B gHccepraqnounuril coner [-212.239.01 npu

,{ncceprauur A. M. Peuteeofi npeAcraBnter co6ofi KoMIIJIeKcHoe,

norur{ecKu 3aBep[IeHHoe, KoHrlerrryanbHoe HayqHoe I4ccneAoBaHHe' Crpyxrypa

Ar.rcceprarluonsofi pa6orrr npeAcraBn.aercq BTIoJIHe nornqsofi H otITI'IMaJIrsofi'

Ona COCTOHT tI3 BBeAeHI4fl, AByX lJIaB, IIISSTH naparpa$On, 3aKItOrIeHHs vI

6u6nuorpa$nn. Co4epxauue pyKottncu o6yclonleuo IIeJIbIo Lr 3aAarIaMI{

I{CCJre.iIOBaHI,lf, kI [o3BOJIseT AOCTaTOqHO IOJIHO' CUCTeMHO paccMoTpeTb ero

OCHOBHbIE I]OJIOXEHI4f, .

O6rext, [peAMeT HccJIeAoBaH[s, ero IIeIIb I'I 3a4al.u CSopnaynnpoBaHbl

npeAenbHo qerKo u o6crosrelruo. Kosqenqns Auecepralll4rl 6asupyercfl Ha

r{CIIOJI63OB a1g{u pa3nEr{HbIX MeTOAOB nO3HaHI4{' KaK O6IqeUayuugX, TaK 14

cnerIHaJIbHbIX.. Brino4lt coI{CKaTeJlfl [peACTaBnf,IoTCq AocTaTor{HO

apryMeHTI'IpOBaHHbIMI4 U O6OCHOBaHHbIMH.

HayrHax HoBI{3Ha llccneAoBaHut o6ycnoBJleHa reMofi pa6orbl, a raK}Ke

rroJloXeHLIqMI{, BbIHocHMbIMI4 A. M. Penrenofi Ha 3aUI'ITy. B Lrx rtgc;te:

pa3pa6orKa HoBOfO roAXoAa K sOpuaponaHr.rrc cLIcTeMbI ooruenpaeoBblx

11p14ruIruoB npu HcrroJ]HeHr{r4 HaxasaHlafi cpeAl4 HecoBeplleHHoJlerHi4x

ocyxAeHHbrx, $oprvlylllponna KoHrlenTyaJrbHbIX oCHOB HX nparcu'recxofi

peanH3arllrr{; KOHKpeTHbre npeAJroxeHl4.s no coBepIIIeHcTBOBaH}IIO HOpM IIpaBa u

3aKOHoAaTeJIbCTBa, pernaMeHTHpygUHe flpoqecc or6HsaHlas HaKa3agnt

HecoBepueHHoJIeTHHMH OCyXAeHHbIMI{.

Pesylrmrrr AHccepTarILroHHOfo I{CCIeAOBaHHt IIOJD,rI{I4JiH AOCTaTOTIHytO

anpo6aqraro, o rreM cBr4AerenbcrByer neperreHb ony6nuxoBaHHbrx pa6oT aBTopa,

BKrroiraroulnfi ylefinoe noco6r4e r4 rnaBy B KoJIJIeKTHBHofi uonorpa$Hu, qerblpe

Haf{Hbre crarbr4 B r43AaHr4sx peKoMeHAoBaHHbIX BAK MunucrepcrBa o6pa3oBaurrfl'

H HayKH Poccuu, a rarcKe 6olee ABaAI{arI4 ry6nraraUl4fi B HHIIX IIerIarHbIx H3AaHI{f,x.

O.rnae.{ag HecoMHeHHbIe Aocror4HcTBa ALIccepraI{}Iu, cneAyer BblcKa3arb 14

HeKoropble 3aMer{anwfl. Tax v3 coAepxaHufl aBTopeoepara He tcHo,

paccMaTpHBaJra JIr4 aBTop rrptrHr{Hrrbl neHHTeHrIHapHoro 3aKoHoAaTeJIbcTBa Apyfl'Ix

"cTpaH vL To, KaK OHH peanl43ytoTct B AesTeJ'IbHocTI4 COOTBeTCTByIOIUI4X

ni npanuteJ'IbHblx f{pexAeHufi .

BMecre c reM, yKa3aHnoe 3aMeqaHue He MeHrer o6urero nonoxrlTeJlbHoro

BrIeqaTJIeHHs. O EVCCepTar{Hr,r, KOTOpas OTJTHt{aeTCr aKTy€LnbHocrbro u HayrHofi

nonuluoft, .ierxofi apryueuraqnefi n AoKa3areJrbuocrbro BbrABufaeMbrxnoroxeHnft, TBopirecKUM u HoBaropcKHM rroAXoAoM K aHaJrr43r{pyeMbrMnpooneMaM, a TaKXe caMocTotTeJlbHocTblo BbrBoAoB.

,{r,rccepraquoHHoe rlccnegoBauue A. M. Peurenofi, xax 3To cneAyer r43

aaropeQepara, coAepxr4T coBoKynHocrb HoBbrx Haf{Hbrx pe3ynbraroB u

IIoiIoxeHI{fi, nrtqnnraeMblx aBTopoM 4nr ny6nraqHofi raulurbr, uMeer BnyrpeHHee

eAr4HCrBO r{ CBr4AeTeJrbCTByeT O JTHqHOM BKJraAe aBTOpa B HayKy.

flpe4crauflercfl, r{To AHcceprarlus A. M. Penresofi coorBercrByerrpe6onauutM tI. 1 n. 9 H n. 10 flonoxenns o ropsAKe rrpr4cyxAenr{lr 1n{eHbrxcteneueft, yrBepxAeHnoro IIocraHoBJIeHHeM flpaaurerrcraa Poccuficxofi

Oe4epaqnu or 24 ceuu6pr 2013 roAa }le 842, .rrBrrrerc{ eAr.{Horr.rqHoBrIIIoJIHeHHbIM 14 3aBeprueHHbrM r{ccneAoBaHr{eM. O$oprtanenue pa6oru oTBer{aer

rpebonauu.slr MnHucrepcrBa o6pasonau vfl v HayKlr Poccnfi cxoft @egepaquu.

