Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
OrsHs
Ha aBropeSepar rnaceprarJr4vr
Marpocona Humoraq ArencaHApoBnqa
Ha reMy: <OcodeHHocrn cyAorlpou3BoAcrBa rlo AeJIaM o pacropxeHrltl
6parca H cBfl3aHHbrx c HHM crropoB)>, [peAcraBrennofi Ha corlcnaHue yueHofi
crerreHu KaHA[Aara roprrArrqecKlrx HayK rlo c[equaJrbHocrrl
12.00.15 - rpalr(Aancrcufi rpoqecc, ap6urpaxnufi rpoqecc
,{uccepraqzr Marpoco B a Huxoras AnercanApoBrlrra laanr4caHa Ha aKTy€ulbHyro
TeMy. Kax clpaBeAJrr4Bo 3aMerreHo AprccepraHToM, aKTy€ulbHocrb I4ccJleAoBaHvrfl
npoqeccy€rrrbHbrx oco6esHocrefi pacropxeHr{s 6para Bo MHoroM orlpeAen.aerct
3Haqr{Mocrrro 6para, KaK corlu€urbHoro }rHcrr4Tyra. PasnoAbr {BJI{Iorct oAHHM I43
onpeAenf,Iorqux Sarropon, Koropbre cHr{xaror 4err,rorpa$r4trecKue noKa3arenn nro6ofi
crpaHhr, KpoMe roro, oHrr lopoxAaror cour4€LnbHy]o HanptxeHHocrr. llocto.sHHrtil
MoHrdropr{Hr geficrnyroulero 3aKoHoAareJrbcrBa B coBoKynHocru c Hay{HbrMr4
Teoperr4qecKr,rMr4 rlccneAoBaHuflMu no3BoJrHT npraBecrr4 rroJroxeHur fpaxAaHcKoro
[poqeccy€LllbHoro KoAeKca P@ v Ceiuefiuoro KoAeKca P@ B coorBercrBr4e c
npaKTl{qecKr4Mr{ norpe6uocrfMu o6ulecrna (c.3). lloroxenr{r HbrHe 4eficrnyroqefi
HOpMaTLT BHO-rrpaBOBOZ 6a:u, pernaMeHrupyroulefi uop.f,AoK 3aKJrroqeHr{r,
14 cocTorHHf, B HeM, rroABepfaroTcf, cLrcTeMaTHqecKoMy6para
Bblluecrofl ITITIMI4 cy g.aMv, rrro cBr4AerenbcrByer o6 nx HecoBeprrreHcrBe.
Cava npoueAypa pacropxteHr,ur 6paxa 14 pa3perueHLrs, cBr3aHHbrx c Hr,rM cnopoB,
HecMoTpf, Ha Kaxyulyrcc{, Ha nepBbrr,r B3fn.rrA npocToTy, Bbr3brBaeT Ha npaKTr4Ke
3HalrlrreJrbHbre rpyAHocr u (c.4).
flocraueHHat AvccepraHToM rlenb - BbrrBJreHrre Ha ocHoBe KoMnJreKcHoro
r43yqeHkrfl coBpeMeHnux npo6neM cyAonpon3BoAcrBa no AenaM o pacropxeHkrv 6para
u clopoB, cBt3aHHbIX c pacropxeHueM 6para, npoqeccy€rJrbHbrx oco6eHsocrefi
paccMorpeHurfl. cyAe6uux Aen Aauuofi Kareropr4r.,r ATrfl onrr{Mr{3arl}rr4 rrpaBoBoro
perynlapoBaHvrfr cyAorlpolr3Bo.{crBa no AaHHbrM AenaM; aupa6orKa reoperuqecKLrx
pacropxeHHt
TOJIKOBAHLIIO
/
ocHoB yKa3aHHofo cy.{olpoH3Bo.qcrBa vr HayqHo-[paKTI4qecKLIX r4HLrrILrarr4B nO
coBeprueHcrBoBaHHro 3aKoHoAareJrbHofi 6azst
3aKoHoAareJrbHbrx HoBeJrJr B o6racru
npaBorrplruenurenrnofi AerrenbHocrr4 cyAoB
vr o6ner.{eHl,Iq ucrroJrb3oBaHr4fl
6par<opa":BoAHbrx npoqeccoB B
Ar4ccepraHToM 6lur,a Aocrr.rrHyra.
r4ccneAoBaHr4lr u nonyrIeHHbIX pe3ynbTaTax He
Lr3JrO)KeHHr AT4CCepTaIIHOHHOfO HCCJIeAOBAIJT4S.
[3roxeHr4q - Hayr{HbIM. I4uerouluecs BoceMb
ny6mlraqwit, y roM rrr4cre rpu crarbr4 B xypHanax, BKJIIoT{eHHbIX n llepeuens BAK
Bu6paHnax reMa Anccepraur{oHHoro r{ccireAoBaHvrfl, pacKpblTa vr coorBercrByer
coAepxaHurc pa6omr.
JIu.rHoe yqacrlre aBTopa B
craBI,ITct no.rl coMHeHI,Ie. -flgrrr
qBlseTcr AocTynHbrM, a cTHJIb
Munucrep crBa o6pa: o na HLrfl, 14 HayKr{ P occufi cro fi O e4ep aIJvrr4, orpaxalor ocHoBHbIe
rroJroxeHufl, u p $yJrbrarbl AI,IccepTaIII4 oHHof o I{c c JIeAOB AHUfl..
I4ccreAoealne npoBeAeHo nyreM rrpr4MeHeHr4r o6ulzx MeroAoB HayqHoro
IIo3HaHrrr Lr TpaAI{IITIOHHbIX MeTOAOB An{ fpaXAaHCKOfO rIpOqeCCa.
TeoperuvecKffr ocHoBa pa6oru npe.qcraBJl.lercs coorBercrnyrcqef
AkrccepTarlr4oHHbrM I{ccJreAoBa:HLIflM - r,rcrroJlb3oBaHbl I4cToIIHI/IKI/I B O6laCrU
rpaxAaHcKoro npoqeccyaJrbHoro npaBa, ceueftsoro npaBa, I4cTIoJIHI{TeJIbHoro npaBa,
a raKxe r4Hbrx orpacnefi poccuficroro ilpaBa. BrreoArr v ilpeAJloxeHvrfr,
co.{epxaqvrecfl. B Ar{ccepTarlr4r4, rroAKpenneHbl aHaJII43oM AefiCrnytOqefo
3aKoHo.qareJrbcrBa. 3ivruupuvecKas 6aza tBJlserct Aocraro.rHofi. ,{uccepraHr
rlcrroJrb3yer rrpaKTrary BepxoBHoro Cylu PO, cyAoB perLIoH€LIIbHoro u pafionHoro
ypoBHs, a raKxe npaKTHKy HcnoJrHr4reJrbHoro rrpou3BoAcrBa, peaJIIByeMyIo Cnyx6ofi
cyAe6Hbrx [ptrcraBos PO no AenaM, BbrreKaroqrrx lr3 ceMefiHo-6pauurx ornourenufi.
Peaynrrarbr, orpaxeHHbre B Aucceprarrvpr MoryT 6rrrr xnanra$uqllpoBaHbl KaK
HoBbre. HoeugHa r4ccJreAoBa*r4fl, r4 rtolryqeHHbrx pe3yJlbraroB cocrollT B ToM, rITo
Ar4cceprarlra.rr H.A. Marpocona aoAep)Klrr ps4 r{eHHhIX BbIBoAoB u noloxenufi,
cnoco6crByroqux p€l3Br.rrr.rrc Teopur4 rpaxAaHcKoro Ilpoqecca I{ HcnoJIHIaTeJIbHoro
npolr3BoAcrBa u o6HosreHlrro 3aKoHoAarenbcrBa B Ilensx oIITI{MH3aIII{I4
cyAonpou3BoAcrBa no AenaM o pacropxenvrv 6pana H cBt3aHHbIX c HI,IM cnopon. [oHacrorrqero BpeMeHH oco6eHHocrr4 cyAorrpou3BoAcrBa no yKa3aHHbIM KareropurlM
AeJr raccneAoB€rJurcb B Teopr4u BecbMa noBepxHocrHo. Ha ceroAusmuufi AeHb B
,)r-
coBpeMeHHofi HayKe lpax{AaHcKoro npoqecca rpo6neMa pacropxeHl,Iq 6paxa Lr
cBr3aHHhrx c HtrM cnopoB u3yqeHbr He AocTaTorIHo IIOJIHO, A [pOqeCCyaJIbHbIe
oco6eHnocrr{ pacropxeHn;r 6para, KaK Ha xaNAofi ara4vrkr rpaxAaHcKoro rlpoqecca,
TAK I{ B coBoKynHocrr4, He 6brnr,I [peAMeroM cneIII4aJIbHoro Hayr{Horo I{ccJIeAoBaHLrfl..
o6crosreJrbcrBo o6yclonulo nu6op reMbl LlccneAoBanvrfl, no3BoJII{JIo,{auHoe
c$opvrynupoBaTb ero 3aAaqu u o6o:HaquTb llenb HayqHoro aHuru3a.
Anropovt BnepBble HayKe fpa)KAaHcKofo IlpoqeccyulllbHofo [paBa
orrpeAeJreHu oco6eHHocrrr cyAorrpo[3BoAcrBa no AeJIaM o pacropxeHl{I4 6paxa u
cMexHbrx c Hr4M c[opoB; Bbrf,BJreHbr 14 r,rccneAoBaHbl llpoqeccy€ulbHble ocooeHHocTl4,
xapaKTepHbre lnfl r<aNAofi arag.nvr cyAe6Horo pas6upateJlbcrBa rlo AeiIaM o
pacropxeHr4r4 6para u cBr3aHHbrx c Hr4M cnopoB, BHeceHbI rlpeAnoxeHrafl. tlo
r{3MeHeHlrro u pa3Brrrr{ro 4eficrnyroulero 3aKoHoAareJlbcrBa B o6nacru
p eryJrr{po BaHus. paccM arprsaeN{ofi Kareropllll AeJI (C. 7 - 8 ).
floloxeuz.t, BbrHocr.IMbre Ha 3arrlr4Ty, .lBJlsrorct AocroBepHbIMI4,
caMocTorTeJrbHo BbrBeAeHHbrMpl u krMeroT noATBepx(AeHlIe B TeKcTe paooTbl.
Hayvuax 3Haqr4Mocrb r,rccJreAoBaHufl, o6osHa.{eHa B cauofi pa6ore v ee
anropeSepare u cocror{T B Bo3MoxHocrr4 r4crroJlb3oBalus, pe3ynbraron pa6orbl Ant
4alrHefiurzx HayqHbrx nccJreAoeaHufi n o6racrv rpuK4aHcKoro npoqeccy€tllbHoro
npaBa. BrrsoAH lr peKoMeHAarlr{rl, npeAno)KeHHble n pa6ore, MoryT 6urr rIoJIe3HbI B
npoqecce HopMorBoptrecrBa, B rrpaBorrpllMeHl{Telrnofi Aef,TeJIbHocrI4, B HayqHbIX
r4ccneAoBaHvrfix npo6nerra rpax{AaHcKoro cyAonpou3BoAcrBa 14 I{crIoJIHLITeJIbHoro
npoLl3BOACTBa, CBt3aHHbIX C rrpeAMeToM ALICCepTaqI{OHHOfO I4CCneAOBaHI,If, .
o6ycnonreua o6osHaqeHHbIMrI Ha crp. 5 3aAaqaMI4.Crpyrcrypa pa6oru
.{ncceprarlu{ cocrovrr kr3 BBeAeHHf,, Tpex ruraB,3aKrlorleHus,u6u6nnorpaQuu.
