27

国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!"# $%&'()*+,-.#

Page 2: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!"

!" #$%&'()*+,-

. /01234&567234&'()*89,:;+<=

>1?@ABCDE5'()*;FGH>

. IJK2LIMNO5'()*;,:

#$%&'()*+,-./0)1234567897:;<=>?@1ABCDE

9)FGHIJK-LMNO7PQ<IRSTUV)W.XY7/0ZUV7[)W\

]^_`CDabB@= cdefghijkl.mn7NOopiETqrs@tuv1

wx@yzSmY{=|}~@1��7����K��i��]T.X

cdefgh7yz�[email protected]^_`2�CD����������Bh=1^_

`CDabB�Ka��t�uuu�����tvr��{c^_`� O�¡¢Bh�KA

B£¤7mn7¥¦�""u�����tvr��i§¨1`©��)ª¨.cdefgh

7yzi�«)¬­¢®¯X°ZJ)op±²=LMNO)³T]=1tu´7tuµ©@

¶u��i·¸{S1µ¹�KyzS]T.º6)³T]=1tu´7tuµ©@tu��i·

¸{S]T.Xop�7»*{Z.¼½=1¾�¿Àd½1ÁÂéÄÅÆÇȽ1É

¡@ÊËl.Ì͵Î7ÏÍ1yEabÄÐÑÒÓÔÑÕÑ7Ö×Æ1gØzÙ7ÚÆ

ZÛ@W.X

P 5'()*;2<Q=RST

Y7/0Z|}~ZNOiyzl.Y{I@ÜmÝÞ{S]1ß7/0ZY{Iàá

K-.X

�q�âãri¬­äåæçIèSåéê)Z\]T.ëì1âãr7¸­ZTíîiÖ

ïl.mn)c2�7ðÛF=2�@D].h{T0ñ�I2�AB)òó)ô�,

- c2�ðÛFCõhZÛ)ö��÷Óø{S]�ù.úûIüåZ\]T.Xâ1

ãrCD���7s)Fý6~Z¬¢iþÿS]Tm ) cdefgh7!"I`1

Ä(#$CDabB�KÕ%&'Ñ)(Ã,-mX

�)�^_`CDabB=*¹�K c+,-.�� c/01À234 c5677Îg1 h h

Ø cârº62�3438<jkNO c9:Se7 �;<=ur��K��>r?h h h

@ câãr7ö��÷Óø34jkhZÛ1âãr7ëì~Z@A)Bá.NOi�

CNDEÄûsº6{F6{Z\]NOiGHS]ÜmyIIW­1Y7Y{)/\

](#$@FJK7L2IW­cdefghIM&ÑN)GH,-mX

� � c h� �/ ��tOr�)`IÙPSm QC�R STå­jk`ûB� UV WXYSZ

I ce7i[{S]LmZ2�Ð\]÷Ói!^S1ðÛF7�_8ÄM`8iD1

�l.hmn)adefgbi�`~)yzl.Y{i(c,-mX

! 5'()*;+GHUV

¡`)ª¨.��tvr�)Eù-mcdefgh7yzUViJ.{1du(#7tuv

wx@Eù-1gØe=)Ø/ìIfg~)üTI1>wx@=hØiì7ìj@yz

Page 3: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!=

S]T.Xk

lSm56e

=!�"d=m1

qwx�n!!

[email protected]

Øox@pF

üT7=qû

r�"swx�

@ßT@ûg

ZÛ7WÆz

Ù�¶"wx 1âãrzÙ[email protected]@�

1 1 1[x{Z\]y|¿��)Wm\mº6@pFüT7=z{|@ ßT@45B ð}B

âãr~�D�º61u7�{S]�z�Ä��B7�@W.X

ër��n]yzSm^_(�����e7�56esdsm cùåùåM�Ñ�h�

7y|�K��?@1[x~Z��i�\m����Z�z{|�=ß7/0)�S]å

-mX

c��u0Z7@�ܧ¨?SmX�b!um@ÁÂS?SmI�n]7�JZ7@�

SklS]å-.���@SmI1ÁÂ�bi�á.BÁ�IW­�Ü?SmX

qûriBo{Sm7@�ýÄ NËý7_¡1ª¢£ZÛ¤óZ¥AIW­?Sm

I12�7Só7��)/\]@Ai¦§l.NI¨î?SmX©N7ª]«Ñ¬­1

©­7®T¯S1_¯ZÛ=�]kl�IET?SmI°)¥A=Zå±S®@Tm7

IÇ*~@SmX©Ni¬\]©²14³ s)=´µÄº¶@ sI·¸1¹n]º

»Z�¼½�&@SmI567À2I>?­W¾@W\m{¿\]ª­?lXÖÀ�)

{\]FÁTìe@SmIðÂ-6Ã{ðÛF)³T]àá.ÄB)Z\m{1Å"i

ÆT]ÇÜÈ®@T?lX

�n]y|SmÉdefgÊI�ËS?SmI12�73m°7��6Ìi¬.Y{

IpF�Í@1��S]Tm¯Tm#©BV7Î�)žS]T?lX)Ø/ì7ìj

@=kl�¡Ï7ÐÑFZå�Ò7�36Ã)ZKZT7@Óî=V}7fgiàám

T7@lI1Ô�x1Õ%ÖZÛqûr7ÙÌ7×yÄÖÀ�7¯¦iØ.Y{I@A

@W.{¿\]T?l hX

W 5'()*;+XY

2�CD����������B{`CDabB=1

cdefgh7ÙÚ)³T]1'ÑÛÖÜÕc=Ýn?

Þ®�ß2�@³å.defghÄcàÑ&áÑâhZ

Ûi¬�S]ãä7åæiç.è�1ék2�Kêëi

ìT]7íîB7Hï1yEabB7¢ð<Ä��)³

T]ñò)óôSmcõ�Æh7¬�ZÛö¹~Z¬¢

iET(#$7yEabBi÷øS]T.X

¡CDabB=Y7cdefgh)klSm56ÄÖ

!"#

"!$#

$!%#

%!&#

&!'#

()*

+,-

./

012

345

67./

89:

;<=

!"#$

%&'(

)*+

,-.

/0 12 34 35 6 6 6 7 896:4 7; 3 6 3 < 8: = ; ; ;>? < = 3 37< = 8 6 6 7 = 8 8 6 8@ =; =6 3 6 6 7 89=7; 7: = 6 3 : 73 ; 5 ; 5

A0 12 7; 73 8 6 6 8 <77 8= 8 7 7 5 8: 3 7 8>? 83 = < 8 6 8 5=8 < 8 7 6 3 86 8 8 8@ 34 7< 4 8 6 7 89353 78 7 = 7 : 7: = 8 3 8

B0 12 7= 73 8 6 6 6 <;6 : 7 3 3 < 88 = 8 3 ;>? 83 6 6 6 8 6 4 6 6 8 6 6 6 8@ 7; 73 8 6 8 6 <;4 : 7 = 3 < 88 ; 8 3 ;

C@ 12 4< 47 7 6 6 3 79;<6 =4 5 ; 4 76 =: 88 5 86 88>? 78 47 86 8 8 8 :<5 88 7 3 6 ; 8= 3 7 8 8@ 864 :6 87 8 8 = 39;=5 ;: 4 4 4 7; 53 8= 4 88 87

D&84"EFGHIJKLMCNOPQRSTUVSWXY+NZZZ[ZZZ\ZZZ]

^]_

NZZZZZ[ZZZZZ_ `abc_

QZd

Page 4: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!"

#$%&'()*+,-'./012345678)9:;<=>?*@ABCDE?*

F % G % HIJ@K LCMN?OKP QRSTUVCWXYZ PJ[\S-IT \S-IT

P]^%W!YCUV_`a[QRbKcd?eSJSKF

G\S@PfITgPHhZ Gijkhlm@gP_hlTH_n[op%q@h%

Grjs_i^T GtubKvw_hlT GxS@rjs_hlTHCyhzKFH H

G{|}tH(QRST~(G��C��(z@&�bK��(mITH_;:Y%q

@hG��C*A(QRbK��(mITH_��Yh%����P��[PC��_}

t?��(��SJ@KgP_�-KF

q(%�����(��IT)*+,C./012CMN?OKP%��STgPP

SJ G����C��H_n[op%q@hG��[C ¡ G¢AC£¤ G¥¦/% H H

§¨.C©ª G|«¬­®¯°PC3±H?²³J@KFH

´~CG{|}tH(�@J Gµ¶)9ST@¬hl·¸)9ST@HP¹^T+%

,ZXXYPº»¼(o@F

½¾¿ÀhZ G{|}t(QRSJOJ´ÁhÂ'm-IT��[CÃÄ?ÂKg%

H%G %Å ÆP_hlT ´C��[Ts(ÇÈJ@KPgÉ?ÊIJ@pTË(Z {|}t

Z�ÌÍ@Pf@ÁbCh´~[ÎÏSJ)9ST@ GÐÑhZ%ÒTÓÔ(�IH%

J['IJ@TA?%gC}thZ½Õh�KAh%��[Ts_Ö-Ã�×ØS%�

lpmIJp·TÙ_bKHm�%´~CÚÛ(7ÜbKÝ_Þ@F

!"#$%&'()#*+

gC��(UV¬ª#$¬)*+,-'Cß@7Ü(¹^KTË(%´~CÛàPá

â(�@Jãäå+,æCçÒ$ZqC��(èIJp·TF

G´aéZêëìPSJíî=hïuðñC}t?)9ST_%´~ZòêëìAB

C×N?.ó1ìSJØ78C}t?ôõST@Fö|Ï÷øù_ª#$(úûSJü

{@CUV_ý^%vw��þCQR$_ÿmpmK d_!'·KgP-' Å{|%

}tÆCäå"N?�C��(ã�(#^K-LC$%?D&ST@F'LCTË(%

()$P*+häå"N?,|¼(-.bK$%[D&ST@F/012äå+,æP

C34?5(6ËKPP[(%��C�Ts?M781ë¨91:1C;×?D&ST

@ HF

<=ã(>ÈK?×:XaéCG{|}tHZQRSTUVZ@ùCgP%|«%ª#

$%��C)*+,æ-'Þ@AB?CJDEST G{|}tH?F(SJ��(GF

×&·T�8�HZ%��(>ÈKIÿaäåCJPmÓ%ñK��C�LM(MN�

phz�F

ÁT%L·O·C��h*�·KG{|}tH?%PØQRPäå+,æ_ÃvPm

IJSTS×U(V@TgPZ%Iÿaäå?WXbKYh%´~C*ZCzÓ$?e

[bK[CP\^KF

5]2 ^Ã>

Page 5: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!"

