Upload
pauline-peapod
View
52
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
KENSINGTON COLLEG OF BUSINESS AND UNIVERSITY OF WALES
BP Market Analysis and
Strategic Marketing
Recommendations In the USA after the Gulf of Mexico Oil spill
Nahid Mohsen Pour
2/28/2011
Contains: 2962 words
Without charts, content, references, tables
In this essay, I am performing Macro environmental analysis of BP business in the USA, after the gulf of
Mexico oil spill, and also try to give Strategic Marketing recommendations to recover from the so called
Marketing disaster in the USA market
Nahid Mohsen Pour
2
Table of Contents
Introduction ............................................................................................................................................ 4
Approach ............................................................................................................................................. 4
Importance of Marketing ..................................................................................................................... 4
Part I: Macro Environmental Analysis of BP business in the USA after the Gulf of Mexico Oil Spill ............ 5
Political Analysis .............................................................................................................................. 5
Economical Analysis ......................................................................................................................... 5
Social Analysis .................................................................................................................................. 6
Technological Analysis ..................................................................................................................... 6
Legal Analysis................................................................................................................................... 7
Environmental Analysis .................................................................................................................... 7
SWOT Analysis ..................................................................................................................................... 8
Strengths ......................................................................................................................................... 8
Weakness ........................................................................................................................................ 9
OPPORTUNITIES ............................................................................................................................... 9
THREATS .......................................................................................................................................... 9
Part II: Strategic marketing recommendations to BP to recover from Marketing disaster after the Gulf of
Mexico oil spill ....................................................................................................................................... 11
Industry Analysis (Porters Five Forces) .............................................................................................. 11
Industry rivalry............................................................................................................................... 12
Bargaining power of Suppliers ....................................................................................................... 13
Bargaining power of buyers ........................................................................................................... 13
Threats of new Entrants ................................................................................................................. 13
Threat of substitute products......................................................................................................... 14
Porter's Generic Competitive Strategies (ways of competing) ............................................................ 14
Ansoffs Model ...................................................................................................................................... 15
Marketing Mix Mc Carthy 4Ps ......................................................................................................... 16
Product .......................................................................................................................................... 16
Price .............................................................................................................................................. 16
Promotion ..................................................................................................................................... 17
Place .............................................................................................................................................. 17
Conclusion ............................................................................................................................................. 17
Nahid Mohsen Pour
3
Bibliography .......................................................................................................................................... 18
Table of Figures ..................................................................................................................................... 19
Nahid Mohsen Pour
4
Introduction In this essay, I am going to have a look at the Gulf of Mexico oil spill and how it affected BP business in
the USA. In order to have an academic approach, I have divided this report into two parts, where in part
I, I will perform business Macro Environmental analysis and in Part II, I will give my recommendations,
based on business and management tools and models.
Approach
My approach to address this problem is to look at the THEORY, give EXAMPLES, and ANALYSE the
issue. In THEORY part, I explain the relevant theory or model I am applying, in the EXAMPLES, I offer
examples from the case study that matches to the theory and finally in ANALYSE, I try to address the
issue and analyze the problem according to the relevant theory and model.
Importance of Marketing
(Kotler P. , 2006) Argues that marketing is the Achilles' heel of many formerly prosperous companies
such ad GM, Kodak, Sears and many other companies. He adds that even giant companies such as
Microsoft, Intel or others, just cant sit and relax. Jack Welch, GEs former CEO, always warned his
company to Change or die." (Kotler P. , 2006)
I think BP, although a huge company in oil industry is not an exception. I can say that, constant revision
of marketing strategies is essential for a firm to live, while in case of BP, after the tragedy of Gulf of
Mexico, which has lead to financial and non-financial losses to BP, it is compulsory to review and update
the marketing strategies.
Nahid Mohsen Pour
5
Part I: Macro Environmental Analysis of BP business in the USA after the
Gulf of Mexico Oil Spill
According to (Kotler P. , 2006), Macro environmental analysis is find out the external forces that affect a
company to produce and sell, which are consisted of Political, Economical, Social, Technological, Legal
and Environmental factors that affect externally a business.
Political Analysis
THEORY
According to (OxfordUniversity Press, 2007) political factors refer to government policy such as the
degree of intervention in the economy. This might include trading policies, lobbying, inter-countries
relations, and that can affect the business.
