Upload
others
View
4
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Experience of Coping with Social Labeling in
Female Adolescents in Conflict with Law
A Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the
Requirements for the Award of the Degree of
Master of Philosophy
in
Psychology
by
Mili Reddy
(Reg. No. 1434211)
Under the Guidance of
Tissy Mariam Thomas
Associate Professor
Department of Psychology
CHRIST UNIVERSITY
BENGALURU, INDIA
April 2016
ii
Approval of Dissertation
Dissertation entitled ‘Experience of Coping with Social Labeling in Female Adolescents in
Conflict with Law’ by Mili Reddy, Reg. No. 1434211 is approved for the award of the degree of
Master of Philosophy in Psychology.
Examiners:
1.____________________________________ ______________
2.
3.
Supervisor:
_____________________________________ ______________
Chairperson:
_____________________________________ ______________
Date: __________________
Place: Bengaluru
iii
DECLARATION
I, Mili Reddy, hereby declare that this dissertation, titled ‘Experience of Coping with Social
Labeling in Female Adolescents in Conflict with law’ is a record of original research work
undertaken by me for the award of the degree of Master of Philosophy in Psychology. I have
completed this study under the supervision of Dr Tissy Mariam Thomas, Associate Professor,
Department of Psychology.
I also declare that this dissertation has not been submitted for the award of any degree,
diploma, associateship, fellowship or other title. It has not been sent for any publication or
presentation purpose. I hereby confirm the originality of the work and that there is no
plagiarism in any part of the dissertation.
Place: Bengaluru Signature of Candidate
Date: __________________ Mili Reddy
Register Number: 1434211
Department of Psychology
Christ University, Bengaluru
iv
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the dissertation submitted by Mili Reddy (Reg.No.1434211), titled,
‘Experience of Coping with Social Labelling in Female Adolescents in Conflict with Law’ is
a record of research work done by her during the academic year 2014-2015 under my
supervision in partial fulfilments for the award of Master of Philosophy in Psychology.
This dissertation has not been submitted for the award of any degree, diploma, associateship,
fellowship or other title. It has not been sent for any publication or presentation purpose. I
hereby confirm the originality of the work and that there is no plagiarism in any part of the
dissertation.
Place: Bengaluru Signature of the Supervisor
Date: __________________ Dr Tissy Mariam Thomas
Associate Professor
Department of Psychology
Christ University, Bengaluru
Signature of the Head of the Department
Department of Psychology
Christ University, Bengaluru
v
Acknowledgement
I would firstly like to thank the Department of Psychology, Christ University, for giving me
this great opportunity to conduct a study on the topic of my interest.
I am thankful to my supervisor, Dr Tissy Mariam Thomas, without whom I would have never
been able to complete my study. Her constant support, help and patience has become my
strength that has helped and motivated me through the toughest of times.
I would also like to thank the participants of this study who were an integral part of it, for
being so sharing, trusting and making this research possible for me.
I am thankful to SFS Academy and the Principal, for giving me the time and space to work
on my research and being ever so understanding.
I am very grateful to my friends, Samantha Philips, Chandni Mehta, Fr Jim Jose and all my
MPhil classmates who have been my rock keeping me grounded, so patient and calm
throughout my research. They have helped me grow as a researcher and learn a lot during this
period.
I would love to thank my parents, Venkat Reddy and Eben Reddy, for their trust, love and
prayers and being a constant motivation for me to reach my goals, also my sister, Evie Reddy
who provided me with support, love and laughter when I was at my lowest.
I express my love and appreciation to Ravijith Rai, who has always backed me, regardless of
the circumstances and has been my strength throughout this study.
vi
Abstract
Social labeling deals with the phenomenon of majorities to negatively label minorities or
individuals seen as deviant from standard cultural norms; this phenomenon is primarily seen to
affect the coping methods and development of social identity of anindividual. The study was
conducted with the aim to understand the experience of coping with social labeling in female
adolescents in conflict with the law. The sample consisted of six female participants who were
selected from a rehabilitation center for children in conflict with law, where purposive sampling
method was used. The data was collected through a semi structured interview schedule which
had gained credibility through the validation of four professionals who are related to the field of
study. Results were analyzed using interpretative phenomenological analysis. The themes
generated from the collected data in the research study focused on the experiences of social
labelingand stigma in female adolescents (before or after being in the remand home or
rehabilitation center), and generation of coping methods, its sustenance, while in the remand
home or rehabilitation center. Individual case analysis, as well as cross case analysis were
conducted to gain results. The results showed that female adolescents in conflict with law
experience social control, labels and stigmatization. These experiences generate negative
emotions and distort social identity. Also, there is an interface between support groups and
coping methods. Female adolescents in conflict with the law show that through sharing coping
methods, there is a development in a positive sense of self and reduction in deviant behaviors.
The strong basis of the findings, create knowledge and insight about the wide spread of the
labeling phenomenon and will help in client empowerment, helping them cope with labeling
influences and how it can be managed in situations they face, more effectively and various
fields of Psychology can use this information as a base for understanding the process of coping
with social labels and its effects on the child’s wellbeing.
Keywords: Social labeling, Social identity, Conflict with law, Coping, Deviance.
vii
Table of Contents
Approval of Dissertation……………………………………………………………………... ii
DECLARATION……………………………………………………………………………. iii
CERTIFICATE……………………………………………………………………………… iv
Acknowledgement …………………………………………………………………………….v
Abstract ………………………………………………………………………………………vi
Table of Contents ……………………………………………………………………………vii
List of Tables ………………………………………………………………………………….x
List of Figures ………………………………………………………………………………..xi
Chapter 1 Introduction…………………………………………………………………………1
The Labeling Phenomenon…………………………………………………………….1
Labeling of Women…………………………………………………………………....2
Children in Conflict with the Law……………………………………………………..3
Theoretical Framework………………………………………………………………..4
Social Labeling Theory………………………………………………………………..4
Coping Theory………………………………………………………………………....6
Social Identity Theory…………………………………………………………………7
Research Paradigm…………………………………………………………………....8
Significance of the Study……………………………………………………………..9
Objectives of the Study………………………………………………………………10
Chapter 2 Review of Literature………………………………………………………………12
Justice System and Social Labeling…………………………………………………13
Identity Formation and Labeling…………………………………………………….14
viii
Coping and Psychological Health…………………………………………………...16
Familyand Delinquency…………………………………………………………….18
Causes and Consequences of Delinquency…………………………………………..20
Chapter 3 Method……………………………………………………………………………23
Research Design ……………………………………………………………………..23
Participants…………………………………………………………………………..24
Key Concepts………………………………………………………………………...25
Method of Data Collection ………………………………………………………….26
Data Collection Strategies……………………………………………………………27
Data Analysis………………………………………………………………………...28
Validation of Data……………………………………………………………………31
Ethical Guidelines……………………………………………………………………31
Chapter 4 Results and Discussion……………………………………………………………33
Analysis of Data……………………………………………………………………...35
Discussion of Individual Results……………………………………………………..37
Objective 1: To Understand the Experience and Perception of Social Labeling and the
Subjective Experience of Being Labeled…………………………………………….85
Objective 2: To Understand Coping Strategies of Female Adolescents in Conflict
with the Law in Rehabilitation Centers who Face or Faced Social Labeling and are
Affected by it…………………………………………………………………………93
Objective 3: To Analyze the Reasons for Adopting a Certain Coping Strategy…….99
Propositional Model………………………………………………………………...105
Chapter 5 Summary and Conclusion………………………………………………………..107
Major Findings of the Study……………………………………………………….108
ix
Limitations of the Study……………………………………………………………109
Implications of the Study…………………………………………………………..110
Scope for Further Research………………………………………………………...111
References…………………………………………………………………………………..113
Appendices………………………………………………………………………………….120
Appendix A: Consent form…………………………………………………………………120
Appendix B: Demographic Sheet…………………………………………………………...122
Appendix C: Semi Structured Interview Schedule………………………………………….124
x
List of Tables
Table 1: Process of Analysis from the Raw Data to Conceptualizing Master Themes ……..30
Table 2: Details of Participants ……………………………………………………………...34
Table 3: Themes and Super Ordinate Themes Generated from Analyzing Results of
Participant 1…………………………………………………………………………………..37
Table 4: Themes and Super Ordinate Themes Generated from Analyzing Results of
Participant 2 ………………………………………………………………………………….49
Table 5: Themes and Super Ordinate Themes Generated from Analyzing Results of
Participant 3 ………………………………………………………………………………….56
Table6: Themes and Super Ordinate Themes Generated from Analyzing Results of
Participant 4…………………………………………………………………………………..65
Table 7: Themes and Super Ordinate Themes Generated from Analyzing Results of
Participant 5…………………………………………………………………………………..72
Table 8: Themes and Super Ordinate Themes Generated from Analyzing Results of
Participant 6 ………………………………………………………………………………….78
Table 9: Objective 1 Results ………………………………………………………………...85
Table 10: Objective 2 Results ……………………………………………………………….93
Table 11: Objective 3 Results …………………………………………………………….....99
xi
List of Figures
Figure 1: Super Ordinate and Master Themes of Objective 1……………………………….87
Figure 2: Super Ordinate and Master Themes of Objective 2 ………………………………94
Figure 3: Super Ordinate and Master Themes of Objective 3 ……………………………..100
Figure 4: Representation of the Propositional Model for the Study ………………………104
1 Running head: COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN
CONFLICT WITH LAW
Chapter 1
Introduction
Interpretation of knowledge is viewed as a human outcome which is socially
constructed in the form of labels (Prat & Floden, 1994). Having said this, what certifies the
most to be labeled in society is of course the deviation from set social rules, more commonly
crime.
Tennenbaum, who is also known as one of the pioneers of the labelling theory, in his
work Crime and Community(1938), describes social interaction as a main component of the
occurrence of crime. The complex external environment involves a large variety of social
contacts that are crucial in helping and causing distress in individuals faced with any social
anxiety (Nataraj, 2004).
The Labelling Phenomenon
The idea or experience of being tagged or labelled comes from a social constructivist
perspective (O‟ Grady, 2011). It is viewed that social labelling behaviour is possible largely
due to social interaction. Criminals do not differ from others in their original impulse to
commit crimes but societal interaction plays an important role in developing a pattern of
deviant behaviour (Tennenbaum, 1938). Theorists like George Herbert Mead (1934) and
other sociologists have involved themselves in studying how interactions make persons and
communities. Deviance is often considered to be the failure to conform to the norms and rules
of a group. This tendency leads to the labeling of the individuals by the group, as an offense
to their social or moral norms of behavior (Jones, 1986).
2
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Labeling of Women
In the Indian context, women are seen to be not as educated as men as well as
occupation wise they are ridiculed and deemed unfit for most jobs (Kumar & Shiva, 1996).
This phenomenon leads them to be more strongly labelled and stereotyped by society.
Female foeticide, infanticide, dowry deaths, rape, acid attacks and such experiences make
them the subject of bias and tags(Kumar &Shiva, 1996).With this view in mind, it is also
important not to ignore the recent development in the image or a women in Indian society, a
compilation of various researches in India (Chakrapani & Kumar, 1994), viewed that today
Indian women have moved from child rearing to bread winning, yet there are negative
assumptions still made about women which is culturally in tuned. Also although literacy rates
are on the rise, female literacy is lower than male literacy rate. Statistics show that females
stand at 65.46 per cent, compared to 82.14 per cent for males (Literacy rate in India, 2011).
Literacy could provide women with a stronger stand in society to overcome the labelling
stigma that could be directed towards them. It is now apparent that women in India are in dire
need to be equipped with positive coping tools to overcome social anxieties that manifests
itself external and internally. Also daily confrontation with societal pressure and expectations
has probed this research in to understanding if there is a pattern of coping that female
adolescents with delinquency adopt against being labelled by society. Focussing on recent
issues such as debates over unsafe environment for women, suicide cases that have been
brought to public notice because of social stigma, juvenile age for death penalty, sexual
assaults and also the subjective experiences of the perception of social realities probe the
researcher to understand the phenomenon of labelling and dealing with the same in female
adolescents in conflict with the law. The population is seen to be vulnerable to social
assumptions, labelling and biases (Chakrapani & Kumar, 1994). The current situation in
relation to the above mentioned aspects probe the researcher to conduct the present study.
3
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
In relation to coping with stress, there seems to be a prominent difference between
genders. Studies show that men use problem focused coping at a higher rate than women.
Men tend to ponder over problems longer than women do, even in situations where nothing
can be done (Folkman & Lazarus, 1988). In 2006, a study on gender analysis and coping
theories was conducted by Banyard and Bermann. In this study feminist theories were used to
critique psychological theories of coping with stress. Feminist ideas focused on the issue that
coping theories portrayed women as less cable of coping with stress than men. The results of
this research leaned towards the reformulation of coping theories based on the varied
experiences of women and the influence of social elements on female coping, such as sexism
and racism. Revised feminist ideas and methodologies are seen to encourage more accurate
appraisal of female coping methods and this would in turn help increase the formulation of
more inclusive and representative theories of coping with social stress.
Children in Conflict with the Law
Children in conflict with the law refers to any person below the age of 18 who has
come in contact with the juvenile justice system as a result of committing a crime or being
suspected of committing a crime, sometimes coerced into crime by adults (UNICEF, 2014).
Juvenile/ Juvenile delinquent or offender is an individual who is under the age of 18, who is
found to have committed a crime and may not be sentenced as an adult, where it has been
declared by law that a minor lacks responsibility (Siegel &Welsh, 2011).Causes and
consequences of juvenile delinquency in India, was an article by Prakash Haveripet in 2013
that focused on the alarming increase in juvenile crime. It also had its main idea centered on
the risk factors and causes of this phenomenon amongst which family, mental health and drug
abuse were seen as main elements. Through this study it emerged that the inter relation that
exists between society or external factors such as, illegal activities, school drop outs,
damaged peer relations were seen as factors that led to the development of maladaptive
4
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
coping behaviors and also had an impact on the emergence of juvenile delinquency and
repeated deviant behaviors. In India the juvenile justice act of 1986 provides rehabilitation,
protection, care and treatment of delinquents or the neglected. Under this act it is also stated
that in India, a juvenile is defined as male below 16 years and females below 18 years of age.
The under aged or juvenile is also seen to be characterised by lower physical maturity and
mental capabilities which as a major factor differentiates them from an adult (Crime in India,
1995). This group in society often faces what is called “social stigma” (Mead, 1934).
Theoretical Framework
This study has its foundations based on two main theories, the social labeling theory
and coping theory. It is important to note that the researcher intends to link social labeling as
directly affecting coping abilities of female adolescents in conflict with the law, through this
research. The influence of social forces such as labels and stigma is seen to have an effect on
the perception of self and therefore formation of coping methods.
Social labeling theory is seen to be closely linked to symbolic interaction as well as
the social constructionist perspective. It was introduced by sociologists during the 1960‟s.
This theory views deviance as not an inherent act but instead focuses on the tendencies of a
large population to attach stigmatizing labels to minorities or individuals seen to be diverting
from standard cultural norms (Mead, 1934). This also views how due to certain names and
roles expected and attached to juveniles, one tends to work/ act on it and it becomes a part of
one‟s psychological self, similar to self-fulfilling prophesies and stereotyping. The labelling
theory of deviance which was largely seen popular in the 1960-70‟s saw how labelling
perspective was applied to one area being- juvenile delinquency which have indicated that
individuals tend to adopt negative ways or harmful ways of coping with social labelling. This
study views the juvenile perspective of how the society, inclusive of family, friends, peers,
5
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
police, authorities, label their behaviour and the changes in their perception society plus the
influence it has on their coping abilities.
The labels/ tags experienced by the juvenile offenders are often seen as a stigma that
negatively changes a person‟s self-concept, social identity as well as how one views society.
It is seen that in many societies labelling has led to the re occurrence of a deviance and had
acted as a reinforcement for future crime, which can also be viewed as a coping strategy
adopted by the individuals who are being labelled (Bernburg & Krohn, 2006).Labelling
theory hypothesizes that stigmatizing labels determine criminal behaviour (such as- thief,
murderers, abuser, loser, rowdy, rapists). These labels become a self-fulfilling prophecy
where an individual who is labelled has little or no choice but to conform to essential
meaning of judgment (Mead, 1934).
Sociologists introduced certain key concepts to the labelling theory that stated that
social groups themselves mould deviance by formulating rules whose infraction creates
deviance, and by administering those rules to particular individuals and labelling them as
outsiders. Therefore seen, deviance is not a quality of the action the individual commits, but
rather is a consequence of the application of these rules and sanctions to an 'offender‟ by the
others. The deviant individual would therefore be the one to whom that label has been
successfully applied (Becker, 1963).
In the midst of understanding social labelling phenomenon, the concept has been
criticised as being too vaguely defined and individually focussed (Link & Phelan, 2001).
Labelling theory and criminology was a study by Wellford in 1975 that was a detailed
critique on the short comings of the labelling theory to explain deviance. The study saw that
labelling perspective currently used is not a useful model to base deviant behaviour on.
6
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Critics also suggested modification of the model and analysis of situational aspects in order to
bring about a more useful labelling approach.
Coping Theory
Lazarus and Folkman (1984) spoke about a transactional model of stress and coping.
Their theory largely focused on interaction that occurs between a person and the
environment. Due to the imbalance that occurs between demands of society over behaviour
(relating to the study) and exceeds one‟s ability to cope and mediate that stress, the theory
suggests that two main types of coping strategies are formed. Thus the interpretation of the
stressful event (being labelled) will become more important than the event itself. First,
Problem based coping occurs when individuals feel that they have control over the situation.
They define the problem and learn new skills to cope with the problem. Emotional base
coping is used when individuals feel they have little or no control over the situation, resulting
in distancing oneself, avoidance or acceptance of the problem.
Coping is largely seen as a way of using one‟s internal mental abilities to deal with
or minimize the stress or difficulties that usually arises externally (Snyder, 1999). The terms
coping strategies or coping skills is used interchangeably with coping mechanisms in the field
of psychology. It is seen that there are three main styles of coping, which are: Appraisal-
focused, Problem-focused and Emotion-focused. Coping can also be classified as positive/
adaptive coping and negative/ maladaptive coping. Coping strategies are the actions that
individuals adapt to master, tolerate, minimize or decrease the stressors which have occurred
(Weiten & Lloyd 2008; Snyder, 1999). According to Lazarus (1993) coping strategies can be
defined as behavioural and cognitive efforts to balance both internal and external demands.
When we look at the nature of stressful environment, coping strategies are controlled by both
traits of personality and social context (Carver & Smith, 2012). Therefore in light of this
7
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
study the researcher is focussing on being negatively labelled by society as a stressor that
would in turn affect the coping ability of individuals.
Social Identity Theory
The aim of the study was to understand the experience of coping with social labels in females
adolescents in conflict with the law. It has been seen that social labels have a great effect on
the development of identity (Tennenbaum, 1938). Identity can be seen as the expressions,
beliefs and qualities that make a person who he/she is. This is self identity. There are other
kinds of identities such as cultural, racial, national identities, out of which the researcher
intended to focus upon social identity as it refers to a label and how one incorporates these
labels to form the self. The process of identification itself is a classifying act. The formation
of an identity develops through one‟s identification of a significant other (parents, care givers
etc) (McLeod, 2008). This process is seen to be prevalent in the case of children in conflict
with the law. Therefore, the researcher focuses on social identity theory as a base for the
study.
Social identity theory relates to the self- identification that occurs through group membership,
group processes and intergroup relations. The theory rests on the belief that collective
phenomenon cannot be explained using individualistic processes. Social psychology stress on
the study of individuals in relation to the environments they live in. Social identity theory
address phenomena such as stereotypes, prejudice, conflict, conformity, normative
behaviours and so on (Burke, 2006). In order to gain a deeper understanding of the subjective
experiences of negative labels being attached to female adolescents in conflict with the law, it
is important to understand how this affects their formation of social identities using this
theory.
8
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Research Paradigm
The study used Interpretative phenomenological paradigm that follows the IPA,
interpretative phenomenological analysis format in order to explore in detail how the
participants are making sense of the societal labels assigned to them. The understanding of
the emotional, cognitive and behavioural coping patterns and deep set meanings that are
subjective can be conducted and understood through this paradigm. It involves a detailed
examination of the participant world view, and emphasizes on the changes of the process,
during which the researcher had an active role to play. Gaining deep insights into the
participant‟s world view is seen as an important criterion of this paradigm in research
(Conrad, 1987).Under this paradigm, the social constructivist idea and phenomenology was
also used to view the structure of experiences, consciousness and processes of the sample in
relation to society. Husserl in the 20th
century investigated consciousness which later became
the study of philosophy of subjective experiences- phenomenology. He proposed what he
called “life-world”, and explained it as how human beings experience society in relation to
other objects and are influenced by them and act upon them. He summarised this as the
natural attitude of humans to act upon the world, within the world (Schutz, 1970).
