Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
BRIEF COMMUNICATION
Colitis caused by Escherichia coli 0157:H7:
A study of six cases
LB E1nus. MD, FRCPC , M G UIN[)! , MD, J DROUIN, MD, FRC PC, S GREGOIRE, MD, FRC PC, JR BARR, M B, C HB
ABSTRACT: The clinical and pathologic features of six pa tients with proven vcrotoxin-producing Escherichia coli colitis are described . C lin ical data, 25 biopsy ~recunens and two autopsies from these patien ts are reviewed. A ll presented with crnmpy abdomina l pain and bloody d iarrhea. Colonoscopic find ings included eJema, erythema, pseudomembranes and hemorrhage. O n hiopsy, two patients had ischemic colitis, one had pseudomembranous colitis and th ree had a com-1'ination of concurrent ischemic and pseudomem branous colitis. Four cases showed fibrin-platelet thrombi in mucosa! capillaries and submucosal a rte rio les. The classical patte rn of infect ious colit is was no t seen in these cases. Other niimpecific changes inc lud ed patchy mucosa! e<lema, congest ion, focally rrominent interstitial hemorrhage and mild, patch y increase of the lymphoplasmocytic component of the lamina. Ischemic necrosis was present in 10 of 25 biopsies (40% ), pseudomembranes in seven of 25 biopsies (28%), and four of25 riopsies (1 6%) showed both. Colon from one aut0psy revealed edema, pseudo membranes and intramura l infarc tio n . Concurrent thro mbotic thro mbocytopenic purpura was clinically documented in three of six patients. It is concluded that, in the context of hemorrhagic colitis, the following observations are indicative of E coli Ol 57:H7: the combination of pseudomcmbranous and 1schemic colitis; ischemic colitis in a yo ung pat ient; or pseudo membranous colit is with Closcridium difficile-negative culture and toxin. Multiple biopsies are reyuired to demonstrate the full-blown features. E coli 0 157:H 7 colit is should he aJJed to the differen tial diagnosis of submucosal edema. Can J Gastroenterol 1990;4(4): 141-146 (pour resume, voir page 142)
Key Words: E col i O 157: H 7, lschemic colitis, Pseudomembranous colitis, Verocoxin
University of Ouawa, Oc/)(lrtmenL~ of Pachology and Internal Medicine, Occawa General Hosp1cal; and Department of Paiholoi.,ry . Oua~,a Civic Hos/Jiwl , Ottawa, Ontario
Correspondence and reprmrs: Dr Leslie B Eidus , De/Jartmen1 of Pathology. Onawa General Hospiwl, 501 Smyth Road , Onawa , Ontario KI l-1 8L6
ThL1 paper was presented m pare ar the Canadian Con,1rress of Laboracory Mt!d1cine, Ottawa, Omario, June 1989
Received for publicatwn Ocwber 5, 1989. Accc/ncd December I 2. 1989
CAN J GASmOENTER()L VOL 4 No 4 M AY/JUNE 1990
v:EROTOX!N-PRODl.X::TNG ESC/ !ERIC/ /IA coli O 157:117 i~ an important cau~e
of hemorrhagic colitis which is he ing diagnosc<l with increasing frequency ( l ). The w mpl1cat ions a rc potent ially life th rea tenin g: hemo lyri v ure mtc syndrom e is we ll documented , and , more recently, th rombotic thrombocywpenic purpura has been observed (2-4 ).
The i<lenrifi cation of diagno~t ic pa t h n lo g1ca l les io ns t hat suggest verotoxin-produc ing E coli in fec tion is important hecause clin ical markers of the disease may be negarive or inapparent. For instance, in the adu lt age group, hacteria arc shed in the ~tool only for a few Jays to a week after onset o f sy mp toms (4,5) . T h e assay fo r veroto xm is positive for only a few addit ional days, and i~ not available in man y te rtiary care hospitals. Thus, de lay by the pat ient in seeking me<l ical attention, or by cl inicians in ohta ining stool for culture, reduces the likelihood of isolating the organism. Thrombotic t hrombocytopen ic purpura may dominate the clinical p icture to the extent tha t co lit is is overlooked a ltogether (4).
