Upload
lamdang
View
220
Download
3
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Chapter1
This introductory chapter reviews the recent advances in the synthesis, bioactivity and
application of chalcones as intermediate in organic synthesis.
Chalcones:Chemistry&Bioactivity
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|1
1.1 Introduction
Throughout the ages mankind is dependent on nature, particularly on plants as
source of carbohydrates, proteins and fats for food and shelter. In addition, plants are
valuable source of a wide range of secondary metabolites, which are used as
pharmaceuticals, agrochemicals, flavours, fragrances, colours, bio pesticides and food
additives. With the presence of a wide variety of secondary metabolites, plants have
formed the basis of the traditional medicine systems that have been in existence for
-
phenolic compounds, including tannins and derived poly-phenols and their different
derivatives form one major group of phytochemicals.1 It has been found that in many
plants flavonoids protect them against their pathogenic bacteria and fungi.2 The
is the prime beneficiary of the dietary flavonoids knowing or unknowingly
utilizing them for prevention of diseases or cure. Their antioxidant properties,
cytostatic effects in tumorigenesis and ability to inhibit a broad spectrum of enzymes
have led researchers to regard these compounds as potential anticarcinogens and
cardio protective agents.3
The basic flavonoid structure is the flavan (1) nucleus, which consists of fifteen
carbon atoms arranged in three rings (C6-C3-C6), which are labelled A, B, and C
(Figure 1.1). The various classes of flavonoids differ in the level of oxidation and
pattern of substitution of the C ring, while individual compounds within a class differ
in the pattern of substitution of the A and B rings.4 Chalcones (1,3-diphenyl-2-propen-
1-one, 2) are the biogenetic precursor of flavonoids abundant in edible plants in
different chemical forms. Chalcone based compounds both natural and synthetic are
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|2
very versatile as physiologically active compounds with a diverse array of biological
activities associated with them.
OA
B
C
1 O2
Figure 1.1 Structure of flavan and chalcone.
The therapeutic potential of the chalcone based compounds is supported by
their ease of preparation, potential of oral administration, safety and profound natural
abundance. The last decade witnessed the devotion of tremendous effort around the
world to elucidate the mechanisms of these chalconoids for their unparallel array of
biological activities. Consequently, a number of synthetic methods have also been
developed for the synthesis of this very important class of molecules including the
structural modification of the core chalcone moiety. Chemically, chalcones (2) are
unsaturated carbonyl system. Variation of the core chalcone moiety is mainly based on
used as traditional medicine for different ailments have been reported to contain a
substantial amount of these chalconoids.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|3
In addition to their numerous biological activities, chalcones find a pronounced
application in synthetic organic chemistry. Application of chalcones in the synthesis of
many heterocycles5 and as intermediate in the synthesis of many pharmaceuticals6 has
been well -hydroxychalcone is the main
synthon in the synthesis of different flavonoids (Scheme 1.1). Having such a varied
pharmacological activity and synthetic utility, chalcones have attracted chemists to
develop a large number of synthetic methodologies for their synthesis around the
world.
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
OHOH
Flavone Flavonone
Flavonol
Flavononol
Isoflavone Isoflavonone
OH
Scheme 1.1 Conversion -hydroxychalcone to different flavonoids.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|4
1.2 Biological activities of chalcones
A number of naturally occurring chalcones as well as their derivatives have
been isolated from various sources and identified with different biological activities. A
perusal of the existing literature reflects a number of activities associated with
different chalcones, some representative examples are given in this section.
1.2.1 Anticancer activity
Among the currently identified antitumor agents, chalcones represent an
important class of molecules. Deregulation of apoptosis or programmed cell death, in
multicellular organisms is a major contributor to the survival of tumour cells. The
process of apoptosis can be divided into two parts, sensors and effectors. The sensors
(extrinsic pathway) are responsible for monitoring the extracellular and intracellular
environment for conditions that influence whether a cell should live or die. These
signals regulate the second class of components (intrinsic pathway or mitochondrial
apoptosis pathway), which function to induce apoptotic death. Chalcones have been
found to act through the intrinsic as well as extrinsic apoptosis pathway to prevent
tumour progression.7 Traditions from different geographical regions of the world and
different time periods have documented the extensive use of liquorice (
) for the cure of different human ailments including as an anti-ulcer agent.8
Modern studies have identified different chalcones and flavonoids as the active
ingredients for their activity. Chalcones like isoliquiretigenin (3), licochalcone A (4)
and licochalcone E (5) have been isolated from liquorice and reported to be effective
against a series of human cancer cell lines.9
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|5
O
OHHO OH
Isoliquiretigenin (3)
O
HO MeO
OH
Licochalcone A (4)
O
HO
OMe
OH
Licochalcone E (5)
O
OMeMeO
Flavokawain A (6)
OH
OMe
Xiaolin et al.10 isolated Flavokawain A (6) from Kava ( )
extract, which was found to be a suppressor of bladder tumour growth. In addition to
these natural chalcones, a number of chalcones have been synthesised and reported to
show anticancer activities.
