An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    1/26

    A STUDYGUIDE by RobeRt lewis & AndRew Fildes

    www.metromagazine.com.au

    www.theeducationshop.com.au

    a global warning

    by the mst tey m

    yu eve see

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    2/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    OVERVIEW

    A Icovit Tuth (David Guggenheim, 2006) is a powerul resource or engaging stu-dents in the classroom in an investigation o the issue o enhanced global warming mean-

    ing the human contribution to climate change and its potentially disastrous consequences.

    > The lm is a 90-minute version o ormer United States Vice President Al Gores modestly

    described slide show about global warming. > In act the slide show is a brilliantly illustrat-

    ed and animated lecture, interspersed with biographical asides on Gores journey to become

    a passionate advocate o the need or people to act to slow down global warming develop-

    ments. > The lecture presents a variety o types o evidence and illustrations o the causes,

    maniestations and impacts o increased carbon dioxide in the atmosphere and the subse-

    quent change to global temperatures. > Ater presenting a compelling case, Gore concludes

    on an optimistic note, by providing practical ways in which ordinary people can take personalresponsibility to lessen the global problem. > The graphics, interactives and explanations o

    the aspects covered provide an excellent way o illustrating dicult ideas and developments

    simply and clearly in the classroom, and in a way that will engage students and promote un-

    derstanding. > While the lm itsel states that there is no scientic doubt about the act o in-

    creasing human-infuenced global warming, teachers in the classroom will need to approach

    the issue in a constructively critical way, helping students both to evaluate Gores evidence,

    and also to be aware o the major criticisms that exist to the global warming case, and the

    scientic validity they do or do not have. > The lm is packed with evidence and inormation

    and this study guide suggests ways o breaking it into manageable sections in the classroom,

    as well as providing ways o critically exploring the evidence and arguments provided, and

    deconstructing the methods o persuasion used so skilully and eectively in the lm.

    Mount KiliManjaro in 2005

    SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    3/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    CURRICULUM APPLICABILITY

    A Icovit Tuth e ch d che

    esuce mdde d se secdy d tety

    eve studets :

    Geography/Society and Environment Ce d

    memet pces

    Science The scetc methd d m

    Engish Exp ctempy ssues

    Media Studies ays ctvst dcumety

    Inormation Technoogy wys peset -

    mt

    Environmenta Studies g pems d the

    suts

    Civics and Citizenship Pepes d vemets

    hts d espstes

    Vaues Education Ethc d m ehvu

    BEfOREWATCHINGTHEfILM

    Brainstorm about globalwarming

    1 Hve studets stm the

    kede d des ut

    m. recd these hte-

    d.

    2 ask studets t cssy the des

    t:

    Dete cts

    Psse cts Thees expts.

    Studets shud cme ck t

    ths st te tch the m,

    d cmmet hethe they

    ud che y spects

    t.

    3 ask studets h a ge s. Des

    ht amec ptc sy

    hve y eevce aust?

    why?

    Understanding key terms

    Du the stm ve t my e

    ecessy t mke sue studets

    udestd sme key tems used

    the m:

    Greenhouse gases ay s tht

    ss -ed dt the

    tmsphee. geehuse ses

    cude te vp, c dxde

    (Co2), methe (CH4), tus xde

    (n2o), heted fucs

    (HCFCs) , ze (o3), pefuted

    cs (PFCs), d hydfu-cs (HFCs). The m s tht

    fueces m s tuy

    SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    4/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    ccu te vpu. The m e

    pduced y hum ctvty s c

    dxde.

    Carbon dioxide The s eesed y

    the u ss ues such s .

    Goba warming The seve

    cese tempetues

    cused y the emss ses

    tht tp the sus het the Eths

    tmsphee.

    Cimate change sttstcy s-

    ct deece the mesuemets

    ethe the me stte vty

    the cmte pce e ve

    exteded ped tme, typcy

    decdes e.

    http://.ses.cm/tpc/ee-

    huse-s

    Understanding thescience Global warmingexperiments

    Hve studets cy ut these expe-

    mets t hep them udestd the

    scece eehuse ses d

    m.

    1. Maurg Car dxamp (Gra lv: sr)

    To compa dii popotio o

    Cabo Dioxid (CO2) i a om

    dit ouc

    resuces: F ech up - 2 t 4

    studets

    Test tues d std

    a duted cyde a ue st

    a me-sze pece pstce

    4 deet cued s

    4 tst-tes cps

    a -ecked tte (the eck

    shud e euh -

    t t ve t)

    a dppe tte mthymue dct sut

    a dppe tte dute huse-

    hd mm (1:50 mm t

    dsted te)

    100 ml ve

    5 ml k sd

    Sety es t e t tmes

    access t cyce tye pump

    pump

    Teachers Notes:

    The studets s th

    c dxde, exhed , d m-

    et . Yu (the teche) shud the

    s ct the c exhust

    ses. F sety ess, yu shud

    e thck ves t ptect yu

    hds m e ued. F the

    s pe e d he

    sht eeze s t keep the

    exhust ses y m yu ce.

    Pce ve the ed

    met ue d pce the de ed

    the ue ve the exhust ppe u c. whe fted, the -

    s shud e ut 7.5 cm dm-

    ete. it my e ese t ve-fte

    the d the et tte s

    escpe. Tst d te the

    use cp. repet the pcedue th

    the sme c ut yu hve

    e ech up studets.

    nte tht the sut tue a

    t tu ye. The eve Co2

    met s t t ectmthym ue.

    Studets eed ud 60 dps

    the duted mm t eutze

    the sut test tue D (ve-

    k sd ect). The the t

    vs shud eque etee 7 d 40

    dps. w studets t dd the dpssy d shke suts etee

    dps s they c et ceu ecd

    he the c ches ck t the

    sme c ue s the ct.

    Sce the studets hve t dd

    etvey e mut mm t

    the sut v D, the c ths

    smpe my e ected y dut.

    T equze ths eect, yu c te stu-

    dets t dd sme te t the the

    smpes t mke the vume ech

    smpe equ. Ths s esest t d

    smpe D s ttted st.

    Yu shud demstte the

    pcedue st t vd e.

    Procedure:

    1. add 15 ml te d 10 dps

    mthym ue dct su-

    t t ech test tue. le the

    vs a, b, C, D, d Ct.

    2. F ech ut t hs 7.5cm dmete.

    Sampe A (Ambient Air) Use

    tye pump t fte the -

    t the equed dmete.

    Tst the ue eck the

    d ste t shut th

    tst te. The te shud e t

    est 1 cm m the pe

    the . recd the cu

    the used ths

    smpe.

    Sampe B (Human Exhaation) Hve e tem meme

    up t the equed

    -

    -

    this iMage of a glacier in Patagonia was taKen 75 years ago, today this vast exPanse of ice is now gone.

    SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    5/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    dmete. Tst d te the -

    , d ecd cu.

    Sampe C (Automobie

    Exhaust) Yu teche

    suppy yu th ths .

    recd the cu.

    Sampe D (Neary pure CO2)

    Put 100 ml ve the

    -ecked tte. Us

    ue, dd 5 ml ksd. let the mxtue ue

    3 secds t dve the

    ut, the sp the ve

    the eck the tte. let the

    fte t the ppe

    dmete. Tst, te, d ecd

    the cu.