Arrop Penrena Asua MuxafiroeHa 3acnyxuBaer rrpracyxAeHr4fl efiucrouoft crerleHl4 KaHAHAara iopr4Ar4qecKr4x HayK iro c[equaJrbHocrr,r 12.00.08 -

yrono BHo e rrpaBo r4 KpHMr.{Hon ofHr ; yf oJr o BHo -r{crroJrH HTeJrbHoe rrpaBo.

frasurrfi uayuuufi corpyAHHKfil.{l }lb 4 OfKy (BHI4i4 MBA Poccr.ru>AoKTop ropr.rAr.rqecKr..rx HayK, npo$ eccop

KoHraxrnax uu$opruarlr.lr :123995 r. Mocrsa, yl. flonapcKan,reneSon 8 (495) 915-18-95,e-mail : lesnikovOT@rambler.ru

r\r).rrHBaps 2015 r,

f.IO. Ilecrruros

25, r-69 fcn-5.

Orsrrn

o6 anropeQepare A?Iccepraquu Penresofi Aunrr MuxafinosHbr (Pean r43arruflo6rqenpaBoBblx rIpI4HI{I4noB B npoqecce I4crroJrHeHr4.f, HaKa3aHr4-s B BoclgTareJrbHbrx

KoJIoHLItx), npeAcraereHHofi Ha coucKaHl4e yrreHofi creuenrl KaHAr4Aara ropr,rA14qecKnxHayK rlo cl]elluilJlbHocrl4 12.00.08

- yronoBHoe rrpaBo u r

z

He6esHHTepecHo aBTopcKoe olpeAeneHr{e nouxruir (upr4Hrlr4[ yronoBHo-I{cIIoJIHI{TeJIbHoro [paBa>, ((3aKoHHocTb), (ryMaHz3M>, AeMoKpaTr43M)), (O11paBe ilrw1-Bocrb)), (yBaxeHr4e rrpaB r{eJroBeKa> (cn. c.7,9, 12, lg, 1g,21,22). o4Haxo Bo3Hr4KrrocoMHeHI4e B ToM' qro (npuHUHrI yfonoBHo-HctloJlHl4TenbHoro [paBa

- oro 3aKoHona-TeJrbHo 3aKpelneHHoe rpe6onauae>>.oco6rrfi LIHTepec lpercraBJl.f,ror pe3yJrbrarbr npoBereHHoro ruccepraHToM aH-

KerHoro orpoca pecnoHAeHroB (cvr. c. 6, 14-17, l9-2l).A.M. Penrena, [o-BZAr4MoMy, lpaBa B ToM, r{To corepxaHr{e 11paHrI una ryMa_

HI43Ma B yroJIoBHO-I4CnOJIHI4TeJIbHOM npaBe Mo)r{Ho paccMarpvBarb c Tpex cropoHB3aI{MoorHorueszfi: a) alunHvcrpaIJr4fl yr{pe)KAeHr{{ yronoBHo-vc[oJrHrrreJrbH ort cuc-reMbr - ocyxreuurrfi; 6) o6qec ocyxAeHHrrfi; n) ocyxAeHHufi _ ocyx4eungfi(cvr' c' 17)' lyuaercfl'' r{ro r{erBeprofi cropoHoft Moryr 6rrrr orHorrreHr4.rr Mex.qy 1,o-TepneBrrrr4M oT npecTynJreHH.rr nr4rloM r4 OCyXAeHHbrM.

Coucrareleu nplzBereHbl y6e4rarenbHbre apryMeHTbr B o6ocnonanzenonr{eHHblx HayqHbrx pe3yJlbraroB, rrro o6ecnequno nrrcor

3

4. fieitcrw4reJlbHo JIIr y ilpl4HrlrrroB cnpaBeAJrr4Bocrr4 14 yBaxeHr{{ npaB r{eJroBeKa

6onrure ror{eK corlpl4KocHoBeHr,rr, rrro [o3BoJrHJIo cor4cKarenlo paccMorperb Ltx B oA-HoM naparya$e Avrccepralll4rl, Hexer:;a y rrpr.rHrlr4noB clpaBeAJruBocru Lr ryMaHrr3Ma(cu. c. 19-22)? 14 sosN,roxHo JIII B corepxaHpru yKa3aHHbrx npr.rHrlrlrroB uafirw MecroI,IHTep e CaM noTepneBrrref o oT rrp e cTyrrJr eHlrf, ttu\a?

BosuuxruI4e Bonpocbl He oKa3blBaror HefarnBHofo BIrr4flHnfl ua o6ruee rroJroxru-

TeJIbHoe BrlerlarJleHrre or npeAcraBJreHHoro Hayr{Horo rpyAa. Co4epNaHr,re aBTope$e-para cBl{AerenbcrByer o roM, rrro Ar4ccepraHT [poBen AocrarorrHo rny6oKoe r,rccneAo-

BaHI4e npo6neutr pearll43allnz o6ulenpaBoBbrx npHHrIHnoB npr4 r4crroJrHeH:ar4 HaKu3an:afl

B BocIrHTareJIbHbIX KoJIoHI{rx. llpone4enurrfi cr4creMHbrit auanug srofi upo6leuu no-3BOJII,IJI OrIpeAeJII4Tb CTerIeHb COOTBeTCTBI4.f, yfOnOBHO-r4CIrOJIHr4TeJIbHOfO 3aKOHOAa-

TeJIbCTBa, npaKTI4KH efo npl{MeHeHr4.s yKa3aHHbrM npr{HrlrrrraM, froJro}KeHHbrM B ocHoBy

yfonoBHo-r4crroJrHr,rTeJlbHofo rrpaBa.

llpone4eHHoe uccneAoBaHl4e coorBercrByer rpe6oeaHuxla, rrpeAbrBlqeMbrM K

pa6orau AaHHoro poAa, a ero aBTop - Peurena AHsa MuxafinoBHa

- 3acnyltcuzaemnpr4 cyxA enufl, yueHofi crerr eHr,r KaHAHAaT a wpn4u.u.e cKrrx H ayK.

llpoSeccop raSe4pbr yronoBHorou yfonoBHo-[cnoJrHr4TeJrbHofo npaBaHuNeropoAcr

B 4uccepraguonnrlft coser [-212.239.01 npr,r @fEV BIIO(CaparoBcKar rocyAapcrBeHlltu rcpltAlrqecraa ana4eMrrs, r. CaparoB,

yn. r{epubrrreBcxoro, 104.

