ETIPWind Steering Committee Meetingetipwind.eu/files/events/160307-ETIPWind-Steering... · 2019-12-09 · Agreement on ETIPWind Work Programme2016. ... * EERA to confirm the other

MARCH 7 2016 Rue d’Arlon 80, 1040Bruxelles

Agenda

11:00 –

11:30

Welcome

Introduction of participants

11:30 –

12:00

ETIPWind Governance

Communication of the structure and governance ofETIPWind.

Appointment of “2nd” to the ETIPWind SC representative.

12:00 –

12:45

ETIPWind Work Programme 2016 - approval

Based on the draft ETIPWind Work Programme distributed by the secretariat a discussion of theWork

Programme 2016 will be calledfor.

Agreement on ETIPWind Work Programme2016.

12:45 –

13:30

Lunch

13:30 – Strategic Research Agenda (SRA)

• The methodology on collecting data for writing the “status report on the implementation of the SRA and

the SET-Plan integrated roadmap including analysis of short, medium and long term priorities for future

wind energy related topics” will be presented

15:30

15:30– Validation workshop delivering input to the Horizon 2020 Energy Programme 2018 -2020

16:15 Communication about the planed workshop validating the key content of the SRA 2016

Discussion of topic for the workshop 01 taking place 26 or 27 September 2016, Hamburg.

16:15 – AOB and next step

16:45 Next step and AOB

Political momentum

“Europe is to become #1 in the next generation of renewables worldwide”

Jean Claude Juncker, European CommissionPresident

COP 21 – ParisAgreement

Politicalmomentum

5 Pillars:

Security of Supply

Internal Energy Market

Energy Efficiency

Emissions Reduction

Research and Innovation

SET-Plan

Towards an Integrated Strategic Energy Technology (SET) Plan: Accelerating the European Energy System Transformation C(2015) 6317

• SET-Plan 10 actions to accelerate the energy system

transformation:

1: Sustain technological leadership by developing highly

performant renewabletechnologies and their integration in the

EU’s energy system.

2: Reduce cost of keytechnologies.

3: etc…

https://setis.ec.europa.eu/system/files/Communication_SET-Plan_15_Sept_2015.pdf

SET-plan

Delivering on the SET-Plan priority actions:

For each of the 10 priority actions the EC will define

with MS:

A: The level of ambition (in terms of prioritiesand

funding).

B: The modalities for implementation.

C: The timing for achieving results and adopting

expected deliverables.

Horizon2020 timeline

Nearly doubling of non-nuclear energy research funding (from € 3.8bn in FP7 + CIP to €

5.6bn in H2020).

€ 1,099.000.000*for non-nuclear low carbon energy research andinnovation

H2020 budget 2018 -2020

EU funding granted for windenergy projects:

Program Period Funding

EU research programmesFP1-FP7 1984-2013 € 528m

European Energy programme for Recovery(EEPR) 2009 € 565m

NER300 2011 € 340m

European Investment Bankloans 2005-2013 € 11.5bn

EU Cohesion policy (Structuralfunds) 2007-2013 € 666m

Horizon2020 2014-2020 € 5.6 bn (available tonon-

nuclear energy)

InnovFin (EIB + H2020) 2014 -2020 € 24 bn (available to allsectors)

What are ETIPs?

What areETIPs

European Technology and Innovation Platform’s

“…European Technology Platforms are industry-led stakeholder fora recognised by the

European Commission as key actors in driving innovation, knowledge transfer and European

competitiveness. These platforms develop research and innovation agendas and roadmaps

for action at EUand national level to be supported by both private and public funding. They

mobilise stakeholders to deliver on agreed priorities and share information across theEU.”

EWEA R&Iactivities

WG R&I

R&I

CTO

EWEA

BOARD

Ap

pro

valG

uid

ance

Alignment

Adoption

WGR&I

Proposal

R&ICTO

Sign-off

EWEABoard

Formal

adoption

ETIPGovernance

SECR.