    3. Ste the pstce d p t

    ud e ed the st t

    mke sm tht c tht

    t t the eck . The

    c shud k ke ce ththe st ts mdde, d shud

    e e euh t pu the eck

    -

    -

    the .

    4. Pck up b a. Keep the te

    t, sp the s eck ve the

    c d hd t st the c

    t mke tht se. Pce the

    the ed the st t the test

    tue te d mthym ue

    eed a. Hve the pte

    emve the te the d

    sy utst the . Keep- the eck the pched

    t ct the f s, ety

    squeeze the s the s

    sy ues thuh the sut.

    5. repet the sme pcedue th the

    the s d the tues. i

    sme cses, the mthym ue

    sut che c, m ue

    t ye, dct the pesece

    cc cd med m Co2.

    6. ayse ech the smpes y

    ttt them th dps dutemm. amm eutzes the

    cc cd. The mthym ue

    etu t ue cu he

    the cd hs ected. add dps

    mm t ech the smpes

    tht tued ye, ceuy cut

    the ume dps eeded ut

    they e ut the sme c s

    yu ct. recd the esuts.

    Discussion:

    Mke cht the d t p

    ech ups esuts.

    whch smpes hd the mst d

    the est c dxde?

    why ddt the met smpe

    tu ye? (The test st ses-

    tve euh t detect cce-

    tts Co2. C dxde s

    tu pt u tmsphee,

    ut t much Co2 cud mke the

    Eth me thuh cesed

    eehuse eect.)why s utme exhust

    cce?

    another glacier that

    has disaPPeared

    SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    6/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    2. Mg h Grhueffc

    Ths smpe expemet seves s

    tduct t the eehuse eect

    y e. Studets c see

    themseves the eects ee-huse, d ete ths udestd

    t ht ccus u tmsphee.

    Objective:

    1. Hlp tudt udtad th

    hou ct a a phical ph-

    omo.

    2. U impl xpimtatio

    tchiqu icludi: obvi ad

    codi data, u o a cotol, da-

    i cocluio om ult, u o amodl.

    Resources:

    F evey up (ut) u stu-

    dets:

    2 Sm themmetes

    1 e eke the ce ss

    cte

    1 Cck, tch tme.

    1 Cpy the ksheet

    Sump ccess t suy e

    t pem the expemet

    Method:

    gup the studets d dstute the

    mtes. Ech up shud pce

    the themmetes e ches

    pt ude the sump dect

    suht.

    wt ut thee mutes s the

    themmetes e v ccute

    eds, d the hve the studets

    ecd the tempetue eds

    th themmetes s e s the tme.

    Ech up shud pce thej ve e the themmetes,

    tk ce tht the j des t cst

    shd ve the ucveed e. i the

    themmetes e t e t em

    hzt sde the js, t s e t

    std them st e sde.

    Evey mute, te mutes, the

    studets shud ecd the eds

    th themmetes the te e.

    Expanation:

    The ve the expsed themm-

    ete s cstty ch, d s t

    ets m t s epced y ce .

    becuse the the j ct c-

    cute t the est the m, ths

    stys the suht d ets me

    d me. a sm tpp het

    hppes the Eths tmsphee.

    Suht psses thuh the tm-

    sphee d ms the Eths suce.

    The het dt m the suce s

    tpped y eehuse sses.

    wthut tmsphee, the Eths

    tempetue ud vee ut

    0F (-17.8C). Ths m due t

    het-tpp sses s ced the

    geehuse Eect. bth the tm-

    sphee d the j ht t ete,

    ut the tp tht eey he t s

    cveted t het. They k de-

    ety, heve, ecuse the j keeps

    the heted , he the eehuse

    sses s dtve het.

    Extension:

    Studets c ph the dt. T

    smute m, the expe-met c e de us t js,

    e ed th d the the th

    c dxde.

    ode studets c vestte the ct

    tht th the j d the tmsphee

    veeths ht ut

    y efect sme veeths ck

    ut , hch s the mst sct

    het-tpp eect. They mht s

    vestte the Veus eect hee

    vey hh eves Co2 cuse extemehet.

    Instructions

    1 Pce the t themmetes the

    suht e mutes t et

    them et m.

    2 recd the eds th

    themmetes t the tp the

    cums.

    3 recd the tme ext t the stt-

    tempetues.

    4 Pce the j ve the st the-

    mmete.

    5 Evey mute, ecd the eds

    th themmetes thut ds-

    tu them. (see the te e:

    Dt)

    observation nuMber therMoMeter #1 therMoMeter #2

    Time

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    7

    data

    SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    7/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    Understanding theargument

    A Icovit Tuth s m tht

    pesets umet. Ths umet

    s:

    tht hum use esuces sees ces muts

    c dxde t the tms-

    phee,

    hch s ed t cesed tem-

    petues,

    hch e tu ch u e-

    vmet ys tht e d

    cesy ctue t e hmu

    t the eth d ts pepe.

    it s th vemets ddvdu pepes espsty

    t mpve the stut y the

    cts. Ths s th ptc d

    m mpetve.

    H s ths umet suppted?

    lk t the steps d

    exp h ech heps ud up the

    ve umet. The tme cde d-ctes hee ech spect c e ud

    the m.

    EXPLORINGISSUESANDIDEASINTHEfILM

    SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    8/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    1 How does goba warming work?

    (07:42 - 11:30)

    The m pvdes ths expt:

    Suht etes the eths tms-

    phee, sme s sed, sme s

    efected, ut sme the efected

    suht s tpped y the tmsphee.

    i eehuse ses cese, they

    mke t hde efected suht t

    escpe, s me s tpped, ed t

    me tmsphee.

    1.1 Pepe sketch tht shs

    ths.

    2 Carbon dioxide is increasing in

    the atmosphere (11:43 - 16:14)

    The key evdece s the jed ed

    e ceses Co2 ccet-

    ts the tmsphee. (See the

    dm pe 9.)

    2.1 wht s t?2.2 wht des t sh?

    2.3 why des t up d d

    ech ye?

    2.4 wht s ts csstet ted?

    2.5 wht s key t e the c-

    ect etee ths d s

    tempetues?

    3 We can see evidence o go-

    ba warming in gaciers (16:18

    - 18:24)

    The m shs the stte vus

    ces d ce es t sh tht

    ths s hppe. (See the t mes

    pe 11.)

    3.1 why d pemet ce es ex-

    st?

    3.2 wht des ge sh hp-

    pe Kmj, gce

    nt Pk, it aps d

    Suth amec?

    3.3 why s ths pem, ptcu-

    y th the Hmys?

    4 This is more than a cycica phe-nomenon (18:30 - 24:40)

    ge shs t tme es. oe s

    1000 yes. See the ph t tp

    pe 10.

    4.1 wht cycc ptte des ths

    sh?

    4.2 wht cect des t sh

    etee c dxde eves

    d tempetue?

    4.3 why mht ths eke ges

    umet?

    4.4 H des ge mpy tht t

    des t eke t?

    The the e shs much e

    tme ped, 650,000 yes. See the

    ph t ttm pe 10.

