Upload
sj293
View
224
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
1/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
IND IAN BROKING INDUSTRY:Poised For Growth 17th August 2009
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
2/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
Table of Contents
Process Flow Chart 03
Business Model 04
Parameter Evaluation Chart.. 05
Final Recommendations. 07
Overview of Indian Broking Sector
Introduction.. 08
Market Capitalization/GDP... 16
Value of Share Trading. 17
Turnover Velocity... 18
Household Sector Financial Savings.. 19
Valuations Comparative. 21
Outlook. 22
Motilal Oswal Financial Services Limited (MSOL)... 23
India Infoline Financial L imited. 26
Geojit BNP Paribas Limited 29Disclaimer.. 32
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
3/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
Process Flow
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
4/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
We analyzed the companies according to their presence in various segments represented in the graph
below and finally selected few companies which we believe are the leaders in these segments and can
gain substantial market share over a period of time.
Exhibit: Business Verticals
Broking & Distribution Wealth Management
Equities & D er ivatives Investment Advisory
Commodities PM S
Currency Private Equity
Depository Services Fixed Deposits
Research
Insurance & Mutual Fund
IPO
Financing
Inv e s tment Ba nkingInstitutional Equities
Arbitrage
Financial
Products
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
5/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
The various segment found during the analysis of business models of the companies are provided in thetable below:
Companies having presence in traditional brokerage segment
Companies having prsesnce in future growth driver segment
Equities Commodity Financing Research Insurance Mutua l Fund
Motilal Oswal Y Y Y Y Y Y
Edelweiss Capital Y Y Y Y Y Y
Geojit BNP Paribus Y N Y Y Y YIndia Infoline Y Y Y Y Y Y
Religare Enterprises Y Y Y Y Y Y
Emkay Global Financial Y Y Y Y Y Y
Indiabulls Securities Y Y Y Y N Y
JM Financial Y Y Y Y N Y
LKP Finance Y Y Y Y Y Y
Alka Securities Y Y N Y N Y
CompaniesSelection Grounds
Instutional
Equities
Investment
Banking
Wealth
ManagementPMS
Private
EquityCurrency
Motilal Oswal Y Y Y Y Y Y
Edelweiss Capital Y Y Y Y N Y
Geojit BNP Paribus Y Y Y Y N Y
India Infoline Y Y Y Y N Y
Religare Enterprises Y Y Y Y Y Y
Emkay Global Financial Y Y Y Y N Y
Indiabulls Securities Y Y Y Y N Y
JM Financial Y Y Y Y Y Y
LKP Finance Y Y N Y N Y
Alka Securities Y N N N N Y
Companies
Selection Grounds
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
6/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
Here we carried out the ratio analysis of the companies, based on our financial parameters. Afteranalyzing the financial parameters, we gave our recommendations on three (3) companies
Ratios which were analyzed are:
Debt Equity Ratio
Interest Coverage Ratio
Return on Capital Employed (ROCE)
Return on Equity (ROE)
P/E Ratio (TTM Basis)
P/BVPS
Other financial parameters that were considered are:
Avg. Market Capitalization/Sales (TTM Basis)
Avg. Market Capitalization/Customer Base
Avg. Market Capitalization/Total number of branches
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
7/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
Ratio Analysis Sheet
The competition in the financial services industry space has been intensified with competition from large
brands with well capitalized balance sheets and financial parameters. The smaller players will soon face
the heat of this intensifying competition in the industry with larger players would further gain market share.
After analyzing the financial parameters, we gave our recommendations on the following three (3)
Companies.
Given the fact that because of the rise in global equity markets the prices of the mentioned stocks have
already gone up by an average of 150% in last 6 months, one can make an initial small investment and
then add on dips. The SIP form of investment with equal weight on the three stocks is also a feasible way
to invest.
Company View
Motilal Oswal Financial Services Ltd BUY
India Infoline Ltd BUY
Geojit BNP Paribas Financial Services Ltd HOLD
Motilal
Oswal
Edelweiss
Capital
Geojit BNP
Paribas
India
Infoline
Religare
Enterprises
JM
Financial
Debt/Equity Ratio 1 1 1 0 0 1
Interest Coverage Ratio 1 0 1 1 0 1
ROCE 1 1 0 1 0 0
ROE 1 0 1 0 1 0
P/E Ratio (TTM) 1 1 1 0 0 0
Price/BVPs 0 1 0 1 0 1Avg. Market Cap/Sales (TTM) 0 1 0 1 1 0
Avg. Market Cap/Total Customers 1 0 1 1 0 0
Avg. Market Cap/Branches 1 0 1 1 1 0
Financial Parameters
Companies
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
8/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
IntroductionIndia is one of the oldest stock markets in the world with a strong presence of domestic and loca
intermediation. Stock markets in India surged over a decade on back of a wide range of economic
reforms, liberalization of financial markets buoyed by greater freedom and flexibility.
