39
www.midwestcleanenergy.org Combined Heat and Power and the Traction It’s Gaining in the Midwest Session: Microgrids and Combined Heat and Power Traction, Trends, and Opportunities 2015 NASEO Energy Policy Outlook Conference February 4, 2015 Cliff Haefke US DOE Midwest CHP TAP Co - Director

Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

www.midwestcleanenergy.org

Combined Heat and Power and the

Traction It’s Gaining in the Midwest

Session: Microgrids and Combined Heat and Power

Traction, Trends, and Opportunities

2015 NASEO Energy Policy Outlook Conference

February 4, 2015

Cliff Haefke

US DOE Midwest CHP TAP Co-Director

Page 2: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

o Market Opportunity Analysis.Supporting analyses of CHP market opportunities in diverse markets including industrial, federal, institutional, and commercial sectors

o Education and Outreach. Providing information on the energy and non-energy benefits and applications of CHP to state and local policy makers, regulators, end users, trade associations, and others.

o Technical Assistance.Providing technical assistance to end-users and stakeholders to help them consider CHP, waste heat to power, and/or district energy with CHP in their facility and to help them through the development process from initial CHP screening to installation.

CHP Technical Assistance PartnershipsKey Activities

http://www.energy.gov/eere/amo/

chp-technical-assistance-

partnerships-chp-taps

Page 3: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

o Analyzing Recent Midwest CHP Project

Market Trends and Drivers

o Highlighting Recent CHP Installations and

Projects Under Development (additional CHP systems highlighted in Appendix)

o Midwest CHP Technical Potential

o DOE Midwest CHP TAP Education &

Technical Assistance Efforts

Outline

3

Page 4: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

0

25

50

75

100

125

150

175

200

CH

P G

en

era

tin

g C

ap

acit

y I

nsta

lled

2005 2006 2007 2008

2009 2010 2011 2012

2013 2014* 2015-2016*

0

5

10

15

20

25

0

25

50

75

100

125

150

175

200

Nu

mb

er

of

CH

P S

ys

tem

s I

ns

tall

ed

CH

P G

en

era

tin

g C

ap

ac

ity I

ns

tall

ed

Capacity (MW) Number of Systems

Midwest Annual Installed CHP

Generating Capacity (2005 – 2016)

4

* Publically announced CHP projects. only. Sizes

of some projects are not known and therefore

not accounted for. Others are under develop-

ment that haven’t been announced and/or

were not identified at time of presentation.

Source: DOE CHP Installation

Database (2005-2013 data) ICF Internal

Estimates, & Publically Announced CHP

Projects (2014-2016 data)

4

Page 5: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

0

50

100

150

200

250

CH

P G

en

era

tin

g C

ap

acit

y (

MW

)

CHP Gen. Capacity

-

2

4

6

8

10

0

50

100

150

200

250

Nu

mb

er

of

CH

P S

yste

ms

CH

P G

en

era

tin

g C

ap

acit

y (

MW

)

CHP Gen. Capacity Number of CHP Systems

Source: DOE CHP Installation

Database (2005-2013 data) ICF Internal

Estimates, & Publically Announced CHP

Projects (2014-2016 data)

Midwest CHP Projects by

Industry Type (2013 – 2016)

5

* Publically announced CHP projects. only. Sizes

of some projects are not known and therefore

not accounted for. Others are under develop-

ment that haven’t been announced and/or

were not identified at time of presentation.

Note significant CHP

generation capacity

in utilities

Page 6: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

CHP Generating Capacity (MW)

Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

2013 88.7 100.1 188.8

2014* 1.7 100.4 102.1

2015-2016* 45.6 140.6 186.2

Total 136.0 341.2 477.1

Number of CHP Systems

Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

2013 17 2 19

2014* 2 5 7

2015-2016* 4 8 12

Total 23 15 38

CHP Generating Capacity (MW)

Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

2013 88.7 100.1 188.8

2014* 1.7 100.4 102.1

2015-2016* 45.6 140.6 186.2

Total 136.0 341.2 477.1

Source: DOE CHP Installation

Database (2005-2013 data) ICF Internal

Estimates, & Publically Announced CHP

Projects (2014-2016 data)

Midwest CHP Projects by Fuel

Type (2013 – 2016)

6

* Publically announced CHP projects. only. Sizes

of some projects are not known and therefore

not accounted for. Others are under develop-

ment that haven’t been announced and/or

were not identified at time of presentation.