    4.5 why ud t e sct t

    hve ths ped ve?

    4.6 wht ptte des t sh?

    4.7 wht s the key etue the

    mde ped?

    4.8 H des t chee the cyc-

    c they?

    4.9 wht pedct des ge mkem ths?

    4.10 is ths ese?

    The Enhanced Greenhouse Effect

    Some solar

    radiation is refected

    by the Earth and

    the atmosphere

    Solar radiation

    passes through

    the clear atmosphere

    Some of the infrared

    radiation passes through

    the atmosphere, and some

    is absorbed and re-emittedin all directions by

    greenhouse gas molecules.

    The effect of this is to warm

    the Earths surface and the

    lower atmosphere

    ATMOSPHERE

    EARTH

    Most radiation is

    absorbed by the Earths

    surface and warms it. Infrared radiation

    is emitted from the

    Earths surface

    SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    9/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    390

    380

    370

    360

    350

    340

    330

    320

    310

    1958 1965 1975 1985 1995 2005

    ATMOSPHERIC CO, AT MAUNA LOA OBSEVATORY

    CO

    2(ppm)

    5 It is happening a over the word

    and aects oceans as we (28:00

    - 33:24)

    ge shs tempetue ecd m

    the 1860s. See the ph pe 11.

    5.1 wht des t sh?

    5.2 wht mpcts s ths hv?

    5.3 wht mpct s ths hv

    ces tempetue es?

    5.4 why?

    5.5 wht eect des ths hve

    huce ctvty?

    5.6 why?

    6 This resuts in both severe

    storms and drought increasing

    precipitation and changing rain-a distribution (36:36 - 39:13)

    6.1 g m hs eect

    pecptt, d the dst-

    ut tht pecptt. wht

    s ths?

    6.2 why s ths pem?

    7 Two major warnings (41:59

    - 49:34; 51:42 - 54:26; 54:29 -

    01:01:21)

    A Icovit Tuth desces sme

    vey ecet pheme seved

    geed d atctc hch my

    hve pd eects se eves.

    le ps mette ee -

    seved the ce she ttched t the

    atctc cst d the geed

    pteu.

    i atctc, these ee pecus

    t the ek-up mj ce she s

    the mette eded d thuh

    ccks the ce t mmouli.

    The temmouli s Fech m.

    Usuy t ees t dm ut hee

    t ees t the te che

    te m, hch these etues the

    ce eseme.

    i the ce she, these mus d-

    eed ccks d cevsses the ce

    d teed mssve ek-up

    the et sheves hch exted ve

    the ce. The ce ve the d the

    e t cpse s e. whe they

    ccu ve d, te pus d

    thuh mus ut t eches the

    ck udeeth. t the hs uct-

    eect, cus the ce sheet t sp

    the ck.

    The met the ft ce the

    actc p ce d the atctc

    sheves shud hve tte eect

    the se eve. Ths s esy t

    demstte.

    as yu stt k t ths pt

    the m e ss eke

    tuh d h- t th te.

    add ume ce cues

    peces t smute ft ce

    pck the suce. Ths s sm

    t the actc oce hee the

    pck s mss ce cks d

    fes hch hve cstty pt

    meted d eze t m

    ke mss.

    Mk the te eve the sde

    the ss. wht d yu thk

    hppe t the eve the te

    he the ce hs meted? Du- the ess, s the ce mets,

    seve the ches the te

    eve. The eve shud se vey

    tte, dey t t , eve thuh

    the ce s ft pty ve

    the te eve.

    The ess e smpe. The m pt

    the ce, ke cee, s edy

    eeth the suce. Secdy, the

    ce s ess dese th qud te.

    Uusuy, te s ess dese tssd stte thts hy t fts! C-

    sequety, he t mets the pt

    SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    10/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    Medieval Warm Period Little Ice Age

    0.5

    1000 1200 1400 1600

    Year

    1800 2000

    0.0

    -0.5

    -1.0

    Departuresintemperature(C)

    fromt

    he1961to1990avera

    ge

    Data from thermometers (red) and from tree rings,

    corals, ice cores and historical records (blue).

    Temperature and CO2concentration in the atmosphere over the past 400 600 years

    (from the Vostok core)CO2 concentration, ppmv

    Temperature change from present, C

    Year before present (present = 1950)

    Year before present (present = 1950)

    300

    280

    260

    240

    220

    200

    180

    160

    400 000 350 000 300 000 250 000 200 000 150 000 100 000 50 000 0

    400 000

    4C

    4C

    2C

    0C

    -2C

    -4C

    -6C

    -10C

    350 000 300 000 250 000 200 000 150 000 100 000 50 000 0

    10SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    11/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t ha n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    the ce ve the suce shud

    e excty equvet t the ss

    vume the meted ce. i the p

    ft ce, sme s hed ve the

    te ude pessue ut the mut se eve se shud e ee.

    Heve, he the met exteds t

    d es, the esut s vey deet.

    Ths s te hch hs ee hed

    ut the ces ec tme

    mes, up t ms yes.

    oce the destz eect su-

    ce mette d mus s est-

    shed ce sheets d ces, ths

    te s eesed ck t the ds

    ces. Yu my hve see the ue-

    sh cu sme the ce ek

    up ths dctes tht t s vey d

    ce hch hs ee cmpessed ve

    thusds yes. Ths s y see

    t the edes sheves d ces s

    they f utds t me es

    these ek d met msses

    e etet ck up d. The

    esut s se se eve.

    Ths s the equvet tpp me

    ce t the tuh eke the -

    te eve ses pdy.A Icovit

    Tuth suests tht e c see ths

    hppe the d tdy, thuhthe mt.

    ges ks t the stte ce t

    the actc Cce.

    7.1 wht s hppe t the ce

    the actc?

    7.2 wht s the physc evdece

    tht t s hppe?

    7.3 why s tht pem?

    7.4 ge exps tht the met-

    the ce cp ceses the

    tempetue the te. whe

    the sus ys ht the ce, me

    th 90% s efected ck. but

    he t hts the te, me th

    90% s sed, d ms

    the te. S the ess ce thee

    s, the ete the mth the

    te. iustte ths pcess th

    smpe dm. See the t

    mes t the tp pe 13.

    7.5 why s ths pem?

    Ths s hs eect cu-

    ets the gu Stem, tht

    fs etee nth amecd este Eupe.

    The gu Stem

    The m cuets the gu Stem

    cde th the cd ds cm

    the actc d geed. (See me

    t ttm pe 12) Het evptes

    m the gu Stem d s ced

    tds este Eupe. Ths te

    et ehd s ce ut s ste,

    d sks, hee t stts t f

    suth. Ths pcess cts ke pump,

    keep the g oce Cvey

    bet mv ud the d. aut

    10 000 yes hue vume

    meted esh te fed t the gu

    Stem, d t vtuy stpped. as the

    m s e e

    css Eupe, ce e deveped,

    st ey 1000 yes.