Some of the fundamental changes that fuelled rapid pace of market growth was the introduction of
electronic trading (secondary markets), allowing foreign ownership (FIIs) of shares, permitting Indian
companies to raise capital from abroad (ADRs/GDRs), expansion in the product range (equities
commodity, currency, derivatives and debt), book building process and transparency in IPO issuance, T+2
settlement cycle, dematerialization of shares and internet trading (e-broking). These changes resulted in
dramatic growth of the stock markets in India as well as the equity broking firms. The broking industry is
emerging as a rapidly growing segment in Indian finance, in terms of business growth, distribution &
network and enterprise value.
The first signs of trouble appeared in the US and Western Europe in August 2007. Indian economy kept
growing at a considerable pace till the middle of 2008. The Indian market continued to rise till January
2008 and appeared to be going through a relatively mild correction till the middle of 2008. It was in
September 2008 that Lehman filed for bankruptcy and the whole world was shaken. The credit markets
froze in the west and Indian corporate which were accessing western credit markets found their credit
drying up and therefore, wanted to borrow in India. Our markets went through a period of unusual liquiditysqueeze with its attendant impact on interest rates, foreign exchange rates, and mutual funds till liquidity
was restored through aggressive steps (stimulus package) by the Central Bank and Government.
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
9/32
8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
10/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
Market Capitalization & TurnoverThe market capitalization of BSE was up by 37.23% from Rs. 3,545,041.0 cr as on December 2007 to Rs.
4,865,044.91 cr as on May 2009. The market capitalization of NSE was up by 35.55% from Rs
3,367,350.0 cr as on December 2007 to Rs. 4,564,572.18 cr as on May 2009.
Business has been exceptionally good in primary and secondary markets, in the equities and derivatives
segments across both the national level stock exchanges. Indias combined turnover in NSE and BSE in
the equity segment which was around Rs. 2,901,471 cr in the year 2006-2007 has grown 1.33 times to Rs.
3,852,097 cr in the year 2008-2009, despite the market fallen by approximately ~50% in the same year
The derivate segment during the same period has gone up by 1.50 times to Rs. 11,010,482 cr.
Particulars 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009 Apr-09 May-09
Market Capitalisation
BSE 3,545,041.00 5,138,014.13 3,086,075.17 3,586,977.71 4,865,044.91NSE 3,367,350.00 4,858,121.72 2,896,194.22 3,375,024.63 4,564,572.18
Gross Turnover
BSE 9,56,186.00 15,78,855.29 11,00,073.70 88,942.92 1,28,541.70
NSE 19,45,285.00 35,51,038.00 27,52,022.98 2,66,696.50 3,82,560.99
NSE Derivatives 7,356,271.00 13,090,478.00 11,010,482.00 56,210,317.00 48,285,515.00
Source: SEBI
Figures in CroresExhibit: Major Indicators of Stock Markets
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
11/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
The contribution of retail volumes has declined from 61% in FY08 to 55% FY09; the retail contribution ratiohas been more volatile than the other two market segments while the contribution of institutional volumes,
i.e. volumes from FIIs and domestic institutional investors (DIIs) such as mutual funds, banks and
insurance companies has remained stable at 15% for FY08 and FY09. The contribution of proprietary
volumes, which include arbitrage and other proprietary volumes of stock brokers, has increased from 24%
in FY08 to 30% in FY09.
Primary Market
Primary markets too performed very robust over a period of last three years. During the period 2006-2009
capital mobilized through public issues, rights issues and qualified institutional placements (QIB) reached
Rs. 167,431 cr in 295 issues, highest being witnessed in the year 2007-2008 when Rs.112,554 cr were
mobilized from the primary markets. The same trend is likely to follow in coming years as various
companies had planned to raise capital either through initial public issue (IPO) or via QIB routes to fund
their future expansion projects.
Source: NSE & BSE
Exhibit: Segmental Mix of total volumes (NSE & BSE combined)
FY2008
24%
11%
4%
61%
Propietary FII' s DII's Retail
FY2009
30%
10%5%
55%
Propietary FII' s DII's Retail
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
12/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
Demat Accounts
The number of demat accounts in the country shows the depth of equity penetration. CDSL and NSDL
together have over 15 million active demat accounts, registering a compounded annual growth rate of
23% over a period of nine years (FY00-FY09).