OT3bIBHa aBropeQepar I.krccepT ar\vvr

Penresofi AHurr MuxafinoBHbr,Ha TeMy: ((Pean[3aqr4r o6qenpaBoBbrx rrpr4Hrlr{rroB B rrpoqecce ucfroJrHeHr4t

HaKa3aHrrfl B BOC[II{TaTeJIbHbIX KOJIOHT4fX>>, npeACTaBJreHHyrO K 3aIIII4Te Ha

COHCKAHI{E YI{CHOft CTETIEHI4 KAHAI{AATAIOPKITI.{IsECKUX HAYK TIO CIEIII4AJIbHOCTI{

12.00.08 - yronoBHoe npaBo r,r KpuMI4HonorI{t;yf onoBHo-zctroJIHI4TeJIbHoe rlpaBo

Teua, vrc6paHlr.ar colrcKareJreM A. M. Peuresofi, flBlrs.ercfl. aKTyanbnoi4 urrpeAcTaBJr.rreT HayqHbrfi v npaKTLrrrecKr4ft r{HTepec, [ocKoJIbKy B HacTo.fluleeBpeMr l]poqecc oT6brBaHLrs. lF.aKa3a:Hkrfl. B Bocrrr4TaTeJrbHbrx yqpe)KAelfl]/rflx Anfl,HecoBeprxeHHonerHr4x r4Meer cBor{ cleqxor4qecKr{e qeprbr H xapaKTepucrprKllBeaycronHo, corpyAHrdKr.r, HerrocpeAcrBeHHo pa6oraroque c ocyxAeHHbIMrroApocrKoM, 0613aHbr co6nrcIarb 3aKoHoAareJrbcrBo, 6rrTb [pooeccr4oHaJrbHonplrfoAHbl, I{MeTb rlcl4xoJlofnr{ecKr4e n neAafofr{qecKl4e HaBbIKH pa6oru cocy)KAeHHbrM. OAnarco AaHHoro ypoBHr MoxrHo Aocrlaqb JILITTIr krv'efl. BbrcoKLIfiypoBeHb 3aKoHoAarenbHoft 6asil H ilpaBkrnbHoe roJrKoBaHI,Ie efo rlonoxeHuft.O6rqeupaBoBbre lprrHrlr4rrbr B AaHHoir. auryar\vrkr vrcparor ocHoBorloJrararoqyrcponb He roJrbKo B nocrpoeHl{I{ uI.ICIIOnHLITeJIbHOfO 3aKOHO.IIaTeJIbCTBa

MexAyHapoAHbrM craHAapraM), Ho uTOJIKO BAHVII{I V TIDUMEH EHVTI"I.

3aclyxrzBaror B:ar4lr'aHvrfl. u [oAAep]KKLI rIoJIo)KeHI4.g, BbrHocpIMbIe Ha3arrIHTy A. M. Peuresofi, B ToM qr4cre 06 onpeAeJreHr{Lr cyrqHocrvr rroluflTnfl,((npr,lHrlr4rl), efo Aef.vrHvuJvrv, c TotIKH 3peHkI.f, He roJIbKo yfonoBHo-r4crroJlHrrTeJrbHofo rrpaBa, Ho rI [paBoBeAeHprfl B IIenoM; ocBelrleHr4u npuHIJLrnayBaxeHHfl, npaB r{enoBeKa B yfoJroBHo-r{crroJIHI4TeJIbHoM [paBe c TOTIKH 3peHLrfl.Tpex ocHoBHbrx acrreKToB: yBaxeHue rrpaB qeJIoBeKa qepe3 IaAero orpaxAaHurHe, Koropuit yageJreH orrpeAeneHHbrM KoMnJIeKcoM npaB, cBo6oA I{o6.ssaHHocreit; yBa)KeHr.re [paB rreJroBeKa qepe3 yBax{eHLIe K 3aKouy, npe)K,qeBcero K VrorosHo-HcrroJrHrdrenbHoMy KoAeKcy P@, xoroprtfi 3aKpenJltero6u1ue, 6asxcHrre rroJro)KeHvrs, Kacarculuecs or6rteaHkrfl. lr.aKa3anus; yBa)KeHI4eIIpaB qeloBeKa qepe3 IoqTuTenbHble, ocHoBaHHbre Ha IIpI{3HaHuI{ AocToI4HCTBaJrr{rrHo cTr4 Apyf Apyf a oTHorrre Hr4r BHyTpr.r c o o 6qe crB a 3 aKrloq eHHbIX.

llpe4noxeuvrfl. o BHeceHHr{ nonpaBoK B yronoBHo-vcrIoJIHI{TeJIbHoe3aKoHo,qareJrbcrBo, cQopvrynkrpoBaHHbre Ar{ccepraHToM, AocrarorlHo JIorHrIHoBbrcTpoeHbr Lr aKTyaJIbHhI.

CyqecreeHHoe BHI{MaHIre, rITo, 6eaycronno, rpaBLrJIbHo, AlaccepraHTyAenf,er a]F'ankBy ucropr,rqecKofo craHoBJreHr4f, oorqelpaBoBbrx rrpI4HIII4tIoB Byf oir oBH o -r4 cnonHI4TeJIbHoM 3 aKo HoAaTeJIb cTBe.

$opuupoBaHuu HopM yronoBHo-(e roM rrucJre coorBercrByroqux

B AanbHefirrreM r4x rlpaBr4nbHoM

B qenovr neo6xo4r4Mo orMerLrrb, qro Alrccepral{I4oHHoe I4ccJreAoBaHkreA. M. Penrenofi rpeAcraBr-f,er JrornqecKpr-3aBeprlennrrfi nayunufi TpyA,roropufi rro3BoJrlrr o[peAenr4Tb Aamnefiruue HaIIpaBneHI4flcoBeplxeHcrBoBaHl4f yronoBHo-r4crroJrHr,rreJrbHoro 3aKoHoAarenbcrBa P@ HAOCTI4X{eHrI.fl e4raHOO6pA3Vrfl. B peAn]Z.3arl]1l]1l O6qenpaBoBbrx [p]rHr{zrroB Bnp oqec c e u cIIOJIH eHI{t HaKa3 aHufl. B BocnHTaTe JrbHbrx KoIoHI{.f, X.

