Upload
vipan-bhatia
View
225
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
1/30
1
1. INTRODUCTION
It is a very sad reflection on the reputation of politicians in the Western world
that the title of this session "Ethics and Politics," is perceived as an oxymoron, ethics
and politics don't seem to go together. Politicians are generally considered to be the
least trustworthy professionals. This is a long - and widely - held view expressed in
numerous aphorisms.
1.1 POLITICS WITHOUT ETHICS
On 15th August 1947 when India after centuries of foreign domination started breathing
fresh air of wisdom, none would have thought that this very fresh air would turn foul
and with the passage of time, get so much contaminated that it would poison the whole
of the countrys democratic set up and the persons to whom the responsibility of
governing the country is given would be the fountain head of such contaminated air.
The present day politicians, the leaders governing the country, are obsessed with the
monomania to loot the country and fill their own coffers, could be seen fighting for the
bone like the snarling stray dogs on the street. Power by any means is their aim and this
leads to the birth of conspiracy, murder, forging a network of like-minded politicians
and bureaucrats and mafia. Now-a-days politics has become a lucrative profession,
wherein prior investment of money and muscle power to grab the chair once is
sufficient to feed the several generations and gives one the status and respectful position
in society. Politicians are very much willing to liaise with any political party so long as
it serves their interest. Trading and defection among the political parties have become a
common practice. A number of scam cases are pending before the courts, relating to
misappropriation, frauds, corruptions in which the present day politicians are
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
2/30
2
shamelessly involved. The definition of politicians has since modified by these
politicians tearing every fabric of morality and ethics.
Talking of ethics in terms of politicians is the most traumatic joke of the day. In every
big scandal, whether, Telgi Stamp Case, Jain Dairy Case, bank security scam, Tehelka
Case, Hawala case, Fodder scam, we find wires connected to some powerful politicians.
Many politicians have reached the nadir of immortality when as a last ditch effort to
grab power, they resort to both capturing and rigging with the help of criminals and
dreaded gangsters. A leader in the office has the authority to direct the course of
nations socio-economical development. He enjoys the powers to make policies for
developmental activities to be initiated at a macro level. But if he himself becomes
corrupt, spells unethical and immoral acts it can wreck havoc on the country. The ills of
communalism, casteism, nepotism have gradually become the necessity of political
arena. Rightly observed by our late Prime Minister Sh. Rajiv Gandhi, that out of 100
only 17% is actually spent on the developmental work and rest goes into the pockets of
officials and politicians. today our country has acquired many ills such as corruption,
casteism, communalism, etc all because the leaders have forgotten their moral and
ethical duties towards their Motherland and have the motto to grab the power and earn
money by any means.
People have lost faith in their leaders. The youth are disillusioned, are moving to the
west for higher education, and then settle there permanently. Voters have become
increasingly indifferent towards the process of election. The situation is undoubtedly
grave. It is not appropriate to blame the politicians alone. It is even the public that is
responsible in making the politicians corrupt, unethical, and goons. Even the most
rational approach to ethics is defenceless if there isnt the will to do what is right
It is not to conclude that all the politicians are corrupt and unethical. The hope lies with
such honest, dedicated and devoted politicians who have sacrificed a lot for the welfare
of this nation. It is high time that we enforce a code of conduct to stem the root and
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
3/30
3
begin this exercise. A transparency in the working is very urgently needed. Responsible
opposition and the media can play a vital role in exposing the immoral and unethical
corrupt politicians. Let us generate a ray of hope that the people of country use their
rights and duties in favour of dedicated, sincere and honest leaders for the good of
themselves and for the welfare of this great nation. We need timeless principles to steer
by in running our organizations and building our personal careers. We need high
standards the ethics of excellence.
1.2 ETHICS AND POLITICAL LEADERSHIP
Einstein once famously said that the twentieth century was characterized by perfection
of means and confusion of ends. Over the past six decades, our politicians have
certainly mastered the art of acquiring power without purpose. Power has become an
end in itself. In India, this quest for power has been largely disconnected from public
purpose. The notion of ethical leadership is limited to a few symbolic leaders to be
paraded before the public to enhance saleability of a party. And morality is at best
limited to private conduct, and rarely extended to public duty.
In a democracy, there is always a conflict between the slow rate of social pay off that
results from sound policies and the short-term political price you have to pay in pursuit
of them. True leadership is the ability to reconcile the two and promote long-term
public good.
A far more dangerous threat is the loss of purpose for leadership. In the corridors of
power, most often all that matters is who is in and who is out; and notions of morality,
constitutionalism and public good are inconvenient abstractions. Serious imbalance in
exercise of power has accelerated this decline of political morality. If power is defined
as the ability to influence events, resources and behaviour for the larger public good,
such positive power is severely curtailed in our public sphere. We have created a
messy, unaccountable, non-performing system in which there are a million legitimate
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
4/30
4
alibis for political failure. But if power is defined as pelf, privilege, patronage, petty
tyranny and plain nuisance value, then every state functionaryfrom the mighty to the
humble exercises such negative power in ample measure; and there are very few
safeguards against abuse of office.
Three factors led to a crisis of leadership in India. First, unlike during freedom
struggle, the best minds and hearts have shunned politics and the vacuum is filled
mostly by those who converted politics into commerce. Ethical leadership is
increasingly marginalized.
