65
"#$%&'()% *#)+,$- *,./ 0&%,$(%% 1$2 -#3()$'($. 4#) 1$ ,'5)#3(2 '1)+(.561"( !"!# %&'() *+,))+- . 78 /0&&,- 1&,&'+&- 2'+3,4& 5.* !67 9 :8;<=> ?@AB?CDBEAFA 9 GGGHI;<JKL=MJI;K<INOHI;L "/1$-,$- 61$2%"15( #4 *,)(6(%% 561$% EPPF )(3,(* #4 5)(51,2 1$2 5#%.51,2 *,)(6(%% 561$% 1$2 "#$%&'() "#$"()$%

C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

!"#$%&'()% !*#)+ ,$- !* ,./ !0&% ,$(%% !1$2 !-#3()$'($. ! 4#) !1$ ! ,'5)#3(2 !'1)+(.561"( !

! " ! # $ % & ' ( ) $ * + , ) ) + - $ . 7 8 $ / 0 & & , - $ 1 & , & ' + & - $ 2 ' + 3 , 4 & $5. * $ ! 6 7 ! 9 ! : 8 ;< = > ! ? @A B ?CD B EAFA ! 9 !GGG H I ;< JKL= M J I ;K< I N O H I ;L !

!

!

!

!

!

"/1$-,$-!61$2%"15(!#4!*,)(6(%%!561$%!

EPPF!)(3,(*!#4!5)(51,2!1$2!5#%.51,2!*,)(6(%%!561$%!1$2!"#$%&'()!"#$"()$%!

Page 2: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$8

!

Page 3: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$9

.RTO=!;Q!";<7=<7J!

.RTO=!;Q!";<7=<7J HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHD!

1IU<;GO=SV=L=<7JHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHW!

1T;K7!78=!";<JKL=MJ!";K<INO!;Q!"R<RSR HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHW!

4;M=G;MSHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHA!

(X=IK7NY=!%KLLRMZ HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH[!

,<7M;SKI7N;<!R<S!0RIUVM;K<SHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHF!

,<SKJ7MZ!R<S!%=MYNI=!#Y=MYN=G HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH@@!

*NM=O=JJ!$=7G;MUJ\!#:=MR7;MJ!R<S!.=I8<;O;VN=J HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH@@!

'3$#J!R<S!*8N7=BORT=O!TMR<SJHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH@E!

5M=:RNS!R<S!5;J7:RNS!*NM=O=JJ!%=MYNI= HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH@E!

5M=:RNS!*NM=O=JJ!%=MYNI=!2=JIMN:7N;< HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH@D!

5;J7:RNS!*NM=O=JJ!%=MYNI=!2=JIMN:7N;< HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH@C!

5;J7:RNS!*NM=O=JJ!5OR<J!]!";L:RMNJ;<!R<S!#TJ=MYR7N;<J HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHE?!

*NM=O=JJ!'RMU=7!^!,<SKJ7MZ!,JJK=JHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHEW!

-;Y=M<L=<7\!";<JKL=M!1SY;IRIZ\!0O;VJ!R<S!,<SKJ7MZ!%N7=J!]!%KLLRMZ!;Q!,JJK=JHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHEW!

";LLNJJN;<=M!Q;M!";L:ORN<7J!Q;M!.=O=I;LLK<NIR7N;<J!%=MYNI=J HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHEW!

.8=!5KTONI!,<7=M=J7!1SY;IRIZ!"=<7M=HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHEA!

*NM=O=JJ!%;R:T;X!]!*,$2!';TNO=HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHEA!

.8=!#QQNI=!S=!OR!5M;7=I7N;<!SK!";<J;LLR7=KMHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHE[!

/;GRMS!4;MKLJ HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHE[!

_H2H!5;G=M!R<S!1JJ;INR7=J!EPPF!"R<RSNR<!*NM=O=JJ!%R7NJQRI7N;<!%7KSZ HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHEC!

,<SKJ7MZ!-;Y=M<R<I=!B!"*.1 HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHEC!

"R<RSNR<!'RMU=7!6=VNJOR7N;<!`!1I7NYN7Z HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHEF!

4=S=MRO HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHEF!

#<7RMN;!R<S!1OT=M7RHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHEF!

Page 4: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$.

aK=T=IHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHDP!

)=YN=G!;Q!%N7KR7N;<!]!#K7JNS=!;Q!"R<RSRHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHD@!

%KLLRMZ!;Q!&H%H!%N7KR7N;<J!R<S!)=VKOR7N;<HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHD@!

1KJ7MRONR!]!.=O=I;LLK<NIR7N;<J!,<SKJ7MZ!#LTKSJLR< HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHDE!

*NM=O=JJ!%=MYNI=!";L:ORN<7!1<ROZJNJ!]!"".%!2R7R!R<S!&J=M!%KMY=ZHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHD?!

"".%!";L:ORN<7!1<ROZJNJ HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHD?!

";L:ORN<7J!1<ROZJNJ!%KLLRMZHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHDC!

";<JKL=M!%KMY=Z!]!5M=:RNS!R<S!5;J7:RNS!5OR<JHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHDF!

'=78;S;O;VZHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHDF!

%KMY=Z!%KLLRMZHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH?P!

5M=:RNS!*NM=O=JJ!%KMY=Z!%KLLRMZ HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH?@!

5;J7:RNS!*NM=O=JJ!%KMY=Z!%KLLRMZ HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH?D!

.;:!,JJK=J!%KLLRMNb=SHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH??!

";<QNMLR7N;<!%KMY=Z!;Q!1I7NY=!";<JKL=MJHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH?W!

'=78;S;O;VZHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH?W!

5,$!%KMY=Z!)=JKO7J!R<S!4==STRIUHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH?W!

";<IOKJN;<J!R<S!5;7=<7NRO!-;Y=M<L=<7!)=J:;<J=HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH?[!

1::=<SNI=J HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH?F!

1::=<SNX!1!]!5M=:RNS!*NM=O=JJ!.RU=J!;QQ HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH?F!

1::=<SNX!0!]!";<7MRI7!"R<I=OOR7N;<!4==J HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHWP!

1::=<SNX!"!]!";<JKL=M!%KMY=Z HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHWE!

1::=<SNX!2!]!1I7NY=!";<JKL=M!%KMY=Z!EP@PHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHWA!

1::=<SNX!(!]!)=Q=M=<I=JHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHAE!

Page 5: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$7

1IU<;GO=SV=L=<7J!

";<JKL=MJ!";K<INO!;Q!"R<RSR!M=I=NY=S!QK<SN<V!QM;L!,<SKJ7MZ!"R<RSRcJ!";<7MNTK7N;<J!5M;VMRL!Q;M!$;<B:M;QN7!";<JKL=M!

R<S!3;OK<7RMZ!#MVR<NbR7N;<JH!.8=!YN=GJ!=X:M=JJ=S!N<!78NJ!M=:;M7!RM=!<;7!<=I=JJRMNOZ!78;J=!;Q!,<SKJ7MZ!"R<RSR!;M!;Q!78=!

-;Y=M<L=<7!;Q!"R<RSRH!)=J=RMI8!Q;M!78NJ!M=:;M7!GRJ!I;LLNJJN;<=S!R<S!:M=:RM=S!TZ!%INM=!%;OK7N;<J!,<IH!R<S!%=R0;RMS!

-M;K:H!

.8=!RK78;MJ!G;KOS!ONU=!7;!78R<U!78=!";<JKL=MJ!";K<INO!;Q!"R<RSRcJ!J7==MN<V!I;LLN77==!d+=<!*8N7=8KMJ7\!1LN7!+RLN<=M!

R<S!78=!$=7G;MU!;Q!e;K<V!";<JKL=MJ!;Q!#<7RMN;fH!,7J!VKNSR<I=!GRJ!N<YROKRTO=\!RJ!G=M=!78=!N<:K7J!QM;L!;KM!

L=78;S;O;VNJ7\!'=VR<!";O=JH!!/;GRMS!'RU=M\!";LLNJJN;<=M!;Q!78=!"".%!R<S!LR<Z!N<SKJ7MZ!N<JNS=MJ!R<S!M=7RNO=MJ!ROJ;!

VRY=!78=NM!7NL=!R<S!N<JNV87J\!G8NI8!G=M=!LKI8!R::M=INR7=SH!

";:N=J!;Q!78NJ!S;IKL=<7!IR<!T=!S;G<O;RS=S!R7!877:>^^GGGHI;<JKL=MJI;K<INOHI;L!

!

!

1T;K7!78=!";<JKL=MJ!";K<INO!;Q!"R<RSR!

.8=!";<JKL=MJ!";K<INO!;Q!"R<RSR!NJ!"R<RSRcJ!L;J7!RI7NY=\!I;K<7MZGNS=\!LKO7NBNJJK=!I;<JKL=M!VM;K:H!.8=!";K<INO!8=O:J!

TKJN<=JJ!R<S!V;Y=M<L=<7!LR<RV=!7;SRZcJ!I;<JKL=M!NJJK=JH!,7!RNLJ!7;!IM=R7=!R<!=QQNIN=<7\!=gKN7RTO=\!=QQ=I7NY=!R<S!JRQ=!

LRMU=7:ORI=H!#MVR<Nb=S!RJ!R<!N<S=:=<S=<7\!<;7BQ;MB:M;QN7!;MVR<NbR7N;<\!78=!";K<INO!GRJ!Q=S=MROOZ!N<I;M:;MR7=S!N<!@FF?H!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

h!EP@P!";<JKL=MJ!";K<INO!;Q!"R<RSR!

Page 6: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$:

4;M=G;MS!

.8=!";<JKL=MJ!";K<INO!;Q!"R<RSR!N<Y=J7NVR7=S!78=!M=RO!R<S!:=MI=NY=S!I;<JKL=M!NJJK=J!GN78N<!78=!GNM=O=JJ!LRMU=7:ORI=\!

=J:=INROOZ!Q;M!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!N<!"R<RSR!R<S!M=I;LL=<SJ!RI7N;<J\!NQ!M=gKNM=S\!7;!NL:M;Y=!I;<JKL=M!:M;7=I7N;<H!

.8NJ!NJ!N<!U==:N<V!GN78!78=!LNJJN;<!;Q!78=!";<JKL=MJ!";K<INO!;Q!"R<RSR!7;!:M;YNS=!IM=SNTO=\!=YNS=<I=BTRJ=S!

M=:M=J=<7R7N;<!;Q!78=!I;<JKL=M!:=MJ:=I7NY=!7;!V;Y=M<L=<7!R<S!TKJN<=JJ\!N<!;MS=M!7;!=<8R<I=!:;ONIZ!S=Y=O;:L=<7!R<S!

:M;VMRLLN<VH!,<!RSSN7N;<\!78=!";K<INO!J==UJ!7;!G;MU!I;OORT;MR7NY=OZ!GN78!I;<JKL=MJ\!TKJN<=JJ!R<S!V;Y=M<L=<7!7;!J;OY=!

LRMU=7:ORI=!:M;TO=LJH!.8=!";K<INO!:M;YNS=J!N<Q;MLR7N;<!<==S=S!TZ!I;<JKL=MJ!R<S!I;<JKL=M!M=:M=J=<7R7NY=J!7;!G;MU!

GN78!TKJN<=JJ!R<S!V;Y=M<L=<7!7;!=<JKM=!78=!MNV87J!;Q!";<JKL=MJH

Page 7: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$;

(X=IK7NY=!%KLLRMZ!

.8=!";<JKL=MJ!";K<INO!;Q!"R<RSR\!R!I;<JKL=M!RSY;IRIZ!R<S!M=J=RMI8!;MVR<NbR7N;<\!I;LLNJJN;<=S!M=J=RMI8!Q;M!78NJ!J7KSZ!

GN78!JK::;M7!QM;L!,<SKJ7MZ!"R<RSRcJ!#QQNI=!;Q!";<JKL=M!1QQRNMJ!7;!N<Y=J7NVR7=!I;<JKL=M!NJJK=J!I;<I=M<N<V!:M=:RNS!

GNM=O=JJ!:OR<J!N<!78=!"R<RSNR<!LRMU=7:ORI=H!";<JKL=MJ!RM=!:RJJN;<R7=!RT;K7!78=NM!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!R<S\!RJ!;Q!78=!QROO!;Q!

EPPC!G8=<!78NJ!M=:;M7!GRJ!:M;:;J=S\!I;<JKL=M!I;L:ORN<7J!M=OR7=S!7;!=XNJ7N<V!GNM=O=JJ!:OR<J!N<IOKS=S>!

• 1II=JJ!4==J!diAHFWBiCHFWf!

• ,<I;LN<V!.=X7!L=JJRVN<V!"8RMV=J!

• "ROO!2=7RNO!)=I;MS!RYRNORTNON7Z!Q;M!TKOU!LN<K7=!:OR<J!

• 0NOON<V!,<RIIKMRIN=J!R<S!NJJK=J!

• 5M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!(X:NMZ!5;ONIN=J!

• /NSS=<!"8RMV=J!

• ";<7MRI7!.=MLN<R7N;<!R<S!8NSS=<!Q==J!

!

)=J=RMI8!GRJ!K<S=M7RU=<!78M;KV8!N<SKJ7MZ!I8R<<=OJ!R<S!I;<JKL=M!JKMY=ZJ!7;!S=7=MLN<=>!

• *8R7!RM=!78=!J;KMI=J!;Q!78=!I;<JKL=M!I;L:ORN<7Jj!

• *8R7!7Z:=J!;Q!GNM=O=JJ!:OR<J!RM=!;QQ=M=Sj!*8R7!NJ!78=!I;<JKL=M!=X:=MN=<I=j!

• *8R7!RM=!78=!I;L:ORN<7J!7Z:=J!R<S!J8;KOS!R<Z!I;<JKL=M!:M;7=I7N;<!O=VNJOR7N;<!T=!N<7M;SKI=Sj!

• /RY=!;78=M!I;K<7MN=J!N<7M;SKI=S!R<Z!I;<JKL=M!:M;7=I7N;<!M=OR7=S!7;!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=J\!:RM7NIKORMOZ!:M=:RNSj!

• *8R7!J8;KOS!78=!V;Y=M<L=<7!S;!7;!=<8R<I=!I;<JKL=M!:M;7=I7N;<j!

0RJ=S!;<!78=!M=J=RMI8!I;<SKI7=S!SKMN<V!78=!J7KSZ\!78=!I;<IOKJN;<J!RM=!RJ!Q;OO;GJ>!

@H ,<!78=!EPPF!";<JKL=MJ!";K<INO!;Q!"R<RSR!M=J=RMI8!M=:;M7\!6;<V!2NJ7R<I=!58;<=!"RMSJ\!N7!GRJ!Q;K<S!78R7!J8;M7!

=X:NMZ!:=MN;SJ!;<!:M=:RNS!O;<V!SNJ7R<I=!I;KOS!:M;YNS=!78=!I;<JKL=M!R!V;;S!YROK=!78M;KV8!Y=MZ!O;G!MR7=J!;M!

K<ONLN7=S!7ROU!7NL=!Q;M!R!J8;M7!:=MN;SH!!4;M!78NJ!M=RJ;<!R<S!I;<JKL=M!T=<=QN7\!<;!I;<7M;OJ!d;78=M!78R<!NL:M;Y=S!

SNJIO;JKM=f!G=M=!M=I;LL=<S=SH!!5M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!:OR<J\!;<!78=!;78=M!8R<S\!V=<=MROOZ!I;<7RN<!=X:NMZ!:=MN;SJ!

78R7!RM=!gKN7=!J8;M7!I;L:RM=S!7;!;78=M!:M=:RNS!J=MYNI=J\!GN78!<;!R::RM=<7!I;<JKL=M!T=<=QN7!;M!N<I=<7NY=!Q;M!

78=J=!ONLN7=S!=X:NMZ!7=MLJH!!#KM!L;J7!I;J7BI;<JIN;KJ!I;<JKL=MJ!dFC!:=M!I=<7f!I8;;J=!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!7;!I;<7M;O!

;M!LN<NLNb=!78=NM!I;J7\!TK7!78=J=!JRL=!I;<JKL=MJ!RM=!JKTk=I7!7;!L;<78OZ!lTROR<I=!IO=RMN<Vc!K<O=JJ!78=Z!RVM==!7;!

:KMI8RJ=!L;M=!I;<<=I7N;<!7NL=H!

EH 5M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=\!ONU=!:M=:RNS!O;<V!SNJ7R<I=\!I;<7RN<J!R<!=X:NMR7N;<!:;ONIZ!78R7!SNQQ=MJ!RJ!R!:M=:RNS!

:M;SKI7^J=MYNI=!K<S=M!IKMM=<7!:M;YN<INRO!ORGH!!aK=T=IcJ!0NOO!AP!:M;:;J=J!7;!N<IOKS=!78NJ!J=MYNI=!K<S=M!R!l:M=:RNS!

KLTM=OOR\c!TK7!:M;YN<INRO!ORGJ!J;!QRM!J==L!:N=I=L=RO!Q;M!G8R7!NJ!R!<R7N;<RO!J=MYNI=H!!$R7N;<RO!GNM=O=JJ!:M;SKI7J!

S;!<;7!I;<7RN<!I;<JNJ7=<7!7=MLJ!R<S!I;<SN7N;<J!RIM;JJ!78=!"R<RSNR<!LRMU=7H!

DH ";LL;<!:MRI7NI=!N<!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!M=7RNO!ROO;GJ!78=!JRO=!;Q!ONLN7=S!7=ML!:M;SKI7J!JNS=BTZBJNS=!GN78!K<ONLN7=S!

7=ML!:M=:RNS^VNQ7!IRMSJH!!";<JKL=M!I;<QKJN;<!NJ!N<8=M=<7!GN78!78NJ!I;LL;<!:MRI7NI=H!

?H @C!:=M!I=<7!;Q!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!KJ=MJ!RM=!I;<I=M<=S!RT;K7!8NSS=<!Q==J!R<S!L;M=!78R<!?P!:=M!I=<7!RM=!K<JKM=!;Q!

Q==J!78R7!LRZ!T=!N<!78=NM!L;<78OZ!I8RMV=H!!W[!:=M!I=<7!T=ON=Y=!78R7!78=Z!RM=!I8RMV=S!1II=JJ!4==J!Q;M!:M=:RNS!

GNM=O=JJ!G8=<\!N<!QRI7\!IRMMN=MJ!S;!<;7!I8RMV=!78NJ!Q==!;<!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJH!";<JKL=M!I;<QKJN;<!RT;K7!RJJ;INR7=S!

J=MYNI=!Q==J!NJ!R::RM=<7H!

WH [W!:=M!I=<7!;Q!ROO!"".%!I;L:ORN<7J!N<!:;J7:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!G=M=!N<!Q;KM!IR7=V;MN=J>!0NOON<V!(MM;MJ\!";<7MRI7!

.=MLN<R7N;<!2NJ:K7=J\!"KJ7;L=M!%=MYNI=!-MN=YR<I=J\!R<S!.=MLJ!`!";<SN7N;<J!"8R<V=JH!!.8=J=!IR7=V;MN=J!G=M=!

M=YN=G=S!N<!S=7RNO!R<S!RJJ=JJ=S!Q;M!L;M=!VMR<KORMN7Z!N<!78=!I;L:ORN<7!78=L=JH!!

Page 8: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$<

AH m&<QRNM<=JJn!NJ!R!I;LL;<!78=L=!RL;<V!ROO!IR7=V;MN=J!;Q!I;L:ORN<7J\!JKVV=J7N<V!IKJ7;L=MJ!:=MI=NY=!R<!K<=Y=<!

:ORZN<V!QN=OS!7N::=S!N<!QRY;KM!;Q!78=!IRMMN=MJ\!=J:=INROOZ!GN78!M=VRMSJ!7;!";<7MRI7!.=MLN<R7N;<!2NJ:K7=J!R<S!

.=MLJ!`!";<SN7N;<J!"8R<V=JH!

[H 1OL;J7!AP!:=M!I=<7!;Q!:;J7:RNS!JKMY=Z!M=J:;<S=<7J!IO;J=OZ!N<J:=I7!78=NM!L;<78OZ!J=MYNI=!TNOOJo!?W!:=M!I=<7!JRNS!

78=Z!Q;K<S!@BD!TNOON<V!=MM;MJ!;<!78=NM!L;<78OZ!J=MYNI=!TNOO!;Y=M!78=!ORJ7!Z=RM!R<S!0NOON<V!(MM;MJ!GRJ!R!O=RSN<V!

"".%!I;L:ORN<7!IR7=V;MZH!"KMN;KJOZ\!R!JKMY=Z!;Q!78=!";<JKL=MJ!";K<INO!;Q!"R<RSRcJ!5KTONI!,<7=M=J7!$=7G;MU!

d5,$f!Q;K<S!M=J:;<S=<7J!RM=!I;<QNS=<7!N<!78=NM!IRMMN=M!Q;M!TNOON<V!RIIKMRIZ\!TK7!O=JJ!J;!M=VRMSN<V!;<=BTNOON<VBIZIO=!

M=J;OK7N;<!G8=<!QRI=S!GN78!R!TNOON<V!SNJ:K7=H!!!

CH "KJ7;L=MJ!I;MM=OR7=!J:==S!;Q!TNOON<V!:M;TO=L!M=J;OK7N;<!GN78!gKRON7Z!;Q!IKJ7;L=M!IRM=o!N7!IR<!T=!N<Q=MM=S!78R7!78=!

?[!:=M!I=<7!;Q!:;J7:RNS!JKMY=Z!M=J:;<S=<7J!G8;J=!TNOON<V!=MM;MJ!G=M=!M=J;OY=S!GN78N<!;<=!TNOON<V!IZIO=!

=X:=MN=<I=S!R!M=OR7NY=OZ!8NV8!gKRON7Z!;Q!IKJ7;L=M!IRM=H!!$;7=>!J:==S!;Q!IRMMN=M!M=J;OK7N;<!NJ!R!<=VR7NY=!QK<I7N;<!;Q!

78=!RL;K<7!N<!SNJ:K7=H!

FH ';M=!78R<![P!:=M!I=<7!;Q!:;J7:RNS!M=J:;<S=<7J!S=JIMNT=S!78=NM!IKJ7;L=M!JR7NJQRI7N;<!O=Y=O!RJ!!"#$!%#!dDA!:=M!

I=<7f!;M!%&&'!dDW!:=M!I=<7fH!0RJ=S!;<!5MNI=^3ROK=\!5,$!M=J:;<S=<7J!MR7=S!78=NM!IRMMN=M!RJ!!"#$!%#!dDE!:=M!I=<7f!

;M!(&&$!dD?!:=M!I=<7fH!!!

@PH !"KJ7;L=M!J=MYNI=!I=<7M=J!;Q7=<!=XRI=MTR7=!IKJ7;L=M!I;L:ORN<7J^:M;TO=LJ!GN78!N<I;<JNJ7=<7!:MRI7NI=J!R<S!N<Q;MLR7N;<H!

0RJ=S!;<!78=J=!I;<IOKJN;<J!G=!;QQ=M!78=!Q;OO;GN<V!M=I;LL=<SR7N;<J>!

• 5M;VM=JJNY=!I;<JKL=M!:M;7=I7N;<!N<N7NR7NY=J\!JKI8!RJ!78;J=!:M;:;J=S!N<!aK=T=IcJ!0NOO!AP!J8;KOS!T=!SMNY=<!R7!R!<RB

7N;<RO!O=Y=OH!!1J!R<!N<N7NRO!J7=:\!,<SKJ7MZ!"R<RSR!I;KOS!R::M;RI8!78=!"*.1!7;!:M;:;J=!NL:M;Y=S!R<S!I;<JNJ7=<7!

<R7N;<RO!:;ONIN=J!M=OR7=S!7;!:M=:RNS!R<S!:;J7:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=J!R<S!ROO;G!N<SKJ7MZ!J=OQBM=VKOR7N;<!7;!=X=IK7=H!

• 1!JNL:O=\!J7R<SRMS^VKNS=ON<=!Q;M!Q==!SNJIO;JKM=!J8;KOS!T=!M=I;LL=<S=S!R<S!RS;:7=S!TZ!ROO!GNM=O=JJ!IRMMN=MJ!7;!

=ONLN<R7=!I;<JKL=M!I;<QKJN;<H!!.8NJ!SNJIO;JKM=!J8;KOS!T=!J8;G<!GN78!:MNIN<V!]!<;7!TKMN=S!N<!.=MLJ!R<S!";<SNB

7N;<J!;<!R!G=TJN7=H!!"O=RM!SNJIO;JKM=!78R7!78=!IRMMN=M!RJJ=JJ=J!<;<BLR<SR7=S!Q==J!dONU=!(F@@f!7;!M=I;Y=M!I;J7J!;Q!

N<QMRJ7MKI7KM=!J8;KOS!ROJ;!T=!M=gKNM=SH!!/;G=Y=M\!R!L;M=!:M;VM=JJNY=!=Y;OK7N;<!TZ!IRMMN=MJ!7;!I;<7N<K=!7;!=ONLNB

<R7=!=X7MR!Q==J\!TKNOSN<V!78=J=!I;J7J!N<7;!78=!L;<78OZ!I8RMV=\!NJ!M=I;LL=<S=SH!

• 5M;YN<INRO!N<N7NR7NY=J!dONU=!aK=T=I!0NOO!APf!J8;KOS!T=!M=YN=G=S!R<S\!NQ!M=gKNM=S\!SMNY=<!Q=S=MROOZ!RJ!L;J7!GNM=O=JJ!

J=MYNI=J!RM=!<R7N;<RO!TZ!<R7KM=!R<S!QRNM!I;<JKL=M!:M;7=I7N;<!J8;KOS!I;Y=M!ROO!"R<RSNR<JH!

• ";<JKL=MJ!LKJ7!T=!RGRM=!78R7!G8=<!I;LLN77N<V!7;!R!I=OO!:8;<=!I;<7MRI7\!78=Z!RM=!RVM==N<V!7;!R!I;L:M=8=<JNY=!

ONJ7!;Q!7=MLJ!R<S!I;<SN7N;<J\!ONU=OZ!GN78!QN<R<INRO!;TONVR7N;<J\!]!gKN7=!SNQQ=M=<7!78R<!G8=<!LRUN<V!R!J7MRNV87Q;MB

GRMS!M=7RNO!:KMI8RJ=H!"KJ7;L=MJ!LKJ7!S;!78=NM!:RM7!7;!=SKIR7=!78=LJ=OY=J!RT;K7!78=!QK7KM=!;TONVR7N;<J!;Q!78=NM!

GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!I;<7MRI7\!T=Q;M=!K<S=M7RUN<V!78=!I;LLN7L=<7H!!1::M;:MNR7=!V;Y=M<L=<7!T;SN=J!d=HVH!4=S=MROB

5M;YN<INROB.=MMN7;MNRO!";<JKL=M!'=RJKM=J!";LLN77==f!J8;KOS!=XRLN<=!G8=78=M!78=!7Z:NIRO\!;<=BJNS=S!I;<7MRI7!

J8;KOS!T=!78=!ROO;GRTO=!J7R<SRMS!Q;M!ROO!"R<RSNR<JH!

• "RMMN=MJ!J8;KOS!:M;YNS=!I;<JNJ7=<7!N<Q;MLR7N;<!7;!I;<JKL=MJ!QM;L!78=!:;N<7!;Q!JRO=!78M;KV8!7;!78=!RQ7=MBJRO=!IROO!

I=<7M=!=X:=MN=<I=H!"O=RM!TNOON<V!J7MKI7KM=J!R<S!:M;L;7N;<RO!;QQ=MN<VJ!RM=!U=Z!7;!LRN<7RN<N<V!R!V;;S!QO;G!;Q!N<B

Q;MLR7N;<!T=7G==<!T;78!:RM7N=JH!

• *N78!M=J:=I7!7;!I;<7MRI7!IR<I=OOR7N;<!Q==J\!M=J=RMI8!8RJ!J8;G<!78R7!IKMM=<7!I;<7MRI7!OR<VKRV=!NJ!TNRJ=S!7;GRMSJ!

78=!RSYR<7RV=!;Q!78=!IRMMN=M!O=RYN<V!I;<JKL=MJ!GN78!ROO!78=!ONRTNON7Z!R<S!MNJU!;Q!I;<7MRI7!7=MLN<R7N;<H!";<JKL=MJ!

RM=!V=<=MROOZ!RGRM=!78R7!78=!I;J7J!;Q!8R<SJ=7J!RM=!JKTJNSNb=S!R<S!RM=!<;7!RY=MJ=!7;!:RZN<V!R!Q==!7;!7=MLN<R7=!

78=NM!I;<7MRI7!RJ!O;<V!RJ!78NJ!Q==!NJ!lQRNMc!TRJ=S!;<!YRMNRTO=J!JKI8!RJ!78=!M=7RNO!I;J7!;Q!78=!8R<SJ=7!R<S!78=!M=LRN<B

N<V!SKMR7N;<!;Q!78=!J=MYNI=!RVM==L=<7H!!aK=T=IcJ!0NOO!AP!ROJ;!:M;:;J=J!I8R<V=J!7;!I;<7MRI7!7=MLN<R7N;<!Q==J!R7!R!

I;<7M;OO=S!I;J7!7;!78=!I;<JKL=M\!TK7!K<QRNM!I;<JKL=M!:MRI7NI=J!J8;KOS!T=!S=RO7!GN78!Q=S=MROOZH!

• .8=!"".%!NJ!R!YROKRTO=!I8R<<=O!Q;M!I;L:ORN<7!M=J;OK7N;<!R<S!R!YROK=S!M=:;JN7;MZ!;Q!NJJK=J!78R7!I;<I=M<!"R<RSNR<!

I;<JKL=MJH!!.8NJ!M=J=RMI8!:M;SKI=S!K<NgK=!R<S!YROKRTO=!I;L:ORN<7!SR7R!IR7=V;MNbR7N;<!<;7!<;MLROOZ!RYRNORTO=!

78M;KV8!=XNJ7N<V!7;;OJ!R<S!SR7RTRJ=!J;M7JH!!.8=!J7RU=8;OS=MJ!;Q!"".%!J8;KOS!N<Y=J7!N<!NL:M;Y=S!SR7RTRJ=!7;;OJ!

R<S!IR7=V;MNbR7N;<!;Q!NJJK=J!7;!T=77=M!RJJ=JJ!GNM=O=JJ!NJJK=J!R<S!78=!:M;VM=JJ!;Q!78=NM!L=LT=MJ!7;!M=J;OY=!78=LH!

Page 9: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$"

,<7M;SKI7N;<!R<S!0RIUVM;K<S!

,<!EPPC\!78=!"R<RSNR<!V;Y=M<L=<7!I;L:O=7=S!R!LKI8BR<7NIN:R7=S!GNM=O=JJ!J:=I7MKL!RKI7N;<!7;!=<RTO=!78=!=L=MV=<I=!;Q!

J=Y=MRO!<=G!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=MJ!;Y=M!78=!<=X7!Q=G!Z=RMJH!!,7!NJ!=X:=I7=S!78R7!78=!I;<JKL=M!RS;:7N;<!MR7=!Q;M!

GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!GNOO!N<IM=RJ=!MR:NSOZ!GN78!<=G!;:=MR7;MJ!R<S^;M!J=MYNI=!:OR<JH!!!

";<JKL=MJ!RM=!:RJJN;<R7=!RT;K7!78=NM!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!R<S\!RJ!;Q!78=!QROO!EPPC!G8=<!78NJ!M=:;M7!GRJ!:M;:;J=S\!I;<JKL=M!

I;L:ORN<7J!M=OR7=S!7;!=XNJ7N<V!GNM=O=JJ!:OR<J!N<IOKS=S>!

• 1II=JJ!4==J!diAHFWBiCHFWf!

• ,<I;LN<V!.=X7!L=JJRVN<V!"8RMV=J!

• "ROO!2=7RNO!)=I;MS!RYRNORTNON7Z!Q;M!TKOU!LN<K7=!:OR<J!

• 0NOON<V!,<RIIKMRIN=J!R<S!NJJK=J!

• 5M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!(X:NMZ!5;ONIN=J!

• /NSS=<!"8RMV=J!

• ";<7MRI7!.=MLN<R7N;<!R<S!/NSS=<!4==J!

!

*8NO=!m"=OO!58;<=!"8;NI=J!Q;M!"R<RSNR<J!]!1!"8=IUONJ7n!d;QQ=M=S!TZ!78=!#QQNI=!;Q!";<JKL=M!1QQRNMJf!NJ!RYRNORTO=!7;!8=O:!

I;<JKL=MJ!I8;;J=!R<!R::M;:MNR7=!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!:OR<!TRJ=S!;<!R<!RJJ=JJL=<7!;Q!78=NM!J:=INQNI!<==SJ\!78NJ!M=:;M7!Q;IKJ=J!

;<!IKJ7;L=M!JR7NJQRI7N;<!GN78!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=J!R<S!K<I;Y=MJ!78=!J=MYNI=!M=OR7=S!)*+#,($*+-H!

.8=!";LLNJJN;<=M!Q;M!";L:ORN<7J!Q;M!.=O=I;LLK<NIR7N;<J!%=MYNI=J!d"".%f\!R<!N<S=:=<S=<7!RV=<IZ!GN78!R!LR<SR7=!7;!

M=I=NY=!R<S!M=J;OY=!I;<JKL=M!R<S!JLROO!TKJN<=JJ!I;L:ORN<7J!M=OR7N<V!7;!L;J7!S=M=VKOR7=S!7=O=I;LLK<NIR7N;<J!J=MYNI=J\!

GNOO!T=!R!M=J;KMI=!Q;M!K<S=MJ7R<SN<V!=XNJ7N<V!NJJK=J!RL;<VJ7!I;<JKL=MJ!R<S!JLROO!TKJN<=JJH!!1J!;Q!78=!QROO!EPPF\!R7!O=RJ7!

Q;KM!<=G!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=MJ!8RY=!N<SNIR7=S!78=NM!:OR<J!7;!TKNOS!<=7G;MUJ!R<S!;QQ=M!J=MYNI=!7;!78=!"R<RSNR<!:KTONIH!!

,<!RSSN7N;<\!<=G!';TNO=!3NM7KRO!$=7G;MU!#:=MR7;MJ!d'3$#Jf!IR<!T=!=X:=I7=S!7;!;QQ=M!lM=JRO=c!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!K<S=M!<=G!

I;<JKL=M!TMR<SJ!]!<NI8=!TMR<SJ!GN78!K<NgK=!R<S!:M=:RNS!:MNIN<VH!!0M;RS!I;<JKL=M!I8;NI=!NJ!G=OI;L=S\!TK7!R<!N<Q;ML=S!

I;<JKL=M!IR<!RY;NS!TNOON<V!R<S!J=MYNI=!S=ONY=MZ!JKM:MNJ=JH!