    7.6 whee des ge sy mde

    KiliManjaro, africa

    GLOBAL TEMPERATURE CHANGES (1880-2000)1.4

    1.2

    1

    0.8

    0.6

    0.4

    0.2

    0

    -0.2

    -0.4

    -0.6

    -0.81880 1890 1900 1920 1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000

    YEARSource: U.S. National Climate Data Center, 2001

    Departurefroml

    ong-termm

    ean(F)

    11SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    12/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t ha n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    equvet dy esh tecud cme m t ptety

    dsupt the gu Stem ?

    7.7 Che cmte c s ed

    t che sess d

    ms ty t ve th

    htt. H hs tht hd

    mpct the evmet?

    (See phs t the ttm ths

    pe.)

    7.8 H c t hve eect hu-

    m heth?

    ge s ks t the stte atc-

    tc ce hee sustt pt

    the lse b ce she hs meted.

    (See the me lse b ce she,

    ve et)

    7.9 a hue mut te s

    tpped s ce. i t mets, t

    cuse se se eves. why s

    ths pem?7.10 i se ce mets, t t cuse

    y se; ut d ce des, t

    . H s the met se

    ce hep the met d

    ce?

    7.11 The cet mouli s hep-

    cuse pem. Mouli

    exst he d ce stts t

    met, cet tues te

    tht ucte the pt hee

    d ce meets the ck se,

    me tht t c mve me

    esy t the se. See the d-

    ms pe 14.

    7.12 why t cuse pem?

    7.13 nte h my the ds

    mj ctes e the cst d

    hve -y es. Exme

    the stut yu e.

    wht eect ud mj se

    eve se hve the ctes tht

    yu k?

    8 There are three key causes(01:03:43 01:09:40)

    Populatio (See me pe 17.)

    8.1 wht hs hppeed t ppu-

    t?

    8.2 why s ths pem?

    Tcholo

    8.3 wht s hppe t tech-

    y?

    8.4 why s ths pem?

    8.5 ge sys tht:

    Old habit + old tcholo =

    pdictabl coquc

    Old habit + tcholo

    = damaticall altd co-

    quc

    why? H des he ustte ths

    th hs dscuss ts d

    t?

    CHAnges In THe LArsen B ICe sHeL

    SOURCE: Scientific American

    April 1 May 1 June 1

    SHIFTS IN SEASONS: 1980 Bird Ar riva l B ird Hatching Caterpi ll ar Hatching

    April 25Peak bird arrival

    June 3Former peak bird hatchingand caterpillar season

    April 1 May 1 June 1

    SHIFTS IN SEASONS: 2000

    April 25Peak bird arrival

    May 25New peakbird-hatching season

    May 15New peakcaterpillarseason

    effects of a shift in seasons

    THe reD nUMBers AnD OrAnge

    LInes rePresenT THe OLLOwIng

    DATes:

    1 MArCH 1986

    2 AUgUsT 1993

    3 JAnUAry 1995

    4 JULy 1997

    5 JAnUAry 1999

    6 OCTOBer 2000

    7 eBrUAry 2002

    8 MArCH 2002

    9 JULy 2004

    1SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    13/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t ha n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    effects of sun on the arctic ice

    the gulf streaM and the global ocean conveyor belt

    1SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    14/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t ha n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    Aa

    8.6 wht s the messe

    ut the ?

    9 There are three causes

    o misconceptions

    that aect awareness

    (01:12:18 01:27:57)

    Diamt amo ci-

    tit

    9.1 wht pt s he mk

    ut the smp

    scetc tces ut

    m, cm-

    ped t justc

    tces?9.2 why s ths mptt?

    9.3 H mht t ect u

    edess t ct?

    9.4 i hse teest s ths?

    Choic bt coom ad

    viomt

    9.5 ge ees t the us-

    tt sh d

    e ty sce, d

    the eth the the.

    why des he sy ths s

    se chce?

    9.6 He dest ctuy -

    sh the setece i e

    dt hve pet

    Fsh t hm.

    9.7 wht des the c ex-

    mpe ustte?

    Too lat, caot b olvd

    9.8 ge pvdes e

    exmpes pems tht hve

    ee sved the pst.

    lst sme these. is

    m sm

    pem t these? gve

    ess d st.

    Concusion

    10 Des the m cvce

    yu tht:

    cmte s ch? thee s m-

    ?

    the m cuse y

    cuet cmte che

    d m s

    the cese c

    dxde the tms-

    phee due t hum

    ctvty? Exp yu

    ess.

    Critically evaluatingthe argument

    The umet A Icov-

    it Tuth s peseted s ce

    d cteste ct. The

    m ssets tht thee s

    scetc dseemet th t,

    d tht the dut tht exsts

    s peseted thuh ju

    tces y thse th vested

    teest t ch theamec pepes excessve

    use eey esuces.

    is ths chctest

    the sceptcs d dutes?

    we eed t csde ths.

    1 lk t pe 16. it s

    te th thee cums.

    The st tes my the

    key ssues sed the

    m. The secd s k

    yu e t summze

    efy ht the m cms

    ut ech these s-

    sues.

    2 ate yu hve de ths,

    k t the thd cum.

    it pvdes spce yu

    t pce t the pp-

    pte umet cm

    mde y the dutes

    ech ssue. Seect the

    pppte cm m thest the cum the

    ht pe 15, cut ech

    ut, d pste them the

    pppte pce the

    3d cum Te 1. (

    pe 16)

    An Inconvenient

    Truth and scientifcmethod

    FA Icovit Tuth te cede t must ct

    d scece.

    1 why?

    Moulins

    1SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    15/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t ha n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    All attempts to link specic recent outbreaks to climatechange cannot survive a conrontation with the acts. Inall cases, local conditions (such as the banning o theinsecticide DDT, land use changes, or oreign contact)account or expansions o disease vectors or increases ininection rates.

    Nobody denies that CO2 is increasing. But changes inglobal temperature are better correlated with changes insolar activity. Solar magnetic fux shows trends similar tothat or temperatures rom 1880 to the present.

    O thirteen populations o polar bears in Canada two aregrowing, two are in decline, the rest are stable. The growthis in areas where there is warming, the decline wherethere is cooling.

    Only two per cent o ice foats, so i that melts it will havelittle impact on sea levels. Ice is increasing in size in partso the Antarctic, balancing out any melt. Melting may bedue to the Atlantic Multi-decadal Oscillation (AMO). TheAMO is an ongoing series o long-duration changes in thesea surace temperature o the North Atlantic Ocean, withcool and warm phases that may last or twenty to ortyyears at a time and a dierence o about 0.5C betweenextremes. These changes are natural and have been oc-curring or at least the last 1000 years.

    Since 1976 the world has warmed at a remarkable con-stant and non-alarming rate o 0.17C per decade, and thisis not a problem.

    The act that greenhouse gas emissions add heat energyto the climate system and are bound to warm the planet tosome extent has never been in doubt. The real question is

    how much the climate will warm, how ast, and with whateects.

    The Gul Stream is a wind-driven system that depends onthe earths spin and lunar tides, not on salt.

    There have always been patterns o rainall variability overtime in all areas.

    There have been periods o abnormally high temperaturesin the past such as in the Mediaeval period.

    There is no change globally in the requency o cyclonesover the past thirty-ve years. Some portion o the 0.5Cwarming o the sea surace temperature is due to thecyclical Atlantic Multi-decadal Oscillation (AMO).