EW

EA R

&IA

CTIV

ITIE

S

ET

IP

AC

TIV

ITI

ES

R&ICTO

Ap

pro

va

l

Gu

ida

nc

e

Alignment

EWEA

BOARD

Adoption

Steering

Committee24

EERA

8

WGR&I

16

EERA INDUSTRY

ETIP WIND STEERINGCOMMITTEE

R&ICTO

GROUP

ETIP WIND ADVISORYGROUP

ETIP WINDSECRETARIAT

SECRETARIATHosted by EWEA

ETIPWindStructure

ETIPWind Steering Committee

Organisation First name Family nameA2SEA JesperT. Kristensen

ABB Adrian Timbus

DNV GL Lars Landberg

Dong Energy Wind Power Jørn ScharlingHolm

E.ON Climate & Renewables Ralph Chamberlain

EDF EnergiesNouvelles Stéphanie Muller

Iberdrola RenewableEnergy César Yanes Baonza

LM Wind Power John Korsgaard

MHI Vestas OffshoreWind Anders BachAndersen

Renewable EnergySystems Mike Anderson

Senvion Martin Knops

Siemens Wind Power Aidan Cronin

Statoil Rune Yttervik

Vestas Agnar Gudmundsson

EERA JP Wind Coordinator Peter Hauge Madsen

EERA Offshore WindEnergy JohnO. Tande

* EERA to confirm the other academia representatives in the ETIPWind Steering Committee at its AGM in April2016.

ETIPWind Advisory GroupOrganisation Firstname Familyname

A2SEA Hans Schneider

Siemens Wind Power (Chair) Ruediger Knauf

ABB Ernst Scholtz

Acciona Miguel Nunes Polo

Adwen Representation TBC

Dong Energy Wind Power Christina Aabo

E.ON Climate & Renewables Jorgen Bodin

EDF EnergiesNouvelles Pierre-Guy Therond

EDPRenewables Jorge Casillas

ENEL GreenPower Fabrizio Bizzarri

GE Power & WaterRenewables Representation TBC

Iberdrola RenewableEnergy Cristina Heredero

LM Wind Power Roel Schurring

MHI Vestas Offshore Wind Torben Hvid Larsen

Nordex Jorge Scholle

Renewable EnergySystems Mike Anderson

Senvion Bernhard Telgmann

Statoil Rajnish Sharma

Vattenfall Ole Bigum Nielsen

Vestas Anders Vedel

ETIPWind Work Programme 2016

Proposed deliverables:

• Launch ETIPWind website: Link

• Update the SRA

• Input to other research and innovationprocesses

• Workshop and events

Timeline:

MARCH

Launch of website Online survey Validation workshop

• Release of SRA

• Implementation Plan to Global

Leadership in Offshore Wind

• Workshop on R&I

APRIL JUNE SEPTEMBER

http://etipwind.eu/

Analyst input

Presented by Daniel Fraile

Kick off meeting

Data collection

Industryand stakeholder

surveyGapAnalysis

Validation workshop

MARCH JUNEMAYAPRILMARCH/

APRIL

Outline

• WP1 in anutshell

• Objective of the meeting

• Methodological steps- Presentation and discussion

WP1 in a Nutshell

• Objective

• Assess the level of implementation of the R&l priorities from

SRA/MDS & SET-Plan Integrated Roadmap (SET-PlanIR)

• Provide for recommendations for short, medium and long term

priorities for future R&Ipriorities.

• Inform about the latest technological developments,investment

trends in R&l, regulatory and market frameworks affecting the

implementation of the SRA/MDS and the SET-PlanIR.

• Deliverables

• Detailed work plan: Done

• Status report: implementation of R&I + R&I priorities (Sept 2016)

• Updated status report: implementation of R&I + R&I priorities

(May2018)

WP1 in a Nutshell

Kick-off Meeting

• March

Data Collection

• Feb-March

Survey

• April

Gap Analysis

• May

Validation workshop

• June

Status Report

• Sept

• Methodology andTimeline

1 2 3 4 5 6

Objective of this meeting

1. Align expectations

2. Present Methodology

• Present ongoing work on step 2 (datacollection)

• Feedback and open questions

• Identification of experts

• Detailed discussion on step 3 (survey)

• Type of survey (length, scope,timing)

• Target list

• Initial discussion on Step 4 (Gapanalysis)

• Criteria for weighting ofR&I priorities

• Open Discussion

• Analysis is based on the

SRA/MDS 5 main pillars

• R&I Topics within the SET-

Plan integrated roadmap

are well represented in the

SRA/MDA

Step 2. Data Collection


• 28 Sub-categories under 5 Pillars. About 120 R&Itopics

Pillar Sub-category

External

condition:

climate,

wavesand

soil

1.1Measurement systems

1.2Interaction climate-wind turbines

1.3Multi-scale modelling

1.4Wakes

1.5Forecasting

1.6Condition monitoring

1.7Standardization

Wind

turbine

system

s

2.1Wind turbine as a flowdevice

2.2Wind turbine as mechanical

structures/materials

2.3Wind turbine as a grid connectedelectricityplant

2.4Wind turbine as a controlsystem

2.5Innovative concepts along the valuechain and integrated design

2.6Operation and maintenance (O&M)