EomruuucrBo noroxenufi, BbIHeceHHbIX Ha 3aqrlTy, MoxHooxapaKTepz3oBarb KaK orBeqarculue rpe6onaHr,rro Hayunofi HoBr43Hbr,AOCTOBepHbIe 14 apfyMeHTr.rpoBaHHbre. Bce lroJloxteHr4fl, BbrHocr4Mble Ha3aIqI4Ty, z3JrolKeHbr B crporofi lora.{ecxofi [ocJreAoBareJlbHocrl4.

Buecre c reM, HeKoropble cyxAeHr,r.f, Lr BbrBoAbr, orpaxeHHbre BanropeQepare, KaK rlpeAcraBrrs.ercfl, rpe6yror yroqHeHr,rr n, Bo3MolKHo,Aanluefiruero, 6oree AeranbHoro u3yq eHus..

1. Ha Harrr B3rJrrA, aBTop He AocraroqHo BHr4MaHr{fl y4enfler n pa6oreo6rqeupaBoBoMy npuHllany paBeHcrBa ocylrAeHHbrx nepe.q 3aKoHoM,KoHKpeTrzr3r4pyroqe\ay o6rqelpr43HaHHrrfi npzHr{r.rn MexrAyHapoAHofo npaBa pr3aKpelnennrrfi B cr. 19 Koncrnry\uu P@. B ro xe BpeMs Heo6xo4zrvrooTMeTI{Tb, r{TO paBeHCTBO OCyXAeHHbTX nepeA 3aKOHOM He O3HaqaeTp aBeH crBa yc JroBr4fi or6Hea Hvrfl. Hana3aHufl..

2. Pa6o^ty yKpacr4tu 6w AaHHbre aHKerr4poBaHvrfl, Lr rrHTepBbrcr,rpoBaHLrtcorpyAHHKoB Bocrrr{TareJrbHbrx rorouufi rro acrreKTaM, orpDKeHHbrM HaocHoBaHr{u MHeHI{r HecoBeprxeHHoJreTHr4x ocy)KAeHH6IX, B r{acTHocTI{, IIoBOIIpOCaM CnpaBeAnLIBOCTH IIpHMeHeHHbIX Mep B3bICKaHI4s. K HapyUuTeJItM,yBaxr4TeJrbHoro oTHorrreHr{r K ocyxAeHHbrM Lr r.A.

3. I4HrepecHhrM 6rrno 6u paccMorperb B lrrcceprarlr{oHHoMr4ccJreIoBa[r4hr crerleHb BllvflHkrs. Hapy[reHr4{ peanr4garJhru o6ueupaBoBbrxnpr,lHrlurroB B rrpoqecce ncrroJrHeHrar lnaKa3aHr4fl. Ha pocT pequ4nnHofirrpecryrrHocrt4 apeAvr HecoBeprueHHoJrerHux. ,{annrrfi no,4xoA o6orarzn 6rr neTOJrbKO Teoperr,rqecKyro, Ho Lr npaKTkrrrecKyro 3Haqr.rMocrr pa6oru.

VKasaHHbre 3aMe,uanvrfl. He yMeHbrrraror Hayr{Horo ypoBH.rr pa6oru, eelpaKTr4qecKyro 3Harrr4MocTb, [ocKonbKy Hoc.rrT nper4MyrqecTBeHHoArzcKyccraoHnuft xapaKTep v He BJrr{rror Ha o6qufi BbrBoA o roM, rrronpoBeAeHHoe A. M. Penreeofi LrccJreAoBaHHe BbrrroJIHeHo Ha aKTyanbHyroTeMy, coAep)Kr{T rny6orufi Teoperuqecxzfi anarru3 H [paKTr4qecKr4epeKoMeHAarJLrv\ Koropbre Moryr 6uru rrpr4MeHeHbl B lpaKTnqecxofiAesrenbHocrr{ @e4epanrsofi cnyx6u r{c[oJrHeHr4.rr lr'axasarruir, 14 rrpoqeccerrpenoAaB annfl. yve6Hoft Ar.rcrdr.rrrJrranrr

yrBepxAenHoro llocranoBJreHr,reM llpanureJrbcrBa Poccuficrcofi Oe4epaIJvrvr or24 ceurx6px 2013 roAr J\b 842, rBrrtrerc.f, eAr4HonuqHo BrIIToJIHeHHrIM n3aBeprrreHHbrM r4ccneAoBaHlreM, a ee aBTop Penreea AHHa Mlrxafinonua,3acnyxr4BaeT npr4cyxrAelF^prfl, r.rcKoMofi yuenofi cTe[eHLI KaHI.LIAaTaropraAur{ecKlrx HayK rro crerlr{anbHocrr4 12.00.08 yronoBHoe rrpaBo LrKpr4 MHH O not'Is,: yf OnOBHO - H CnOnHr4TenbHO e np aBO.

Otsrrn Ha anrope$epar A. M. Penreeofi noAroroBrreH npo$eccopovxa@e4prr yronoBHo-r{crroJrHr4TeJrbHoro npaBa KaHAvrAaroM ropr4Ar{qecKnx HayK,,qor{eHroM Jla4onrru 34yap4ou Bn a4urvrup oBLrq eM.

Orsrm Ha aBrope$epar A. M. Peurenofi o6cyNgeH r.r o4o6peu Ha sace4antrzrra$e4prr yronoBHo-ucrroJrHureJrbHoro upaBa Ara4euvn @CI4H Pocuu(nporonor J\b 8 or nnBapn 2015 r.).

HaqanrHrar xaQe4puyfoJroBHo-r4crroJrHr4TenbHofo IIpaAraleuu u @ CIrftl P oc ct r u,KAHAtTAAT ropr,rAr4qeoKr,rx HayK, AOIIe eprefi Py4onr$osrr TrorzKos

Arageruzfl. npaBa I4 ynpaBJrenvrs.@e4epanrsofi cryx6u ucIIoJIHeHI{.fl390000, r. PssaHr, yr. CeHwa4 l.rc:l,. (4912) 25-55-79ren./Saxc (49 12) 27 -21 -12apu-fsin@mail.ru

HAKA3AHI,.IKI

,-l' 4 n Arto z;w czlh poYe-U 6n_ ?.! .

