31
Benefits of protease on top of carbohydrases at times of high protein prices in poultry Ahmed Amerah, Global Technical Manager, Danisco Animal Nutrition 14 NOVEMBER 2012

Benefits of protease on top of carbohydrases at times of ...animalnutrition.dupont.com/fileadmin/user_upload/live/animal_nutrition/... · at times of high protein prices in poultry

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • View drawing guides

    1. Right-click on slide and

    select ’Grid and Guides...’

    2. Check ’Display drawing

    guides on screen’

    3. Select ’OK’

    Benefits of protease on top of carbohydrases at times of high protein prices in poultry

    Ahmed Amerah, Global Technical Manager, Danisco Animal Nutrition

    14 NOVEMBER 2012

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    220240260280300320340360380400420440460480

    Soybean meal prices (€)

    Source: http://www.indexmundi.com/commodities/?commodity=soybean-meal&months=12&currency=eur

    147 €

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    In the news

    7/26/2015

    Nov 7 (Reuters) - U.S. wheat, corn and soybeans rose on

    Wednesday as global markets rallied following President

    Barack Obama's election victory, while an export-boosting fall

    in the U.S. dollar also supported.

    Nov 7 (Reuters) - Argentina's 2013 soybean crop may be 3

    million to 6 million tonnes below earlier forecasts of 55

    million to 56 million tonnes as repeated rain is disrupting

    sowing.

  • Presentation objective

    How DuPont/Danisco Animal

    Nutrition can help reduce feed costs

    at times of volatile vegetable protein

    prices

  • Some strategies to cope with high raw material prices

    New raw materials

    Greater focus on quality issues

    Feed formulation strategies (e.g. decrease energy/ nutrient levels with some loss of performance)

    Increased use of feed additives (enzymes and synthetic amino acids)

    Maximise nutrient extraction (enzymes, feed processing)

    Ravindran (2007)

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    Presentation overview

    Soybean meal alternatives

    Features of Danisco protease

    Research data to support the use of protease

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    Major protein meals production % (2012)

    United States Department of Agriculture

    Foreign Agricultural Service

    The second largest component of poultry feed after cereals is the

    protein source

    68

    13

    5

    1 6

    2 3 2

    Soybean Meal

    Rapeseed Meal

    Sunflower Meal

    Copra Meal

    Cottonseed Meal

    Fish Meal

    Palm Kernel Meal

    Peanut Meal

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    Comparison of protein level and digestibility in some

    vegetable protein sources (% "as received") 1

    CP level CP

    digestibility Cost/t (€)

    Cost (€) per unit

    of dig. protein

    Soybean meal 48.0 89 462 10.7

    Rapeseed meal 34.0 78 288 10.9

    Sunflower meal 28.0 83 233 10.0

    Wheat DDGS 37.5 71 265 10.0

    1 Premier atlas, ingredients matrix 2008 ; Cozannet et al. 2009 and 2010

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    Metabolisable energy in some vegetable protein

    sources (kcal/kg)

    Source: Premier atlas, ingredients matrix 2008

    2462

    1673 1482

    2605

    Soybeanmeal

    Rapeseedmeal

    Sunflowermeal

    WheatDDGS

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    Non-starch polysaccharide in some vegetable protein

    sources (% dry matter)

    15

    21

    25 23

    Soybeanmeal

    Rapeseedmeal

    Sunflowermeal

    WheatDDGS

    Source: Danisco Non Starch Polysaccharide (NSP) database (2012); Widyaratne and Zijlstra (2007)

  • Soybean meal proteins

    P = protein bodies

    Glycinin + b-conglycinin 80%

    Antinutritional factors 5%

    Other proteins 15%

    Fischer (2006)

  • Global soybean meal survey (88% DM)1

    1Source: Mateos 2012

    n DM CP CF NDF EE TIA

    (g/kg)

    ARG 136 885 45.4c 4.8b 9.2b 1.7ab 2.5b

    BRA 131 88.6 46.6b 5.5a 10.6a 1.8a 2.6b

    USA 164 88.6 47.3a 3.8c 7.8c 1.6b 3.1a

    SEM 0.08 0.12 0.08 0.13 0.04 0.05

    P NS *** *** *** ** ***

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    Protein digestion

    aminopeptidases

    dipeptidases

    Protein

    Smaller peptides

    oligopeptides and dipeptides

    amino acids, dipeptides and tripeptides

    www.cellinteractive.com/ucla/nutrition_101/phys_lect3b.html

    Active transport

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    Agenda

    High prices and volatility of soybean meal

    Features of Danisco protease

    Research data to support the use of protease

  • The protease in Avizyme® 1505

    Bacillus Subtilis serine endopeptidase

    Designed for rapid hydrolysis of proteins

    Degrades Soybean storage proteins

    Degrades soybean anti-nutritional factors

    proteins

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    Effect of Danisco protease on trypsin inhibitor activity

    in raw soybean

    Measured in a slurry at 50ºC, enzyme at 1% w/w

    *Control TIA 47.5 mg/g after 1 hour incubation

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12

    Try

    psin

    in

    hib

    ito

    r acti

    vit

    y*

    (%

    of

    co

    ntr

    ol)