Second, our first-past-the-post electoral system gives exaggerated importance to the
marginal vote. In our system, one more vote means victory, and one less vote leads todefeat. On top of it, the middle classes habitually stay away from the polling booths,
and the poor vote in large numbers as the vote gives them some dignity and bargaining
power. The politicians and traditional parties have cynically used the vulnerability of
the poor to convert vote into a commodity. In most parts of India, vote is bought with
money and liquor. Large expenditure to buy vote does not guarantee victory, but non-
expenditure almost certainly guarantees defeat! Even when the vote is not bought,
absurd and counter-productive freebies are offered as a party platform. Free rice, free
power, free TV, easy money without workall are the staple of our electoral battles in
politics of competitive populism. If vote buying and freebies do not work, there is
always cynical exploitation of primordial loyalties in society caste, region, religion,
language. It is easy to rouse passions and fashion a group as a vote bank, by portraying
the other as the enemy.
Third, in an emerging democracy where constitutional values have not yet been
internalized in our political conduct or social mores, power is essentially meant for
private gain. Culturally, control of levers of power is seen as a way of promoting
private fortunes.
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
5/30
5
Given these circumstances the rot is not limited to politics, and most institutions of
state are perverted and compromised. Bureaucracy and judiciary are increasingly prone
to corruption, unethical behaviour and arbitrary exercise of power. Even the Fourth
Estate, the media, has not escaped this decline. As all self-correcting mechanisms are
blunted, we entered a vicious cycle, with each institution blaming the others. No matter
how guilty other players are, the primary responsibility to set things right rests with the
political leadership.
Can something be done to restore and promote ethical leadership?
Once political recruitment improves, ethical leaders are attracted to politics, and
honesty becomes an asset and not a liability, we have to address the issues ofaccountability. Two broad approaches promote accountability and sustain ethical and
effective leadership. First, power should be decentralized, and there must be clear links
between vote and public good, and taxes and services. Local government
empowerment and institutionalizing and strengthening the third tier of federalism will
bring back people into the governance process. When power is localized, and at the
community level people are allowed to participate in decision making (in a village
Panchayat or a municipal ward), authority fuses with accountability and alibis for non-
performance disappear. Second, corruption and abuse of power should be swiftly and
surely punished. Independent crime investigation, strong, independent and well-
coordinated anti-corruption agency, independent and effective prosecution, swift
confiscation of assets of corrupt public servants, and special courts for quick disposal of
corruption cases will achieve this objective.
None of these is a pipe-dream. We deserve better politics and ethical leadership.
Democracy needs to be reformed and strengthened in every generation, and decency
and honesty need to be nurtured and promoted with great care. The middle class, media
and the moral elites of society should shed mutual mistrust and work together to
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
6/30
6
improve the substance of our democracy. Ignoring politics and reviling politicians is not
an option.
1.3 POLITICS, ETHICS AND DEMOCRACY
The Indian Independence Act, 1947, provided for the setting up of two dominions of
India and Pakistan with effect from August 15, 1947. It was, according to Lord Samuel,
an event unique in history a treaty of peace without war.
The Founding Fathers of the Constitution chose the system of representative
parliamentary democracy with universal adult franchise. Freedom brings responsibility.
Building on the traditions of the national movement, Indian leaders strengthened the
foundations of democracy in the country by the manner of their functioning. They gave
due importance to the institutional aspects of the democratic system and adhered not
only to the forms of democratic institutions and procedures but also the spirit.
From an electorate of around 173 million in 1951 when India went to the polls for the
first time under the Constitution, the number of electors swelled to nearly 672 million in
2004. The fair and peaceful conduct of elections periodically with a large turn-out of
voters, especially of the rural folk and women, and the participation of all groups with
differing ideology and religious faith, is an indication of the acceptance of the
framework of the Constitution and the growing political awareness among the people.
India is the largest democracy in the world. These elections have demonstrated that the
democratic urge is very deep-rooted among the people of India and their faith in a
constitutional system of government very strong.
If we are to live in peace and happiness, every nation, community, and the individual
must envision universal and humanitarian ideals and must strive to practise them in
thought, speech and action. Religion and even politics must be founded on moral and
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
7/30
7
spiritual fundamentals. In ancient India, politics was regarded as a branch of ethics.
Peace, justice and liberty for all were the prime purposes of politics.
Mahatma Gandhi recommended that politics should be a branch of ethics. While there
has been considerable progress on the economic front, there has been regression of the
values in the society and devaluation of the institutions.
The expectation at the time of Independence that public men would sacrifice their
personal interest for public welfare has not been fulfilled. Mahatma Gandhi did not
want the constructive workers, the men and women who had directed the several
organisations over the years to remove untouchability, extend basic education, improve
food cultivation, develop village industries and encourage hand spinning, to go intopower politics. That would, he felt, spell ruin.
Democracy is at stake if the loudest voice counts as the voice of wisdom or when
coercive pressures take the place of reason and persuasion. Referring to his tours,
especially concerned with the general elections that were approaching at that time,
Nehru wrote: Elections were an inseparable part of the democratic process and there
was no way of doing away with them. Yet, often enough, elections bring out the evil
side of man and they do not always lead to the success of the better man.