1.2.2 Anti-inflammatory activity
Inflammation is characterized by activated immune cells in which there is a
vicious cycle of tissue destruction and repair due to either irremovable injurious
stimuli or a dysfunction in any component of the normal inflammatory response.11 The
vicitis,
gastritis, and hepatitis, for example, reflect inflammation of the bronchus, colon,
cervix, stomach, and liver, respectively. Many diseases are preceded by inflammation
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|6
and it is already proven that inflammation is a major risk factor for type 2 diabetes,
atherosclerosis, cancer, and other chronic diseases.12 Several naturally occurring
chalcones have been reported to show anti-inflammatory properties. The inhibition of
prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) and nitric oxide (NO) production has been proposed as a
potential therapy for different inflammatory disorders.13
4-Hydroxycorodoin (7), which is reported to occur in
is found to possess anti-inflammatory effect through reduced activation
of the nuclear factor- B (NF- B) p65 and activator protein-1 (AP-1) pathways.14
O
O OH OH
4-Hydroxycorodoin (7)
O
MeO OMe
Flavokawain B (8)
OH
O
HO
OH
OHOH
OH
OH
Urundeuvine A (9)
O
HO
O
HO
OH
OHOH
HOOH
OH
Urundeuvine C (10)
H
H
O
A potent anti-inflammatory compound flavokawain B (8) was isolated from
, it significantly inhibited production of NO, and PGE2 in
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|7
lipopolysaccharide (LPS) -induced RAW 264.7 cells.15 Two dimeric chalcones 9 and
10 were isolated from the stem bark of and were identified
with potent anti-inflammatory activity.16
1.2.3 Antioxidant activity
Free radicals are being formed during normal cellular metabolism and they are
known to contribute to healthy functions in human health and development when they
are not excessive. A mechanism for balancing the formation of free radicals and their
detoxification is essential for normal cellular function. When such a balance is
disrupted as a result of excessive generation of damaging species or low levels of
antioxidants, a cell enters into a state of oxidative stress and is damaged. If the damage
persists, the cell will enter a state of genetic instability that can lead to chronic diseases
including cancer.17
Many chalcones have been isolated from natural sources with impressive
antioxidant properties. Karanjapin (11) was isolated from the root bark of
and found to possess significant antioxidant activity.18 Paratocarpin B (12),
isolated from 19 and butein (13) isolated from was
also identified with antioxidant activity.20
OOH
MeO O
O
OMe
HO
karanjapin (11)
O
O
OH
OH
paratocarpin B (12)
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|8
Xanthohumol (14) a prenyl chalcone present in hops and beer21 and 15, a
prenylated chalcone--glycoside22 isolated from displays
antioxidant activity.
O
OHHO OH
OH
butein (13)
HO
O
OH
OMe
Xanthohumol (14)
OH
O
O OH
15
OH
OHO
HO OH
OH
1.2.4 Antimicrobial activity
The increasing incidence of infection caused by the rapid development of
bacterial resistance to most of the known antibiotics is a serious health problem.23 The
increasing number of multi drug resistant microbes stimulates research efforts for
finding effective nature derived therapeutics.
Salem et al.24 reported the isolation and leishmanicidal activity of chalcones 16
and 17 from methanolic extract of . Prenylated
dihydrochalcones 18 and 19 were isolated from with antimalarial
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|9
activity.25 Panduratin A (20) and hydroxypanduratin A (21) were isolated from
and reported to posses anti HIV26 and anti dangue27 activity.
Isobavachalcone (22) isolated from by ElSohly et al.28 was
identified with activities against AIDS-related opportunistic fungal pathogens
and .
O
CH3OMeHO
H3COH
R
16 R=H17 R=OH
HO OH
OH O
OH
18
HO OH
OH O
OH
19
O HH
OHRO
OH
20 R=CH321 R= H
O
HO OH OH
Isobavachalcone (22)
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|10
1.2.5 Miscellaneous activities
In addition to the above-mentioned ones, there are many other activities
associated with chalconoid compounds. Hydroxy safflor yellow A (23),29 isobutrin
(24)30 and silymarin (25)31 are some hepatoprotective chalconoids/flavonoids isolated
OO
OHOH
OH
O
OHO
OHHO
HOHO
HO
HO
Hydroxysafflor yellow A (23)
OH
OH
OOH
OH
OO
OHHO
Isobutrin (24)
O
O
OH
OH
OHHO
OH
HO
O
O
O
OH
HO
OOH
OHO
OH
Silymarin (25)
O
H3CO OH OH
4-Hydroxyderricin (26)
O
HO OH
Xanthoangelol (27)
OH
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|11
from natural sources. Enoki et al.32 identified 4-hydroxyderricin (26) and
xanthoangelol (27) from that showed strong insulin like activities in
controlling diabetes mellitus. 4-Hydroxyderricin (26) is reported to possess
antihypertensive activities also in rats.33
1.3 Synthesis of Chalcones
In 1880-81 L. Claisen34 and J. G. Schmidt35 published the reports of their
individual research of base catalyzed condensation between an aldehyde and a ketone,
which appear to be the first published report of chalcone preparation. The succeeding
century witnessed an ever-increasing interest of chemists and biologists towards the
synthesis as well as bioactivity studies of these chalconoids resulting numerous
research publications published and patents filed in different countries. Different
variations of Claisen-Schmidt condensation (CSC) using different catalysts or reaction
conditions have been developed. Amidst these numerous methodologies the classical
aqueous base catalysed version of CSC still stands as the most popular method of
chalcone synthesis.36
1.3.1 CSC via Enolate formation
In aldol condensation an enol or an enolate ion reacts with a carbonyl
- -hydroxyketone, followed by a
dehydration to give a conjugated enone. Basically, the CSC is a crossed aldol
-hydrogen and an aldehyde with no
-hydrogen. The base catalysed CSC proceeds via the formation of an enolate of the
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|12
ketone which attacks the aldehydic carbon to form the adduct (A). Finally, elimination
of a water molecule gives the product chalcone (Scheme 1.2). Different inorganic and
organic bases have been employed for catalysing CSC under homogeneous and
heterogeneous reaction conditions. Among them hydroxides of alkali and alkaline
earth metals like NaOH, KOH, Ba(OH)2, LiOH, etc. are prominent.
O O
OH-
H
O
+
O
H
OH
O
-H2O
A
OH-
Scheme 1.2 Mechanism of base catalysed Claisen-Schmidt condensation.
1.3.1.1 NaOH
NaOH is one of the most used bases for the synthesis of chalcones. In these
methods equimolar amounts of the ketone and the aldehyde in ethanol is stirred with 2
to 3 equivalents of the base either in aqueous or non-aqueous conditions. For a
representative example, Cabrera et al.37 synthesized a number of substituted chalcones
employing NaOH (3.0 equiv) as catalyst in anhydrous ethanol (Scheme 1.3). After
completion, the reaction mixture is neutralised with dil. HCl and most of the products
were recrystallised from methanol.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|13
In their studies for the development of relatively small molecules as
antimicrobial agents, Sivakumar et al.38 synthesised a series of chalcones with
different substituents on the aryl rings using NaOH in methanol at room temperature in
3 h of reaction time with more than 80% product yields.
OO O
+i) aq.NaOH, EtOH, rt, overnightR' R R' R1'
2'3'
4'
5'6' 6
5
43
21ii) 10% HCl
R' = H R = H, 4-Cl, 2-Br, 4-Br, 4-OCH3, 4-SCH3, 4-NHCOCH3
R' = 2'-OH R = 4-NO2, 2-NO2, 4-Cl, 4-Br, etc.
