ridnxneu* Rlcm 06* L}xlp Kpnufmj Ki}d$Kd}smp Dls Njxmpjlxnijld* 022=*07

Umm cmjmpldd~ Ki}d &022=.$ Eflrxmp *03 Umm cmjmpldd~ xfm SXI smùnxm$ ljh nj rlpxne}dlpUiam Glexu ljh Gnc}pmu$ Uxlxu gip Umlxxdm*[fxxr?))sss*sxi*ipc)mjcdnuf)xfmsxiYm)anjnuxYm)anj>>Ym)mjcdnuf)lì}xYm)00glexYm*fxaQ* Pmxpnmwmh * &Xlpnggu smpmpmh}emh `~ f}jhpmhu ig `nddniju ig hiddlpu nj u}eemuunwm jmcixnlxnij pi}jhu h}pnjc xfm CLXX ~mlpu ljh lgxmp xfm ]p}c}l~ Pi}jh$uncjngneljxd~ eijxpn`}xnjc xi l cdi`ld rmp elrnxld njeiam njepmlum ig 0=2- iwmp xfm =2!~mlp rmpnih 86!>6*.06

Xfm CLXX umxu }r l Gplamsipk gip xfm mvefljcm ig xlpngg eijemuuniju ljh `~ muxl`dnufnjc l eihm ig p}dmu ij jij!hnuepnanjlxnij ljh }jglnp xplhnjc rplexnemu* Ki}d &022=.$ r >* Pmeicjnznjc xflx xfmnp pmdlxniju nj xfm gnmdh ig xplhm ljhmeijiane mjhmlwi}p ufi}dh `m eijh}exmh snxf l wnms xi plnunjc uxljhlphu ig dnwnjc$ mju}pnjc g}dd mardi~amjx ljh l dlpcm ljhuxmlhnd~ cpisnjc wid}am ig pmld njeiam ljh mggmexnwm hmaljh$ hmwmdirnjc xfm g}dd }um ig xfm pmui}pemu ig xfm sipdh ljhmvrljhnjc xfm rpih}exnij ljh mvefljcm ig ciihu$ @mnjc hmunpi}u ig eijxpn`}xnjc xi xfmum iòmexnwmu `~ mjxmpnjc njxi pmenrpieldljh a}x}ldd~ lhwljxlcmi}u lppljcmamjxu hnpmexmh xi xfm u}ùxljxnld pmh}exnij ig xlpnggu ljh ixfmp `lppnmpu xi xplhm ljh xi xfmmdnanjlxnij ig hnuepnanjlxip~ xpmlxamjx nj njxmpjlxnijld eiaampem$ Flwm xfpi}cf xfmnp pmrpmumjxlxnwmu lcpmmh lu giddisu &CLXXRpmla`dm* [fxxr?))sss*sxi*ipc)mjcdnuf)hieuYm)dmcldYm)clxx83Ym*rhgQ* Pmxpnmwmh

Xfm Rlpxnmu xi xfnu Lcpmmamjx$ Pmeicjnznjc xflx xfmnp pmdlxniju nj xfm gnmdh ig xplhm ljh meijiane mjhmlwi}p ufi}dh `m

eijh}exmh snxf l wnms xi plnunjc uxljhlphu ig dnwnjc$ mju}pnjc g}dd mardi~amjx ljh l dlpcm ljh uxmlhnd~ cpisnjc wid}am ig pmld

njeiam ljh mggmexnwm hmaljh$ ljh mvrljhnjc xfm rpih}exnij ig ljh xplhm nj ciihu ljh umpwnemu$ sfndm lddisnjc gip xfm irxnald}um ig xfm sipdhu pmui}pemu nj leeiphljem snxf xfm iòmexnwm ig u}uxlnjl`dm hmwmdiramjx$ ummknjc ìxf xi rpixmex ljh rpmumpwmxfm mjwnpijamjx ljh xi mjfljem xfm amlju gip hinjc ui nj l aljjmp eijunuxmjx snxf xfmnp pmurmexnwm jmmhu ljh eijempju lxhnggmpmjx dmwmdu ig meijiane hmwmdiramjx$ Pmeicjnznjc g}pxfmp xflx xfmpm nu jmmh gip riunxnwm mggipxu hmuncjmh xi mju}pm xflxhmwmdirnjc ei}jxpnmu$ ljh murmenldd~ xfm dmlux hmwmdirmh laijc xfma$ ume}pm l uflpm nj xfm cpisxf nj njxmpjlxnijld xplhmeiaamju}plxm snxf xfm jmmhu ig xfmnp meijiane hmwmdiramjx$ @mnjc hmunpi}u ig eijxpn`}xnjc xi xfmum iòmexnwmu `~ mjxmpnjc njxipmenrpield ljh a}x}ldd~ lhwljxlcmi}u lppljcmamjxu hnpmexmh xi xfm u}ùxljxnld pmh}exnij ig xlpnggu ljh ixfmp `lppnmpu xi xplhm ljh