The authors previously reported two
141
E1nus et al
Colite causee par Escherichia coli 0157:H?: Etude de six cas
RESUME: L'etude Jccrit les manifestations clini4ues et pathologiques Je six patients atteints Jc colite a Escherichia coli pro<luisant <les vermoxincs. Les donnees cliniqucs, 2 5 prelevcmcnts biopsiques ct dcux autopsies sont passes en revue.Tousles sujets prescntaient Jes doulcurs abdominalcs a type de crampcs et Jes <liarrhces sanglantcs. La colonoscopie a rcvele de l'oedemc, <le l'erytbcmc, des pseudomcmbrancs ct des hemorragics intcstinales. D'apres les biopsies, Jeux patients souffraient de colitc ischcmique; un, de colitc pseuJomembrnneusc; ct trois, d'unc combinaison de colite ischemique et pscu<lomembraneuse. Quatre cas montraient des thrombi fibrinoplaquertaires Jans lcs capil laircs de la muqueusc ct les arterioles de la sousmuqueusc. Aucun des cas nc prescntait la morphologie classiquc de la colitc infectieuse. Parmi les aurrcs changements non specifiques figurcnt l'oedcme disscminc de la muqucuse, la congestion, l'hemorragic interstitielle en foyers, er l'infilrration moderce et en aires de la lamina par Jes plasmocytes et des lymphocytes. Une necrose ischemiquc ctait prescntc Jans d1x des 25 biopsies ( 40%); Jes pseudomembrancs, Jans sept cas sur 25 (28%); ct les dcux phcnomencs ecaient manifesres dans quatre des 2 5 hiopsies (16%). Le colon d'un sujet autopsie a rcvele LIO oe<lemc, Jes pseu<lomembrnncs et unc infection intramurale. Un purpura thromhocytopcnique thrombotique a ete cliniquement confirme chez trois patients sur six. On conclut quc, dans le contexte de la colite hemorragique, les observations suivantcs in<liquent la presence d'E coli Ol 57:H7: une colite pseudomcmbraneuse ct ischemiquc combinec; unc colitc ischemiquc chcz un jcunc patient; ou une colite pseudomembrancuse accompagnee d'unc culture negative de Clostridium difficile ct de toxine. De multiples biopsies sont necessaires pour reveler toutes lcs caracteristiques <le cette affection. E coli 0157:H? Jcvrnit figurer au diagnostic d1ffcrcntiel de l'oedeme de la sousmuqueuse.
cases of E coli 0 157: H7 colitis compli cated by thrombotic thrombncytopenic rurpura anJ briefly described the unusual finding of simultnneous ischcmic and pscu<lomcmhranous colit is (3). In the present rcpon, several pathological alteratiom arc described, which, in comhination, strongly suggeM the diagnosis of verotoxin-producing E coli.
PATIENTS AND METHODS Sixteen patients wnh positi ve Moo!
cultures for E coli 0157: 11 7 were identified from the records of the microbiology labora tories of two teaching hospitals over a r eriod of one-and-ahalf years. Six of these patients had a total of 25 colonic biopsies. T wn of the s ix patients died and the autopsy material was reviewed. The biopsies were seria lly sect ioned and stamed with hematoxylin and cosin. C linica l features, abdominal x-rnys, and endoscopic findings of these six patients were reviewed.
RESULTS Clinical features: All six patients presented with a one to five day history of
crampy abdominal pain, blnody diarrhea, nau~ea ,md vomiting. There was no history of travel outside of Canada. Two patients received a few doses of c rythromycin. Four of the ca~cs were sporadic. In the o ther two cases, a milder, self- limited form of diarrhea developed in other family members and soc ial contacts. Three patients developed thrombotic thmmbocycopcnic purpura (as defined by the presence of thmmbocyropenia, microangiopathic hemolytic anemia, fever, normal proth rombin and partial rhromboplastin times, normc1I fibrinogen levels, and declining neurological and rena l functions). Dilated, edematous small and large howel ( with occasional thumbprinting) were seen on standard a bdominal x- rays (Figure I) . C olonoscopy showed erythema , edema and hemorrhage in all six patients and pseudomembranes in two (Figure 2). There was pancolitis in on e patient with predominance on the right side. O nly the left colon was visua lized in the remaining five paticms. However, bleeding above rhc level of the colonoscope was repo rted int woof these fi ve patients.
