53
The science of climate change Barry Lefer University of Houston Department of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences 28 August 2013 UH Law Center ANTCI, 2005

ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

The science of climate change

Barry Lefer

University of Houston Department of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences

28 August 2013

UH Law Center

ANTCI, 2005

Page 2: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

The science of climate change

ANTCI, 2005

I. Basics of Earth System Science

II. Climate change on geologic and historical time scales

III. Natural and anthropogenic causes of climate change

IV. Consequences of future climate change

Page 3: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic
Page 4: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic
Page 5: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

All climate scientists agree that:

1) Earth’s average surface temperature has warmed by 0.7°C

since 1900, a conclusion based on direct measurements.

2) concentrations of CO2, CH4, N2O, and other greenhouse

gases have built up in the atmosphere over the last 100

years due to human activities.

The issue at the heart of the greenhouse debate is not whether

rising greenhouse gas levels have contributed to the

warming, but rather the magnitude of the amplification of

the warming by various feedbacks.

Climate change debate

Lefer 3 – i. basics

Page 6: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Climate vs. weather

Weather Climate

Shorter-term fluctuations Longer-Term Changes

Current atmospheric conditions Broad composite of average (or mean)

(e.g., temp, press, ws, wdir, condition of a region (e.g., temp, rain,

rainfall, etc.) snowfall, ice cover, winds)

Hours, Days, Weeks Years (and longer), Typically 30 yr ave.

Specific location for specific time Mean state of a specific region

(e.g., continent, ocean, or entire planet)

Lefer 4 – i. basics

Page 7: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

What is a greenhouse gas?

globalwarmingart.com Lefer 5 – i. basics

Page 8: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Greenhouse gas warming

Earth’s Ave. Temperature = 15ºC

Natural GH Effect = 31ºC Warming

Ruddiman, 2008 Lefer 6 – i. basics

Page 9: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Greenhouse gas warming

Dessler, 2012 Lefer 6 – i. basics

 

Tone _ layer =476

5.67 ´10-84 = 302.7K

 

P

a= sT 4 = 476W m2 = Eout

Page 10: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Greenhouse gas warming

Lefer 6 – i. basics Dessler, 2012

 

Tone _ layer =714

5.67 ´10-84 = 335K = 62 Ctwo_layers

Page 11: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Some basic “reactions”

C6H12O6 + O2 → CO2 + H2O + heat

H2O + CO2 + sunlight → C6H12O6+ O2

C6H12O6 + O2 → CO2 + H2O + heat + NO + SO2

NO → NO2 → HNO3

SO2 → H2SO4 → sulfate aerosol

NOX + VOCs + sunlight → O3

CO2 + H2O = HCO3- + H2CO3

Lefer 7 – i. basics

Page 12: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Where does atmospheric CO2 go?

Ruddiman, 2008 Lefer 8 – i. basics

Page 13: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Geochemical reservoir and fluxes

At Steady-State Input = Output

Residence time = Reservoir size / Flux rate in (or out)

Ruddiman, 2008

Page 14: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Global Carbon Cycle

Lefer 10b – i. basics GLOBE, 2007

8.3 Pg C

2011

Page 15: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

How long is CO2 in the atmosphere?

http://www.globalwarmingart.com/images/4/48/Carbon_Dioxide_Residence_Time.png Lefer 9 – i. basics

Page 16: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

CO2 lifetime in the atm-ocean system

http://www.globalwarmingart.com/images/4/48/Carbon_Dioxide_Residence_Time.png Lefer 10 – i. basics

Page 17: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Climate system response

Ruddiman, 2008 Lefer 11 – i. basics

Page 18: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Response times of climate system components

Ruddiman, 2008 Lefer 12 – i. basics

Page 19: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Ruddiman, 2008 Lefer 13 – i. basics

Albedo-temperature feedback

Page 20: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Source: NASA Lefer 14 – i. basics

Albedo-temperature feedback

Page 21: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Albedo-temperature feedback

Source: NASA Lefer 15 – i. basics

Page 22: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Another positive feedback