Scheme 1.3 Synthesis of chalcones using NaOH.
1.3.1.2 KOH
KOH is another Gr. I base widely used as catalyst in CSC to synthesize
chalcones. Different reports are there39 for the synthesis of substituted chalcones using
aq. KOH as catalyst (Scheme 1.4).
OO O
+i) 50% KOH, EtOH,12 hR' R R' R1'
2'3'
4'
5'6' 6
5
43
21ii) 2M HCl, pH = 3-4
R' = H R = H = H = 4-OMe = H = 3,4-O-CH2-O- = H = 3,4,5-OMe = 3-OMe, 4-OH = 3,4,5-OMe, etc.
Scheme 1.4 Synthesis of chalcones using KOH.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|14
In addition to chalcones, this method was used to prepare some heterocyclic
chalcone analogues40 (Scheme 1.5).
N
O
N
O O
+i) 50% KOH, EtOH,12 hii) 2M HCl, pH = 3-4
78%
OO
+i) 50% KOH, EtOH,12 hii) 2M HCl, pH = 3-4
78%
NH
H
ONH
MeO MeO
Scheme 1.5 Synthesis of heterocyclic chalcone analogues.
1.3.1.3 LiOH.H2O
LiOH.H2O was found to be a highly efficient dual activation catalyst for
Claisen-Schmidt condensation of various aryl methyl ketones with aryl/heteroaryl
aldehydes providing an easy synthesis of 1,3-diaryl-2-propen-1-ones under mild
conditions. Quantitative yields of substituted chalcones were obtained when equimolar
mixture of the ketone and aldehyde was stirred in ethanol at room temperature in
presence of 10 mol% LiOH.H2O in 1-240 min41 (Scheme 1.6). The reactions were
found to be chemoselective with carbonyl substrates bearing halogen atom and nitro
group without any competitive aromatic nucleophilic substitution. The resultant
chalcones did not undergo Michael addition with the ketone enolate.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|15
Ar1COCH3 + Ar2CHO Ar1
O
Ar2i) LiOH.H2O, 1-240 minii) 2% HCl
Ar2 = Ph = 4-OMePh = 4-NMe2Ph = 4-ClPh, etc.
Ar1 = Ph = Ph = Ph = Ph (34 examples).
Scheme 1.6 LiOH.H2O catalysed CSC.
Other bases like Ba(OH)2.8H2O,42 Mg-Al-OtBu hydrotalcite43 was also utilized
for the synthesis of chalcones under homogeneous conditions. Quantitative yields can
be obtained using these methods in substrates where the aromatic ring contains no
hydroxyl group except in the ortho position. With the presence of hydroxyl group on
the phenyl ring, the electrophilicity of the benzaldehyde carbonyl carbon reduces due
to the delocalization of the phenoxide anion formed. This results in decreased product
formation44 (Scheme 1.7).
HO
H
O
-O
H
O
O
H
O-BHB-
Scheme 1.7 Delocalisation of the phenoxide anion formed in presence of base.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|16
However hydroxy groups present in the ortho position are not available for
phenoxide formation owing to intramolecular hydrogen bonding with the carbonyl
oxygen (Scheme 1.8).
R
O
R = H, CH3
OH
R
OH
O
Scheme 1.8 Formation of intramolecular hydrogen bond.
On the other hand the basic salts of hydroxy substituted aromatic carbonyls
precipitate out in the highly alkaline environment.37,39(b) Thus it becomes necessary to
use protecting groups in the preparation of hydroxychalcones under basic
conditions.39(b) The hydroxyl groups are protected by converting it to their THP,40
MOM45 or benzyl ether37 which are stable in basic medium. With hydroxy protected
aromatic carbonyls, Ba(OH)2.8H2O is the catalyst of choice and anhydrous alcohols
are used as solvent in general, to keep the protecting groups intact.
In addition to these inorganic bases there are also reports of using organic
bases for the synthesis of chalcones. Trivedi et al46 used piperidine as catalyst in
CHCl3 at 80 °C for the synthesis of a series of novel coumarinyl chalcone derivatives
for their studies of antiviral activity (Scheme 1.9).
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|17
OR4
R3
R2
R1 OH
O
O
H
O
OR4
R3
R2
R1 OH
O
O
RR
R = H = 4-OH = 4-OCH3 = 4-OC6H5 = 2-NO2 = 3-NO2 = 4-N(CH3), 4-OH = 4-O(CH3), 4-OH = 3,4-di-OCH3
R1 = CH3, R2 = H, R3 = H, R4 = CH(CH3)2R1 = H, R2 = Cl, R3 = CH3, R4 = H
+ piperidine, CHCl380 °C
Scheme 1.9 Synthesis of coumarinyl chalcones.
1.3.2 Heterogeneous & Ecofriendly methods
One of the major drawbacks of these alkali base catalysed methods for
chalcone synthesis is that 2.5 to 3.0 equivalents of catalyst, as well as same equivalents
of mineral acid for its neutralisation is required in the work up of these methods. Like
other homogeneously catalysed methods of organic syntheses47 these are also
criticised for their highly detrimental environmental impact as a large volume of
aqueous waste is generated in the catalyst quench and product separation stage.
Responding to this environmental cry, methods are developed for the synthesis of
chalcones using these alkali bases under environmentally benign reaction conditions.
Rateb et al. reported the synthesis of chalcones under solvent free conditions in
quantitative yields by grinding the methyl ketones and aldehydes with solid NaOH
(1.4 equiv) in 5-10 minutes of reaction time.48 The solid catalyst was removed by
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|18
simple cold aqueous washing and the products were purified by recrystallisation
(Scheme 1.10).
NaOH, Grinding3 -15 min
RCOCH3 R'CHO+ RCOCH=CHR'
R = 2-furyl R' = 2-furyl = 2-thienyl = C6H5 = 4-CH3C6H4 = 4-FC6H4 = 4-ClC6H4
R = 2-naphthyl R' = C6H5 = 4-CH3C6H4 = 4-FC6H4
= 4-CH3C6H4 = 4-ClC6H4 = 2-thienyl
Scheme 1.10 Synthesis of chalcones using NaOH under solvent free condition.