    This may be a orest management problem. The beetleslike thick, old-growth orests. Thinning the orests willsolve the problem.

    text for table 1 exercise

    2 D yu thk t des c-

    t d scece? why?

    ree t eemets th

    the m tht cvce yu

    tht the scece s ccute

    d ee.

    Hee s cm ut the sc-

    etc methd:

    S ht s scece? wht

    s the Scetc Methd?

    F smeth t e c-

    sdeed scetc ct, t

    must e teste th the

    scetc methd.

    1. oseve sme spect theuvese.

    2. ivet tettve exp-

    t, ced hypthess,

    hch s csstet th

    ht yu hve seved.

    3. Use the hypthess t mke

    pedcts.

    4. Test thse pedcts y

    expemets uthe

    sevts d mdy

    the hypthess the ht

    yu esuts.

    5. repet steps 3 d 4 ut

    thee e dscepces

    etee they d expe-

    met d/ sevt.

    re scece s hume.

    Sme ths e uk-

    e. it s hum tue

    t t ccept the de tht

    sme ths e eyd

    u ech k, ut t

    s te the cse.

    Step 4 the scetc

    methd eques ex-pemet. a expemet

    eques ct. wht

    e the cts cmte

    scece?

    http://xtcs.cm/ee-

    ece/m.htm

    3 Dscuss ths det. D

    yu ee tht ecuse

    cmte scece s t

    csed system tht t c-

    t e k? H ud

    yu se the pesve?

    Australia inAnInconvenient Truth

    aust eceves e me-

    ts A Icovit Tuth:

    u c ue ececy

    t (ette th the USaut t ds est);

    mp pces the d

    hee u veett

    s ctut t eehuse

    s emsss (yet mst u-

    s the th hee e s

    eeded t ce up cuty

    d cuse e-veett);

    d mp sh pces

    hee hs ched

    sustty ve the st ce-

    tuy ( mp hch s dectyctdcted y e Tm

    Feys Th wath Mak-

    , pes 108 t 109); d

    u -vvemet the

    Kyt Ptc.

    A Icovit Tuth me-

    ts the Kyt Ptc

    seve tmes, th the

    eeece e tht the Uted

    Sttes d aust e the

    y t deveped ts

    h hve eused t ty ts

    tems.

    1 wht d yu thk the

    Kyt Ptc s?

    2 wht s yu ect t

    the y ge epesets

    aust d Kyt?

    3 why mht aust t

    hve ee pt t?

    The Kyt Ptc s

    eemet mde ude theUted nts Fmek

    Cvet Cmte

    Che (UnFCCC). Cutes

    tht ty ths ptc cmmt

    t educe the emsss

    c dxde d ve the

    eehuse ses

    a itevemet Pe

    Cmte Che (iPCC) hs

    pedcted vee

    se tempetue 1.4C(2.5F) t 5.8C (10.4F) e-

    tee 1990 d 2100.

    1SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    16/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t ha n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    table 1: *based on: p://..//030,05288.m p://../m/.m

    1 asPect 2 Point Made in an inconvenient truth(write your suMMary here)

    3 scePtics/deniers (cut and Paste in here)

    Global warming isreal

    Carbon dioxide isincreasing rapidly

    Temperatures areincreasing

    Ice melts inglaciers, Arctic andAntarctic

    Ocean currents /Gul Stream

    Rising oceantemperatures andextreme weather

    conditions rain,hurricanes anddrought

    Changes in seasonsand pest inesta-tions

    Polar bears

    Drought

    Ten hottest years

    Global warming andinsect vectors

    1SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    17/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t ha n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    The Kyt Ptc s devsed t cut

    emsss eehuse ses

    s s t stze educe the ses

    the tmsphee.

    lk t the st mj ts d

    the eehuse s emsss the

    ext pe.

    4 wht e the ks the USa

    d aust ths st?

    5 is aust mj pye ths

    st? Justy yu ve. Yu eed t ee t th austs

    tt ctut, s e s u

    pe pes e yu dscuss.

    Kyt set ecee tets

    ptcpts, usuy decese 5%

    1990 emsss, hch ud me

    ut 29% decese expected

    2010 emsss.

    it cme t eect 2005. i success-

    uy mpemeted, the Kyt Ptc educe the eects cesed

    eehuse s emsss y sme-

    hee etee 0.02C d 0.28C y

    the ye 2050.

    6 D yu thk ths s sustt

    mpvemet? Exp yu ve.

    The aust gvemet ued

    deet utcme tse, d

    ce t cese ts

    eehuse s emsss t 108%

    ts 1990 eves (u tht the 1990

    see s t ccute d typ-

    c ye.

    Ths pped t mj deveped cu-

    tes, ut t t devep ec-

    mes, such s Ch d id.

    Ths s ccepted, ut aust, he

    ccept the tet, hs eused t

    ty the Ptc tht s, mke t e-

    y ecee eemet aust.

    aust ued tht s ts ecmy

    s s depedet c-sedpe d s c expts, e

    educt ud cuse t et ec-

    mc hm th ss mkets,

    pductvty d js.

    The Kyt ssue s cmpex e, ut

    e tht eeds t e ked t. Hee

    e thee extcts ut the ssue. oe

    s m speech y aust Fe

    Mste aexde De the

    ssue Jue 2006, the secd s m

    speech y l pmet

    Pete gett speech ap 2005,

    d the thd s m Cmmeth

    Pmet be dcumet thessue m Septeme 2002. red

    them d se the quests tht

    .

    A. A Auraa GvrmMr v

    Thk yu the pptuty t tk

    t yu tdy ut tet ets

    t ddess cmte che.

    Ths s mst seus ssue d mj chee the tet

    cmmuty.

    12

    11

    10

    9

    8

    7

    6

    5

    4

    3

    2

    1

    0

    BillionsofPeople Old Stone

    Age

    2.6 million

    years

    New StoneAge

    BronzeAge

    IronAge

    MiddleAges

    ModernAge

    Future

    2100

    1998

    1990

    1975

    1960

    1800

    7000

    BC

    8000

    BC

    5000

    BC

    4000

    BC

    3000

    BC

    2000

    BC

    1000

    BC

    1

    AD

    1000

    AD

    2000

    AD

    3000

    AD

    4000

    AD

    Source: Population: A Lively Introduction. Joseph A. McFall, Jr. Population Bulletin, Volume46, Number 2, October 1991, pages 1-43, Population Reference Bureau, Washington, D.C.