Oco6oro BHr4MaHlrr 3acnyxl,IBaer rIpoBeAeHHoe
lporrrJrofo, KoTopoe ilpelocraBl,IJlo Bo3MoxHocrb
oTAeJIbHbIX I4HCTI4TyTOB, KOTOpbIe B HaCTOsIqee
cyAonpou3BoAcrBe no AeiIaM o pacropxeHr4vr 6para. (C.
.{uccepraHToM
cy.4orlpou3BoAcrBa rlo
no4po6uo aHanv3prpyeTct
pacropxeHZl{
aBTopoM o6o6rqenue orrblTa
BbrrBr4rb e$SerrunHocrb
BpeMr rrcilonb3ylorct B
14-1s).
crarr4s. noa6yN4enur
3
.qenaM o opaKa, fAe pacKpbrBaroTcf,
OTNI,IIII{TEJIbHbIC I{EPTbI AAHHOI{ ATATI,4.I,.I |PAXAAHCKOfO IIPOqECCA, AH€LIII43I4PYETC{
AeficrByroqee 3aKoHoAareJrbcrBo u npzBoArrct [pI{MepbI cyAe6Hofi TIpaKTHKH.
Anrop BepHo orMeqaer, rrro roJrbKo cyqe6Hafl. npolleAypa cuoco6Ha B noJluofi uepe
frecrb rrpr{ BbrHecenuu peilreHr4r o pacropxeHr{H 6paxa Bce cofiyrcrBytoql{e oroMy
npoqeccy Bonpocbl, B ToM rrlrcJre, co6nlocrpr r4HTepecbl HecoBepueHHoJlerHux Aerefi
(C.16). I4nrepeurbrM rrpeAcraBr-f,ercr BbrBoA aBropa o neo6xolllMocrla I/tcIIoJIb3oBarb
cyAbe anSSepeHrlnpoBaHHrrfi noAXoA K ycraHoBJleHuro laaJru-uufl. rIpeArIocbIJIoK I4
co6moAeHrrro ycnonnfi, peanvr3alrywr flpaBa Ha npeA]tBJIeHHe I4cKoBoro 3aflBJIeHIzf,
3ar4HTepecoBaHHbrMr4 cy6terrauu Ha craplnvr nos6yx4eHur npol43BoAcrBa IIo
3afrBJrenktflM o pacropxeHull 6para lI cBt3aHHbIX c HI4M cnopon (c.17).
llpu uccneAoBaH?ru oco6essocrefi noAroroBKl4 Aen o pacrop)Keuun 6parca r
cy.le6norvry paz6uparcJmcrny .qrlccepraHror\4 aHzlnl{:Irpylorcx ueJII4 u taAarrll,
KoMrrJreKc Aeficreufi cyAbr{ 14 cropoH Ha AaHHofi craptuu c f{eroM cnequSuqecKux
oco6ennocrefi Aen o pacropmeHura 6para (c.17). Oco6ufi LlHrepec rpeAcraBJl.ler
BbrBoA aBTopa o seo6xoAuMocrr4 pernaMeHTr4poBaHurfl, flpoqeccy€ulbHblx
oco6esnocrefi, Bo3HLrKaroqux rtpu noAroroBKe raKrIX Aen K paccMorpeHl{Io, a
r{MeHHo, 3aKoHoAareJrbHoro 3aKperrnenlrfl rpe6yror: o6.f,sarenbHoe 4ocy4e6noe
yperyJrupoBaHue ceuefisoro rouQmama; upnuepurtfi
rroAirexalrll4x AoK€BbIBaHuIo IIo AeJIaM O paCTopxeHI4I4
o6cro.sreJrbcrB, rIpH H€LlI4rIHe Koropblx, B o6.ssarerbHoM
rrpoBoArrrbcf, rrpeABapr{renbHoe cy4e6noe 3aceAanue (c. 1 7).
Ayanvtzupyx oco6ennocru cyAe6noro paz6upareJlbcrBa rlo AeJIaM o
pacropxeHLrr,r 6paxa, aBTop r43yqaer npo6reunue Bolpocbl IIpeAcraBHTeJIbcrBa,
; u.tracrufl, Tperblrx Jrr{rl, Bo3MerrIeHHr MopaJrbHoro BpeAa. Oco6oe BHIIMaHLIe yAen.lerct
Saxrarra, uoAnex{arqlrM AoKa3bIBaHI4Io, B rracrHocrl4, ALIccepraHT cnpaBeAnlaBo
yKa3brBaer, rrro saAa.refi cyra B craAvrvr cy4e6Horo pas6rapareJlbcrBa Aeila sBJlf,erct
ycraHoBJIeHI{e AeficrsureJrbHbrx o6crogreJrbcrB, HMeBruI4x Mecro B peaJlbHocrl4
(c.18). Tar xe nogpo6uoMy aHaJrr{3y roABepraerct cnequQura cy4e6Horo petueHufl, o
pacropxeHprr4 6paxa. B pa6ore BepHo orMerraercr, rITo oco6ennocm cy4e6noro
repeqeHb Qaxron,
6para; IIepeqeHb
AOJDKHOrropf,AKe
4
perueHlat no AenaM o pacTopxeHHlr opaKa 3aKlroqaeTcf, B ToM, tITo AeKJIapaTI4BHbII4
MoMeHr B perrreHulr iloAo6Hofi Kareroprlld AeJI orcyrcrByer, T.K. rlpeAMeroM
noATBepiK[eHufl, B cyAe flBIrfleT1fl, BOJIeH3bflBJIeHVe CynpyfoB o HeBo3MOXHOCTI4
Aamsefiurefi coeN,Iecruofi xs43HI{ cynpyroB (c. 1 9).
Oco6oro BHr{MaHr{r 3acJryxr{Baer rJraBa rperbt <Oco6euuocrll paccMorpeHr4fl,
uogpo6noe
BCTpeqaeMbIe
cnopoB, cBr3aHHbrx c pacropxeHlreM 6paru. B lansofi rJIaBe AllccepraHT rIpoBoAI{T
onucaHl{e yKa3aHHbIX ClOpoB, yKa3bIBaeT Ha
B cy.ue6nofi [paKTI4Ke cnopbl, cBt3aHHbIe c
ilpoqecco1,r. Anrop BepHo foBopHT o6 arrunHofi nosurJnLr cy!.a npll pa3peIrIeHLII4
BbrreKaroquit us 6paropa:BoAHoro npoqecca I4 cBf,3aHsufi c pa3AeiloM coBMecrHo
HaxgToro LrMyrlecrBa. O6ocuonano, rrro pe[reHl{e AaHHoro Bolpoca rpe6yer
11pr4BnerreHu-f, 6onr[rofo o6reir,ra AoKa3areJlbcrBeHHofi 6asn u o6paqeHl{e Ko MHorIlM
HopMaM MarepnanbHoro rrpaBa p€Bnr4rrHbrx orpacneir (c.21). Baxnofi I4 HHrepecuofi
qacrbro pa6oru flBrrfl,ercfl. uaparpaQ nropofi rJIaBbI rperrefi <<Oco6eHnocrn
r4crroJrHeHr{.rr perxeHr,rfi no AenaM o cnopax, Bo3HI4KaIoqux rrpu pacropxeuvtu 6paxa>>,
rAe BbrAeneHbr aBTopoM oco6enHocru I4cIIoJIHI,ITeJIbHoro IIpoI{3BoAcrBa IIo reM
KareroplrrM Aetr, Koropbre 6suru rIccJIeAoBaHbI paHee (c.2I). O6ocuosaHHo
yK€L3brBaercr, rrro upo6nerrau, cB.rI3aHHbIe c ncloJIHeHrIeM LIcTIoJIHIITeJIbHrIX
AOKyMeHTOB O B3brCKaHHr4 €LIrUMeHTOB, XapaKTepl{3yloTc.f, coqeTaHl{eM npI4qLIH KaK
o6lerrusHoro, TaK u cy6tercruBHoro xapaKTepa.
3arnro.reHrae AI{ccepraIluoHnofi pa6omt orpaxaer nau6olee 3HarILIMbIe
xapaKTepy flBlrflercfl eMKLIM Upe3ynbrarbl rlpoBeAeHHofo HccneAoBaHLrfl', no
apfyMeHTI{poBaHHbIM.
HaHoonee qacro
6paropasBoAHbIM
BonpocoB, KacaloulvIxc\ npexAe Bcefo,
HecoBepIxeHHoJIerHHX Aerefi (c. 19).
Bax(Hocrb cofJlalrleHl4fl, o BocfII4TaHI4H,
Koropoe Mor(er 6urr oQoPrr,rneno
cnopoB o MecTolKrITeJIbcTBe E coAep)KaHhpr
Kporvre roro, Al4ccepraHT noAr{epKl4Baer
nopflAKe o6ulesun u coAepxanuv 4erefi,
rrpeABapI4TeJIbHO L\ ilpeACTaBJIeHO CyAy
oAHoBpeMeHHo c 3af,BJreHrleM o pacropxeHl4rl 6para nE6o yxe B npoqecce
paccMorpeHnfl. Aerla (c.20).
pac[pocTpaHeHHblx BorpocoB,
flBJTflETCfl. BbITIJIATA EUII{MCHTOB
BepHo orMeqeHo' rrro oAHI4M Lr3 caMbIX
pa3perxaeMbrx cyAoM rlpu pacropll(eHllll 6para,
(c.2I). fiuccepraHroM raK)I(e paccMorpeH Bonpoc'
c
B qenou Aracceprarlus H.A. MarpocoBa rlpeAcraBJl{er co6ofi ocHoBarenruufi
HayvHrrfi TpyA, rroKa3brBaroulrEfi necoMHeHHyIo cnoco6nocrb ero aBTopa K Hayr{HoMy
I4CCneAOBaHr{ro, coAepxaHue Ar{ccepTar\uv cBI4AeTenbcTByeT o ToM, rITO ee aBTop
BnoJIHe BnaAeeT MeTo,uaMI{ HayqHofo aHuIu3a I{ cpaBHI4TeJIbHOfO npaBoBe,4eHvlr'.