Sarda et al. used NaOH (20 mol%) over neutral Al2O3 at 60 °C to synthesise ten
different chalcones under solvent free condition.49
Solid K2CO3 (10 mol%) in PEG-400 was used to synthesise chalcones. The
reaction mixture was stirred at 90-120 °C for 1.5-2.5 h and the product was
recrystallised after removal of the catalyst by cold aqueous washing (Scheme 1.11).
O
H
O O
RR
R = H, 4-CH3, 4-OCH3, 4-Cl, 4-NO2
+K2CO3, PEG-400
90-120 °C, 1.5-2.5 h
Scheme 1.11 Synthesis of chalcones using K2CO3, PEG-400.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|19
It was found that longer reaction times were needed in the reactions for the products
with high melting points. Higher yields could be obtained in the condensation of
ketones and aldehydes with electron-withdrawing groups in the aromatic ring, such as
-Cl, -Br, and -NO2, than with electron-donating groups, such as -CH3 and -OCH3.50
Two basic activated carbons Na- and Cs-Norit were used to catalyze the CSC
under sonochemical irradiation by C. J. Duran-Valle and his co-workers.51 A new type
of catalyst were prepared by grafting amino groups on sodium and cesium exchanged
X zeolite.52 This new catalyst was successfully applied for the synthesis of chalcones
in solvent free conditions under ultrasonic irradiation.
Solhy et al. synthesised a reusable hydroxyapatite [Ca10(PO4)6(OH)2] and used
with water as co-catalyst for the synthesis of fifteen substituted chalcones53 (Scheme
1.12). They studied the impact of water on the catalyst reactivity and high activation of
the same was observed in its presence. To investigate the origin of this activation,
different organic solvents of similar or higher microwave absorbance as/to water were
also tested, and it was confirmed that water is acting as co catalyst when combined
with hydroxyapatite, making the process highly efficient.
O
H
O O
RR+Hydroxyapetite
H2O, MWR' R'
R' = H R = H = 4-Cl = 3-NO2 = 4-OMe = 4-OH
R' = 4-NO2 R = H = 4-Cl = 3-NO2 = 4-OMe = 4-OH
R' = OMe R = H = 4-Cl = 3-NO2 = 4-OMe = 4-OH
Scheme 1.12 Synthesis of chalcones using reusable hydroxyapetite.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|20
1.3.3 CSC via Enol mode
The acid catalysed version of CSC proceeds through the formation of an enol.
The enol attacks the protonated aldehyde to give the addition product. This is followed
by elimination of a water molecule to give the product chalcone (Scheme 1.13). The
advantage of the CSC via enol mode over the enolate mode is that, it can be directly
applied for the synthesis of hydroxychalcones without prior protection of the hydroxy
group.43
O
H+
OH OH+
+
O
H+
O
H
OH O
-H2O
Scheme 1.13 Mechanism of CSC via enol mode.
CSC via enol mode is advantageous for the preparation of chalcones with base
sensitive groups. Though different mineral acids were used to catalyze this reaction,44
a perusal of the recent literature showed a sharp decline in their use. It is because of
the requirement of harsh reaction conditions,49 formations of unwanted side products36
and associated waste disposal problem54 in realizing most of these methods.
Sipos et al55 used HCl gas saturated in absolute ethanol for the condensation of 4-
hydroxy benzaldehyde with different substituted acetophenones (Scheme 1.14).
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|21
O
H
O O
+ HCl, rtabs. EtOH
R' R'
R' = 3-NO2 = 2-OH, 4-NO2 = 3-OH, 4-NO2 = 3-OH, 6-NO2
OH OH
Scheme 1.14 Claisen-Schmidt condensation using HCl in absolute ethanol.
Eun-Jin et al. used catalytic amount of H2SO4 in methanol for the synthesis of a
variety of substituted chalcones. The method was extended for the synthesis of some
sulfonamide--chalcones and sulfonate--chalcones for their biological studies56
(Scheme 1.15).
O
H
O O
+R1 R1R2 R2H2SO4MeOH
R1 = H R2 = H = OH = OH = NH2 = OH
O
HN OH
SO
OR
R = H, CH3, F, NH2
O
O OHSO
OR
R = H, CH3, F, NH2
Scheme 1.15 Synthesis of substituted chalcones using H2SO4.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|22
In situ generated HCl was used for carrying out this reaction by Petrov et al. by
using SOCl2/EtOH system. Four hydroxy substituted chalcones were also prepared in
addition to other substituted chalcones44 (Scheme 1.16).
O
H
O O
RR+ abs. EtOH, rtR' R'
R' = H R = H = 2-OMe = 3-OMe = 4-OMe = 3-OH = 4-OH = 3-Cl = 4-Cl
SOCl2
R' = 4-OCH3 R = H = 4-OMe = 4-ClR' = 4-Cl R = H = 4-OMe = 4-OH = 4-ClR' = 4-OH R = H
Scheme 1.16 SOCl2/EtOH catalysed synthesis of chalcones.
A novel solid sulfonic acid, bamboo char sulfonic acid was applied to catalyse
the Claisen-Schmidt condensation of substituted benzaldehydes with acetophenones
under solvent-free condition to synthesize chalcones. The solid acid catalyst was
prepared from bamboo sawdust via sulphuric acid charring and sulfonation. Moderate
to good yields of chalcones were obtained in 24 h reaction time.57
Lewis acids provide environmentally benign alternative routes for many
hitherto mineral acid catalysed organic transformations.58 Various Lewis acids have
been successfully applied for the synthesis of chalcones also.
Kumar et al.59 used ZrCl4 both in solvent free and in solvent (dry DCM)
reaction conditions to catalyze the CSC (Scheme 1.17). In this fast and clean reaction,
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|23
substituted chalcones were synthesised in moderate to good yields (70-93%) using 20
mol% of the catalyst. No solvent was used when one or both the substrates are liquid
and anhydrous CH2Cl2 was used when both the substrates are solid. Use of 60-80
mol% of ZrCl4 resulted in the formation of 1,4-conjugate addition product in addition
to the chalcone.
