Upload
vunga
View
223
Download
3
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
BACHELOR THESIS IN AERONAUTICAL ENGINEERING15 CREDITS, BASIC LEVEL 300
School of Innovation, Design and Engineering
Effects of Mach cruise number on conventional
civil jet aircraft sizing
Author: Niklas Bergman Report code: MDH.IDT.FLYG.0216.2009.GN300.15HP.Ae
ii
ABSTRACT
This thesis work was executed at Swift Engineering Incorporated located in San
Clemente, California during spring in 2009. Placement supervisor from Swift was Mark Page
and advisor and examiner from the Division of future products at Mälardalen University,
Sweden was Gustaf Enebog.
The objective with this thesis work was to examine the effects of fitness ratio, lift over
drag, lift coefficient at cruise, winglet span, wing sweep angle, wing aspect ratio, wing area
and weights with respect to Mach number for a conventional business jet capable of 18
passengers. The cruise speed study range from Mach 0.88 to 0.99.
The Excel based conceptual design tool Jetsizer 2008c was used to make four models
with similar configuration and mission but with different cruise Mach numbers.
A new Jetsizer module was then created to handle a modification process where the
models are optimized for their speed and configuration. The result in this report gives
guidelines for the needed values when creating an initial CFD model for this type of airplane.
Date: 31 July 2009
Carried out at: Swift Engineering Inc.
Advisor at MDH: Gustaf Enebog
Advisor at Swift Engineering Inc: Mark Page
Examinator: Gustaf Enebog
iii
NOMENCLATURE
Abbreviation Declaration
AR Wing Aspect Ratio
c Chord of wing
CD Drag coefficient
CD,i Induced drag coefficient
CL CRZ Lift coefficient at cruise speed
CFD Comptional fluid dynamics
ICA Initial cruise altitude
ISA International Standard Atmosphere
L/D Lift over Drag
M Mach number
MCRZ Mach number at cruise
MLW Maximum Landing Weight
MTOW Maximum TakeOff Weight
ROC Rate Of Climb
SL Sea Level
SLST Sea Level Standard Thrust
iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION 1
1.1 Background ..........................................................................................................1
1.2 Objective ..............................................................................................................1
1.3 Problem formulation .......................................................................................... 2
1.4 Limitations .......................................................................................................... 2
Chapter 2 METHOD 3
2.1 Mission ................................................................................................................. 3
2.2 Sizing tool............................................................................................................ 4
Sizing tool modification ............................................................................................................ 4
2.3 Baseline model .................................................................................................... 5
2.4 Mach study models ............................................................................................. 6
2.5 Geometry modification tool ................................................................................ 7
Chapter 3 RESULTS 9
Winglet height study ............................................................................................................... 12
Chapter 4 DISCUSSION 14
Chapter 5 FUTURE WORK 15
Chapter 6 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 16
Chapter 7 REFERENCES 17
Appendix A Baseline model for M=0.88
Appendix B Optimized model for M=0.88
Appendix C Optimized model for M=0.92
Appendix D Optimized model for M=0.96
Appendix E Optimized model for M=0.99
Appendix F Program code for the modification tool
1
Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background
Swift was consulted by a customer to design and build a civil jet aircraft based on a
special developed wing structure. The requirements where similar to the daily operating civil
jets but with a preferably higher cruise speed near Mach one. In order to design this airplane
an initial study was needed to investigate the relations of aircraft geometry and the
aerodynamic effects on an airplane with cruise speed near Mach one.
This study was needed to be able to generate a conventional baseline which allows Swift
to develop the initial CFD geometry for this project.
1.2 Objective
The purpose of this study is to demonstrate the effects of Mach number ranging from
0.88 to 0.99 for a conventional business jet in respect to
• fitness ratio
• lift over drag
• lift coefficient at cruise
• winglet span
• wing sweep angle
• wing aspect ratio
By creating a number of aircraft models with the same configuration but optimized for
different speeds a study can be made to compare the geometry variation due to the Mach
number. This result will give guidelines for the geometry when making CFD models for a
certain cruise speed.
2
1.3 Problem formulation
First a mission has to be defined in order to be able to define a design and to have a
meaningful study.
A tool has to be chosen to use in the aircraft sizing stage in order to generate different
models that can be compared in a Mach cruise study. It is recommended to use Jetsizer 2008c
for this study but it is maybe necessary to implement some new modules to estimate the
transonic wave drag since Jetsizer does not take that in count.
Another tool has to be created to handle the input values in the optimization process and
to display the results from each iterated step.
1.4 Limitations
This survey is only aimed at generating guidelines for a future conceptual study. For this
reason there are some limitations.
• Engine inlet effects have not been taken account of.
• Limited to the size and configuration of a conventional civil jet aircraft capable of
caring 18 passengers.
3
Chapter 2
METHOD
When design an aircraft from scratch you usually start with determine the mission
profile. In the early phase of this project there was no specific mission. The only given
specification was that it should be a civil jet aircraft with competitive performance of modern
aircrafts in the same category.
The first step was to do a basic investigation of already constructed and functional civil
jet aircrafts and take their mission and performance as guidelines for this project.
In order to calibrate and to see how well Jetsizer correlate its calculations a model of the
Gulfstream G650 was entered in Jetsizer with a set mission.
2.1 Mission
The mission for the models was determined by looking at other aircrafts. A summary of
airplane performance was found in Aviation week & space technology1. It was decided to use
the Gulfstream G650 as a calibration baseline. The G650 has a very high cruise speed
together with a very long range as shown in table 1 below. The results made it to be an
interesting baseline for the initial study in Jetsizer.
Table 1: Mission for Gulfstream G650
1 Aviation week & space technology, Aerospace source book, January 26, 2009
Maximum Range 7000 nm (Mach 0.85)
Normal Cruise Mach 0.85 / 488 ktas
High Speed Cruise Mach 0.90 / 516 ktas
Takeoff Distance (SL, ISA, MTOW) 6000 ft
Landing Distance (SL, ISA, MLW) 3000 ft
Initial Cruise Altitude 41000 ft
Maximum Takeoff Weight 99600 lb
Basic Operating Weight 54000 lb
Maximum Fuel Weight 44200 lb
Passengers 11 - 18
Rated Takeoff Thrust 16100 lb
4
The final mission and requirements for the Mach study was determined from the G650.
An increase of the Mach number will affect some of the mission variables there for are only a
few clarified. Table 2 shows the mission for the models in the mach study.
Table 2: Mission for the increased mach study model
2.2 Sizing tool
Jetsizer2008c was used as the sizing tool for this research. It is user friendly and it is
possible to remodel the program for suiting the study since the source code is open. It is
capable of the most important calculations in the conceptual design stage of general
configured passenger jets. Since Jetsizer is based on Excel, it is very easy for the user to work
through another Excel documents and by a macro import and export data for analysis.
Sizing tool modification
The wing area in Jetsizer is calculated in a conventional manner including the whole
wing span through the fuselage. This gives an incorrect geometry when entering a specified
wing area that does not involve the middle section through the fuselage. When sizing an
airplane it makes a good assumption to let the configured wing for a conventional design pass
all the way through the fuselage to obtain elliptical lift distribution. When calculating the
drag, this section through the fuselage gives a drag rise that Jetsizer does not neglect. This
drag rise was left in the calculations to be canceled by other drag distributing sources that
Jetsizer does not recognize e.g. interference between wing and fuselage.
Business jet passengers demand a higher comfort than a regular commercial airliner
offers. There for a comfort factor was added to simulate the assumed weight increased for
cabin equipment. The comfort factor works as a multiplier to the passenger weight.
Jetsizer 2008c lacks the ability to handle cruise speed near Mach one. A module was
implemented to handle compressibility interference between components. This module is
based on two papers from NACA, “Examples of the Applications of the Transonic and
Supersonic Area Rules to the Prediction of Wave Drag” (references number 7) and “A Study
of the Zero-Lift Drag-Rise Characteristics of Wing-Body Combinations near the Speed of
Sound” (references number 8). The results and the equations are implemented in Jetsizer to
simulate the transonic wave drag due to volume.
Maximum Range @ ICA & Mcrz 7000 nm
Takeoff Distance (SL, ISA, MTOW) 11000 ft
Landing Distance (SL, ISA, MLW) 5000 ft
Initial Cruise Altitude 41000 ft
Passengers 18
Mission revenue cargo 2630
% Mission fuel @ MLW 10%
5
2.3 Baseline model
The first model that was made in Jetsizer was based on data from the Gulfstream G650.
The unpublished geometry was measured from a 3-view picture and entered in Jetsizer. The
model was not supposed to be identical with the G650 but similar enough to see how well
Jetsizer correlates with the published performance.
Table 3: Geometry of Gulfstream G650 that was used in the baseline model.
Wing
AR 7.73
Area 1283 ft2
Axial position 366 ft
Dihedral 3 deg
Span 99.58 ft
Sweep @ c/4 33 deg
Horizontal stabilizer
AR 4.84
Dihedral 0 deg
Sweep @ c/4 33 deg
Taper ratio 0.47
Vertical stabilizer
AR 1.07
Sweep @ c/4 30
Taper ratio 0.95
Fuselage
Total length 1043.3 in
Cabin length 643 in
Cabin width 102 in
Cabin height 77 in
The generated results were at first
not satisfying but after some
modifications in Jetsizer and to the
model it correlated with the G650. The
modifications were; inserting the
comfort factor in Jetsizer, changing
structural materials to correlate the
empty weight and modifying wing area
to meet the performance.
The baseline model was later used
in the mach study as the model with the
lowest cruise speed, Mach 0.88.
The complete baseline model is found in
appendix A.
Figure 1: Baseline model from Jetsizer
6
2.4 Mach study models
Four different models were entered in Jetsizer with a conventional civil jet configuration
and with individually determined mach cruise numbers ranging from 0.88 to 0.99. The
purpose was to have four optimized models for each cruise speed with similar configuration.
In that way it is possible to see the effects of geometric related to the cruise speed.
The mission used for the models is determined in chapter 2.2.
To keep the models comparable regarding to cabin size the middle fuselage section
diameter was kept constant as well as the cabin floor area. The upper and lower lobe diameter
was set to 102 inches and with a separation vertically of 3 inches. The cabin floor length was
set to 767 inches. These measurements are based on the G650 and defined by the first
baseline model.
Figure 2: Fuselage cross
section of the models.