EXAMPLES
The US President Barack Obama has established the National Commission on the BP Deepwater Horizon
Oil Spill and Offshore Drilling On May 22, 2010, this can shows the very high intervention of politicians in
the business. (Oil Spill Comission)
Evidence in our case is the increase of royalty rate to fund stronger government oversight of the
offshore drilling, proposed by Barack Obama. (A.Dlouhy, 2011)
Due to the importance of the oil spill, Mr Obama toured the oil-hit areas several times and assured he would triple the manpower to contain and clean up the spill. (BBC,2010)
ANALYSE
I can argue in here that in major businesses such as oil, which has a very high financial turn over, or
there are many health and safety measures or environmental precautions, the political intervention will
be higher.
Economical Analysis
THEORY
Economical factors that might affect a business can be world economy or national economy of the
environment where the business is running.
EXAMPLES
Some experts believe that this incident could be the trigger of the American economic collapse.
Economy is supported fundamentally by its energy industry markets producers (IEA, 2004).Energy
Nahid Mohsen Pour
6
industry markets will face to increasing demand s about 60 percent, with the higher rate in fossil fuels,
nuclear and replacement energy industry markets having restricted comparative contribution (IEA,
2004). Discovering new substitute energy is growing and is replacing a percentage of total energy
production. From 2 percent in 2002 towards 6 percent in 2030.
ANALYSE
Critically reviewing the economical environment where BP is active in the USA, we can see that the 2008
credit crunch has not affected the oil industry, especially crude oil production at all, the reason is that
the demand in the market is too high. I also can conclude that the crude oil is not only used as a source
of energy but as a raw material for petrochemical industries such as plastic and other products.
Social Analysis
THEORY
Social factor may include the population growth rate, society attitude, average society age and cultural
issues.
EXAMPLES
After the deep water horizon disaster, and due to huge political and legal pressure by the US
government and local authorities especially in Louisiana, BP set up its $20bn Gulf spill claims fund to
compensate those who have been affected, without court intervention, however, many lawyers and
judges in the US, have rolled out that this fund is not acting neutral. (Guardian.co.uk, 2010). This not
only did not recover the bad image of BP, but I believe it made BP image worse.
The amount of environmental damages destroyed BPs brand image, thus maybe the consumers
avoid PB products in the US market. During this decades refer to the statistic shows People's
consuming patterns completely are changed especially in the energy industry market which is notable
to a concern over the sustainability of the future.(bp.com/statistic)
ANALYSE
I can conclude the oil spill had negative impact on BPs reputation in the US, especially in the areas that
peoples lives have been directly and indirectly affected. After the oil spill, many people lost their jobs,
or their business declined including tourism, fishing and other industries.
Technological Analysis
THEORY
Nahid Mohsen Pour
7
Technology is another environmental and external force that affects a business. In case of BP, as we can
see on many sources of information, such as websites and newspapers, we can find out BP has the
advantage of having advanced technology in deep water exploration of the oil.
EXAMPLES
BP has advanced technology in deep water exploration; they are concentrating on energy efficiency,
investing in low carbon future and production of more efficient energies.
ANALYSE
As BP has advanced technology and is also working to develop its technical know hows, I can argue that
in this regard, BP has competitive advantage over its rivals. Referring to the oil spill in Gulf of Mexico, we
can observe that BP, finally could manage the largest oil disaster in human history.
Legal Analysis
THEORY
Legal factors are those legislations that affect a business, such as employment law, anti trust law and
etc.
EXAMPLES
In our case, the BP oil spill, we can observe the new legislations, forced BP to be more accountable for
health and safety rules and paying compensation to those who have been affected. (Guardian News and
Media Limited, 2010)
Another applicable rule that has affected BP is the so called oil pollution act that Judge Carl Barbier, of
the federal court of Louisiana has used to force BP in fulfilling its legal obligations. (Guardian.co.uk,
2010)
ANALYSE
Gulf of Mexico oil spill has already leaded to many legal limitation of oil industry in the US trying to make
BP accountable for the damages caused to the environment and society. (Guardian.co.uk, 2010) We can
see that the amount of accountability has increased significantly.
Environmental Analysis
THEORY
Environment is very important and environmental activists are playing more important roles in the
business. Sometimes the environmental activist can put pressure to the government and make new
legislations.