!"#$%&'()*+,-.(/0*12345

6 -.(/0*1782345

#$%&'()*+,-./01234512678931-&:;<=>?@AB

CDEF@GH>?IJKLMN&348<=OPQRLMST-UVW>?@ABX

Y67Z[\[]^_6`Ba^-#$%8bFJc3AMdefEgh@ABijA

BkENlmnokB,pq8@a^7fEN

96:.(/0*13;<

rsGcO-tuv?sRw7,RQ-x?8fEYnyzJ{`-|}nfE~

�1'(�������8��7-����2-�1���nbE��78��cg

JARO4G�n�G�E]_7fEN

9 :783=>?

��wTM�8�����+��� �J(/�EN

¡¢£¤Oyz'(J¥¦�§+@�EN

¨©ª«E¬7�(B­®8¯°J±²�EN

9@:ABC

³UVW!´µ¶·¸8>?¹nºAB-»´µ¶J<=�EN

9D:EFGHIJ

9317!¼UVW7½�AMN

KLMNOP378EFQR

SGHI+TUVGHIJWOXYZ[\?(]96:EFGHIJ

./»¾1 ./»¿1 ./»"1

½�UVWÀ !¾ ÁÁ »Â

ÃUVWÀ Ã"! Ãļ üÂ

Ž�ÆÇ Å¼!ȼÉÇ Å¼´È¿ÉÇ Å!"È"ÉÇ

9 :O^EF_J 9@:`a,bcdSeJ_fSg_hgijU6_klEF

Å Ç1�½�ÊÀ UVWÀÅËÌÇ ÍR��ÎÏ UVWÀ ËÌ

³ Ê »!ž"ȼÉÇ ��� ÐÅ!¾È¼ÉÇ

0 Ê 9Å»ÄÈ"ÉÇ ~�1'(�� ÑÅÁÁÈ¿ÉÇ

9 Ê ³Å ÄÈ!ÉÇ Ò8Ó Ôż´ÈÂÉÇ

5 Ê ³Å ÄÈ!ÉÇ

9m:EFnJÕ Ê ³Å ÄÈ!ÉÇ

Šǽ�YÀ UVWÀ ËÌ

0�9Y ³Å ÂÈ´ÉÇ9D:opiq

Ö×�Ø UVWÀÅËÌÇ 9�5Y »´Å!´È!ÉÇ

rGc8¬ ÕÅ!¾È"ÉÇ 5�ÑY ÐÅÁ¼ÈÁÉÇ

rÙsGc Ôż¿È¼ÉÇ Ñ�ÚY 0Å ¾È´ÉÇ

rÙÛ�c 9Å»ÄÈ"ÉÇ Ú�ÕY ÚÅ»"ÈÁÉÇ

Õ�ÐY ³Å !È´ÉÇ

Ð�ÔY 9Å ÂÈ´ÉÇ

Page 6: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

@ `arstu

ųÇ�1���nbEcgÜÝ ��� Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå�

Å0ÇæçGè ����������� éêë^-ìíîïð�

Å9Çñògh ����������� óÜôõ-ö÷øùúûüýþ�

Å5ÇGègh ����������� �ÿ- $',$-

."/0123*45672389

!"#$%&'(

:";<=>?0@A=>BC ''' DE/FGHIJ=KLMN

O"@AP>QR%S ''''''' TUVW#$P>*XYJ8Z[\]^%&

) *+,-./01234#56$%789:;<=>

?@ABCDEFG34#6H.IJK-L%;MN

AOD.IPQ&RS

_`abI*cdefghijF?0kHIJLDE

/Rlmnop^qn ZRrsntu v#w( xy * k

z{Z#|yn=Kpz}Z\~���

��*HIJj���?\a�����n���R�

������W*����~fTUV�5�R��n

TUVWX-;YZ[��*�I��� ¡L¢��£L�*Jj/¤¥�n

¦�*}R^q�HIJR%Y§\/¨©��1z�

A\D.I&]^

defª«¬#UR.*­IVn®¯Z��*U°ªR±²³G´µ¶·��-R

N¸n¹S�*!º.»R¼I½¾J(ºn;��1z�_`a¿IÀÁL\�ULM

N*_`b�IÀLÂÃpz�

ÄI«ÅÆÇ?0a�ÅÈÇ\ÉÊ»?0ËÊ»R!º.»L;��1z�ÌÍ�*

ÎÏQRÐÑÒ'ÓÍOÔÕZfHIJ+Öa�×ÕLØÙ��1z�

A_DZ[`abc

ÚfHIJj'''''ÎÏQZÛÓn[\�~W0ÜÝ�~P>npz�ÜJjW

ÞßL®àpz�

áfTUV�5�j''HIJjWâãL�ä\~zaåæ¤�ÁL*ÆU��DE/�

çR#$Gèé-RP>\��z�

êëghijFìj''íî�~ïð\��z�

ñ%&ªò Âó"

ô õö�÷6 '''' õøù?ún;���*ûlLünõ¡��pz�

÷ xýþ1�÷6 '' ÿ n!1��*l"�çL#$'ØÙ���pz�

%÷·&'()*+�6 %,-./ %012ç89

%34·567÷8� %9·�:$k;(�<�5·y

�l={n>��úz}ZL*DE/�çR?@�~`AnBz�C*D�E�*

¬F1�/çG¡*HGI*JKLM�NÎ{ú~1�Á�*OPQRSGTUZR

VF*WXCRYZ-/Â[�\Z��1z�

Page 7: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!"#! !

! "#$%&'()*+,-./01%&0234!

5,-.6789:;<=>5?!

!

@! ABCDE!

! ! $%&'()*&+,-./0123456789($:;<=>?@AB+CDE

FGHIJKLM:NO(PQERSTUVWKXYZ++[6\]^_`DabcU

Fd1e&fg1VWhXYR;(ij[kl6mnopq(rstuvwxyz{O

|}~t|ti+F�o�Z�:<��O'&���6�Z�1:N�Qqh��O����

���1:N�+9o���6�R;Z��6F�<�!

! ! ��������O' ¡¢£¢(4¡¢¤¢(¥¦¡¢w¢(§¡¨¢(©ª¡¢

«¢12E(¬­®(\�®(¯J°±®(²³´�®(&�µ®Fdh¶8·;o�

Z�·R6�¸­1:N�¹X6º»o(rst¼v6'��6½¾»(¿ÀK>9oÁ

NÂ�+ÃÄÅhÆE�Ç5KÈEN³�É�oÊË+9oÌÍ@BÎ�ÏÐbKlÑ

9o�Z�!

! ! ÒÓv��ÐbO'$%&Éd[µ�sÔ³µ+$%&��ÕÖµ1]×6�ZØ�

Ù�ÚsÐb1Û($%&ÒÓvÜÝA�Î�O' 4¡ÞKßà+9<�×ÐbKl

Ñ9o�Z��×ÐbO'áâ´ãDÞä´ã(å¡aæ(Bç�è(��´ãFdéê

F´ãëì�íîKïx¨ðñ�BOòó9o�Z�:<(Uôõ+1ö÷µÒÓv�

sø6�Zäù[��6úû;o�Z�!

!

F! GHIJCKL!

M@NABI111%&C6789!

! ! ! $%&�ü1>¡³ýþÿ1+ 1!"'#³ý>¡$%'(

UôS�1&OlÑ·;<�þNF'6$%&�Õ'(Ë%�!

! ! ! rst)v*x(&÷6+Z,-þ./,-%1-01Kµ

2+9o(,-ER34O>¡56O+�<$% ¡¢17

vÞt8!hw9«:51ý9];ÞäK<qFhR(=>æ

qD-01��÷1?@12E(UA1&�Bc6�ZiCDE1FG(�÷1HÞ

µ(¿&IJK(LM FdK´ã9<�ÿ1³ý>¡1MN14O+F�<&�c

´�ÒÓvP��sKQnZRi1µþS^(Ri1µ%�'T1(1>¡³ýO[4

O�UVKW�o�Qÿ+6FZ�!