Cr"nrcreli?'*F criri?*A:rqiem=;li'*"'{.ill-i

B duccepmatluonuutil coeemfi-212.239.01 npu @fEV BIIO< C apamoecrcan zocydapcmr eHHafl npuduvecrcan arcadeuun>,

e. Capamoe, yn. Vepuaru.reecxozo, 104.

OT3bIBHa aBrope@epar Aucceprar\ur4 ,npeAcraBJleHHofi Penresofi Ansoft MuxafinoBHofi Ha cor4cKaHLre yqeHofi crerreHr{KaHAI4AaTaropkIIut{ecKI,IX HayK IIo c[eIdlIaJIbHocTLI 12.00.08 -yronoBHoe rrpaBo r'rKpI{M 14 H On O f r4q ; yf On O B H O - I4 Crr O JTHHTe Jr b H O e rrp aB O .

ilpoHsorueAlrrne e Poccr4z $yn4arvreHTaJrbHbre corlr4aJrbHbre ilpeo6p€BoBaHr4-soTpasunhrcb Ha MHO|I,IX csepax )Kvr3]f.iu o6ulecrna, r43MeHr'IJrrr HeKoTopbre rrpaBoBbleHHcrr4ryrbr. Yrnepx4eHHar B 2010 roAy Konqeuqux pa3Bvrrufl yronoBHo-I{cIIoJIHHTenbHofi cl4creMbl Poccufict

2

OOqeilpaBoBbIX IIpHHIII4IOB IIpI4 LIcIIoJIHeHI4I4 HaKAsaIIkIq B BocrIHTaTeJIbHbIxKOJIOHI4'X.

Anrop, [poaHanl{3r4poBaB 3aKoHoAarenbcrB$, exeroAHbre AaHHbre,rlpeAocTaBrqeMble vnorHol,roqeHHbrM rro [paBaM r{efioFeKa, cpelcTBaMr.r MaccoBofiI4HQopMaiII4I4, pe3yJlbrarbl rlpoBepoK, crarr{crr4r{ecKr.re AaHHbre, a raKxe p$ynbrarbrco6crBeHHbrx oMnl4pt4r{ecKr,rx HccneAoBa:nnit Bbr.{en.ser Qne4yroulue nau6oree qacroBcTpeqaloul4ec.x HapyIrreHnfi, npaB ocyxAeHHbrx B BocrrlrTaTeJrrHbrx ronoHprsx: 1.flpano Ha 6e3onacHocrb, Aocrol4HcrBo JrrlrrHocrr4, saujrary or rlbrroK, xecroKoro,yHl{xarcu1ero Aocrol{HcrBo odpaulenus,. 2. llpano Ha rpyl. 3. llpano Ha oxpaHy3AopoBbfl H ilonyqeHl4e KBarrrz$uqzponannofi MeAr4rluHprofi noMorrln. 4. llpano HaronyrleHl4e ocHoBHoro oSqero o6pasonaHlax Lr cp$rurero (nolHoro) o6rqeroo6pa:onasux.S.llpano Ha ilonyqeHue rcnanHSuqnponanfofiropugvrtecrcofi rroMorrlr{.

B saKrlo.telnvru rIoABeAeHbI HTorI4 Ia HaMeqeHbr rlepcileKTr{Bbr r4ccneAoBaHLrflKareropl4l,I ([pI{HIII4TD) B poccuficroM rreHr{TeHr{uapHoM FpaBe r{ 3aKoHoAarenbcrBe.Buecre c reM, rloJlaraeM Bo3MoxHbrM BbrcKa3arb noNerjaurle, Hoc{qee B ocHoBHoMpeKoMeHAaremnrrfi xapaKTep. Tar, He coBceM rloH-srHa tto3r.rrlrir aBTopa,orHocI4reJIbHo QopuynupoBKI{ oupe4ereuufi o6rqenpaBoBbrx rrpr4Hrlr,rrroB. Tar,rrpr{Hrlr{n 3aKoHHocTr4 rrpeAnafaeTcr rroHr4MaTb rrepw npr43My ((coBoKynHocTr{pyKoBo.qqqux rpe6onaHIafi>>, TofAa KaK Bce ocrarbubrp upuuqznbr Bbrcrylaror BKaqecrBe (pyKoBoAtIrIHX rpe6onaHufi>. Ha Harrr Bqrnf,.q, TaKr4e oAHopoAHbreKareropr4n AonxHbI ToJrKoBarbcr r4AeHTr4rrHo rur6o 4alrHyro aBTopcKyro rro3r{rlzrccneAyer c$opuynupoBarb 6oree rrerKo.

Bnpoueu, BbrcKa3aHHbre .qr4cKyccr4oHHoe noroxleuue Hr.r B xoefi Mepe HeBrr,r-rrer Ha rroJroxHTenbHyro orIeHKy Ar4ccepra[uu. Coulrarem [poAenaJr 6omnyopa6ory uo c6opy kr aHarrr43y 3Mnupr{.recKofi 6aslr, pe3ynbraroB corlr4oJrornqecKlrxottpocoB, 3HaqHTeJIbHofo MaccI4Ba HopMaTr4BHbrx [pagoBbrx aKToB, cnequalrHofiropuAr4rrecrofi nr4Teparypu, o6cro.rrreJrbHo r43Jroxrr4Jr co{epxaHr4e AaHHofi reuu. HaocHoBe npoBeAeHHoro rny6oxoro reoperl4rlecKoro aHanl43a A. M. Penreea cAenalrap.sA BaxHbrx BbrBoAoB, I4MeroilII4x IrpaKTr4qecKylo 3HaqLI44ocTb, u TeM caMbIM BHecJIaorrpeAenenuufr BKnaA B pa3BVTr4e yronoBHo-l4c[onHureJlbHoro lpaBa.BnyruureJrbHoe KoJrr{qecrno ony6nr4KoBaHH6rx aBTopov paSor e Heo6xoAIarurofi MepeoTpaxaeT TeMy 4r4ccepT a\r4r4.