0KNOSN<V!K:;<!78=!M=JKO7J!;Q!m6;<V!2NJ7R<I=!58;<=!"RMSJ!]!1M=!";<JKL=MJ!%R7NJQN=Sjn!dEPPCf\!G8NI8!Q;K<S!I;<JKL=MJ!IR<!

T=!LNJO=S!GN78!RSY=M7NJ=S!MR7=J\!8NSS=<!Q==J!R<S!:M=:RNS!J=MYNI=J!78R7!K<QRNMOZ!=X:NM=\!78NJ!:M;k=I7!GNOO!S=7=MLN<=!G8R7!

I;<JKL=M!NJJK=J!LKJ7!T=!RSSM=JJ=S!GN78N<!78=!GNM=O=JJ!N<SKJ7MZ\!:RM7NIKORMOZ!Q;M!:M=:RNS!J=MYNI=JH!!/;G=Y=M\!LR<Z!

:;J7:RNS!NJJK=J!IRL=!7;!ONV87!R<S!78NJ!GNM=O=JJ!:M;SKI7!GRJ!ROJ;!=XRLN<=SH!!.8=!7NLN<V!;Q!78NJ!M=:;M7!I;N<INS=J!GN78!78=!

:OR<<=S!ORK<I8!SR7=J!dLNSBEP@Pf!;Q!J;L=!<=G!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=MJ!d3NS=;7M;<\!';TNONIN7Z\!5KTONI!';TNO=f!R<S!

8=<I=\!LRZ!:M;YNS=!N<:K7!7;!78;J=!<=G!IRMMN=MJ!7;!=ONLN<R7=!mK<QRNM!I8RMV=Jn!R<S!7;!I;<JNS=M!I;<JKL=M!I;<I=M<JH!

5M=:RNS!L;TNO=!J=MYNI=!I;<7N<K=J!7;!T=I;L=!L;M=!:;:KORM!]!78=!VO;TRO!LRMU=7!Q;M!:M=:RNS!L;TNO=!J=MYNI=J!I;<7N<K=S!7;!

VM;G!L;M=!78R<!7GNI=!RJ!QRJ7!RJ!78=!I;<7MRI7!d:;J7:RNSf!LRMU=7!RII;MSN<V!7;!,<Q;MLR!.=O=I;LJ!`!'=SNR!dEPPCf!R<S!78NJ!

7M=<S!LRZ!T=!R::RM=<7!N<!"R<RSR!GN78!78=!<=G!:M;VMRLJ!R<7NIN:R7=S!TZ!78=!<=G!GNM=O=JJ!=<7MR<7JH!!!

#<!#I7;T=M!@J7\!EPP[\!78=!78=<!#<7RMN;!'N<NJ7MZ!;Q!";<JKL=M!R<S!-;Y=M<L=<7!%=MYNI=J!TR<<=S!=X:NMZ!SR7=J!;<!VNQ7!IRMSJ!

N<!;MS=M!7;!:M;7=I7!#<7RMN;!I;<JKL=MJ!G8;!:KMI8RJ=!;M!M=I=NY=!VNQ7!IRMSJ!;M!I=M7NQNIR7=JH!!&<Q;M7K<R7=OZ\!78NJ!RL=<SL=<7!

7;!78=!";<JKL=M!5M;7=I7N;<!1I7!EPPE!S;=J!<;7!I;Y=M!:M=:RNS!L;TNO=!:8;<=!J=MYNI=\!G8NI8!7Z:NIROOZ!=X:NM=J!R<ZG8=M=!

QM;L!DP!SRZJ!7;!AP!SRZJ!QM;L!RI7NYR7N;<!dJ;L=!<NI8=!TMR<SJ!R7!DAW!SRZJf\!S=:=<SN<V!K:;<!78=!YROK=!:KMI8RJ=SH!!

";<JKL=MJ!";K<INO!;Q!"R<RSR!M=J=RMI8!M=OR7=S!7;!lGNM=ON<=c!:M=:RNS!O;<V!SNJ7R<I=!Q;K<S!I;<JKL=M!QMKJ7MR7N;<!M=JKO7N<V!

QM;L!<;7!T=N<V!RTO=!7;!M=I=NY=!78=!QKOO!YROK=!;Q!78=!:M;SKI7!:KMI8RJ=S!T=Q;M=!78=!IRMS!=X:NM=JH!

Page 10: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$! #

)=J=RMI8!N<!78=!GNM=O=JJ!:M=:RNS!R<S!:;J7:RNS!RM=R!GRJ!K<S=M7RU=<!7;!K<S=MJ7R<S!I;<JKL=M!JR7NJQRI7N;<!R<S!I;<I=M<J!

GN78!K<QRNM!:;ONIN=JH!.8NJ!M=J=RMI8!GNOO!NS=<7NQZ!78=!J;KMI=!;Q!I;L:ORN<7J!R<S!LRU=!M=I;LL=<SR7N;<J!7;!RSSM=JJ!K<QRNM!

:MRI7NI=JH!!*8NO=!78NJ!M=:;M7!GRJ!N<7=<S=S!7;!:MNLRMNOZ!N<Y=J7NVR7=!NJJK=J!N<!78=!GNM=O=JJ!:M=:RNS!LRMU=7\!78=!JI;:=!GRJ!

=X:R<S=S!7;!N<IOKS=!I;<JKL=M!I;<I=M<J!N<!78=!:;J7:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!LRMU=7!R<S!8NV8ONV87!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=M!:OR<!

I8R<V=J!;Y=M!EPPF!R<S!N<N7NR7NY=J!K<S=MGRZ!78M;KV8!:M;:;J=S!0NOOJ!N<!J=O=I7=S!:M;YN<I=JH!!

Page 11: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

!"# $%&' ( $ ) ! "%# * + , ) " - ) ! . # ./ . ) !0123 423 ) 51267!189 ):; )< 4=95977 ) 8 5127 )!

" "

4#/%$>(?).#/)7'(@+*'):@'(@+'A)!"#$%$&&'($)*+#,&-'./$#0)+#&'012'3$451+%+6"$&'

1)A+(','$$)"()&"B+,')CD"#')#'>A"(E)*.#)B')/'-+#'/).$).)#'>A"(E)*"&C"$'/)"-)(./+")*',,$)>D.>)'#.B,')&"B+,')CD"#'$)>")*"&&%#+*.>')A+>D)"#').#">D'()A+>D"%>)>D')*"#$>(.+#>)"-)A+('$F))<+(','$$)CD"#'$G)AD+*D).(')C"(>.B,')>','CD"#'$G)('*'+@')"()$'#/)*.,,$)>D("%HD).)*',,)$+>')"()>(.#$&+>>+#H)>"A'()B?)%$+#H)(./+")A.@'$)>")>(.#$-'()$+H#.,$)B.*E).#/)-"(>D)B'>A''#)>D')/'@+*'$F)))

4#)2"(>D)1&'(+*.G)>D')>'(&$)A+(','$$)CD"#'G)&"B+,')CD"#').#/)*',,)CD"#').(')%$'/)+#>'(*D.#H'.B,?F)

ID('')#.>+"#.,)A+(','$$)#'>A"(E)"C'(.>"($)/"&+#.>')>D')&.(E'>)+#)!.#./.J1)

KF L',,)M"B+,+>?)N)1)$%B$+/+.(?)"-)L',,)!.#./.G)L',,)M"B+,+>?)OE#"A#).$)L',,)!',,%,.()%C)>")KPPQR)+$)"#')"-)!.#./.S$)>D('')#.>+"#.,)+#*%&B'#>)A+(','$$)$'(@+*'$)C("@+/'($F))<+>D)+>$)-,.#E'()B(.#/$G)7",").#/)T+(H+#G)L',,)M"B+,+>?)D.$).CC("U+&.>',?)VFW)&+,,+"#)$%B$*(+B'($G)"()QX)C'()*'#>)"-)>D')A+(','$$)$'(@+*'$)&.(E'>).#/)(%#$)0781)O$D.('/)A+>D)I',%$)M"B+,+>?R).,"#H$+/')+>$)!6M1)#'>A"(EF)

YF I',%$)M"B+,+>?)N)L.$'/)+#)L(+>+$D)!",%&B+.G)I',%$)M"B+,+>?)"--'($)A+(','$$)$'(@+*'$)>D("%HD"%>)!.#./.)A+>D)+>$)-,.#E'()B(.#/$)M+E').#/)Z""/")M"B+,'G).#/),.%#*D'/)+>$)$D.('/)OA+>D)L',,)M"B+,+>?R)0781)#'>A"(E)+#)'.(,?)2"@'&B'()YXXP)>")(%#).,"#H$+/')+>$)!6M1)#'>A"(EF))4>)D.$).CC("U+&.>',?)VF[)&+,,+"#)$%B$*(+B'($)"()YP)C'()*'#>)"-)>D')A+(','$$)$'(@+*'$)&.(E'>F))

QF ="H'($)<+(','$$)N)1)$%B$+/+.(?)"-)="H'($)!"&&%#+*.>+"#$G)="H'($)<+(','$$G)A+>D)+>$)-,.#E'()B(.#/);+/"G)"C'(.>'$)0781).#/)37M)#'>A"(E$)+#)!.#./.).#/)*"%#>$).)$%B$*(+B'()B.$')"-).CC("U+&.>',?)\F[)&+,,+"#)"()QW)C'()*'#>)"-)>D')A+(','$$)$'(@+*'$)&.(E'>F)

4#)&+/]6'*'&B'()YXXPG)<426)M"B+,')B'H.#)+>$)#.>+"#.,),.%#*DG)$>.(>+#H)+#)I"("#>").#/)!.,H.(?G).$)!.#./.S$)#'A'$>)#.>+"#.,)A+(','$$)$'(@+*'$)C("@+/'()"--'(+#H)@"+*'G)>'U>).#/)/.>.)$'(@+*'$)>D("%HD)>D'+()H("A+#H)0781)#'>A"(EF))<426)*%$>"&'($)(".&)"#)>D')="H'($)#'>A"(E)AD'#)"%>$+/')>D')<426)*"@'(.H').('.F))1>)>D')>+&')"-)A(+>+#H)>D+$)('C"(>G)<426)$%B$*(+B'()#%&B'($)A'(')%#.@.+,.B,'F)

!',,%,.(G)"()^A+(','$$GS)#'>A"(E)>'*D#","H+'$).(')>?C+*.,,?)*,.$$+-+'/)B?)>D'+()/'@',"C&'#>.,)$>.H')"())^H'#'(.>+"#FS))!.#./+.#)A+(','$$)#'>A"(E$).(')/"&+#.>'/)B?)$'*"#/]).#/)>D+(/]H'#'(.>+"#)>'*D#","H+'$)*"&&"#,?)('-'(('/)>").$)!").#/)#"F)

ID')Y3).#/)Q3)>'*D#","H+'$)C('@.,'#>)+#)!.#./.).('J)

307%$'89':;<<0#='+>'!"#$%$&&'3$451+%+6"$&'"1'?01020'

!"#$%&"&'()*+"$ ,'#$%&"&'()*+"$#$%! &'()*!#+,$! -%.$!!/)&0! 1$+23!4567*89! :)%2;<<<!&)#&! !"=,..! !

1 !<I1);.*>$)N)_QG)YXXP

Page 12: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$! 8

.8=M=!RM=!7G;!LRN<!I;L:=7N<V!GNM=O=JJ!<=7G;MU!7=I8<;O;VN=Jo!"2'1!R<S!-%'H!!.8=!<=7G;MU!7=I8<;O;VZ!=L:O;Z=S!TZ!R<!

;:=MR7;M!S=7=MLN<=J!78=!I;<JKL=M!8R<SJ=7!J=O=I7N;<H!!4;M!=XRL:O=\!78=!N<N7NRO!1::O=!N58;<=p!R<S!N7J!JKII=JJ;MJ\!78=!D-!

R<S!D-%\!;:=MR7=!;<!-%'^&'.%!<=7G;MUJH!!&:!7;!$;Y=LT=M!EPPF\!0=OO!';TNON7Z!R<S!.=OKJ!';TNON7Z!;:=MR7=S!"2'1!

<=7G;MUJ!]!78=Z!I;KOS!<;7!;QQ=M!78R7!I;Y=7=S!S=YNI=H!!!);V=MJ!*NM=O=JJ!]!78=!J;O=!-%'!;:=MR7;M!]!78=M=Q;M=!8RS!R!

d7=L:;MRMZf!L;<;:;OZ!;<!N58;<=p!J=MYNI=!N<!"R<RSRH!!!

!

!"#$%&'()&*+,-./0'1.0&12'()%&

'3$#J!

1!.&/*0#,"*$-1!0,+#-2&$3,&(#$!-&$!d'3$#f!NJ!R!M=J=OO=M!;Q!L;TNO=!:8;<=!J=MYNI=Jo!G8;O=JRO=!L;TNO=!:8;<=!J=MYNI=J!RM=!

M=J;OS!7;!<NI8=!LRMU=7J!7Z:NIROOZ!;<!R!:M=:RNS!TRJNJ!GN78!J;L=!M=I=<7OZ!;QQ=MN<V!:;J7:RNS!J=MYNI=JH!!'3$#J!S;!<;7!;G<!

78=NM!;G<!GNM=O=JJ!J:=I7MKL!R<S!7Z:NIROOZ!S;!<;7!;G<!<=7G;MU!N<QMRJ7MKI7KM=H!

3NMVN<!';TNO=!NJ!:M;TRTOZ!78=!L;J7!G=OO!U<;G<!'3$#H!!4NMJ7!ORK<I8=S!N<!78=!&+\!3NMVN<!';TNO=!"R<RSR!ORK<I8=S!'RMI8!@\!

EPPW!J;O=OZ!;<!R!:M=:RNS!TRJNJ\!7RMV=7N<V!R!Z;K<V=M!R<S!7M=<S!I;<JIN;KJ!LRMU=7H!!5;J7:RNS!J=MYNI=J!G=M=!;QQ=M=S!N<!=RMOZ!

EPPCH!!.8=!'3$#!GRJ!G8;OOZ!RIgKNM=S!TZ!0=OO!"R<RSR!;<=!Z=RM!OR7=MH!3NMVN<!';TNO=!J=MYNI=J!RM=!<;G!J;OS!RJ!R!0=OO!

';TNON7Z!QOR<U=M!TMR<SH!!

*8N7=!6RT=O!0MR<SJ!

'R<Z!"R<RSNR<J!8RY=!R!J=O=I7N;<!;Q!O=JJ=MBU<;G<!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!:M;SKI7J!RYRNORTO=!7;!78=L!K<S=M!U<;G<!I;<JKL=M!

TMR<S!ORT=OJH!!(XRL:O=J!;Q!J=O=I7=S!TMR<SJ!N<!78NJ!IR7=V;MZ!RM=>!5M=JNS=<7cJ!"8;NI=\![^@@!R<S!5=7M;B"R<H!!.8=!G8N7=!ORT=O!

:M;SKI7J!;QQ=M!R!JLROO!J=O=I7N;<!;Q!I;<JKL=MB:KMI8RJ=S!S=YNI=J!;<!:M=:RNS!J=MYNI=!;<OZ\!:KMI8RJ=S!N<!G8;O=JRO=!QM;L!R!

QRINON7ZBTRJ=S!IRMMN=MH!!

32.4',)&'()&35%-4',)&*,2.0.%%&6.27,8.&

*NM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!IR<!T=!SNYNS=S!N<7;!7G;!LRN<!IR7=V;MN=J!TRJ=S!;<!8;G!78=!J=MYNI=!NJ!KJ=S!]!:M=:RNS!R<S!:;J7:RNS!J=MYNI=H!!

5M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!NJ!:KMI8RJ=S!N<!RSYR<I=!;Q!KJ=\!G8NI8!L=R<J!78R7!R!I;<JKL=M!G;KOS!8RY=!7;!:RZ!Q;M!78=!O=Y=O!;Q!

J=MYNI=!78R7!78=Z!M=gKNM=!T=Q;M=!8RYN<V!RII=JJ!7;!78R7!J=MYNI=H!

";<Y=MJ=OZ\!78=!IRMMN=M!:M;YNS=J!:;J7:RNS!J=MYNI=!Q;M!78=!SKMR7N;<!;Q!R<!RVM==S!7=MLH!&J=MJ!RM=!TNOO=S!Q;M!78=!O=Y=O!;Q!

J=MYNI=!78R7!78=Z!8RY=!KJ=S!N<!R!:M=YN;KJOZ!;IIKMMN<V!:=MN;SH!.8=!V=<=MRO!7=MLJ!R<S!I;<SN7N;<J!;Q!JKI8!R<!RVM==L=<7!

J:=INQZ!R!O=Y=O!;Q!J=MYNI=!78R7!NJ!7;!T=!TNOO=S!R7!R!QOR7!L;<78OZ!MR7=\!GN78!R<Z!;Y=MRV=J!T=N<V!TNOO=S!RSSN7N;<ROOZ!=RI8!L;<78!

RJ!78=Z!;IIKMH!

,<!"R<RSR\!:;J7:RNS!J=MYNI=!NJ!78=!L;J7!:;:KORM!GN78!CP!:=M!I=<7!;Q!"R<RSRcJ!EEHW!LNOON;<!JKTJIMNT=MJ!;:7N<V!Q;M!78NJ!M;K7=H!!!

/;G=Y=M\!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!NJ!VM;GN<V!N<!:;:KORMN7Z!dJ==!1::=<SNX!1f!R<S!GNOO!M=I=NY=!R!Q;IKJ!N<!R<ROZJNJ!S=J:N7=!78=!QRI7!

78R7!N7J!KJ=M!TRJ=!NJ!JNV<NQNIR<7OZ!JLROO=M!78R<!78R7!;Q!:;J7:RNS!JKTJIMNT=MJH!

.8=!:;:KORMN7Z!;Q!:;J7:RNS!J=MYNI=!IR<!T=!R77MNTK7=S!7;!N7J!I;<Y=<N=<I=H!"KJ7;L=MJ!S;!<;7!=X:=MN=<I=!J=MYNI=!N<7=MMK:7N;<\!

<;M!RM=!78=Z!M=gKNM=S!7;!7;:BK:!78=NM!TROR<I=J!G8=<!IM=SN7!NJ!O;G\!;M!KJ=!K:!78=NM!TROR<I=J!T=Q;M=!78=!=X:NMR7N;<!SR7=H!!!

"KJ7;L=MJ!RM=!ROJ;!R77MRI7=S!7;!:;J7:RNS!J=MYNI=!TZ!78=!S=YNI=!JKTJNSN=J!;QQ=M=S!7;!IKJ7;L=MJ!N<!=XI8R<V=!Q;M!QNX=S!7=ML!

J=MYNI=!I;<7MRI7JH!/R<SJ=7J!JKI8!RJ!78=!N58;<=p!;M!)=J=RMI8!N<!';7N;<cJ!0ORIUT=MMZp\!G8NI8!M=7RNO!Q;M!R::M;XNLR7=OZ!

Page 13: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$! 9

iAPP\!RM=!LRS=!RYRNORTO=!7;!IKJ7;L=MJ!Q;M!R!78NMS!;Q!78R7!:MNI=!;M!O=JJ\!S=:=<SN<V!;<!78=!O=<V78!;Q!78=!I;<7MRI7!I;LLN77=S!

7;!TZ!78=!IKJ7;L=MH!!!

";<Y=MJ=OZ\!J;L=!KJ=MJ!I8;;J=!7;!Q;MV;!78=!RQ;M=L=<7N;<=S!RSYR<7RV=J!;Q!:;J7:RNS!:OR<J!Q;M!78=!QM==S;L!R<S!JNL:ONIN7Z!

;Q!R!:M=:RNS!L;TNO=H!"KJ7;L=MJ!RM=!<;7!M=gKNM=S!7;!VNY=!RSSM=JJ!N<Q;MLR7N;<!;M!K<S=MV;!R!IM=SN7!I8=IU!GN78!:M=:RNS!

GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=H!!%=MYNI=!RI7NYR7N;<!NJ!NLL=SNR7=!]!;<I=!78=!S=YNI=!NJ!:KMI8RJ=S!R<S!7;::=S!K:!GN78!IM=SN7!]!R<S!J8;KOS!

78=!KJ=M!S=INS=!7;!7=MLN<R7=!78=!J=MYNI=\!78=!IKJ7;L=M!IR<!S;!J;!N<J7R<7OZ!GN78;K7!Q==J!;M!:=<RO7N=J!YNR!SNJI;<7N<K=S!KJ=H!!!

!9,:;2.&<=<&&&32.4',)&7%=&35%-4',)&*,2.0.%%&3.(.-2'-,5(&

32.4',)&*,2.0.%%&6.27,8.&>.%82,4-,5(&

.8=M=!RM=!R!<KLT=M!;Q!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=MJ!d*%5f!MR<VN<V!QM;L!78=!LRk;M!N<IKLT=<7!IRMMN=MJ!N<IOKSN<V!

0=OO\!.=OKJ\!);V=MJ\!78=NM!lJ=I;<SRMZ^YROK=!TMR<SJc2\!JKI8!RJ!%;O;\!+;;S;!R<S!4NS;!M=J:=I7NY=OZ\!RJ!G=OO!RJ!J=MYNI=!M=J=OO=MJH!!

)=J=OO=MJ!N<IOKS=!5=7M;B"R<RSR\!5M=JNS=<7cJ!"8;NI=!R<S![B@@\!RL;<VJ7!;78=MJH!

,<!V=<=MRO\!R!:M=:RNS!*%5!;QQ=MJ!R!I;<JKL=MB:KMI8RJ=S!L;TNO=!S=YNI=!R<S!R!IM=SN7!;<!78=!:M;VMRL!RII;K<7H!!&JRV=!;Q!78=!

J=MYNI=!S=TN7J!78=!KJ=M!RII;K<7!R7!MR7=J!78R7!YRMZ!QM;L!*%5!7;!*%5H!!';J7!*%5J!;QQ=M!:OR<J!;M!:RIURV=J!78R7!IR<!M=SKI=!

78=!I;J7!;Q!IROON<V^7=X7N<V\!TK7!78=!I;L:RMNJ;<!;QQ=M=S!N<!78NJ!M=:;M7!O;;UJ!;<OZ!R7!TRJNI\!:=MBLN<K7=!:OR<J!R<S!R<Z!

RSSN7N;<RO\!LR<SR7;MZ!Q==JH!

%KTJIMNT=MJ!IR<!I8;;J=!7;!l7;:BK:c!;M!RSS!L;<=Z!7;!78=NM!RII;K<7!78M;KV8!J=Y=MRO!L=78;SJ\!G8NI8!N<IOKS=!78=!:KMI8RJ=!;Q!

R!:M=:RNS!L;TNON7Z!IRMS\!KJ=!;Q!*%5!G=TJN7=\!;M!YNR!IM=SN7!IRMS!]!RK7;!M=QNOO!;M!;<BS=LR<S!7;:BK:H!!.8=!IRJ8!RSS=S!7;!R<!

RII;K<7!M=LRN<J!K<7NO!78=!I;<JKL=M!KJ=J!78=!YROK=!;M!78=!S;OORMJ!=X:NM=!RII;MSN<V!7;!78=!*%5!7=MLJH!

!"#$%&'(%)#*%+,#%-.'

1!I;LL;<!L=78;S!Q;M!I;<JKL=MJ!7;!RSS!IKMM=<IZ!7;!78=NM!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!:8;<=!NJ!78M;KV8!78=!KJ=!;Q!R!:M=:RNS!IRMS!

J;OS!R7!M=7RNO!;K7O=7J!JKI8!RJ!I;<Y=<N=<I=!J7;M=J\!VM;I=MZ!J7;M=J!R<S!=O=I7M;<NI!M=7RNO=MJ!R<S!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=M!

J7;M=J^UN;JUJ!dJ==!T=O;G!Q;M!=XRL:O=fH!.8=J=!M=7RNO=MJ!N<IOKS=!ORMV=!I8RN<J!JKI8!RJ!4K7KM=!%8;:\!0=J7!0KZ!R<S!6;TORGJH!!

%LROO=M!J7;M=J\!JKI8!RJ![B@@!R<S!5=7M;B"R<\!ROJ;!J=OO!78=NM!;G<!Y=MJN;<!;Q!:M=:RNS!J=MYNI=H!!

E!1OJ;!7=ML=S!lQOR<U=M!TMR<SJHc!

Page 14: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$! .

9,:;2.&<=?&&&@A4,8'0&B.-',0&>,%40'A&C52&32.4',)&*,2.0.%%&D'2)%&

#<I=!78=!S=JNM=S!IRMS!YROK=!NJ!:KMI8RJ=S!R7!R!:;N<7B;QBJRO=\!78=!IKJ7;L=M!N<:K7J!78=!K<NgK=!5,$!M=Y=RO=S!;<!78=!IRMS!7;!

l7;:BK:c!78=NM!:M=:RNS!J=MYNI=!YROK=H!!!

9,:;2.&<=E&&&&6'F40.&5C&32.4',)&*,2.0.%%&D'2)&

/.0&%."'$.1'2,#-3$#%4'56-70,78'

1!I;<JKL=M!LRZ!I8;;J=!7;!RSS!lLN<K7=Jc!;M!YROK=!7;!78=NM!:M=:RNS!:OR<!78M;KV8!R!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=McJ!;<ON<=\!*=TBTRJ=S!

M=I8RMV=!7;;OH!!.8NJ!:RZL=<7!L=78;S!LRZ!ROO;G!R!;<=B7NL=!;M!M=IKMMN<V!l7;:BK:c!;Q!R!S;OORMBYROK=!;Q!78=!I;<JKL=McJ!

I8;;JN<VH!!';J7!M=IKMMN<V!l7;:BK:c!:OR<J!GNOO!IRMMZB;Y=M!R<Z!K<KJ=S!YROK=!7;!78=!<=X7!TNOON<V!:=MN;S\!7Z:NIROOZ!L;<78OZH!

!

Page 15: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$! 7

9,:;2.&<=G&&&$(/0,(.&32.4',)&H@54/;4I&6'F40.J&D5;2-.%AK&L.00&!51,0,-AJ&B5:.2%&

9*"7$%1':%*"&"))';<7%*$#%-.'9-&%4='

1OO!;Q!78=!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!:OR<J!M=YN=G=S!I;<7RN<=S!R<!=X:NMZ!7=ML!Q;M!78=!S;OORM!YROK=!78R7!NJ!S=:;JN7=S!N<7;!78=!

J=MYNI=!RII;K<7H!!(X:NMZ!7=MLJ!MR<V=!QM;L!DP!SRZJ!dJ8;M7=J7f!7;!DAW!SRZJ!dO;<V=J7f!]!K<ONLN7=S!=X:NMZ!7=MLJ!RM=!<;7!

RYRNORTO=H!!,7!NJ!N<7=M=J7N<V!R<S!NL:;M7R<7!7;!<;7=!78R7!)=7RNO!5;N<7B;QB%RO=!SNJ:ORZJ!Q;M!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!:OR<J!d4NVKM=!@HE!

RT;Y=f!LNX!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=J!GN78!LR<Z!;78=M!J=MYNI=J!dM=7RNO!I8RN<J\!M=J7RKMR<7J\!=7IHf!Q;M!G8NI8!=X:NMZ!7=MLJ!RM=!<;7!

O=VROH!!.8NJ!7Z:=!;Q!SNJ:ORZ!NJ!N<8=M=<7OZ!LNJO=RSN<V!7;!R!I;<JKL=MH!

";<JKL=MJ!LRZ!8RY=!78=!RTNON7Z!7;!YN=G!78=NM!7MR<JRI7N;<J!R<S!L;<78OZ!RI7NYN7Z!QM;L!78=NM!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=MH!!,Q!R<!RII;K<7!

TROR<I=!=X:NM=J\!78=!*%5!GNOO!:=MQ;ML!R!lTROR<I=!IO=RMN<V\c!RJ!J8;G<!N<!4NVKM=!@HW\!G8NI8!=JJ=<7NROOZ!M=L;Y=J!78=!

I;<JKL=McJ!IM=SN7!M=LRN<N<V!;<!78=!RII;K<7H!

9,:;2.&<=M&&&6'F40.&5C&'&32.4',)&6.27,8.&HL'0'(8.&D0.'2,(:I&

!

>$&&'>?$*@%.@'

.8=!*%5!GNOO!S=TN7!78=!RII;K<7!TRJ=S!;<!78=!:KTONJ8=S!MR7=!R<S!RI7KRO!KJRV=!dRNM7NL=fH!!/;G=Y=M\!RNM7NL=!LRZ!T=!

L=RJKM=S!SNQQ=M=<7OZ!Q;M!=RI8!*%5H!!4;M!:M=:RNS!J=MYNI=\!L;J7!*%5J!M;K<S!K:!78=!RNM7NL=!7;!78=!<=RM=J7!LN<K7=!R<S!J;L=!

*%5J!I8RMV=!QM;L!78=!L;L=<7!78R7!R!JKTJIMNT=M!8N7J!78=!l%=<Sc!U=Z!K<7NO!78=!JKTJIMNT=M!8N7J!78=!l(<Sc!U=Z\!N<!=QQ=I7!

I8RMVN<V!78=!I;<JKL=M!Q;M!IROO!J=7BK:!7NL=!RJ!G=OO!RJ!RI7KRO!7ROU!7NL=H!!!

Page 16: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$! :

6=7%4$&'9*"7$%1'A"")'$.1'9".$&#%")'

Emergency 911

1J!;Q!2=I=LT=M!@\!EPPF\!R!<=G!LK<NIN:RO!7RX!GNOO!R::OZ!N<!aK=T=I!7;!8=O:!QK<S!F@@!=L=MV=<IZ!I=<7M=JH!%=7!R7!?P!I=<7J!:=M!

L;<78!TZ!78=!-;Y=M<L=<7!;Q!aK=T=I\!78NJ!7RX!NJ!I;OO=I7=S!TZ!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=MJ!G8;!M=LN7!78=!M=gKNM=S!RL;K<7J!7;!)=Y=<K!

aKqT=IH!%NLNORM!:M;YN<INRO!Q==J!RM=!N<!:ORI=!Q;M!$;YR!%I;7NR\!%RJUR7I8=GR<\!$=G!0MK<JGNIU!R<S!5(,!R<S!78NJ!7RX!NJ!N<!

RSSN7N;<!7;!78=!;:=MR7;MBNL:;J=S!F@@!(L=MV=<IZ!%=MYNI=!Q==H!

';J7!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!:OR<J!I;<7RN<!R!Q==!Q;M!(L=MV=<IZ!F@@!d(F@@f!J=MYNI=H!!/;G=Y=M\!78=!(F@@!J=MYNI=!Q==!NJ!(5-!

R!V;Y=M<L=<7!Q==H!!*%5J!KJ=!78NJ!I;LL;<!Q==!7;!S=QMRZ!J;L=!I;J7J!:;JJNTOZ!RJJ;INR7=S!GN78!78=!:M;YNJN;<!;Q!78NJ!

IR:RTNON7ZH!!.8=!SNJIO;JKM=!;Q!78NJ!Q==!NJ!KJKROOZ!I;<7RN<=S!N<!78=!*%5!.=MLJ!R<S!";<SN7N;<Jo!LR<Z!RM=!L;M=!;:=<OZ!

SNJIO;JN<V!78NJ!I8RMV=!;<!78=!)R7=J!R<S!5OR<J!J=I7N;<!;Q!78=NM!J=MYNI=!S=JIMN:7N;<JH!

Account maintenance fees

'RN<7=<R<I=!Q==J!RM=!J;L=7NL=J!R::ON=S!7;!R!:M=:RNS!RII;K<7!7;!U==:!78=!RII;K<7!RI7NY=!GN78!R!QNX=S!S=TN7!R::ON=S!;<!R!

L;<78OZ!TRJNJH!!*8NO=!78NJ!:MRI7NI=!8RJ!V=<=MROOZ!S=ION<=S!;Y=M!78=!Z=RMJ\!78=J=!Q==J!LRZ!=XNJ7!N<!R!*%5!:OR<!R<S!GRJ!

SNJIO;J=S!TZ!R7!O=RJ7!;<=!:M;YNS=MH!

Account cancellation policy – reactivation fees

';J7!:M=:RNS!*%5!:OR<J!I;<7RN<!R!IR<I=OOR7N;<!:;ONIZ!78R7!ROO;GJ!78=!:M;YNS=M!7;!IR<I=O!78=!JKTJIMNT=McJ!RII;K<7!R<S!

L;TNO=!<KLT=M!RQ7=M!R!J=7!<KLT=M!;Q!SRZJ!GN78!<;!IM=SN7!N<!78=!RII;K<7H!!1II;K<7!IR<I=OOR7N;<!:=MN;SJ!MR<V=!QM;L!?W!SRZJ!

7;!@EP!SRZJ\!S=:=<SN<V!K:;<!78=!*%5\!TK7!78NJ!I;<7MRI7!7=ML!GRJ!<;7!ROGRZJ!JNL:O=!;M!=RJZ!7;!NS=<7NQZH!!,Q!R<!RII;K<7!NJ!

IR<I=OO=S\!78=!JKTJIMNT=M!LRZ!T=!RTO=!7;!M=RI7NYR7=!78=!RII;K<7!78M;KV8!78=!:RZL=<7!;Q!R!Q==!;M!:=<RO7ZH!!.8NJ!Q==^:=<RO7Z!

=<I;KMRV=J!R!I;<JKL=M!7;!:ORI=!L;<=Z!N<7;!78=NM!RII;K<7!M=VKORMOZ^L;<78OZ!7;!RY;NS!O;JN<V!78=NM!:8;<=!<KLT=M!R<S!

N<Y=J7L=<7!N<!78=!L;TNO=!S=YNI=H!

9*"7$%1':%*"&"))'9&$.'>-37$*%)-.'

.8=!L;J7!I;LL;<^:;:KORM!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!:OR<J!G=M=!J=O=I7=S!Q;M!M=YN=G!TRJ=S!;<!;TJ=MYR7N;<!;Q!:OR<J!RYRNORTO=!dT;78!

SNM=I7!M=7RNO!R<S!,<7=M<=7!J=RMI8=JfH!!*8NO=!J;L=!M=VN;<RO!'3$#!:OR<J!LRZ!<;7!T=!I;Y=M=S\!N7!NJ!T=ON=Y=S!78R7!ROO!<R7N;<RO!

:OR<J!RM=!ONJ7=SH!!1!JKLLRMZ!;Q!78=!:OR<J!M=YN=G=S^7=J7=S!Q;M!78=!R<ROZJNJ!NJ!J8;G<!R<S!78=!U=Z!:OR<!I8RMRI7=MNJ7NIJ!RM=!

JKLLRMNb=S!RJ!Q;OO;GJ>!

Page 17: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$! ;

@'10.&?K&&6;FF'2A&5C&6.0.8-.)&32.4',)&30'(%D!!