Phenomenology focussed upon how an individual in a given context makes sense of
a given phenomenon. (Giorgi, 1970).The social constructivist view focused upon culture and
understanding what happens in one‟s environment as a base for constructing knowledge
(McMahon, 1997). Therefore in this study interpretation of this knowledge that is a human
product which is socially constructed in the form of labels was understood (Glasersfeld,
1999; Prat & Floden, 1994). This paradigm helps the researcher to also look at the
communicating groups and social meanings that individuals form due to experiences
(Gredler, 1997; Prat & Floden, 1994). Also interpretative analysis is ideal for a small sample
9
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
size plus detailed case by case analysis, which also extended the researcher‟s understanding
of new information and activities among the sample (Rogoff, 1990).
Significance of the Study
Statistics show that there are 10.2 juvenile offenders per 1 lakh population in the
world. The recorded adolescent crimes in India are 0.9 to per cent of the total crimes
committed in the nation (Haveripet, 2013). „Juvenile delinquency in India‟ an article posted
online by Hemangana Kalita on February 16, 2013, clearly stated the evolution of juvenile
delinquency into what it is today. The crucial elements in society such as familial
relationships, peer affiliations and socio-economic status, are seen as major cause of
delinquent/ deviant behavior. The stigma related to them has directly influenced the way the
society „brands‟ children in conflict with the law and the effect of it in maintaining, coping
or even raising the criminal behavior. The rapidly changing patterns of modern lifestyle, has
created many difficulties among young people regarding adjustment to new ways of life.
Daily confrontation with issues related to the failure to differentiate between what is right or
wrong, the ability to think rationally and feel effectively is seen depleting.
Labelling experiences are instrumental in producing issues of adjustment and causes
commitment to further deviance. Critiques have time and again stated this aspect as a
drawback to the theory but it can be considered in the area of children in conflict with the
law as it produces a larger perspective to the system and the causes for such norm breaking
(Paternoster & Iovanni, 2006). With regard to adolescent females chosen in the study,
Literacy rate in India (2011) show that females stand at 65.46 per cent, compared to 82.14
per cent for males in terms of education. India ranks one of the leading countries to report
higher cases of gender discrimination and crime against women (Kumar, 1996). Also due to
factors such as emotional quotient, low socio economic status and isolation, it is more likely
10
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
that females are impacted and experience social labelling and stigma at a higher level
(Goleman, 2011). Therefore the researcher intends to study this sample.Regarding mental
health field, understanding how female adolescents in conflict with the law cope with the
social labelling stress can make it much easier to reinforce better behaviour, and ensure
emotional stability. Certain methods of creating and maintaining employment and social
relationships can be undertaken by bringing into the awareness various steps one has taken
to tackle being labelled or perceiving labelling, individuals will be able to recognize the
various avenues and coping strategies available to them and gain insight on how they react to
situations and adapt to it (Wurzburg, 2014). This will heighten theirunderstanding of the inter
relations with peers, authorities as well as family systems increasing needed communication
between systems and also focussing on the legal understandings of delinquency could also be
improvised or changed by attempting to understand delinquent‟s subjective experiences more
deeply.
Researcher focuses to become aware and help assign meaning to the labeling
experience faced by juvenile females in conflict with the law. The significance can also be
perceived with regard to helping the sample understand their situation and cope positively
with the negativity. This research intends to help the sample gain more insight, become
aware of the beliefs they possessand process of attaching meaning to them. The researcher
organised general group discussions with the consent of the participants, after analysing the
results attempting to help increase adaptive methods of coping with social stigma.
Objectives of the Study
Major Objective:
To understand the experience of social labelling and coping infemale adolescents in
conflict with the law.
11
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Specific Objectives:
To understand the experience and perception of social labeling and the subjective
experience of being labeled.
To understand the coping strategies of female adolescents in conflict with the law in
rehabilitation centers who face or faced social labeling and are affected by it.
To analyze the reasons for adopting a certain coping strategy.
12
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Chapter 2
Review of Literature
Review of literature focused on the connections that could be made between what
the researcher intends to study. The idea was focusing on mainly surrounding the reasons
and influences to coping behaviours in relation to being labelled and situations or
experiences of socially labelling adolescents with delinquency.
The studies that were reviewed focused on the role the justice system had to play in
reinforcing deviant behaviours in children in conflict with the law. In the studies the
authorities, courts and legal systems were examined to find certain laws in India that
involves helping and protecting children from becoming or subjecting themselves to youth
offenses. The Juvenile Justice Act (1986) was passed in India for the main reason of
protecting, treating and rehabilitating children in conflict with the law so as to help them
understand their situation and have a better future. The reviews also examined the link
between coping and psychological health as well as identity formation and self-labelling
being a reason for a negative outlook of self and lowered self-concept. The external factors
such as background of children, immediate family and parenting practices also showed how
social interaction plays a main role in shaping a child who might grow up to be in conflict
with the law. The personality of people and coping patterns around adolescents with
delinquency has also been topic of studies portraying inter- subjectivity and could externally
be an indicator of psychological health.
Through these studies conducted around coping and conflict with the law, the
researcher aims at understanding the labelling phenomenon at a much deeper level and
finding reasons for the sustenance of adaptive coping strategies.
13
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Justice System and Social Labelling
A study conducted by Hagan (1972), showed how the authorities that managed
juvenile delinquents were seen to adversely respond to juvenile behaviours. It focused on the
assumption that it is not the actor alone but the reactors too (agents of social control) who
are partially responsible for the problems of delinquency. Conclusions were that labelling
perspective- societal reactions school and underdog philosophy may have the potential of
directing us into the type of research that will inform us as to what the police “really do” and
what the consequences of these actions “really are”. This study showed how the labels given
to juveniles by authority too impacted their development. Though one is looking at how
these children are not the sole cause of deviance but are only displaying learnt behaviour,
one must also focus on how the justice system and authority has been taking advantage of
the labelling theory in sentencing the juveniles without court interventions, also at a large
level highest human interaction they experience is from authorities. This phenomenon could
also increase the chances that the criminal activity would repeat. In the same year, a study
was conducted by Lemert titled Human deviance, social problems and social control, which
oriented towards the role of authorities in being the sole cause for deviance to reoccur. The
support groups for children in conflict with the law play a massive role in reinforcing any
type of behaviour. Social control theory was focused upon and cases were presented to show
the influence of the elements on each other. Deviance was seen to be perpetuated by the
social forces which are to be appointed for its elimination/ control.
Anne Rankin Mahoney, University of Denver conducted a project with the Juvenile
Justice Standards and the National Institute of law enforcement and criminal justice in 1973-
74. They reviewed the evidence that showed how juveniles had been stigmatized by the
justice system and the authorities. Findings suggest that the term “labelling theory” is almost
14
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
always used among the officials in the juvenile justice system in order to minimize the court
intervention procedures into the children‟s lives, but yet there has been little examination of
its empirical support. The team attempted to put together existing empirical evidence about
the effects of police and court labelling upon juveniles. The link that the researcher intends
to study which is of labelling and stigmatization can be seen and understood here. Thomas
and Cage (1977) conducted a study that was published online in 2005, titled: The Effect of
Social Characteristics on Juvenile Court Dispositions found that a form of labelling that
leads to discrimination in the juvenile court is based on social background and
demographics. Many rehabilitation centres in India operate within a population of low socio
economic status and below poverty line dwellers. This study saw that consideration of these
elements leads to the intensity of severity of sanctions imposed on juveniles, due to the fact
that extra-legal variables project an effect on case disposition even when the seriousness of
the offence and previous records of delinquency are held constant, showing that the justice
system was not free of bias. These studies therefore, centred on the role justice systems
played modifying delinquent or deviant behaviours as well as how this institution is not free
from bias and also play a part in the social labelling phenomenon. The researcher‟s main
focus on studiesconcentrated towards authorities and the legal system, as this is the first and
probably the most prominent place for stigmatization to occur.
Identity Formation and Labelling
Once a child is exposed to negativity by society or family, the idea of “self” and
identity is usually seen distorted (Jensen, 1980). The researcher tries to gain information on
how distorted self images find adaptive coping methods and tries to heal it. Jensen in 1980
conducted a study on labelling and identity- toward a reconciliation of divergent findings,
which was published online in 2006. This article he wrote was meant as a response to
15
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
criticism of some of his work on how relevant labelling is to adolescent self-conceptions and
an attempt to reconcile divergent findings. His findings suggested that official labelling as
well as self-reported delinquent behaviours are in relation to delinquent self-images but self-
reported delinquency is seen to be more in connection with negative self-images than the
prior. This study relates to the self-fulfilling prophecy where by external source of labelling
will induce the idea that the stigmatizing labels is actually what defines oneself and
delinquents tend to self-label and act upon the labels addressed to them. In the American
Journal of Sociology in 1992 an article was published by the university of Chicago press, on
the principles of labelling explained by Mead and other symbolic interactionists. An
integrated framework was used to test the causal model of consequences of reflected
appraisals and delinquent behaviour. Findings showed that appraisals that were reflected of
self-had been largely affected by the appraisals of parents and previous delinquent
behaviours. Delinquent behaviour in the future is clearly seen as affected by appraisals
reflected of self as violator of rules. This study showed the impact of self-labelling on the
delinquent behaviour and the need to understand the process that leads to such self- harming
behaviour and thoughts. Similar to this, Galinsky, Hugenberg, Groom and Bodenhausen
(2003) conducted a study, titled: The re-appropriation of stigmatizing labels: implications for
social identity. The study focused upon the phenomenon whereby a stigmatized group, make
externally given negative labels their own, by self-consciously referring to oneself as the
label/tag. A model was put forth that showed the causes and effects of re-appropriation as
well as how certain external conditions are a pre-requisite for re-appropriation to be
effective. Roots of stigma, social identity formation and devalued social identity were
studied in the model. This study‟s results showed that it had a positive implication for both
groups and teams, outside and within a group.
16
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Interactionists argued that humans are social animals. In order to survive,
interaction and communication play an important role. When one‟s environment is not
conducive for proper and positive mental growth, it affects individuals negatively. Children
can be a group seen to be affected the most by outer environment as they approach the
identity formation stage.
Coping and Psychological Health
An interesting approach in the study of coping, viewed the link between feelings
and coping methods. What was interesting is that the researcher, in this study aimed at
understanding how amongst negative criticisms, humans can develop positive and adaptive
coping methods and reasons for its sustenance.
Folkman and Lazarus in 1988 undertook a study titled: Coping as a mediator of
emotion, that focussed on the idea that coping affects emotion. This was a neo view as
theory and research usually suggested that emotions affected coping. The procedure
includedevaluating imbalance in two Caucasian, community residing samples, that sought to
study the extent to which coping mediated emotions during stressful encounters. Subjects'
recently experienced stressful encounters, the ways they coped with the demands of those
encounters, and the emotions they experienced during two stages of those encounters were
assessed repeatedly. A regression analysis was conducted. Results showed that coping was
associated with changes in emotional state of individuals, with some forms of coping
associated with increases in positive emotions and other forms associated with increases in
negative emotions. The importance to study coping is stressed upon as it proves to be linked
to other psychological functioning as well as coping could portray the sense in which
individuals view the world around them. For the current study it could also prove helpful to
understand the levels of tolerance and prior experiences that shape children‟s world view. In
17
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
2001, a study titled Coping with stress during childhood and adolescence: problems,
progress and potential in theory and research, was undertaken by Compas, Smith, Saltzman,
Thomsen and Wadsworth, that concerned itself on the relationship between coping and
responses to stress. Data was collected through questionnaires, interviews and observation
on an adolescent sample. It was found that there were issues in conceptualization and
measurement of coping in adolescents. The elements of development and correlation of
coping were yet to be studied and identified. This study outlined the agendas for further
research on child- adolescent coping.
In 2005, Jane, Carol, and Boustead conducted a study titled: Coping style and
psychological health among adolescent prisoners: a study of young and juvenile offenders,
whichexplored the role of coping styles as a predictor of poor psychological health among
adolescent offenders. This study shows that coping pattern could externally indicate
psychological health and in light of the study undertaken now this could prove beneficial as
it intends to view coping in female adolescents with delinquency, which could also help the
researcher understand participant‟s psychological health and help generate insights to how
coping and mental health is linked. Sontag, Graber, Gunn & Warren in 2008 conducted a
study titled: Coping with Social Stress: Implications for Psychopathology in Young
Adolescent Girls. The study investigated the impact of social stress on symptoms of
psychopathology at the entry into adolescence. Previous as well as this study, focussed on
gender differences in adoption of coping methods. Researcher aims at understanding how
females conceptualise labelling and adopt or generate methods to cope with it. The sample
consisted of 111 adolescent girls, who were examined whether peer stress and pubertal
timing were associated with the internalization of distress and anger. Results of this study
showed that early matures and girls with higher levels of peer stress showed heightened
response to stress, distress and aggression. The findings also helped to identify coping
18
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
patterns that can be used to help girls in the more successful transition into adolescence.
Basic coping patterns can arise by positively externalizing the internal trauma that
individuals go through. Through this study researcher found that hormonal changes
experienced by girls are crucial in understanding their response to stress. The unexpected
benefit of being nice according to science is the title of article writing by Sammy Nickalls in
July, 2015. This article aims at explaining one of the coping strategies used to overcome the
experience of social anxiety. Recent research by social psychologists at the university of
British Columbia and Simon Frarer University suggested that doing good deeds can help
with social anxiety. 115 undergraduate students were split into 3 groups. Group 1 were asked
to go out of their way and be kind to others. Group 2 were asked to confront their social
anxiety and group 3 were asked to maintain a journal. The results of the experiment
suggested that act of kindness may help to counter negative social interaction by promoting
positive perception and expectation of person‟s social environment. In light of this research,
kindness can be viewed as a coping strategy in order to reduce the stress caused by the social
phenomenon- labelling. Overall it becomes clear that coping rises due to external as well as
internal factors and is a clear indication of mental health. Females are seen to be more prone
to maladaptive coping due to environmental and biological changes.
Family and Delinquency
In Indian scenario most cases of children in conflict with the law arise due to
abandonment and loneliness, sometimes fear. Family is the first institution every individual is
exposed to. Therefore the experiences faced in relation to them concretize the way one
perceives others and self. Social interactionism has suggested that the external environment
of an individual has a role to play in shaping his/ her overall personality and outlook towards
life. Family being the primary source of support, it is important to understand the crucial role
it plays during the formative years of the child- adolescence. A study conducted by Kowalski
19
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
in 2013, focused on the relationship patterns between parents and their children with learning
disabilities and delinquency. Through a qualitative study it was found that unlike previous
studies, parenting dynamics that was related to the better adaptations on the part of the child
showed a lower possibility that a child with learning disability would also emerge as a
delinquent one. The study tried to make a link between learning disability and deviant
behaviours. It was then seen that different parenting styles and practices, including reactions
and accommodations would affect the families as well as the individuals as either successful
or abandoning. While the researcher aims at understanding labelling and coping, researcher is
aware that parenting and care are main elements that form an individual and by focusing on
this study, gaining information on this link, makes it simpler to understand and emphasise
with participant‟s personal experiences.
In 2011, Baqutayan published a study titled, Stress and Social Support, which
discussed the effectiveness of social support in managing academic stress among students.
She examined 120 students who were divided into experimental and controlled groups
equally. The experimental group were assigned classes on social support as a coping agent.
The findings indicated that experimental group participants cope with academic stress better
than the control group and also projected consistency and stability with their academic
performances. In the context of the present study, social support can be perceived as familial/
primary support and stress here could relate to the outcome of being labelled, therefore linked
to delinquency.
The researcher intends to spread awareness about the role support groups play is
sustenance of positive mental health and coping methods. Educating institutions in society
will help reduce the stigma that children in conflict with the law face.
20
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Causes and Consequences of Delinquency
In order to understand how children in conflict with the law perceive social labelling
is important for the researcher to understand how stigmatization phenomenon occurs. Further
research mentioned here focussed on understanding the conceptualization of stigmatization.
Link and Phelan in the year 2001 came about with a study titled
ConceptualizingStigma, which was a social psychological research that focussed on stigma as
the co-occurrence of elements such as loss of status, stereotyping, labelling and
discrimination for further stigmatization to occur. It was seen that stigmatization affects
multiple domains of individual‟s life that include health, criminal involvement and so on. The
study was largely based on the role of stigma in understanding core problems in social
research and definitions of stigmatizing concepts. Rentzsch, Schröder-Abé and Schütz (2013)
conducted a study titled- Being called a Streber, which focused on the personalities of the
labeller and the individuals being labelled. This study was oriented towards understanding
academically oriented students, but the results seen can somewhat explain labelling in other
domains too such as Juvenile labelling. The results of the study viewed how labelling others
was related to extraversion, low agreeableness and low conscientiousness and the individuals
who were being labelled were associated with introversion and conscientiousness.This helps
the researcher to understand the psychological effects of being labelled and perception of it in
children in conflict with the law.
Recent research in India too aimed at finding causes for deviance in children and
creating a model to increase adaptive behaviours. A study was conducted in Karnataka,
India, by Haveripet (2013). The study titled: Causes and consequences of juvenile
delinquency in India, focussed upon juvenile delinquency being one of the hot topics in world
and is on a rise. The study aimed at exploring the factors, causes and criminal activities
21
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
undertaken by juvenile delinquents through a social survey method. The sample was selected
using purposive sampling, which focused upon finding reasons to the deviant behaviours seen
in adolescents. The results showed that family, which includes lack of proper family control,
conflict in family, and situation of residential area were major causes for juvenile
delinquency. Also inability to meet basic needs and maladaptive peer relations were seen to
give rise to criminal behaviours and incapability to cope effectively with the external
environments. These studies aimed at gaining a much broader understanding in to the
behaviours and relapses towards crime in juvenile delinquents. It is important for the present
study as these studies relate to various avenues that give rise or sustain delinquent behaviours
and a clearer picture is gained towards understanding how this group copes with social
stigmatization and how it can be improved or understood better.
Most of the articles reviewed and discussed here aim at linking utmost two concepts
like family and delinquency, authority and labelling, coping and psychological health and so
on. The researcher aims at gaining a larger perspective towards understanding the core
perception of labelling, experience of labelling, coping with it, development of coping
methods and sustenance of coping methods. Labelling can be viewed as being too narrow to
be dealt with qualitatively.Therefore the researcher is seen to be open to any form of social
negativity or stigma that can be linked to similar feelings and thoughts generated when being
labelled. All these gaps are yet to be explored and filed. Though this study the researcher
intends to gain new information and awareness about variety of experiences of females
adolescents in conflict with the law face that are crucial in shaping and concretizing their
identities as adults.
Many researchers and theorists have critiqued the idea on which social labelling
rests as a theory to explain human behaviour as a social phenomenon. As seen in some of the
22
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
studies analysed and stated above, in India, the idea of labelling is used more to discuss the
“whose fault is it” phenomena rather than a deep understanding of where it began or more
importantly, how do we manage it? Through this study, the researcher intends to fill the gaps
seen in previous research and focus on generating a positive way of dealing with this negative
phenomena that will help adolescence recovery better and sooner form stress and anxiety;
contribute to the need for further research in the area of social ideals affecting human psyche-
especially in a close knit, constantly aware and culturally rich society like India.
23
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Chapter 3
Method
The method section intended to describe in detail, the ways through which the
researcher collected data for the study. The main objective of the study wasto explore and
understand the experience of social labelling and coping in female adolescents in conflict
with the law. Details of the research design, participants, tools to be used and the operational
definitions for the study are stated. It will also give a brief account of the data collecting
strategies, data analysis, validation and ethical considerations of the study.
Research Design
Qualitative study using Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA), this design
gives more importance to the process of research than the outcome. IPA‟s main aim in this
study is examine closely the individual experiences of the participants (social labeling) in
relation to the variable being studied (coping). Usually this design draws on account of a
small number of people (Reid, Flowers & Larkin. 2005). Participants provided the researcher
with rich insights pertaining the topic being discussed during the informal screening process.