! ! ! X�orst|v«x6�$%>¡³ýYZ�íî�þ�×[Ri1µ%h\×·;<�

rst|v]1>¡³ý'¨^5S_1`5O(�qaQ1Éd[<NKbZ++[6(

MN'Uô�´O(aQ1S�+cd6eqfgÿ+6��oLX56F>¡³ý+

FZ+��Ri1µ1hºþi�%ER1\×O+�<�YZ�íîO'fjJkD

lmn�oBpÍqr�K>9o(>¡³ý+��ëì�íî1ÿ+K��o[R�

+;Ç6(MN1stÊË[�<uQ<Y6vQ&�Kßà+9oúû;<�!

MFN6789OPQRST'UQCVW-XYOZ!

! ! ! YZ�íî\×+;Ç`6($%&ÒÓvÜÝA�Î�O[rst|v]1�×Ðb

+9o>¡³ýÐb1lÑKwx9o�<�TÿO(Ri1µ+ÒÓvÜÝA�Î�

8967C[\C]0

Page 8: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!"t! !

OsyKz{<|}(~ê��OlÑ�Z�q[(��6Ô��s�6�ZlÑ1�

h�q�}�O+Z+1|�6�9<<Y(YZ�íî1��ÅDRi1µh��E

»<&�c´FdO�s·;<>¡³ýlúÕÖµ+$%&��ÕÖµþ$%&ÒÓ

vÜÝA�Î�%1]×+���OlÑ�Zÿ++F�<�!

!

! GHCD^!

M@N6789OPQRS_(ABCU`abcdef?!

! ! ! rst|v]ER1>¡³ý'$%&ÒÓvÜÝA�Î�Kµ2+9o(>¡³ýl

úÕÖµ+$%&��ÕÖµþ$%&ÒÓvÜÝA�Î�%+1]×O�::OlÑ

·;o�Zh(l�6'>¡³ýlúÕÖµh4O+F�oMN·;o�Z�!

! ! ! +ÿ�O(n6û>¡³ý1{R�'�1w�O+Z�!

!

�! �%K�;o�cÞäK<Z4O(�Ð(��(?@Fd1Þä´ãäùK4

O6(Û1´ãäù[eq�;FhR(Uô1�ê+1=�K�Yo�Qÿ+6

��o(Éd[1á�ODÞät1º_(sj� �-µ�(¡¢�ZtKÚ��!

£! UôS�6�ZlúÕÖµKf¤9o(>¡³ý1MNKXYo�Qÿ+K>

9o(UôS�1=�K¬qFhR(�Uô1Éd['UôO�oZ�h¥K¦

s9(�%��ÊË6[MFhZUô1��t1º_K¬Z�!

!

! ! ! §<NhlÑ�Z>¡³ýO'_¨�1>q(Éd[6©�

Z{R�6º»o1ef++[6(_¨£1��6ª«D1¬

c´(­bFd1®f'K¯noUô1§ih��(=�9(

°9³�Kz{FhR±MFh�o²� (§i<N1tK|

�·³o�Q4O�Uô1��t1º_�K¬�o�Q(M:

q�Uô1��mÍÏ´�@�K�µ9o�QëìABO+q(

T;'S�+ú¶1s�6�ZUô�QqO+Z+[·nZ�!

!

MFNghijklCGHD^!

! ! ! rst|v]'*xþ*9£:%+wxþ79¤:%6lÑ(rst¸v] �t}v]

'+[6¹xþ£9¹:%6lÑ9<�:<(lúÕÖµ1�sº�»�[v]õ+

6¼½1¾¿h+�<�ÿÿO'rst}v]1ÐbÀÁKÂÃ�Z�!

ÄÐb!Årst}v]! n6û>¡³ýÆÇÈÉÆ!

! ! ! ?%lÑ�´! ! >¡³ýlúÕÖµ!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! ! ! Ê%`5þ`5%! ! rst}v¹x¼¼Æ8#:þ£9¹:%!

! ! ! Ë%ßàþiÌ%! ! $% ¡¢(Í ¡¢(ÎÏ ¡¢17ÆÐvÞ! 8#!!

1mnSo8SM%&Ap1qAp1rsApN! 1tuvM%&w7\1qw7\1rsw7\N

1%&'\xS! ! 1%&'UyS! ! 1qw7\z{|CS! ! 1%&'023S`ho8S!

1}~k��`h��,Y��CS! ! 1%&�����'�CS! ! 1%&������S!

1��7\%&���C���(�?! ! 1"#$�U�7C7�������!

1��QR� QRo¡¢£SM%&Ap¤qAp¤rsApN! ! 1¥¦'�������!

!"#$%&'(&)*

Page 9: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!"#! !

! ! ! $%&'! ! #()*+++,-./01(*+++,23+456781")*+++,%!

! ! ! 9%:;<=>?!

! ! ! ! ! @ABCDE8FGHIJK7LAMN5OPQRSTU=VWX678YFZ!

! ! ! [%\]^_`!

! ! ! ! ! abcdefghi5jk5lm5nopqrs5_

t9uv5wxyepz{x5HIJK7LA|n}7

~�p./5�>����py���u�5����n

�5����-��p�5�p��OPQRSTU=V

���%5��-��p�%5��fgr��r����

 ¡fgp¢£�b¤Z!

! ! ! ¥%¦p�!

! ! ! ! ! HIJK7LApA§�_U¨©ª«¬­®��p_

t9uv[V¯GS°±²�./³«®´fgµ¶�Z!

!

! ! <=>?p·¸efg�5¹¤º�»«¬­¼n��G½¾

¿À5jk5lmpª¯ÁÂ<p�5_t9uv:;5Ãn�

�5z{xGqrspÄÅ5�pu�cd:;5Æǧc:;5CÈ��b¤�É­Z!

! ! Ê�5ËÌÍÎQÏpÐÑ«DÒf�|ËÌÍÎQÏ! Ó«Ô@ABCÕÖs×Õ�-Ø{

|Ös×�%�m�5�p@ABC��¤¶º�ÙÚØÛpBCÜÚ�ÝÀgr­Þ5ß

¶�ËÌÍ"QàÑ«áâ7}ãäRåæç�7}DèRåTU=VéEp|ËÌÍ3QÏ

ç�7}êëDìíî! êë«ïÀ­@ABCcdpDì«ðñ­íîRå�pòó�

ºe«ÜÚ�Ýôfgr­Z|Ös×�«ðfg�5Öõ«ïÀ­ö�efgDÒf�Ô

À�Þ5÷J«¬­¢@øùÛpße�úûfg5OPQRSTU=Vüýþºÿr

!"Axp#$-ßpe��àQ§ØÛ%�%&ef5BCÜÚº'µfgpDÒ�É

(�Z!

! ! bï5ßßÐQÚ�)Ñ*+Þô,fgï�5-½º./Üp*+�úÓgr­Z!

!

+, -.&/0123,

456/0,

! ! ! Q�5cd01Þ2D3456¶gr­ßeÞ5@ABC½p./³WX78³p

ªU9V�Æ:;<º=üÞÓ­Zßß«ËÌÍ(QÏp;<�>?fò@ñ­Z!

A./³B ! C ! |egº¬ru��(��|¬ru��(��pB: !

! D ! ni���f�u�1(3E3F ! ! ! ! ! ! D ! jk3lm�f�u�1 G+E+F !

! D ! H�ºI�J¶gCÈf�u�1 GÎEGF ! D ! KµpL�»eMN«ni�f�u�1(3E3F !

A78³B! C ! @ABC½üýÐÙÚOÏ5./³pP¹�Qgp|LR¦=S=�|¦=S=�|Ê

ÉÊɦ=S=�pB: !

! D ! ØT¬�5U�bV�»Þ����5¢WÞXÊ(�1 YÎEGF !

! D ! ØT¬�5Z[Gjkb¤5ï®\r�ñ­¬=«b(�1 Y+E+F !

! D ! ØT¬�5]«%f^_p`a»�@ñ¬=«b(�1 G+E+F !

! D ! ØT¬�5¹¤ºüý]«bfüÀ­¬=«b(�1ÎÎEGF !

! D ! ØT¬�5Sr@�«býbrßeºcd��­¬=«b(�1(+E+F !

789:&)*,

,

;<=>?@ABCD)*

Page 10: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!"3! !

! ! ! 78³pe«e(g�-ªU9V�p^fg«ºhiÞÉ­Þ%"6bßeºjk

-¹¤º«%ñ­lýr«ïÀ­%¹¤ºpÌm�éQñ­ßeÞ���5D�É­

@ABC�É(�eóÓ­ZÊ�78³ªU9V�p=»|ØT¬�5]«%f^_

p`a»�@ñ¬=«b(���G+E+F5|ØT¬�5¹¤ºüý]«bfüÀ­¬=

«b(���ÎÎEGF�nk5opqeº78³rst-3+4%pàupÐØÛ�É(

�Z߶ýüý�5¹¤ºÞMÙÚØÛºIv�J¶g§cf�ße«¬(g5rü

«Iv-78³%ÞÉ�Þ�µ5Lwbxæ-yz%�É­ü�{|}5É­r�~

kg|}���ßee��6¶­Z!

! ! ! Ê�DE8F��UÁV�jk5��3��ñ­LLptºQ��Ógï�5ËÌ

ÍGQÏ���#3345ËÌÍ(QÏ���#GY4�É(�Z@ABC�@f�êëpLL

�»p�bÞ�üý§Ê¶­��;Æf�êëp7}�p�Û5ñbÔ»êëp7}

�>��V�p��Þ�ý¶g�gr­ºpeúÓ­Z!

!