E x h i b i t : D e m a n t A c c o u n t s ( C D S L & N S D L ) o v e r F Y 0 0 - F Y 0 9
S o u r ce : C D S L & N S D L
D e m a t A c c o u n t s
2.353 .5 3.85 4.04
5.84
7.31
9.1110.27
14.1715.21
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
F Y 0 0 F Y 01 F Y 0 2 F Y 0 3 F Y 0 4 F Y 05 F Y 0 6 F Y 0 7 F Y 08 F Y 0 9
(InMillions)
Exhibit: Funds Mobilised in the Primary Market
Particulars 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009 Apr-09 May-09
Public Issue 29,796 54,511 3,582 0 0
Right Issue 3,710 32,518 12,637 0 9
QIB 4,963 25,525 189 1,621 2,657
Figures in Crores
Source: SEBI
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
13/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
FIIs
FIIs were allowed to invest in India since 1991 when the economy opened up. Since, then the total FIIsinvestments in domestic equities have crossed the US$ 60 bn (till July 2009). The bull run which started
in the year 2003-2004, lasted till mid of year 2008, registered a net FIIs investment to the tune of Rs.
230,176 cr while, the year 2008-2009 reported the biggest ever FIIs sell-off for the Indian markets. FIIs
sell of Rs. 45,881 cr during the same period accounting for ~15% sell-off of the total FIIs investment
(equity + debt) since 1991. October and January were two carnage months, where US$ 3.8 bn and US$
3.2 billion, respectively, were sold.
With the economic outlook improving globally, global majors are finding a way to buck the downtrend by
investing in India. In FY2009-10 alone (as on July 2009), India has received about Rs. 44,484.30 cr of FIIs
money, accounting ~20% of total FIIs inflow into the emerging markets.
Source: SEBI, * Till July 2009
Exhibit: Trend in FIIs Investment in India
FIIs Investment
-60000
-45000
-30000
-15000
0
15000
30000
45000
60000
75000
FY1994
FY1995
FY1996
FY1997
FY1998
FY1999
FY2000
FY2001
FY2002
FY2003
FY2004
FY2005
FY2006
FY2007
FY2008
FY2009
FY2010*
Rs.
Crores
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
14/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
Mutual Funds
Due to the overall slowdown in global economy on account of collapse of the US sub-prime mortgage
market, the liquidity squeezed from both the global and domestic financial markets. Indian economy too
was affected with withdrawal of liquidity from markets, resulting in a steep fall. Subsequently, domestic
factors like rising inflation, increasing interest rates, rising fiscal deficit (due to ever-increasing crude /
commodity prices and subsidies) and prospects of an economic slowdown took over.
The Indian stock market lost more than half its value last year and closed in the red for the first time in the
seven years, becoming one of the worst performers in Asia in 2008. As a result, fund houses faced
redemption pressure from the Indian incorporate resulting in the asset under management (AUM) to
decline by 21% y-o-y to Rs. 417,300 cr for the financial year ended FY2009.
AUM of mutual funds in India is about 6% of GDP; in other emerging countries such as Brazil, with similar
GDP size, this is about 40%, and in developed nations such as USA, it is 79%.
Year/Month Equity Debt Total
2009-2010 (April-July) 41,521.70 2,962.60 44,484.30
Apr-09 6,508.20 2,490.30 8,998.50
May-09 20,117.20 (2,711.40) 17,405.80
Jun-09 3,830.00 1,068.30 4,898.30
Jul-09 11066.3 2115.4 13,181.70
Exhibit: Investment by FIIs Figures in Crores
Source: SEBI
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
15/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
With the economic outlook improving, the market is likely to perform well going forward. In FY2009 til
date, the mutual funds invested a total of Rs. 81,847.90 cr, of which Rs. 4,994.70 cr was invested in equityand Rs. 81,487.90 was invested in debt. The AUM for the month ended July 2009 improved by 65.33% to
Rs. 689,946.10 cr as compared to Rs. 417,00 cr reported for the financial year ended FY2009.
Source: SEBI, * Till July 2009
Exhibit: Trend in Mutual Fund Investment in IndiaMutual Fund Investment
-20000
020000
40000
60000
80000
100000
120000
140000
160000
180000
FY1999
FY2000
FY2001
FY2002
FY2003
FY2004
FY2005
FY2006
FY2007
FY2008
FY2009
FY2010*
Rs.Crores
0
100000
200000
300000
400000
500000
600000
700000
800000
Total AUM
Year/M onth Equity Debt Tota l
2009-2010 (April-M ay) 4,994.70 76,493.20 81,487.90
Apr-09 38.60 26,422.50 26,461.10
M ay-09 2,291.30 10,368.00 12,659.30Jun-09 839.30 10,739.50 11,578.80
Jul-09 1825.5 28963.2 30,788.70
Exhibit : Investment by Mutual Funds Figures in Crores
Source: SEBI
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
16/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
Market Capitalization/GDPIndias GDP of US$ 1,176.89 billion is just 2.15 percent of World GDP of US$ 54,583.78 billion as on
August 5th, 2009. Market cap as a percentage to GDP in India is 0.91 times despite growing above 6.0%
against US and UK which commands 0.87 and 0.97 times respectively during recessionary times and
China commanding 1.09 times despite being a communist country. With host of IPOs in pipeline and
PSUs to get listed, the market cap of India is bound to see a sharp increase in future. Market
capitalization as a percent of gross domestic product, which was about 25% in the early 2000s, now
almost equals the GDP. Several leading emerging economies enjoy a market capitalization as a multiple
of GDP.