IPA design largely takes a hermeneutic stance attempting to make sense of participant‟s
attempt to make sense of a particular experience (Larkin, Watts & Clifton, 2006). This design
intended to study the phenomenon of collaboration of interaction and subjective experiences
of the participants.
The semi- structured interview in this design took shape from the insights provided
by the participants during the informal rapport session. Important points, ideas and
experiences were taken note of and framed into potential questions for the semi structured
interview, with the help of a psychologist and care takers of the rehabilitation center. These
24
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
questions were then validated by experts in the field.The translation for the use of language in
the semi structured questionnaire as well as the transcriptions was done by a Kannada lecturer
with a B Ed and D Ed degree. The semi structured schedule was then validated by 3
counseling and child psychologists with Phd and PG degrees in psychology as well as a
welfare officer (MSW, MBA) in charge of a school that caters to the education of children in
conflict with the law. The main feedback given to the researcher was to simplify the
language, lower the use of multiple questioning and clear and specific formulation of
questions.
The data is gathered over steps during the semi structured interview, where the
participants will be given the freedom to narrate their subjective experiences, views or
stories, which later would be reduced to the information needed for the study.
Participants
Qualitative research sampling involves a higher degree of researcher participant
relationship, when compared to quantitative research. This study used purposive sampling
method that focused on learning and understanding the experience of social labeling and the
interaction of the phenomenon with subjective coping abilities in female adolescents in
conflict with the law. Researcher chose this method of sampling as it is based on the selection
of participants through a validated screening interview, which lead to the selection based on
who the researcher believed to be appropriate for the study, due to the limited number of
individuals who fit the criteria of the study that was conducted.
The sample consisted of 6 female adolescents in conflict with the law (under the age
of 18 and have expressed deviance), between the ages 13 to 18 as this age group were able to
verbalize and analyze their experiences in a better fashion as they approach to establish a
concrete identity (Richard, 1983).This sample of juvenile delinquents/ offenders would have
25
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
experienced or perceived some form of social labeling presently or in the past and have
adopted certain coping methods in relation to it.
The sample was obtained from a juvenile rehabilitation center for girls located in
Bangalore city in the state of Karnataka. The rehabilitation center is a non-governmental
organization, run by a charitable foundation which is licensed by the state. The center focuses
on rescuing and rehabilitating the homeless, abandoned children and children who are in
conflict with the law. They also are allotted with children from child welfare associations as
well as the state law. They tend to the children‟s need such as their basic food, clothing and
shelter as well as education. They care for the children and teach them values and conduct
psycho education classes. When the children are old enough (above 18 years of age), they are
given employment in organizations working with the center and even help them marry into
good families. The center is also in constant touch with the legal system of the state and most
of the residents are from south India consisting of migrants as well as natives belonging to
low socio economic status. The center also caters to all religions and the residents are mostly
Hindus, Christians and Muslims. The participants were selected based on the criteria of
experiencing social labeling and the understanding of coping with the same.
Key Concepts
1. Social Labelling deals with the phenomenon of majority of the population
attaching stigmatizing labels to the minorities or persons viewed as to being
deviant from standard cultural norms (Mead, 1934).
2. Children in conflict with the law refers to any person below the age of 18 who has
come in contact with the juvenile justice system as a result of committing a crime
or being suspected of committing a crime, sometimes coerced into crime by adults
(UNICEF, 2014).
26
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
3. Juvenile delinquency is characterised by lower physical maturity and mental
capabilities which as a major factor differentiates them from an adult. They are
therefore vulnerable groups to fall a prey to temptations, inducements and
mechanizations by vested groups to embark on a path of criminality (Crime in
India, 1995).
4. Coping is largely seen as a way of using one‟s internal mental abilities to deal
with or minimize the stress or difficulties that usually arises externally (Snyder,
1999).
5. Adolescence is a transitional stage of physical and psychological development that
generally occurs during the period from puberty to legal adulthood (Halsey,
2010).
Method of Data Collection
This study followed a purposive sampling method of data collection, where the
participants expressed their subjective experiences towards social labeling and coping. This
method helped the researcher understand the individual experiences in much deeper detail
and would be able to identify the adaptive and maladaptive coping patterns (Conrad, 1987)
For the study, the researcher used one validated interview schedule. A semi
structured questionnairewas used to collect the final data. The schedule was validated by 4
experts in the field.The validation for the use of language and translation was done by a
Kannada lecturer with a B Ed and D Ed degree. Semi structured interviews include a pre-
determined set of questions that reflect the idea that the researcher intends to study, but it was
also flexible and open to new information that wasn‟t already determined by the researcher‟s
questions. It gave the researcher the freedom to explore certain themes and responses further
(Barriball &While, 1994).Semi structured schedules are used as they assist to establish
27
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
rapport with the respondent. The order in which the questions are placed doesn‟t hold much
importance as long as it addresses the gist of the study. Also this schedule made it simpler
probe interesting areas that may rise during the interview, and also the interview followed the
participant‟s flow of thought (Smith & Osborn, 2007). The basic lines of enquiry for this
study were as follows:
1. An understanding into the personal life of the participants
2. An understanding on personal experiences of social stigma/ labeling faced by the
participants
3. Self-perceived roles and responsibilities and expectations of them by society
4. Specific emotional vulnerabilities caused due to social stigma/ labeling
5. Learnt behavior regarding coping with social stigma/ labeling
6. Testimonials on coping with social labeling, shared with others facing similar
situation.
7. An understanding of the importance of a support system for girls in same situations.
Based on the information gathered from the informal screening, the researcher
formulated a semi- structured interview that helped with keeping the details of various
participants on track and created a sort of uniformity based on the questions asked. It is ideal
for this study as it focused on subjective experiences of participants and set a foundation
based on which the researcher rooted her questions.
Data Collection Strategies
Participants were recruited with the help of the administrators in the rehabilitation
center for girls located in Bangalore city in the state of Karnataka. The rehabilitation center is
a non-governmental organization, run by a charitable foundation which is licensed by the
state. The sample included 6 female adolescents in conflict with the law. The age range of the
28
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
participants was from 13 to 18 years. Each participant was selected for the study only after
gaining their consent. The process included the researcher approaching the rehabilitation
center and providing the administrators with all necessary information and documents in
order to gain consent or permission to undertake the research. The rehabilitation center was
made aware of how the researcher intends to select and study a particular sample and the
details of what the study is about. After which researcher briefed the participants on what the
study is about. This phase was the preparation phase for the study, setting its firm foundation.
After analyzing participant‟s method of coping and the understanding of being labeled, the
researcher then moved to administer the semi structured interview.
During this phase the researcher used the rapport process data to create a clear semi-
structured interview schedule which was validated by a set of experts, on the bases of which
final data was collected for the study. The researcher gained more insight on how the
participants view societal labeling as well as how they cope with it, and whether they are
influenced by those stressors, through a validated interview schedule. Each participant
wasthen asked to narrate experiences or views based on the questions in the semi- structured
interview. The researcher needed to meet the sample more than once to collect necessary data
and for validation purposes. This way the researcher was able to gain a uniform, organized
data for analysis. This phase of research was pertaining the main study.
Data Analysis
Results were analyzed using interpretive phenomenological analysis (IPA) method.
This method involved understanding how participants attach meanings and make sense of
their experiences, perceptions, interactions and social world (Smith & Osborn, 2007). The
researcher had an active role to play when using this method of analysis. IPA has its origins
form hermeneutics and theories of interpretation. Participant‟s point of view is given the most
29
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
importance. IPA follows a much deeper pattern of understanding each participant‟s world
view and experiences. It could be used to analyse a single case too, therefore analysing a
small sample will produce rich data results. The idea of this method is to state in detail about
the perceptions and understandings of the participants rather than making certain general
claims.
The study generated insight into the coping strategies and patterns of juvenile(s)
offenders and the social labeling effects in relation to their external environment, which was
then organized into themes.A theme represents a level of patterned response or meaning from
the data that is related to the research questions at hand (Braun & Clark, 2006).
IPA was conducted with the help of certain steps. These steps are: Looking for
themes from raw data that involves examining one case at a time and finding patterns:
reading and re-reading. Next step involves connecting the themes that focuses on ordering
and making sense of the data: initial noting. Clustering the themes then follow after viewing
descriptive comments and deconstruction of ideas, to make sure the connections made are in
sync with the participant‟s world view or is interpreted correctly (Smith, Flowers & Larkin,
2009). Looking for connection, patterns and similar steps were applied in analysing the other
cases resulting in a final write up that focused on translating the final themes into a narrative
account making the data expansive as the themes were explained in detail (Smith & Osborn,
2007).
30
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Table 1
The process of data analysis from the raw data to conceptualizing master themes
The super ordinate themes were further
analyzed and grouped to construct
master themes
MASTER THEMES Defining and naming
masterthemes
Thematic table of master themes
Report writing
The themes were further analyzed across
data sets
SUPER ORDINATE
THEMES
super ordinate themes were
derived from the collection of
various themes across data sets
Initial ideas were recognized and derived
to form themes
THEMES Themes were formed for each data
set separately, all basic themes
were listed for further processing
Important points and patterns were
noted, extracts were taken from each
data set
INITIAL CODES Initial codes were gathered from
each data set
Language, important remarks and
semantic content were questioned and
analyzed
EXPLORATORY
COMMENTS
Highlighted descriptions,
emotional response and
assumptions of each participant
are understood at a deeper level.
Transcription of audio files into written
document
RAW DATA Written transcripts were read and
familiarized forfurther case by
case analysis
31
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Validation of Data
The data collected was validated using two processes involving the participants and
the researcher.
Member checks: This process of validation ensured that the participants were aware
of the data collected and were asked to cross check the raw data in order to give explicit
meaning to certain statements or make any changes.
Reflective notes: To reduce subjectivity and bias of the researcher, the researcher
took down reflective notes in order to be aware of the thoughts, experiences and emotions of
the researcher that were triggered during data collection and interactions with significant
people involved in the study.
Ethical Guidelines
1. The study was conducted only after gaining informed consent of participants as
well as the center from which data was collected.
2. The participants were given the right to withdraw if they get uncomfortable or the
information is too much to handle.
3. The study focusing also on social labeling by the authorities towards adolescents
with delinquency, might affect the image or reputation of authorities, therefore the
identities of the participants and contents of the raw data was kept confidential.
4. Complete confidentiality was maintained regarding any information acquired
through the research process of the participant.
5. Participants were also informed and debriefed about the full aims of the research,
and they were permitted to review their data given during the interview.
32
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
6. Researcher was well equipped to manage and deal with break downs and catharsis
during the session.
7. Towards the end of the research, the researcher helped the participants cope with
being labeled in a more adaptive manner and provided the participants with a
basic insight into their behaviors/ beliefs regarding coping with social labeling;
this idea may not be acceptable to those who are uncomfortable to changes.
8. The data collected during the study was not used for any purpose other than this
research itself.
9. There was a psychologist present during the interviews to collaboratively assess
the proceedings and precautions were taken to safeguard the participant
psychologically, socially and physically.
33
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Chapter 4
Results and Discussion
This chapter is divided into 2 parts. The results chapter will be focussing on
individual case results. The researcher intended to analyse each case separately in order to
develop deeper understanding into the participant‟s world view and perception on social
labelling and coping. This step will be beneficial for the cross case analysis which is the
discussion in part 2 of this chapter.
Social labelling is seen as the idea/ experience of being tagged or labelled negatively
by society. This process is seen possible due to social interaction (O‟ Grady, 2011). Society is
seen to have certain set rules and norms of behaviour. The failure to conform to the same is
considered as deviance (Jones, 1986). Deviance therefore is usually followed by being
labeling by the majority who conform to these moral norms.
Juvenile delinquents are individuals under the age of 18, who have been found to
have committed a crime i.e. broken social moral norms, expressed deviance and cannot be
sentenced as adults. Within this group, female population is seen to be more vulnerable to
social assumptions and labeling biases (Chakrapani & Kumar, 1994). When this imbalance
occurs, the demands of society exceed the ability to cope with it and stress is created. The
confrontation with societal pressure and expectations has probed this research to understand
the pattern of coping that female adolescents in conflict with the law adopt against being
labelled. The major research objective of the study was to understand the experience of social
labelling and coping in female adolescents in conflict with the law.
34
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
The specific objectives are as listed below:
To understand the experience and perception of social labeling and the subjective
experience of being labeled.
To understand the coping strategies of female adolescents in conflict with the law in
rehabilitation centers who face or faced social labeling and are affected by it.
To analyze the reasons for adopting a certain coping strategy.
The participants were selected based on purposive sampling method. The
participants who engaged in the study were 6 female adolescents between the age range of 13
to 18 years. The sample was collected from a rehabilitation centre for girls located in
Bangalore city in the state of Karnataka, non-governmental organization, run by a charitable
foundation which focuses on rescuing and rehabilitating the homeless, abandoned children
and children who are in conflict with the law. Some key demographic characteristics of the
participants are given in table 2 below:
Table 2
Details of Participants (initials)
Name
Age (in
years)
Time spent in the
remand home/
rehabilitation centre
(in years)
Education Socio
Economic
Status
Languages
known
S.S
18
3
High school
Low SES
Lived with
aunt who
worked in a
garments
factory
Kannada,
English
L.P 14 5 Primary school
(drop out)
Low SES
Worked as a
maid to help
family
Kannada,
Tamil
35
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
financially
S.T 15 10 5th
grade (drop
out)
Low SES
Orphan,
lived with
elder sister
in different
facilities
Kannada,
Tamil,
English
P.D 18 1 SSLC (drop out) Low SES
Orphan,
worked in
different
facilities
Telugu,
Hindi,
Kannada
S.P 17 10 ---- Low SES
Found on
the streets as
a child,
begging for
livelihood
Hindi,
Kannada
G.G.R 17 4 Upper Primary
school (drop out)
Low SES
Orphan,
lived with
aunt
Telugu,
Kannada
Data Analysis
A semi structured interview was conducted on 6 female adolescents, aged between
13 to 18 years. In terms of educational qualification, majority of participants have completed
primary studies. Sample was collected from centres that cater to the needs of children in
conflict with the law. Majority of these children in rehabilitation centres, seem to hail from
poor economic background and have experienced some form of loss and abandonment. The
sample also consisted of girls who were previously in remand homes and have experienced or
perceived some form of social labelling presently or in the past. Many of them also have
pending court cases mostly regarding custody. Languages known by each participant revealed
the different cultural backgrounds they hail from.
36
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
The data was collected and analysed using interpretive phenomenological analysis
method (IPA). This method involved understanding how participants attach meanings and
make sense of their experiences, perceptions, interactions and social world (Smith & Osborn,
2007).IPA followed a much deeper pattern of understanding each participant‟s world view
and experiences. Looking for connection, patterns and similar steps were applied in analysing
the other cases resulting in a final write up that focused on translating the final themes into a
narrative account making the data expansive as the themes were explained in detail (Smith &
Osborn, 2007). Using this method the researcher was able to state in detail about the
perceptions and understandings of the participants regarding social labeling and coping.
37
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
PARTICIPANT 1
Participant 1 SS is an 18 year old girl who has been in a remand home and
rehabilitation centre for 3 years. She is currently pursuing her studies in high school.
Participant 1 showed eagerness to be a part of this study. She believes to have enough
experience to be able to perceive social labeling in a true manner. Participant showed how
some authoritative figures and society to be controlling of the behavior of children like her
(in conflict with the law). Participant also is seen to have experienced being labeled before
coming into the remand home and rehabilitation center. She also had an experience of an
enmeshed relationship with a care giver. Participant has an approachable personality and
believes in helping others in the centre fight social stigma. The result of participant 1 is
shown in table 3.
Table 3
Themes and Super ordinate Themes Generated from Analysing Results of Participant 1:
Themes Super ordinate Themes
1.111.Formation of an identity due to the
influence of family
1.112.Indifference from family impacting her
view of self
1.113.Society‟s labels affecting her identity
1.114.Introspection of feelings, identity
generated in relation to the outside
world
1.115.Sense of independence and formation
of a strong identity
1.116.Trust towards others a main factor
influencing her perception of self
1.117.Development of an identity as a
survivor of difficult experiences
1.121.Idea of family presented from
circumstances experienced by
participant
1.122.Understanding the institution that
1.11. Formation of self and
social identity
38
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
substitutes family
1.123.Understanding different functions
performed by society and her role in it.
1.124.Problems are inevitable in her
understanding of the institution of
marriage
1.125.Observation and understanding of
other‟s situations and behaviours
1.126.Changes in her idea of relationships
leading to the formation of
independence and freedom
1.127.Understanding of outside institutions
and functions of society
1.12. Understanding
institutions, it‟s functions and
role of self in relation to them
1.211.Support and understanding generated
by people around her to make good life
choices
1.212.Deprivation of „parents‟ seen as
saviours
1.213.Support from centre seen through
portrayal of equality and impartiality
1.214.Idea of sharing and happiness derived
from behaviour of authorities
1.215.Information and counselling support
provided by the centre
1.216.Positive experiences provided by
support group in the centre
1.217.Support groups approached when she
was younger
1.218.Authorities in the centre as main
support sources
1.221.Vulnerability to becoming enmeshed
with care provided by authorities
1.21.Role of support groups in
encouraging life choices
1.22.Attachment towards care
givers or support systems
1.311.Unaware about the proper functions of
the institution of marriage
1.312.Unable to understanding the
controlling nature of society
1.321.Expectations from society shaping
the way she perceives it
1.322.Feeling of being moulded by others
1.323.Constraints by society and assumptions
leading to negative behavioural
patterns
1.324.Forced to make life choices
1.31.Feeling of being
controlled by others in
society
1.32.Restrictions put on the
way of life by society
39
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
1.411.Feeling powerless over situations
1.412.Coping through questioning wrong
notions and adjusting with situations
1.413.Acceptance of a supernatural power,
belief to be patient and time will heal all
troubles
1.414.Helpless that situations are out of her
control and adjusting to difficult
situations
1.415.Rationalizing situations
1.416.Using a non-confronting method to deal
with difficulties increased others trust in
her.
1.41.Feeling helpless and coping
through acceptance of
situation
1.511.Sharing thoughts with others facing
similar situations
1.512.Need to be independent to make own life
choices
1.513.Sharing experiences and helping others is
good for both parties
1.514.Sharing her way of coping to adjust to
difficulties and understand situations
1.515.Other‟s trust in her plays a main role in
sharing her experiences with coping
1.516.Need to share her experiences to help
others and prevent them from not facing
the same situations
1.517.Feeling of satisfaction by sharing coping
methods and experiences.
1.518.Freedom to choice to others she shares
her coping method with.
1.519.Mutual trust and understanding to share
experiences
1.51.Freedom to make own
choices and feelings
associated with sharing
coping strategies
1.611.Feeling of being abandoned by family
1.612.Marriage seen as a reason to get rid of
her. Risk of abandonment
1.613.Being labelled and feeling of loneliness
1.621.Experience of being labelled
1.622.Accepting circumstances of being
labelled
1.61.Feeling of loneliness and
abandonment from being
labelled
1.62.Feeling of sadness and
helplessnessdealingwith
labelling
40
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
While social labelling phenomenon focuses on social interactionism, there are other ways of
influencing one‟s behaviours. Every social situation demands a particular behaviour and soon
these behaviours and the expectations of us, create roles in society. These roles are seen to
have a major influence on the development of an identity (McLeod, 2008)
Formation of self and social identity:adolescence is that period in life which brings most
changes in a child‟s psyche. The environment that one is most often exposed to has a great
role in influencing one‟s ideas about the outside world as well as building up identities. The
influence of family in the formation of an identity is quite clearly seen in the participant‟s
experiences. The participant states that she has experienced labelling even before being sent
to a remand home. This experience of being abandoned and how it has brought about a sense
of insecurity and unsure social identity can be seen from what she says below.
“My aunty had adopted me first my grandma used to take care of us after my parents
passed away, through her I met aunt. When grandma passed away my aunt adopted
me but she was very mean to me and did not like me”.(SS, personal communication,
December 24, 2015)
The indifference expressed by a family member can affect the way one perceives oneself.
Identification that occurs most in relation to a care giver, is lost due to the lack of emotional
connection. She feels that because she wasn‟t able to establish a secure bond with her aunt,
she found it hard to understand where she belonged.