BrrsoA: ArIccepraIII{oHHat pa6ora Marpocoea Hnrolas AlercaHApoBl'Iqa
reMy: <<Oco6esHocrl4 cyAorlpoll3BoAcrBa rlo AenaM o pacropxeHl4H opaKa
cBs3aHHbIX C HI{M CIIOpOB) flBJIfleTCfl' CaMOCTO'TeJIbHO
rnalnQuqllpoBaHHblM HayqHbIM rpyAoM, B KoropoM coAepxl4rct
gAp;arrrr4, xiueroulefi cyilIecTBeHHoe 3HaqeHLIe AJIS HayK?I
HA
u
HA[I4CAHHbIM
HOBOe peIXeHI4e
fpaxAaHcKofo
rpoqeccy€urbHoro npaBa, coorBercrByer BceM rpe6onaul{sM pa3Aela II floloxenus o
rroprAKe npucyxAenr4fl. freHbrx creneHefi, yrBepxAeHHoro llocrauouleHueM
flpanurerbcrBa Poccuficrofi Qe4epa\uv or 24 ceurr6pr 20t3 roAa Ns 842, a aBrop
Ar{ccepraqnu H.A. MarpocoB 3acJryxuBaer nplrcBoeHlrfl yrleHofi creneru4 KaHAr4Aara
ropI4AuqecKLIX HayK rlo cfleqllanbHocrl4:
apdurpaxnufi upoqecc.
12.00.15 rpax4ancrufi npoqecc;
fi ra$eapofi oprauv3ar\nu
Hbrx npl4craBoB 14
fo ilpoI{3BoACTBa
poccufi crrafi rocyAapcrnenurrZ
rocrr4lluu (PIIA Mnnrocra Poccuu)>>,
AOKTOp rOpI4AUqecKI4x HayK, AOIIeHT B.A. fypeenBla4IaIr,rup fypeee
1I7638, r. Mocrea,yr. Agoecraq, A.2, ropu. 1
TereSou: 8 (a99) 317-35-66[toAxucn3ftEepfiFCI
f{aoadxsssm orAefia14.E€" Kmee,resa
www.rpa-mu.ru
29 vapra20l6 r.
OT3LIBHa asrope$epa"r ,1}'tcceprall,4l"I MarpocoBa I{r4xo;,taJi Anp}icaHrpoBt{Lta
<Oco$eHxocrt{ cy,[CInpol{3nCIgcrBa no re.ralrl o pacropxenr.ru 6paxa H cgr3agHbrx cHlrl.{ CnSpOB}), npiAcT&8].Ie}{HOii ua cr:llcK&HHe y.ier_roli CTsneHr.l KaHJl}tAaTa
Idlpl'r;lHqe{KHx HayK Ilo cneitl{&[r]HocTH 1 3,0i1. I 5.
flpanon*e prrynffpogilurc npoqeAypbt pac"ropxeHI.l.,{ 6paxa Bcer;lii rjbl3bulo*rro \:
3AKOrIOilATeilff Ofipene.ileHHbre TpJ"'ilHCIc1'l{, l"lOCKO;Tb}tV 3geCL TeCHO nepe[JeTA]OTCn
n}'"6"[].rqHbtfi n .lacrubifr HHTepec! "r1'l{rlnr}re }.J Hstyuecrgt:uHbrr npaga fi o6.q:ai{rroc.r}l
cynpyroB !1 fix &ergfr, a raKX(e l\'tHorCIe npyroq" Ilouul.to :)Tclror o cJroxurlcrl1 l{
3H&t{Hs{s{rx elt$paHuofi Tevbt roBCIpHT H&r'rui{r{e pfl"{s llocraxoslennlyl flrreH,u-.lra
Bepxoruor0 Cyna FS, nocgt:Jjeaxurx *So:Harienuoli npo6:reue. B:r,recre c rerr,
Hech.{oTpff I"{e c}{ffint{}{oe} B }{acToff.U{Hit l{CIlr.leur coxpaH.[eTc.fi M]{OrrecTBo np06e.lo8 t1
Ilporl4BopeqNii B per,v"ryl.{poBa.t{ptl.{ lrHcrr.rrvrit c;-,leSuoro p;}cropxeHr.{r 6paxa^
KoroplJe :pe$yrrr, c CIg$of,I crCIi]onbt, Teopcrr.{qecxofe ocl.{r,lcrleH}ir, a c ,urvror:t -Ae T&rIb H Oro $roph{ i}T }.t s H 0 r0 os ocH$eaHi.ffi .
B 3Tofi cB.{3t{, Se::,vciroei-roii ;lac-rr"vroii itlrccepra}jta flB{.1"rrocb o-rpaxeHr{e B
paSore gHcKyccHoHHbIX tsonpocoe, onpeile"renr{e cofcrnennoro MHeHri.{, }3 pg,lle
ctyqaeB QSgcNoeaNl e .*onorHlirejlbHbrNrlr aprv^ueHTaMrl y)ke BbrcKa3aHHbrx B
l0pHjlHqec;iofr rHTepe?ype rroJyolr{eHr4li, a rarxe prjl HoBbrx nojro}xsnNfi BtiHoil.ts.{btx
Ha 3aultr"y. B LtacrHscrFll nonoxHTerbHo oueHLiBafrcff npe&iloxie Ht{e aBTopa
coKpaTl.tTb cpox ;lrrl npl.{}.1}ipeHHsi TTOpOH il0 oiTir0f.o necHua {c. g). nocxoiri,x\
aH&rCIrl{Lrnurfr cpox .ycrageg-{}"rBaercr .djl}t 3&Kr,-t}oqer.li4ff Spnxa {n. 1 c.r. 1 I CK p$).
Taxxe npe&crann"{ercfr u*tecoc6paSfrbrh.t B o"rre-rrbHblx c.;r"vtraflx Ha3HaLie}jHe
HecCIBepuleHHoJ'rerlrHil.l HeSaBr,{cr{Moro npercraBr4rel* f c. I 2} n r.,a.
C l"lexoropbtt'iI'{ BbtBo,na}lH 11 no.iloxeHL{fr.i14 il.rcceprau}ri.j \.{br cor":l3L:rrbr rl
pa3,{eJ'Ixeiv! MHeHI4e aBTopa. 3r:o or1{ocHTcr K 13r}rBo;tarrr Fi.A. \,{arpocora o ro5r. rrro
'lHcrliryr c)'AnSHor(} pacropxelJLt.q' 6paxa tsceLfa CITrH.la.;rcx 3Hat{lirejlbHCIii
cneuI44x'tKoii, B ToM t{HciTe cot{er&Hx*il,r n,v$nl"rruntx ,i qacrublx Haqan {c. S),
olla:ll'{qeHHb}M ;leftcrsHeM }lHc"rH'I}'Ta s{i'rpororo cori.iamei{}r.g (c. 9), no3N.to}*(Hoc1bK}
paccs{{}TpsHttfi qacl"ti ,:l*,'tit B 3ii}il'}bl"f0t{ rrollfijtK* (c. 9l H .I.J.
Kax H Bcffxofl ca:vlocTCItTe,'I;)I{oe HCCjTejlOBaH}'{e, l:laHHag A}.{ccepTaul{riHfrAX
pafioTa i.:tf t{oxeT' ilf B}}l:}t}fi}i.'tTb 3ar.icLii.}}ii'fi. N Koropbl\1 ol"L{ocxrcfi c,1eI\'}oI-t{}{e:
1. llacxpurBax cojlepii{ant{e pafiorbr. aBTop Bo }3Topo}l naparpar}re rraBbt o'rn;roir
<<lloArotcsKa ren o pacropx{ei{rnr 6para K c;-&e6lrolry pa:Snpale"'rrrcrB\1))
npe.a,tarn*T Saxous"aar€irbHo saKpenHTr] odx:sre,ruHoe rocyilefiHue ypefyili{poBaH}re
seueitHora xoHt]:;rnxla (c. 17). a Hecxoi'rbKo pilHee pa*cylti.Tae'r o co3rllaHHl{ ;l-itu
?Tofo c ne t.tr.i zur lr3 ]r po BaH I-{o J'o },{ e;ltiar}i B }{ o ro op f i1 H a 1 c . ? ).
Ha naur H3fJrg, Tora;rbl{CIe npil},{er{enne ofi.:r,:arerssoii nporieryFbr Nre:t.tailult
.r{B;ISeTCX HeUgJteCOO6palHtnvr: nocKOjlbfi}, s uenor,{ pn;le cry\aeB no,lo6uute
npe:r.nucaxtls saxoua S;*lyr r{.inrb $Tsrouilrr" c1,'le$H.v$ npoueilypy paclop}ieHttt
6paxa. Tax, $arr1.{qecx}t Spaliinre orilomeutrlff r.lorvl Ilpexpaua"tbctl satojlro JC)
ospaue Hr.rx cynp,vrog Il c,y-jt: u npouerypa l,{e;1r{aut'r}i 61'ler HailpaBiie Ha ila
coxpaxenr.{e 'roro, qefo }{er yxe !lilCIr"tie rorr,r. J'arixe cynp-y-rr{ r{oly"r pijc'ropi'lti-t)
Spax no B3&i.tl,{Hol.r!' corxact{rs, noi}Hl]crbto }rileryx}.rpoBr1B B lccy'le6uo${ noptr}ie
eonpocbt o t\,{ecTe :{il.{T*itbcTBa ;,icreii 14 nopfiJiie \'njtaTbl axltI,{el{TCIB Ha r{x
co"tepx{aHue In. I cr.2'1 CH p{ij, CI nnprjiKe o6uteuus c pe6*uxou (n I cr'" 6{: [,ld
PS) l.t r.r1. f{p1'rurtl cJlona:\".ifi, }{oxt{o npriBecrH Ntauc}' np}'t1\,{epon. Korjlil
*6N:a:rertuuas npouf;g.vpa npHto{}4p*r-{}.is 6y.ler Bbrcr!'nt}Tb trofloJII{t'{Terb}{bti\I
npeIlffTCTts!{eh,l HS IIYTH OC"VU{eCTBjleHt{ff 3ii}i0Hl-iblX flpaB.
Kpo*le roro, He Bile,'tHe iloF{J{'rHo, KaKoB 61.'lel crarvc cileut{ani{3}4po*aHnoro
ll.1egnar'.teuoro opr*xa {rocy.ilapcre{tHHLr}:i, [.{yHt4ld}.tnaJbHbtii, gacrnntt't) l't :a cqs'f
KaJ{r'rx cpe'lcrB S,v;ier oc,yn{ec'ftl,i{t{Tbet ern (rttHaiicltponilHi.le.
2. onpelerenHbls coMH*Hlifl l3bl3blilaer 1l npe;tjlol'Kenuc aBTop[l BKjllorjt'{rb lt
fpaxlaHcxnii npr:ueccytulbHbrft soi:,exc Psr flau,r" 31.3 <llpnlt3Boilcrlso no ,[era\l o
Flacrspxeux[t 6paxa fi ctsx3a]{Hblx c H}r\r cfiopot}> tc. l0-1?}. flpe.lc'ranJtte'rcfr, Lil.o
nulcl6uatii n$j{xojl *o FFe;ueHer.{ np}'iBejler K lilrpo\.{oiK;1eHI'tK) fipoueccYa"lbl'lill'o
3apogoiere.Tllcrga ofpollnbt*.l Ko"r],{Ltfcl'Bol{ }lopu, nocilxu-lg}{t{btX nolotJHbl\t .\ iKti.\j
S0npsce}.l| pl 3arpy,&Hr.iT ero npl'{s{eHel{He xR}t cy,uol{. TaN I't ,vqacTHI4KA$'11{ npQuecrit^
B XasHoHa c;Iyq$e yxaSeuxbit &BTopo$r flarotlteu}l.s ${Qxt}to 6uro pa3u*cr}irb B
Cetreitgix4 xo;1exr"e PS, rge yix* co;epxilrrct liacca npo:"leccyil:lllHbl\ npaBlljl (c].