Exhibit : Market Capitalization/GDP Figures in US$ Billion
Country GDP Market Capitalization Market Cap/GDP
Taiwan 355.46 589.408 1.66
Australia 820.97 1029.243 1.25
China 3,205.51 3480.02 1.09Canada 1,329.88 1419.052 1.07
United Kingdom 2,772.02 2690.862 0.97
South Korea 769.79 710.479 0.92
India 1,176.89 1075.633 0.91
United States 13,751.40 12023.586 0.87
Brazil 1,313.36 1051.593 0.80
Japan 4,384.26 3501.899 0.80France 2,589.84 1657.104 0.64
Germany 3,317.36 1279.015 0.39
Mexico 1,022.82 306.891 0.30
Italy 2,101.64 624.154 0.30
Source: Bloomberg
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
17/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
Value of Share TradingThe value of share trading is the total number of shares traded multiplied by their respective matching
prices. Indias value of share trading (NSE + BSE) constitutes only 1.52% of world total value of share
trading despite having a large population base, well governed companies, largest democracy and second
fastest growing economy.
Exhibit: Value of Share Trading
Exchanges 2009* 2008 2007NASDAQ OMX 14,722,742.41 36,446,548.50 28,116,428.20
NYSE Euronext (US) 9,528,245.51 33,638,937.00 29,113,786.70
Shanghai SE 2,136,688.28 2,600,208.56 4,028,590.30
Tokyo SE 1,977,035.25 5,607,321.90 6,412,700.80
London SE 1,803,766.09 6,271,520.64 10,333,685.88
Shenzhen SE 1,105,019.34 1,248,721.80 2,046,013.76
NYSE Euronext (Europe) 896,320.86 4,411,248.70 5,639,760.70
Korea Exchange 750,429.70 1,432,479.94 2,005,640.78Hong Kong Exchanges 680,378.85 1,629,782.28 2,133,642.96
Taiwan SE Corp. 420,066.18 829,612.20 1,010,039.51
Borsa Italiana 419,361.50 1,499,456.52 2,311,193.98
SIX Swiss Exchange 400,361.51 1,500,366.49 1,883,261.91
NASDAQ OMX Nordic Exchange 378,752.45 1,338,181.11 1,818,207.57
Australian SE 369,151.29 1,213,239.58 1,371,744.92
National Stock Exchange India 343,249.04 725,398.65 751,333.02
Johannesburg SE 147,885.84 395,235.21 423,384.91
Bombay SE 117,137.95 301,648.28 343,775.81
Source: WFE, * Till June 2009
Figures in US$ Million
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
18/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
Turnover VelocityThe turnover velocity is the ratio between the turnover of domestic shares and their market capitalization
Indias turnover velocity as on June 2009 was about 86.6% (NSE) which is way below when compared to
the developed markets and its Asian peers. South Korea and Taiwan commands more than double the
Indias turnover velocity despite having lesser number of businesses, population and growth.
Exchange Jun-09 2008 2007NASDAQ OMX 1242.6% 1026.5% 625.2%
Shenzhen SE 334.0% 235.9% 389.2%
Korea Exchange 248.8% 196.3% 192.6%
NYSE Euronext (US) 228.4% 240.2% 166.9%
Shanghai SE 170.6% 118.2% 211.0%
Borsa Italiana 166.6% 182.3% 204.1%
BME Spanish Exchanges 164.5% 171.4% 191.9%
Taiwan SE Corp. 162.5% 145.5% 153.3%
Tokyo SE 145.9% 151.2% 138.4%
London SE 137.9% 152.7% 154.2%
NASDAQ OMX Nordic Exchange 134.1% 138.0% 137.0%
NYSE Euronext (Europe) 120.6% 141.8% 136.9%
SIX Swiss Exchange 116.0% 121.8% 133.9%
TSX Group 111.8% 103.8% 83.7%
Australian SE 103.5% 113.0% 101.6%
Hong Kong Exchanges 88.6% 86.0% 94.1%
National Stock Exchange India 86.6% 75.7% 67.7%
Exhibit : Turnover Velocity
Source: WFE
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
19/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
Household Sector Financial SavingsIndians presence in equity markets including government securities, units of mutual funds and other
securities is just ~8.0% compared to more than 60% in US, speaking out loud on the prospects on the
equity penetration in this country.