The four models were all generated from the baseline model and then converged with a
defined cruise Mach number. Each model works as a baseline for the individual Mach
number. The models were optimized by using the geometry modification tool. By taking the
best values from the iterating process a new model for each study was generated. Data from
the final optimized models can be found in Appendix B to E.
7
2.5 Geometry modification tool
To investigate the relations between the geometry and Mach number a tool was needed
to handle the input data and the communication with the sizing tool and to display the
calculated results. This tool was made in excel with a macro to control the calculations and
the communication with Jetsizer. The specific models are designed in Jetsizer after a
defined cruise Mach number which allows the modification tool to only look at one model
and Mach number at a time. By combining the results from several studies it is possible to
make a trend of the Mach number effects.
The application works directly under Jetsizer were the user is allowed to select a range
of values for a specified study. For each step Jetsizer is told to modify and converge to the
model for the best result. The results are given back to the application and are shown in a
table.
Figure 3: The loop of the geometry modification tool.
8
The application is limited to handle only six different studies for each model (AR, wing
sweep, winglet span, fuselage length, bypass ratio and SLST) which was decided to be
enough for this study. Figure 4 shows the interface were the user is allowed to enter a
number or a series of numbers in the cells to the right of AR, Sweep, Winglet span,
Fuselage length, Bypass ratio or SLST.
In the top left corner the user is allowed to enter the Jetsizer file name that wants to be
used. The only criterion is that both the active Jetsizer file and this tool have to be saved in
the same map. The archive is directly connected to which archived model in Jetsizer the
user wants to use.
By pressing one of the buttons to the left for each study respectively the program will
start the calculation on the active cell and continue as long as there is a number written on
that same row. The results will be shown in respectively column below where it is easy to
see the trend or copy the values to make a plot.
Figure 4: The interface of the geometry modification tool.
9
Chapter 3
RESULTS
The project resulted firstly in a tool that can be used with Jetsizer to optimize different
geometries. Although it is limited to only a few different modification options it can easily be
extended for other studies of interest by copying the code and entering new addresses in the
links to Jetsizer.
3.1 Mach cruise study
The results from the optimization tool is gathered and summarized in some plots. These
shows the trend lines for the increasing Mach number and the modifications needed to the
models.
0
20 000
40 000
60 000
80 000
100 000
120 000
0,86 0,88 0,9 0,92 0,94 0,96 0,98 1
lbs
Mach number
Weights
TOGW
OEW
FB
Figure 5. Trend line of weight versus Mach number.
10
The total weight is increasing a lot due to higher speed as shown in figure 5. This is an
effect of the acting transonic wave drag when traveling in high speeds. The rise of the
operating empty weight is an effect of the increasing wing area that is needed for high speeds.
It can be seen in figure 6 that the aspect ratio is descending when the Mach number goes
up. By lowering the AR the fuel volume in the wings increases and the weight of the wing
structure decreases. ROC decrease and TOFL gets longer. This is an effect of CD,i that is
inversely proportional to the aspect ratio (equation 3.1) which then affects the total drag
(equation 3.2). With a higher Aspect Ratio the induced coefficient of drag will decrease.
��,� =���
��
�� = � + ��,�
The increasing wing area with rising Mach number is an effect of lower aspect ratio and
the larger fuel capacity needed for higher speed.
800
850
900
950
1 000
1 050
1 100
1 150
1 200
1 250
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0,86 0,88 0,9 0,92 0,94 0,96 0,98 1
Win
g A
rea
, ft
2
AR
Mach number
Wing Aspect Ratio & Area
AR
Sw
Figure 6. Trend line of AR and Sw versus Mach number.
(3.1)
(3.2)
11
In figure 7 it is shown the result of wing sweep angle when converging to the lowest CD
possible. With a grater sweep the total coefficient of drag is reduced and there for ROC is
increased. Greater sweep gives a heavier wing structure and a lower fuel capacity which is
there for compensated with a larger wing area.
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
0,86 0,88 0,9 0,92 0,94 0,96 0,98 1
Sw
ee
p a
ng
le
Mach number
Wing Sweep
Swe…
Figure 7. Trend line of Wing sweep versus Mach number.
12
The reason for the dropping Lift over Drag curve in figure 8 is generally because the drag
gets significantly higher when it closes to Mach one. Also the increase of weight due to
higher speed affects the lift directly. The CLcrz curve is mainly effected by the Weight devided
by the wing area which both increases with the higher speeds.
Winglet height study The winglet span (or height) is proportional to the vortex drag and is also affecting the
weight of the wing structure and fuel quantity.
When extending the winglets the vortex drag decreases and the weight of the wing
increases this result in a loss of total fuel because of the change of the wing structure and a
lower CD. When adding a winglet in Jetsizer it affects the CD and when extending the winglet
you will get an even lower CD.
In the winglet height study it was discovered that Jetsizer uses a simplified formula for
the winglet calculations. This results in an endless decrease of CD when the winglet height
goes towards infinity. This result rejected the winglet span study.
0,000
0,050
0,100
0,150
0,200
0,250
0,300
0,350
0,400
0,450
0,500
13,50
14,00
14,50
15,00
15,50
16,00
16,50
17,00
0,86 0,88 0,9 0,92 0,94 0,96 0,98 1
CLc
rz
L/D
Mach number
L/D & CLcrz
L/D
CLcrz
Figure 8. Trend line of L/D and CLcrz versus Mach number.
13
Figure 9 shows the Fuselage length trend line, same as fuselage length to thickness ratio in
this study because the thickness does not vary between the models. This curve is only affected
by the transonic wave drag in this study.
1 000
1 050
1 100
1 150
1 200
1 250
1 300
1 350
0,86 0,88 0,9 0,92 0,94 0,96 0,98 1
Len
gth
, in
ch
Mach number
Fuselage length
Fuselage length
Figure 9. Trend line of fuselage length versus Mach number
14
Chapter 4
DISCUSSION
First of all, this study is only meant to give guidelines for the initial input values of a
future conceptual study on this type of aircraft. The characteristics of the results are known
from fundamental aeronautical equations but the numerical values related to the speed and
geometry is individual for each aircraft. The result of the plots shows expected shapes in the
higher Mach region and by comparing other airplanes in the same category it shows similar
results.
For M=0.88 and M= 0.92 the results show no or only a slight change in the performance
which should need a more accurate investigation. This could be an effect of converge the
models to the lowest CD. Probably should the M=0.88 study be rejected because that case is
not optimized in perspective of the compressibility interference module. Instead it is made
directly from the baseline of G650.
15
Chapter 5
FUTURE WORK
• Improve the modification tool with more input variables and include it in Jetsizer.
• Improve the winglet formula in Jetsizer.
• Improve the compressibility interference module in Jetsizer.
16
Chapter 6
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I want to thank my supervisor Mark Page at Swift Engineering for arranging this thesis
work and made it possible for me to join them at Swift for 10 weeks. I have to thank Mark for
all his help and for his imaginativeness that usually solves even the toughest problems.
Thanks to all the guys at Swift; Ed Smetak, for helping me arrange a living during the
stay and driving me to work every day and letting me experience the life in California. Any
Luo, for supervising me in this project and helping me with everything associated with
computers and aerodynamics. John Winkler, for your experienced help with aeronautical
topics and for showing me around in the mountainous Californian run track.
Thanks to Chris Thompson for letting a complete stranger from Sweden to occupy one of
your wonderful bedrooms in the magnificent beach house.
Special thank to my supervisor Gustaf Enebog at MDH, Sweden, for helping me with the
formal elements of this thesis work and for the contacts who gave me this opportunity.
I finally want to thank the international unit at MDH for financing my time abroad.
Niklas Bergman
17
Chapter 7
REFERENCES
1. Dr. Jan Roskam. Airplane Design Part I,”Preliminary Sizing of Airplanes”, DARcorporation
2005, ISBN-13: 978-1-884885-42-6
2. Dr. Jan Roskam. Airplane Design Part II, ”Preliminary Configuration Design and Integration
of the Propulsion System” ,DARcorporation 2005, ISBN: 1-884885-43-8
3. Dr. Jan Roskam. Airplane Design Part III, ”Layout Design of Cockpit, Fuselage, Wing and
Empennage: Cutaways and Inboard Profiles”, DARcorporation 2005, ISBN: 1-884885-56-x
4. Dr. Jan Roskam. Airplane Design Part VI, ”Preliminary Calculations of Aerodynamic, Thrust
and Power Characteristics”, DARcorporation 2005, ISBN-13: 978-1-884885-
52-5
5. Dr. Jan Roskam. Airplane Design Part VII, ”Determination of Stability, Control and
Performance Characteristics: FAR and Military Requirements”, DARcorporation 2005, ISBN-
13: 978-1-884885-54-9
6. Aviation week & space technology, Aerospace source book, January 26, 2009
7. Robert L. Nelson Clement J. Welsh. “Examples of the Applications of the Transonic and
Supersonic Area Rules to the Prediction of Wave Drag”, NACA RM L56D11, Langley
Aeronautical Laboratory, Langley Field, Va., 20 March 1957.
8. Whitcomb, Richard T. “A Study of the Zero-Lift Drag-Rise Characteristics of Wing-Body
Combinations Near the Speed of Sound”, NACA RM L52H08, Langley Aeronautical
Laboratory, Langley Field, Va., 3 September 1952.
9. John D. Anderson, Jr. Fundamentals of Aerodynamics, Mc Graw Hill 2007, ISBN: 007-
125408-0
18
A. APPENDIX
Baseline model cruise speed Mach 0.88.
Fuselage & Materials
Ncrew = 2 n.d. Typ 3 class
Nattendants = 2 n.d. Natt =1
Diameter (avg), Dfus = 8,6 ft Dfus =6,1
Total Length, Lfus = 87 ft Lfus =59
# Coach Seats Abreast = 2 n.d. -
Number of Aisles = 1 n.d. -
Fineness Ratio (L/Dia)fus = 10,0 n.d.
LH2:TankWt/FuelWt | InsulatnWt/Area = 0,0 0,0
n.d. | lbs/ft2
Wing Materials = COMP "AL", "ALLI", "COMP"
Fuselage Materials = COMP "AL", "ALLI", "COMP"
Empennage Materials = COMP "AL", "ALLI", "COMP"
Fuel Type = Kerosene "Kerosene", "LH2"
Propulsion
SLST per engine = 14 600 lbs 2 Engines
Neng = 2 n.d.