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
8/30
8
2. POLITICS WITHOUT ETHICS IS A DISASTER
In modern states absolute power rests with the politicians. This is so in India too. The
huge expenses involved in electioneering and the desire for a grand life style tempt the
political leaders to amass money, often unethically.
The result is a political culture without ethics that naturally degenerates into wilder
corrupt practices. As power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely every
aspect of Indian life becomes corrupt.
2.1 INTELLECTUAL EFFECT
One has to admit that the status of a nation is to be measured by its intellectual
achievements, its achievements, in science, technology, art, music, literature and the
such. The intellectuals make culture grow. However, the intellectuals in India at the
moment are disillusioned a lot.
They are aware of the unethical domination of the un intellectual politicians in their
domain. Often the men at the top in intellectual organizations are political appointees
and the incumbents have to please their political masters in various ways.
Further, when political leverage works, it does in such a way that, individual initiative is
not encouraged and real achievements are not appreciated. This results in glorification
of mediocrity in the field of arts, science and technology.
Many brilliant, honest and hard working men of ability, in order to free themselves
from such choking atmosphere go away to foreign countries.
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
9/30
9
This exodus of the meritorious is often referred to as brain-drain. Some say they go in
search of greener pastures. But it is not the truth that they go away for money. They go
tempted by the more conducive working conditions, unfettered by the disgusting
influence of politicians.
This may perhaps explain why no Indian scientist working in India has reached the
Nobel- status though a few of them have risen to that level after leaving the motherland.
In the field of art and literature too, the suffocating political hold prevents excellence
from coming to lime-light.
As long as the corrupt tendencies of politics remain in the intellectual field, India is
unlikely to contribute substantially in science or art, technology or industry, literature,drama or music.
One may talk of a Tagore or a Ray or a Chandrasekhar. But they are of an earlier
generation not subjected to the utterly immoral political wheeling and dealings of the
present.
2.2 MORAL DAMAGE
Unethical politics has a very unwholesome effect on the morality of a nation. One of the
things over which Indians can be rightly proud of is the humanitarian traditions of
ancient India. But that glorious tradition of the Indian way of living started to fade into
thin air, during the second half of the present century.
Political parties, in order to gain popular appeal, play the communal card indiscrimi-
nately. This is true not only with the BJP and the Sangh pariwar, but also with all other
major parties, that glibly proclaim secularism.
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
10/30
10
Appealing to the communal and caste feelings may bring in temporary gains by winning
a few more seats in Parliament or even by gaining power at the centre. But during the
process they are immorally fomenting hatred in the minds of people.
This has a cascading effect and the result surely is a society devoid of moral sense, a
nation without humanitarian feelings. When the materialistic world, disillusioned with
the meaningless life it leads, is looking to the east with a longing for a better model of
life, this moral degradation found in India will only add to its disillusionment.
The loss is not only to India, it is to the whole human race. Further, Indian religion, one
of the most tolerant in the world is losing that nobility and is becoming fundamentalist
like aggressive religions.
There is another side to the moral issue. The corruption that starts from the political
field is disseminating fast. Corrupt practice, now, is the rule than the exception which it
was in the past. This leads to distortion of values leading to the justification of evil on
the ground that evil is found practiced everywhere.
If people in high places are noticeably corrupt, the average man may justice himself inindulging in it, rather without any pricking of conscience. Corruption has become the
norm and there is a human tendency to justify their is a human tendency to justify the
norm.
But it is a fallacious view. Just because about 95% Americans have diseased teeth, as it
is reported, none can think that disease in teeth is something we should aim at. Further
the widespread existence of corruption in society will lead the coming generation to
grow up into unscrupulous people.
In the absence of any societal morality, to guide them, they turn to evil without any
pricking of conscience. We have already begun to see the consequences. Some of the
heinous crimes committed in recent day India are committed by greedy teenagers.
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
11/30
11
It is absolutely clear that the consequences of the immorality the political leaders
practice in public life, has its repercussions in society at large. The numerous bride
burnings that frequently one hears of, the Naina Sahni case and incidents like those
amply illustrate this.
The violent demonstration Delhi University law students held defending a colleague, a
notorious murderer that too in a court of law, is another shocking example. Are the
politicians who are the root-cause of this phenomenon aware of their role in corrupting
the society of not only today, but that of tomorrow also?
If yes, they are callous people not suitable to be leaders of society. If the answer is no
they are ignorant ones unfit to belong to the ruling class. A palpable effect of this moraldecay is the break down of law and order in the country. Now, might is right. It is not
only so in the big cities.
For a few thousand rupees you can lure a gangster to eliminate an adversary, almost
anywhere in India. Extortions and kidnappings have become the order of the day.
Law enforcement officers themselves are involved in crimes. Recently there was astrike call by customs officers in defense of their colleagues who were arrested red
handed for extorting bribes from exporters.
There is definite connection; social scientists say, between corruptions in high places a
euphemism for corruption among the politicians-and the break down of law and order
countrywide.
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
12/30
12
2.3 SOCIOLOGICAL EFFECT
The social, or rather sociological effect of the spread of immoral politics is shockingly
felt on the Indian society, from the family to big organizations like religion and political
parties. The harm done to the family is perhaps the most west have started appreciating
the very salutary family bond found in Indian society.
