CNVH Petition to AG Schneiderman 5 of 7

8/3/2019 CNVH Petition to AG Schneiderman 5 of 7

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/cnvh-petition-to-ag-schneiderman-5-of-7 1/99

Petition to New York State Attorney General

The Honorable Eric T..Schneiderman

WE THE llN

DERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to usc his authority including New York State N-PCL

Section 51 I(a)-(b) and Section 511 (a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of

Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion ora full service hospital with an emergency room in

compliance with NY State law and the needs of tile lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York State.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511 (a)-(b) S1. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 51 1(a)( 4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is

fair and reasonable and that the sale is in the best interests of the community.

We also bel ieve that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 501 (c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this

sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of St. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a

full service hospital.

Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center H'DS a tragic Mow for

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the en/ire West Side ofManhattan. Unless a 2.f.-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood. entire communities ofNew Yorkers 1,1'i11o without the adequate health

services they deserve .. r and "The bottom line is: the lvest side cf Manhattan both deserves and needs' an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. fI

This is your opportunity to in fact ensure that reality and fulfil! your campaign promise. We call upon you to block this

sale pending the inclusion of a full service hospital and compliance with all relevant state and other applicable laws.

Sincerely,

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 2G6, New York, NY 10010 Demand.vl+ospitat.hlngapot.corn





WE THE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York

State N-PCL Section 51l(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical

Center of Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a full service hospital with an

emergency room in compliance with NY State law and the needs of the lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York

State.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 511 ( a) ( 4 ) must show the disposition of substantially al l assets is for consideration that is


We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 50 1(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this



Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side of Manhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities of New Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the west side of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. "

This is your opportunity to in fact ensure that reality and fulfill your campaign promise. We call upon you to block this


Sincerely,

SIGNATURE PRINT NAME ZIPCODE

/

L o o I f

C .. ition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospital. blogspot.comV





WE TIlE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York

State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former S 1 . Vincent's Catholic Medical



State.

Inspecific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 51 1(a)(4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is


We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 50 1(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code inthat this









Sincerely,

SIGNATURE

. 1.-

PRINT NAME ZIPCODE

(~':~[

C . .a,) Ci

\ .\~ , C ) ( )

Coali,ii for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S.# 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospita1.blogspot.comV






State N-PCL Section S11(a)-(b) and Section S 1 1 (a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical



State.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section SU(a)-(b) S 1 . Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 511(a)(4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is


We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of S O l (c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this



Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blowfor


services they deserve. " and "171ebottom line is: the west side of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. 'I

This is your opportunity to in fact ensure that reality and fulfill your campaign promise. We call upon you to block tills


Sincerely,

SIGNATURE PRJNTNAME ZIPCODE

~ -, "" "

~J. - v v J~ l~ { 3 l~ie v i

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S.# 206, NewYork, NY 10010 DemandAHospital.blogspotcom




The Honorable Eric T" Schneiderman

WE TIlE UN


Section 51 I (a)-(b) and Section 51 J (a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of

Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion ora full service hospital with an emergency room in

compliance with NY State law and the needs of the lower West S ide of Manhattan, and New York State.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 51! (a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 511 (21)(4) must show the disposition of substantially a II assets is for consideration that is


\Ne also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this

sale and the proposed Rudin pJan docs not continue the charitable mission ofSt. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a

fu n service hospital.

Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure ofSt. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blowfor

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the en/ire TVestSide of Manhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities of New Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve .. s and "The bottom line is: the lvest side ofManhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. n


sale pending the inclusion ofa full service hospital and compliance with all relevant state and other applicable laws.

Sincerely,

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 Demand.'!dfospitnl.blogspot.com




The Honorable Eric 'r, Schneiderman

WE THE UN

DERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York State N-PCL

Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of

Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a full service hospital with an emergency room in

compliance with NY State law and the needs of the lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York State.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511 (a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 511 (a)(4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is

fair and reasonable and that the sale isin the best interests of the community.

'v V e also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 50 1(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this



Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure ofSt. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow/or

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood entire communities ofNew Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the west side ofManhattan both deserves and needs' an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done 10 make certain that becomes a reality. II



Sincerely,

i

I \ o o ~l_________ _J~~_______ __ ~

r




The Honorable Eric T., Schneiderman

WE THE UN


Section 51 1(a)-(b) and Section 511 (a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Cathol ic Medical Center of



In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511 (a)-(b) St. V incenf s is required to serve you with notice of the sale


fair and reasonable an d that th e sale is in the best interests of the community.

We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 501 (c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that th is



Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure ofSt. Vincent's Catholic Medica! Center was a tragic blowfor

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire TVes!Side of Manhattan. Unless a 24-h01l1'acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities ofNew Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the lvest side ofManhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. rr

This is your opportunity to in tact ensure that reality and fulfill your campaign promise. We call upon you to block this

sale pending the inclusion of a full service hospital and cornpl iance with all relevant state and other applicable laws.

Sincerely,

" ;Coantrbn for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DcmaudxHospitat.hlogspot.com



Petition to NewY ork State Attorney General

The Honorable Eric T ..Schneiderman . y ' ' iWE THE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to Lisehis authority including New York State N-PCL

Section Sll(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of

Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion ofa full service hospital with an emergency room in


In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section Sll(a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale



We also believe that this sale does 110t comply with the provisions of 50 l(c)3 ofthe Internal Revenue Code in that this



Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure ofSt. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire FVestSide ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood. entire communities of New Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the west side ofManhattan both deserves and needs' an acute care

hospital with all emergency room. Anything and everything should he done to make certain that becomes a reality. /I



Sincerely,

Coalition fnra New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 Domand.AHospital.blegspot.com





WE THE UN


Section S11(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale ofthe former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of



In specific. under New York State N-PCL Section 51! (a)-(b) St. V incents is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 51 I (a)(4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is


We also believe that th is sale does not comply with the provisions of 501 (c)3 of the r nternal Revenue Code in that this



Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure q/SI. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blowfor

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side of Manhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood, en/ire communities of New Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom fine is: the H'estside ofManhattan both deserves and needs all acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done 10 make certain that becomes a reality. /I



Sincerely,

) ~\ '/~}~-~-""~:,.-:~:~!-

J // f'~il' ~.liLl

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospital.blogspot.com




The Honorable Eric T@Schneiderman

WETHEUN

DERSIGN1<:n call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York State N-PCL

Section 51 1 (a)-(b) and Section 51 1(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St . Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of

M anhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a full service hospital with an emergency room in


In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 51] (a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, an d under Section 51 ] (a)( 4) must show the disposition of substantially a I I assets is for consideration that is

fair and reasonable and that the sale is in the best interests or tile community.