“My aunt thought I already adopted her, now there is nothing I can do. She wouldn’t
take care of me so she found some ashram”. (SS, personal communication,
December 24, 2015)
Participant shows that when children don‟t get the support they need or a person who they
can identify with, they tend to drift towards an introspection intending to find one‟s true
41
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
identity. They begin to question ideas, norms and notions of society in a quest to find their
identities. And as the researcher interviewed the participant the researcher could sense how
difficult experiences during childhood have moulded the participant‟s identity and
confidence.
Understanding institutions, its functions and role of self in relation to them: As roles start to
concretize and identities are formed, individuals try to find their place in society. Society and
its expectations play a very important role especially in the lives of adolescents (Beckett&
Herbert, 2010). Adolescents try to rationalise and find ways to fit in to the expectations
created by society. Participant states that the experiences she has gained through observations
of the way elements in her environment function, helps her understand and deal with stigma
in a positive manner. Participant shows a mature thought process when she says,
“Whatever they say or do is right it’s just about our understanding capacity like when
they scold if we think-chi!!Why are they scolding them always thinking bad then it’s
bad. But if we feel it’s for our own good then we know that it’s good”. (SS, personal
communication, December 24, 2015)
Most of their understanding comes from the observation of their environment and the people
around them. In this case the researcher could see how the participant‟s personal experiences
and the information gathered through observation helped in the formation and concretization
of her role and identity. Participant finds peace in helping others in similar situations through
sharing her experiences. As an example, she states the advice she gives to others at the centre.
“I tell her for your age and job that you’re doing many guys will propose you and
that you’re not at an age to take decisions like this and accept them.so she asks me
this happened what to do? I told her this is not your age just wait 5/6 years and we’ll
42
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
talk or approach sister and talk to them”.(SS, personal communication, December 24,
2015)
Participant also narrates an experience of a new girl who was brought to the rehabilitation
centre, and her experiences of being labelled. Participant states how she has tried to help her
by empathising with her situation, therefore, concretising her role in the centre as similar to a
care giver.
“She could not adjust with it, also with the clothes also we would have to wear what
they give she wouldn’t do that if she didn’t like it, but knows she’s better in all aspects
except in the matter of anger. She gets angry very fast, she doesn't realise what she’s
doing at that time. She starts beating and verbally abusing me so i just won’t be there
when she gets angry”.(SS, personal communication, December 24, 2015)
The interaction that occurs on the part of the children in the rehabilitation centre, and the
support systems, who are the primary care givers to these children, is an important aspect in
personal development of each child. Researcher found that the residents of the centre find the
authorities there to be caring and encouraging to their life goals.
Role of support groups in encouraging life choices: As the researcher probed further into
trying to understand the development of coping and experiences of labelling, the participant
showed clear indication about the satisfaction she has gained after being in the centre. This
feeling is seen mostly due to the freedom the participant experiences, to make own life
choices. She feels grateful towards the centre and what rehabilitation centres help children
like her become independent and successful. She narrates various ways the centre has helped
her and others there to make adaptive life choices.
“No one can really do any more than this. I have not seen anyone more than this. No
matter what situation they come from they can share their happy and sad experiences
43
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
with sisters here and they take care of us. If anyone scolds or they are finding it hard
to adjust, they would help us. They are very open to understand what we want to do in
life and what we like and help us achieving that”.(SS, personal communication,
December 24, 2015)
Attachment towards care givers or support systems: For children who have not experienced
normalcy in their childhood and are uncertain about who they are and their roles, attachment
towards a person/ people who show and provide care is inevitable. The participant showed
attachment towards one individual who according to her helped her and took care of her.
Participant talks about this one stable figure in her life in the remand home that would help
her by listening to the issues she faces and assist her in dealing with these issues. She feels
their relationship had been misinterpreted by the authorities and others in the rehabilitation
centre. The experience of being labelled also has risen from this situation. While talking
about this experience participant shows a slight attachment towards this person who has been
a strong support to her.
“There was this brother who always takes care of me, like a younger sister and i used
to tell him all my trouble but people outside thought differently about the relationship
we should like if i needed anything he would get that for me so people used to not
trust me”.(SS, personal communication, December 24, 2015)
Restraint experienced from society: The participant has experienced various forms of control
imposed on her by various institutions in society. These unpleasant experiences have shaped
her understanding of the way society functions and the restrictions imposed on her behaviour.
Participant states that her aunt had control over most of the important life choices and
therefore, she felt helpless and restricted by her. This process occurred to a point where the
44
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
participant began to accept the situation and decide that maybe this feeling of not being in
control of her life is actually good for her.
“So when this happened and my aunty wanted to get rid of me and get me married
because for her that was ideal, I decided to agree to the marriage. At least then I
would be able to leave that house for good”. (SS, personal communication, December
24, 2015)
Feeling of being controlled by others in society:social interactions are only possible if the
individuals involved in them have an understanding of the roles they play and norms that they
have to abide by. Children in conflict with the law usually express certain disagreement with
these social moral norms. When certain institutions impose these rules on the participant, she
finds them controlling. The participant expresses similar concerns when she recalls an
experience of being in a social gathering and how she did not have the freedom to do what
she wanted and talk or interact with anyone she wanted. She narrates this experience as the
following.
“So one day when there was another function they said here itself that I shouldn’t go
to talk to the brothers so much when I go there. You will sit where we say and do what
we ask. Don’t wander and talk to people and all that. So once we reached there, there
was no place for us so we went up to the roof”. (SS, personal communication,
December 24, 2015)
Restrictions put on the way of life by society: The participant expresses the feelings of not
being able to meet the expectations of society because of the restriction on her behaviour. The
control she experienced during her stay in the remand home and her aunt‟s house moulded
the way she perceives society. Apart from there being control over her interaction patterns
and likes, participant also vents how restrictions have been put on the way she behaves and
45
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
feels that because of this she cannot project who she really is. Her real self is hidden due to
the restraints she experiences on her life choices and outlook towards society.
“Whenever we go to any gathering functions they say sit here or sit there, guests
come here so don’t come sit here. So stand and all this then I feel really bad. I have
experienced this also”. (SS, personal communication, December 24, 2015)
Development of a coping method:Coping is largely seen as a way of using one‟s internal
mental abilities to deal with or minimize the stress or difficulties that usually arises externally
(Snyder, 1999). The participant expresses helplessness when it comes to dealing with the
stress created by social labeling. The feeling of having no choice but to accept what is
happening and avoid any confrontation is her coping strategy.
“Generally I don’t cope with issues that arise out of situation I cannot deal with/
change so I just avoided those situations consciously. We can talk only to counsellors
alone and no one else if we do talk to others they'll say we are talking about them and
gossiping about them. We should wait till our time comes to tell them the truth. So it’s
best we don’t talk about it”.(SS, personal communication, December 24, 2015)
Feeling helpless and coping through acceptance of situation: The participant also expresses
how when she had no one to rely on and nowhere to go during the difficult times she faced;
she began to believe in the super natural power. The participant feels safe to know that there
is always someone watching over her and it gives her the strength to keep moving forward. In
some sense, her belief in the supernatural has made coping with stress easier.
“God as made everyone unique so we shouldn’t consider ourselves with what others
say or do. They all have that belief that these kids one hostel kids they have nothing
they buy and get money and they like this. This sort of view sometimes I also feel that
you people gives us things. We are beggars, and i feel sad. But sometimes I feel if we
46
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
continue here we'll have a life we'll soon be independent so we have that belief”.(SS,
personal communication, December 24, 2015)
Adaptive feelings when sharing coping strategies:The researcher found that after being in the
centre, the participant has developed a sense of responsibility towards others who seek her
guidance. She feels confident enough to help them through her experiences. Participant has a
strong urge to help anyone in need and intends to gather the trust of everyone at the centre.
To this she says,
“Almost everyone who stays here talk to me about how I cope with then I tell them my
experience the mistake I’ve made and how I've come off it. Sometimes praying helps
too. so when I tell them to do it. They do it because they trust me. Sometime it works
and they get adjusted”. (SS, personal communication, December 24, 2015)
Freedom to make own choices and feelings associated with sharing coping strategies: There
is a set of positive emotions the participant goes through when she is able to help others.
These empathetic feelings provide motivation to help them persistently as well as it is
assurance to her that her coping strategies are working and beneficial to the people around
her. Even though she experiences constraints on her behaviour when she is out of the centre,
being in the centre makes her feel she has the freedom to say or do what she wants. It‟s a
controlled environment where she feels safe and trusted.
“One girl had come to me one day. She was sad about being restricted to do things
she wanted. I told her see we are orphans we have to bear with all this and take care
of our self, until God’s here everything will be okay”.(SS, personal communication,
December 24, 2015)
Perception of social labelling: The phenomenon that deals with the majority of the population
attaching stigmatizing labels to the minorities or persons viewed as to being deviant from
47
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
standard cultural norms, essentially defines social labelling (Mead, 1934). The effects of this
are hardly seen positive. The impact that labelling has on the social identity and idea of self in
the participant is quite evident as she expresses being punished for things she has not done,
indications of life being unfair to her. Participant expresses her feelings of how life is unfair
towards children like her. She feels that others outside the centre aren‟t aware of the
experiences they have faced and how strong it has made them. But from time to time hard
criticisms she faces does impact the way she perceives society and herself.
“Many hostel kids go there to study if we do any mistake they scrutinize and say
"hostel kids did this”. They don’t know anything, we did not do anything. They punish
us and if we are standing outside, the other kids who live at home say look all hostel
orphans got punished”.(SS, personal communication, December 24, 2015)
Feeling of loneliness and abandonment from being labelled:as stated by social labelling
theorists, labelling portrays a power position in the hands of the majority to attach negative
labels to minorities. In this sense, minorities are already considered to be deviating from
normalcy. Therefore, the feeling of loneliness and abandonment doesn‟t come as a surprise in
the case of the participant. Participant states that her strongest support is herself. And she
shares this with others in the centre as well. She narrates and experience of a new girl who
joined the rehabilitation centre and how she felt alone and found it difficult to adjust there
with all the restrictions from outside environments.
“One girl had come to me one day. She was sad about being restricted to do things
she wanted. I told her see we are orphans we have to bear with all this and take care
of our self, until God’s here everything will be okay”.(SS, personal communication,
December 24, 2015)
48
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Feeling of sadness and helplessness dealing with labelling:the feelings that the participant
faced according to her experience with labelling is the main cause to have led to the
development of acceptance as a copingmechanism. The combination of feeling sad and
helpless proved to be overwhelming to the participant, to sometimes making her defensive
and proactive of how she feels.
“So every time there is only one problem. We have the inability to control what
people say about us and scold us. But we are used to it now. I have forgotten what
sadness this used to cause me”. (SS, personal communication, December 24, 2015)
The results of participant 1 show that the role she experiences and is exposed to from society
has a great influence on the development of her identity. The support she has from the centre
has a positive influence on her personal development. The participant experiences social
stigma in the form of the control and restrictions she faces through society. Participant shows
strong negative perception of social labels, followed by negative feelings such as loneliness
and abandonment. Acceptance of stressful situations she faces is the coping strategy she
mainly uses. Participant experiences adaptive emotions such as self-worth and happiness
when she is able to help others by sharing her coping strategy.
49
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
PARTICIPANT 2
Participant 2 LP is a 14 year old girl who has been in a remand home and
rehabilitation centre for 5 year. LP is a primary school dropout. She has participated in two
other research studies dealing with parental abandonment and social stigmatization. She is
slow to warm up and believes to keep things to herself. LP has a quiet demeanour almost like
she has given up fighting the injustice that has happened to her. She has experienced social
labelling but sees that it has not affected her functioning. With regard to sharing she believes
every individual should be able to manage their own issues and feels uncomfortable to
involves herself in others matters. The result of participant 2 is given in table 4.
Table 4
Themes and Super ordinate Themes Generated from Analysing Results of Participant 2:
Themes Super ordinate Themes
2.111.Financial trouble and no control over
circumstances
2.112.Feeling of helplessness over certain
situations
2.113.Avoiding attachments, rationalized
coping due to circumstances
2.114.Feeling of no control over her own
life
2.121.No significant changes due to being
labelled
2.122.Views being negatively labelled as a
motivator to do better
2.11.No control over
circumstances leading her
to join rehab
2.12. Exhibiting effects of being
labelled
2.211.Support of authority increases her
ability to do what she feels
2.212.Openness to change and the role she
plays in helping others
2.213.Accept circumstances and
understands society
2.221.Making sense of being labelled,
trying to understand her feelings
2.222.Aware of facing her problems in the
future
2.231.Feelings related to being labelled and
2.21.Increased understanding of
outer institutions
2.22.Rationalizing circumstances
as method of coping
50
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
trying to adapt
2.232.Coping through avoidance of
confrontation
2.233.Acceptance of situations
2.234.Dealing with situations from within,
not confronting it with people
involved
2.235.Adapting to negative situations
through venting and prayer
2.236.Rationalizing the use of coping
strategy
2.237.Adapting to negativity
2.238.Satisfied with coping method used to
deal with experiences from society
2.23.Avoidance of confrontation to
cope with negativity from
society
2.311.Perception of support systems
available to her
2.312.Not receptive to other support
systems available to her.
2.313.Comfortable with coping strategy
2.321.Understanding the emotions involved
in helping others
2.322.Doesn‟t feel the need to share their
difficulties.
2.331.Thinking about the implications of
getting involved in others matters if
one is not in authority
2.332.Understanding the role of authorities
to deal with social stigma
experiences
2.31.Role and perception of
support systems
2.32.Low confidence in ability to
help others
2.33.Role of authorities to deal
with labelling experiences
The researcher intended to examine the way that society shapes how we view certain
behaviours. If and when a child is seen to be deviating from the norms of society, the
consequences are sometimes in-human for them. Labelling is one such phenomenon that
psychologically affects the individual who is subjected to it leading to many negative
experiences.
51
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
No control over circumstances leading her to join rehabilitation centre: The participant
expressed unpleasant experiences faced by her from society. Some of these situations were
not in her control, such as financial troubles. Many of the children in conflict with the law
hail from low economic backgrounds. With this in mind, they all ill equipped to cater to the
expectations and restrictions set by society(Nataraj, 2004). Participant expresses acceptance
of situation and authority when it comes to making any sort of choice.
“I would do whatever they would ask me to do… I have gone for confession also. I
usually don’t react to any situation because it is not in my control”.(LP, personal
communication, December 24, 2015)
The participant also had no set environment where she could grow and flourish. The constant
dynamics in the facilities she was being shifted to, affected her ability to cope and trust others
as well.
Exhibiting effects of being labelled: The researcher found that the participant believes that
the circumstances were never good to her. Social stigma had an impact on her, but the effects
of labelling alone did not have a significant influence on her daily functions and thoughts. In
turn she indicates that being labelled has made her stronger to face society. Participant
narrates that the feelings that accompanied the teasing behaviour was unpleasant to her and
made her feel incompetent. Even then she states that she knew that she had to fight that
feeling and become better. She says that,
“It’s been pretty much the same for me, I have not faced much difference from before
and how I am now…just in the remand home they would tease me, I would feel very
inferior to them. When friends in school used to call me names and tease me I would
just keep to myself. But I felt very low and sad. But I had the determination to be
better than them”.(LP, personal communication, December 24, 2015)
52
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Children are seen to grasp and model behaviour of people who are in regular touch with
them. Less or no stability in the surroundings of the child could have a maladaptive effect on
the psychological functioning of the child as well. Due to the instability of the environment
the participant experienced, she was able to understand various roles performed by the people
around her as well as the functions of institutions. Participant felt that she had no power to
change the present functioning of the institutions around her, and in turn adapted to
them.While stating the following, researcher finds that participant has the insight that
accepting negativity will not help her situation, but she lacks the motivation to do something
about it.
“Being labelled by others teasing and scolding, beating friends… that… I know that
by letting it be, it happens everywhere I go, I am not solving anything but I don’t
know when I'd face them and deal with the root of my troubles”. (LP, personal
communication, December 24, 2015)
Increased understanding of outer institutions: participant shows her eagerness to help others
not face the situations she has. But also shows certain level of discomfort sharing her ideas.
This might be due to the changing environments and feelings of abandonment leading to trust
issues. The participant is aware of how her surroundings functions through her experiences
which she states in the following.
“I don’t talk to others only about my problems, it never helped me. Otherwise I speak
to everyone generally. But now on I should try helping other people too and directly
address my issues as well”. (LP, personal communication, December 24, 2015)
Rationalizing circumstances as method of coping: conscious avoidance of addressing her
problems was evident from the information collected by the researcher. The participant has
come to rationalise the behaviour of people around her, as well as her own when it comes to
53
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
negative experiences or stigma. Participant says that she has empathetic feelings towards
others in the centre and at the remand home and does not want any responsibility of negative
experiences happening to them because of her.
“I don’t like it. I don’t like to see my friends getting hurt. It’s like I go complain about
them... Then they would get punished and I don’t like that. I don’t like them getting
beatings”.(LP, personal communication, December 24, 2015)
Avoidance of confrontation to cope with negativity from society:the researcher viewed that
the participant‟s nature was that of a closed person. Children who usually go through
negative experiences regarding societal roles at early stages of their lives find it hard to cope
and express positivity in their outlook towards society. The method that the participant seems
to be most comfortable with in dealing with social stigma is that of avoidance and emotion
based coping. She says that,
“No whenever I feel sad or face any difficult situation, I don’t tell anyone about it. I
just keep it to myself and not do anything about it”.(LP, personal communication,
December 24, 2015)
The only outlet she finds to cope with stress is that of self-talk. Participant rationalizes her
situation and decides on avoidance as a better method of coping.
“When I am overwhelmed with feelings, I curse them within me (smiles) I don’t tell
them anything directly I just curse them and then I will be fine. I don’t like recalling
and talking about my issues. The best for me is to let it go”.(LP, personal
communication, December 24, 2015)
“I don’t go get angry very often. I am very quiet always. I used to talk before but
every time you would get close to someone I would have to leave and go elsewhere.
54
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
So I don’t like talking to anyone now. If they come here I would not mind talking to
them. But that’s the reason”.(LP, personal communication, December 24, 2015)
Researcher finds that the only care the participant has experienced comes from that of the
support groups around her. The participant tends to testify to others as well to address their
issues with the authorities (who are seen as support and care givers), and they would help
them. She herself too copes with very difficult situations by depending on her support group.
Role and perception of support systems: Researcher found that the role of care givers is seen
to be very important in the regular functioning of the participant. Apart from the feeling that
she can manage stressful situations by herself, she shows to trust only towards her support
system. She talks about speaking to outside assistance providers such as counsellors,
teachers, but feels that it doesn‟t help her much.
“Even when they say go speak to them, I feel uncomfortable disclosing my issues
with people who come from other places. I feel fine talking to sisters and priests only
because from before I was like this”. (LP, personal communication, December 24,
2015)
Low confidence in ability to help others: from all the experiences gained by the participant,
her stance is to sort out her own difficulties before she feels apt to help others with theirs. The
participant is seen to be unsure about whether she would be able to help others through
sharing her experiences and coping strategies with others. Although, she feels confident that
she will be able to manage her own difficulties that arise from society, rather well.
“I'd rather feel happy….but I don’t think i can trust anyone until I solve all my
troubles first. I am not very close to anyone that why not many people come to me for
help. Nothing is permanent here so rather than facing the pain of leaving someone
55
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
close or them leaving its better not to be close to anyone. And deal with the troubles
ourselves”. (LP, personal communication, December 24, 2015)
Participant also narrates that she doesn‟t want to involve herself in other‟s problems just like
the way she isn‟t comfortable in other people involving in her matters. Mostly it is the fear of
not being able to give others in the centre a positive solution and her insecurities in her
ability, prevents her from sharing her coping strategies.
“I don’t like getting involved. I like to help but I myself have my own issues to deal
with so no need to involve in other matters. I don’t want people to blame me and tell
that because I suggested something, this happened and all that”. (LP, personal
communication, December 24, 2015)
Role of authorities to deal with labelling experiences: According to the participant it is seen
that the ultimate power position lies within the support groups. In the social settings that the
participant has experienced, the roles of care givers are firmly set. Participant also shows trust
in the systems and propagates others to seek help from them as well.
“When people facing the same situation come to me I tell them to go speak to the
authorities because everyone will listen to them… I am powerless in this matter”.(LP,
personal communication, December 24, 2015)
The results of participant 2 show that she has negative experiences that has shaped her
perception of social stigma and developed feelings such as helplessness and avoidance of
attachments. Participant involves herself in observing roles performed in society and
understands functions of society. This understanding in turn has shaped her coping of being
avoidant of confrontation. Participant also shows signs of dependence on the authorities in
the centre to cope with stressful experiences.