Eng Location = F
"W"ing, "F"uselage
Engine Cert Date & EIS = 1980 year
Bypass Ratio (BPR) = 4,4 n.d. **TFAN**
SexposedPylon = 86,0 sq-ft per pylon
Fuel Price = 1,1 $/USgal
Geometry (Trap) Wing Horiz Vert Planform Area, S = 950,0 207,2 103,8
Span, b = 87,2 26,9 10,9
19
Mean Aero Chord, MAC = 12,2 8,0 9,9
Croot = 17,4 10,5 12,9
Ctip = 4,4 4,9 6,1
CSOB = 16,2 - -
bH/bw = - 0,309 -
Wing Sw = 950 sq-ft
(t/c)avg = 0,101 n.d. Drag Div AOK
Λχ/4 = 35,00 deg Drag Div AOK
ARw = 8,00 n.d. AOK - no flutter
Ult. Load Factor Nult = 3,5 g's
TRw = 0,25 n.d.
Winglet Height, hwglt = 6,0 ft AOK - no flutter
SplanformWinglet = 35,3 sq-ft total both panels
Airfoil Type = SCDTE "CONV", "SC", "SCDTE"
Φλαπ Σπαν ηΟ/Β φλαπ = 0,75
fraction of semispan
FlapType = D "N"one,"S"ingle,"D"ouble
Leading Edge Slat = No "Yes". "No"
Empennage Horizontal Vertical
Tail Volume Ratio, VH = 0,707 0,04
1 n.d.
Aspect Ratio, ARH = 3,50 1,15 n.d.
Tail Sweep, LH = 44,0 44,0 deg
Taper Ratio, TRH = 0,47 0,47 n.d.
Tail Length, LH = 39,5 32,9 ft
Elevator / Rudder Types = Simple SHR See comments
SASoff SM% / Tail Pos'n = 9 T See comments
D
Performance Actual Limit Crz SFC = 0,633743 - lb/hr/lb
TOGW = 84 326 - lbs
MLW = 73 652 - lbs
OEW = 38 195 - lbs
Fuel Burn = 35 566 - lbs
TOFL = 10 368 11 000 ft @TOGW
LFL = 4 989 5 000 ft @ MLW
Buffet Limited CL@ICA = 0,43 0,67 n.d.
ROC@ICA = 301 300 fpm
Wingspan = 87 120 ft
VLdg@MLW = 136 150 @1.3Vsmin
L/Dcrz = 16,77 - n.d.
DOC/pax-nmi = 0,19 $/pax-nmi
Performance Summary TOGW/Sw = 88,8 psf
TOGW/PaxNmi = 0,67 lbs/Pax-nmi
20
Thrust/TOGW = 0,35 n.d.
FB/PaxNmi= 0,282 lbs/Pax-nmi
Floor Space per Pax = #N/A sq-ft
Cargo Bay Volume per Pax = 6,71 cu-ft under-floor cargo
OEW/TOGW = 45,3% n.d.
FB/TOGW = 42,2% n.d.
PAY/TOGW = 7,7% n.d.
Cruise Conditions
Max Allowable CL@ICA = 0,67 n.d. Buffet Limited CLcrz
=CLbuffet/1.3
qCrz = 202,9 psf
VtrueCrz = 851,789 fps
Mission Requirements
Mixed-Class Pax Count = 18 n.d.
(Pax) Customer Reqm't
Still Air Range = 7 000 nmi. Customer Reqm't
Mcrz = 0,88 n.d. Design Variable
Mission Revenue Cargo = 2 630 lbs Customer Reqm't
Max Payload @ MLW = 35 000 lbs Customer Reqm't
%Mission Fuel @ MLW = 0,1 % Customer Reqm't
User Selected ICA = 41 000 ft Design Variable
Min ROC @ICA = 300 fpm Customer Reqm't
Max TOFL @ MTOGW = 11 000 ft Customer Reqm't
Max LFL @ MLW = 5 000 ft Customer Reqm't
Max VLdg @MLW = 135 KEAS Customer Reqm't
TOFL & LFL Altitude = 0 ft Customer Reqm't
TOFL & LFL Temp = 59 °F Customer Reqm't
Max Wingspan = 99,85 ft Customer Reqm't
Number of Planes Built = 500 n.d. Customer Reqm't
Wing & Tails Wing Horiz. Vertical Winglet
Tail Volume Ratio, V = NA 0,71 0,041 NA n.d.
Axial Tail Pos'n (Xc/4-Xblkhd) = NA 180 100 NA in.
Aspect Ratio, AR = 8,00 3,50 1,15 2,04 n.d.
Sweep Angle, Lc/4 = 35,00 44,00 44,00 40 deg
Planform Break Pos'n Ybreak/(b/2) = 0,2 0,00 0,00 NA n.d.
Break Taper Ratio Cbreak/Croot = NA 1,00 1,00 NA n.d.
Tip Taper Ratio, Ctip/Croot = 0,25 0,47 0,47 0,35 n.d.
Glove Extension at SOB, DC/CSOB = 0 NA NA NA 0,5
Yehudi Extension at SOB, DC/CSOB = 0,15 NA NA NA n.d.
Flap Chord Fraction Cflap/Cw = 0,18 0,25 0,25 NA n.d.
Area, total trapezoidal, S = 950 207 104 35 sq-ft
Span, b = 87 27 11 6 ft
Wing Dihedral Angle, G = 3 0,00 NA 75 deg
Vertical Offset, DZ = -40 150,00 30,00 NA in.
Airfoil t/c @ SOB = 0,150 NA NA NA n.d.
Airfoil t/c @ Break = 0,120 0,07 0,07 NA n.d.
21
Airfoil t/c @ Tip = 0,085 NA NA NA n.d.
MAC Incidence Angle = 2 -3,00 NA NA deg
Axial Wing pos'n, Xc/4trap@C/L = 454,1984 NA NA NA in. Front Spar Pos'n, XFS/C
= 0,1 NA NA NA n.d.
Rear Spar pos'n at SOB, XRS/C = 0,75 NA NA NA n.d.
Rear Spar pos'n, Break->Tip, XRS/C = 0,7 NA NA NA n.d.
Fuselage Total Fuselage Length, Lfus = 1040 in.
Nose Fineness Ratio, Lnose/Dia = 1,9 n.d.
Tailcone Fineness Ratio, Ltail/Dia = 3,5 n.d.
Tailcone Height Ratio, Htip/Hfus = 0,2 n.d.
Tailcone Width Ratio, Wtip/Wfus = 0,05 n.d.
Nose Droop Ratio, DZ/Hfus = 0,16 n.d.
Tailcone Rise Ratio, DZ/Hfus = 0,2 n.d.
Cockpit Bulkhead pos'n, DX/Lnose = 0,65 in.
Aft Blkhd pos'n, DX/Ltailcone = 0,6 in.
Cabin FloorSpace (blkhd to blkhd) = #N/A sq-ft
Usable Floor Space per Passenger = #N/A sq-ft/pax
Nacelles Number of Nacelles = 2 1-4
Fan diameter, Dfan = 48,84282 in.
Length Ratio, L/Dfan = 3 n.d.
Dia.Ratio, Dnac/Dfan = 1,25 n.d.
Inboard Outboard
Lateral pos'n Y = 0,00 80,00 in.
(Xnozzle-XLEwing) = 0,00 -20,00 n.d.
Z rel to WingLE or floor = 0,00 35,00 n.d.
Nose Gear Z pos'n of Trunnion = -30 in.
X station of nosegear = 98,0 in.
Tire Pressure = 900 psi
Number of Tires = 2 1,2
Limits
MinWng/GW @ aft c.g. = 0,04 n.d.
1g Pitch Angle = 10,0 deg
No Gear Load Pitch Angle = 12,0 deg
1g Roll Clearance Angle = 8,0 deg
Main Gear Static Ground Line pos'n
= -90,0 in.
Z pos'n of Trunnion = -46,0 in.
22
Y pos'n of Trunnion = 75,0 in.
Strut Aft-sweep, Extended = 3,0 deg
Strut Aft-sweep, Retracted = 6,0 deg
Oleo Stroke-Out from 1g = 10,0 in.
Oleo Stroke-In from 1g = 1,0 in.
X maingear = 642,0 in.
Tire Pressure = 200 psi
Number of Tires per Truck = 2 1,2,4
23
B. APPENDIX
Optimized model for cruise speed Mach 0.88
Fuselage & Materials
Ncrew = 2 n.d.
Typ 3 class
Nattendants = 2 n.d. Natt =1
Diameter (avg), Dfus = 8,6 ft
Dfus =6,1
Total Length, Lfus = 87 ft Lfus =59
# Coach Seats Abreast = 2 n.d. -
Number of Aisles = 1 n.d. -
Fineness Ratio (L/Dia)fus = 10,0 n.d.
LH2:TankWt/FuelWt | InsulatnWt/Area = 0,0 0,0
n.d. | lbs/ft2
Wing Materials = COMP "AL", "ALLI", "COMP"
Fuselage Materials = COMP "AL", "ALLI", "COMP"
Empennage Materials = COMP "AL", "ALLI", "COMP"
Fuel Type = Kerosene "Kerosene", "LH2"
Propulsion
SLST per engine = 15 200 lbs 2 Engines
Neng = 2 n.d.
Eng Location = F
"W"ing, "F"uselage
Engine Cert Date & EIS = 1980 year
Bypass Ratio (BPR) = 5 n.d. **TFAN**
SexposedPylon = 86,0 sq-ft per pylon
24
Fuel Price = 1,1 $/USgal
Geometry (Trap) Wing Horiz Vert Planform Area, S = 930,0 183,7 105,5
Span, b = 86,3 25,4 11,0
Mean Aero Chord, MAC = 12,1 7,6 10,0
Croot = 17,3 9,9 13,0
Ctip = 4,3 4,6 6,1
CSOB = 16,0 - -
bH/bw = - 0,294 -
Mission Requirements
Mixed-Class Pax Count = 18 n.d.
(Pax) Customer
Reqm't
Still Air Range = 7 000 nmi.
Customer Reqm't
Mcrz = 0,88 n.d.