Note higher ratio of Natural Gas CHP Projects

Page 7: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

Source: DOE CHP Installation

Database (2005-2013 data) ICF Internal

Estimates, & Publically Announced CHP

Projects (2014-2016 data)

Midwest CHP Projects by Prime

Mover Type (2013 – 2016)

7

CHP Gen Capacity (MW)

Year

Boiler/

Steam

Turbine

Combined

Cycle

Combus-

tion

Turbine

Micro-

turbine

Recipro-

cating

Engines

Un-

known Total

2013 67.0 100.0 13.8 0.2 7.8 - 188.8

2014* 99.0 - - 0.2 1.8 - 102.1

2015-2016* 34.0 - 47.4 - 25.9 80.0 186.2

Total 200.0 100.0 61.2 0.4 35.5 80.0 477.1

Number of CHP Systems (#)

Year

Boiler/Stea

m Turbine

Combine

d Cycle

Combus-

tion

Turbine

Micro-

turbine

Recipro-

cating

Engines

Un-

known Total

2013 4 1 3 2 9 - 19

2014* 1 - - 2 3 - 7

2015-2016* 1 - 4 - 6 2 12

Total 6 1 7 4 18 2 38 * Publically announced CHP projects. only. Sizes

of some projects are not known and therefore

not accounted for. Others are under develop-

ment that haven’t been announced and/or

were not identified at time of presentation.

CHP Gen Capacity (MW)

Year

Boiler/

Steam

Turbine

Combined

Cycle

Combus-

tion

Turbine

Micro-

turbine

Recipro-

cating

Engines

Un-

known Total

2013 67.0 100.0 13.8 0.2 7.8 - 188.8

2014* 99.0 - - 0.2 1.8 - 102.1

2015-2016* 34.0 - 47.4 - 25.9 80.0 186.2

Total 200.0 100.0 61.2 0.4 35.5 80.0 477.1

Page 8: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

Source: DOE CHP Installation

Database (2005-2013 data) ICF Internal

Estimates, & Publically Announced CHP

Projects (2014-2016 data)

Midwest CHP Projects by

State (2013 – 2016)

8

CHP Generation Capacity (MW)

Year IL IN IA KS MI MN MO NE ND OH SD WI Total

2013 1.1 1.2 2.6 - 101.1 0.3 16.0 - - 0.2 - 66.3 188.8

2014* 0.3 - - - 0.1 0.1 - - 99.0 0.1 - 1.4 102.1

2015-2016* 6.3 80.0 - - 49.2 25.0 - - - 25.7 - - 186.2

Total 7.7 81.2 2.6 - 150.4 25.4 16.0 - 99.0 27.1 - 67.7 477.1

Number of CHP Systems (#)

Year IL IN IA KS MI MN MO NE ND OH SD WI Total

2013 2 1 2 - 3 1 1 - - 2 - 7 19

2014* 1 - - - 1 1 - - 1 2 - 1 7

2015-2016* 1 1 1 - 4 1 - - - 4 - - 12

Total 4 2 3 - 8 3 1 - 1 6 - 8 38

* Publically announced CHP projects. only. Sizes

of some projects are not known and therefore

not accounted for. Others are under develop-

ment that haven’t been announced and/or

were not identified at time of presentation.

CHP Generation Capacity (MW)

Year IL IN IA KS MI MN MO NE ND OH SD WI Total

2013 1.1 1.2 2.6 - 101.1 0.3 16.0 - - 0.2 - 66.3 188.8

2014* 0.3 - - - 0.1 0.1 - - 99.0 0.1 - 1.4 102.1

2015-2016* 6.3 80.0 - - 49.2 25.0 - - - 25.7 - - 186.2

Total 7.7 81.2 2.6 - 150.4 25.4 16.0 - 99.0 27.1 - 67.7 477.1

Page 9: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

2013 CHP Projects

o Diamond K Dairy / Ponderosa Dairy

o Milwaukee Metro Sewerage Dist (3)

o University Of Missouri

o Michigan State University

o Gundersen Lutheran Health System

o University of Wisconsin Oshkosh

o Northern Michigan University

o 2G Cenergy

o GEM Energy

o Domtar Paper Company (WE

Energies)

o Lansing Board of Water and Light

o GEM Energy

o Danville WWTF

o City of Rock Island

o Forest Country Potowatomi

Community

o Cedar Rapids / Linn County Solid

Waste Agency

o Sievers Renewable Energy

List of CHP Projects by

Organization (2013 – 2016)