Favorable demography and income age would drive consumption in the coming years. The working age
population is expected to grow from 62.9% in year 2006 to 68.3% in year 2025 with total Indias population
is expected to be 138 cr by year 2025 (Source: NCAER). The India per capita income in US$ terms is
expected to grow by ~30 times in the next 40 years, with maximum of population would be in the age
bracket of 15-64 years.
(In Percent)
Financial Asset FY2004 (P) FY2005 (P) FY2006 (P) FY2007 (P) FY2008 (#)
Currency 11.20 8.50 8.90 8.60 10.90
Fixed Investment Investments 81.60 85.40 83.70 84.50 80.50
Deposits 38.80 37.00 47.00 55.30 56.50
Insurance/Provident/Pension Funds 27.30 28.90 24.50 24.10 25.70
Small Savings 15.50 19.50 12.20 5.10 (1.70)
Securities Market 7.50 6.00 7.40 6.90 8.50
Mutual Funds 1.20 0.40 3.80 5.20 7.70
Government Securities 7.50 4.90 2.40 0.20 (2.00)
Other Securities (1.20) 0.70 1.20 1.50 2.80
Exhibit : Savings of Household Sector in Financial Assets
Source: RBI, (P): Provisional, (#): Preliminary Estimates
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
20/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
The Capgemini report on Asia-Pacific Wealth 2008 highlights India and China as key investmentdestinations for high net worth individuals (HNWIs) worldwide. It mentions that in CY07, the standout
markets in the Asia-Pacific region were China and India, with the number of wealthy individuals, and their
overall level of wealth growing at a faster rate than the global averages. In CY07, the Indian market
experienced the largest increases in HNWI wealth and population size in the region. The Emerging-HNWI,
HNWI and Ultra-HNWI populations in India increased to 167,000 - a 23% increase from the previous year.
Compared with other investors in the Asia- Pacific, HNWIs in India (36%) allocated the highest percentage
to equities (after Australia - 38%).
Exhibit :Growth of HNWI's in various countries (Asia-Pacific Region)
Source: Data for 2007 from Capgemini Lorenz curve analysis, 2008
Growth of HNWI's
0.00%
5.00%
10.00%
15.00%
20.00%
25.00%
30.00%
Vietn
am
In
dia
Ch
ina
So
uth
Ko
rea
Indonesia
Singap
ore
Hong
Kong
Taiw
an
Austr
alia
Japan
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
21/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
Valuations Comparative
Current 2009E 2010E Current 2009E 2010E
Brazil 56,038.07 2,419.61 3,864.69 4,976.74 23.16 14.50 11.26
Nikkei 10,252.53 - 220.67 432.41 - 46.46 23.71
China 3,598.98 96.28 138.26 167.39 37.38 26.03 21.50Hong Kong 20,494.77 993.93 1,151.39 1,377.34 20.62 17.80 14.88
India (Sensex) 15,903.83 840.14 845.50 1,011.69 18.93 18.81 15.72
Korea 1,559.47 47.26 111.55 149.95 33.00 13.98 10.40
Malaysia 1,179.49 57.34 67.94 77.96 20.57 17.36 15.13
Mexico 2,786.92 161.28 175.17 202.98 17.28 15.91 13.73
Taiwan 6,848.24 79.06 284.40 428.28 86.62 24.08 15.99Thailand 640.16 28.13 53.57 61.44 22.76 11.95 10.42
Dow Jones 9,230.19 688.82 625.35 736.06 13.40 14.76 12.54
S&P 500 1,005.65 57.50 59.97 74.60 17.49 16.77 13.48
Nasdaq 2,011.31 59.49 80.71 112.99 33.81 24.92 17.80
FTSE 4,686.08 87.36 341.55 412.14 53.64 13.72 11.37
CAC 3,498.01 278.50 279.84 324.19 12.56 12.50 10.79DAX 5,420.51 134.30 339.42 451.33 40.36 15.97 12.01
Exhibit: Valuation Matrix
Source: Bloomberg, As on August 5th, 2009
P/E (X)Index Value
Earning Per Share (EPS)
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
22/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
OutlookEquity brokerage industry in India is going to experience a rapid growth in coming years, following the fact
that it is no more a brokerage business to offer. Over a period of years the broking companies has
diversified their business from brokerage offerings to a wide range of financial services, offering a range of
financial products and services, focused on wealth creation for their customers. A large distribution
network, uses of modern technology and wide range of product portfolio argues well for the established
players in the industry to gain market share both in the domestic as well as global markets.