    1SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    18/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t ha n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    list of Major nations and their greenhouse gas eMission. httP://www.carbonPlanet.coM/hoMe/country_eMissions.PhP for

    data on greenhouse gas (*australias figure was 564.7 Mt for 2004 with a PoPulation of 20 Million. this was 2.3% above1990 figures, coMPared to the target of an increase of 8% by 2012 httP://www.greenhouse.gov.au/inventory/2004/national-

    rePort.htMl)

    country year co2 eMissions(Megatonnes Mt)

    PoPulation (Mil-lions)

    co2 eMissions (PerPerson)

    Albania 1994 7.06 3.20 2.21

    Australia 2000* 535.30 19.44 27.54

    Canada 2003 740.00 31.56 23.45

    China 2004 3650.00 1198.50 3.05

    European Union 1999 4030.00 375.30 10.74

    Hong Kong 2003 43.5 6.803 6.39

    India 2001 1228.54 914.00 1.34

    Indonesia 1994 904.433 191 4.74

    Iran 1994 417.01 57.67 7.23

    Israel 1996 62.71 5.69 11.02

    Japan 2002 1224.98 126.93 9.65

    Laos 1990 0 4.57 0.00

    Malaysia 1994 76 20.1 3.78

    Marshall Islands 1990 0.0025 0.055 0.05

    Mexico 2000 686.10 97.48 7.04

    Micronesia 1997 0 0.106 0.00

    Mongolia 1998 15.6 2.42 6.45

    Nauru 1994 0.019 0.013 1.46

    Netherlands 1999 174.10 15.80 11.02

    New Zealand 1999 54.70 3.79 14.43

    Niue 1994 0 0.002 0.00

    Philippines 1994 100.738 73.527 1.37

    Russian Federation 1999 1880.00 145.60 12.91

    Samoa 1999 0.43 0.17 2.53

    Singapore 1994 26.80 3.20 8.38

    Solomon Islands 1994 0.32258 0.4 0.81

    South Arica 1994 379.84 40.60 9.36

    Thailand 1994 286.37 62.00 4.62

    United Kingdom 2003 656.00 59.60 11.01

    US 2003 6746.00 280.00 24.09

    Zimbabwe 1994 0.00 10.64 0.001SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    19/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t ha n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    ad ts e hee, qute ky,

    thee e esy ses.

    but s i thk ut cmte che, t

    ys ccus t me tht e eed t

    push my ts t ce.

    we eed t k dmestcy t

    educe emsss.

    ad e eed t ud tet c-

    pet educ emsss d

    s dpt t cmte che.

    Mst mptty, e eed t ctue

    t pusue e teches d e

    ppches t educe c ems-

    ss hee d y.

    Thts hy i m st suppte

    the Pme Mstes c t eeks

    u dete the use

    uce eey aust.

    it s tee yes sce the d

    theed t r d ed the Un

    Fmek Cvet Cmte

    Che.

    The tet cmmuty eed

    the eed t stze eehuse

    ses t eve tht ud pevet

    deus teeece th the c-

    mte system.

    Tht much, e cud ee . ad

    aust ud ke ths thy

    mpemeted.

    The, te yes the Kyt Pt-

    c s etted, t petze

    the Un Fmek Cvet y

    sett tets d tmetes de-

    veped cutes t mt eehuses emsss.

    Kyts et chevemet s tht

    ty deveped cutes peded

    t cu emsss.

    Heve, Kyts et f s tht

    t exempted the 149 cutes the

    devep d m mk sm-

    et.

    Meve, t cked shp dstc-t etee deveped d devep-

    cutes tht 2006 des t

    efect the ety emsss

    d d s eve ess y 2012.

    n, e e te ctczed t

    s t the Kyt Ptc ut

    the ct the mtte s tht aust

    s tck t meet u Kyt tet uke, y the y, my the de-

    veped cutes.

    The test eehuse ccuts sh

    tht aust hs educed pe cpt

    emsss y thtee pe cet sce

    1990 d emsss pe d gDP

    y thty-ve pe cet.

    we e deed tk seusy the

    eed aust t ctute t

    eehuse mtt.

    Yet e emttes such s bz, Mex-

    c, id, ides, Ke d Ch,

    hve mde such cmmtmet.

    The et esut s tht ee-

    huse s emsss e pjected t

    y ty pe cet y 2012.

    wthut Kyt, emsss ud

    hve y ty-e pe cet.

    http://.emste.v.u/

    speeches/2006/060602_es.htm

    b.A Auraa oppMmr v

    The vemets espse, ecd

    d pess hve ee eu.

    The dvet cmte che d the

    kehd ces m-

    mes ths ssue s e the

    mst ctc e ce. its tme sce s, ts mpct s vst s the ces

    edy m. it hs pesded ve

    sustt cese eehuse

    s emsss hch y 2020 e

    expected t cese y 23%. ad

    [expets pedct] u eey csump-

    t t cese y hpp 53%

    y tht ye t. Yes e e tck

    t ech the Kyt st phse tet

    108% 1990 eves ut y ecuse

    the aust cuse heey e

    cud cude s e d ce-, mey the eets the educ-

    ts udetke y the [Queesd]

    vemet, u emsss tt.

    othese e e stued, th c-

    heet pcy sttut mek

    t ddess the eve ee-

    huse s sp.

    whteve the pecse eects

    ces muts c dxde

    d the ses e ve the

    tem, thee s st csesus tht

    deep cuts eehuse s ems-

    ss eed t e mde sme-

    th the de 60% y 2050,

    d tht the d eed th

    tet eemets d c

    stumets t ee d eute

    tht pcess.

    The Kyt Ptc, ce, s

    the st ttempt y the tet

    cmmuty t ddess the ssue. The

    ptc hs ee ced md-

    est st step, hch deed t s, ut

    Kyt s epesets csdee

    chevemet ;

    1) b e ume sttes t

    the te;

    2) Estsh tet e

    mek educts tht c-

    ttes the td c d the

    vestmet eey ecet tech-

    es s t steps the pth

    t eehuse s educts.

    Ctcs hve ccetted the de-

    ceces Kyt; the sttus c

    sks, tht the tety s equte, the

    sece devep ts d

    sme pduces eehuse

    emsss ke id d Ch, d

    the p tck ecd thse Eu-pe ts tht hve sed ut

    mde tte pess.

    Sme these ctcsms e

    uded. Ch d id, th

    ume devep cutes e

    pt Kyt, theyve sed , ut

    t ct yet. ideed the st -

    t eed t mst the deve-

    ped ts, mey t educe the

    emsss hch hve pemtted the

    exst hh eves devepmet,hs t ey stted.

    1SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    20/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t ha n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    ad t s tue tht pess Eupe

    hs ee ess th spectcu. but

    thse h sy ts t mdest

    scpe, m tte ths ths

    e sy.

    http://.peteett.cm.u/c.sp?d=35

    C. A Auraa ParamarPapr ummar

    aust mde tet cm-

    mtmet Deceme 1997 t Kyt

    t mt ts eehuse s emsss

    th t 108 pe cet ts 1990

    see, hch equtes t ey 30

    pe cet educt m ts usess

    s usu pjects.

    aust s e thee cutes

    the the t e ny d

    iced ted cese

    ts emss eves ts 1990 se;

    umet the ccept

    deetted tets sed

    cutys ptcu ecmc ccum-

    stce. i ctst, ths cmpes

    t deveped cutes cectvey

    ee t educe the ete

    emsss eehuse ses y t

    est 5 pe cet m 1990 eves the

    st cmmtmet ped 20082012.

    whst aust hs t eed t

    ty Kyt t hs put pce d

    e mesues epeset -

    mst $1 th vestmet, t

    esue tht the cmmtmet mde t

    Kyt c e met.