4E6 FG&H3I123,

! ! ! @ABCT«Ñ�r�V<��r56ý«BC½p�r�:�rpDE8F��*

+f�ZQ�5DE8F���Ìñ­Çu56��_U¨©ªÞ�Ó­ße«¬�5

��«��ñ­Çup��³G6�pLtº�Ó­ÔÀ�Þ5êëp¹¤º�»p�

k«¤p¬=bßeÞ��­üer=5�UÁVp@ABC«%ñ­P�bSrG�

rÞéó6¶­�k5�ý¶���/Ú0«ïrg5rü«���«bfB(gºý

=üer=��5bfBrp���ÌG��p �¡E�¢=DE8F�i£¤p�

¥Þ¦Ô¶­ßeÞKrZ!

!

4J6KL&MN,

! ! ! §zp¨v6«ïÀ­@ABC��5OPQRSTU=V�©�efgª«�@A

¬­b"Axp#$�%&efgr­�k5¤=fgºàx-¨v"Ax5®"Ax5

!"Ax%p��pDÒ«�ý¶5�p"Ax¯#$«@ABC�u�6°­ße

Þ��brZ6ý«êëüýp|@ABC�G±=²�er=`³ÞÉ(gߦ5ê

ë´��µ¶ef�a·¬­b@ABCÞDÒ��­er=5@ABCDE8F�e

.PpúÓ�«Eãeºâ(gr­�k5ÉÓgEãeüý�pêë�p*+ò¸º

E(grbrZ!

! ! ! ßp¬=b¹º«¬�5�p"Ax¯�pD§Þb6¶»«-�«¼(gr­ÔÀ

�(�Þ5D�ËÌÍYQÏ«ïrg5߶Ê�pàxؽp�"Ax�@ABCÞ:

¾6¶gr­Zßp&ô6¶gr­"Ax��5x¯pêë´�Þµ¶eb(g:¾

�¡kgï�5¿°gEãeÀº����ÞÁký¶gr­eß±�ºÉ­Z!

! ! ! ¬(g5ËÌÍYQÏ�"6bÂÞ���É­Þ5¨v6ù"Ax¯�p@ABCD

§er=�rÞM«T¡f�Ãeb­&ô�É­Z!

! ! ! ¨v6Þ|�pÊ»�eeº«5|@ABCpÊ»�eÄŶ­�ÞÆ­ße��(

g5-½ºêëeeº«Ç�ÈÉ�r��rZ!

-Ê­! ËÌ%!

Page 11: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!!

!"#$%&'()*+,-./012345667 89

: ;<=>?

@:A;<BC

"#$%&'()*+,-./01234"#$%&'56789:;3<

@DA;<=E.F

=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPAQGRSBTUKVWX

YZ[\O].-^E_`@AQGRSBabKTUcdGX

efgJhEijQGkEBlmnopcKTqcdGX

rstBuvwE_`Bstxywzfg({|}~-���wK��z��cd

GX

�fgJh�OfgB���Ky�QGwB�TvKE�_O�Blmn��K��

QG��EQGX

@GAHI

��������>������>��� � ¡>

@ AJKL

"#$%&¡�@ ¢£¤4¥¦§¨©ª«¬­B®R¯°<

@MANO

"#±h²

@PAQR

³´µ�¶·��¸¹º�»

@SATUVWXY

¼½¾¿;O&ÀOxÁOxÂO¡�@ÃÄOf'y�3¿;O

@ZA[\L

f'st4ÅÆÇÈ OÉÊB3OI@AËÌ/0:;OÍÎZÃÏÐ;<

@]A()=^_`a

fÑZ[KÒÓO¯°BsÔ�ÕÖ_Os×Ø¥ÙBÚÛBRSN���ÜÝÞ«

ßà@AK_FÞáâFãFäFåRXæ ç«Bèéêz)ëìLíØ�p«îF

ïXð¥zñòzóôØÕ`PõÜ«OÅÆØ�ãïÅÆö÷ØøáFïXIùúÜ

Øûµü«ýáâþÿ ã!ø_`"ïX#$B%&ØP'O%&N()_FïX@

A�B*+ØÕ`����QGX,�_Fä`�"ïX

@b6AIc

� > ü - . /

���>��� 071O23ENð¥OñòOóôOP'\4

��¡>�5� 67@AB%84%& Oð¥OñòOóôO�ãïÅÆ<

��9>�:� ð¥OñòOóôOP'\4 ;Å<=

��>>�?� >B®@AOð¥OñòOóôO�ãïÅÆ

���>�B� ð¥OñòOÕ²CóOP'\4

����>��� DECóOF71OGHÙE3ØIKs×Õ;«IJG

Page 12: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

@bbAde=fg

=�ãïÅÆBiK)*+, -./0&1234567'(89:;<=)>?@A

BC#&D#12EFGHI&#=127JKL M!"#$%&NOP;QR3A

ST!U3VW-XYZ[\3F]&^7B;_S`ab-cd^F]3efM

ghij-F3kI&lIm;QR3VWEno8pq=M

rs+t&uv;wx`yzc`3{|8-1}~�`�=M

!"#$%&'()

n���E456`��&�~�J)���;�I-��b=M���JE���

- - A M - -&�� ��&�� ��6�&�� ;��b= d�8 �X0�3@#p^

���a8;8D#M

gv�X ¡¢£�^-QR¤¥7¦§d¨C-vQ&QRVW3¦d=M

- - Mr©ª«��¬�3^ QR­®&¯°�8p «±z&�X3@#p¯²;!"f

³´µ¶&456&·B¸¹^���ºD#M

* +,'-.

»¼©^-½¾¿&ÀÁ-ÂéÄIÀ�ÅÆÇÈ&ÉÊËÌ.&ÍÎ3ϹdÐÑÒ

.03ÓÔb=ÕÖ¸D¼×Ø©`¦=MÙ^ÚJÛ-ÌÜÛ-Ý^Þß©-À^àá

- - M -Û Í^â¼Û ãäåÛ�æ8p#= ©¶çÙHI3ÉÊËè7À¸"Í3éê8

ë&êì&íî.^ïðDñ.7ò7§pFI-óô;õöô38p#=M

÷øùúGûÇüý+»¼Û-þÿ -!" -Ù# -$ -Í% -Ý# &ýÛs

7C&8-'()*+)*,'-¿-.�&Û�8p/0P18dM23-÷ø))GûÇüý

+©�;3�8-4G`Æ5Gt;67dMë8p4 8¦9:c&$¸F=��Ø©E-

»¼;;tV8-z<&¤=3�7=>:-?@��A7B·8pCDD3E3FIG

H`#=MíIû5GJüKLM-'())+û*Ç'-NOPûÇ+,)ÇNOM

/ 0123'45

íIû*GQ¸"½¾¿õR&8qSk"8#B·TU¢£Qô ).ìVW�­XT;

U7B·8p-.ì&YZ;�¸8dST!U&­®XY;nob=TUXY&¢£A

7Ï[ 8\]^/_P`¢£Qô;�8aôTU>b¢£Qô;;¶c3-deL3M

.ìVW�­XTU&B·7�fg=h/ij;kl8-B·3Ä=TUno;mÏ8

p#:n��D§dM

»¼©`!n&8\]^/_P`¢£Qô;;o¹-¿03pq¹pJ@&r­X/

`stL3FIGH�Më&�@`¦=uvr­X7-.ìVW�&B·3Ä=C�w

­;n38d&`¦=M

xDq3-¿¸"©Û �&�y0�^-©Û \]^/_P`z{B|W-r­X

/\]^/_P`¢£B|W&}~���-B·��`Qô&n3M�y�^-ý©Û

¦dIÆÇ��`¦=M

Page 13: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

� Æ, �

6 01'789:;

<#78

ST!U7w,U&��¹`�X��;8-��s+&C��X;~fb=n�3

ÄI-ãBDw�;@¹dM�7"gd���]j;nDb&`^D:-�I�=w

- - -�zµ;��3��bdºw,U`�7 �8#��;�l8dI �3_8H�I

�U�&'ê&¨38dI-ëg�g��� ;8pw�zµ;��X¡b=n�7

`BdM.ì&12¸"8!"#$%;;b=n�3ÄI-.ì&mD�ST!U7

¢£"8#'ê;b=n�7`BdMcd-QR3'(8d456!.ì&mD�\

¤¥¦§Ph¨©7Fg-ª«D¬­;l:n�7`BdM!"#$%;®¯8d.

ì&mDS�~�J;��8d^]©i°±&qD²H!ST!U�&'êS.ì�

³´7`Bdn�`-µ¶·�UI·;¸@n�7`B-n&¹!£H`B�8d#

�#fstº7apBdM

*#:;

­Xõ�`»¼S?FI;8ddº-­X�&½�7ãB:D§p8c§dM4\

¾JD:¿À²Á=dº3^-¬­Â�&B���;ÄIÃ�D!&38-8§¸I

�8dÄÅ,�;Æ"D¹gÇD"D#M

/#=>'?@

.ì�­X&B·3ÄI-ÄIÈ:&.ì&mDSB�Â�É7¬fI¾JD:¿

À8p#:dº&h/ij;kl8p#Bd#M

)ÊË ÌÍA

Page 14: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!"#! !

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!"#$%&'()*+,-./01,23

!

Page 15: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!"