?3 nPacraplxe'r'ir sparca n cyresx*M rropr&Ke np, B3ar4MHo*{ coruac}.r' c}.npyro* Hapacrcpi*f,Hfie 6paxar>; cr' :4 <Bonpocnt. pffipeu,aeN{bre cytohr np' Bbr}receH}.*Jpeue*I{tt o pacropi{ie'I'll. 6paxa>; cr' j9. <<onpele:rc11p1s .{o,rel:r n}r,.r pa.3,lere ooueroHSr)'ujecTBA Cynpliran:r n r.r1.).
3' He BnoJIlIe fioHffTffa no3!ru$x H.A. &{arpcco*a orHoc'Te.[br.io $opl.rr,reor'au:ex't'i o "iler'gx' ltoropbte npe'-fiaraercr yrBspxflarb n,y-Ter.{ Br}iHece}*r,coorBerlrEr$uero ofipeAe-rreHHA Cyra fio {-lHA-lQri.{}.i c ${r,poBbri\,r}, cornaueHl{s$t}.i,Tax' cc'"&u,le*I'lt o noptrx*e odutessx c pefe*Kor,r 3a*rmqaiorc,, B nucl:ueu'oii$*prue {n. ? cr. 66 CK p$j N npxueHeg}"re yxa3aHuoro noprrxa Bnolrue .,rlor,vc.r}:lr.to.o;:Hnro corfleue'ttg os ,*ruIa're &{a${eHToB rlogJre}Kar Horap,a{b'or{,vy,ilocrCIEppeillils (n. I cr, 100 CK FS) x l.ix yrneplrleilue cytrol,{ 6-v,rer rj3n}iur}r}.n,.B i{AHHOI\.| Cfiyqae j\.ICI}fiH(} np{]BCCTH aH&{Ortlru C :1OKatA.r.er,rbcTBa,\.{tr, KoTOpbleofscne'{Hga}orc.{ Horapayceuu {cr. l0: Ocso* 3axoxo&arer,t},crga poccllficroii$egepailnlt o Horapnare) tJ nCIc,ne sToro xe rpespor r{}r*axoro },rocro'epeH}.r.s cocT{ipsHhr c};Ia. 6onee Tor0, HoTitp}iyc & no"1lo6strx cJ}.qarx p,vi{CIFoncr8verc!coorBgrc?Byl4lr{}rMH HOp}'lAl!{H rpax.{aHCKOTO ilpCIueccyafibI-toro 3aKOHO.[&Te;..ri:c.fBiiPoccxfrcxos seaep&i{Ntl {cr. 103 ocxor 3afiCI}ro,aareJ.rr}crBa pocci.lricxoir sexepaqrJljo uorapr.rare).
Bxgcr* c ?es.t, HSjToli{ei-i}tbte Sarlerr&fiH,{ He cntfxiaioT ueHuocr!{ itpogej1eHnoro
'{}iccepraukoHHoro }lcc'flefioBaHHg, Koropoe npe;{cTets,'Lse'r cr:Soli cepbe3H}jKli'ayu'yr* pa60ry. fien,ca'Hyn, HA a*ry&rrbHylo !r xl,rerouyFo 60ri,uoeTeopeTr4qecxos sHAqeHt{e Tet{y.
Kax BI{glto }r3 anrope$epaTa, oclrorJHbre TLlopgl},rrecKu* Bbrgo;rbr }.r
npaKTl{qe(xfie peKo]\'leuxauliH Hau"Ill cBoe orparieHHe n ony6lnr{oBllH}.rt}Jx aBTorloupa6orax, & Ta*lr{e B ero Bbrcryni.rer{Hfix xa xou$*pe}{u}rxx.
Anrcpe$eper coornercrnyer rsrvre rl.{cceprau}.ig }.{ pacxpbr3aer ee co.{epxaH}ie .
coxepxax'e a'Tope$epara no3'ojrr{er crej,rarb Bbr'or, o roj\r. vro pa6*.ral{.A. &{arpoco*a orgeqfirr rpe6onangNn:, npsAate.{reNrbr${ K }iaH,{lr,{arcrdusrgHccepTal{il.{1v1, a ee aBTOp tAcnyX{HB&eT npr.jC}.iKrxeH}.{e F{Onc}rvroli yUexofi CreneUlr *xaI{AHgeTa ispfi,{HqecxHx H&VH.
Omuln noilrorogflefi AoIieHToM xa$eapar rpax,qaHcxoro npaBa H npotlecca
lOVpfY, KaHAHaaroM lopt{.{r.,qecxu"x Hayx A,A. AsexceeBbrilr, o6cy'xrten i.r o,to6peu
sa 3aeexaxNx xa$*rpu 3 anpers 2016 r. {npo,oxon J\h 8)
3anelymur,rfr xa$enpofi rpaxaanexcro npana npouesca
SFfSy BnO <<ioxno-Ypanncxnfi rocysapcrneHnaifi
yxssepsxterx {HtriIY}, ran,qn (cr topu"&lrqec KHX HayK,
goue$T {euiraosa l-anxna CrenanosHa
yuxrepcnrer> (HHY). rel. (351) 267-71-16
flo.{ronhlfr a.qpsc : 4 5 4080, t{exx 6N ncx, Y;r. Ko rn* r*lyuri,
x. 149, x" 403. e-mail: lqpfbdqp..gp@rnail,ru
Cafir: http: jurfak. susu. ru
Ha aBTopeoepar
OT3bIB
Aucceprarlru Marpocona Hurco.nas A.nerccanApoBntl<<Oco6enHocrrr cyAorrpo[3BoAcrBa no AeJraM o pacropxeHr{r{ 6parca *r
cBfl3aHHbrx c HrrM crropoB>>, flpeAcraB.nenHofi Ha coI{cKaHHe y.reuofi crerleHrrKaHArrAara roprrAurrecKnx HayK rro c[eq[aJrbHocrr{ 12.00.15 - rpa}r(Aaucnufirpoqecc; ap6urpaxnufi rpoqecc (Caparon 12016. - 28 c.)
flpuvrenureJrbHo rc z:6pansofi cueqkr€LrrbHocru (12.00.15) cyaoupolr3BoAcrBoIIo AeJraM o pacTopxreHnn opaKa Lr cB.rr3aHHbIX c Hr4Mrr cnopoB - BecbMa 3HaquMhIH
rroABLrA cy4e6nofi AerrenbHocrn, opraHr43arlprr Koroporo HanptMylo 3aBHcI4T orypoBHr pa3Burrus rpax(AaHcKo-[poqeccyurJrbHbrx orHor]rennfi. s o6qecrse.
Cpa:y cJleAyer orMeruTb, rITo upo6levra eS$exrzBHocrLI coIII4€uIbHo-
focyAapcTBeHHbrx cr4cTeM pr rroAcr4creM, p€I3HoBr4AHocTbro Koropblx flBJrflercfi.
cyAonpor43BoAcrBo rro AeJraM o pacTop)KeHr{u opaKa I4 cBt3aHHbIX c HI4MLI clopoB,BceFAa krHTepecoBaJra rrpeAcraBurerefi rcpr{Auqecrofi HayKH. K coNareHl4ro, ro-HacrorrqeMy KoMUIeKcHbrx, MHoroacreKTHbrx LrccJreAoBasuit srofi upo6reuaruru(nupouevr, KaK r4 Bo MHorr,rx LrHbrx pa3HoBr4AHocrrx cy4e6Hofi Ae.f,TeJlbHocrn) AoHacTof,rrlefo BpeMeHr4 He rrpoBolranocb.
Ocuosa 3aMbrcJra Ar{ccepraHTa - MHoroJrernLre vccne4oBaHLrfl. amyamHofinpo6neuu - Sarr caM rro ce6e uoroxr.rreJrbHstit, u6o rcpuAurrecKoMy coo6qecrnyylKe AaBHo nopa rroHfTb, qTo cyqecrBoBaBrrrr4e Br4Abr cyAorlpou3BoAcrBapacrop)KeHlrr{ 6parca u cB.fl3aHHbIX c IaLTMLT cnopoB npoBepKu Lr
cy.{e6nrtx perueuzfi,HacrpoeHbr.
O6reKrusHrle
uaros$SeKTr{BHbr, a 3aqacrylo soo6qe a6conronro HeBepHo
[pllqlrHbr I4HTepeca K rrpo0JreMe opfaHI{3aIILILI
cyAonpou3BoAcTBa rro AeJraM o pacTopx(eHvrkr opaKa I4 cBt3aHHbIX c HI4MI4 CTIOpOB -gro mo6arbHble I{3MeHeHI4.g B c
coBpeMeHHoro o6rqecrsa, rpoQ epe S opuupo BaHkrfl, coIII{€uIbH o-rlpaBoBoro craryc a
6ylorqero [pI4HIIIl[uaJIbHo HoBbIx BI4AoB, Qopr*,cnoco6oe, uppleMoB I{ MeroAoB ero 3aIrII4TbI.
XaparrepLr3ys, aKTyanbHocrb reMbr Akracepralll4oHHoro tlccJleAoBannfl, HeJIb3t
He o6parurr B:ntrvra:nr4s, Ha ruy6oro cnopHyro, uopofr AI4aMerp€IJIbHo
rrporr4BorroJroxHyro rpaKroBKy cyAonpor3BoAcrBa rlo AeJIaM o pacropxeHl{I{ 6paxa
u cB{3aHHbrx c HI{MH CnOpOB, HeOAHO3HaqHOCTb OIIeHOK IIepCneKTpIB pa3BIdTUfl.
AaHHO|O kTHCTI{Tyra, B qaCTHOCTI{.
I,Iueercs ocrp€u norpe6nocm o6HonneHz.s non-stufiHo-KareroprraJrbHoro
anilaputa B Teopr4ll opraHl.43arJvrkr cyAorrpon3BoAcTBa no AenaM o pacTopxteHI4I4
6parca H cBr3aHHbrx c HLrMr{ clopoB. Tpe6yerct rloAroroBKa Hayr{Ho o6ocnosauHrrx
npegroxennfi co Bep rrreHcTBoBaHI{Io Hopruarunuofi npanonoft
AesreJlbHocrl{ cy6terron [pol{3BoAcrBa IIo AeJIaM o pacropxeHl{Iz
cBf,3aHHbIX C HI,IMI4 CTIOpOB.