9

2014 CHP Projects

o Great River Energy

o Jay Industries

o Medina High School

o Washtenaw Community

College

o Downers Grove Sanitary

District

o 2G CENERGY,

Gundersen Lutheran

Health Group Company

o Schmidt Artist Lofts

Under Development

o Coldwater Board of Public

Utilities (CBPU)

o Agonne National Laboratory

(Amerseco)

o Marquette Green Energy

LLC

o SABIC

o Golden Renewable Energy

o Ohio's Center for Resource

Recovery and Recycling

o University of Minnesota

o IGS Generation – Dublin

Rec Center

o Sustainable Partners LLC

o Kraton Polymers U.S.

o Solvay Specialy Polymers

o Cliffs Natural Resources

Page 10: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

Emerging CHP Drivers Being Realized

o Benefits of CHP recognized by policymakerso 2012 Executive Order to accelerate investments in industrial EE and CHP set

national goal of 40 GW of new CHP installations by 2020

o Midwest SEOs exploring CHP opportunities (e.g. DOE SEP Competitive Grants)

o Policy Makers being educated on impacts of State Portfolio Standards (RPS,EEPS,APS), tax incentives, grants, standby rates, net metering, etc.

o Favorable outlook for natural gas supply and price in North America

o Utilities exploring and engaging in CHP opportunitieso Utilities owning and partnering on CHP projects

o CHP being explored and implemented in utility energy efficiency programs

o Opportunities created by environmental drivers

o Energy resiliency and critical infrastructure

o Other (Energy Star, net zero facilities, site vs. source, etc.)

10

Page 11: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

11

SABIC Innovative

PlasticsMt. Vernon, IN

Status: Under Development

Capacity: 80,000 kW

Fuel: Natural Gas

Prime Mover:

Expected Completion: 2016

The CHP facility is expected to reduce annual emissions by an

amount equivalent to 110,000 automobiles. Site impacted by

Boiler MACT emissions standards.

Source: http://www.industrysourcing.com/articles/286116.aspx

CHP System Highlights:

Page 12: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

12

City of Coldwater and

Mastronardi ProduceColdwater, MI

Status: Under Development

Capacity: 13,000 kW

Fuel: Natural Gas

Prime Mover: Recip. Engines

Expected Completion: 2015

New CHP engines will meet the

City’s energy demand and

provide Mastronardi with heat

and CO2, enabling the addition

of 28.8 acres of greenhouses.

Source: http://www.inlandpowergroup.com/media_pdfs/doc_20140919114838.pdf

CHP System Highlights:

Page 13: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

CHP System Highlights: Increased ENERGY STAR

Building Score

ProMedica Health

System - WildwoodToledo, OH

Capacity: 130 kW

Fuel: Natural Gas

Prime Mover: Microturbines

Installed: 2013

Benefits include

a reduction in annual

energy costs and

greenhouse gas

emissions as well as a

higher ENERGY STAR

building score

Source: http://www.gemenergy.com/wp-

content/uploads/2014/03/optimize-chp-

flexset-ProMedicaWildwood-030414.pdf13

Page 14: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

14

Gundersen Health

System La Crosse, WI

Capacity: 500 kW

Fuel: Biomass

Prime Mover: Boiler / Steam Turbine

Installed: 2013

Gundersen Health System reached

100% Energy Independence in Fall

2014 (implemented 4 CHP projects).

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"At Gundersen, our goal is to reduce

the cost of care and improve the health

of the community through our Envision

program. We believe this project will

help us do both.”

“When we looked at all of our options,

installing a biomass boiler was the

right choice. Not only will the biomass

boiler save the organization an

estimated $500,000 a year, it will help

us reduce carbon dioxide and coal

emissions in the community,"

- Jeff Rich, Executive Director, GL

Envision, LLC, a subsidiary of

Gundersen Health System

Source: http://www.gundersenhealth.org/news/gundersen-powers-up-biomass-boiler

CHP System Highlights:

Page 15: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

Midwest “Industrial” CHP

Technical Potential (MW)

15

0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000

Other Industrial

Machinery/Computer Equip

Fabricated Metals

Stone/Clay/Glass

Textiles

Lumber and Wood

Rubber/Misc Plastics

Primary Metals

Petroleum Refining

Trasportation Equip.

