COR Motion to Dismiss Lawsuit

8/18/2019 COR Motion to Dismiss Lawsuit

1/105

SUPREME COURT

OF

THE

STATE

OF

NEW YORK

APPELLATE DIVISION, FOURTH DEPARTMENT

CITY

OF

SYRACUSE,

Plaintiff-

Appellant,

AlT ll) W 1 1

-against- IndexNo.: 2015EF5077

COR DEVELOPMENT COMPANY,

LLC,

CO R INNER HARBOR COMPANY, LLC,

COR

SOLAR STREET COMPANY IV ,

LLC,

CO R VAN RENSSELAER STREET COMPANY, LLC,

CO R

WEST

KIRKPATRICK

STREET

COMPANY, LLC

and

JOHN DOE,

Defendants-Respondents.

STATE OF NEW

YORK

)

: ss.:

COUNTY OF ALBANY )

CHRISTOPHER

E.

BUCKEY,

being

duly

sworn,

deposes and

says:

1.

I

am

a member

of Whiteman

Osterman

&

Hanna

LLP,

attorneys fo r Defendants-

Respondents

COR Development Company,

LLC,

COR Inner

Harbor Company, LLC,

COR

Solar Street Company IV , LLC, CO R Van Rensselaer Street Company,

LLC,

and

COR

West

Kirkpatrick Street Company, LLC in

this

matter.

I submit

this

affidavit

in support

of

Defendants-Respondents' motion to

dismiss

.

Plaintiff-Appellant's appeal for failure to perfect within the sixty-day period provided in this

Court's

rules. (22

NYCRR

§

1000.2

(b)).

4832-3079-5567,

v.

1


2/105

Plai

ntiff-

Appe

llant

c

omm

ence

d th

is a

ction by

sum

mons

an

d c

ompl

aint

date

d

.

Dece

mber

15, 201

5

alle

ging

, am

ong

othe

r thing

s,

tha

t D

efend

ants

-Res

pond

ents m

ade

mis

repre

sent

at ion

s to

it in

conn

ec tio

n wi

th the

trans

fer

of ce

rtain lan

d.

P

la int

iff Appe

llant

a

lso

filed

a

notic

e of p

ende

ncy aga

inst

certa

in prop

er ty at

issu

e

in

t

he

action

.

4.

By

orde

r date

d Jan

uary 25

, 2

016,

Sup

reme

C

ourt

dism

issed t

wo

caus

es o

f acti

on

in th

e

comp

laint

,

in

cludi

ng

the

fifth cau

se

of a

ction for

res

cissio

n

of the

pa

rties Dis

posit

ion

A

gree

men

t

d

ated A

ugu

st

2

7,

2012

(the

D

ispo

sition

Agr

eem

ent )

. A

cop

y of Su

prem

e Cou

rt s

ord

er

is

a

ttach

ed

here

to as E

xhib

it A. In

dism

issin

g the res

cissi

on

cau

se of a

ction

, Supr

eme

C

ourt

did not

reach the merits.

Rather, Supreme

Court

determined

that:

(A) Plaintiff-Appellant

had

an

adequ

ate re

medy

fo r its

cla

ims;

na

mely

, dam

ages

;

a

nd

(B)

it w

ould

be

v i

rtual

ly

im

poss

ible

to

resto

re th

e s

tatus

quo

if

th

e

Disp

os iti

on A

gree

ment wa

s res

cinde

d.

(E

xhibi

t A [De

cem

ber 30,

2

015

tran

scrip

t,

at

6]).

As

a

resu

lt of the

dism

issa

l o

f the r

escis

sion cla

im ,

Sup

reme

Co

urt a

lso

vaca

ted

.

the

no

tice of

pen

denc

y filed b

y P

lainti

ff-Appe

llan

t in

con

nectio

n

wi

th

this act

ion.

Sup

reme

Co

urt

he

ld th

at, bec

ause

the

resc

iss io

n

c

ause

of a

ction had

be

en

dism

issed

,

th

e

actio

n

di

d n o

t

af

fect,

title,

pos

sess

ion

use

or

enjo

yme

nt o

f rea

l prop

erty as

conte

mpla

ted by

CPLR

6

501.

(Id

.

[D

ecem

ber 30

, 201

5

tran

scrip

t, a

t

7]).

6

. By

no

tice

of ap

peal

dated

an

d serve

d on

Feb

ruary 1,

20

16,

Plain

tiff-A

ppe

llant

app

ealed fr

om

thi

s o

rder.

A c

opy of

the

notic

e o

f

a

ppea

l is atta

ched as

Exh

ib it

B

.

Under

Section

1000.2

(b)

of

th is

Court s

rules,

Plaintiff-Appe llant

was

required to

.

perf

ect

it

s a

ppea

l wit

hin s

ixty

days

.

More

than

sixty da

ys

hav

e e

lapse

d since

servi

ce

o

f the

no

tice

of ap

peal a

nd

Pla

in tif

f App

el lan

t has not

pe

rfec

ted it

s ap

peal.

4832-3079-5567, v.


3/105

8

Ac

c

or

d

in

gl

y,

D

e

fe

n

da

n

ts-

R

es

p

on

d

en

ts

re

s

pe

c

tfu

lly

r

eq

u

es

t

th

at

th

is C

o

u

rt

en

te

r

a

n

o

rd

e

r d

ism

i

ss

in

g

th

e

ap

p

ea

l f

or

fa

ilu

re

t

o p

e

rfe

c

t

w

ith

in

th

e

ti

m

e p

e

rio

d

p

ro

vi

de

d

fo

r

in

th

is

C

ou

rt

s

r

ule

s

.

9

D

e

fe

nd

an

ts

-R

e

sp

o

nd

e

nt

s a

lso

re

s

pe

c

tfu

ll

y s

u

bm

it

th

a

t

th

e

in

st

an

t

ap

p

ea

l,

a

t

le

as

t

as

it

re

la

te

s

to

t

he

d

is

m

is

sa

l

o

f t

he

r

e

sc

is

sio

n c

au

s

e

o

f a

c

tio

n

a

nd

t

he

c

an

c

el l

at

io

n

o

f

the

n

o

tic

e

o

f

p

e

nd

en

c

y,

ha

s

b

e

en

r

en

de

r

ed

a

ca

de

m

ic

.

B

y

o

rd

e

r

a

nd

ju

dg

m

e

nt

d

a

te

d

Fe

b

ru

ar

y

29

,

2

01

6

,

S

u

pr

em

e

C

o

u

rt g

ra

n

te

d th

e

co

nv

e

rte

d

m

o

tio

n

o

f

D

ef

en

d

an

ts

-R

e

sp

o

nd

e

nt

s fo

r

s

u

m

m

ar

y

ju

dg

m

e

n

t

a

n

d

di

sm

i

ss

ed

th

is a

c

tio

n

i

n

its

e

n

tir

et

y.

A

co

p

y

o

f t

he

no

ti

ce

o

f e

nt

ry

of

Su

p

re

m

e C

o

ur

t s

o

rd

er

and

judgment

is

attached hereto

as Exhibit

C.

A

copy

of

the

December

15,

2016

complaint

filed

by

P

la

in

tif

f-A

p

p

el

la

nt

i

n t

hi

s

ac

tio

n

is

a

tta

c

he

d

he

re

to

a

s

E

x

h

ib

it D

.

S

up

re

m

e C

o

u

rt

s

ju

d

ge

m

e

nt

,

in

te

r

al

ia,

d

is

m

is

se

d o

n

th

e

m

e

rit

s

th

e

s

ec

o

nd

fra

u

du

le

n

t m

is

re

p

re

se

n

ta

tio

n

a

n

d

th

ir

d f

ra

u

du

le

n

t

in

d

uc

e

m

en

t)

c

au

se

s

o

f a

ct

io

n

i

n t

he

c

o

m

pl

ai

nt

. T

h

es

e w

e

re

th

e

on

ly

cl

ai

m

s u

po

n

w

hi

ch

P

la

in

tif

f-

A

pp

e

lla

n

t c

o

ul

d

p

r

em

is

e a

re

qu

e

st

fo

r

re

sc

is

si

on

. A

d

d

iti

on

a

lly

, t

he

r

eq

u

es

t

f

or r

e

sc

is

sio

n

wa

s

th

e

o

nl

y c

la

im

w

h

ic

h

a

ffe

ct

ed

tit

le

,

po

s

se

ss

io

n,

u

se o

r

e

nj

oy

m

e

nt

o

f re

al

p

r

op

e

rty

an

d,

th

er

ef

or

e,

w

a

s

the

on

ly

ba

s

is

fo

r

th

e

fil

in

g

o

f a

n

ot

ice

o

f p

en

d

en

c

y

in

th

is

a

ct

io

n.