We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 5 0 I ( e) 3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this



Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure ofSt. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center H'as a tragic blowfor

Greenwich Village, Chelsea LInd the entire Wesf Sid~~ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in {his neighborhood. entire communities of/view Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve .. , and "The bottom line is: the west side ofManhattan both deserves and needs ' an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. /I



Sincerely,




The Honorable Eric T@Schneiderman

WE THE UN


Section 511 (a)-(b) and Section 51l (a)(4) to block the sale of the former S1. V incent's Catha Iic Med ical Center of

Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of tile inclusion of a full service hospital with an emergency room incompliance with NY State law and the needs ofthe lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York State.

1 1 1 specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 51] (a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 511 (a)( 4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is


We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 50 I (c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this

sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission ofSt. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a


Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure of 81. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center ,vas a tragic blow/or

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire yVestSide ofManhattan. Unless a 2~-hour acute care hospital with an

emergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities of New Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom fine is: the west side ofManhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done 10 make certain that becomes a reality. 1/



Sincerely,

PRINT NAME

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY I tHHO DemandAHospital.blogspot.com




The Honorable EricT ..Schneiderman

WE THE UN


Section Sll(a)-(b) and Section 5J 1(a)(4) to block the sale of the ronnel' St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of






We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this

sale an d the proposed Rud i n plan does not continue th e charitable mission ofSt. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a



Greenwich Village. Chelsea and the en/ire 11Ies(Side ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood. entire communities ofNew Yorkers 1 1 ' 1 1 1 go without the adequate health


hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. II

This is your opportunity to in fact ensure that reality and fulfill your campaign promise. We call upon YOLl to block this


Sincerely,

. ..~.-.--.-----. ----~--.-.--.--~_.--~~--.-.---~

.__ P_R_INI_.~~~I._E_' +____~ ZIPCODE _.~_

_ _ I




The Honorable Eric T. Schneiderman

'WE THE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York

State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section Sll(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical

Center of Manhattan to the Rudin Organization inthe absence of the inclusion of a full service hospital with an


State.




We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of SOl(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code inthat thissale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of St. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a



Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side of Manhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with an


services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is.' the west side of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care




Sincerely,

PRINT NAME ZIPCODE

t« /C{)(

11"'''''''!,~/{..j~

/

Coalition for a New Vill age Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandA Hospital. blogspot.com '






State N-PCL Section S11(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical



State.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale



We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that thissale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of St. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a





services they deserve. " a.nd "The bottom line is: the west side of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality, "

This is your opportunity to infact ensure that reality and fulfill your campaign promise. We call upon you to block this


Sincerely,

ZIPCODE

{O'~€f

SIGNATURE I PRINT NAME~ - - . ~ - - ~ - - - - - - ~ ~ - - - - - - - - ~ ~ r - ~ - - - -. A ~~S'c_~ J,t:>KY(Hfl/ilc r;)c,f-IP;N2..£R..

I cc tf

I 0 0 I

{ 60U

100 I ICoalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S.# 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospital.blogspot.com



Petitionto New York State Attorney General


WE THE UN


Section 51 1(a)-(b) and Section 51 1(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of









Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure o r Sf. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center lvas a tragic blow/or

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in [his neighborhood. entire communities ofNew Yorkers will go without the adequate health





Sincerely,

I

-





WE THE UN


Section 51 ] (a)-(b) and Section 511 (a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of



In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b) St. Vi ncent' s is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 51 !(a)(4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is


We also believe that this sale docs not comply with the provisions of 50 1(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this

sale and the proposed Rudin plan docs not conti 1 1 L I e the charitable 1 1 1 ission of S1. Vincent's as it is requ ired to, namely a


Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure ofSt. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center lvas a tragic blowfor



hospital with an emergency room. Ant,thing and everything should be done 10 make certain that becomes a reality. rr

This is your opportunity to in fact ensure that reality an d fulfill your campaign promise. We call upon you to block this


Sincerely,

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 Dcmand.cfiospltal.blngspot.com




The Honorable Eric T o Schneiderman

WE THE UN

l)ERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York State N-PCL

Section Sll(a)-(b) and Section 51 I (a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of



In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 51 1(aj-Ib) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 51 I (a)( 4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is tor consideration that is


We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 50 I (c)3 ofthe Internal Revenue Code in that this


fu IIservice hospital.


Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities of New Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the west side of Manhattan both deserves and need, an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality."

This is your opportunity to in fact ensure that reality and fulfill your campaign promise. '0/e call upon you to block this

sale pending the inclusion of a full service hospital and compliance with all relevant state and other applicable laws,

Sincerely,





WETHE1JN


Section 5 1 1(a)-(b) and Section 51 1(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of

Manhattan to the Rud i n Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a full service hospital with an emergency room in

compliance with NY State law and the needs of the lower West S ide of Manhattan, and New York State.


tran saction , an d under Section 511 ( a) ( 4) must show the d ispos i t ion of substantially all assets is for consideration that is

fair and reasonable and that the sa 1e is in the best interests of the cornmun ity.

We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 50 I (c)3 ofthe Internal Revenue Code in that this

sale an d the proposed Rudin plan does not cont inue the charitable mission of St. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a


Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure (lSI. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side of Manhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in {his neighborhood. entire communities ofNew Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bot/om line is: the west side ofManhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room, Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. /I


sale pend ing the inclusion of a full service hospital and compliance with all relevant state and other applicable laws.

Sincerely,

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospitaLblogspot.com





WE THE UN


Section SI1(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of

Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of tile inclusion of a full service hospital with an emergency room in

compliance with NY State law and the needs of the lowerWest Side of Manhattan, and New York State.

In speci fic, under New York State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b) SL Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 511(a)(4) must show the disposition of substantia! Iy all assets is for consideration that is




fu II service hospital.

Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure ofSt. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center }vas a tragic blow/or

Greenwich Village. Chelsea and the entire West Side of Manhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood. entire communities ofNewYorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the H'est side ofManhattan both deserves and needs an acute care


Tilis is your opportunity to in fact ensure that real ity and fulfill your campaign promise. We call upon you to block this


Sincerely.

Coalit ion for /1 New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # Z(}6,New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospital.blogspot.com



:'- "



WE THE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to lise his authority including New York State N-PCL

Section Sl J(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of

Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a full service hospital with an emergency room incompliance with NY State law and the needs of the lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York State.


transaction, and under Section 51 1(a)(4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is


We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions 0f 50 I(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this



Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure ofSt. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center lvas a tragic blow for

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side of Manhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood entire communities of New Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the west side ofManhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with all emergency room. Anything and everything should be done 10make certain that becomes a reality. /I



Sincerely,

Coalition for a NevI' Village Hospital 304 Park Ave, S. # 206, New York, N\" 10010 Demaud.e Hospital.blogspot.com





WE THE UN


Section SI1(a)-(b) and Section 511 (a)(4) to block the sale ofthe former SL Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of

Manhattan to the Rud in Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a full service hospital with an emergency room in


In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 51l (a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 5 II (a)( 4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is

fair an d reasonable an d that the sale is in the best interests of the community.

