68
Earthquake Engineering in Armenia

Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

  • Upload
    vanbao

  • View
    217

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Earthquake Engineering in Armenia

Page 2: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

SPITAK DEVASTATING EARTHQUAKE

M7.1

Armenia 07.12.1988.

Page 3: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Grave consequences

Brief Information on Spitak M7.1 Earthquake

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

Casualties: 25 000

Invalids 19 000

Homeless: 500 000

Desrupted: 21 towns and settlements

Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public facilities

Property loss: 13 billion USD

Destruction extent: 40 percent of the area

Page 4: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Collapsed facilities

Page 5: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Town of Spitak

Page 6: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Town of Gyumri

Page 7: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Town of Gyumri

Page 8: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Town of Gyumri

Page 9: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Basically destructed buildings

Page 10: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Destructed buildings

Page 11: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Destructed buildings

Page 12: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Heavily damaged buildings

Recreation building

Hospital

Page 13: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Settlements and buildings damaged during earthquakes in some countries

Page 14: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Skopje, Macedonia, 26.07.1963, M7.2

Page 15: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Skopje, Macedonia, 26.07.1963, M7.2

Page 16: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Skopje, Macedonia, 26.07.1963, M7.2

Page 17: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Gujarat, India, 26.01.2001, M7.7

Page 18: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Gujarat, India, 26.01.2001, M7.7

Page 19: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Izmit, Turkey, 17.08.99 M7.4

Page 20: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Izmit, Turkey, 17.08.99 M7.4

Page 21: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Friulli, Italy, 06.05.1976, M6.5

Page 22: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Main reasons of destruction

Page 23: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

1. Untrue assessment of seismic hazard

3. Faults in constructive solutions

4. Low quality of construction

5. Unproper exploitation

2. Not strict seismic building codes

Page 24: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Untrue Assessment of Seismic Hazard

Page 25: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

0.2g0.3g

0.5g

0.2g

0.4g 0.3g

0.5g

0.2g

0.3g 0.2g

0.4g

0.4g

Spitak

Kajaran

Yerevan

Goris

Before 1988 After 1996

Seismic Zoning Maps of Armenia

Page 26: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Not Strict Seismic Building Codes

Page 27: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Seismic building codes Ñ Í

È Ï

II-7.81 were in force in Arm enia during Soviet era

Since 1994 the Regulations “Seismic ally Resistant Construction. Design Codes ”

ÐÐÞÜ

II-2.02-94 have

been applied in Armenia

Since 2006 the updated Regulations “Seismically Resistant Construction. Design Codes”

ÐÐÞÜ

II-6.02-

2006 were in force in Armenia

Page 28: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Faults in Constructive Solutions

Page 29: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public
Page 30: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Low Quality of Construction

Page 31: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Low quality of construction works

Page 32: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public
Page 33: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Unproper Exploitation

Page 34: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public
Page 35: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

[email protected]

Classification of Buildings by Constructive Solutions in Armenia

1. Stone-wall (masonry) (up to 5 story)

2. Large panel buildings (9 story)

3. Frame-panel buildings (9 story)

4. Buildings with frame-tied system (12-16 story)

5. Buildings constructed with story-raising technology(12-16 story)

6. Buildings construted with new constructive solutions

§ê»ÛëÙÇÏ

ä³ßïå³ÝáõÃÛ³Ý ²½·³ÛÇÝ Ì³é³ÛáõÃÛáõݦ

·áñͳϳÉáõÃÛáõݧNational Survey for Seismic Protection¦

Agency

Page 36: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

§ê»ÛëÙÇÏ

ä³ßïå³ÝáõÃÛ³Ý ²½·³ÛÇÝ Ì³é³ÛáõÃÛáõݦ

·áñͳϳÉáõÃÛáõݧNational Survey for Seismic Protection¦

Agency

[email protected]

Stone-wall (masonry) buildings (up to 5 story)

30 percent of building stock

High vulnerability

Retrofitting required

Page 37: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public
Page 38: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public
Page 39: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public
Page 40: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

[email protected]

Large Panel Buildings(9 story)

10 percent of building stock

Low vulnerability

§ê»ÛëÙÇÏ

ä³ßïå³ÝáõÃÛ³Ý ²½·³ÛÇÝ Ì³é³ÛáõÃÛáõݦ

·áñͳϳÉáõÃÛáõݧNational Survey for Seismic Protection¦

Agency

Page 41: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public
Page 42: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public
Page 43: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

[email protected]

Frame Panel Buildings(9 story)

15 percent of building stockHigh vulnerability

After Spitak 1988 Earthquake were not constructed

Retrofitting required

§ê»ÛëÙÇÏ

ä³ßïå³ÝáõÃÛ³Ý ²½·³ÛÇÝ Ì³é³ÛáõÃÛáõݦ

·áñͳϳÉáõÃÛáõݧNational Survey for Seismic Protection¦

Agency

Page 44: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public
Page 45: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public
Page 46: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

[email protected]

Buildings with Frame-Tied System

(12-16 story)

15 percent of building stock

Low vulnerability

§ê»ÛëÙÇÏ

ä³ßïå³ÝáõÃÛ³Ý ²½·³ÛÇÝ Ì³é³ÛáõÃÛáõݦ

·áñͳϳÉáõÃÛáõݧNational Survey for Seismic Protection¦

Agency

Page 47: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public
Page 48: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public
Page 49: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

[email protected]

Buildings Constructed with Slab Lift Technology

(12-16 story)

7 percent of building stock, mainly in Yerevan-city

After Spitak 1988 Earthquake were not constructed

§ê»ÛëÙÇÏ

ä³ßïå³ÝáõÃÛ³Ý ²½·³ÛÇÝ Ì³é³ÛáõÃÛáõݦ

·áñͳϳÉáõÃÛáõݧNational Survey for Seismic Protection¦

Agency

Page 50: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public
Page 51: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public
Page 52: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

High-rise Buildings with New Constructive Solutions

Page 53: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public
Page 54: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public
Page 55: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Special Seismically Resistant Systems

• Dynamic vibration dampers

• Switch on and switch off ties

•Rubber-metallic layered bearings

•Vibration Damping increasing constructions

•Bonding of existing structure with newly constructed rigid structure

Page 56: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Vibration Dynamic Dampers

Page 57: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Model of 9 story frame building with dynamic

damper

Page 58: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Building in Vanadzor town strengthened

with dynamic damper

Page 59: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Upper flexible story on rubber metallic bearings

Page 60: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public
Page 61: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Rubber metallic layered bearings

Page 62: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Seismic isolation bearings at the buildings

Page 63: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Armenian International Airport Production of rubber metallic bearings

(Kuala Lumpur, Robinson Seismic Ltd NZ)

Page 64: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Bonding existing structure with newly constructed facility

Page 65: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Building before reconstruction

Page 66: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Constructive solutions

Page 67: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Building after reconstruction

Page 68: Earthquake Engineering in Armenia - UNECE · Collapsed: 10 000 apartment buildings, hundreds of kindergartens and schools and tens of higher education establishments, 2000 public

Thank You