Credit: Comparison format courtesy of Frugal Trader4, 2008 %=MYNI=!:OR<J!LRZ!I8R<V=!gKNIUOZ!R<S!78=!RT;Y=!NJ!;<OZ!R!J<R:J8;7H!!%=Y=MRO!I;LL=MINRO!JN7=J!;QQ=M=S!VKNSR<I=!R<S!

I;L:RMNJ;<!;Q!:OR<J!]!R<!=XRL:O=!;Q!G8NI8!NJ>!!877:>^^GGGHI=OO:8;<=JHIR^I=OOB:OR<J^!H!!1<!,<7=M<=7!J=RMI8!GNOO!:M;SKI=!

J=Y=MRO!JNLNORM!JN7=J!7;!VKNS=!R!I;<JKL=M!I;L:RMNJ;<H!

9*"7$%1':%*"&"))'9&$.'/+)"*B$#%-.)'

<=&&NO4,2'-,5(&350,8AK!!,<!V=<=MRO\!R!I;<JKL=M!IR<!;T7RN<!R!O;<V=M!=X:NMR7N;<!:=MN;S!GN78!78=!:KMI8RJ=!;Q!R!8NV8=M!YROK=!

:M=:RNS!RL;K<7H!!6;G=M!7;:BK:!RL;K<7J!GNOO!:M;YNS=!T=7G==<!DP!7;!AP!SRZJ!T=Q;M=!78=!YROK=!GNOO!=X:NM=H!!1!LRXNLKL!;Q!

DAW!SRZJ!NJ!RYRNORTO=!Q;M!ORMV=M!7;:BK:!RL;K<7Jo!;<OZ![B(O=Y=<!M=J=OO=MJ!;QQ=M!78NJ!J:=INQNI!7=ML!Q;M!R!L;S=J7!7;:BK:H!!*8NO=!

L;<N7;MN<V!78=J=!:OR<J!SKMN<V!R!ABL;<78!M=J=RMI8!:=MN;S!=<SN<V!N<!_R<KRMZ!EP@P\!R!7M=<S!7;GRMSJ!J8;M7=M!=X:NMZ!:=MN;SJ!

D!1J!;Q!_R<KRMZ!EP@P!?!877:>^^GGGHLNOON;<S;OORMk;KM<=ZHI;L^:M=:RNSBGNM=O=JJB:OR<BI;L:RMNJ;<H87L!!

Page 18: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$! <

GRJ!;TJ=MY=S!N<!R7!O=RJ7!D!;Q!78=!:OR<JH!!";<JKL=MJ!G8;!I8;;J=!7;!O=7!78=NM!J=MYNI=!YROK=!=X:NM=!GNOO\!N<!L;J7!IRJ=J\!T=!

JKTk=I7!7;!R!M=RI7NYR7N;<!Q==!RQ7=M!R!J=7!:=MN;S!NQ!78=Z!GNJ8!7;!KJ=!78=NM!J=MYNI=!RVRN<H!

*8NO=!=X:NMR7N;<!:;ONIN=J!RM=!78=!J7R<SRMS!Q;M!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=J\!I;<JKL=MJ!R<S!78=!M=J=RMI8=MJ!LKJ7!gK=J7N;<!G8R7!

LRU=J!78NJ!:M;SKI7!L;M=!l:=MNJ8RTO=c!78R<!;78=M!VNQ7!IRMSJ!J;OS!K<S=M!O=VRO!I;<7M;OH!

?=&&P%':.&'()&Q>&2'-.%!]!-=<=MROOZ!78=M=!NJ!<;7!R!I;MM=OR7N;<!T=7G==<!78=!:M=:RNS!YROK=!:KMI8RJ=S!R<S!KJRV=!I;J7!Q;M!78=!

J=MYNI=H!!&JRV=!R<S!6;<V!2NJ7R<I=!MR7=J!Q;M!78=!TRJ=!J=MYNI=!d<;!!l:RIURV=Jc!JKTJIMNT=S!7;f!RM=!J=7!R7!78=!8NV8=J7!MR7=JH!!1OJ;!

<;7=S!GRJ!78R7!R<!N<IM=RJ=!N<!O;<V!SNJ7R<I=!MR7=J!GRJ!;TJ=MY=S!N<!J=Y=MRO!;Q!78=!:OR<J!SKMN<V!78=!RT;Y=!<;7=S!L;<N7;MN<V!

:=MN;S\!G8NO=!LRMU=7!O=Y=O!:MNIN<V!Q;M!O;<V!SNJ7R<I=!NJ!7M=<SN<V!S;G<GRMSH!

E=&&>,%805%;2.&5C&@.2F%&'()&D5(),-,5(%!]!5M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!IRMSJ!SNJIO;J=!Y=MZ!Q=G!7=MLJ!R<S!I;<SN7N;<J!;Q!J=MYNI=\!

;78=M!78R<!=X:NMR7N;<!:;ONIZH!!/;G=Y=M\!ROO!*%5J!GNOO!SNM=I7!Z;K!7;!78=NM!G=TJN7=!Q;M!I;L:O=7=!7=MLJo!J;L=!RM=!

JKLLRMNb=S!G=OO!N<!:OR<!7=MLJ\!TK7!;78=MJ!RM=!SNQQNIKO7!7;!K<S=MJ7R<SH!

,<!R!7=J7!;Q!*%5!U<;GO=SV=!;Q!=X:NMR7N;<!7=MLJ!N<!;<=!IRJ=\!N7!GRJ!=YNS=<7!78R7!78=!IKJ7;L=M!J=MYNI=!RV=<7!SNS!<;7!

K<S=MJ7R<S!78=!:;ONIZ\!G8NI8!IR<!LNJO=RS!R!I;<JKL=M!d4NVKM=!@HAf!R<S!O=RS!7;!R!O;JJ!;M!:RM7NRO!O;JJ!;Q!78=NM!:M=:RNS!

:KMI8RJ=H!

9,:;2.&<=R&&&D'00&S:.(-&NO'F40.&2.:'2),(:&32.4',)&NO4,2A&

G=&&B.-',0&>,%40'A%!]!6=VNJOR7N;<!8RJ!T==<!=<RI7=S!;M!:M;:;J=S!N<!J;L=!:M;YN<I=J!78R7!TR<!=X:NMR7N;<!;<!I=M7RN<!VNQ7!IRMSJ!

Q;M!:M;SKI7J!R<S!J=MYNI=JH!!)=7RNO=MJ!78R7!I8;;J=!7;!SNJ:ORZ!IRMSJ!GN78!SNQQ=M=<7!=X:NMR7N;<!:;ONIN=J!N<!78=!JRL=!RM=R!GNOO!

IRKJ=!I;<JKL=M!I;<QKJN;<H!

35%-4',)&*,2.0.%%&6.27,8.&>.%82,4-,5(&

1::M;XNLR7=OZ!@C!LNOON;<!"R<RSNR<J!JKTJIMNT=!7;!:;J7:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=H!.8NJ!J=MYNI=!NJ!:M;YNS=S!TZ!78=!IRMMN=M!;Y=M!R!

I;<7MRI7=S!7=ML!dKJKROOZ!EBD!Z=RMJf!R<S!SNQQ=MJ!QM;L!:M=:RNS!J=MYNI=!TZ>!

• 1TJ=<I=!;Q!M=gKNM=L=<7!7;!l7;:!K:c!]!78=!JKTJIMNT=M!M=I=NY=J!R!L;<78OZ!TNOO!S=7RNON<V!78=!:M=YN;KJ!L;<78cJ!J=MYB

NI=!I8RMV=J!78R7!8=^J8=!8RJ!N<IKMM=S!

• ";<JKL=MJ!O;;UN<V!7;!JNV<!K:!7;!R!:M=:RNS!:OR<!RM=!JKTk=I7!7;!R!IM=SN7!I8=IU!R<S!M=gKNM=!R<!RSSM=JJ!

• 1J!;::;J=S!7;!:M=:RNS!:OR<J!G8=M=!I;<JKL=MJ!:RZ!Q;M!=RI8!Q=R7KM=\!78=M=!NJ!R!O=Y=O!;Q!J=MYNI=!R<S!Q=R7KM=J!78R7!NJ!

RVM==S!K:;<!RJ!:RM7!;Q!78=!I;<7MRI7!78R7!78=!JKTJIMNT=M!JNV<J!K:;<!N<I=:7N;<!

• .8=M=!NJ!R!!l8RMSGRM=!JKTJNSZc!RJJ;INR7=S!GN78!78=!J=MYNI=!RVM==L=<7!G8=M=TZ!78=!JKTJIMNT=M!M=I=NY=J!R!M=TR7=!

Q;M!78=!I;J7!;Q!78=!8R<SJ=7!

!

.8=!ORMV=J7!:M;YNS=MJ!;Q!:;J7:RNS!J=MYNI=!N<!"R<RSR!RM=!);V=MJ!*NM=O=JJ\!.=OKJ!';TNON7Z!R<S!0=OO!';TNON7ZH!.8=J=!

N<IKLT=<7J!;QQ=M!7G;!7N=MJ!;Q!J=MYNI=\!R!:M=LNKL!:;J7:RNS!J=MYNI=!K<S=M!TMR<SJ!N<!78=NM!;G<!<RL=\!R<S!R!SNJI;K<7!J=MYNI=!

;QQ=M=S!K<S=M!78=NM!QOR<U=M!TMR<SJ>!4NS;!d);V=MJf!+;;S;!d.=OKJf\!%;O;!d0=OOf!R<S!3NMVN<!';TNO=!d0=OOfH!

Page 19: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$! "

4OR<U=M!TMR<SJ!RSY=M7NJ=!78=NM!:;J7:RNS!J=MYNI=!GN78!78=!;:7N;<!;Q!Q;MV;N<V!78=!EBD!Z=RM!RVM==L=<7!;Q!78=!:M=LNKL!

TMR<SJH!,<J7=RS\!I;<JKL=MJ!8RY=!78=!;:7N;<!7;!JNV<!K:!Q;M!R!:OR<!GN78!JNLNORM!Q=R7KM=J!78R7!IR<!T=!IR<I=OO=S!;<!R!L;<78B

TZBL;<78!TRJNJH!!!

@'10.&E&T&6;FF'2A&5C&35%-4',)&6.27,8.%&;().2&42.F,;F&12'()%&

$ !"#$%&' ($)*&' +$))'=),$ 5&'+>$ =,4?)$@3'()$$

A9#$B$A.7$$ A9#$B$A7#$ A9#$B$$A:#$

C3D+4E)$ 54'F+)G$2HH),)I$

!##$ E4'G$ JK7#$ L&'FGM$ N$9##$E4'G$JK!##$L&'FGM$

!##$ JK$ 7#$ L&'FGM$ N$ .7#$ JK7#$L&'FGM$

!##$ JK7#$ L&'FGM$ N$ 77#$ JK7#$ L&B'FGM$

OP+,3$ /)3+F,)G$Q'?0FI)I$4'$=03'$

R'04E4+)I$ OS)'4'(G$ 3'I$T))U)'IG$3H+),$"=5$$!"##$%& #'%& #(& )"%& (#**#+,-'./&&C&FV0)$ D&F,$E4'F+)G$ JV&B'FG$E4'F+)G$)P?0FI)IM$5%7$ W&?30XY3+4&'Z4I)$F'04E4+)I$ +30U-$ +)P+-$S4I)&X[4?+F,)$E)GG3(4'(M$!###XF'04E4+)I$ G)'+$E)GBG3()G$ J*5*-$ Q5-$ [4?B+F,)XS4I)M$ 3'I$ F'04E4+)I$,)?)4S)I$E)GG3()G$

R'04E4+)I$ OS)'4'(G$ 3'I$T))U)'IG$3H+),$"=5$!"##$%&#'%&#(&)"%&(#**#+-'./&&R'04E4+)IX'3+4&'Z4I)$ 0&?30$+30U$+)P+$[4?+F,)G$

R'04E4+)I$ OS)'4'(G$ 3'I$ T))UB)'IG$3H+),$"=5$$!"##$%&#'%&#(&)"%&(#**#+-'./&&R'04E4+)I$ '4(>+G$ 3'I$ Z))U)'IG$0&?30$ E4'F+)G$ X$ W&?30$ /3V$ /4S)$JF'04E4+)I$ +30U$ 3'I$ +)P+M$ X$ Y3B+4&'Z4I)$/3V$/4S)$ JF'04E4+)I$?300B4'($3'I$+)P+M$

\II4+4&'30$]>3,()G$

A97$3?+4S3+4&'$H))$A#^97XE4'F+)$ Z>4?>$ )PB?))IG$+>)$[03'$

A97$3?+4S3+4&'$H))$A#^97XE4'F+)$ Z>4?>$ )P?))IG$+>)$[03'$

A97$3?+4S3+4&'$H))$A#^97XE4'F+)$ Z>4?>$ )P?))IG$ +>)$[03'$

!

Page 20: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$8 #

@'10.&G&T&6;FF'2A&5C&35%-4',)&6.27,8.%&;().2&C0'(U.2&12'()%&

$ ,-."' /""."' 0")"' 1-%#-2'3"4-)$'=),$ 5&'+>$=,4?)$@3'()$$

A!7$B$A;#$&'$+30U$[03'G$A.#$3'I$A:#$&'$]4+D$/4I&$[03'G$ 3S3403V0)$ 4'$ G)0)?+$?4+4)G7:$

A87BA97$ A!7BA87$ A8"^""$B$A."^""$

C3D+4E)$ 54'BF+)G$2HH),)I$

7#$N$8###$\'D+4E)$E4'BF+)G$7#$ N$ R'04E4+)I$ 1)P+$E)GG3()G-$ /,))$ @)B?)4S)I$1)P+$5)GG3()G$

!##$ N$ 9##$ \'D+4E)$Y3+4&'Z4I)$54'F+)G$;X7$ =5$ $ R'04E4+)I$)S)'4'(G$ 3'I$ Z))UB)'IG$7#$ N$ R'04E4+)I$ *)'+$+)P+$ E)GG3()G-$ /,))$,)?)4S)I$E)GG3()G$

7#$ N$ !##$ \'D+4E)$54'F+)G$7#$ N$ R'04E4+)I$JR'04E4+)I$ Q'+),B'3+4&'30$1)P+$5)GBG3()G$ Z4+>$ A87$[03'M$

9##$ N$ R'04E4+)I$ \'DB+4E)$E4'F+)G$$!###$ N$ R'04E4+)I$ )S)B'4'(G$ 3'I$ Z))U)'IG$E4'F+)G$ G+3,+4'($ 3+$;=5$

OP+,3$ /)3+F,)G$Q'?0FI)I$ 4'$=03'$

]300$T34+4'(-$]&'H),)'?)$]300$

]&'H),)'?)$ ?3004'(-$ ?300$Z34+4'(-$ "!!$ 3'I$ =),B*)?&'I$V4004'($

$ $

\II4+4&'30$]>3,()G$

A97$&')$+4E)$3?+4S3+4&'$A8XE&'+>$ [3[),$ V4004'($H))$A#^97XE4'$ 0&?30$ 3'I$0&'($I4G+3'?)$$$

A#^!7X$ +)P+$ E)GG3()G$)P?))I4'($ [03'$ 04E4+3B+4&'G$A#^97XE4'$ )P?))I4'($E4'F+)G$A#^97XE4'$ ]3'3I43'$0&'($I4G+3'?)$A!^##XE4'$ R*C$ ,&3EB4'($

A#^!7X+)P+$ E)GBG3()$ )P?))I4'($[03'$$A#^97XE4'$ 0&?30$3'I$0&'($I4G+3'?)$$$

A#^8#XE4'$ 3II4+4&'30$E4'F+)G$$

";<JKL=MJ!IR<!:KMI8RJ=!:;J7:RNS!:OR<J!R<S!8R<SJ=7J!;<ON<=!SNM=I7OZ!78M;KV8!78=!IRMMN=M!G=TJN7=\!;M!TZ!IROON<V!78=!IRMMN=M!

IROO!I=<7=M!R<S!V;N<V!78M;KV8!78=!:M;I=JJ!;Q!JNV<N<V!R<!RVM==L=<7!GN78!R!IKJ7;L=M!J=MYNI=!M=:M=J=<7R7NY=H!"KJ7;L=MJ!IR<!

ROJ;!:KMI8RJ=!8R<SJ=7J!R<S!:OR<J!QM;L!ONI=<J=S!S=RO=MJ8N:J!RJ!G=OO!RJ!M=7RNO=MJ!JKI8!RJ!0=J7!0KZ\!4K7KM=%8;:\!.8=!%;KMI=!

R<S!*NM=O=JJ!*RY=H!!

W!"N7Z!4NS;!:OR<J!RM=!R::ONIRTO=!N<!78=!Q;OO;GN<V!IN7N=J>!3NI7;MNR\!3R<I;KY=M\!(SL;<7;<\!"ROVRMZ\!6;<S;<\!.;M;<7;\!#77RGR\!

-R7N<=RK\!';<7M=RO\!aK=T=IH!A!"N7Z!4NS;!:OR<J!:M;YNS=!E\PPP!;M!?\PPP!R<Z7NL=!LN<K7=J!R<S!K<ONLN7=S!7=X7!L=JJRVN<V!GN78N<!R<!KMTR<!RM=RH!

Page 21: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$8 !

9,:;2.&<=V&T&>.'0.2%+,4&6-52.%&5C&-+.&L,:&E&

'

6=7%4$&'9-)#7$%1'A"")'$.1'9".$&#%")'

System Access Fees – where do they stand?

.8=!JZJ7=L!RII=JJ!Q==!GRJ!R!Q==!NL:;J=S!TZ!78=!IRMMN=MJ!Q;M!78=!I;J7J!;Q!ONI=<JN<V!<=7G;MU!K:VMRS=J^LRN<7=<R<I=H!.8=!

O=YN=S!Q==!GRJ!iAHFW!B!iCHFW!;<!R<Z!GNM=O=JJ!:OR<!R<S!GRJ!;Q7=<!GM;<VQKOOZ!=X:ORN<=S!7;!I;<JKL=MJ!RJ!R!Q==!I;OO=I7=S!TZ!

IRMMN=MJ!;<!78=!T=8ROQ!;Q!V;Y=M<L=<7JH!*8NO=!JKI8!R!V;Y=M<L=<7RO!Q==!GRJ!:K7!N<!:ORI=!G8=<!78=!GNM=O=JJ!N<SKJ7MZ!GRJ!

kKJ7!J7RM7N<V!;K7\!N7!8RJ!JN<I=!T==<!SNJI;<7N<K=S[H!,<!#I7;T=M!EPPF\!.=OKJ!R<S!0=OO!R<S!);V=MJ!ROO!SM;::=S!78=!%ZJ7=L!

1II=JJ!4==H!";<Y=MJ=OZ!ROO!:OR<J!N<IM=RJ=S!N<!:MNI=!TZ!R::M;XNLR7=OZ!iWH!

#Q!78=!TNV!78M==\!);V=MJ!M=L;Y=S!78=!iAHFW!%ZJ7=L!1II=JJ!4==!R<S!M=:ORI=S!N7!GN78!R!)=VKOR7;MZ!)=I;Y=MZ!"8RMV=!;Q!

T=7G==<!iEH?A!B!iDH?A!S=:=<SN<V!;<!78=!M=VN;<H!.8=!IRMMN=M!RMVK=J!78R7!78NJ!I8RMV=!8=O:J!N7!I;L:OZ!GN78!78=!I;J7!;Q!

YRMN;KJ!V;Y=M<L=<7!M=VKOR7N;<J!N<!SNQQ=M=<7!V=;VMR:8NIRO!O;IR7N;<JH!!

Contracts and Contract Termination Fees

.8=!=X8NTN7!T=O;G!I;L:RM=J!R<S!I;<7MRJ7J!78=!(RMOZ!"R<I=OOR7N;<!4==J!NL:;J=S!;<!I;<JKL=MJ!TZ!0=OO\!);V=MJ!R<S!.=OKJ!

K:;<!R!IKJ7;L=McJ!S=JNM=!7;!7=MLN<R7=!R!GNM=O=JJ!I;<7MRI7!T=Q;M=!I;L:O=7N;<H!!!

@'10.&M&T&D5F4'2,%5(&5C&N'20A&D'(8.00'-,5(&9..%&1.-W..(&E&42.F,;F&W,2.0.%%&12'()%&,(&D'(')'&

($)*&' !"#$%&'' +$))'56%)7'8629$))6:-"2',$$;'_,)3+),$&H$$A!##$&,$$A8#$P$E&'+>G$,)E34'4'($4'$D&F,$?&'B+,3?+$N$'&$E3P4EFE$<6:6'56%)7'8629$))6:-"2',$$;'\II4+4&'30$A!##$

56%)7'8629$))6:-"2',$$;'_,)3+),$&H$$A!##$&,$$A8#$P$E&'+>G$,)E34'4'($4'$D&F,$?&'B+,3?+$+&$E3P$&H$A.##$<6:6'56%)7'8629$))6:-"2',$$;'A7$P$E&'+>$,)E34'4'($ 4'$?&'+,3?+$ +&$3$E3P4EFE$&H$A!##$

56%)7'8629$))6:-"2',$$;'_,)3+),$&H$$A!##$&,$A8#$P$E&'+>G$,)E34'4'($4'$D&F,$?&'B+,3?+$+&$E3P$&H$A.##$<6:6'56%)7'8629$))6:-"2',$$;'A8##$VF+$L)00$>3G$I4G?,)+4&'$+&$')(&B+43+)$3$0&Z),$3E&F'+$

[!877:>^^GGGH78=J7RMHI;L^0KJN<=JJ^RM7NIO=^EWCP?F!

Page 22: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$8 8

4M;L!78=!RT;Y=\!N7!NJ!=YNS=<7!78R7!0=OO!R<S!);V=MJ!T;78!I8RMV=!iEP!:=M!L;<78!Q;M!=Y=MZ!L;<78!M=LRN<N<V!;<!78=!I;<7MRI7!

7;!R!LRXNLKL!;Q!i?PPH!.=OKJ!;<!78=!;78=M!8R<S!S;=J!<;7!8RY=!R!LRXNLKL\!J;!=RMOZ!7=MLN<R7N;<!I;KOS!M=JKO7!N<!R!

IR<I=OOR7N;<!I8RMV=!;Q!L;M=!78R<!i?PPH!,Q!Z;K!8RY=!R<!=XNJ7N<V!SR7R!:OR<!]!O;;U!;K7!]!T=IRKJ=!78=!I8RMV=J!GNOO!T=!=Y=<!

8NV8=MH!

,<!78=!IRJ=!;Q!78=!QOR<U=M!TMR<SJ\!78=!Q;OO;GN<V!;TJ=MYR7N;<J!IR<!T=!LRS=!N<!M=OR7N;<!7;!I;<7MRI7!IR<I=OOR7N;<!Q==J!Q;M!

:;J7:RNS!;QQ=MN<VJ>!

• 1OO!;Q!78=!lL;<78OZB:OR<Jc!;QQ=M=S!TZ!78=!78M==!QOR<U=M!TMR<SJ!4NS;\!%;O;!R<S!3NMVN<\!RM=!JKTk=I7!7;!JNLNORM!IR<I=OB

OR7N;<!:;ONIN=J!RJ!78=!:M=LNKL!TMR<SJH!

• %;O;!N<!QRI7!K7NONb=J!78=!JRL=!G;MSN<V!N<!M=OR7N;<!7;!IR<I=OOR7N;<!;Q!lL;<78OZB:OR<Jc!RJ!N7J!:RM=<7!I;L:R<Z!0=OO!

';TNON7Z!d%==!1::=<SNX!0!Q;M!(X8NTN7!Df!

• 4NS;cJ!=RMOZ!IR<I=OOR7N;<!:;ONIZ\!NOOKJ7MR7=S!T=O;G!8RJ!R!LRXNLKL!;Q!iDPP!d78R7!NJ!i@PP!O=JJ!78R<!:RM=<7!I;L:R<Z!

);V=MJ!*NM=O=JJf!TK7!NJ!O=<V78Z\!IKLT=MJ;L=!R<S!JKTk=I7!7;!LR<Z!I;<QKJN<V!lNQc!IORKJ=J!78R7!LRU=!N7!SNQQNIKO7!7;!

K<S=MJ7R<S!78=!7;7RO!RL;K<7!;GN<V!GN78;K7!IROON<V!7;!J:=RU!7;!R!IKJ7;L=M!J=MYNI=!M=:M=J=<7R7NY=H!

9,:;2.&<=X&T&9,)5I%&N'20A&D'(8.00'-,5(&9..&'%&'-&Y'(&?Z-+&?[<[&

• %NLNORMOZ\!+;;S;!T;RJ7J!;Q!<;!lL;<78OZB:OR<Jc!K<ONU=!I;L:=7N7;MJ!4NS;!R<S!%;O;H!/;G=Y=M!415-&.#$5,!$#,+&-,!06

0&2#',-&,-#$.*+!-#,-7#*$,5#$"*4#,1+-*0,-7#8,7!"#,$#(!*',*+,)100,-7#,+#%!-*"#,/!0!+4#,&+,-7#*$,9-!/9,dR<Z!:;JN7NY=OZ!RIBIKLKOR7=S!TROR<I=!NJ!RK7;LR7NIROOZ!O;J7!R<S!<;7!M=QK<S=S!G8=<!78=!IKJ7;L=M!7=MLN<R7=J!78=!J=MYNI=f!

';M=;Y=M\!G8=<!=XRLN<N<V!78=!7=MLJ!R<S!I;<SN7N;<J!;Q!(RMOZ!"R<I=OOR7N;<!:;ONIN=J!J=7!TZ!78=!IRMMN=MJ\!J;L=!:;7=<7NRO!

RM=RJ!;Q!K<QRNM<=JJ!M=JKO7\!=J:=INROOZ!G8=<!I;<JNS=MN<V!78=!GRZ!78R7!78=!(RMOZ!"R<I=OOR7N;<!:=<RO7Z!IR<!T=!N<IKMM=SH!

);V=MJ!*NM=O=JJ!J7R7=J\!m1<!=RMOZ!IR<I=OOR7N;<!Q==!R::ON=J\!NQ!Q;M!R<Z!M=RJ;<!Z;KM!J=MYNI=!NJ!7=MLN<R7=S!:MN;M!7;!78=!=<S!;Q!

78=!J=MYNI=!RVM==L=<7Hn!.=OKJ!';TNON7Z!=OKINSR7=J!78=!RT;Y=!IORNL!L;M=!IO=RMOZ!TZ!J7R7N<V>!m"R<I=OOR7N;<!I8RMV=J!LKJ7!T=!

:RNS!G8=78=M!78=!J=MYNI=!NJ!7=MLN<R7=S!TZ!.(6&%!;M!Z;KHn!

0;78!78=J=!J7R7=L=<7J!KO7NLR7=OZ!N<Q=M!78R7!ONRTNON7Z!ON=J!GN78!78=!I;<JKL=M!Q;M!:RZN<V!78=!IR<I=OOR7N;<!:=<RO7Z\!

NMM=J:=I7NY=!;Q!G8=78=M!8=!;M!J8=!7=MLN<R7=S!78=!I;<7MRI7H!"RMMN=MJ!RM=!78=M=TZ!RTO=!7;!7=MLN<R7=!78=!J=MYNI=!RVM==L=<7!

GN78!R!I;<JKL=M!R<S!J7NOO!I8RMV=!=RMOZ!IR<I=OOR7N;<!:=<RO7N=JH!!

.8=!M=RJ;<!Q;M!78NJ!IORKJ=\!G8NI8\!R7!QNMJ7!VOR<I=\!R::=RMJ!8=RYNOZ!TNRJ=S!7;GRMSJ!78=!T=<=QN7!;Q!78=!IRMMN=M\!8RJ!7;!S;!GN78!

8R<SJ=7!JKTJNSN=JH!!

"RMMN=MJ!:M;YNS=!78=J=!8R<SJ=7!JKTJNSN=J!7;!I;<JKL=MJ!=N78=M!RJ!R!8RMSGRM=!K:VMRS=!;<!R<!=XNJ7N<V!I;<7MRI7!;M!G8=<!

J=MYNI=!NJ!QNMJ7!:KMI8RJ=SH!/;G=Y=M\!78=!QRNOKM=!7;!8NV8ONV87!78=!O;VNIRO!ON<U!T=7G==<!78=!JKTJNSNb=S!I;J7!;Q!78=!8R<SJ=7!R<S!

78=!J=MYNI=!RVM==L=<7!O=RSJ!7;!I;<QKJN;<!;<!T=8ROQ!;Q!I;<JKL=MJ\!G8;!RM=!K<RGRM=!;Q!78NJ!M=OR7N;<J8N:H!

Page 23: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$8 9

#Q!78=!!l0NV!Dc\!.=OKJ!R<S!);V=MJ!LRU=!<;!=QQ;M7!7;!=X:ORN<!N<!78=NM!.=MLJ!R<S!";<SN7N;<J!78=!M=RJ;<J!Q;M!78=!RT;Y=BJ7R7=S!

IR<I=OOR7N;<!Q==!:;ONIN=JH!0=OO!';TNON7Z!NJ!78=!;<OZ!IRMMN=M!7;BSR7=!R77=L:7N<V!7;!NOOKJ7MR7=!78=!ON<U!T=7G==<!8R<SJ=7!JKTJNSZ!

R<S!=RMOZ!IR<I=OOR7N;<!:=<RO7N=JH!

,<!78=NM!7=MLJ!R<S!I;<SN7N;<J\!0=OO!J7R7=J!78=!Q;OO;GN<V!GN78!M=J:=I7!7;!=RMOZ!IR<I=OOR7N;<!:;ONIN=J>!

m,Q!Z;K!8RY=!M=I=NY=S!:M;L;7N;<RO!I;<JNS=MR7N;<!N<IOKSN<V!M=SKI7N;<!;M!M=TR7=!;<!78=!:MNI=!;Q!Z;KM!S=YNI=!Z;K!RVM==!

=N78=M!7;>!

Rf ";<7N<K=!7;!:KMI8RJ=!78=!J=MYNI=J!QM;L!0=OO!Q;M!78=!";LLN77=S!%=MYNI=!5=MN;S!M=gKNM=S!TZ!0=OO!

Tf 5RZ!R!%=MYNI=!5MNI=!1SkKJ7L=<7!d%151f!NQ>!

RH e;K!7=MLN<R7=!Z;KM!J=MYNI=J!T=Q;M=!78=!=<S!;Q!78=!I;LLN77=S!%=MYNI=!5=MN;S!

TH *=!7=MLN<R7=!Z;KM!J=MYNI=J!Q;M!<;<B:RZL=<7!;M!;78=M!TM=RI8!T=Q;M=!78=!=<S!;Q!I;LLN77=S!%=MYNI=!

5=MN;S!

IH e;K!S;!<;7!RI7NYR7=!78=!2=YNI=!GN78N<!?W!SRZJ!;Q!:KMI8RJ=!SR7=n!

C)$@"'!")#*%4#%-.)'D';<#*$'>?$*@")'

Incoming Text Messaging

,<!1KVKJ7!EPPC!.=OKJ!R<S!0=OO!T=VR<!O=YZN<V!R!I8RMV=!;Q!iPH@W^L=JJRV=!Q;M!ROO!N<I;LN<V!7=X7!L=JJRV=J!78R7!G=M=!<;7!:RM7!

;Q!R!l7=X7N<Vc!:OR<!RSSB;<H!

);V=MJ!SNS!<;7!J7RM7!I8RMVN<V!Q;M!N<I;LN<V!7=X7!L=JJRV=J!K<7NO!_KOZ!EPPF!G8=<!N7!RS;:7=S!78=!iPH@W^L=JJRV=!I8RMV=!Q;M!

L=JJRV=J!<;7!:RM7!;Q!R!l7=X7N<Vc!RSSB;<!;:7N;<H!!

.8NJ!<=G!:MRI7NI=!GRJ!I;<7M;Y=MJNRO!Q;M!78=!Q;OO;GN<V!M=RJ;<J>!

@H .8=!R::=RMR<I=!;Q!I;OOKJN;<!T=7G==<!0=OO!R<S!.(6&%!]!0=OOcJ!R<S!.(6&%cJ!JNLKO7R<=;KJ!R<<;K<I=L=<7J!N<!=RMOZ!_KOZ!EPPC!QK=O=S!J:=IKOR7N;<!;Q!I;OOKJN;<!T=7G==<!78=!7G;!N<IKLT=<7!IRMMN=MJH!!

EH .(6&%cJ!RMVKL=<7!Q;M!S;N<V!J;!]!7;!M=I;Y=M!78=!I;J7!;Q!N<Y=J7L=<7!LRS=!7;!78=NM!<=7G;MU!7;!8R<SO=!78=!=X:;<=<B7NRO!VM;G78!N<!7=X7!L=JJRVN<V!]!GRJ!TM;KV87!N<7;!S;KT7!TZ!78=!RMVKL=<7!78R7!;:=MR7N<V!I;J7J!RM=!N<J=<JN7NY=!7;!7=X7!

Y;OKL=o!78R7!7MR<JLN77N<V!R!8K<SM=S!LNOON;<!L=JJRV=J!I;J7!<;7!LKI8!L;M=!78R<!R!LNOON;<H!.=X7!L=JJRV=J!RM=!QM==!

MNS=MJ!78R7!:NVVZTRIU!;<!I;<7M;O!I8R<<=OJ!GN78N<!GNM=O=JJ!7MR<JLNJJN;<J\!78=M=TZ!I;J7N<V!IRMMN=MJ!<=X7!7;!<;78N<V!

7;!7MR<JLN7H!#<I=!R<!N<Y=J7L=<7!NJ!LRS=!N<!I=<7MRONb=S!J7;MRV=!=gKN:L=<7!dJ7;MN<V!R!7=MRTZ7=!<;G!I;J7J!;<OZ!!i@PP!

R<S!I;<7N<K=J!7;!SM;:f!R<S!N<!78=!J7RQQ!7;!LRN<7RN<!N7\!78=!I;J7J!;Q!7=X7!L=JJRVN<V!RM=!TRJNIROOZ!I;Y=M=SH!!

DH 0=OOcJ!R<S!);V=MJc!RMVKL=<7!]!78R7!78=Z!RM=!5*.(08,!0*%+*+%,-7#.5#0"#5,2*-7,.!$3#-,$#!0*-*#5!]!G8NI8!7MR<JOR7=J!7;!!l#78=M!IRMMN=MJ!RM=!S;N<V!N7c!]!S=L;<J7MR7=J!78=NM!:M=Q=M=<I=!7;!T=!K<I;L:=7N7NY=!N<!78=!LRMU=7!R<S!7RU=J!RSYR<B

7RV=!;Q!I;<JKL=MJ!G8;!8RY=!<;!;78=M!I8;NI=JH!