AxryanrHocrb Ar4ccepraqr{oHHoro IaccJIeAoBaHufl, o6yclonlvrBaerlfl' Lr
AuAaKrr4rrecKlrMr4 Saruopauz. B yre6no-ueroAu.{ecxofi nl,ITeparype BorlpocaM
IIO.IIEJIAM O
IIepecMoTpa
OCHOBbI
6paxa 14
OpfaHI{3aIII{LI CyAOIpOLI3BOACTBa rIO AeJIaM O pacTop)KeHI4I4 OpaKa V cBfl3aIIHhIX c
Hr{M[ CnOpOB yAeJrreTCt {BHO HeAOCTaTOTIHOe BHUMaHr4e: nHOfAa O HeKOTOpbIX
BaxHbrx acrreKrax AaHHoft pur3HoBr4AHocrr4 cyAe6Hofi AerreirbHocrr{ Boo6qe He
y[oMLIHaeTC.[. 3aMarqflsarorcf ee pe3yJrbrarbr, coorBercTBeHHo, He IroKa3brBaeTc.rr
HX r{eHHOCTb, a paBHO He AHUrr43LrpyrOTCr pefyJI.STnBHbre BO3MOXHOCTT4
cyqecrByarrlr4x: HopMaTr{BHo-npaBosofi 6a3H r{ npaKrHKr4 cy6beKroB rrpoqecca.
XaparrepLrsyfrpa3pa0oraHHocrlr,6olrruuncrno pa6or, cnequaJrbHo nocBrrrleHHbrx opranvrca\Lrr4 cyAonpou3BoAcrBarro AeJraM o pacrop)KeHr4lr 6par<a n cBflsanHbrx c Hr4Mr4 crropoB, e$SerrraaHocrl4cyulecrByrorlzx ero cxeM, rroAroroBJreHo 6es yrera Bcex noeefinzx AocrLDKenufi so6nacru rcpr{AuqecKr{x HayK.
CoucnareJreM yuenoft crerreHrr rrpeAeJrbHo flcHo rI ToqHo orlpeAeJrenblrleJrr{ u 3aAarr[ uccJreAoBaHr{fl, ero o6beKT, rrpeAMer rr npeAeJIbI, crpyKTypa llcoAeplr(aHue pa6orbr, Kpyr [ccJreAyeMblx npo6.nena LI BorlpocoB.
HavqHaq HOBII3HA IICCJIEtrOBAHI,.fl onpeAenreTcfl) [pe]KAe Bcero,
HeopAr{HapHocrbro KoMrrJreKcHoro noAxoAa K aHaJrr,I3y coAepxaHrzx sSSercrI{BHocrLI
cyAorrpou3BoAcrBo no AeJraM o pacropxenuu 6paxa Lr cBt3aHHbIX c HI{MI,I clopoB.O uayuHofi HoBr43He r4ccJreAoBantrs, B onpeAeJlesuofi crerleHl{
cBI{AeTeJIbCTByTOT 14 ITOJTOXeHI{{, BbIHOCT{Mbre Ha 3aIrII4Ty, KaXAOe U3 KOTOpbIX
o6raAaer He roJrbKo rrpl{3HaKaMr4 aKTyanbHocrla, Ho }r ueo6xoAuMbIMLI ceoficrsa\4l4Teop ernrrecrofi I4 rrp aKTla.recKofi 3 HarrHM ocrlr.
CragaHnoe o6rerrusHo o6ycraerr4Baer reoperlaqecKyro 3HarIIiIMocrb
rrpoBeAeHHoro l4ccJreAoBaHr4fl., TaK KaK pa:pa6oraHHble aBTopoM troJlo)KeHla.fl B
orrpeAeJreHnofi Mepe o6oraulalor reopr4ro npaBa u rocyAapcrBa, f{eHl4e o
rrpor43BoAcrBe no AeJraM o pacropxeHur 6para u cB.rr3aHHbIX c HI4MII cnopoB.
Jlr,r.rHsrfi BKJTaA aBTopa B r43yrreHr,re ga.ssreHuofi TeMbI cocrol4T B
cJreAyroqeM:-HacrorreJrbHoMrpe6onanuuaKTvrBn3ar\vrr4Me4r4ar\nv;- ycrpaHenuu SoprvraJrbHocreit, ua:-l.uuwe Koropblx, cKopee - AaHb rlpoilrnoMy,
qeM BaxHa.fl TeKyIrIar HeooxoAl{Mocrb;
Crpyrrypa padorrr o6ycnoBJreHa rlenflMr4 rrpoBeAeHHoro I{ccneAoB ankrfl.
OrMe.taq B rIeJroM ruacmra6sufi xapaKTep fi r.ny6uHy rlpoBeAeHHoro
aBTOpOM I{CCJTeAOBAHIIfle HeJrb3fl B TO }I(e BpeMfl He OTMeTHTb, rITO OTAeJIbHbIe
rloJro?r(eHrrfl. \t BbrBoAbr AaJreKo ne 6eccuopHbl, n pa6ore lrMerorcs paccyll(Aennfl,rpe6yrcqne yrorlHeHrlfl .
1. I4crnnqr4TeJrbHo BaxHoe [paKTr4rrecKoe 3HarIeHI,Ie TIMeJII{ 6rI no.f,cHeHvrr,
H. A. Marp ocoBa orHo cr{TeJrbH o peKoMeHA a\uit rro opraH u3aTJrz.pr cyAonpor3BoAcrBa rlo
AeJraM o pacropxeHr{r4 6para fi cBs3aHubrx c Hr.rMr.r clopoB He ToJIbKo B ycJIoBI4tx
coBpeMeHHocrr{, Ho u caMoro 6maxafiuero 6ylyqero. Hanounuu, rITo Bce
cyulecrByrouuae B Mr{pe no4o6une cr{creMbr, cnofictneHHble ux SynrqLIoHI{poBaHI{Io
aKTy€IJTbHOCTb TeMbI T4CCJTeAOBAHI/Ifl, Lr CTe[eHb ee
Ar4CCepraHT npaBHJrbHo oTMeqaer, qTo noAaBJlf,Iolqee
3
TexHoJIortIId rlopoxAeHr4e srroxz krn4yarplranbHofi (nera rporrrJroro, a ro uno3arlpounoro). I4M npocro Her Mecra B nocrr'rHAycrpr{anbHoM o6rqecrne. HacMeHy <<oQucy cy.ue6Hornrp> crpeMr.rreJrbHo LrAer <<oQzc> To)Ke cy.ue6nrrft, Ho yx{eBl,Ipryanbuufi... Cueua cl{creM MblcJrrr nezs6exHo BeAer K cMeHe Bcex nporrr4xcrparen{qecKlrx cxeM }r cr{creM, B pf,Ay Korophrx cr{creMbr pacropxewtx 6paxa ncYAe'
2. Anrop He BcerAa yrelrfler AocrarorrHoe BHrrMaHue BonpocaM 3Harrr4Mocrr4
nuQpacrpyKTypbl cyAonpoll3BoAcrBa rro AeJrilM o pacropxenuz 6paxa pr cBflsa\rHbD( c HtrMr{
crropoB, a paBHo cpeAbl, B Koropyro raKoBa.lt o6rr.ruo rrorpy]KeHa. Buecre c reM,I4MeHHo HecoBeplleHcrBo nepeoft, a B pflAe cJry{aeB He ro, rrro ee SparrraenrapHocrb,Ho H ee rIoJIHoe orcyrcrBlre He rro3BoJrrer o6rqecrBy B nonHofi rvrepe saAeficreoBarbea6laroepeMeHHo co3.{aHHbre r4M (MoIIIHocrLD) cr{creM, opLreHTupoBaHHbIX Ha
3aIIII,lTy orHorrreHnit, cxnagbrBaroqraxcr B paMKax rpaxAaHcKoro cyAonpon3BoAcrBa.SunupuuecKrrM nyreM AaBHbrM-AaBHo AoKa3aHo, rrro s$$ercrnBHocrb cyAa
3aBI,iCVTT He OT KarreCTB (GrrlrCTO BHyTpeHHeft CUCreUnOft UnQpaCTpyKTypU>> (ZlaUUX,o6opy4oeaHvre, ra4ponrrfi auuapar), a or ypoBH.s noAforoBKr{ yqacrHaKoBrouQmrxra, rroHrrMas, vMu oyru rrpoqecca npaBooxpaHbr, 3HaHr.rr ero oco6eunocrefi.B qacrnocrl{, HanprrMep, cyA, B ToM rlucre I4 ocyqecrBJrrroil{uit cygonpor{3BoAcrBo no
AenaM o pacropxenuu 6para u cBfl3anHbrx c Hr4Mr,r cnopoB, - 9To, B rlepByro oqepeAb, He
frpexAeHr4e, a MeroA. B nocrcoBercKr4x o6qecreax rocnoAcrByror uqekrI{xAIrBeHqecrBa, Iax rrJIeHbI 3aMepnl4 B oxtuAaHlrz, (KorAa npl4eAer BbIcIuHia cynHaBeAer nopx4oro>. B raKr4x cnyqarx nro6ofi BLr[, cy4e6nofi AesreJrbHocrrlBhrpo)KAaercr B oAHy ras Qopvr aAMr{HlrcrparuBHoro yrlpaBnelevrs*
3. Xorerocr 6s raKxe, .{ro6u aBTop He sa6unar, qro cl{creMacyAorrpor{3BoAcrBa rro AeJraM o pacropxeuun 6paxa 14 cBflsaHHbrx c HI,IMIa crlopoB - He 6oleerreM oAHa r{3 rrpoqeccy€rJrbHbrx noAcrlcreM, rrpr{qeM B Lrx ps.Ay AaJIeKo He caMaf,
BaxHar. CreAosareJrbHo, eS$enrranHocrb pa6oru cl4creMbl (SarirnuecrunoAcl{creutt) cyaonpor,r3BoAcrBa rro AenaM o pacropxeHrara 6para pr cBssauHbnt c HI{MII cnopoB
HalprMyro gaBucur or cxeMbr cno)KeHra.f, aKTlrBHocrefi scero ptAa no.qcllcrevr. Bsroft cB.rr3r{ or r4ccneAoBarenr xoreJrocb 6rr noryql4Tb orBer: Moxter JII4 6sIrre$Serrznnrrvr SynKIITIoHLIpoBaHLIe cLIcreMbI cyAonpor.r3BoAcrBa no AenaM o pacropxeHrl,I
6parca rr cBfl3arrHbD( c Hr.rMr.r cuopoB, ecJIIr B KoHKperuufi ucropl4qecl<uit nepuoA BpeMeHI,I
ne sSSeru.IBHa npoqeccyaJrbHafl. TIoJILITLIKa B IIenoM.
Pa6ora HafiLrcaHa xopourr{M HafrHbrM f,3bIKoM, rlonHocrblo coorBercrByerny6rnraqr4rM aBropa.
V.rr,lrrreat Bbrrrrel43Jro)KeHHoe, ecrb Bce ocHoBaHIa.{ 3aKJrIotII4Tb, rrro pa6otaH.A. Marpocona flBJlrrerc.tr caMocro.[TeJrbHbrM vrouorpaSuqecKl4M 3aKoHqeHHbIM
HocJreAoBaHneM aKTyarbHorz AJr[. HayKLr yronoBHo-npoqeccyaJlbHoro npaBa
upo6leuu, coorBercrByer rpe6onanvrflM) npeAbtBJIfeMbIM K .qlaccepralll{rM Ha
cor{cKaHrae yreuofi crerreHr{ KaHAr4Aara ropu4vrtlecKl,Ix HayK a6g. 2 n. 9, I4 I{HrIM
rpe6orauvrfrM, ycraHoBJreHHbrM Pas4enoir,r II floroxenufl. o rlpl4cyx4ertru yqeHbIX
creneseft, yrBep)KAeuHoro IIocraHonJreHI4eM llpanurenbcrBa Poccnficrofi(De,4epaquu or 24 ceurxSpr 2013 roAa Is 842 (n peA. lIocraHosJIeHI{rI
4
flpannrenbcrBa PO or 30 I4IoJIf, 2014 r. .Nlb 723), a ee aBrop 3acnyxr4Baernpl4cyxAeHLrfl ucrouofi yueHofi cre[eHLr KaHALrAara ropraArarrecKr4x HayK rrocrequaJrbHocrlr 12.00 .1 5 - rpax Aaucrcnfi npoqecc, ap6urpaxHrrfi upoqecc.