India remains the second fastest growing economy in Asia and as per a report by Goldman Sachs could
become the fourth largest economy by 2025 and the third largest by 2050, behind only United States and
China. We expect markets to move up once it gets more visibility and confidence in FY10 earnings, which
will make the markets attractive with a medium term perspective. This should lead to improved FIIs
liquidity especially as India, despite the slow-down, is expected to be the second-fastest growing economy
with largest democracy, largest growing middle class and lowest per capita consumption across
commodities and services in the world argues well scope for future growth.
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
23/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
Motilal Oswal Financial Services Limited
BSE : 532892NSE : MOTILALOFSBloomberg : MOFS INCMP : 145.85Sector : Financial ServicesView : BUY
Key MetricsListing NSE/BSE
Current Price 145.85
Market Cap (Rs Crores) 2,071.43
Free Float (%) 29.63
52-WeeK High (Rs) 189.7
52-Week Low (Rs) 43.6
BETA 1.38
P/B (x) 2.62
Current P/E (x) 21.29
Face Value 1.00
PEG Ratio NA
Dividend Yield (%) 0.53
Price Performance (%)
Time Period Stock Nifty 50
1 Month -2.39 7.94
3 Month 24.79 23.50
1 Year 36.45 0.16
Shareholding Pattern (%)Promoter 70.37
Pledged 17.67
FII"s 3.28
DII's 7.57
Public 6.29Others 12.49
Company Background:
MOSL is a well-diversified, financial services company offering arange of financial products and services such as wealthmanagement, broking & distribution, commodity broking, portfoliomanagement services, institutional equities, private equity,investment banking services and principal strategies.
Investment Rationale:
The company has 486,751 retail clients as on June 30
th
, 2009and is also empanelled with more than 300 institutionalclients, including ~200 FIIs clients, which endeavours theirstrong brand presence.
MOSL key strength is its vast distribution reach with pan IndiaPresence. The company has a network of 1,308 businesslocations, spread across 555 cities and towns and has a totalclient base of more than 5,57,373 customers.
MOSL offers wide range of financial services. This creates an
integrated platform to sell financial services which therebyenables to cross sell the products.
ROE is likely to improve significantly as business growthstarts gaining momentum, with company has beenconsistently lowering its debt to equity ratio.
Key Risks:
Downturns or disruptions in securities market could reduce
transaction volumes, causing a decline in business.Revenues from operations arise largely during bullish phasein equity market which is not a consistent phenomenon.
Though MOSL is increasingly diversifying its revenue profile,it will continue to significantly depend on retail broking andmargin finance businesses for growth and earnings.
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
24/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
Source: Company
Exhibit: Trend in retail Clients
Retail Equity Broking Clients
3100060000
159091
238421
396388
471062 486571
0
100000
200000
300000
400000
500000
600000
FY04 FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 Q1FY10
Source: Company
Exhibit: PMS AUM
Asset Under Management
522
1821
5200 5089
7981
4767
6807
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
9000
FY04 FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 Q1FY10
I nM
i lli
o n
MOSL has registered a72.32% CAGR in its retailclient base over a period of 5years (FY04-FY09), owing to
its strong brand and largestdistribution network.
MOSL has registered a55.64% CAGR in its assetunder management over aperiod of 5 years (FY04-FY09). This indicates thecompany strongrelationship with HNIs andhigh credibility, resulting in
cross selling of products.
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
25/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
The company total income has declined during FY2009 as compared to FY2008, mainly on account ofdecline in the equity broking income which reported a fall of 40.0% y-o-y to Rs. 351.74 cr.
The company endeavor to diversify their revenue streams resulted in 30% of our revenue coming fromnon-broking businesses for the financial year ended FY2009 as compared to 20% reported in previousyear.
The company has negligible debt to equity ratio for the period ended FY09, indicating company able tomeet its working capital requirement through internal accruals.
The interest coverage ratio has significantly decline over years, though it is still at comfortable levels.
Exhibit : Financial Analysis
Particulars FY2009 FY2008 FY2007
Total Income 459.41 688.49 365.39
EBIDTA 173.98 258.53 134.56
EBIT 153.71 243.68 123.56
PBT 142.58 239.83 121.80
Reported PAT 89.60 170.62 68.44
Earning Per Share 6.31 11.51 6.43
EBIDTA (%) 37.87 37.55 36.83
EBIT (%) 33.46 35.39 33.82
NPM (%) 19.50 24.78 18.73
ROE (%) 11.29 24.06 20.54
ROCE (%) 19.26 28.21 36.59
Interest Coverage Ratio 8.61 16.35 31.36
Debt To Equity Ratio 0.00 0.20 0.00
Current Ratio 2.09 1.89 1.33
Source: Company
Figures in Crores
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
26/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
India Infoline Limited Company Background:
India Infoline is a well-diversified financial services company withpan India presence. The company has a network of 1,616business locations spread over 445 cities and towns, and hasmore than 676,107 customers with international presence inDubai, New York and Singapore.