?H 1QQ=I7=S!IKJ7;L=MJ!8RY=!ON77O=!O=VRO!M=I;KMJ=!RJ!ROO!I;<7MRI7J!J7N:KOR7=!78R7!)##5,!$#,!02!85,51/:#4-,-&,47!+%#,2*-7&1-,+&-*4#H! ! "RMMN=M! M=J:;<J=!8RJ!T==<! 7;! RSYNJ=! IKJ7;L=MJ! 7;!SNJRTO=! 78=! 7=X7!L=JJRVN<V!;:7N;<!;<! 78=NM!:8;<=J! 7;!RY;NS!K<=X:=I7=S!7=X7!I8RMV=J!;<!78=NM!TNOOJH!

E%&&%.@'F.$44,*$4%")'$.1'F)),")'

0NOON<V!RIIKMRIZ!8RJ!T==<!R!O;<VJ7R<SN<V!I;<JKL=M!NJJK=H!!*NM=O=JJ!TNOOJ!RM=!;Q7=<!8NV8=M!]!QM=gK=<7OZ!LKI8!8NV8=M!]!78R<!

IKJ7;L=MJ!=X:=I7H!!"KJ7;L=M!SNJ:K7=J!RM=!I;LL;<H!!'R<Z!;Q!78=!SNJ:K7=J!N<Y;OY=!r=X7MRr!Q==J!N<IKMM=S!G8=<!IKJ7;L=MJ!

K<U<;GN<VOZ!=XI==S!78=!ROO;7L=<7J!J=7!;K7!N<!78=NM!:OR<JH!

,<!M=J:;<J=!7;!78NJ!NJJK=\!IRMMN=MJ!8RY=!IM=R7=S!;<ON<=!7;;OJ!TZ!G8NI8!JKTJIMNT=MJ!IR<!7MRIU!78=NM!M=RO!7NL=!KJRV=!;Q!

Q=R7KM=J!JKI8!RJ!SRZ7NL=!Y;NI=!LN<K7=J\!=Y=<N<V!LN<K7=J\!7=X7!L=JJRVN<V!R<S!SR7R!I;<JKL:7N;<H!4KM78=ML;M=\!IRMMN=MJ!

<;G!RO=M7!Z;K!YNR!%'%!G8=<!Z;K!RM=!IO;J=!7;!M=RI8N<V!78=!ONLN7J!;Q!Z;KM!:OR<H!.8NJ!N<N7NR7NY=!NJ!RNL=S!R7!M=SKIN<V!TNOON<V!

JKM:MNJ=J!R<S!:M;YNSN<V!L;M=!7MR<J:RM=<IZ!7;!KJ=MJH!!

Page 24: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$8 .

$;<=78=O=JJ\!;78=M!Q==J!R<S!I8RMV=J!JKI8!RJ!M;RLN<V!R<S!O;<V!SNJ7R<I=!;<OZ!R::=RM!;<!78=!QN<RO!TNOOH!";<JKL=MJ!RM=!<;7!

LRS=!RGRM=!G8=<!78=Z!N<IKM!I8RMV=J!Q;M!78=!RSSN7N;<RO!N<J7R<I=J!G8=<!78=Z!8RY=!7;!KJ=!78=J=!J=MYNI=J\!RJ!78=!TNOO!GNOO!T=!

LKI8!8NV8=M!78R<!<;MLRO!R<S!J;L=!T=ON=Y=!78R7!78=J=!I8RMV=J!RM=!=XI=JJNY=H!

35%-4',)&*,2.0.%%&30'(%&T&D5F4'2,%5(&'()&$1%.27'-,5(%&

4M;L!78=!RT;Y=!R<ROZJNJ!;Q!78=!:;J7:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!:OR<J\!78=!JNLNORMN7Z!;Q!:MNI=!:;N<7J!T=7G==<!78=!78M==!GNM=O=JJ!IRMMN=MJ!

N<!78=NM!:M=LNKL!TMR<S!;QQ=MJ!N<SNIR7=J!78R7!"R<RSNR<!IRMMN=MJ!RM=!IKMM=<7OZ!<;7!I;L:=7N<V!;<!:MNI=!TK7!;<!YROK=H!!

1!L;M=!S=7RNO=S!M=RSN<V!M=Y=RO=S!78R7!YROK=\!RJ!M=QO=I7=S!TZ!78=!:OR<J\!N<IOKS=J!

• .8=!RYRNORTNON7Z!;Q!=X7MR!:=MUJ!N<!RSSN7N;<!7;!78=!SRZ7NL=^=Y=<N<VJ!LN<K7=J!ROO;7L=<7H!.8NJ!N<IOKS=J!78N<VJ!JKI8!

RJ!QRY;KMN7=!<KLT=MJ\!7=X7!L=JJRVN<V!R<S!IROON<V!Q=R7KM=J!

• 0;<KJ!IROON<V!Q=R7KM=J!JKI8!RJ!IROO!Q;MGRMSN<V\!IROO!GRN7N<V!

• 4M==!N<I;LN<V!7=X7!L=JJRVN<V!

• )=L;YRO!;Q!78=!JZJ7=L!RII=JJ!Q==!

• &::=M!MR<V=!;Q!8RMSGRM=!RYRNORTO=!7;!:KMI8RJ=!GN78!R!I;<7MRI7!

,7!NJ!R!V=<=MROOZ!RVM==S!QRI7!78R7!I;<7MRI7!O=<V78!R<S!=RMOZ!IR<I=OOR7N;<!Q==J!RM=!78=!J7MN<VJ!R77RI8=S!7;!JKTJIMNTN<V!7;!R!

:M=LNKL!TMR<S!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!N<!"R<RSRH!!

5M;LN<=<7!I;<JKL=M!NJJK=J!M=OR7=S!7;!:;J7:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!V=<=MROOZ!JKMM;K<S!TNOON<V!SNJ:K7=J\!N<I;<JNJ7=<7!

IKJ7;L=M!J=MYNI=!N<Q;MLR7N;<!R<S!:MRI7NI=J\!78=!QRNM<=JJ!;Q!I;<7MRI7!7=MLN<R7N;<!Q==J\!7=MLJ!`!I;<SN7N;<J!I8R<V=J\!

I;<JKL=M!ONRTNON7Z\!R<S!78=!=XNJ7=<I=!R<S!MR7N;<RO=!Q;M!1II=JJ!4==JH!

G"H';.#*$.#)I':?$#8)'%.')#-*"J'

4;OO;GN<V!78=!1*%!J:=I7MKL!RKI7N;<!TZ!,<SKJ7MZ!"R<RSR!N<!EPPC\!<=G!=<7MR<7J!RM=!:M=:RMN<V!7;!ORK<I8!78=NM!J=MYNI=J!R<S!

T;;J7!I;L:=7N7N;<!N<!T;78!:M=:RNS!R<S!:;J7:RNS!LRMU=7JH!!

,<!2=I=LT=M!EPPF\!<=G!GNM=O=JJ!=<7MR<7!*,$2!';TNO=!ORK<I8=S!J=MYNI=J!N<!.;M;<7;!R<S!"ROVRMZH!!$=G!=<7MR<7J\!5KTONI!

';TNO=!R<S!';TNONIN7Z\!RM=!:;NJ=S!7;!ORK<I8!78=NM!J=MYNI=J!N<!LNSBEP@P\!3NS=;7M;<!Q;M!78=!78NMS!gKRM7=M!;Q!EP@P!N<!aK=T=I!

R<S!%8RG!Q;M!EP@@!N<!*=J7=M<!"R<RSRH!

.8=!<=G!=<7MR<7J!RM=!Q;IKJN<V!;<!YRMZN<V!R<S!=<ORMVN<V!78=!MR<V=!;Q!78=NM!:M;SKI7!;QQ=MN<VJH!*,$2!';TNO=\!Q;M!=XRL:O=\!

8RJ!ORK<I8=S!:OR<J!MR<VN<V!QM;L!i@W!7;!i?W!S;OORMJ\!G8NI8!;QQ=M!KJ=MJ!K<ONLN7=S!SR7RC\!N<I;LN<V!IROON<V!R<S!QM==!N<I;LN<V!

7=X7!L=JJRV=JH!4KM78=ML;M=\!*,$2!';TNO=!8RJ!RT;ONJ8=S!78=!(RMOZ!"R<I=OOR7N;<!4==\!:M;LNJN<V!<;7!7;!:=<RONb=!I;<JKL=MJ!

J8;KOS!78=Z!I8;;J=!7;!JGN7I8!GNM=O=JJ!:M;YNS=MJH!!

%NLNORMOZ\!5KTONI!';TNO=!;<!78=NM!G=TJN7=!NJ!RSY=M7NJN<V!K<ONLN7=S!7ROU!R<S!7=X7!:OR<J!Q;M!i?P^L;<78!GN78!<;!J=7!I;<7MRI7!

7=ML!R<S!<;!IR<I=OOR7N;<!:=<RO7N=J!K:;<!SNJI;<7N<KR7N;<!;Q!J=MYNI=H!!

C!*N<S!';TNO=!M=J=MY=J!78=!MNV87!7;!LR<RV=!7MRQQNI!RQ7=M!R!KJ=M!8RJ!KJ=S!W-0!;Q!SR7R!N<!R!L;<78!!

877:>^^J8;:HGN<SL;TNO=HIR^5M;SKI7"R7RO;V^2R7R5OR<J^!

Page 25: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$8 7

*NM=O=JJ!'RMU=7!^!,<SKJ7MZ!,JJK=J!

*NM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!NJJK=J!RM=!8=R7=SOZ!SNJIKJJ=S!R<S!S=TR7=S!N<!"R<RSRH!!,<!R<!=QQ;M7!7;!K<S=MJ7R<S!78=!TM=RS78!R<S!J;KMI=!

;Q!I;<JKL=M!SNJI;<7=<7\!M=J=RMI8=MJ!8RY=!N<Y=J7NVR7=S!I;L:ORN<7!N<Q;MLR7N;<!QM;L!J=Y=MRO!N<SKJ7MZ!R<S!I;<JKL=M!

RSY;IRIZ!JN7=J!R<S!I;<SKI7=S!R!TMN=Q!!I;<JKL=M!JKMY=Z!7;!I;OO=I7!Q==STRIU!R<S!J=<7NL=<7H!

\57.2(F.(-J&D5(%;F.2&S)758'8AJ&L05:%&'()&]();%-2A&6,-.%&T&6;FF'2A&5C&]%%;.%&

)=J=RMI8=MJ!G;MU=S!GN78!J=Y=MRO!;MVR<NbR7N;<J!7;!I;OO=I7!R<S!LN<=!SR7R!QM;L!78=NM!O;VJ\!:;J7N<VJ!R<S!:=MJ;<<=OH!

D5FF,%%,5(.2&C52&D5F40',(-%&C52&@.0.85FF;(,8'-,5(%&6.27,8.%&

.8=!";LLNJJN;<=M!Q;M!";L:ORN<7J!Q;M!.=O=I;LLK<NIR7N;<J!%=MYNI=J!d"".%f!NJ!R<!N<S=:=<S=<7!RV=<IZ!mGN78!R!LR<SR7=!7;!

M=I=NY=!R<S!M=J;OY=!I;<JKL=M!R<S!JLROO!TKJN<=JJ!I;L:ORN<7J!M=OR7N<V!7;!L;J7!S=M=VKOR7=S!M=7RNO!7=O=I;LLK<NIR7N;<J!

J=MYNI=JHn!!"".%!GRJ!IM=R7=S!Q;OO;GN<V!R!:KTONI!:M;I==SN<V!8=OS!TZ!78=!")."\!N<!M=J:;<J=!7;!R<!#MS=MBN<B";K<INO!

LR<SR7N<V!78=!IM=R7N;<!;Q!R!7=O=I;LLK<NIR7N;<J!I;<JKL=M!RV=<IZH!"".%!;:=<=S!N7J!S;;MJ!R<S!T=VR<!M=I=NYN<V!I;<JKL=M!

I;L:ORN<7J!N<!_KOZ!EPP[H!!*N78!78=!IORMNQNIR7N;<!TZ!78=!")."!;Q!78=!;MVR<NbR7N;<cJ!LR<SR7=!d'RZ!EPPCf\!78=!R::;N<7L=<7!;Q!

78=!N<S=:=<S=<7!0;RMS!;Q!2NM=I7;MJ!d_K<=!EPPCf!R<S!78=!QNMJ7!";LLNJJN;<=M!d1KVKJ7!EPPCf\!"".%!L;Y=S!;<7;!N7J!G;MU!N<!

OR7=!EPPCH!

"".%!NJ!R!K<NgK=!J7RU=8;OS=MBO=S\!N<SKJ7MZBQK<S=S!;MVR<NbR7N;<!GN78!N<S=:=<S=<7!RK78;MN7Z!7;!M=J;OY=!I;L:ORN<7J!M=OR7=S!

7;!S=M=VKOR7=S!7=O=I;LLK<NIR7N;<J!J=MYNI=JH!1J!JKI8\!N7!M=:M=J=<7J!R!SNJ:K7=!M=J;OK7N;<!L;S=O!78R7!;:=MR7=J!N<!78=!:KTONI!

N<7=M=J7!TK7!NJ!;K7JNS=!V;Y=M<L=<7!:M;I=JJ=J!R<S!GN78;K7!V;Y=M<L=<7!QK<SN<VH!!!"".%!NJ!RI7NY=!N<!IM=R7N<V!N<IM=RJ=S!

RGRM=<=JJ!Q;M!N7J!M;O=!N<!78=!"R<RSNR<!LRMU=7:ORI=\!N<!:RM7<=MJ8N:!GN78!78=!:RM7NIN:R7N<V!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=MJ\!G8NI8!8RY=!

7RU=<!J7=:J!7;!:KTONINb=!"".%!;<!IKJ7;L=M!TNOOJ!R<S!;<!78=NM!G=T!JN7=JH!

1II;MSN<V!7;!78=!"".%!1<<KRO!)=:;M7\!EPPCBEPPF9\!D\E@?!I;L:ORN<7J!G=M=!;:=<=S!N<!78=NM!ORJ7!;:=MR7N<V!Z=RM!R<S!DC!:=M!

I=<7!;Q!78=J=!I;L:ORN<7J!M=OR7=S!7;!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!]!L;M=!I;L:ORN<7J!78R<!R<Z!;78=M!IR7=V;MZH!

9,:;2.&<=Z&&&DD@6&D5F40',(-&>'-'&6;FF'2A&

F!877:>^^GGGHII7JBI:MJ7HIR^=<^:RV=^1<<KRO)=:;M7!!

Page 26: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$8 :

"".%!NJ!LR<SR7=S!7;!S=RO!GN78!GNM=O=JJ!I;L:ORN<7J!QM;L!78=!"R<RSNR<!I;<JKL=M!:KTONI!78R7!8RY=!T==<!N<IR:RTO=!;Q!

M=J;OK7N;<!SNM=I7OZ!T=7G==<!78=!I;<JKL=M!R<S!78=!:M;YNS=MH!!,L:M;Y=S!SR7RTRJ=!7;;OJ!R<S!L;M=!M=QN<=S!IR7=V;MN=J!;Q!

I;L:ORN<7!SR7R!G;KOS!ROO;G!78NJ!;MVR<NbR7N;<!7;!7RU=!R!J7M;<V=M!M;O=!N<!RSSM=JJN<V!U=Z!RM=RJ!;Q!I;<JKL=M!SNJJR7NJQRI7N;<H!

@+.&3;10,8&](-.2.%-&S)758'8A&D.(-2.&

.8=!5KTONI!,<7=M=J7!1SY;IRIZ!"=<7M=!d5,1"f!NJ!R!<;<B:M;QN7!;MVR<NbR7N;<!78R7!:M;YNS=J!O=VRO!R<S!M=J=RMI8!J=MYNI=J!;<!

T=8ROQ!;Q!YKO<=MRTO=!I;<JKL=M!N<7=M=J7J!I;<I=M<N<V!78=!:M;YNJN;<!;Q!NL:;M7R<7!:KTONI!J=MYNI=JH!!2K=!7;!78=!<R7KM=!;Q!78NJ!

;MVR<NbR7N;<\!I;L:ORN<7J!RM=!;IIRJN;<ROOZ!M=I=NY=S!TZ!78=!5,1"H!!1OO!I;L:ORN<R<7J!RM=!RSYNJ=S!78R7!78=!"".%!NJ!T=J7!

=gKN::=S!7;!8R<SO=!;M!M=J;OY=!J:=INQNI!I;<JKL=M!NJJK=JH!

/;G=Y=M\!78=!5,1"!SNS!<;7=!J=Y=MRO!RM=RJ!;Q!I;<I=M<!78R7!M=gKNM=S!N<Y=J7NVR7N;<!R<S^;M!L;M=!RI7NY=!I;<JKL=M!

N<7=MY=<7N;<>!

@H *NM=O=JJ!5OR<!.=MLN<R7N;<!"8RMV=J!

EH "8R<V=J^N<IM=RJ=J!7;!5OR<J!TZ!78=!;:=MR7;M!dNH=H!<=G!7=X7!L=JJRV=!I8RMV=Jf!

DH )=J:;<JNTNON7Z!Q;M!QMRKS^=gKN:L=<7!78=Q7!NJ!GN78!78=!I;<JKL=M!

?H "*.1!";S=!;Q!";<SKI7!]!=OR:J=S!7NL=!7;!=JIROR7N;<!

*,2.0.%%&65'415O&T&*]#>&!51,0.&

$=GB7;BLRMU=7!=<7MR<7!*,$2!';TNO=!VRY=!GNM=O=JJ!I;<JKL=MJ!R!Y;NI=!:MN;M!7;!78=!ORK<I8!;Q!78=NM!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!N<!

"R<RSR!R<S!I;<7N<K=J!7;!LRN<7RN<!R<!;:=<!Q;MKL!;<!78=NM!G=TJN7=!GGGHGN<SL;TNO=HIRH!!

5MN;M!7;!N7J!ORK<I8!N<!2=I=LT=M!EPPF\!I;<JKL=MJ!G=M=!=<I;KMRV=S!7;!SNJIKJJ!78=NM!=XNJ7N<V!GNM=O=JJ!=X:=MN=<I=!N<!78=!

=QQ;M7J!;Q!=<RTON<V!78=!K:BR<SBI;LN<V!*,$2!';TNO=!7;!VRN<!N<JNV87!N<7;!78=!VMN=YR<I=J!R<S!S=JNM=J!;Q!78=!"R<RSNR<!

GNM=O=JJ!I;<JKL=MH!!

2NJIKJJN;<!7;:NIJ!N<!78=!%;R:T;X!G=M=!;MVR<Nb=S!N<!78=!Q;KM!Q;OO;GN<V!IR7=V;MN=J>!

• ,S=RJ!R<S!%KVV=J7N;<J!

• 58;<=J!R<S!5OR<J!

• $=7G;MU!R<S!";Y=MRV=!

• -=<=MRO!";LL=<7J!

!

1J!:RM7!;Q!;KM!M=J=RMI8!N<7;!78=!:;JJNTO=!J;KMI=J!;Q!I;L:ORN<7J!M=VRMSN<V!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=\!%;R:T;XcJ!I;LL=<7J!G=M=!

=XRLN<=SH!!/;G=Y=M\!78=M=!RM=!N<7MN<JNI!:M;TO=LJ!GN78!K7NONbN<V!78=!GNM=O=JJ!J;R:T;X!RJ!R!S=QN<N<V!J;KMI=!;Q!GNM=O=JJ!

I;L:ORN<7JH!!

.8=M=!NJ!R!:M;TO=L!GN78!TNRJH!&<ONU=!78=!"".%\!GN78!LR<SR7=!7;!M=YN=G!R<S!IR:7KM=!I;<JKL=M!I;L:ORN<7J!R<S!:;G=MJ!;Q!

M=I;KMJ=!N<!78=!LRMU=7\!78=!%;R:T;X!8RJ!<;!GRZ!;Q!RK78=<7NIR7N<V!78=!YRONSN7Z!;Q!78=!I;L:ORN<7J!N7!M=I=NY=JH!.8NJ!IM=R7=J!R!

LRk;M!:M;TO=L!N<!78R7!I;L:ORN<7J!JKTLN77=S!7;!78=!%;R:T;X!IR<!T=!I;LLNJJN;<=S!=N78=M!TZ!*,$2!JK::;M7=MJ!;M!*,$2cJ!

;::;JN7N;<H!,<!=N78=M!IRJ=\!78=!I;L:ORN<7J!G;KOS!<;7!V=<KN<=OZ!M=QO=I7!78=!M=RON7N=J!;Q!78=!GNM=O=JJ!LRMU=7\!;M!M=:M=J=<7!78=!

RI7KRO!SNQQNIKO7N=J!G8NI8!I;<JKL=MJ!=<I;K<7=M!G8=<!KJN<V!78=!J=MYNI=H!*8NO=!%;R:T;X!8RJ!VR78=M=S!R!O;7!;Q!Q==STRIU\!N7!NJ!

SNQQNIKO7!7;!RJI=M7RN<!G8NI8!:;J7J!RM=!V=<KN<=OZ!I;LL=<7N<V!;<!M=O=YR<7!NJJK=J!N<!78=!GNM=O=JJ!J:RI=!RJ!;::;J=S!7;!78;J=!

:;J7J!78R7!8RY=!R<!N<I=<7NY=!7;!=N78=M!SNJIM=SN7!*,$2!;M!N7J!I;L:=7N7;MJH!!

!

Page 27: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$8 ;

.8=M=Q;M=\!G8NO=!78=!M=:;M7!S;=J!<;7!KJ=!*,$2cJ!%;R:T;X!RJ!R!Q;MLRO!J;KMI=!Q;M!78=!I;L:ORN<7J!R<ROZJNJ\!78=!N<Q;MLR7N;<!

QM;L!78=!%;R:T;X!NJ!KJ=S!7;!7=J7!78=!YRONSN7Z!;Q!78=!M=:;M7cJ!I;<IOKJN;<J!Q;OO;GN<V!78=!LN<N<V!;Q!78=!"".%!GNM=O=JJ!

I;L:ORN<7!SR7RTRJ=H!

,<S==S\!:MN;M!7;!78=!ORK<I8!;Q!*,$2!';TNO=\!L;J7!I;<JKL=MJ!;<!78=!*,$2!%;R:T;X!=X:M=JJ=S!SNJI;<7=<7!RT;K7>!

• 6=<V78Z!I;<7MRI7J!R<S!YRMN;KJ!:=<RO7N=J!NL:;J=S!TZ!=XNJ7N<V!IRMMN=MJ!Q;M!TM=RI8N<V!78;J=!I;<7MRI7J!

• &<=X:=I7=S\!ORMV=!TNOOJ!R<S!78=!SNQQNIKO7Z!;Q!M=J;OYN<V!JKI8!NJJK=J!78M;KV8!IRMMN=MJc!Q;MLRO!L=78;SJ!;Q!M=I;KMJ=H!!

!

@+.&$CC,8.&).&0'&325-.8-,5(&);&D5(%5FF'-.;2&

)=J=RMI8=MJ!I;<7RI7=S!aK=T=IcJ!#QQNI=!S=!OR!5M;7=I7N;<!SK!";<J;LLR7=KM!7;!=XRLN<=!R<S!K<S=MJ7R<S!78=!I;<JKL=M!

I;<I=M<J!M=OR7=S!7;!GNM=O=JJ!78R7!8RY=!T==<!:M=J=<7=S!7;!78NJ!;MVR<NbR7N;<H!!.8NJ!;QQNI=!RI7J!RJ!R!I;<SKN7!Q;M!I;L:ORN<7J!R7!

R!:M;YN<INRO!O=Y=O!R<S!8RJ!ROJ;!T==<!N<J7MKL=<7RO!N<!SMNYN<V!LR<Z!RJ:=I7J!;Q!I;<JKL=M!:M;7=I7N;<!N<!78=!:M;YN<I=!;Q!

aK=T=IH!!";<JKL=M!I;L:ORN<7!SR7R!GRJ!<;7!RYRNORTO=!QM;L!78NJ!;QQNI=!Q;M!;KM!R<ROZJNJH!/;G=Y=M\!78=!;QQNI=!S;=J!:M;YNS=!R!

YROKRTO=!G=TJN7=!M=J;KMI=!7;!RJJNJ7!I;<JKL=MJ!N<!J=O=I7N;<!;Q!:M=:RNS!;M!:;J7:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=H!!

d877:>^^GGGH;:IHV;KYHgIHIR^*=TQ;MLJ^%Kk=7J";<J;LLR7N;<^0N=<J5=MJ;<<=OJ^"=OOKORNM=J(O=I7M;<NgK=^"8;NX4;KM<NJJ=

KMs(<HRJ:Xf!!

.8NJ!;QQNI=!NJJK=S!R!:M=JJ!M=O=RJ=10!78R7!N<SNIR7=J!.'20A&-.2F,('-,5(&C..%&'()&85(-2'8-&0.(:-+!RM=!78=!L;J7!I;LL;<!

42510.F%!MRNJ=S!TZ!I;<JKL=MJ!7;!78=NM!;QQNI=H!!.8NJ!;QQNI=!JK::;M7J!aK=T=IcJ!0NOO!AP!7;!L;SNQZ!aK=T=IcJ!";<JKL=M!

5M;7=I7N;<!1I7H!

^5W'2)&952;F%&

/;GRMS!4;MKLJ!NJ!R<!;<ON<=!SNJIKJJN;<!T;RMS!S=SNIR7=S!7;!L;TNO=!:8;<=JH!.8=!I;LLK<N7Z!T;RJ7J!;Q!8RYN<V!L;M=!78R<!

@\PPP\PPP!L=LT=MJ!R<S!SNJIKJJ=J!=Y=MZ78N<V!QM;L!8RMSGRM=!LR<KQRI7KM=MJ!R<S!S=YNI=J11!7;!IRMMN=MJ!R<S!78=NM!J=MYNI=J!

ROO!;Y=M!78=!VO;T=H!!/;GRMS!4;MKLJ!:M;YNS=J!7G;!SNJIKJJN;<!RM=RJ!;Q!U=Z!N<7=M=J7!7;!78NJ!M=:;M7>!!"R<RSNR<!"RMMN=M!

2NJIKJJN;<!R<S!"R<RSNR<!5M=:RNS!^!'3$#!2NJIKJJN;<H!!1O78;KV8!78=!<KLT=M!;Q!"R<RSNR<!L=LT=MJ!NJ!<;7!U<;G<\!78=J=!

SNJIKJJN;<!RM=RJ!:M;YNS=!78;KJR<SJ!;Q!78M=RSJ!R<S!7=<J!;Q!78;KJR<SJ!:;J7JH!

,7J!YRMN;KJ!SNJIKJJN;<!78M=RSJ!G=M=!RTO=!7;!:M;YNS=!J;L=!N<JNV87J!N<7;!M=O=YR<7!NJJK=J!N<!78=!N<SKJ7MZ!R<S!78KJ\!R!V;;S!

:ORI=!7;!YRONSR7=!78=!SNM=I7N;<!;Q!;KM!M=J=RMI8!JN<I=!N7!NJ!I;L:MNJ=S!;Q!QRNMOZ!U<;GO=SV=RTO=!N<SNYNSKROJ!]!;Q7=<!78;J=!

N<SNYNSKROJ!G;MU!N<!YRMN;KJ!RM=RJ!;Q!78=!GNM=O=JJ!J:RI=!]!G8;!IR<!;QQ=M!J:=INQNI!S=7RNOJ!R<S!IRMMZ!;K7!N<BS=:78!SNJIKJJN;<JH!!

.8=M=!GRJ!<;!I;L:ORN<7!N<Q;MLR7N;<!7;!T=!VR78=M=S!QM;L!/;GRMScJ!4;MKLH!/;G=Y=M\!G=!SNS!KJ=!78=!Q;MKL!RJ!R!J;KMI=!;Q!

7;:NIJ!Q;M!78=!GNM=O=JJ!JKMY=Z!78R7!GRJ!I;<SKI7=S!Q;M!T;78!:M=:RNS!R<S!:;J7:RNS!KJ=MJH!!!,<!RSSN7N;<\!YNJN7;MJ!7;!78=!

/;GRMS4;MKLJHI;L!^!"R<RSNR<!"RMMN=M!2NJIKJJN;<!^!"R<RSNR<!*NM=O=JJ!,<SKJ7MZ!2NJIKJJN;<!Q;MKL!RM=R!G=M=!N<YN7=S!7;!

:RM7NIN:R7=!N<!R<!=<SBKJ=M!JKMY=Z\!G8NI8!GNOO!T=!SNJIKJJ=S!OR7=M!N<!78NJ!M=:;M7H!!

@P!877:>^^GGGH;:7N;<BI;<J;LLR7=KMJH;MV^=<^:M=JJsM;;L^:M=JJsM=O=RJ=J^EDF^!!@@!877:>^^GGGH8;GRMSQ;MKLJHI;L^!

Page 28: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$8 <

Y=>=&35W.2&'()&S%%58,'-.%&?[[Z&D'('),'(&*,2.0.%%&6'-,%C'8-,5(&6-;)A&

,<!N7J!QNQ78!Z=RM\!78NJ!J7KSZ!=XRLN<=J!78=!:=MI=:7N;<!;Q!GNM=O=JJ!IKJ7;L=MJ!GN78!78=NM!J=MYNI=\!L;TNO=!:8;<=J!R<S!M=7RNO!

=X:=MN=<I=H!!!

"KJ7;L=M!JR7NJQRI7N;<!MR<UN<VJ!RM=!TRJ=S!;<!IROO!gKRON7Z\!TNOON<V\!J=MYNI=!:OR<!;:7N;<\!I;J7!;Q!J=MYNI=\!R<S!IKJ7;L=M!J=MYNI=H!

.8=!EPPF!J7KSZ\!M=JKO7J!J8;G<!T=O;G\!Q;K<S!3NMVN<!';TNO=!MR<U=S!78=!8NV8=J7!RL;<V!:;J7:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=MJ!

TRJ=S!;<!:RM7NIKORMOZ!8NV8!:=MQ;MLR<I=J!N<!TNOON<V\!IROO!gKRON7Z!R<S!I;J7!;Q!J=MYNI=H!

3NMVN<!';TNO=!MR<U=S!78=!8NV8=J7!RL;<V!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=MJ!Q;M!78=!QNQ78!I;<J=IK7NY=!Z=RM!TRJ=S!;<!

:RM7NIKORMOZ!8NV8!IKJ7;L=M!=YROKR7N;<J!N<!ROO!QNY=!RM=RJH!

9,:;2.&?=[&&&Y=>=35W.2&D;%-5F.2&6'-,%C'8-,5(&B'(U,(:&T&35%-4',)&'()&32.4',)&

]();%-2A&\57.2('(8.&/&D*@S&

#<!@F!1KVKJ7!EPPF\!78=!"R<RSNR<!*NM=O=JJ!.=O=I;LLK<NIR7N;<J!1JJ;INR7N;<!d"*.1f!RS;:7=S!78=!";S=!;Q!";<SKI7!Q;M!

*NM=O=JJ!%=MYNI=!5M;YNS=MJH!!.8NJ!";S=!=<JKM=J!78R7!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!I;L:R<N=J!GNOO!KJ=!QKOO!SNJIO;JKM=!G8=<!S=RON<V!GN78!

IKJ7;L=MJ\!VKRMR<7==!78R7!78=NM!RSY=M7NJN<V!NJ!RIIKMR7=\!R<S!M=J:=I7!I;<JKL=M!MNV87J!G8=<!I8R<VN<V!=O=L=<7J!N<!

Page 29: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

!"# $%&' ( $ ) ! "%# * + , ) " - ) ! . # ./ . ) !0123 423 ) 51267!189 ):; )< 4=95977 ) 8 5127 )

!" #

*"#>(.*>$?12))1**"(/+#@)>")>A+$)$'>)"-)$>.#/.(/$B)>A')C+(','$$)$'(D+*')*.((+'($).(').,$")('$E"#$+F,')-"().)@('.>'()'--"(>)+#)*%$>"&'()$'(D+*').#/)*"&E,.+#>)('$",%>+"#?)

)

:E>+"#)!"#$"&&.>'%($)/'#"%#*'/)>A')!"/')"-)!"#/%*>).$)#">)$",D+#@)>A')('.,)+$$%'$)!.#./+.#$)-.*')C+>A)C+(','$$)*"&E.#+'$?))GA'H)F',+'D')+>)/"'$)#">)>(%,H)('I%+(')*"&E.#+'$)>")-%,,H)/+$*,"$')+#-"(&.>+"#)"().//('$$)>A')+$$%'$)"-)'.(,H)>'(&+#.>+"#)-''$)"()*"#*'(#)C+>A)*"#>(.*>),'#@>A?13)

4#).)2'>C"(J)<"(,/)!.#./.).(>+*,'KL)"-)7'E>)MB)MNNOB)>A').%>A"()$%&&.(+P'$)>A.>)>A')*"/')/"'$)('I%+(')C+(','$$)$'(D+*')"E'(.>"($)>")$+&E,+-H),.#@%.@').#/)('$",D')*"&E,.+#>$)C+>A+#)QN)/.H$B).#/)C(+>'$B)R>A')*"/')C"#S>)$>"E)"E'(.>"($)-("&)+$$%+#@)&%,>+TE.@')F("*A%('$)+#)-+#')E(+#>)/'>.+,+#@)>A'+()$'(D+*'$B)#"()C+,,)+>)$>"E)"E'(.>"($)-("&)%#+,.>'(.,,H)*A.#@+#@)"().//+#@)'U>(.)-''$)"()*A.(@'$)+-)QN)/.H$S)#">+*')+$)@+D'#?V)

!"#"$%"#&'"()*+&,*-%./"+%0#&1&23+%4%+5&

GA')(',.>+"#$A+E)C+>A)('$E'*>)>")E(+*'$).#/)>'(&$)"-)$'(D+*')F'>C''#)>','*"&&%#+*.>+"#$)E("D+/'($).#/)*"#$%&'($)+$)#">)-'/'(.,,H)('@%,.>'/B)F%>).)F(+'-)('D+'C)"-)+#+>+.>+D'$).#/)E("E"$'/),'@+$,.>+"#)C.$)%#/'(>.J'#)>")'UE"$')>A"$')(','D.#>)>")*"#$%&'()*"&E,.+#>).('.$?))6'>.+,'/).#.,H$+$)W)('D+'C)+#)>A').('.)C.$)/'>'(&+#'/)>")F'),'$$)(','D.#>)>A.#)'U>'#$+D')!!G7)*"&E,.+#>)/.>.)('D+'CB)F%>).#)"D'(D+'C)+$)$A"C#)F',"C?)