Se

e

CP

L

R

6

5

01

1

0.

P

u

rs

ua

nt

t

o

22

N

Y

C

R

R

§ 2

0

2.

5-

b(

h)

(3

),

De

fe

n

da

n

ts

-R

es

p

on

d

en

ts

s

er

ve

d

n

ot

ic

e

o

f e

n

try

o

f

Su

p

re

m

e

Co

u

rt

s

o

r

de

r a

n

d ju

d

g

m

en

t

o

n

F

eb

ru

a

ry

2

9

, 2

0

16

.

(S

e

e

E

x

hi

bi

t C

).

T

h

us

,

P

la

in

ti

ff-

A

pp

e

lla

n

t

w

a

s r

eq

u

ire

d

to

f

ile

a

nd

s

e

rv

e

it

s

n

ot

ic

e

o

f

ap

pe

a

l

fr

om

th

e

o

rd

er

an

d

ju

dg

m

e

n

t o

n

o

r b

e

fo

re

M

a

rc

h

30

, 2

01

6

. S

e

e

C

P

L

R

§

55

1

3(

a)

.

T

o

da

te

,

Pl

ai

nt

iff

-A

p

p

el

la

nt

ha

s

no

t

s

er

ve

d

th

e

no

ti

ce

o

f appeal

and,

therefore, it cannot challenge the

dismissal

of

this

action

in

it

s e

n

tir

et

y.

4832-3079-5567,

v.

1


4/105

Thu

s,

the

o

nly

cla

im

s for

wh

ic

h P

la i

ntif

f-A

pp

ell

an t

co

ul d

s

eek

res

cis

sio

n

ha

ve

1.

be

en

di

sm

isse

d on

th

e

m

eri

ts a

nd

th

at d

ism

iss

al

ca

nno

t be

ch

all

eng

ed

. Th

is m

ean

s

tha

t,

ev

en i

f

P

la i

ntif

f-A

pp

el l

ant

co

uld d

em

on

stra

te

S

up

rem

e Co

ur

t s

d

ism

iss

al

of

th

e

fi ft

h c

aus

e o

f

act

ion i

n

the J

an

uar

y 2

5,

2

01

6 o

rde

r E

xhi

bit

A

) w

as

err

on

eou

s,

Pl

ain

tiff-

Ap

pe

lla

nt,

as

a

m

atte

r of l

aw

,

is

no

t en

titl

ed

to

re

scis

sio

n.

A

dd

itio

na

lly ,

s

inc

e P

lain

tif f

-A

pp e

lla

nt

is n

ot

en

titl

ed to

re

sc

iss

ion

,

th

er

e

is no

la w

fu

l bas

is

fo r

fi

lin

g a

no

tice o

f p

end

en

cy

in

thi

s

act

ion

. Ac

co

rdi

ngl

y,

an

y c

ha

llen

ge

to S

upr

em

e C

ou

rt s

Ja

nu

ary

25,

2

01

6

ord

er

ca

nc

elli

ng th

e

n

otic

e o

f pe

nd

en

cy

in

thi

s

ac

tio

n als

o

ha

s

be

en

re

nde

re

d ac

ade

mi

c.

CH

R

IS T

OP

H

ER

K

B

UC

IC

EY

n

to

b

efo

re m

e

this

s

n

ay

of

A

pri

l, 201

6

N

0 a

7 P

U

dSs

lE

rN?

Int


5/105

EXHIBIT

A


6/105

I

NDE

X

NO.

20 1

5EF

50

[

FIL

ED

:

ON

ON

DAG

A

CO

UN

TY

CL

ERK

01

/2

5/2

01

6

0

2:

54

PM)

R

ECE

IVED

N

YSC

EF: 0

1/2

5/20

YSCE

F

D

OC .

N

O.

9

4

At a

n IA

S T

erm

of

the S

upr

eme

C

ou

rt o

f the Sta

te

o

f N

ew Yo

rk,

held

in

and

fo r

the

County

of

Ono

nda

ga a

t the C

ou r

thou

se

t

here

of in

S

yrac

use

, Ne

w

Y

ork

on t

he

30th

da

y

of

De

cem

ber

, 20

15.

P

RE

SEN

T: H

ON. J

AME

S

P. M

URP

HY

, J.S

.C.

SU

PR

EM

E C

OU

RT

S

TAT

E O

F N

EW

Y

OR

K C

OU

NTY

OF ON

OND

AG

A

C

ITY

OF

SYRA

CUS

E

OR

DE

R

P

la i

nti ff

,

Ind

ex No

.:

201

5EF

507

7

v

CO

R DE

VE

LO

PME

NT

CO

MP

ANY

, LLC

COR

IN

NE

R HAR

BO

R CO

MP

AN

Y, LL

C

CO

R SO

LA

R

STR

EE

T CO

MP

ANY

IV ,

LLC

C

OR

V

AN RE

NSS

EL

AER

STR

EET CO

MP

AN

Y, L

LC

CO

R

W

ES

T K

IRK

PA

TR

ICK

STR

EE

T

C

OM

PAN

Y, L

LC ,

a

nd JO

HN

D

OE.

D

efen

dan

ts.

W

HE

REA

S,

on

or ab

out

Dec

emb

er

15,

2015

, Pla

inti

ff

Ci

ty

o

f

Sy

racu

se ( Pl

aint

iff )

co

mm

ence

d this

a

ction

by

fi

ling a S

umm

ons

and C

omp

lain

t in t

he O

ffice

of th

e

Ono

ndag

a

C

ount

y Cler

k;

W

HE

REA

S,

con

tem

pora

neou

s w

ith th

e

com

me

ncem

ent

of

this a

ctio

n,

Pla

inti

ff filed a

N

otice

of Pen

denc

y

of

Acti

on in

the O

ffice o

f

the

On

ond

aga

C

oun

ty C

lerk

ag

ains

t c

erta

in

real

pr

ope

rty

ow

ned by

D

efen

dan

ts

CO

R D

eve

lopm

ent

C

omp

any, L

LC,

CO

R In

ner

H

arbo

r

C

omp

any

, L

LC, C

OR

S

olar

Stree

t

Com

pan

y IV

,

L

LC,

COR

V

an R

ens

sela

er S

tree

t Co

mpa

ny,

1


7/105

L

LC

, a

nd

C

O

R

W

es

t

K

ir

kp

atr

ick

S

tree

t

Co

mp

an

y,

L

LC

(co

lle

cti

ve

ly

De

fen

da

nt

s )

,

a c

opy

of

w

hi

ch

is a

ttac

he

d h

ere

to,

a

s

E

xh

ib

it

A

(th

e

No

tic

e

o

fP

en

de

nc

y )

.

WHEREAS,

on or

about December

18,

2015, Defendants, by

th

ei

r

att

orn

ey

s, W

h

ite

ma

n

O

ste

rm

an

Ha

nn

a,

LL

P

a

nd

Ma

nn

ion

C

op

an

i, m

ov

ed

for

, a

m

on

g o

the

r t

hin

gs,

an

o

rde

r

pu

rsu

an

t

t

o C

P

LR

321

1

an

d

CP

LR

65

14(

a), d

ire

ct

ing

th

e

On

on

dag

a

Co

un

ty

Cle

rk

t

o c

anc

el

the

No

tice

of Pe

nd

en

cy,

dis

m

iss

ing

the

a

cti

on i

n it

s

en

tire

ty,

sc

he

du

ling

an

inq

ue

st p

ur

sua

nt

to

CP

L

R

65

14

(c)

to

d

ete

rm

in

e

the

c

os

ts

a

nd

ex

pe

ns

es o

f

De

fen

da

nts

o

cc

asi

one

d

b

y th

e

fil

ing

a

nd

ca

nce

lla

tio

n o

f th

e

No

tic

e of

Pe

nde

nc

y,

an

d

aw

ard

in

g

De

fen

da

nts

c

os

ts a

nd

a

tto

rne

ys

'

fe

es

p

urs

ua

nt to

22

NY

C

RR

1

30

-1.