56
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
PARTICIPANT 3
Participant 3 ST is a 15 year old girl who has been in a remand home and
rehabilitation centre for 5 years. ST has studied till grade 5 and dropped out of school due to
her disinterest in academics. ST has a bubbly attitude and has an approachable personality.
Participant is seen to have a positive outlook towards life and is happy to help anyone in
need. ST also has a strong belief in the super-natural. Most of her coping happens through
this belief. She believes to have not faced social labelling directly but has experienced it
through someone close to her. The result of participant 3 is shown in table 5.
Table 5
Themes and Super ordinate Themes Generated from Analysing Results of Participant 3:
Themes Super Ordinate Themes
3.111.Sharing coping strategies with others
aids in development of an identity
3.112.Feels the need to help others by
sharing own experiences
3.113.Expects positive outcome by
addressing labelling issue
3.114.Increase in sharing behaviour due to
trust in others
3.115.Feeling of satisfaction within oneself
by helping others
3.121.Prayer and venting proved helpful,
influencing sharing coping method
with others
3.122.Feels satisfaction in the choice of
method adopted to cope with social
stigma
3.123.Positive emotions generated due to
sharing behaviour
3.11.Moulding identity through
sharing coping strategies
3.12.Feeling of satisfaction as
reason for the sustenance
and sharing coping
strategies
3.211.Constantly moving and no control
over living space
3.212.Feeling helpless and sad over social
3.21.Restricted and controlled by
57
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
situations not in her control
3.221.Rationalizing with social situations
in relation to labelling
3.222.Acceptance of any outcome
regarding sharing of coping methods
circumstances
3.22.Acceptance of social
situations
3.311.Observation of close friends
experiences shaped her
understanding of social stigma
3.312.Perceived social labelling from
family
3.313.Idea of family affected due to
labelling experience
3.321. Understanding the institution of
marriage as an escape from reality
3.322. Is not affected by various functions
performed in society
3.31.Perception of social labelling
through other‟s experiences
3.32.Understanding the
institutions in society and
their functions
3.411.Belief in supernatural power and
coping through prayer and venting
generating positive results
3.412.Confidence in her method of coping
through prayer
3.413.Venting seen as another coping
strategy
3.414.Confronting the people involved in
labelling people
3.421.Support from other institutions
helped her better understand how to
deal with stigma
3.422.Support gained in the centre, assisted
adjustment process
3.423.Ways through which support systems
help in overall development
3.41.Prayer and venting applied to
cope with social labels
3.42.Role of support systems in
overcoming negativity
Adolescence is a developmental period that is quite stressful as it involves the transition from
childhood dependency to being independent and self-sufficient in adulthood (Smith, Cowie,
& Blades, 1998). During this period, therefore, it is important to have proper personal growth
58
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
and positive outlook towards life. The researcher found that this participant was quite
satisfied and had a good understanding of how sharing coping strategies was helping her. She
experiences positive feelings when she is able to make a change in another person‟s life. She
states that,
“When people share their trouble with me about how they went to CWC, I know how
it is to be an orphan but I have sister, so I always tell them to not think they have no
one there always somebody to take care of you. I feel very happy helping them I don’t
remember any bad felling when coming across my experience”.(ST, personal
communication, December 28, 2015)
Moulding identity through sharing coping strategies:Most of the ideas the participant shares
with individuals who come to her seeking for help, emerge from her experiences with social
stigma. Participant also believes that her strategy of praying and venting is helpful for her
own development as well as others too. The researcher also observed the trust other children
in the centre invested in her. And over all she feels positive about sharing.
“Most of the friends have come to me to help them with their relationship issues.so we
are too young to be involved in romantic relationships before I used to help them
because I really like helping. So now here i will help when i can and if anything else i
go and tell sister about it. But I’ll always help one way or another. I’d tell the
authorities if it’s something that i cannot handle”.(ST, personal communication,
December 28, 2015)
Feeling of satisfaction as reason for the sustenance and sharing coping strategies: coping
strategies that the participant adopts to deal with social stigma has largely been influenced by
her support system (centre). Modelling the behaviour of authorities has helped her adapt to
59
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
difficult situations and help her peers confront the same as well. The participant also has a
strong belief in the super natural forces that she believes helps her be strong and confident.
“Yes, they used to always say that I should pray to god but I never believed and since
I came to this hostel facility I did it because I couldn’t manage so well initially. And it
worked and my intentions grew and I started to believe in god. I’d have the courage
to face my problems and tell the authorities. They would help me. That’s when I
started telling others that if they'd also do this it’ll be better”.(ST, personal
communication, December 28, 2015)
The role of parents in a child‟s life is known to be most important as influencers of their
personal welfare. The participant expressed her understanding of the reason she isn‟t with her
parents but has also metaphorically expressed super natural power she believes in, to be
guiding her like a parent would. To this she says that,
“I feel like I’m talking to my own mother. If anyone consoles me they know that if they
say gods here pray to statue of mother Mary i feel better. I forget my issues for few
days then. So only when I face similar situation again, I remember it”. (ST, personal
communication, December 28, 2015)
The participant had no control over the facilities she was being shifted to. The researcher
found that the participant expressed her understanding of the way society functions, as to
having many restrictions and controls on her behaviour. The roles of authorities are also well
known to her and she tends to model the behaviour of her support group that has led her to
develop coping techniques.
Restricted and controlled by circumstances: Participant feels helpless and sad over the social
situations that aren‟t in her control. She expresses the way she misses her family due to
60
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
shifting different facilities and her concern about not having a stable environment to live in.
But researcher also found that the participant adapts easily to new and stressful situations.
“Before that I was in CWC and before that I was in Nagarabhavi. So that place some
problem happened and they put me in CWC because that place closed down when I
was in the rehab I discontinued my studies s they sent me to this centre and it’s been
10 years since I am with authorities and in different facilities, so initially I would
always cry saying I wanted to see my sister or family, because for so long I wouldn't
see them”. (ST, personal communication, December 28, 2015)
Acceptance of social situations:Viewing the changes that have happened around her and the
restrictions by society, the participant feels helpless and rationalises her behaviour and the
behaviour of others around her to cope with the changing circumstances. When the stress
event is overwhelming, individuals tend to adapt to it if there is no other way to control it.
The same way, the participant begins to accept her situation and uses this acceptance to cope
with social stigma.
“I know the reasons I faced labelling by society. But it’s ok… I understand why
people need to show their power over others. I deal with my problems by venting it to
god and I know that situations always have explanations and I have learnt to accept
it”. (ST, personal communication, December 28, 2015)
At a stage where observation and modelling play an important role in a child‟s life, the
participant expressed the way listening to other‟s experiences of being labelled had a more
intense impact on her understanding of society. The idea she has about the institutions and
functions in society large arise due to this.
61
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
“I had a close friend whose family used to torture her a lot, so she had come here
with me. She was with me in CWC and rehab. Most of my awareness about social
labelling came from this experience”. (ST, personal communication, December 28,
2015)
Perception of social labelling through other‟s experiences:When one considers sharing
experiences especially to children, individuals must also be aware about the imaginative
capacity of a child‟s mind. The participant expressed how her idea on stigmatising society
arises from the experiences she has heard of her peers. This has largely influenced the way
she perceives society as well. A friend of hers shared her story with the participant, and this
dialogue had a deep impact on her understanding of social stigma.
“Her parents used to scold her a lot like for example they used to ask her to do so
much work. Second mother was always torturing her they only would ask her to do
some things and say why you are doing this. They would make fun of her in front of
other people”. (ST, personal communication, December 28, 2015)
Understanding the institutions in society and their functions:
The researcher aimed at understanding the interface between various institutions in society,
with the development of adolescents. The researcher found that,observation and experiences
of social stigma influenced the way she understood functions in society. Also the participant
had various sources to aid her understanding of roles in society. Such as marriage as an
institution was an idea that interested her. Participant talks about a friend who shared her
story with her, and feels that she can relate to the same situation. They have together made
future plans as well showing how social interaction can affect identity and thinking.
62
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
“There was a bomb blast at a hospital in which her mother passed away only her
father is alive now she’s 19 now so she wants to get married so she’s waiting for me
to first finish my studies so we’ll find someone and marry together she’s working now
in another centre, because both of us need to earn money. In society nothing works
without money”. (ST, personal communication, December 28, 2015)
Participant‟s ideas about society arise from the way she has experienced interaction and
contact with the outside world. She does not feel comfortable interacting with the society that
deems them to be deviant and negative.
“I never think about society at all. Society has so many types of people within it and
all have different views about us. Even before I wouldn’t do that and I only concern
myself with me, my centre, my sister and friends”. (ST, personal communication,
December 28, 2015)
Most of the knowledge gained by the participant about the way society functions and how to
perform the roles assigned by society has come from the observation of support groups. In
order to decrease the psychological stress that the participant experiences due to various
factors such as stigmatization, these support systems have helped her find positivity in her
coping strategies. Social interactionism has suggested that the external environment of an
individual has a role to play in shaping his/ her overall personality and outlook towards life.
Family being the primary source of support, it is important to understand the crucial role it
plays during the formative years of the child- adolescence (Kowalski, 2013).
Prayer and venting applied to cope with social labels:family and primary support systems
(centre) are seen to be widely influential in catering to the psychological needs of the
participant. The development of prayer as a method to cope with difficulties and belief in
63
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
super natural powers, are seen to be stemming from observation of the authorities in the
centre.
“Since I came to that centre, actually in there, I didn’t believe in god so much. But I
experienced it since then. sometimes when I feel negative and want something like call
my sister and speak to her on the phone…..I’d feel scared to ask sister, generally i feel
uneasy to aske anything from any one, so what i do most of the time is write a letter
and put it under mother Mary’s statue and pray”. (ST, personal communication,
December 28, 2015)
Role of support systems in overcoming negativity: Children coming from remand homes and
rehabilitation centres initially are seen to experience a lot of negativity from people around
them. The participant states that in this centre the authorities and friends she has made are
indeed very supportive of her. The care they provide doesn‟t make her feel different than
others around her. The participant states in the following, how the support system has been
crucial in helping her overcome the negativity she faces.
“Many ways they have helped me. When I initially came here, I used to cry a lot. The
studies and all I would hate that. Then they explained it to me here saying if I
completed my studies, how I am counselled by others I could do the same and help
others too later. If i study it’s good for my life. I could be independent”. (ST, personal
communication, December 28, 2015)
“Here they take care of us and think about our future. In the remand home we had no
such opportunities. I would be so sensitive but sister consoled me”.(ST, personal
communication, December 28, 2015)
64
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
The results of the participant show that she experiences feelings of satisfaction and positivity
through sharing coping methods. This in turn also plays a role in the formation of her
identity. The restriction she experiences from the circumstances she faces has led her to
develop acceptance of social situations as a coping strategy. Support systems too have been
influential in generating prayer and venting as methods of coping. Perception of labelling that
the participant has is largely due to the stigmatization effects of other‟s experiences.
65
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
PARTICIPANT 4
Participant 4 PD is an 18 year old girl who has been in a rehabilitation centre for 1
year. PD dropped out of school when she failed to pass her SSLC examinations. Participant 4
shows strong ability to analyse and rationally think over every situation she faces. She
propagates to others to do the same. PD believes in not taking the negativity she faces by
society personally, and dealing with it through empathy and understanding .she has an older
sister image in the centre. PD has been exposed to social stigma before she was in the centre
and believes most of her coping methods have developed due to personal experiences.
Listening and advising others is her main concern. PD also has very strong feminist ideas and
strongly believes in women empowerment. The result of participant 4 is shown in the table
below.
Table 6
Themes and Super ordinate Themes Generated from Analysing Results of Participant 4:
Themes Super Ordinate Themes
4.111.Established identity and role
4.112.Formation of identity through
life experience
4.113.Empathy and sense of self with
relation to others.
4.121.Rationalised thinking about life
4.122.Labelling in inevitable in
society and analysing situations
will help overcoming this
4.123.Role of the centre and
authorities and its functions in
helping labelled children
4.124.Role of society and girl child to
tackle social labelling
4.125.Higher understanding of the
functioning of social
institutions
4.11.Formation of social identity
and role in society
4.12.Understanding functions of
society and social roles
66
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
4.211.Shares coping method
providing support to those in
similar situation
4.212.Sharing troubles gives access to
positive coping strategies
4.213.Feelings with regard to labels
arising due to failure
4.214.Method of coping plays a main
role in the formation of identity
4.215.Experience of negativity
becomes a lesson to cope with
social issues
4.216.Sharing coping method with
those being labelled
4.217.Feelings associated with
sharing coping methods
4.221.Support systems seen as
models for sharing behaviour
4.222.Observing and adopting pro
social behaviours of support
groups
4.21.self-fulfilment as reason for the
sustenance and sharing of coping
strategies
4.22.Modelling behaviour of support
system
4.311.Empathising as a coping
strategy
4.312.Analysing situations to
understand labelling better
4.313.Rationalizing negative
experiences
4.314.Dealing with issues by oneself
seen as being independent
4.315.Process of coping with negative
labels
4.321.Labels that arise due to failure
4.322.Role of society in social
labelling of females
4.323.Idea of social labels gained
through other‟s experiences
4.324.Role of females in tackling
social labels
4.31.empathy and analysing situations
as coping strategies
4.32.Influences on the idea of being
labelled
In order to avoid being labelled the participant makes sure that her role is definitive
in relation to that of which she is assigned by society. The researcher found that the ability to
67
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
analyse situations plays an important role in this participant‟s life. Over all her idea of coping
with social stigma arises from empathy and avoidance of confrontation.
“For me it is like I avoid being labelled. Usually I tell the others what to call me, and
they call that way only”. (PD, personal communication, December 28, 2015)
Formation of social identity and role in society: The formation of identity during the period
of adolescents is what determines the level of self- concept and self-worth. Constant exposure
to negativity and labelling in children gives rise to negative self-image (Jensen, 2006). The
participant shows definite identity that she has created for herself in order to tackle labelling.
She employs a non-judgemental stance when it comes to her idea about the functioning of
society.
“The way we see ourselves is very important. As you grow older your thoughts
become better you know what’s right and what’s wrong”.(PD, personal
communication, December 28, 2015)
Participant tries to empathise with other people around her. She has the tendency not to react
to situations on impulse but rather act on it after careful consideration. She propagates the
same to the others at the centre.
“We should not be judging people on what they tell us. We don’t know what they are
going through or who they are as people. What those people might be feeling. Some
people are brought up that way they don’t know the difficulties we face. They have
different thinking and thought process”.(PD, personal communication, December 28,
2015)
Understanding functions of society and social roles: for an individual to develop a certain
coping method to tackle social stigma, understanding the roles of various institutions and
68
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
functions of the same is crucial. In the case of the participant it can be clearly seen that she
assess the situations she faces based on her idea of the roles they play in society. Also the
researcher found that the participant categorises her peers based on how able they are to
analyse the difficult situations they face. She talks about her peers at the centre as well as
society in general with regard to negative experiences she has faced.
“Some people have lesser analysis power it takes some time for them to understand
things when they are angry, they might just say rude bad things, but should not feel
bad about that we should be able to understand their situation too. If we concern
ourselves with this our trouble only will increase. If we are about to fight or label just
because they are doing so there would be no difference between us and them”.(PD,
personal communication, December 28, 2015)
The participant tends to compare the situation of females in conflict with the law now, to the
time when she was first exposed to the system. She states that it‟s much easier for her now
and about the functioning of families and society.
“Before it was very difficult they had to work so much. No money. No help. Now
society is growing and is not backward anymore. People have better understanding
power too. Science is progressing and in society people are equipped to face
problems”.(PD, personal communication, December 28, 2015)
The participant‟s feeling of responsibility towards her peers is a main factor that influences
her sharing behaviour. The participant finds the need to help others around her not face
situations she has, as she knows how that would feel. Researcher also found that others
exhibit a level of trust in her and find it comfortable to share their difficulties with her.
Self-fulfilment as reason for the sustenance and sharing of coping strategies: Participant
provides care and support to others who are in similar situations as her or are facing some
69
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
sort of social stigma. The positive emotion of being able to help others and change their lives
is what sustains this behaviour in her. The coping strategy she adopts largely defines her
identity in the centre. She states this with an example of how people approach her at the
centre.
“Others when they faced difficulty situations they would say elder sister I am facing
this, what should I do? What should I say? I feel hurt then I start to analyse that you
there in some trouble when there is a problem I hear both sides of the story. I think
from both sides and then give them solution”.(PD, personal communication,
December 28, 2015)
Modelling behaviour of support system: The development of pro-social behaviour arises from
the observation of the support group, i.e. people the participant is in constant touch with. The
generation of coping strategies employed by the participant too has been due to modelling the
actions of the authorities, how they manage difficulties and analyse situations.
In 2005, Jane, Carol, and Boustead conducted a study titled: Coping style and psychological
health among adolescent prisoners: a study of young and juvenile offenders, which explored
the role of coping styles as a predictor of poor psychological health among adolescent
offenders. Adolescents usually are seen struggling to find their identity and role in society.
When this feeling is coupled with the way they perceive labels, the results can be quite
negative for the self- image of the child. The participant is seen to be modelling the behaviour
of the authorities and elders around her. She stresses on upbringing and relationships with
parents showing how important it is for proper development of children.
“Through others like parents or sister with see that is situation how we should
manage things they would make us brave and support us and our decision”. (PD,
personal communication, December 28, 2015)
70
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Empathy and analysing situations as coping strategies: The participant shows that the
labelling experience she has faced or heard from her peers has only helped her to understand
society better. In a way she sees this experience in a positive light motivating her to learn
more about the behaviours of others. Rationalization of issues is seen as to be a mature way
of thinking and participant has learnt this from her environment and people she interacts with.
She states that,
“When we calmly think about what happened… it builds independence dealing with
our own troubles and anxieties its importance that we don’t recall the situations and
let it be. Also I don’t discuss much of my troubles with others; I just let it sort out
itself when the time comes”. (PD, personal communication, December 28, 2015)
Influences on the idea of being labelled: The participants had strong views about the
institutions involved in the social labelling phenomenon. The researcher also found that the
participant has had many experiences where female children have narrated incidents from
their lives regarding social labels. Participant shows strong feminist ideas and supports
empowerment of women. She believes that women have the ability to be strong and
independent and shares the same views with the others at the centre.
“I feel pain to hear the things these girls come and tell me. I feel sad that they have to
face all that alone. It affects us all mentally as well. In life and society every girl
should live well and be good. The reason i adopt this coping is because my mother
brought me up this way. She taught us that we should respect others, value life and
help others”. (PD, personal communication, December 28, 2015)
The results of the participant 4 show how through understanding the roles various institutions
play in society, has influenced the formation of her identity. Participant feels self-fulfilment
after being able to share her coping methods. Modelling the behaviour of her support system
71
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
has helped generate venting issues, empathy and analysing situations before reacting to them,
as coping methods.
72
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
PARTICIPANT 5
Participant 5 SP is a 17 year old girl who has lived in remand homes and
rehabilitation centres for 10 years. SP has never gained any sort of formal education but is
currently pursuing a course in tailoring in order to establish her independence. SP comes
from a very traumatic childhood where she was abandoned on the streets by her biological
parents and then experienced the same with her adoptive parents. She has very poor
development of speech but has shown significant overall improvement since she has joined
the rehabilitation centre. SP has experienced social stigma and labelling from a young age,
even before coming into the remand home and rehabilitation centre and shows how evidently
it has affected her self-worth and social identity. SP shows a strong urge to help others in the
centre but sees herself to be still learning to be pro social. Participant shows eagerness to
learn more and establish independence. She has no feelings of animosity towards society and
believes the negative experiences she had faced has helped her grow. The result of participant
5 is shown in table 7.
Table 7
Themes and Super ordinate Themes Generated from Analysing Results of Participant 5:
Themes Super Ordinate Themes
5.111.Experience of stigma from a young
age
5.112.Negative experiences of social
stigma
5.113.Feeling of abandonment from
family and society
5.114.Social adjustment troubles and
loneliness
5.115.Trying to rationalise behavioural
change in her family
5.116.Questioning negative experiences
from society
5.117.