6*$*("/&

4#)!.#./.)+#)MNNXB).)*".,+>+"#)*"&E"$'/)"-)>A')8%F,+*)4#>'('$>)1/D"*.*H)!'#>('B)>A')!.#./+.#)4#>'(#'>)8",+*H).#/)8%F,+*)4#>'('$>)!,+#+*B)>A')!"#$%&'($)!"%#*+,)"-)!.#./.B)>A')!"#$%&'($S)1$$"*+.>+"#)"-)!.#./.B)>A'):E>+"#)!"#$"&&.>'%($B).#/)>A')2.>+"#.,)8"D'(>H):(@.#+P.>+"#).EE(".*A'/)'D'(H)&.Y"()-'/'(.,)E.(>H)>").//('$$)*"#*'(#$)+#)>A')>','*"&&%#+*.>+"#$)&.(J'>B)$E'*+-+*.,,H)('@.(/+#@)*"#$%&'()(+@A>$).#/)*"&E'>+>+"#?15)

7#+"(%0&"#$&2/8*(+"&

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

4#):#>.(+"B)QN)`%,H)MNNaB)>A')!"#$%&'()8(">'*>+"#)1*>)*.&')+#>")'--'*>?))GA+$)+#*,%/'$)*"#$%&'()(+@A>$)$%*A).$)#'@.>+D'T"E>+"#)F+,,+#@B)F'+#@)E("D+/'/)C+>A)C(+>>'#)*"#>(.*>$)-"(),"#@T>'(&).((.#@'&'#>$B)-%,,)/+$*,"$%(')('@.(/+#@)*"$>$).#/)+#>'('$>B).#/)>A')"E>+"#)>")*.#*',).#).@(''&'#>)C+>A+#).)H'.()+-)>A'(').(')%#-.+()F%$+#'$$)E(.*>+*'$?18))GA+$).*>)C.$)#">)C(+>>'#)>")>.(@'>)+$$%'$)+#)>A')C+(','$$)&.(J'>B)F%>)$"&')"-)>A')*"#/+>+"#$)*'(>.+#,H).EE,H?)

KM)A>>EbWWCCC?*C>.?*.W!<G17+>'W'#@,+$AW*"/'"-*"#/%*>?A>&,))KQ)A>>EbWWCCC?"E>+"#T*"#$"&&.>'%($?"(@W'#WE('$$c(""&WE('$$c(','.$'$WMQOW))KL)A>>EbWWCCC?+>C"(,/*.#./.?*"&W#'C$WC+(','$$T"E'(.>"($TE("&+$'T$+&E,'T,.#@%.@'T+#T*"#>(.*>$WKQ_LQX))15 A>>EbWWCCC?E+.*?*.W>','*"&W&.Y"(cE.(>+'$c.$J'/c>"c$%EE"(>c*"#$%&'(c(+@A>$c+#c>','*"&&%#+*.>+"#$W 16 A>>EbWWCCC?*F*?*.W*"#$%&'(W$>"(HWMNNZWNaWMOW@+->*.(/T'UE+(H?A>&, 17 A>>EbWWCCC?$'(D+*'.,F'(>.?@"D?.F?*.WKMON?*-& 18 A>>EbWWCCC?&@$?@"D?"#?*.W'#W2'C$W7G95NMcNLZKQa?A>&,

Page 30: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$9 #

_;.1.8&

,<!_K<=!;Q!EPPF\!0NOO!AP!GRJ!:M;:;J=S!N<!aK=T=IH!!.8NJ!TNOO!NJ!78=!J=I;<S!:8RJ=!;Q!R!78M==B:RM7!:OR<!S=JNV<=S!7;!K:SR7=!

aK=T=IcJ!";<JKL=M!5M;7=I7N;<!1I7H!!.8=!QNMJ7!:RM7!GRJ!Q;IKJ=S!;<!J=MYNI=J!:M;YNS=S!R7!R!SNJ7R<I=\!R<S!78=!ORJ7!:RM7!GNOO!

Q;IKJ!;<!IM=SN7!I;<7MRI7JH19!

0NOO!AP!NJ!R!:M;:;JRO!7;!M=Q;ML!78=!ORGJ!M=VRMSN<V!:M=:RNS!IRMSJ\!I;<7MRI7KRO!RVM==L=<7J\!R<S!J=MYNI=J!:M;YNS=S!R7!R!

SNJ7R<I=H!!,Q!0NOO!AP!:RJJ=J\!:M=:RNS!IRMSJ!G;KOS!T=!:M;8NTN7=S!QM;L!8RYN<V!=X:NMZ!SR7=J\!RJ!O;<V!RJ!78NJ!S;=J!<;7!M=JKO7!N<!

K<ONLN7=S!KJ=\!RJ!G=OO!RJ!NJJKR<I=!;M!KJRV=!Q==JH20!.=MLJ!R<S!I;<SN7N;<J!;Q!78=!IRMS!G;KOS!ROJ;!8RY=!7;!T=!SNJIO;J=S!R<S!

:M;YNS=S!N<!GMN7N<VH!*8NO=!;78=M!:M;YN<I=J!8RY=!ORGJ!TR<<N<V!=X:NMZ!SR7=J!;<!VNQ7!IRMSJ!GN78!IRJ8!YROK=\!0NOO!AP!NJ!

M=Y;OK7N;<RMZ!N<!N7J!:M;:;JRO!7;!=X7=<S!78R7!ORG!7;!ROO!:M=:RNS!IRMSJ\!N<IOKSN<V!:8;<=!IRMSJH!

.8=!J=I7N;<!;Q!78=!TNOO!78R7!:M;:;J=J!I8R<V=J!N<!I;<7MRI7!ORG!=JJ=<7NROOZ!J7MNY=J!Q;M!J7MNI7=M!I;<7MRI7!M=VKOR7N;<H!!.8=!TNOO!

J7R7=J!78R7!<;!K<NOR7=MRO!I8R<V=J!IR<!T=!LRS=!7;!=JJ=<7NRO!=O=L=<7J!;Q!R!QNX=SB7=ML!I;<7MRI7H!!*8=<!78=!I;<7MRI7!NJ!

:M;YNS=S\!R!IORKJ=!LKJ7!T=!N<IOKS=S!7;!NS=<7NQZ!G8NI8!=O=L=<7J!IR<!T=!I8R<V=SH21!!.8=!L=MI8R<7!G;KOS!T=!:M;8NTN7=S!

QM;L!RL=<SN<V!R<Z!J=I7N;<!;Q!78=!I;<7MRI7!GN78;K7!:M;YNSN<V!78=!I;<JKL=M!GN78!R!GMN77=<!<;7NQNIR7N;<!AP!SRZJ!N<!RSYR<I=!

R<S!ROO;GN<V!78=!I;<JKL=M!7;!IR<I=O!78=!I;<7MRI7!N<!78R7!:=MN;S\!QM==!;Q!I8RMV=H!!'=MI8R<7J!G;KOS!ROJ;!T=!:M;8NTN7=S!QM;L!

IR<I=OON<V!R!QNX=SB7=ML!RVM==L=<7\!R<S!LKJ7!:M;YNS=!AP!SRZJ!:MN;M!GMN77=<!<;7NI=!7;!IR<I=O!R<!N<S=7=MLN<R7=B7=ML!

RVM==L=<7H22!!5=<RO7Z!IORKJ=J!G;KOS!ROJ;!T=!TR<<=SH!!,Q!I;<JKL=MJ!S;!<;7!QKOQNOO!78=!;TONVR7N;<J!7;!78=NM!I;<7MRI7J!dNH=H!

:RZL=<7f\!78=<!N<7=M=J7!;<!78=!:RZL=<7!NJ!78=!;<OZ!:=MLNJJNTO=!RSSN7N;<RO!I8RMV=H23!

.8=!TNOO!ROJ;!:M;:;J=J!I8R<V=J!7;!J=MYNI=J!:M;YNS=S!R7!R!SNJ7R<I=H!!.8=!TNOO!J7R7=J!78R7!I=M7RN<!7=MLJ!;Q!78=!I;<7MRI7!LKJ7!T=!

LRS=!IO=RM!7;!78=!I;<JKL=M\!JKI8!RJ!J=MYNI=J!;QQ=M=S!RJ!R!:M=LNKL\!=I;<;LNI!YROK=!;Q!R<Z!N<SKI=L=<7J\!78=!=X:NMZ!;Q!

I;<7MRI7\!R<S!G8=<!78=!IKJ7;L=M!NJ!ROO;G=S!7;!IR<I=O!78=!I;<7MRI7H24!!0KJN<=JJ=J!G;KOS!<;7!T=!ROO;G=S!7;!RK7;LR7NIROOZ!

M=<=G!R!QNX=SB7=ML!RVM==L=<7!78R7!=XI==SJ!AP!SRZJH!!1OJ;\!R!I;<JKL=M!IR<!IR<I=O!R!I;<7MRI7!R7!R<Z!7NL=!78M;KV8!GMN77=<!

<;7NI=!7;!78=!L=MI8R<7H!!6NLN7=S!N<S=L<N7N=J!IR<!T=!I;OO=I7=S\!K<O=JJ!78=!IR<I=OOR7N;<!GRJ!IRKJ=S!TZ!R!K<NOR7=MRO!

RL=<SL=<7!TZ!78=!L=MI8R<7\!N<!G8NI8!IRJ=\!<;!RSSN7N;<RO!I8RMV=J!IR<!T=!I;OO=I7=S\!;78=M!78R<!N<7=M=J7H!

1Q7=M!RL=<SL=<7J!RM=!LRS=\!0NOO!AP!NJ!=X:=I7=S!7;!:RJJ!J;L=7NL=!N<!EP@PH!!1II;MSN<V!7;!kKJ7NI=!LN<NJ7=M!+R78O==<!*=NO\!

m*=rM=!V;N<V!7;!TMN<V!N<!R!M=VKOR7N;<!7;!=<JKM=!78R7!78=J=!:=<RO7N=J!S;!<;7!=XI==S!78=!T=<=QN7!78R7!I;<JKL=MJ!M=I=NY=SHn!

@F!877:>^^GGGHTORU=JHI;L^=<VONJ8^YN=GHRJ:j,2tDE?C!EP!NTNS!E@!NTNS!EE!NTNS!ED!NTNS!E?!877:>^^GGGH;VNOYZM=<RKO7HI;L^=<^M=J;KMI="=<7M=sF?AAH87L!

Page 31: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$9 !

)=YN=G!;Q!%N7KR7N;<!]!#K7JNS=!;Q!"R<RSR!

6;FF'2A&5C&P=6=&6,-;'-,5(%&'()&B.:;0'-,5(&

.8=!&<N7=S!%7R7=J!NJ!R!O=RSN<V!I;K<7MZ!N<!78=!GNM=O=JJ!N<SKJ7MZH!!.8=!IM=R7N;<!;Q!78=!%LRM7:8;<=\!;QQ=MN<V!78=!QNMJ7!L;TNO=!

6.(!R<S!*N'RX!<=7G;MUJ\!R<S!78=!QRI7!78R7!1L=MNIR<J!KJ=!78=!L;J7!D-!SR7R!J=MYNI=J!ROO!7=J7NQZ!7;!1L=MNIR<!:M;LN<=<I=!N<!

GNM=O=JJ!7=I8<;O;VZH25!!.8=M=Q;M=\!N7!Q;OO;GJ!78R7!78=!&<N7=S!%7R7=J!NJ!R7!78=!Q;M=QM;<7!;Q!I;<JKL=M!GNM=O=JJ!NJJK=J\!

=J:=INROOZ!M=OR7=S!7;!J=MYNI=!I;Y=MRV=\!I;<7MRI7!RVM==L=<7J\!R<S!=XIOKJNY=!RVM==L=<7J!T=7G==<!GNM=O=JJ!:M;YNS=MJ!R<S!

I=OO!:8;<=!LR<KQRI7KM=MJH!

,<!78=!&H%H\!+=<7KIUZ\!6;KNJNR<R\!R<S!78=!&H%H!3NMVN<!,JOR<SJ!G=M=!78=!QNMJ7!7;!:RJJ!ORGJ!Q;M!I;<JKL=M!MNV87J!N<!78=!GNM=O=JJ!

N<SKJ7MZH!!+=<7KIUZ!M=gKNM=S!78=!:KTONI!J=MYNI=!I;LLNJJN;<!7;!M=J;OY=!I;<JKL=M!I;L:ORN<7J\!6;KNJNR<R!:M;8NTN7=S!

I;L:R<N=J!QM;L!RK7;LR7NIROOZ!M=<=GN<V!I;<7MRI7J\!R<S!78=!&H%H!3NMVN<!,JOR<SJ!M=gKNM=!GNM=O=JJ!:M;YNS=MJ!7;!I;L:OZ!GN78!

"=OOKORM!.=O=I;LLK<NIR7N;<J!R<S!,<7=M<=7!1JJ;INR7N;<cJ!";<JKL=M!";S=!Q;M!*NM=O=JJ!%=MYNI=H26!!,<!EPPC\!QNY=!;78=M!J7R7=J!

N<7M;SKI=S!TNOOJ!M=VRMSN<V!TNOON<V!;:7N;<J!R<S!M=gKNMN<V!I;L:R<N=J!7;!:M;YNS=!QKOO!SNJIO;JKM=!GN78!78=NM!IKJ7;L=MJH!

,<!EPP[\!78=!"=OO!58;<=!";<JKL=M!(L:;G=ML=<7!1I7!GRJ!N<7M;SKI=SH!!,7!S=LR<S=S!78R7!I;L:R<N=J!:M;YNS=!QKOO!

SNJIO;JKM=!7;!78=NM!IKJ7;L=MJ\!S=7RNOJ!;<!I;Y=MRV=\!R<S!ROO;G!I;<JKL=MJ!7;!M=JIN<S!QM;L!78=!I;<7MRI7!GN78;K7!R<!=RMOZ!

7=MLN<R7N;<!Q==!DP!SRZJ!N<7;!78=!I;<7MRI7H27!

.8=!Q;OO;GN<V!Z=RM\!3=MNb;<!*NM=O=JJ!R<S!1.`.!RS;:7=S!78=!:MRI7NI=!;Q!:M;BMR7N<V!=RMOZ!7=MLN<R7N;<!Q==JH!!,<!I;L:ONR<I=!

GN78!78=!"=OO!58;<=!";<JKL=M!(L:;G=ML=<7!1I7\!78=!I;L:R<N=J!ROO;G=S!IKJ7;L=MJ!7;!7=MLN<R7=!78=!I;<7MRI7!N<!78=!QNMJ7!

DP!SRZJ!NQ!K<JR7NJQN=S!GN78!78=!J=MYNI=H!!1Q7=M!78R7\!QNY=!S;OORMJ!G;KOS!T=!7RU=<!;QQ!78=!RL;K<7!;Q!i@[W!Q;M!=Y=MZ!L;<78!78=!

IKJ7;L=M!M=LRN<=S!N<!78=!I;<7MRI7H28!!*8NO=!78NJ!J==L=S!7;!T=!R!O=R:!Q;MGRMS!Q;M!I;<JKL=M!MNV87J\!GN78N<!78=!<=X7!Z=RM!

1L=MNIR<J!G=M=!S=LR<SN<V!L;M=!I;<JKL=M!MNV87J!N<!78=!GNM=O=JJ!N<SKJ7MZH!

,<!m.8=!";<JKL=M!*NM=O=JJ!(X:=MN=<I=n!8=RMN<V!N<!EPPF\!_;8<!2H!);IU=Q=OO=M!,3\!"8RNMLR<!;Q!78=!&H%H!";LLN77==!;<!

";LL=MI=\!%IN=<I=!R<S!.MR<J:;M7R7N;<!=X:M=JJ=S!8NJ!I;<I=M<J!RT;K7!78=!I;L:ORN<7J!1L=MNIR<J!8RY=!RT;K7!I;<QKJN<V!

I;<7MRI7J!R<S!:;;M!I;Y=MRV=\!=J:=INROOZ!N<!MKMRO!RM=RJH29!!,<!8NJ!7=J7NL;<Z!R7!78=!8=RMN<V\!_;8<!(H!);;<=Z\!5M=JNS=<7!R<S!

"(#!;Q!78=!&<N7=S!%7R7=J!"=OOKORM!";M:;MR7N;<\!J7R7=S!78R7!8=!T=ON=Y=J!78=!4=S=MRO!";LLK<NIR7N;<J!";LLNJJN;<!d4""f!

J8;KOS!=XRLN<=!=XIOKJNYN7Z!NJJK=J!R<S!:K7!M=J7MNI7N;<J!N<!:ORI=!78R7!:M;8NTN7!78=J=!RMMR<V=L=<7JH!!/=!I;LL=<7=S!78R7!

=XIOKJNY=!S=ROJ!T=7G==<!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=MJ!R<S!LR<KQRI7KM=MJ!RM=!ONLN7N<V!78=!VM;G78!;Q!TM;RSTR<S!J=MYNI=J!N<!78=!&<N7=S!

%7R7=JH30!!,<!MKMRO!RM=RJ!;Q!78=!&H%H\!G8=M=!:M;LN<=<7!GNM=O=JJ!I;L:R<N=J!S;!<;7!:M;YNS=!J=MYNI=!I;Y=MRV=\!78=!;IIK:R<7J!

S;!<;7!8RY=!RII=JJ!7;!78=!OR7=J7!I=OO!:8;<=JH!!4;M!=XRL:O=\!:=;:O=!ONYN<V!N<!R<!RM=R!;K7JNS=!;Q!1.`.cJ!<=7G;MU!I;Y=MRV=!

G=M=!K<RTO=!7;!KJ=!N58;<=Jp!SK=!7;!1.`.cJ!=XIOKJNY=!S=RO!GN78!1::O=!,<I!7;!T=!78=!;<OZ!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=M!Q;M!N58;<=pH!

EW!877:>^^LH<=GJHI;L^E@AAB@EsDB@PD@WP[CBEAAH87LO!!EA!877:>^^GGGHTMN7R<<NIRHI;L^T:J^RSSN7N;<ROI;<7=<7^@C^DW?F[?ED^*,)(6(%%B"#$%&'()B0,66%B#4B),-/.!!E[!877:>^^UO;TKI8RMHJ=<R7=HV;Y^<=GJM=O=RJ=JsS=7RNOHIQLjNStECWWDW`!!EC!877:>^^TO;VJHI;<JKL=MM=:;M7JH;MV^=O=I7M;<NIJ^EPPC^P?^R77B7;B:M;BMR7=H87LO!!29!877:>^^I;LL=MI=HJ=<R7=HV;Y^:KTONI^N<S=XHIQLj4KJ=1I7N;<t/=RMN<VJH%7R7=L=<7`%7R7=L=<7s,2tA??FTPTCBQQFFB???WB

FF@DBWAI[@DWSQDSF! DP!877:>^^I;LL=MI=HJ=<R7=HV;Y^:KTONI^N<S=XHIQLj4KJ=1I7N;<t/=RMN<VJH.=J7NL;<Z`/=RMN<Vs,2tPDTC@QQSBTRFQB?E=AB

CDD@B[IECQAS@@ETP`*N7<=JJs,2tRWWFQ@WDBQE[CB?[C[BTSEABSSP@S@=FAIDE!!

Page 32: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$9 8

);;<=Z!ROJ;!I;LL=<7=S!78R7!78=J=!=XIOKJNY=!MNV87J!SRLRV=!<R7N;<RO!I;L:=7N7N;<!R<S!LRU=!N7!SNQQNIKO7!Q;M!JLROO=M!I=OOKORM!

I;L:R<N=J!7;!U==:!K:H31!

6R7=M!N<!EPPF\!78=!4""!R<<;K<I=S!N7!G;KOS!ORK<I8!7G;!N<gKNMN=J!N<7;!TNOON<V!L=78;SJ!R<S!I;L:=7N7N;<!N<!78=!LRMU=7H!!"8MNJ!

-K77LR<B'I"RT=\!78=!YNI=!:M=JNS=<7!;Q!M=VKOR7;MZ!RQQRNMJ!Q;M!".,1\!78=!N<7=M<R7N;<RO!RJJ;INR7N;<!Q;M!78=!GNM=O=JJ!

7=O=I;LLK<NIR7N;<J!N<SKJ7MZ\!J7R7=S!78R7!8=!T=ON=Y=S!78=!TNOON<V!N<gKNMZ!G;KOS!J8;G!78R7!78=!V;Y=M<L=<7!I8RMV=J!7;!78=!

I=OOKORM!I;L:R<N=J!8RY=!IM=R7=S!G8R7!8=!T=ON=Y=J!NJ!R!7RXH!-K77LR<B'I"RT=!ROJ;!JRNS!8=!GRJ!VORS!78=!4""!NJ!S;N<V!

78;M;KV8!M=J=RMI8!N<!;MS=M!7;!LRU=!R<!N<Q;ML=S!S=INJN;<!;<!78=!NJJK=JH32!!,<!M=VRMSJ!7;!78=!N<gKNMZ!N<7;!GNM=O=JJ!

I;L:=7N7N;<!R<S!N<<;YR7N;<\!78=!4""!NJ!=XRLN<N<V!78=!=XIOKJNY=!S=ROJ!LRS=!T=7G==<!I;L:R<N=J\!JKI8!RJ!1.`.!R<S!1::O=\!

;M!%:MN<7!R<S!5ROL!5M=Hp33!)=J=RMI8!NJ!T=N<V!I;<SKI7=S!7;!S=7=MLN<=!NQ!78=J=!RMMR<V=L=<7J!RM=!SRLRVN<V!7;!I;L:=7N7N;<!

R<S!I;<JKL=M!;:7N;<JH!

*N78!M=J:=I7!7;!=RMOZ!7=MLN<R7N;<!Q==J!d(.4Jf\!78=!S=TR7=!;Y=M!)!*$!=RMOZ!7=MLN<R7N;<!Q==J!NJ!T=N<V!J=77O=S!TZ!R!J=MN=J!;Q!

IORJJ!RI7N;<!ORGJKN7JH!!%:MN<7!$=X7=O!GRJ!;MS=M=S!TZ!R!"RONQ;M<NR!I;KM7!N<!_KOZ!EPPF!7;!M=QK<S!i@CHEW'!7;!78=NM!IKJ7;L=MJ!

G8;!:RNS!JKI8!Q==JH!!3=MNb;<!*NM=O=JJ!RVM==S!7;!S;!78=!JRL=!GN78!iE@'\!R<S!1.`.!M=I=<7OZ!S=INS=S!d_R<KRMZ\!EP@Pf!7;!

J=77O=!R<!i@C'!IORJJ!RI7N;<!JKN7o!1.`.!GNOO!M=7KM<!K:!7;!i@?P!;Q!78=!i@[W!(.4!NL:;J=S!;<!RQQ=I7=S!IKJ7;L=MJ\!V;N<V!RJ!QRM!

TRIU!RJ!@FFCH!!.8=!I;L:R<Z!ROJ;!J7RM7=S!7;!:M;BMR7=!N7J!7=MLN<R7N;<!Q==!;Y=M!78=!M=LRN<N<V!ONQ=!;Q!78=!I;<7MRI7!N<!EPPCH!!!

/;G=Y=M\!;<!78=!JRL=!SRZ!78R7!1.`.!R<<;K<I=S!78=NM!J=77O=L=<7!;QQ=M\!78=!4""!J=<7!O=77=MJ!7;!78=!Q;KM!.N=M!@!GNM=O=JJ!

IRMMN=MJ!RJ!G=OO!RJ!-;;VO=\!RJUN<V!78=L!7;!=X:ORN<!N<!S=7RNO!78=NM!=RMOZ!7=MLN<R7N;<!Q==!d(.4f!:;ONIN=J!Q;M!8R<SJ=7J\!

JKVV=J7N<V!78R7!78NJ!I;<7M;Y=MJNRO!RM=R!GNOO!M=LRN<!K<S=M!JIMK7N<ZH!

S;%-2'0,'&T&6;FF'2A&5C&6,-;'-,5(&'()&B.:;0'-,5(&

1KJ7MRONR!8RJ!=J7RTONJ8=S!78=!.=O=I;LLK<NIR7N;<J!,<SKJ7MZ!#LTKSJLR<!RJ!R!QM==!R<S!N<S=:=<S=<7!RO7=M<R7NY=!SNJ:K7=!

M=J;OK7N;<!;MVR<NbR7N;<!Q;M!JLROO!TKJN<=JJ!R<S!M=JNS=<7NRO!I;<JKL=MJ!N<!1KJ7MRONR!G8;!8RY=!R!I;L:ORN<7!RT;K7!78=NM!

7=O=:8;<=!;M!,<7=M<=7!J=MYNI=H!!(J7RTONJ8=S!N<!@FFD!K<S=M!R!4=S=MRO!1I7!;Q!5RMONRL=<7\!78=!.,#!NJ!N<S=:=<S=<7!;Q!N<SKJ7MZ\!

78=!V;Y=M<L=<7!R<S!I;<JKL=M!;MVR<NbR7N;<JH!!

.8=!.,#!NJ!RK78;MNb=S!7;!N<Y=J7NVR7=!I;L:ORN<7J!RT;K7!78=!:M;YNJN;<!;M!JK::OZ!;Q!7=O=:8;<=!;M!,<7=M<=7!J=MYNI=JH!2=7RNOJ!;Q!

78=NM!;:=MR7N;<\!J7MKI7KM=!R<S!M=OR7N;<J8N:!7;!78=!N<SKJ7MZ!R<S!V;Y=M<L=<7!IR<!T=!Q;K<S!R7!N7J!G=TJN7=>!

877:>^^GGGH7N;HI;LHRK^!!

.8NJ!;MVR<NbR7N;<\!JNLNORM!7;!78=!"".%!N<!"R<RSR\!S=RO7!GN78!EDP\PPP!I;<JKL=M!I;L:ORN<7J\!GN78!FP!:=M!I=<7!T=N<V!

M=J;OY=S!78M;KV8!R!M=Q=MMRO!TRIU!7;!78=!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=MH!!,<!1KJ7MRONR\!L;TNO=!J=MYNI=!8RS!78=!8NV8=J7!<KLT=M!;Q!

I;L:ORN<7J\!O=S!TZ!TNOON<V!R<S!:RZL=<7!NJJK=J\!IKJ7;L=M!J=MYNI=!R<S!I;L:ORN<7!8R<SON<VH!!.8=!7;:!NJJK=J!N<!TNOON<V!R<S!

:RZL=<7!N<IOKS=!SNJ:K7=S!KJRV=!I8RMV=J\!SNJ:K7=S!M=IKMMN<V!I8RMV=J!R<S!SNJ:K7=S!I;<<=I7N;<^7=MLN<R7N;<!Q==JH!!

,<!_K<=\!EPPF\!R<!1KJ7MRONR<!";<JKL=M!6RG!0NOO!GRJ!N<7M;SKI=S!N<7;!5RMONRL=<7!;Q!78=!.MRS=!5MRI7NI=J!1L=<SL=<7!

d1KJ7MRONR<!";<JKL=M!6RGf!0NOO!EPPFH!.8=!0NOO!GNOO!N<7M;SKI=!R!JN<VO=!<R7N;<RO!I;<JKL=M!ORG!d7;!T=!U<;G<!RJ!78=!

1KJ7MRONR<!";<JKL=M!6RGf\!G8NI8!N<IOKS=J!:M;YNJN;<J!M=VKOR7N<V!K<QRNM!I;<7MRI7!7=MLJH!!.8=!1KJ7MRONR<!";L:=7N7N;<!R<S!

";<JKL=M!";LLNJJN;<!d1"""f!8RJ!NS=<7NQN=S!F51,0.&42.F,;F&%.27,8.%!R<S!:8;<=!IRMSJ!RM=!7G;!;Q!78=!J=MYNI=J!R7!78=!

Q;M=QM;<7!;Q!1"""cJ!I;<JKL=M!RI7N;<JHD?!!u,<!M=I=<7OZ!R<<;K<IN<V!78=!:M;:;J=S!1KJ7MRONR<!";<JKL=M!6RG\!G8NI8!RNLJ!7;!

D@!!877:>^^I;LL=MI=HJ=<R7=HV;Y^:KTONI^N<S=XHIQLj4KJ=1I7N;<t/=RMN<VJH.=J7NL;<Z`/=RMN<Vs,2tPDTC@QQSBTRFQB?E=AB

CDD@B[IECQAS@@ETP`*N7<=JJs,2tRWWFQ@WDBQE[CB?[C[BTSEABSSP@S@=FAIDE!!DE!877:>^^LH<=GJHI;L^E@AAB@EsDB@PD@WP[CBEAAH87LO!!DD!NTNS!D? 877:>^^GGGHR7KVHI;LHRK^1.&-EPPF^5M=J=<7R7N;<J^-MR=L=%RLK=OH:SQ!!

Page 33: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$9 9

7RIUO=!K<QRNM!I;<7MRI7!7=MLJ\!";<JKL=M!1QQRNMJ!'N<NJ7=M!"8MNJ!0;G=<!8NV8ONV87=S!78R7!J7R<SRMS!Q;ML!I;<7MRI7J\!JKI8!RJ!

78;J=!KJ=S!TZ!L;TNO=!:8;<=!;:=MR7;MJ\!RM=!78=!UN<S!;Q!I;<7MRI7J!78R7!GNOO!T=!JKTk=I7!7;!78=!<=G!ORGJHu!

P(,-.)&`,(:)5F&&

.8=!#QQNI=!;Q!";LLK<NIR7N;<J!d#QI;Lf!NJ!78=!N<S=:=<S=<7!M=VKOR7;M!R<S!I;L:=7N7N;<!RK78;MN7Z!Q;M!78=!&+!

I;LLK<NIR7N;<J!N<SKJ7MN=JH!!.8NJ!;MVR<NbR7N;<!NJ!ROJ;!RI7NY=!N<!L;<N7;MN<V!R<S!M=J:;<SN<V!7;!I;<JKL=M!I;L:ORN<7J!RJ!

=YNS=<I=S!N<!78=NM!L;J7!M=I=<7!M=J=RMI8!M=:;M7\!.8=!";<JKL=M!(X:=MN=<I=\!EPPFHDW!!.8=!&+!LRMU=7!GRJ!<;7!M=J=RMI8=S!

=X7=<JNY=OZ!RJ!:RM7!;Q!78NJ!M=:;M7!RJ!<;!JNV<NQNIR<7!N<N7NR7NY=J!M=OR7=S!7;!78=!"R<RSNR<!LRMU=7!JN7KR7N;<!G=M=!;TJ=MY=SH!

/;G=Y=M\!N7!GRJ!;TJ=MY=S!78R7!L;TNO=!:M=LNKL!J=MYNI=J!d:M=LNKL!MR7=!J=MYNI=Jf!G=M=!ROJ;!8NV8ONV87=S!RJ!R!S;LN<R<7!

I;L:ORN<7!RM=R!N<!78=!L;TNO=!:M=LNKL!J=MYNI=!LRMU=7!78R7!I;KOS!T=!78=!JKTk=I7!;Q!QK7KM=!M=J=RMI8H!

!

DW!877:>^^GGGH;QI;LH;MVHKU^M=J=RMI8^7I=^I=PF^M=J=RMI8PFH:SQ!

Page 34: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$9 .

*NM=O=JJ!%=MYNI=!";L:ORN<7!1<ROZJNJ!

]!"".%!2R7R!R<S!&J=M!%KMY=Z!

1J!:RM7!;Q!78=!J7KSZ\!M=J=RMI8!GRJ!:=MQ;ML=S!7;!S=7=MLN<=!78=!MR<V=!R<S!=X7=<7!;Q!JR7NJQRI7N;<!M=OR7=S!7;!U=Z!GNM=O=JJ!

:OR<J!RYRNORTO=!7;!78=!"R<RSNR<!I;<JKL=MH!1<!=<SBKJ=M!JKMY=Z!GRJ!S=Y=O;:=S!7;!S=7=MLN<=!RM=RJ!;Q!I;<I=M<!R<S!

K<S=MOZN<V!NJJK=J!GN78!78NJ!:;:KORM!I;<JKL=M!J=MYNI=\!TK7!8NJ7;MNIRO!I;L:ORN<7!SR7R!GRJ!ROJ;!;T7RN<=S!R<S!IR7=V;MNb=S!

QM;L!78=!";LLNJJN;<=M!Q;M!";L:ORN<7J!Q;M!.=O=I;LLK<NIR7N;<J!%=MYNI=H!

DD@6&D5F40',(-&S('0A%,%&

.8=!";LLNJJN;<=M!Q;M!";L:ORN<7J!Q;M!.=O=I;LLK<NIR7N;<J!%=MYNI=!GRJ!R!7RMV=7=S!M=J;KMI=!Q;M!R<ROZJNJ!;Q!I;<JKL=M!

I;L:ORN<7J!SK=!7;!78=NM!LR<SR7=!7;!M=J;OY=!GNM=O=JJ!I;L:ORN<7JH!!.8=!";<JKL=MJ!";K<INO!;Q!"R<RSR!8RJ!:M=YN;KJOZ!

M=I;LL=<S=S!"".%!RJ!R!I;L:ORN<7!I8R<<=O!Q;M!I;<JKL=MJ\!R<S!78=!"*.1!*NM=O=JJ!";S=!;Q!";<SKI7!M=LN<SJ!I;<JKL=MJ!

78R7!"".%!GNOO!M=YN=G!I;L:ORN<7J!RT;K7!QRNOKM=!TZ!:M;YNS=MJ!7;!M=J:=I7!N7J!:M;YNJN;<JH!!

"".%!:M;YNS=S!M=J=RMI8=MJ!GN78!S=7RNO=S!SR7R!QM;L!@\P[?!I;L:ORN<7J!N7!M=YN=G=S!SKMN<V!N7J!EPPF!4NJIRO!e=RM!d_KOZ!D@\!

EPPC!]!1KVH!@\!EPPFfH!!.8=!LRk;MN7Z!;Q!78=!GNM=O=JJ!I;L:ORN<7J!7;!78=!";LLNJJN;<!G=M=!N<!78=!RM=R!;Q!0NOON<V\!G8NI8!NJ!

gKN7=!TM;RS\!J;!78=!I;L:ORN<7J!G=M=!JKTBIR7=V;MNb=S!RJ!J8;G<!N<!4NVKM=!EH@H!!.8=J=!IR7=V;MN=J!G=M=!J=O=I7=S!TZ!78=!

M=J=RMI8=MJ!d"".%!S;=J!<;7!IKMM=<7OZ!IR7=V;MNb=!7;!78NJ!S=7RNO!O=Y=Of\!R<S!=RI8!I;L:ORN<7!GRJ!M=YN=G=S!N<SNYNSKROOZ!R<S!

RJJ;INR7=S!7;!R!IR7=V;MZ!TRJ=S!;<!78=!U=Z!I;L:ORN<7!RM=R!d;Q7=<!L;M=!78R<!;<=!I;L:ORN<7fH!!

Page 35: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$9 7

9,:;2.&?=<&&&DD@6&*,2.0.%%&D5F40',(-%&T&6;FF'2,a.)&

*,2.0.%%&D5F40',(-%K&&(b<J[VG

.8=!:M=:RNS!I;L:ORN<7J!IR7=V;MZ!GRJ!QKM78=M!TM;U=<!S;G<!N<7;!78=!Q;OO;GN<V!IR7=V;MN=J>!