    Incubation time (h)

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    Agenda

    High prices and volatility of soybean meal

    Features of Danisco protease

    Research data to support the use of protease

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    Effects of protease on top of XA on amino acid digestibility

    in diets with or without corn DDGS

    Meta-analysis of 4 Trials with similar design: Massey University, NZ and U. of Illinois, USA

    21-d digestibility trials

    Ross 308 males

    Three treatments in each trial: control, XA, and XAP (Avizyme 1505)

    Two trials with corn/SBM based and two trials with corn/SBM/DDGS (7-10%)

    Amino acid digestibility evaluated on an apparent ileal basis

    Titanium oxide was marker

    Mixed Procedure of SAS. Experiment was random term

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    Addition of XAP increased amino acid digestibility by 2.8%

    compared to 0.4% for XA

    -0.5% -0.6%

    1.4%

    1.0%

    0.5%

    0.0%

    -0.5%-0.3%

    0.6%

    0.0%

    1.6%

    0.4%

    1.2%

    0.6%

    5.6%

    3.5%

    2.1%

    1.5%

    2.9%

    1.4%

    5.1% 5.1%

    4.6%

    2.8%

    -1%

    0%

    1%

    2%

    3%

    4%

    5%

    6%

    7%

    8%

    Lys Met Cys Thr Val Arg

    Dif

    fen

    ren

    ce

    fro

    m c

    on

    tro

    l (%

    )

    XA - Corn/Soy XA - Corn/Soy/DDGS

    XAP - Corn/Soy XAP - Corn/Soy/DDGS

    2.8%

    0.4%

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    Why are there differences in the

    response to enzymes between

    the different amino acids?

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    Avizyme 1505 (XAP) effects on undigested fraction of

    amino acids were very consistent

    y = 0.03x

    R2 = 0.56

    y = 0.03x

    R2 = 0.42

    y = 0.12x

    R2 = 0.96

    y = 0.13x

    R2 = 0.94

    -0.20

    0.00

    0.20

    0.40

    0.60

    0.80

    1.00

    0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0

    Apparently undigested fraction of amino acid (g/kg)

    Ap

    pare

    nt

    up

    lift

    on

    am

    ino

    acid

    dig

    esti

    bilit

    y (

    g/k

    g)

    XA-Corn/SBM XAP-Corn/SBM

    XA-Corn/SBM/DDGS XAP-Corn/SBM/DDGS

    Each dot represent a single amino acid

    3% improvement

    12.5% improvement

    9.5 %

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    Amino acids with high concentration x low digestibility had

    greater improvements due to Avizyme® 1505

    Amino

    acid

    Ileal

    digestible

    (g/kg)

    Ileal

    digestibility

    (%)

    Ileal undigested

    fraction (g/kg)

    Digestibility

    coefficient (%)

    Ileal digestible

    (g/kg)

    Lysine 12.2 87.1 1.81 1.4 0.17

    Methionine 5.9 93.3 0.42 0.7 0.04

    Cysteine 2.4 72.2 0.91 5.8 0.14

    Threonine 6.1 75.3 2.01 3.7 0.23

    Valine 8.6 81.1 2.00 2.4 0.20

    Total of

    17 A.A

    34.61 4.10

    7/26/2015

    Avizyme 1505 effect

    Improvement due to Avizyme 1505 = 11.8%

    Corn/SBM

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    Amino acids with high concentration x low digestibility had

    greater improvements due to Avizyme® 1505

    Amino

    acid

    Ileal

    digestible

    (g/kg)

    Ileal

    digestibility

    (%)

    Ileal undigested

    fraction (g/kg)

    Digestibility

    coefficient (%)

    Ileal digestible

    (g/kg)

    Lysine 10.8 82.6 2.28 2.6 0.29

    Methionine 5.7 90.1 0.62 1.3 0.07

    Cysteine 2.5 68.9 1.12 4.9 0.12

    Threonine 5.8 71.3 2.33 4.9 0.29

    Valine 8.0 77.3 2.36 4.3 0.34

    Total of

    17 A.A

    40.10 5.22

    7/26/2015

    Avizyme 1505 effect

    Improvement due to Avizyme 1505 = 13%

    Corn/SBM/DDGS

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    What does that mean?