[racceprarlr4oHHoe r{ccneAoBanue A. M. Penresofi flBITAercfl HafrHo-rnanz$HraquoHnoft pa6orofi, B Koropofi co4epNvrcs. pelxeHl4e 3aqaqr4 utuerolqeftcyuecTBeHHoe 3HarreHr4e AJI_rI yfonoBHofo, yfonoBHo-ncIIoJIHI{TeJIbHofo npaBa uKpr{Mr4HoJIofLtI4. Pa6ora HanurcaHa coHcKareJIeM caMocro{TeJlbHo, rlpeAcraBJl.aerco6ofi coBoKynHocrb HoBbrx HayqHbrx pe3ynbraroB 14 tloJlo)Kettuit, BbIABLIfaeMbIXaBropoM 4lx ny6nu,ruon 3arrlrrrbr, r4Meer BHyrpeHHee eAHHcrBo kI cBl4AerenbcrByero rurrHoM BKnaAe aBTopa B HayKy. O$oprvrneuue Lr4ccepraIJuu, ucxoA.tl Irt3

1

aBropeQepara A. M. Peuresofi, coorBercrByer rpe6onaHHru MIaHucrepcrBaHay Kvr P o c cufi cxofi @ e4ep a\ur4.o6pa:onaHHs. vr

BrrsoA: Ar{cceprarlilq A. M. Penresofi coorBercrByer rpe6onaHl4tM rI. I n.9 ur. l0 lloloNesrEs o nopslKe rrpr4cyxAentrs. yqeHbrx creueHefi, yrBepx.{eHHororrocraHoBneHraeM llpanurerbcrBa Poccufrcrofr OeAepaqlr'V or 24 ceHT{6pq 2013roAa N 842. flBrrfl,erafl, E,III,IHOJII{IIHO BbIIIOJIHEHHbIM 3aBeprrreHHbrM

3

I4cciIeAoBaHI4eM, a ee aBTop Peurena AHHa MuxaftnoBHa 3acnylKr,rBaer upvcyxAeHr4s,efi ucrcoiraofi crenenr4 KaHALrAuta rcpr44r4.tecKr4x HayK no cleura€rirbHocrr,r 12.00.08 -yfOJIOBHOe [paBo 14 KpI4MLIHOIOTI{q; y|OIoBHo-I{CIIOJIHI{TeJIbHOe IIpaBO.

Orsrre Ha anropeQepar A. M. Penresofi ro.[roroBJreH AOKTOpOMIopI4AI4rIecKI{x HayK, npoQeccopoM KaSeApbI yronoBHoro rrpaBa H KplrMr4HoJrornnEapHaynrcKoro ropkIAl4qecKoro HncrLrry'ra MBA Pocczn A6rrsoeuNa Pasr,ureraMuxafrnoBr{rreM.

Orsrm Ha aBropeQepar A. M. Peuresofi o6cyx4eu u o4o6peH Ha 3ace$alr4uraQe4prr yronoBHoro rrpaBa 14 Kpr4Mr4HonoruulrHcrrlryra MBI Poccr.rr.r (npororon Nt _f or u4,

HaqartrHr.r r< ra$ e4pbr yronoBHororrpaBa 14 KpHMHHoJrorHLr EapHaynrcKoroIopl4AlzvecKoro I{HcrI{Tyra MraHracrepcrBaBHyrpeHHr{x Aerr Poccuficxofi @e4ep awuKaHAr,rAaT neAaf ofr{rrecKr4x HayK,

TOIIEHT

(yr. r{ranova,49, r. BapHayr, 656038, renerafin233314 "Kren", rere$arc (385-2)37-91-5l,rere$ou (385-2) 24-22-11, E-mail: info@buimvd.ru, www.buimvd.ru)

&Sz-^4e.a L./.? Pq-b€

OT3hIB

rpe

KAH

Hp aBrope$ ep ar rl4c cepraquu

C roqKvI 3peHI4{ HayrlHofi HoBr43Hbr u 3Haqr4Mocrn pa6orhr Mo)nHoorMerl4Tb ro o6crosreJrbcrBo, rrro AHccepraHToM, B qHOJre nepBhrxodqenpasonofi IpLIHIITIn I4crIoJIHeHvrfl HaKa3aHufl cpeAr4 HecoBepueHHoJrerHrrx

ocyxAeHHbrx KaK loplrAHrrecKa.f, Karefopplr paccMarpuBaercfl KoMnneKcHo 14

BcecropoHHe, a I4MeHHo, B KaqecrBe: pyKoBoA.rrxlero rpe6ouaHkrr, orpaxarcnlero

o6rexrnsHyro 4eficrBl4TeJlbHocrb pa3Br4Tprfl o6rqecrna u npeAonpeAenf,rorrleroAONX{HOE IOBEACHLIE TTTO4Efi B COOTBETCTBLII4 c JIeTLITHMHO VcTaHOBJIeHHbIMLI

HOpMaMH kr CTaHAApTaMr4.

oqeHranar rroJroxl{TenbHble MoMeHTbr, AocrouHcrBa pa6oru, MoxHo

oTMeTZTb, qTO ATICCepTaHT CnpaBvrrrQfl c IIocTaBneHHbIMLr 3aAaqaMlr, pearrH3oBan

IIOCTaBJIeHHyIO rIM Ilenb AHCCeprarIr4OHHOrO r4CCneAOBaHVrs, [OCKOnbKyorlpeAeJrkIJr reoperrrqecKl4e kIcroKpr, Ha3HarreHue v co\ua-nrnrrfi cMbIcJr rrpr.IHllnna

KaK Kareroprll4 HayKrr; o6o6rqzn [peAcraBrrenlrfl, o cyrrlHocru vr coAep)KaHaa

npanoeofi Kareropuu (npr4Hrlur>, Bbrpa6ora-u ee o6qee olpeAeneHuTe; pacKpbrn

coAepxaHl{e ocHoBHbIX KoHrlemlufi noHuMaHr4s npuHrlr4rra B npaBe uvx BJr}rrHHe

HA rrocneAyroqee pa3BHTHe ropr4AHrrecKoro 3}]allus; r4ccneAoBElrr noHsTue r4

cr4creMy rrpHHrILrnoB yronoBHo-ncrroJrHLrreJrbHoro rrpaBa Pocczu u HaKoHer{,o[peAenr{Jr cocTosHne r4 nepcrreKTr4Bbr pa3BuTnfl. cHcTeMbI IIpLIHIII4IOB yfonoBHo-

HcrroJrHrrreJrbHoro rrpaBa B coBpeMennofi orerrecrBeHnofi nparonofi HayKe.

pa6ore r,rMerorctHapr.gy c HecoMHeHHbIMI{ AocroI4HcrBaMrI B

orrpeAeneHHble HeAocTarKkI.