1 a

s a

sa

nct

ion

fo

r

P

la in

ti

ffs fr iv

ol

ou

s

co

ndu

ct.

W

HE

R

EA

S,

o

n D

ece

mb

er

3

0,

20

15

, th

e

C

our

t he

ard

o

ral

arg

um

en

ts b

y

c

oun

se

l

for

Pla

in

tiff a

nd

D

ef

end

an

ts a

nd

iss

ue

d

a be

nch

d

ec

isio

n

on

De

fe

nda

nt

s' m

oti

on

,

a c

op

y o

f w

hic

h is

at

tac

hed

he

ret

o

as E

xh

ib

it B

.

N

o

w,

up

on

re

ad

ing an

d f

ilin

g

t

he

O

rd

er t

o

Sh

ow C

aus

e d

at

ed

the

18

th d

ay

o

f D

ece

mb

er

2

015

;

the A

ff

ida

vi

t

o

f St

eve

n

F.

A

iell

o,

in

s

up

po

rt of t

he

m

otio

n,

s

wo

rn to

o

n

the

18

th

da

y o

f

D

ec

em

be

r,

2

01

5;

the

S

um

m

on

s

an

d V

er

ifie

d

C

om

pl

ain

t;

th

e N

ot

ice

o

f Pe

nd

en

cy;

th

e

Aff

irm

at

ion

o

f

Joh

n

A

. S

ick

ing

er

, E

sq

., i

n

opp

os

itio

n

to

th

e m

ot

ion

, d

at

ed

the

28t

h

da

y o

f

D

ec

em

be

r, 2

01

5; t

he

R

ep

ly

Af

fid

av

it o

f C

hri

sto

ph

er

E

, B

uc

ke

y, Es

q.,

sw

or

n to

on

the

2

9th

d

ay

of

De

ce

mb

er,

2

01

5; an

d

aft

er

he

ar

ing

ar

gu

me

nts b

y

Ch

ris

top

he

r

E,

B

uck

ey

,

E

sq

., c

oun

se

l

fo

r t

he

D

ef

end

an

ts,

a

nd

Jo

hn

A

. Si

cki

nge

r,

E

sq

.,

c

ou

ns

el

f

or

the

P

lain

tif

f,

on

De

ce

mb

er

30

, 2

01

5, a

nd

a

fte

r du

e d

el

ibe

rat

ion

h

avi

ng b

ee

n h

eld

the

reo

n,

in a

cc

ord

an

ce

wit

h th

e C

ou

rt's

b

en

ch d

ec

isio

n,

it

is

2


8/105

OR

D

ER

E

D

tha

t D

e

fen

da

nt

s'

mo

tio

n

to

di

sm

iss

th

e

F

irs

t C

au

se

of

A

cti

on

i

n

th

e

C

om

pl

ain

t

f

or b

rea

ch

of

th

e im

pli

ed

c

ov

en

an

t

of

go

od

fai

th a

nd

fai

r

d

ea

lin

g i

s he

re

by

gr

an

ted

,

and it

is

further

OR

D

ER

E

D

th

at

De

fen

da

nt

s'

m

oti

on

to

d

ism

is

s t

he

ca

us

e

of a

ct

ion

in

the

C

om

p

lai

nt fo

r

r

es

cis

sio

n i

s h

er

eb

y g

ra

nte

d, a

nd

it i

s

fu

rth

er

O

R

DE

R

ED

th

at D

e

fen

da

nt

s'

m

ot

ion

to

di

sm

iss

the

Se

co

nd

C

aus

e

o

f A

ct

ion

in

th

e

C

om

p

la

int

f

or

fra

ud

ul

en

t

mi

sre

pr

ese

nt

ati

on

, th

e T

h

ird

C

au

se

o

f A

ct

ion

in

the

Co

m

pla

in

t f

or

fra

ud

ul

en

t in

du

ce

me

nt

,

and t

he

F

ou

rth

Ca

use

o

f A

ct

ion

in

th

e

C

o

mp

la

int

f

or

pr

om

is

so

ry e

st

op

pe

l

is he

reb

y

d

en

ied

w

ith

ou

t pr

eju

d

ice

, an

d

it

i

s

f

ur

the

r

O

R

DE

R

ED

tha

t

De

fe

nd

an

ts'

m

oti

on

to

di

sm

iss

the

S

ec

on

d Ca

us

e

o

f

Ac

tio

n

in

the

Co

m

pl

ain

t

fo

r

f

rau

du

le

nt

m

is

rep

re

se

nta

tio

n,

th

e T

hi

rd

Ca

us

e

o

f A

c

tio

n in

th

e C

om

p

lain

t f

or

fr

au

du

le

nt

i

nd

uc

em

en

t, an

d

the F

ou

rth

Ca

use

o

f A

cti

on

i

n

th

e C

om

pl

ain

t fo

r pr

om

is

so

ry

e

sto

pp

el

w

il

l b

e

c

on

sid

er

ed a

s

a

m

oti

on

for

s

um

m

ar

y j

ud

gm

en

t

pu

rsu

an

t to

CP

L

R

3

21

1(c

),

re

tur

na

ble

on

J

an

ua

ry 21

,

20

16

at

2

:00 P

.M

.,

a

nd

it

is

fur

th

er

O

R

D

ER

ED

t

ha

t

t

he

N

ot

ice

of

P

en

de

ncy

b

e

an

d

th

e

sa

me

is

he

reb

y c

an

ce

lle

d

a

nd

di

sch

ar

ge

d

as

o

f

re

co

rd as

t

o

all

pa

rc

els

up

on w

hi

ch

it

h

as b

ee

n r

ec

ord

ed

'

pu

rsu

an

t to

C

P

LR

6

51

4(

a),

a

nd

it is

fu

rt

he

r

O

RD

E

RE

D

tha

t

the O

n

ond

ag

a

C

ou

nty

C

le

rk

is

he

re

by

dir

ec

ted t

o c

an

ce

l an

d

d

isc

ha

rge

t

he N

o

tic

e

o

f P

en

de

ncy

,

to

e

nte

r a

n

otic

e

o

f ca

nc

ell

ati

on

an

d

dis

ch

ar

ge on

t

he m

arg

in

o

f t

he

rec

or

d

of the

N

o

tic

e

o

f P

en

de

ncy

, a

nd

to

in

de

x

th

is c

an

ce

lla

tio

n

an

d d

isc

ha

rge

in

D

ef

en

da

nts

'

c

ha

in

of

ti

tle

, an

d

it

is fu

rth

er

OR

D

ER

E

D

th

at

D

efe

nd

an

ts'

ap

pl

ica

tio

n

to

sc

he

du

le a

n

in

qu

es

t

pu

rsu

an

t

to

CP

LR

65

14

(c

) is

den

ie

d,

an

d

it

is

fu

rth

er

3


9/105

O

R

D

E

RE

D

th

a

t D

ef

en

da

n

ts

a

pp

lic

at

ion

fo

r

an

a

w

ard

o

f a

tto

rn

ey

s'

fee

s

pu

rs

ua

nt

to

22

N

YC

R

R

1

30

1

.1 i

s

de

ni

ed

.

E

n

ter

D

a

te

d: J

an

ua

ry

^

^2

0

16

H

on

J

am

es

P

/M

u

rp

]

4

MO- tuM xas.v. t


10/105

E

X

H

I

I

T

A


11/105

IF I

LED

s

O

NO

ND

AG

A C

OU

NT

Y

CL

ER

K

1

2 /1

5 /

20

15 11

;

1

5 A

MI

IN

DE

X

NO . 2

01 5

EF5

07 7

R

ECE

IVE

D N

YSC

EF:

1

2/1 5

/2 0

15

YS

CE F D

OC.

N

O. 3

STA

TE O

F

NE

W YO

RK

S

UPR

EM

E C

OU

RT

CO

UN

TY OF

ON

ON

DA

GA

CITY

OF

SYRACUSE,

Pl

aint

iff,

N

OT

ICE

OF

P

EN

DE

NC

Y

OF

AC

TIO

N

In

dex

No

,;

s

CO

R D

EVE

LO

PM

EN

T CO

MP

ANY

,

LLC

,

CO

R IN

NE

R HA

RB

OR

C

OM

PA

NY

,

LLC

.