Ruddiman, 2008 Lefer 16 – i. basics

Page 23: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Positive and negative feedbacks

Ruddiman, 2008 Lefer 17 – i. basics

Page 24: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Time scales of climate change

Ruddiman, 2008 Lefer 18 – ii. past climates

Page 25: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Ocean sediment core record

GlobalWarming Art (t), Ruddiman, 2008 (b) Lefer 19 – ii. past climates

Page 26: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Coring Earth’s ice sheets

Lefer 20 – ii. past climates Twickler – GISP2 SMO (1994)

Page 27: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Bubbles trapped in ice core

EPICA (2004) Lefer 20 – ii. past climates

Page 28: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Ice core proxy T, CO2, dust record

GlobalWarmingArt.com Lefer 21 – ii. past climates

Page 29: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Atmospheric CO2 measurement record

Lefer 23 – iii. natural & anthro cc

Page 30: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Anthropogenic CO2

Ruddiman, 2008 Lefer 24 – iii. natural & anthro cc

Page 31: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

GlobalWarmingArt Lefer 25 – iii. natural & anthro cc

Anthropogenic CO2

Page 32: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Global Temperature Anomaly

Lefer 26 – iii. natural & anthro cc NASA GISS

Page 33: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Global Temperature Anomaly

Lefer 26 – iii. natural & anthro cc NASA GISS

Page 34: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Lefer 27 – iii. natural & anthro cc NASA GISS

Page 35: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Lefer 28 – iii. natural & anthro cc NASA GISS

Global Temperature Anomaly - April 2013

Page 36: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Volcanic cooling and El Niño warming

Ruddiman, 2001 Lefer 29 – iii. natural & anthro cc

Page 37: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Natural warming and greenhouse effects

Ruddiman, 2008 Lefer 31 – iii. natural & anthro cc

Page 38: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Modeling climate change attribution

Lefer 32 – iii. natural & anthro cc http://www.globalwarmingart.com/

Page 39: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Lefer 33 – iii. natural & anthro cc

Natural temperature changes

(<0.07 ˚ C)

Ruddiman, 2008

Page 40: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Natural interannual variability

Lefer 34 – iii. natural & anthro cc Science, 2010

Page 41: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Apple Stock Price – June 2013

Lefer 34 – iii. natural & anthro cc NASADAQ, 2013

Page 42: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Apple Stock Price – today

Lefer 34 – iii. natural & anthro cc NASDAQ, 2013

Page 43: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Apple Stock Price – Past Year

Lefer 34 – iii. natural & anthro cc NASDAQ, 2013

Page 44: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Apple Stock Price ~ 30 years

Lefer 34 – iii. natural & anthro cc NASDAQ, 2013

Page 45: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

150 0.0450.012 100 0.0740.018

50 0.1280.026

25 0.1770.052 Period Rate

Years /decade

Kevin Trenberth, 2008

Rate of global temperature rise

Lefer 35 – iv. future cc

Page 46: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Radiative forcing of recent warming

Ruddiman, 2008 Lefer 36

Page 47: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Ruddiman, 2008 Lefer 37 – iv. future cc

Response to abrupt CO2 and SO2 emissions?

Page 48: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Ruddiman, 2008 Lefer 38 – iv. future cc

Response to abrupt CO2 and SO2 emissions?

Page 49: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Response to abrupt CO2 and SO2 emissions?

Ruddiman, 2008 Lefer 39 – iv. future cc

Page 50: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

A future global temperature forecast

Science, 2010 Lefer 40 – iv. future cc

Page 51: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

http://www.globalwarmingart.com/ Lefer 41 – iv. future cc

Another future global temperature forecast

Page 52: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Projected impacts of climate change

IPCC, 2007 Lefer42 – iv. future cc

Page 53: ACS Climate Change - University of Houston Law Center · 2013-08-31 · The science of climate change ANTCI, 2005 I. Basics of Earth System Science II. Climate change on geologic

Questions? Thank you.

Beals, 2008 Barry Lefer University of Houston

Department of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences [email protected]