Design Variable
Mission Revenue Cargo = 2 630 lbs
Customer Reqm't
Max Payload @ MLW = 35 000 lbs
Customer Reqm't
%Mission Fuel @ MLW = 0,1 %
Customer Reqm't
User Selected ICA = 41 000 ft
Design Variable
Min ROC @ICA = 300 fpm
Customer Reqm't
Max TOFL @ MTOGW = 11 000 ft
Customer Reqm't
Max LFL @ MLW = 5 000 ft
Customer Reqm't
Max VLdg @MLW = 135 KEAS
Customer Reqm't
TOFL & LFL Altitude = 0 ft
Customer Reqm't
TOFL & LFL Temp = 59 °F
Customer Reqm't
Max Wingspan = 99,85 ft Customer Reqm't
Number of Planes Built = 500 n.d. Customer Reqm't
Wing Sw = 930 sq-ft
(t/c)avg = 0,116 n.d. Drag Div AOK
Λχ/4 = 42,00 deg Drag Div AOK
ARw = 8,00 n.d. AOK - no flutter
Ult. Load Factor Nult = 3,5 g's
TRw = 0,25 n.d.
Winglet Height, hwglt = 6,0 ft AOK - no flutter
SplanformWinglet = 34,9 sq-ft total both panels
Airfoil Type = SCDTE "CONV", "SC", "SCDTE"
Φλαπ Σπαν ηΟ/Β φλαπ = 0,75 fraction of semispan
FlapType = D "N"one,"S"ingle,"D"ouble
25
Leading Edge Slat = No "Yes". "No"
Empennage Horizontal Vertical
Tail Volume Ratio, VH = 0,661 0,04
4 n.d.
Aspect Ratio, ARH = 3,50 1,15 n.d.
Tail Sweep, LH = 44,0 44,0 deg
Taper Ratio, TRH = 0,47 0,47 n.d.
Tail Length, LH = 40,4 33,8 ft
Elevator / Rudder Types = Simple SHR See comments
SASoff SM% / Tail Pos'n = 9 T See comments
D
Performance Actual Limit Crz SFC = 0,61866 - lb/hr/lb
TOGW = 83 135 - lbs
MLW = 73 633 - lbs
OEW = 38 189 - lbs
Fuel Burn = 34 502 - lbs
TOFL = 9 594 11 000 ft @TOGW
LFL = 4 986 5 000 ft @ MLW
Buffet Limited CL@ICA = 0,43 0,76 n.d.
ROC@ICA = 302 300 fpm
Wingspan = 86 120 ft
VLdg@MLW = 136 150 @1.3Vsmin
L/Dcrz = 16,72 - n.d.
DOC/pax-nmi = 0,19 $/pax-nmi
Performance Summary TOGW/Sw = 89,4 psf
TOGW/PaxNmi = 0,66 lbs/Pax-nmi
Thrust/TOGW = 0,37 n.d.
FB/PaxNmi= 0,274 lbs/Pax-nmi
Floor Space per Pax = #N/A sq-ft
Cargo Bay Volume per Pax = 6,75 cu-ft under-floor cargo
OEW/TOGW = 45,9% n.d.
FB/TOGW = 41,5% n.d.
PAY/TOGW = 7,8% n.d.
Cruise Conditions
Max Allowable CL@ICA = 0,76 n.d. Buffet Limited CLcrz
=CLbuffet/1.3
qCrz = 202,9 psf
VtrueCrz = 851,789 fps
Wing & Tails Wing Horiz. Vertical Winglet
Tail Volume Ratio, V = NA 0,66 0,044 NA n.d.
Axial Tail Pos'n (Xc/4-Xblkhd) = NA 180 100 NA in.
Aspect Ratio, AR = 8,00 3,50 1,15 2,06 n.d.
Sweep Angle, Lc/4 = 42,00 44,00 44,00 40 deg
26
Planform Break Pos'n Ybreak/(b/2) = 0,2 0,00 0,00 NA n.d.
Break Taper Ratio Cbreak/Croot = NA 1,00 1,00 NA n.d.
Tip Taper Ratio, Ctip/Croot = 0,25 0,47 0,47 0,35 n.d.
Glove Extension at SOB, DC/CSOB = 0 NA NA NA 0,5
Yehudi Extension at SOB, DC/CSOB = 0,15 NA NA NA n.d.
Flap Chord Fraction Cflap/Cw = 0,18 0,25 0,25 NA n.d.
Area, total trapezoidal, S = 930 184 106 35 sq-ft
Span, b = 86 25 11 6 ft
Wing Dihedral Angle, G = 3 0,00 NA 75 deg
Vertical Offset, DZ = -40 150,00 30,00 NA in.
Airfoil t/c @ SOB = 0,150 NA NA NA n.d.
Airfoil t/c @ Break = 0,128 0,07 0,07 NA n.d.
Airfoil t/c @ Tip = 0,105 NA NA NA n.d.
MAC Incidence Angle = 2 -3,00 NA NA deg Axial Wing pos'n, Xc/4trap@C/L
= 403,3681 NA NA NA in. Front Spar Pos'n,
XFS/C = 0,1 NA NA NA n.d. Rear Spar pos'n at SOB,
XRS/C = 0,75 NA NA NA n.d. Rear Spar pos'n, Break->Tip,
XRS/C = 0,7 NA NA NA n.d.
Fuselage Total Fuselage Length,
Lfus = 1040 in.
Nose Fineness Ratio, Lnose/Dia = 1,9 n.d.
Tailcone Fineness Ratio, Ltail/Dia = 3,5 n.d.
Tailcone Height Ratio, Htip/Hfus = 0,2 n.d.
Tailcone Width Ratio, Wtip/Wfus = 0,05 n.d.
Nose Droop Ratio, DZ/Hfus = 0,16 n.d.
Tailcone Rise Ratio, DZ/Hfus = 0,2 n.d.
Cockpit Bulkhead pos'n, DX/Lnose = 0,65 in.
Aft Blkhd pos'n, DX/Ltailcone = 0,6 in.
Cabin FloorSpace (blkhd to blkhd) = #N/A sq-ft
Usable Floor Space per Passenger = #N/A sq-ft/pax
Nacelles
Number of Nacelles = 2 1-4
Fan diameter, Dfan = 50,33223 in.
Length Ratio, L/Dfan = 3 n.d.
Dia.Ratio, Dnac/Dfan = 1,25 n.d.
Inboard Outboard
Lateral pos'n Y = 0,00 80,00 in.
(Xnozzle-XLEwing) = 0,00 -20,00 n.d.
27
Z rel to WingLE or floor = 0,00 35,00 n.d.
Nose Gear Z pos'n of Trunnion
= -30 in.
X station of nosegear = 98,0 in.
Tire Pressure = 900 psi
Number of Tires = 2 1,2
Limits
MinWng/GW @ aft c.g. = 0,04 n.d.
1g Pitch Angle = 10,0 deg
No Gear Load Pitch Angle = 12,0 deg
1g Roll Clearance Angle = 8,0 deg
Main Gear Static Ground Line
pos'n = -90,0 in.
Z pos'n of Trunnion = -46,0 in.
Y pos'n of Trunnion = 75,0 in.
Strut Aft-sweep, Extended = 3,0 deg
Strut Aft-sweep, Retracted = 6,0 deg
Oleo Stroke-Out from 1g = 10,0 in.
Oleo Stroke-In from 1g = 1,0 in.
X maingear = 638,8 in.
Tire Pressure = 200 psi
Number of Tires per Truck = 2 1,2,4
28
C. APPENDIX
Optimized model for cruise speed Mach 0.92
Fuselage & Materials
Ncrew = 2 n.d. Typ 3 class
Nattendants = 2 n.d. Natt =1
Diameter (avg), Dfus = 8,6 ft
Dfus =6,1
Total Length, Lfus = 92 ft Lfus =59
# Coach Seats Abreast = 2 n.d. -
Number of Aisles = 1 n.d. -
Fineness Ratio (L/Dia)fus = 10,7 n.d.
LH2:TankWt/FuelWt | InsulatnWt/Area = 0,0 0,0
n.d. | lbs/ft2
Wing Materials = COMP "AL", "ALLI", "COMP"
Fuselage Materials = COMP "AL", "ALLI", "COMP"
Empennage Materials = COMP "AL", "ALLI", "COMP"
Fuel Type = Kerosene "Kerosene", "LH2"
Propulsion
SLST per engine = 15 800 lbs 2 Engines
Neng = 2 n.d.
Eng Location = F
"W"ing, "F"uselage
Engine Cert Date & EIS = 1980 year
Bypass Ratio (BPR) = 5 n.d. **TFAN**
SexposedPylon = 86,0 sq-ft per pylon
Fuel Price = 1,1 $/USgal
29
Geometry (Trap) Wing Horiz Vert Planform Area, S = 940,0 116,4 97,7
Span, b = 86,7 20,2 10,6
Mean Aero Chord, MAC = 12,1 6,0 9,6
Croot = 17,3 7,8 12,5
Ctip = 4,3 3,7 5,9
CSOB = 16,1 - -
bH/bw = - 0,233 -
Mission Requirements
Mixed-Class Pax Count = 18 n.d.
(Pax) Customer
Reqm't
Still Air Range = 7 000 nmi.
Customer Reqm't
Mcrz = 0,92 n.d. Design Variable
Mission Revenue Cargo = 2 630 lbs
Customer Reqm't
Max Payload @ MLW = 35 000 lbs
Customer Reqm't
%Mission Fuel @ MLW = 0,1 %
Customer Reqm't
User Selected ICA = 41 000 ft Design Variable
Min ROC @ICA = 300 fpm
Customer Reqm't
Max TOFL @ MTOGW = 11 000 ft
Customer Reqm't
Max LFL @ MLW = 5 000 ft
Customer Reqm't
Max VLdg @MLW = 140 KEAS
Customer Reqm't
TOFL & LFL Altitude = 0 ft
Customer Reqm't
TOFL & LFL Temp = 59 °F
Customer Reqm't
Max Wingspan = 105 ft Customer Reqm't
Number of Planes Built = 500 n.d. Customer Reqm't
Wing Sw = 940 sq-ft
(t/c)avg = 0,114 n.d. Drag Div AOK
Λχ/4 = 42,00 deg Drag Div AOK
ARw = 8,00 n.d. AOK - no flutter
Ult. Load Factor Nult = 3,5 g's
TRw = 0,25 n.d.
Winglet Height, hwglt = 6,0 ft AOK - no flutter
SplanformWinglet = 35,1 sq-ft total both panels
Airfoil Type = SCDTE "CONV", "SC", "SCDTE"
Φλαπ Σπαν ηΟ/Β φλαπ = 0,75 fraction of semispan
FlapType = D "N"one,"S"ingle,"D"ouble
Leading Edge Slat = No "Yes". "No"
Empennage Horizontal Vertical
30
Tail Volume Ratio, VH = 0,445 0,04
4 n.d.