xi xfm mdnanjlxnij ig hnuepnanjlxip~ xpmlxamjx nj njxmpjlxnijld xplhm pmdlxniju$ Pmuidwmh$ xfmpmgipm$ xi hmwmdir lj njxmcplxmh$ aipmwnl`dm ljh h}pl`dm a}dxndlxmpld xplhnjc u~uxma mjeiarluunjc xfm Cmjmpld Lcpmmamjx ij Xlpnggu ljh Xplhm$ xfm pmu}dxu ig rluxxplhm dn`mpldnzlxnij mggipxu$ ljh ldd ig xfm pmu}dxu ig xfm ]p}c}l~ Pi}jh ig A}dxndlxmpld Xplhm Jmcixnlxniju$ Hmxmpanjmh xi

rpmumpwm xfm `lune rpnjenrdmu ljh xi g}pxfmp xfm iòmexnwmu }jhmpd~njc xfnu a}dxndlxmpld xplhnjc u~uxma$ Lcpmm lu giddisu?


9/27

>

rpnjenrdmu xflx njurnpmh xfm ipcljnzmpu ljh jmcixnlxipu xfpi}cfi}x xfm dngm ig xfm CLXX)SXI*52

Xfm ipcljne hmwmdiramjx ig xfm SXI ljh nxu rpmhmemuuipu flu ufisj nxumdg xi `m wmp~

rplcalxneldd~ ipnmjxmh$ ljh fncfd~ g}jexnijld* Xfm dmlhmpufnr ig xfm SXI gie}umu ij xfnu

r}prium$ ljh xfm ueirm ig xfm SXIu anuunij*5< Xfm SXIu dmlhmp$ Rlueld Dla~$ alhm nx edmlp

xflx fm sljxu xfm ipcljnzlxnij xi uxl~ pmurijunwm xi xfm jmmhu ig nxu Ama`mpu*50 Xf}u$ nx si}dh

umma xflx xfm ipcljnzlxnij nu smdd lslpm xflx nxu mvnuxmjem hmrmjhu ij Ama`mp eijumjx*

SXI Ama`mpu flwm l pncfx xi xfnu gie}u ij umpwnenjc xfmnp jmmhu* Ama`mp lcpmmamjxu

lpm dmcldd~ `njhnjc xpmlxnmu plxngnmh `~ xfm wlpni}u jlxnijld dmcnudlxnwm ìhnmu* Xfm SXI

njeipriplxmu nxu Ama`mpu lcpmmamjxu njxi l ìh~ ig dls$ ljh xfmj rpiwnhmu l amefljnua xi

pmuidwm hnur}xmu glnpd~* Xf}u Ama`mpu flwm l pncfx xi flwm xplhm hnur}xmu pmuidwmh nj l sl~ xflx

pmluijl`d~ njxmprpmxu xfm xpmlxnmu xi pmgdmex Ama`mp lcpmmamjxu* ]jgipx}jlxmd~$ nj km~ lpmlu$ xfm

SXI flu glndmh xi lefnmwm rpnjenrdmh hnur}xm pmuid}xnij* Xfm glnd}pm ig xfm HU xi flpaijnzm nxu

ljld~unu ig ulgmc}lph hnur}xmu snxf xfm rpnjenrdmu ig xfm Lcpmmamjx ij Ulgmc}lphu nu

rpi`dmalxne$ ìxf ij rpnjenrld ljh rplexneldd~*

Eijum|}mjxd~$ lx dmlux snxf pmurmex xi ulgmc}lphu$ xfm HU ufisu nxumdg xi `m i}x ig xi}ef

snxf xfm SXIu anuunij ljh snxf xfm dmcld gi}jhlxniju ljh xplhnxniju }rij sfnef xfm SXI HU

Rpmla`dm$ Alpplkmuf Lcpmmmamjx Muxl`dnufnjc xfm Sipdh Xplhm Ipcljnzlxnij*[fxxr?))sss*sxi*ipc)mjcdnuf)pmuYm)ìikurYm)ljld~xneYnjhmvYm)sxiYlcpmmY2? Lu N flwm ulnh

alj~ xnamu `mgipm$ nx nu xi ~i}p jmmhu ljh lurnplxniju xflx xfnu ipcljnzlxnij a}ux elxmp$ ljh N empxlnjd~ firm xflx xfnu Gip}a sndd

mjl`dm xfm mjxnpm SXI gland~$ ama`mpu ljh Umepmxlpnlx uxlgg ldnkm$ xi `mxxmp kmmr xfmnp gnjcmpu ij xfm r}dum ui xi urmlk* Nj ixfmpsiphu$ xi `mxxmp clcm ~i}p eijempju ljh mvrmexlxniju ig fis sm$ nj xfm SXI$ elj hi xfnjcu `mxxmp nj g}x}pm*[fxxr?))sss*sxi*ipc)mjcdnuf)jmsuYm)urrdYm)urrd