5.11.Experience of social stigma
and perception of society
73
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
5.121.Idea about the way society
functions
5.122.Powerlessness when facing social
labelling
5.123.Exposed to other supporting
institutions that help deal with
labelling
5.12.Understanding the roles of
various institutions in society
5.211. Coping with social stigma through
venting out difficulties
5.212. Belief in supernatural power and
prayer as a method of coping
5.213. Satisfaction with coping method
leading to sharing of the same
5.221.Support system‟s role in coping
5.222.Support groups helping to generate
ability to be self sufficient
5.223.Role of support group in
encouraging to fight against social
stigma
5.224.Support experienced from peers at
the centre
5.225.Confidence provided by support
systems helping build strong self-
image
5.226.Feeling independent and capable to
deal with negative experiences
5.21.Venting and belief in super
natural to help cope with stress
5.22.Role of support groups in
building strong sense of self
5.311.Satisfaction leading to sharing of
coping strategies
5.312.Positive feelings associated with
sharing behaviour
5.313.Motivated to help others to feel
good about self
5.321.Modelling behaviour of support
systems to deal with difficulties
5.322.Satisfaction with current coping
method
5.31.Development of self-image
through sharing coping
strategies with others
5.32.Positive feelings associated with
the sustenance of coping
strategy
Social labelling is a phenomenon whereby a stigmatized group, make externally given
negative labels their own, by self-consciously referring to oneself as the label/tag (Galinsky,
74
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Hugenberg, Groom &Bodenhausen, 2003). The participant has had the experience of stigma
from a young age. She has been abandoned by family twice and has since coped with her
situation through prayer and rationalization.
Experience of social stigma and perception of society: The participant shows her
understanding of the way society functions through her experiences with it. The participant
has had negative experiences regarding social stigma. Being abandoned by her family and
feeling of loneliness due to lack of communication skills is evident from her behaviour. But
the participant has also has begun to understand the role society plays in her life. Participant
narrates the incident where her own family abandoned her. She experienced stigmatization
before coming into the remand home and rehabilitation setting, therefore, finding it difficult
to adjust without being able to communicate how she feels.
“I found them once while I was still in the hostel, but they refused to recognise me.
They said they did not know who I was. The hostel people said I could go back home
now. But my family did not want me. When this family refused to take me back or even
recognise me, I felt really bad. I was so sad that no one wanted me”. (SP, personal
communication, December 30, 2015)
Understanding the roles of various institutions in society: The idea about the way society
operates,seems to be stemming from the powerlessness the participant faced when being
labelled. The environments she was exposed to have also helped her understanding of various
roles people have in society. She uses her knowledge of roles and functions in society to
compare with her own situation and feels emotionally vulnerable. She states that,
“If I had a good family i would be so happy from the start. People like me... it’s very
difficult for us to understand others. Because we were brought up in so many different
75
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
environments and after being rejected by the only two families I knew... I trusted.... I
realised that this was my life”. (SP, personal communication, December 30, 2015)
The participant feels that she has not had a stable environment where she could learn how to
behave and what her roles are in society. Due to abandonment she faced at a young age, the
only stability she views in her life is that of the support group she has.
Venting and belief in super natural to help cope with stress: The participant copes with social
stigma through venting out difficulties, due to modelling her support group, she has also
developed a strong belief in the super natural, and uses prayer as a method to vent out her
difficulties. The participant showed satisfaction in her coping technique.
“Whenever I feel alone, sad of when I could not handle something, I would always
speak to god (pray). And then I would feel my burden has decreased and everything
has become lighter. I talk to sisters also if I feel I am facing a really difficult
situation”.(SP, personal communication, December 30, 2015)
Role of support groups in building strong sense of self:Support groups helped the participant
to generate ability to be self-sufficient. The participant expresses that the encouragement she
gets through her support system helps her build a strong self-image, and she feels capable of
dealing with the negative experiences she faced and become independent.
“Everyone is very supportive here. They would say we are here for you; you don’t
have to suffer alone. I talk to people now, this is my family now. I don’t want to go
back”. (SP, personal communication, December 30, 2015)
When children are exposed to positive emotions and environments in day to day life, they
tend to develop a positive, adaptive perception of themselves as well as the society around
76
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
them. The participant sees society receptive to her efforts of sharing and caring for others
around her. The participant also feels positivity and growth in her self- image.
Development of self-image through sharing coping strategies with others:Through sharing the
participant‟s method of coping with negativity, such as prayer and venting, she finds a sense
of satisfaction that she is able to affect somebody‟s life. The participant feels that she had no
role to play before she came to the centre. Now she feels responsible and part of a
community. Participant shares her difficulties and issues with her peers and care takers and
feels positive about it. She says that,
“But now that I am able to communicate with them and share my experiences I also
tell them the same thing that they should pray or just talk to someone so they feel
lighter and happy. Because that is what worked for me”. (SP, personal
communication, December 30, 2015)
Positive feelings associated with the sustenance of coping strategy:Researcher found that the
participant was satisfied with the coping method she adapted through modelling and
observation of her support group. There are positive feelings associated with her behaviour of
wanting to help others around her. The feeling of being trusted by her peers helps sustain the
coping strategy she applies to deal with social stigma.
“God only told me. Before I would feel angry but I would not react… I thought I had
no power or control over this. I would just bear it… I did not learn to talk for so long.
And only now I can share things with people. I would feel so alone… when I was
quiet, people used to tell each other and say things like why is she so dumb... now i
saw girls and people here praying and they all look so happy. So i learnt that this
works for me too”. (SP, personal communication, December 30, 2015)
77
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
The participants feeling of being helpless has deteriorated since she has been able to
communicate her feelings to her support group. She is able to vent how she feels and believes
that when people listen, it makes her believe in it more. Regarding how her support group has
helped her, she says that,
“When I have difficulties, they would say pray to god and everything will be fine…
before no one would come to me for help, because I myself was very helpless. But now
that I am able to communicate with them and share my experiences”. (SP, personal
communication, December 30, 2015)
The result of the participant shows that she experienced negative feelings such as
abandonment, loneliness and adjustment troubles due to being labelled. The participant has
developed an understanding about how society works and her role in it as being submissive
and powerless. She has a strong belief in the super-natural and uses venting as a coping
strategy. Support system has played an important role in helping her build a strong sense of
self. Through sharing her coping methods, she feels positive and has developed a strong self-
image. Participant shows satisfaction with her current coping methods.
78
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
PARTICIPANT 6
Participant 6 GGR, is a 17 year old girl who has experienced being in remand homes
and rehabilitation centres for 4 years. GGR is a upper primary/ middle school dropout. GGR
found it hard to adjust with her peers due to her anger issues. Participant experienced many
situations where her anger went out of her hand due to her inability to control the situation
around her. She lived with her aunt who was indifferent to her. GGR believes that all that she
has learnt is due to her own experience. She looks at being in the centre in a positive manner.
GGR believes that most of her coping abilities towards social stigma were maladaptive
before she was sent to the rehabilitation centre. After coming to the centre she recollects
many positive experiences and changes in her personality. Result of participant 6 is shown in
the table below.
Table 8
Themes and Super ordinate Themes Generated from Analysing Results of Participant 6:
Themes Super Ordinate Themes
6.111.Violent outbursts of aggression
due pent up anger
6.112.Feeling of loneliness, guilt and
sad due to being labelled
6.113.Formation of an identity due to
the labels given by others
6.114.Negative reactions to labelling
clouding judgement
6.121.Self-defeating thoughts
impacting perception of society
and identity
6.122.Indifference of society towards
helping her cope with social
labels
6.131.Negativity experienced from
family
6.132.Stigmatized by peers in remand
6.11.Displacement of anger caused
due to social labelling
6.12.Distorted idea of self and identity
generated by society
79
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
home generating feeling of
being unwanted
6.133.Labelling experienced in
school
6.134.Social labelling influencing
development of negative
identity
6.135.Feeling hopeless and helpless
about her situation and
displacing anger
6.136.Feeling of anger against
authorities and sense of being
helpless
6.137.Losing control over reactions to
stressful situations
6.13.Feelings associated with being
labelled
6.211.Coping with overwhelming
emotions through avoidance of
situation
6.212.Avoiding confrontation to deal
with situations not in her
control
6.221.Did not perceive coping
method as a choice
6.222.Ability to help others increase
in self-concept
6.231.Development of new coping
strategies to deal with social
pressures
6.232.Coping with stress through
meditation
6.21.Avoiding confrontation as a coping
strategy
6.22.increase in self-concept promotes
sharing behaviour
6.23.Influence of support groups in
developing new coping strategies
6.311.Assistance and guidance
provided by support groups
6.312.Experienced positive and
helpful nature of people in
society
6.313.Support of one person main
role in development of her
identity
6.314.Socializing in the centre largely
affects identity and coping
6.315.Changing idea of a negative
society to a positive one
6.31.Role of support systems in
overcoming negativity and change
in perception of society
80
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
6.321.Reduction in guilt feeling after
being able to help others
6.322.Trust plays a main role as an
influencer to adopt certain
coping method
6.323.Satisfaction and
accomplishment gained
through sharing coping
strategies
6.32.Increased self-worth from sharing
coping strategies
Criminals do not differ from others in their original impulse to commit crimes but societal
interaction plays an important role in developing a pattern of deviant behaviour
(Tennenbaum, 1938). In this regard it is very important – the interaction that takes place
between individual and society largely affects the perception of identity and self.
Displacement of anger caused due to social labelling:Pent up negative emotions usually are
displaced in a very violent manner. The participant‟s anger towards her family that she is not
able to express directly to them was projected over her peers at school. Constant negativity
experienced by the participant during her childhood, made her form maladaptive ways of
coping with the stress around her.She became violent due to her helplessness over her
situation. She says that,
“I used to fight physically beat them and all. All used to scold me that I have come
like a beggar and I got so angry. They all have parents who take care of them but they
don’t know anything about me. I lost my patience and i took a slate and hit them (her)
on the head then went home and cried a lot about why i am like this. I felt so alone”.
(GGR, personal communication, December 31, 2015)
Distorted idea of self and identity generated by society:The participant faced many self-
defeating thoughts that shaped the way she perceived herself as well as the environment
around her. The participant showed signs of generalizing the behaviour of a few prominent
81
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
people in her life, to that of society. The researcher also found that the participant wasn‟t very
open to the help that was available to her at difficult times. This may be due to the trust issues
she had developed during her childhood.
“When I get angry and would react so violently no one would come to help me… Help
me understand what was happening. All the names they would call me started to make
me feel like they were true”.(GGR, personal communication, December 31, 2015)
There was also expression of comparison between the participant and others who she was in
contact with. She believed to be unlucky not to have had parents and family who‟d treat her
well and care for her. For this the feeling of guilt is evident.
“Before I used to think that everyone else is happy. They all have a good life… and I
am the only one suffering like this alone. And no one wants to be a friend with me was
my thinking back then. I used to think that society is very selfish. No one will help
anyone in need”.(GGR, personal communication, December 31, 2015)
Feelings associated with being labelled: There were many negative experiences the
participant faced during her childhood that made her adapt anger as a coping method. The
feeling of being stigmatised came not only from her peers and family but also few authorities
in the centre she was at. In reality the researcher found that the participant had a strong
feeling of loneliness, helplessness and loss of self- control regarding the situations she faced.
Regarding authorities and peers at the remand home, she states,
“All people would call me very mean names like mad and mental and all that and
because they used to call me bad names i would get angrier. In life everything was
going wrong, I could not control anything. It was as though my life was falling apart.
So I would just react angrily and finish that matter. When I was being labelled, I had
no one to talk to at that time. Then I would react very impulsively… Difficulties
82
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
meaning everyone used to blame me, scold or beat me for any mistake even if I did not
do it”. (GGR, personal communication, December 31, 2015)
When faced with stressful situations the participant began to understand there wasn‟t much
she could do about it but avoid instances that would trigger her anger. In the centre she
encountered her support group who helped her understand the maladaptive nature of her
coping and encouraged new coping strategies.
Avoiding confrontation as a coping strategy:The participant copes with overwhelming
emotions by avoiding confrontations and feels the need to take her time to understand
situations that are not in her control. She narrates that her only support at the time even before
being in the remand home, her aunt, was indifferent towards her.
“I felt so alone. My aunty also used to hit me, i felt so suicidal. Then only i decided to
run away from home... so yeah when i get angry i would just react badly. But now I
give it some time to understand what is happening around me”. (GGR, personal
communication, December 31, 2015)
Increase in self-concept promotes sharing behaviour:Participant feels that she had no choice
but to fight back at the situations she faced when she was younger. The feeling of not having
anyone to look up to or trust was evident. The social situation of the participant at that time
made her feel that she had no choice but to cope through violence and acting out her
emotions.
Through sharing her experiences and the way she has developed adaptable methods of coping
has generated a positive feeling in her life and the participant feels more responsible.
“Before I feel alone and like I had to do everything but now that I am able to help
others I feel I myself am improving. I share that power to change someone else life if
83
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
feel everything nice to know that people trust me completely and that only because I
help them. But talking to someone really helps. They have that conviction to do what i
ask and it does help me too”.(GGR, personal communication, December 31, 2015)
Influence of support groups in developing new coping strategies: The researcher found that
the participant has been able to positively adapt to stressful situations through mediation and
self-talk. The participant also feels confident to talk about her issues to authorities and
believes she can feel better equipped to tackle social stigma, with their support.
“When they told me to go to the counsellor, I was not very open to her and did not
speak much. Slowly I understood that they were only trying to help. Venting out and
talking about my feelings instead of expressing anger worked well. It felt better and I
did not feel guilty”.(GGR, personal communication, December 31, 2015)
While talking about counselling and how it could help the way she perceives society outside
the rehabilitation centre, she states that,
“Initially I could not do it… I would count very fast and finish it. It did not help at
all… but now I learnt to stay and say it calmly and control my breathing so more
peaceful now. I have started meditating too… I tell myself that I am not the only one
suffering now... or who has difficulties. Others have too. So by myself i can relate
now”. (GGR, personal communication, December 31, 2015)
Psychologists state that every child is like a blank slate when they are born. Through
observation of the environment and people around them, they tend to internalise information
that helps form their identities. In processes like this, a care giver‟s role is crucial for the
effective functioning of the child in a social environment. With children in conflict with the
law, their primary care giver‟s usually become their support systems and aid in the proper
development of the child.
84
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Role of support systems in overcoming negativity and change in perception of society:The
assistance and guidance provided by the support group of the participant has helped her
experience positivity around her and create more adaptable reaction behaviour to
psychological stress. The participant shows trust towards one person who has been able to
help her in difficult times.
Socializing with peers and people around in the rehabilitation centre, the participant has
helped her develop a stronger identity and changed the way she used to view the negativity
found in society.
“When I came here I have improved so much. Here they look after me really well...
when I am sad and sitting alone they come and ask me what is wrong. Before no one
would show me that concern... I have many friends here too… Before I did not have
any friends now I know what mothers love means. One counsellor had come here and
sisters had sent me to her saying I have anger issues”. (GGR, personal
communication, December 31, 2015)
Increased self-worth from sharing coping strategies:A lot of anger was expressed by the
participant when she faced any form of social stress. Sharing her coping abilities now have
helped her reduce the feeling of guilt she has been facing. Emotion oriented coping has come
to place where sharing coping methods is sustained due to the positive feelings it generates.
The participant shows that adapting certain methods of coping or advice, goes hand in hand
with trust in that particular individual and therefore feels responsible.
“Usually the others who I share my things with listen to me because they have seen
that I have changed for good and they know that what i am saying will work. I had
nothing to share before when if I wanted to I could not really help anyone so when I
85
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
kept doing it and now I like helping other people it very peaceful”. (GGR, personal
communication, December 31, 2015)
The result of the participant shows that there is a distorted idea of self and identity and
negative feelings associated with having experienced labelling. Anger is a concern in the case
of this participant. Participant now uses avoidance of confrontation as a coping strategy.
Through the support from the authorities and peers at the centre, participant is able to
experience increase in self- concept and self-worth through sharing her abilities to cope with
stress.
Cross Case Analysis
This part of the chapter focusses on the cross case analysis, with research objectives
in mind. After gaining insight into each participant‟s idea, concept of social stigma and
coping, the researcher proceeded toward the formulation of master themes cross case wise.
The deeper understanding gained in the result part of this chapter, plays a very important role
in helping the researcher understand how children in conflict with the law perceive labelling.
The results of the cross case analysis is shown in the figures that follow.
Table 9
Results of Objective 1:To Understand the Experience and Perception of Social Labeling and
the Subjective Experience of Being Labeled.
Theme Superordinate Theme Master Theme
Formation of self
and social identity
Distorted idea of
self and identity
generated by
society
Feeling of
1.01.labeling impact on
social identity
1.0 Distorted social identity
and negative emotions of
being labeled
86
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
loneliness and
abandonment from
being labelled
Negative feelings
associated with
being labelled
Low confidence in
ability to help
others
Displacement of
anger caused due to
social labelling
Feelings associated
with being labelled
Feeling of being
controlled by others
in society
Restrictions put on
her way of life by
society
No control over
circumstances
leading her to join
rehab
Restricted and
controlled by
circumstances
Exhibiting effects
of being labelled
Perception of social
labelling through
other‟s experiences
Influences on the
idea of being
labelled
Experience of social
stigma and
perception of
society
1.02.Negative feelings
associated with
being labeled
2.01.Societal
restraints on
thoughts and
behavior
2.02.Influencers
and
experience of
stigmatizatio
n
2.0 Experience of social
control, labels and
stigmatization
87
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Figure 1: Super Ordinate and Master Themes of Objective 1.
2.0.EXPERIENCE OF
SOCIAL CONTROL,
LABELS AND
STIGMATIZATION
1.01. Labeling impact on
social identity
1.02. Negative feelings
associated with being labeled
1.0 DISTORTED SOCIAL
IDENITY AND
NEGATIVE EMOTIONS
OF BEING LABELLED
2.01. Societal restraints on
thoughts and behavior
2.02. Influencers and
experience of stigmatization
88
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
1.0.Distorted social identity and negative emotions of being labelled
Stigmatising labels are often internalised by adolescents to form their identities and
outlook toward society. Children who are surrounded with a strong support system are seen
to adapt well and tackle social stigma positively. Most adolescents though, are not able to
understand the proceedings and functions of certain institutions in society due to their
complexities as well as their own physical, mental changes into adulthood.
Labeling impact on social identity:Family being the primary source of support, it is important
to understand the crucial role it plays during the formative years of the child- adolescence
(Kowalski, 2013). Most children in conflict with the law have already been scrutinized for
their dis regard towards societal norms, it is crucial for the primary support systems to guide
and nurture the goodness in them. Participant 1 strongly states how being stigmatized before
coming into the remand home has affected the way she perceives herself. This process in turn
affects the development of coping methods once she was in the remand home and
rehabilitation centres.
“My aunty had adopted me… first my grandma used to take care of us after my
parents passed away, through her I met aunt. When grandma passed away my aunt
adopted me. My aunt thought I already adopted her, now there is nothing I can do.
She wouldn’t take care of me, and used to call me names and criticise everything I do,
so she found some ashram”. (SS, personal communication, December 24, 2015)
The indifference expressed by society also plays a very important role in shaping the identity
of children. Societal pressures, labelling experienced from family member, friends etc. give
rise to self- defeating thoughts that in turn impact the perception of society and formation of a
social identity. Participant 6 clearly shows how she compares herself to others in society and
her social identity is seen to concretize around this aspect.
89
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
“Before I used to think that everyone else is happy. They all have a good life… and I
am the only one suffering like this alone. And no one wants to be a friend with me was
my thinking back then. I used to think that society is very selfish. No one will help
anyone in need”.(GGR, personal communication, December 31, 2015)
Negative feelings associated with being labeled:Social support is usually provided by the
primary care givers of children. In adolescents this system consists of the family of the child.
In the case of children who are in conflict with the law, it is important to note that this link
that would help children adapt to social stress in a positive manner is usually severed
(Baqutayan, 2011). Thus creating feelings of abandonment and loneliness as well as
generating negative emotions towards society. The feeling of helplessness is usually seen to
modify into anger and other mal adaptive behaviours. Participant 1 states that she feels
helpless when it comes to controlling what other people think about children like her. She is
accustomed to feeling sad due to being labelled and now feels that it does not matter as much
as it used to.
