8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

1/25

Alternate ProjectDelivery

Opportunities

April 21, 2010

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

2/25

2

Master Builder

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

3/25

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

4/25

4

The 60s

Time and theHandshake

Aerial views ofEast Los Angeles College

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

5/25

5

70s and 80s

AdversarialRegulation

Craft Talent

Building Systems

Users Requirements

Edison Center for the Arts /ELAC auditorium (left) Mural by Roberto Chavez in 1970s (right)

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

6/25

6

The 90s and Present

Stop the Conflicts

Design-Build

ConstructionManagement

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

7/25

7

Technological Revolution

Communication

Design

Construction

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

8/25

8

Technological Revolution:

SustainabilityMaterials and TechniquesCode Requirements

Construction

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

9/25

9

3D Models

Lines vs. Objects

Technological Revolution:

Building InformationModeling (BIM)

Material Lists

Cost Estimating

Personnel Scheduling

Funding Schedules

Clash Detection

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

10/25

10

BIM Storm

BIM

Brain Storming

Design Charrettes

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

11/25

11

Back to the Master Builder

Eliminate Conflicts

Changes in Designand Construction

Technology

Fluid Changes inOwners Needs

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

12/25

12

Project Delivery Methods

Design Bid Build

CPM-AdvisorCPM-At Risk

Design Build

DB

A/E B

CPM

O

A/E B

O

CPM

A/E CM

O

Sub-contractors

A/E CPM

O

Sub-contractors

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

13/25

13

DB

A/E Builder

CPM

Owner

CPM

A/E Builder

Owner

LACCD Project Delivery Methods

Design Bid Build Design Build

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

14/25

14

Design Bid Build Delivery Process

NeedA/E TeamSelection

Progra

Owner

A/E B

O

CPM

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

15/25

15

Design Bid Build

PROS:

Independent A/E

Low Bid Focus

Owner: Maximum Design Control

CONS:

Lengthy Linear Process

No Pre-Qualification of BuilderExtensive finger pointing

No constructability input by Builders

Owner: Maximum Design Risk

A/E B

O

CPM

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

16/25

16

Design Build Delivery ProcessDesi Buil Delivery ro ess

Neero ra iA E Tea

ele tio

ro ra

Crit

BA/E

O

DB

CPM

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

17/25

17

Design Build

PROS:

Single Sources of Responsibility

Pre-Qualification ofENTIREENTIRE Team

Constructability Input by Builders

CONS:

Independence of A/E Team

BA/E

O

DB

CPM

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

18/25

18

Current Design Build Process Results

Schematic Design/ Design Development

Fixed Price

Design Fees

Construction Costs

Builders Fees

RFP Issuance to Award: 100 120 Days

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

19/25

19

Construction Cost Comparison

WLAC Parking Structure #8

Harbor Parking Structure

Harbor FMO

Pierce FMO

9/6/07 DBB $83.14/sq.ft.

1/14/09 DB $81.50/sq.ft.

Trade Tech South Campus

Mission East Campus

4/20/06 DBB $342.51/sq.ft.

8/6/09 DB $269.27/sq.ft.

3/22/07 DBB $658.01/sq.ft.

1/14/09 DB $646.71/sq.ft.

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

20/25

20

TeamBack to the Master Builder

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

21/25

Integrated Project Delivery

Partnered process

All participants

A / E

Contractor

Subcontractor

Suppliers

Owners

Open book

Shared savings

21

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

22/25

22

LACC Student Union

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

23/25

23

Current Design Build Projects

LAPC Facilities Maintenance & Operations

LASC Student Services Center WLAC Athletic Campus

LAHC Science Complex

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

24/25

24

Current Design Build Projects

LASC Student Services Center

WLAC Watson Center

LAMC East Campus

LACC Student Union

8/9/2019 Alt Proj Delivery 4-10

25/25