EXAMPLES
Nahid Mohsen Pour
8
Environmental activists warned that the BP spill, which covers an area about the size of Cornwall, could
turn out to be as catastrophic as the impact of the Exxon Valdez tanker spill off Alaska was 21 years ago.
(Guardian.co.uk, 2010)
ANALYSE
The oil spill disaster on the US has caused many environmental activists to oppose exploration of oil
under the sea, which might seriously affect some legislation as its consequences.
New laws USA government, EU Pollution standards, International Environment Organizations, Change in
consumer patterns, consumer behavior, global demands to alternative energy and discovering new
energy sources could be considered as macro environmental forces on BP market.
SWOT Analysis
THEORY
SWOT analysis can help managers to understand the organization and its market or environment, by
contrasting its Strengths and Weaknesses with the Opportunities and Threats in the market.
(WILLIAMS, 2009)
EXAMPLES
Strengths
British Petroleum is third largest energy company in the world because of its international markets
activities is considered as a multinational Oil company Headquartered in London and as a largest
producer of oil and gas in the North of America. (BP) The company has huge market impact, which gives
it notable trading performance in the global energy industry. (BP)
One of the other strengths of BP is Good performance in International energy industry by the network of
its subsidiaries and retail brands such as: BP, AMOCO, ARCO, ARAL, CASTROL, BP EXPRESS, BP CONNECT,
BP TRAVEL, AMPM, BURMAH CASTROL. (BP)
ANALYSE
I can argue in here, BP can build its competitive advantage on its strengths which has already proven in
the oil industry.
Having established different brands, and a very wide distribution network, is one of the KSF1s of BP.
Creating a high level loyalty by BP AMOCO as a strong oil brand.
1 - Key Success Factor
Nahid Mohsen Pour
9
Adding two comments to BP`s statement: No harm to people and No damage to the
environment
A notable increasing profit due to oil and gas energy prices.
A strong marketing performance more than 8o countries such as Europe, the US, Middle East
and China, etc. therefore Bp has a significant geographic marketing activities.
Weakness
Oil spill in deep horizon water in Mexican Gulf, in April 2010, has made a huge financial loss to BP, and
has ruined the companys reputation. I can argue that one of the very important weaknesses of BP is
improper management and safety issues.
I can recommend to BP, trying convert this weakness into strength, by better management practice.
There has been several incidents for BP, including 2005 Texas refinery explosion, causing 100 injuries
and 17 death, 2000 gallons of Methanol ran out in the oil field (Prudhoe Bay), distribution of 270000
Gallons of crude oil In the Alaska tundra and many other similar incidents.
OPPORTUNITIES
When we talk about opportunities, we are in fact considering external environment, that affect a
business, such as (demographic-economic, natural and other macro environmental factors). Being
among the top 5 oils companies in the world, BP has several external opportunities, including by
acquisition in the North Sea area, BPs future profit by acting in the suitable boundaries area in the
Russia region, Implement plan to achieve alternative energy methods insist of Hydrogen, natural gas,
wind and solar by 8b.US$ investment. (BP)
THREATS
Same as opportunities, threats are also external elements, such as environment, legal and political
issues. My research shows that one of the most external threats to BP is the pressure of environmental
activist and legal pressure that will increase the cost of operation for BP.
Unfortunately, there are many external threats that affect BP, many of them is originated from careless
attention of BP, that has caused damages to the environment.
ANALYSE
It is very important to find out BPs Weaknesses (internal analysis) and transform them into Strengths.
On the other hand, we need to find out BPs Threats and try to transform them into opportunities
(External analysis). I can argue in here that one of the threats for BP has been so far, is less attention to
the environment, I can recommend to BP to try to have some sort of emphasis on green products. Also
as BP has been successful in controlling the oil spill, now it can be considered as strength for BP, and
they can have new division for environmental protection.
Nahid Mohsen Pour
10
Figure 1 SWOT
How to?
Weakness Strengths
Threats Opportuniti
es
Nahid Mohsen Pour
11
Part II: Strategic marketing recommendations to BP to recover from
Marketing disaster after the Gulf of Mexico oil spill
In this section, I am reviewing the possible ways where BP can develop its market, according to common
business and management frameworks.
Industry Analysis (Porters Five Forces)
THEORY
Porters five forces, is a framework for analysing an industry, as shown on the following diagram.
Figure 2 Porter's Five Forces
The aim of Porters five forces analysis is to find out how a business can compete is a specific sector.
