1
REFERENCES 1. Flickinger, J. E., Trusler, L. and Brock, J. W., 3rd: Clinical care pathway for the management of ureteroneocystostomy in the pediatric urology population. J Urol, part 2, 158: 1221, 1997 2. Buck, M. L.: Clinical experience with ketorolac in children. Ann Pharmacother, 28: 1009, 1994 3. Lieh-Lai, M. W., Kauffman, R. E., Uy, H. G. et al: A randomized comparison of ketorolac tromethamine and morphine for post- operative analgesia in critically ill children. Crit Care Med, 27: 2786, 1999 4. Gonzalez, A. and Smith, D. P.: Minimizing hospital length of stay in children undergoing ureteroneocystostomy. Urology, 52: 501, 1998 5. Eberson, C. P., Pacicca, D. M. and Ehrlich, M. G.: The role of ketorolac in decreasing length of stay and narcotic complica- tions in the postoperative pediatric orthopaedic patient. J Pe- diatr Orthop, 19: 688, 1999 6. Burke, J. P., Pestotnik, S. L., Classen, D. C. et al: Evaluation of the financial impact of ketorolac tromethamine therapy in hospitalized patients. Clin Ther, 18: 197, 1996 7. Park, J. M., Houck, C. S., Sethna, N. F. et al: Ketorolac sup- presses postoperative bladder spasms after pediatric ureteral reimplantation. Anesth Analg, 91: 11, 2000 EDITORIAL COMMENTS We have all felt the economic pressure to lower health care costs by reducing the length of hospitalization, or even reducing many sur- geries to ambulatory procedures or 23-hour stays. However, as child advocates, we can only comply with this paradigm when our patients and the families would be better served at home. The ability to produce adequate postoperative analgesia is crucial to this stipula- tion. The literature is replete with reports of the superior analgesic efficacy of ketorolac compared to narcotic agents in children under- going surgery. The reports in the pediatric urology literature have been few. The authors cite 2 recent articles, including 1 in which the length of hospitalization was reduced after extravesical ureteral reimplantation, partly attributed to the use of ketorolac (reference 4 in article), and another bladder spasms were reduced by ketorolac after intravesical ureteral reimplantation (reference 7 in article). In this study the authors evaluated the safety profile of ketorolac in children undergoing ureteral reimplantation and, in particular, 2 of the most worrisome adverse effects, namely, bleeding and renal insufficiency. A total of 118 children underwent either intravesical or extravesical ureteral reimplantation, including 50 who received cau- dal anesthesia along with either narcotics and 68 ketorolac. There were no differences between the groups in regard to minor or major adverse effects of postoperative analgesia, including postoperative hematocrit and creatinine. Interestingly, children undergoing ure- teral reimplantation without other associated bladder pathology who received ketorolac were discharged home 1 day earlier than those receiving narcotics. We should be encouraged to learn that ketorolac has an excellent safety profile for children undergoing ureteral reimplantation. This important information should be viewed in the context of other postoperative studies indicating the superior analgesic efficacy and perhaps antispasmodic effect of ketorolac after ureteral reimplanta- tion. These findings should be shared with our anesthesiology col- leagues so that we can better and more safely treat our patient postoperative analgesia needs. If the secondary gain is a shorter hospital stay and reduced cost then certainly everyone benefits. Lane S. Palmer Schneider Children’s Hospital/Long Island Jewish Medical Center New Hyde Park, New York I read with interest the report by Chauhan et al about the safety of ketorolac in children undergoing ureteroneocystostomy from 1997 to 1998. This paper provides an evaluation of the concerns that many practitioners have when applying pain management techniques to the pediatric population when the pharmacological tools and tech- niques have been historically ignored. Bleeding and kidney dysfunc- tion have always been a concern with the use of nonsteroidal anti- inflammatory drug perioperatively. However, we have not experienced this as a major clinical event in the 10 years of ketorolac use at the Children’s Hospital of Denver during this particular operation when these drugs have been used appropriately. I am concerned about the conclusions drawn from this retrospec- tive review, as many pieces of important information are not avail- able. For instance, the dose, drugs and additives to the caudal can dramatically affect postoperative pain results. Epidural morphine can last as long as 8 to 24 hours, whereas epidural fentanyl may only last a few hours. I am also unclear if only 1 dose of caudal drugs was used and whether an epidural catheter was left in place to “top off” the block. Other areas of concern include a lack of evaluation of the perioperative fluids as well as the preoperative fast of each child. What other drugs, including antibiotic or anesthetic, may have been used in those children in whom creatinines increased? The authors imply that the gastrointestinal tract and some of the other side effects are not part of the ketorolac profile. However, we have noted that many of the side effects, such as nausea, dyspepsia, headache and dizziness, may be attributed to nonsteroidal anti- inflammatory drug and ketorolac in particular. At our institution the checking of preoperative and postoperative hematocrit, creatinine, and liver function test is not routinely per- formed. Is it ketorolac alone or a combination of multiple factors that really contributed to the reduced length of hospitalization reported in this article? In summary this paper does provide more evidence demonstrating the importance of balanced analgesia and how the use of ketorolac may enhance the care of the reimplantation popu- lation without impacting patient safety. Glenn R. Merritt Department of Anesthesia University of Colorado Health Sciences Center The Children’s Hospital Denver, Colorado SAFETY OF KETOROLAC IN PEDIATRIC POPULATION AFTER URETERONEOCYSTOSTOMY 1875