!"#$%&'()*+,-./01

2 34/56

#$%&'()*+,-./012/345678&9:;<(=>?@ABCD<

E%FGHIJK*LCD<(=>?@ABMN%#$O?PQR#$SQ%#$OTU

VTWXY(Z@B+[+\]^T_/0?C`a#$OTbc%def>?/0g+

@hiQ_ABjkl("GmnQopApqrNst>9jMuIvwQbcxAyS

sz{B

:;<9*LCD<(=|v?}~QL�s(�KQ��a�p��(����T�

��a�.@AB4Tpq��?������TvQ}~T&�I���+.4���

���#$O��9}~TCDYI��Q�@p���������a�I�a�.@

AB

 p9#$Q%¡��¢(£_09¤G}¢Q¥¦§(¨2+.@AB©ª«¡��Q

«¥¦§?_0���¥¦§T¬­(�0�x@�@�hiQ_AB

®¯¤"°±²³�´�WXµ¶�+.·¸��¹º»TvQ¼½[awI%¾�|}

~���¿<VN 9¥¦§»TvQ¥¦§��ÀÁVN»(ÂÃÄ-ÅÆ.@ABÇ

7 89:;/<=

®¯¤!°[ÅTÈÉ��Ê7ËÌQÍ@9L�sp�Q}~?T½[a����TÎ

¸IÏÐxApq9#$S?%¥¦§��TÑÒIÓ�pBÔ�Õ�ÊÖQL�sp�

I×Ø�+p�`��VIÙÚ+9��IÛ+.ÜÝxAa�9L�sp�(¥¦§Q

B 9 9ÞeQßAàáIâã+p  p }~É�?L�sp�I�.AäåICqApqQ

¥¦§?�æxA}~Tç��è��é(L�sp�T��QWoAê�[-ë0I=

qpB4TìíéVN�+.9}~Tî&p�(ïðY�ñòY�+.óÚxA9¥¦

§?TÁô����IÒõ+pB

Û�ÀÁVNTöÅ@�+.÷øTùú(_ûÅÆ.@Aü

ýL�sp�T¼²êAòÇT�¯

}~TL�sp�(}þT¥¦§?Áô+a(Åÿ°Dü ç?!"²�I#$9

%V�&'(I)*p�?����?9L�sp�T)+�ñòTwI%¾�|B

,}~T��òT-¯

}~Tî&(L�sp�T²������Iè.�/xA��IÛ+.9}~¾A

$?L�sp�I�s��xAÎ0ICqABÛ�ÀÁVNTó1Y%9®¯¤!°±

Q%2VN9¤GG&?_�p(9¤"°±Q%3VN9¤!4&Q51+.@AB

> ?@ABCD/EF-.89/8GHI

J2KLMH)

®¯¤!°«6Q7�a�p¥¦§(8.9KÅÆ9:*°T�¯VNQ30òI;

ÆA��Qa�pBL�sp�T²êAò9}~��òT-¯TpqTVNI<K.

@p(9=>^?T@A¥¦§(Òõ+.@A¥¦§Áô��VNQBCID�9E

IFêQ��pBGTL�sp�%H���´@VQI+xJ.KL��ÞM�@�

N�(*a@9êO�L@(*a@9}~Tî&�TPa(0sa@�@�hi?¥

Page 16: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!4

#$%&'()*+',

-./01234567/23893:;<=>[email protected]+CDE*+FGHI

DJK'LMK*+?(NO23PLQ.J)PRSTK.UNVW*+X%+YJ

ZP[J*K\*Q]K-Q.U^Y_`%aWTY,XJ?bcdefghijk

JYlm*no%pq(rYJst.,

!"#$%&'

567QuvTr+wxyzg{|}~<�����~�����(#$)

567/23?��|�:*+ ,

��=,K'K��P8�YuJ%()*+?(��K.�"=9�k���-. /

T.,��@A?��k�t]+Y,

���� 4����X��������"XN U*+¡8¢#$£¤�'W¥01 2 ,

��N¦'W§�¨©�>

567¢#$34 5

�Lª�o «j¬g8¢#$­�4$®J¢#$¯°¥= N#:@A67 8 >

ª�N±XoN²XoN³´�µN¶·¸9¹oNº»¼½¾

9"#$%:;

(<=%>?@AB%CCDE

567¢#$?·2¿À°Á?ÂÃ8NÄÅ?ÆÇ*µwNXÇ%ÈÉQ]+Yu

J(rY,¢#$PÊË%*+.Ì�Í8¦Î?ÏÐP¦?ÑÒzÓ¬y(LQ]+

Y%N³´�µ4<�½?[ÔÕÖ×½%Ø+>%ÙT]LQ]+Y,ÚgÛÜÝÞK

D³´�µ?ßà(rY,±Xo8áâN²Xo8ãâkHID.BJ�äP*Q]

åQ]+Y,¶·¸9¹o823'W¢#$-(8æç(��¡\W+''Y¢#$'

W23-(?è3Né3?êëN¢#$?$®Dã�äP23-(+Q]+Y,

ìí'Wî^uJk6ïPK]+Y.ÌNº»¼8HID.BP8ðkañ*+l

mPK]+Y%NHID.B%23PLQ]+YòPóôÜõ+ök÷øQ]\TY

ùuQúUûüjýþÿ JK]��K]+Y,!"?#$y%&kK]+Y'ì?

X8(UD?P*W*+)%Q.*d$+*Ik,�]\TY*I�Lª�-.?º

»¼Ü!/?0#%ÈÉQ]+Y,

*FGHI%JKLM

�1?.Ì?23ok¥4�1K]+YN546P¨N|�:J¢#$¯°J(·

2¿À?78k9]YN¥46?23o(HID.B%O:J*Q];åUÜ=<å

UkLQ]+Y,

N"#$%OP

(QRST%.U

=>8º»¼?ò'Wù*Ö(¢#$%úu-(ÜY?' J+Q.?@?ADr

Q.%N��^YHID.B%J]DBC?(DÖDÖJEFK]).,��ë8�

�k�t][UG(8 ù��:P*Q.W·2¿ÀP��()Y J+m?%HIN

D.B?HKIP*Q]+Y,

Page 17: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

<�

*<=%VWXYZ

·2¿À?�1PlQ]!"?XJðaVUP*YNJO(DKL^Y*IÄÅ?

OPùHIDkaMY N%C+]+YNOLPQ?RSDrY?(8*+'Jst

WTY,

-.¢#$P�^YTU%VÉQ.N·2¿ÀPÈÉQ.WX.B%RXP¢#$

kYZ^YlmP*UNuT-(YZ%Ø'Q.[\¼]D�(8*\NHID.B

?[^ÕÖN[ÔÕÖ×½%YZ^YlmP*U_`?��¼D�(8*\NÆÇ*

agz{bM%:-T]+Y,¢#$bM%bcdK.J+tY,

·2¿Àkef^YuJPlQ]gÁ:DyhijJK]��^YlmP*Q])

.,G�8kl?[3:%��KNmn{hÿhgk�1K.%N[3:JHID.

B?¶o?pJD*Q]+Y,

-FGH%[\]^_`abO

q�f�YuJPlQ]rU*'Q.��:%NsN¨N|�J2�ktuYvJ

PKQ'UK]+\uJ%6PatY,|�:?HID%��:?Àwkxt]ry

.UNÏÐ(?{g{kxt.UK]+Y4®+z8{|*+JDÌDl } ,>

0cd%VWX%YZ

=>?�8~�?23%~��DQ.%��:P8CW'Q.?(N��'W���

PVt.,&�P�Y?%++?'Nãv�8â�*\]D++?'kIÖ*(st

.,umK.uJk�ìíPøtYuJPlQ]Nìí?x�N?`�P��K]+

YJst]+Y,-.Nº»¼�?ÿjfg�kaYJù�X8DB�Ö?uJ�D

��Dú?H%+*+:bP�Ì]��k�GYuJ%().lmP�m ù�Q]

).�H%��UW)\*Q.J�G]+Y *IHIDJ?`)¿+�P�üy?

��k�t]+YlmD,

3eBfgh#ij/

·2¿Àk)Q'�P�ox��?��kDJPNuT-(5XDQ.¢#$¯°

k¥XPKN¢#$%HID?°Á? �k¡YlmP*Q.,G(8}P5�ùP

uPu J+m¢#$¢Ukå£KN23k·G]93:æP¤¥K]+Y,

k"lmZ%nopIqo

(lmrsIst

+C�1^Y?%++?'NI?\W+?®Õ%¦§*?'Nq�¨©kª-t*

%W«8K]+Y,ú?.Ì8/23J�?¬­8®¯°(rY,·2¿À?±òk

23?L°Jt*W*+lmP²³KN±òO8/23?´:%q�¶½(HID.

B?ÆHkaPµ]DWmlmPK]+Y,-.·2¿À?�?23(?ÆHk¶\

lmPK]+Y4·úmPK]+*'Q.'*I ,�?¬­?.ÌP8ÿjfg�>

²¸k�1KN�?Ak¨¹ÕñYlm*º»kK]+Y,

*uvw@uxyI%z{

�����½?X.BPI?lmPÿ�Óg¼^T|++?'kst]+Y,G�8�

Ó½üÛ?a¾g�kù¿z¿ghij¹o PrÖDJu������½?~�X\W+

?¹N%ÀWT.,Ø\?×½%HID.BPÈÉYpJK]¢#$J+mÁö8R

SÂ*#gÃÄJK]?TÅk¤Q]+Y,GSÕWP·2¿À}Æj�Äk �Õ

ñ]+).+,

4OÇ ÈÉ>

Page 18: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!"