2.7Standards and certification

Pillar Sub-category

Windenergy

integration

3.1wind power capabilities for ancillary

services provision

3.2Grid connection, transmission and

operation

3.3grid management and powermarkets

Offshore

technolo

gy

4.1Sub-structures

4.2Logistics, assembly and decommissioning

4.3Electrical infrastructure

4.4Wind turbines

4.5Operation and maintenance

4.6External conditions

Market

deployme

nt strategy

5.1Enabling market deployment

5.2Adapting policies

5.3Optimising administrative procedures

5.4Integrating wind to the natural environment

5.5Ensuring public acceptance of windpower


INPUT-Two work streams for eachsub-category:

1. Quantitative: based on Key conferences proceedings

• EWEA annualconferences

• Offshore EWEAconferences

• EWEA technicalworkshops

• Wind Integration workshop

• 3 years analysis- number of conf. papers & posters

2. Qualitative: Analysis of most relevant scientific

papers, publicly-funded project supported by experts

views (phone interviews)

• Interview guidelines

• 2-3 experts per pillar

•


OUTCOME-Two work streams for eachsub-category:

1. Quantitative:

• Traffic light table- indicators of activities (relativeto

overall efforts and over time)

2. Qualitative:

• Short update on progress and wayforward

• A list of key projects, and peer-reviewedpapers.