10/27


11/27

Ulgmc}lphu lpm edmlpd~

5= Nh*57 Nh* lx 035*53 Nh*56 HU>6$ Kipml Hmgnjnxnwm Ulgmc}lph Amlu}pm ij Naripxu ig Empxlnj Hlnp~ Rpih}exu &Eiardlnjljx? M}pirmlj Eiaa}jnxnmu.$ &3.* HU.* HU020$ ]jnxmh Uxlxmu Hmgnjnxnwm Ulgmc}lph Amlu}pmu ij Naripxu ig Enpe}dlp SmdhmhElp`ij \}ldnx~ Dnjm Rnrm gpia Kipml &Eiardlnjljx? Kipml.$ &$ ]jnxmh Uxlxmu Hmgnjnxnwm Ulgmc}lphAmlu}pmu ij Naripxu ig Empxlnj Uxmmd Rpih}exu &Eiardlnjljx? Olrlj.$ &02 Alpef 0220.* HU0=

Nx nu njhnur}xl`dm xflx muelrm edl}um rpiwnuniju$ sfnef lddis Ama`mpu xi mjlex rpixmexnijnux amlu}pmu xi ufnmdh lndnjc hiamuxnenjh}uxpnmu$ p}j eijxplp~ xi xfm cildu ljh r}priumu ig xplhm dn`mpldnzlxnij ljh flpaijnzlxnij }jhmp xfm CLXX ljh SXI*

Jijmxfmdmuu$ xfm muelrm edl}um pmalnju lj njxmcpld mdmamjx ig xfm a}dxndlxmpld gplamsipk* Alj~ Ama`mpu$ gmlpg}d ig xfm flpag}d


12/27


13/27


14/27


15/27

Rpmunhmjx I`lal njuxnx}xmh l 5=- xlpngg ij rluumjcmp elp ljh dncfx

xp}ek xnpmu naripxmh gpia Efnjl*8> Xfnu lexnij slu `lumh ij xfm pmeiaamjhlxnij ig xfm ]U

Njxmpjlxnijld Xplhm Eiaanuunij$ sfi nu r}priumh snxf njwmuxnclxnjc rmxnxniju xi xlkm lexniju

`lumh ij xfm ]Uu SXI i`dnclxniju* Xfm NXE nu lj njhmrmjhmjx gmhmpld lcmje~$ ljh flu l

`ldljemh pmeiph ig ulgmc}lph njwmuxnclxniju*=2 Sfmj xfm NXE alkmu l ulgmc}lph

pmeiaamjhlxnij nj xfm lggnpalxnwm$ xfm Rpmunhmjx flu xfm irxnij xi nardmamjx xfmnp

pmeiaamjhmh pmamh~* Rpmunhmjx I`lal o}uxngnmh fnu hmenunij ij xfm cpi}jhu xflx mjgipemamjx

ig mvnuxnjc xplhm lcpmmamjxu nu jmemuulp~ xi xfm xplhnjc u~uxma*=< Xfmpm flwm ijd~ `mmj 7 ixfmp

flwm el}umh ip lpm xfpmlxmjnjc xi el}um umpni}u njo}p~ xi l hiamuxne njh}uxp~ }jhmp xfm xmpau ig xfnu Lcpmmamjx$ xfm eiarmxmjxl}xfipnxnmu ufldd mwld}lxm ldd pmdmwljx glexipu ig lj iòmexnwm ljh |}ljxngnl`dm jlx}pm flwnjc l `mlpnjc ij xfm unx}lxnij ig xflxnjh}uxp~$ nj rlpxne}dlp$ xfm plxm ljh lai}jx ig njepmlum nj naripxu ig xfm rpih}ex eijempjmh nj lùid}xm ljh pmdlxnwm xmpau$ xfmuflpm ig xfm hiamuxne alpkmx xlkmj `~ njepmlumh naripxu$ efljcmu nj xfm dmwmd ig uldmu$ rpih}exnij$ rpih}exnwnx~$ elrlenx~}xndnzlxnij$ rpignxu ljh diuumu$ ljh mardi~amjx* SXI Lcpmmamjx ij Ulgmc}lphu$ Lpxnedm 8$Hmxmpanjlxnij ig Umpni}u Njo}p~ ipXfpmlx Xfmpmig* [fxxr?))sss*sxi*ipc)mjcdnuf)hieuYm)dmcldYm)0=!ulgmc*rhgQ* Pmxpnmwmh 62!0227.$ R>3* [fxxr?))sss*}unxe*ciw)xplhmYpmamh~)hie}amjxu)Pmripx!2*.=>< ljh elj `m gi}jh ij xfm SXI Smùnxm [sss*sxi*ipcQ*7 !022 &*Urpnjc0228.*3

Documents

FACTORIAL CAUSATION ANALYSIS: HOW TO RESOLVE SAFEGUARDS PARADOX IN WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION DISPUTE SETTLEMENT