!"#$%&'()*+,-./0*12345

#$%&'()*+,)-.+/01234526789:*+;<=85>?@AB

CD)*;<EFGHIJKLMCINOPGQROS3T+/U126)V+WXYZ

[5\]^CINOPGQROS_`abcd2ef1gh+,KQROS

6 7839:

ij"kVlm2#$%YnoT%pq9-rHIst#$%u9vwHDSxyz!{|

}~ 2��"{�����KQ2()*|�*2�)*"{*2WXw��14�l��KQ�

ROS'()*1#$%+'�5>?H2�5���2'5��2�51���Y��

��5�MCINOS

��51�&��V+�� ¡¢£¤2�¥¦2���§¨© ª©¤2^B51�

��«¬­®b¯+w°)±]²9ROSWX�1³©¤´+pµ+4��5¶·IN

S 2 2 2 SO ¸¹ºEF w°)±EF »¯¼½EF¼E¾Q *¿+;<5ZÀOÁÂ1ÃN

WX�12ij"�VÄm47ÅÆ2"{�ÇQROS6*�)ÈQROS

; <=>?3@A

'()*+� ¡¢£¤,)-.12ij"kV4m"�É�"7ÊÄV 2�ËÉ�"7ÊpÌ

VÌQ\]^CD+9ÍMKQROSÎ"kVÏÐB6)VZ[+,)-.Y\]HDS

ij"�VÏQlVÑ5bOJLQROS

6)VYZ[52;<=85>?@ABCD,)-.+¾Ò12ÓÔÕQROÖ×Ø

Ù*Ú+ÛÜ*#$�j()*ÊÝÞqÌ5ßAOtà+)±u5áâ9ROS

Ö×*Ú12ij"�VÏÐB"!VÏMQpVã2:*5ÆÜ�2)*Û+äåàQ£

æçhKÀOb¯èé+êëYìb9B2à+)±5JKLíîSïð+TVã2:*

ÛY#¾HIhOPG!Ë}~27ñò5yÀOhóMQÄVw+WXGG¼54ôT7+

à+)±Y\õHDS

6ö8Y÷øÀODù5.ôHD+9úû�&��V;<]²QRO� ¡¢£¤Q

R·DS� ¡¢£¤+ü�ýþ5>?ÀO'()*5ÿÜHDÖ×*Ú+ +�52

tà+)±u+!126*,)-.+"Ò9#ÐíQNDS;$+�%b&Z¼2'K

(�)�+Ö×*ÚQR·DS

B <=39CDEFGHIJKLMNOP0*1239C

Q6RST

*ã12ij"�V"ËmT7+m,ÐB�7+-,MQ+34.QR·DS

/ÄVw12T7+m,É�7+-,MQ+Äô07Êêë1|2|!Ë3Ì

/l¡pVw12p7+4,É�7+-,MQ+lôp7Êêë1"2��Ë3Ì

/4¡TVw1Ä7+5,É�7+-,MQ+Tôl7Êêë1"26!Ë3Ì

/0Vw107+7,É�7+-,+4ôT7Êêë186Ë3Ìß91:;<K

0Vw124m5\]^COl*=ó-.Êlôp7Ì5êëÀOSP+-.12

Page 19: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!�

pmÐB>?&'()*+,-./01./2.34(356789:;<=>:?

@3A9/BCDEFGHIJKLMN9O>:?

!"#$%

P'C7QROS3TU3V#WXYZ[\OW: ]^_`3abcdefg/?

hi3jkl ]mn/opq3rs ]tuvw=3xyz{lQR7|}AD~�� �

=>:?H�JCD3����G ]�7�\AtuD~3&=/�E�Mq7;�/

�O�qRAg�F;}Ag�:�M3��[L�ef�MX=�: �4� CD?

3����G ]��z�{d�MLq7;��O~w�:�M7QRO/�E�3/

�[L�\Ag/h�3X��gL�eWAg�: ��CD3����G ]�I? /

BKMW��Wb/�7�\AtuD~7QRO/� {¡¢£N¤¥R£W¦§{

¨©ª£N3¦§'«Lh�"#*�=¬­R ®h�3�MGh�={: ®¯°/ ±

Ovw�: ®²³3�MGmn�:±£N3Af´RWµ7rO: �BCD3�± ?

���G ]tu=D~�:�°=3xyz{¶·¸£xyz/lQR7|}A¹º/

¸£D~£N7/¦§7QR£X#»LUF: �?

¼¨©ªG/½¾¿À3ÁÂàÄLÅf"#Æ�\OWAÁÇ3ÈÉ=>:?

&"'()*+,-

Êh�3�MGh�=�:?¤¥/�3aXROW:�M|h�=�:?

ÊËÌGh�=ÍÎÏUf:?

Ê¡¢Gh�=�:?ÐÑ{ÒÐ3Ó°GJK�EFÔ}Of:?ÕÖL×�?

ÊËØ"#ÙÚ3ÛbLGÜÝ7ÔA�/Þß3hร~w3Ûb7áâ�:?

Ê��z�Gãä¸L a=HÎL�:?~wÎÍËÌåg/æç£NÏMD~Î

Íèé=V:�¡¢£NÏ

."/012345

PKê�ë�_ìGíî3Qg=>:?�CD3�ë�_ì=ï|mn/op7ð

9#\:3G/4K�3¨©ª=>:?Hñ òóL�ôRO/õÛLö÷øù7k

}O/úûÛLüýþLÑfMW�ÿv=>:? LG/£!["#=$%/&'?(

)*()/;¹úû)L+,Ç�!=>:?¨©ª=ö÷ø7-.RA�MX/MO|

�W/W0Mh1L£}AR/23�{"F4£N=aMq7;��:�M3��[

7¦5�:�MX=�A?

ñ�K�36HÛbG/789=:;Xv�\A?<=å>7'��:V#W=

>:??@[\:3GAB3CD[�=>:?E(��D=/R"|FG/2.'(

=HIJ"�7[\OW:K_LMNOMW�"#PQW?KRG�RWHIJ"�

7ROf\:K_LMNO/@3èSaLT7U\#\OVfWN|3îX7YZ�

:EF=[°Of:?

�ë�_ìM?@Äa\3]XWN|7^°OW:?�CD3]µL_}A~w`

`a4�G/Hb]P(cdefz /Jb]¨©ª /4b]gK3Ì åg£N� �

3D~¦§�=>}A?P(ÞßXhi�:]£"�RjkL�cdefz�M]l

Page 20: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

m no m

pzågÍHñ�CDPq�úrst �G/ueLe`LaMvw:=>x�?4�Ï

CD3]GyUg¦§�|/H�JCD3]RSIMg¦§�|hiRAÞß3z

{�:�ë�_ì=>}A?

P(ÞßXhi�:Q';<=G/D~3>#|:}P=C²3ÄL~�:C�Ä

3��X��M[\:R/��L�v[\:?@3}P3/�U�U3�I�VX/

C²�C�@\�\3Þß3s�7�RA=>x��MG�W£W?

. (6789:3;<=8>?

2.'(3Q';<G/��(�3�.M?@q/@\L�°A�Bq3��RA�

�M�vqL�}O4C3�I7��s�7>�A?¶·�rXà@�:Q';<MG

�W/Q';<3�M�7�9O/@3P¦7?@R/��R/w�eF:�MX=�

:MW��LCWO L¡¢R��|£W£W¤�7>�OW:?@\|PÞß7~¥

L�¦=�OW:3=>:"#�§£W¨©X=�:?@\EFL/(�{�qXª�

}O|/«X¬­RO|�v®¯£°±�²M³´7µ¶�:�MX��=>x�?

@3·¸=G/'(M¹º3°±�²7»Z¼�:�M£f/C½�ML¾Q¿ÀL

�²RAW?@3�°=/�ë�_ìMÁ`Mì7ÂÃL®Ä¸LÅÆÇÈ�w�=>

x� ]WN|ÉãÊ�3~È£N/FGG(Ë"#3ÌÊ@U£NL|Íq[\OC?

g/ÎP¸£ÏÐMÍqXÑÒLÓ�\/ÔÕ�Mv,L�[�RW?

ÍÖ× ØÙÏ

Page 21: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

mnÚm

@ABCDEFGHIJKLMJNOPQRBS

!"#

! " # $% & ' ( ) *% +, !"#$%

&'()

*+,

-

()

*+,

.

/ $ %&-. /00

1234 #/"0

0 0

56

! 7 %& 8% "/"09:; #/00

'()*+,-.

/0

123456

789:;<

<=>?@ A/00B!0/00

=>?@;9:;ABC

@@9;;

D

EF

GH

IJ

( #

56

" C %& '/"0 8% "/ &9:; "/"0

DEFG A/00B!0/00

=>?@;9:;ABCKL

@@9;;D

EF

MN ( #

56

%& '/"0

HIJKL O4P

QR

=>?@;9:;ABC

@@9;; ( #

M

N

6

MN6

8%STUVW&67:9;;<789;;

#/00:;=>7X9;;

OP?@QRST

@@9;; A (

56

%& '/"0UV

A/00B 0/00

8% "/"09WXYZ<[\]

%Y"Z[UO\]^_`6

7X9;;=>Uab6?ABC

OP?@QRST

@@9;; ( #

M

N

6

MN6

'/"0 ^_ `abcEd cdefdOP?@QRST

=>?@;9:;ABC

@@9;; A (

,

e

6

,e6

8% "/"09 #/00:;

7X9;;=>U%&b6ABC

OP?@QRST

@79:; !0 !"