Step 2. Data Collection (First Results)Total

Index Category sub-category 2 0 1 3 2 0 1 4 2 0 1 5

1.1 External conditions Measurement systems 22 1 8

1.4 External conditions Wakes 11 9 25

1.5 External conditions Forecasting 22

21

61 60

1.6 External conditions Condition monitoring 2 18

2.1 Wind turbine systems Wind turbine as a flowdevice 11 12 4

2.2 Wind turbine systems Wind turbine as mechanical 50 14 15

2.3 Wind turbine systems Wind turbine as a grid connected electricity 32 26 42

422.4 Wind turbine systems Wind turbine as a control system 51 30

2.5 Wind turbine systems Innovative concepts along the value chainand 11 1 8

2.6 Wind turbine systems Operation and maintenance (O&M) 45 82 43

3.1 Wind energy integration wind power capabilities for ancillary services 34 32 26

3.2 Wind energy integration Grid connection, transmission and operation 48 34 44

3.3 Wind energy integration grid management and power markets 52 49 32

4.1 Offshore technology Sub-structures 42

54

51

0

0

48

38

384.2 Offshore technology Logistics, assembly and decommissioning

4.3 Offshore technology Electrical infrastructure 35

4.4 Offshore technology Wind turbines 32 0 62

4.5 Offshore technology Operation and maintenance 33 0

0

18

4.6 Offshore technology External conditions 17 38

5.1 Market deployment strategy Enabling market deployment 2 4 29

5.2 Market deployment strategy Adapting policies 4 0 0

5.3 Market deployment strategy Optimising administrative procedures 6 5 2

5.4 Market deployment strategy Integrating wind to the natural environment 20 20 27

5.5 Market deployment strategy Ensuring public acceptance of wind power 4 4 2

Step 2. Data Collection (First Results)conference papers

Index Category sub-category 2013 2014 2015

1.1 External conditions Measurement systems 5 0 3

1.4 External conditions Wakes 4 2 6

1.5 External conditions Forecasting 4 17 12

1.6 External conditions Condition monitoring 0 1 1

2.1 Wind turbine systems Wind turbine as a flowdevice 7 2 0

2.2 Wind turbine systems Wind turbine as mechanical 10 8 4

2.3 Wind turbine systems Wind turbine as a grid connectedelectricity 27 20 36

2.4 Wind turbine systems Wind turbine as a controlsystem 16 5 20

2.5 Wind turbine systems Innovative concepts along the value chain and 4 1 1

2.6 Wind turbine systems Operation and maintenance (O&M) 8 42 12

3.1 Wind energy integration wind power capabilities for ancillary services 31 29 22

3.2 Wind energy integration Grid connection, transmission and operation 30 22 34

3.3 Wind energy integration grid management and power markets 35 35 24

4.1 Offshore technology Sub-structures 42 0 38

4.2 Offshore technology Logistics, assembly and decommissioning 54 0 38

4.3 Offshore technology Electrical infrastructure 28 39 21

4.4 Offshore technology Wind turbines 32 0 62

4.5 Offshore technology Operation and maintenance 33 0 18

4.6 Offshore technology External conditions 17 0 38

5.1 Market deployment strategy Enabling market deployment 1 0 7

5.2 Market deployment strategy Adapting policies 4 0 0

5.3 Market deployment strategy Optimising administrative procedures 2 5 1

5.4 Market deployment strategy Integrating wind to the natural environment 5 13 11

5.5 Market deployment strategy Ensuring public acceptance of wind power 4 0 0

Conference Posters

2013 2014 2015

17 1 5

7 7 19

18 44 48

21 1 17

4 10 4

40 6 11

5 6 6

35 25 22

7 0 7

37 40 31

3 3 4

18 12 10

17 14 8

0 0 0

0 0 0

23 9 14

0 0 0

0 0 0

0 0 0

1 4 22

0 0 0

4 0 1

15 7 16

0 4 2

Step 2. Data Collection (First Results)

First results

Caveats:

• Market development strategy- not well covered

• Overall more papers for offshore and grid integration

• Offshore conference is bi-annual

FirstObservations:

• Grid integration & offshore: most popular categories (largededicated

annual conferences)

• External conditions assessment concentrating mostly in off-shore

environment

• Forecasting among top topics within External conditions assessment.

• Within Turbine systems: grid related aspects & O&M the mostaddressed.


Issues and open questions:

• Level of analysis- sub-category vs R&I topics

• Offshore& O&M vs. Capabilities for ancillaryservices

• Authorship of papers (Industry vs. academia, EU vsGlobal)

• Pillar 5 (Energy policy and environmental issues): not really

well covered in technical sessions of EWEAEvents.


OUTCOME-Two work streams for eachsub-category:

1. Quantitative:

• Traffic light table- indicators of activities (relativeto

overall efforts and over time)

2. Qualitative:

• Short update on progress and wayforward

• A list of key projects, and peer-reviewedpapers.


Projects overview on grid integration (analysisongoing)

TopicScope Project title Scope

Funding

source

Results

published

3.1 REPlan National Denmark 2015

3.1 3.3 REServices EU-wide EC-funded 2014

3.1 3.2 3.3 Twenties EU-wide EC-funded 2014

3.3 E-Highways EU-wide EC-funded

BestPaths EU-wide EC-funded

3.1 3.3 R2Wind National Industry 2015

3.2

TenneT AC Projects in Schleswig-

Holstein National Industry 2015

4.3 OffshoreDCProject 2014


External conditions: climate, waves andsoil

1.1Measurement systems

Tomas Blodau, Senvion

Taylor Geer, DNV GL

Breanne Gellatly, AXYS

1.2Interaction climate-wind

turbinesLars Landberg, DNV GL

1.3Multi-scale modellingHans Ejsing Jørgensen, DTU

Gil Lizcano, Vortex

1.4WakesJan Coelingh, Nuon

Mike Courtney, DTU

1.5ForecastingLars Landberg, DNV GL

Beatrice Brailey, R&D Specialist, Forecasting DNV GL

1.6Condition monitoring

Hans Ejsing Jørgensen, DTU

Simon Watson, Loughborough University

Sergio Velez, Gamesa

1.7Standardization

Identifying experts (ongoingwork)


