Upload
truongdang
View
215
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Communicating Program Impact-Using Research Outcomes to Promote Community Buy-in
Locally
Presented by : Sebrina Doyle and Stephanie Bradley
EPISCenter
April 24th, 2012
A note on stakeholders…
A person, group, or organization that has direct or
indirect stake in an organization because it can affect or
be affected by the organization's actions, objectives,
and policies.
Source: http://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/stakeholder.html
∗ Academic (attendance, grades)
∗ Social (bullying, peer relationships)
∗ Behavioral (antisocial behavior, risky behavior)
∗ ATOD use/abuse (timing of onset, use, risk for abuse)
∗ Family Relationships (parent-child, sibling)
∗ Mental health
Program Outcomes:
∗ Time-
∗ Initial investment of time in training
∗ # of hours spent implementing program
∗ Money-
∗ Amount of funds required for start-up
∗ Amount of funds required for maintenance
∗ Cost/Benefit-
∗ Amount of time/money saved by running the program
Other metrics that can be used for measurement:
Data Toolkit
Program Logic Model
WSIPP Economic Research
National Program Results
External Local and State Data Sources
(EpiQMS, PAYS)
External National Data Sources (CDC,
Kids Count)
Agency/Local Data
∗ What is it?
∗ Describes how and why the program produces changes in the targeted outcomes
∗ Why is it important?
∗ Provides theoretical backbone
∗ Guides quality implementation
∗ Guides quality evaluation
Logic Model Basics
Lessons
Group Activities
Role-Playing
Self-reflection
Homework
Projects
Skill Practice
Individual Therapy
Group Therapy
Program Components, Activities, Features
Increased knowledgeIncreased skillsImproved attitudes
Better communicationIncreased norms knowledgeRecognizing emotionsIncreased belief in self
Short Term Outcomes
Increased school successBetter relationshipsDecreased substance useBetter mental health
Long Term Outcomes
Risk Factors:Poor family relationshipsAcademic disengagementLack of study skillsPoor social skillsIsolation
Protective Factors:Attachment to schoolProsocial activitiesPositive relationshipsEmotion regulationNorms knowledge
Targets
Essential Features of a Logic Model – A General Example
How…? What…?
After an eighteen month period, BBBSA youth:
∗ were 46% less likely than control youth to initiate drug use.
∗ were 27% less likely to initiate alcohol use than control youth.
∗ were almost one-third less likely than control youth to hit someone.
∗ were better than control youth in academic behavior, attitudes, and performance.
∗ were more likely to have higher quality relationships with their parents or guardians than control youth.
∗ were more likely to have higher quality relationships with their peers at the end of the study period than did control youth.
Program Outcomes for BBBSA* From the Blueprints for Violence Prevention Website
Program youth compared to control group youth:
∗ Spent 60% fewer days incarcerated at 12 month follow-up;
∗ Had significantly fewer subsequent arrests;
∗ Ran away from their programs, on average, three time less often;
∗ Had significantly less hard drug use in the follow-up period;
∗ Had quicker community placement from more restrictive settings (e.g., hospital, detention); and
∗ Had better school attendance and homework completion at 24 months follow-up.
Program Outcomes for MTFC* From the Blueprints for Violence Prevention Website
The Economic Return on PCCD’s Investment in Research-based Programs: A cost-benefit assessment of delinquency prevention in Pennsylvania. 2008, p.5.
From the PA Epidemiological Report
Construct ALCOHOL TOBACCO ILLICIT DRUGS
Mortality
Alcoholic Liver Disease Death Rate
Percent Fatal Motor Vehicle Crashes Involving Alcohol
Fatal Motor Vehicle Death Rate Involving Alcohol
Percent Drinking Drivers of Total Drivers in Fatal Crashes
Lung Cancer Death Rate
Emphysema Death Rate
Drug Death Rate Percent Persons 12+
Meeting DSM-IV Criteria for Illicit Drug Abuse/Dependence
Crime
DUI Arrest Rate Self-reported DUI (youth only) Public Drunkenness Conviction
Rate Underage Purchase of
Alcohol/Tobacco Conviction rate DUI Conviction Rate
Drug Possession Conviction Rate
Illegal Alcohol/Drug Sales Conviction Rate
Other Consequences
Percent Persons 12+ Meeting DSM-IV Criteria for Alcohol
Abuse/Dependence Treatment Admissions (%) for
Alcohol Use
Treatment Admissions (%) for Illicit Drug Use
Consumption
Current Use (youth only) Binge Drinking
Lifetime Use (youth only) Heavy Drinking (adults only)
Alcohol Sales
Current Use Lifetime Use (youth
only) Daily Smokers (adults
only) Smoking During
Pregnancy
Current Use Lifetime Use (youth
only)
Two examples:
EpiQMShttp://www.portal.state.pa.us/portal/server.pt?open=514&objID=596553&mode=2
PAYShttp://www.pays.state.pa.us
Binge Alcohol Use in Past Month by Persons aged 12-20 by PA Substate Region
SAMHSA, Office of Applied Studies, National Survey on Drug Use and Health, 2006, 2007, and 2008.
A Few Bridges
Funding agency Cost-benefit
Potential Volunteers
Community
Time Commitment/ program effects
EpiQMS, PAYS
Who: What: Where:
WSIPP Economic Report
Program Developer Website
Risk & protective factors