56

%& '/"0UV

A/00B 0/00

8% "/"09WXYZ<[\]

WXYZ<[\]

=>C @@9;; ( #

MN6

MN6

'/"0 => @@9;; A (

,e6

,e6

'/"0 8%:f '/"0B

OP?@QRST

@79:; !0 !"

g6

g6 8% "/"09 #/00:;

hijk lm?@nopcJqIrnstuv:f

ghidjkdlYm

@@9;; ' !

%& '/"0 wxMN

6'/"0 wx

,e

6'/"0 wx

g6 '/"0 wx

nopq

!

"#$%&%'($)&%'

*+,!-,./0$1&''($2&''

*+,!-,./0$3&''(4'&''

! "#$%%%%%%%%%%%&$'()

*+,!-,./0$1&''($2&''

&$'()*+,-.

!567

89::(;&''

<=>,?@

ABCDEFGHIJ

KL*+$$&%'($M&''

NO PQR /0123455678

! "#$%%%%%%%%%%%&$'()

9:%%;<%=>?@ABCDEFG

2H4I5.J*+--%%1KLMNOLPQ@8

STUVWXYZD[\]^_`abaJ

RST'UVW"XY1Z[\U2]$\^_`a'()bI3$\cOL@dLe8

fghE"XY

cdXYZ

cOL@dLe

9:

2i]iIi3ijklmno`Lp"1J]-qm8

$%&%'eSTUVWXfghijkDlH^_m7baJ

rs

tuvwxyz

{|}~

stuv�wx��

nUoD!pIh=!qJ

N�_���F�L��

{|}~rs

tuv��x����wxyz

!qhr!$3&M'($;&4'

$;&%'(4'&''stuvwxyTz{|V}o~�d����

�)�������R�o�{�oW�T���]��w��R

3

1

&�n�E�1���������8

! "#$%%%%%%%%%%%&$'()

!=!qhr!D�T!J

!�G�7DE�G1����6IJ

cdXYZ

��������� �¡¢£� �&$1K@�¤"��8

M �

^Kc'{¥¦�'%%%%§u¨©ª«4I5.2¬455%%%^_`Fa­2®455

�d

!5673&''(;&''�G�7

Q¯La°±L

!5673&''(;&''��� ¡¢£¤¥¦

) §

! "#$%%%%%%%%%%%&$'()

Page 22: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!!

!"#"$%&'()*+,

- ./(01

"#$#%&'( )*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABC+DE

)FGH/54IJ8KE&LMN+OPQ>?RSTUOPQVWX<Y5Z[JT

U\]^_+`Pabcd5<e;fghij0k8El<'mm<n5opUq

2 ./34(56

rs!t<guv8i#%&wx<yz{:&|4}~Ers�m<>?PQ+����

�eg�]�_+�������������5m�<eghi�K0k8K�iq�8

KE�+m�<e+��5��TUg�ijE�18KCi��+�L& ¡¢£¤¥'

:¦5§¨KCUYc,-PQg©n8E9:;<=>?`Pab��'ªU)*+,

-./50k8KCUq

«<=J¬U9:;<=(E#%&wx<yz{:&|4}~­®¯J¬�KE°&

+@ABC+D'ªU)FGH/54IgE±-²gX]\_+`Pab5³´OPQ

+X<Y5Z[J8K0k8iq

µ+9:m�<=g(Ewx<yz{:&|4}5¶,J8K`Pab012345·

¸§¨E¹ºZ[¯5&LgMNªUOPQ+V<YWX<YJ8E�e»\]^_5

<eMf0kTU¬¼JC�i½¾5¿jE¡À+)*+,-./+ÁÂ5ÃÄ8iq

�+ÅE<Æ�ÇÈÉÊË+¾05¿jNNE9:mÌ<=g(<e^fE°mÍ<=>

?(;fJTU¬¼E0kfÎ5ÏÐ8l_gÑ�KCUq

ÒÓTÔ�( )*+,-./+cdÕÖ~×ØÙÚE9:m�<=g(E4I'ªUE

@ABC+D)FGH/+ÏÛÄ ¿¹Ü¥~1hÚE��g`PabÝÞ+b]ßE

E E qàáâË~ÏãÙÚ ¡À( äå¾08i`Pabcd~æçÙÚKCU�J'ªU

789:;!"#<=>?@ABCDEFGHI JKLMN

Page 23: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!�

O &'()*+,(PQ

#%&'(E°&è{234+<=éê'ªUë4è{+ìígEYc,-PîJ8

K)*+,-./5ïðgñòóôUJJ»gE�+0kõöJ8K9:m÷<=(møù

úû5üýþJ8Ké§8KCUq

)*+,-./+ÿ 5!"g#Tq

 $ )*+,-./+<eç®éê5E%<=+�&"'gu1TU&+())*>~¥

�/'+LTU,>EV&§'gPQ5`-K./8KCUq

 �¥0812�(Ewx<yz{:&|4}�34'ªjE;fzK+¹º¯+565

<=�«g01234'1�KCUq¬*E¹º¯+56g�i�K(E01234

g*CKEP<g788NNE&L+MN+OPQ>?9É�:;<=¼»i¸~¹

ºTU;>g?@8KCUq

 � )*+,-./+i¥

AgÝB+.C5*C

KCUqDiEç.E

g(E.CFGH.C

  ¥ EIJKL¯ gºp

M�N<j+KLË'

ÎA+OÉ�PQ�~

RSFGKLg�i�

KCUq

 V )*+,-./+ä¥

Ef�ij+¹º¯Î(

,-.J8KT¦²J

UhÚKCUEm!AV

=+xAÎ'0k8K

q E ECU Di ¹ºö(

äA�ijM�WJ8

KMXû5YZ8KC

Uq

 M¥_[(E\]XE~

E E^_ ÌÌE~`aJ8

b"Qg(&cI+9

:~��+LdOPQ

5e�EVN+OPQ

5ff8K=¼»i¸

+go58KCUqD

iEha_'ªUij

_+kÅFG_j_g

(,-cd5�ÇÈÉ

Êl8KCU  _Vm¹Ü¥q

&'()*+,RST

n

on n nn «_+ij_n _n jn _n `n Pn _n

^_n n XEn XEn

pq>iNôn

rs��tunn XEWXEm!vn XEWXEm!vn

]Mwxn

yz+{enn XEm!vWXEù�vn XEm!vWXEù�v

]Mn

Å>iNônn XEù�vW\Em�vn XEù�vW\Em�v

bQn n n \Eù�vn

n n

k%|n :}~��n

�n Mn z�Mn

kn Ån �:���n

PQn

"Qn

ç.�n mÍEn

����P����

,-cdn

nm�Eù�vn

��j_(m!Eù�v

�Mwxn

¬¼�cdnm�Eù�vWmtEù�v m�Eù�vWmtEù�vn mtEWm÷En

�M�Å>iNô mtEù�vWm÷En mtEù�vWm÷En m÷EWm÷Eù�vn

��Jt�n m÷Eù�vWmøEù�v m÷Eù�vWmøEù�vn møEWÌ�En

��PQ�Èn

Pî��+�nÌ�EWÌmEù�vn Ì�EWÌmEù�vn Ì�EWÌmEù�vn

`an ÌÌEn ÌÌEn ÌÌEn

nn n n ��n n $�_j_~��+Ia(ELdO,{�'�:���51CDTqn

n n n n n n n ���j_+"QÅE�$Ee+�6'�+�GÐ��GË51CDTqn

n n n n n n n ��þj_+�M�Å>iNôÅgE)*�Ú4/51CDTqn

n n n n n n n V� ¡_ i¥(E`P_J°-Ee¢'1d8DTqn

Page 24: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!t

U &'()*+,(VW

#%&~0kTU�+)*+,-./+Ò£J8K(E¤\]^_JC>cd5<e

;f»0k8KCUJC>�eJfÎ+¾0E¥&LMN+OPQ+¦PQE¦P<+

=¼»i¸+¹ºE§äf�ijm!AV=+T¦²¬xAÎJTUè{²¬¨©Eª«

¬¯+iA+kã'ªU)­ÚªCb]kã®FGH /54IJ8K0k8KCU�¯

J'ªUq

8>8E�+;>¬°±?8C)*+,-./~ «>?0k'�ihô'(¬Cq

)*+,-./5Y2E{KK�i+(°&ë4è{234+}C53AKCUEwx

<yz{:&|4}4C+²³´µ+¶·J1d¸g¹>J�º~»�Cq¸¬2gE

J»TÚ¼1½¾2J¬j~¸¬¿Àq,+|'E°&|4}'(E&LMQÁg67

5ãôUJJ»gEä¢�ijmt�û+4ö5hAEcd+÷5JÄ8KCUq

DiE=¼»i¸+b"QE+9:gNCK»E¡À(&cI+9:J+�JÅ~E

�«(&L+Æ�~cI+9:5ÇÈ8K<Úi�>'ªUqDiE�+Å(��gª

UÉʬË�+ÌÍ·'9:5Î8KCiÅCiJ+�J'ªUq¬*E�+Ë�(E

¡À»)*+,-./0k�e|gE=¼»i¸5ÏÐgÑÒ8K<ÚKCUJ+�J

'ªUq

9:m�<=gE4I'ªU@ABC+D)FGH/~E`Pab+iAgÏÛÄÙÚ

E ) /i~ �ÚgNCK»ÓÔ8»ÝÞ'(¬C@ABC+D5cÞ8¬~? *+,-.