EXAMPLES
Nahid Mohsen Pour
12
Industry rivalry
Oil industry is very vast, starting from exploration to refining and distribution, and there are many
companies active in oil industry. However, the number of main oil companies who can explore and mine
oil fields is very limited.
As shown on the following diagram, the major oil companies are:
Figure 3Major oil Companies
BP
Chevron
Conoco Philips
Royal Dutch Shell
BP is in third place as a producer of crude oil in compare with Chevron, Shell, Total, Conoco.
It seems Mexican golf disaster had not effective impact on BP to refinery Crude oil.
Nahid Mohsen Pour
13
Figure 4 Major Gas companies
I can argue in here that unlike many other industries, the rivalry in the oil industry and specifically in the
oil exploration is too low.
Bargaining power of Suppliers
The suppliers for BP are countries that have oil reservoirs and oil fields. They usually have a bid for their
oil field explorations. I can argue that here the bargaining power of suppliers is too high and they can
choose the contractor.
Bargaining power of buyers
The buyers or the crude oil, usually purchase in the oil markets, and the market price is determined by
the demand.
Threats of new Entrants
As the capital for oil companies is too high, and the level of technical knowledge is too high and
advanced, this has created a very high barrier for the new entrants. Thus I can conclude there is almost
no new entrants threat in oil industry and also for BP.
Nahid Mohsen Pour
14
Threat of substitute products
Crude oil cant be substituted by any other product, as it is not only the fuel but also the raw material for
petrochemical industries. Other sources of energy are bio fuel, nuclear energy, solar energy and which
at the moment arent cost effective.
Porter's Generic Competitive Strategies (ways of competing)
THEORY
Porters generic Strategies, try to define where the firm can compete. As shown on the following
diagram, a firm can compete on either cost or product differentiation.
Figure 5 Porter's Generic Strategies Source: http://www.socialmediamarketinguk.com/2008/11
I can argue in here that, there is not too much room in to compete on the price in the oil industry in two
senses:
Cost
Differentiation
Nahid Mohsen Pour
15
Crude oil price is determined in oil markets, and this product cant be differentiated.
Focus
However, I can recommend to BP to try to focus on a specific service in the US. As, BP is the best
company in deep water exploration, I would argue to BP to try to focus on deep water exploration.
Ansoffs Model
Figure 6 Ansoffs Market Development Model
The Ansoff Growth matrix is a tool that helps businesses decides their product and market growth
strategy.
Ansoffs product/market growth matrix suggests that a business attempts to grow depend on whether
it markets new or existing products in new or existing markets.
Nahid Mohsen Pour
16
The output from the Ansoff product/market matrix is a series of suggested growth strategies that set
the direction for the business strategy. These are described below:
Market penetration
Market penetration means where the business focuses on selling existing products into existing markets.
In our case, it means trying to continue deep water exploration in the US. Based on my analysis on
previous sections, I would recommend to BP to use this as marketing strategy.
Market development
Market development means the business seeks to sell its existing products into new markets. This would
be trying to enter other countries market. This, I can argue can work very well for BP, as its competitive
advantage in deep water exploration.
Product development
Product development means introducing new products into existing markets. This for BP means
introducing bio fuel and other products to the US market.
Diversification
Diversification is the name given to the growth strategy where a business markets new products in new
markets.
This is an inherently more risk strategy because the business is moving into markets in which it has little
or no experience.
For a business to adopt a diversification strategy, therefore, it must have a clear idea about what it
expects to gain from the strategy and an honest assessment of the risks.
(Ansoff, ansoff's product / market matrix)
Marketing Mix Mc Carthy 4Ps
Product
Although oil industry has vast sets of products, but the main product is the crude oil, which cant be
differentiated. In this regard, BP hasnt any choice, except planning to develop substitute products such
as bio fuel. However, if we consider crude oil exploration, I can argue there is no substitute product.
Price
The price of crude oil, as the primary product of BP and the major oil companies, is determined by
international markets and OPEC, and BP cant play with the price.
Nahid Mohsen Pour
17
Promotion
Having discussed several environmental disasters caused by PB, I can argue the image of BP in the
society has already changed to a company that is not environmental friendly. However, as we can see on
BPs website, recently they are trying to show their support toward environmental awareness.
I would recommend to BP to try to have advertising campaign toward a better support of environment,
and environmental awareness.