Paper

Food

Chemicals

CHP Technical Potential (MW)

Source: ICF Internal Estimates

Page 16: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

Midwest “Commercial” CHP

Technical Potential (MW)

16

Source: ICF Internal Estimates

0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000

Other Comm/Inst

Data Centers

Military

Schools

Nursing Homes

Food Stores

Prisons

Restaurants

Retail

Hotels

Multifamily Buildings

Government Buildings

Hospitals

College/Univ.

Commercial Buildings

CHP Technical Potential (MW)

Page 17: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

o Midwest CHP Market experiencing an increase in Project

Development Activity due to a mix of emerging and

realized drivers

o DOE Midwest CHP TAP will collaborate with SEO’s to

drive technical assistance through:

– Identification of potential key CHP projects (including microgrids)

– Build awareness through education of prospective CHP

end-users in high potential target market sectors in each

state

o Additional Highlighted CHP Projects in Appendix

Concluding Remarks

17

Page 18: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

QuestionsCliff Haefke

DOE Midwest CHP TAP Co-Director(312) 355-3476

[email protected]

A program sponsored by A program at

www.MidwestCHPTAP.org

18

Page 19: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

Example CHP System Highlights

Appendix

19

Page 20: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

20

CHP System Highlights:

Mill Street Wastewater

Treatment PlantRock Island, IL

Capacity: 1,000 kW

Fuel: Biomass

Prime Mover: Recip. Engines

Installed: 2013

The newly installed engines will provide heat and

electricity for the plant, as well as 4 to 8 percent of the

power for city facilities

Source: http://www.epa.gov/chp/partnership/partners/cityofrockislandil.html

Page 21: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

21

Downers Grove

Sanitary DistrictDowners Grove, IL

Capacity: 280 kW

Fuel: Biomass

Prime Mover: Recip. Engines

Installed: 2014

Restaurant waste grease is used to produce the digester

gas which fuels the 280 kW engine. This offsets 50% of the

treatment plants energy consumption.

Source: http://www.baxterwoodman.com/projects/combined-heat-power-improvements/

CHP System Highlights:

Page 22: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

22

Argonne National

LaboratoriesArgonne, IL

Status: Under Development

Capacity: 6,300 kW

Fuel: Natural Gas

Prime Mover: Combustion Turbine

Expected Completion: 2016-2017

The proposed system

will use existing

infrastructure, such as

boiler feed pumps and

the steam distribution

system.

Source: http://www.districtenergy.org/assets/pdfs/2013CampConference/Wednesday/Track-B/3B.1LIEGOISBILLSTANLEYANL-for-IDEA-Rev-A.pd f

Interior Rendering

Argonne National Laboratories Campus

CHP System Highlights:

Page 23: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

23

Cedar Rapids Site 2 LandfillCedar Rapids, IA

Capacity: 1,600 kW

Fuel: Biomass

Prime Mover: Recip. Engines

Installed: 2013

Instead of being flared

off, landfill methane is

captured and fuels the

1600 kW engine, saving

the county’s Solid Waste

Agency $90,000/yr while

feeding the rural electrical

grid.

Energy production from

methane is a bonus for a

methane collection

system designed firstly to

manage the landfill’s

methane gas and to cut

down on its odor.

Source: https://www.solidwasteagency.org/#/news/2012/08/22/cedar-rapid-gazette-article-about-agency-landfill-gas-to-energy-project

CHP System Highlights:

Page 24: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

24

Sievers Family

FarmStockton, IA

Capacity: 1,000 kW

Fuel: Biomass

Prime Mover: Recip. Engines

Installed: 2013

Electricity is sold to

Alliant Energy, and waste

heat is used for heating

the anaerobic digesters

(L to R) Bryan Sievers, Paul Owen (CAT Financial), Jon Sievers, David Harris (Altorfer)

Source: http://www.americanbiogascouncil.org/projectProfiles/stocktonIA.pdf

CHP System Highlights:

Page 25: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

25

Golden Grain EthanolMason City, IA

Status: Under Development

Capacity: 8,000 kW

Fuel: Natural Gas

Prime Mover: Recip. Engine

Expected Completion: 2015

The ultra-high efficiency

(48.7%) engine

implemented by Golden

Renewable Energy boosts

overall efficiency to 90%!