R1 = Ph R2 = Ph = Ph = 4-OMePh = 4-OMePh = Ph = 4-OMePh = 4-OMePh = 2,6-ClPh = Ph = 2-C4H3O = 4-OMePh = 2-NO2Ph = Ph
R1 R2
O O+ neat/ dry DCM, rt
ZrCl4 (20 mol%)
O
R1 R2H
R1 = 3-NO2Ph R2 = 2-OHPh = 4-NO2Ph = Ph = Ph = 4-OHPh = 4-OMePh = 4-OHPh = Naphthyl = Ph = Naphthyl = 4-OMePh = Ph = 4-OC2H4NC4H8Ph
Scheme 1.17 Synthesis of chalcones using ZrCl4.
Narender et al. used BF3-Et2O for the synthesis of chalcones in dry dioxane in
a very short reaction time with very good product yield.36 They applied this method for
the synthesis of chalcones with a varied substituents (Scheme 1.18).
R' = CH3 R = 3,4-OMePh = Ph = Ph = 4-OHPh = 4-OHPh = 4-OAcPh = 4-OHPh = 4-AcNHPh = 4-OMePh = 3-OHPh = 2-NO2Ph
R' R R'
O
RO O
+BF3-Et2O,
dry Dioxane, rtH
R' = 4-NO2Ph R = 4-OMePh = 2,4-OMePh = 2-NO2Ph = 4-OHPh = 3,4-OMePh = 2,4-ClPh = 3,4-OMePh = 2,4-OMePh = 3,4-FPh = 3-OHPh = 4-OMePh
Scheme 1.18. Chalcone synthesis using BF3-Et2O.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|24
In addition to its applicability in synthesising hydroxychalcones, another
feature of this method is that it can be applied for substrates with base sensitive groups
like esters and amides (Figure 1.2).
O
O
O
OH
O
HN
O
OMe
O
OHO
O
OMeOC16H33
OMe
Figure 1.2 Synthesised chalcones with base sensitive substrates using BF3-Et2O.
K. V. Sashidhara and his co-workers used readily available, mild and
inexpensive Lewis acid molecular iodine in dry dioxane for the synthesis of
substituted chalcones60 (Scheme 1.19).
OO O
+ I2 (5 mol%)R' R R' R1'2'
3'4'
5'6' 6
5
43
2140°C, (15-20 min)
Dioxane
R' = H R = 4-OEt = 4-Me = 4-OEt = 4-OMe = 4-OEt = 4-Cl = 4-OEt = H = 2-OMe
R' = 4-Me R = 2-OMe = 4-OMe = 2-OMe = 4-Cl = 2-OMe = 4-Me = 3-OEt, 4-OH = 4-OMe = 3-OEt, 4-OH = 4-Cl = 3-OEt, 4-OH
Scheme 1.19 Molecular iodine catalysed CSC.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|25
Wang et al.61 used molecular iodine for catalyzing the CSC between different
ketones and aldehydes under solvent free and grinding conditions. In this very simple
reaction, chalcones were synthesised in 83-95% yield in 5-10 minutes of reaction time
(Scheme 1.20).
R' = H R = 4-CH3 = H = 3-NO2 = H = 4-N(CH3)2 = H = 2-OH = 4-CH3 = H
OO O
+ I2 (10 mol%)R' R R' R1'2'
3'4'
5'6' 6
5
43
21Grinding, rt
5-10 min
R' = 4-NO2 R = H = 2,4-OMe = 3-NO2 = 4-Br = 4-OH = 3-OMe = 2-NO2 = 2,4-OH = 4-N(CH3)2
Scheme 1.20 I2 catalysed synthesis of chalcones by grinding.
In a recent report, Siddiqui et al.62 synthesized a series of chromonyl chalcones
employing Zn-(L-proline)2 as a recyclable Lewis acid catalyst in water. The catalyst
was reused for five consecutive cycles without any loss of activity (Scheme 1.21).
O
O OR
Q
O+
H2O, Zn(L-proline)2reflux, 15-30 min
O
OR
Q
O
N
N
HO
HO
OQ = etc., R = H, CH3, Cl
Scheme 1.21 Synthesis of chromonyl chalcones using Zn-(L-proline)2.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|26
1.3.4 Ionic liquids in catalyzing CSC
In recent years, ionic liquids have been emerged as a powerful alternative to
conventional organic solvents due to their particular properties, such as undetectable
vapour pressure, wide liquid range, as well as ease of recovery and reuse, making them
a greener alternative to volatile organic solvents.63 Different research groups have
investigated the applicability of these ionic liquids in the synthesis of chalcones.
Dong et al.64 used some sulfonic acid functionalised task specific ionic liquids
(TSIL) for catalysing the CSC to synthesise chalcones. Seven TSILs were studied and
found to effectively catalyse the CSC (Scheme 1.22).
R1 R2
O O+
TSIL
O
R1 R2H140°C
R1 = Ph R2 = Ph R1 = Ph R2 = 3-ClPh = Ph = 4-OMePh = 4-OMePh = Ph = Ph = 3-OMePh = 4-OMePh = 4-OMePh = Ph = 2-OMePh = 4-OMePh = 4-ClPh = Ph = 4-ClPh = 4-NO2Ph = 4-OMePh
TSILs: [TMPSA][HSO4]
[TEPSA][HSO4],
[TBPSA][HSO4], etc.
Scheme 1.22 Sufonic acid functionalised TSIL catalysed synthesis of chalcones.
Shen et al.54 reported an efficient and environmentally friendly solvent-free
method for the synthesis of chalcone using Brønsted acidic ionic liquids as dual
catalyst and solvent. Ionic liquids like [(HSO3)BBIM]BF4 catalysed the reaction most
efficiently at 140 °C and the catalyst was reused for three cycles without any
appreciable loss of activity.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|27
Four readily available and economic TSILs viz. [TEBSA][HSO4], [TEBSA][NO3],
[TEBSA][CF3COO] and [TEBSA][pTSO] have been used as recyclable catalysts for
the CSC of benzaldehydes and acetophenones to synthesize chalcones by Qian et al.65
A clean and efficient method for the synthesis of chalcones using reusable
phosphonium ionic liquid catalyst [PhosILCl] was developed by Pawar et al.