Securities of all the members are assured in the traditional Indian family life. However,
under the shattering influenced of the murky corrupting situation, that exists now, the
Indian family bond is wearing thin and in the urban set up it has already disappeared.
Religion is another social organization which has ceased to be of positive contribution,
under the cloud of prevailing corruption. First politicians started to patronize religious
organizations for electoral advantages, despite the fact they didn't have any religious
convictions whatsoever.
Slowly, even honest religious leaders, started to swing away from their idealistic
convictions and became pragmatists. The tragic consequence is that religion has lost its
positive influence on Indian society. Religion no longer can help Indian society in
keeping its traditional humaneness, its intellectual honesty and its social awareness.
Sanyasins, Maulahs, Sants and Bishops who used to be the conscience keepers of Indian
society now have no conscience to keep, neither that of the society nor their own. In
such a situation society decays quickly. The existing poverty of India makes the decay
quicker.
It is an approved fact that a poverty stricken nation is kept in the upright path by
religion even by religious superstition. The ultimate damage done to Indian society
through the vanishing influence on religion will be realized only later. All sane minds
think that the damage will be considerable.
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
13/30
13
The influences on political organizations are reciprocator, creating a vicious circle:
Corruption starts with the individual politician and it has a cascading effect, ultimately
corrupting the whole organization.
Thus the fully corrupt organization, goes on to corrupt the new entrants coming into its
fold. Thus it forms a vicious circle perpetuating corruption. The same corrupting
influence works on industrial and financial firms, social and sports of organizations.
The various scams that acquired notoriety, recently and the hawala connection of
political heavy-weights are glaring examples of the evil effect of corruption at political
level on society.
2.4 ECONOMIC DAMAGE
The economic damage that political corruption causes is perhaps the most palpable. The
liberalization of the Indian economy has brought in hitherto unseen prosperity and
growth to Indian industrial firms and financial institutions.
However, the economic benefits that pundits predicted for the common people are yet
to be realized. An independent firm indulging in economic analysis says that India has
lost at least four billion dollars worth of foreign exchange during the two financial years1991-92 and 1992-93, through hawala deals and similar irregularities.
These anti-national deals continue to exist, just because the politicians at the very top
enjoy a share of it. The nexus between the politicians with hawala dealers like the Jams
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
14/30
14
and underworld dons like Dawood Ibrahim has come to the open recently. But it has
been in existence for a long time and one finds that no party is innocent of it.
The economic damage done to the country by extending political patronage to anti-
national dealers is devastating. The apparent prosperity the country enjoys now is
dependent on heavy borrowings, both foreign and internal.
Unless the gains coming out of the new liberalization reach the country's coffers, very
soon, India will be caught up in a debt trap. The irresponsibility shown by the corrupt
politicians, by aligning themselves with anti-national elements, is hastening the
approach of a catastrophe in Indian economy.
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
15/30
15
3. ETHICS COMMITTEEAN INTRODUCTION
3.1 MORALITY IN POLITICS
Ethics and morality have been the hallmark of public life in India since ancient times.
Rulers were expected to observe stricter ethical values and an unethical king was shown
no mercy. Ethics and politics, in other words, were inseparable. This ethical and moral
legacy was inherited by its national leaders, who demonstrated a high degree of probity
and honesty in public life during the freedom struggle led by Mahatma Gandhi, who
himself was an embodiment of this tradition. He not only preached morality in public
life but also practiced it. He believed that politics without morality is a thing to be
avoided.However, in recent years there is a general feeling that all is not well with the Indian
political system which is functioning under great strain. Concerns are being expressed
over the general decline of values in public life. Recent trends in politics, however,
appear to have created an impression as if, the capacity of our democratic system to
ensure probity in public life is increasingly going down. Such a situation does not augur
well for the future of democracy and needs to be arrested immediately.
3.2 ROLE OF PEOPLES REPRESENTATIVES
That there has been general erosion of moral values in all walks of life cannot be
denied. Role of peoples representatives, who are largely responsible for guiding the
system in such a situation, therefore, becomes very critical. Members of Parliament as
peoples representatives are looked at by the people as their role models and the ones
who are guiding their destiny, have, therefore, to be beyond the realm of any kind of
suspicion. By and large, the ideological base and the spirit of service which should
activate most of them is getting eroded and the kind of elements who are trying to
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
16/30
16
influence the political parties and the political system at large, make everybody think as
to how probity in the entire system could be ensured. There may be many ways for
ensuring probity in public life, but a self-disciplining mechanism, appears to be the best
in an institution like Parliament.
3.3 THE VOHRA COMMITTEE :
It was in this backdrop and amidst alleged charges of corruption involving politicians
and general perception of criminalisation of politics, that the government of the dayappointed on 9 July, 1993, a Committee headed by Shri N.N. Vohra, the then Home
Secretary, Government of India, to take stock of all available information about the
activities of crime syndicates/mafia organizations who allegedly had developed links
with and were being protected by some Government functionaries and political
personalities. The Committee after considering the matter presented its report to the
Government of India which laid it before both Houses of Parliament on 1 August 1995.
The report was discussed in the Houses of Parliament on 8 , 23 and 24 August, 1995.