    XAP effects on amino acid digestibility may be predicted based on ileal undigested fraction: ~12.5% of ileal undigested amino acids

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    DESIGN

    720 male Ross 308 broiler chicks housed in floor pens

    6 treatments with 8 pen replicates/treatment and 15 birds/pen

    Corn/Wheat/Wheat DDGS/Soybean meal-based mash diets

    6 dietary treatments

    • Positive control (PC)

    • Negative control (NC; - 85kcal ME/kg feed, - 2.5% amino acids versus PC)

    • NC + 200 g/t competitor protease

    • NC + 500 g/t competitor carbohydrase (Amylase + β-glucanase + xylanase)

    • NC + 700 g/t competitor protease + carbohydrase (Amylase + β-glucanase + xylanase)

    • NC + 200 g/t Avizyme 1505

    Birds and feed weighed at 42 days of age

    Avizyme 1505 outperforms competitor products in broilers fed

    mixed grain diets

    1505.UK.B.10.19

    Roslin Nutrition, Midlothian, UK

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    1505.UK.B.10.19

    Roslin Nutrition, Midlothian, UK

    Avizyme 1505 outperforms competitor products in broilers fed

    mixed grain diets

    Weight gain (g, 1-42 days)

    2826 ab

    2766 bc

    2705 cd 2696 cd

    2857 a

    2676 d

    PC NC NC + P NC + CHO NC + P

    + CHO

    NC +

    Avizyme

    1505 PC = Positive control NC = Negative Control

    CHO = amylase + β-glucanase + xylanase P = Protease

    a,b,c,d P

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    1505.UK.B.10.19

    Roslin Nutrition, Midlothian, UK

    Avizyme 1505 outperforms competitor products in broilers fed

    mixed grain diets

    FCRc* (1-42 days)

    1.80 c

    1.84 bc

    1.88 ab

    1.80 c

    1.93 a

    1.90 a

    PC NC NC + P NC + CHO NC +

    Avizyme

    1505

    * FCR corrected 3 points for every 100g difference in bodyweight versus the Positive control

    a,b,c P

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    1505.UK.B.10.19

    Roslin Nutrition, Midlothian, UK

    Avizyme 1505 outperforms competitor products in broilers fed

    mixed grain diets

    Τ Expressed relative to the Positive control, including product prices

    Cost/kg gain (%) τ

    100

    103 103

    101

    100

    97

    PC NC NC + P NC + CHO NC +

    Avizyme

    1505

    NC + P

    + CHO

    PC = Positive control NC = Negative Control

    CHO = amylase + β-glucanase + xylanase P = Protease

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    Danisco Animal Nutrition can help reduce feed costs at

    times of volatile vegetable protein prices

    Basal diet

    (BD)*

    BD + Avizyme

    1505 (CP&AA)*

    BD + Avizyme

    1505 (full matrix)*

    Ingredient price

    (€/t)

    Corn 48 50 51 245

    Wheat 15 15 15 235

    SBM 48% 28 26 26 477

    Rapeseed meal 3.0 3.0 3.0 300

    Soy oil 3.1 2.9 1.6 910

    Economics

    Feed cost (€/t) 339.3 337.3 328.6 -

    Net savings (€/t) - -2.0 -10.7 -

    * Calculated analysis for all diets: 20% CP and 12.7 MJ/kg ME

  • Text starts with no bullet

    Click once on

    ’Increase Indent’ for bullet

    and click max. three times

    for more bulletdesign

    To get previous design back,

    click on ’Decrease Indent’

    Change Date and insert

    Presentation Title under

    >Insert >Header and Footer

    and write in Fixed Date field

    and field ‘Footer’ >Apply to All

    Deactivate by clicking

    off the checkboxes

    Conclusions – Take home messages

    Protease on top of XA increased digestibility of undigested amino acid

    fraction from ~3.0% (XA) to 12.5 % (XAP)

    In the current situation of high raw material prices, enzymes are one of the

    tools to help reduce the price pressure on poultry producers and consumers

    Using matrix values for Avizyme 1505 (energy, protein and amino acids)

    allows reductions of 10.7 €/t and for protein and amino acids 2.0 €/t

  • Copyright © 2012 DuPont or its affiliates. All rights reserved. The DuPont Oval Logo, DuPont™ Danisco® and all products denoted with ™ or ® are

    registered trademarks or trademarks of E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company or its affiliates.

    7/26/2015