Chalcones were synthesised in high yields using this ecofriendly method in 2.5 to 3.5
h reaction time.66
1.3.5 Miscellaneous Methods of Chalcone synthesis
Apart from Claisen-Schmidt condensation, some other routes were also
developed for the synthesis of chalcones. In particular Suzuki reaction using phenyl
boronic acids, Julia-Kocienski olefination and Wittig reaction were studied for the
synthesis of chalcones.
1.3.5.1 Via Suzuki reaction
Palladium-catalyzed Suzuki cross coupling of haloarenes with arylboronic acid is
among the most powerful C-C bond-formation reactions available to synthetic organic
chemists.67 Like in many other organic syntheses, palladium catalysed cross coupling
reactions find their application in chalcone synthesis also. Eddarir et al.68 developed a
method for the synthesis of chalcones based on the Suzuki reaction either between
cinnamoyl chlorides and phenylboronic acids or between benzoyl chlorides and
phenylvinylboronic acids (Scheme 1.23). The reaction is not affected by substituents
located either on the acyl chloride or on the boronic acid.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|28
Cl
OR''R'
R
BOH
HO+
Cs2CO3, toluene
O
R
R'R''
R R' R''
H H HH CF3 HH H CF3H NO2 HOMe H HOMe OMe H
(PPh3)4Pd
Scheme 1.23 Chalcone synthesis via Suzuki reaction.
Mohammad et al.69 developed a method for direct cross-coupling reaction of
benzoyl chlorides and potassium styryltrifluoroborates to the corresp -
unsaturated aromatic ketones in the presence of PdCl2(dtbpf) catalyst under microwave
irradiation. This method was used for the synthesis of chalcones with a variety of
substituents (Scheme 1.24).
O
R1 R2BF3K
Cl
O
R1 R2PdCl2(dtbpf)
K2CO3, 1,4-DioxaneMW, 140°C, 30 min
+
8 examples.
Scheme 1.24 Pd (II) catalysed cross-coupling reaction in the synthesis of chalcones.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|29
1.3.5.2 Julia-Kocienski olefination
Kumar et al. developed 2-(Benzo[]thiazol-2-ylsulfonyl)-1-phenylethanones as
a new reagent for the synthesis of chalcones via Julia-Kocienski olefination with
aldehydes in presence of a base in good to excellent yields70 (Scheme 1.25).
OS
O O
S
N+ R1CHO
DBU
Ph
O
R1
THF, 13-21h
S
NSH
OBr
i) K2CO3, acetone, 30 min, rtii) mCPBA, DCM, rt, 1.5h
R1 = Ph = 4-OMePh = 4-OCH2CH2ClPh = 4-FPh = 4-ClPh, etc.
Scheme 1.25 Julia-Kocienski olefination in the synthesis of chalcones.
1.3.5.3 Chalcone synthesis by Fries Rearrangement
Jeon et al.71 prepared chalcones using aryl cinnamates by Fries rearrangements
catalysed by TiCl4 in moderate to good yields (Scheme 1.26).
O
OTiCl4
130°C
O OH
R1 = H, 3-Me, 4-Me, 3-OMe, 4-OMe, 3-OH, 2-Me, 2-OMe
37-70%
R1
R1
Scheme 1.26 TiCl4 mediated chalcone synthesis via Fries rearrangement.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|30
1.3.5.4 Via Wittig reaction
The Wittig reaction is a powerful method for the regio- and stereo controlled
construction of carbon-carbon double bonds. Wittig reaction was also used for
synthesising chalcones.72,73 In these methods reaction of a stable ylide with aldehydes
is used for synthesising the desired chalcones (Scheme 1.27).73
CHO
COR2Ph3P COR2
water
R1 = H R2 = Ph = 4-NO2 = Ph, etc.
R1 R1
Scheme 1.27 Synthesis of chalcones using stable ylides.
1.4 Chalcones in organic synthesis
Chalcones find many applications in organic synthesis as intermediates.
Flavanones are important naturally occurring pharmacological compounds and are
valuable precursors for the synthesis of flavanoids. Preparation of flavanones (29) has
been carried out by intramolecular cyclis -hydroxychalcone (28) under
various conditions using acids, bases, thermolysis, electrolysis and photolysis.74
Different catalysts like acetic acid,37 piperidine,74 CH3COONa,75 H3PO4,76 PEG-40077
have been employed for this conversion (Scheme 1.28).
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|31
O
OH
O
O
2928
Scheme 1.28 Conversion of 2 -hydroxychalcone to flavonone.
Flavones (30 -hydroxychalcones are refluxed in DMSO in
presence of I237 and it can be further transformed to flavonol (31) by treatment with
HOF.CH3CN78 (Scheme 1.29).
O
OH
O
OI2, DMSO
reflux
O
OHOF.CH3CN
1 minOH
30 3128
Scheme 1.29 Synthesis of flavones and flavonol from 2 -hydroxychalcone.
2,3-Dihydroflavanols (32) can be obtained from chalcones using NaOH-
H2O2,74 or diethylamine-H2O279 (Scheme 1.30).
O
OH
O
O
OH
28 32
Scheme 1.30 Synthesis of 2,3-dihydroflavanol.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|32
-Hydroxychalcones can be converted to their corresponding isoflavone (33)
and isoflavonone (34) by the action of thallium nitrate trihydrate followed by
-double bond80 (Scheme 1.31).
(i) Tl(NO3).3H2O, DCM:MeOH(ii) 1N HCl, MeOH, reflux
O
O
O
O
10% Pd-C, HCO2NH4acetone-methanol
OH
O 33
33
28
34
Scheme 1.31 Synthesis of isoflavone and isoflavonones.
1.5 Conclusion
With the presence of numerous secondary metabolites, plants have been a
source of medicinal products from time immemorial and many useful drugs were
developed from these plant sources. It is clear that plants will continue to be a major
source of new drug leads. Effective drug development will depend on
multidisciplinary collaboration embracing natural product lead discovery and
optimization through the application of total and diversity oriented synthesis.