“So every time there is only one problem- Our inabilities to control what people say
about us and scold us. But we are used to it now. I have forgotten what sadness this
used to cause me”. (SS, personal communication, December 24, 2015)
Participant 6 discusses about how she feels about being labelled. Due to being called names
and criticised she states that she would get angry and react violently, which is pretty evident
in the behaviours of children in conflict with the law. She narrates this experience as,
“I used to fight physically beat them and all. All used to scold me that I have come
like a beggar and I got so angry. They all have parents who take care of them but they
don’t know anything about me. I lost my patience and i took a slate and hit them (her)
90
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
on the head then went home and cried a lot about why i am like this. I felt so alone”.
(GGR, personal communication, December 31, 2015)
When one‟s own identity is strongly affected by the social stress that one goes through, it is
important to know that their self-image is usually damaged and children in this state have
very low confidence and self-esteem. They perceive themselves to be alone, abandoned and
incapable of helping other people. Participant 2 narrates that if she would be able to tackle the
stigma she faces from society, she would feel positive and trusting. Due to continuously
being exposed to negative name calling in the remand home, she feels incapable to create
good interpersonal relations.
“I'd rather feel happy….but I don’t think i can trust anyone until I solve all my
troubles first. I am not very close to anyone that why not many people come to me for
help. Nothing is permanent here so rather than facing the pain of leaving someone
close or them leaving its better not to be close to anyone. And deal with the troubles
ourselves”. (LP, personal communication, December 24, 2015)
2.0.Experience of social control, labels and stigmatization
External sources of labeling usually induce the idea that the stigmatizing labels is
actually what defines a child and children adopt to self- labeling behaviors and act upon them
(Jensen, 2006). These external sources are institutions in society that are constant reminders
of the deviance committed by children in conflict with the law.
Societal restraints on thoughts and behavior:Since children can be molded into functional
adults, society usually takes it upon itself to dictate the behaviors and roles to various people
in society. Especially female children in conflict with the law express their feelings over the
control and restrictions on their movement, speech, clothes and like. Participant 1 perceives
91
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
stigma through their control expressed by society in modifying the behaviors of children like
her. This experience has influenced the way she thinks and this phenomenon is seen in other
children in the centre as well. Participant 1 state talks about how she feels controlled and
influenced by society in the following:
“Suddenly people there were like don’t sit here stand there. Don’t wear dress like this
or like that what will people day.one hand there is no freedom at all to do what we
want but we can’t do anything about it”. (SS, personal communication, December 24,
2015)
Participant 2 conveys that because of the actions of few children breaking the social moral
norms of society, some of them also express the way they have no control over the facilities
they are being shifted to and feel helpless, slowly adapting to the situation around them even
though they feel negative about it.
“I don’t have that in my control. If they send me from one facility to another, I cannot
say anything. It’s not in my power. So if I am close to someone, I have to leave
eventually anyway. So I don’t need to share and be close to anyone”. (LP, personal
communication, December 24, 2015)
Influencers and experience of stigmatization: The perception towards being labeled depends
on the child‟s own self-concept and analyzing capacity. Many children in conflict with the
law show lowered self- worth and self- criticizing behaviors after being exposed to social
stigma. These children find it hard to manage the emotions they go through when being
labeled. Some of the participants though, did not feel that labeling has changed the way they
function much. Participant 2 states:
“It’s been pretty much the same for me, I have not faced much difference from before
and how I am now…just in the remand home they would tease me, I would feel very
92
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
inferior to them. When friends in school used to call me names and tease me I would
just keep to myself. But I felt very low and sad. But I had the determination to be
better than them”. (LP, personal communication, December 24, 2015)
The idea about social stigma and labelling also is seen arising from the narrated experiences
of others in the facility. The imaginative capacity of children is usually very high and in
situation regarding feelings and difficulties faced they tend to graphically picture the story in
reality. Participant 3 talks about her perception of labelling that have risen from the
experience of a close friend. She states that she has a strong relationship with a girl at the
centre who has influenced her ideas on social stigma.
“Her parents used to scold her a lot like for example they used to ask her to do so
much work. Second mother was always torturing her they only would ask her to do
some things and say why you are doing this. They would make fun of her in front of
other people”.(ST, personal communication, December 28, 2015)
Some of the ideas on social stigma came from the indifference they experienced during their
stay with their families. This experience of constant negativity from people outside as well as
close to them defines how they generalise and view society- understanding the way it
functions. Participant 5 has faced social stigma from a very young age, even before being
admitted in a remand home.She talks about a family who had adopted her from the streets
and how she assumes that they might have faced negative views from society for this
behaviour and therefore, abandoned her. She relates this incident to being abandoned by her
biological mother as well. She has not been able to cope with the same until she came to the
centre.
“I believe society and people used to always make fun of them for taking me in. and
maybe that is why they did not want me there anymore. My real family also said they
93
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
don’t know me. They left me on the streets and so I can understand now why they
would say that. When I was younger, they traced where I might have come from, but
my parents said they did not know me. I remember sometimes, when someone says
bad things to me”.(SP, personal communication, December 30, 2015)
Table 10
Results of Objective 2:To Understand the Coping Strategies of Female Adolescents in
Conflict with the Law in Rehabilitation Centers who Face or Faced Social Labeling and are
Affected by it.
Theme Superordinate Theme Master themes
Role of support groups in
encouraging life choices
Attachment towards care
givers or support systems
Role of authorities to deal
with labelling
experiences
Role of support systems
in overcoming negativity
Modelling behaviour of
support system
Role of support groups in
building strong sense of
self
Influence of support
groups in developing new
coping strategies
Role of support systems
in overcoming negativity
and change in perception
of society
Feeling helpless and
coping through
acceptance of situation
Rationalizing
circumstances as method
of coping
avoiding confrontation to
3.01. Role of
support groups in
the development
of adaptive coping
strategies
3.0 Interface between support
groups and developing
coping strategies
94
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
cope with negativity from
society
Acceptance of social
situations
Prayer and venting
applied to cope with
social labels
empathy and analysing
situations as coping
strategies
Venting and belief in
super natural to help cope
with stress
Avoiding confrontation
as a coping strategy
3.02. Coping
strategies against
social labels
Figure 2: Super Ordinate and Master Themes of Objective 2.
3.0.The interface between support groups and developing coping strategies
Many children find it easier to adapt to societal norms when they are in
rehabilitation centers, as these centers are trained in providing the care and support need for
the children to join back society. Coping usually is seen as a mediator of emotion. The
development of coping strategies in the sample, were largely seen as products of observation
3.0. INTERFACE
BETWEEN SUPPORT
GROUPS AND
DEVELOPING COPING
STRATEGIES
3.01. Role of support groups
in the development adaptive
of coping strategies
3.02. Coping strategies
against social labels
95
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
and modeling (Folkman& Lazarus, 1988). The participants expressed positive emotions while
adopting new methods to cope with labels and stigma. The researcher was also able to find
the main system involved in the development of these children was the support group.
Role of support groups in the development of adaptive coping strategies:The role of social
support groups in managing stress play a very important role in the overall development of a
child‟s identity (Baqutayan, 2011). Freedom is not generally experienced by the children in
conflict with the law. Society always scrutinizes the actions of those who are deviant from
social norms. Participants like SS (participant 1), expressed positive emotions stemming from
the idea of how support systems, that is the rehabilitation centre, were encouraging of their
life choices and did not express any control or restrictions over them.
“Here it is much better, here they take care of everyone equally and same way. When
sister gets a cake also we will say no sister you eat they say we should share and give
us everything they can, so basically you won’t get that sort of love and care from
family or home and they are very open to our life choices and encourage us to do
what we want and what makes us happy”.(SS, personal communication, December
24, 2015)
Support groups are viewed as role models and people in power with the ability to make
changes, to these children since they help them tackle any difficulty they have. With relation
to dealing with social labelling as well, support groups are seen helping children understand
better the choices people make and various behaviours they portray. Participant 3, ST, talks
about how she attended a seminar to deal with the situation they are in, and found that to be
helpful to a point where she is motivated to do the same later in her life.
“I like to help because last year we all went out for a function and then there was a
brother there who conducted some seminar and they were so helpful so i want do that
96
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
too. If anyone asks me for help i have to help them i cannot say no to them”.(ST,
personal communication, December 28, 2015)
Participant 2, feels happy about the support she receives from the centre but at the same time
senses that she is incompetent to help them the same way. Hence, when others at the centre
approach her for some help, she directs them to the authorities at the centre.
“When people facing the same situation come to me I tell them to go speak to the
authorities because everyone will listen to them… I am powerless in this matter”.(LP,
personal communication, December 24, 2015)
When children arrive at the centre they are usually ill equipped to deal with the stress society
creates for them. In this scenario, supports systems are seen to change and influence the way
these children cope with such distress. Being exposed to constant negativity from society,
children in conflict with the law exhibit low self- concept and distorted identities, participants
like SP (participant 5), often hail from abusive backgrounds and centre as a support system
helps build a strong sense of self. SP talks about her experience with social stigma and how
her support group helped her.
“Now here I see sisters and my friends all so selflessly helping children like me. I feel
happy, I feel happy to be in the centre, before I had no hope about my life. Now I
believe I can live. The people her help me to move forward. They help me become
independent and now I don’t feel worthless”. (SP, personal communication,
December 30, 2015)
Participant 6 narrates her experience in the rehabilitation centre, how they were able to help
her overcome the stigmatization she faced from society even before she was put into the
remand home, and increase her interpersonal abilities.
97
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
“When I came here I have improved so much. Here they look after me really well...
when I am sad and sitting alone they come and ask me what is wrong. Before no one
would show me that concern... I have many friends here too… Before i did not have
any friends now I know what mothers love means. One counsellor had come here and
sisters had sent me to her saying i have anger issues”. (GGR, personal
communication, December 31, 2015)
Coping strategies against social labels:Coping with social stress has a great impact on the
psychopathology of adolescent girls and is seen that pubertal timings were associated with
internalization of social stress leading to distress and anger (Sontag, Graber, Gunn & Warren,
2008). Avoidance of confrontation and acceptance of situation were seen as the two main
coping strategies applied by female adolescents in conflict with the law. Participant 2 talks
about how she does not like to confront the issues she faces from society.
“I don’t know I don’t like talking about it directly to them. I did not like to stress on
one thing once it’s done. So I just let it be. I don’t find the need to talk to others about
it and whenever I feel sad or face any difficult situation, I don’t tell anyone about it. I
just keep it to myself and not do anything about it”. (LP, personal communication,
December 24, 2015)
Participant 3 rationalizes with the situation, accepts the way things are in her life and clearly
shows her belief in the supernatural.
“I know the reasons I faced labelling by society. But it’s ok… I understand why
people need to show their power over others. I deal with my problems by venting it to
god and I know that situations always have explanations and I have learnt to accept
it”. (ST, personal communication, December 28, 2015)
98
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Belief in the super natural and prayer is seen as the second highest method of coping, which
is usually due to the influence of support groups but is seen effective against tackling social
stress, from what participant 5 states:
“When I have difficulties, they would say pray to god and everything will be fine…
before no one would come to me for help, because I myself was very helpless. But now
that I am able to communicate with them and share my experiences and whenever I
feel alone, sad of when I could not handle something, I would always speak to god
(pray). And then I would feel my burden has decreased and everything has become
lighter. I talk to sisters also if I feel I am facing a really difficult situation”. (SP,
personal communication, December 30, 2015)
Due to the feeling of helplessness experienced by some of the participants like LP
(participant 2) and PD (participant 4), they have developed rationalizing and analysing as
their coping strategies. Apart from accepting that they cannot change how society thinks or
feels about them, they try to understand the reason behind such negative behaviour and
rationalise with it. LP states that she likes to empathise with the people involved in teasing
her, and don‟t want to be responsible for others to get punished because of her.
“I don’t like it. I don’t like to see my friends getting hurt. It’s like I go complain about
them... Then they would get punished and I don’t like that. I don’t like them getting
beatings”. (LP, personal communication, December 24, 2015)
Participant 4, on the other hand thinks about how she has learnt through experience that
through analysing situations, solving issues become much easier. She is able to help others by
making them understand to be patient and think before they react.
“I learnt through growth only as in I grew older I could understand situations better
and when I applied this understanding to my problems they get solved, it’s all about
99
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
trial and error. Now I’d think that like how i feel they’d also probably feel that way.
Shame shy and all that to confront them troubles, I just wait for them to be
comfortable enough to share things with me”. (PD, personal communication,
December 28, 2015)
Table 11
Results of Objective 3: To Analyze the Reasons for Adopting a Certain Coping Strategy.
Basic Theme Organizing Theme Global Theme
Moulding identity through
sharing coping strategies
self-fulfilment as reason for
the sustenance and sharing
of coping strategies
Development of self-image
through sharing coping
strategies with others
increase in self-concept
promotes sharing behaviour
Increased self-worth from
sharing coping strategies
Freedom to make own
choices and feelings
associated with sharing
coping strategies
Feeling of satisfaction as
reason for the sustenance
and sharing coping
strategies
Positive feelings associated
with the sustenance of
coping strategy
4.01. Development of self
and social identity
through sharing coping
strategies
4.02. Adaptive feelings
associated with sharing
coping strategies
4.0 Sharing of coping
strategies
promoting the
development of a
positive self
100
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Figure 3: Super Ordinate and Master Themes of Objective 3.
4.0.Sharing of coping strategies promoting the development of a positive self
Learning to share can be challenging for children. In the case of this research, the
participants showed immense positive growth after adapting sharing behavior. Even though
the sharing that has happened is not materialistic in nature, the emotions the participants go
through when they share cooing strategies are seen very similar to that. Children in conflict
with the law struggle during the period when they build their identities and concretize roles in
society. Especially at adolescents, it is crucial for them to have the right guidance. Through
sharing coping methods with other facing or faced similar social stigmas, participants were
able to develop their self- concept and establish strong identities. In turn they also
experienced positive emotions.
Development of self and social identity through sharing coping strategies: Stigmatizing labels
applied externally to individuals is seen to create a phenomenon in these individuals, where
these negative labels are self- consciously applied to them. They tend to refer to themself by
4.0 SHARING OF
COPING
STARTEGIES
PROMOTING THE
DEVELOPMENT OF
A POSITIVE SELF
4.01. Development of self
and social identity through
sharing coping strategies
4.02. Adaptive feelings
associated with sharing
coping strategies
101
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
those labels attached and in turn this process becomes their identity (Bodenhausen, 2003). In
the similar manner, sharing of coping strategies applied by the participants helped generating
a positive social identity as they received appreciation and positive emotions from others
around them; this feel good feeling sustains the sharing behaviour in children, as shown by
participant 3.
“Most of the friends have come to me to help them with their relationship issues.so we
are too young to be involved in romantic relationships before I used to help them
because I really like helping. So now here i will help when i can and if anything else i
go and tell sister about it. But I’ll always help one way or another. I’d tell the
authorities if it’s something that I cannot handle”. (ST, personal communication,
December 28, 2015)
The researcher also found that a lot of positivity was generated through the sharing coping
strategies with others that in turn uplifted their self- image and self-worth. Participant 4, 5
and 6 speak about the feeling of being wanted and gaining the ability to help others in times
of their difficulties, makes the participants feel responsible and appreciated. When participant
4, PD shares her coping with others at the centre, she experiences positive emotions as stated
below.
“I feel I have done something good. I have helped them and I have that ability to help
others. And the ones I help also always model what I do when people they know need
help”. (PD, personal communication, December 28, 2015)
Participant 5 talks about when she faces issues support groups helping her cope with it and
how that works for her. She is yet to experience the feeling of sharing her coping methods
with others and helping others in similar situations as her.
102
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
“When I have difficulties, they would say pray to god and everything will be fine…
before no one would come to me for help, because I myself was very helpless. But now
that I am able to communicate with them and share my experiences”. (SP, personal
communication, December 30, 2015)
Participant 6 feels accomplished and trusted when she is able to help others at the centre who
go through social stigma. She says that,
“Before I feel alone and like I had to do everything but now that I am able to help
others I feel I myself am improving. I share that power to change someone else life if
feel everything nice to know that people trust me completely and that only because I
help them. But talking to someone really helps. They have that conviction to do what i
ask and it does help me too”. (GGR, personal communication, December 31, 2015)
Adaptive feelings associated with sharing coping strategies: Pro- social behaviours promotes
harmonious relations with others, usually this behaviour is associated with achieving success
and satisfaction(Jackson &Tisak, 2001). Sharing coping strategies is mainly for the outcome
of promoting pro social behaviour. In the participants, it gave rise to positive emotions such
as happiness, satisfaction and freedom. These factors become the main reason for the
sustenance of sharing behaviour. Participant 1 SS, relates to others in the rehabilitation
centre, and that is what motivates her to help them cope with the issues she faces. She
believes through helping others, she is helping herself. She states that,
“When people share their trouble with me about how they went to remand homes, I
know how it is to be an orphan but I have sister, so I always tell them to not think they
have no one there always somebody to take care of you. I feel very happy helping
them I don’t remember any bad felling when coming across my experience”. (SS,
personal communication, December 24, 2015)
103
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Participant 5 SP, talks about positive emotions she goes through when she is able to help
others. She too believes that helping others makes her feel accomplished and sustains this
pro-social behaviour.
“I feel very happy that I am able to do something for others too. And when I tell them,
they will pray and vent…and I have seen that it helps them too the way it helps me.
It’s all about trust I think. If we believe in something it will work”.(SP, personal
communication, December 30, 2015)
104
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Propositional model
MANIFESTS ITSELF
MANIFESTS ITSELF
LEADING TO
Figure 4: Representation of the Propositional Model for the Study
EXPERIENCE OF SOCIAL LABELLING&
STIGMATIZATION
Control and Restrictions by society Negative impact on development of self
Distorted thoughts and
deviant behaviour
Lowered Self- Worth,
Sadness, Guilt, Anger
SUPPORT SYSTEM AS AN INFLUENCER
Promoting adaptive coping
strategies
Happiness, Self – fulfilment,
increased self- concept
Reduction in repetition
of deviant behaviours
Increase in sharing and
pro-social behaviour
105
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
The propositional model focused on linking the main objective of the study to the
master themes that are derived from the data collected. The main objective of the study
wasto understand the experienceof social labelling and coping infemale adolescents in
conflict with the law. The master themes derived from the cross case analysis shows that the
results can evidently be placed in two categories.
The first and second master theme derived which are distorted social identity and
negative emotions of being labelled, and experience of social control, labels and
stigmatization, both focus on the development of distorted identities, feelings of low self-
worth, sadness, anger and guilt. Participants also showed that stigmatization was mostly
experienced by them through the control and restrictions placed on them by society over their
thoughts and behaviours. Participants also exhibited negative experiences of being labelled
such as loneliness, trust issues, abandonment, anger, vengefulness and remorse.
The third and fourth master themes being, the interface between support groups and
development of coping strategies and sharing of coping strategies promoting the development
of a positive self, show a more positive approach towards dealing with social labelling
phenomenon. This process generated and increased self- worth, competence, empathy,
happiness, satisfaction and overall growth. Support groups play a very important role in
generating adaptive methods of coping in children in conflict with the law. Development of
self and identity and adaptive feelings such as happiness, self-fulfilment and increase in self
concept can be seen though sharing of coping strategies with others facing similar difficulties.
Through this model one will be able to understand that social labelling is perceived
to be negatively affecting the development of identity and sense of self. Through the
experiences faced by the participants it can also be viewed that this negativity experienced by
them, influences the way they perceive society in general as well as any re-occurrence of
106
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
crime (McGrath &Weatherburn, 2012). Regarding coping, through the results of the study
and this model, support systems (authorities and peers at the centre), play a very important
role in help generating positive and adaptive methods of coping with stressful situations. The
model can also help in the generation of interventions for children in conflict with the law.
By educating the general population and individuals who have firsthand experience in
handling children in conflict with the law, one can help create conducive environment for
positive growth and lessen the occurrence and repetition of deviant behaviours.
107
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Chapter 5
Summary and Conclusion
Social labelling phenomenon dictates that when a child is being labelled, he/she is
found to internalise these labels and act upon them giving rise to a self- fulfilling prophecy.
This is seen as the idea/ experience of being tagged or labelled negatively by society. This
process is seen possible due to social interaction (O‟ Grady, 2011). When one deviates from
standard cultural norms, it gives rise to deviance. Children in conflict with the law express
this deviance towards the control and restrictions they perceive coming from society.