Tar, n aaropeQepare He o6osHa.{eHa rro3rarllrt aBTopa no coorHolueHl{Io

rrpr4Hrlr{noB yfonoBHo-r4crroJrHr{TeJrbHofo npaBa c IpI{HIILITIaMI4 Apyfl4x Orpacleft

npaBa (n qacrHocrrI, yronoBHoro u yronoBHo-npoqeccyalruoro), HopMbrKOTOpbTX TaK)Ke nppI3BaH6I npeAyIIpe)KAaTb npecTy[HocTb B npoqecce

H C fI O JI H E HLT1. IIAI(A3AH-VI fl .

BrrcrasaHHoe 3aMerraHr4e He rBJrtrerc-s [puHqrrrII{€LIIbHbIM I4 He orpaxaerc.f,

na o6uleru, BecbMa [onoxl{TeJrbHoM BnerlarJre:ntflr or pa6oru.

[ucceprarlr4oHHoe r4ccJreAoBanue A. M. Peureeofi, KaK gro cJreAyer I43

anrope$epara, Hanlrcauo aBTopoM caMocro{TeJlbHo, coAepxl4T coBoKynHocrb

HoBbIX HafIHbIX pe3ynbTaroB vr rroJIo)KeHI{fi, BbrABHraeMbrx aBTopoM Anflny6nplqHofi rarquru, plMeer BHyrpeHHee e4r4HcrBo H cBlrAerenbcrByer o raqHoM

BKnaAe aBropa B HayKy. vxasaHsue B anrope$epare ny6marcaquu aBropa(6onee 20) n uoluofi Mepe orporaror reMy pa6oru.

flpe4cranrflerefl, rrro Arlcceprarlr.rf, A. M. Peureaofi coorBercrByerrpe6onaHtrsM Lr. 1 n. 9 pr n. 10 llonoxeHtrfl o noprAKe npucyxrAerrufl )rureHbrxcreneHefi, yrBep)KAeHHoro nocraHoBJreHLreM flpaararelbcrBa Poccuficrofi

@e4epaqau or 24 ceuu6px 2013 ro.qa }lb 842, flBrrflerefl eAraHorLrrrHoBbrrroJrHeHHbIM Lr 3 aBeprueHHbrM r{c cneAoBaHueM.

Anrop Penreea AnHa MuxafinosHa 3acny)KlrBaer rpucyxrAeHus, efi,ucrorr,rofi creneHrI KaHAI4Aara ropu4rrqecKr4x HayK no cner{krarrbHocru 12.00.08 -

yf ono BHoe [paBo kr Kpr{Mr4 Honof rar ; yf onoBHo- r4 cnoJrHrrTeJrbHoe rrpaBo.

[oqeur rca$e4pu yronoBHoro rrpaBa r4 npoqecca

ropr4Ar{qecKoro $arynrrera

OfEOy BIIO

B daccepda\tuEsdn casen I-2I2 239 0I hpu @lEy B O(Capan@cvt acyddpcm@Hr@ ppudt\ectg oKaoeMB\

. Capohoq, yl qepHhtuej.rcea, 104

OT3hIBHa aBTopeQepaT ArrccepTaurr[

ocHoBHbre rloJroxeHltr. Buto4u cottcratelt npe.qcraBJlfiIorcn AocraroqHoo6ocHogaguHvu.

Hay+rax HoBr.rHa uccne.qoBaHr,t o6yclon:rena reMo, pa6or6r,nocraBJIeHHBIMll IIerqMIz H 3aaa.qaMv, a raKxe rroJroxeHlljrMr]) aErHocr.IM6rMItA. M. Penresoi Ha 3arrlr4Ty. B r.rx qucle: onpeAeneHr.re noHrrrr, (npt{Hr1r{nyfoJloBHo-r4 clloJlHr.rreJrbl{oro npaBa); AoKa3aHuui re:tc o6 olgecegzu ttqllcny oolllenp oB6rx npHHIII4rroB 3aKoHHocrI4, fyMaHz3Ma, AeMoKparr.I3Ma,yBaxeEr.I_s IpaB qeloBeKa, cIpaBe.{nr.IBocTI.I! HaxoA_{IuUX CBOe oTpaxeHlre Byf oJIoBHO-HCrroJIHzTeJrbHoM nDaBe.

Pesylrratr ,4zccepralluoHuoro llccJrcaoBar rl ocuoBareJlbHo anpo6zpoaanrr,

rrerbrpe HarrHBre crarBu B v3EAHvrsX, peKoMeHAOBaHHbX BAK M],Irnrcreocrna

neqaTHbx I.I3AaHIiJIX.

He nrmena pa6ora A. M. penregoi r.r HeKoropbD< He,4ocrarKoB. BqacTHOCTr,r, atroporrl o6ocnonuaaercl ueo6xoguuocTl I4CCJrenOBaHr4rr nprrHllr{naryMaHU3Ma I,IMeHI.TTeJIBHO K HOpMaTI.IBHOMy noHIrMaHrrIo, ocHoBaHHOMy HaTOJIKOBaHI4I.I HOpM yronoBHo_ucIIoJIHt4Te[EHOrO 3aKOHOAaTelhgTBa, B Tpexacrrexrax, KaK nporBneHr4e: 1)ryuanuocra a.qMr.rur.rcrpaqr.ru yqpexAeHrznyfonoBHo-I4cnoJrHl.ITerrHofi crlcreMrr Iro orHorIeHI.IIo K ocyxAeHH6rM;2) ryl,,rauusua ro orHorrerruro K o6rqecrBy nocpeAcrBoM HaAexHofr oxpaHbr r{u3oJrfl\uu ocyxAeHn6x; 3) rylralrnocru ocyx.qeHHhrx Apyr K ,4pyry BHCnpaBuTeJrbHoM yqpex(AeHr.ru.