8<`$

!"`$

"`$

!`$

9`$

!;`$

;`$

7`$ !!`$

=-%$)$&&'8">?)6-2:&'86:$#"%-@$.'

L4004'($O,,&,G$

]&'+,3?+$1),E4'3a&'$C4G[F+)G$

1)P+$5)GG3(4'($]>3,()G$

\??)GG$/))G$

/3F0+D$b3,IZ3,)$

]FG+&E),$*),S4?)$

54G?)003')&FG$

=,)[34I$

1),EG$c$]&'I4a&'G$

Page 36: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$9 :

9,:;2.&?=?&&&DD@6&*,2.0.%%&32.4',)&D5F40',(-%&T&6;FF'2,a.)&

32.4',)&D5F40',(-%K&&(bME

D5F40',(-&6;1/8'-.:52,a'-,5(&!.-+5)505:A&

.8=!:MNLRMZ!L=78;S!Q;M!ROO;IR7N<V!78=!GNM=O=JJ!I;L:ORN<7J!GRJ!TZ!7Z:=H!5;J7:RNS!I;L:ORN<7J!G=M=!J=VM=VR7=S!QM;L!

:M=:RNS!I;L:ORN<7J!R<S!R<ROZJNJ!GRJ!IRMMN=S!;K7!N<S=:=<S=<7OZ!Q;M!=RI8!LRN<!JKTBIR7=V;MZ!]!78=J=!IR7=V;MN=J!RVRN<!

J=O=I7=S!TZ!78=!M=J=RMI8=MJH!!

#Q!R!JRL:O=!;Q!@\P[?!GNM=O=JJ!I;L:ORN<7J\!;<OZ!W!:=M!I=<7!dM;KV8OZ!WD!I;L:ORN<7Jf!:=M7RN<=S!7;!:M=:RNS!KJ=MJ!78R7!

=X:=MN=<I=S!J=MYNI=!SNQQNIKO7ZH!+=Z!NJJK=J!G=M=!IR7=V;MNb=S!RJ!Q;OO;GJ>!

• 0ROR<I=!"O=RMN<V!^!(X:NMZ!

o ";L:ORN<7J!M=OR7=S!7;!JNV<NQNIR<7!S;OORM!TROR<I=J!RIIKLKOR7=S!N<!R<!RII;K<7\!TK7!lIO=RM=Sc!G8=<!R!JKTB

JIMNT=M!SNS!<;7!RSS!L;M=!QK<SJ!GN78N<!S=QN<=S!7NL=QMRL=!

• 0NOON<V!(MM;MJ!!

o ";L:ORN<7J!M=VRMSN<V!KJRV=!T=Z;<S!=X:=I7R7N;<J\!QK<SJ!<;7!I;MM=I7OZ!RSS=S\!S=RI7NYR7N;<!;Q!L;<78OZ!

7;:BK:!<;7!I;L:O=7=!

• .=X7!'=JJRVN<V!"8RMV=J! !

o ";L:ORN<7J!M=OR7=S!7;!78=!N<7M;SKI7N;<!;Q!N<I;LN<V!7=X7!L=JJRV=!I8RMV=JH!!';J7!NJJK=J!M=OR7=S!7;!l:M=B

LNKLc!7=X7!L=JJRV=J!

• "ROO!2=7RNO!)=I;MS!

o ";L:ORN<7J!M=OR7=S!7;!78=!JKTJIMNT=M!<;7!T=N<V!RTO=!7;!Y=MNQZ!;M!M=YN=G!KJRV=!I;L:RM=S!7;!TNOON<V!

o #5-.>!!'R<Z!*%5J!<;G!ROO;G!JKTJIMNT=MJ!7;!M=YN=G!78=NM!KJRV=!;<ON<=\!G8NI8!J8;KOS!S=RO!GN78!78NJ!

I;L:ORN<7!RM=R!=QQ=I7NY=OZH!

• 4==J!Q;M!"KJ7;L=M!%=MYNI=!;M!1SLN<^.=MLJ!R<S!";<SN7N;<J!

o ";L:ORN<7J!M=OR7=S!7;!K<=X:=I7=S!Q==J!7;!KJ=!R!IKJ7;L=M!J=MYNI=!IROO!I=<7M=!RV=<7\!L;<78OZ!RSLN<!Q==J!

;M!;78=M!RJJ=JJ=S!Q==!

8"`$

87`$

<`$

;`$

7`$

;`$

;`$!8`$

A%$?6-.'=-%$)$&&'8">?)6-2:&''

L303'?)$]0)3,4'($X$OP[4,D$

L4004'($O,,&,$

]300$C)+340$@)?&,I$

/))G$H&,$]FG+$*S?$&,$\IE4'$

Y&$,)HF'I$&'$)P+,3$[3DE)'+$

*Z4+?>)I$+&$]&'+,3?+$

1),EG$3'I$]&'I4a&'G$

1)P+$5)GG3()$]>3,()G$

Page 37: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$9 ;

o &<=X:=I7=S!I8RMV=J!<;7!K<S=MJ7;;S!N<!78=!.=MLJ!R<S!";<SN7N;<J!

o .=MLJ!`!";<SN7N;<J!<;7!RYRNORTO=!7;!M=YN=G!N<!R!SNJ:K7=!

DD@6&32.4',)&D5F40',(-&6;FF'2A&

.8=!7;:!NJJK=!=L=MVN<V!QM;L!"".%!I;L:ORN<7!SR7R!M=OR7=J!7;!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!TROR<I=!IO=RMN<V^=X:NMZ!;Q!LN<K7=JH!!,<!

J=Y=MRO!IRJ=J\!I;<JKL=MJ!8RS!8K<SM=SJ!;Q!S;OORMJ!;Q!TROR<I=!N<!78=NM!RII;K<7\!;<OZ!7;!O;J=!78NJ!YROK=!T=IRKJ=!78=Z!SNS!<;7!

RSS!L;M=!7;!78=NM!RII;K<7!]!=N78=M!T=IRKJ=!;Q!78=!7NL=QMRL=!M=gKNM=S!7;!RSS!L;M=!LN<K7=J!;M!78=!I;<JKL=M!<;7!<==SN<V!

L;M=!YROK=\!TK7!K<RGRM=!;Q!78=!I;<J=gK=<I=JH!

DD@6&35%-4',)&D5F40',(-%&

.8=!M=LRN<N<V!@\PE@!S=RO7!GN78!YRMN;KJ!:;J7:RNS!NJJK=J!78R7!G=M=!IR7=V;MNb=S!TZ!78=!"".%!RJ!!l*NM=O=JJHc!!

,<!;MS=M!7;!T=77=M!IORJJNQZ!78=!78MKJ7!;Q!=RI8!I;L:ORN<7\!78=!Q;OO;GN<V!KLTM=OOR!IR7=V;MN=J!G=M=!IM=R7=S!Q;M!I;L:ORN<7!

ROO;IR7N;<>!

• 0NOON<V!(MM;MJ!!

o ";L:ORN<7J! M=VRMSN<V! =XI=JJNY=! GNM=O=JJ! TNOOJ! SK=! 7;! =X7MR! I8RMV=J! JKI8! RJ! M;RLN<V\! O;<V! SNJ7R<I=!

I8RMV=J\!SR7R!M;RLN<V\!,<7=M<=7!TM;GJN<V!

o ";L:ORN<7J!M=VRMSN<V!78=!M=I=N:7!;Q!N<I;MM=I7!TNOOJ!M=VRMSO=JJ!;Q!RL;K<7!

• ";<7MRI7!.=MLN<R7N;<!"8RMV=J!

o ";L:ORN<7J!M=VRMSN<V!=XI=JJNY=!I8RMV=J!N<IKMM=S!RJ!R!M=JKO7!;Q!=RMOZ!7=MLN<R7N;<!

o ";L:ORN<7J!M=VRMSN<V!I8RMV=J!N<IKMM=S!K:;<!7=MLN<R7N;<!S=J:N7=!78=!<R7KMRO!=X:NMR7N;<!;Q!R!I;<7MRI7!

o ";L:ORN<7J!M=VRMSN<V! 78=!DPBSRZ!IR<I=OOR7N;<!<;7NI=!R<S!JKTJ=gK=<7!TNOON<V!G8NI8!GRJ! N<IKMM=S!RJ!R!

M=JKO7!;Q!78NJ!:;ONIZ!

• "KJ7;L=M!%=MYNI=!

o ";L:ORN<7J!M=VRMSN<V!78=!:;;M!gKRON7Z!;Q!IKJ7;L=M!J=MYNI=!

o ";L:ORN<7J!M=VRMSN<V!78=!:;;M!7MRN<N<V!;Q!IKJ7;L=M!J=MYNI=!M=:M=J=<7R7NY=J!R<S!78=NM!N<RTNON7Z!7;!SNJB

J=LN<R7=!I;<JNJ7=<7!N<Q;MLR7N;<!7;!78=!I;<JKL=M!

• .=MLJ!`!";<SN7N;<J!

o ";L:ORN<7J! M=VRMSN<V! I8R<V=J! 7;! 78=! 7=MLJ! R<S! I;<SN7N;<J! ;Q! I;<7MRI7J\! L;M=! J:=INQNIROOZ! 78;J=!

I8R<V=J!G8NI8!N<IM=RJ=S!78=!:MNI=!;Q!:OR<J!;M!M=L;Y=S!Q=R7KM=J!QM;L!:OR<J!

o ";L:ORN<7J!M=VRMSN<V!78=!V=<=MRO!:MRI7NI=!;Q!IRMMN=MJ!LRUN<V!K<NOR7=MRO!I8R<V=J!7;!:OR<J^I;<7MRI7J!R<S!

J7NOO!8;OS!I;<JKL=MJ!ONRTO=!Q;M!78=!SKMR7N;<!;Q!78=NM!=XNJ7N<V!I;<7MRI7!

• .=X7!'=JJRVN<V!"8RMV=J!

o ";L:ORN<7J!M=VRMSN<V!O;<V!SNJ7R<I=!7=X7!L=JJRVN<V!I8RMV=J!

o ";L:ORN<7J!M=VRMSN<V!=XI=JJNY=!:M=LNKL!7=X7!L=JJRVN<V!I8RMV=J!

• 1II=JJ!4==J!

o ";L:ORN<7J!M=VRMSN<V!78=!=XNJ7=<I=!R<S!=<Q;MI=L=<7!;Q!RII=JJ!Q==J!;<!L;<78OZ!TNOON<V!

• 4RKO7Z!/RMSGRM=!

o ";L:ORN<7J!M=VRMSN<V!78=!:M;I=JJ!;Q!M=:RNMN<V!8R<SJ=7J\!M=7KM<N<V!QRKO7Z!8R<SJ=7J!

• 'NJI=OOR<=;KJ!

o #<=B;QQ!I;L:ORN<7J!78R7!8RY=!T==<!;K7J7R<SN<V!Q;M!R!JNV<NQNIR<7!7NL=!:=MN;S!R<S!RM=!I;L:O=X!N<!<R7KM=!

#Q!78=!7;7RO!:;J7:RNS!I;L:ORN<7J!R<ROZb=S\![W!:=M!I=<7!QROO!N<7;!Q;KM!LRk;M!RM=RJ!;Q!I;<JKL=M!QMKJ7MR7N;<>!

@H 0NOON<V!(MM;MJ!dEC!:=M!I=<7f!

EH ";<7MRI7!.=MLN<R7N;<!2NJ:K7=J!d@F!:=M!I=<7f!

DH "KJ7;L=M!%=MYNI=!d@[!:=M!I=<7f!

?H .=MLJ!`!";<SN7N;<J!d@@!:=M!I=<7f!

0NOON<V!(MM;MJ!NJ!78=!O=RS!RM=R!;Q!I;<JKL=M!I;L:ORN<7J\!GN78!R!F!:=M!I=<7!O=RS!;Y=M!78=!J=I;<S!L;J7!QM=gK=<7!I;L:ORN<7!

M=OR7N<V!7;!";<7MRI7!.=MLN<R7N;<JH!";<JKL=MJ!78R7!SNJ:K7=!TNOON<V!;Q7=<!SNJ:K7=!I8RMV=J!:MNLRMNOZ!SK=!7;!78M==!LRN<!

QRI7;MJ>!!

Page 38: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$9 <

@H .8=!TNOON<V!JZJ7=L!V=<=MR7=S!R<!NJJK=!SK=!7;!N<I;MM=I7!N<Q;MLR7N;<!;<!78=!RII;K<7!

EH .8=!I;<JKL=M!GRJ!K<RGRM=!78R7!8=^J8=!GRJ!N<IKMMN<V!R!TNOON<V!I8RMV=!

DH .8=!IKJ7;L=M!NJ!SNJ:K7N<V!78=!:M;YNJN;<!;Q!78=!J=MYNI=!Q;M!G8NI8!8=^J8=!NJ!T=N<V!TNOO=S!

,<!78=!J=I;<S!L;J7!:;:KORM!RM=R!;Q!SNJ:K7=J\!";<7MRI7!.=MLN<R7N;<!SNJ:K7=J\!LRN<!I;L:ORN<7J!Q=OO!N<7;!78=!T=O;G!NJJK=J>!

@H 0=ON=Q!78R7!78=!=RMOZ!IR<I=OOR7N;<!Q==J!O=YN=S!K:;<!78=NM!RII;K<7!SNS!<;7!I;MM=I7OZ!M=QO=I7!78=!O=Y=O!;Q!J=MYNI=!78R7!

GRJ!M=I=NY=S!QM;L!78=!IRMMN=M!R<S!GRJ!<;7!:M;:;M7N;<R7=!7;!78=!O=<V78!;Q!7NL=!M=LRN<N<V!N<!78=!I;<7MRI7!

EH "8RMV=J!N<I;MM=I7OZ!O=YN=S!Q;M!7=MLN<R7N<V!L;<78BTZBL;<78!RVM==L=<7J!

DH &<QRNM<=JJ!;Q!78=!DPBSRZ!IR<I=OOR7N;<!;Q!J=MYNI=!SKMN<V!G8NI8!78=!IKJ7;L=M!NJ!TNOO=S!

*N78!M=J:=I7!7;!IKJ7;L=M!J=MYNI=!I;L:ORN<7J\!I;<JKL=MJ!G=M=!L;J7OZ!SNJJR7NJQN=S!GN78>!

@H .8=!7;<=!R<S!LR<<=M!N<!G8NI8!78=!IKJ7;L=M!GRJ!RSSM=JJ=S!TZ!78=!IROO!I=<7M=!M=:M=J=<7R7NY=J!!

EH .8=!N<I;<JNJ7=<IZ!;Q! N<Q;MLR7N;<!G8NI8!GRJ!:M;YNS=S!7;!I;<JKL=MJ!TZ!IROO!I=<7M=!R<S!M=7RNO!JRO=J!M=:M=J=<7RB

7NY=J!

DH .8=!<==S!7;!LRU=!LKO7N:O=!IROOJ!7;!78=!IROO!I=<7=M!N<!;MS=M!7;!RSSM=JJ!78=!JRL=!NJJK=!T=Q;M=!RI8N=YN<V!M=J;OK7N;<!

.8=!QN<RO!RM=R!;Q!I;<JKL=M!I;L:ORN<7J!M=OR7=J!7;!:;J7:RNS!I;<7MRI7!7=MLJ!R<S!I;<SN7N;<J\!J:=INQNIROOZ>!!!

@H .8=!RTNON7Z!;Q!78=!IRMMN=M!7;!=<Q;MI=!=XNJ7N<V!I;<7MRI7J!GN78!NL:K<N7Z!S=J:N7=!8RYN<V!I8R<V=S!N7J!7=MLJ!R<S!I;<SNB

7N;<JH!.8NJ! NJJK=!M=Q=MM=S!L;J7OZ! 7;! N<IM=RJ=J! N<!:OR<!:MNI=J!;M! 78=!M=L;YRO!;Q! ! lVMR<SQR78=Mc! Q=R7KM=J!;<!:OR<J!

78R7!78=!IRMMN=M!GRJ!:M=YN;KJOZ!;QQ=MN<VH!";<JKL=MJ!G8;!TM;KV87! Q;M78!78=J=!I;L:ORN<7J! Q=O7! 78R7!R<Z!LR7=MNRO!

I8R<V=J!;Q!78=!J;M7!S=JIMNT=S!RT;Y=!Y;NS=S!78=!YRONSN7Z!;Q!78=!I;<7MRI7H!

EH .8M==!gKRM7=MJ!;Q!I;<JKL=M!I;L:ORN<7J!N<!78NJ!IR7=V;MZ!ROJ;!JRG!R!SNJ:RMN7Z!T=7G==<!78=!J=MYNI=J!T=N<V!RSY=MB

7NJ=S!R<S!78=!RI7KRO!J=MYNI=J!M=I=NY=SH!.8=Z!ROJ;! Q=O7! 78R7! 78NJ!SNJIM=:R<IZ! N<!M=RO!J=MYNI=! O=Y=OJ!Y=MJKJ!J=MYNI=!

O=Y=OJ!:M;LNJ=S!N<!78=!I;<7MRI7!Y;NS=S!78=!RVM==L=<7!

DH );KV8OZ!?P!:=M!I=<7!;Q!I;<JKL=M!I;L:ORN<7J!N<!78NJ!IR7=V;MZ!=X:M=JJ=S!I;<QKJN;<!GN78!78=!RI7KRO!7=MLJ!;Q!78=!

I;<7MRI7!78R7!78=Z!RVM==S!7;!R<S!N7J!L=I8R<NJLJH!4;M!=XRL:O=\!J;L=!I;<JKL=MJ!SNS!<;7!J==!78=!ON<U!T=7G==<!RIB

I=:7N<V!R!8RMSGRM=!K:VMRS=!R<S!=X7=<SN<V!78=!7=MLJ!;Q!78=NM!I;<7MRI7J!Q;M!R<!RSSN7N;<RO!78M==!Z=RMJH!%NLNORMOZ!

I;<JKL=MJ!=X:M=JJ=S! QMKJ7MR7N;<!GN78!78=! N<RTNON7Z!;Q! 78=!IRMMN=M! 7;!:M;YNS=\!K:;<!78=NM!M=gK=J7\!R!JNV<=S!I;<B

7MRI7H!

!

*N78!M=J:=I7!7;!.=X7!'=JJRVN<V!R<S!1II=JJ!4==J\!G8NI8!8RY=!T==<!8NV8ONV87=S!N<!:M=YN;KJ!J=I7N;<J\!78=!Q;OO;GN<V!

I;<IOKJN;<J!=L=MV=!QM;L!78=!I;L:ORN<7J!M=J=RMI8>!

;#<-,=#55!%*+%,>?,(#$,4#+-@,.8=! YRJ7!LRk;MN7Z! ;Q! 7=X7BL=JJRVN<V! I;L:ORN<7J! RM=! SK=! 7;! 78=! M=I=N:7! R<S! TNOON<V! ;Q! :M=LNKL! 7=X7!L=JJRV=J!

G8NI8! 78=!IKJ7;L=M!S=<N=J! JNV<N<V!K:! Q;M!;M!G8NI8! 78=!IKJ7;L=M!8RJ! 7MN=S!K<JKII=JJQKOOZ! 7;! J7;:H!";L:ORN<7J!

MR<V=!:MNLRMNOZ!QM;L!SNJJR7NJQRI7N;<!GN78!N<I;MM=I7!TNOON<V!TK7!ROJ;!GN78!78=!QRI7!78R7!IRMMN=MJ!S==L!78NJ!7;!T=!R<!

NJJK=!G8NI8!78=!IKJ7;L=M!LKJ7!M=J;OY=!N<S=:=<S=<7OZ!GN78!78=!:M=LNKL!7=X7!L=JJRV=!G=TJN7=H!

A44#55,B##5,>C,(#$,4#+-@,

*N78!kKJ7!K<S=M!@!:=M!I=<7!;Q!ROO!I;L:ORN<7J\!G=!IR<!JRQ=OZ!I;<IOKS=!78R7!:M=YN;KJ!NJJK=J!G8NI8!I;<JKL=MJ!8RS!

GN78!78=!O=YZN<V!;Q!78=!%ZJ7=L!1II=JJ!4==!K:;<!78=NM!RII;K<7!8RJ!<;G!T==<!M=J;OY=S!TZ!78=!RI7N;<J!G8NI8!IRMMNB

=MJ!8RY=!NL:O=L=<7=S!GN78N<!78=!:RJ7!Z=RMH!!

D5F40',(-%&S('0A%,%&6;FF'2A&

.8M==!LRN<!;TJ=MYR7N;<J!IR<!T=!SMRG<!QM;L!78=!I;L:ORN<7!SR7R!R<ROZJNJ!RT;Y=H!!

@H .8=!LRk;MN7Z!;Q!ROO!I;L:ORN<7J!7;!78=!"".%!J7=L!QM;L!78=!LNJI;LLK<NIR7N;<!;Q!N<Q;MLR7N;<!T=7G==<!78=!IRMMN=M!

R<S!78=!IKJ7;L=M!M=VRMSN<V!I;<7MRI7!7=MLJ\!78=!:M;YNJN;<!;Q!J=MYNI=J!R<S!TNOON<V!I;L:O=XN7ZH!!!

Page 39: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$9 "

EH "KJ7;L=MJ!G=M=!K<IO=RM!RT;K7!8;G!=RMOZ!I;<7MRI7!7=MLN<R7N;<!Q==J!G=M=!IROIKOR7=S\!R<S!I;KOS!<;7!J==!R<Z!ON<U!

T=7G==<!:OR<!7G=RUJ^8RMSGRM=!K:VMRS=J!R<S!R<!NL:ONIN7!RVM==L=<7!7;!M=<=G^=X7=<S!I;<7MRI7!O=<V78H!!

DH "KJ7;L=MJc!V=<=MRO!=X:=I7R7N;<!NJ!78R7!78=NM!IRMMN=M!:M;YNS=J!78=!RVM==SB7;!O=Y=O!;Q!J=MYNI=!R<S!:M;LNJ=S!O=Y=O!;Q!

IKJ7;L=M!IRM=!N<!M=7KM<!Q;M!IKJ7;L=M!I;L:ONR<I=!R<S!RS=gKR7=!:RZL=<7JH!!"KJ7;L=MJ!S;!$#.!=X:=I7!IRMMN=MJ!7;!

I8R<V=!J=MYNI=!RVM==L=<7J!;Y=M!78=!SKMR7N;<!;Q! 78=!I;<7MRI7H! !4KM78=M\! N<!78=!IRJ=!;Q!I;<7MRI7!7=MLN<R7N;<\! 78=!

IKJ7;L=M!=X:=I7J!7;!T=!:=<RONb=S!GN78!=RMOZ!7=MLN<R7N;<!Q==J!;<OZ!N<!78=!IRJ=!G8=M=!78=!7=MLN<R7N;<!8RJ!T==<!

N<N7NR7=S!TZ!78=!IKJ7;L=M\!R<S!$#.!78=!IRMMN=MH!!

?H .8=M=!NJ!R!SNJIM=:R<IZ!T=7G==<!78=!RL;K<7!IRMMN=MJ!I8RMV=!Q;M!I;<7MRI7!IR<I=OOR7N;<!Q==J!R<S!78=!RL;K<7!78R7!

78=!I;<JKL=M!Q==OJ!NJ!QRNM!7;!:RZ!VNY=<!gKRON7Z!;Q!J=MYNI=!O=Y=OJ!R<S!M=LRN<N<V!I;<7MRI7!SKMR7N;<H!

D5(%;F.2&6;27.A&T&32.4',)&'()&35%-4',)&30'(%&

!.-+5)505:A&

,<!;MS=M!7;!I;L:O=L=<7!;KM!I;<JKL=M!I;L:ORN<7!R<ROZJNJ!GN78!:=MJ:=I7NY=J!;Q!78=!O=JJ!Y;IRO!L;TNO=!:8;<=!KJ=MJ\!R!

<;LN<RO!JKMY=Z!;Q!EWP!"R<RSNR<J!GRJ!I;<SKI7=S!7;!RJU!RT;K7!78=NM!S=VM==!;Q!JR7NJQRI7N;<!GN78!L;TNO=!:8;<=!J=MYNI=JH!!

%KMY=Z!gK=J7N;<J!G=M=!S=Y=O;:=S!7;!=X:R<S!K:;<!RM=RJ!;Q!I;<I=M<!NS=<7NQN=S!78M;KV8!:M=ONLN<RMZ!M=J=RMI8!R<S!Q;MKLJH!

EPF!I=OO!:8;<=!J=MYNI=!IKJ7;L=MJ!QM;L!#<7RMN;\!aK=T=I\!(RJ7=M<!"R<RSR!R<S!*=J7=M<!"R<RSR!M=J:;<S=S!=N78=M!N<B:=MJ;<!!

dA@!M=J:;<S=<7Jf!;M!;<ON<=!d@?C!M=J:;<S=<7JfH!!.8=!JRL:O=!;Q!M=J:;<S=<7J!GRJ!;T7RN<=S!78M;KV8!R<!N<YN7R7N;<!7;!78=!

JKMY=Z!YNR!M=J=RMI8=McJ!I;<7RI7!ONJ7J!d=X7=<JNY=!TKJN<=JJ\!:=MJ;<RO!R<S!M=J=RMI8!ONJ7Jf!R<S!:;J7N<VJ!;<!/;GRMS!4;MKLJ!

R<S!4RI=T;;U!dM=J=RMI8=MJc!:=MJ;<RO!:RV=J!R<S!$=7G;MU!;Q!e;K<V!";<JKL=MJfH!!,7!J8;KOS!T=!<;7=S!8=M=!78R7!78=J=!

J;KMI=J!;Q!N<:K7J!G=M=!ONU=OZ!7;!V=<=MR7=!N<:K7!QM;L!N<SNYNSKROJ!L;M=!U<;GO=SV=RTO=!78R<!<;MLRO!M=VRMSN<V!78=!GNM=O=JJ!

J=VL=<7!R<S!78R7!78=!J;KMI=!;Q!78=!M=J:;<S=<7!GRJ!<;7!7MRIU=SH!!.8=!mO=JJ!Y;IROn!JRL:O=!GRJ!;T7RN<=S!MR<S;LOZ!78M;KV8!

SNM=I7!R::M;RI8!JKMY=ZJ!I;<SKI7=S!N<!TKJN<=JJ!I=<7=MJ\!M=J7RKMR<7J\!JI8;;OJ!R<S!LRMU=7:ORI=J!dLROO!R<S!;K7S;;MJfH!!

/;G=Y=M\!JKMY=Z!gK=J7N;<J!G=M=!NS=<7NIRO!N<!T;78!L=78;SJH!

%KMY=Z!S=L;VMR:8NI!S=7RNOJ!RM=!J8;G<!N<!1::=<SNX!"H!!.8=!V=;VMR:8NI!J:M=RS!;Q!78=!JKMY=Z!GRJ!TNRJ=S!7;GRMS!#<7RMN;!

R<S!(RJ7=M<!"R<RSR\!JN<I=!78=!;<=B;<B;<=!JKMY=ZJ!G=M=!I;L:O=7=S!N<!78=J=!M=VN;<JH!!.8=!JKMY=Z!ROJ;!M=JKO7=S!N<!RV=!R<S!

N<I;L=!O=Y=OJ!TNRJ=S!7;!78=!Z;K<V=M\!O;G=M!N<I;L=!O=Y=OJ!SK=!7;!78=!I8R<<=OJ!J=O=I7=SH!!/;G=Y=M\!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!

IKJ7;L=MJ!RM=!V=<=MROOZ!L;M=!I;LL;<!N<!78NJ!S=L;VMR:8NI!R<S!78=J=!N<:K7J!G=M=!J:=INQNIROOZ!S=JNM=SH!

!

#Q!78=!EPF!M=J:;<S=<7J\!?F!G=M=!:M=:RNS!IKJ7;L=MJH!

2=:=<SN<V!;<!G8=78=M!78=!M=J:;<S=<7!GRJ!R!:M=:RNS!;M!:;J7:RNS!IKJ7;L=M\!78=!JKMY=Z!R77=L:7=S!7;!S=7=MLN<=!78=!O=Y=O!

;Q!IKJ7;L=M!JR7NJQRI7N;<!:M=S;LN<R<7OZ!78M;KV8!78=!NJJK=J!;Q!K<QRNM!Q==J!R<S!K<IO=RM!KJRV=!:;ONIN=J!;M!N<I;MM=I7!TNOON<V!

R<S!M=J;OK7N;<^IKJ7;L=M!J=MYNI=!gKRON7ZH!

Page 40: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$. #

.;!=<JKM=!78=!JKMY=Z!gK=J7N;<J!G=M=!IO=RM!7;!:;7=<7NRO!M=J:;<S=<7J\!JKMY=Z!SMRQ7J!G=M=!:RJJ=S!;K7!7;!l7MNROc!M=J:;<S=<7J!R!

7;7RO!;Q!Q;KM!7NL=J!N<!;MS=M!7;!V=7!SNM=I7!R<S!NLL=SNR7=!Q==STRIU!R<S!RSkKJ7!78=!JKMY=Z!RJ!R::M;:MNR7=H!

6;27.A&6;FF'2A&

.8=!RNL!;Q!78=!JKMY=Z!GRJ!7G;Q;OS>!!.8=!JKMY=Z!GRJ!LRN<OZ!RNL=S!R7!:M=:RNS!KJ=MJ!SK=!7;!78=!QRI7!78R7!78=!"".%!

I;L:ORN<7J!SR7RTRJ=!8=OS!ONLN7=S!N<Q;MLR7N;<!M=VRMSN<V!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!I;L:ORN<7JH!.8=!JKMY=Z!GRJ!ROJ;!RNL=S!R7!

:;J7:RNS!KJ=MJ!7;!VRN<!L;M=!S=7RNOJ!;<!J;L=!;Q!78=!TNOON<V!NJJK=J!78R7!RM;J=!QM;L!78=!I;L:ORN<7J!R<ROZJNJH!

1!J=MN=J!;Q!gK=J7N;<J!RJU=S!;Q!JKMY=Z!M=J:;<S=<7J!Q;M!T;78!:M=:RNS!R<S!:;J7:RNS!M=J:;<S=<7J!RM=!JKLLRMNb=S!T=O;GH!

*8R7!UN<S!;Q!GNM=O=JJ!:OR<!S;!Z;K!KJ=j!

!

.8NJ!gK=J7N;<!RJU=S!M=J:;<S=<7J!7;!NS=<7NQZ!78=!7Z:=!;Q!GNM=O=JJ!:OR<!78R7!78=Z!G=M=!KJN<VH!.8=!gK=J7N;<!GRJ!L=R<7!7;!

S=7=MLN<=!G8=78=M!M=J:;<S=<7J!G=M=!;<!:;J7:RNS!;M!:M=:RNS!:OR<JH!.8=![ABE?!:=M!I=<7!M=J:;<J=!J:ON7!RIIKMR7=OZ!M=QO=I7J!

78=!7MK=!I;<SN7N;<J!;Q!78=!:;J7:RNS^:M=:RNS!LRMU=7!J:ON7!N<!"R<RSR!dG8NI8!NJ!IO;J=M!7;!CP!:=M!I=<7!B!EP!:=M!I=<7f!RJ!G=OO!RJ!

78=!LRN<!:KM:;J=!;Q!78=!JKMY=Z\!G8NI8!GRJ!7;!RJI=M7RN<!NJJK=J!78R7!:M=:RNS!IKJ7;L=MJ!8RY=!GN78!78=NM!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=H!!

Page 41: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$. !

5M=:RNS!*NM=O=JJ!%KMY=Z!%KLLRMZ!

1!J=MN=J!;Q!gK=J7N;<J!G=M=!RJU=S!;Q!78=!JKMY=Z!M=J:;<S=<7J!]!R!I;L:O=7=!JKLLRMZ!;Q!78=!JKMY=Z!M=J:;<J=J!RM=!J8;G<!N<!

1::=<SNX!"H!!+=Z!N<Q;MLR7N;<!QM;L!78NJ!JKMY=Z!NJ!J8;G<!T=O;GH!!

*8Z!5M=:RNSj!

#Y=MG8=OLN<VOZ\!FC!:=M!I=<7!;Q!KJ=MJ!;Q!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!I8;;J=!:M=:RNS!J=MYNI=!7;!I;<7M;O!;M!LN<NLNb=!

78=!I;J7!;Q!78=NM!GNM=O=JJ!KJRV=H!

5M=:RNS!,JJK=J!

';M=!78R<!WP!:=M!I=<7!;Q!78;J=!JKMY=Z=S!8RS!R!I;<I=M<!GN78!78=!=X:NMR7N;<!:;ONIZ!G8NO=!ROL;J7!@F!:=M!I=<7!T=B

ON=Y=!78R7!78=M=!RM=!8NSS=<!Q==JH! ! ,<7=M=J7N<VOZ\!L;J7!:M=:RNS!:OR<J!8RS!J;L=!7Z:=!;Q! Q==!RJJ;INR7=S!G8NI8!GRJ!

<;7!SNJIO;J=S!;<!78=!:KMI8RJ=S!IRMSH!

!

&JRV=!7=MLJ!IO=RMj!

[F!:=M!I=<7!;Q!:M=:RNS!M=J:;<S=<7J!IORNL=S!78R7!78=Z!K<S=MJ7;;S!78=!I;J7^LN<K7=!Q;M!KJRV=!;Q!78=NM!J=MYNI=H!

!

(X:NMZ!

';M=!78R<!AP!:=M!I=<7!;Q!:M=:RNS!M=J:;<S=<7J!:KMI8RJ=!DPBSRZ!=X:NMZ!:OR<J\!TK7!L;J7!;Q!78;J=!:OR<J!RM=!7;::=S!

K:!;M!RK7;BM=I8RMV=S!7;!ROO;G!Q;M!R!M;OO;Y=M!7;!78=!<=X7!L;<78H!!1OL;J7!EC!:=M!I=<7!;Q!78NJ!JKMY=Z!VM;K:!=X:=MNB

=<I=S!R!O;JJ!;Q!78=NM!:M=:RNS!YROK=!L;<78OZ\!G8NO=!ROL;J7!@W!:=M!I=<7!S;!<;7!U<;G!G8R7!8R::=<J!7;!78=NM!TROR<I=!

R7!L;<78B=<SH!

Page 42: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$. 8

(X7MR!4==J!

';J7!:M=:RNS!JKTJIMNT=MJ!Q=O7! QKOOZ! N<Q;ML=S!;Q!78=!RSSN7N;<RO! Q==J!I8RMV=S!7;!78=L!;<!R!L;<78OZ!TRJNJ\!TK7!R<!