CO

R SOL

AR

STR

EE

T

CO

MP

AN

Y IV

,

L

LC

,

CO

R VA

N

R

EN

SSE

LA

ER S

TRE

ET

CO

MP

AN

Y, LLC

,

CO

R W

EST

K

IRK

PA

TRI

CK

ST

REE

T CO

MP

AN

Y,

L

LC,

and

JOHN

DOE.

De

fend

ants

.

N

OT

ICE

IS H

ERE

BY G

IVE

N,

that a

n ac

tion

h

as b

een

com

me

nce

d and

is n

ow pe

nd

ing

in

th

e Su

prem

e

Co

urt o

f ON

ON

DA

GA

C

oun

ty upo

n th

e C

om

pla

int

of th

e abo

ve

Pla

intif

f

aga

inst

th abo

ve-

nam

ed

D

efen

dan

ts,

fil

ed h

erew

ith

. Th

e Co

mp

lain

t alle

ges

th

at

CO

R De

velo

pm

ent

Com

pa

ny, L

LC—

a

nd

th

e spe

cia

l

p

urpo

se

e

ntiti

es a

nd/o

r af

filia

tes

of

CO

R D

eve

lopm

en

t

Co

mpa

ny,

LLC

:

CO

R

Inn

er Ha

rbo

r

C

omp

any

, L

LC

,

CO

R S

olar Str

eet

Co

mpa

ny

I

V, LLC

, C

OR

V

an R

ens

sela

er

St

reet Co

mp

any

, L

LC,

and C

OR

W

es

t K

irk

patr

ick S

tree

t Co

mpa

ny,

LL

C

(he

rein

afte

r D

efen

dan

t

C

OR

)— fr

aud

ule

ntly in

duc

ed

Pl

ain

tiff

to e

nter

int

o a Di

spo

sitio

n

Ag

ree

men

t

(date

d A

ugu

st

27,

201

2)

and

sub

seq

uen

tly tran

sfe

r ow

ner

ship

an

d

co

ntro

l o

f th

e r

eal

p

rop

erty (he

rein

afte

r '•p

rem

ise

s )

des

crib

ed in

E

xh

ibit

I

L

ega

l De

scr

iptio

n Of P

rem

ises

By

Pa

rce

ls De

ede

d To

Defe

nda

nt CO

R,

and

Ex

hibi

t

2

L

ega

l De

scri

ptio

n Of

P

rem

ises

1 P

arce

l

A

2,

atta

che

d

h

eret

o an

d m

ade

pa

rt

he re

of, as

pa

rt o

f t

he Sy

racu

se

Inne

r H

arb

or P

roje

ct.

P

arc

el

A2

is

co

mm

itted

to b

e tran

sfe

rred

to

De

fen

dan

t CO

R

und

er th

e

Dis

pos

itio

n

Ag

ree

men

t.


12/105

Plaintiff farth

er allege

s k t

he

Comp

laint t

hat Defendan

t

COR breache

d the

implie

d

covenant

of

good

faith

an d

fair

dealing

with Plainti ff

when

Defendant

COR

sought

and

obtained

a

paymen

t in lieu of

taxes P

ILOT )

agreeme

nt

wi

th

the Onond

aga Coun

ty Ind

ustrial

Developm

en t Agenc

y ( OCID

A ),a

fter

D

efendant

CO

R impliedl

y promised a

nd represe

nted

that it

wou

ld

not

see

k any PI

LOT agre

ements. Acco

rdingly,

in its

Complain

t, Plaint

iff

as

ks the

Co

urt to rescind

die Inn

er H

arbor Disposit

ion Agr

eement

between Pla

intiff

and

D

efendan

t COR

in

it

s entire

ty,

and res

ckd all deeds tr

ansferred

pu

rsuant

t

o

the

sa

me Dispos

ition A

greemen

t

AND, NOTICE

IS

FURTHER GIVEN,

that

the

premises and parcels described

in

such

civi

l action af

fected b

y this laws

uit were—a

t t

he

tim

e

o

f

the c

ommence

ment

of

this

action for

resc

ission of

the Inner

Harbo

r Disp

osition

A

greement

an

d

re

scission

of

all

deed

s conv

eyed

to

Defen

dant CO

R

p

ursuant to

the s

ame agreem

ent, and at

the time

of the

filing of

this Notice

—

sit

uated in the

Cou

nty

of

ONOND

AGA and

S

tate

of

New Y

ork, and ar

e

de

scribed

in Ex

hibit 1

and

Exhib

it 2 a

ttached her

eto

and

mad

e

p

art hereo

f-—i.e.:

Exhibit

It

Parcel

A I

Lot

A3,

Parcel B

Lots

Bl-1 ,

B2-1, B2-2,

B2-3,

B2-4, B2-5, B2

Iron P

ier Driv

e,

B2

North

Geddes

,

an

d B2

Salt Shed

Drive

) Parc

el C Lots C

l

C

-2,

and C-3);

and

Exh

ibit 2:

Parcel

A2

.

The Clerk

o

f

the

County of ONO

NDAGA

, is dire

cted to in

dex this

Notice ag

ainst

the

names

o

f

all Def

endants.

2


13/105

Dated

; De

cember 15

2015

Syracu

se, w

York

R

obert

P,

Stamey

, Esq.

Cor

poration

Counsel

By:

i...

t j

JdfiNA.

SICK

INGER E

SQ

Assistant

Co

rporation Couns

el

Attorn

ey for Defenda

nt

Ci

ty

of

S

yracuse

300

City,

Hall

Syra

cuse,

New

York 13202

Te

l.;

315)44

8-8400

jsicldnge

r@syrgov

.net

3


14/105

Ex

hib

it 1 :

Le

gal D

esc

ripti

on O

f

Pre

mise

s,

By

Parcels

Deeded

To Defendant

COR


15/105


16/105


17/105

» *

L

stSl

rl

9

AL

L

TH

AT

TRAC

T

OR PA

RCEL OF

LAN

D, situa

te

in

the

City

of

Sy

racuse

,

Count

y of

^

Ono

nda ga

and

State o

f

Ne

w

Yor k

,

bein

g part

of

Lot B1 o

f the

Re su

bd ivis

ion ofA

ba nd o

ne dN e

w

Y

ork

Sta

te Barge

Canal

Term

inal Land

s into

Lo t

s

Al

,

A2* A3,

A4

,

A5

, A

6» B1

B2 ac

cordin

g

S

Z

to

a map

of sa

id re

subdi

vision f

iled

A

pril

3

0, 2012 a

s Ma

p

No

.

11527

in di

e

On

ondag

a C

ounty

Cler

k s Offi

ce, bo

unded

and des

cribed

as follo

ws:

Begin

ning

a

t

the inte

rsectio

n o

f the north

easter

ly bound

ary

ofV

an R

ensse

laer Stre

ctwith

;

the northwester

ly boun

dary

o

fWes

t

K

irkpa

trick

Street: runn

ing

thenc

e

N

50*

26*30

W

alo

ng

said

n

orthea

sterly

b

oundar

y

o

fV

an R

enssel

ae r St

reet

a d

istanc

e of

266.01

feet

to

a point

there

in;

eS

th

ence

throug

h

said tot Bl

of the

abo

ve

me

ntione

d Re

subdiv

ision

the

fo llow

ing c

ourses

and

dista

nces: 1)

N 3

W 30

E.

367

,71 fee

t; 2)

N

50

*26*3

0

W, 90

.00 fee

t; 3) N 5

3*19*

43 W.

531.

40

f

eet;

4) N 50

°26*30

M W, 3

67.33 fec

i;

5) S

39 *33

*30 W

, 20.9

1 fe

et to

a

p

oint in

the

.

nort

heaste

rly

b

oundar

y of s

aid Lo t

B2;

thenc

e N 53

*19*0

3

W

al

ong sa

id north

easter

ly bou

ndary

o

f

to t

B

2, a d

istanc

e of

70. 16 fe

et t

o

a po

int

in a

southe

asterly

boun

dary of la

nds

convey

ed t

o

— th

e Stat

e

of New

York by

deed re

corde

d in

Book

5

1

97

of De

eds at

page 5

79; thenc

e N

•

43

°32 49

E a

long

said sout

heaste

rly

boun

dary of la

nds co

nveye

d to

the St

ate

ofNew

Yo

rk, a

di

stance

of 6

1 .08 fee

t to

a corn

er

t

herein

; thence

south

easte

rly alo

ng t

he south

weste

rly b

ounda

ry

o

f said lan

ds conve

yed to

the

State

ofN

ew

Y

ork the

follow

ing

cou

rses

an

d

dista

nces: 0

S

46*42

*20 E.,9

5.63

feet;

2) S 60

°35,4

0*

E

, 208.