The Committee in its report, inter alia, pointed out that the nexus between the criminal
gangs, police, bureaucracy and politicians had come out clearly in various parts of the
country. The existing criminal justice system, which was essentially designed to deal
with the individual offences/crimes, was unable to deal with the activities of the mafia;
the provisions of law in regard to economic offences were found to be weak and there
were insurmountable legal difficulties in attaching/confiscating the properties acquired
through mafia activities.
The report suggested setting up of a nodal agency under the Ministry of Home Affairs,
Government of India, to be handled directly by the Union Home Secretary, who would
be assisted by one or more selected officers of the Ministry for the collation and
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
17/30
17
compilation of all information received from different intelligence agencies.
Subsequently, an All-Party Meeting was held on 15 September 1995, under the
Chairmanship of the then Union Home Minister, Shri S.B. Chavan, to look into the
whole gamut of criminal-politician nexus and the related issue of declaration of assets
and liabilities by the Members of Parliament and Ministers. The points, which inter
alia, constituted the agenda were :
1. Setting up of a Parliamentary Committee on Ethics as distinct from the Committee of
Privileges which would act as a guardian on the activities of members of Parliament.
2. Adoption of a Code of Conduct at the level of political parties to ensure a cleaner
public life, e.g., not to give party tickets to persons having criminal record.
3. All political parties should have open audited accounts which must be publishedannually.
4. Changes in the legal system, simplification of the procedure and dispensation of
quick justice.
3.4 BIRTH OF ETHICS COMMITTEE
Rajya Sabha, the Second Chamber of Indian Parliament also was seized of the matter
for quite some time. The Business Advisory Committee of Rajya Sabha had decided in
1996, that this matter should be considered by Leaders of parties and groups in the
House. At the initiative of the former Prime Minister of India, Shri I.K. Gujral, who
then was the External Affairs Minister, a meeting was held in 1996, with the leaders of
parties and groups in Rajya Sabha to discuss the issue. Thereafter, the matter was
placed before the General Purposes Committee of Rajya Sabha in 1997. The Committee
after considering the matter carefully, decided to have an internal mechanism of the
House itself which would work as a self-regulatory body for the members of Rajya
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
18/30
18
Sabha. The Committee authorized the Chairman, Rajya Sabha to constitute an Ethics
Committee with a mandate to oversee the moral and ethical conduct of its members.
Thus, the Ethics Committee, Rajya Sabha, the first such Committee by any legislature
in India was constituted by the Chairman, Rajya Sabha on 4 March 1997, to oversee the
moral and ethical conduct of the Members and to examine the cases referred to it with
reference to ethical and other misconduct of Members. It was provided that in all
respects of procedure and other matters, the rules applicable to the Committee of
Privileges shall apply to the Ethics Committee with such variations and modifications
as the Chairman, Rajya Sabha may, from time to time, make. The committee was
inaugurated by the then Vice-President of India and the Chairman of Rajya Sabha, Shri
K.R. Narayanan, on 30 May 1997.Setting up of an institution like Ethics Committee was, in fact, a significant event in the
history of Indian parliamentary democracy. Such Committees are functioning only in a
few countries of the world and with the setting up of this Committee here, India also has
joined the group of these select countries.
Ethics Committee, Rajya Sabha consists of ten members, including its Chairman, who
are nominated by the Chairman, Rajya Sabha. Chairman of the Committee is from the
largest party in the House. Other members normally are the Leaders, Deputy
Leaders/Chief Whips of their parties/groups in Rajya Sabha. Commenting on the fact
that leaders of parties/group are made members of the Ethics Committee, Shri K.R.
Narayanan while inaugurating the Committee on the 30 May, 1997 said :
By choosing the leaders of parties as Members we have tried to invest the Committee
with prestige and influence. In this way we have also sought to forge a link, though
indirectly and informally, with the political parties all of whom are intensely interested
in maintaining the highest ethical standards in our parliamentary life. This, indeed, is a
common platform on which all of us can meet together to sustain the high standards of
the august institution of Parliament.
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
19/30
19
3.5 WORK OF THE COMMITTEE
The Committee apart from consulting expert opinion has been meeting simultaneously
to hold its own deliberations. It has, so far, held 50 meetings and presented three
Reports to Rajya Sabha. Its first Report was presented on 8 December, 1998, the second
Report on 13 December, 1999 and the third Report on 12 August 2002.
Rajya Sabha discussed and adopted the first and the second Reports on 15 December,
1999 and the third Report is yet to be discussed and adopted by the House.
3.6 RECOMMENDATIONS/OBSERVATIONS
The Members of the Ethics Committee express general appreciation for the work done
and recommendations made by the previous Committee in its first and the second
reports.The Committee is aware that issues falling within the mandate of the Committee
are complex and varied. The Committee is of the view that a holistic view has to be
taken while dealing with the issues relating to decline in standards of behaviour of the
members. There can be no single remedy for it. The ethical questions cannot be dealt
with entirely by legislation. These are mainly matters of one's conscience. The
Committee is also aware that merely by prescribing a Code of Conduct the problem
cannot be solved. However, the Code of Conduct, like many of them in different
countries, could help in evolving certain standard norms of behaviour which everyone
intending to enter a legislature is expected to follow.