Chalcone, the synthetic precursor of many plant derived secondary metabolites, is a
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|33
privileged structure with varied biological and synthetic utilities. With the replacement
of homogeneously catalysed classical yield oriented methods of their synthesis with
environmentally benign methods and with advanced techniques of biological studies,
chalcone based research is gaining momentum. The impressive number of publications
coming out from different laboratories around the world in the preceding years clearly
indicates the possibility of the development of chalcone based drugs for various
human ailments coming to the market in the near future.
References
1. Rao, S. R.; Ravishankar, G. A. 2002, , 101-152.
2. Cowan, M. M. . 1999, , 564-582.
3. Skibola, C. F.; Smith, M. T. 2000, , 375-383.
4. Pietta, P. G. . 2000, , 1035-1042.
5. Powers, D. G.; Casebier, D. S.; Fokas, D.; Ryan, W. J.; Troth, J. R.; Coffen, D.
L. 1998, , 4085-4096.
6. Perozo-Rondon, E.; Martín-Aranda, R. M.; Casal, B.; Duran-Valle, C. J.; Lau,
W. N.; Zhang, X. F.; Yeung, K. L. 2006,, 183-187.
7. Liu, X.; Kim, C. N.; Yang, J.; Jemmerson, R.; Wang, X. 1996, , 147-
157.
8. Fiore, C.; Eisenhut, M.; Ragazzi, E.; Zanchin, G.; Decio, A.
. 2005, , 317-324.
9. a) Takahashi, T.; Takasuka, N.; ligo, M.; Baba, M.; Nishino, H.; Tsuda, H.;
Okuyama, T. . 2004, , 448-453; b) Xiao, X-Y.; Hao, M.; Yang,
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|34
X-Y.; Ba, Q.; Li, M.; Ni, S-J.; Wang, L-S.; Du, X. . 2011, , 69-
75; c) Yoon, G.; Jung, Y. D.; Cheon, S. H. . 2005, , 694-
695.
10. Zi, X.; Simoneau, A. R. . 2005, , 3479-3486.
11. Westbrook, A. M.; Szakmary, A.; Schiest, R. H. . 2010, , 40-59.
12. Yadav, V. R.; Prasad, S.; Sung, B.; Agrawal, B. B. . 2011, ,
295-309.
13. Nowakowska, Z. . 2007, , 125-137.
14. Feldman, M.; Tanabe, S.; Epifano, F.; Genovese, S.; Curini, M.; Grenier, D.
. 2011, , 26-31.
15. Lin, C-T.; Kumar, K. J. S.; Tseng, Y-H.; Wang, Z-J.; Pan, M-Y.; Xiao, J-H.;
Chien, S-C.; Wang, S-Y. . 2009, , 6060-6065.
16. Viana, G. S. B.; Bandeira, M. A. M.; Matos, F. J. A. 2003, ,
189-195.
17. a) Spallolz, J. E. . 1994, , 45-64; b) Ugir, H. S.;
Bhattacharya, S. . 2007, , 1149-1154.
18. Ghosh, A.; Mandal, S.; Banerji, A.; Kar, M.; Banerji, J. .
2009, , 209-210.
19. Chin, Y-W.; Jung, H-A.; Liu, Y.; Su, B-N.; Castoro, J. A.; Keller, W. J.;
Pereira, M. A.; Kinghorn, A. D. . 2007, , 4691-4697.
20. Lee, E. H.; Song, D-G.; Lee, J. Y.; Pan, C-H.; Um, B. H.; Jung, S. H.
. 2008, , 1626-1630.
21. Miranda, C. L.; Stevens, J. F.; Ivanov, V.; McCall, M.; Frezi, B.; Deinzer, M.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|35
L.; Buhler, D. R. 2000, 3876-3884.
22. Cioffi, G.; Escobar, L. M.; Braca, A.; Tommasi, N. D. . 2003, ,
1061-1064.
23. Saleh, M.; Abbott, S.; Perron, V.; Lauzon, C.; Penney, C.; Zacharie, B.
. 2010, , 945-949.
24. Salem, M. M.; Werbovetz, K. A. . 2005, , 108-111.
25. Carroll, A. R.; Fechner, G. A.; Smith, J.; Guymer, G. P.; Quinn, R. J.
. 2008, , 1479-1480.
26. Cheenpracha, S.; Karalai, C.; Ponglimanont, C.; Subhdhirasakul, S.;
Tewtrakul, S. . 2006, , 1710-1714.
27. Kiat, T. S.; Pippen, R.; Yosof, R.; Ibrahim, H.; Khalid, N.; Rahman, N. A.
. 2006, , 3337-3340.
28. ElSohly, H. N.; Joshi, A. S.; Nimrod, A. C.; Walker, L. A.; Clark, A. M.
. 2001, , 87-89.
29. Zhang, Y.; Guo, J.; Dong, H.; Zhao, X.; Zhou, L.; Li, X.; Liu, J.; Niu, Y.
. 2011, , 438-444.
30. Gupta, S. R.; Ravindranath, B.; Seshadri, T. R. 1970, , 2231-
2235.
31. Dixit, N.; Baboota, S.; Kohli, K.; Ahmad, S.; Ali, J. . 2007,
, 172-179.
32. Enoki, T.; Ohnogi, H.; Nagamine, K.; Kudo, Y.; Sugiyama, K.; Tanabe, M.;
Kobayashi, E.; Sagawa, H.; Kato, I. . 2007, , 6013-
6017.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|36
33. Ogawa, H.; Ohno, M.; Baba, K. . 2005, , 19-
23.
34. Claisen, L.; Claparede, A. . 1881, , 349.
35. Schmidt, J. G. . 1880, , 2342.
36. Narender, T.; Reddy, K. P. . 2007, , 3177-3180.
37. Cabrera, M.; Simoens, M.; Falchi, G.; Lavaggi, M. L.; Piro, O. E.; Castellano,
E. E.; Vidal, A.; Azqueta, A.; Monge, A.; de Cerain, A. L.; Sagrera, G.;
Seoane, G.; Cerecettoa, H.; Gonzaleza, M. . 2007, ,
3356-3367.
38. Sivakumar, P. M.; Seenivasan, S. P.; Kumar, V.; Doble, M.
. 2007, , 1695-1700.
39. a) Lv, P-S.; Sun, J.; Luo, Y.; Yang, Y.; Zhu, H-L. .