    [Heve],the eey sect s e

    ctu th emsss d

    ces she austs tteehuse emsss. accd t the

    aust geehuse oce (ago),

    emsss the Eey Sect e

    expected t y ve 39 pe cet

    etee 1990 d 2010 [hch ud

    me tht] ve the ped 20082012

    austs emsss ud e 111 pe

    cet 1990 eves vee.

    http://.ph.v.u/y/t-

    ude/SCi/kyt.htm

    7 why hs the vemet t t-

    ed the Kyt Ptc?

    8 The vemet cms tht

    d cmmtmet t the Kyt

    Ptc ud e st the

    t teest he hv

    mpct the tet ee-

    huse emss stut. is ths

    ese tttude ve-met t dpt?

    9 The vemet s cms tht

    t s mpemet pces tht

    cheve the educt equed

    thut hv ted Kyt. Des

    ths seem t e hppe?

    aust s educ ts emsss,

    d hs s jed the as-Pcc

    Pteshp Ce Devepmet

    d Cmte ( aP6), cud USa,

    aust, Ch, Jp, Suth Ked id. These ts, seve

    them devep ecmes, epeset

    ve 50% emsss. The m s t

    c-pete the devepmet d

    tse e techy t educe

    eehuse ses. but thee e

    set tets, d y tets vuty

    dpted e t ey ecee.

    Hee s dcumet pduced y the

    aust gvemet.

    lk t the cht the ext pe, p-

    duced y the aust gvemet.

    10 wht des t sh?

    11 wht s met y the stst

    te?

    12 wht ths stst te

    d?

    13 Dvde t seve ups. Hve

    ech up esech d exp

    excty h ech thse seve

    eemets hep sve the p-

    em eehuse emsss ed- t m. rept ck

    t the he css, d dd e

    setece expt t ech

    the seve sttees.

    14 D yu thk aust s ct

    espsy ts eehuse p-

    ces d pms?

    15 H ud yu epeset aust-

    s stut yu cud dd

    sm sect tA Icovit

    Tuth?

    LOOKING AT THE fILMSTRAILER AND POSTER

    The te t the m hs ee mde

    y deet cmpy t the m

    tse. lk t the te t .-

    cveettuth.cm.u the m,d ed ths cmmet y ge du

    teve:

    It a at tail, v ctiv. But

    th popl ho mak th tail a

    compltl dit om th popl

    ho mak th movi. I thik thv

    do a tifc job o th movi, ad I

    thik a dit oup did a tifc job

    o th tail.

    Th pupo o a tail i v di-t om th pupo o a movi. I

    talkd ith stv spilb, ho a

    th movi ad lovd it, ad a th

    tail ad lovd it. Ad I akd him

    ptt much th am qutio ou

    aki m. H aid, Al, ouv ot to

    ko thi: th pupo o a tail i

    to ab a audic b th thoat ad

    tl thm ito th at. [Lauh.]

    Thv ot to miut itad o

    it-to miut, ad th at to

    t popl i to th movi.

    http://.st./es/m-

    dsh/2006/05/09/ets/dex.htm

    lk s t the pste the m,

    d the tectve execse t, t

    .cveettuth.cm.u

    1 wht s ech ty t cheve?

    2 ae they epesetts the

    m?

    3 ae they pesusve?

    CONSIDERINGSOLUTIONS

    Finding out more

    oe the es thtA Icovit

    Tuth ses s tetves t d

    c eey.

    Hee e sme tetve suces tht

    e efy meted.

    S

    wd

    0SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    21/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t ha n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    We call the avoidedemissions thestabilization triangle.

    Billions of toncarbon emittedper year

    I emissions could be keptfat or the next ty years,wed be on track to avoid

    more than doubling CO2rom its pre-industrialconcentration.

    The new course is pre-dicted to avoid the worstpredicted consequenceso dramatic warming, butwill require avoiding mas-sive quantities o carbondioxide emissions over thenext ty years.

    * The verticle axis represents carbon emissions not CO2

    (other greenhouse gases are not included). Thegraph also does not include emissions rom land-use change and orestry.

    Historicalemissions

    Towardtripling

    CO2

    Avoiddoubling

    CO2

    Curre

    ntpath

    1955 2005 2055

    14

    7

    2

    Stabilisation

    Triangle

    GtC

    CO2released to atmosphere*

    global strategies(exaMPles)

    australian action

    1. Installing 700 times thecurrent global capacity osolar electricity

    MRET $3 billion boost in RE investment REDI $100 million Solar Cities $75 million RRPGP $205 million PVRP $52 million (7,500 systems installed AP6 LETDF $500 million

    2. Using best eciencypractices in all residentialand commercial buildings

    Minimum appliance standards Solar Cities Building codes Energy eciency opportunities

    3. Capturing and storingCO2 rom 800 coal-redpower stations

    LETDF $500 million AP6 Otway Basin Pilot Industry contribution (ACA $300 million)

    State program (Qld / Vic)

    4. Doubling uel economy othe worlds cars

    Green Vehicle Guide Alternative Fuel Conversion Program National Fuel consumption Target Fuel consumption labelling Participation in global hydrogen initiatives

    5. Using natural gas insteado coal at 1400 electricitypower stations. Cogen-eration, waste gas use

    GGAP Greenhouse Challenge Plus AP6

    6. Elimina ting tropical de-orestation and doublingthe rate o new orestplanting

    2.1 million ha revegetated NRM/NHT/NAP $4.4 billion Halting land clearing Greenhouse Action in Regional Australia

    7. Tripling the worldscurrent nuclear capacity

    PM announced Switkowski review

    Global Stabilisation Triangle- Australias Action 14Gt C

    7Gt C

    2005 2055

    Source based on S. Pacala and R. Socolow, Science, 13 August 2004.

    Ren

    ewable

    Ene

    rgyan

    dFu

    el

    Ener

    gyEf

    cienc

    y

    CO2Ca

    pturean

    dStorage

    Efc

    ientV

    ehicl

    es

    FuelSw

    itching

    Forests

    andSoi

    ls

    NuclearPower

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    7

    1SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    22/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t ha n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    Hyd

    bmss

    wve pe

    gethem

    1 Dvde yu css t sm

    ups, th ech up hvespsty exp de-

    et suce. The key quests t

    ept e:

    H des t pduce eey?

    whee s t e used?

    T ht extet?

    wht e ts dvtes d ds-

    dvtes s eey suce?

    (Csde th evmet d

    ecmc spects hee.)

    w t pmte ecc sust-

    ty?

    2 oe the tetve suces tht

    s t meted A Icov-

    it Tuth s uce eey. is t

    -eehuse emsss te-

    tve? D the ptet des

    sscted th ts use mke t

    uccepte tetve? re-

    sech d dscuss ths mptt

    ssue.

    whse espsty s t t educe

    eehuse emsss? is t up

    t vemets, d dvdu-

    s hve espsty? D the

    deveped ts hve ete

    espsty th the devep

    es, ve tht e hve edy

    eeted m eey use y

    tht devep ts e

    ty t d? C dvdu

    ey d yth, s t t

    vehem?

    The ms este suests ume

    pctc steps tht evey dvduc tke t educe the ee-

    huse mpct.

    3 Hee s pctc y ccut-

    yu pes ctut

    t eehuse emsss:

    C Dxde s emsss e

    mesue d ecded kms.