Investment Rationale:
India Infoline has de-risked its revenue model by diversifyingits core business of equity broking to bouquet of financialservices. The company has a little over 55 percent of the totalrevenues coming from the equity brokerage business, theleast among listed broking companies
The company recently tie up with Interactive Brokers, LLC(USA) to provide its clients direct market access to over 80global exchanges in 18 countries. This will provide clients todiversify their portfolios with having exposure in globalmarkets.
Opportunity to scale up non fund based business, ascompany has re-commenced its mortgage business withbook size of Rs. 922 cr at the end of June 2009.
The company doesnt have much debt on its books. The debtequity ratio is a negligible at 0.03. It has repaid a substantialamount of debt in the last two years and has interestcoverage of 7.60 which shows that the company has strongfundamentals and can raise further debt to expand its
business
Key Risks:
An increasing number of players in the financial servicessector could lead to stiff competition, making customerretention and business growth a challenge.
BSE : 532636NSE : INDIAINFOBloomberg : IIFL INCMP : 127.00Sector : Financial ServicesView : BUY
Key MetricsListing NSE/BSE
Current Price 127.00
Market Cap (Rs Crores) 3,599.18
Free Float (%) 66.28
52-WeeK High (Rs) 173.25
52-Week Low (Rs) 34.40
BETA 2.09
P/B (x) 2.33
Current P/E (x) 29.53
Face Value 2.00
PEG Ratio NA
Dividend Yield (%) 2.07
Price Performance (%)
Time Period Stock Nifty 50
1 Month 2.49 7.94
3 Month 40.29 23.50
1 Year -17.32 0.16
Shareholding Pattern (%)Promote 33.72
Pledged 0.16
FII"s 22.22
DII's 10.59
Public 13.17Others 20.3
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
27/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
Source: Company
Exhibit : Trend in retail Clients
Retail Equity Broking Clients
5500
75000
150000
438864
596056
676107
0
100000
200000
300000
400000
500000
600000
700000
800000
FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 Q1FY10
India Infoline hasregistered a robust222.65% CAGR in its retailclient base over a period of4 years (FY04-FY09),owing to its diversified
business model and a panIndia presence.
Source: Company
Exhibit : IIL Market Share
NSE Market Share
3.63
3.03
0
2
4
6
Jun-07 Sep-07 Dec-07 Mar-08 Jun-08 Sep-08 Dec-08 Mar-09 Jun-09
%
India Infoline has gainedNSE Market Share from3.03% reported in June2007, to 3.63% in June2009, an increase of 60basis points in a matter of
just 2 years. The companyis further going to gainNSE market share owing
to its high credibility andstrong business network.
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
28/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
The company total income has reported a CAGR of 159.54% over a period of four years (FY05-FY09),while the net profit witnessed a CAGR of 69.66% over the same period.
The company has been consistently lowering its debt to equity ratio, with maintaining current debt toequity ratio at negligible level.
The current ratio is above the industry peers while the ROCE and ROE has declined over years, owing to
the expansion taken over years and declined in the business on account of global slowdown
Exhibit : Financial Analysis
Particulars FY2009 FY2008 FY2007
Total Income 962.43 1023.5 425.72
EBIDTA 291.59 402.13 141.23
EBIT 251.99 373.93 126.31
PBT 219.47 282.75 114.6
Reported PAT 144.82 159.87 75.61
Earning Per Share 4.76 5 2.99EBIDTA (%) 30.30 39.29 33.17
EBIT (%) 26.18 36.53 29.67
NPM (%) 15.05 15.62 17.76
ROE (%) 9.38 10.74 23.26
ROCE (%) 13.20 15.28 24.92
Interest Coverage Ratio 7.60 4.09 10.79
Debt To Equity Ratio 0.03 0.45 0.55
Current Ratio 2.37 2.53 2.38
Source: Company
Figures in Crores
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
29/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
Geojit BNP Paribas Limited
Company Background:
Geojit BNP Paribas is a leading retail financial services companyin India. In the year 2007, Global banking major BNP Paribas tooka stake and thus become the single largest shareholder in thecompany.
Investment Rationale:
The company has 22 years of in-depth broking experience inthe Indian Capital Maret with pan India presence. The
company currently has more than 4.8 lakh clients and overRs. 8,400 cr (as of 30th, June 09) in Assets underManagement reflect the client trust in company expertise.
The company has formed strategic joint ventures andbusiness partnerships in the Middle East, which will furtherextend its services to the growing population of non-residentIndians. The company is also well positioned to furtherexpand its reach in 85 countries.