The ethanol plant’s

demand for reliable

steam and power over

24/7 operating hours

made it an excellent

candidate for CHP

Source: http://www.iowaeconomicdevelopment.com/userdocs/documents/ieda/GoldenRenewEnergy6-28-13.pdf

Golden Grain Ethanol’s Facilities

CHP System Highlights:

Page 26: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

Source: www.lansingstatejournal.com/article/20130630/BUSINESS/306300016/BWL-s-REO-Town-plant-fuels-next-generation-

power?nclick_check=1

http://www.lbwl.com/About-the-BWL/News/Lansing-BWL-Cogeneration-Plant-%E2%80%9CGoes-Commercial%E2%80%9D/

26

Lansing Board of Water

& Light (REO Town

Cogeneration Plant)Lansing, MI

Capacity: 100 MW

Fuel: Natural Gas

Prime Mover: Boiler / Steam Turbine

Installed: 2013

“BWL’s REO Town cogeneration plant is among the most clean and efficient in

Michigan and the U.S. This state-of-the-art cogeneration plant scores a major

victory for the environment. And, we’re proud that the project has been called a

“game changer” for economic development in the Lansing region.”

- J. Peter Lark, BWL General Manager

CHP System Highlights:

Page 27: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

27

Washtenaw

Community CollegeAnn Arbor, MI

Capacity: 130 kW

Fuel: Natural Gas

Prime Mover: Recip. Engines

Installed: 2014

Benefits include

a reduction of $60,000 in annual energy

costs and reduced greenhouse gas

emissions by an amount equivalent to

146 automobiles.

Source: http://www.gemenergy.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/CHP-Washtenaw-102814.pdf

CHP System Highlights:

Page 28: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

28

Marquette Green

Energy PlantGwinn, MI

Status: Under Development

Capacity: 34,000 kW

Fuel: Biomass

Prime Mover: Steam Turbine

Const. Begins: 2015Fmr. K.I. Sawyer Air Force Base will be home to the new CHP plant

The CHP plant will be built on 21 acres at the former K.I. Sawyer

Air Force Base, a decommissioned base and unicorporated

community in Michigan’s upper peninsula. Of the 34 MW

capacity, 26 MW will be deliverable to the grid.

Source: http://www.midwestenergynews.com/2014/11/10/new-generation-project-plans-surface-in-upper-peninsula/

CHP System Highlights:

Page 29: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

29

University of MinnesotaMinneapolis, MN

Status: Under Development

Capacity: 25,000 kW

Fuel: Natural Gas

Prime Mover: Combustion Turbine

Expected Completion: 2016

Decreases the Twin

Cities Campus carbon

footprint by 15%

8 Year Return on

Investment

Source: http://www1.umn.edu/regents//docket/2012/february/heatandpower.pdf

Rendering of Turbine and Heat Recovery Steam Generator

Minimal changes will need to be made to the existing building’s exterior

CHP System Highlights:

Page 30: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

30

Great River Energy

Spiritwood StationJamestown, ND

Capacity: 99,000 kW

Fuel: Natural Gas

Prime Mover: Steam Turbines

Installed: 2014

The CHP plant supplies steam to

the Cargill Malt plant and the

Dakota Spirit AgEnergy biorefinery.

Source: http://www.greatriverenergy.com/makingelectricity/newprojects/spiritwood_fact_sheet.pdf

In addition to utilizing beneficiated

lignite, Spiritwood Station will use

state-of-the-art control technologies

to control emissions.

CHP System Highlights:

Page 31: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

31

Jay IndustriesMansfield, OH

Status: Under Development

Capacity: 1,100 kW

Fuel: Natural Gas

Prime Mover: Recip. Engine

Expected Completion: 2014/2015

First CHP project in Ohio to be submitted to the Public Utility

Commission of Ohio (PUCO) under Energy Efficiency Resource

Under Ohio Law.

CHP System Highlights:

Source: http://www.puco.ohio.gov

Page 32: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

32

Medina High

SchoolMedina, OH

Capacity: 125 kW

Fuel: Natural Gas

Prime Mover: Recip. Engines

Installed: 2014

Source: http://www.cleveland.com/medina/index.ssf/2014/02/medina_city_school_district_tu.html

The new unit powers the school

and heats the Medina Community

Recreation Center’s two pools

and spa, all while saving the

school district $82,000 annually

CHP System Highlights:

Page 33: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

33

Dublin Community

Recreation CenterDublin, OH

Status: Under Development

Capacity: 248 kW

Fuel: Natural Gas

Prime Mover: Recip. Engine

Complete by: 2014/2015

“This CHP solution is expected to save us $20,000 in energy costs

over the next 5 years. It negates the need for our boiler replacement,

which will save us approximately $70,000. The CHP system also

provides backup power during a power outage, which will be a benefit

to us and our guests.”