    1. wk ut h my kmetes

    yu my dve st ye tt.i y meme yu my dves

    the vehce s pt j,

    estmte the dstce dve ve

    the ye. Ccute the mut

    ue used my memes

    hve vey d de the c-

    sumpt ech vehce. 2.35k s

    pduced pe te pet ccu-

    te the tt mut pduced ye.

    2. Check yu eectcty s the

    pst ye. F ech kwh (k-

    tt-hu) 0.8k c

    dxde.

    3. D the sme yu s s.

    F ech cuc mete 300MJ

    tu s (methe) tht yu

    husehd used, yu pduced

    2.5k c dxde.

    4. i yu fe cmmec e

    the st ye, dd 0.35k ech kmete f y ech pe-

    s (.e. my u et

    hdy, mutpy the dstce y

    u).

    add the tts ech sect.

    The due t t ue

    used the ds d sevces

    yu used (c dxde s p-

    duced t mke the pducts tht

    yu uy d het c

    the uds tht yu vst). whts

    the ume?

    n, st the ys hch yu

    cud educe yu mpct.

    Extes Quest: s t ette

    yu my t fy t hdy des-

    tt 500km dstt t dve

    thee? (e the cts!)

    Ccute the cmptve ems-

    s ues.

    Personal actions

    4 lk t este http://.

    cmtecss.et g t the TaKEaCTion pe.

    The ext pes sh psse cts

    tht dvdus my c tke.

    Use the mt t yu

    espses t ech the cums

    ths te.

    (SEE TABlE 2 OVERlEAf)

    Conclusion

    A Icovit Tuth shes th

    ths sttemet:

    utu atio ma ll hav oc-

    caio to ak thmlv: what

    ou pat thiki? wh didt th

    ak up h th had a chac?

    w hav to ha that qutio, om

    thm, o.

    1 D yu ee tht hum ctvty s

    cet eehuse ses tht e

    ctut t m tht

    my cete hmu eects the

    d?

    2 i t, e yu ctai tht hum

    ctvty s t hv ths eect?

    3 D yu eeve tht yu hve

    pes espsty t ct

    y tht educes pes ee-

    huse s emsss?

    4 D yu ee th ges stte-met ve?

    5 H ud yu se the ques-

    t?

    Further resources

    A Icovit Tuth este: http://

    .cmtecss.et

    a teve th a ge: http://

    .st./es/m-

    dsh/2006/05/09/ets/dex.htm

    a cmte scetst ste, th ts vedct

    the m: http://.ecmte.

    /dex.php?p-299

    a m educt ste: http://

    .cmtecheeduct./

    The Pe Cete esech cmte

    che: http://.pecmte.

    The Cmte isttute esech

    cmte che: http://.cmte.

    austs CSiro ste: http://.

    cs.u

    aust gvemet Deptmet the Evmet d Hete

    aust geehuse oce:

    http://.eehuse.v.u

    Sceptc stes: http://.ce.

    http://.jukscece.cm

    http://.m.

    a ge,A Icovit Tuth, r-

    de, Pesyv, 2006.

    Tm Fey, Th wath Mak,

    Text Push, Meue, 2005.

    bj lm, Th skptical evio-

    mtalit, Cmde UvestyPess, Cmde, 2001.

    SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    23/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t ha n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    1 suggestedaction

    2 why is itdesirable?

    3 are there any unde-sirable asPects to it?

    4 would youconsider doing it? yes,no, Maybe and why.

    5 iMPact see thewebsite to get thesefigures

    Replace a regular

    incandescent lightbulb with a compactfuorescent light bulb(cf).

    Move your thermo-stat down 1C inwinter and up 1C insummer.

    Clean or replace l-ters on your urnaceand air conditioner.

    Install a programma-

    ble thermostat.

    Wrap your waterheater in an insula-tion blanket.

    Use less hot water.

    Use a clotheslineinstead o a dryer

    whenever possible.

    Unplug electronicsrom the wall whenyoure not usingthem.

    Only run your dish-washer when theresa ull load and usethe energy-savingsetting.

    Insulate andweather proo your

    home.

    Be sure youre recy-cling at home.

    Plant a tree.

    Switch to greenpower.

    table 2

    SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    24/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t ha n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    1 suggestedaction

    2 why is itdesirable?

    3 are there any unde-sirable asPects to it?

    4 would youconsider doing it? yes,no, Maybe and why.

    5 iMPact see thewebsite to get thesefigures

    Buy locally grown

    and produced oods.

    Buy resh oodsinstead o rozen.

    Seek out and sup-port local armersmarkets.

    Buy organic oods asmuch as possible.

    Avoid heavily pack-aged products.

    Eat less meat.

    Reduce the numbero miles you driveby walking, biking,car pooling or taking

    mass transit wher-ever possible.

    Start a car pool withyour coworkers orclassmates.

    Keep your car tunedup.

    Check your tyresweekly to make suretheyre properly

    infated.

    When it is time ora new car, choose amore uel ecientvehicle.

    Try car sharing.

    Try telecommutingrom home.

    Fly less.

    table 2

    SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    25/26a n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t ha n i n c o n v e n i e n t t r u t h

    Want to do stomething to help stop global warming?Here are ten simple things you can do and how much carbon dioxide youll save doing them.

    Change a lightrepc e eu ht u th cmpct fuescet ht u sve 68 kms c dxde ye.

    Drive lesswk, ke, cp tke mss tst me te. Yu sve 282 ms c dxde evey kmete yu dt dve!

    Recycle more

    Yu c sve 1.1 tes c dxde pe ye y ecyc just h yu husehd ste.Check your tyres

    Keep yu tyes fted ppey c mpve ue ececy y me th thee pe cet.

    Evey te pet sved keeps 2.4 kms c dxde ut the tmsphee!

    Use less hot waterit tkes t eey t het te. Use ess ht te y st f shehed

    (160 kms Co2 sved pe ye) d sh yu cthes cd m te (225 kms sved pe ye).

    Avoid products with a lot o packagingYu c sve 544 kms c dxde yu cut d yu e y te pe cet.

    Adjust your thermostat

    Mv yu themstt d just e deee te d up e deee summecud sve ut 900 kms c dxde ye.

    Plant a treea se tee s 900 kms c dxde ve ts etme.

    Be a part o the solutionle me d et ctve t CmteCss.et

    Spread the word! Encourage your riends to see An Inconvenient Truth.

    tenthingstodo

    aninconvenienttruth cems 14 Septeme

    sch up ks:

    .cveettuth.cm.u

    SCrEE

    nEDUCaTion

  • 8/3/2019 An Inconvenient Truth - A Global Warning

    26/26

    Ths study ude s pduced yATOM aToM 2006

    [email protected]

    F me mt Screen education

    mze t dd the ee study udes vst

    www.metromagazine.com.au

    F hudeds tces Fm s Text, Sceeltecy, Muttecy d Med Studes, vst

    www.theeducationshop.com.au

    Notice: a educt sttut my mke cpes pt ths Study gude, pvded tht t y

    mkes d uses cpes s esy equed ts educt, -cmmec, cssm pu-

    pses d des t se ed such cpes.

    SCrEE

    nEDUCaT