Pathological findings: The hi ,ropatholngical find ings arc shown in Figure 3. Pscu<lomcmbranous coli tis wa, diagnosed whe n the type 2 lesion desc ribed by Price and Davies (6) wa, identified (Figure 3h) . This as well ,h
the other histological types I and~ were nmed in fourpmients. Mucosa! biopsic, in five patients revealed isc hem1c colitis defined ns va riable depth of coagulative necrosis, with or without type 3 pscudnmembranes (Figure k). In three pallcnts pseudomemhranou, colitis was seen concurrently with ischemic coliti s. Pse u<lo mem bran nu, w litb and ischemic co lit is were present in seven of 25 (28%) and 10 of 25 (40%) biopsies, respective ly. The two processes occurred cont igunusly m four of 25 ( 16%) b1ops1es.
Platelet-fibrin rhromhi were visual· ized in the hinpsie., of four patient-. Patchy, sometimes prominent, mrcr stitial hcmorrhagt' and edema of rhe lamina was prcscm in a ll parienrs.
Ncut rophiliL infi lt ration of gland and lamina was not a feature of the biopsies, and only the rare microfocu, could be identified. The lymphopla,mocytic component of the lamina was only foca lly and mildly increased . Submucosa was included in two bior sies from the same patient and was markedly edematous.
Two patient~ died; both were elderly and both cases were complicated hy thrombotic rhromhocytopenic purpura. At autopsy, the colon of one patient showed o nly ede ma and petechial hemorrhages. The second patient died fo llowing central ne rvous system compl icatiom of thrombo ti c thrombocytopenic purpura. In this case, the colon sh owed extensive ischcmic necrosis with focal pseu<lomcmhrane formation (Figure 4 ).
DISCUSSION The sa I ient pathologic changes seen
in these six cases of E coli Ol 57:H7 infection were ischcmic col it is and all three morphological types of pseudo· membra nou s co liti s. Half of the patients h ad the unusual finding of simultaneous pseudomembranous and ischemic colitis. None of the biopsies showed the feature~ of infec tious colitis.
142 CAN J GAt,TRt)ENTEROL Vm 4 No 4 MAY/JUNE 1990
Figure 1) Abdominal x-ray showing tlnnnb/)nnting ( aiww) in the asceruling colon
fil(llre 2) Colonic endoscopy showing submucosal edema (Za) and /)seudumembranes, erythema an;/ hemorrhage ( 2 b)
Since ischemic colitis was iJcnrificd in only 10 of 2 5 biopsies anJ pseudomembranous colitis in only seven of 25, 1r is evident that muluple samples arc necessary for demonstralion of lhe lesions and for aJequale evalumion of rhe colonic mucosa.
Concurrenl bowel infarction and pscudomembranc formatinn have been Jescnbed in a subset of ischemic bowel disease under Jiagnostic terms such as nonocclusive inteslinal ischemia and
pscudomcmhranous entcmcolilis. They occur a~ complications of various conditions such a~ shock, postoperative states and heart failure (6-9). ln contrast with E coli 0157:1-17 colilis, small bowel involvement is common and the prognosb is poor. On ncca~ion, pseuJomembrane~ can abo be seen associated wnh ischemic colitis in mesenteric artery occlusion. Usually only type 3 pscudomembranes, and not the full spectrum of types l to 3, are present in
CAN J GASTROENTl:RL)L Vm 4 No 4 MAY/JUNE 1990
E co/i0157:H7 colitis
occlusive ischemic colitis (8). In conw1st, mucosa! hemorrhagic necrosis of the type seen in ischcmic bowel disease, as well as intramural and transmural infarction, arc not a feature of antibiotic-associated pseudomem hranous colitis. Thus, in the context of hemorrhagic coli tis, the simultaneous occurrence of pscudnmembranous colitis and ischcmic colitis seems to be a distinctive finding of E coli Ol 57:H7 coli tb.