Aspect Ratio, ARH = 3,50 1,15 n.d.
Tail Sweep, LH = 50,0 50,0 deg
Taper Ratio, TRH = 0,47 0,47 n.d.
Tail Length, LH = 43,7 37,0 ft
Elevator / Rudder Types = Simple SHR See comments
SASoff SM% / Tail Pos'n = 9 T See comments
D
Performance Actual Limit Crz SFC = 0,633812 - lb/hr/lb
TOGW = 84 459 - lbs
MLW = 74 161 - lbs
OEW = 38 708 - lbs
Fuel Burn = 35 225 - lbs
TOFL = 9 570 11 000 ft @TOGW
LFL = 4 998 5 000 ft @ MLW
Buffet Limited CL@ICA = 0,40 0,69 n.d.
ROC@ICA = 302 300 fpm
Wingspan = 87 120 ft
VLdg@MLW = 136 150 @1.3Vsmin
L/Dcrz = 16,28 - n.d.
DOC/pax-nmi = 0,19 $/pax-nmi
Performance Summary TOGW/Sw = 89,9 psf
TOGW/PaxNmi = 0,67 lbs/Pax-nmi
Thrust/TOGW = 0,37 n.d.
FB/PaxNmi= 0,280 lbs/Pax-nmi
Floor Space per Pax = #N/A sq-ft
Cargo Bay Volume per Pax = 6,23 cu-ft under-floor cargo
OEW/TOGW = 45,8% n.d.
FB/TOGW = 41,7% n.d.
PAY/TOGW = 7,7% n.d.
Cruise Conditions
Max Allowable CL@ICA = 0,69 n.d. Buffet Limited CLcrz
=CLbuffet/1.3
qCrz = 221,8 psf
VtrueCrz = 890,507 fps
Wing & Tails Wing Horiz. Vertical Winglet
Tail Volume Ratio, V = NA 0,45 0,044 NA n.d.
Axial Tail Pos'n (Xc/4-Xblkhd) = NA 200 120 NA in.
Aspect Ratio, AR = 8,00 3,50 1,15 2,05 n.d.
Sweep Angle, Lc/4 = 42,00 50,00 50,00 40 deg Planform Break Pos'n Ybreak/(b/2)
= 0,25 0,00 0,00 NA n.d.
Break Taper Ratio Cbreak/Croot = NA 1,00 1,00 NA n.d.
31
Tip Taper Ratio, Ctip/Croot = 0,25 0,47 0,47 0,35 n.d. Glove Extension at SOB, DC/CSOB
= 0 NA NA NA 0,5 Yehudi Extension at SOB,
DC/CSOB = 0,35 NA NA NA n.d.
Flap Chord Fraction Cflap/Cw = 0,18 0,25 0,25 NA n.d.
Area, total trapezoidal, S = 940 116 98 35 sq-ft
Span, b = 87 20 11 6 ft
Wing Dihedral Angle, G = 3 0,00 NA 75 deg
Vertical Offset, DZ = -40 140,00 35,00 NA in.
Airfoil t/c @ SOB = 0,150 NA NA NA n.d.
Airfoil t/c @ Break = 0,130 0,07 0,07 NA n.d.
Airfoil t/c @ Tip = 0,100 NA NA NA n.d.
MAC Incidence Angle = 2 -3,00 NA NA deg
Axial Wing pos'n, Xc/4trap@C/L = 451,9088 NA NA NA in. Front Spar Pos'n,
XFS/C = 0,1 NA NA NA n.d. Rear Spar pos'n at SOB,
XRS/C = 0,75 NA NA NA n.d. Rear Spar pos'n, Break->Tip,
XRS/C = 0,7 NA NA NA n.d.
Fuselage Total Fuselage Length,
Lfus = 1108 in.
Nose Fineness Ratio, Lnose/Dia = 2,9 n.d.
Tailcone Fineness Ratio, Ltail/Dia = 3,5 n.d.
Tailcone Height Ratio, Htip/Hfus = 0,2 n.d.
Tailcone Width Ratio, Wtip/Wfus = 0,05 n.d.
Nose Droop Ratio, DZ/Hfus = 0,16 n.d.
Tailcone Rise Ratio, DZ/Hfus = 0,2 n.d.
Cockpit Bulkhead pos'n, DX/Lnose = 0,65 in.
Aft Blkhd pos'n, DX/Ltailcone = 0,6 in.
Cabin FloorSpace (blkhd to blkhd) = #N/A sq-ft
Usable Floor Space per Passenger = #N/A sq-ft/pax
Nacelles Number of Nacelles = 2 1-4
Fan diameter, Dfan = 51,31601 in.
Length Ratio, L/Dfan = 3 n.d.
Dia.Ratio, Dnac/Dfan = 1,25 n.d.
Inboard Outboard
Lateral pos'n Y = 0,00 80,00 in.
(Xnozzle-XLEwing) = 0,00 40,00 n.d.
Z rel to WingLE or floor = 0,00 33,00 n.d.
Nose Gear Z pos'n of Trunnion = -30 in.
32
X station of nosegear = 100,0 in.
Tire Pressure = 900 psi
Number of Tires = 2 1,2
Limits
MinWng/GW @ aft c.g. = 0,04 n.d.
1g Pitch Angle = 10,0 deg
No Gear Load Pitch Angle = 12,0 deg
1g Roll Clearance Angle = 8,0 deg
Main Gear Static Ground Line
pos'n = -90,0 in.
Z pos'n of Trunnion = -42,0 in.
Y pos'n of Trunnion = 75,0 in.
Strut Aft-sweep, Extended = 3,0 deg
Strut Aft-sweep, Retracted = 6,0 deg
Oleo Stroke-Out from 1g = 8,0 in.
Oleo Stroke-In from 1g = 1,0 in.
X maingear = 683,0 in.
Tire Pressure = 200 psi
Number of Tires per Truck = 2 1,2,4
33
D. APPENDIX
Optimized model for cruise speed Mach 0.96
Fuselage & Materials
Ncrew = 2 n.d. Typ 3 class
Nattendants = 2 n.d. Natt =1
Diameter (avg), Dfus = 8,6 ft
Dfus =6,1
Total Length, Lfus = 107 ft Lfus =59
# Coach Seats Abreast = 2 n.d. -
Number of Aisles = 1 n.d. -
Fineness Ratio (L/Dia)fus = 12,4 n.d.
LH2:TankWt/FuelWt | InsulatnWt/Area = 0,0 0,0
n.d. | lbs/ft2
Wing Materials = COMP "AL", "ALLI", "COMP"
Fuselage Materials = COMP "AL", "ALLI", "COMP"
Empennage Materials = COMP "AL", "ALLI", "COMP"
Fuel Type = Kerosene "Kerosene", "LH2"
Propulsion
SLST per engine = 17 300 lbs 2 Engines
Neng = 2 n.d.
Eng Location = F
"W"ing, "F"uselage
Engine Cert Date & EIS = 1980 year
Bypass Ratio (BPR) = 4,5 n.d. **TFAN**
SexposedPylon = 86,0 sq-ft per pylon
Fuel Price = 1,1 $/USgal
34
Geometry (Trap) Wing Horiz Vert Planform Area, S = 1025,0 107,3 96,6
Span, b = 84,7 19,4 10,5
Mean Aero Chord, MAC = 13,6 5,8 9,6
Croot = 19,4 7,5 12,5
Ctip = 4,8 3,5 5,9
CSOB = 17,9 - -
bH/bw = - 0,229 -
Mission Requirements
Mixed-Class Pax Count = 18 n.d.
(Pax) Customer
Reqm't
Still Air Range = 7 000 nmi.
Customer Reqm't
Mcrz = 0,96 n.d. Design Variable
Mission Revenue Cargo = 2 630 lbs
Customer Reqm't
Max Payload @ MLW = 35 000 lbs
Customer Reqm't
%Mission Fuel @ MLW = 0,1 %
Customer Reqm't
User Selected ICA = 41 000 ft Design Variable
Min ROC @ICA = 300 fpm
Customer Reqm't
Max TOFL @ MTOGW = 11 000 ft
Customer Reqm't
Max LFL @ MLW = 5 000 ft
Customer Reqm't
Max VLdg @MLW = 140 KEAS
Customer Reqm't
TOFL & LFL Altitude = 0 ft
Customer Reqm't
TOFL & LFL Temp = 59 °F
Customer Reqm't
Max Wingspan = 105 ft Customer Reqm't
Number of Planes Built = 500 n.d. Customer Reqm't
Wing Sw = 1 025 sq-ft
(t/c)avg = 0,114 n.d. Drag Div AOK
Λχ/4 = 45,00 deg Drag Div AOK
ARw = 7,00 n.d. AOK - no flutter
Ult. Load Factor Nult = 3,5 g's
TRw = 0,25 n.d.
Winglet Height, hwglt = 6,0 ft AOK - no flutter
SplanformWinglet = 39,2 sq-ft total both panels
Airfoil Type = SCDTE "CONV", "SC", "SCDTE"
Φλαπ Σπαν ηΟ/Β φλαπ = 0,75 fraction of semispan
FlapType = D "N"one,"S"ingle,"D"ouble
Leading Edge Slat = No "Yes". "No"
35
Empennage Horizontal Vertical
Tail Volume Ratio, VH = 0,396 0,04
6 n.d.
Aspect Ratio, ARH = 3,50 1,15 n.d.
Tail Sweep, LH = 55,0 55,0 deg
Taper Ratio, TRH = 0,47 0,47 n.d.
Tail Length, LH = 51,3 40,9 ft
Elevator / Rudder Types = Simple SHR See comments
SASoff SM% / Tail Pos'n = 9 T See comments
D
Performance Actual Limit Crz SFC = 0,661906 - lb/hr/lb
TOGW = 92 528 - lbs
MLW = 76 768 - lbs
OEW = 41 252 - lbs
Fuel Burn = 40 184 - lbs
TOFL = 10 625 11 000 ft @TOGW
LFL = 5 005 5 000 ft @ MLW
Buffet Limited CL@ICA = 0,37 0,67 n.d.
ROC@ICA = 301 300 fpm
Wingspan = 85 120 ft
VLdg@MLW = 136 150 @1.3Vsmin
L/Dcrz = 15,44 - n.d.