Place
I can argue that in terms of place, there are some limitations for oil companies, as the oil fields are
limited around the world. BP, and other oil companies cant determine where to go for exploration, as it
is a natural resource and is only available in limited number of places.
Conclusion
Based on the analysis I gave on Part II, I can formulate the marketing Strategies for BP in the USA, as:
1- Focus of deep waters oil exploration(Focusing Strategy)
2- Try to have green advertising campaign (Promotion)
3- Try to penetrate more into the USA market
4- Try to create better image (Social factor), by better approach to compensate those who have
been affected.
5- Continue lobbying (Political factors), or do it more efficiently.
6- Care for the environment (Environmental factor)
Nahid Mohsen Pour
18
Bibliography
A.Dlouhy, J. (2011). Newspaper, Hearts .
Ansoff, I. (n.d.). ansoff's product / market matrix. Retrieved 02 19, 2011, from Tutur2u:
http://tutor2u.net/business/strategy/ansoff_matrix.htm
Ansoff, I. (1957). Strategies for Diversification. Harvard Business Review , 113-124.
BP. (n.d.). BP Homepage. Retrieved 02 13, 2011, from BP.com:
http://www.bp.com/bodycopyarticle.do?categoryId=1&contentId=7052055
BusinessDictionary.com. (2010). BusinessDictionary.com. Retrieved 06 01, 2010, from
BusinessDictionary.com: http://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/environmental-scanning.html
Cayman News Service. (2010, 06 11). Retrieved 06 11, 2010, from Cayman News Service:
http://www.caymannewsservice.com/aggregator/sources/1?page=3
EMI. (2010). About EMI. Retrieved 06 06, 2010, from Music Jobs Ltd: http://uk.music-
jobs.com/directory/emi-music-uk-ireland-984977
EMI Group Limited. (2010, May 28). ABOUT EMI MUSIC. Retrieved 05 28, 2010, from EMI:
http://www.emimusic.com/about/
Guardian News and Media Limited. (2010). Behind the music: Can we ever measure the impact of
downloading? Retrieved May 29, 2010, from Music Blog:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/musicblog/2009/nov/12/measure-impact-downloading
Guardian.co.uk. (2010, 07 18). BP oil spill: failed safety device on Deepwater Horizon rig was modified in
China. Retrieved 02 17, 2011, from Guardian.co.uk:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2010/jul/18/deepwater-horizon-blow-out-preventer-china
he. (n.d.).
Kotler, P. (2006). Marketing Management Twelfth Edition. New Jersey: Pearson Prentice Hall.
Kotler, P. (2000). Marketing Management, Millennnium Edition. London: Printice Hall.
Oil Spill Comission. (n.d.). Oil Spill Comission. Retrieved 02 13, 2011, from
http://www.oilspillcommission.gov/page/about-commission
OxfordUniversity Press. (2007). Gillespie: Foundations of Economics - Additional chapter on Business
Strategy. Retrieved 02 15, 2011, from OXFORD University Press:
http://www.oup.com/uk/orc/bin/9780199296378/01student/additional/page_12.htm
Porter, M. E. (1980). Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors. Newyork: The Free Press.
Nahid Mohsen Pour
19
Porter's Five Forces Model. (n.d.). Retrieved May 29, 2010, from Czech Airlines:
http://student.dcu.ie/~slejhad2/porter.htm
Sandiego State Universit. (2010, 05 29). Rohan Academic Computing. Retrieved 05 29, 2010, from Rohan
Academic Computing: http://www-rohan.sdsu.edu/~renglish/370/notes/chapt11/life_cycle_01.gif
Tomspencer. (2009, 11 13). Product Life Cycle . Retrieved 11 13, 2009, from Tomspencer:
http://www.tomspencer.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/01/product_life_cycle_2.gif
WILLIAMS, K. (2009). Strategic Management. New York: DK Publishing.
Table of Figures Figure 1 SWOT ....................................................................................................................................... 10
Figure 2 Porter's Five Forces .................................................................................................................. 11
Figure 3Major oil Companies ................................................................................................................. 12
Figure 4 Major Gas companies ............................................................................................................... 13
Figure 5 Porter's Generic Strategies Source: http://www.socialmediamarketinguk.com/2008/11 .......... 14
Figure 6 Ansoffs Market Development Model ...................................................................................... 15