50k8:¦5§¨K�i0Õ5ÖDpE&CEè{C5×AE}4ØÙ¯Ë+ÚÛ~

ª�K0¡8i»+'ªº>q«¬¯+iA+kã54IJ8K0k8KCU©(EÜ

�Ee ÝhÚ¬CEe¥~ÞCRßkã5EàTJ�º¬<áÞTUJC>E*âã

+;>¬cÞäå'ªUq

�+iG)*+,-./50ægçè8EéÐ$+üýþË5�ÒTU'»¬<EÃ

vi¸+¿À(Ãvi¸+¸'JC>EDÙg)¿5ê>ë4è{/+ÁÂ5çiëC

'ªUq

 ìí îï¥

XYDZ[\]GH^_`abcdMefgahijk+l(dM

Page 25: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

!"

!"#$%&'()*+,-./0'1)*+23$45

63$452789:;2<=6

!"#$%&'#()*+,-./0123+456789:;<=>?=%@AB

CD=E+FGH!IJ:KL=AMN%O!PQ3RSTUCDT.H+EVWXFY

> ?@2789ABCDEFG()*,1)*

Z[\.GH!/012!]^_`aMbcdY

eH$%fghij.Z[\klmnopqrstu#%fghvjw.x\yzmyz$+{N

p|}~�0�#>?��d/012#bFY�[\#$%���p#fgh�j.�-

�/0����5M��cdY #$%��M�cE+F}~�0��3���p!

/012.H+EKLVWXFY

AB%�p�1�.�cE%yzp|}~�0�$��z�|}~�0�.%���

p$���3AcdY���p!/012!��#bF�� ¡0�$%���|��

 ¡0�3AcdY

H IJKL2M;N,OPQRSTUV

}~�0�!¢£¤¥¦�=0�§$%fgh�j¨©¤&ª«¬­®&ªn¬�#¯°®

&!&±#%¤j�²N³j��#´0jµ¶·58¸¹ºu»t¼·%1½¾¿·!ÀÁ

Â#>Ã��dYÄÅÂ$%}~�0�ÆÇÈ3}~É�ÊjË#%ÌÍMyzpqr

stu3}~�0�3AcE+FY

���p!£¤¥�-�/0����5$%Î-:fgh�jÏ©ÐÑ.¨°¼&%Ì

-:xjµ¶©³&ªÒ¬­Ó&ª&¬¼°¯&!1½®°Ô&3+4&±#%Ì-./0�

ÕdYÀÁÂ$�0�µ¿·�¯jÖ× %Ø0�¼·#bcdYÄÅÂ$��pÙÚÛ�

3��pÜÝ)uÞ^Âßàu#bcdY

}~�0�¢¦�=0�§!ÄÅÂ!el$}~É�ÊjË#bFYá,!Z[âã

äI!åæ=. ¢ÊjËMçèÞé§3êëAìíMîcE+FY%

+cï4!���p!ÊjË$fgh�jw.$ðñ=E+dY���p$òóôõ.

�cE%fg¿hj.ö¨÷ø+døùM%¨jÌ!fg¿vj.$ö¤÷Ïúø.%ûü

ýþXFÉÿ !:"E%Éÿ:#$Eëd%uqr&'Ë $%AB()!e*:d

ÝcE+dYfghij%���p!�-�/0����5!ÄÅÂ#bF��pÜÝ)

uÞ^Âßàu$%O��#+,-=E./01.B2+cE+dxßàu:34X5

6%p�.Ê7j!8Uqr���59::;43+4<<:dEE%=hhj²N>>

.?cdYp²N@A:BC��dpDE:FG.%h¾­hvj3HI2!JKL:I2

McE:NMOPN�d ¢:QAMNR4%R+AMN:F§:1+ST.UV3%Y

=²=WK².OPN�dY���59X6Q.YZ=dÜÝ)uÞ^Âßàu![\

]^_M%�-�/0����5>`!a.AcE+cdY

Page 26: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

b hc b

W XYZ2[\]$%^_2!",`a^_2./

}~�0��!/012!æ;�$0�qrdef.bcdY���p!/012!

æ;�$%uqr.bcdY}~�£¤¥>?äg!¤h.%}~�0��iÒjkl

]�!mnìMop��E+FYq6 ¢yzp$Éÿ0rsOÉ�!Þt:uv%p%

qr!Ãw.êë6`Q×xN��y %pqrstu�Qz'_A{|:uv%O��

:0�M}~XFA²#É��ÚM �cE !��.ß�=E+d�ë%@%�6�

���E+F¢�²Aø�T:rEF§qr!e�:�Q�dI:��#+F)!#b

F §�N².%0�qr!��²N}~��d/012#bFYY

+cï4%���p!/012$%1�_.%uqr>?!;<3�.Xv.�cE

����dY}~�£¤¥>?äg$����!¾¶h.��)!#��?Q#bFY�

��p!£¤¥�-���5!äg$H�2!�e58e�_ìí#%h�h!��.�

�#%���. '�v:¡¢=E:cd£¤A)!#bFY¥¦§.)¨+MbFY

b ac2[\]de2!",DfVg$%2./

}~�0�!¢¦�=0�§!2°�$%x�0�²N©+Eöh¶ª!«¬õØ­.

bF®¯õ°±²�³�´µ�¶�#bFY

% Y � ����p!2°�$ G-.ª²�F Î-$���59#`Qa��d�- /0

���5%Ì-$%fg¾¿j.��cd·Aø#bF�� ¡0�#!/012#b

FY¹º»j.��¼M½º=EÖ¾%'¿_A/012M��cdY

h !"#$%&,-./023$452ij

�¤�ÀÂ3).%]`>?3Á�.Â�Ã=+*+,-²N��cd`a#bFY

�¨�}~�0�!¦�=0�$%yzpMÉÿ0rsOÉ�!Þt:uvd 3MÄÅ

.AcEBQ%0�!}~.É��ÚMß�XF3+4ÆÇ#��cdY

�¼����p$%`ÈÃw3=E1É.ÊJ:åA+/012·Aø3=E ¢p|%

�� ¡0�§:ËJ.�Q¸Ì=dY�� ¡0�$%ÍɼÎÏ.��¼3��

ì-ÐÑÒ��_!Øaø:D=E+FYÓ#ÔÕ:Ö×=%ØKÙAÝ!�Ú:

ÛÜ=%Ýo::Q%Þß:Ö×=%f�7à:rá=8X6Q.`Qa�#ëdY

�¯�}~�0�!¦�=0�$%Bâ:ãA=E+F 3MêëAPQ#bFY�¶!

% YÞä3>>.�cE O��#ÜÝ)M ¡=d 3!A+£¤AåIM�æ��F

¢ç­$(«!èé�§!STM£¤¥>?äg.�cE+FY

�®����p!/012$%³°Ô&:z'&±3=E¤¥µ¶·!êë#%j�춥>

Ã=EëdY¹º»j²Nµ�j�>Ã=EëdY/012!íîï3ð��E+FY

k lm2!"#$%&,-./023$45

�¤�}~�0��£ìh¥¦�=0�$%¹ºµ�jµ¶©µ¶&ª«¬­µi&ªn¬¯°®&!&

±#°±²�«¬õ�#>Ã��dYÀÁÂ$¤j�²N³j��#0jñ3!ÀÁ

øt$xò#$A+M%óôh¶·#bcdY}~�0�ÆÇÈMÄÅ=dYäg!N

õö.$0�3ÆÇÈMO���»÷:ªø=Eìí/Qe 0ù!úû:=dYü

å%ýå!,�.$ ¢$=:IcE%;4².þñ3.¤ÿ# ÿ ¢´!#%=% §

Page 27: 国立教育政策研究所 National Institute for …! @ `arstu ųNj1Œ“ŽnbEcgÜÝ œœœ Þ>gh-ßà-áâ-Sãäå† Å0ÇæçGè œœœœœœœœœœœ éêë^-ìíîïð†

b ¾¶ b

% § %¢ § Y"5N# ,��.��#å5F ì¶$h¶. ´!3%&b+�H 3��E+F

>?äg$¾ch.��'UA)!M:N�E+E%£¤¥>?äg3û3�Ý(ÃN

A+Y

�¨����p$%¹ºµ�j¼©.���.1�=dY1�Ì!����!�0�)$ìì

�#bFY ��#!p�*e!�0�K+!/0123$S(ÃQ=dY3Qb$

#%¤0-$,->Ã=Eëd���0�¹º!.:K+.>Ã=dY¨0-Ö¾$

1��:K+.¨�e5!12:>Ã=dYeH$%���0�¹º!.:K+.=

d,-/!³°Ô&!/0123%0!eH$¨°¼&!�� ¡12#bFYÌÂ

$���0�:1+dìµ�!®U³j�¹º:K+.=d12#bFY�� ¡12

$23&4̳,.Z1=E&3&4Ì®,.ðñXFY

% Y %H�Q /0=A+12#bF ¨0-$���0�3ìµ�!¹º$5V!6º.

¼0-$1��7º!þ68#>Ã��dY���p|�� ¡0�.$A²cd9

)�0�!7º.�F123AcdYj�!>Ã¥)$µi¥%ÀÁ¹º$öµi¶·#

bcdYO!42%���0�Ö:²N!ÀÁÂ$ì¾·#bcdY

�´¹ ;<