DOC/pax-nmi = 0,20 $/pax-nmi
Performance Summary TOGW/Sw = 90,3 psf
TOGW/PaxNmi = 0,73 lbs/Pax-nmi
Thrust/TOGW = 0,37 n.d.
FB/PaxNmi= 0,319 lbs/Pax-nmi
Floor Space per Pax = #N/A sq-ft
Cargo Bay Volume per Pax = 5,80 cu-ft under-floor cargo
OEW/TOGW = 44,6% n.d.
FB/TOGW = 43,4% n.d.
PAY/TOGW = 7,0% n.d.
Cruise Conditions
Max Allowable CL@ICA = 0,67 n.d. Buffet Limited CLcrz
=CLbuffet/1.3
qCrz = 241,5 psf
VtrueCrz = 929,224 fps
Wing & Tails Wing Horiz. Vertical Winglet
Tail Volume Ratio, V = NA 0,40 0,046 NA n.d.
Axial Tail Pos'n (Xc/4-Xblkhd) = NA 270 145 NA in.
Aspect Ratio, AR = 7,00 3,50 1,15 1,84 n.d.
Sweep Angle, Lc/4 = 45,00 55,00 55,00 40 deg Planform Break Pos'n Ybreak/(b/2)
= 0,3 0,00 0,00 NA n.d.
36
Break Taper Ratio Cbreak/Croot = NA 1,00 1,00 NA n.d.
Tip Taper Ratio, Ctip/Croot = 0,25 0,47 0,47 0,35 n.d. Glove Extension at SOB, DC/CSOB
= 0 NA NA NA 0,5 Yehudi Extension at SOB,
DC/CSOB = 0,36 NA NA NA n.d.
Flap Chord Fraction Cflap/Cw = 0,18 0,25 0,25 NA n.d.
Area, total trapezoidal, S = 1 025 107 97 39 sq-ft
Span, b = 85 19 11 6 ft
Wing Dihedral Angle, G = 3 0,00 NA 75 deg
Vertical Offset, DZ = -40 145,00 33,00 NA in.
Airfoil t/c @ SOB = 0,130 NA NA NA n.d.
Airfoil t/c @ Break = 0,140 0,07 0,07 NA n.d.
Airfoil t/c @ Tip = 0,100 NA NA NA n.d.
MAC Incidence Angle = 2 -3,00 NA NA deg
Axial Wing pos'n, Xc/4trap@C/L = 588,8221 NA NA NA in. Front Spar Pos'n,
XFS/C = 0,1 NA NA NA n.d. Rear Spar pos'n at SOB,
XRS/C = 0,75 NA NA NA n.d. Rear Spar pos'n, Break->Tip,
XRS/C = 0,75 NA NA NA n.d.
Fuselage Total Fuselage Length,
Lfus = 1283 in.
Nose Fineness Ratio, Lnose/Dia = 5,5 n.d.
Tailcone Fineness Ratio, Ltail/Dia = 3,5 n.d.
Tailcone Height Ratio, Htip/Hfus = 0,2 n.d.
Tailcone Width Ratio, Wtip/Wfus = 0,05 n.d.
Nose Droop Ratio, DZ/Hfus = 0,16 n.d.
Tailcone Rise Ratio, DZ/Hfus = 0,2 n.d.
Cockpit Bulkhead pos'n, DX/Lnose = 0,65 in.
Aft Blkhd pos'n, DX/Ltailcone = 0,6 in.
Cabin FloorSpace (blkhd to blkhd) = #N/A sq-ft
Usable Floor Space per Passenger = #N/A sq-ft/pax
Nacelles Number of Nacelles = 2 1-4
Fan diameter, Dfan = 53,25472 in.
Length Ratio, L/Dfan = 4 n.d.
Dia.Ratio, Dnac/Dfan = 1,25 n.d.
Inboard Outboard
Lateral pos'n Y = 0,00 80,00 in.
(Xnozzle-XLEwing) = 0,00 0,00 n.d.
Z rel to WingLE or floor = 0,00 33,00 n.d.
Nose Gear
37
Z pos'n of Trunnion = -30 in.
X station of nosegear = 100,0 in.
Tire Pressure = 900 psi
Number of Tires = 2 1,2
Limits
MinWng/GW @ aft c.g. = 0,04 n.d.
1g Pitch Angle = 10,0 deg
No Gear Load Pitch Angle = 12,0 deg
1g Roll Clearance Angle = 8,0 deg
Main Gear Static Ground Line
pos'n = -90,0 in.
Z pos'n of Trunnion = -42,0 in.
Y pos'n of Trunnion = 75,0 in.
Strut Aft-sweep, Extended = 3,0 deg
Strut Aft-sweep, Retracted = 6,0 deg
Oleo Stroke-Out from 1g = 8,0 in.
Oleo Stroke-In from 1g = 1,0 in.
X maingear = 840,4 in.
Tire Pressure = 200 psi
Number of Tires per Truck = 2 1,2,4
38
E. APPENDIX
Optimized model for cruise speed Mach 0.99
Fuselage & Materials
Ncrew = 2 n.d. Typ 3 class
Nattendants = 2 n.d. Natt =1
Diameter (avg), Dfus = 8,6 ft
Dfus =6,1
Total Length, Lfus = 110 ft Lfus =59
# Coach Seats Abreast = 2 n.d. -
Number of Aisles = 1 n.d. -
Fineness Ratio (L/Dia)fus = 12,7 n.d.
LH2:TankWt/FuelWt | InsulatnWt/Area = 0,0 0,0
n.d. | lbs/ft2
Wing Materials = COMP "AL", "ALLI", "COMP"
Fuselage Materials = COMP "AL", "ALLI", "COMP"
Empennage Materials = COMP "AL", "ALLI", "COMP"
Fuel Type = Kerosene "Kerosene", "LH2"
Propulsion
SLST per engine = 23 300 lbs 2 Engines
Neng = 2 n.d.
Eng Location = F
"W"ing, "F"uselage
Engine Cert Date & EIS = 1980 year
Bypass Ratio (BPR) = 5 n.d. **TFAN**
SexposedPylon = 86,0 sq-ft per pylon
Fuel Price = 1,1 $/USgal
39
Geometry (Trap) Wing Horiz Vert Planform Area, S = 1210,0 124,5 138,4
Span, b = 85,2 19,3 12,6
Mean Aero Chord, MAC = 15,9 6,7 11,4
Croot = 22,7 8,8 14,9
Ctip = 5,7 4,1 7,0
CSOB = 21,0 - -
bH/bw = - 0,227 -
Mission Requirements
Mixed-Class Pax Count = 18 n.d.
(Pax) Customer
Reqm't
Still Air Range = 7 000 nmi.
Customer Reqm't
Mcrz = 0,99 n.d. Design Variable
Mission Revenue Cargo = 2 630 lbs
Customer Reqm't
Max Payload @ MLW = 35 000 lbs
Customer Reqm't
%Mission Fuel @ MLW = 0,1 %
Customer Reqm't
User Selected ICA = 41 000 ft Design Variable
Min ROC @ICA = 300 fpm
Customer Reqm't
Max TOFL @ MTOGW = 11 000 ft
Customer Reqm't
Max LFL @ MLW = 5 000 ft
Customer Reqm't
Max VLdg @MLW = 140 KEAS
Customer Reqm't
TOFL & LFL Altitude = 0 ft
Customer Reqm't
TOFL & LFL Temp = 59 °F
Customer Reqm't
Max Wingspan = 105 ft Customer Reqm't
Number of Planes Built = 500 n.d. Customer Reqm't
Wing Sw = 1 210 sq-ft
(t/c)avg = 0,110 n.d. Drag Div AOK
Λχ/4 = 49,00 deg Drag Div AOK
ARw = 6,00 n.d. AOK - no flutter
Ult. Load Factor Nult = 3,5 g's
TRw = 0,25 n.d.
Winglet Height, hwglt = 6,0 ft AOK - no flutter
SplanformWinglet = 46,0 sq-ft total both panels
Airfoil Type = SCDTE "CONV", "SC", "SCDTE"
Φλαπ Σπαν ηΟ/Β φλαπ = 0,75 fraction of semispan
FlapType = D "N"one,"S"ingle,"D"ouble
Leading Edge Slat = No "Yes". "No"
Empennage Horizontal Vertical
40
Tail Volume Ratio, VH = 0,332 0,05
3 n.d.
Aspect Ratio, ARH = 3,00 1,15 n.d.
Tail Sweep, LH = 59,0 59,0 deg
Taper Ratio, TRH = 0,47 0,47 n.d.
Tail Length, LH = 51,4 39,7 ft
Elevator / Rudder Types = Simple SHR See comments
SASoff SM% / Tail Pos'n = 9 T See comments
D
Performance Actual Limit Crz SFC = 0,660371 - lb/hr/lb
TOGW = 108 806 - lbs
MLW = 82 705 - lbs
OEW = 47 068 - lbs
Fuel Burn = 49 572 - lbs
TOFL = 10 982 11 000 ft @TOGW
LFL = 4 962 5 000 ft @ MLW
Buffet Limited CL@ICA = 0,34 0,72 n.d.
ROC@ICA = 300 300 fpm
Wingspan = 85 120 ft
VLdg@MLW = 135 150 @1.3Vsmin
L/Dcrz = 14,01 - n.d.
DOC/pax-nmi = 0,23 $/pax-nmi
Performance Summary TOGW/Sw = 89,9 psf
TOGW/PaxNmi = 0,86 lbs/Pax-nmi
Thrust/TOGW = 0,43 n.d.
FB/PaxNmi= 0,393 lbs/Pax-nmi
Floor Space per Pax = #N/A sq-ft
Cargo Bay Volume per Pax = 5,49 cu-ft under-floor cargo
OEW/TOGW = 43,3% n.d.
FB/TOGW = 45,6% n.d.
PAY/TOGW = 6,0% n.d.
Cruise Conditions
Max Allowable CL@ICA = 0,72 n.d. Buffet Limited CLcrz
=CLbuffet/1.3
qCrz = 256,8 psf
VtrueCrz = 958,263 fps
Wing & Tails Wing Horiz. Vertical Winglet
Tail Volume Ratio, V = NA 0,33 0,053 NA n.d.
Axial Tail Pos'n (Xc/4-Xblkhd) = NA 260 120 NA in.
Aspect Ratio, AR = 6,00 3,00 1,15 1,56 n.d.
Sweep Angle, Lc/4 = 49,00 59,00 59,00 40 deg Planform Break Pos'n Ybreak/(b/2)
= 0,35 0,00 0,00 NA n.d.