The clin ical prcsentntton m many previously reported cases of E coli 01 57:H7, as well as in the present stu<ly, suggested ischcmic rather than infectious colitis (1,3,4). Three of the present six patiems were under 50 years of age, anti mucosa! ischemia was a component of the hisropmholngy in five cases. lschcmic colitis is unusual in young patients. Thus, its presence in young patients would also suggest a diagnosis of£ coli 0157:l 17. Conversely, the possibility of an infectious etiology may be overlooked in the e lderly patient presenting clinically with ischemic colitis.
A hiopsy showing pseuJomembranous or pscudomembranous and 1schemic colitis may he the only clue ro E coli Ol 57:117 colitis. The tliagnosis of E coli Ol57:Il7 is suggested in any patient with biopsies showing pseudomem branous colitis but nega1 ive Clostridium difficile cultures or toxin.
Other pathological findings seen raJiologicall y and/or cntloscopically may also be helpful in pointing to the diagnosis of E coli Ol 57:I 17 . The differential diagnosis ofsuhmucosal edema of the colon b essentially limited to inflammatory bowel disease (particularly Cmhn 's disease), ischemic colitis, and pseudomembranous colitis. Since the basic pathology of E coli Ol57:H7 coli tis was that of ischemic, pscudomembranous, or pseudomemhranous and ischemic colitis, it is not ~urprising t hat subrnucosal edema was also present. Other colonic lesions associ<1ted with 1~chem1c colitis were also found in the prescm study: focal interstitial hemmrhage (six cases) anJ small vessel fibrin-platelet thrombi (four cases). The rare section showed capillary thrombi in otherwise normal mucosa.
14}
EJL)US et al
3a
3e
3d
Figure 3) Colonic bio/Jsies . 3a Segment of colonic mucosa where pseudomembranous colitis ( long arrow) is continuous wi1h ischemic co/iris ( short arrow). 3b On higher magnification, the pseuclomembranous component is formed of rhe typical 'fire cracker' lesions and streaming exudate . 3c There is full thickness infarction of the mucosa in 1he ischemic />orrion of the biopsy with thrombi in submucosal vessels and mucosa! capillaries (arrows). 3d Several biopsies show a lesser degree of 1schemia identified only by aitenuation of the superficial portion of a few glands (arrows). 3e Microf oci of superficial hemorrhages are common and result from rupture of large, di/aced mucosa/ capillaries ( short arrows ouiline capillary, long arrow the dismpiion)
T he colonic patho logy obse rved here has been reported to a limited extent in the literature. One case reported by Morrison et al (2) was associated with pseudomembranes identified his-
144
rologically but not recognized on endoscopy. Richardson et al ( LO) described three cases of E coli 0157:H7 colitis complicated by he mo lytic-urem ic syndrome in the pediatric age group.
Pse udome mbran e fo rm atio n was present in one case, (again seen only on mic roscopic examination) and ischemic necrosis (personal communic;i. tion) in two cases (10) . None of these
CAN J GASTROENTEROL VOL 4 NO 4 MAY/JUNE 1990
E co/i 01 57:H7 colitis
,. . . 4c
. . .. .. .. •
,, .. ~ '"
• . . ~ ..
.. w ..
" . ~ -... .• .. ' · • .