There is an imbalance that occurs when the stress created by society exceeds the
coping ability of the child. The confrontation with societal pressure and expectations has
probed this research to understand the pattern of coping that female adolescents in conflict
with the law adopt against being labelled. The current study focuses on understanding the
experience of social labelling and coping in female adolescents in conflict with the law.The
specific objectives are as listed below:
To understand the experience and perception of social labeling and the subjective
experience of being labeled.
To understand the coping strategies of female adolescents in conflict with the law in
rehabilitation centers who face or faced social labeling and are affected by it.
To analyze the reasons for adopting a certain coping strategy.
The study followed a qualitative research method using semi structured interviews
for data collection. Six female adolescents were interviewed and data was recorded and
analyzed using Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA).The individual case results
showed that each participant had generated their own perception of social labelling due to
negative experiences they have faced of heard of from someone close to them. Each
108
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
participant also had a different set of coping strategies to deal with social stigma such as
meditation, self- talk, praying, projecting feelings, venting and avoidance of stressful
situations. Most of the participants also stated to have faced loneliness, worthlessness, low
self-esteem and feelings of abandonment during some part in their lives. Relationship wise,
participants showed low trust towards others around them, strained relations with family,
generating new ideas around support groups being their true family and using their own
negative experiences to help others around them. The major findings of the study are listed
below.
Major Findings of the Study
The principle focus of the study aimed at understanding the experience of social
labelling and coping in female adolescents in conflict with the law. The researcher
performed case by case analysis and proceeded towards a cross case analysis using IPA
method. The findings are as follows:
1. There is a social identity and labelling interface that shows how this develops a
distorted sense of self that is seen to be generated through society.
2. Stigmatization leads to negative emotional experiences such as loneliness,
displacement of anger, abandonment, trust issues and low confidence, which were
feeling associated with being labelled
3. Having no control over own circumstances and feelings of being controlled and
restricted by society are experiences of social control, labels and stigmatization that
children in conflict with the law go through.
4. Experience of being labeled that shaped their perception,was seen through the
exhibition of negative effects of being labeled such as aggression, loneliness, low
109
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
interpersonal skills and trust issues. Perception of social labelingalso was generated
through other‟s experiences of social stigma.
5. Role of support groups in developing coping strategies was seen through overcoming
negative labeling experiences, developing new coping strategies, encouraging life
choices, building a strong sense of self and changing the perception of society in
children in conflict with the law.
6. Coping strategies adapted against social labeling were, acceptance of situations,
avoiding confrontations, rationalizations, analyzing difficulties, prayer, venting and
feeling of empathy for others.
7. Sharing coping strategies led to the development of a sound social identity, self-
fulfillment, increased self-image, self- concept and self- worth.
8. Adaptive feelings that were associated with sharing coping strategies were, freedom
to make own choices, feeling of satisfaction and positive emotions as outcome to
sharing behavior.
Limitations of the Study
1. Labelling theory largely seems to be focusing on adopting impractical policies which
has been critically looked upon as it does not tend to explain more serious crimes in
society which are considered universally wrong or deviant. Due to this factor
labelling can become an automatic response and not a conscious one.
2. The process of being labelled emphasizes on not the fault of individuals but that of
the society and family in inducing deviance, this can increase the repetition of
deviant behaviours.
3. Personality traits, Parenting styles and other phenomena could also be a reason for
deviance and concept of social labelling alone might not be able to explain it.
110
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
4. During the process of narration or questioning, the study might induce ideas in
children in conflict with law, which go against their wellbeing and establishing
coping patterns might be difficult.
Implications of the Study
1. The strong basis of the findings, create knowledge and insight about the wide spread
of the labelling phenomenon and will help in client empowerment, helpingthem cope
with labelling influences and how it can be managed in situations they face, more
effectively.
2. Various fields of Psychology can use this information as a base for understanding the
process of coping with social labels and its effects on the child‟s wellbeing.
3. Study shows that there are changes and influences that occur in the coping pattern of
children in conflict with the law, due to being labelled; therefore it would be helpful
to bring such changes in to the awareness of the participants.
4. Furthermore the study implies Psycho-educating the participants, families, authorities
and institutions/ managements involved on how to effectively manage stress.
5. Generate methods for effective emotional management and adaptive behaviours as
well as the awareness and guidance will help children in conflict with the law deal
with other elements that social labelling generates, such as stress, loneliness, anger
and helplessness more effectively.
6. Help in reduction of crime and deviance committed by children in conflict with the
law once they re-integrate back to society.
7. To probe further research on the relationship between societal labelling and crime as
well as factors and experiences that lead to deviance of social moral norms.
111
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Scope for Further Research
This study aimed at understanding the experience of social labeling phenomenon,
coping with social stigmas and reasons for adopting certain coping strategies. Many areas
can be researched upon using the information in this study:
1. Detailed study on the psychological processes of children in conflict with the law can
help understand their psyche. Further research can generate many helpful insights to
it.
2. Research can be conducted to understand authorities, parents or care-givers
perspective on the labeling phenomenon. This in turn might also be beneficial in
helping children handle intimacy and relationships in a much adaptive manner.
3. Learning about the coping strategies employed by different stigmatized groups such
as, orphans, child laborers, children below poverty line, disabled children and so on
will help generate interventions which can be applied to help cope with social stigma
positively. These interventions can enhance adaptive feelings such as worthiness,
self- image and self- concept in stigmatized populations.
4. Peer pressure and education influencing the repetition of deviant behaviors can be
further researched upon.
5. The study focused upon the idea of social stigma in female children in conflict with
the law. Research can also be undertaken to understand male perspectives on the
matter.
6. Psycho- educating the care- givers on the psychological processes of children and
providing guidance towards Career development in children in conflict with the law
are also topics that have good scope for research.
112
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
7. Research on proceedings of the juvenile justice system and understanding the
interface between deviance and labeling can help the general population to better
understand the concepts that come under social stigma.
The study on coping with social labeling in female adolescents in conflict with the
law concludes here with the understanding that factors which are involved in the labeling
phenomenon have strong emotional effects on children in conflict with the law. Care- givers/
support systems play a crucial role in generating adaptable coping strategies for these
children.
113
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
References
Asquith, S. (1996). Children and young people in conflict with the law. London: Jessica
Kingsley, 37-44
Banyard, V.L.,& Bermann, S.G. (2006). A gender analysis on theories of coping with stress.
Psychology of Women Quarterly, 17 (3), 303-318
Barriball, K. L,. & While, A. (1994). Collecting data using a semi-structured interview:
A discussion paper. J Adv Nurs Journal of Advanced Nursing, 19 (2), 328-335.
doi:10.1111/j.1365-2648.1994.tb01088.x
Baqutayan, Shadiya. (2011). Stress and Social Support.Indian Journal of Psychological
Medicine, 33(1), 29-34.
Beckett, K., & Herbert, S. (2010). Penal Boundaries: Banishment and the Expansion of
Punishment. Law & Social Inquiry, 35(1), 1-38. doi:10.1111/j.1747-
4469.2009.01176.x
Bernburg, J, G., & Krohn, M, D. ( 2003). Labelling, Life changes, and Adult Crime: The
Direct and Indirect Effects of Official Intervention in Adolescence on Crime in Early
Adulthood. Criminology, 41(4), 1287–1318. doi:10.1111/j.1745-
9125.2003.tb01020.x
Braun, V. & Clarke, V. (2006). Using Thematic Analysis in Psychology. Qualitative Research
in Psychology, 3 (2), 93.
Burke, P. J. (2006). Contemporary social psychological theories. Stanford, CA: Stanford
Social Sciences. 6, 111-114.
Carver, C. S., & Connor-S.J. (2010). Personality and Coping. Annual Review of
Psychology.61, 679–704.
114
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Carver, C.S., Scheier, M, F., & Weintraub, J, K. (1989). Assessing coping strategies: A
theoretically based approach. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 56(2),
267-283. doi:10.1037/002-3514.56.2.267
Chakrapani, C., & Kumar, S. V. (1994). Changing status and role of women in Indian
society. New Delhi: MD Publications. 356-361
Child Protection Information Sheet-UNICEF. (n,d.). Retrieved October 30, 2014, from
http://www.unicef.org/publications/files/Child_Protection_Information_Sheets.pdf
Compas, B.E., Connor- Smith, J. K., Saltzman, H., Thomsen, A. H., & Wadsworth, M. E.
(2001). Coping with stress during childhood and adolescence: Problems, progress
and potential in theory and research. Psychological Bulletin, 127 (1), 87-127.
doi:10.1037/0033-2909.127.1.87
The Indian Express. (n.d.). Retrieved December 12, 2014, from
http://indianexpress.com/tag/national-crime-records-bureau/
Feldman, M.P. (1977).Criminal behavior: A psychological analysis. Chichester: Wiley. 357-
365.
Folkman, S.,& Lazarus, S. R. (1988). Coping as a mediator of emotion. Journal of
Personality & Social Psychology, 54(3), 466-475.
Galinsky, A. D., Hugenberg, K., Groom, C., &Bodenhausen, G. V. (2003). The
Reappropriation of Stigmatizing Labels: Implications for Social Identity. Research on
Managing Groups and Teams, 221-256. doi:10.1016/s1534-0856(02)05009-0
Gaulin, S. J.,& McBurney, D. (2003). Evolutionary Psychology. Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Pearson/Prentice Hall, 121-142.
115
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Giorgi, A. (1970). Psychology as a human science/ a phenomenological based approach,
New York: Harper & Row.
Glasersfeld, E.V. (1999). Radical constructivism: A way of knowing and learning. London:
Falmer Press.
Goleman, D. The Brain and Emotional Intelligence. Retrieved October 30, 2014 from
http://danielgoleman.info/are-women-more-emotionally-intelligent-than-men/
Gredler, M. E. (1997). Learning and instruction: Theory into practice. Upper Saddle River,
NJ: Prentice-Hall. 54-62
Hagan, J. (1972). Labelling perspective, the delinquent, and the Police: A Review of
Literature. 14 Canadian Journal of Criminology & Corrections, 150.
Hagan, J. (1973). Labelling and Deviance: A Case Study in the “Sociology of the Interesting”
Social Problems, 20(4), 447-458. doi:10.1525/sp.1973.20.4.03a00050
Halsey. W, D. (2010). Macmillan dictionary for students. New York: Macmillan
Haveripet, P. (2013). Causes and Consequences of Juvenile Delinquency in India.Recent
Research in Science and Technology. 5(3), 29-31
Jackson, M., & Tisak, M.S. (2001). Developmental research on adolescence: European
perspectives for the 1990‟s and beyond. British Journal of Developmental
Psychology. 10(4), 319-337. doi:10.1111/j.2044-835x.1992.tb00581.x
Jane L.B., & Rebacca, C. A. (2005). Coping style and psychological health among adolescent
prisoners: A study of young and juvenile offenders. Journal of adolescents, 28(3),
411 – 423. doi:10.1016/j.adolescence.2004.11.002
Jones, A R. (1986). Emile Durkheim: An Introduction to Four Major Works. Beverly Hills,
CA: Sage Publications, 60-81
116
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Kalita, H. (2013).Juvenile Delinquency and India. Crimspace- The Criminology and Criminal
Justice Network, 1-6. doi:10.1002/9781118517383.wbeccj292
Kumar, A. K.,& Shiva. (1996). Gender equality and political participation: implications for
good health. Institute of Social & Gender Studies.1-
9.doi:10.1080/09589236.2014.964668
Kowalski, M.P. (2013). Learning disabilities, Juvenile Delinquency and the Family: The role
of Intensive Parenting. Australia: Cengage Learning/Wadsworth. 17 (1), 21-41.
Kruger, L., & Schoombee, C. (2010). The Other Side of Caring: Abuse in a South African
Maternity Ward. Journal of Reproductive and Infant Psychology, 28(1), 84-
101.doi:10.1080/02646830903294979
Larkin, M.W.S., & Clifton, E.(2006). Giving voice and making sense in interpretative
phenomenological analysis. S..: S.n. 32, 102-120.
Leary, M. R., & Tangney, J. P. (2003). Handbook of Self and Identity. NewYork: Guilford
Press.
Lazarus, R. S., & Folkman, S.(1984). Stress, Appraisal, and coping. New York: Springer
Pub.
Lazarus, R. S., &Folkman, S. (1988). Coping as a mediator of emotion. Journal of
Personality and Social Psychology, 54(3), 466-475.
Lemert, E.M. (1972). Human deviance, social problems and social control, (2), 277.
Lemert.E.M. (1967). Human Deviance, Social Problems and Social Control. Englewood
Cliffs, NJ: Printice Hall.
117
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Link, B.G., & Phelan, J.C. (2001). Conceptualizing stigma. Annual Review of Sociology, 27,
363-385.
Literacy Rate in India. (n.d.). Retrieved September 17, 2015, from
http://www.mapsofindia.com/census2011/literacy-rate.html
McGrath, A., & Weatherburn, D. (2012). The effect of custodial penalties on juvenile
reoffending. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology,45(1), 26-
44.doi:10.1177/0004865811432585
McLeod. S.A.(n.d.).Social Roles. Retrieved April, 2008, from
http://www.simplypsychology.org/social-roles.html
McMahon, M. (1997).Social Constructivism and the World Wide Web - A Paradigm for
Learning. New York: Teachers College Press.
Becker, S.H. (1963). Labelling theory: Social constructionism, Social stigma,
Deinstitutionalisation, Labelling. Gale Ecco, U S Supreme C
Mead, G. H. (1934). Mind, Self, and Society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Nataraj, P. (2004). Psychology. Srinivasa Publication.1, 88.
Nickalls, S. (n.d.). The Unexpected benefit of being nice According to Science. Retrieved
July 20, 2015 from http://hellogiggles.com/benifits -nice-science/2/#read.
O'Grady, W. (2011). Crime in Canadian Context. Ontario: Oxford University Press.
Paternoster, R.,& Iovanni, L. (2006). Labelling perspective and delinquency: An elaboration
of the theory and assessment of the evidence. 359-394.
Prat, R. S., & Floden, R. E. (1994). Philosophical Perspectives on Constructivist
118
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Views of Learning.Educational Psychologist, 29(1), 37-48.
Reid, K., Flowers, P., & Larkin, M. (2007). Exploring Lived Experiences: An Introduction to
Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis. The Psychologist, 18(1), 20-23.
Rentzsch, K., Schröder-Abé, M. &Schütz, A. (2013).Being called a Streber. The Roles of
Personality and Competition in the Labelling of Academically Oriented
Students. European Journal of Personality, 27, 411-427.
Rogoff, B. (1990). Apprenticeship in thinking: cognitive development in social
context. New York: Oxford University Press.
Schutz,A. (1970). Some Structures of the Life-World. Phaenomenologica. 22, 116-132
Siegel, L.J., &Welsh, b. (2011). Juvenile delinquency:Theory, practice, and law. Belmont,
CA: Wadsworth Cengage Learning
Smith , J, A., & Osborn, M.(2007). Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis, 53-54
Smith, J, A., Flowers, P.,& Larkin, M.(2009). Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis:
Theory, Method and Research. 79-105
Smith, P. K., Cowie, H., & Blades, M. (1998). Understanding Children’s Development.
Massachusetts: Blackwell Publishers.
Sontag, L. M.,Graber, J.A., Brooks-Gunn, J., &Warren, M.P. (2008). Coping with Social
Stress: Implications for Psychopathology in Young Adolescent Girls.Journal of
Abnormal Child Psychology. 36(8), 1159-1174. doi:10.1007/s10802-008-9239-3
Snyder, C.R.(1999) Coping: The Psychology of What Works. New York: Oxford University
Press.
Stevens, R. (1983). Erik Erikson: an introduction. New York: St. Martin's Press.
119
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Tannenbaum, F. (1938). Crime and Community. London and New York: Columbia
University Press
Thomas, C.,& Cage, R. (1977).The Effect of Social Characteristics on Juvenile Court
Dispositions: The Sociological Quarterly, 18(2), 237–252
UNICEF. United Nations Children‟s Emergency Fund. (n.d.). Retrieved October 15,2014,
from http://www.unicef.org/
Vito, G. F., Jeffery R. M,.& Ronald M. H.(2006). Criminology: Theory, Research and Policy.
Sudbury: Jones & Bartlett. Print.
Willing, C. (2001).Introducing qualitative research in psychology: Adventures in theory and
method. Buckingham: Open University Press.
120
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Appendix A
Consent Form for Participation in a Research Study
Christ University
EXPERIENCE OF COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE
ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Description of the research and your participation
You are invited to participate in a research study conducted by Mili Reddy, currently
pursuing a Masters of Philosophy in Psychology program, under the guidance of Dr. Tissy
Mariam, Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology, Christ University.
The purpose of this research is to understand the experience of social labelling and coping
strategies adopted and propagated in female adolescents in conflict with the law.
Your participation will involve providing the researcher with an interview, lasting for about
one hour.
Should you choose to participate in this research, you will be given due recognition
for your contribution in the event of it being published, albeit in anonymous form. This
research may further help the researcher to gain a better understanding of Juvenile
perspective(s) of how they cope with trauma and abandonment, create strategies to deal with
difficult social situations and reasons for choosing certain coping method as sharing the same
with other individuals in similar situations.
Protection of confidentiality
The researcher will ensure that your privacy is maintained and that the information
you provide will be kept strictly confidential. Your identity will not be revealed in any
121
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
publication regarding this study. Tapes and transcripts will be numbered and stored safely.
The data will be revealed to concerned authorities and the institution, only after gaining your
permission to do so.
Voluntary participation
Your participation in this research study is voluntary. You may choose not to
participate and you may withdraw your consent to participate at any time. You will not be
penalized or questioned in any way should you decide not to participate or to withdraw from
this study.
Contact information
If you have any questions or concerns about this study or if any problems arise, please
contact the researcher [email protected]
Ph. No: 7829069702
Consent
I have read this consent form and have been given the opportunity to ask questions. I
give my consent to participate in this study.
Participant‟s signature_______________________________ Date: _________________
122
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Appendix B
Demographic details of the participants
Demographic sheet
Name:
Age:
Years spent in the remand home or rehabilitation centre:
Education:
Socio Economic Status:
Languages known:
Personal Details:
1. Can you tell me something about yourself?
2. What are your interests?
3. Can we talk about your friends?
4. Who are you most comfortable with?
Relationship with primary care givers:
1. Can you describe your relationship with your care giver(s)?
2. Who are you closer to in your family? Who do you spend most time with?
3. Could you describe your role in or some activities you do in your family?
4. Could you describe your relationship with your care giver(s)?
5. Can we talk about your relationship with your siblings?
123
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
About self in relation with others:
1. Can you describe your relations with others?
2. Could you talk about your feelings when you‟re with your friends?
3. Can we discuss instances where you have had negative experiences from society?
4. Do have any idea about how your relatives, neighbours and friends perceive you as a
person?
Subordinate questions:
1. Have you ever looked back into your history to explore the experiences that have
shaped you into the person you are today?
2. What are the major feelings you went through during the times you spent in the
remand home or rehabilitation centre?
3. Have you ever thought of how your future would be?
124
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
Appendix C
Semi Structured Questionnaire
EXPERIENCE OF COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE
ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
(Social labelling: deals with the phenomenon of majority of the population attach stigmatizing labels/
name calling, to the minorities or persons viewed as to being deviant from standard cultural norms.)
1. Think about the time you have been here at the centre or at a remand home,
please discuss if you have faced or experienced social labelling by the
authority, peers, family or society.
2. How has the experience affected your work and functioning?
3. Let us talk about the people involved in the experience?
4. What are the ways you dealt/ deal with the experience in your life?
5. How are you been able to manage it?
6. Let us discuss about the difficulties you have faced in coping with labelling
and how has it affected you?
7. How do you view social experiences? How has it changed the way you see
society?
8. What are the major changes that took place in your life due to being labelled?
9. What are the ways that the centre can help you to deal with the difficulties you
face?
10. Which are the support systems you have come across? How have they helped
you cope with labelling?
11. Shall we talk about the reasons you chose this pattern of coping?
12. Let us talk about sharing your pattern of coping with others at the centre?
125
COPING WITH SOCIAL LABELLING IN FEMALE ADOLESCENTS IN CONFLICT WITH LAW
13. Let‟s talk about the experience of sharing your coping strategies with others
facing similar situations or difficulties.
14. What are the ways they have been able to incorporate your methods to deal
with their difficulties related to being labelled?
15. How does this make you feel about yourself and the people involved?
16. What are the reasons why you share your coping strategies with others?
17. Discuss experiences, functioning, processing, coping, precautions.