72 fee

t;

3) S 53

*40*39

E, 3

0351

feet;

4) S

48 *01 *30

E, 40

2.24

fee

t; 5) S 55°

19 14

* Et 94.

52

feet ; 6)N

8

4*25*0

5 E,

20.22

feel; 7)S


18/105

50°49'36w W, 1 4,25 feet;

14)

N

56*09*55* E,

73

.64 feet to a

point in

the southwesterly

boundary of said Lot At ; thence southerly, southwesterly and southeasterly

along

said

southwesterly boundary of

Lot

A1 the following courses and distances: 1)S33°50WE, 26.68

feet; 2)

S57°I4WW, 126.84

feet; 3)S 77°4r55HE,61,79 feet;

4)

S E, 47.00

feet;

5)S40°2r50 E.

35,81

feet to the

aforementioned northwesterly boundary of

West

Kirkpatrick Street; thence

southwesterly

along said

northwesterly

boundary of

West

Kirkpatrick

the following courses

and distances: I)S56ol3'50*W,189.52fcet;

2) $64°3riO W , 369.77

feet to

the point of

beginning.

Intending

to

describe

New

Lot

BH

of

the Resubdivision

ofLotBl

and

Lo t

B2

of

Resubdivision of

Abandoned New

York

State

Barge

Canal

Terminal Lands into

Lots

Al,

A2,

A3, A4, AS, A6,

B1

&

B2

into

New

Lots Bl-1, B2-1, B2-2, B2-3, B2-4 & B2-5 and

Future

Streets

according

to

a map by

latum &

Romans Land Surveying,

P.C.

dared

February

18 , 2014

to

be filed in

the Onondaga County Clerk's Office.

Subject

to

any

easements or restrictions of record.

Approved

only

u

to Am md

kgaflfyi

JkjL

Aiahtmt CbrponttonCoimcI

By»


19/105

SCH

BBIM A

ALL

THAT TRAC

T OR PA

RCEL OF

LAND

,

situ

ate inthe

City ofSyrac

use,

Coun

ty

of

On

ondaga

a

nd State ofNe

w York, being

pa

rt

of

Lots B1 and

B2

of

the R

esubdivisio

n of

Abandone

d New

York State Ba

rge Ca n

al Term

inal

L

an ds

into Lots AI,

A2, A3,'A4.

A5. A6, Bl

B2 acc

ording

to ma p

of

s

aid resubdi

vision f iled Apr

il 3

0

201

2 as

Map No

,

11527

in the

Onond

aga County C

lerk's

Office, bounde

d and described

as

follows:

Beginning

at

a

point

in

the

current southeasterly bou

ndaryof l

ands convey

ed to

the

State

ofN

ew Y

ork by deed reco

rded in Bo

ok

519

7 of

De eds at

page 57 9 in the Ono

ndaga C

ounty

Clerk's Of

fice, said p

oint

be

ing

the

no

rtherly

most c

omer

of

said Lot

B2 an

d

the

westerl

y

most

corne

r of

sa

id LotBl

of th e a bov e

mention

ed Resu

bdivision;

running

thence S

53°l 9*03

E •

.

along the

northeaste

rly boundary of said Lo

t B

2

and t

he sou

thwesterly bou

ndary of

said Lot Bl

ofthe a

bove

me

ntioned Res

ubdivision,

adista

neeof70.1

6feetto

a

point

therei

n; thenc

e

nort

heasterly, s

ou theaster

ly southw

esterly

end

n

orthwester

ly throug

h sa id Lot

Bl

and

said

L

ot

B2

of the

ab

ove

me

ntioned Resubdivis

ion

the fo

llowing cou

rses and dist

ances; 1

N

3

9°33'3(T

..E

20.91 fee

t; 2)S

5Q°26'30

E, 367.33 feet

;

3 S

53°1

9*43 E 30.04;

4)

S

3

9°33*30 W,

9 .01 fee

t; 5) N 50e26r

3(T

W

,471

.9

4

feet

to a poin

t in

said southeas

terly boundary of

l

ands

conv

eyed to

the Sta

te

ofN

ew Yo

rk;

t

henceN 4

3°32,49 E

along

said southe

asterly boundary

of

la

nds

con

veyed (othe

State o

fNew York,

a distan

ce of 6

5.23 feet

to

the poi

nt ofbeginning

.

Intendin

g

to d

escribe

Ne

w Lot B2 1

o

f the R

esubdivis

ion of

Lot Bl and Lot B

2

o

f

Resubdivision

of

Abandoned

New

York

Slate

Barge

Canal

Terminal

Lands

into Lots

Al A2,

A

3.A4 A

5, A6, Bl

B

2 into

New Lots

Bl-1, B2-1,

02-2,

B2-3, B2-

4

B2-5

an d

Fu

ture

Approved

form

an d kfp ty.

v

J

ub

UM arpora

Soa wtmd

•e>A


20/105

Stree

ts a

ccordin

g to a m

ap

by lanuzi

oman

s Land S

urvey

ing, P.

C. d

ated

F

ebrua

ry 18,

2014

t

o be

file

d in

the

O

nonda

ga County

Cle

rk s O

ffice.

Subjec

t to

an

y easem

ents

or

restric

tions

of reco

rd.

infyin

tofbnn

aiikttfty

.

|

i

m


21/105

S

CH

E

D

U

LE

A

iM tiH

A

L

L T

H

A

T T

R

A

CT

O

R

P

A

R

CE

L O

F

LA

N

D

, sit

ua

te

k

i

\n

C

it

y o

f

S

yra

c

us

e, C

ou

n

ty

o

f

O

no

n

da

ga

an

d S

ta

te

of

Ne

w

Y

or

k, b

e

ing

p

art o

f L

ot

B1

fin

d

Lo

t B2

o

f

t

he

R

e

au

b

dM

s

io

no

f

A

ba

n

do

ne

d N

e

w

Y

o

rk S

ta

te

B

ar

ge

Ca

n

al

Te

rm

in

a

l

lan

d

s in

to

L

ot

s

A

I

,

A

2

, A

3,

A4

,

A5

, A

6(

B

_

B

2 a

c

co

rd

ing

to

a m

ap

of

s

ai

d

t

es

ub

dl

vls

lo

n

fi

led

A

p

ril

3

0,

20

12

as

M

a

p

N

o,

15

27

in

th

e

^

O

n

on

da

ga

C

ou

nt

y

C

le

r

ks

O

ff

ice

b

ou

n

de

d

a

n

d

de

sc

rib

ed

as f

oll

ow

s

:

B

e

gi

nn

in

g at

a

po

in

t

in

s

aid

L

o

t B

2 o

f t

he

a

bo

v

e

m

en

tio

ne

d R

es

u

bd

lvi

sio

n

, sa

id

po

in

t

be

in

g

th

e f

ol

low

in

g

c

ou

rs

es

an

d

dis

ta

nc

es

fro

m

t

he

Int

er

se

cti

on

o

f t

he

n

or

th

ea

st

er

ly b

ou

n

da

ry

o

f

Va

n

Re

n

sse

la

er

S

tre

et

w

i

th th

e n

o

rth

we

s

ter

ly

b

ou

n

da

ry

o

fW

es

t

K

irk

pa

tr

ick

St

re

et;

1 )

N

50

°

26

W

W

a

lo

ng

s

aid

no

rth

ea

s

ter

ly bo

un

d

ary

ofV

a

n

Re

n

sse

la

er

St

re

et,

3

5

6.0

1

f

fcc

t to

a p

oi

nt

th

er

ei

n; 2

)

N

3

9

°3

3

W

E th

ro

ug

h

s

aid

L

o

t B

2

, 25

4

,00

fe

et ;

3)

N

5

0

°2

6

W

W

c

on

tin

u

in

g

t

hr

ou

gh

sa

id

Lo

t B

2,

30

.0

0 f

ee

t t

o

h

e a

c

tua

l p

oi

nt

o

fbe

g

inn

in

g;

r

un

ni

ng

the

n

ce

n

o

rth

w

es

te

rly

,

northeasterly;

southeasterly

and

southwesterly

con

tin

u

ing

t

hr

ou

gh s

a

id

Lo

t

B

2

an

d

th

ro

ug

h

sa

id

L

o

tB

l

of

th

e a

b

ov

e

m

en

ti

on

ed

R

es

ub

dl

vis

io

nt

he

f

oll

ow

in

g co

u

rse

s

an

d di

sta

nc

es

:

1

)N

50

°

26

W

W

, 4

20

.0

0

fe

et

;

2)

N

3

9°

3

3W

B

,

9

1.