ROL;J7!=gKRO!RL;K<7!;Q!KJ=MJ!S;!<;7!U<;G!NQ!78=M=!RM=!=X7MR!;M!!l8NSS=<c!Q==JH!!,<7=M=J7N<VOZ\!W[!:=M!I=<7!;Q!:M=B

:RNS!KJ=MJ!IORNL!78=Z!RM=!T=N<V!I8RMV=S!R!L;<78OZ!1II=JJ!4==\!G8=<\!N<!QRI7\!78=M=!NJ!<;!1II=JJ!4==!Q;M!:M=:RNS!

J=MYNI=!]!;<OZ!:;J7:RNSH!!/;G=Y=M\!I;LL;<!(F@@!Q==J!G=M=!L=<7N;<=S!TZ!EF!:=M!I=<7!;Q!M=J:;<S=<7JH!

Page 43: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$. 9

5;J7:RNS!*NM=O=JJ!%KMY=Z!%KLLRMZ!

.8=!M=JKO7J!;Q!78=!JKMY=Z!7RMV=7=S!R7!:;J7:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!IKJ7;L=MJ!N<SNIR7=S!78R7>!

• .8=!4&+"#+*#+4#!QRI7;M!]!78=!=X:=I7R7N;<!;Q!b=M;!J=MYNI=!SNJMK:7N;<!SKMN<V!=RI8!TNOON<V!IZIO=!]!GRJ!78=!L;J7!IN7=S!M=RJ;<!RL;<V!M=J:;<S=<7J!Q;M!I8;;JN<V!:;J7:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!;Y=M!:M=:RNS!R7!D@!:=M!I=<7\!T=R7N<V!;K7!($#6'*4-!/0#,/*005!R<S!4&5-,.*+*.*D!-*&+\!T;78!R7!ED!:=M!I=<7!

• E#"*4#,51/5*'8F5#0#4-*&+!8RS!ON77O=!N<QOK=<I=!RL;<V!;KM!M=J:;<S=<7Jc!S=INJN;<!T=7G==<!:;J7:RNS!R<S!:M=:RNS!J=MYNI=!R7![!:=M!I=<7!

*N78! M=J:=I7! 7;!TNOON<V! NJJK=J\! W[!:=M! I=<7! ;Q! :;J7:RNS! M=J:;<S=<7J! JRNS! 78=Z! IO;J=OZ! N<J:=I7! 78=NM! TNOOJ!L;<78OZ!

G8NO=!DA!:=M!I=<7!JRNS!78R7!78=Z!;<OZ!N<J:=I7!78=NM!TNOOJ!G8=<!78=Z!RM=!<;7NI=RTOZ!8NV8=MH!!!

*8=<!RJU=S!RT;K7!<;7NI=RTO=!SNJIM=:R<IN=J!;<!78=NM!L;<78OZ!TNOO!;Y=M!78=!:RJ7!Z=RM\!?W!:=M!I=<7!;Q!M=J:;<S=<7J!

JRNS!78=Z!<;7NI=S!@BD\!G8NO=!ROL;J7!=gKROOZ\!R7!?D!:=M!I=<7\!b=M;!TNOON<V!=MM;MJ!G=M=!<;7NI=SH!!,7!NJ!K<IO=RM!G8=78=M!

78=J=!M=J:;<J=J!JKVV=J7!78R7!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=MJ!RM=!LRUN<V!Y=MZ!Q=G!TNOON<V!=MM;MJ\!;M!78R7!IKJ7;L=MJ!RM=!

<;7!JKII=JJQKOOZ!<;7NIN<V!=MM;MJ!78R7!RM=!RI7KROOZ!T=N<V!LRS=H!!!

!

*N78!M=J:=I7!7;!M=J;OK7N;<!;Q!78=J=!<;7NI=S!=MM;MJ\!?[!:=M!I=<7!;Q!JKMY=Z!M=J:;<S=<7J! N<SNIR7=S!78R7!78=NM!TNOON<V!

=MM;MJ!G=M=!M=J;OY=S!GN78N<!;<=!TNOON<V!IZIO=\!@A!:=M!I=<7!GN78N<!7G;!TNOON<V!IZIO=J\!R<S!@E!:=M!I=<7!G=M=!;<V;N<V!

;M!K<M=J;OY=SH!!E?!:=M!I=<7!J7R7=S!78R7!78=Z!SNS!<;7!M=:;M7!78=NM!TNOON<V!SNJIM=:R<IN=J!7;!78=!IRMMN=MH!!!

!

.;! 78=!IKJ7;L=M\! 78=M=! NJ!R!:;JN7NY=!I;MM=OR7N;<!T=7G==<! 78=!J:==S!;Q! M=J;OK7N;<!R<S! 78=!:=MI=NY=S! O=Y=O!;Q! IKJB

7;L=M!IRM=H!!/=<I=\!78=!QRJ7=M!R<!NJJK=!NJ!M=J;OY=S\!78=!T=77=M!78=!gKRON7Z!;Q!IKJ7;L=M!J=MYNI=H!!.8=M=Q;M=\!QM;L!78=!

JKMY=Z!M=JKO7J\!N7!IR<!T=!N<Q=MM=S!78R7!?[!:=M!I=<7!;Q!78;J=!M=J:;<S=<7J!G8;J=!TNOON<V!=MM;MJ!G=M=!M=J;OY=S!GN78N<!

Page 44: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$. .

;<=!TNOON<V!IZIO=!M=I=NY=S!R!M=OR7NY=OZ!8NV8!gKRON7Z!;Q!IKJ7;L=M!IRM=H! !/;G=Y=M\!E?!:=M!I=<7!;Q! 78;J=!78R7!<;7NI=S!

TNOON<V!=MM;MJ!SNS!<;7!M=:;M7!78=L!7;!78=!IRMMN=MH!!!

!

.8NJ! N<7=M:M=7R7N;<! NJ!JK::;M7=S!TZ!78=!M=JKO7!;Q! 78=! Q;OO;GN<V!gK=J7N;<!M=VRMSN<V!;Y=MROO!JR7NJQRI7N;<!d=XIOKSN<V!

S=YNI=f!;Q!:;J7:RNS!J=MYNI=H!!!

!

DA!:=M!I=<7!;Q!JKMY=Z!M=J:;<S=<7J!S=JIMNT=S!78=NM!:;J7:RNS!J=MYNI=!JR7NJQRI7N;<!O=Y=O!RJ!!"#$!%#\!G8NO=!R<!ROL;J7!=gKRO!:=MI=<7RV=!;Q! M=J:;<S=<7J! dDW!:=M!I=<7f!S=JIMNT=S! 78=NM!JR7NJQRI7N;<! O=Y=O!RJ,%&&'H! !@F!:=M!I=<7!S=JIMNT=S!78=NM! :;J7:RNS! JR7NJQRI7N;<! O=Y=O! RJ! #<4#00#+-H! ! ";<Y=MJ=OZ\! @@! :=M! I=<7! M=:;M7=S! 78=NM! :;J7:RNS! J=MYNI=! RJ, (&&$H!.8=M=Q;M=\!N7!IR<!T=!N<Q=MM=S!78R7!L;M=!78R<!8ROQ!;M!L;M=!;Q!JKMY=Z!M=J:;<S=<7J!8RY=!8RS!:;JN7NY=!IRMMN=M!IKJ7;L=M!

J=MYNI=!=X:=MN=<I=JH!!

!

!

@54&]%%;.%&6;FF'2,a.)

9*"7$%1':%*"&"))'K,*B"='!"),&#)'

<= NO4,2'-,5(&350,8A!]!FC!:=M!I=<7!;Q!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!M=J:;<S=<7J!I8;;J=!78NJ!J=MYNI=!;:7N;<!7;!I;<7M;O!;M!LN<NB

LNb=! 78=NM! J=MYNI=! I;J7H! !W[!:=M!I=<7!;Q! 78;J=!8RY=!R! I;<I=M<^NJJK=!GN78! 78=!=X:NMR7N;<!:;ONIZ\! 78=!LRk;MN7Z!;Q!

G8NI8!I8;;J=!R!DPBSRZ!=X:NMZ!:OR<\!RJ!78=J=!:OR<J!RM=!V=<=MROOZ!78=!O;G=J7!L;<78OZ!I8RMV=!R<S!?[!:=M!I=<7!T=B

ON=Y=!78R7!78=!=X:NMR7N;<!:;ONIZ!NJ!K<QRNMH!

?= >,%805%;2.& 5C& 9..%&]! WW! :=M! I=<7! ;Q! :M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ! M=J:;<S=<7J! T=ON=Y=! 78R7! 78=M=! RM=! l8NSS=<c! I8RMV=J! ;M!

S;<c7! U<;G! NQ! 78=J=! I8RMV=J! =XNJ7H! !*8NO=! S=7RNO=S! 7=MLJ! R<S! I;<SN7N;<J! IR<!T=!K<I;Y=M=S!;<! R!*%5!G=TJN7=\!

7Z:NIRO!I;<JKL=MJ!S;!<;7!QKOOZ!K<S=MJ7R<S!78=J=!7=MLJH!

9-)#7$%1':%*"&"))'K,*B"='!"),&#)'

@H L,00,(:&]!W[!:=M!I=<7!;Q!:;J7:RNS!M=J:;<S=<7J!IO;J=OZ!N<J:=I7!78=NM!L;<78OZ!J=MYNI=!TNOOJ\!G8NO=!DA!:=M!I=<7!;<OZ!

N<J:=I7!78=L!NQ!78=Z!RM=!<;7NI=RTOZ!8NV8=MH!!.8NJ!JKVV=J7J!78R7!78=!LRk;MN7Z!;Q!M=J:;<S=<7J!S;!<;7!7MKJ7!78=!RIIKB

MRIZ!;Q!78=NM!IRMMN=McJ!TNOON<V!:MRI7NI=Jo!?W!:=M!I=<7!;Q!78=!M=J:;<S=<7J!JRNS!78R7!@BD!TNOON<V!SNJIM=:R<IN=J!G=M=!

Q;K<S!;<!78=NM!L;<78OZ!J=MYNI=!TNOO!;Y=M!78=!ORJ7!Z=RMH!!!

!

EH D;%-5F.2&6'-,%C'8-,5(&]!5M;XN=S!TZ!78=!J:==S!;Q!M=J;OK7N;<\!N7!IR<!T=!N<Q=MM=S!QM;L!78;J=!?[!:=M!I=<7!;Q!M=J:;<B

S=<7J!G8;J=!TNOON<V!=MM;MJ!G=M=!M=J;OY=S!GN78N<!;<=!TNOON<V!IZIO=!78R7!R!M=OR7NY=OZ!8NV8!gKRON7Z!;Q!IKJ7;L=M!IRM=!

GRJ!=X:=MN=<I=SH! !$;7=>!J:==S!;Q!M=J;OK7N;<!TZ!78=!IRMMN=M! NJ!R!<=VR7NY=!QK<I7N;<!;Q!78=!SNJIM=:R<IZ!RL;K<7! N<!

SNJ:K7=H!

!

"KJ7;L=M! JR7NJQRI7N;<!GRJ! ROJ;!L=RJKM=S! SNM=I7OZ! 78M;KV8! :;J7:RNS! JKMY=Z! gK=J7N;<! @P!G8NI8! RJU=S! M=J:;<B

S=<7J!7;!=YROKR7=!78=NM!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!TZ!I8;;JN<V!;<=!;Q!Q;KM!;:7N;<J>!:;;M\!RY=MRV=\!V;;S!R<S!=XI=OO=<7H! !DA!

:=M!I=<7!;Q! JKMY=Z!M=J:;<S=<7J!S=JIMNT=S! 78=NM!:;J7:RNS!J=MYNI=!JR7NJQRI7N;<! O=Y=O!RJ!!"#$!%#\!G8NO=!R<!ROL;J7!=gKRO!:=MI=<7RV=!;Q!M=J:;<S=<7J!dDW!:=M!I=<7f!S=JIMNT=S!78=NM!JR7NJQRI7N;<!O=Y=O!RJ,%&&'H!!

Page 45: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$. 7

";<QNMLR7N;<!%KMY=Z!;Q!1I7NY=!";<JKL=MJ!

!.-+5)505:A&

.8=!";<JKL=MJ!";K<INO!;Q!"R<RSR!LRN<7RN<J!R!M;J7=M!;Q!RI7NY=!I;<JKL=M!RSY;IR7=J!G8;!RM=!GNOON<V!7;!J8RM=!78=NM!;:N<N;<J!

R<S!U<;GO=SV=!Q;M!M=J=RMI8!RI7NYN7N=JH!!#<I=!78=!:MNLRMZ!M=J=RMI8!GRJ!I;L:O=7=S\!78=!:M=ONLN<RMZ!M=JKO7J!R<S!

M=I;LL=<SR7N;<!I;<I=:7J!;Q!78=!M=J=RMI8!G=M=!YRONSR7=S!GN78!78NJ!VM;K:!;Q!N<Q;ML=S!I;<JKL=MJ!GN78!R!8NV8!RGRM=<=JJ!

;Q!S=RON<V!GN78!I;<JKL=M!NJJK=JH!1!JKMY=Z!GRJ!IM=R7=S!R<S!J=<7!7;!RI7NY=!I;<JKL=MJ!]!7;!S=7=MLN<=!78=NM!KJ=^QRLNONRMN7Z!

GN78!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=J\!I;<I=M<J!;M!NJJK=J!=<I;K<7=M=S!RJ!G=OO!RJ!78=!R::M;:MNR7=!M=J:;<J=J!R<S!

M=I;LL=<SR7N;<J!78R7!IR<!T=!I;<JNS=M=S!TZ!78=!";<JKL=MJ!";K<INO!;Q!"R<RSRH!!1!I;:Z!;Q!78=!JKMY=Z!J=<7!NJ!R77RI8=S!RJ!

1::=<SNX!2H!

3]#&6;27.A&B.%;0-%&'()&9..)1'8U&

,<!;MS=M!7;!7=J7\!I;<7=X7KRONb=!R<S!YRONSR7=!;KM!;TJ=MYR7N;<J\!M=JKO7J!R<S!I;<IOKJN;<J\!R!5KTONI!,<7=M=J7!$=7G;MU!JKMY=Z!

GRJ!S=Y=O;:=S!R<S!ORK<I8=S!N<!_R<KRMZ^4=TMKRMZ!EP@PH!

5)(51,2!5,$!)(%&6.%!

CE!:=M!I=<7!;Q!M=J:;<S=<7J!Q=O7!78R7!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!J8;KOS!T=!7M=R7=S!K<S=M!78=!JRL=!:;ONIZ!RJ!;78=M!:M=:RNS!

J=MYNI=!]!#"#+,*),-7*5,4!15#5,-7#,15!%#,4&5-,>(#$,.*+1-#,&$,(#$,-#<-@,-&,*+4$#!5#G!!1OL;J7![D!:=M!I=<7!;M!M=J:;<S=<7J!N<SNIR7=S!

78R7!M=7RNON<V!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!IRMSJ!RO;<VJNS=!<;B=X:NMZ!IRMSJ!G;KOS!LNJO=RS!R!I;<JKL=MH!

';J7!M=J:;<S=<7J!dC@!:=M!I=<7f!G=M=!RGRM=!;Q!(F@@!I8RMV=J!T=N<V!I8RMV=S!L;<78OZ!7;!78=NM!RII;K<7!TROR<I=\!TK7!LR<Z!

dDA!:=M!I=<7f!LNJ7RU=<OZ!N<SNIR7=S!78R7!78=Z!G=M=!T=N<V!I8RMV=S!1II=JJ!4==J!d78=Z!G=M=!<;7fH!

4N<ROOZ\!WP!:=M!I=<7!;Q!M=J:;<S=<7J!N<SNIR7=S!78R7!<R7N;<RO!M=VKOR7N;<!7;!RQQ=I7!I;<JNJ7=<7!7=MLJ!R<S!I;<SN7N;<J!Q;M!:M=:RNS!

J=MYNI=J!G;KOS!T=!78=!L;J7!=QQ=I7NY=!L=78;S!7;!S=RO!GN78!78=NM!:=MI=NY=S!NJJK=JH!!1<!N<SKJ7MZBSMNY=<!:M;VMRL!R<S^;M!

G=TJN7=!7;!=SKIR7=!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!I;<JKL=MJ!GRJ!S==L=S!7;!T=!78=!O=RJ7!=QQ=I7NY=!L=78;S!7;!S=RO!GN78!78=J=!NJJK=JH!

5#%.51,2!5,$!)(%&6.%!

*8=<!RJU=S!8;G!I;<QNS=<7!M=J:;<S=<7J!RM=!78R7!78=NM!L;<78OZ!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!TNOOJ!G=M=!RIIKMR7=\!?[!:=M!I=<7!M=:ON=S!

4&+)*'#+-!G8NO=!D?!:=M!I=<7!I8;J=!5&.#27!-,4&+)*'#+-H!!.8NJ!M=JKO7!MK<J!I;K<7=M!7;!;KM!N<7=M:M=7R7N;<!;Q!LNJ7MKJ7!;Q!IRMMN=M!

TNOON<V!RIIKMRIZ!QM;L!78=!:M=YN;KJ!JKMY=ZcJ!M=JKO7!78R7!Q;K<S!WAHE!:=M!I=<7!IO;J=OZ!N<J:=I7!78=NM!L;<78OZ!J=MYNI=!TNOOJ!RJ!

LNJ7MKJ7!;Q!IRMMN=M!TNOON<V!RIIKMRIZH!!!

,<7=M=J7N<VOZ\!G8=<!RJU=S!8;G!I;<QNS=<7!M=J:;<S=<7J!RM=!78R7!78=NM!IRMMN=M!GNOO!QKOOZ!M=J;OY=!R!TNOON<V!SNJIM=:R<IZ!GN78N<!

78=!<=X7!IZIO=\!I;<QNS=<I=!SM;::=S\!RJ!;<OZ!EF!:=M!I=<7!JRNS!4&+)*'#+-,R<S!?E!:=M!I=<7!JRNS!5&.#27!-,4&+)*'#+-H!!!

1JU=S!RT;K7!8;G!M=J:;<S=<7J!G;KOS!:M;I==S!NQ!<=V;7NR7N;<J!JKMM;K<SN<V!R<!;<V;N<V!SNJ:K7=!TM;U=!S;G<!GN78!78=!

IRMMN=M\!WP!:=M!I=<7!JRNS!78R7!78=Z!G;KOS!4&+-*+1#,-&,-$8,-&,$#!5&+,2*-7,-7#,415-&.#$,5#$"*4#\!@C!:=M!I=<7!JRNS!78=Z!G;KOS!

kKJ7!'$&(,-7#,*551#,!+',(!8,-7#,/*00\!R<S!EF!:=M!I=<7!JRNS!78=Z!G;KOS!)*0#,!,4&.(0!*+-,2*-7,-7#,HH;IH!!6=JJ!78R<!D!:=M!I=<7!

G;KOS!'$&(,-7#,*551#,/1-,+&-,(!8,-7#,/*00H!!!!!!

.8KJ\!78=!5,$!M=JKO7J!JKVV=J7!78R7!M=J:;<S=<7J!RM=!I;<QNS=<7!N<!78=NM!IRMMN=M!Q;M!TNOON<V!RIIKMRIZ\!TK7!O=JJ!I;<QNS=<7!N<!78=NM!

IRMMN=M!G8=<!QRI=S!GN78!R!TNOON<V!SNJ:K7=H!!,<!78=!=Y=<7!78R7!<=V;7NR7N;<J!TM=RU!S;G<!GN78!78=!IRMMN=MJ\!78=!LRk;MN7Z!;Q!

M=J:;<S=<7J!R7!WP!:=M!I=<7!JRNS!78R7!78=Z!G;KOS!I;<7N<K=!7;!7MZ!7;!M=J;OY=!78=!SNJ:K7=!78M;KV8!78=!IRMMN=M!IKJ7;L=M!

J=MYNI=!I=<7M=H!!

Page 46: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$. :

1JU=S!7;!MR7=!78=NM!GNM=O=JJ!IRMMN=M!TRJ=S!;<!:MNI=!R<S!YROK=\!DE!:=M!I=<7!M=J:;<S=S!!"#$!%#\!G8NO=!D?!:=M!I=<7!JRNS!(&&$H!!

1OL;J7!R<!=gKRO!:=MI=<7RV=!;Q!M=J:;<S=<7J!d@A!:=M!I=<7!R<S!@C!:=M!I=<7f!MR7=S!78=NM!IRMMN=M!RJ!"#$8,(&&$!R<S!!/&"#,

!"#$!%#!TRJ=S!;<!78=J=!IMN7=MNRH!!!

)R7N<V!78=NM!GNM=O=JJ!IRMMN=M!TRJ=S!;<!IKJ7;L=M!J=MYNI=\!?[H?!:=M!I=<7!I8;J=!!"#$!%#,R<S!E@H@!:=M!I=<7!I8;J=!!/&"#,

!"#$!%#H!J&&$!R<S!"#$8,(&&$!G=M=!I8;J=<!TZ!R<!=gKRO!:=MI=<7RV=!;Q!M=J:;<S=<7J!R7!@A!:=M!I=<7!R<S!D?!:=M!I=<7H!

*8=<!RJU=S!7;!:MN;MN7Nb=!R!ONJ7!;Q!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!R77MNTK7=J\!M=J:;<S=<7J!MR<U=S!J$*4#FK!01#!RJ!78=!L;J7!NL:;M7R<7H!!

L#-2&$3,H&"#$!%#!MR<U=S!78=!J=I;<S!L;J7!NL:;M7R<7\!G8NO=!H15-&.#$,I#$"*4#,M<(#$*#+4#!MR<U=S!78NMSH!

,Q!5MNI=^3ROK=!NJ!N<S==S!78=!L;J7!NL:;M7R<7!IMN7=MNR!;Q!R!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=M!7;!I;<JKL=MJ\!N7!NJ!N<7=M=J7N<V!7;!J==!

78R7!78=!LRk;MN7Z!;Q!M=J:;<S=<7J!R7!AA!:=M!I=<7!MR7=S!78=NM!GNM=O=JJ!IRMMN=M!!"#$!%#!dDE!:=M!I=<7f!;M!(&&$!dD?!:=M!I=<7f!

TRJ=S!;<!78NJ!IMN7=MN;<H!!"O=RMOZ\!IRMMN=MJ!RM=!<;7!NL:M=JJNY=!7;!I;<JKL=MJ!N<!78NJ!M=VRMSH!

.RUN<V!N<7;!I;<JNS=MR7N;<!IRMMN=MJc!RMVKL=<7!Q;M!78=!<=I=JJN7Z!;Q!=RMOZ!7=MLN<R7N;<^I;<7MRI7!IR<I=OOR7N;<!Q==J\![C!:=M!I=<7!

;Q!M=J:;<S=<7J!JRNS!R!lQRNMc!=RMOZ!7=MLN<R7N;<!Q==!G;KOS!T=!7;!I;Y=M!78=!4&5-,&),-7#,7!+'5#-\!@DHW!:=M!I=<7!M=:ON=S!4&"#$,-7#,

4&5-,&),7!+'5#-,!+',!,)*<#',!.&1+-,)&$,$#.!*+*+%,.&+-75\!G8NO=!C!:=M!I=<7!M=:ON=S!&-7#$,TK7!SNS!<;7!J:=INQZ!G8R7!78=Z!

L=R<7H!!!

*8=<!RJU=S!RT;K7!K<O;IUN<V!78=NM!8R<SJ=7!QM;L!78=NM!IRMMN=M!RQ7=M!78=!I;L:O=7N;<!;Q!R!I;<7MRI7\!WFHW!:=M!I=<7!M=:ON=S!78R7!

IRMMN=MJ!J8;KOS!T=!;TONVR7=S!7;!K<O;IU!78=NM!8R<SJ=7J\!EFH[!:=M!I=<7!M=:ON=S!78R7!IRMMN=MJ!J8;KOS!;QQ=M!N7!RJ!R!J=MYNI=\!R<S!

O=JJ!78R<!?!:=M!I=<7!JRNS!78R7!78=Z!M=:ORI=!78=NM!8R<SJ=7!RQ7=M!78=!I;L:O=7N;<!;Q!=Y=MZ!I;<7MRI7H!!!!!

Page 47: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$. ;

";<IOKJN;<J!R<S!5;7=<7NRO!-;Y=M<L=<7!)=J:;<J=!

)=J=RMI8!N<!78=!GNM=O=JJ!LRMU=7!GRJ!K<S=M7RU=<!7;!K<S=MJ7R<S!I;<JKL=M!JR7NJQRI7N;<!R<S!I;<I=M<J!;Q!K<QRNM!N<SKJ7MZ!

:MRI7NI=J!R<S!:;ONIN=JH!!.8=!M=J=RMI8!GNOO!NS=<7NQZ!78=!J;KMI=!;Q!I;L:ORN<7J!R<S!LRU=!M=I;LL=<SR7N;<J!7;!RSSM=JJ!K<QRNM!

:MRI7NI=JH!!1J!;Q!78=!QROO\!EPPC\!R7!O=RJ7!Q;KM!<=G!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!:M;YNS=MJ!8RY=!N<SNIR7=S!78=NM!:OR<J!7;!TKNOS!<=7G;MUJ!

R<S!;QQ=M!J=MYNI=!7;!78=!"R<RSNR<!:KTONIH!!!

.8=!U=Z!M=J=RMI8!gK=J7N;<J!N<IOKS=>!

• *8R7!RM=!78=!J;KMI=J!;Q!78=!I;<JKL=M!I;L:ORN<7Jj!

• *8R7!7Z:=J!;Q!GNM=O=JJ!:OR<J!RM=!;QQ=M=Sj!!*8R7!NJ!78=!I;<JKL=M!=X:=MN=<I=j!

• *8R7!RM=!78=!I;L:ORN<7J!7Z:=J!R<S!J8;KOS!R<Z!I;<JKL=M!:M;7=I7N;<!O=VNJOR7N;<!T=!N<7M;SKI=Sj!

• /RY=!;78=M!I;K<7MN=J!N<7M;SKI=S!R<Z!I;<JKL=M!:M;7=I7N;<!M=OR7=S!7;!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=J\!:RM7NIKORMOZ!:M=:RNSj!

• 1M=!78=M=!U=Z!O=JJ;<J!Q;M!78=!I;<JKL=Mj!!/;G!J8;KOS!78=!I;<JKL=M!T=!LRS=!RGRM=j!

• *8R7!J8;KOS!78=!V;Y=M<L=<7!S;!7;!=<8R<I=!I;<JKL=M!:M;7=I7N;<j!

";<IOKJN;<J!TRJ=S!;<!78=!M=J=RMI8!I;<SKI7=S!SKMN<V!78=!J7KSZ!RM=!RJ!Q;OO;GJ>!

@H ,<!78=!EPPF!";<JKL=MJ!";K<INO!;Q!"R<RSR!M=J=RMI8!M=:;M7\!6;<V!2NJ7R<I=!58;<=!"RMSJ\!N7!GRJ!Q;K<S!78R7!J8;M7!

=X:NMZ!:=MN;SJ!;<!:M=:RNS!O;<V!SNJ7R<I=!I;KOS!:M;YNS=!78=!I;<JKL=M!R!V;;S!YROK=!78M;KV8!Y=MZ!O;G!MR7=J!;M!K<B

ONLN7=S!7ROU!7NL=!Q;M!R!J8;M7!:=MN;SH!!4;M!78NJ!M=RJ;<!R<S!I;<JKL=M!T=<=QN7\!<;!I;<7M;OJ!d;78=M!78R<!NL:M;Y=S!SNJB

IO;JKM=f!G=M=!M=I;LL=<S=SH! !5M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!:OR<J\!;<!78=!;78=M!8R<S\!V=<=MROOZ!I;<7RN<!=X:NMZ!:=MN;SJ!78R7!

RM=!gKN7=! J8;M7! I;L:RM=S! 7;!;78=M!:M=:RNS!J=MYNI=J!GN78!<;!R::RM=<7!I;<JKL=M!T=<=QN7!;M! N<I=<7NY=! Q;M! 78=J=!

ONLN7=S!=X:NMZ!7=MLJH! !#KM!L;J7!I;J7BI;<JIN;KJ!I;<JKL=MJ!dFC!:=M!I=<7f!I8;;J=!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!7;!I;<7M;O!;M!

LN<NLNb=! 78=NM! I;J7\! TK7! 78=J=! JRL=!I;<JKL=MJ!RM=! JKTk=I7! 7;!L;<78OZ! cTROR<I=! IO=RMN<Vc!K<O=JJ! 78=Z!RVM==! 7;!

:KMI8RJ=!L;M=H!

EH 5M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=\!ONU=!:M=:RNS!O;<V!SNJ7R<I=\!I;<7RN<J!R<!=X:NMR7N;<!:;ONIZ!78R7!SNQQ=MJ!RJ!R!:M=:RNS!:M;SB

KI7^J=MYNI=!K<S=M! IKMM=<7!:M;YN<INRO! O=VNJOR7N;<H! !aK=T=IcJ!0NOO!AP!GNOO! R77=L:7! 7;! N<IOKS=! 78NJ! J=MYNI=!K<S=M!R!!

l:M=:RNS!KLTM=OOR\c!TK7!:M;YN<INRO!O=VNJOR7N;<!J==LJ!:N=I=L=RO!Q;M!R!<R7N;<RO!J=MYNI=H!!$R7N;<RO!GNM=O=JJ!:M;SKI7J!

J8;KOS!I;<7RN<!I;<JNJ7=<7!7=MLJ!R<S!I;<SN7N;<J!RIM;JJ!78=!"R<RSNR<!LRMU=7H!

DH #"1!J8;KOS!=XRLN<=!78=!I;LL;<!:MRI7NI=!;Q!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!M=7RNO\!G8NI8!ROO;GJ!78=!JRO=!;Q!78=J=!ONLN7=S!7=ML!

:M;SKI7J!JNS=BTZBJNS=!GN78!K<ONLN7=S!7=ML!:M=:RNS^VNQ7!IRMSJH! !";<JKL=M!I;<QKJN;<! NJ! N<8=M=<7!GN78!78NJ!I;LB

L;<!:MRI7NI=H!

?H @C!:=M!I=<7!;Q!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!KJ=MJ!RM=!I;<I=M<=S!RT;K7!8NSS=<!Q==J!R<S!L;M=!78R<!?P!:=M!I=<7!RM=!K<JKM=!;Q!

Q==J! 78R7!LRZ!T=! N<! 78=NM!L;<78OZ! I8RMV=H! ! W[!:=M! I=<7!T=ON=Y=! 78R7! 78=Z! RM=! I8RMV=S!1II=JJ!4==J! Q;M!:M=:RNS!

GNM=O=JJ!G8=<\! NQ! QRI7\! IRMMN=MJ!S;!<;7!I8RMV=! 78NJ! Q==!;<!:M=:RNS!GNM=O=JJH! !";<JKL=M!I;<QKJN;<!;<!RJJ;INR7=S!

J=MYNI=!Q==J!NJ!R::RM=<7H!

WH .8=!Q;KM!LRN<!IR7=V;MN=J!;Q!:;J7:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!I;L:ORN<7J!I;L:MNJ=!;Q!0NOON<V!(MM;MJ\!";<7MRI7!.=MLN<R7N;<!2NJB

:K7=J\!"KJ7;L=M!%=MYNI=!-MN=YR<I=J\!R<S!.=MLJ!`!";<SN7N;<J!"8R<V=J\!G8NI8!7;V=78=M!I;L:MNJ=!;Q![W!:=M!I=<7!;Q!

ROO!"".%!I;L:ORN<7J!N<!78NJ!JRL:O=H!

AH l&<QRNM<=JJc! NJ!R! I;LL;<! 78=L=!RL;<V!ROO! IR7=V;MN=J!;Q! I;L:ORN<7J! JKVV=J7N<V!IKJ7;L=MJ!:=MI=NY=!R<!K<=Y=<!

:ORZN<V! QN=OS! 7N::=S! N<! QRY;KM! ;Q! 78=! IRMMN=MJ\! =J:=INROOZ! GN78! M=VRMSJ! 7;! ";<7MRI7! .=MLN<R7N;<! 2NJ:K7=J! R<S!

.=MLJ!`!";<SN7N;<J!"8R<V=JH!

[H 1OL;J7!AP!:=M!I=<7!;Q!:;J7:RNS!JKMY=Z!M=J:;<S=<7J!IO;J=OZ!N<J:=I7!78=NM!L;<78OZ!J=MYNI=!TNOOJ!JKVV=J7N<V!78R7!78=!

LRk;MN7Z!S;!<;7!7MKJ7!78=!RIIKMRIZ!;Q!78=NM!IRMMN=McJ!TNOON<V!:MRI7NI=Jo!?W!:=M!I=<7!Q;K<S!@BD!TNOON<V!=MM;MJ!;<!78=NM!

L;<78OZ! J=MYNI=! TNOO! ;Y=M! 78=! ORJ7! Z=RMH! "KMN;KJOZ\! 5,$! JKMY=Z! M=JKO7J! J8;G! 78R7! M=J:;<S=<7J! RM=! I;<QNS=<7! N<!

78=NM!IRMMN=M!Q;M!TNOON<V!RIIKMRIZ\!TK7!O=JJ!J;!M=VRMSN<V!;<=BTNOON<VBIZIO=!M=J;OK7N;<!G8=<!QRI=S!GN78!R!TNOON<V!SNJB

:K7=H!!!

CH "KJ7;L=MJ!I;MM=OR7=!J:==S!;Q!M=J;OK7N;<!GN78!gKRON7Z!;Q!IKJ7;L=M!IRM=o!N7!IR<!T=!N<Q=MM=S!78R7!78=!?[!:=M!I=<7!;Q!

:;J7:RNS! JKMY=Z! M=J:;<S=<7J!G8;J=! TNOON<V! =MM;MJ!G=M=! M=J;OY=S!GN78N<! ;<=! TNOON<V! IZIO=! =X:=MN=<I=S! R! M=ORB

7NY=OZ!8NV8!gKRON7Z!;Q!IKJ7;L=M!IRM=H! !$;7=>! J:==S!;Q!IRMMN=M!M=J;OK7N;<! NJ!R!<=VR7NY=! QK<I7N;<!;Q! 78=!RL;K<7! N<!

SNJ:K7=H!

FH ';M=!78R<![P!:=M!I=<7!;Q!:;J7:RNS!M=J:;<S=<7J!S=JIMNT=S!78=NM!IKJ7;L=M!JR7NJQRI7N;<! O=Y=O!RJ!!"#$!%#! dDA!:=M!I=<7f!;M!%&&'!dDW!:=M!I=<7fH!0RJ=S!;<!5MNI=^3ROK=\!5,$!M=J:;<S=<7J!MR7=S!78=NM!IRMMN=M!RJ!!"#$!%#!dDE!:=M!I=<7f!;M!(&&$!dD?!:=M!I=<7fH!!!