4b
\
Figure 4) Co/on removed at autopsy . 4a Variegated pmrem of mucosa/ infarction ( anow heads), ,dcerarwn (.1/inrtanow) and adherent exuaate fonning [!se11domembranes (long mww) . 4b .Secr,on wken m lite let•el uf rhe {)m1Jomemhrane. Then.' is <'xrcn.1i1•e rran.miural h1?1T1onltage (long anow) and m1ram11ral infarction extending inro rhc nmsculans /)m/Jria (shorr amiw) . 4c lschemu: necrosis (am>w) and hemcmhage of muscularis Jiro/Jria
TABLE 1 Algorithm for diagnosis of Escherichia co/i0157:H7 infection
Diagnosis of E co/i0157:H7 is suggested by biopsies showing· lschemic colitis in a young patient Simultaneous ischemic and pseudomembronous colitis Pseudomembronous colitis with negative Clostridium difficile culture/toxin Pseudomembronous colitis in elderly with c linical picture of ischemlc colitis
Diagnosis of E co/i0157:H7 should be included in the differential diagnosis if: Minimal findings on biopsy with rodiolog,colly or endoscopicolly proven submucosol
edema or hemorrhage Biopsy-proven ischemlc colitis in on elderly patient
report e<l cases s h owed pseu<lomembranous and 1schemic colitis. In all other reported cases, the pathological alterations in mucosa! biopsies showed a spectrum, including: no altcratinns; nonspecific changes including interstitial hemorrhage, mi ld increase of the lymphoplasmocytic component of the lamina propria and edema; neurrophilic infiltrates of the lamina propria and
g la nd~ in the fashion of infectious col itis; and apL)pto:,is o f su rface epithelium ( 1,4,5, 11 ). It is surpnsing that on ly four of a ll of the reported cases showed ischemic colitis or pseudo, membranous colitis, and that pseudomembranou:, and ischem ic colitis was not seen in any report of E coli O I 57:H7 infection; othcrassociated features such as submucnsal edema a nd hemorrhage
CAN] GASTROENTERl)L VL)L 4 NO 4 MA Y/JLJNE 1990
were prominent findings in most cases. Possible explanat ions for ch is discrepancy include mucosa I sampling limited to the distal colon (wirh the mo re seve re prox imal d isease nor visualized endoscopically) and a patient population with a milder form of colitis than observed in the present study. In deed, th ree of the six cases were compli cated by thrombotic thrombocywpen ic purpura and two of the six patients died, a far higher percentage of complications than in ocher se ries.
The relationship betwee n pseudome m bra n o us col ir is and isch e mic colitis has heen extensively debated. So m e authors co n si d e r pseu<lome mbrano u~ col itis as pan of the spectrum of isch emic colitis, whereas o th ers regard pseudomembranous colitis and ischemic colitis as dist inct a nd sepa rate e ntiti es. T he findings
145
Eml sec al
JescribcJ in the present six cases suggest that pseuJomemhranous col it is and 1schemic colitis arc inJeed on a cnntinuum of the :mme disease. The mechan1,m hy whicL the pseudomembrane forms has been suggested by Norris in h is review of the spectrum of ischemic bowel disease ( 12). Whereas total cessation of hloodflow to bowel results in coagulative necrosis, a n acute inflammatory in filtrate Jcvclops in bowel mucosa when colonic bloodtlow
REFERENCES I. Riley LW. The ep1dcm1nlogic, c.linilal,
and microb1olog1cal features llf hcmorrhagll col itis. Annu Re\' M1Crnh1ol 1987;4 I: 383-407.
2. Morrison D, Tyrrell D, Jewell L Colonic h1opsy m vcmll)xin-mJuceJ hemorrhagic clllitis and thromhmic rhromht1Cytopen1c purpura (TIP). AmJ Clm Pathol 1986;86:108-12.
3. Kovacs M, Roddy J, Gregoire S, ct .ii. Thrombmic thromhocytopcm~ purpurn fo llowing col itis J ue co E rnli 0157:11 7. Am J Med l 990;88: 177-9.
4. Ryan CA, Tm,xc RV, Ho,ck GW, ct al. facheric/1iu col, 0157:11 7 dh1rrhca in a nursmg home: C linical, cp1demiolog1cal, anJ p,1thological fmJ ings. J lnfocr Dis 1986; 154:6 31-8.