Ilpegcrarlxercx, rITo nepcrreKTHBHbIM HarrpaBJreHI4eM AJr, .{ar,IbHerI urerov3yqeH's aBTopoM ,{aHHofi npo6neuaflzr

ny6nlr.rHofi 3arql-ITbr, r.IMeer BHyrpeHHee eAr.IHcrBo II cBuleTeJr6crByer o JU{qHoMBKnaae aBTopa B HayKy.

flpe4craa:uerc.x, rrro rvcceprarlus A, M. penleBofi goorBercrByerrpe6oeauuru.{. I n. 9 u n. 10 flo:roNenv.s o fioprAKe nplcyxneHxs yqeHlrxcTereHefr, yTBepx.qeHHoro rocTa.HoBJreHHeM flparr,rrelrcrna pocctaficKoiiOegepaquu or 24 coum6pr 2013 rona No 842, aa:rrercl eAt4 Hofir,rrrHoBBTnoIHeHHBTM I.I 3aBepIIIeHHEIM HCClenOBaHr4eM. OrpoprnIllel{Iae pa6oGr ora aerrpe6onanuav Munzcrepcrea o6pasonauwt u uayrcu p occui.tcrofi @e4epaqzz.

Aarop Penreaa AnHa M[xafi:rosHa 3acJr]r(xBaer npucy)KAeHu, e|aucroMot cleneHr.r KarrAvnara ropu.{}rqecKrlx Ha},K no cnerlr4albnocru 12.00.0g _yfoJroBHoe npaBo I.I KpI.IMI.IHOJIOIr4{; yIOJIOBHO_UCnOJIHr.rTeJIr,HOe npaBo.

-flinrn Axgpei Bnagraur,rpour.ru,KaHnnnaT ropr,rar.rqecKrD( HalT,goqem raSegprr

OrsbrsHa aBTopeQepar Arrcceprarlnn AsHu MuxaftJroBHbr Penresofi

3Mnl4pnr{ecKyro 6ary r{ccneAoBaHtrr. Harrrls rvr 3To AoK€BarenbHoeNOATBEPXACHI4C HNZ ABTOP ONCPHPYCT TOJIbKO AAHHbIMI4 OUPOCA ?

2. He.scHo, H3JIo)I{eHIre crarbl4 8 yl4K PO s Hosofr peAaKrIr{H, nreudr Jrr4 3aco6ofr Bo3JlolKeHI4e AononHI4TeJIbHbix o6.ssaHHocrefi Ha ocyx4duuoro n-vrrIpI4BoA?Ir roJIbKo x 4alruefiurefr ryvraHk:ca\r4u [eHr,rreHl{r4ap1ortcl4creMbl ?

3. llyuxr 2 Pe$opnarapoBaHl4e cl4creMbr yvpeN4eHr,rfr, r4crroJrHrrorrlnxHaKa3aHVfl B BI{AO JIHITIOHI4-I cno6o4lt, tI coBeplxeHcrBoBaHae vx opfaHr43aul,IoHHo-crpyKrypHofo nocrpoeHnt, pa3.qena III OcHosHrIe Ha[paBneHgrr pa3B1rrv1yronoBHo-zcnoJlHHrelrnofi czcreMbl, Konqeuquu pa3Bvrrzr1 yronoBHo-r{clroJlHl4Te;Ibnofr cl4creMbr P@ ao 2020 foAa, yrnepN4euHofi pacnoprxeHr4eMflpanzrerbcrBa Pocczfrcxoft @e4epaqurz or 14 onrq6p" 2010 r. J.lb 1772-pIIpeAIonafaeT upeodpa:oBaHHe BOCIIIITATCJIbHbIX xolosurT nilAHecoBepixeHHoJlerHl,tx B BOC[HTareJIbHbre ueHTpbr Enfl rr4u, coBeprxr4Brut4xrlpecry[neHl4e B HecoBepIUeHHoJierHeM Bo3pacre. I4cxo M pr3 3Toro He rep{er cfl rrvrcMbrcJI rloroxeHl4fr nsrgocuMblx Ha:arqnry ?

Bltecre c TeM BbIcKa3aHHbIe 3aMeqalufl He yMan.rror Aocrol4HcrBoBbI[OJIHeHHOfO AI4CCepTaqHoHHofo acCiTeIOBaiF^vIN, HOC{T peKoMeHtrarelrnUfixapaKTep v Bo MHoroM opHeHTr4poBaHbr Ha 4anrnefruryo Hay{Ho-nccJreAoBarenbcKyro pa6ory cor4cKareJrr.

flpe4cranJleHHall pa6ora orBerlaer rpe6onanr4rrM, npeAb.rrBJr.rreMbrM K Ha) {HbrMI4ccJIeAoBaHHrIM, BbIrIoJIHeHa Ha Aocraror{Ho BbIcoKoM ypoBHe, o6laAaer Houa:uofr,apryMeHTl4poBaHHocrbto BbIBoAoB H upe4loxeuufi. Aerop Ar4cceprarlkroHHoroI4ccJIeAoBaHHt A.M. Peuresa 3acnyxl4Baer rtpzcy]KleHr4,s yuenofi crerreH[Karl4r44ara ropv4larlecKtlx HayK rro cneqaa^rrbHocra 12.00.08 _ yfonoBHoe nDaBo r4Kpi4Mr4HOnOrVfl; yfonoBHo-r4cfroJrHrrTeJrbHoe npaBo.

Aoqerir rcaSe4prr yronoBHo-npaBoBr,rx lr4cunrnr4HTuxooxearicKoro rocyAapcrBeHHoro yHr,rBepcaTera,KaHIHAaT rOpr4ArZrrecKHX HayK A.B.

lloAlucr Creneuro A.B. salre@(/

,/,2/hd lL680035 r. Xa6aPoncryn. TuxooKeaHcKat, t36(4212) 22-43-92

20.U.2015r.

Crerermo

Apreru BwePseaau

v step enko @matlJ