We also believe that this sale does not comp ly with the provis ions of 50 I(c)3 of the rnternal Revenue Code in that this




Greenwich Village. Chelsea and the entire r V e s t Side ofManhattan. U nle s s a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood entire communities of N . ell' Yorkers wil l go without the adequate health


hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. rt

This is your opportunity to in fact ensure that reality and fulfill your campaign promise. Vlie call upon you to block this


Sincerely,

Coalition for a New ViHage Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospital.blogspot.com





WE THE UN


Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 51 I(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Cathol ic Medical Center of



Itl specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 511(a)( 4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is


We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 50 I(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this

sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of S1.Vincent's as i t is required to, namely a


Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure ofSt. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center lv(lS a tragic blowfor

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side ofManhattan. Unless a 24-/;ollr acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood. entire communities ofNew Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the H'est side cfManhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room: Anything and everything should be done 10 make certain that becomes a reality. fI

This is your opportunity to in fact ensure that reality and fulfill your campaign promise. We call upon YOll to block this

sale pending the inclusion of a full service hospital and compliance with all relevant state and other appl icable laws.

Sincerely,

Demand.A Hospital.blogspot.com





WE THE UN


Section 511 (a)-(b) and Section 51l (a)( 4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Cathol ic Mod ical Center of

Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence ofthe inclusion of a full service hospital with an emergency room in


In specific. under New York State N-PCL Section 511 (a)-( b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale




sale and the proposed Rudin plan does 110t continue the charitable mission of St. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a


Last year,Mr. Schneiderman, )'OU said "The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blowfor

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire r V e , ' ; ! Side ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities of Neil' Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the lyes! side ofManhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done (0 make certain that becomes a reality. II


sale pend ing the inclusion of a full service hospital and cornpl iance with all relevant state and other appl icable laws.

Sincerely,

l

\ {t~---i

Coalition fo" a New \'mage Hospital 304 Park. Ave. S. # 206, New York, NV WOW DemandAHospital.blogspot.com




The Honorable Eric T, Schneiderman

WE THE UN

DERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T, Schneiderman to use his authority including New York State N-PCL

Section S J I(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of

Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion ofa full service hospital with an emergency room incompliance with NY State law and the needs of the lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York State,

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section Sll(a)-(b) SL Vincent's is required to serve you wi th notice of the sale

transaction, an d under Section 51 I (a)( 4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is


We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 5 01 (c)3 o f th e I ntern al Revenue Code in that this



Last year. Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure ofSt. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blowfor

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities ofNew Yorkers 11'iTl go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the west side ofMonhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done 10 make certain that becomes a reality. II



Sincerely,

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY lOOlO Demanda.Hospital.blogspot.corn



Petitionto NewYork StateAttorney General

The Honorable Eric T,.Schneiderman

WE THE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York State N-PCL

Section 51 1(a) -(b) and Section 51 1(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of

Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of tile inclusion of a full service hospital with an emergency room in


ln specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511 (a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 5]1 (a)( 4) m ust show th e disposition of substantially al l assets is for consideration that is





Last yearvMr. Schneiderman, yon said "The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center ,vas a tragic blowfor

Greenwich Village. Chelsea and the entire jiVes!Side ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities ofNew Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bot/om line is: the west side ofManhattan both deserves and needs an acute care



sale pending the incl usion of a fu II service hospital and campi lance with all relevant stale and other applicable laws.

Sincerely,

ZIPCODE

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave, S. # 206, New Ynrk, NY lOOlO Demanda Hospitst.blogspot.com



: .. ." .

; "" ;- _.



WE THE UN

DERSIGNED call upon Attorney Genera! Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York State N-PCL

Section 511 (a)-(b) and Section 511 (a)( 4) to block the sale of the former S1. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of

Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion ofa full service hospital with an emergency room incompliance with NY State law and the needs of tile lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York State.

In specific. under New York State N-PCL Section 511 (a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale


fair and reasonable and that the sale is in the best interests ofthe community.

W e also bel ieve that th is sale does not comply with the provisions of 50 1(c)3 of th e Internal Revenue Code in that this



Last year. Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute core hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities a/New Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the H'es!s ide ofManhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done 10 make certain that becomes a reality. tt



Sincerely..,II

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Pad ...Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 100lO Demandx+lospltal.blogspot.com





"o/V ETH E U N


Section 511 (a)-(b) and Section 511 (a)( 4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of



In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511 (a)-(b) St. Vincent's is requi red to serve you with notice of the sale



\Ve also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 50 1(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this


f u l l service hospital.


Greenwich Village. Chelsea and the entire West Side of Manhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital witli anemergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities ofNew Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve." and 'The bottom line is: the west side ofManhattan both deserves and needs an acute care




Sincerely,

ZIPCODE






WE THE UN

DERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York State N·PCL

Section 511 (aHb) and Section 511 (a)( 4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Cathol ic Medical Center of



In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b) St. Vincent's is requ ired to serve youwith notice of the sale



We also bel ieve that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 50 I(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this

sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of Sf. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a



Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute core hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities ofNew Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the H'esfside of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done 10 make certain that becomes a reality. 11

This is your opportunity to in fact ensure that reality and fulfill YOL l r campaign promise. We call upon you to block this


Sincerely,

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 3{}4PH,k Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 Dcmand.a Hcspital.blogspot.com




The Honorable Eric T 9 Schneiderman

WETHEIJN


Section 511 (a)-(b) and Section 51 1(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of

Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a full service hospital with an emergency room incompliance with NY State law and the needs of the lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York State.

In specific. under New York State N-PCL Section 5 J 1(a)-(b) St. Vi ncents is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 51 I(a)( 4) must show the disposition of substantially a II assets is for consideration that is




fu 1 1 service hospital.

Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure q(SI. Vincent's Catholic Medica! Center 1vas a tragic blow for

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side ofManhattan. Unless a 24-houl' acute care hospital with an

emelgencv room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities of N·c)v Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the lFest side ofManhattan both deserves and needs an acute care



sale p en din g th e inclusion of a full service hospital and compliance with a ll r el evant state and other a pp li cab le la w s.

Sincerely,

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY lOOlO DemandAHospital.blogspot.com





WE THE UN

DERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including NC\v York State N-PCL

Section 51 1(a)-(b) and Section 51 1(a)( 4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of

Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a full serv ice hospital with an emergency room in


In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 5 I 1(a)-(b) St. Vincent's is reqU ired to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 51 J (a)( 4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is



sale and the proposed Rud in plan does 110t continue the charitable 111 iss ion of St. Vincent's as it is req uired to, namely a



Greenwich Village. Chelsea and the entire West Side ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities ofNew Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services the}:'deserve. " and "The bottom fine is: the lPest side ofManhauan both deserves and needs an acute care




Sincerely,

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 100tO Demanda Hospital.blogspot.com





WE TIlE UN


Section 51 I (a)·(b) and Section 511 (a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of

Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a full service hospital w ith an emergency room in


I n specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 51 I(a)( 4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is

fair and reasonable and tha t the sale is in the best interests of th e community.





Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities ofNew Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "171ebottom line is: the H'est side ofManhauan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality, "

Th is is your opportun ity to in fact ensure that reality and fulfill your campaign promise. We call upon you to block this


Sincerely,

/~ ~

L[()f"Ae~, __ .~~~

; ; , c

,ii

--__j

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave.S, # 206, New York. NY lOOlO Demanda Hospttal.blogspot.cem





WE THE UN

lJERSIGNED cal! upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York State N-PCL

Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 51l (a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of

Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a fu II service hospital with an emergency room in

compliance with NY State law and the needs ofthc lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York State.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 51] (a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 5]] (a)( 4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is


We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of501(c)3 of tile Internal Revenue Code in that this



Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure ofSt. Vincent's Catholic Medica! Center ~·j!asa tragic blowfor

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities ofNew Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the west side ofManhattan both deserves and n e e d s ' an acute care




Sincerely,






WE THE UN

DERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T, Schneiderman to use his authority including New York State N-PCL

Section 51 I ( a )- (b ) and Section 51 I ( a )( 4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Cathol ie Medical Center of

Manhattan to the Rud in Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a fu II service hospital with an emergency room incompliance with NY State law and the needs of the lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York State.·

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section Sll(a)-(b) S1 . Vincent's is required to serve yo u with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 51 I (a)( 4) m ust show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is



sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of 51. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a


Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure a/St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blowfor

Greenwich Village. Chelsea and the entire West Side ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities ofNew Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services (hey deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the west side ofManhattan both deserves and need) an acute care

hospital with an emergency room, Anything and everything should be done 10 make certain that becomes a reality. rr

This is your opportun ity to in fact ensure that reality and fulfill your campaign promise. We call upon you to block this


Sincerely,

Coalition fOI" a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S, # 2(]6, New York, NY WOW Demands.Hospital.blogspot.corn





WE THE UN

DERSIGNED call upon Attorney Genera! Eric T. Schneiderman to lise his authority including New York State N-PCL

Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 5] I(a)(4) to block the sale o r the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of



In specific. under New York State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 511 (a)(4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is tor consideration that is


We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 5 0 1(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this



Last year. Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure ofSt. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blowfor

Greenwich Village. Chelsea and the entire West Side ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital 'with a 1 7

emergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities ofNew Yorkers will go without the adequate health





Sincerely,





WE THE UN


Section 5 I I (a)-(b) and Section 511 (a)( 4) to block the sale of tile Fonner St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center of

Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a fu 11service hospital with an emergency room incompliance with NY State law and the needs of the lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York State.



fair and reasonable an d that the sale is in the best interests of the community.

\Ve also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 501 (c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this

sale an d the proposed R ud in plan does not continue the charitable m ission of St. V in cen t's as it is required to , namely a

full service hospita l.

Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure (?lSI. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center lvas a tragic blow/or

Greenwich Village. Chelsea and the entire West Side of Manhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with an


services they deserve. " an d "The bottom line is: the lvest side of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done 10 make certain that becomes a reality. "


sale pending the inclusion of a full service hospi tal and compliance with all relevant state and other ap plicable law s.

Sincerely,

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, N\' 10010 Demendxl+ospltal.blogspot.com





WE THE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including NewYork

State N-PCL Section S11(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former S1.Vincent's Catholic Medical


emergency room in compliance with NY State law and the needs of the lower West Side of Manhattan, and New YorkState.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 51 1 (a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale




sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of S1.Vincent's as it is required to, namely a

full service hospitaL







Sincerely,


/ 0 O( (

/C--Olj

If' !./L~ \f

I00 ( I

l e N ) } /

//J /~7/) i,'l/{··CI/

I

!

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospital.blogspot.eom



h~cd

Petition to New York State Attorney GeneralThe Honorable Eric T ..Schneiderman


State N-PCL Section Sll(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former s t. Vincent's Catholic Medical



State.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b) St . Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale


fair and reasonable and that the sale is in the best interests o f the community.

We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that thissale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission ofSt. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a






hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should he done to make certain that becomes a reality. II

This is your opportunity to in fac t ensure that reality and fulfill YOLL- campaign promise. We call upon you to block this


Sincerely,


~ / ~ ~ l A } \ / ( ; = t t L".)F !}

Coalition ~or a New Village Hospital

, 1 . ( ' : ; . . ; f a n i j h i J 1 ;< • j V - r ' A ' : : ' _ I : : ' _ < ' _ ~ _ < ,L__~~ __,

:j304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospital.blogspot.com





WE THE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attomey General Eric T. Sclmeidennan to use his authority including New York

State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 511 (a)(4) to block the sale of the fanner St. Vincent's Catholic Medical

Center afManhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a full service hospital with an


State.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) 81 . Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 511(a)(4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is far consideration that is











Sincerely,

SIGNATURE PRINTNAM:E ZIPCODE

/"7(~L \ : fA-\i-;;:·· f?fv\ \~~ !\, 1

\00\

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave_ S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospital.blogspot.com






State N-PCL Section 511 (a)-(b) and Section 511 (a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical


emergency room in compliance with NY State law and the needs ofthe lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York

State.




We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 50 1 (c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that thissale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of St. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a


Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said liThe closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blowfor



services they deserve." and "The bottom line is: the west side a/Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care


This is your opportunity to in fact ensure that reality and fulfill you; campaign promise. We call upon you to block this


Sincerely,

ZIPCODE

I//? E \ / (k 1 /~ ' : - ~ l ~ ' 7 t C ~ ' ~ ~ / ~_ - - ~0~t~'~!'~~~~ -L~ __ ~\J~t~~~~~'~'~~.~,_/~~'\ I ~ i G ~ ; ~ Q ~ r M J ~ U ~ ( ( ~ , ~ ill

(,c Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. i ; " i 0 6 , New Yor~,NY 10010 DemandAHosPital.Jogspotcom

',,1

~_ t lArI .XPt + . \ t J . . I l ' o C f , , 1






State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former S1.Vincent's Catholic Medical


emergency room incompliance with NY State law and the needs of the lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York

State.




We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that thissale.aadtlieproposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of S1.Vincent's as it is required to, namely aservice hospital. -- ,

:::::=::.:,,-"-.~.. , _/ ,",--)

Last year, Mr. ScIilleidennan, you said "The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with an






Sincerely,

ZIPCODE

I(Ji If IL

Coalit ion fo 'New Village Hospital 304Park Ave. S.# 206,NewYork, 1\ry 100]0 DemandAHospital.blogspot.com

/f






State N-PCL Section Sll(a)-(b) and Section 511 (a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent 's Catholic Medical

Center of Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a fun service hospital with all


State.