EDITORIAL COMMENT

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: EDITORIAL COMMENT

REFERENCES

1. Flickinger, J. E., Trusler, L. and Brock, J. W., 3rd: Clinical carepathway for the management of ureteroneocystostomy in thepediatric urology population. J Urol, part 2, 158: 1221, 1997

2. Buck, M. L.: Clinical experience with ketorolac in children. AnnPharmacother, 28: 1009, 1994

3. Lieh-Lai, M. W., Kauffman, R. E., Uy, H. G. et al: A randomizedcomparison of ketorolac tromethamine and morphine for post-operative analgesia in critically ill children. Crit Care Med, 27:2786, 1999

4. Gonzalez, A. and Smith, D. P.: Minimizing hospital length ofstay in children undergoing ureteroneocystostomy. Urology,52: 501, 1998

5. Eberson, C. P., Pacicca, D. M. and Ehrlich, M. G.: The role ofketorolac in decreasing length of stay and narcotic complica-tions in the postoperative pediatric orthopaedic patient. J Pe-diatr Orthop, 19: 688, 1999

6. Burke, J. P., Pestotnik, S. L., Classen, D. C. et al: Evaluation ofthe financial impact of ketorolac tromethamine therapy inhospitalized patients. Clin Ther, 18: 197, 1996

7. Park, J. M., Houck, C. S., Sethna, N. F. et al: Ketorolac sup-presses postoperative bladder spasms after pediatric ureteralreimplantation. Anesth Analg, 91: 11, 2000

EDITORIAL COMMENTS

We have all felt the economic pressure to lower health care costs byreducing the length of hospitalization, or even reducing many sur-geries to ambulatory procedures or 23-hour stays. However, as childadvocates, we can only comply with this paradigm when our patientsand the families would be better served at home. The ability toproduce adequate postoperative analgesia is crucial to this stipula-tion. The literature is replete with reports of the superior analgesicefficacy of ketorolac compared to narcotic agents in children under-going surgery. The reports in the pediatric urology literature havebeen few. The authors cite 2 recent articles, including 1 in which thelength of hospitalization was reduced after extravesical ureteralreimplantation, partly attributed to the use of ketorolac (reference 4in article), and another bladder spasms were reduced by ketorolacafter intravesical ureteral reimplantation (reference 7 in article).

In this study the authors evaluated the safety profile of ketorolacin children undergoing ureteral reimplantation and, in particular, 2of the most worrisome adverse effects, namely, bleeding and renalinsufficiency. A total of 118 children underwent either intravesical orextravesical ureteral reimplantation, including 50 who received cau-dal anesthesia along with either narcotics and 68 ketorolac. Therewere no differences between the groups in regard to minor or majoradverse effects of postoperative analgesia, including postoperativehematocrit and creatinine. Interestingly, children undergoing ure-teral reimplantation without other associated bladder pathology whoreceived ketorolac were discharged home 1 day earlier than thosereceiving narcotics.

We should be encouraged to learn that ketorolac has an excellent

safety profile for children undergoing ureteral reimplantation. Thisimportant information should be viewed in the context of otherpostoperative studies indicating the superior analgesic efficacy andperhaps antispasmodic effect of ketorolac after ureteral reimplanta-tion. These findings should be shared with our anesthesiology col-leagues so that we can better and more safely treat our patientpostoperative analgesia needs. If the secondary gain is a shorterhospital stay and reduced cost then certainly everyone benefits.

Lane S. PalmerSchneider Children’s Hospital/Long Island Jewish Medical

CenterNew Hyde Park, New York

I read with interest the report by Chauhan et al about the safetyof ketorolac in children undergoing ureteroneocystostomy from 1997to 1998. This paper provides an evaluation of the concerns that manypractitioners have when applying pain management techniques tothe pediatric population when the pharmacological tools and tech-niques have been historically ignored. Bleeding and kidney dysfunc-tion have always been a concern with the use of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug perioperatively. However, we have notexperienced this as a major clinical event in the 10 years of ketorolacuse at the Children’s Hospital of Denver during this particularoperation when these drugs have been used appropriately.

I am concerned about the conclusions drawn from this retrospec-tive review, as many pieces of important information are not avail-able. For instance, the dose, drugs and additives to the caudal candramatically affect postoperative pain results. Epidural morphinecan last as long as 8 to 24 hours, whereas epidural fentanyl may onlylast a few hours. I am also unclear if only 1 dose of caudal drugs wasused and whether an epidural catheter was left in place to “top off”the block. Other areas of concern include a lack of evaluation of theperioperative fluids as well as the preoperative fast of each child.What other drugs, including antibiotic or anesthetic, may have beenused in those children in whom creatinines increased?

The authors imply that the gastrointestinal tract and some of theother side effects are not part of the ketorolac profile. However, wehave noted that many of the side effects, such as nausea, dyspepsia,headache and dizziness, may be attributed to nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug and ketorolac in particular.

At our institution the checking of preoperative and postoperativehematocrit, creatinine, and liver function test is not routinely per-formed. Is it ketorolac alone or a combination of multiple factors thatreally contributed to the reduced length of hospitalization reportedin this article? In summary this paper does provide more evidencedemonstrating the importance of balanced analgesia and how theuse of ketorolac may enhance the care of the reimplantation popu-lation without impacting patient safety.

Glenn R. MerrittDepartment of AnesthesiaUniversity of Colorado Health Sciences CenterThe Children’s HospitalDenver, Colorado

SAFETY OF KETOROLAC IN PEDIATRIC POPULATION AFTER URETERONEOCYSTOSTOMY 1875