01

fe

et

; 3)

S

5

3

°

IW

E

,

42

0.5

3

fe

et

; 4

)S

3

9°

33

W

W

1

12

. 19

f

ee

t to

t

he

p

oi

nt o

f

be

gi

nn

in

g.

In

te

nd

in

g

to

de

sc

rib

e

N

ew L

o

t

B

2-

2 o

f th

e

R

es

u

bd

lvi

sio

n o

f

Lo

t

B

1 e

nd

L

o

t B2

of

R

e

su

b

dlv

is

ion

o

f

Ab

an

d

on

ed

N

e

w

Yo

rk

St

ate B

ar

ge

C

an

a

l T

e

rm

in

al

L

an

d

s in

to

t

at

s A

l

,

A

2,

A

3

, A

4

, A

S,

A

6,

B1

B

2

I

nt

oN

c

w L

ots

B

M

,

B

2

-I

, B

2-

2,

B

2

-3

,

B

2

-4

&

B

2-

5 a

nd

F

ut

ure

S

i

2

Ap

pr

ait

tl

k(

m

lo

fcr

a a

od te

t*1

Uy.

iU

i

y

i

An

im

a

lC

wj

MM

tio

n

o»


22/105

St

ree

ts

ac

cor

din

g

to a

m

ap by

lan

uz

i Ro

ma

ns.

L

and

Su r

vey

ing

.

P.O

. da t

ed

Fe

bm

ary 18.

20

14

to

be

file

d in

the O

no

nda

ga

C

ou

nty

Cle

ric

s

Of

fice

,

S

ub

jec

t

to

a

ny

e

as

em

ent

s o

r res

tric

tio

ns o

f re

cor

d.

By

r

A

md

rtiM

Ct

tryw

itkn

Cm

iom I


23/105

*

o

Sf

flBm

BA

Lo tB2-3

AL

L THAT

T

RACT O

R

PAR

CEL

OF

L

AND, s

ituate

in the

C

ity

o

fSyra

cuse,

Coun

ty of

O

nonda

ga and

Slate

ofNew

York, be

ing p

art

of Lot B2

o

f

the Re

subdlv

ision

of

Aban

doned N

ew

t

Yo

rk Stat

e Barg

e

Canal Te

rmina

l Lands

into

Lots AL

A3. A

3, A

4, A5, A

6,

B1 B2

accord

ing

to

a

m

ap o

f said r

esubd

lvision f

iled Apr

il

30, 2012

as Ma

p N

o.

11527

in

th

e O

nonda

ga Co

unty

Cle

rk s

Offic

e,

b

ounde

d a

nd d

escrib

ed as follow

s*,

B

eginn

ing at

a p

oint

I

n the cu

rrent

In the

curren

t north

easter

ly b

ounda

ry o

fVan

Renss

elaer

Stree

t, s aid poin

t bein

g 836.01

feet d

istant

nor

thwes

terly along

said

north

easte

rly

bo

undar

y

ofV

an Ren

sselae

r

Street

from

its inters

ection w

ith

the nor

thwes

ter ly bou

ndary

o f

West

Kiik

patric

k S

treet;

ru

nning

then

ce

N

SO

WSO

W along

sai

d n

orthea

sterly bound

ary

of

V

an

Rens

se laer

Stree t

, a dist

ance of 36

0.00

feet

to a p

oint th

erein;

thence

north

ea ster

ly,

so

uthea

sterly

and

south

weste

rly

th

rough

sa

id

L

ot B

2

of

t

he abo

ve me

ntione

d

Resub

divisio

n

th

e

following

courses

and

distances:

1) N

39°33 30n E, 194,00

feet;

2)

S

50°26 30

E, 360,00 feet;

3) S

39®33

'30w

W, 194.00 f

eet

to toe

point

of beg

inning

.

Inten

ding to descr

ibe

New

Lot

B2-3

of

the

Res

ubdlv

ision

of Lot Bl

and Lot

B2

o

f

Resub

divisio

n of A

bandon

ed N

ew York

Sta

te Barge

Cana l

T

ermina

l

Land

s in

to L

ots

A

l,

A2.

A

3, A4, A5

, A6,

BI

B2

in

to

N

ew

Lots Bl

-1. B

2-l,B

2-2, B2

-3, B2-4

B

2-5 and

Future

Street

s ac

cordin

g

to

a m

ap by Ionu

zi Ro

mans

L

and Su r

veying

. P.C,

date

d

Feb

ruary

18,

2014

t

o be

filed in to

e O no

ndaga

Cou

nty Cler

k s O

ffice.

Su

bject to

any ease

ments

or restri

ctions

o

f record

.

9

Af

fiw

r i tp* a i to A

m and hg

UKy.

lu

itfh

yt

AHU

tut

Corp

orate*

(M

mmI


24/105

S

CHE

DUL

E A

L

?l

ALL

TH

AT TR

ACT

OR

P

ARC

EL OF

LAN

D, s

ituate in

the C

ityo

fSyr

acuse

, Coun

ty o

f

On

onda

ga an

d Sta

te

o

f

Ne

w

Yo

rk, b

eing

p

art ofL

ot B2

of the R

eaub

dlvis

ion

of A

bando

ned

N

ew

Yo

rk S

tate

Barg

e

C

anal

Term

inal

Lan

ds i

nto Lot

s A1 ,

A2, A

3, A4,

A5

, A6,

B1

ft B2

acc

ordin

g

to

a m

ap of

said

resu

bdivis

ion file

d Ap

ril 3

0.

2012

as M

ap No.

1 15

27 In

the On

onda

ga C

ounty

C

lerk

s O

ffice

, bo

unde

d and

des

cr ibe

d as follo

ws:

D

Beginningat

a

po int

in

the

cu rrent northeasterly bounda ry

of

Van

Re nsselaer S t reet said

poin

t bein

g

4l6.

0lfe

et

d

istan

t nort

hwes

terly

alon

g said n

orthe

aster

ly

bou

ndary of

V

an

Ren

ssela

er St

reet

from it

s inters

ectio

n wit

h

th e nor t

hw es

terly

bo

undar

y

o

f

Wes

t

Kirk

patric

k

St

reet;

runn

ing t

henc

e

N

50*2

6*30

W

alo

ng

s

aid no

rthea

sterl

y bo

unda

ry o

fV

an Ren

sselae

r

Stre

et a

dis

tance of

360.

00

feet t

o a

poin

t there

in; the

nce no

rthea

sterly

,, sou

theas

terly

an

d

s

outhw

este

rly th

rough

sa

id

L

ot

B2

o

f the ab

ove men

tione

d R

esub

divisi

on th

e foll

owin

g co

urses

and dista

nces

:

1)N

39 33

30- E

, 194,

00

feet;

2)S

5W

30

E,

360 .

00 fee

t; 3)8

39*3

3*30

W, 19

4 00

feet

to die

poin

t

of

be

ginni

ng.

In

tendi

ng t

o

desc

ribe

New L

ot

B2-

4 of the

Re

subd

ivisio

n of

Lot

B1 a

ndLo

tB2

of

Re

subd

ivisio

n of

Aban

done

d N

ew Yo

rk

State B

arge C

anal

Te

rmin

al Land

s into

Lots

A1, A

2,

A

3 A4,

A5,

A6

, B1 ft B

2

into New

L

ots-B

I-1,

B

2-1, B2-2

, B

2-3,

B2-

4 B2

-5 and

Futur

e

Stre

ets acc

ordin

g to a

m

ap by

lanu

zi ft

Rom

ans La

nd

Surve

ying, P.O

. d

ated Fe

bruar

y

1 8.

201 4

to

be

file

d in the

Ono

ndag

a C

ount

y C

lerk

s

O

ffice

.