Inspecific, under New York State N-PCL Section 51Ia)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale



We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 501(c)3 ofthe Internal Revenue Code inthat this



Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure a/St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side of Manhattan., Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with an


services they deserve. "and "The bottom line is: the ,vest side oj Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care


This is your opportunity to in fact ensure that reality and fulfill your campaign promise. Y'/e call upon you 10block this


Sincerely,

----.~~-_.-~~-.------------,---------PRINT NAME ZIPCODE

O~~~l} (! ) l't~t,~ _ + - - - , - , , ' ( ; , , - - ) _ O _ ' I_~-" -../_ .-oj

I-_~:-----~__"_+=- -+-~) (/ IS -r~~:>l.d f C ) o

I t:L / z _ 1 1 1 3 E71J Jt!I/;u; 1 J . ~ c J - t - - - - , - / ~ c ?0._:_/+----1

/(:)0 /.2--

/OO{)q

/\.

[I/i ;(/!. If PJ>/TP/~"d'

/7 .L'A0</Zov~




The Honorable Eric T~Schneiderman

WE THE UNDERSIGNED callupon Anorney General Eric T. Schneiderman 10 use hi s authority in d uc tin g N ew York

State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical

Center of Manhattan 10 the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a full service hospital with an

emergency room in compliance with NY State law and the needs ofthe lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York

State.


transaction, and under Secrion 511(a}(4) must show the disposition of substantially ali assets is for consideration that is


We also believe that this sale docs no r comply with the provisions of50l(c)3 ofthe Internal Revenue Code in that this

sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue tile charitable mission of St. Vincent's as i t is required to, namely a


Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure oiSt. Vincent \ Catholic Medica! Center 1+'(ISa Tragic blowfor

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side ·ollvfaduwan. Unless a 24·i lOU! ' acute care hospital with an

emergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities ofNew Yorkers will go without [he adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: flit: 11('.1'1 side ofManhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergen,:,y room. Anything and everything should he done to make certain that becomes a reality."

This is your opportunity 10 in fact ensure thai reality and fulfill your campaign pronnse. \Ne call upon you w block this

sale pending the inclusion ora full service hospital and compliance with ali relevant s ta re and other applicable laws.

Sincerely.

,0'; P,lrk Ave. S;; 206. New York. NY j( .i DCll1al1dAHospital.blogspot.com






State N-PCL Section Sll(a}-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical



State.


transaction, and under Section 51 ia)(4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is


We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 501 (c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this




Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side 0/Manhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with an

emergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities a/New Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the west side 0/ Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care