5. P.ii Cl I, Gordon R, Suns I IV. ct al. SporaJu.: cases of hcmorrhag1l col it is
146
ceases and is then re-established. N orris suggests that thb process evnlves m pseuJomem bra ne format ion.
The nuthurs have demonstrated in
these cases of E coli Ol 57:H7 colitis, disruption a nd /or thrombosis of mucosal cap1llan es and, to a lesser extent, thrombosb of small submucosal arterioles. Lysb of these thrombi or collatera l blood supply from the rich mucosa! plexus to the ,,chemic mucosa may result in reflnw uf blood, acute in-
""nuated wnh r\chenchw coli 0157:H7. Ann Intern Med l 984; LOI :738-42.
6. Price AB, [}.1\•1e, DR. Pst'11domcmbrnnou, colitis. J C'lm P,1thol [977;30:1-12.
7. Goul,ron SJM, McGovem VJ. Pscudomemhranoll', rnliu,. G ut 1965;6:207 .-12
8. \Xlh,rcheaJ R. !,chemic cnrcronilit1s: An exprc,,ion of thl' incrava,cubr co.1gulmion syndrome. Ciu1 1971; 12:912-7.
9. Rl•edcrsJWAJ,Ty1garGNJ,Ro,enbu,ch G, Gracam,1 S. bchem,c rnl,m. Boston: Martmu, N11ho(f Puhl,shcr~. 1984:23,29.
10. R,ch.irdl'(m SE, l<.anna li MA, 111:cker LE, Smith CR. The histllpathnlogy of the hemolytic uremic ,yndmmc as.,oc iatcJ with \'erotoxm produung E~clwrichia colr infections. I !um Pathol
flammatory infiltrate anc.l s11hsl'qt1ent pseudomembrane formation.
Fi na lly, in light of the preceding dis· cussion, the authors have found the ,11-gorichm presented in Tahle I usefu l in the diagnosis of E culr 0157:117 coliw,.
APPENDIX: While th,, work wa, 111 prcparatmn, two paper, ,hm, mg pathol,1g1-c;1 I findi ng,somcwhat "milar w I ho,c :ihove were prc,cnred ,lt thl· lntcrnauonal Academy of Pat ho logy, San Fr,lntl\CO California, March 1989 (I>, 14).
1988;19:1102 8. 11. Kelly JK, Pm CK, Jadrn,mgh 111, ct ,ii.
The histoparholngy of rccto,igmoid h1ops1c, from ,,dults w11h hloodv d,ar rhea due to vemtux 111-pmducing Eschmchia coli. Am J ('Im P,1thol I 987;88:78-82.
12. Norris I IT. Rccxam111ation of I he ,pccrrum of i,chem1c howcl dl'casc In: Norris I IT, ed. Pathology of thl· Colnn, Small lnre,tinc and Anus. New York: Churchill L1vmg,tonc, 1983: 109-20.
I 3. Olm,tc.1d LC, Petra, RE, Unffin PM. E.1cherich1a ml, 0 I 5 7: l 17-assoc ,aced col it is: A h isl ologit study of IO cases Lab Invest I 989;60:68A. (Ahst)
14. Kelly J, Wcnc,tck M, Ory,hak A, l't ,11. The rnlon ic pathology of fache1·1ch111 coli Ol 57:H7 1nfccr1,m. Lah Invest I 989;60:46A. (Ahst)
CAN JU I\STROENT! ROI Vt)L 4 Nt) 4 MAY/JUNI: 1990
Submit your manuscripts athttp://www.hindawi.com
Stem CellsInternational
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
MEDIATORSINFLAMMATION
of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Behavioural Neurology
EndocrinologyInternational Journal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Disease Markers
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
BioMed Research International
OncologyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Oxidative Medicine and Cellular Longevity
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
PPAR Research
The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Immunology ResearchHindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Journal of
ObesityJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Computational and Mathematical Methods in Medicine
OphthalmologyJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Diabetes ResearchJournal of
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Research and TreatmentAIDS
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Gastroenterology Research and Practice
Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014
Parkinson’s Disease
Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine
Volume 2014Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com