Subject

to

any

easements

or

restrictions of

record.

s

3

Appro

ved

Mfy u to

torn

aid

tgilltf.

b>

(

Mjlo

Aukt

wt

Cfy

portikm

Ow

n


25/105

SCHEDULE

A

Lot

B2-5

ALL

THAT TRACT OR PARCEL OF

LAND,

situate in

tie City of Syracuse,

County

of

Onondaga

and State

of

New York, being

part of

Lot

B1

and

LotB2 of

the

Resubdivishm of

Abandoned

New

York State Barge

Canal

Terminal Lands into Lots Al, A2, A3, A4, A5, A6, B1

& B2 according to a map

of said

resubdivi&ion Bled

April 30, 201

2 as

Map

No, 1 1 527 in the

Onondaga County Clerk's Office, bounded and described

as

follows:

Beginning at a

point

in

the current northeasterly boundary of

Van

Rensselaer Street,

said

point

being 266.01

feet distant northwesterly

along said

northeasterly boundary of

Van

Rensselaer Street from

its

intersection with

the

northwesterly boundary of West KIrkpatrick

Street;

running

thence N

50°26'30M

W along said northeasterly boundary of Van

Rensselaer

Street, a distance

of90.00

feet

to a point therein; thence northeasterly, northwesterly,

northeasterly, southeasterly and southwesterly through said .Lot B1

and

Lot B2 Gf the above

mentioned Resiibdivision

the

following

courses

and distances: 1)N39°33 3(T E, 254.00 feet;

•2)N W31T W ,

30.00

feet;

3)N39W3trB,

112.19;

4)S53°19'43*

E, 30,04

feet;

5)S

50°26'30

E,

90.00 feet; 6) S

W1VW W, 367,71 feet

to the

point of beginning.

Intending

to describe New LotB2-5 of the Resubdivision of Lot B1 and Lot

B2

of

Resubdivision of

Abandoned

New York State Barge Canal Terminal Lands Into

Lots At,

A2,

A3, A4, A5, A6, Bl &

B2

into New

Lots

Bl-l,

B2-1, B2-2, B2-3,

B2-4 &

B2-5

and

Future

Streets

according

to a map by lanuzi

&

Romans

Land Surveying,

P.O.

dated February 1

8,

201 4

tobe filed in the'Onondaga

County

Clerk's Office.

Subject

to any easements or

restrictions of record.

3

^3

»

(o

fomt

ud Ifflllty.

AW

AubttntOorporatlanCouBwl


26/105

'

•»

SCHEDULE

A

Iron Pier

Drive

ALL

THAT TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND,

situate

in the City

of Syracuse,

County

of

Onondaga

and State

of

New

York,

being part

of* B2 ofthcResubdlvlsion

of

Abandoned

New

_ York State Barnc Canal

Terminal Lands

fyto

Lots

AI,

A2, A3, A4f A5,

A6,

B1

Sc

B2

according

D

. ^

to a

map

of said

resubdivisign filed

April 30, 20

1 2 as

Map No. 1 1 527

in

the Onondaga County

Clerk's

Office,

bounded

and

described

as follows:

ep

Beginning

at a

point

in the current northeasterly

boundary

ofVan

Rensselaer Street,

said

point being 780.29 feet distant northwesterly along said

northeasterly

boundary ofVan

Rensselaer Street from its intersection

with tho

northwesterly

boundary of

WestKlrfcpatrick

Street;

running thence

N 50W30

W along

said northeasterly

boundary

of

Van Rensselaer

Street, -a

distance of 60,00

feet

to a point therein; thence northeasterly,

southeasterly

and

. southwesterly through said Lot B2of

the

above

mentioned

Regubdivision the following courses

•

•

and'distanccs:l)N39°33$30,%E(

190,00

feet;

2)

S

50fl26\30

E,

60.00 feet; 3)

S

39°33'30w W,

1 90.00 feet

to

the

point

of beginning, containing 1 1 ,400 square feet of land, more or less,

- Subject to any easements or restrictions of record.

ufo

fern and lt|iUty.

PI

MX&\\aumMua

Anlrtwrt

Cnrpontiott

Cow


27/105

I.

k towma

North

Geddcs

ALL THAT

TRACT PARCEL

OF

LAND,

situate in

the City

of

Syracuse,

County of

Onondaga and State of New York, being

part ofLotB2

of

the.

Resubdivision of

Abandoned

New

York

State

Barge Canal

Terminal

Lands into Lots Ai, A2, A3, A4, A5, A6; B1

&

B2 according

r

V* to a

map of

said resubdivision Bled April 30, 2012

as Map

No. 11527ln the Onondaga County

Clerk's Office, bounded

and

described

as

follows;

Beginning at

a

point in the

current

northeasterly boundary

ofVan

Rensselaer Street, said

point being

1

,204.29 feet distant northwesterly along said

northeasterly

boundary ofVan

Rensselaer Street from its

intersection

with

the

northwesterly boundary

of

West Khkpatrfck

Street; running

thence N 50^26*30* W

along

said

northeasterly boundary

ofVan

Rensselaer

- Street adIstanceof33.47ftettoapdinttherein; thence northerly and northeasterly along

the

westerly#, northwesterly boundary

ofsaid Lot

B2

of the above

mentioned

Resubdivision the

following-courses

and distances;

l)NO0°26'36 E,

44.01

feet;

2)N10°59'44M W,

34.00 feet;

3)

N

43°32'49 B, 134.58 feet to a point

therein;

thence southeasterly and southwesterly

through

said

Lot B2 of the above

mentioned Resubdivision

the following courses

and

. distances',1) S 50W30* B, 78.12

feet; 2)

S 39°33'30 190.00 feet

to

the point of

beginning,

- containing 14,340 square feet

of

land, more or less.

Subject

to

any

easements or restrictions

of

record.

\

,orty it to

form

and

ttfaJIfy.

l

M&0

Attbteat (ferporatkm foumi


28/105

«

scwBPvy;A

ALL THAT TRACT

OR

PARCEL OF LAND, situate in the City of Syracuse. County of

Onondaga

and State of New York, being

part

of Lot B2 of the

Rcsubdivision

of

Abandoned

New

^ York State Barge

Canal

Tenuinal

Lands into

Lots A1

, A2,

A3, A4, A5,

A6,

B1 &

B2 according

to

a map of said rcsubdivision

filed

April

30, 2012

as Map No.

1

1

527

in the

Onondaga

County

Clerk's

Office,

bounded and described as

follows;

Beginning

at apoint in the current northeasterly boundary

of

Van Rensselaer Street said

point

being

356.29

feet distant northwesterly along said

northeasterly

boundary

of

Van

Rensselaer

Street horn Its

Intersection

with

the

northwesterly boundary

of West Kirkpatrick

Street; running thence N 50°26'30 W

along

ssld northeasterly boundary ofVan Rensselaer

Street

a

distance

of 60.00

feet to a point therein;

thence

northeasterly, southeasterly and

southwesterly

through said Lot B2 of

the

above

mentioned Rcsubdivision the following

courses

and

distances:

) N

39*33*30

E, 190.00

foot; 2)

S

50°26'30H

E,

60.00 feet;

3)

S

39°33'30M

W,

190.00 feet to the

point

ofbeginnlng, containing

1

1,400 square feet of

fand.

more or less.

Subject

to

any easements or restrictionsof record.

V \

Approve

ovel

only M to

ton*

ntd legality

Aarirtent Onrporatton

CVuma

M to

toftMtwl

legality.

eyi


29/105

«•

S

treet

a dista

nce

o

f 60.00

feet to t

he point ofb

egtaning

containing

55

44

squ

re feet of

land more

or less

Subject to

ny

e semen

ts or

res

trictions

of re

cord

pro

ved

oil

y m to

fo

r

. ttd Wfi ty

uV

ldVt

u k

loni Cerpiwiflon Io

ukmI


30/105

. .

f

SCHEDULE

A

ALL THAT

TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND

located in the City of

Syracuse, County of

Onondaga,

State of New

York,

being pert of

Pastures

Lots

1-4

in said city, and being more

particularly

described as follows: beginning

at

the intersection of the southwesterly

street line

of

; 3 Van Rensselaer Street with

die

northerly street line

of

West

Kirkpatrick

Street; thence

S,

y 75457*40 W„ along

said

northerly street line of West Kirkpatrick Street,

a distance of

59533

feet to its intersection with the former easterly line of Onondaga Creek;

thence

along

said

former

v,

easterly

line

of

Onondaga

Creek the

following courses

and

distances: N.10°37'25 W, a

distance

^ of 36.30

feet, N.19»42>35 W.

a distance

of 50.64

feet, N«26W25*W, a

distance

of

54.55 feet,

N33*22'05HW,

a

distance of

38.22

feet, N.46*20'35 W.

a

distance of

46.29

feet.