Cyars BepxonHoro CyAa PtD (n orcranrce),npoQeccop KaQegpu cyAe6Hofi uacru,rrpaBooxpaHrrreJrbHofi n rrpaBo3arrlrlrHofiAefl TeJrbHocrrr I4Hcrnryra coqr{aJrbuo-ryMaHlrrapHoroo6pasonanrq (DIEOY BO<<Mocrcoecrcnfi rreAarorrrqecrcnfirocyAapcrseHHrrfi yHlrBepcrrrer>>,
AOKTOp rOpUAUqeCKrrX HayK, AOTIeHT ,1
H.A. Kororcoros
Jr" 03
Hurcura A.nerccanApoBuq Ko.norco.non
/'A/6e .
.4 &, #o,rir{cad!1-.,{L rrg57t, r. MocKna,, J ;,! , Itrpocrerr BepuaAcKofo, ,q. 88
nt/,;,t",/,/ / Ter.: (495)438-18-45V/{K{ --r-v -
ffi
OT3hIB
Ha aBTope{epar Aucceprarl*fir Ha reMy: <<Oco6eHHocrr4cyAorlpou3BoAcrBa rlo AeJraM o pacropxeHlrrr 6parca r{ cBfl3aHHbrx c HrrMCnOpOB> BI'IrIoJrHeHnofi na concKaHrre yvenoft cTerleHrr KaHArrAaTa ropuAuqecKr.rxHayK ro crequaJrbHocrlr 12.00.15-rpalr(AaHcKr{fi npoqecc, ap6nrpaxutrft upoqecc,
upeAcraBJrennofi K 3arrlrrre B Ar{cceprarluonnrrft coBer (DIFOy BIIO <<Caparoncrcanf ocyAapcTBeHHas roprrArrqecKaq aKaAeMr.rfl )>,
Marpoconrrnr Huro.rraen ArercaHApoBilrreM
lzccepralll4oHHat pa6ora H.A. MarpocoBa BbrnoJrHeHa Ha aKry€ubHyro B
HayqHoM I4 npaKTHqecKoM oTHoIIreHkru TeMy, rrocBfrr{eHHylo ocooeHHocTf,M
cyAonpou3BoAcTBa Iro AenaM o pacTopxeHr4r4 6parca v cBr3aHHbrx c Hr,rM
cnopoB. Ar<ryamHocrr TeMbr ALraceprarlvtL ollpeAentreTcf, HayqHbrM u
[paKTHr{ecKr4M r{HTepecoM K o6beKTy r4ccneAoBaHr4r. Kax cnpaBeAnr4Bo yK€B€Ln
Ar4CCepTaHT B O6OCnOSaHr4e aKTyanbHOCTr,I nrr6pannOfi TeMbr, (Hzurr4r{r4e
--AeTaJrbHo npopaooTaHHofo 3aKoHoAaTeJrbcTBa, HopMbr KoTopofo pa3paooTaHbr
Ha ocHoBe TeopeTHqecKHX oooouleHnl4 u B cooTBeTcTBtrx c npaKTHrlecKrrMr4
rrorpe6HoerflMLr odulecrna, c ytreroM Bcex oco6eHHocrefi npoqeccy€LnbHoro
noprAKa pacropxeHr4.rr 6paxa, 6y4er flBrrflTbcfl. fapaHTkrefi coxpaHeHr4f,
ceMefiHbrx r{eHHocrefi c freroM npaB r{ rrHTepecoB Aerefi)).
Arryamuocrb Aracceprarlr4r4 TarcKe o6rxcusercr reM, qro [oro]r(eHr4t
HbrHe 4eficrnyroqefi HopMarr4BHo-npanonofi 6a:rr, pernaMeHrupyrorqefi
froprAoK 3aKJrrorreHufl, pacroplKeHr4q 6paxa u cocro.xHl{t B HeM, rlo.{Beprarorc-f,
cI{creMaTI4rIecKoMy T0JIKOBaHI4TO BbIITIeCTO.[qIrMLI CyAA]|idI,j.) rITO
cBr{AereJrbcrByer 06 r{x HecoBeprxeHcrBe, a cav'a npoqe.qypa pacropxteHl4{
6paxa r4 pa3peueHprfl cBfl3aHHbrx c Hr4M crropoB, HecMorps Ha Kaxyqyrocfl,, Ha
nepnrrfr B3rJr;rA npocrory, Bbr3brBaer Ha rrpaKTI4Ke 3HaqI4TerbHbIe rpyAHocrr{.
3ry npo6neMy B cBor4x rpyAax e rofi utru ulr'oit Mepe 3arparlzlBaJru C.H. Bypoe,
P.E. fyracxu, O.A. Ka6rtures, VIII. Kopxaron, f .K. Marneen, H.VI.
llpor<ourxnna, T.M. I{enr<oea. OAsaro 6oruurzncrno rpoqeccyanl{croB, B
cBor4x r{ccneAoBaEuflx Aenzlnu aKrIeHT Ha coquonofur{ecKyro cTopoHy opaqHbrx
orHorrreHvit, ttu6o nocBfrrl€tirr4 cBoe r43yqeHr4e rarofi-ru6o ysrofi TeMarrrKe.
HoeugHa pa6orrr cocrolrr B ToM, r{To oHa flBlrflerefl [epBbrM Ha
coBpeMeHHoM grarre pa3Burufl 3aKoHo.qareJrbcrBa vronorpaSr4rrecKr4M
prccneAoBaHr4eM, B KoropoM orrpeAeJreHbr oco6eunocrr4 cyAolpor{3BoAcrBa rro
AenaM o pacTopxeHr4r4 opaKa n cMexHbrx c Hr4M crropoB; BbrflBJreHbr rt
HccJreAoBaHbr [poqeccy€urbHbre oco6eHuocrrz, xapaKTepHble 4.nfl rcaxAofi
cra^r4v cy4e6uoro paz6upareJrbcrBa rro AenaM o pacrop)KeHl{I4 6parca v
cB.s3aHHbrx c Hr4M crropoB; BHeceHbr npeAno)KeHvrfl IIo I{3MeHeHI4Io vI pasBI4TuIo
4eficrnyroulero 3aKoHoAareJrbcrBa
paccMarpueaer4oft Kareropr4v Len.
[uccepraquoHHoe r4ccneAoB aHr4e
aBTOp yKa3brBaeT 14 pacKpbrBaeT
prccneAoBaHnfl; crerreHb nayvnofi paspa6oraHHocrlr reMbr; o6lerr u [pe.{Mer
r4ccneAoBaHprfl; rleJrr4 v 3a\aqu r4ccneAoBaHufl;
MeroAoJroruqecKa.s, TeoperlrqecKaf, kr SMnllpuqecKa.f, ocHoBa
Qopuynrapyrorcr ocHoBHbIe rIoJIox{eHI{t, BhrHocrrMble
xapaKTepr{3yeTcq npaKTurleaKafl. u Teoperl4tlecKa{ 3Haql4Mocrb
npr4BoA{Tcs cBeAeHus, o HayqHofi anpo6a\uu [onyqeHHblx pe3ynbraroB.
B nepnofi rJraBe <<LlcropuqecKue rrpeArrocbrJrKn I{ccJreAoBaulutfl
oco6euHocrefi cyAorrpon3BogcrBa rrpu paccMorpeHrllr AeJra o pacroprKeHlrrr
6para>> Aaercfl aBTopcKr{fi mrn.a4 Ha cyqecrByrorqyn [peeMcrBeHHocrb I4
oco6yro AH€ureKTLrKy pa3Br.rrufl vrmcrnryroB rpaxAaHcKoro rlpoqeccyaJlbHoro
rrpaBa, cBs3aHHbrx c pacropxeHl4eM 6paxa. Anrop [pI{xoAI4T K BbIBoAy, r{To,
HecMoTpg Ha npeI4MyrIIecTBeHHoe 3Har{eHue AofoBopHoro Har{aJra Bo Bcex
sJreMeHTax 6paunoro coro3a, rocyAapcrBeHHail I4AeororkI-fl nocrotHHo
KoppeKTr4poBulna o6qrae reHAeHrILrrz B pasBurvrv 6pavno-ceuefinrx
ourourenrafi. llo4o6nyro recHyro B3aIrMocB.l36 Me)KAy rocyAapcreeHHofr
B OOJIACTI,I pefynHpoBaHr4fl
HaqHHaeTct c BBeAeHr4fr, B KOTOpOM
aKTyaJlbHocrb sa-f,nreHHofi TeMbI
pacKpbrBaeTct
r4ccJreAoBaHus,
HA 3arrlr4Ty,
I4CCneAOBAHvIfl.)
uAeonorraefi u sonpocaMr{ pacropxeuux Spaxa AvrccepraHT npocJre)r{HBaer 14 B
AaJrbHer{meM, aHaJru3r4py fl yxe 3aKoHoAaTenbcTBo coBeTcKofo nepHola.
Bo nropofi r.nane <<flopn4oK cyAorrporr3BoAcrBa rrpu paccMorpeHr{r{
AeJr o pacroplneH[r{ 6parca>> aBTop BLr-rrBrqer oco6esnocrr{ cyAorrpor,r3BoAcrBa
no AenaM o pacrop)KeHm 6parca Ha pa3nr4rrHhrx npoqeccyzurbHbrx cra4urx. Ha
rrpr{Mepe 4efrcrnynIqero 3aKoHoAareJrbcrBa Ar.rccepraHr xapaKrepn3yer
cyle6uyo rporleAypy, [enafl, BbrBoA o seo6xoArrMocrrz ee coBeprreHcrBoBaHra{.
B peaynrrare npoBeAeHHoro r4ccneAoBaHkrfl 6sllu ycraHoBJreHbr rr o6ocHoeaHrr
oco6euuocrr4 craAuu cyge6Horo paz6upareJrbcrBa rro AenaM o pacroplreHr{rr
opaKa.
B rpersefi r.uane <<Oco6esHocrr.r paccMorpeH[q c[opoB, cBfl3aHHbrx c
pacrop)KeHueM 6parca>> ArrccepranToM 6uru Hccne.qoBaHbl npoqeccyanbHrle
oco6ennocru paccMorpeHvrfl. v pa3perueHl4rl crlopoB, cBt3aHHbIX c
pacropxeHfleM 5para.
Crpyrrypa pa6orbr B rlenoM Jrorur{Ha, coorBercrByer reMe 14 no3BoJl.xer
ee pacKpbrrb.