Page 48: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$. <

@PH "KJ7;L=M!J=MYNI=! I=<7M=J!;Q7=<!=XRI=MTR7=! IKJ7;L=M!I;L:ORN<7J^:M;TO=LJ!GN78! N<I;<JNJ7=<7!:MRI7NI=J!R<S! N<BQ;MLR7N;<H!

0RJ=S!;<!78=J=!I;<IOKJN;<J!G=!;QQ=M!78=!Q;OO;GN<V!M=I;LL=<SR7N;<J>!

• 5M;VM=JJNY=!I;<JKL=M!:M;7=I7N;<!N<N7NR7NY=J\!JKI8!RJ!78;J=!:M;:;J=S!N<!aK=T=IcJ!0NOO!AP!J8;KOS!T=!SMNY=<!R7!R!<RB

7N;<RO!O=Y=OH!!1J!R<!N<N7NRO!J7=:\!78=!#QQNI=!;Q!";<JKL=M!1QQRNMJ!J8;KOS!R::M;RI8!78=!"*.1!7;!:M;:;J=!NL:M;Y=S!

R<S!I;<JNJ7=<7!:;ONIN=J!M=OR7=S!7;!:M=:RNS!R<S!:;J7:RNS!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=J!R<S!ROO;G!N<SKJ7MZ!J=OQBM=VKOR7N;<!7;!

=X=IK7=!N7H!

• 1!JNL:O=\!J7R<SRMS^VKNS=ON<=!Q;M!Q==!SNJIO;JKM=!J8;KOS!T=!M=I;LL=<S=S!R<S!RS;:7=S!TZ!ROO!GNM=O=JJ!IRMMN=MJ!7;!

=ONLN<R7=!I;<JKL=M!I;<QKJN;<H!!.8NJ!SNJIO;JKM=!J8;KOS!T=!J8;G<!GN78!:MNIN<V!]!<;7!TKMN=S!N<!.=MLJ!R<S!";<SNB

7N;<J!;<!R!G=TJN7=H!!"O=RM!SNJIO;JKM=!78R7!78=!IRMMN=M!RJJ=JJ=J!<;<BLR<SR7=S!Q==J!dONU=!(F@@f!7;!M=I;Y=M!I;J7J!;Q!

N<QMRJ7MKI7KM=!J8;KOS!ROJ;!T=!M=gKNM=SH!!/;G=Y=M\!R!L;M=!:M;VM=JJNY=!=Y;OK7N;<!TZ!IRMMN=MJ!7;!I;<7N<K=!7;!=ONLNB

<R7=!=X7MR!Q==J\!TKNOSN<V!78=J=!I;J7J!N<7;!78=!L;<78OZ!I8RMV=\!NJ!M=I;LL=<S=SH!

• 5M;YN<INRO!N<N7NR7NY=J!dONU=!aK=T=I!0NOO!APf!J8;KOS!T=!M=YN=G=S!R<S\!NQ!M=gKNM=S\!SMNY=<!Q=S=MROOZ!RJ!L;J7!GNM=O=JJ!

J=MYNI=J!RM=!<R7N;<RO!TZ!<R7KM=!R<S!QRNM!I;<JKL=M!:M;7=I7N;<!J8;KOS!I;Y=M!ROO!"R<RSNR<JH!

• ";<JKL=MJ!LKJ7!T=!RGRM=!78R7!G8=<!I;LLN77N<V!7;!R!I=OO!:8;<=!I;<7MRI7\!78=Z!RM=!<;7!I;Y=M=S!TZ!78=!JRL=!:M;B

7=I7N;<J!RQQ;MS=S!78=L!G8=<!LRUN<V!R!J7MRNV87Q;MGRMS!M=7RNO!:KMI8RJ=H!"KJ7;L=MJ!8RY=!7;!S;!78=NM!:RM7!N<!=SKB

IR7N<V!78=LJ=OY=J!RT;K7!78=!GRZJ!N<!G8NI8!78=NM!GNM=O=JJ!J=MYNI=!;:=MR7=J!T=Q;M=!K<S=M7RUN<V!78=!I;LLN7L=<7H!!

.8=!#QQNI=!;Q!";<JKL=M!1QQRNMJ!J8;KOS!=XRLN<=!G8=78=M!78=!7Z:NIRO\!;<=BJNS=S!I;<7MRI7!J8;KOS!T=!78=!ROO;GRTO=!

J7R<SRMS!Q;M!ROO!"R<RSNR<JH!

• "RMMN=MJ!J8;KOS!:M;YNS=!I;<JNJ7=<7!N<Q;MLR7N;<!7;!I;<JKL=MJ!QM;L!78=!:;N<7!;Q!JRO=!78M;KV8!7;!78=!RQ7=MBJRO=!IROO!

I=<7M=!=X:=MN=<I=H!"O=RM!TNOON<V!J7MKI7KM=J!R<S!:M;L;7N;<RO!;QQ=MN<VJ!RM=!U=Z!7;!LRN<7RN<N<V!R!V;;S!QO;G!;Q!N<B

Q;MLR7N;<!T=7G==<!T;78!:RM7N=JH!

• *N78!M=J:=I7!7;!I;<7MRI7!IR<I=OOR7N;<!Q==J\!M=J=RMI8!8RJ!J8;G<!78R7!IKMM=<7!I;<7MRI7!OR<VKRV=!NJ!TNRJ=S!7;GRMSJ!

78=!RSYR<7RV=!;Q!78=!IRMMN=M!O=RYN<V!I;<JKL=MJ!GN78!ROO!78=!ONRTNON7Z!R<S!MNJU!;Q!I;<7MRI7!7=MLN<R7N;<H!";<JKL=MJ!

RM=!V=<=MROOZ!RGRM=!78R7!78=!I;J7J!;Q!8R<SJ=7J!RM=!JKTJNSNb=S!R<S!RM=!<;7!RY=MJ=!7;!:RZN<V!R!Q==!7;!7=MLN<R7=!

78=NM!I;<7MRI7!RJ!O;<V!RJ!78NJ!Q==!NJ!lQRNMc!TRJ=S!;<!YRMNRTO=J!JKI8!RJ!78=!M=7RNO!I;J7!;Q!78=!8R<SJ=7!R<S!78=!M=LRN<B

S=M!SKMR7N;<!;Q!78=!J=MYNI=!RVM==L=<7H!!aK=T=IcJ!0NOO!AP!ROJ;!:M;:;J=J!I8R<V=J!7;!I;<7MRI7!7=MLN<R7N;<!Q==J!R7!R!

I;<7M;OO=S!I;J7!7;!I;<JKL=MJ\!TK7!K<QRNM!I;<JKL=M!:MRI7NI=J!J8;KOS!T=!S=RO7!GN78!Q=S=MROOZH!

• .8=!"".%!NJ!R!YROKRTO=!I8R<<=O!Q;M!I;L:ORN<7!M=J;OK7N;<!R<S!R!YROK=S!M=:;JN7;MZ!;Q!NJJK=J!78R7!I;<I=M<!"R<RSNR<!

I;<JKL=MJH!!.8=!J7RU=8;OS=MJ!;Q!"".%!J8;KOS!N<Y=J7!N<!NL:M;Y=S!SR7RTRJ=!7;;OJ!R<S!IR7=V;MNbR7N;<!;Q!NJJK=J!7;!

T=77=M!RJJ=JJ!GNM=O=JJ!NJJK=J!R<S!78=!:M;VM=JJ!;Q!78=NM!L=LT=MJ!7;!M=J;OY=!78=LH!

Page 49: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$. "

1::=<SNI=J!

S44.(),O&S&T&32.4',)&*,2.0.%%&@'U.%&5CC&

Page 50: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$7 #

S44.(),O&L&T&D5(-2'8-&D'(8.00'-,5(&9..%&

(X8NTN7J!T=O;G!RM=!78=!IR<I=OOR7N;<!:;ONIN=J!RJ!J7R7=S!;<!_R<!@C\!EP@P!Q;M!78=!l0NV!Dc!:M=LNKL!GNM=O=JJ!TMR<SJH!!

NO+,1,-&<&T&D5(-2'8-&@.2F,('-,5(&9..%&T&@.0;%&

NO+,1,-&?&T&D5(-2'8-&@.2F,('-,5(&9..%&T&B5:.2%&

Page 51: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$7 !

NO+,1,-&E&T&D5(-2'8-&@.2F,('-,5(&9..%&T&L.00&&

Page 52: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$7 8

S44.(),O&D&T&D5(%;F.2&6;27.A&

6;27.A&B.%45(%.&6;FF'2A&

L"."*$&'M,")#%-.)'

Page 53: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$7 9

9-)#7$%1'M,")#%-.)'

Page 54: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$7 .

9*"7$%1'M,")#%-.)'

Page 55: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$7 7

Survey Demographics

Page 56: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$7 :

S44.(),O&>&T&S8-,7.&D5(%;F.2&6;27.A&?[<[&

&

&

&

Page 57: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$7 ;

&&

&

&&

Page 58: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$7 <

&

Page 59: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$7 "

&&

Page 60: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$: #

&

Page 61: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$: !

&

&

Page 62: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

";< JKL= M J ! " ;K< I N O ! ; Q ! " R < RS R ! "/1$- ,$- ! 61$2%"15( !#4 !* ,)(6(%% ! 5 61$% !

$: 8

S44.(),O&N&T&B.C.2.(8.%&

u"0"!$=GJ!]!";<JKL=M!6NQ=!]!#<7RMN;!TR<J!VNQ7!IRMS!=X:NMZ!SR7=JHu!HNHG4!,6,H!+!'*!+,L#25,I(&$-5,M+-#$-!*+.#+-,O*'5,E&45,P!'*&,;KH!$H:H\!<HSH!*=TH!D@!2=IH!EPPFH!877:>^^GGGHITIHIR^I;<JKL=M^J7;MZ^EPP[^PW^EF^VNQ7IRMSB=X:NMZH87LO!

u"*.1!]!";S=!;Q!";<SKI7Hu!HQ;A,F,AH;IH!$H:H\!<HSH!*=TH!D@!2=IH!EPPFH!877:>^^GGGHIG7RHIR^"*.1%N7=^=<VONJ8^I;S=;QI;<SKI7H87LO!

2=L=MJ!\!1<<NIU\!R<S!0MZ<R!0M;S7H!u5M;:;J=S!1L=<SL=<7J!7;!aK=T=I!";<JKL=M!5M;7=I7N;<!1I7!/RY=!*NS=B)=RI8N<V!

,L:RI7Hu!N0!3#H!$H:H\!<HSH!*=TH!D@!2=IH!EPPFH!877:>^^GGGHTORU=JHI;L^=<VONJ8^YN=GHRJ:j,2tDE?C!

-M=<N=M\!+R7=MNB1<<=!H!u0NOO!AP>!"8R<V=J!7;!aK=T=IrJ!";<JKL=M!5M;7=I7N;<!1I7!%7R<S!7;!/RY=!R!'Rk;M!,L:RI7!v!#VNOYZ!

)=<RKO7Hu!R%*0"8,P#+!10-,6,N15*+#55,0!2,*+,H!+!'!,2*-7,*+'15-$8,!+',*+-#$+!-*&+!0,)&415H!$H:H\!<HSH!*=TH!D@!2=IH!EPPFH!877:>^^GGGH;VNOYZM=<RKO7HI;L^=<^M=J;KMI="=<7M=sF?AAH87L!

u'I-KN<7Z!V;Y=M<L=<7!J7M=<V78=<J!I;<JKL=M!:M;7=I7N;<!B!-;Y=M<L=<7!;Q!#<7RMN;!d"R<RSRfHu!Q#04&.#,-&,=*+*5-$8,&),S&"#$+.#+-,I#$"*4#5,6,S&"#$+.#+-,&),R+-!$*&,>H!+!'!@H!$H:H\!<HSH!*=TH!D@!2=IH!EPPFH!877:>^^GGGHLVJHV;YH;<HIR^=<^$=GJ^%.(6PEsP?[@DWH87LO!

u#:7N;<!I;<J;LLR7=KMJ!]!5M=JJ!);;L!]!5M=JJ!)=O=RJ=J!]!"*.1!";S=!;Q!";<SKI7!]!kKJ7!JL;U=!R<S!LNMM;MJ\!JRZJ!#:7N;<!

";<J;LLR7=KMJHu!R(-*&+,4&+5&..!-#1$5,6,A441#*0H!$H:H\!<HSH!*=TH!D@!2=IH!EPPFH!!877:>^^GGGH;:7N;<BI;<J;LLR7=KMJH;MV^=<^:M=JJsM;;L^:M=JJsM=O=RJ=J^EDF^!

u5,1"!v!'Rk;M!5RM7N=J!1JU=S!7;!%K::;M7!";<JKL=M!)NV87J!N<!.=O=I;LLK<NIR7N;<JHu!;7#,J1/0*4,T+-#$#5-,A'"&4!48,H#+-$#,U,JTAHG4!H!$H:H\!<HSH!*=TH!D@!2=IH!EPPFH!877:>^^GGGH:NRIHIR^7=O=I;L^LRk;Ms:RM7N=JsRJU=Ss7;sJK::;M7sI;<JKL=MsMNV87JsN<s7=O=I;LLK<NIR7N;<J^!

u%=MYNI=!1OT=M7R>!1OT=M7RrJ!-NQ7!"RMS!)=VKOR7N;<Hu!I#$"*4#,A0/#$-!V,H!$H:H\!<HSH!*=TH!D@!2=IH!EPPFH!877:>^^GGGHJ=MYNI=ROT=M7RHV;YHRTHIR^@EFPHIQL

0OZJURO\!_=QQH!u";<JKL=M!)=:;M7J!(O=I7M;<NIJ!0O;V>!1.`.!7;!:M;BMR7=!=RMOZ!7=MLN<R7N;<!Q==J!Q;M!I=OOB:8;<=!I;<7MRI7JHu!

H&+51.#$,P#(&$-5,M0#4-$&+*45,N0&%H!$H:H\!<HSH!*=TH!D@!2=IH!EPPFH!877:>^^TO;VJHI;<JKL=MM=:;M7JH;MV^=O=I7M;<NIJ^EPPC^P?^R77B7;B:M;BMR7=H87LO!

)=RMS;<\!'RMVK=MN7=H!u4""!7RU=J!R!IO;J=M!O;;U!R7!GNM=O=JJ!N<SKJ7MZ!]!"$(.!$=GJHu!;#47+&0&%8,L#25,6,HLM;,L#25H!$H:H\!<HSH!*=TH!D@!2=IH!EPPFH!877:>^^LH<=GJHI;L^E@AAB@EsDB@PD@WP[CBEAAH87LO!

);IU=Q=OO=M\!_;8<H!u&H%H!%=<R7=!";LLN77==!;<!";LL=MI=\!%IN=<I=\!`!.MR<J:;M7R7N;<Hu!WGIG,I#+!-#,H&..*--##,&+,H&..#$4#X,I4*#+4#X,Y,;$!+5(&$-!-*&+H!$H:H\!<HSH!*=TH!D@!2=IH!EPPFH!877:>^^I;LL=MI=HJ=<R7=HV;Y^:KTONI^N<S=XHIQLj4KJ=1I7N;<t/=RMN<VJH%7R7=L=<7`%7R7=L=<7s,2tA??FTPTCBQQFFB

???WBFF@DBWAI[@DWSQDSF!

);;<=Z\!_RIUH!u&H%H!%=<R7=!";LLN77==!;<!";LL=MI=\!%IN=<I=\!`!.MR<J:;M7R7N;<Hu!WGIG,I#+!-#,H&..*--##,&+,H&..#$4#X,I4*#+4#X,Y,;$!+5(&$-!-*&+H!$H:H\!<HSH!*=TH!D@!2=IH!EPPFH!877:>^^I;LL=MI=HJ=<R7=HV;Y^:KTONI^N<S=XHIQLj4KJ=1I7N;<t/=RMN<VJH.=J7NL;<Z`/=RMN<Vs,2tPDTC@QQSBTRFQB?E=AB

CDD@B[IECQAS@@ETP`*N7<=JJs,2tRWWFQ@WDBQE[CB?[C[BTSEABSSP@S@=FAIDE!!

u%=<R7;M!1LZ!+O;TKI8RMHu!I#+!-&$,A.8,O0&/147!$H!$H:H\!<HSH!*=TH!D@!2=IH!EPPFH!877:>^^UO;TKI8RMHJ=<R7=HV;Y^<=GJM=O=RJ=JsS=7RNOHIQLjNStECWWDW`!

u*,)(6(%%!"#$%&'()!0,66%!#4!),-/.H!]!0MN7R<<NIR!#<ON<=!(<IZIO;:=SNRHu!M+4840&(#'*!,6,N$*-!++*4!,R+0*+#,M+4840&(#'*!H!$H:H\!<HSH!*=TH!D@!2=IH!EPPFH!877:>^^GGGHTMN7R<<NIRHI;L^T:J^RSSN7N;<ROI;<7=<7^@C^DW?F[?ED^*,)(6(%%B"#$%&'()B0,66%B#4B),-/.!

Page 63: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

!

!"#$%!&'(%)*+,-*.%/.0('-*+,*-,/$(1,-*-0)-*.(!*,203,)*4556*+,-*.%/.0('-*+,*-,/$(1,-*-0)-*.(!*7/#708#-*,'*7%-'708#-*

,'*+,-*7/#%11&70'(%)-*+,-*1%)-%330',&/-*"#$%&#$'&(')*+',('-*)./01',/.'2*).*++&3/(#.',('-&)&,&'%&#'4/&5*&#,'6#*(%'7'420#/'4*1(30*).'8)29'

-9::;<=>*!>*19?@><A*B>@*C9?@9::;D>E=@*BE*1;?;B;F*9=G;?<@:>*B>*BHI>?@>*B>@*C9?@9::;D>E=@*>D*B>*=>CJ>=CJ>F*;*B>:;?BH*C>DD>*HDEB>*;K>C*A";LLE<*BE*ME=>;E*B>*A;*C9?@9::;D<9?*B"(?BE@D=<>*1;?;B;*>?*KE>*B">?NEOD>=*@E=*A>@*>?P>EQ*>?*C9?@9::;D<9?*L9=D;?D*@E=*A>@*I9=I;<D@*B>*@>=K<C>@*@;?@*I<A*L=HL;RH@*@E=*A>*:;=CJH*C;?;B<>?S*!>@*C9?@9::;D>E=@*9?D*T*C9>E=*A>E=@*@>=K<C>@*@;?@*I<AS*U*A";ED9:?>*455VF*;E*:9:>?D*9W*A"<BH>*B>*C>*=;LL9=D*;*H:>=GHF*A>@*LA;<?D>@*T*A"HG;=B*B>@*I9=I;<D@*B>*@>=K<C>@*@;?@*I<A*>Q<@D;?D@*L9=D;<>?D*@E=*C>*NE<*@E<D*X*

• A>@*I=;<@*B";CCY@*ZB>*[F6\*]*T*VF6\*]^_*• A>@*I=;<@*L9E=*A>@*:>@@;G>@*D>QD>@*>?D=;?D@_*• A;*B<@L9?<`<A<DH*BaE?*=>A>KH*BHD;<AAH*B>@*;LL>A@*B>@*I9=I;<D@*B>*`A9C@*B>*:<?ED>@_*• A>@*>==>E=@*B>*I;CDE=;D<9?*>D*A>@*>?P>EQ*A<H@*T*A;*I;CDE=;D<9?_*• A>@*L9A<D<NE>@*B">QL<=;D<9?*B>@*@>=K<C>@*@;?@*I<A*L=HL;RH@_*• A>@*I=;<@*C;CJH@_*• A;*=H@<A<;D<9?*B>*C9?D=;D*>D*A>@*I=;<@*C;CJH@*@aR*=;DD;CJ;?DS*

*

+>@*D=;K;EQ*B>*=>CJ>=CJ>*9?D*HDH*>?D=>L=<@*;E*:9R>?*B>@*C;?;EQ*BE*@>CD>E=*>D*B>*@9?B;G>@*;EL=Y@*B>@*C9?@9::;D>E=@*;I<?*B>*=HL9?B=>*;EQ*NE>@D<9?@*@E<K;?D>@*X*

• bE>A@*@9?D*A>@*:9D<I@*B>*LA;<?D>*B>@*C9?@9::;D>E=@c*• bE>A@*@9?D*A>@*DRL>@*B>*I9=I;<D@*B>*@>=K<C>@*@;?@*I<A*9II>=D@c*bE>AA>*>@D*Aa>QLH=<>?C>*BE*C9?@9::;D>E=c*• bE>A@*@9?D*A>@*DRL>@*B>*LA;<?D>@F*>D*B>@*A9<@*@E=*A;*L=9D>CD<9?*BE*C9?@9::;D>E=*B>K=;<>?Dd>AA>@*OD=>*

;B9LDH>@c*• +a;ED=>@*L;R@*9?Dd<A@*:<@*>?*LA;C>*B>@*:>@E=>@*T*AaHG;=B*B>@*@>=K<C>@*@;?@*I<A*L9E=*L=9DHG>=*A>@*

C9?@9::;D>E=@F*L;=D<CEA<Y=>:>?D*B;?@*A>*C;@*B>@*@>=K<C>@*L=HL;RH@c*• bE>*B>K=;<D*I;<=>*A>*G9EK>=?>:>?D*L9E=*;:HA<9=>=*A;*L=9D>CD<9?*BE*C9?@9::;D>E=c*

$9<C<*A>@*C9?CAE@<9?@*B>@*D=;K;EQ*B>*=>CJ>=CJ>*:>?H@*BE=;?D*A"HDEB>*X*

eS !>*=;LL9=D*B>*=>CJ>=CJ>*@E=*A>@*C;=D>@*B";LL>A@*<?D>=E=`;<?@*=HB<GH*>?*4556*L;=*A>*19?@><A*B>@*C9?@9::;D>E=@*BE*1;?;B;*;*L>=:<@*B>*BHD>=:<?>=*NE>*A>@*C9E=D>@*LH=<9B>@*B">QL<=;D<9?*B>@*C;=D>@*B";LL>A@*<?D>=E=`;<?@*L=HL;RH>@*L9EK;<>?D*@";KH=>=*;K;?D;G>E@>@*L9E=*A>@*C9?@9::;D>E=@S*,?*>II>DF*C>@*B>=?<>=@*9?D*;<?@<*;CCY@*T*B>*D=Y@*I;<`A>@*D;=<I@*9E*T*E?*D>:L@*B>*C9?K>=@;D<9?*<AA<:<DH*L>?B;?D*E?>*C9E=D>*LH=<9B>S*79E=*C>DD>*=;<@9?F*>D*B;?@*A"<?DH=OD*B>@*C9?@9::;D>E=@F*;ECE?*C9?D=fA>*Z;ED=>*NE"E?>*:><AA>E=>*B<KEAG;D<9?*B>*A"<?I9=:;D<9?^*?";*HDH*=>C9::;?BHS*7;=*C9?D=>F*A>@*I9=I;<D@*B>*@>=K<C>@*@;?@*I<A*L=HL;RH@*C9:L9=D>?D*GH?H=;A>:>?D*B>@*LH=<9B>@*B">QL<=;D<9?*;@@>g*C9E=D>@*L;=*=;LL9=D*;EQ*;ED=>@*@>=K<C>@*L=HL;RH@F*>D*C>F*@;?@*;ECE?*;K;?D;G>*9E*<?C<D;D<I*;LL;=>?D*L9E=*A>@*C9?@9::;D>E=@*>?*C9?D=>L;=D<>*B>*C>@*:9B;A<DH@*B">QL<=;D<9?*A<:<DH>@S*!>@*C9?@9::;D>E=@*A>@*LAE@*@9EC<>EQ*B>@*C9hD@*9?D*9LDH*ZB;?@*E?>*L=9L9=D<9?*B>*6V*i^*L9E=*B>@*@>=K<C>@*@;?@*I<A*L=HL;RH@*;I<?*B>*A<:<D>=*9E*B>*=HBE<=>*A>@*C9hD@S*%=F*A>E=*@9AB>*>@D*=;:>?H*T*gH=9*CJ;NE>*:9<@*T*:9<?@*NE"<A@*;CC>LD>?D*B";CJ>D>=*B;K;?D;G>*B>*D>:L@*B>*C9?K>=@;D<9?S*

4S !>@*@>=K<C>@*@;?@*I<A*L=HL;RH@F*C9::>*A>@*;LL>A@*<?D>=E=`;<?@*L=HL;RH@F*@9?D*;@@9=D<@*B>*L9A<D<NE>@*B">QL<=;D<9?*B<IIH=>?D>@*>?*D;?D*NE>*L=9BE<D*9E*@>=K<C>*L=HL;RH*@>A9?*A>@*A9<@*L=9K<?C<;A>@*>?*K<GE>E=S*

Page 64: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

!

!"#$%&'"(#)"#*&+#,-#).#/.01"2#$%&$&3"#)"#%"4%&.$"%#2"#(5$"#)"#3"%6+2"3#)783#.8#9"83":1*"#)"#3"%6+2"3#$%0$7503;<#=%>#'.3?.@+2+>#*"3#*&+3#$%&6+82+7*"3#3":1*"8(#5#7**"%#7.#2&.$#$7%#2&.$#A#*@047%)#)"#2"#?.+#2&83(+(."#"8#B7+(#.8#3"%6+2"#87(+&87*<#!"3#$%&).+(3#3783#B+*#87(+&87.C#)"6%7+"8(#D(%"#733&%(+3#)"#2&8)+(+&83#.8+B&%:"3#A#*@02E"**"#).#:7%2E0#2787)+"8<#

F< !"#G.%"7.#)"#*7#2&83&::7(+&8#)"6%7+(#"C7:+8"%#*7#$%7(+?."#2&.%78(">#"8#:7(+H%"#)"#6"8("#7.#)0(7+*#)"#3"%6+2"3#3783#B+*#$%0$7503>#?.+#2&83+3("#A#$"%:"((%"#*7#6"8("#)"#2"3#$%&).+(3#)@.8"#).%0"#*+:+(0"#$7%7**H*":"8(#A#*7#6"8("#)"#27%("3#27)"7.C#&.#)"#27%("3#$%0$750"3#)@.8"#).%0"#+**+:+(0"<#I"(("#$%7(+?."#2&.%78("#"3(#3&.%2"#)"#2&8B.3+&8#$&.%#*"3#2&83&::7(".%3<#

J< !"3#.(+*+37(".%3#)"#3"%6+2"3#3783#B+*#$%0$7503#3&8(#$%0&22.$03#$7%#*"3#B%7+3#272E03#)783#.8"#$%&$&%(+&8#)"#KL#M>#"(#$*.3#)"#J-#M#)@"8(%"#".C#8"#376"8(#$73#"C72(":"8(#2"#?."#2&.6%"8(#*".%3#B%7+3#:"83."*3<#N*3#2%&+"8(#$75"%#)"3#B%7+3#)@722H3#$&.%#)"3#3"%6+2"3#3783#B+*#$%0$7503#)783#.8"#$%&$&%(+&8#)"#OP#M#7*&%3#?.@"8#B7+(>#*"3#B&.%8+33".%3#8"#B72(.%"8(#$73#)"#("*3#B%7+3#$&.%#2"#(5$"#)"#3"%6+2"3<#N*#"3(#06+)"8(#?."#*"3#B%7+3#)"#3"%6+2"#2&88"C"3#"84"8)%"8(#)"#*7#2&8B.3+&8#2E"Q#*"3#2&83&::7(".%3<#

O< R7%:+#*"3#?.7(%"#$%+82+$7*"3#27(04&%+"3#)"#$*7+8("3#A#*@047%)#)"3#3"%6+2"3#3783#B+*#$&3($7503>#&8#%"(%&.6"#*"3#"%%".%3#)"#B72(.%7(+&8>#*"3#2&8B*+(3#%"*7(+B3#A#*7#%03+*+7(+&8#)"#2&8(%7(>#*"3#*72.8"3#).#3"%6+2"#A#*7#2*+"8(H*"#"(#*7#:&)+B+27(+&8#)"3#2&8)+(+&83<#I"3#27(04&%+"3#%"$%03"8("8(#PO#M#)"#*@"83":1*"#)"3#$*7+8("3#3&.:+3"3#7.#I&::+337+%"#7.C#$*7+8("3#%"*7(+6"3#7.C#3"%6+2"3#)"#(0*02&::.8+27(+&83#SIRTUVW<#

,< 9!@+8'.3(+2";#"3(#.8#(EH:"#2&.%78(#$7%:+#(&.("3#*"3#27(04&%+"3#)"#$*7+8("3<#I"*7#3.44H%"#?."#*"3#2&83&::7(".%3#&8(#*@+:$%"33+&8#?."#*"3#%H4*"3#).#'".#3&8(#+8047*"3#"(#B76&%+3"8(#*"3#B&.%8+33".%3>#3.%(&.(#"8#2"#?.+#7#(%7+(#7.C#2&8B*+(3#%"*7(+B3#A#*7#%03+*+7(+&8#)"#2&8(%7(#"(#A#*7#:&)+B+27(+&8#)"3#2&8)+(+&83<#

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

\< R*.3#)"#P-#M#)"3#%0$&8)78(3#7.#3&8)74"#3.%#*"3#3"%6+2"3#$&3($7503#&8(#)02%+(#*".%#)"4%0#)"#37(+3B72(+&8#2&::"#203+)#SF,#MW#&.##0)#SFO#MW<#U.%#*"#$*78#).#%7(+&#$%+C]67*".%>#*"3#%0$&8)78(3#7.#3&8)74"#).#RNZ#&8(#7((%+1.0#*7#8&("#203+)#SFY#MW#&.#45%#$+#SFJ#MW#A#*".%#B&.%8+33".%<#

K-< #!"3#2"8(%"3#)"#3"%6+2"#A#*7#2*+"8(H*"#"C72"%1"8(#3&.6"8(#*"3#$*7+8("3#"(#*"3#$%&1*H:"3#)"3#2*+"8(3#"8#%7+3&8#).#:78?."#)@.8+B&%:+(0#)"#*".%3#$%7(+?."3#"(#)"3#%"83"+48":"8(3#?.@+*3#B&.%8+33"8(<#

^8#8&.3#7$$.578(#3.%#2"3#2&82*.3+&83>#8&.3#B&%:.*&83#*"3#%"2&::78)7(+&83#3.+678("3#[#

Page 65: C2010Wireless Reportv7 kw - Consumers Council of Canada · ";

!

• !"#$%&%'%('%)"#$*+,-+"##%)"#$."$*+,'"/'%,&$."#$/,&#,00('"1+#2$/,00"$/"33"#$*+,*,#4"#$.(&#$3"$*+,5"'$."$3,%$67$.1$8149"/2$.")+(%"&'$:'+"$3(&/4"#$;$3<4/="33"$&('%,&(3">$!(&#$1&$*+"0%"+$'"0*#2$3"$?1+"(1$."$3($/,&#,00('%,&$*,1++(%'$#<(.+"##"+$;$3<@##,/%('%,&$/(&(.%"&&"$."#$'434/,001&%/('%,&#$#(&#$A%3$B@CDEF$"&$)1"$."$31%$*+,*,#"+$."#$*,3%'%G1"#$(043%,+4"#$"'$1&%A,+0"#$"&$/"$G1%$($'+(%'$(1H$#"+)%/"#$#(&#$A%3$*+4*(I4#$"'$*,#'*(I4#$"'$(%&#%$*"+0"''+"$3<(1',+4-3"0"&'('%,&$.1$#"/'"1+>$

•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

• R"#$%&%'%('%)"#$*+,)%&/%(3"#$B/,00"$3"$*+,5"'$."$3,%$67$.1$8149"/F$.")+(%"&'$:'+"$+")1"#$"'2$(1$9"#,%&2$,+/="#'+4"#$*(+$3"$-,1)"+&"0"&'$A4.4+(3$4'(&'$.,&&4$G1"$3($*31*(+'$."#$#"+)%/"#$#(&#$A%3$#,&'$."$&('1+"$&('%,&(3"$"'$G1"$',1#$3"#$/,&#,00('"1+#$/(&(.%"&#$.")+(%"&'$94&4A%/%"+$.<1&"$*+,'"/'%,&$4G1%'(93">$

• R"#$/,&#,00('"1+#$.,%)"&'$#(),%+$G1"2$3,+#G1<%3#$#%-&"&'$1&$/,&'+('$."$'434*=,&%"$/"3313(%+"2$%3#$&"$94&4A%/%"&'$*(#$."#$0:0"#$*+,'"/'%,&#$G1"$3,+#G1<%3#$"AA"/'1"&'$1&$#%0*3"$(/=('$(1$.4'(%3>$R"#$/,&#,00('"1+#$.,%)"&'$A(%+"$3"1+$*(+'$"&$#<%&A,+0(&'$#1+$3"$0,."$."$A,&/'%,&&"0"&'$."#$#"+)%/"#$#(&#$A%3$()(&'$."$*+"&.+"$1&$"&-(-"0"&'>$R"$?1+"(1$."$3($/,&#,00('%,&$.")+(%'$4)(31"+$#%$3"$/,&'+('$1&%3('4+(3$'I*"$.")+(%'$/,&#'%'1"+$3($&,+0"$*"+0%#"$*,1+$3<"&#"093"$."#$C(&(.%"&#>$

• R"#$A,1+&%##"1+#$.")+(%"&'$*+4#"&'"+$."#$+"&#"%-&"0"&'#$1&%A,+0"#$(1H$/,&#,00('"1+#2$"'$/"2$.1$*,%&'$."$)"&'"$51#G1S(1$/"&'+"$.<(**"3#$.(&#$3"$/(.+"$."$3<"H*4+%"&/"$(*+L#T)"&'">$J3$"#'$"##"&'%"3$.<(),%+$."#$#'+1/'1+"#$."$A(/'1+('%,&$"'$."#$,AA+"#$*+,0,'%,&&"33"#$/3(%+"0"&'$.4A%&%"#$"&$)1"$."$A(),+%#"+$1&"$9,&&"$/%+/13('%,&$."$3<%&A,+0('%,&$"&'+"$3"#$."1H$*(+'%"#>$

•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

• R"$CXYED$/,&#'%'1"$1&$/(&(3$"AA%/(/"$*,1+$3($+4#,31'%,&$."#$*3(%&'"#$"'$1&$*+4/%"1H$+4A4+"&'%"3$.<"&5"1H$/,&/"+&(&'$3"#$/,&#,00('"1+#$/(&(.%"&#>$R"#$*(+'%"#$%&'4+"##4"#$.")+(%"&'$%&)"#'%+$.(&#$3<(043%,+('%,&$."#$1'%3%'(%+"#$."$9(#"$."$.,&&4"#$"'$.(&#$3($/('4-,+%#('%,&$."#$"&5"1H$(A%&$."$0%"1H$4)(31"+$3"#$"&5"1H$3%4#$(1H$#"+)%/"#$#(&#$A%3$"'$3"#$*+,-+L#$."$3"1+#$0"09+"#$"&$)1"$."$3"#$+4#,1.+">$