N.46°2t'13MW. a distance of 53.75 feet, N37447,lTW. a

distance

of

100.72

feet.

- N.39°29' 14 W.*a distance of 100.40 foot, N;43#29*06**W. a distanceof 100.02*,

a

distance of

100.40 feet, and

N49412*19>*W, a distance of 85.88

feet to

its intersection with fee

£ easterly street

line

of North Geddes Street; thence N.12*45 20**B. along said easterly street

line

.

of

North

Geddes Street,

a

distance

of

261.67

feet

to

its

intersection

with

the lands

of

fed

People

of the State of New

York and a realigned

portion of North Geddes

Street; tiienoe

N.39°33t36*,B,

along tire southeasterly line of

the

lands of the People of fee Stateof New York, a distance

of

102.12 feet to its intersection with

the

former southeasterly line of Onondaga

Creek;

thence

along said southeasterly line of Onondaga Creek fee

following

courses and distances:

• N.46o00*46 E,

a distance

of

45.00

f ee t, and N.32*23'59 E. a .distance

of

23.14 feet

to Its

..

intersection- with fee

southwesterly

street line of Von Rensselaer Street} thence S.SO'M'SOT.,

along said southwesterly street

Une of Van

Rensselaer Street, a distance of 1149.76 feet

to

the

pointofbeginning, .

ALSO BEING

DESCRIBED

AS,

all

tiiat tract or parcel

of land,

situate

In

the City

of

Syracuse, County.

of Onondaga and

State of

New

York, being

1x3

Noi, CM , C-2

and

P3

of

Subdivision' of Parcel C into Lot

Nos. C-I,

C-2

& C-3

New

York

Canal Corporation

Abandoned

Barce Cpnal ycnntnal Lands according

to

a map of

said

tract filed

in

the Onondaga

County

Clark's

Office

October

23,2015 as

Map

No.

1210.

3

4

A

&

yj

. ;

tttoftmnudhfCH)'.

|

WAsMlVsj OYUaa

y.

itautint Qwporrtw fnwul


31/105

Exhibit

2:

Legal Description

Of

Premises'

Parcel

A2


32/105

P

arce

l A

2

'A li

i

T

HA

T

TR

ACT

OR P

AR

CEL

OF LAN

D,

s

ituat

e in th

e Cit

y o

fS

yrac

use

,

Co

unty

of

On

ond

aga,

Sta

te o

fNew

Yo

rk, an

d

be

ing

pa

rt

o

fMar

sh

Lot

s 33, 3

4,

and

35

in

said Cit

y a

nd b

ein

g

m

ore p

artic

ular

ly des

crib

ed a

s

follo

ws: Co

mm

enc

inga

t th

e pre

sen

t inte

rsec

tion

oft

he

nor

thw

este

rly st

reet

H

ue o

f

W

est

Rirk

pat

rlck.

Str

eet

wi

th

d

ie

so

uthw

est

erly str

eet lin

e

of S

ola

r

Stre

et; t

hen

ceN

.50

°26

3 (r

w., a

long

sai

d

sout

hwe

ster

ly str

eet lin

e of

S

olar S

tree

t, a

dis

tanc

e

o

f

1

2.7

4*

footto

th

e

actu

al poi

nt ofb

egh

ming

; t

hcn

ccN

.50°

26'3

()',W

. co

ntin

uing

alon

g

th

e

southwesterly

street

line

ofSolar

Street, a distance

of

76940

feet; thence S.56°10,03MW., a

dis

tanc

e

o

f

156

43 fee

t t

o its

int

erse

ction

with

t

he no

rfhe

aste

rlyli

nc

ofla

nd

sjo be

reta

ined

by

the

' St

ate ofN

ew

Yo

rk;

the

nce a

long

s

aidno

rthea

ster

ly line

of la

nds t

o be

re

taine

d b

y the

Sta

te o

f

N

ew

Yo

rk

t

he M

ow

ing

co

urse

s and

dis

tanc

es; S

.50

D28

,08 E

., a

dista

nce

of2

78,5

0 feet

,

of 30

.00

foet,

S,5

0°2

8W

E., a

di

stan

ce

of

204

.86 fe

et, N

.39

°31

,52M

B.,

a

dis

tanc

e

of 30

.00 fee

t, S

.50°

28

WE

,,

a

d

istan

ce o

f2

98.9

8 f

eet;

then

ce

S.

87°1

9'2

5 E .

,

a

dist

anc

e

o

f 1 164

4 fe

et;

thenc

e

N^

^S S

OT

E., a

dist

ance

of 74

.45

fe

et; the

nce

N

,50

*26

*30*

W., a di

stan

ce

of 6

1.51 fe

et;

th

ence

N.39

°33

130

E.,

a dis

tanc

e of 5

.09

feet

to th

e p

oint

of beg

innin

g.

Con

tain

ing 2.9

8

acre

s o

f

land

mor

e or

le

ss .

The

he

rein

befo

re de

scrib

ed

p

arce

l

of

land is

sub

ject to

an

ease

me

nt for i

ngre

ss

an

d

eg

ress

m

ore

pa

rtic

ular

ly de

scrib

ed as

follo

ws

:

C

omm

enc

ing

at

the pre

sen

t

int

erse

ctio

n

of

th

e no

rthw

este

rly

street

line

of

est

Kirkpatrick

Street

with

the

southwesterly street

line

of

Solar

Street;

thence

N

.50°

26 *3

0, ,W

.,

a

long

said

sou

thwe

ster

ly str

eet li

ne

ofSo

lar

St

reet,

a

dist

ance o

f

4

73.

17

fee

t to t

he

actu

al

poi

nt o

f

b

egin

ning

; then

ce

S.

3903

1'52

,TW

., a

dis

tanc

e

o

f 14

9.3

6

fee

t

t

o the la

nds

re

tain

ed

by

the

Stat

e o

fNe

wYo

rk;

then

ce N

.50°

28,0

8',W

.,

alo

ng said

l

ands

reta

ined

b

y

t

he S

tate o

fNe

w

Yo

rk,

a

dista

nce of

50

.00 fee

t;

then

ce N.3

9°3

1'52

B.,

a

dis

tanc

e o

f 14

9.39 f

eet

to its

inte

rse

ction

with

the

so

uthw

est

erly stre

et

lin

e ofS

olar

Stre

et;

th

ence d

.50

°26*

30

E.,

a

long

the sou

thw

este

rly

stre

et

line

ofSo

lar

Stree

t, a dis

tanc

e o

f

50:0

0

fe

et

to the p

oin

t o

fbeg

inni

ng,

.

'

Th

e h

ere

inbe

fore

de

scrib

ed p

arce

fof

lan

d is

also

su

bjec

t to an

y

an

d

ll ea

sem

ents a

nd

or r

ight

s

o

f

wa

y

of re

cor

d.

'

3


33/105

X

H

I

I

T


34/105

1

SU

P

RE

ME

CO

U

RT

O

F

TH

E

S

TA

T

E

OF

NE

W

YO

RK

t

i.

2 CO

UN

TY

O

F

O

NO

ND

AG

A

3

4 CIT

Y

O

F

SY

R

AC

US

E

,

5

P

la

in

ti

ff

6

MO

T

ION

D

E

CI

SIO

N

s .

7

C

OR

DE

VE

LO

P

ME

NT

CO

M

PA

NY

, L

LC

;

C

OR

I

NN

E

R

H

A

RB

OR

CO

M

PA

NY

,

L

LC

? C

OR

S

O

LA

R S

TR

E

ET

C

OM

P

AN

Y

IV

LL

C?

CO

R

VA

N

R

E

NS

SE

LA

E

R

S

TR

EE

T

CO

M

PA

N

Y,

LL

C

;

CO

R

W

ES

T

K

IRK

P

AT

Documents

COR Motion to Dismiss Lawsuit