Break Taper Ratio Cbreak/Croot = NA 1,00 1,00 NA n.d.
41
Tip Taper Ratio, Ctip/Croot = 0,25 0,47 0,47 0,35 n.d. Glove Extension at SOB, DC/CSOB
= 0 NA NA NA 0,5 Yehudi Extension at SOB,
DC/CSOB = 0,25 NA NA NA n.d.
Flap Chord Fraction Cflap/Cw = 0,18 0,25 0,25 NA n.d.
Area, total trapezoidal, S = 1 210 125 138 46 sq-ft
Span, b = 85 19 13 6 ft
Wing Dihedral Angle, G = 3 0,00 NA 75 deg
Vertical Offset, DZ = -40 140,00 27,00 NA in.
Airfoil t/c @ SOB = 0,150 NA NA NA n.d.
Airfoil t/c @ Break = 0,145 0,07 0,07 NA n.d.
Airfoil t/c @ Tip = 0,085 NA NA NA n.d.
MAC Incidence Angle = 2 -3,00 NA NA deg
Axial Wing pos'n, Xc/4trap@C/L = 579,5438 NA NA NA in. Front Spar Pos'n,
XFS/C = 0,1 NA NA NA n.d. Rear Spar pos'n at SOB,
XRS/C = 0,70 NA NA NA n.d. Rear Spar pos'n, Break->Tip,
XRS/C = 0,7 NA NA NA n.d.
Fuselage Total Fuselage Length,
Lfus = 1316 in.
Nose Fineness Ratio, Lnose/Dia = 6 n.d.
Tailcone Fineness Ratio, Ltail/Dia = 3,5 n.d.
Tailcone Height Ratio, Htip/Hfus = 0,2 n.d.
Tailcone Width Ratio, Wtip/Wfus = 0,05 n.d.
Nose Droop Ratio, DZ/Hfus = 0,16 n.d.
Tailcone Rise Ratio, DZ/Hfus = 0,2 n.d.
Cockpit Bulkhead pos'n, DX/Lnose = 0,65 in.
Aft Blkhd pos'n, DX/Ltailcone = 0,6 in.
Cabin FloorSpace (blkhd to blkhd) = #N/A sq-ft
Usable Floor Space per Passenger = #N/A sq-ft/pax
Nacelles Number of Nacelles = 2 1-4
Fan diameter, Dfan = 62,3164 in.
Length Ratio, L/Dfan = 4 n.d.
Dia.Ratio, Dnac/Dfan = 1,25 n.d.
Inboard Outboard
Lateral pos'n Y = 0,00 80,00 in.
(Xnozzle-XLEwing) = 0,00 0,00 n.d.
Z rel to WingLE or floor = 0,00 33,00 n.d.
Nose Gear Z pos'n of Trunnion = -30 in.
42
X station of nosegear = 100,0 in.
Tire Pressure = 900 psi
Number of Tires = 2 1,2
Limits
MinWng/GW @ aft c.g. = 0,04 n.d.
1g Pitch Angle = 10,0 deg
No Gear Load Pitch Angle = 12,0 deg
1g Roll Clearance Angle = 8,0 deg
Main Gear Static Ground Line
pos'n = -90,0 in.
Z pos'n of Trunnion = -42,0 in.
Y pos'n of Trunnion = 75,0 in.
Strut Aft-sweep, Extended = 3,0 deg
Strut Aft-sweep, Retracted = 6,0 deg
Oleo Stroke-Out from 1g = 8,0 in.
Oleo Stroke-In from 1g = 1,0 in.
X maingear = 874,8 in.
Tire Pressure = 200 psi
Number of Tires per Truck = 2 1,2,4
43
F. APPENDIX
Program codes for the modification tool excel macro.
Dim JetsizerFile As String Sub Iterate_AR() ' ' Iterate_AR Macro ' ' Dim MTOGW As Double, OEW As Double, FB As Double, LD As Double, CLCZ As Double Dim SLST As Double, tcroot As Single, tcbreak As Single, tctip As Single Dim Archive As Integer Dim VarVal As Variant Dim i As Integer, j As Integer, index As String Dim Flutter As String Application.ScreenUpdating = False JetsizerFile = Cells(2, 3) ParentWin = ThisWorkbook.Name Windows(ParentWin).Activate 'Change to WKname i = Selection.Row 'Always assume user selects first variable step on execution j = Selection.Column Archive = Cells(3, 3) 'list baseline archive index to load index = "C11" Do While Cells(i, j) <> Empty VarVal = Cells(i, j) Windows(JetsizerFile).Activate 'Load baseline from archive Sheets("Archive").Select
44
Range("A69").Select Do While ActiveCell.Value <> Archive ActiveCell.Offset(59, 0).Select Loop Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!RestoreFile" 'Load in new Variable Value Sheets("Configuration").Select Range(index).Value = VarVal 'Iterate on tc Do While Cells(81, 2) <> "FAIL" And Cells(23, 3) < 0.151 Cells(23, 3) = Cells(23, 3) + 0.001 Cells(24, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.85 Cells(25, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.7 Loop Cells(23, 3) = Cells(23, 3) - 0.001 Cells(24, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.85 Cells(25, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.7 'Run for Convergence Application.Run "Convergebuttons" Application.Run "reduceslst" 'Get Weights and Parameters MTOGW = Sheets("Mission").Range("I29") OEW = Sheets("Mission").Range("I31") FB = Sheets("Mission").Range("I32") LD = Sheets("Mission").Range("I39") CLCZ = Sheets("Aero").Range("I19") SLST = Sheets("Mission").Range("D19") tcroot = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C23") tcbreak = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C24") tctip = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C25") If Sheets("Mission").Range("K8") = "FLUTTER" Then Flutter = "Flutter" End If Windows(ParentWin).Activate 'Change to WKname Cells(i + 1, j) = MTOGW Cells(i + 2, j) = OEW Cells(i + 3, j) = FB Cells(i + 4, j) = LD Cells(i + 5, j) = CLCZ Cells(i + 6, j) = SLST Cells(i + 7, j) = tcroot Cells(i + 8, j) = tcbreak Cells(i + 9, j) = tctip
45
If Flutter = "Flutter" Then Cells(i - 1, j) = Flutter End If Flutter = Empty j = j + 1 Loop 'Load from archive Windows(JetsizerFile).Activate Sheets("Archive").Select Range("A69").Select Do While ActiveCell.Value <> Archive ActiveCell.Offset(59, 0).Select Loop Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!RestoreFile" End Sub Sub ConvergeButtons() Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!ConvergeCLandTOGW" loopnum = 0 maxloop = 20 indexch = 33 Do While loopnum < maxloop And indexch <= 38 Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!ConvergeCLandTOGW" indexch = 33 Do While Cells(indexch, 14) = "OK" indexch = indexch + 1 Loop Select Case indexch Case 33 Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!SLSTforTOFL" Case 34 Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!SizeSwForLFL" Case 35
46
Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!SizeSwForCLICA" Case 36 Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!SizeSLSTforROC" Case 38 Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!SizeSwForVldg" End Select loopnum = loopnum + 1 Loop End Sub Sub reduceSLST() Windows(JetsizerFile).Activate Sheets("Mission").Range("D19").Select SLSTtemp = ActiveCell.Value indexch = 39 Do While indexch > 38 SLSTnew = SLSTtemp - 1000 Sheets("Mission").Range("D19").Select ActiveCell.Value = SLSTnew indexch = 33 Do While Cells(indexch, 14) = "OK" indexch = indexch + 1 Loop Application.Run "ConvergeButtons" SLSTtemp = SLSTnew Loop End Sub Sub Iteration_Sweep() ' ' Iteration_Sweep Macro '
47
Dim MTOGW As Double, OEW As Double, FB As Double, LD As Double, CLCZ As Double Dim SLST As Double, tcroot As Single, tcbreak As Single, tctip As Single Dim Archive As Integer Dim VarVal As Variant Dim i As Integer, j As Integer, index As String Dim Flutter As String, MDD As String Application.ScreenUpdating = False JetsizerFile = Cells(2, 3) ParentWin = ThisWorkbook.Name Windows(ParentWin).Activate 'Change to WKname i = Selection.Row 'Always assume user selects first variable step on execution j = Selection.Column Archive = Cells(3, 3) 'list baseline archive index to load index = "C12" Do While Cells(i, j) <> Empty VarVal = Cells(i, j) Windows(JetsizerFile).Activate 'Load baseline from archive Sheets("Archive").Select Range("A69").Select Do While ActiveCell.Value <> Archive ActiveCell.Offset(59, 0).Select Loop Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!RestoreFile" 'Load in new Variable Value Sheets("Configuration").Select Range(index).Value = VarVal 'Iterate on tc Do While Cells(81, 2) <> "FAIL" And Cells(23, 3) < 0.151 Cells(23, 3) = Cells(23, 3) + 0.001 Cells(24, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.85 Cells(25, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.7 Loop
48
Cells(23, 3) = Cells(23, 3) - 0.001 Cells(24, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.85 Cells(25, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.7 'Run for Convergence Application.Run "Convergebuttons" Application.Run "reduceslst" 'Get Weights and Parameters MTOGW = Sheets("Mission").Range("I29") OEW = Sheets("Mission").Range("I31") FB = Sheets("Mission").Range("I32") LD = Sheets("Mission").Range("I39") CLCZ = Sheets("Aero").Range("I19") SLST = Sheets("Mission").Range("D19") tcroot = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C23") tcbreak = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C24") tctip = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C25") If Sheets("Mission").Range("K8") = "FLUTTER" Then Flutter = "Flutter" End If If Sheets("Mission").Range("K7") = "FAIL" Then MDD = "MDD" End If Windows(ParentWin).Activate 'Change to WKname Cells(i + 1, j) = MTOGW Cells(i + 2, j) = OEW Cells(i + 3, j) = FB Cells(i + 4, j) = LD Cells(i + 5, j) = CLCZ Cells(i + 6, j) = SLST Cells(i + 7, j) = tcroot Cells(i + 8, j) = tcbreak Cells(i + 9, j) = tctip If Flutter = "Flutter" Then Cells(i - 1, j) = Flutter End If If MDD = "MDD" Then Cells(i - 1, j) = MDD End If Flutter = Empty MDD = Empty j = j + 1
49
Loop 'Load from archive Windows(JetsizerFile).Activate Sheets("Archive").Select Range("A69").Select Do While ActiveCell.Value <> Archive ActiveCell.Offset(59, 0).Select Loop Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!RestoreFile" End Sub Sub Iteration_Winglet_Span() ' ' Iteration_Winglet_Span Macro ' Dim MTOGW As Double, OEW As Double, FB As Double, LD As Double, CLCZ As Double Dim SLST As Double, tcroot As Single, tcbreak As Single, tctip As Single Dim Archive As Integer Dim VarVal As Variant Dim i As Integer, j As Integer, index As String Application.ScreenUpdating = False JetsizerFile = Cells(2, 3) ParentWin = ThisWorkbook.Name Windows(ParentWin).Activate 'Change to WKname i = Selection.Row 'Always assume user selects first variable step on execution j = Selection.Column Archive = Cells(3, 3) 'list baseline archive index to load index = "F20" Do While Cells(i, j) <> Empty