Apart from prescribing a Code of Conduct for members, people should also be educated
not to elect persons with "dubious distinction". Political parties and their leaders also
can play a crucial role in ensuring probity in public life by denying tickets to persons
who are criminals, corrupt or have anti-social proclivities.
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
20/30
20
4.A REFLECTION ON CORRUPTION IN INDIA:
UNETHICAL POLITICS
Corruption in India has permeated every level of society; from senior bureaucrats and
politicians, to high ranking public servants to professionals to criminals to lowly clerks
and street vendors. Interested groups have documented numerous cases of corruption
throughout the country, ranging from corrupt police officers, to government officers in
charge of welfare schemes to local thugs in cohort with local officials. In fact, the two
biggest challenges to tackling corruption in the country are corrupt police officers and
corrupt civil servants. These are the two legs upon which the realization of the rule of
law and protecting citizens rights are based; when these cannot be relied upon, what
are the chances of fighting against corruption? Corruption is a crime, and crimes are to
be contested by law and its enforcement. Ultimately, all societies must be based on the
supremacy of the law, and this law is to be articulated and protected by various
mechanisms. Without government officers to transparently and in good faith run the
government machinery in accordance with peoples needs and wishes, and without
police officers to protect peoples rights and maintain law, society cannot function
effectively. Furthermore, corruption if unchecked will simply eat away at rule of law, as
well as public institutions, democratic principles and mechanisms of good governance,
leaving society in anarchy.
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
21/30
21
4.1 RECENT CORRUPTION SCAMS
Recent scandals in India have revealed the extent of political involvement in corruption,
as well as the incestuous relationship between business and politics. They have also
revealed the enormous amounts of money involved, which is particularly worrying for a
country where a significant number live below the poverty line, and where the gap
between the rich and poor is ever increasing. According to a report by US based groupGlobal Financial Integrity, India lost USD 462 billion between 1948-2008, due to
corruption, tax evasion and other illicit financial practices. 1
Most recently, the appointment of PJ Thomas as head of Indias anti-corruption
watchdog, the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC), has been deemed illegal by the
Supreme Court, on the grounds that Thomas himself faces corruption charges:
PJ Thomas was appointed by the government in 2010; in fact, prime minister
Manmohan Singh headed the committee that oversaw his appointment. As head of the
anti corruption body, Thomas was to investigate allegations that millions of dollars
were stolen by officials running the Delhi Commonwealth games in October 2010.
According to an article published in Al Jazeera, the Commonwealth Games budget
ballooned three times to an estimated USD 6 billion, with the CVC receivin
gcomplaints alleging that up to USD 1.8 billion was misappropriated. An initial report
by the CVC into the Games confirmed the use of sub-standard construction materials in
a host of building contracts and deliberate cost overruns.3
Thomas was also looking into claims that former telecoms minister Andimuthu Raja
was responsible for India's largest ever scandal, costing the country almost USD 40
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
22/30
22
billion: "Mr Raja stands accused of abusing his position and manipulating government
policies to award licences for mobile networks at throwaway prices to companies that
rewarded him privately with huge kickbacks." 4
As Thomas was Telecom Secretary till he was made Central Vigilance Commissioner,
the Supreme Court, monitoring the CBIs investigation into the telecom scam,
suggested that it would be inappropriate for Mr Thomas to preside over an inquiry that
could subject his own actions in the Telecom Ministry to scrutiny.
Another scam involving huge amounts of money and directly affecting the countrys
poorest citizens is the food scandal in Uttar Pradesh. According to BBCs Geeta
Pandey, enormous amounts of food grains and fuel, meant to be distributed through the
public distribution system or given to the poor under welfare schemes like food-for-work and school meals for poor children, have been stolen over the years and sold on
the open market.
The scale is immense. It involves thousands of officials from top-level bureaucrats to
middle-level officers to ground-level workers. It also involves thousands of
transporters, village council leaders and fair-price shop owners.
It stretches across 54 of the states 71 districts, and investigators say the food is carried
out of the state and sometimes even beyond Indian borders to Bangladesh and Nepal.
Indias top investigating agency - the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) - once tried
to withdraw from the case saying it did not have the manpower to deal with it. It said it
would require the registration of 50,000 police cases.
Not only do these corruption scams indicate political involvement, but they also
indicate a breakdown in the countrys rule of law institutions; how else could such
incidents occur, not once, but multiple times, and at the levels they did? The slow
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
23/30
23
response to these incidents, including holding people accountable, further shames the
countrys governance mechanisms and political will. When compared to the recent
convictions of parliament members (MPs) in the UK for false expenses, the situation in
India can truly be said to be dire. As reported by Sandra Laville and Polly Curtis in The
Guardian, the MPs under investigation were immediately barred from their political
parties while many others were required to pay back the fraudulently claimed money. 6
Speedy investigations were followed by effective trials, with those found guilty of false
accounting sentenced to between 12-18 months imprisonment.7 Furthermore, an
agency was constituted to oversee MPs expenses, salaries and so forth.8
Why does this not happen in India? The countrys ongoing corruption scandals have
recently sparked considerable public angst, culminating in quite a few proteststhroughout the country, as well as the launching of numerous anti-corruption websites:
One, Ipaidabribe.com, is run by Raghunandan Thoniparambil, a retired official from the
elite Indian administrative service. The site was launched four months ago and more
than 3,000 people have posted their own stories of graft.