K flBHbrM Kpr4Tepr{{M raccne.{oBareJrbcKoro xapaKTepa npone4enuofr
Ar4ccepraHToM pa6omr neo6xoAr,rrro orHecrrr ry rIoJIeMI4Ky, a I,IHorAa u
Kpr4Tt4 Ky, Korophle rlpncyrcrByror Ha crpaHl4qax pa6orrt.
lloloxureJrbHbrM MoMeHToM Bbrcrynaer MeroAoJIorI4t I,lccneAoBaHnfl.,
6asupyrorqas.es. Ha o6rqenayr{HoM ArraJreKTr4qecKoM Mero.qe [o3HaHrr.s, MeroAe
corluo-KynbrypHoro aHaJrH3a, $oprvranrHo-AorMarl{rlecKoM, I4cropl{Ko-
ilpaBoBoM 14 CpaBHr4TeJIbHO-npaBOBOM A}{a"JrVr3e, MeTOAe AHaJMa U OOOOIIIeH'Ifl.
cy4e6nofi [paKTr{Kr4, r{To rro3BoJrr4Jro Ar4ccepraHTy npoBecrl4 yrny6nennoe
HccJreAoBa:aue oco6ennocrefi cyAorrpoz3BoAcrBa no AeJIaM o pacrop>KeHvrr4
6paxa rr cBs3aHHbIx c HHM crlopoB.
Hayunar v [paKTr4rrecKaq 3Haqr4Mocrb Aanuofi TeMbI o6ycloueua
3a.{aqaMr4, Koropbre aBTop rrocraBlrfi glt. ce6t. Coracrarenb ycneruHo e lnkrv'kr
cilpaBr4lrcfl, a caMlv 3ailalsr4, flBuIrLrcb BepHo r,r36paHHbrMr4 14 rrpaBrrJrbHbrMr4
cp e A c r B a Mu [nfl . Ao cTH x e H r4.f, rr o c T aB Jr e H H o fi rI e Jr 14 r,r c c Jr eA o B aHvrfl .
HonusHa AucceprarlnoHHoro HccneAoBa:nvrfl pacKpbrra B BbrHocr4Mbrx Ha
3arrlrlrTy rroJroxeHusx. LIx colepxaHr4e cBrrAerenbcTByer, qro aBTop noKa3aJr
co6crseHHoe cyxAeHr4e rro ras6panHofi nayunofi rpo6rerrrarnrce, BbrcKa3€ur
HOBbIe MbICJII4 Z nonyr{r4Jr HOBbre pe3ynbTaTbr, COBOKyTTHOCTb KOTOpbTX r4MeeT
BHyTpeHHee eAr,rHcTBo H cBraAeTenbcTByeT o Jrr4r{HoM BKJraAe aBTopa B HayKy
fpaKAaHcKofo rrpoqeccyaJrbHofo npaBa.
Co4epxanrae lzcceprarlr4oHHoro lrccneloBaHr4fl Hoclrr rnopuecrufi
xapaKrep. Anrop KoppeKrHo BeAer AucKyccuto Ha crpaHLIIIax csoefi
ArrccepTarlr4r4, BbrBoAbr I4 npeAnox(efIv'i Jrofr4qHo BbrTeKaroT u3 I4ccJreAyeMofo
Marepr.r€rJra r4 orJlr4rrarorc{ Lr3BecrHofi uayuuofi noeusHofi. Bnaecre c reM, rrepeA
aBTopoM Moryr 6urr rocraBJreHbr cneAyrcIque Borlpochr:
1) Anropol,r yKa3brBaercq, r{To r43yr{eHlle I4cropI/FIecKI4x npeAnocblnoK
cyAonpou3BoAcTBa rro AenaM o pacTopxeHr/rr4 6parca rro3BoJII4JIo ycTaHoBI{Tb,
r{To co BpeMeH o6H.rHoro [paBa kr Ao rro{BJreHra-f, xo4lrSzqupoBaHHblx
HopMarr4BHo-rrpaBoBbrx 3aKoHoB cyrqecrBoBall4 rlpoqeccy€tJlbHble oco6eHnocru
pacropx{eHr4.f, 6parca: o6qgareruHo ocyqecrBJrflIrvrcb rIpeABapI4TeJIbHbIe
p.eitcrsus (nponepxa [pe.qcraBJreHHbrx AoKa3arenbcrBa, BbI3oB B cyA orBerrILIKa,
cnrE4erelefi, Mr4pHoe yperynr4poeanue); ycraHaBnr4BaJracb IToITIJIHHa 3a
o6parqeuvre; B cy4e6Hou perxeHrar4 orrpeAentncs noptAoK npox{vBaHkrfl. Aelefi u
r{MyrrlecrBeHHbre rlpaBa cylpyroB. O6o6u{eHI4e orIbITa nporunofo
rrpeAocraBr4Jro Bo3Molr(Hocrb BburBr4Tb e$SerrznHocrb yKa3aHHbIX uHcrl4TyroB,
KOTOpbre B HaCTOflrrIee BpeMf, r{cnonb3yrorcr B cyAorIpoI43BoAcTBe rlo AenaM o
pacropx(euuu 6paxa.
B srofi eBfl3v\ lepeA aBTopoM Mo)Ker 6uru rocraBJleH Borlpoc, B rIeM
3aKrroqaerc.fl
I.I,ICCepTaHTOM
pacroplKeHl4r{
aS$errznHocrb neperrkrcneHHbrx v HCCJIENOBAHHbIX
T4HCTI4TyTOB B COBpeMeHHOM CyAOIpOI43BOACTBe IIO lenaM O
5parca?
2) Tpe6yer AonoJrHr4reJrbHoro o6ocHosaHr,rq ilpeAJroxeHr4e aBropa o
coKpaIrIeHHu cpoKa, oTBeAeHHofo An-fl rrpr4MrlpeHrrfl cTopoH Ao oAHofo Mecflrla,
I4 3aKperlreHr4fl o6.f,saHHocrr{ cropou o6paqeHprfl K BHecyAe6uonay rop{AKy
ypefynr4poBaEr4t cnopoB B TerreHr{e 3Tofo cpoKa.
B crtytlae 3aKpenneHl4f, o6.asarelbHofo nnecy4e6Horo nopf,AKa
pa3pelreHlzs c[opoB, BbITeKaK)uIr4x vr3 cerrrefino-6pauHux oruorueuufi, He
6yayr nI4 HapyueHo KoHcrrrryr{r{oHHoe lpaBo rpax{AaH, B r{acrHocrr4, [paBo Ha
o6parqeHpre B ay4, a raruKe npaBo Ha pacropx(eHr{e 6parca, ycraHoBneHHoe
CeuefisrrM KoAeKcorr,r P@?
Bucra:annue 3aMer{aHu-tr Hoc{T, B ocHoBHoM, clopnrtfi kr
peKoMeHAarenrnrrfi xapaKTep, rrooroMy He MoryT [oBJrr4rrb Ha o6rqyro
tloJloxturenbHyro oqeHKy AucceprarlLroHHofo r4ccneAoBaHkrs. H.A. Marpocona.
Ha ocHoBaHIlI{ I43JIo)KeHHoro rroJraraeM, qro Ancceprarlr4oHHar pa6ora
Marpocona Huxora-f, Aler<caH4poBr4qa Ha reMy: <Oco6enHocru
cyAorlpo[3BoAcrBa IIo AeJraM o pacrop]KeHurr 6parca rr cBfl3aHHbrx c HrrM
crropoB)) BbrrroirHeHa Ha AocTaTorrHo BbrcoKoM Ha) {HoM ypoBHe, oonaAaeT
uayuuofi HosnsHofi, r.rMeer [paKTrlqecKyro 3HaquMocrb, coorBercrByer BceM
rpe6oaannxu pa3Aena II floronceHuq o roprrAKe rrprcylnAeHrrfl yqeHbrx
creneHefi, yrBeplrqeHHoro rrocraHoBJreHneM flpannreJrbcrBa Poccuficrcofi
(De4epaqur{ or 24 cesrsOpn 2Ol3 roAa Nb 842, a aBrop Akrccepraqrara H.A.
Marpocon 3acJryxrlBaer rrpr4cBoeHrzfl uayunofi creneHr.r KaHAr4Aara
ropuAur{ecKrlx HayK rro crerlrl€urbHocrr{: 12.00.15 - rpaxAaHcrr,rfi upoqecc;
llpe4ce4arerrb MuruuluHcKorofopoAcKofoMocrcoKAH,II x HayK
ap6wpaxnrrfi npoqecc.
or"qgt"qyr.Kol*ffior.Murr,r@iiTer.: (4eii386''20:E-mail : mitishysu [email protected],[email protected]. sudrf.ru
A.C. Pxcescrufi
PxescKrff
o6racru, 141009
pleeBrrq
OT3bIB
Ha aBTo pe{epar ArrccepTaqun MatpocoBa H[KoJIas A.nerccanApoBnrla
<<Oco6ennocTu cyAonpon3BoAcTBa no AenaM o pacTopzI(eHHH 6parca ncBfl3aHHbrx C HIrM CIIOpOB), [peACTaBreHHOfi Ha COITCKaHHe yqeHofi CTerIeHIr
KaHArrAaTa ropr.rAuqecKrrx HayK no crequaJrbHocrlr 12.00.15 - rpaxAaHcKlrfirpoqecc; ap6nrpaxHblfi rpoqecc
(CaParonr20l5)
Zccne,qoeaHlae upoqeccy€urbHblx ocooeHHocTeI{ paccMoTpe}Jufr.
pa3pelueHprs. Aerr o pacropxeHuu 6paxa, a raKxe cnopoB, cBf3aHHbIx c HHM, BHe
BC.SKOIO COMHeHr.rf,, aKTIiaJrbHo, cBoeBpeMeHHo I'I HMeeT KaK TeOpeTUqeCKOe, TaK
r{ [paKTHrIecKOe 3HaqeHI{e.
3Ha.ruNaocrb Hncrllrym 6para
sarqurofi rocyAapcrBa (cr. 38 KoucmryUnu P@). Tarnu o6pa:ou, fracrue
focyAapcrBa B peryJrr4poBaHr,rH BonpocoB ceuefinoro [paBa, B o6rqeu, u
pacropxeHrrrl 6paxa, B rracrHocru, AoJIxHo 6urr o6ecue'IeHo 6anancou
ny6ruunoro H rlacrHoro HHTepecoB.
Kar BepHo orMeqeHo caMHM At4ccepraHToM, rlpol{eAypa pacropxeHl{Jt
6paxa v pa3perueHrarr cB.rr3aHHbrx c HLrM cuopoB, HecMorpf, Ha Kaxyqyloc.f,
npocToTy, BbI3bIBaeT Ha npaKTHKe 3HatII4TerbHbI e rpyAHocTI{.
B srofi CBx3I,I, NIfi. noBbllueHut e$QerrunHocTrl paccMoTpenns. 14
pa3perxeHns, Aen o pacropxeHr,ru 6para lr cnopoB, cBt3aIrHbIX c HI,IM, Heo6xoAI{Mo
cKoppeKTr,rpoBaTb HeKoTopbre KoHcTpyKr{HrI I{ onpeAeJIHTE UaU6Olee y4aunrtfi
MexaHIa3M HX B3arlMoAefi ctsuf
Coo6pasHo TeMe, ALIccepTaHToM onpeAeneHbl IIeJII,I, 3aAaqll, O6renr,
npeAMeT H MeTOAOJIOTH' HCCJIeAOBAHHS.