Sincerely,

~~~~ __~~~~~~~~~~4~Qo/~ II Y/I?-/( '\ fhUf)j 3~leklVo I ) OC) / " 1 !

- - - = - - - - - + ! ' } c,~~ {eJ Iiv ' " y '" I i a o ; d - . . _ IIJ)Jj\}( /TN i - + D X .U J c i < ~ 1 ; /(J6/1

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. II 206, New York. NY If :1 DemandAHospitaLblogspot.com






State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical



State.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) S1.Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction. and under Section 511(a)(4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is





Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure ofSt. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow/or

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side of Manhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with an .



hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. It



Sincerely,

Coalition tor a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY J r : 1 Demand/cllospital.blogspor.com



Petition to New York State Attorney GeneralThe Honorable Eric T..Schneiderman


State N-PCL Section 511 (a)-(b) and Section 511{a)(4}to block the sale oftheformer St. Vincent's Catholic Medical



State.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section Sl1(a)-(b) s t. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale



We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that thissale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of S1.Vincent's as it is required to, namely a







This is your opportunity to in fact ensure that reality and fulfill your campaign promise. We can upon you to block this


Sincerely,

PRINT NAME ZIPCODE

i6D14

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, Ny I!'






State N-PCL Section 51l(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical



State.

Inspecific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) S1.Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale



We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions ofSOl(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this

sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of s t. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a








Sincerely,

~IGNATURE PRINT NAME ZIPCODE

A fr

o /

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S.# 206, New York, tY10010 DemandAHospital.blogspot.com





WE TIlE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York

State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former s t . Vincent's Catholic Medical



State.



fair and reasonable and that the sale is inthe best interests of the community.


sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of St. Vincent's as it is required to, namely afull service hospital.


Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side 0/ Manhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with an


services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the west side of.Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. It

Tills is your opportunity to in tact ensure that reality and fulfill your campaign promise. We call upon you to block this


Sincerely,


r t(/ o 0(

D u ('".,

Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospita1.blogspotcom






State N-PCL Section Sll(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former S1.Vincent's Catholic Medical



State.

Inspecific, under New York State N·PCL Section 511(a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale



We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this

sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of St. Vincent 's as it is required to, namely a

f u n service hospital.

Last year, ML Schneiderman, you said "The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for



services they deserve. "and "The bottom line is: the west side of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care




Sincerely,

"\SIGNATURE PRINT NAME

'iJ

1 ( ) \ ) f ~ f

DemandAHo s p it al . b lo g spo t, c om







Center of Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a fell! service hospital with an


State.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511(a)·{b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale



We also believe that this sale does nor comply with the provisions of 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this

sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission ofSt, Vincent 's as it is required to, namely afull service hospital.

Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center .vas a tragic blowfor







Sincerely,




The Honorable Eric 'I', Schneiderman





State.

In specific, under N ew York State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) St . Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale








emergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities of Ne w Yorkers will go without the adequate health





Sincerely,

PRINT NAl'WE ZIPCODE

f ()O 11

s

lOO/ '

C " t - \'Coalitjon for a~ ewVillage Hospital 304 Park Ave. S.# 206, New York, NY i0010 DemandAHospital.blogspot.com

\ \





"W E THE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York




State.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section S11(a)-(b) S1.Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale



We a180believe that this sale does not comply with the proviif~l1s of 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code inthat this










Sincerely,

PRINT NAME ZIPCODE

f

I dO

Coalition for a New Vi ! lage Hospital 304 Park Ave, S. # 206, N e .w York, 1\'Y 10010 DcmandAHospitaJ.blogspat.com






State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to blockthesalebftheformerSt.Vinct:nt'sCatholicMedical

Center of Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absenceoftheinclusion cf'a.fullservice hospital with an

emergency room in compliance with NY State Jaw and the needs of the lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York

State.




We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of SOl(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this






services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the west side of.Manhauan both deserves and needs an acute care


This is your opportunity to in fact ensure that reality and fulfi ll your campaign promise. We call upon you toblock this

salepending the inclusion of a nJU service hospital and compliance with all relevant state andotherapplicable laws.

Sincerely,

P R IN T NA 1\1.E ZIPCODE

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S.# 206,New York, N'Y l0010 DemandAHospital.blogspot.com






State N-PCL Section 511(aHb) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the fanner st. Vincent's Catholic Medical


emergency room in compliance with NYState law and the needs of the lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York

State.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) s t. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale






Last year, ML Schneiderman, you said "The closure 0/ St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow/or







Sincerely,


..-

t-f. il:5.l)MA.-rJ

loo/t..

I JJ!t-

Coalition for a N , ; » , ' V i l l a g e Hospital 304Park Ave S. # 206, NewYork, NY 10010 DemandAHospitaLblogspot.com






State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former s t. Vincent's Catholic Medical



In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b) S1 . Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale




sale mld the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of St. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a




services they deserve. Hand "The bottom line is: the west side of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. tt

TIllS is your opportunity to infact ensure that reality and fulfill your campaign promise. We call upon you to block this


Sincerely,

SIGNA;fURE PRINT NAME

+l{J/cc)

ZIPCODE

.., / (' <~ /11/dL=:. .t: f / < . ' 1 ' f,f./J. (1-; /--:) ,L \.__~/

..>I r),:;) III c ..

I (f7~)IL/- .






State N-PCL Section 5U(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former S1.Vincent's Catholic Medical








full service hospital. .








Sincerely,

PRINT NAME ZIPCODE

ICC) ((

f ' aoe : i. I

\f

tO O I f

(

Coalition or a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DernandAHospital.blogspot.com




The Honorable Eric T ..Schneiderman


State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the fanner St. Vincent's Catholic Medical









Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure of S t. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for





This is your opportunity to in fact ensure tha t reality and fulfill your campaign promise. We call upon you to block this


Sincerely,

SIGNATURE ZIPCODE

( o ~ {

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S.# 206, New }ork, NY 10010 DemandAHospitaLblogspot.dom









In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section SU(a)-(b) S 1 . Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale












Sincerely,

ZIPCODE

/'(76/1

COftion for a New Village Hospital





WE THE IJNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York







We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of SOl(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code inthat this






hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. rt

This is your opportunity to in fact ensure that reality and fulfill your campaign promise. We call upon you to block tins


Sincerely,

SIGNATURE PRINT NAME

/

-{

ZIPCODE

louO~(6 l/

I 00 I







State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 51 1(a)(4) to block the sale of the former s t. Vincent's Catholic Medical



In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) 8 1 . Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale







Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side oj Manhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with anemergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities of New Yorkers will go without the adequate health

services they deserve." and "The bottom line is: the west side of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care




Sincerely,


r-,

: ' / ' L c - 1 . _ _ _ . _

ZIPCODE

10 ez,

1 00\

1001

100 \ \

IQtJ \ \

J CJ-t) I!

(GD I(

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 P ar k A ve , S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospital.blogspot.com





WE THE l.J1\1)ERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York

State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale ofthe fanner s t. Vincent's Catholic Medical









Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure a/St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for


services they deserve. rr and "The bottom line is: the west side of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. tr



Sincerely,

SIGNATURE PRINT NAlVIE ZIPCODE

/00 /

alition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospital.blogspot.com





WE THE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Sclmeiderman to use his authority including New York

State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b ) and Section 511 (a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical



In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511(aj36?) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale


f~ir and reasonable and that the sale is in the best interests of the community.

We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code inthat this



Last year, Mr. Sclmeiderman, you said "The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for







Sincerely,

SIGNATURE ZIPCODERINT NAME

, f !

!'-"/

\1 Cj. !

(ud/I

/ (3ci: I)

/.., /,{1'/

...v[/.

304 Park Ave. S_# 206, New York, "!'.II' 10010 DemandAHospitaLblogspot.com



_ , : : . ." : : _ >_ .i·.. :··:·-··:.

Petitlonto New York State Attorney General



State N-PCL Section 511 (a)-(b) and Section 511(a)( 4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical

Center of Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a fu ll service hospital with an








Last year, ML Schneiderman, you said "The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side of Manhattan, Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with an





sale pending the inclusion of a fun service hospital and compliance with all relevant state and other applicable laws.

Sincerely,

PRINT NAJVIE ZIPCODE

([1A n V-f I

01 '302

it~. a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospitaLblogspoLcom












We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 50l(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this




Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side of Manhattan. Unless a 24-11ouracute care hospital with an






Sincerely,

c

1Coalition for a N;Y'Niuage Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DcmandAHospital.blogspot.com

~",~~,y

/

"" . . . . . . . ,..



(~ /~



'VE THE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York

State N-PCL Section 511 (a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former SL Vincent's Catholic Medical



In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 5 I1(a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale








emergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities of New Yorkers will go without the adequate healthservices they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the west side of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency 1'00111. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality."



Sincerely,

ZIPCODE

I ,I, I

f ( j ( J J q

\ 0 a '00

o oe»

!I J 02

o lition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York. NY 10010 Demand Allospital.blogspct.com



...... - : - _ .: :_- ..




State N-PCL Section 511 (a)-(b) and Section 511(a)( 4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical




transaction, and under Section 5] l(a)(4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is


We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 501(c)3 of the Intemal Revenue Code in that this




Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side of Manhattan. Unless a 24-haur acute care hospital with an






Sincerely,

ZIPCODE

loo?,b

10614

1 D D ! t r




" .'.- =:':




State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 5] 1(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical


emergency room in compliance with NY State law and the needs of the lower West Side of Manhattan, and New YorkState. _



fair and reasonable and that the sale is in the best interests of the community _

We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 50 I(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this

sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of SL Vincent's as it is required to, namely a

full service hospital,


Greenwich Village, Chelsea and [he entire West Side of Manhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with an

emergency 1'00/11 opens in this neighborhood, entire communities of New Yorkers will go without the adequate health


hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality"



Sincerely,


Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S_# 206. New York, NY 10010 Demand.Al-lospital.blogspot.corn










transaction, and under Section 51 I(a)( 4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is





Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center ·was a tragic blow for





This is your opportunity to in fact ensure that reality and fulfill your campaign promise. We call npon you to block this


Sincerely,


1001 < 6

l o a 1



Petitio.sto New York State Atw.~rneyGeneral



State N-PCL Section 511 (a)-(b) and Section 511 (a)( 4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical



State.









emergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities of New Yorkers will go without the adequate healthservices they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the .vest side of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care




Sincerely,

SIGNATURE ZIPCODERINT NAME

1001 C ;

ll,]{5

304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New Yark, NY 100] 0 Demand/vHospital.blogspot.com





\VE THE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York

State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent 's Catholic Medical



State.


transaction, and under Section 5 I 1 (a)(4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is






Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side of Manhattan. Unless a 24·hour acute care hospital with an






Sincerely,

SIGNATU~.•..} r /

,./-"·'~~~lf

PRlNTNAME ZIPCODE

!t

()() {(

1/ II


I




The Honorable Eric T&Schneiderman


State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 51 1(a)(4) to block the sale of the former st. Vincent's Catholic Medical


emergency room incompliance with NY State law and the needs of the lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York

State.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) St. Vincent 's is required to serve you with notice of the sale

transaction, and under Section 5 I 1 (a)(4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is


We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions ofSOl(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code inthat this

sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of st. Vincent's as it is required to, namely afull service hospital.

Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure 0/ St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side of Manhattan Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with an



hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality II



Sincerely,

/cp J

~\ '·D ') \\

/

to D t ljr

, , 'j/L !

304 Park Ave. S.# 206, New York,NY 10010 DemandAHospital.blogspotcom






State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the fanner S1.Vincent's Catholic Medical



State.







Last year, 11r. Schneiderman, you said "The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side of Manhattan Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with an

emergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities of New Yorkers will go without the adequate healthservices they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the west side ofManhattan both deserves and needs an acute care




Sincerely,

1-- SIGNATURE PRINT NAME ZIPCODE

'\DD \ \

J

(O o I I

/ /\/'~ ;' j/ UI...). I/ l ,

\'

'tyodl

l O u I






State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 51 1(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical







sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of S 1 . Vincent's as it is required to, namely a









Sincerely,

SIGNAlTURE

/ ()CJ/ 1 - /

PRINT NAME ZIPCODE

.t ....

[(Joe:)

{ C tOj

ifi

\ 1r""\

D1 '1, U

I Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave! s. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DernandAHospitaLblogspot.com





WE THE lJNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York

State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)( 4) to block the sale of the fanner St. Vincent's Catholic Medical













hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. if



Sincerely,

,------- '-~---~--"-'-"--,-'-----'----


l 0 0 '2 - 3

/6l) /

)' - - - - _ _../ Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304J:>ark Ave. S. # 206, N t ' ; York, NY 10010 DemandAHospita1.bJogspot.com






State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 51 1(a)(4) to block the sale of the fanner St. Vincent's Catholic Medical






We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code inthat this



Last year, NIt. Schneiderman, you said "The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blowfor



services they deserve. " and TIThebottom line is: the west side of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care




Sincerely,

PRINT NAME ZIPCODE

.Iition for a NewVillage Hospital 304 Park Ave. S.# 206, NewYork, NY 10010 DemandAHospitaLblogspot.com



Petition to New York State Attorney Generalf



State N-PCL Section S11(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical






We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of S O 1(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this

sale and the proposed Rudin plan does 110t continue the charitable mission of St. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a



Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side ofManhauan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with an


services they deserve. »and "The bottom line is: the west side of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute carehospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. It



Sincerely,


iJ

!Y ( ; 7 / 1

[OOO'd--

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospital.biogspot.com





'WE THE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York

State N-PCL Section Sll(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical


emergency room incompliance with NY State law and the needs of'the lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York

State,







Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure of S t. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for


emergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities of New Yorkers will go without the adequate healthservices they deserve." and "The bottom line is: the west side of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care



sale pending the inclusion of a full service hospital and compliance with aU relevant state and other applicable laws.

Sincerely,

~ ' - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~SIGNATVR,E j_ PRINT NAME ZIPCODE

i 0 () t

v ,; ( 1 I \/,' I A ,~D t" .. Vj ¥ 'A 1 .•'::1.'

,J})/I

l'ifIQ('(~

I I A I '1 _ \ 1 \ I CrUL\

\ ('\:. . . . . . . . . . .

I O _ ~ 1 _ ( . ) j

/0014·-

O D 0"'::,

koal~~~ew Village Hospital

\304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospital.blogspot.com



J

L~






emergency room incompliance with NY State law and the needs of the lower West Side of Manhattan, and New YorkState.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511(a)~(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale








emergency room opens in this neighborhood. entire communities of New Yorkers will go without the adequate health


hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. If



Sincerely,


"T/'"' ~~!,>~)(~~f I t t

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospitaLblogspot.com



· . .




State N-PCL Section Sl1(a)-(b) and Section S11(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical



State.

illspecific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale



We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code inthat thissale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of s t. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a





services they deserve." an d "The bottom line is: the west side of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care



sale pending the inclusion of a full service hospital and compliance with ail relevant state and other applicable laws.

Sincerely,


)

ZIPCODE

I / O

/

/ 1r ]























Sincerely,


~ ,. . . - , i ( j '?j-~ ...r! ,:

" ~ {

i ..

Co~;lon for a New '{ age Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, NewYork, NY 10010 DemandAHospitaLblogspot.com






State N-PCl_.,Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical

Center of Manhattan to the Rudin Organization inthe absence of the inclusion ofa full service hospital with an








Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said TIThe closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for



services they deserve. " and "711e bottom line is: the west side of Manhattan botli deserves and needs an acute care




Sincerely,

SIGNATURE ZIP CODERINT NAME

('

Coalition for a New Village Hospital Demandz.Hospiral.blogspot.com