On one day alone 30 December those posting on the site included a restaurateur
forced to pay 25,000 rupees (350) to clerks to have his dossier forwarded to seniorofficials at a Delhi licensing department, a traveller who had to give 100 rupees (1.30)
to get a berth on the otherwise full express train, a dozen or so drivers who had to pay
traffic police after being accused of fictitious offences, and travellers intimidated into
paying customs officials large sums to allow electrical and other goods into the country.
"The aim is not to identify people but to identify the problem," Thoniparambil told the
Guardian.
"Crowdsourcing is a way of finding out what is happening but wont alone alter
anything. We need change from within government that is properly monitored."9
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
24/30
24
Indeed, change from within the government is exactly what is needed. Protest and
publicity are but one step on the ladder to change and the elimination of corruption.
Without an institutional environment conducive to reform and accountability, public
protest cannot do more than creating awareness. For concrete change to occur and legal
action to take place, there must be functioning mechanisms to receive and act on
complaints, whether of corruption, inefficiency or malpractice.
Another civil society response has been to urge the government to pass an anti
corruption law. A weak law has been pending in parliament for several decades now,
with no strong action being taken by any government to modify and enact it. A civil
society version of the law, the Jan Lokpal bill also exists. Veteran activist AnnaHazare began an indefinite fast on April 5, demanding that the government rewrite the
bill and pass it without further delay. As of April 9, the government agreed to set up a
committee to draft the bill and to bring it to the monsoonsession of the parliament.10
4.2 INSTITUTIONAL REFORM
At present, Indias entire justice system is geared to serve political rather than public
interests, as well as being mired in corruption. In such a system, there is no chance of
individual complaints being heard and processed. When politicians and government
officers themselves are corrupt, they will do little to clean up such scams and hold
persons responsible. In a statement of December 2010, the Asian Human Rights
Commission (AHRC), a regional rights body, noted that
In the lower house of the Indian Parliament, the Lok Sabha, out of the 152 sitting
members accused of criminal charges of varying nature, 72 are suspected to be involved
in criminal cases of a very serious nature. These are offenses which, if investigated and
proved, would fetch imprisonment for the accused for a period of not less than seven
years the BJP [Bharatiya Janata Party] has 17, and
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
25/30
25
the INC [Indian National Congress] has 12 of their representatives against whom crimes
of a very serious nature are alleged. 11
Aside from corrupt (and criminal) politicians, India suffers a corrupt police force. It is
an open secret that police officers, irrespective of their ranks, pay bribes to ministers
and other politically influential persons for securing promotions, transfers and for
preventing disciplinary action. The selection and appointment to the state police service
has been referred to as resembling a public auction. According to the AHRC, in the
state of Manipur, as of October 2010, appointment to the rank of Sub-Inspector of
Police required bribes paid to the state Chief Minister, Mr Okram Ibobi Singh, or his
representative, ranging from Rupees 1,400,000 to 1,800,000.13 Transparency
Internationals report on India for the past several years has ranked the Indian police asone of most corrupt government agencies in the country and in the world, while the UN
Rapporteur on Torture has reported that police officers in India routinely use torture as
a tool for extortion of money from the poor.
Despite this, according to a press release issued by the Indian government on 24
February 2010, only 75 police officers were tried for corruption in the past three years.
This lack of prosecution spotlights the lack of complaints made against police officers,
as well as the absence of investigations. Indias police force is ill equipped to deal with
criminal investigations in a professional, efficient manner. Without effective police
reform (including amending the decades old, colonial Police Act), it is not possible to
improve the countrys rule of law and human rights situation.
Linked to police reform is the reform of all justice institutions, which at present are
clearly malfunctioning. This is indicated not only by the way these institutions have
dealt with recent corruption cases, but also by members of these institutions themselves
being implicated in such cases. The most recent suspect is the former Chief Justice of
India who is presently serving as the Chairperson of the National Human Rights
Commission, Justice K G Balakrishnan. The government, despite the substantial and
incriminating circumstances against Balakrishnan, has failed to undertake a thorough
investigation in the case. A Public Interest Litigation filed in the Supreme Court is
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
26/30
26
pending against the government, in which the Court has already expressed its
displeasure about the slow pace of the investigation on the allegations against the
former judge. In addition to the former judge, a former Union Minister is also facing
investigation for corruption.14
The ongoing case of black money stashed abroad is a good study of poor criminal
investigation and procedure. Amongst other aspects, Indias Supreme Court has to date
voiced displeasure regarding the following: Enforcement Directorate (ED) officials not
subjecting Hasan Ali Khan to custodial interrogation; Mumbai Principal Sessions Judge
M L Tahaliyanis order of granting bail to Khan and rejecting the EDs contention
against it; and, the governments lack of investigation into other individuals stashing
money abroad.15
Indias judiciary faces its own problems, with court delays being the biggest obstacle to
those seeking justice. This is largely due to insufficient staffing, with the population-
judge ratio at 10.5 judges for every million Indians; the lowest ratio in the world. The
huge number of cases pending in Indias courts gives further rise to corruption:
A bail petition that requires a mere Rupees 2 court fee stamp to be affixed, to be called
in the bench on the same day or on the subsequent day will require the payment of
bribes ranging from Rupees 300 to 1000 to an array of court officers, which in most
cases also include the Public Prosecutor and even the adjudicating judge. A visit to the
Magistrate Courts at the national capital will prove this true, in addition to the fact that
the entire place resembles a festival ground in chaos. Trial court lawyers everywhere in
India know that unless they pay bribes to the court staff, the court would never take up
their applications and petitions. It is a sad irony that it is this same court system that will
have to deal with corruption cases. 16
Such failings of justice institutions as well as the practice of corruption that drives them
provides the wealthy and connected with an environment of privilege and concession
when they are charged and investigated of corruption. They also benefit from court
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
27/30
27
delays and the misinterpreted provision of the Criminal Procedure Code for prior
sanction to prosecute.