Wind turbine systems

2.1Wind turbine as a flow device

Christiane Montavon, ANSYS UK Ltd. /

Peter Eecen, ECN/

Bernard Stoevesandt, Fraunhofer-IWES

2.2Wind turbine asmechanical

structures/materials

Gerard van Bussel, TU Delft / Po Weng Chen,

University of Stuttgart

2.3Wind turbine as a grid connected

electricity plantMike Anderson, RESLtd

2.4Wind turbine as a control system

William Leithead, University of Strathclyde/

Marta Barreras, Gamesa /

Ervin Bossanyi, DNV GL

2.5Innovative concepts along the value

chain and integrated design

Peter Jamieson, Senior Technology Advisor,

University of Strathclyde, UnitedKingdom

2.6Operation and maintenance(O&M)Simon Watson, Loughborough Unversity

Stefan Schlie, Siemens

2.7Standards and certification




Offshore technology

4.1Sub-structures

4.2Logistics, assemblyand

decommissioning

4.3Electrical infrastructure

4.4Wind turbines

Jesper Mansson, Director, Technical

Business Development, LM Wind Power,

Denmark

4.5Operation and maintenance

Elaine Greig, Head of Department, Offshore

Renewables, DNV GL, United Kingdom

4.6External conditions


Market deployment strategy

5.1Enabling market deploymentChristian Jourdain, Gamesa

Michaela O’Donohue,Adwen

5.2Adapting policies

5.3Optimising administrative

procedures

5.4Integrating wind to thenatural

environment

Jeremy Bass, Senior Technical Manager, RES

Tomas Blodau Head of Department Wind andSite,

Senvion

5.5Ensuring public acceptanceof

wind power

Pia Dorfinger, Deutsche Energie-Agentur GmbH

(dena), Germany


Step 3. Industry & Stakeholders survey

Part 1. Assessment level of implementation (sub-category

level- 28)

• Q1. Rate how important is this R&I are for the windsector?

(from 1 to 5)

• Q2. How important do you consider public funding in this

R&I area? (from 1 to 5)

• Q3. What has been the level of research activity in thisfield

in the last 2-3 years? (cold to hot)

Part 2 .Assessment: priority level (R&I level- for selected

sub-categories- Potentially 120 topics )

Question only applying for those rated [4-5] in Q1

• Q4. Rate level of importance of this R&Itopic?

• Q5. What should be the horizon of implementation

(short,mid, long)?

• Q6. Please refer to key papers, projects and

advancement on high priority R&Itopics?

• Q7. Are there other missing R&Itopics?


Communication

• Open to anyone (available at ETIP, EWEA and ECwebsite)

• 3 weeks

• Input treated confidentially- Surveymonkeytool

Target list

• Member of the previous TPWind workinggroups

• Member of EWEA Working Group meetings (offshore,

networks, grid codes, marketdesign)

• Key contacts identified through ETIP Steeringcommittee

• Targeted EWEA mailinglist


Open Questions

• How to balance accuracy of answers withwide

participation?

• Should we have two parallel surveys (onshorevs

offshore)?

Step 4. GapAnalysis

Objective: matching internal findings withsurvey input

Additional

Criteria?

Step 4. GapAnalysis

Outcome of Gap Analysis -> Material for Validationworkshop

• Matrix of R&I topic with indicators

• Discussion paper- result from gapanalysis

Validation Workshop (Step 5)- 3June

Step 4. GapAnalysis

Issues and open questions:

• Which additional criteria needed for assessing (weighting)R&I

topics?

• Is there any need to rank the selected R&Itopics?

Workshop on wind research in a specific

area TBCtoday

Workshop objective: discuss an area of focus of revisedSRA

with wider community to provide additional input

Target audience: industry, academia, research,policy

Venue: EWEA Annual Conference, Congress CentreHamburg

Date: (tentative) afternoon of27 September 2016 (day 1 of

event)

Topic suggestions:

1. Grid Systems, infrastructure and integration

2. Operation & maintenance

3. Industrialisation

4. Offshore Balance of Plant

Topic1 Grid Systems, infrastructure and integration

Sub-

topics

Wind power grid integration, including energy management and balancing

Improved long-distance transmission systems foron-and offshore wind farms incl. installation andO&M

Energy Storage and conversion, including storageat turbine, wind farm and central levels

Innovative, comprehensive and re-configurable energy systems level test facilities

Topic2 Operation & maintenance

Sub-

topics

Standardised and validated methods andsensor

systems for performance measurements and

condition monitoring

Improvements in energy yield from wind farms

through utilization of adaptive and interactivebig

data control

Improvements in reliability and predictability ofwind farms

Data analysis to improve diagnostics anddecision-making

Lifetime optimisation

Topic3 Industrialisation

Sub-

topics

Sequential (in order of LCOE-impact)

standardisation and industrialisation of

requirements, quality standards, materials,

processes, manufacturing and handling/logisticsof

components and systems

Standardisation component testmethods

Development of industrialised, scalable methodologies

Topic4 Offshore Balance of Plant

Sub-topics

Industrialised transport and installationsystems

Innovative and industrialised offshore towersand

foundations, including better understanding of

seabed interactions

Methodologies for analysis of turbine

substructure interaction on and stationkeeping

of floating wind turbines

Innovative and industrialised offshore substations

and cables

Thank you very much for your attention

Documents

ETIPWind Steering Committee Meetingetipwind.eu/files/events/160307-ETIPWind-Steering... · 2019-12-09 · Agreement on ETIPWind Work Programme2016. ... * EERA to confirm the other