50
VarVal = Cells(i, j) Windows(JetsizerFile).Activate 'Load baseline from archive Sheets("Archive").Select Range("A69").Select Do While ActiveCell.Value <> Archive ActiveCell.Offset(59, 0).Select Loop Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!RestoreFile" 'Load in new Variable Value Sheets("Configuration").Select Range(index).Value = VarVal 'Iterate on tc Do While Cells(81, 2) <> "FAIL" And Cells(23, 3) < 0.151 Cells(23, 3) = Cells(23, 3) + 0.001 Cells(24, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.85 Cells(25, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.7 Loop Cells(23, 3) = Cells(23, 3) - 0.001 Cells(24, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.85 Cells(25, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.7 'Run for Convergence Application.Run "Convergebuttons" Application.Run "reduceslst" 'Get Weights and Parameters MTOGW = Sheets("Mission").Range("I29") OEW = Sheets("Mission").Range("I31") FB = Sheets("Mission").Range("I32") LD = Sheets("Mission").Range("I39") CLCZ = Sheets("Aero").Range("I19") SLST = Sheets("Mission").Range("D19") tcroot = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C23") tcbreak = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C24") tctip = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C25") Windows(ParentWin).Activate 'Change to WKname Cells(i + 1, j) = MTOGW Cells(i + 2, j) = OEW Cells(i + 3, j) = FB Cells(i + 4, j) = LD Cells(i + 5, j) = CLCZ Cells(i + 6, j) = SLST Cells(i + 7, j) = tcroot
51
Cells(i + 8, j) = tcbreak Cells(i + 9, j) = tctip j = j + 1 Loop 'Load from archive Windows(JetsizerFile).Activate Sheets("Archive").Select Range("A69").Select Do While ActiveCell.Value <> Archive ActiveCell.Offset(59, 0).Select Loop Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!RestoreFile" End Sub Sub Iteration_Fuselage_length() ' ' Iteration_Fuselage_length Macro ' Dim MTOGW As Double, OEW As Double, FB As Double, LD As Double, CLCZ As Double Dim SLST As Double, tcroot As Single, tcbreak As Single, tctip As Single Dim Archive As Integer Dim VarVal As Variant Dim i As Integer, j As Integer, index As String Application.ScreenUpdating = False JetsizerFile = Cells(2, 3) ParentWin = ThisWorkbook.Name Windows(ParentWin).Activate 'Change to WKname i = Selection.Row 'Always assume user selects first variable step on execution j = Selection.Column Archive = Cells(3, 3) 'list baseline archive index to load
52
index = "C34" Do While Cells(i, j) <> Empty VarVal = Cells(i, j) Windows(JetsizerFile).Activate 'Load baseline from archive Sheets("Archive").Select Range("A69").Select Do While ActiveCell.Value <> Archive ActiveCell.Offset(59, 0).Select Loop Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!RestoreFile" 'Load in new Variable Value Sheets("Configuration").Select Range(index).Value = VarVal 'Iterate on tc Do While Cells(81, 2) <> "FAIL" And Cells(23, 3) < 0.151 Cells(23, 3) = Cells(23, 3) + 0.001 Cells(24, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.85 Cells(25, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.7 Loop Cells(23, 3) = Cells(23, 3) - 0.001 Cells(24, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.85 Cells(25, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.7 'Run for Convergence Application.Run "Convergebuttons" Application.Run "reduceslst" 'Get Weights and Parameters MTOGW = Sheets("Mission").Range("I29") OEW = Sheets("Mission").Range("I31") FB = Sheets("Mission").Range("I32") LD = Sheets("Mission").Range("I39") CLCZ = Sheets("Aero").Range("I19") SLST = Sheets("Mission").Range("D19") tcroot = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C23") tcbreak = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C24") tctip = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C25") Windows(ParentWin).Activate 'Change to WKname Cells(i + 1, j) = MTOGW Cells(i + 2, j) = OEW Cells(i + 3, j) = FB
53
Cells(i + 4, j) = LD Cells(i + 5, j) = CLCZ Cells(i + 6, j) = SLST Cells(i + 7, j) = tcroot Cells(i + 8, j) = tcbreak Cells(i + 9, j) = tctip j = j + 1 Loop 'Load from archive Windows(JetsizerFile).Activate Sheets("Archive").Select Range("A69").Select Do While ActiveCell.Value <> Archive ActiveCell.Offset(59, 0).Select Loop Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!RestoreFile" End Sub Sub Iteration_Bypass_Ratio() ' ' Iteration_Bypass_Ratio Macro ' Dim MTOGW As Double, OEW As Double, FB As Double, LD As Double, CLCZ As Double Dim SLST As Double, tcroot As Single, tcbreak As Single, tctip As Single Dim Archive As Integer Dim VarVal As Variant Dim i As Integer, j As Integer, index As String Application.ScreenUpdating = False JetsizerFile = Cells(2, 3) ParentWin = ThisWorkbook.Name Windows(ParentWin).Activate 'Change to WKname
54
i = Selection.Row 'Always assume user selects first variable step on execution j = Selection.Column Archive = Cells(3, 3) 'list baseline archive index to load index = "D23" Do While Cells(i, j) <> Empty VarVal = Cells(i, j) Windows(JetsizerFile).Activate 'Load baseline from archive Sheets("Archive").Select Range("A69").Select Do While ActiveCell.Value <> Archive ActiveCell.Offset(59, 0).Select Loop Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!RestoreFile" 'Load in new Variable Value Sheets("Mission").Select Range(index).Value = VarVal 'Iterate on tc Sheets("Configuration").Select Do While Cells(81, 2) <> "FAIL" And Cells(23, 3) < 0.151 Cells(23, 3) = Cells(23, 3) + 0.001 Cells(24, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.85 Cells(25, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.7 Loop Cells(23, 3) = Cells(23, 3) - 0.001 Cells(24, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.85 Cells(25, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.7 'Run for Convergence Application.Run "Convergebuttons" Application.Run "reduceslst" 'Get Weights and Parameters MTOGW = Sheets("Mission").Range("I29") OEW = Sheets("Mission").Range("I31") FB = Sheets("Mission").Range("I32") LD = Sheets("Mission").Range("I39") CLCZ = Sheets("Aero").Range("I19") SLST = Sheets("Mission").Range("D19") tcroot = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C23")
55
tcbreak = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C24") tctip = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C25") Windows(ParentWin).Activate 'Change to WKname Cells(i + 1, j) = MTOGW Cells(i + 2, j) = OEW Cells(i + 3, j) = FB Cells(i + 4, j) = LD Cells(i + 5, j) = CLCZ Cells(i + 6, j) = SLST Cells(i + 7, j) = tcroot Cells(i + 8, j) = tcbreak Cells(i + 9, j) = tctip j = j + 1 Loop 'Load from archive Windows(JetsizerFile).Activate Sheets("Archive").Select Range("A69").Select Do While ActiveCell.Value <> Archive ActiveCell.Offset(59, 0).Select Loop Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!RestoreFile" End Sub Sub Iteration_SLST() ' ' Iteration_SLST Macro ' Dim MTOGW As Double, OEW As Double, FB As Double, LD As Double, CLCZ As Double Dim SLST As Double, tcroot As Single, tcbreak As Single, tctip As Single Dim Archive As Integer Dim VarVal As Variant Dim i As Integer, j As Integer, index As String Application.ScreenUpdating = False JetsizerFile = Cells(2, 3)
56
ParentWin = ThisWorkbook.Name Windows(ParentWin).Activate 'Change to WKname i = Selection.Row 'Always assume user selects first variable step on execution j = Selection.Column Archive = Cells(3, 3) 'list baseline archive index to load index = "D19" Do While Cells(i, j) <> Empty VarVal = Cells(i, j) Windows(JetsizerFile).Activate 'Load baseline from archive Sheets("Archive").Select Range("A69").Select Do While ActiveCell.Value <> Archive ActiveCell.Offset(59, 0).Select Loop Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!RestoreFile" 'Load in new Variable Value Sheets("Mission").Select Range(index).Value = VarVal 'Iterate on tc Sheets("Configuration").Select Do While Cells(81, 2) <> "FAIL" And Cells(23, 3) < 0.151 Cells(23, 3) = Cells(23, 3) + 0.001 Cells(24, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.85 Cells(25, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.7 Loop Cells(23, 3) = Cells(23, 3) - 0.001 Cells(24, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.85 Cells(25, 3) = Cells(23, 3) * 0.7 'Run for Convergence Application.Run "Convergebuttons" 'Get Weights and Parameters MTOGW = Sheets("Mission").Range("I29") OEW = Sheets("Mission").Range("I31")
57
FB = Sheets("Mission").Range("I32") LD = Sheets("Mission").Range("I39") CLCZ = Sheets("Aero").Range("I19") SLST = Sheets("Mission").Range("D19") tcroot = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C23") tcbreak = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C24") tctip = Sheets("Configuration").Range("C25") Windows(ParentWin).Activate 'Change to WKname Cells(i + 1, j) = MTOGW Cells(i + 2, j) = OEW Cells(i + 3, j) = FB Cells(i + 4, j) = LD Cells(i + 5, j) = CLCZ Cells(i + 6, j) = SLST Cells(i + 7, j) = tcroot Cells(i + 8, j) = tcbreak Cells(i + 9, j) = tctip j = j + 1 Loop 'Load from archive Windows(JetsizerFile).Activate Sheets("Archive").Select Range("A69").Select Do While ActiveCell.Value <> Archive ActiveCell.Offset(59, 0).Select Loop Application.Run JetsizerFile & "!RestoreFile" End Sub