I4syueuu, o6o6u{eHbr H npoaHarrr43rrpoBaHbl rpyAbl BeAyIIIHX yqeHbIX -upoqeccyuurr{cToB, oTeqecTBeHHoe 3aKoHoAaTeJIbcTBo pa3IHqHbIX ECTOpHqeCKI{X
[epHoAoB, : apy6 exHoe 3aKoHoAarenbcrno, cy,4e6 Hafl npalcTrrKa.
flpe,qcranilflercs,,.{ro H.A. Marpocory yAaJlocb Aocrutlb 3€ltBJIeHHofi qena u
BeJIrirKa, nocKoJlbKy ceMbs HaxoAl4Tcfl rroA
perxnrb rrocraBJreHHble 3aAaqu. OcHosHHe noJloxeHnfl Lr BbIBoAbI aBTopa,
.,- : .: r..i :!:ri:r:::f 1{'l_:j+}!:r:r .rii r:!r;!..-:r:];i::" ij:_Ifi:1t
BbrHocr,rMbre Ha 3arquTy, orrnrralorcs HoBLI3Hofi noAXoAoB, ttosugHofi apryMeHToB,
co6crseHHblM BHAeHueu npo6leu.
Pxn, uaa6onee 3Hagr4Mbrx, Hd Harlr B3r:rfA, BFTBoAoB 3acJry)Kr{B€rror
rrogepxKu ra oqo6p etr4fl..
1. Teopetuvecru 3Haqr4M6rM rrpeAcraBJlsercr Lr3yqeHl4e ucropnqecKrx
npeArocbrJroK cyAorrpon3BoAcrBa tro Aen,ltra o pacropxenul,I 6para (noroxenue JS
1), qro [o3BoJrHJro aBTopy BbrflBnrb ei[SerruaHocrb ucnoirb3oBaHllr
rrccJreAyeMblx I4HcrHTyroB B coBpeMeHnrr[ neprroA.
2. 3acnyxusaet no4gepxlcrl BbIBo.q aBTopa o ueo6xo4uMocru
guSQeperqupoBaHnoro nogxo4a cy4bla B cra4ur nos6yx4emwfl rtpotr3BoAcrBa no
AeJIy K ycraHoBJreHHK) HaJrHvrr4A ocHoBanllfi Alx orKa3a B IrpLIHfrI,IH ucKoBoro
3€urBJreur{ff; BburcHeHuro Hiulnql,rf, He roJIbKo rrpaBocnoco6Hocrn, Ho vt
Aeecuoco6Hocru 3ar{HTepecoBaHHbrx cy6rerton; [poBepKe MorHBoB pacropxeHla.tr
6para npra oTcyrcTBHLr coilIacnt oAnoro H3 cynpyroB Ha pacropxeHHe 6para;
ycraHoBneHl,rp coHlacut XeHbI B cJIfI€uX, ycTaHoBJIeHHbIX cT. 17 CK
(uorroxenrae Ne 3).
3. IJrrpaxaeM con[rAapHocTb c MHeHI,{eM aBTOpa, O COKpaqeHI/[4 CpOKa,
oTBeAeHHOTO 4lt npllMupeH[It cTopoH, Ao oAHoro MecflIIa v o BHeApeHI{[I
lporleAypbr MeAr{arlnvr 6rs, AeJr AaHHofi rateropnn. B cBt3}I c grtlM, BIIAI,ITcx
Heo6xoAHMbrM co3AaHrre cleqpraJrrr3r{poBaHHoro MeAnarL{BHoro opraHa
(noroxeuue 5).
4. IIpuxnagHoe 3HaqeHHe) Ha Harr B3rlIIA, IrMeroT Bbruocr{Mhle Ha 3al\ury
fioJroxeuilf, 4,6, copep)Karrlne fipoqeccy€urbHrle ocodesuocrs cra4wit [oAroroBKn
AeJra K cy4e6nonry pas6uparenbcrBy lr cyAe6noro pasdnpareJlbcrBa no AenaM o
?pacTopxeHl{H opaKa.
5. llocrconrry cer"refinrre oruolueHr,rr xapalcTepll3ylorcf, csoefr
MHorolpaHHocrbK), rlenecoo6prnHbrM Br,rAI,ITcr lr3yrreHlile npoqeccy€ulbHbrx
ocobeHHocreft paccMorpentrfl. crropoB, cBt3aHHbrx c pacropxeHIleM 6paxa.
,{ncceprarn o6ocHoBaHHo aKr{enTr{pyer BHrrManpre Ha npzlBe cy&a swftrw za
:::.. _ i .::::::::::-:,i,.\jl tlr:iiipil lli'}.it:':;:;tt:LriJff:,r"y.ttrjli:1,:;:,,:,;:,:ZuLgtt{1{l#..Ki
3:rlpe,qenbr 3asBJreHHbrx rpe60,EaHl,{fi, TaK KaK 3To rpecyeT 3au}iTEtr rrpaB v :
3aroHHbrx rrHTepecoB .qeTeft (noxoxenne 8).
B pa6ore co.qeplr(arcs tr Apyrrte lrnTepecHue c Ha1n{Hofi s npaKTr,ruecxof
TOqeK 3perrr4r BhrBoAbr AnccepTaHTa.
B*recre c reM, HeKotoplre cyx{Asnnfi ne deccnopnbr, Tpe6yloT yrorrn€trut
xu6o Aononnratensuo fi apryrvreuTaqr.rv.
l. Ha Haru B3Drx4, rpe6yer )iroquear.rr BbrHocnuoe Ha 3auII{Ty nonoxeulle
Ilb 2. B qerou, nogAep)Klrnarr aBTopa o HeofxoAr{Mocrs o6ecneqenr,rr cygse;fi,
6alauca nydruuuoro u qacrnoro r.rxTepecCIB, ocragrcfi HefcHErM crreAyer JIH oro
gaKpertrirb lra saxorroAareJrbxoru ypoBne sN6o s?o 6yger orrlocr,rrbcfl K
Ar,rcKperlsoHrrErM norHoMolrvfiM cy Na.
2. B r{eJroM, He BospalKarr rro cyu{esrBy cop'eptnawwfi. npeAnaraeMbrx
,qonoruegfiff s fnK PQ a nxge dxanttZ2.3>, cqr4TaeM, qro nocre.4une fioarreryr
Heo6ocgosalrxoe yreJrusegge o6beMa HopMarr4Bllorg npaBoBoro axra, xoropufi
fiBIIfieTAfl ynI4BepCArsHsrM nO OTHOrrrerr4rO Ko BceM paccMaTpHBaeMbIM cnop{lM
,rcroBoro npo?BBoAcrsa. B Aalrr{oM cryqae, Ha }Iatrr B3nInA, 6yger ycMarpl.{Barbct
xersft npaopnTer.{anubrx xareropafi,(er HaA Apyrr{Mrr, He Menes sHaqurvrbrM}r {c.
10-12).
Hecuorpr Ha orMeqexuylo AlrcKyccitonHocrb orAeJlbnbrx uonoNexnft
.qHccepTailaoHHoro litccJle.qoBaHal, 6olbluag ax qacTb, deyuronHo,3acryxr{Baer
BHl4Magr.rf,, A B IIeJIOM [OATBepX,{AeT SrrCOKI,tfi teOpeUmeCXUfi ypOBeHb
rICCJIeAOBAIII{'I.
.{ucceprcrylonnoe pa6ora rBJrfferos Hayrrrro-KBaxuSnxagxosnofi H
[peAcraBJlter codofi KoMnJre$cnoe Monoqpa$auecxoe uccJIeAoBaHrIe, E KoropoM
onpeAeneHrtocc6errxocTEcyAo[poH3FoAcTBaIIoAeJIaMopacTopXeNuu6paxau
cMexHbrx c Hr{M cIIopoB.
Hay.lnyro 3peJrocrb aBTopa noATgepx.{aior crarstl, }BBecrHbIe rayrnofi
o6uecrnenuocrr{. Perylrrarur ,qscceprarluoHuoro [ccJleAonaulla ony6nllroBanbl
B Br{,qe Hayqubrx cratefi (8), B ToM ilxcre B HayiIHbIX w34afififlx,
peKoMeHAoBaHHbIX BAK PO (3).
*-4
F
cxasaHHo e IIA7T OCHOBaHHe CrrHTaTb, qTo AuccepTaqHoHHoe IICCJIeAOBaIII/Ie
Marpocona Hurolax AnercangpoBllqa Ha reMy: <<oco6enuocru
cyAonpomBoAcTBa no AeJraM o pacTopxeHr,Iu 6para II cBt3aHHbIX C HI',IM CnOpoB)
flBlrfrerax KoMnJIeKcHbrM [rccJIeAoBaHr4eM, BHoctIT cyulecrBermrtfi BKnaA B HayKy
[poqeccyaJl6goro rpaBa, o6nagaet UaytUofi HoBH3HOft vr 11O1HOCT6IO
coorBercrByer rr.u. 9, 10 llonoxeHr{r (O nphcyxAeHfiI{ yqeHblx cre[eHefiD'
yrBepxAeHHopo llocrauoerreHrreM flparurenbcrBa or 24 ceutadpx 2013r.Ilb 842
(n peX. floctaHosl erl:zn flpanurenbcrBaP@ or 30 la1()nt 2014 r' Ne 723)
BHsoA: aBrop Ancceprarlnu - Marpocor Hnrconafi A-nercan4poBl4rl
3acJIyxI,IBaeT IIp[cyxAeHHt yrenofi cTeneHu KaHAIlAaTa IopIIAI4qecKHx HayK nO
crreUnzurbHocru 12.00. I 5 - rp2;4Aagcruft npoUecc; ap6ntpaxurrfi npoqecc'
flpaBa Ceaepo-KaBKa3cKoro ifnnuana @e,qepalrHoro rocyAapcTBel{Holo
6pAxefiroro o6pasorareJrbHoro yqpexneHl4s <<POccnficrufi rocyAapcrBeHHblfi
yHI{BepcHTeTnpaBocyAI4fl>,,KaHA.IoPnA.HayK'AoIIeHToMMacrroBofiT.H.'.:
orsrrs o6cyxAen u yrBepxAeH Ha 3aceAaHI4I{ raQegpar rpaxAaHcKoro
npoqeccytUIbHofonpaBa(08))aIIpen'2o|6r.'[poToKorrNe12.I
i.
!
?'
3ae. xaQeApofi rpaxAal{cKoronpoqeccyaJlbHoro npaBa
CKO O|EOYBO <PfYTb)
nar*o flmr*ai lQ' g.
wtaeeprnBedyuait cneqnutll'cm no r$ilPafi
Ktr ",It;-'
nft'o: fto.rrtrartuwa
IO.A. Ilonosa
'encangposHa flonosa
: 350002, r. Kpacnogap,yr. JlenarreBcKoro, 187
TeneQoH: (861) 251-55-rc, E-mail: nc_rla@maif,ru
.www.nc-raJ.ru