4.3 MAKING USE OF TECHNOLOGY TO FIGHT
CORRUPTION
The widespread use of information technology in todays world has done much for
increasing public awareness and supporting movements for democracy and liberty.
From the Saffron Revolution in Burma in 2007, to the recent wave of protests in the
Middle East, blogs and social networking sites have played a significant role in
generating public participation and solidarity. Apart from information and awareness
sharing however, information technology can be used in various ways to protect and
safeguard human rights, from increasing the use of computers and fax machines to
minimize court delays, to using proper forensic equipment to streamline criminal
investigations.
In the same way, information technology can also be used to eliminate corruption. Uttar
Pradeshs state food commissioner for instance, in response to the food scandal there,
noted that, As a first step, we have digitised the entire list of BPL card-holders and
weeded out 400,000 fake cards. To stop pilferage, we have decided to fit in GPS
devices in trucks and fuel tankers to track their movements.17 These are both
important steps in reducing opportunities for corruption, as well as increasing
efficiency, particularly as much corruption takes place in the country due to a prevailing
atmosphere of complacency and inevitability.
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
28/30
28
CONCLUSION
It is clear that politicians remaining at the helm of affairs in the country are important
decision makers, and as such they wield vast amount of power. They utilize their power
for their own private gains neglecting that of the country and its people.
It has very devastating effect on the country's economy, its moral consciousness, its
social and intellectual life. The corrupt politicians are the ultimate cause of keeping
India, one of the poorest countries of the world despite almost half a century of self-
rule.
Indian society is caught in a vicious circle where the politicians through their corrupt
practices make the country miserable and the resulting misery making the individuals
more corrupt. What is the cure? It seems as if there is no man-made cure for the malady
India faces.
Perhaps the cure has to come from outside; for all the inside is already rotten, still
getting more rotten and is unable to reform itself. Bhagawad Geeta says that when evil
becomes all pervasive, a new incarnation of God takes place, to destroy the evil doers
and to protect the good. But as it was .understood earlier, may not happen in this age.
Perhaps incarnation may happen in the form of self destruction of evil, by fighting in
itself. And after the destruction of the evil society a good tomorrow may dawn upon us.
But then, it may take a little time for such an eventuality to take place and in that
process even the few good people that exist may face extreme misery.
What ever that may be, the consequences of corruption in politics has immediate and
long time results that are devastating not only for India, but to the whole humankind of
which one-third are Indians.
8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
29/30
29
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1 India lost $462bn in illegal capital flows, says report, BBC News, 18 November
2010, http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-south-asia-11782795.
2 Thomas no longer CVC: Supreme Court, NDTV, 3 March 2011,
http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/thomas-quits-as-cvc-supreme-court-says-
appointment-was-illegal-89084.
3 India sack Delhi Games chief, Al Jazeera, 24 January 2011,
http://english.aljazeera.net/sport/2011/01/2011124205821776668.html.
4 Thomas no longer CVC: Supreme Court, NDTV.
5 Geeta Pandey, Indias immense food theft scandal, BBC News, 22 February2011, http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-south-asia-12502431
6 Sandra Laville and Polly Curtis, MPs charged over expenses could face up to seven
years in jail, 5 February 2010, Guardian,
http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2010/feb/05/mps-expenses-criminal-charges-
jail?intcmp=239.
7 See Criminal charges in United Kingdom Parliamentary expenses scandal,
Wikipedia,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom_Parliamentary_expenses_scandal#Crim
inal_charges.
8 Editorial, MPs' expenses: Not a special case, 6 January 2011, Guardian,
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/jan/06/mps-expenses-not-special-case.
9 Jason Burke, Indian corruption backlash builds after year of the treasure hunters,
2 January 2011, Guardian, http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/jan/02/india-
corruption-backlash-treasure-hunters.
10 See India wins again, Anna Hazare calls off fast, 9 April 2011, Times of India,
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/India-wins-again-Anna-Hazare-calls-off-
fast/articleshow/7921304.cms.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom_Parliamentary_expenses_scandal#Criminal_chargeshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom_Parliamentary_expenses_scandal#Criminal_chargeshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom_Parliamentary_expenses_scandal#Criminal_chargeshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom_Parliamentary_expenses_scandal#Criminal_chargeshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom_Parliamentary_expenses_scandal#Criminal_charges8/2/2019 Ethics in Politics Final Sim
30/30