The company has also forayed into the property brokeragebusiness to meet the requirement for its clients and act as atrusted intermediary between customers and builders. Thusthe offering will help company to cross sell its products ascompany is backed by broking experience with credentialclient base.
The company is almost a debt free, which going forward willhelp them to raise funds at a cheaper rate to expandbusiness and meet working capital requirements.
Key Risks:
The company closed its commodities business andsurrendered its membership in the various commodityexchanges Thus; the revenue going forward will be impactedas company presently dont have any intention to start upcommodity brokerage business.
BSE : 532285NSE : GEOJITBNPPBloomberg : GSEC INCMP : 39.50Sector : Financial ServicesView : HOLD
Key MetricsListing NSE/BSE
Current Price 39.50Market Cap (Rs Crores) 882.48
Free Float (%) 36.31
52-WeeK High (Rs) 52.5
52-Week Low (Rs) 16.50
BETA 1.25
P/B (x) 2.88
Current P/E (x) 18.81
Face Value 1.00
PEG Ratio NA
Dividend Yield (%) 1.23
Price Performance (%)
Time Period Stock Nifty 50
1 Month 2.73 7.94
3 Month 40.57 23.50
1 Year -12.80 0.16
Shareholding Pattern (%)Promoter 63.69
Pledged 0.00
FII"s 2.34
DII's 0.00
Public 13.36Others 20.61
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
30/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
The company total income for the financial year ended FY09, reported a decline of 24.8% y-o-y to Rs.169.91 cr, mainly because of discontinuation of its commodities broking business. As a result thecompany reported a negative EBIT, while compensation of Rs. 40 cr received from BNP Paribas for thesame included as exceptional gain resulting in reporting a positive PAT for the year ended FY09.
The company is almost a debt free, which going forward will help them to raise funds at a cheaper rate toexpand business and meet working capital requirements.
ROE has kept on deteriorating and has gone done very low. The main reason for this is that assets havekept on increasing tremendously.
ROCE has come down to a negative of 5.2% in 2009. The decline in ROCE is mainly attributable to adiscontinuation of its commodity business which computed a major chunk to the net income in theprevious years
Exhibit : Financial Analysis
Particulars FY2009 FY2008 FY2007
Total Income 169.91 225.77 131.22
EBIDTA 2.88 77.7 40.64
EBIT -8.83 70.82 35.45
PBT 12.18 82.75 37.79
Reported PAT 40.19 58.66 25.21
Earning Per Share 1.83 2.69 1.63
EBIDTA (%) 1.70 34.42 30.97
EBIT (%) -5.20 31.37 27.02
NPM (%) 23.65 25.98 19.21
ROE (%) 12.16 22.36 11.43
ROCE (%) -5.23 60.63 22.73
Interest Coverage Ratio -19.20 116.10 154.13
Debt To Equity Ratio 0.01 0.06 0.00
Current Ratio 1.62 1.40 1.84Source: Company
Figures in Crores
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
31/32
www.kredent.com [email protected]
Equity Research
Source: Company
E xhibit : T rend in retai l Clients
270756
436300465108 478598
0
100000
200000
300000
400000
500000
600000
FY07 FY08 FY09 Q1FY1
R et ail Equity Broking Clients
Geojit BNP Paribas hasregistered a robust114.42% CAGR in its retailclient base over a period of2 years (FY07-FY09),owing to its collaboration
with BNP Paribas and apan India presence.
http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/8/8/2019 brokingsec kredent 190809
32/32
Equity Research
Kredent Brokerage Services Limited
Member: National Stock Exchange (Cash, FO & Currency)Bombay Stock Exchange Limited (Cash & FO)
Disclaimer: This document is for private circulation only. Neither the information nor any opinion expressedconstitutes an offer or any invitation to make an offer, to buy or sell any securities or any options, futures orother derivatives related to such securities (related investment). Kredent Brokerage Services Limited (KBSL)or any of its Associates or employees does not accept any liability whatsoever direct or indirect that may arisefrom the use of the information herein. KBSL and its may trade for their own accounts as market maker, blockpositioner, specialist and/or arbitrageur in any security of this Issuer(s) or in related investments, and may be onthe opposite side of public orders. KBSL, its affiliates, directors, officers, employees and employee benefitprogrammes may have a long or short position in any securities of this Issuer(s) or in related investments. No
matter contained herein may be reproduced without prior consent of KBSL. While this report has been preparedon the basis of published/other publicly available information considered reliable, we are unable to accept anyliability for the accuracy of its contents.
4, Brabourne Road ; 4th Floor ; Kolkata 700001Ph: +91 033 2225 3783/4/5/6/7
Fax :+91 033 2225 [email protected]
www.kredent.com
mailto:[email protected]://www.kredent.com/http://www.kredent.com/mailto:[email protected]