WE THE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attomey General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York

State N-PCJ:.,Section 511(aHb) and Section 511(a)( 4) to block the sale of the former S t . Vincent's Catholic Medical






We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 50l(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code in that this

sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of 51. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a








sale pending the inclusion of aMI service hospital and compliance with all relevant state and other applicable laws.

Sincerely,

PRINT NAME ZIPCODE

/ f

Cealition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospital.blogspot.com




The Honorable Eric r. SchneidermanWE THE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York

State N-PCJ_.Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St Vincent's Catholic Medical
















Sincerely,


3 < 3 4 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010






The Honorable Eric T. SchneidermanWE THE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York




State.








Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side of Manhattan. Unless a 24- hour acute care hospital with an





sale pending the inclusion of a f u n service hospital and compliance with all relevant state and other applicable laws.

Sincerely,

SIGNATURE ZIPCODE

.:C(_4--C.-- t .~_; ,_ /

PRINT NAME

I .

tnt? v O [ , ·- - - ,d t ?

.~J""''''-

0-- \. e,(2.i\A".J\

, ./ (7 <)-,

, -I'

!U

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 Demanda.Hospiral.blogspot.com




The Honorable Eric To Schneiderman



Center of Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion ofa full service hospital with an


State.














Sincerely,

ZIPCODEIGNATURE

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S.# 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospitaJ.blogspot.cum





"\VETHE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York

State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 511 (a)(4) to block the sale of the fanner s t. Vincent's Catholic Medical

Center of Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence ofthe inclusion of a full service hospital with an


State.

Inspecific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511(a)-{b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale




sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of St. Vincent's as it is required to, namely afun service hospital.

Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "T71eclosure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blowfor







Sincerely,


Coalit ion for a New Vil lage Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. #206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospi tal,blogspot .com






State N-PCL Section Sll(a)-(b) and Section Sll(a)(4) to block the sale of the former S1.Vincent's Catholic Medical


emergency room in compliance with l ' ."Y State law and the needs of the lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York

State.

Inspecific, under New York State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b) 81.Vincent 's is required to serve you with notice of the sale




sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of S1.Vincent's as it is required to, namely afull service hospital.


Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side oj Manhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with an




This is your opportunity to infact ensure that reality and fulfi1l your campaign promise. We call upon you to block this


Sincerely,


Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospital.blogspotcom




The Honorable Eric r,SchneidermanWE THE UNDERSIGNED call upon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York

State N-PCL Section 511 (a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical

Center of Manhattan to the Rudin Organization in the absence of the inclusion of a full service hospital with anemergency room in compliance with NY State law and the needs of the lower West Side of Manhattan, and New York

State.


transaction, and under Section 511(a)( 4) must show the disposition of substantially all assets is for consideration that is












Sincerely,

ZIPCODERINT NAME

I (\ (1\ ('(/:t . \ .. ..,1 '., ....- .




Petitibd to New York State Aa,(orneyGeneral



State N-PCL Section 51 1(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale ofthe former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical



Inspecific, under New York State N-PCL SectioI1511(a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale




sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of Sf. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a





services they deserve. " and iThe bottom line is: the westside of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. fI


sale pending the inclusion of afull service hospital and compliance with all relevant state arid other applicable laws.

Sincerely,


Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospltaLblogspot.com

J



." ,- , -.-.

Petitic., to New York State A""orney General



State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 511 (a)(4) to block the sale of the former s r, Vincent's Catholic Medical



Inspecific, under New York State N-PCL SectionSll(a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale





full.servicehospital,

Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure of St. Vincent's CatholicMedical Center was a tragic blowfor

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire WestSide ofManhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with an


services they deserve. " and "The bottom line is: the west side 0/Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute carehospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done to make certain that becomes a reality. "

..'TIns is your opportunity to in fact ensure that reality and fulfill your campaign promise. We call upon you to block this


Sincerely,


I!i

l 1i I! !

,,1

. I '\ "-f"\ ~

I

/00 Id - - -

!{

I

r:s .

Coalition for aNew VillageHospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospital.blogspot.com



Petitio.; to New York State A,-~orneyGeneral



State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 511 (a)(4) to block the sale of the fanner St. Vincent's Catholic Medical



Inspecific, under New York State N-PCL SectionSl Itaj-Ib) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale






Last year, MI. Schneiderman, you said "The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for






sale pending the inclusion of afull service hospital and compliance with all relevant state and other applicable laws.

Sincerely,


I

\j

) ,-

, - - . . , - . . - . . ,~(.~se-~i?74.e 'Y-,'L-L

J

ZIPCODE

! C~)(/

J I ; : ; , 0~"

(eTe)I !

. ; -.;, , , , , , , " , " " " " " / < : : . L{ ~ ,--,"< /

I '1(, /! !c/I .J (/ { r

Coalition for a New Village. Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. if 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospital.blogspoLcom




The Honorable Eric ToSchneiderman

WE THE UNDERSIGNED callupon Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman to use his authority including New York

State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 511 (a)( 4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical



In specific, under New York State N-PCL SectionSl l (a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale




sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of st. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a









Sincerely,

PRINT NAM]J: ZIPCODE

Coalition for a New VillageHospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DernandAHospital.blogspot.com

/

\\



• <










We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 50 1(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code inthat this

sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of s t . Vincent's as it is required to, namely a


Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said 'The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for



services they deserve. " an d "The bottom line is: the west side of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care




Sincerely,

NATURE PRINT NAME ZIPCODE

IDr

,/

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospita1.blogspot.com



Petition toNew York State Attorney General






Inspecific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) St. Vincent's i s required to serve you with notice of the sale



We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions ofSOl(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code inthat this

sale and the proposed Rudin plan does not continue the charitable mission of St. Vincent's as itis required to, namely a


Last year , Mr. Schneiderman, you said "The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for

Greenwich Village, Chelsea and the entire West Side a/Manhattan. Unless a 24-hour acute care hospital with an






Sincerely,

SIGNATURE ZIPCODER IN T 1'IAM E

(




:. ' .. "".:::. _ . - _ . _ .. ' : " ' : .




State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 51 I(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical


emergency room in compliance with NY State law and the needs of the lower West Side of Manhattan. and New YorkState.

In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section511(a)-(b) St. Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sale








services they deserve. nan d "The bottom line is: the west side a/Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care




Sincerely.

PRINT NAME ZIPCODE

Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S.# 206, New York,NY iooio DemandAHospital.blogspot.com






State N~PCL Section 51l(a)-(b) and Section 511 (a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical



In specific, under New York State N-PCL Section 511(a)-(b) S 1 . Vincent's is required to serve you with notice of the sal


fair and reasonable and that the sale is in the best interests of the community,

We also believe that this sale does not comply with the provisions of 50 1(c)3 of th e Internal Revenue Code inthat this



Last year, Mr. Schneiderman. you said "The closure of St. Vincent's Catholic Medical Center was a tragic blow for


services they deserve. rr and "The bottom line is: the west side of Manhattan both deserves and needs an acute care




Sincerely, .r'~~"" • . s' " I

PRINT NAME ZIPCODE

/r

Coalition for a New VillageHospital 304 Park Ave. S. # 206, New York, NY 10010 DemandAHospital.blogspot.com



· .."'

Pctltioi.ro New York State Atc..rney General



State N~PC~ Section 511(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical



State.





sale and the proposed Rud i n plan does not continue the charitable mission of St. Vincent's as it is required to, namely a


Last year, Mr. Schneiderman, you said "Theclosure of St. Vincent's CatholicMedical Center was a tragic blowfor


emergency room opens in this neighborhood, entire communities ofNew Yorkers will go without the adequate healthservices they deserve. sr and "The bottom line is: the west side ofManhattan both deserves and needs an acute care

hospital with an emergency room. Anything and everything should be done tomake certain that becomes a reality. If


sale pending the inclusion of a full service hospital and compliance with all relevant state arid other applicable laws.

Sincerely,


,i






State N-PC,L Section 51 1(a)-(b) and Section 511(a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical
















Sincerely,


Coalition for a New Village Hospital 304 Park Ave. S. #206, New York, NY 10010 Demandaflospital.blogspot.com






State N-PC;L Section S11(a)-(b) and Section 511 (a)(4) to block the sale of the former St. Vincent's Catholic Medical
















Sincerely,

PRINT NAME ZIPCODE

i f . - / lJ.'.' ~ i

Documents

CNVH Petition to AG Schneiderman 5 of 7