2010, , 4657-4660; b) Chimenti, F.; Bizzarri, B.; Manna, F.; Bolasco, A.;
Secci, D.; Chimenti, P.; Granese, A.; Rivanera, D.; Lilli, D.; Scaltrito, M. M.;
Brenciagila, M. I. . 2005, , 603-607; c) Boumendjel,
A.; Boccard, J.; Carrupt, P-A.; Nicolle, E.; Blanc, M.; Geze, A.; Choisnard, L.;
Wouessidjewe, D.; Matera, L.; Dumontet, C. . 2008, , 2307-
2310; d) Bhat, B. A.; Dhar, K. L.; Puri, S. C.; Saxena, A. K.; Shanmugavel,
M.; Qazi, G. N. 2005, , 3177-3180.
40. Montes-Avila, J.; Diaz-Camacho, S. P.; Siacairos-Felix, J.; Delgado-Vargas,
F.; Rivero, I. A. . 2009, , 6780-6785.
41. Bhagat, S.; Sharma, R.; Sawant, D. M.; Sharma, L.; Chakraborti, A. K.
2006, , 20-24.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|37
42. Manna, F.; Chimenti, F.; Fioravanti, R.; Bolasco, A.; Secci, D.; Chimenti, P.;
Ferlini, C.; Scambia, G. . 2005, , 4632-4635.
43. Kantam, M. L.; Prakash, B. V.; Reddy, C. V. . 2005, , 1971-
1978.
44. Petrov, O.; Ivanova, Y.; Gernova, M. . 2008, , 315-316.
45. Khupse, R. S.; Erhardt, P. W. . 2007, , 1507-1509.
46. Trivedi, J. C.; Bariwal, J. B.; Upadhyay, K. D.; Naliapara, Y. T.; Joshi, S. K.;
Pannecouque, C. C.; Clercq, E. D.; Shah, A. K. . 2007, ,
8472-8474.
47. Clark, J. H. . 2002, , 791-797.
48. Rateb, N. M.; Zohdi, H. F. . 2009, , 2789-2794.
49. Sarda, S. R.; Jadhav, W. N.; Bhusare, S. R.; Wasmatkar, S. K.; Dake, S. A.;
Pawar, R. P. . 2009, , 265-269.
50. Cao, Y-Q.; Dai, Z.; Zhang, R.; Chen, B-H. . 2005, , 1045-
1049.
51. Duran-Valle, C. J.; Fonseca, I. M.; Calvino-Casilda, V.; Picallo, M.; Lopez-
Peinado, A. J.; Martin-Aranda, R. M. 2005, , 500-506.
52. Perozo-Rondon, E.; Martín-Aranda, R. M.; Casal, B.; Duran-Valle, C. J.; Lau,
W. N.; Zhang, X. F.; Yeung, K. L. 2006,, 183-187.
53. Solhy, A.; Tahir, R.; Sebti, S.; Skouta, R.; Bousmina, M.; Zahouily, M.;
Larzek, M. 2010, , 189-193.
54. Shen, J.; Wang, H.; Liu, H.; Sun, Y.; Liu, Z. 2008,
, 24-28 and references cited therein.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|38
55. Sipos, G. Y.; Sirokmán, F. 1964, , 489.
56. Kim, E-J.; Ryu, H. W.; Curtis-Long, M. J.; Han, J.; Kim, J. Y.; Cho, J. K.;
Kang, D.; Park, K. H. . 2010, , 4237-4239.
57. Xu, Q.; Yang, Z.; Yin, D.; Zhang, F. . 2008, , 1579-1582.
58. Corma, A.; Gercía, A. . 2003, , 4307-4366.
59. Kumar, A.; Atanksha. 2007, , 212-216.
60. Sashidhara, K. V.; Rosaiah, J. N.; Kumar, A. . 2009, , 2288-
2296.
61. Wang, H.; Zeng, J. . 2009, , 1209-1212.
62. Siddiqui, Z. N.; Musthafa, T. N. M. . 2011, , 4008-4013.
63. Hallett, J. P.; Welton, T. . 2011, , 3508-3576; Dong, F.; Jian, C.;
Zhenghao, F.; Kai, G.; Zuliang, L. . 2008, , 1924-1927.
64. Dong, F.; Jian, C.; Zhenghao, F.; Kai, G.; Zuliang, L. . 2008, ,
1924-1927.
65. Qian, H.; Liu, D. . 2011, , 1146-1149.
66. Sarda, S. R.; Jadhav, W. N.; Tekale, S. U.; Jadhav, G. V.; Patil, B. R.; Gajanan
S. Suryawanshi, G. S.; Pawar, R. P. . 2009, , 481-484.
67. Chang, C-P.; Huang, Y-L.; Hong, F-E. 2005, , 3835-3839.
68. Eddarir, S.; Cotelle, N.; Bakkoura, Y.; Rolandoa, C. . 2003,
, 5359-5363.
69. Al-Masum, M.; Ng, E.; Wai, M. C. . 2011, , 1008-1010.
70. Kumar, A.; Sharma, S.; Tripathi, V. D.; Srivastava, S. 2010, ,
9445-9449.
Chalcones: Chemistry & Bioactivity CHAPTER I
|39
71. Jeon, J-H.; Yang, D-K.; Jun, J-G. 2011, , 65-70.
72. Xu, C.; Chen, G.; Huang, X. . 1995, , 559-561.
73. Dambacher, J.; Zhao, W.; El-Batta, A.; Anness, R.; Jiang, C.; Bergdahl, M.
. 2005, , 4473-4477.
74. Tanka, K.; Sugino, T. . 2001,, 133-134.
75. Chimenti, F.; Fioravanti, R.; Bolasco, A.; Chimenti, P.; Secci, D.; Rossi, F.;
L. . 2010, , 1273-1279.
76. Chen, D-U.; Kuo, P-Y.; Yang, D-Y. . 2005, , 2665-
2668.
77. Kumar, D.; Patel, G.; Mishra, B. G.; Varma, R. S. . 2008, ,
6974-6976.
78. Golan, E.; Hagooly, A.; Rozen, S. . 2004, , 3397-3399.
79. Saxena, S.; Makrandi, J. K.; Grover, S. K. 1985, 110-111.
80. Khupse, R. S.; Erhardt, P. W. . 2008, , 275-277.