-Michelle Crandall, Dublin’s Assistant City Manager

CHP System Highlights:

Source:

http://www.thisweeknews.com/content/stori

es/dublin/news/2014/07/01/city-signs-pact-

for-new-heat-and-power-at-rec-center.html

Page 34: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

34

Ohio Center for

Resource Recovery

and Recycling (COR3)Grove City, OH

Status: Under Development

Capacity: 9,400 kW

Fuel: Biomass

Prime Mover: Recip. Engine

Expected Completion: 2015

Concept illustration of the COR3

“We will be turning trash management from a cost center to a true

profit center by extracting the value that is intrinsically contained

within that trash stream. This allows us to get closer to our vision

of a viable alternative to landfilling.”

-Ronald J. Mills, Exec. Director, Solid Waste Agency of Central OhioSource: http://www.districtenergy.org/blog/2014/04/04/large-biogas-waste-to-energy-chp-plant-planned-in-oh/

CHP System Highlights:

Page 35: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

35

Kraton Polymers U.SBelpre, OH

Status: Under Development

Capacity: 8,165 kW

Fuel: Natural Gas

Prime Mover: Steam Turbine

Expected Completion: 2015

In addition to its improved efficiency, the CHP

system will reduce Hazardous Air Pollutant

(HAP) emissions by 96.5%, and eliminate ~8000

tons of waste ash per year.

CHP System Highlights:

Kraton Plant in Belpre, OH

Source: http://www.kratonyourfuture.com/

http://dis.puc.state.oh.us/CaseRecord.aspx?CaseNo=14-2304-EL-EEC&x=0&y=0

Page 36: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

36

Solvay Specialty

PolymersMarietta, OH

Status: Under Development

Capacity: 7,900 kW

Fuel: Natural Gas

Prime Mover: Combustion Turbine

Expected Completion: 2015

The new CHP installation will replace 100% of

current steam usage, and 97% of current

electrical usage of the plant.

Source: http://www.solvay.us/en/media/press_releases/20140820-Marietta-Expansion.html

http://dis.puc.state.oh.us/CaseRecord.aspx?CaseNo=14-2296-EL-EEC

CHP System Highlights:

Solvay Plant in Marietta OH

Page 37: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

37

CHP System Highlights:

Forest Country Potowatami

Community Renewable

GenerationMilwaukee, WI

Capacity: 2,000 kW

Fuel: Biomass

Prime Mover: Recip. Engines

Installed: 2013

Feedstock for the two 1.3

million-gallon digester

tanks is sourced from

local food producers.

Source: http://www.biomassmagazine.com/articles/9614/wisconsin-biogas-chp-plant-fires-up

Power is sold to WE

Energies, and heat

generated is used by the

adjacent casino.

Page 38: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

38

Gundersen Health System

Community DigesterMiddleton, WI

Capacity:

Fuel: Biomass

Prime Mover: Recip. Engines

Installed: 2014

A partnership between

Gundersen Health, Dane

County, and three family

farms allows for the Health

System to offset 14% of its

energy use, while

preventing 3700 lbs of

phosphorous runoff into

waterways annually.

Source: http://www.gundersenenvision.org/renewable-energy/turning-cow-waste-into-energy

CHP System Highlights:

Page 39: Combined Heat and Power and theenergyoutlook.naseo.org/Data/Sites/6/media/presentations/Haefke.pdf · Total 136.0 341.2 477.1 Number of CHP Systems Year Biomass Natural Gas Total

39

WE Energies (Domtar

Paper Mill)Rothschild, WI

Capacity: 50 MW

Fuel: Biomass

Prime Mover: Boiler / Steam Turbine

Installed: 2013

“The addition of the biomass plant

enables us to produce renewable

energy on demand. That benefit is

simply not available with solar or

wind generation.”

Gale Klappa, the chairman,

president and CEO of Milwaukee-

based We Energies.

Source: http://www.jsonline.com/business/power-plant-to-run-on-wisconsin-biomass-b9985790z1-221960911.htm l

http://www.bizjournals.com/milwaukee/news/2013/11/12/we-energies-launches-biomass-plant.htm l

http://www.risiinfo.com/techchannels/powerenergy/Domtar-partners-for-250M-biomass-power-plant-at-Rothschild-WI-paper-

mill.html

Expected to create approx. 400

construction jobs and 150 permanent

jobs in the surrounding community,

including independent wood

suppliers and haulers from northern

and central Wisconsin who would

secure waste wood for the project.

CHP System Highlights: