42

«7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

����������� ������������������������

��� ��!#"%$&'�)(*,+�-"%./+102(3"%4#+56.7"%8�9#8%:/8�;<� 8%0>=?� 8�9�4#+A@/BC./+D(�02�E"%9�8�028F*G� �E"%HI�)(3"%4#+

J�� .7�LKNM7�POQ@/RLO S�RLT�UV*W� �E"%HI�)(F�Q@#X�!L&Y� .7Z02S[=?� +1&[\^]�_a`�bdc#eQf gih2gkj�emlnbaoLj�lAprq

s�Mr0ut/��0I"%02.Q8v./!L8%0w"x(�02��0yt/��02t7� ��0IZz8�!W{|!L&D&1!d(}8%M/0<K~!L:/�E"%0?(CM/+'KNM�5�&D0IK~8%:/��0IZG+1.,�#� .Q:7� ��9G� .7Z�r0>�r��:7� ��9v! {��ITLTL�v� 8F��+1t7� ��8�+1=�02.k8%!vZQ+�;�� 8�02=?� 8%+'K2�Q@/BC./+1�L0>�E"%+18/-��ZQ02�L&1+���8�:7Z�+�ZQ+is���02.k8%!/�^5A.?8%M/0�LK2�LZQ02=�+'K�9L0I� ���ITLT �Q�dTL��5�M7�)�L0�M7�LZy��"%02=�+1.7� �C!L.<��"%+1=�+D&Y� �F"%:/�r��0wK~8�� 83=x9�M/!L=�0�+1.7"%8%+D8%:/8%+D!L.+1.<*G� �E"��I(V�vJ�!L8�MGK~!L:/�E"%0I"�(�02��0v=�0w� .Q8�8%!u��0?�LZ/ZQ��0I"�"%0IZy8�!�"%8�:�ZQ02.k8�"�(C+D8%M���(�02&D&�Z�0>�L02&1!Lt70IZ�L02./02�E� &7=?� 8%M/02=?� 8�+YK2� &7�7�LKN4#�L��!L:/.�Z?�A=?� ��!L�E"�!L�F�L�E�LZ�:7� 8�0�"%8%:7ZQ02.Q8n"~���/:/8�(C+D8%My!L./&D9��L02��9��7�L"%+YK4#.r!d(C&D0IZQ�L0�! {^� &D�L02�/�E� +YK�!L��KE!L=�t/&102���L0>!L=�028%��9a�

;�9P� +1=�(F�L"�8%!vt/��0I"%0>.Q8^�L02./02�E� &7K~!L.7K~02t/8�"^��02&Y� 8�0IZ�8%!v8%M/03"%:/�r��0IKE82�^��:/��+1./�V8�Mr0�"%+1�v(�02024k"�! {=P9P"%8��)9#+1./��+1.�s���02.Q8�!v5�8���+10IZx8�!PZQ02�L02&1!Lt�8%M/0C=�!#"%8�+D=�t�!L��8n� .Q8^�L"%t70IK~8�"�! {�8%M/0�8�Mr0>!L��9v(C+D8%Mu"%t�02SK~+'� &Q��02�#� �EZv8%!�8�(�!VZQ+D=�02.7"%+1!L.7� &#.r!L��=�� &Q"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18%+D0I"2�i �K>K~!L�EZQ+1./�L&19L@d8%M/0C8�!Lt/+YK2"�(�02��0�!L���#� ./+1H>0IZ+1.¡��K~9kK~&10�! {^&10wK~8%:/��0I"2\�L��¢��k� =�t/&10w"�! {�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+10w"2�OQ��£C0I"%!L&D:/8%+1!L.?! {�"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�+10I"2�¤ ��s�!Lt7!L&1!L�L9�! {�"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�+10I"2��/��¥�:/!L8�+102.Q8n"�� .7Z�8%!L��+'KV"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18%+D0I"2��Q��£�� 8�+1!L.7� &i"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18%+D0I"2�¦ ��s�02��=�+1.7� &i� .7Z?K2� ./!L./+YK2� &�"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18%+D0I"2�

J�0IK2� :7"%0F5�8���+10IZv8%!�t/��0I"%02.Q8��L02��9v�/��!#�LZv"%:/�r��0IKE8�+1.�����02&'� 8%+D�L02&19§"%Mr!L��8�8%+1=�0�� .7Zv� &Y"%!��70IK2� :7"%0! {^:/./0I¨L:�� &�=?� 8�Mr0>=?� 8%+'K2� &i�7�LKN4#�L��!L:/.�Z�! {�8%M/0§"%8%:7ZQ02.Q8�"F5�8%��+D0IZy8%!u�I�L!L+YZ�8�0IK�Mr./+'K2� &�ZQ+ª©uK~:/&D8%+10w"� .7Z�8�MQ:7"�"%!L=�0^! {/8�M/0�tr��!#! {["i(�02��0^!L.r&D9�!L:r8�&1+D.r0wZ«��5A.7"%8%0I�LZi@d5�(F�L"«8���9�+D./��8%!�t/��0I"%0>.Q8�� t/tr��!Lt/��+'� 8%002�k� =�t/&10I"i8%!�ZQ02�L02&D!Ltv�x¬�t/�E�LK~8�+YK2� &'­�4#./! (F&10IZQ�L0^! {78%M/0�"%:/�/��0IK~8>�� �Z/ZQ+18�+1!L.7� &19L@I+1.v8�(�!3� t/t�02.7ZQ+YK~0w"5i&1+Y"%8�0IZv"%!L=�0�:�"%0E{|:r&#./!L8%+D!L.�"�� .�ZV��0w"%:r&D8�"�(FM/+YK�Mv(�02��0�{|��0w¨®:/02.Q8�&19�:�"%0wZ�+1.P8%M/0FK~!L:/�E"%0L��s�M/0�.r!L8�0I"� ��0��LK2K~!L=�t7� ./+10IZ��Q9¡�y.Q:/=x�702��! {�0>��02�EKE+Y"%0I"�(CM/+YK�M�"%Mr!L:/&'Zy��0�:7"%0~{|:/&�{|!L��:r.7ZQ02�E"%8n� .�ZQ+D.r��8%M/0"%:/�r��0wK~82�

5�(�!L:r&'Zy&1+D4L0v8%!y8n� 4L0v8%M/+Y"�!Lt/t�!L��8�:/.r+D8�9y8%!?8�M�� ./4u=x9?{|��+102.7Z/"C+1.�s���02.k8%!/@�0I"%t70IK~+'� &1&19¡;�� �EKE! C.7ZQ��0I� 8%8n��� .7ZG¢�ZQ!#� �EZQ!�J�� &D&1+'K~!/@�(F+18�M¯(FM/!L= 5�M7�)�L0���0202.°(�!L��4�+D./��{|!L�v{|!L:r�v9L0w� �E"V.r!d(V�<5� t/t/��0IK~+Y� 8�0v�L02��9y=P:7KNM�8�M/0P"�K~+102.k8%+ª±�KvK~!L&D&Y� �7!L�E� 8%+1!L.�(F+18�M�8�M/02=²�L"�(�02&1&^�L"�t702�E"%!L.7� &�K~!L.k8��LK~8n"2� C.7Zi@ ./020IZQ&10w"�"³8�!�"��)9L@L5i(F�L"��L02��9V�L&'�LZV8%!�M��I�L0�8�Mr0Ft�!#"�"%+D�/+1&1+D8�9�8�!�tr��0w"%02.Q8�8%M/+Y"^"%02��+D0I"�! {i&D0IK~8�:r��0w"� 8F8%M/0vBC./+D�L02�E"%+18�9P! {�s���02.Q8�!/�

s���02.k8%!v´ *G� �E"%Hw�)(F��r0>�r��:7� ��9v´ ;<� �EK�M�@7�ITLTL�Q�

R

Page 2: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

�§���«�7���/�������3���� V�����°��������3�������^�������������s�!��702�L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y"�K~:7"�"�"%!L=�0�"%8n� .7Zr� �EZ<02�Q� =�tr&D0I"�! {�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"2��*z0?� ��0�t/��+D=?� ��+1&D9+1.k8%02��0I"%8�0IZ+1. 8�Mr0>+1�y�L0>!L=�028%��+'K�ZQ0I"�KE��+1t/8%+D!L.�� �³+D�E"%8�M/! (�02�L0>��(�0<��0IK2� &D&�8%M/0zZQ0~±7./+18�+1!L.,! {P� .� &1�L0>�r�E� +'KC�d� ��+1028�9u� .7Z�8�Mr0§ZQ0~±7.r+D8%+D!L.�! {���"%=�!#!L8%Myt7!L+1.Q8>�

J�9G� .���)©�.r0d��� &1�L02�/�E� +YKv�d� ��+1028�9z(�0�(C+D&1&�:/.7ZQ02�E"%8�� .7Zz��"%0>8�� ����� ZQ0~±7./0IZG�L"v�yH202��!&1!kK~:7"�! {�"%!L=�0�t�!L&D9�./!L=�+'� &Y"2\

� \���� ����� �"!"!"!#�$� � ��\&%i����� �"!"!"!#�$� � �'� R§{|!L�(%*),+.-0/(FMr0>��01+�-2���435�#67�"!"!8!"�$� �:9 +Y"�� .?+'Z�0w� &r! {i{|:/.7K~8�+1!L.7"��d� .r+'"%M/+1./�v� &D!L.r��8%M/0�"%0281�G�^s�M/0�¨L:r!L8�+102.k8

; - �<�z��\��2�3=� � �8!"!"!"�$� � 9?> + -+Y"�8�M/0V��+1./�v! {���02�L:/&Y� �F��� &1�L0>�r�E� +'K)��{|:/.7K~8%+D!L.�"�!L.�G���r!L�F� .Q9Pt�!L+D.Q8:@A)A�²(�0�M7�)�L0��v=?� �#+1=?� &+YZQ0I� &CBED� ; - �F�z�F! {�{|:r.7K~8�+1!L.7"C�d� ./+Y"%M/+1./�?� 8G@i�vs�M/0v&1!kK2� &1+DHI� 8%+D!L.�! { ; - �F�z�3(C+D8%M<��0I"%t�0IKE88%!HB*Dx+'"C8%M/0v&D!QK2� &���+1./� ; -JI DV! {���02�L:/&Y� �F{|:r.7K~8�+1!L.7"�� 8(@i��*z0v(F+1&D&�ZQ02./!L8�0v8%M/0v=?� �#+1=?� &�+YZQ0I� &+1. ; -JI D§� �#� +1.?�Q9HB*DV!L�^��:7"%8C�Q94B��

s�Mr0LK���:/&D&�ZQ+1=�02.7"%+D!L.! {P8%M/0�&D!QK>� &V��+1./� ; -JI D +'"yZQ0~±7./0IZ �L"?8%M/0�=�� ��+D=?� &�&102./�L8%M ! {P���"%8���+YK~8�&19/��ZQ0I"�KE02.7Z�+D./�P"%0I¨®:/02.7K~0�! {^t/��+1=�03+YZQ0I� &Y"�+1. ; -JI D �MAN7O�PRQTSUQWVXP'YHZ\[�]#^`_�aR@A)*�b^dc1cfeA]&]gaih,^Tjka?h�l(m7^TeHl$_ncf^?]#_po&qFBHrC��B > BAs)�k^WctlUu&vxw#y�a�]�a?h�l�z|{#v7yTym7^TeAl}_~cf^i]#_*]#j�aihXl�y?]���w#yR{$^T_x� ; -JI D��|� a?h�l${#�'^Wc�lG��l�c�w���aih�wga���^dcJcf^`_x�nv�yiw#{Jwga�@ �

*z0�./!L8�0�8%M7� 8V8�M/0?ZQ:�� &�"%t7�LK~0P8%!LB > BHs�+'"vK2� &1&D0IZ�8%M/0A�7� ��+'"%4�+^8n� .r�L0>.Q8v"%t7�LK~0P! {:� � 8�@i�s�Mr0�ZQ+1=�02.7"%+1!L.?! {^8%M/0��7� ��+Y"%4#+i8�� ./�L02.k8�"%t7�LK~0�! {��P"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��t7!L+1.Q8�+'"�+D8�"�+1.Q�d� ��+Y� .k82�

  �L02��9�K~!L.Q�L02./+10>.Q8�(F�I9x8�!�K�M/0IKN4�"%=�!#!L8%M/./0I"�"�! {³�vt�!L+1.k81@A)A������� +Y"��Q9P8%M/0����LKE!L�r+'� .K~��+D8%02��+D!L.��p��� =�02&D9L@�8�M/0�t�!L+D.Q8�+Y"V"%=�!�!L8�Mz+ª{3� .7Z�!L./&19<+ª{m8%M/02��0�0>��+'"%8�{|:/.7K~8%+D!L.�"G%��:)�+�-}"%:7K�M8%M7� 8F8%M/0v�#�LK~!L�/+�=�� 8%��+1��! {�ZQ02��+1�d� 8%+D�L0I" ��� %7�� �"���02�d� &1:7� 8�0IZ�� 8�@y+'"�! {³�E� .r44������(CM/02��0G�*��ogqFB�G�� �k��+D!L:�"%&D9L@I8%M/0�� �7! �L03ZQ+Y"�K~:7"�"%+1!L.�M7�L"³+D8�"^.�� 8�:/�E� &�02�#8%0>.�"%+D!L.x{|!L��K~!L=�t/&10>�P� .�� &D9�8�+YK��d� ��+10>8%+10w"2�*z0?./!L8%0�8�M7� 8v+1.G8%M/0?� .7� &19#8%+'K?"%028%SA:/tz8�M/0�+D=�t/&1+'K~+18�{|:r.7K~8�+1!L.z8�M/02!L��02= +D=�t/&1+10w"�8%M7� 8P�y./02+D�LMrS��!L:/��M/!#!QZ�! {���"%=�!#!L8%MGt�!L+D.Q8V+'"�+'"%!L=�!L��t/Mr+'KV8%!���ZQ+Y"�Kx+D.\�� /��5A.°� &1�L0>�r�E� +'KxK>� 8%02�L!L��9¯�[(C+D8%M�7� ��+Y"%4#+�8%!Lt�!L&D!L�L9~¡ �y8�M/+Y"C+'"�./!�&D!L./�L02��8%��:/0L�(¢F! (�02�L02�I@/+ª{�(�0v8n� 4L0v8%M/0PK~!L=�t/&10>8%+1!L.�! {�8�Mr0v&D!QK>� &��+1./�v! {��P"%=�!#!L8%Mut�!L+1.k8�! {�ZQ+1=�02.7"%+D!L.� 8�M/0V��0I"%:/&18�+'"�8�M/0���+D./�x! {�t�!d(�02�F"%02��+10w"�+D.*��� � ��+'� �/&10I"2�

5A.V{[�LK~82@#"%+D.�KE0�8�M/0��7� ��+Y"%4#+�8�!Lt�!L&1!L�L9�+Y"��L0>��9�+D.7K~!L.Q�L02./+10>.Q8��[+18��/��+1./�#"i8%!#!�=x:7K�MV8%!�ZQ0I"�K~��+Dt/8%+1!L.! {F8%M/0�&D!QK>� &���+1./�Q�F(�0�(F+1&D&�ZQ+Y"�K~:7"�"��E� 8%M/02�§� .7� &19#8%+YKPtr��!Lt702��8%+D0I"�! {3� &D�L02�/�E� +YKv"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18%+D0I"2��5A.t7� ��8%+'K~:/&Y� �I@�+D.z�uK~&Y�L"�"%+ ±iK>� 8%+1!L.�@�(�0v(F+1&D&^+YZQ02.Q8�+ª{|9y8�M/0I"%0�"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�+10I"C(FM/+YK�Mz� ��0v+'"%!L=�!L��t/M/+YK�+1.� .7� &19#8%+'KVK2� 8�02�L!L��9L�

Page 3: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

�C!d( (�0Vt/��0I"%02.k8�"%!L=�0�"%8�� .7Z/� �EZ�02�k� =�t/&10I"�! {�"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�+10I"2�

������N�������� ���7N��#Q?P��������� QTS#QWN���Y��i028�� � �  �� � ��0�� .z!Lt702.z"%:/�7"%028�KE!L.Q8�� +D.r+D./�y�?t�!L+D.Q8(@�6L�*z0mKNM/!#!#"%0��3K~!�!L�EZQ+D.�� 8�0�"%9k"%8%02= � � 67�"!8!"!#�$�   ��+D.,�   ���«028k%x�70��C��02�L:/&'� ����� &1�L0>�r�E� +'K�!L�^� .7� &19#8%+YKI�{|:/.7K~8%+D!L.�ZQ0~±7./0IZ�!L.�� � .7Z��d� ./+Y"%M/+D.r�P� 8�@�6L�

�i028C:7"FK~!L.7"%+YZQ02��8�Mr0§� &1�L02�/�E� +'K�"%028

� � �#@A)�� \g%i��@��1�,Rx/*z0P(C+D&1&^�L"�"%:/=�0�8%M7� 8G%z�L02./02�E� 8%0I"�8�Mr0v+'ZQ0I� &�+�- +D.z��./02+D�LMQ��!L:/��M/!�!kZy! {�@�6®@�K2� &D&�+18�� � �#� +1.��s�M�� 8F+Y"'+�-�� %�� ;�� �

J�9V8�M/0��#�LK~!L�/+Y� .�8%M/0Ct7!L+1.Q8k@�6�+'"^��"%+D./�L:r&'� ��t7!L+1.Q8�! {~� + {i� .7Zv!L./&19�+ª{«� &1&#t�� ��8�+Y� &/ZQ02��+D�d� 8%+1�L0w"� % > � ���v�d� ./+Y"%M,� 8H@�6L� ; !L��0>! �L02�I@:@�6 +'"y� .,+Y"%!L&'� 8%0IZ,"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��t7!L+1.Q8�+ª{§� .7Z !L./&19+ {�!L.r0<! {8%M/0V{|!L&D&1! (F+1./��0w¨®:/+1�d� &D02.Q83K~!L.7Z�+D8%+D!L.�"F+Y"�"�� 8�+Y" ±70IZ��AM/02��0 ; ZQ02./!L8%0w"�8�M/0v&1!kK2� &���+D./��! {m� &1�L02�/�E� +YK{|:/.7K~8%+D!L.�"�! {��  �� � � 8�@�6�(F+18%M�8�M/0V=?� �#+1=?� &7+YZQ0I� &RB���\ ��%n�"!$#!$%'& �"!8!"!#�(!$#!$%') �+* B-,�{|!L�3"%!L=�0�.7@ � !$#!$%/& �"!"!"!#� !$#!$%/) �"* B , {|!L��"%!L=�00.7@ ogqFBAr�1 ; > ��%n�"!$#!$%/& �"!"!"!8�(!$#!$%') �325476,@ ogqFB r 1 ; > ��!$#!8%'& �8!"!"!"�9!$#!$%/) � 25476,�

s�Mr0PZQ+D=�02.7"%+1!L.¡� trt70I� ��+1./��+D.�8�M/0x&'�L"%8�"%8�� 8�02=�02.Q8�+'"�K>� &1&10wZ�;�+1&D.r!L�3.Q:/=x�702�C! {�8�Mr0PMQ9#t�02��S"%:/�%{[�LK~0�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8 9a�:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y5=�M/0IKN4�8�M�� 8�8%M/0m� ��! �L0�"%8n� 8%02=�0>.Q8�"�� ��0�0I¨L:/+1�d� &10>.Q82�^�?>^!L:v=?�)9�K~!L.7"%:r&D8�3@�i!�!L+ ��02./�#� 9 � �

*z0�&D+Y"%8P"%!L=�0P{|!L&1&1!d(C+D./�y8�9�t/+'K2� &�02�k� =�t/&10w"V! {FMQ9�t702�E"%:/�%{[�LK~0�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+18�+10I"2�us�Mr0?8�(�!�=�!#"%8t�!Lt/:/&Y� ��� ��0vt/+YKE8%:/��0IZ��702&1!d(V�P5A. {[�LKE8V8%M/+'"�+Y"�!L./&19y8�M/02+1����0I� &^t�� ��8>@i+ª{�9L!L:<(F� .Q8�8%!u4�./!d( 8%M/0K~!L=�t/&D02��t/+YK~8�:/��0�9L!L:u(C+D&1&iM7�)�L0�8�!�(F� +18�:/.Q8�+1&��i0IK~8%:/��0 ¤ �

��K~:7"%tBAgs|� @DC �x./!kZ�0EAgs � @DC"F @�s��+1�L:/��0v�L�

O

Page 4: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

�r!L�FKE:r���L0w"�(�0�� &Y"%!PM7�)�L0�"%!LS�K2� &D&10IZ?"%+D=�t/&10�"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18%+D0I"2\

�   \ @  �� � F A&s�� R ��� ��   \ @~ �� � F @DA s �,R ���°�����\ @ F A C �,R����\ @ C A5F A C � R����\ @� F A<C(�,R

s�Mr0>9�M7�I�L0�8�M/02+1�3K~!L:/.Q8%0>��t�� ��8n"�+D.<Z�+D=�02.7"%+1!L.�OQ\ � ��� ����"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"�! {�"%:/�%{[�LK~0w"��6Z�:���� &"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"2@L�E� 8%+1!L.7� &�ZQ!L:/�/&10�t7!L+1.Q8n"~��\

�   \ @  �� � F Ags F �7s|�,R ������   \ @  �� � F @DA&s F �7s � R ����� � \ @ F A�C"F �7s|� R� � \ @DC$A F A�C"F �7s�� R����\ @� "F A�C"F �7s|� R

��VXPRN��7Y �i028:��������� �70v����"%=�!#!L8%Mi��tr��!L��0IKE8%+1�L0��d� ��+10>8 9?�L+D�L02.y�Q9��xM/!L=�02�L02./02!L:7"�+YZQ0I� &

+.- ���3=� 6 �"!"!"!#�$� �:9 !s�Mr0�"�� =�0�+'Z�0w� &�Z�0E±�./0I"F� .��)©�.r0�K~!L./0(� !d�L02�J����+D. ��� � � �� 0>!L=�028%��+'K2� &1&D9L@x�²+Y"�8%M/0vK~&D!#"%:/��0�! {�8%M/0�+1.Q�L02�E"%03+1=?� �L0�! {'���i:/.�ZQ02��8�M/0Vt/��!L��0IK~8%+D!L.

��� � ��� �IRx/(�����0� "%:7KNM?8�M�� 8 ��@�67�"!"!8!"�$@ � ���� 3=@�6��"!"!"!#�$@ �:9 !�C!L8�0�8�M7� 8�+ª{R���r+'"�./!L8��V&1+D./0I� �F"%:/��"%t7�LK~0�8�M/02.A� +'"�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��� 8�8�Mr0��L02��8�02�?RQ�^ C&'"%!/@�8�Mr0�t7!L+1.Q8Rx+'"C� .u+Y"%!L&Y� 8�0IZy"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�9v+ª{�� .�Z?!L./&19�+ {'���«+'"C"%=�!�!L8�M��

�i028C:7"C��0wK2� &1&i8�M�� 8F8%M/0§K~&1!#"%:/��0�! {^8%M/0��L�E� trMu! {^8%M/0§� ��! �L0�ZQ0~±7./0IZ��E� 8�+1!L.7� &i=?� t���� � � �� � @/K2� &D&�+D8��^@/�LZQ=�+18n"�8�(�!Pt/��!®��0wK~8%+D!L.�"

� ����� � � .7Z ��� � � � � !s�Mr0�±7�E"%8Ct/��!L��0IK~8�+1!L.y=�� 4L0I"�� 8�M/0V8%!L8n� &^"%t7�LK~0V! {�8�Mr0�:/.r+D�L02�E"�� &i�/:/.�ZQ&D0 ; �$��� ��! �L0>��� � @78%M/0"%0IK~!L.7Z?+Y"�8%M/0V�/&1!d(CS6Z�!d(C.�! {�8�Mr0�H202��!?"%0wK~8%+D!L.y! {^8�Mr+'"��/:/.7ZQ&10�8�!�8%M/0V!L��+D�L+1.?! {1� � � � �

s�MQ:7"2@)(�0F=?�)9�8%M/+1./4§� ��!L:/8^�V"%+D=�+1&'� ��t/��!QKE0IZQ:r��0^{|!L�^8%M/0Ct7� +D���F���F�f�z�n��s�M7� 8�+Y"2@L(�0�(F� .Q8�8%!8�� 4L038%M/0C8�!L8�� &�"%t��LKE0�! {�8%M/0C�/:/.7ZQ&10 ; -! �$�V� �³� .7Z�8�Mr0>.�(�0C(F� .k8�8�!v­LK~!L&D&Y� t7"%0I­�+18n"�H20>��!v"%0IK~8�+1!L.8%!�8%M/0u"%+1./�L:/&Y� �Vt7!L+1.Q8��[8%M/0y�L0>��8%02�/���G;�!�0>! �L02�I@^(�0?(F� .Q8V8�Mr0¡­LK~!L&1&'� t7"%+1./�#­�t/��!kK~0IZQ:/��0�8%!z�70

¤

Page 5: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

:/./+Y¨L:r0a@�(FMr+D&10F8%M/0�� ��!d�L0�ZQ0I"�K~��+D��0IZP�L02!L=�028���+YK�K~!L.7"%8���:�KE8%+1!L.�! {R� ZQ02t702.7Zr"^!L.�8%M/0�02=P��0IZ/ZQ+1./������ �0���  t/��0IK~+'"%0VZQ0I"�KE��+1t/8%+D!L.y! {�8%M/+Y"3K~!L.7"%8%��:7K~8%+D!L.y��0I¨L:/+1��0I"�8%M/0v&'� .r�L:7� �L0�! {�� &1�L02�/�E� +'K��L02!L=�0>8%��9L�

� � ./0V=?�I9x8���0I� 8C8�M/+Y"Ct7� ��8�! {�8%M/0V&D0IK~8%:/��0§�L"C� .u02��0>�EK~+Y"%0�!L.y8�M/0V&Y� ./�L:7� �L0�! {�"�K�Mr0>=�0I"2�ª��i028�:7"�8�� 4L0P� .�� =�t/&10V&D+1./0V�/:/.7ZQ&10 � ! �L02����t/��!L��0IK~8�+1�L0v�d� ��+1028�9H��� ��*z0P(C+D&1&�+YZQ02.Q8�+ª{|9u8%M/0

&1+D./0V�/:/.�ZQ&D0 � (C+D8%M<� .�+1.k�L02��8%+D�r&D0�"%Mr0w�){^! {�+18�"3"%0IK~8%+D!L.7"C(CM/+'KNM�(�0�(C+D&1&�Z�0>.r!L8�0V�Q9 � @�8%!#!/�9�i028:7"�K~!L.7"%+YZQ02��8%M/0�a ]ga w#yRc [Rwg��lm! {�8%M/0�m vxw#y7�r:/.7ZQ&10 ��� �^5A.�� &D�L02�/�E� +YK��L02!L=�028���9x+D8FK2� .?��0�ZQ0~±7./0IZ�L"F��"%t�0IKE8%��:/=}! { ; - S�� &1�L0>�r�E�V! {�"%0IK~8%+D!L.7"�! {^=P:/&18�+1t/&10I"^! { � \

��� � ��\ �������� �� 1����� 6 ����� 27!

*z0F��02t�0w� 8�� �#� +D.�@ 8%M7� 8^�L02!L=�028���+YK2� &D&19���� � ��+'"³8�M/0�"%t7�LK~0F! {i8�Mr0FZQ:7� &Q�/:/.7Z�&D0�8%! � @L+A� 0L�#"%0IK~8%+D!L.7"! { � � ��0�{|:r.7K~8�+1!L.7"�!L.���� � � � � � ��s�Mr0>.y8%M/0�K~!L./0V!d�L02�:� � �L"�"%!QK~+'� 8%0IZy8�! � +Y"���:7"%8

��� � ��\ ������� 1����� 6�

6 �<� � � ����� � 27!�#+1.7K~0 � +Y"�� =�t/&D0L@�+18n"�tr��!L��0IKE8%+1�L0P0I¨L:/+1�d� &102.k8 �"!$#&% 1(' ��� 6 � 6 �<� � � � ��� � 2 +Y"���:7"%8�8�M/0x�d� ��+10>8 9��� �� C.7Z�(�0�M7�)�L0���.7� 8�:r�E� &i=�� t�)<\*��� � �1� � ��� � �F�L"�"%!QKE+Y� 8%0wZ�8%!�8%M/0V02�d� &D:�� 8�+1!L.u=?� t7"

�6 �<� � � � ��� ��+ ; - � � � ��� !

s�Mr0�=?� t,)zK~!L.Q8��E�LK~8�"�8%M/0�H202��!�"%0IK~8%+D!L.y! {-�<� � ��8%!�8�M/0��L0>��8%02�?! {.��� � �n�� 0>!L=�028%��+'K2� &1&D9L@i+ª{:����� �0� � .7Z � � ; - �n� ��8�Mr0>.z8%M/0�­LK~!L&1&'� t�"%+D./�#­�=�� t/) +'"�8%M/0?KE!L.rS

./0IK~8�0IZyt7� ��8�! {^8%M/0v�#8%02+D.y{[�LK~8%!L��+DHI� 8%+D!L.y! {^8�Mr0�=?� t

�<� ; - ��� ��� � � ������� � � !s�MQ:7"2@�8%M/0�� ��! �L0�� +'"�!L�r8n� +1./0IZ��Q9<­LK~!L&D&Y� t7"%+1./�#­x+ {F� .7Z !L./&D9�+ª{�+D8�+Y"�./!L��=?� &[�V;�!L��02!d�L02�I@�&10>8:7"�./!L8�0y8%M7� 8�"%:7KNM�� . � +'"x./!L8x./!L��=?� &�+ª{�8�Mr0u02=P��0IZ/ZQ+1./�*��� � �0� +'"�./!L8P�L+1�L02.°�Q9G8%M/0K~!L=�t/&D028%0�&1+1./0I� �3"%9k"%8%02=��F5A.7ZQ020IZi@Q(�0V=?�I9u�L"�"%:r=�0�8%M7� 8�"%:7K�MA����"%t�� .7"!�0� � .7ZA��� � ��� +'"!L�/8�� +D.r0wZ��Q9§��&D+1./0I� ��t/��!L��0IK~8�+1!L.P! {���� �X� �10�@L(CM/02��0:��� �r"%t7� .7" �10}� .7Z32 4 �z��s�M/0�&1+D.r0w� �t/��!L��0IK~8%+D!L.,��� � �����Q9�+D02&YZ/"��V�/+D�E� 8%+1!L.7� &#=?� t�! {�8�Mr03�L"�"%!kK~+Y� 8�0IZ��A�L0>!L=�028%��+'K)�^KE!L.r0w"�(FMr+'KNM�K2� ../!L8���0P� .�+'"%!L=�!L��t/M/+Y"%=���0IK2� :7"%0v8�Mr0��7� ��+Y"%4#+�8�� ./�L02.k8�"%t7�LK~0�! {�8�M/0PK~!L./0V! �L0>�������A��0w"%t������ � �� 8�+18n"��L0>��8%02�?M7�L"�ZQ+1=�02.7"%+D!L.� �[��0I"%t��52 ��� � ./0�=?�)9P02�#8%02.7Zy8%M/+'"�� ���L:r=�02.Q8^8%!�t/��!d�L0C8�M�� 8:�+Y"�./!L��=?� &i� 83Rv+ª{�� .7Z�!L./&D9�+ª{'� � +Y"�t/��!L��0IK~8%+D�L02&19�.r!L��=�� &A@Q"%0>0,3=¢�� ��8�"%M/!L��./0 9 �:9;��6 � �WN�Y0=�!L./0I"�! �L02�FK~:/���L0I"2@/KE!L.r0w"�!d�L02� �^02��!L./0I"%0a�

�i028�:7"�K~!L.7"%+YZQ02�3��"%=�!#!L8%M<KE:r���L037 � .7Z��x&D+1./0V�/:/.7ZQ&10 � ! �L0>�"7 ! {�t7!#"%+18%+D�L0vZQ02�L��020a�Cs�M/0&1+D./0I� �C�/:/.7ZQ&108�<� � � � 7 M7�L"�8%M/0VH20>��!�"%0IKE8%+1!L.9716d�

Page 6: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

:9;RN<���7Q��#N YvX^��! �L0�8%M7� 8F8%M/0v"%0>&ª±7.Q8%0>�E"%0IK~8%+D!L. 7Gs6 +'"�0w¨®:7� &'��o5 � � � �n�:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y �i028.�*) ��� � ���70v8%M/0V�L02��8�02�y! {³8%M/0PK~!L./0V!d�L02�"7 (C+D8%M�8%M/0v&D!QK2� &���+1./� ;�� � .7Zy8%M/0=?� �#+1=?� &7+YZQ0I� &RB � � ;�� ��X^��! �L0�8%M7� 8

ZQ+1=r���B � > B s� � �,ZQ+1=pr � 6 �(7(� � �� .7Zy8%M/0V0w¨®:7� &1+D8�9yM/!L&YZ/"�+ª{m� .7Z�!L./&19?+ª{^{|!L��� .k9AB � O�8%M/0�=?� t �

6 �(7(� � � ��� � �6 � 7(� � ��� �

+Y"F"%:L��0IK~8�+1�L0L�

� RV SUQWN P�S � Q?P ������D��QTSUQWN<�7Y �i028�� ��0P�x±7./+18%0v�L��!L:/t�! {m� &1�L0>�r�E� +'K��6� .�� &D9�8�+YK)�3� :/8%!L=�!L��trM/+'"%=?"! {:�   ��*z0v=��)9��L"�"%:/=�0�8�M�� 8�� +'"���"%:/�/�L��!L:/t?! {�&1+D./0I� ��8%�E� .7" {|!L��=?� 8�+1!L.7"�����������P�V�[8%M/+Y"�+'"�x8�Mr0>!L��02= ! { =m� ��8�� .�(FMr+'KNMu(�0v(C+D&1&�ZQ+Y"�K~:7"�"�+1.�8%M/0�{|:r8�:/��0 ���3s�M/0v�L��!L:/t���LKE8�"C8�Mr0>��0~{|!L��0V!L.8%M/0���+D./��! {Ft�!L&19#./!L=�+Y� &'"0�435��� �"!"!"!8�$�   9 "%!�8%M7� 8V+ { � +'"v�y=?� 8%��+D��+D.�� ��� ��� �����x��� .7Z�%�t�!L&D9�./!L=�+'� &r{|:/.7K~8%+D!L.y8�Mr0>. � � %«�%� ���7�"!"!8!"�$�   ��� %i� � ����� �"!"!"!#�$�   ����� �i028

�435���#�"!"!8! �}�   9�� ���435��� �"!"!"!"�}�   9ZQ02./!L8%0�8%M/0§"%:r�7� &D�L02�/�E��! {^+D.Q�d� ��+Y� .Q8�t�!L&19#./!L=�+Y� &'"��L8%M/0v� &D�L02�/�E�V+Y"�±�./+D8%02&D9��L02./02�E� 8%0wZy� .7Z�+D.Q8%02S�L�E� &19�K~&D!#"%0IZi� =�M/!#!#"%0�M/!L=�!L�L0>.r0>!L:�"^�L02./02�E� 8%!L�E"����U�"!"!"!"��� � ! {��3=���U�"!"!"!#�$�   9 � � .�Z?K~!L.7"%+'Z�0>���=?� t

�����#�"!"!"!#��� � ��\&�   � � � �s�Mr0�+D=?� �L0�! {^8%M/+Y"�=?� tu+Y"�8%M/0V!L���/+18F"%t7�LK~0��   > ���A!L�F8%M/0v"%t70IK~8%��:/= �����)� �3=���#�"!"!"!#�$�   9 � �%���

 C.<./!L.rS[:r./+D8C02&D02=�02.k8 � )����� �����P�C+'"�K2� &1&D0IZ�����]#e�[ny?l��A{"l���l��g^?]#_�+ {�+18�+'"C! {�±7./+18�0v!L�EZ�0>�� .7Zx+18^&D0I�)�L0I"���MQ9#t�0>��tr&'� ./0�t�!L+1.k8 (F+Y"%0�±7�#0IZi�^¢�¨L:/+1�d� &102.k8%&19a@ � +'"���K~!L=�t/&102�v��0���0>��+D!L.�+ª{�+18�M7�L"���L"�� .y0>+1�L02.Q�d� &D:r03! {�=P:/&18%+Dt/&1+YKE+18�9����G�L�^J�9u�V��0I"%:/&18�! { =�M/02�d� &1&10>9L@/"%020p3 X^��+1&1& 9 @L(�0�=?�I9��L"�"%:/=�08%M7� 8�� K~!L.Q8�� +D.7"�./!<K~!L=�t/&10>����0��702�#+1!L.G�70IK2� :7"%0�8%M/0?KE!L=�t/&102�<��0��702�#+1!L.7"VZQ!�./!L8vK�M7� .r�L0�8%M/0��0I"%:/&18�+1./�v�L02��=}! {�� .�� &D9�8�+YK��d� ��+1028�9L��s�Mr0��L��!L:/t�� (F+18�My./!�K~!L=�t/&102����0��702��+D!L.y+'"CK2� &D&10IZcfeAw#y`yA�5 {���+Y"(cfeAw#y`y�8%M/02.<8%M/0�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��&D!QKE:�"�! {m8%M/0�¨L:/!L8%+D02.Q8�K~!L.7"%+Y"%8n"�! {�t7!L+1.Q8n"�(FM/02��0��}ZQ!#0I"�./!L8�LK~8�{|��0202&D9L�

:9;��6 � �WN�� � ��+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�+10I" �   � �i028�:7"�K~!L.7"%+YZQ02���PK~9kK~&1+'K�"%:r�/�L��!L:/tP! {!� ����Ox� �x���L02./02�E� 8%0wZ��k9��vZQ+Y� �L!L.7� &=?� 8���+1�

� \ �#" �%$ RR $

� � � \x(FM/02��0 $ +Y"F�xt/��+1=�+D8%+D�L0���!�!L8F! {�:r./+D8 9�! {�ZQ02�L��020GB'&R!:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y =�M/0IK�4�8�M7� 8C8�Mr0���0I"%:/&D8%+1./��¨®:/!L8�+102.Q8�+'"C��"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+18�9v! {^8�9#t�0 � � � �d�

Page 7: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

��+1�L:/��0�OQ�

�#+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I" �   � .7Z �   ���#:/t/t�!#"%0�8�M7� 8�O�� ������� !P� ��0�+D.Q8%0>�L02�E"�"%:7KNMu8%M7� 8�� F

�� F

�! 4 �7!

s�Mr0>.z8%M/02��0�0>��+'"%8�"v��"%t/M/02��+YK2� &�8%��+Y� ./�L&D0�� !L.°��:/./+18v"%t/M/02��0v(FM/!#"%0�� s � ./�L&10I"�� ��0�� @��/@�� ����� =�0>&19L@^+ª{39L!L:G8�� 4L0y8�M/0y"%t/M/02��+'K2� &^tr��!L��0IKE8%+1!L.G! {38%M/0u"%M7�LZ�0wZW8���+Y� ./�L&10�!L.��+1�L:/��0�OW�6K~!Lt/+10IZ{|��!L=�3@�i!�!L+ ��02./�#� 9 �^9L!L:�(F+1&D&i�L028C8�M/0VZQ0I"%+D��0IZ�8���+Y� ./�L&10��L"�"%!QK~+'� 8%0IZy8�!x8�M/0V��0I"%t70IK~8%+D�L0x� �����&� ! �n�

s�Mr0v��0���0>��+D!L.�"�+D.z8%M/0�"%+YZQ0I"�! {�� �L02./02�E� 8�0��u"%:/�r�L��!L:/t� �+1.z8�Mr0P+Y"%!L=�028%��+D0I"C! {8� s (FM/+YK�MM7�L"��²�L"�8�Mr0P{|:r.7Z/� =�02.k8�� &^ZQ!L=?� +D.��v*z0�K~!L.7"%+YZQ02����"%:/�r�L��!L:/t� � \��� �� ���V� ¤ ���¡�n��C! ((�0v=?�I9y8%M/+D.r4<� �7!L:/8"�'sP�L"���02+D.r�?8�Mr0�K~!L=�t/&D02�yt/��!L��0IK~8�+1�L0v&1+D./0 � � �v �K2KE!L�EZ�+D./�L&19L@�8�M/02��0v+Y"��8�(�!LS {|!L&YZ�KE! �L02��+D.r��� \�� � s � ����� ¤ ���y����*z0x8n� 4L0 � \���� � � �� � �n�v �"�8%M/0P��0I"%:/&18F(�0x!L�/8�� +D."%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"�! {^8�9#t�0 �   � .�Z��   �:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y =�M/0IK�4<8%M/0uK2�L"%0?! {�� �����g� ! �,� �6Ox��Ox�$����(FMr0>��0� ���/�<s�M/+Y"vK>�L"%0�(C+D&1&�&10I�LZz8%!��"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8�9 �   ���³+D�E"%8�t/��! �L0�8�M�� 8� +Y"��L02./02�E� 8%0IZ?�Q9� $ R

R $� � � � .7Z

� R ���� R �(FMr0>��0 $ +Y"F�vtr��+D=�+18�+1�L0���!#!L8�! {^:/./+18�9P! {^ZQ02�L��020�O7������¢C+D.Q82\^./!L8%0�8%M7� 8F8%M/0�=?� t��xM7�L"C�v4L02��./02&K~!L.7"%+Y"%8�+1./�v! {^+'Z�0>.Q8%+D8 9���� .7Z�! {^8�Mr0�=?� 8%��+D�*���/@Q8%Mk:�" ��(F+1&D&i=x:/&18�+1t/&19P��!L8�� 8�+1!L.7"��Q9?OQ�ª��C02�#8�K�M/0IKN4�8%M7� 8C8�M/0 �3SA+1.k� � ��+'� .Q8�"%:/�7� &1�L0>�r�E�V! {��3=@X� A 9 +Y"��L02./02�E� 8%0wZ��Q9

@�s8Ags ��@ s   F Ags   � .7Z @DA&s  �� � � A&@�s  �� � !��+1.7� &19a@�t/��! �L0�8�M7� 8C8�Mr0���02&Y� 8�+1!L.u��028�(�0202.u8%M/0V�L0>.r0>�E� 8%!L�E"�9#+102&'Zr"�8%M/0�0I¨®:7� 8�+1!L.�! {�8 9#t�0 �   �

:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y =�M/0IK�4�8�M/0vK2�L"%0I"�! { � � @ � � � .7Z ��� �

¦

Page 8: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

�§���«�7���/���:���,���k�����F������ ���z����3�������^�������������5A. !L�EZQ02�?8%!�Z�+'"�K~:7"�"?"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+18�+10I"P(�0�(F+1&D&VKE!L.�"%+'ZQ02��8%M/02+D�A{"l c�]#y<v�a?^?]#_nc2� s�M7� 8?+Y"2@�+ª{�� +'"y�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ���d� ��+D028�9y8%M/02.<(�0V(F+1&D&�KE!L.�"%+'ZQ02����"%=�!�!L8�M��d� ��+1028�9A����� .7Z���=?� t )G\&����� � (FM/+YK�M+Y"��L02./02��+'K2� &1&D9x+'"%!L=�!L��t/Mr+'"%=����#!L=�028�+1=�0w"�(�0VK>� &1&����i��cfeA]&]gaihAeA]�mxl$y�! {k�G��s�M/0�02�#+Y"%8%0>.�KE0V! {��0I"%!L&D:r8�+1!L.�! {m"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"C+Y"F.r!L8�K~&D0I� ��� 8�� &1&[@i+18�+'"���t/��! {|!L:/.7Zy.�� 8�:/��0v! {�KE!L=�t/&102�¡� &1�L02�/�E� +YK�d� ��+1028�+10I"�(FM/+YK�My(F�L"Ct/��! �L0wZ�+1.�� ���/+18��E� ��9?ZQ+1=�02.7"%+D!L.y�Q9H¢C+D��!L.�� 4d�Q��¢C02��0v(�0V(F+1&D&�ZQ+'"�K~:7"�"C8�(�!t/��!L�/&102=?"2\�./!L��=?� &D+1HI� 8�+1!L.u! {^�d� ��+1028�+10I"2@/(CM/+'KNM�+'"�8�Mr0V±7�E"%8F"%8�02t�+D.y��0I"%!L&D��+D./�?"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+10w"2@Q� .7Z��0I"%!L&D:r8�+1!L.?! {�O S�ZQ+D=�02.7"%+1!L.7� &7"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+10w"2�

�i028C:7"���0IK2� &D&i8%M7� 8F� .y+D����0IZQ:�KE+1�/&10�� &D�L02�/�E� +YKC�d� ��+D028�9 � +Y"FK2� &1&D0IZ�./!L��=?� &/+ª{�� .�Z?!L./&19�+ {�� .Q9&1!kK2� &���+D./� ; -:I D +Y"P+1.Q8�02�L�E� &19°K~&D!#"%0IZ¯+1.+D8�"�±702&'Z¯! {�{|�E�LKE8%+1!L.7"2�,5A. � .7� &D9�8�+YKy"%0>8%SA:/t8%M/+'"�{[�LK~8K2� .�70y��0I"%8n� 8%0IZ°�L"�{|!L&1&D! (3"2\?� .Q9zM/!L&1!L=�!L��t/M/+YKv{|:r.7K~8�+1!L. % (CM/+'KNMG+Y"�Z�0E±�./0IZG!L.��t/:/.7KNM/0IZ./02+1�LMk��!L:/��M/!�!kZ�� � � �[(CM/02��0 � +Y"F��ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L�Ft7�L"�"%+1./�x8�M/��!L:r�LM @�� .7Z-� +Y"��P.r0>+1�LMQ�7!L:r��M/!#!QZ! {C@���� .7Z�(FMr+'KNM?+'"���!L:/.7Z�0wZ�!L.?8�Mr+'"�./02+1�LMQ�7!L:/��Mr!#!kZ�K2� .y�70�02��8�02.7ZQ0IZ�8%!p@«�ms�M/0�t/��!Lt�0>��8 9P! {./!L��=?� &1+D8�9?K2� .���0P� &'"%!���0I"%8n� 8%0IZ��L"�{|!L&D&1!d(�"2\�8�M/0v+1����0IZQ:7K~+1�/&D0��d� ��+1028�9A� +'"C./!L��=?� &i+ª{�� .7Zy!L./&19+ª{�� .Q9��/+1�E� 8�+1!L.7� &i=?� ty! {³+1����0IZQ:7K~+1�/&D0��d� ��+1028�+10I"��� ��� (FM/+YK�MyM7�L"FR S�ZQ+1=�02.7"%+D!L.�� &Q±7��0>�E"�+'"C� .+Y"%!L=�!L��trM/+'"%=��

5A8V+'"�./!L8VM7� �EZ�8%!<"%020�8�M7� 8v��./!L��=?� &³K~:/���L0xM7�L"�8�!���0?"%=�!�!L8�M��?  "%4L028�K�Mz! {3� .G� .7� &19#8%+'K� ���L:/=�02.Q8�+Y"��L"�{|!L&1&D! (3"2���«028�@y��0��x./!L��=?� &/t7!L+1.Q8�! {^8�M/0VKE:r���L0�+D.�¨L:/0I"%8%+D!L.���*z0�K2� .�K�M/!�!#"%0��{|:/.7K~8%+D!L. � ZQ0~±7./0IZy+1.���.r0>+1�L��!L:/��M/!#!QZ ��! {�@i@ � ��@��:� RQ@�(FMr!#"%0PZQ02��+D�d� 8%+1�L0PZQ!#0I"�./!L8��d� .r+'"%M� .Q9#(CM/02��03!L. � � �#@�/L��s�Mk:�"2@k"%M/��+1./4�+D./� �v@Q+ {^./0IK~0I"�"�� ��9a@�(�0�M7�)�L0��PK~! �L0>��+1./� � � �#@�/ � �#��)� \�R�4�� ����4� /�! {3Z�0>�L��020,o/�H�C! (�@��#+Y�y8�Mr+'"VK~!d�L02��+1./�/@i(�0?K2� .�&1+ª{|8�SA:/t � �y8�!<�y��!L:/.7Z�0>.�ZM/!L&1!L=�!L��t/M/+YK�{|:r.7K~8�+1!L. �?!L. � � �#@�/L�Fs�MQ:7"��?02�#8%02.7Z/"�8%!���� .7Z?+18�ZQ0~±7./0I"F� .�+Y"%!L=�!L��t/M/+Y"%=�"! { � (C+D8%M¡��ZQ+Y"�K �

;�!L��0x�L02./02�E� &D9L@��y./!L��=?� &^�d� ��+10>8 9<+Y"�"%=�!#!L8%MG+1.°K~!kZQ+1=�02.7"%+D!L.zOQ�u5A. t7� ��8�+YK~:/&Y� �§�y./!L��=?� &"%:/�%{[�LK~0�M7�L"�!L./&19�+Y"%!L&Y� 8�0IZy"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�+10I"2�

 C.Q9u+1����0IZQ:7K~+D�r&D0V�d� ��+10>8 9*� �LZQ=�+18n"���:/./+Y¨L:/0v.r!L��=�� &1+1Hw� 8%+1!L. �� � �G\�8%M/0P.r!L��=�� &1+1Hw� 8%+1!L.=?� tu+Y"��r+D�E� 8%+D!L.�� &[@ �� +Y"F�x./!L��=?� &7+1����0IZQ:7K~+1�/&D0��d� ��+1028�9u� .7Zy� .Q9?�/+1�E� 8�+1!L.7� &�=?� t�� ��� {|��!L=��./!L��=?� &��d� ��+1028�9��}=P:�"%8F{[�LK~8%!L��8%M/��!L:/�LM �� � �G�P5A.�8�02��=?"�! {F� &D�L02�/�E� +YK��L0>!L=�028%��9 �� M7�L"� .<�)©?./0�K~! �L0>��+1./� ����� �� ��(CM/02��0�0I�LK�My! {^��+D.r�#" �� ��+Y"C8�Mr0�+1.Q8�02�L�E� &�K~&D!#"%:r��0�! {�� . � ��{|!L��"%!L=�0�)©?./0�K~! �L0>��+1./� ����� � ��! {'�G�

5A.,"%!L=�0<"%02.7"%0L@�8�M/0�.r!L��=�� &1+1Hw� 8%+1!L.°+Y"?�z�/:r+D&18�SA+1.°tr��!Lt702��8�9�A!L�?t/��!QK~0w"�"~�V! {�� .,� &1�L02�/�E� +YK�A!L��� .�� &D9�8�+YK)�m� � ��+D028�9L�Fs�Mk:�"2@Q+D.y=?� .k9�+D.7"%8�� .7K~0I"�(�0V(F+1&D&�"%+D=�t/&19?�L"�"%:/=�0�8%M7� 8F8%M/0P"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8�9+Y"�./!L��=?� &A�?s�M/0�./02��8P��� .7Zz0I"�"%02.Q8�+Y� &|��"%8�02tG+1.z��0w"%!L&1�#+1./��"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18%+D0I"�+Y"���K~!L.7"%8%��:7K~8%+D!L.z! {3���0I"%!L&D:r8�+1!L.?! {��v./!L��=?� &i"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18�9L�

s�!�ZQ0I"�KE��+1��0�����0I"%!L&1:/8�+1!L.V! {r��"%+1./�L:/&Y� �7t�!L+1.k8�@�6�!L.v�F.r!L��=�� &L"%:/�%{[�LK~0'�}(�0�"%8n� ��8�(F+18�MV��0I"%!L&D��+D./�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"�! {��Ptr&'� ./0VKE:r���L0a�^s�M7� 8�+Y"2@Q(�0�(C+D&1&it/��! �L038%M/0�{|!L&D&1! (F+1./�/\

U

Page 9: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

��� NgV � N 6 Y��nv�[�[�] c�l a?h�wga 7 � ��s*^WcAw �8v�{���lHcf^`_x�nv�yiw#{Awgaa?h�l�]#{$^��g^T_,R��?_�]ga�_�l#��l c$c�w#{$^`y��^T{${"lUm v��f^�y?l�� �� hXl}_ a?h�l${"lGl��g^Wc"aFc�w�c�l#ugvxl$_R��l(]#j'cf^Te�[~yil��y?]�����v�[.cJ]���l}{FR��� � �   ��� !"!"!���� � � � � � s

c"v�� haih�wga�a?h�l1l��n��lf[ka?^i]#_�w#yxc�l#aR]#j��   \�� � � s ^Wc'w v7_�^?]#_�� �|�~]#jncfeA]g]ga?h�{"wgai^?]#_�w#yn�"v7{���l c�w#_Rmw#yTy�a?h�lp��]#e�[k]#_Xl}_�aFc�]#j:a?h�lGc�l#a�� � � �(7v�1��� 7 ���� � �|��w#{"lGcfeA]&]gaih w#_Rm*a?h�lf�*eHl"l#a�[Rw#^T{#�'^Wc�la?{"w#_nc���l${ c�w#y �Awga1]#_�l1[�]#^T_.a�wga�eA] c"a �s�Mr0�K~!L=�t7!L./02.Q8�" � 7 �� ! {F8%M/0�+D.Q�L02�E"%0v+1=�� �L0�� � � � 7v��(FMr+'KNM�ZQ!L=�+1.7� 8�0 7 � ��0�K2� &D&10IZ<8%M/0

"%8%��+'K~8�8%�E� .7" {|!L��=?"^! {.7P��*z0�(F+1&1&�"%0>0V8%M7� 8�!L.7K~0�8%M/0§"%=�!�!L8�M/.r0w"�"�! { 7 ���� "�+'"��LKNM/+D02�L0IZi@Q8%M/02.u8%M/08%�E� .7"%�L02�E"�� &D+18�9�K~!L.7Z�+D8%+D!L.yK>� .���0V��0w�LKNM/0IZ�0I�L"%+D&19L�

�#:/trt7!#"%0^8%M7� 8 7+'"�ZQ0~±7./0IZV+D.P��./02+D�LMQ��!L:/��M/!#!QZ�! {78%M/0�!L��+1�L+D.v�Q9�� .x0w¨®:7� 8%+D!L.�%«� �����$� s ��� RQ�s�� 4L0�8�M/0��/&1! (FSA:/t�� � � ��sL���i028v:7"���0wK2� &1&^8%M7� 8���P+Y"V�y:/./+1!L.�! {F8 (�!<KE!Ltr+D0I"�! {(��s�(C+D8%MK~!#!L�EZQ+1.7� 8%0I"��! R��"Q��� .7Zy�! R� ����"�� ��(CM/+YK�Mu"�� 8%+'" {|9�8�M/0�{|!L&D&1!d(C+D.r�P��02&'� 8%+1!L.7"

� � � > � .�Z " � �� #" !s�Mr0�=?� tH� ��� ��sV+Y"�8%M/02.u�L+1�L02.¡�L"m{|!L&D&1!d(�"

� ��"Q���� � �"���"��'������� �$� s � � .7Z �! � ��" � ���� �!" � �� � " � �'������� �$� s ��!s�MQ:7"2@�(�0�=?�I9x8�M/+1./4?� ��!L:/8�8�Mr0�K~!#!L�EZQ+1.7� 8%0w"C�! �$"��m� .7Z¡� �i��" �Y�^!L.A��3�L"�0I¨L:7� &�8�!y����� > � s �$� s �� .7Z���� s�> ���#�$� s ��@���0I"%t70IK~8�+1�L02&D9L��s�M/0�02�QKE02t/8%+1!L.7� &^"%0>8 �|��! {�� � � ��sV+'"�ZQ0~±7./0IZy�Q9y0w¨®:7� 8%+D!L.7""���"��~� RQ�

s�Mr0�+D.Q�L02�E"%0�+1=?� �L0�! {«��KE:r���L0FZQ0~±7./0IZV�Q9v0w¨®:7� 8%+D!L.,%A�,+Y"^ZQ0~±7./0IZV�Q9�0I¨®:7� 8�+1!L.7"'%«�! #" �$"����%«�" �F�$ �%"�� �'�,RQ���#+1.7K~0�%«�6Rx��R��1�,RV+18^{|!L&1&D! (3"�8%M7� 8�0I�LK�M�! {�8�Mr0w"%0�0I¨L:�� 8�+1!L.7"�(F+1&1&/�70VZQ+D��+'"%+1�/&10��Q9"%!L=�0vt7! (�02��! {&"�� .7Z'" �|@i��0I"%t�0IKE8%+1�L0>&19L�Ps�Mr0v=�� ��+D=?� &)(¯"%:7K�M�8%M7� 8*"�+ � %«� �"���"Q��+Y"�K2� &D&10IZ<8%M/0=P:r&D8%+Dtr&D+YK~+D8�9y! {:%°� 8vRQ��¢�¨L:r+D�d� &102.Q8�&19L@,(¯+'"�8%M/0�ZQ02�L��020P! {�8%M/0?"%=�� &1&10w"%8�=�!L./!L=�+Y� &�� t/t�0I� ��+D./�+1.��¡{|!L��=�� &F"%02��+10I"V0>��t7� .7"%+1!L.°! {(% �[+1.°(CM7� 8%0>�L02��KE!�!L�EZQ+1.7� 8�0y"%9k"%8%0>= (�0¡KNM/!#!#"%0 ���G5A.°!L8%M/02�(�!L�EZ/"2@-(�+Y"F8%M/0V=�+D./+1=?� &i.Q:/=P��02�F"%:7K�My8�M�� 8�%�+'"C./!L.rS[H202��!P+1.�8%M/0§¨®:/!L8%+D02.Q8 ; 6 > B + � � @�(CM/02��0B²Z�0>.r!L8�0I"�8%M/0v=?� �#+1=?� &i+'Z�0w� &i! {^8%M/0V&D!QK>� &���+1./� ; 6 ! {^��02�L:/&'� ��{|:r.7K~8�+1!L.7"�� 8F8%M/0V!L��+D�L+1.����C!L8%08%M7� 8F+ª{^8�M/0�=P:/&18�+1t/&1+'K~+18�9.(�+Y"��V8%M/02.97 +'"C"%=�!�!L8�M��

s�Mr0�0I¨L:7� 8%+D!L.�" %i�! #" ��"Q��� %i�!" � �� � " � �'� R

ZQ0~±7./0�8�M/0,a ]ga�w#y�ai{"w#_ncfjF]#{$e �7�! {.7 (CM/+1&D0�8%M/0V0I¨L:7� 8%+D!L.�"

%«� �"���"��" + � %«�" �F�� �/" �Y�

" �0+ � R

1

Page 10: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

ZQ0~±7./0�8�M/0�c"a?{$^F�8aJai{"w#_~cfjF]#{$e 7J��! {.7P�m56.�!L8�M/02�C(�!L�EZ/"2@Q8�Mr0�c"a?{$^<�"aJai{"w#_�jF]#{$e +'"C8%M/0�&1+ª{|8�SA:/t�! {���L02./02��+'K�t7!L+1.Q8�! { 7P���«028F:7"�./!L8�0V8%M/0�{|!L&1&1!d(C+D./�v��02&Y� 8�+1!L.y! {³ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L�E"

�7 � 7:��F (��|�#!�i028V:7"V� &'"%!y./!L8%0�8%M7� 8V+ {�� +Y"v� .�+1����0IZQ:7K~+1�/&D0vK~:/���L0Pt��L"�"%+D./��8�M/��!L:r�LM�8%M/0x!L��+D�L+1.z(FM/+YK�MzZQ!#0I"./!L8FK~!L.Q8n� +1.�� .k9?K~!L=�t7!L.r0>.Q8�! { 7 8�M/02.y8�Mr0�8%M/0�=x:/&D8%+1t/&D+YK~+D8 9P! {�8%M/0V+D.Q8%02�E"%0wK~8%+D!L. 7 ���}� 8FRx+'"� 8�&10I�L"%8�(���LK~8�:�� &D&19L@�!L./0x=?�I9�ZQ0~±7./0�(¯�L"�8%M/0x=�+1./+1=P:/= � =�!L.r�u� &D&�t7!#"�"%+1�/&10P"%:7K�M�+1.Q8�02�E"%0IK~S8%+D!L.z.Q:/=P��02�E"~�n�V5A.7ZQ020IZi@�+18�+'"�02./!L:/�LM�8�!�K~!L.7"%+'Z�0>��8�M/0�"%8���+YK~8�8��E� .7" {|!L��=�� � ! {�� � .7Z 8�!�:�"%0t/��!L��0IK~8%+D!L.�{|!L��=P:/&Y�

� ��72��� � � �7 ��� � � �!(��|� F 7J�E� � (�� �����+� �|�2� ��(�!*z0�(F� .Q8�8�!�t/��! �L0�8�M�� 83�){|8%0>����.k:r=P��0>��! {��/&1!d(CS[:rt7"^8%M/0v"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18%+D0I"�! {³8%M/0v"%8���+YK~8�8��E� .�"%S

{|!L��= (F+1&1&��d� ./+Y"%M���s�Mk:�"�(�0�(F� .Q8?8�!¯t/��! �L0�8�M�� 8u8%M/0<=x:/&18�+1t/&1+'K~+18�9°! {v8%M/0�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8 9°(C+D&1&ZQ0IK~��0I�L"%0a��s�!�02.7"%:r��0�8�Mr+'"�(�0�+1.Q8���!QZQ:7K~0�� ./!L8%M/02�F+1.Q�d� ��+'� .Q82���#:/t/t�!#"%0�8%M7� 8F8%M/0V=P:/&18%+Dt/&1+YKE+18�9�! {%<� 8�Rx+'"�(�@Q8�M/02.<ZQ:r0�8�!�8%M/0V*�02+102�E"%8��E�L"�"�t/��02t7� �E� 8%+1!L.�8%M/02!L��02= (�0�=?�)9��L"�"%:r=�0�8�M7� 8

%A� � +� F �I� � s � � + � �� F !"!"!�F + � � s �(FMr0>��0�x�A��� s �^� ��0F{|:r.7K~8�+1!L.7"�! {k� s ! {�=P:/&18�+1t/&1+'K~+18�9 � q%�^ F�#� +1.�@�(�0�=��)9PK�M�� ./�L0F8%M/0�K~!#!L�EZQ+1.7� 8%0w""%028�8%+1./�����3\�� ����F� �>��� s � > (<"%!V8%M7� 8>@Q+1.�./02( K~!#!L�EZ�+D.7� 8%0I"��A(FMr+'KNM�(�0�K2� &1&������ �$� s ��� �#� +1.i�C%yK2� .��0�(C��+D8%8�02.��[=�!QZQ:/&1!�� .y+D.Q�L02��8�+1�/&10C{|:/.7K~8�+1!L.i��\

%*� � +� F s ��� s ��� + � s� F !"!"!�F + ��� s �$! C.7Z�(�0§"%028

\�� +D.�{�� =x:/&18�������� %������� \$qC� Ox�"!8!"!"��( "%:�K�M?8%M7� 8� +� F� s � � s � � + � s� F !"!8! F� + � � s ���L02./02�E� 8�0I"�+'ZQ0I� &i! {.7��� .7Z�+ {�� &1&�x� � "F� ��0�R�8�M/02.�(�0�"%028 ���L� �i028F:7"�./!L8%0�8%M7� 8 ���v� .7Z ) �

+! �" ��C!d( &D028�:7"�K~!L.7"%+'Z�0>���x�/&D! (FSA:/tA�� � ��sv�L"C+D8�(F�L"�ZQ0~±7./0IZy� �7! �L0L��*z0PK~!L.7"%+'Z�0>�C8�Mr0P"%0>8� � � 7 � � �$A � �"!"!8! � A , /L��5A.�!L�EZQ02�F8%!?t/��! �L0�!L:r�3ZQ0I"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+'"�� 8%+D!L.y"%8n� 8%02=�02.Q8F+18�+'"C02./!L:/�LM�8%!K~!L=�t/:/8%0�+D.Q�d� ��+Y� .Q8n")($# � � .7Z # � � 8^t�!L+D.Q8�"�! {i8�M/0�+1.Q8�02�E"%0IK~8�+1!L. � � �"7 � � .7Zv8%!PK�M/0IKN4�8%M7� 8��){|8�02�"%!L=�0�"%8%0>t�"�(�0�(C+D&1&i��0I�LK�M (*���L��56.?{[�LK~82@7!L.r0�K�M/0IKN4k"�8%M7� 82\��� �?+ª{ � ��8%M/02. . 4 �v� .7Z�{|!L�3� &1&Rq^(�0�M7�I�L0 ($# � 4 (�@��O��?+ª{ 4 ��8%M/02.8�Mr0>��0y+Y"P!L.r&D9¯!L./0yt7!L+1.Q8 A +D.8%M/0y+D.Q8%0>�E"%0IK~8%+D!L. �|���/7 ��(C+D8%M��0I"%t70IK~8%+D�L0

+1./�d� ��+Y� .k8�"�( # @ # ! { 7 �i� .�Z?02+18�M/02� ( # 4 (<!L� # � ��L�

T

Page 11: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

*z0§KNM/0IK�4�8%M/0§� ��! �L0�K~&'� +1= ��KE!L=�t7� ��0�(F+18�M�3 ; :/=x{|!L�EZ 9 �n���+1�E"%8�(�0V./!L8%0�8%M7� 8F8%M/0V0w¨®:/+1�d� &D02.7K~0

4 � +ª{³� .�Z?!L./&19?+ª{ K2� �EZr� 7J��� �|�2�'� �

K~!L=�0w"�{|��!L= 0>��t7� .7"%+1!L.! {§8%M/0'(�SA8%M Mr!L=�!L�L02./02!L:7"�8�02��= % + ! {�%�� 5A.�ZQ020wZ«@F8%M/+Y"�8�02��= +Y"?�=�!L./!L=�+'� &�� +� +ª{«� .7Zx!L./&19P+ª{ 4 �L� � .�8%M/0�!L8�M/02��M7� .7Zx8%M/0�+D.Q8%0>�E"%0IK~8%+D!L. � � �17 � +'"�ZQ0~±7.r0wZ��Q98%M/0 (�S[8%M�M/!L=�!L�L02./02:/!#"�8%0>��= ! {k%���s�MQ:7"2@#"%+1.7K~0F8%M/0�8%0>��= � s � + � �� +Y"�=�+Y"�"%+1./��+1.�!L:r��02�#t�02.7"%+1!L.�@8%M/0�+1.Q8�02�E"%0IK~8�+1!L. 7J� ���|�3K~!L.7"%+'"%8�"�! {�!L./0Vt7!L+1.Q8�+ {�� .7Z�!L.r&D9?+ª{C% + ��� +� �

5 {�8�M/0�+D.Q8%0>�E"%0IK~8%+D!L. 7J� � �|�3K~!L.k8�� +1.7"�=�!L��038%M7� .?!L.r0�t7!L+1.Q8�8%M/02.y8�M/0�=P:/&18�+1t/&1+'K~+18�9P! { 7:�3� 80I�LK�My! {^8�M/0Vt�!L+D.Q8�=P:�"%8���0§"%=?� &1&D02��8%M7� . (���s�Mr+'"�+'"��70IK2� :7"%0

�(� � �(��|� F 7J�>���2� ( F �|� ��7:�J� R

� .7Zy8%MQ:7"!� � �*7 � � (�� � .�8%M/0v!L8�Mr0>��M7� .�Zy8�M/0V+1.k8%02�E"%0IKE8%+1!L.�� � ��7 � +Y"C8�Mr0P"%:/= ! {�t�!L+D.Q8�"�+1.7:�����|��K~!L:/.Q8�0IZy(F+18%M<+1.k8%02�E"%0IKE8%+1!L.u.Q:/=x�702�3� 8�0I�LK�M�! {�8�M/02= (CM/+'KNM�+'"C./!L8�"%=?� &1&D02�F8%M/02.<8%M/0=P:r&D8%+Dtr&D+YK~+D8�9x! {.7:�3� 8C0w�LKNMu! {^8%M/02=��

�#!/@�8�!?K~!L./&1:7ZQ0�(�0�K~!L.7"%+'Z�0>��8%M/0�K2�L"%0�(CM/02.��|� � 7:�F+Y"�!L.r&D9�!L./0�t�!L+D.Q8(�$A�/|�2� � ��"Q��\ �"��,Rx/�� .7Zx8�Mr03=x:/&18�+1t/&1+'K~+18�9�! {-7J�m� 8�8%M/+Y"^t�!L+D.Q8^+Y"�(���J�:/8�8�Mr0>.�8%M/0�02�#t7� .7"%+1!L.�! {X%«�! #" �$"�� > " +� ��!L:/.7Z�8�M/+Y"�t�!L+1.k8�+Y"

+ F s �"��" s + � s F !"!"!�F + �!"Q�

" +(FMr0>��0L@Q�Q9�!L:/�3�L"�"%:r=�tr8�+1!L.�!L. ( # (�0�M7�)�L0Go5 � �� �A�"�� > " � � � q%���C!d( (�0�"%020�8�M�� 8

#��,=�+D.�" o5 � �� �A�"�� > " � �q &A� ��7!:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y =�M/0IK�4�8�M7� 8C8�Mr0�8��E� .�"%�L0>�E"�� &1+18�9�K~!L.7ZQ+18%+D!L.�K2� .u��0�!L�r8n� +1./0IZu"%+1=�+D&Y� ��&19a�

�i028?:�"P+1&1&D:7"%8%�E� 8%0�8�M/+Y"�t/��!QK~0w"�"x�Q9¯��0w"%!L&1�#+1./�z8%M/0<"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18�9 � � �L+1�L02.,�Q9°8%M/0�0I¨L:�� 8�+1!L.@ F A�C4� RQ��s�M/02.z8%M/0�"%8%��+'K~8�8%�E� .7" {|!L��= ! {F8�Mr+'"�K~:/���L0x+'"�� &D��0I�LZQ9<"%=�!#!L8%M<�r:/8�=�020>8%+1./�u8%M/002�kK~02t/8%+D!L.7� &F"%028V! {38%M/0?�/&1! (FSA:/tG� 8�!L.r0?t7!L+1.Q8§� 8v=x:/&18�+1t/&1+'K~+18�9 ¤ �<;�!L��0�t/��0IK~+Y"%0>&19L@�8%M/0u"%8%��+YKE88%�E� .7" {|!L��= ! {v8�M/0<K~:/���L0y(F+1&1&3M��I�L0y0I¨L:7� 8%+D!L. " � F �@C � R¯�A+D. 8�M/0<K~!�!L�EZQ+D.�� 8�0I"x+D.Q8%��!kZQ:�KE0IZ� ��!d�L0 ��(FM/+1&10�8%M/0V0>�QK~0>tr8�+1!L.7� &^K~:/���L0�(C+D&1&���0�"��X��RQ�3s�Mk:�"�(�0v(F+1&1&�M7�)�L0�8%!?t�02�%{|!L��= �/&1!d(CS[:rt8%M/��020P8%+D=�0I"�8%!y0>.�"%:/��0v8�Mr0�8%�E� .7"%�L02�E"�� &1+D8�9yKE!L.�ZQ+D8%+1!L.<´ � 8�0I�LK�MG"%8%02t�(�0x��0IZQ:7K~0v8�Mr0�K~!L.Q8��LKE8

�IR

Page 12: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

��+1�L:/��0 ¤ �

�A=P:/&18�+1t/&1+'K~+18�9?� 8F8%M/0Vt7!L+1.Q8�! {³+1.Q8�02�E"%0IK~8�+1!L.i���k9��L�C�#020V8�M/0v��+1�L:/��0 ¤ �/�Q9u� �/:�"%0�! {^./!L8n� 8%+1!L.u(�0ZQ02./!L8%0§�xK~:/���L0�� .7Z�+D8�"F"%8%��+YKE8C8��E� .�" {|!L��= �Q9�8%M/0§"�� =�0�.7� =�0L�

:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y =�!L.�"%+'ZQ02��8%M/0V��0w"%!L&1:/8%+D!L.y! {^!L8�Mr0>��"%+D=�t/&10�t/&Y� ./0§K~:/���L0V"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�+10I"2@#�L"�ZQ0~±7./0IZ�+1.�i0IK~8%:/��0��L��¢C+D.Q82\�8�M/0vK2�L"%0I" �   � .�Z��   (C+D&1&�ZQ02t702.7Z�!L.y8�M/0Vt7� ��+18�9�! {����

s�Mr0§� ��!d�L0VZQ0I"�KE��+1��0wZ�t/��!QKE0I"�"�! {���0I"%!L&D��+D./��"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18�9x! {��xt/&Y� ./0vK~:/���L0�&10w�LZr"F"%:/t/��+Y"%+1./�L&D98%!P�v��0I"%!L&D:r8�+1!L.P! {^�V./!L��=?� &�"%:r�%{[�LKE0�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8 9a��s�M/0�+YZQ0I�V+'"�8%!v��02&'� 8%0�8�M/0�"%:/�%{[�LK~0�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8�9(F+18%M�"%!L=�0FK~! �L0>��+1./��� .7Z�8�M/0C��0I"%!L&D:/8%+1!L.v! {�8%M/03"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+18�9�(F+18%M�����0w"%!L&1:/8%+D!L.v! {����/�E� .�K�Mv&1!kK~:7"! {^8�Mr0§K~! �L0>��+1./�/���� =�0>&19L@�(�0§K2� .�±�.7Z��x±7./+18%0�=?� t�! {m"%!L=�0V./02+D�LMQ��!L:/��M/!#!QZ-� ! {m��"%+D./�L:r&'� �Ct7!L+1.Q8 @ ! {m�"%:/�%{[�LK~0 � !L.Q8%!?"%!L=�0V./02+1�LMk��!L:/��M/!�!kZ�� ! {mR,) ��s®� �«0>8 � ������0v8�M/0V�/�E� .7KNMu&1!kK~:7"C! {�8%M/0=?� t � � �P@ � +'"V8%M/02.°�y:/./+1!L.z! {3+1����0IZQ:7K~+D�r&D0vt/&Y� ./0�KE:r���L0w"2��*z0?=?�I9z�L"�"%:/=�0v8�M7� 8 � +'""%+1./�L:/&Y� ��!L./&19<� 8PRQ�?B3"%+1./��8%M/0�t/��!kK~0I"�"VZQ0I"�KE��+1��0wZ�� �7! �L0�(�0?K>� .z��0I"%!L&1�L0�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"�! {����s�M�� 8F+Y"2@k�){|8%02����"%0I¨L:r0>.�KE0�! {³�r&D! (FSA:/t7"

� � ���   ��� !8!"!��~��� � �

8%M/0�+D.Q�L02�E"%0^+1=?� �L0�! { ��@LK2� &1&#+18 ���@®(F+1&D&�M7�I�L0�"%=�!#!L8%MPK~!L=�t�!L./02.Q8n"�� .7ZV8%M/029�(C+D&1&#=�02028�8%�E� .7"%�L02��S"�� &19a��C!d( (�0�K~!L.7"%+YZQ02��8%M/0�±7��02�Ft/��!QZQ:7K~89������ � � .�Z�+D8�"C./!L��=?� &D+1HI� 8�+1!L.�(FM/+YK�M�(�0�ZQ02./!L8%0��Q9� �|��s�M/02.?8%M/0�=?� t-� � � ��+'"��/+D�E� 8%+1!L.7� &i�A+D8�+Y"�� .u+Y"%!L=�!L��t/M/+Y"%= !L:r8n"%+YZQ0�! {C@���(FM/+1&1038%M/0�=?� t� � � � � +Y"F�§±7./+18�0�=�� t��/�E� .7K�Mr0wZ�� &1!L./�v8%M/0§K~:/���L0 �����s�M/02��0~{|!L��0�8%M/0�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"�! {� � � ��0! {³"%t�0IK~+'� &�8�9#t�0L����� =�02&D9L@�� �i�LZQ=�+18n"�&D!QK2� &D&19?�V±7./+18%03=?� t?!L.Q8%!P�v:/.r+D8�ZQ+Y"�KF(CM/+YK�M?+Y"��/�E� .7KNM/0IZ� &1!L./���xZQ+D��+'"%!L��"%:/t/t�!L��8�0IZ�!L.y8%M/0§"%028 �#��� � s � Rx/L�

�L�

Page 13: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

B�"%+D.r��8%!Lt�!L&D!L�L+YK2� &³� ���L:r=�02.Q8�"��A(FM/+YK�M�(C+D&1&���0v+D.Q8%��!kZQ:�KE0IZy+1.�8�Mr0�"%:/�7"%0I¨®:/02.k8�&10IK~8�:/��0 ��!L./0=?�I9vtr��!d�L0C8�M7� 8�8%M/0�&1!kK2� &/{|:r.7Z/� =�02.k8�� &Q�L��!L:/t�! {�"%:7K�M?�v"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8 9�+Y"�±7./+18�0�� .7Z�K~9kK~&1+'K ���6 C./S!L8%M/02�F� t/t/��!#�LK�M�K~!L=�0I"�{|��!L= &D+ª{|8�+1./�v:/t�8�M/0V�LKE8%+1!L.?! {'��� �,����:/t?8%! � �|�ª�§s�M/0I"%0�"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�+10I"(F+1&1&7��0�ZQ0I"�K~��+D��0IZx&'� 8%02����ZQ:/��+1./��8%M/0�Z�+'"�K~:7"�"%+1!L.P! {�8�!L��+YK�"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�+10I"~�n���%�#020�� &'"%!H3@��� :�{|0>� 9 ���^5A.t7� ��8%+'K~:/&Y� ��8%M/02+D�C��0w"%!L&1:/8%+D!L.�+'"�4#./! (F.��� �E� .k8%0IZ�8%M/+'"2@Q(�0VM7�)�L0�t/��!d�L0IZ

��� NgV � N 6 Y�Z:_&�,_�]#{$eAw#ync"v7{$jFwg��l �i^Wc�]#yiwga l#m��:cf^T_x�nv7y?w#{$^<aT�?�F�*�$@��:wgm7e,^Fa<cJw({"l c�]#yFv�a?^i]#_ )�\���� �� ��� ]#{"l"] ��l${���w#eA]#_x�H{"l c�]#yFv�ai^?]#_nc ]#jC�F� �$@���a?h�l${"l�l��&^dc"aFc�w#yWc�]Aw�� ��]&]�mA{"l c�]#y<v�a?^?]#_��) �'h�^F��heAl"w#_nc*a?h�wgaa?h�l�l��n��lf[ka?^i]#_Xw#y�y?]��"vgc ]#jpa?h�lHeAw"[ ) ��]#_ncf^Wc"a<c ]#jGcfeA]g]ga?h �"v7{���l c*�'h ^<� h eAl"lUaa?{"w#_nc���l${ c�w#y ���a���]�wgat]#_�l1[�]#^`_�a�wga'eA] c"a �s�Mr+'"V+Y"P�zO S�ZQ+1=�02.7"%+1!L.7� &^�L02�E"%+1!L.G! {38%M/0�K~0>&102�/�E� 8%0wZ ��0I"%:/&18v! {|¢C+1��!L.7� 4d� (FM/!�t/��!d�L0IZz8%M/0

02�#+Y"%8�02.7K~0V! {��v��0I"%!L&D:r8�+1!L.?! {�"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18%+D0I"³{|!L���xK~!L=�tr&D02���d� ��+10>8 9?! {�� ���/+D8%�E� ��9�Z�+D=�02.7"%+1!L.��

 C./!L8%M/02���L02�E"%+1!L.! {�8%M/0���0I"%:/&D8x! {G¢F+1��!L.7� 4d�Wt/��!d��+'Z�0w"���0I"%!L&D:/8%+1!L.°! {§"%:r�k� � ��+D028%+D0I"2�,£C!L:/�LM/&19"%t�0w� 4�+D.r�/@F(�0zK>� . ��0I"%!L&1�L0�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"x! {P�G./!L.rS6"%=�!�!L8�M "%:/�Q�d� ��+D028�9¯! {P�°"%=�!#!L8%M �d� ��+10>8 9�/&1!d(C+D.r��:rt,8%M/0<&Y� 8�8%02�u!L.r0�� &1!L./�°"%=�!#!L8%M K~02.Q8�02�E"x´ (�0<ZQ+YZ,�¯"%+D=�+1&'� ��t/��!QKE0I"�"�{|!L�yt/&'� .r0K~:/���L0I"2��5A.�t7� ��8%+'K~:/&Y� �F(�0vK2� .y±7.7Zy��0I"%!L&D:r8�+1!L.7"�! { � � � ���}"%:/�%{[�LK~0v"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18%+D0I"�(FMr+'KNMu(�0M7�)�L0v+D.Q8%��!kZQ:�KE0IZ +D.�8�M/0�t/��02��+D!L:7"C&10IKE8%:/��0L�Ps�M/+'"�8�+1=�0P8%M/0P�/&1! (FSA:/t�! {�8�M/0�!L��+1�L+D.�! {�� Cx(C+D8%MK~!#!L�EZQ+1.7� 8%0I"C� @�� A �}����(F+1&D&i��0�K~!d�L02��0IZ��Q9P8%M/��020�K~!Lt/+10w"�! {�� C @Q&10>8�:�"�K>� &1&i8%M/02= � D @ � # � .7Z � % @(F+18%M¡K~!#!L�EZ�+D.7� 8%0I"

��@�� A > @��$� > @��$� � @ > A � A��$� > AQ�$� � @ > �x� A > �x�$���}���0I"%t70IK~8%+D�L02&19a��s�M/0�=?� t7"�! { � � "�8�!A��C�� .7Z�8%M/0���02&Y� 8�+1!L.7"���0>8 (�0>02.?8%M/02= � ��0�ZQ0~±7./0IZ�.�� 8�:/�E� &19L@8%M7� 8�+Y"2@��k9x8�Mr0302=x�70IZ/ZQ+1./��! {���02�L:/&Y� ��{|:/.7K~8�+1!L.7"�!L.�0w�LKNM?! {�8%M/05� � "�+D.Q8%!v8�Mr03��+1./�V! {i{|:/.7K~8%+D!L.7"��02�L:/&Y� ��!L.*� � �� � �,� � (FM/+YK�M�+Y"J�435@��$@�� � � A�� A�� � �$�x�$�� � 9 ��K~!L=�t�� ��03(C+D8%M?8%M/0�ZQ+Y"�K~:7"�"%+1!L.P! {8%!L��+'K�� � ��+D028%+D0I"~���ms�M/0V0>�QK~0>tr8�+1!L.7� &�ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L�F! {�8�M/0V�/&1!d(CSA:/t?!L.y0w�LKNMu! {^8%M/0v"%0>8�" ��D#@ � #§� .�Z-� %+Y"FZQ0~±7./0IZ��Q9�8%M/0V0I¨L:7� 8%+D!L.*@ � RQ@DA�� Rx� .7ZH�0� RQ@Q��0I"%t�0wK~8%+D�L02&19L�

�i028C:7"FZQ+Y"�K~:7"�"�8%M/0§K2�L"%0�! {�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8 9 �����L+1�L0>.y�Q9�8�M/0V0I¨L:7� 8%+1!L.

@ F A C F � s �,Rx!s�Mr0¡"%8%��+'K~8v8%�E� .7" {|!L��= ! {�8�M/+Y"�ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L�v8�!z8%M/0u�r&D! (FSA:/tG! {�� C (F+1&D&�+1.Q8�02�E"%0IK~8v8�M/0y02�kK~02t/8%+D!L.7� &ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L�3� &1!L./���¡�6ZQ!L:r�/&D0 ��&D+1./0�� .7Zy(C+D&1&�M��I�L0��x:/.r+'¨®:/0§"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+18�9�� 8�8%M/0�!L��+1�L+1.u! { � D �F; !L��0t/��0IK~+'"%02&19L@Q8�M/0�./02(�0I¨L:7� 8%+D!L.�� 8 � D +'"

@�s � F @.� A�C� F �7s� �,R (CM/02��0G@~��� @��9A���� A > @�������� � > @�!s�Mr0�02�kK~02t/8�+1!L.7� &�KE:r���L0�! {^8�M/+Y"��r&D! (FSA:/t�+Y"�8%M/0�&1+1./0G@~��� ���J�,RQ�

�IO

Page 14: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

*z0���02t70I� 8^8%M/0F�r&D! (FSA:/tVt/��!kK~0IZQ:/��0C�A(F+18�M�./02(KE!�!L�EZQ+1.7� 8�0I""¡ª��8�!��L0>8���:/.r+'¨®:/0m"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+18�9�! {8%M/0§"%8%��+YKE8C8��E� .�" {|!L��= � 8C8�Mr0�!L��+1�L+D.y! { � s# �A8%M/0§"%:r�/S�� .7Zy"%:/t�0>�E"�K~��+1t/8�"�ZQ+'"%8%+1./�L:/+Y"%M�"%:r�7"%0I¨L:/02.Q8�/&1!d(CSA:/t7"~����; !L��0>! �L02�I@k� 8C8�Mr+'"�t7!L+1.Q8�8�M/02��0�(C+D&1&�=�02028�8�Mr0�8�(�!x./02(�02�kK~02t/8%+D!L.7� &i&1+1./0I"�8%!L�L0>8%M/02�(F+18%Mu8%M/0v"%8���+YK~8�8��E� .7" {|!L��=}! {�8�M/0V02�kK~02t/8%+D!L.7� &i&1+1./0�! {^8�Mr0�t/��02�#+1!L:7"��r&D! (FSA:/t���s�M/0V0I¨L:7� 8%+D!L.y! {8%M/0§Z�+D��+'"%!L��+1.u.r0>( KE!�!L�EZQ+1.7� 8�0I"�+1.�� s# +Y"F�L"�{|!L&1&1!d(�"2\

@ ss F @ s A ss F � ss � R

"%!P8%M7� 8C8�M/0V8�(�!x0>�QK~0>tr8�+1!L.7� &i&1+D./0I"�+D. � # � ��0��L+1�L0>.y�Q9�0w¨®:7� 8%+D!L.7"2\

A s � R0� @ s F qF� s � .7Z A s � R � @ s ��qF� s(FMr+D&10�8%M/0§"%8%��+YKE8�8%�E� .7" {|!L��=}! {^8�Mr0�02�kK~02t/8%+D!L.�� &i&D+1./0�! {^8%M/0�tr��0>��+D!L:�"��/&D! (FSA:/t�+'"J@ s � � s � RQ�

 C�#� +D.�@/(�0V�/&D! (FSA:/t�8�M/0 � s# � 8�8�Mr0�!L��+1�L+D.�� .7Z��L"C8%M/0���0I"%:/&18F(�0v�LZ/Z�8�(�!�&D+1./0I"C=�0>028%+D.r��� 88%M/0�!L��+1�L+1.?! {^8�M/0 � C# ��s�M/0V./02( 0I¨L:7� 8%+D!L.�!L. � C# +Y"

@ sC F @ C A C F � sC � Rx!s�MQ:7"³(�03� ��0F&10~{|8�(C+D8%Mu�V¨L:7�LZ���+'K�K~!L./0�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8�9�(FM/+YK�M�(F+1&1&/�70C��0I"%!L&D�L0IZv+1.�8�Mr03&Y�L"%8^�/&1! (FSA:/t��s�Mr0�+1.7K~+'Z�0>.�KE0�! {³02�QKE02t/8%+1!L.7� &�K~:/���L0I"F� 8C0I�LK�My! {�8�Mr0§"%8%02t7"�+Y"Ct/��0I"%0>.Q8%0IZ?� 83��+1�L:/��0��/��s�M/0�{[� 8t�!L+D.Q8�+Y"�8%M/0§"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��t�!L+D.Q8�9L028F8%!���0w"%!L&1�L0L�

��+1�L:/��0��/�

B�"%:7� &1&D9L@�8%M/0x±7.7� &���0w"%:r&D8V+[� 0L��8%M/0?+1.7K~+YZQ02.7K~0�! {3K~:/���L0I"V+1.°��=�+1./+1=�� &��A+[� 0L��./!L8vKE!L.Q8�� +D.r+D./��$��� �AS�KE:r���L0w"~����0I"%!L&D:/8%+1!L.�! { � � � � ��"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+10w"�+Y"�t/��0I"%02.k8%0IZ�+1.P�C{|!L��= ! {/8�M/0FZ�:7� &kZQ+Y� �L�E� =+1.�(FM/+YK�M�t�!L+D.Q8�"C��0>tr��0w"%02.Q8FK~:/���L0I"�� .7Zy&D+1./0v"%02�L=�02.Q8�"F��02t/��0I"%02.Q8�+D.�KE+YZQ02.7K~0L�3s�M7� 8�+'"2@�� .Q9u8�(�!�L02��8�+YK~0I"�! {^8�Mr0��L�E� t/M�� ��0���!L+1.Q8��k9y�v&1+D./0v"%02�L=�0>.Q8�+ {�� .7Z�!L./&19?+ª{³8%M/0V��0I"%t70IK~8�+1�L0�K~:/���L0I"�=�02028>�

� ¤

Page 15: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

��� 8%02��(�0�(C+D&1&7"%020�8%M7� 8^8%M/03ZQ+Y� �L�E� = ZQ0I"�KE��+1��0w"���¨®:7�LZQ�E� 8%+'K�{|!L��= ! {i+D.Q8%02�E"%0wK~8%+D!L.v! {i02�kK~02t/8%+D!L.7� &K~:/���L0I"2�:9;RN<���7Q��#N YvB3"%0V8%M/0§� ��! �L0�ZQ0I"�K~��+D��0IZ�t/��!kK~0IZQ:/��0�8�!�t/��! �L0�8�M/0�{|!L&1&D! (F+1./�/\��N56 6 ��Y��1wg� h*]#j1aih�l � ��� ��� cf^T_x�nv7y?w#{$^<a?^?l c�m l c"�f{$^!xl#m�^T_���l#�"a v7{"l�� wgm�ep^FaFc�wG{"l c�]#yFv�a?^i]#_�'^Fa?hHa?h�l'^`_ � ^Fmxl$_R��l1m7^iw"�g{"w#e �'^Faih,� ��l${#ai^F��l ct�'h�^F��h�^Wc�w:{"l c [kl#�"ai^ ��l � � ��� ���J�x_g^T_Hm7^?w"�g{"w#emxl c"�f{$^ l#m,wga��C^ �nv7{"l� �

��+1�L:/��0��Q�

�2�

Page 16: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

�§���«�7���/���:������ v���������²���<����3�������^�����������.��C!d((�0�(C+D&1&7ZQ+Y"�K~:7"�"�8�!Lt�!L&1!L�L9v! {�8%M/03"%+1./�L:/&Y� �^"%028>����+D�E"%82@ &D028^:�"�02�#t/&Y� +D.?� .�� t/t/��!#�LK�Mv8%!v"%8�:7Z�9��"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18�9x:7"%+D.r��"%!L=�0�� =P�r+D02.Q8m"%t��LKE0L� �i028�:7"CKE!L.�"%+'ZQ02��� .u+Y"%!L&'� 8%0IZ�"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18�9�� 8�@�6V! {��MQ9#t�02�E"%:/�%{[�LK~0:�����  �� � �L+1�L02.?�Q9?� .u� &D�L02�/�E� +YK��A!L�FMr!L&D!L=�!L��t/M/+YK)��{|:/.7K~8�+1!L.H%���s�M/+Y"�K2�L"%0�(F�L"ZQ+Y"�K~:7"�"%0IZ?K~&'�L"�"%+YK2� &D&19P�Q9L3 ;�+1&D.r!L� 9 � .7Zy� &'"%!x!L8�M/02�E"2�

s�Mr0�+YZQ0I�y+Y"v8%!�K~!L.7"%+YZQ02�§��"%=?� &1&m"%t/Mr0>��0 ����! {3�E�LZQ+1:7" �§K~02.Q8�02��0IZG� 8�@�6y� .7Zz8%!<K~!L.7"%+'Z�0>�8%M/0�+1.Q8�02�E"%0IK~8�+1!L.A����\ � � � ������s�M/0§"%028J����+Y"���KE!L=�t7�LK~887 �A��0I� &|��=?� ./+ª{|!L&'Z�! {�Z�+D=�02.7"%+1!L.O7����+D.y8%M/0§"%trM/02��0����^! {�ZQ+D=�02.7"%+1!L.uO7� F,�L��5683K2� .u��0Vt/��!d�L0IZ�8%M7� 8�{|!L�3"%:Q©uK~+D02.Q8%&D9�"%=�� &1& �8%M/0�=?� ./+ª{|!L&'Z0����� .7Z�8%M/0�+1.7K~&D:7"%+1!L.,����� ���^ZQ!#0I"�./!L8�ZQ02t702.7Z�!L.?8�Mr03�E�LZ�+D:7" �F���LK~8�:�� &D&19L@#+1.u�./02+1�LMk��!L:/��M/!�!kZ�! {.@�6�8�M/0�=?� ./+ª{|!L&YZ(� +Y"�M/!L=�02!L=�!L��t/M/+YK�8�!�8%M/0���0I� &/K~!L./0�! �L02���������^;�!L��02!d�L02�I@8%M/02��0�+'"�� � ^Ty`_�]#{ � �{"wgai^?]#_

�u\5��� � ����� � � "%:7K�M�8�M7� 8 �i� ����� %i����� > � %«� ��� � !s�Mr0�=?� +1.v8�M/02!L��02= ! {C3 ; +D&1./!L� 9 �L"�"%02��8�"i8%M7� 8�0w�LKNMV±7��0>��! { �vM7�L"���Mr!L=�!L8%!LtQ9�8�9#t�0F! {7����!L:7¨L:r0>8! {���S�"%t/M/02��0I"��  �� !"!8! � �   (F+18%M�8�M/0v.Q:/=x�702��! {m"%trM/02��0w"���02+D.r�?0I¨L:7� &�8�!?8%M/0 � ^Ty`_X]#{:_�v7e l${ZQ0~±7./0IZ�+D.-�i0IK~8%:/��0P�L�

*z0�+D&1&D:�"%8��E� 8%0F8%M/+Y"�� t/t/��!#�LK�Mx+D.�8�M/0�"%+1=�t/&D0I"%8^t�!#"�"%+1�/&D0FK2�L"%0�! {³�Vtr&'� ./0�K~:/���L0:������s®�^s�M/0"%028�����+Y"^8%M/02.u��:/./+1!L.P! {�ZQ+Y" ��!L+D.Q8^K~+D�EK~&10I"^02=P��0IZ/ZQ0IZ��A4#.r!L8�8%0IZ?� .7Zx&D+1./4L0IZ���+1.�� ¤ S�ZQ+1=�02.7"%+D!L.�� &"%t/M/02��0L� s�M/0�.Q:/=P��02��! {�K~!L=�t�!L./02.k8�"x! { ���PK~!L+D.�KE+YZQ0I"�(F+18�M 8%M/0<.Q:/=x�702��! {§&10I�I�L0I"�! {§8%M/0./!L��=?� &1+DHI� 8%+D!L.z! {�� � 8�@�6 ���r!L�V0>�Q� =�t/&D0L\�"%:/t/t�!#"%0P8%M7� 8�� M��L"V8�(�!��/�E� .7KNM/0I"�(CM/+'KNMG=�020>88%�E� .7"%�L02�E"�� &D9�� 8�@�6L��s�M/02.y8�Mr0�8�(�!?K~+D�EK~&10w"�&1+1./4u�L"�tr+'K~8%:/��0IZ��702&1!d(V�

��+1�L:/��0 ¦ �

s�!���:7"%8%+ {|9�8%M/+'"�&1028�:7"�+1=�� �L+1./0C8�M/0�t/��!L��0IK~8�+1!L.�! {�8%M/0�"%t/M/02��0 � C���� �2��s�!L.Q8�!�� C3{|��!L=8%M/0�t�!L+1.k8���Rx�"��� � � s * � �� � ���#�$� s � �� ���x������) � ���

(FM/02��0v���x�����1� 1���� >�� I��� s F,� �$� �&B���� s � >�� I� � s F�� � 2s�Mr0>.x+D.�"%+'ZQ0 � C �2��s � � (�0�M��I�L0F��&1+1./0 7J�^�L+D�L02.P�Q9V0I¨L:7� 8%+D!L.�0�,R�(CM/+'KNMv+'"��L"�"%!kK~+'� 8%0IZ

8%!�8%M/0V+D.Q8%02�E"%0wK~8%+D!L.y! {^8�Mr0vt/&'� .r0��#����� Rx/V(F+18�M ��CI�Cs�M/0�+1.Q8�02�E"%0IK~8�+1!L. 7 s � �#� s � Rx/ � � C�+'"8%M/02.u8%M/0vKE+1�EK~&D0�� � �x������\ � ����� �7�����,Rx/L��s�Mr+'"�0>��t/&Y� +D.7"�8%M/0V&D+1./4d� �L0vZQ0I"�K~��+D��0IZ?� ��!d�L0L�

�I�

Page 17: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

��+1�L:/��0VU#�

;�!L��02! �L02�I@L+D.A��� � (�03M��I�L0�8�(�!P­ 8%�E� .7"%�L02�E"�� &'­3{[� =�+1&1+D0I"�! {³K~+D�EK~&10I"��L"�"%!QKE+Y� 8%0wZ�8�!�±7�#+1./�v! {0I�LK�My! {�KE!�!L�EZQ+1.7� 8�0I"2\'��������(FM/02��0�R 4�� � � 4RQ@��L"�+1.7ZQ+YK>� 8%0IZ?!L.���+1�L:/��0VU#�

s�Mr0w"%0�8�(�!v{[� =�+1&D+10I"��L+1�L0�8�(�!�"%8%��:7K~8%:/��0�! {³� � � ±7�/��0��/:/.7ZQ&10�!L.u8%M/0v"%028

�� C ��� C � � � ��� �$� s �m\,��� � s �,Rx/(� � C � �(7:� � 7 s �!L.Q8�!y8%M/0�t/:/.7KNM/0IZ�ZQ+'"�K � �p�b�$�,) �²\R�4 � � � 4}�7/L��C!L8%0�8%M7� 8v� .Q9y±7�702�V! {m0I�LKNM�! {F8%M/0±7�/�E� 8%+1!L.7"^+Y"��P"%0IK~8%+D!L.?! {�8�Mr0�!L8�Mr0>��!L.r03! �L02�F"%!L=�03&1!#!Lt��L0>.r0>�E� 8%+1./�3)~�I� � �I���[8%M/+Y"���02=?� ��4P(C+D&1&��0?:7"%0IZ�&'� 8%02�2�n�<; !L��02!d�L02�I@ �� CxM7�L"V8%M/0?M/!L=�!L8%!LtQ9�8�9#t�0?! {38%M/0?8%!L��:7" � � �/� � �<s�M/+'"V&Y� 8%8�02���02=?� ��4P=?� 4L0I"�+18F0I�L"%9?8%!�ZQ!�8%M/0�{|!L&1&D! (F+1./�/\:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y?5 {1� +Y"���t/&'� +1.�K~:/���L0PK~:7"%t��L+D�L02.��k9y8%M/0P0I¨L:�� 8�+1!L.L�7s� � � Cs 8%M/02.z8�Mr0P�L"�"%!kK~+'� 8%0IZ������� C�+'"C��K~+1�EK~&D01� � 4�./!L8�8%0IZ��L"C!L.¡��+1�L:/��0 1 �

��+1�L:/��0 1 �

¢C+D.Q82\�K~!L.7"%+YZQ02��8�Mr0�t7� �E� =�028%��+DHI� 8%+D!L.

� * � � � � �� � � C � � s ��)9� C � � s !� ¦

Page 18: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

*z0vM7�)�L0�=�0>��02&19?=�02.k8%+1!L./0IZ?8%M/0V��0w"%:r&D8�"�!L.�MQ9#t�02�E"%:/�%{[�LK~0I"F� .7Z�{|��!L= .r!d( !L.�(�0vKE!L.�KE02.Q8%�E� 8�0!L.�; :/=x{|!L�EZ � "�� t/t/��!#�LK�My8%!u"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18%+D0I"�! {�"%:/�%{[�LK~0w"2��s�Mr+'"�� t/t/��!#�LKNMu+Y"�=�!L��0V+D.Q8%0>��.�� &[@r8�M7� 8+Y"2@Q+D8�ZQ!#0I"�.r!L83ZQ02t�0>.�Z?!L.�� .u02=x�70IZ/ZQ+1./�v! {^8%M/0�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8�9L�

s�Mr03"%028�SA:/tx+'"�./! (,�L"�{|!L&1&1!d(�"2\�&1028�@�6|)A� �70��V./!L��=?� &k"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8�9V! {��V"%:/�%{[�LK~0��A8�MQ:7"'@ 6�+'"� .�+'"%!L&Y� 8%0wZx"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18�9r�n���«028�:7"��L"�"%:/=�0�8�M7� 8���� ��� +Y"^���L!�!kZx��0I"%!L&D:r8�+1!L.P! {i8�Mr03"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8�9� 8(@ 6 �C*z0v��0wK2� &1&�8%M7� 82\3� &1&�02�kK~02t/8%+D!L.�� &³Z�+D��+'"%!L�E" � � � ��0P"%=�!#!L8%M<� .7Zy0I�LK�M�8�(�!�! {�8%M/02= =�020>88%�E� .7"%�L02�E"�� &D9P� 8�� 8�=�!#"%8�!L.r0�t7!L+1.Q8 �~� �d��s�M/0�0>�QK~0>tr8�+1!L.7� &�±7��02�F! {�8%M/0���0I"%!L&1:/8%+D!L.uK~!L.7"%+Y"%8�"�! {³�:/./+1!L.�! {mK~:/���L0I" � �|�[� �C!d( ;�:/=x{|!L�EZ�K~!L.7"%8%��:7K~8n"��*afv#xv�yiw#{�_�l$^��gh ]gv7{$h�]&]�mx! { � �|��+D. ���|�¢C+'"VK~!L.7"%8%��:7K~8�+1!L.�� t/tr&D+10I"���0I� & 7 wgm�ep^Wc$cf^!�yil�j�v7_R�"a?^i]#_~c�(FM/+YK�M�@i��!L:/�LM/&19¡"%t�0I� 4#+1./�/@�=�0w�L"%:r��08%M/0¡Z�+'"%8�� .7K~0u+1. ����{|��!L= � �(��� .7Z� ��0?!L�/8�� +D.r0wZ�L"�t/:/&1&D���LK�4k"�! {�"%!L=�0A¢F02��=�+18�+Y� .°=�028%��+'K� ��!L:/.7Z @�6 )H�G��s�M/02. 2 +'"C�v&102�L0>&�=?� ./+ {|!L&YZ�! {^"%:7K�M��V{|:/.�KE8%+1!L.���s�M/0�8%!Lt7!L&1!L�L+'K2� &�"%8%��:7K~8�:r��0! { 2 ZQ!�0w"�.r!L8mZQ02t�02.7Z�!L.?8%M/0�K�M/!L+YK~0I"�8�M7� 8�(�0�M7�)�L0F8%!P=?� 4L0V�A��0w"%!L&1:/8%+D!L.�@L=�0>8%��+YKd@Q�LZQ=�+Y"�"%+D�/&10{|:/.7K~8%+D!L.«��� .7Z 2 K2� .u��0§Z�0w"�K~��+1�70IZ?�L"m{|!L&D&1! (3"2�

�i0281� � � �|���70v8%M/0 � � �/:r.7ZQ&10�! {�:r./+D8�K~+1�EKE&10I"C+D.�8�M/0v.r!L��=�� &��/:/.7Z�&D0V! { �|�^+D.*��� �G�C!L8%08%M7� 8 � � =��)9<��0�8�Mr!L:/�LMQ8§� ��!L:/8v�L"v�y�7!L:/.�Z/� ��9�! {3"%!L=�0 ��.r0>+1�LMQ�7!L:r��M/!#!QZ<! {�� � +1.L� � ����5(F+1&1&i./!L8FK2� ��0�=P:7KNMu� ��!L:/8��702+1./�P8%!#!?"%t�0IKE+ª±�K�Mr!d( "%=�� &1&�8�M/0 ��+Y"2�ª��*z0���0I"%8���+YK~8�8�Mr0��/:r.7ZQ&1038%!� �� \ � � � � � � � � (FMr0>��00� � � +Y"F�x�7� &1&i! {³�E�LZ�+D:7"�O �F� ��!L:/.�Z�8�Mr0�=�02028�+1./��t7!L+1.Q8-� � � � � � � � � ��C!d( (�0ut7� 8�K�M8%!L�L028�Mr0>��� �3(C+D8%M��n���A+ª{ �|�F=�0>028�"x(F+18�M �:�2�v�Q9G�L&1:/02+D.r�<+1.,��yT^T_g^T_x� a v�xl�R� �V(FM/+YK�M�+'"�!L�r8n� +1./0IZy{|��!L=²�?"%=?� &1&�"%t/Mr0>��0P� ��!L:r.7Z �~� �v! {��E�LZQ+D:�" � � ���Q9¡K~:/8%8�+1./�?!L:r8�8�Mr0 �./02+1�LMk��!L:/��M/!�!kZ/"³! {C���J� Rv� .7Z� s � Rx��"%0>0�8�M/0�±7�E"%8^t7� ��8�! {�8%M/0�&10IKE8%:/��0 ����s�Mr0�O S�ZQ+1=�02.7"%+D!L.�� &+1.k8%:/+18�+1!L.¯�[(CM/+YK�MG+Y"P�y�/+18v=�+'"%&10I�LZQ+1./�?+1.°"%!L=�0���0I"%t�0IKE8~��+Y"vKE!L=�+1./�y{|��!L= ��"%+D=�t/&10�t/&1:/=P�/+1./�t/��!QKE0IZQ:r��0�Z�0>tr+'K~8%0wZy!L.���+1�L:/��0�TQ�

��+1�L:/��0�TQ�

:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y =�M/0IKN4<8%M7� 8P��"%+D=�t/&10P�r&D! (FSA:/t�! {�� � � 8P�yt7!L+1.Q8�!L. � � � ZQ!#0I"V./!L8vK�M7� .r�L0�8%M/08%!Lt7!L&1!L�L+'K2� &�"%8%��:7K~8%:/��0v! { 2 ��� ¢C+1.k82\V./!L8%0P8%M7� 8�8%M/0 � � �/:/.7ZQ&10v+1.�8%M/0�8%!L8n� &�"%t��LKE0x! { ; �$��� �! �L0>� � � +'"���:7"%8C8�Mr0�¢F!Lt�{�±��/�E� 8�+1!L. ��C � �'s � �?B�"%+D.r��8%M/+Y"Ct/��!d�L0�8�M7� 8�8%M/0P� ��!d�L0vZQ0I"�K~��+Dt/8%+1!L.

� U

Page 19: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

! { 2 +Y"�:/./+Y¨L:/0V+A� 0L��+D8VZQ!#0I"C./!L8�ZQ02t�02.7Zy!L.<8%M/0PK�Mr!L+'K~0v! {�8%M/0�Z�0w"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+Y"�� 8�+1!L.i��� ¢C+1.Q8>\�� .Q98�(�!�ZQ0I"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+Y"�� 8�+1!L.7"^Z�+ � 02�F�Q9?��"%0I¨®:/02.7K~0�! {^�/&D! (FSA:/t�"2� �:9;RN<���7Q��#N YuX���!d�L0V8%M7� 8���./02+D�LMQ��!L:/��M/!�!kZ � ! {1@�+Y"FMr!L=�02!L=�!L��t/M/+YK�8%!?8%M/0��[��0I� &F¡ �?K~!L./0v! �L0>�2 �

*z0PZQ0~±7./0V8�Mr0�&1!kK2� &�{|:/.7Z/� =�02.Q8n� &i�L��!L:rt,) D ! {�@�) � 8%!?��0v0w¨®:7� & ).�I� 2 �n��¢�¨L:/+1�d� &102.k8%&19a@!L./0�=?�)9?ZQ0~±7./0�+183�L"�8�M/0V+1.k�L02�E"%0�&1+D=�+18

) D \��,&1+D=�

)~�I�/� � �#@�/ �8�� 4L0>.�! �L02��./02+D�LMQ��!L:/��M/!�!kZ/""� ! {C@i�:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y��i028 � �70v�PZQ02�L��020Go 4Rv&1+1./0��/:/.�ZQ&D0�! �L02��� � X���!d�L0�8%M7� 8F8%M/0�&1!kK2� &«{|:/.7Z/� =�02.Q8n� &�L��!L:/t�! {m8%M/0��L02��8�02��! {�8�M/0?K~!L./0 ��� � �3+Y" "�� ��¢C+D.Q82\�K~!L.7"%+YZQ02�1� � �/:/.7Z�&D0v+1.z8�M/0x8�!L8�� &�"%t7�LK~0��� � �3(CM/+YK�M<+Y"�!L�/8�� +1./0IZ��Q9u�L&1:/02+1./�?8�(�!uK~!Lt/+10I"�! {�� � � � (F+18�MGK~!#!L�EZQ+1.7� 8%0I"V� ��� � $ �|�C�k9�8%M/0��02&'� 8%+1!L.7"2\ � s � � � �� � .7Z $ s � $ � �#� �� !�C02�#8�:7"%0�8%M/0V8�M/02!L��02=}! {���� .�K�� =�t�02.��:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y�X���! �L0�8�M�� 8F8%M/0�&1!kK2� &�{|:/.7Zr� =�02.Q8�� &7�L��!L:/ty! {��x./!L��=?� &�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8 9P!L�/8�� +D.r0wZ��Q9u�K~!d�L02��+1./�P! {���ZQ+Y"�K��/�E� .7KNM/0IZ?� &1!L./�P8%M/0v"%0>8 �#���8� s � Rx/V+Y"�±7.r+D8%0§� .�ZuK~9kK~&1+'K �1¢C+D.Q82\�t/��!d�L0�8�M7� 82 +Y"�M/!L=�!L8%!Ltk9�0I¨L:r+D�d� &102.Q8F8%!��x&D02.7"C"%t7�LK~0L�

�C!d( (�0vKE&Y� +1= 8�M7� 8 2 �LZQ=�+18n"��x=?� t �\ 2 � � � � (FMr+'KNM�!d�L02� ���� \�� � � � 1 � � � � � � / 2+Y"^��:�"%838%M/0v��0I"%8%��+'K~8%+D!L.�! {.�R� � �(�A��;�!L��02! �L0>� � � � � �~� �)�F+Y"F8%M/0v8%!L��:7"���� � � � � � � � (CM/+'KNM�+'"8%M/0PZQ0~{|!L��=?� 8�+1!L.u��028%�E�LK~8F! {�� � �v��"%020�8%M/0V±7�E"%8Ct7� ��8F! {^8%M/0v&10wK~8%:/��0 �n�Cs�M/0PK~!L.7"%8%��:7K~8�+1!L.y! { � +'"!L�/8�� +D.r0wZ��Q9��L&D:/02+1./�P8%M/0�tr��!L��0IKE8%+1!L.u! {^8%M/03� � �/:r.7ZQ&1038%!L�L028�Mr0>��(C+D8%Mu8%M/0V=?� t

� � � � � � � @ � �$@ s ��\g@ � @ s � Rx� � @ � � s F � @ s � s �,O � /(FMr+'KNMu+Y"FK~!L=�+D.r�V{|��!L= 8�Mr0�8�(�! � � ±7�/�E� 8%+D!L.7"�! { ���C�ZQ0I"�K~��+D��0IZ?��0~{|!L��0L���� =�0>&19L@�!d�L02��8�Mr0¡"%:/��"%0>8 ���C�� ��C?! {�8%M/0y:/./+18�"%t/M/02��0?8%M/0y±7�r�E� 8�+1!L.�K2� .��0¡Z�0w"�K~��+1�70IZ�L"V{|!L&1&1!d(�"2� � :/8�"%+YZQ0�! {�8%M/0y8�!L��:�"��b��� � ��� � s � � � s � sE� � > Ox/L@^8%M7� 8x+'"�!L.°8%M/0u"%028H� � ��� � 4� > Ox� � � s �84 � > Ox/L@C(�0�8n� 4L0�t/��!L��0IK~8�+1!L.!L.Q8�! � s K~!#!L�EZ�+D.7� 8%0<K~!L=�t7!#"%0IZ(C+D8%M "%Mr��+D./4�+D.r��8%M/0� ./.Q:/&1:7"1�L� > O 4 � � s � 4 �7/�8�!��vt/:/.�K�M/0IZ�ZQ+Y"%4 � �s ´ "%!v8�M�� 8�8�M/0�t/��!®��0wK~8%+D!L.�!L.?8�Mr0��7!L:r.7Z/� ��9��02=?� +D.7"³8�M/0�"�� =�0a���#+1=�+D&Y� ��&D9L@ (�0Ftr��!kZQ:7K~0���=?� tP! {�� � � � �*4�� > Ox� � � s � 4�� > Ox/C!L.Q8�!v��t/:/.7KNM/0IZZQ+Y"�K � �� �J�F! (�(�0V�L&D:r0 � �� � .�Z�� �s 8%!u�x./02+1�LMk��!L:/��M/!�!kZ�! {^8%M/0v+1.k8%02�E"%0IKE8%+1!L.L�#� � � s � Rx/v� .7Z±7��8�M/0�t/��!L��0IK~8�+1!L. � �Q9<=?� t/tr+D./� � � � � � s � � � s � s � � > Ox/�8%!�RQ�*�C!d(}8%M/0�t/��!L��0IK~8�+1!L.G! {38%M/0yT^`_&^`_ � afv#xl"� � � +'"�!L�/8�� +D./0IZ��Q9�"%Mr��+D./4�+D.r��8%M/0v� �7! �L0�t/+YK~8�:/��0�8�!�8%M/0 �F"%+1H20a�

J�992 ��(�0PZQ02./!L8�0 � � � �(�R� ��� .7Z ��0I"%t70IK~8�+1�L02&D9L@�2 �� � � � � � � �� �3� .7Z92 �� � � � � �'� �� �n�v*z0./!L8%0u8%M7� 82@^��0IK>� :�"%0u! {�8�M/0�� ��!d�L0uZ�0w"�K~��+1t/8%+D!L.G! { ��! �L02� � � �I@�� &1&�8�M/��020 2 � � "P� ��0�M/!L=�!L8�!LtQ90I¨L:/+1�d� &102.k82�

� 1

Page 20: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

s�Mr0PZQ0I"�KE��+1t/8%+D!L.y! {&�,K~!L=�t/&D028%0I"F8%M/0�KE!L.�"%8���:7K~8%+D!L.�(�0v.r0>0IZ 8�!?tr��!kK~020wZ (F+18�M�8�Mr0PKE!L=�t/:rS8�� 8�+1!L.�! {�M/!L=�!L&1!L�L9��L��!L:/t7"2���3� =�02&19a@�{|!L&D&1! (F+1./�P;�:/=x{|!L�EZi@�(�0�K~!L.7"%+YZQ02��8�Mr0�+1.7ZQ:7K~0IZ�=?� t7"2\

� � \ )~�2� 2 �:� � )~�)� � �|�|� � .7Z � � \ � �2� 2 �:� � � �2� � �|�|���+1�E"%8>@�(�0V./!L8�0�8�M7� 8�"%+D.�KE0 � �(��M7�L"�./+YK~0�"%8%��:7K~8�:/��0�(�0��L028>\ � � � +Y"�M/!L=�!L8%!Ltk9x0I¨L:/+1�d� &10>.Q8C8�!?�v��!L:7¨®:/028F! {�K~:/���L0I" � � � 8�8��LK�M/0IZ�� 8C!L./0�t�!L+D.Q8�8%!L�L0>8%M/02�(F+18%M��x&D!�!Lt7"2@ (FM/02��0 ��+'"�8�Mr0�.k:r=P��0>��! {i&D!�!Lt7"�+1.P8%M/0F�L�E� trMPZQ0~±7./0IZv�Q9 � � � �^5A.�t7� ��8%+'K~:/&Y� �

� � � � � � ��� "����� ��� � � � � � �

)~�2� � �|�|��+'"C�L02./02�E� 8�0IZ��Q9�.r!L./SA(F+1&'Z�&1!#!Lt�"�(FMr+'KNM¡K2� .���0�&1+ {|8%0IZy:/t��[./!L.rS[:r./+'¨®:/02&D9~¡ ��8%! 2 @8%M/02��0E{|!L��0�8�M/0V=?� t � � +Y"F"%:/�A��0IK~8%+D�L0�´ � &'"%!x+D.y8%M/0§K2�L"%0�! {^M/!L=�!L&1!L�L9L�

s�MQ:7"2@�+1.G!L�EZQ02��8%!<�L028v8%M/0�+D.�{|!L��=�� 8%+1!L.�!L. � �I� 2 �P��� .7Zi@�&Y� 8%0>�I@^� &Y"%!�!L. )~�)� 2 �%��(�0?� ��0"%:/t/t�!#"%0IZ�8%!�K~!L=�t/:/8%0�8%M/0V4L0>��.r0>&i! {)� � \ � �I� 2 � � � �I� � �|� �n��s�!P8%M/+Y"�02.7Z�(�0�./!L8%0�8%M7� 82\ 8%M/0�4L02��./02&i! { � � +Y"C�L0>.r0>�E� 8%0IZy�Q9�&1!#!Lt�"�����Z�0E±�./0IZ��L"�{|!L&1&D! (3"2\��'��+Y"�8%M/0v&D!�!Lt�+D.y8%M/0V±7��0>�! { 2 �� � � �� (F+18%Mu8%M/0V!L��+D02.Q8n� 8%+1!L.uZQ0~±7./0IZ��k9�8%M/0vKE!L=�t/&102�?"%8���:7K~8%:/��0L@

8%M/0���02&Y� 8�+1!L.7"���028�(�020>.y8%M/0��L02./02�E� 8%!L�E"�! {^8�M/0V4L02��./02&i! { � � � ��0V�L"�{|!L&1&D! (3"

q � � �(� � �:�)��� ���,RJ! � �L�

s�Mr0�� �7! �L0V��0>&Y� 8%+D!L.uK2� .���0���0I�LZy�L"�{|!L&1&D! (3"2\�{|!L���§±7�#0IZ�K~:/���L0 � � @r&D028�� ��� �8!"!"!#� � � � ��0�8%M/0K~:/���L0I"�=�02028�+1./� �|�A��s�Mr0>.y+1.,2 ����� .7Z?8%MQ:7"�+1. 2 �� �

��� s� ��� � ��� ��� F !"!8!�F�� � � ! � ���L�

s�Mr0�t/��!#! {^! {�8�M/0I"%0vK~&'� +1=?"�K>� .���0�{|!L:/.7Z�+1. 3 ;�:r=P{|!L�EZ 9 ��#+1.7K~0�8%M/0�=?� 8%��+D�y� �|� � �J�2�m+Y"�.r0>�#� 8%+1�L0�ZQ0~±7./+18�0V(�0�!L�/8�� +1.u8%M/0�{|!L&D&1!d(C+D.r�v��0w"%:r&D8F� ��!L:/8F8%M/0

4L02��./02&i! { � � \��N56 6 ��Y���l#a(vgc|w c$c"v7eAl�aih�wga�)G\�� � � � ^Wc w�{"l c�]#yFv�a?^i]#_ ]#jJw�_�]#{$eAw#yRc"v7{$jFwg��lGcf^T_x�nv7y?w#{$^<aT��F� �$@�����^<a?h aihXl�l��n��lf[ka?^i]#_�w#y�yi]x�8v&c � �|� � ��l#a ��\�2 � � �(� xl�w afv#xv�yiw#{(_Xl}^��gh,x]gv�{$h�]g]xm��]#_nc"a?{#v��"a�l#m w x]���l(w#_Rm � � \ � �I� 2 � � � �>� � �|� � l�a?h�l:^T_Rm�v���l#m�eHw"[ ]#_Ah�]#eA]#yi]"�7� � hXl}_

xl${ � � � a ]#{ cf^i]#_ [Rw#{#a�]#j � � � 2 �}���w#{#m�� xl${2�!� � �%� � o5 ��� � � � � � �}!�i028�:7"�./!L8�0v8%M7� 8���"%+1=�+D&Y� ���A�/:/8C=�!L��0�+D.Q�L!L&1�L0IZ���� ���L:/=�02.k8FK2� .���0§Z�!L./0�{|!L� )~�)� 2 ����s�M/0

K~!L=�t/:/8�� 8�+1!L.?! {�8%M/0V4L02��./02&7! {�8�M/0V=?� t � � {|!L��)~��+'"CZQ!L./0��Q9E3 ;�:r=P{|!L�EZ 9 (FM/02. � �|��+Y"F��8���020! {^�E� 8�+1!L.7� &iK~:/���L0I"2�^s�M/0V��0I"%:/&D8�+Y"3�L"m{|!L&D&1! (3"2\

�IT

Page 21: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

�5� V ��V �#QTS#QWVXPCY � � v7e,jF]#{#m ���J^T{���l �{#v���h-���F_�a?h�l(w ]���ltc�l#afai^T_x�c"v�[�[�] c�l�a?h�wga�� �|�.^WcJwpa?{"l"l(]#j.�{"wga?^i]#_Xw#yR�"v7{���l c�� �(�#�"!"!"!#� � , / � hXl}_ aih�lJj�v7_Rmxw#eAl$_�a�w#yx�g{"]gv�[ ).�I� 2 ��^Wc���l}_Xl}{"wga l#m U�py?]g]"[.c��� ���'h�l${"l�qC� �7�"!8!"!"� .a�]"��l#a?h�l${���^<a?h*aih�l�jF]#y`y?]7�'^T_x�G{"l$yiwga?^?]#_nc1mxl ��_�l#m|jF]#{�� qf� %r�m\x� � qf��% � .#�

�'� ��� ��� ��� �� �� � � � � �� ��� �� ���'�� � � � � � � �� ��!"!"!���� ��� ��� � � �, � �7!

s�Mr+'"�ZQ0I"�K~��+1t/8�+1!L.?! { )~��+Y"�./020IZQ0IZ�8�!�t/��! �L0�8�M/0�{|!L&1&D! (F+1./���� NgV � N 6 Y � � v7e,jF]#{#m���� j�a?h�l�j�v�_Rmxw#eAl$_.a w#y �g{"]gv�[,)~�2� 2 �1^dc|ai{$^ �#^?w#y'aihXl}_A��^dc1cfeA]&]gaih wga�@ �� ]#{"l ��l$_�l${"w#y`y���7^`j � �|��^Wc�wGai{"l"lJ]#j�{"wgai^?]#_�w#y~�8v�{���l c�]#_ w�cfeA]g]ga?h�c"v7{$jFwg��l�c"v���ha?h�wga�aihXl�eAwgai{$^ �� �(��� �J�I�1^Wc:_Xl ��wga?^ ��l�mxl ��_�^Fa�l w#_Rm,^Fa<c�afv#xv�yiw#{J_�l$^ �gh, ]gv7{$h�]g]xm�^Wc�cf^`e�[ny��L��]#_�_�l#�"a lUm*a?h�l$_ a?h�la?{"l8l���w#_ l�� ]#_�a?{"wg�"a�l#mAa�],wG_X]#_ �icf^`_x�nv�yiw#{�[k]#^T_�a �

*z0§"%4L028�K�My8�Mr0�t/��!#! {^! {�8�M/+Y"�8%M/02!L��02= ��0~{|02��+D./�x8�!�3 ;�:/=x{|!L�EZ 9 {|!L�3ZQ028�� +D&Y"2��r��!L= 8%M/0�Z�+'"�K~:7"�"%+1!L.�! {FM/!L=�!L&D!L�L9y! {�2 (�0P4�./!d( 8%M7� 8�8%M/0x8���+1�#+Y� &D+18�9�! { � �I� 2 ��+1=�t/&D+10I"

8%M7� 8 � �|�/+'"���8%��020�! {��E� 8%+D!L.�� &�K~:/���L0I"^� .�Zv=�!L��02!d�L02��8%M7� 8^8%M/0�ZQ028�02��=�+D.�� .k8�! {�8%M/0C+D.Q8%0>�E"%0IK~8%+D!L.=?� 8���+1��� �|��� �J�2�F+Y"��§�L�V;�!L��02! �L0>�I@r�70IK2� :7"%0v! { =��L"%8�02&1.Q:/!d�L0vK~��+D8%02��+D!L.�@/(�0v=?�I9��L"�"%:/=�0V8�M7� 8./!PK~:/���L0�+1. � �|�i+'"CK~!L.k8%�E�LK~8�+1�/&10�8�!��P"%=�!#!L8%M?t�!L+D.Q8�(F+18�M/!L:r8FZQ0I"%8���! 9#+1./�v8%M/0��L!#!QZQ./0I"�"�! {�8%M/0��0I"%!L&D:r8�+1!L.���s�M7� 8C+'"2@Q8%M/02��0�+Y"�./! �J��"%:7K�M?8%M7� 82\ ��s� �2�V�L@/� .7Z �J��=�02028�"3� 8�=�!#"%8�8�(�!�!L8%M/02�3K~:/���L0I"�{|��!L= � �|�[�

 �K~8�:7� &1&19a@Q+18F+Y"�K~!L.Q�L0>.r+D02.Q8�8%!?�L"�"%:/=�0F8%M7� 8F8%M/0���0I"%!L&1:/8%+D!L.?+Y"�=�+1./+1=�� &�� =�!L.r�v�L!#!kZy��0I"%!L&1:/S8%+D!L.7"2@�8%M7� 8�+'"�(�0v=��)9��L"�"%:/=�0�8�M�� 8�8�Mr0v.k:r=P��0>��! {�02�QKE02t/8%+1!L.7� &^KE:r���L0w" .y+'"�=�+1./+1=�� &�� =�!L./��L!#!QZy��0I"%!L&D:/8%+1!L.7"�! {^8%M/0P"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18�9,@*)*�G�F; :/=x{|!L�EZ � "�� ���L:r=�02.Q8�+Y"�+1.7ZQ:7K~8%+D�L0V(F+18�M���0I"%t�0IKE88%! .7�^��+1�E"%8>@L(�0C./!L8%038%M7� 8�{|!L�9.�� �C8%M/0v�2S6K~!L./.r0wK~8%0IZQ./0I"�"^! { 2 +D=�t/&1+D0I"�8%M7� 8 ��s� � �V��"%!v8�M7� 88%M/0§K~:/���L0�+'"CKE!L.Q8%�E�LK~8�+1�/&10�8�!���"%=�!�!L8�Myt�!L+D.Q8��Q9�=m�L"%8%0>&1.Q:/! �L0�K~��+18�02��+1!L.���C!d( +D.�!L�EZQ02�C8�!?� ����+1�L0�8%!�8�M/0PK~!L.Q8%�E�LZQ+'K~8%+D!L.y&10>8C:7"��L"�"%:/=�0�8%M7� 8F8%M/02��0v02�#+Y"%8n"���K~:/���L0 �|�(FMr+'KNM°=�02028n"x� 8�&10I�L"%8v8�Mr��0>0y!L8%M/02�I@m"��)9�� s �"!"!"!#� � � @�(FM/02��0HB � �/�¯s�M/02.8%M/��! (F+1./�<�I(F�)9� � (�0P"%t/&1+1838%M/0x8���020 � � � +D.Q8%!uZQ+Y" ��!L+D.Q8�:/./+1!L.�! {�8���020I" � s �"!8!"! � � �v5 { � � ZQ02./!L8%0I"�8%M/0v�L��!L:/t�L02./02�E� 8�0IZ��Q9�&1!#!Lt�"FK~!L=�+D./��{|��!L= 8%M/0�8%��0>0�� � =�!kZQ:/&1!�� trt/��!Lt/��+Y� 8�0���02&'� 8%+1!L.7"�(�0��L028

) � � 2 � > ��� � � � � � � � s ��!"!"! � � � � > ��� s �7!8!"! ��� � � � �}�(FMr0>��0 � � �}ZQ02./!L8%0I"�8%M/0�{|��020Vt/��!kZ�:7K~8�! {³�L��!L:rt7"2�

J�9°����0I"%:/&18v! {�� &1�L02�/�E����"%0>0�3 ;�:/=x{|!L�EZ 9 �3!L.r0u! {�8%M/0u�L��!L:rt7" �G�C=P:7"%8v��0u8%��+1�#+Y� &[�¯s�M/+Y"2@�Q9u+1.7ZQ:�KE8%+1!L.<!L. .�@i+D=�t/&1+10w"C8%M7� 8�8%M/0P8%��020 �X�^=?�I9y�70�K~!L.k8%�E�LK~8�0IZ 8�!��u"%=�!�!L8�M�t7!L+1.Q83!L. �|�w@K~!L.Q8��E� ��9�8%!P!L:/���L"�"%:/=�t/8�+1!L.?8%M7� 89.?+Y"�=�+D.r+D=?� &A�

OLR

Page 22: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

s�Mr0>��0~{|!L��0�(�0���0IZQ:7K~0IZ�!L:/�FZQ+Y"�KE:�"�"%+D!L.�8%!P8%M/0§K2�L"%0�! {^�,c"ai{$^T_x�P! {��E� 8%+1!L.7� &�K~:/���L0I"2��s�M7� 8F+Y"2@(�0V=��)9��L"�"%:/=�0�8�M�� 838%M/0PK~:/���L0I"��|�³� ��0V!L�EZQ02��0IZu"%!?8%M7� 8 �|��=�0>028�"C!L./&D9�� s @ � , =�020>8�"C!L./&19� , � �F� .7Z�{|!L��8�Mr03+1.7ZQ02�,q�@��54 q 47.7@L8%M/0�K~:/���L0��|�7=�020>8�"�!L./&19 �|� � �F� .7Z �|� � �w��*z0�=?�I9�� &'"%!�L"%:/=�0�8�M�� 83� &1&�.Q:/=P��02�E" ��� ����s�� ��0��/+1�L�L02�F8%M7� .��L�:9;RN<���7Q��#N YvB3"%0�8�M/0VX^��!Lt�!#"%+D8%+1!L.?8�!xt/��! �L0F+1.7ZQ:7K~8%+D�L02&19�8%M7� 8�8%M/02.,).�>� 2 ��+Y"��PK~9kK~&1+'K��L��!L:rt "��(FMr0>��0 o�+'"�8�Mr0�./!L=�+D.�� 8�!L��+1.u8%M/0�{|!L&D&1! (F+1./��K~9kK~&1+'KV¨L:r!L8�+102.k8

o! �� � � �

s � ��������

s�Mr+'"�K~!L.7K~&1:7ZQ0I"�8%M/0Vt/��!#! {�! {³8%M/0�8%M/02!L��02= ! {�;�:/=x{|!L�EZi�*G� ��./+1./�/\�8�M/02��0V+'"�./!�0w¨®:/+1�d� &D02.Q8�! {�8%M/0v8�Mr0>!L��02= ! {m;�:r=P{|!L�EZ�+1.<ZQ+D=�02.7"%+1!L. � ¤ @�8�M�� 8�+'"

8%M/02��0�� ��0§"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��t7!L+1.Q8n"�(F+18�My8�Mr0�8%��+D��+'� &i&1!kK2� &«{|:/.7Z/� =�02.Q8n� &��L��!L:/t��:9;RN<���7Q��#N YvX^��! �L0�8%M7� 8F8%M/0vKE!L.r0�!d�L02�C8�M/0vO S�ZQ+1=�02.7"%+1!L.7� &/¨L:��LZQ��+'K

� s � � �� � � � � C

M7�L"�8���+1�#+Y� &i&D!QK2� &i{|:/.7Zr� =�02.Q8�� &/�L��!L:/t�� 8F+18n"��L0>��8%02�7�

OQ�

Page 23: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

�§���«�7���/������� �3���7��������¯���� ������� � ����3�������^�����7�������5 {n����+Y"^��"%=�!#!L8%MP�d� ��+1028�9§� .�Z � �3±7./+18�0��L��!L:/tv! {�� &1�L02�/�E� +'K��A!L��Mr!L&D!L=�!L��t/M/+YK)�7� :/8%!L=�!L��trM/+'"%=?"�LK~8�+1./�v!L.,���r8�M/02.?8%M/0���0I"%:/&18�+1./�v¨L:/!L8%+D02.Q8���� > � +'"���./!L��=?� &/�d� ��+1028�9P(C+D8%Mu¨®:/!L8�+102.Q8m"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+DS8%+D0I"2�^5 {�(�0�±7�P��t�!L+1.k8�@H)A���r(F+18�M�8%M/0F+Y"%!L8%��!Ltk9V�L��!L:/t � D � �,8%M/02.?8%M/03"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8 9�! {R��� > �� 8G35@ 9 +Y" � D > � D (FM/02��05� D +'"�� D SA+D.Q�d� ��+Y� .Q8�� .7� &19#8%+'K��$¡ �v./02+1�LMQ�7!L:/��Mr!#!kZ�! {C@i���#M/��+1./4#+1./��� D +ª{./0IK~0I"�"�� ��9a@�(�0vK>� .�K�Mr!#!#"%0�K~!#!L�EZ�+D.7� 8%0I"��0������� �"!"!8!"�$�   ��� ��!L:r.7Z@A�,RQ��s�M/02.u(�0v"%028

� � \ �������1� �� � ���

� � � � � � � � �����(FMr0>��0 � � +'"C8%M/0�ZQ02��+1�d� 8%+D�L0v! { � � 8�RQ@�8%M7� 8�+Y" � � � � � � � > � � � �%�6R����v5 {m(�0v8�� 4L0 ��)�� DP8%M/02.<+1.8%M/0�.r0>(�K~!#!L�EZ�+D.7� 8%0I"��u�LK~8�"3�L"m{|!L&D&1! (3"

����� �Y�'����� �7�����%�1� � � ��� � � �Y� �� � � � ������������ � �<� � � � ��� �%� � ��� � � �

� � � ���� � � � �1��� � �� .7Z�8�Mr0>��0~{|!L��0�(�0�M7�I�L0�t/��!d�L0IZi\��N56 6 ��Y ����w#{#a�w#_-��ZJ_&� u&vx]gai^?l$_�aGcf^T_x�nv7y?w#{$^<aT�¯�<� > ���#35@ 9 �G^Wc�^Wc�]#eA]#{f[nh�^F��a ]�aih�lcf^T_x�nv7y?w#{$^<aT��f��  > ���#3 R 9 � �R��h�l${"l � � ���� �����P�1^Wc�w��_�^Fa l1�g{"]gv�[ �

s�Mr0u8%M/02!L��02= ! {�=�� ��8n� .+Y"x�L02��9�K~!L.Q�L02./+D02.Q8P"%+1.7K~0�+D8���0IZQ:7K~0I"v8%M/0�t/��!L�/&102= ! {§"%8%:7ZQ9�+D./�¨L:r!L8�+102.k8V"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�+10I"C8�!�¨L:/!L8%+10>.Q8��Q9y±7.r+D8%0P&1+D.r0w� ���L��!L:/t7"2�v;�!L��02! �L0>�I@��Q9 3 X^��+1&D& 9 @7+18�=?�)9��70�L"�"%:/=�0IZx8�M7� 8�8%M/0��L��!L:rt�� � � ������� �x��+Y":cfeAw#yTy[@L8%M7� 8C+'"2@�+D8FK~!L.Q8�� +D.7"�.r!v=�� 8%��+1�P(FMr+'KNM?M7�L"���L"�� .�02+1�L02.k� � &D:/0C! {�=P:/&18%+Dt/&1+YKE+18�9�� �<�L�^5 { � +'"�"%=?� &D&/� .7Zx8%M/0�"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18�9�+Y"�+'"%!L&Y� 8�0IZx+18^{|!L&1&D! (3"8%M7� 8 � �LK~8n"3{|��0>02&19?!L. �   � �IRx/L�F C&D&�8%M/0I"%0�!L��"%0>��� � 8�+1!L.7"��A(FMr+'KNM�(�0§ZQ!�./!L8�t/��! �L0�M/02��0 �m"%:r=:/ty8�!�8%M/0�{|!L&D&1!d(C+D.r�v��0w"%:r&D8�´ "%0>03 J���+D0I"%4L!L��.�@Q�Q� 8�HvOQ� T 9��� NgV � N 6 Y h�l${"l1^dc��1�¯����]#{${"l c [k]#_Rm l}_ �8��l� lUa ��l8l$_^Wc�]#eA]#{f[nh�^Wcfe �fyiw c$c�l cJ]#j�� ��m7^TeAl$_ncf^i]#_Xw#yugv ]gai^?l$_.a'cf^T_x�nv7y?w#{$^Fai^?l cJw#_RmH��]#_��"v���wg�����fy?w c$c�l c ]#j'cfeHw#yTy�c"v# �g{"]gv�[.ct]#j!� ����Ox� �x� �

5A.,ZQ+1=�02.7"%+D!L.OQ@�8%M/0�8%M/02!L��0>= ! {v;�:/=x{|!L�EZi@�(FM/+YK�M(�0�M7�)�L0�ZQ+'"�K~:7"�"%0IZ +D.8%M/0�t/��02��+D!L:7"&10wK~8%:/��0L@Q�L+D�L0I"�8�M/0�{|!L&1&D! (F+1./�PK�M�� �E�LKE8%02��+DHI� 8%+D!L.��� NgV � N 6 Y �Fj��<�*�$@��'^WcJw�_X]#{$eHw#y�� � m�^`eAl$_ncf^?]#_�w#y�cf^T_x�nv7y?w#{$^<ad�paihXl}_ ^<a ^dctw�ugv ]gai^?l$_.a�cf^T_x�nv7y?w#{$^<aT�^Tj�w#_ m]#_�y��^`j ^<aFcJyi]x��w#yRj�v7_Rm w#eHl$_�a w#yx�g{"]gv�[9) D ^dc ��_�^Fa�l ��5� V V $Y�56.7ZQ020IZi@#+ª{�R�) � s > � +'"C��¨L:/!L8%+D02.Q8F"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8�9�� .7Z � +Y"F"%=?� &D&�8%M/02.

� s � �IRx/(� � �f� s � �IRx/ � > �+Y"F� .�:/./�E� =�+ª±70IZ�KE! �L02��+D.r�v(F+18�M�8%M/0 � � &1!L+'"��L��!L:/t�� � .7Z?8%MQ:7"�) D � �v� =�!L.Q�L02�E"%02&D9L@Q"%:/t/t�!#"%08%M7� 8 ) D � )~�2�/� � �#@�/ ��+Y"�±7./+18�0x�/� +Y"3�x./02+1�LM/!L��!L:/��M/!#!QZ�! {�@����Fs�M/02.�(�0�8�� 4L0v8%M/0�:r./+D�L02�E"�� &

OLO

Page 24: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

K~!d�L02� � � � � � �#@�/�(FMr+'KNM<´ �Q9z�LZ/ZQ+1./�¡�yt�!L+1.k8�@���!d�L02��@�´ (�0�02�#8%02.7Z 8�!<��KE!L.Q8%+D.r!L:7"=?� t ��� � �v��s�M/02.�@��LK2K~!L�EZQ+1./�<8%!G��0I"%:/&18n"x! { � �E� :r0>��8�� .7Z£C02=�=�02��82@�����M7�L"��z:/./+Y¨L:r0"%8%��:7K~8�:/��0C! {��V./!L��=?� &/KE!L=�t/&102�v�d� ��+10>8 9�"%:7KNM�8%M7� 8�8�Mr03=?� t,��� � � +Y"�M/!L&1!L=�!L��t/M/+YKd��J�:/8�8%M/0&1!kK2� &�{|:/.7Z/� =�02.Q8n� &i�L��!L:/t ) D +Y"F8%��+1�#+Y� &³� .�Zy8�MQ:7"2@r�k9y;�:/=x{|!L�EZi@x����+Y"�"%=�!#!L8%M<� .7Z��<�*�$@���+'"��¨L:/!L8%+10>.Q8F"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8 9a�

 C=�!L./�<8%M/0u¨®:/!L8�+102.Q8P"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�+10I"�� �L02��9W"%t�0IK~+'� &FK~&Y�L"�"V+'"�t/��!d��+'Z�0wZW�k9 ±7./+18�0y"%:/�/�L��!L:/t7"�! {� ���������P������� =�0>&19L@Q+ {�8�Mr0�=?� 8���+1� � +Y"�+D.?8%M/01� ��� �����P��8�Mr0>.�+D8�"F�LK~8%+D!L.yt/��0I"%02���L0w"�8%M/0��L!L&1:/=�0{|!L��= og� ��� !"!"! � o&�   �A(FM/+YK�M�@k�L"�(�0�(F+1&1&�"%0>0�&Y� 8�02�I@Q+Y"�0I¨L:/+1�d� &10>.Q8�8%M7� 8�!L.*��  > ��8�Mr0>��0�02�#+Y"%8�"F�M/!L&1!L=�!L��t/M/+YK:��S {|!L��=y�n�

��:���� &^KE&Y�L"�"%+ª±70IZ�±7.r+D8%0P"%:/�/�L��!L:/t�"�! {�8%M/0�"%trM/02��0�! {�:r./+D8�¨®:7� 8�02��+1!L.7"��[:rt<8%!uK~!L.L��:/�#� .7K~9/�� .7Z�8�Mr0���0I"%:/&18�+Y"��� NgV � N 6 Y�� ��v���w#y~[ � � ����Z:_&��ugv ]gai^?l$_.a�]#j���s U�Hw�c"v� �g{"]gv�[*]#j-� � s ^dc�^Wc�]#eA]#{f[nh�^F�:a ]�]#_�l]#j � ��� � � c"v7{$jFwg��l�cf^T_x�nv7y?w#{$^<a?^?l cJm7^Wc"�"vgc$c�l#m�^`_���l#�"afv7{"l � �

 C./!L8%M/02��+D=�t�!L��8n� .Q8�KE&Y�L"�"�! {�"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18%+D0I"�KE!L=�0I"�{|��!L= K~9kK~&D+YK��L��!L:/t7" "�� @Q(�0�(F+1&1&�K2� &1&�"%:7K�M"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"�K~9kK~&D+YK ��s�M/02.u8%M/0V�L��!L:/t�� � ����������P��+'"��L02./02�E� 8%0IZ?�Q9?�v=?� 8%��+D��@/K>� &1&i+18 � �^*z0=?�I9?ZQ+Y� �L!L.7� &1+DH20 � @�8%M7� 8F+Y"�8�� 4L0�K~!#!L�EZQ+1.7� 8%0I"������#�8!"!"!#�$�   �m"%:�K�M?8%M7� 8 � �LK~8n"C!L. �   �L"m{|!L&D&1!d(�"2\

� ����� �"!"!"!8�$�   �'� � $ � � ���#�"!"!"!#� $ � ) �   �(FMr0>��0 $ +Y"F�,o®S[8%Myt/��+D=�+18�+1�L0���!#!L8C! {³:r./+D8 9a�:9;RN<���7Q��#N Yv��+D.�Z?(CM/02.¡"%:7KNMu�x�L��!L:/t?+Y"F"%=?� &1&[�

s�Mr0��L��!L:/t�� �LKE8�"C!L.u8%M/0V��+D.r�v! {³t�!L&19#./!L=�+Y� &'"J�x� �����8!"!"!#�$�   9 \� � %«� �����"!"!"!8�$�   ���'��%i� $ � � ���#�"!8!"!#� $ � ) �   �

� .7Z�8�Mr0���02�L:/&Y� ��{|:/.7K~8%+D!L.7"�!L.u8%M/0v¨L:/!L8%+10>.Q8|�   > � � ��0�+1.Q�d� ��+Y� .k8�(C+D8%My��0w"%t�0IK~8F8%!�8%M/+Y"F�LK~8%+D!L.��s�M�� 8F+Y"2\ �   > ��� ��� �I�f�435���#�"!"!8! �}�   9�� �}!5A8C+'"CKE&10I� �F8%M7� 8�8%M/0���+1./�v! {^+1.k� � ��+'� .Q8^t�!L&D9�./!L=�+'� &Y"J�435��� �"!"!"!#�$�   9 � +Y"F�4��SA�L0IK~8�!L��"%t7�LK~0��L02./02��S� 8%0wZ �Q9?=�!L./!L=�+'� &Y"2��  =�!L./!L=�+Y� &R� , �� !"!"! � , )  ) �435��� �"!"!8! �}�   9 +'" � S[+1.Q�d� ��+Y� .k8�+ª{^+D8�"C02�#t�!L./02.k8�""�� 8%+'" {|9?8%M/0�{|!L&1&1!d(C+D./�x��02&'� 8%+D!L.

x� .g� F� s . s F !8!"!�F   .   ) o5� " ! � �L�

;�!L��0x�L02./02�E� &D9L@�&D02832 ����0?�y&'� 8%8�+YK~0?t7� �E� =�028���+1H2+D.r�?02�#t�!L./02.k8�"V! {F=�!L./!L=�+'� &Y"�+1.z8�M/0���+D./�y! {{|:/.7K~8%+D!L.�"���02�L:/&Y� ��!L.¯� � �I�   � �   @�8%M7� 8�+Y"�+D. �435��� �$� � �� �"!8!"!#�$�   �$� � �  9 �?s�M/02.�8%M/0�"%:/�/&Y� 8�8%+'K~0

O ¤

Page 25: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

2 � 2 �r! {78%M/0I"%0F(FMr+'KNM�� ��0�+1.k� � ��+'� .Q8�(C+D8%M���0I"%t70IK~8�8�!V8�Mr03�LK~8�+1!L.�! { � K~!L.7"%+Y"%8n"�! {�8�M/0I"%0C(FM/+YK�M"�� 8%+'" {|9?8%M/0���02&Y� 8�+1!L.�� �L���

s�MQ:7"«(�0�M7�)�L0m� ����+1�L0IZV.7� 8�:r�E� &D&19�8%!�8�Mr0FKE!L.�KE02t/8�! {���8�!L��+YK��d� ��+10>8 9a��s�Mr0FKE9QK~&D+YK�¨L:/!L8%+10>.Q8^K2� .��0mK~!L.7"%8%��:7K~8�0IZV�L"���8�!L��+YK��d� ��+1028�9v�A+D.v8%M/0� Ct/t�02.7ZQ+1��OC9L!L:V(F+1&D& ±�.7Z�.r!L8n� 8%+D!L.v� .7Z�K~!L.7"%8%��:7K~8%+D!L.7"��02&'� 8%0IZ?8%!�8�!L��+YK��d� ��+1028�+10I"~�n\

s�� 4L0��x�7�L"%+Y"C� #���8!"!"!#�&   ��! {�� .*��S�ZQ+D=�02.7"%+1!L.7� &/��0I� &i�L0IK~8�!L� ��� .7ZyKE!L.�"%+'ZQ02��8�(�!x&'� 8%+YKE0I"��� .7ZA���i+1. �P\

� � \ � � " � ��x� �(#��� � \�� � � F " � � �o �%�(#� F !"!"!�F   �

s�� 4L0�K~!L./0I"�� �����i8%!��70v"%t7� ./.r0wZ�!L.u�L0IK~8�!L�E" #���:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y =�M/0IK�4�8%M7� 8F8%M/0���0I"%:/&18%+D./�v=?� t?! {��)©?./0�8%!L��+'K�� � ��+D028%+D0I"9� � � � � +Y"�8%M/0�¨L:r!L8�+102.k8=?� tu��02&Y� 8�0IZ�8�!�8%M/+Y"F�L��!L:rtu�LK~8�+1!L.��1¢C+D.Q82\�K�Mr0wKN4�8�M7� 8C8�Mr0§ZQ:�� &i�L��!L:/t7".2 � � #�B � �*� " �F� .7Z2 �X� � # B � ���F� " ��"�� 8�+Y" {|9?8%M/0���02&Y� 8�+1!L.�� �L�C�6K~!L=�t7� ��0�(C+D8%M 3 �r:/&D8%!L. 9 �n�

�i028�:�"�./!L8%0v8�M7� 82@�{|!L��� .Q9y�E� 8�+1!L.7� &^"%+1=�tr&D+YK~+'� &�K~!L./0��G+1.<�u"%t��LKE0 � � ��� "%t7� .r./0IZy�k9��&Y� 8�8%+'K~0H� (�0?K>� . ��0>t�0I� 8v8�Mr0u� �7! �L0?K~!L.7"%8���:�KE8%+1!L.��us�M7� 8v+'"2@�(�0?8�� 4L0?�<"%:/�/&Y� 8%8�+YK~04����� �"%t7� ./.r0wZ��Q9?±��E"%8F./!L./SAH202��!p�ySAt�!L+D.Q8�"��( � � �"!"!"!#�& �   �F!L.�8%M/0?�2S�ZQ+D=�02.7"%+1!L.7� &r{[�LKE0I"�! {�8�M/0PK~!L./0�����i028�o�\ � o5 ��� � � �"!8!"!#�& �   ���:9;RN<���7Q��#N YPX���!d�L0�8%M7� 8C8�M/0v¨L:r!L8�+102.k8C�L��!L:/tH� > ���X� 2 � > 2 +Y"�KE9QK~&D+YK�� .�Z?+183�LK~8�"3�L"C� � � &1!L+'"�L��!L:/t?!L.y8%M/0§K~! �L02��+D./� � � � � � �

s�MQ:7"�(�0�M7�I�L0�t/��!d�L0IZ�8%M/0�{|!L&D&1! (F+1./��5� V ��V �#QTS#QWVXPCY hXl�jF]#yTyi]7�'^T_x�Ha���]�c"a�wga l$eAl}_�aFc�w#{"l(l#u&v7^ �Uw#yil$_�a ��i^%�z�F� �$@��1^Wc�w� �.�fyT^<� ugvx]ga?^?l}_�a'cf^T_x�nv7y?w#{$^<ad� ��?^`^%�z�F� �$@��1^Wc�w�cf^T_x�nv7y?w#{$^<aT�]#j�w#_ w�,_�lGa ]#{$^<� �"w#{$^?lUa?^?l c(� � w c$c�]��f^?wga�l#mAa�],w�cf^`e�[nyT^<�f^?w#yk��]#_�l� ���V ��V �����D�8��Y � _Lm7^TeAl$_ncf^i]#_ �A� �.�fyT^<� ugvx]ga?^?l}_�a'cf^T_x�nv7y?w#{$^<a?^?l c���]#^T_R�f^<m lG�'^Faih a ]#{$^<��cf^`_ �nv7yiw#{$^Fa?^il c �

*z0<(C+D&1&�.r!d( � .7� &19k"%0��¯��0I"%!L&1:/8%+D!L. ! {�"%:7KNM��°"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8 9°:7"%+1./�G8%M/0z&Y� ./�L:7� �L0<! {v8%!L��+'K�L02!L=�0>8%��9L�

�i028|��s > � "�� ��0§�x"%:/�%{[�LK~0�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8�9L��*z0�=?�)9��L"�"%:r=�0�8%M7� 8

� � � $ RR $

��� �(FMr0>��0 $ +Y"v�*oLSA8%MG��!#!L8V! {3:/.r+D8�9<� .�Z/!?+Y"VKE!Ltr��+D=�0P(C+D8%M or@^R 4 !-4 o/��5A.z8%!L��+'Kx8%02��=�"V8%M/0¨L:r!L8�+102.k8�+Y"�ZQ0~±7./0IZ��Q9�8�Mr0§K~!L./0����L02./02�E� 8%0wZy�Q9y��Rx�>� ��� .7Z � o �8�8! �����L"F� ��!d�L0 ���

*z0PK~!L.7"%8���:�KE8�8%M/0P��0I"%!L&1:/8%+D!L.y! {m8%M/0P"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8 9?�Q9¡ZQ+1�#+YZQ+1./��8�Mr0PKE!L.r0 �z+1.Q8�!u��{[� . � ´8%M/0�ZQ+D��+'"%+1!L.?ZQ0~±7./0I"^�V�/+1�E� 8%+D!L.7� &r=�� t�! {�8%!L��+'K��d� ��+10>8%+10w"�� .�Z�� &1&iO S6K~!L./0I"�+1.�� (F+1&D&��70�"%t7� .r./0IZ!L.y�7�L"%0I"�! {�� �6"%020V8�M/0VKE��+18%0>��+1!L.y!L.u./!L.rS6"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+18�9v! {³�x8%!L��+'K�� � ��+D028�9r�n�

O �

Page 26: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

��+1�E"%8>@�(�0yZQ+D��+'Z�0?8�Mr0uK~!L./0?�Q9z8n� 4�+D./� "7�A�²���7��R���8�Mr0u��0I"%:/&18�+1./��8%!L��+'K��d� ��+D028�9z+Y"PK~! �L0>��0IZ�Q9°8 (�!°�)©?./0��d� ��+10>8%+10w"2\ ��s�(FM/+YK�M,K~!L=�0I"x{|��!L= 8�Mr0�K~!L./0��6��Rx�>� �$�~�n�7��R������ .�Z,� ./!L8%M/02�?!L./0�L"�"%!kK~+Y� 8�0IZ 8�!?8%M/0�KE!L.r0��A���7��R��}�~��o��"� !a�����v*z0�K2� .�KNM7� ./�L0vK~!#!L�EZQ+1.7� 8%0w"�"%!?8%M7� 8�8%M/0v&Y� 8�8%02��!L./0+Y"�+Y"%!L=�!L��trM/+'K�8%! �~�3"%t7� .r./0IZ��Q9P�L0IK~8�!L�E"��6Rx�2� �m� .�Zy� o � �"� ! �2��@/(FMr0>��0(o �:� !v� .7Z�R�4 ! � 4 ox�+Y"FK~!Lt/��+1=�0�(C+D8%M�ox�I��s�M7� 8F+Y"2\

o�� x� !��/! � {|!L��"%!L=�0 x� �O � .�Z R�4 !#�94 !� .7Z�8�Mr0§KNM7� ./�L0�! {�KE!�!L�EZQ+1.7� 8�0I"�+'"��L+D�L02.y�k9�8%M/0V=�� 8%��+1�� R �V�

� � �5 {�o � � !|� ��8%M/02. � � � +Y"F"%=�!#!L8%M�� � 8%M/02��(F+Y"%03(�0V��02t70I� 8C8�M/+Y"�tr��!kK~0I"�"�:/.Q8�+1&Ro , � �L�

5A.�8%M/0�� ��!d�L0�KE!L.�"%8���:7K~8%+D!L.?�LZ/Z�+D./�V! {��V�E�)9v+D.?8%M/0C{[� .?+Y"�0I¨L:/+1�d� &10>.Q8�8�!P�LZrZQ+D.r�§� � � +D.?8%M/0��0I"%!L&D:r8�+1!L.���;�!L��02! �L0>��K~!L=�t�� ��+D./�x8�Mr0���0I"%:/&18�+1./��{[� .<(F+18%M�8�!L��+YK�� � ��+D028%+D0I"�ZQ0~±7.r+D./�,¢C+D��H202�/��:7KNM"%:/�%{[�LK~0I"C�6� .�Zy8�MQ:7" � � � "�(F+18%Mu./02�#� 8%+D�L0V./!L��=?� &��/:/.7ZQ&10I"~��9L!L:�K2� .<ZQ!P8%M/0�{|!L&1&1!d(C+D./�:9;RN<���7Q��#N YPs�Mr0�02�kK~02t/8�+1!L.7� &�"%0>8C! {^8�M/0V��0I"%!L&D:r8�+1!L.uK~!L.7"%+Y"%8n"�! {³��"%8���+1./�x! { � � �L"FZQ0I"�K~��+D��0IZu� 88%M/0v02.7Z?! {�8�M/0Vt/��02�#+1!L:7"�&D0IK~8�:r��0a�C;�!L��02!d�L02�I@Q8%M/0v"%0>&ª±7.Q8%0>�E"%0IK~8%+D!L.y! {^0w�LKNM�! {�8%M/02= +Y"C0w¨®:7� &�8%!��x��@Q(FM/02��0�8%M/0Vt7!#"%+18%+D�L0�+1.Q8�02�L02�� ��+Y"�!L�r8n� +1./0IZ�+1.�8�M/0�t/��!kK~0I"�"FZQ0I"�K~��+1�70IZ?� ��!d�L0L�

�C!L8�0V8%M7� 8F!L:/�C+D.�ZQ:7K~8�+1�L0�t/��!QK~0w"�"��L+1�L0I"F� ./!L8%M/02�Ftr��!#! {�! {^8%M/0V0w¨®:7� &1+D8�9

o! �� ��� �

s � ��������

ZQ+Y"�K~:7"�"%0IZ�+D.y8%M/0�tr��0>��+D!L:�"�&D0IK~8�:r��0a�

5A.�M/+D�LMr0>��ZQ+1=�02.7"%+D!L.�"F8%M/0PK~&Y�L"�"�! {m8%!L��+YKv"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�+10I"C+'"��r��!#�LZQ02�38%M7� .�8�M/0�K~&'�L"�"�! {FK~9kK~&1+'K"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"2�<�r!L�v02�k� =�t/&10L@�8�M/0��)©?./0?K~!L./0?! �L0>�x8�Mr0u¨L:7�LZ���+'K � � � � � � �EC�+Y"P� .�)©�.r08%!L��+'K��d� ��+D028�9��L"�"%!kK~+Y� 8�0IZx8�!P�VK~!L./0 ��� � C�"%t7� .r./0IZv!L.��L0IKE8%!L�E"��n�7��Rx��R��n@���Rx�2�7��R��n@r�6Rx��Rx�2� ��� .7Z���7�>�7�"�V� �n�

s�!L��+'K�"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�+10I"7� ��0��F��0I� :/8%+ {|:/&#"%:r�/��0IK~8>��¢C!d(�02�L02�I@IZQ:/��+1./��!L:/��"%0>��+10I"i! {Q&D0IK~8�:r��0w"«�70IK2� :7"%0! {�8%M/0<&Y�LK�4¯! {�8%+D=�0�(�0�(C+D&1&�./!L8��70z� �/&D0y8%!°t7�)9¯t/��!Lt702�?� 8%8�02.Q8�+1!L.,8%!G8%M/02=�� 5A. !L�EZQ02��8%!� t/t/��0IK~+Y� 8�0�8%M/+'"V"%:/�r��0wK~8V8�Mr0?��0I�LZQ02��+Y"��LZ��#+Y"%0wZW8�!�:7"%0���0~{|02��02.7K~0w"�&1+'"%8%0IZG� 8v8�Mr0�02.7ZW! {F8�M/0I"%0./!L8%0I"2�

OL�

Page 27: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

�§���«�7���/���:���,������������?����3�������^�������������s�Mr+'"�(�02024P(�0C(F+1&D&�ZQ+'"�K~:7"�"��V"%t70IK~+Y� &7K~&'�L"�"�! {«"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+18�+10I"2�� �"^:7"%:�� &D&19L@L(�03�L"�"%:/=�0�8%M7� 8��F�*�}@��+Y"��C./!L��=?� &#"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8 9a� �F!L��=?� &1+D8 93+1=�t/&1+D0I"i8%M7� 8-) � ; - �� ; - {|!L�³� .Q9���0I"%!L&1:/8%+D!L.�)z\���� ���! {^8�Mr0§"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8 9a�MAN7O�PRQTSUQWVXP'YHZ cf^T_x�nv7y?w#{$^<ad�u�F� �$@��J^dc ��w#y`y?l#m�{"wga?^?]#_�w#yR^Tj � � ) � ; - ��R�jF]#{(c�]#eHlJ{"l c�]#yFv�a?^i]#_ ]#jcf^T_x�nv7y?w#{$^<a?^il c )<\�� � ��� w#_Rm�q-4,R �

£�� 8�+1!L.7� &1+D8 9v+'"��V�L02��9�K~!L.Q�L0>.r+D02.Q8�t/��!Lt702��8�9L�^5 {��V� � ��+D028�9xM7�L"^�E� 8%+1!L.7� &7"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"�8%M/02.?+D8�"�L02!L=�0>8%��+YK�+D.Q�d� ��+Y� .Q8n"�Z�0E±�./0IZ��Q9�K~!LM/!L=�!L&1!L�L9�! {�8%M/0§"%8%��:7K~8%:/�E� &�"%Mr0w�){^K2� .��70�K~!L=�t/:/8%0IZ?!L.����0I"%!L&D:r8�+1!L.�! {�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+18�+10I"2��;�!L��0vt/��0IK~+'"%02&197\�"%:/t/t�!#"%0�8%M7� 8��¯+Y"���&1!kK2� &19y{|��020�"%M/0I�){F�A0L� �/�i8%M/0"%8%��:7K~8�:/�E� &/"%M/0I�){2��!L.��G@�8%M/02.�K~!LM/!L=�!L&1!L�L9�! {�) � �y!L.�����0I"%!L&1:/8�+1!L.�� � � ��0�8�M/0�"�� =�0F�L"�! {���!L.�G�^s�Mr+'"�+'"���0wK2� :7"%08) � ) � �*����� .7Z �

� ) � � ) � ����� R�{|!L�1q-4,RV"%!V8�M/0 �«0>�E�)9P"%t�0wK~8%�E� &7"%0I¨L:/02.7K~0{|!L� ) ���z+'"CZQ02�L02./02�E� 8�0L�

�i028C:7"���0IK2� &D&i8%M7� 8C8�M/0��i02�E�)9?"%t70IK~8��E� &�"%0I¨®:/02.7K~0

�� s � � � �F�*� � ) ��� � �� �

� � �F� � � � �

� &1&D! (3"x8%!°K~!L=�tr:/8�0<K~!LM/!L=�!L&1!L�L9G! {§�G"%Mr0w�){ � ! �L02�p� � :7"%+1./�z+18n"?Z�+D��0IK~8�+D=?� �L0I"�� .7Z¯8�Mr0>+1�K~!LM/!L=�!L&D!L�L9�! �L02�38%M/0P­ 8�� ���L0283"%t7�LK~0I­��G�3s�M/0 �«02�E�I9u"%t�0IK~8��E� &�"%0w¨®:/02.7K~0�=?�)9?��0v�#+10>(�0IZ��L"��"%t�0wK~+Y� &�K2�L"%0�! { � ��!L8%M/02.7ZQ+10IK�4?"%t70IK~8%�E� &�"%0w¨®:/02.7K~0P��"%020���02&D! (����

�i028x:7"v./!L8%0?8%M7� 8P+ª{�8�Mr0u� �7! �L0y�d� ./+Y"%M/+D.r� �� ) � ; - � R�(FMr0>��0Aq34 R�+Y"v8%��:/0?{|!L��"%!L=�0

��0I"%!L&D:r8�+1!L.,)W8�M/02.�+D8�+Y"F8%��:/0�{|!L��� .k9y��0I"%!L&D:r8�+1!L.���5A.7ZQ020IZi@�{|!L��"%:/�%{[�LK~0I"�8%M/+'"�K>� .���0v�L02��+ ±�0wZy�L"{|!L&1&D! (3"2���#:/t/t�!#"%0F8%M7� 8�(�0�M7�)�L0F8�(�!V��0I"%!L&D:r8�+1!L.7" )<\�� � ���²� .7Z �z\7� � � � �G��s�Mr0>.�(�0�K2� .t/��!QZQ:7K~0��PZ�!L=�+1.7� .Q8���0w"%!L&1:/8%+D!L.

��� � � �� � � � �� �

"%:7KNM�8%M7� 8�8%M/0�=?� t7" )��«\7��� � ��� ���i� .�Z � �i\���� � � � ��� �i� ��0�K~!L=�t�!#"%+D8%+D!L.�! {��/&1! (FS�ZQ! (F.7"2�i*z00I�L"%+D&19?�L02��+ª{|9u8%M7� 8����/&1!d(CS�ZQ!d(C.?! {m�y�$�V� �[S�K~:/���L0v"�� 8�+Y" ±70I"C8�M/0V�d� ./+Y"%M/+1./��! {�8%M/0vM/+1�LM/02�3ZQ+1��0IKE8+1=�� �L0�! {³8%M/0�"%8%��:7K~8%:/�E� &�"%M/0I�){��^s�M/02��0~{|!L��0

�� ) �� ; - � � � � � � ; - �,R {|!L� q-4Rx!

�C!d( (�0vK2� .¡� t/tr&D9�8�(�!x�L0>�E"%+1!L.7"�! { � ��!L8�M/02.7Z�+D0IK�4�"%t70IK~8%�E� &�"%0I¨L:/02.7K~0�� s � �

� ) � � � )��� ; - � ��� �� � � )� )�� � � ; -

� �� s � � � � � � � � � � ; -! � ��� �

� � ���� � � � � ; -! O ¦

Page 28: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

8%!�tr��!d�L0�8%M7� 8F8%M/0V�d� ./+Y"%M/+D.r� �� ) � ; - � R�+D=�t/&1+D0I"��d� .r+'"%M/+1./� �

� � � ; - � RP� .7Z��#+YK~02S[�L02�E"��Q�

�#+1=�+D&Y� ��&D9L@Q:7"%+1./� � ��!L8%M/02.7ZQ+10wKN4u"%t�0wK~8%�E� &^"%0w¨®:/02.7K~0v!L./0vt/��! �L0I"F8%M7� 8�¨®:/!L8%+D02.Q8�"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�+10I"� ��0��E� 8%+D!L.�� &[�'¢C02��0�+Y"F�vtr��!#! {�{|!L�FO S�ZQ+1=�02.7"%+D!L.�� &7¨L:/!L8%+10>.Q8�"2���i028�� \x� s ��� �70V8%M/0�¨L:r!L8�+102.k8=?� tu� .7Z�&D028�)�\ � ���²8%M/0V��0w"%!L&1:/8%+D!L.�! {^"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�+10I"2�k�C! ( (�0�8n� 4L0�� 8%!P��0§�xZQ0I"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��S+1Hw� 8%+1!L.�! {�8%M/0v±7��02��t/��!QZQ:7K~8���s �'-�� (F+18�Mz+1.7ZQ:7K~0IZ�=?� t7" � ��\�� � ��s�� .7Z )���\�� � ���*z0u4�./! ( 8�M�� 8P8%M/0u=?� t�� ��+Y"v�r+D�E� 8%+D!L.�� &F� .7Z )����L02./02��+'K2� &1&D9z±�./+D8%0L�¯*�0�K~!L.7"%+YZQ02�P"%t70IK~8��E� &"%0I¨L:/02.7K~0I"2\

�� s � �

� � � � � � � � ;�� � �� �� � ��� � �Y� � ;��

� �� s � �

� ) � � � )��� ;�� � �� �� � � ) .)��Y� � ;��

*z0P./!L8%0�8�M�� 8 � � s +Y"�Z�0>�L02./02�E� 8%0P+A� 0L��+18�+Y"�./!L./SAH202��!?!L./&19y{|!L� � � � ��RQ�PJ�:/8V(�0v./!L8%0�8�M7� 8{|��!L= 8%M/0v"%0w¨®:/02.7K~0 � � � s +18�{|!L&1&D! (3"�8�M7� 8

R�� � �� ) � � ) �� ;�� ����� �

� � ) .) � � � ;��� .7Zx8%Mk:�" �

� ) � � )��� ;�� ��=x:7"%8��70�H202��!/�'¢C!d(�02�L02�I@#"%+1.7K~0 )�+Y"��L0>.r0>��+YK2� &D&19�±7./+18�0�� .7Z � +'"�./!L��=?� &�A+D8C+'"�0>�L02.<"%=�!#!L8%Mi�^(�0�K2� .<ZQ0~±7.r0�8�Mr0�8��E�LK~0V=?� t

;�� � % �� �(! � A��%«�:) ;�� (CM/02��0 � ! � ���%«��� AQ�J� �ZQ02� � � � % � � � � � # � %«� ���

(FMr+'KNM¡"%t/&1+18n"�! � ;�� �L"F��ZQ+1��0IK~8F"%:/=�=�� .�ZP! { )��� ;�� ��s�M/0�"%:/= � ��! �L0�+'"�(�02&D&�ZQ0~±7.r0wZ�!L:/8�"%+'Z�08%M/0?�E� =�+ ±iK>� 8%+1!L.G&D!QK~:7"V! {38%M/0y=�� t )����/:/8P"%+1.7K~0�"%:�K�M � ! � � %«��+Y"v&1!kK2� &19���!L:/.7Z�0wZ � .7Z � +'"./!L��=?� &�+D8�ZQ0~±7./0I"��xM/!L&D!L=�!L��t/Mr+'Km{|:/.7K~8�+1!L.y!L.�����s�M/+Y"�t/��! �L0I"�8�Mr0��d� .r+'"%M/+1./�v! { �

� ) � ;�� �5A.�ZQ+1=�02.7"%+1!L.?Ox8�!L��+YK�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"�� ��0�¨L:r!L8�+102.k8�"2@/"%!P8%M/029u� ��0��E� 8%+1!L.7� &�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+18�+10I"2��s�M/+'"

"%8�� 8�02=�02.k8���02=?� +1.7"�8���:r0�+D.�Mr+D�LM/02�FZQ+1=�02.7"%+D!L.�"��L"�(�0>&1&A@/"%0>03 s�!L��!L+YZ/� &7¢�=P��0IZ/ZQ+1./�#" 9 �£�� 8�+1!L.7� &�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+18�+10I"�M7�)�L0�"%!L=�0��L02��9<./+YK~0?t/��!Lt�02��8�+10I"2@�(CM/+'KNMG� ��0�=�!#"%8V8��E� .�"%t7� ��02.k8�+1.

K2�L"%0�! {«"%:/�%{[�LK~0I"2�^ C�#� +D.�@L&D028 �\7��� ��� ��0�����0I"%!L&D:r8�+1!L.�! {«�v"%:/�%{[�LK~0�"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�9�@H)A� (C+D8%M8%M/0�02�QKE02t/8%+1!L.7� &�"%028 � �|�[��*�0V:7"%0�8%M/0V02�k�LK~83"%0I¨L:r0>.�KE0

R�� � " � � ; - � D ����x� � ; �- � � R

! {�"%M/0I�I�L0I"�! {^�L��!L:/t7"�!L.A� � � .�Z�(�0�tr:7"%M?+18�{|!L��(F� �EZ�8%!,�²8%!��L028

R�� � �� � � �|�<� " ��� � � �

� � � ; - � D � � � �� � � ; �- � D � � � s ��� �|��� " ����� R

�A(�0P+YZQ02.k8%+ª±70IZy8�M/0�"%M/0I�I�L0I" �� � � � " �3"%:/t/t�!L��8�0IZ�� 8�8%M/0xt7!L+1.Q8 @�(C+D8%M<�L&1!L�7� &^K~!LM/!L=�!L&D!L�L9uK~!LS

M/!L=�!L&1!L�L9 �� � � �|�<� " ������5A8F+Y"�0I�L"%9?8%!?"%020�8�M�� 8F8%M/0§� ��! �L0�"%0I¨L:/02.7K~0�+Y"�02�k�LK~82�

O�U

Page 29: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

s�Mr0<�L��!L:/t � �� � � ; �- � D +Y"�8%M/0GX^+YK2� �EZ�L��!L:/t! {P�G.r0>+1�LMQ�7!L:r��M/!#!QZ¯! {.� �|����X�:7"%M/+1./�

{|!L��(F� �EZ,Z�+D��+'"%!L�E"x{|��!L= ����Z�!d(C. 8%! � 4#+1&1&'"��¯"%:/�/�L��!L:/t "%t7� ././0IZ �k9 �|� � "u� .7Z ZQ0~±7.r0w"y�"%:/�A��0IK~8�+1�L0�=?� ty!L.k8%!��xZQ+1�#+Y"%!L�3K~&'�L"�"��L��!L:/t

7v� ; -JI D ��\ � *z02+D&�ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L�E"�� 8�@tr��+D.7K~+1t7� &7ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L�E" !

s�Mr+'"�9#+10>&YZ/"C� .u+Y"%!L=�!L��t/M/+Y"%=7v� ; -:I D ��� � �

� � � ; �- � D " �|� !

�C!d( (�0�K2� .u:7"%0V!L:/��8%!Lt7!L&1!L�L+YK>� &�K~!L.7"%8���:�KE8%+1!L.?(FM/+YK�My(F�L"�02��t/&'� +1./0IZ�8�(�!P(�02024k"�� �L!P8%!��L0283�"%0I¨L:/02.7K~0

R�� � �� � � � � � " ����� � �

� � � ; �- �fD�� � 7v� ; - I�� ����x� � � � � 2 � " � 8%!L�E" � � R

(FMr0>��0�8%M/0�=?� t���8%!�� .�0 � 0wK~8%+D�L0vZQ+1�#+Y"%!L� ��� �²�L"�"%!kK~+Y� 8�0I"�+18n"�+1.Q8�02�E"%0IK~8�+1!L.?(C+D8%M?8%M/0�8�:/�r:/&'� �./02+1�L�7!L:/��Mr!#!kZ 2 ��;�!L��0�t/��0IK~+Y"%0>&19

��� �?��� � � � � � �|�|�����(FMr0>��0�8�M/0V&1!#!Lt7" �'��� ��0�8�Mr0��L02./02�E� 8%!L�E"�! { � �I� 22� " � 8%!L�E" ZQ+'"�K~:7"�"%0IZ�8 (�!P(�02024k"F� �L!/�:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y =�M/0IK�4�8�M7� 8C8�Mr0�� �7! �L0v"%0w¨®:/02.7K~0�+Y"�02�k�LK~82�

5 {��F� �$@���+Y"F�x�E� 8%+D!L.7� &i"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8�9x8�Mr0>.y8%M/0§� ��! �L0�"%0I¨L:/02.7K~0vZQ02�L0>.r0>�E� 8%0I"�8�!

7v� ; -:I D ��� � �I� 22� " � 8�!L�E" !s�MQ:7"2@�{|!L���E� 8%+D!L.�� &�"%:/�%{[�LK~0�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+10w"C8%M/0?ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L�§K~&Y�L"�"��L��!L:/t�+'"�8%!L�E"%+D!L.��x*z0?"��I9�+1.z8�M/+Y"K2�L"%0�8%M7� 8�8%M/0P"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18�9�+Y"���� .7� &19#8%+'K2� &1&D9r���PS {[�LKE8%!L��+Y� &[�Fs�M/+Y"��A�Q9u����0I"%:/&18F!L.�K���:/&1&i��+D./�#"~��+'"0I¨L:/+1�d� &102.k8C8�!�8�M/0�{[�LK~8�8�M7� 8C8�Mr0v&D!QK>� &���+D.r� ; -JI D +'"�� &1=�!#"%8�{[�LKE8%!L��+Y� &[@r8�M7� 8C+'"2@�"%!L=�0�t7! (�02��%  ! {�� .Q9P{|:r.7K~8�+1!L. % ) ; -:I D +Y"F�xt/��!QZQ:7K~8�! {�t/��+1=�0�02&D02=�02.Q8n"�! { ; -JI D �:9;RN<���7Q��#N YX^��! �L0�ZQ+1��0IK~8�&19z�[0L� �/��:�"%+D./��8�!L��+YKv�L02!L=�028���9r�38%M7� 8�+ª{(��s > " � +Y"��yK~9kK~&1+'K�¨L:r!L8�+102.k8"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8�9��[!L�I@Q0I¨®:/+D� � &D02.Q8�&19L@Q8�!L��+YKV"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�9/��8%M/02.u8%M/0vZQ+D��+'"%!L�FK~&Y�L"�"��L��!L:/t�+'" " � �:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y<X���!d�L0V8�M�� 83+ª{F�F�*�}@��3+Y"��?K~!L./0P"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8 9��L"�"%!QK~+'� 8%0IZ�8%!u� �^02��!L./0I"%0v02=P��0IZ/ZQ+1./�� �

� � � � 8%M/02.z8�Mr0PZQ+D��+'"%!L��K~&Y�L"�"��L��!L:/t�! {�8�M/0P"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+18�9?+Y"��L02./02�E� 8�0IZ��Q9���&1+D./0V{|��!L= 8%M/0��:/&1+D.r�v! {³8%M/0vK~!L./0L�

5 {F8%M/0u"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8 9u+Y"��E� 8%+1!L.7� &^8%M/02.G8�Mr0�� ��! �L0�"%0I¨®:/02.7K~0�+1=�t/&1+D0I"�8�M7� 8 �� � � �|�<� " �G� R�� .7Z

8%Mk:�" � �|�3+Y"���8���020y! {§"%=�!#!L8%M�E� 8�+1!L.7� &FK~:/���L0I"2�s�M/+Y"x&'� 8%8�02����02=?� ��4�M��L"P+18�"Ptr��!#! {�+D.8%M/0� &1�L0>�r��!LS[�L02!L=�028���+YK�"%028�8%+D.r�/�

O 1

Page 30: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

��+1�E"%8>@ M/! (�02�L02�I@d(�0�M��I�L0�8%!���0IK2� &1&/8�Mr0F./!L8%+D!L.x! {«� ��+18%M/=�0>8%+YK��L0>.Q:7"�{|!L��� .Q9?�2S6K~9QKE&10���ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L�2�!L.G�u"%=�!�!L8�Mz"%:/�%{[�LK~0a���«0>8 7 \ � � x� 7J�^�70�� .�0 � 0IKE8%+1�L0¡�2S�K~9kK~&10P!L.z�u"%=�!#!L8%M¯�[tr��!L��0IKE8%+1�L0d�"%:/�%{[�LK~0 �m@)8�Mr0�K~!L=�t�!L./02.Q8n"�7J�k� t/t�0I� ��+D./��+1.�8%M/0�ZQ0IK~!L=�t7!#"%+18%+D!L.�� ��0��L"�"%:/=�0wZC8%!��70^+1����0IZQ:7K~+1�/&D0L@8%M/0�KE!�0~©�K~+102.k8�" x��� ��0Ft�!#"%+D8%+1�L0F+1.k8%02�L02�E"2��*z0�K2� .uZQ0~±7./0���"�KNM/02=�0L@L(CM/+YK�M�(�03� �#� +1.?ZQ02./!L8�0C�Q97P@L(CM/!#"%03"%:/trt7!L��8�+Y"�� 7J��� .7Zx(FMr!#"%03"%8%��:7K~8�:/�E� &/"%M/0I�){ ;�� +Y"�ZQ0~±7.r0wZ��L"�8�Mr0�¨®:/!L8%+D02.Q8�K~!L=�+D./�{|��!L= 8%M/0v"%0w¨®:/02.7K~0

R���� ;�� �$� � � x� 7J�|��� � ;�� ��� ;�� � � Rx!5 {�� 7:�i+Y"�KE!L.r./0IKE8%0IZu� .�Z?��0IZQ:7K~0IZ�8%M/02. �

6 �(7 � ;�� ���2���*z0�ZQ0~±7./0F8%M/0�� ��+18�M/=�028%+'KC�L02.Q:7"�! { 7P@�ZQ02./!L8�0IZx�Q9����(7v�n@Q�L"�8%M/0�ZQ+D=�02.7"%+1!L.P! { �

� �(7(� ; � �n��C!d(V@Q(�0�K2� .�t/��! �L038%M/0�{|!L&D&1! (F+1./���N56 6 ��Y �Fj )�\�� � ��� ^dcJw �^T{"wgai^?]#_�w#y~eH]#{f[~h�^dcfe ]#j _�]#{$eAw#ync"v7{$jFwg��l cJw#_Rm � ^Wc�w#_El�� l#�"ai^ ��l� ��� �.�fyil���]#_�ai{"wg�"a lUm U� ) a?h�l$_

��� �����2m7^Tepr � � ) � ; - !�F_ [Rw#{#a?^<�"v7y?w#{���^`j�) ^Wc0wp{"l c�]#yFv�ai^?]#_�]#jJw{"wga?^i]#_�w#y'cf^T_x�nv7y?w#{$^<ad� a?h�l$_ w#_g��l�� l#�8a?^ ��l � ��� �.�fy?l� ]#_ �a?{"wg�8a l#m'U� ) h�w c|w#{$^Faih eHl#a?^<����l}_�vgc�� � h.v&c ��^Tj�� �(� ^dc|aih�l l��n��lf[ka?^i]#_�w#y yi]x�"vgc|]#j ) a?h�l$_H^Fa�^dcw�a?{"l8l|]#j�{"wgai^?]#_�w#y��8v�{���l c�eAl"lUa?^T_x�Hai{"w#_~c���l}{ c�w#y���na���] wga�]#_�l�[k]#^T_�a'wga�eA] c"a)�?_�]ga lGa?h�wga�w� [~{$^i]#{$^��lGm7^Fm�_�]ga1w c$c"v7eAl(a?h�wga:a?h�l�{"l c�]#yFv�a?^i]#_ ^dc �f��]g]�m ��� ��5� V V $Y��#+D.�KE0V8%M/0P¨L:/0I"%8%+D!L.�+Y"C&D!QK2� &i{|��!L= 8�M/0vt�!L+1.k8C! {^�#+10>( ! {�� (�0V=?�I9y�L"�"%:/=�0�8�M�� 83+18�+'"�)©?./0�� .7Z�)�������+Y"F��t7!L+1.Q8>� �i028F:7"CK~!L.7"%+'Z�0>��8%M/0V02�k�LK~83"%0I¨L:r0>.�KE0vZQ0~±7./+1./�v8%M/0vKE9QK~&D0���\

R�� � ; - �}� ����� � ; - � � ;�� ��� Rx!*z0�8�� 4L0V8�M/0vZQ+1��0IKE8�+1=?� �L0�8%!��L028C8�M/0�0>�Q�LK~8�"%0I¨®:/02.7K~0�! {�KE!LMr!L=�!L&1!L�L97\

�� ) � ; - � � �

� ) � ;�� � � � ���:� ;�� ��� � � s ) � ; - �$� ���

(FMr0>��0C8�Mr03&Y�L"%8^8%02��=��d� ./+Y"%M/0I"��70IK2� :7"%0F8%M/0C±7��02��+Y"^! {�Z�+D=�02.7"%+1!L.?�L��s�Mr+'"^K~!L.7K~&1:7ZQ0I"�8�M/0�t/��!�! {��

*z0§Z�0E±�./0�./! (�8%M/0�.r!L8�+1!L.u! {���j�v7_Rm w#eHl$_�a w#yk� �.�fy?l��,{|!L��8%M/0V��0w"%!L&1:/8%+D!L.y! {��x�E� 8�+1!L.7� &�"%+1./�L:/S&Y� ��+D8�9L�

�i028�)¯\ � � � � ��0P���L!#!kZ���0I"%!L&1:/8�+1!L.�! {m��./!L��=?� &�"%:/�%{[�LK~0v"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18�9H@ )�� (F+18%M�8%M/002�kK~02t/8%+D!L.7� &�"%0>8 � � � �^��+1�E"%8�(�0FK~!L.7"%+YZQ02�^8�Mr0��2S6K~9QKE&103Z�0E±�./0IZv�Q9�8%M/0Ct/:/&1&DSA�7�LKN4�! {78%M/0F=?� �#+1=?� &+YZQ0I� &�B*D�+1. ; -JI Da���A*�0?K2� &1&^+D8v"%!L=�028�+1=�0w"�8�M/0x±7��02�§"%8%��:7K~8%:/��0v! { ) � � ��@��n�ª��; !L��0Pt/��0IK~+Y"%0>&19L@+1.8�M/0<"%8%��:7K~8%:/�E� &F"%M/0I�){ ; - (�0¡K~!L.7"%+YZQ02�P8%M/0<"%M/0I�){�! {�+'Z�0w� &Y",B*D�� ; - �L02./02�E� 8%0wZ¯�Q9G8%M/0t/:/&1&1�7�LK�4Q"�! {�{|:r.7K~8�+1!L.7"�{|��!L= 8%M/0V=�� ��+D=?� &�+'Z�0w� &RB D ���C! (�(�0�"%028

; - �}� ����\�� � B D � ; - � � �OLT

Page 31: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

(FMr0>��0 � ��\ ��� #�B�� � � ; �FZQ02./!L8%0I"�8%M/0vZQ:7� &�"%M/0I�){�! {��x"%M/0I�){ � ��J�02+D./����0��702�#+1�L0�� .7Z�! {^�E� ./4� ; -! �$� ���^+'"�+D.Q�L02��8�+1�/&10�� .7ZuZ�0E±�./0I"F�PZ�+D��+'"%!L� � "%:/trt7!L��8%0IZ�!L. � �|�A�� 0>!L=�028%��+'K2� &1&D9 � K2� .y�70vK~!L.7"%8���:�KE8%0IZ?�L"�{|!L&1&1!d(�"2\�(�0�8�� 4L0v�V{|:/.7K~8%+D!L.*%*) ; -JI D � � ./+'"%Mr+D./�

� 8:@�� .7Z?K~!L.7"%+YZQ02��8%M/0�t/��+1.7K~+Dt�� &7ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L��� ) �I��%«���F�L"�"%!kK~+Y� 8�0IZ�8%!�+D8�"�tr:/&D&1SA�7�LK�4�% )<Z�0E±�./0IZ�!L.��� ��s�Mr0�t/��+1.7K~+1t7� &7ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L�3K2� .y�70V(F��+18�8%02.¡�L"m{|!L&D&1! (3"2\

� ) � ��%i�%��� � � � x� �|�|��F �(FMr0>��0�8�M/0v"%:/t/t�!L��8�! { � ZQ!�0w"C./!L8FK~!L.Q8�� +D.�� .Q9 �|��� .�Zu� &1&�x�^� ��0�t�!#"%+D8%+D�L0L�'�C! (�(�0�8�� 4L0

� ��\���=�+1. � ��\�� ) � � %«�%����� � � x� �|�A��F �}{|!L��%�)*B D � ; -JI D �� .7Z�(�0�"%028

��\�� � � � � �(��!��N56 6 ��Y h�l c�lGa���],mxl ��_�^Fai^?]#_ncJw"�g{"l"l ��5� V V $Y9�i0289A,)H� � ��0��Vt�!L+D.Q8�!L.u8%M/0�02�QKE02t/8%+1!L.7� &�"%028 � �|�[�"=�&10I� ��&D9L@®{|��!L= 8%M/0�K~!L.7"%8%��:7K~8%+D!L.+18�{|!L&1&D! (3"�8%M7� 8 B D � ; -! TI # � ; -! TI # �}� � � � � �(� ��� ; - `I # !�C!d( &10>8�:7"�./!L8%0<8%M7� 8?+ª{�%�� .7Z % ��� ��0<8�(�!z{|:r.7K~8�+1!L.7"�{|��!L= B D �d� ./+Y"%M/+D.r�W� &1!L./� �|��(C+D8%M=P:r&D8%+Dtr&D+YK~+D8�9 x��� .�Z��� � @Q��0I"%t70IK~8%+D�L02&19a@Q8%M/02.y8�M/02+1�F�L02./02�E� &�&D+1./0I� �FK~!L=P�/+1.7� 8%+D!L. ~% F "g% ���A(FM/02��0 ?� .7Z�"P� ��0FK~!L=�t/&10>�v.Q:/=x�702�E"~���d� ./+Y"%M/0I"�� &1!L./� �|�7(C+D8%M�=P:/&18%+Dt/&1+YKE+18�9V=�+D.R� �i� �� � /L�^s�M/02��0~{|!L��0L@8%M/02��0v0>��+'"%8�"��x{|:r.7K~8�+1!L.L%�) ; -JI D (CM/+YK�M��d� ./+Y"%M/0I"�� &D!L.r�u���L02./02��+'K�t�!L+D.Q8�! {�0I�LK�M�! {!�|��(C+D8%M=P:r&D8%+Dtr&D+YK~+D8�9 � ����J�:r8F8%M/02.u8%M/0V0>=x�70IZQ+1./�

% � ; - I # � � ; - I # �}� � � � � �|�|�+Y"V+'"%!L=�!L��t/M/+Y"%=�"C!L:/8�"%+YZQ0?��±7./+18�0?"%028>��s�M/02��0~{|!L��0L@��Q9��y�L02./02�E� &�t/��!Lt�0>��8 9�! {�ZQ:7� &1+Y"�� 8�+1!L.<(�0K~!L.7K~&D:�ZQ0�8%M7� 8

� B D � ; - � � � � ; - �}� � � � � �|�|�$!�r!L���E� 8�+1!L.7� &�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"�!L./0�=?�)9�KNM/0IK�4?8%M7� 8�B D � ; - +Y"�+1.Q�L02��8�+1�/&10�� .�Z

B D � ; - ~� ; -! �$� � � � � �|� �}!s�Mr+'"�+'"�./!L8�8���:r0�+1.u�L02./02�E� &A�

¤ R

Page 32: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

:9;��6 � �WN�Y �«0>8 7 ��03�VK~:/���L0�! {�t�!#"%+18�+1�L0F�L02.Q:7"^� .7Z�&D028 � ��03��&D+1./0��/:/.�ZQ&D0�! �L02�.7,! {it7!#"%+18%+D�L0ZQ02�L��020�(CM/+YK�My+'"C./!L8C�L0>.r0>�E� 8%0IZy�Q9?�L&D!L��� &�"%0IK~8�+1!L.7"2� �i028�����\ � �<� � �C�70v��8%!L8n� &�"%t7�LK~0�! {�8%M/0&1+D./0C�/:/.7Z�&D0 � (C+D8%Mu�VH202��!§"%0IK~8�+1!L. 7163� .�Z�K~!L.7"%+YZQ02�^8%M/0�K~!L&D&Y� t7"%+1./��! {-7�6C8%!v8�Mr03�L02��8%02�p@*)A����L"3Z�+'"�K~:7"�"%0IZx+D.-�i0IK~8%:/��0�� ��\

)�\7� � � �<� � ��� � ��� � ��� � !:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y =�M/0IK�4?8%M7� 8�8%M/0�tr:/&D&1�7�LKN4 ) �)� %«�F! {�� .Q9u"%0IKE8%+1!L. % ) � 6 � 7(� � ���d� ./+Y"%M/0I"�� &D!L./� 7�6(F+18%Mu=x:/&D8%+1t/&D+YK~+D8 9¡�L�^s�M/02.utr��!d�L0�8%M7� 8C8�M/0vK~!L4L02��./02&7! {^8%M/0�02=x�70IZ/ZQ+1./�

B D � ; - � � ; - �$� 716I�+Y"F"%:/t/t�!L��8%0wZ�!L.�8�M/0��7�L"%02S[t�!L+1.k8�&1!kK~:7"C! { � �*z0PK2� .WK~!L=�t/:/8%0V8�M/0�{|:/.7Z/� =�02.Q8n� &�K~9QKE&10P! {F� . � � � � � "%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8�9�:7"%+1./��+18n"�02=x�70IZ/ZQ0IZ��0I"%!L&D:r8�+1!L.z(FM/+YK�MG(�0yZQ+'"�K~:7"�"%0IZ +D. �i0IK~8�:r��0uOQ���i028x:7"vZQ+Y"�KE:�"�"�8%M/0uK2�L"%0�! { � � �L+1�L02.G�Q9�8%M/00I¨L:7� 8%+1!L.L@ F A�C F �7s�� RQ���i028 � � � C � � s � �X� � ��Cv��0P8%M/0P"%0I¨L:/02.7K~0x! {��/&1!d(CS[:rt7"(FMr+'KNM?(�0�M7�)�L0�t702�%{|!L��=�0IZ?"%!L&D��+D.r�v8�M/+Y"�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8�9v+1.-�i0IK~8�:/��0VOQ�^*z0�ZQ02./!L8%0�8%M/0�02�kK~02t/8%+D!L.7� &ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L�E"�! {F0I�LKNMG! {38%M/02= �k9������[�Q9z� �/:7"%0�(�0�(F+1&D&�:7"%0�8�Mr0�"�� =�0�.7� =�0x{|!L�P� .G02�kK~02t/8%+D!L.7� &ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L�3� .7Z�{|!L��+D8�"F"%8%��+YKE8C8��E� .�{|!L��=}´ � &D8%M/!L:/�LMy8�Mr0>9y� ��0§ZQ+ � 0>��02.Q8"¡ �����r!L�F8%M/0V=�� ��+D=?� &i+YZQ0I� &BA6�! {^R�) � CV(�0�(F+1&D&�±7.�Z?8%M/0�"%M/0I�){�BA6 � ;���� �^*z0�±7�E"%8�.r!L8�0V8�M�� 8

B 6 � ; � � � ; � � �$��� � �(FMr+'KNMP+Y"�+D=�=�0IZQ+Y� 8�0�{|��!L= 8%M/03Z�0E±�./+D8%+1!L.P! {i8�M/0C�/&1!d(CS[:rtv! {«��"%=�!�!L8�M�t�!L+D.Q82�k�C! ((�03K~!L=�t/:/8%08%M/0�8%!L8�� &�8%�E� .7" {|!L��= ! { ;�� �2�}�����2��+1.�8�02��=?"�! {^+18n"�"%8%��+'K~8F8%�E� .7" {|!L��= ��K>� &1&10wZy�Q9?� �/:7"%0��'�2�F� .7Z8%M/0���02=�� +1./+1./��02�kK~02t/8�+1!L.7� &/ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L�E"2� � �L0>� � s 8%M/0���0I"%:/&18�+Y"1��������� s �^s�M/02.�@L"%+1.7K~0�(�0��/&1!d(CS[:rt�Vt�!L+D.Q8�!L.���� ��� s (�0��L028(�������� s ��O� C !L. � C � .7Zi@�+D.�8�M/0�0>.�Zi@k"%+1.7K~0�(�0��/&D! (:/tu��t7!L+1.Q8!L.��'����� C (�0��L028 BA6 � ;���� � ;���� �}������� � s �GO� C � ¤ � �}!*z0?KE!L=�t/:r8�0x8�M/0���0I"%8%��+'K~8%+D!L.z! {F8%M/+'"v"%Mr0w�){�8%!�8�M/0���0I"%!L&1:/8�+1!L. � � � � ! {F8�M/0?"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8 9u+1.¨L:r0w"%8%+1!L.��^*z0�"%028

O �(��\ ����� �"��� � s F�� �s \���� s �"���� \ ��� �"��� � C F�� �C \���� C �"���

�A(�03��0IK2� &1&k8%M7� 8 �|�m(F�L"��vZQ!L:/�/&10�&D+1./0C+D.�8%M/0C±7�E"%8^�/&1!d(CSA:/ti����s�M/02��0~{|!L��0F(�0C�L028�8%M/0�ZQ0I"�K~��+Dt/8%+1!L.! {^8�Mr0�{|:/.�Z/� =�0>.Q8��L"%&7K~9kK~&10

� � O �|��F � s F � �s F°O � C F°O � �C F ¤ � !:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y�=�!L=�t/:/8%0V8�M/0�{|:/.7Zr� =�02.Q8�� &�KE9QK~&D0V{|!L��!L8%M/02� � ��� � �}"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18%+D0I"2���?>^!L:�=��)9K�Mr0wKN4�8�M/0v"%!L&1:/8�+1!L.?(C+D8%M 3 J�� ��8%M/S�X�028%0>�E"%S ��� .?ZQ0 �^02. 9 t���ULU#�ª�

¤ �

Page 33: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

�§���«�7���/���:�������~� ��3��������3�������^�����������z���� �G��3���� �����?����3�������^�������������s�Mr0>��0V� ��0�"%02�L0>�E� &i(F�)9k"�8%!?ZQ0~±7./0�8%M/0vK2� ./!L./+YK>� &iZQ+1�#+Y"%!L���,- !L.��v./!L��=?� &��d� ��+D028�9 �G��5 {'� +'""%=�!#!L8%M��d� ��+D028�9v! {�Z�+D=�02.7"%+1!L.��?8%M/02.�(�0F8�� 4L038%M/02.?"%M/0I�){�! {�=�02��!L=�!L��t/M/+YK'��S {|!L��=?"��C- ���  - �s�Mr0P"%M/0I�){�'- +Y"�+1.k�L02��8%+D�r&D0�� .�Z�8%Mk:�"3�L"�"%!QK~+'� 8%0IZy8�!u� =m� ��8%+D02�v��� .7Zy*z02+D& �3ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L���,-v�V5 {��+Y"F.r!L83"%=�!#!L8%M��/:/8C=�02��02&19?./!L��=?� &i8�Mr0>.�(�0vK~!L.7"%+YZQ02�F8%M/0§"%028�! {�"%=�!#!L8%M�t7!L+1.Q8n"J�p6 � � � .7Z02�#8%02.7ZG8%M/0?*z02+1&FZQ+D��+'"%!L��,- & 8�!z�<ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L���,- !d�L02���G� �#+1.7K~0� +Y"V./!L��=?� &�8%M/02.�� � �,6+Y"V! {�K~!kZQ+1=�02.7"%+D!L.GO�� .7Zz8%Mk:�"�� - +Y"V(�0>&1&FZQ0~±7./0IZz�L"P�y*z02+1&FZQ+D��+'"%!L�I��s�M7� 8v+'"2@���0IK2� :7"%0?! {8%M/0v./!L��=?� &D+18�9�! {'� 8%M/+'"�ZQ0~±7.r0w" � - �L"��x&D+1./0I� ��0w¨®:/+1�d� &D02.7K~0vK~&'�L"�"2�F C&Y"%!/@/!L./0vK2� .�ZQ0~±7.r0�� .�L"�"%!kK~+Y� 8�0IZ�"%M/0I�){�� - 8%!y�70�ZQ+D��0IK~8�+D=?� �L0v! {�� - & !L��8%M/0�ZQ!L:r�/&D0PZ�:7� &�! {m8%M/0�"%Mr0w�){�! {tK��� M/&10>�ZQ+ � 02��02.Q8�+Y� &Y"��� - ��s�M/0I"%0�ZQ0~±7.r+D8%+D!L.�"�� ��0�0I¨L:/+1�d� &10>.Q8C�70IK2� :7"%0(� +Y"F�L"�"%:/=�0IZ�8%!���0�./!L��=?� &A�

5A.?�L02./02�E� &��,- ZQ!�0I"�./!L8�M7�)�L0�8�!x�700=m� ��8%+D02�I@�./02+D8%M/02���[0I¨®:/+D� � &D02.Q8�&19/���C- M7�L"�8%!P��0�+D.Q�L02��8%S+1�/&D0L�^�r!L��!L:r��t/:r��t7!#"%0C+D8�(C+D&1&7��0�K~!L.k�L02./+102.Q8^8�!��L"�"%:/=�0�8�M�� 8F"%!L=�0�=x:/&D8%+1t/&D0�! {��,- +'" =�� ��8�+102�I�*z0�"��)9P8%M/02.?8�M�� 8��p- +Y"��PS/=m� ��8%+D02�I�^s�Mr+'"2@ {|!L��02�Q� =�tr&D0L@Q+Y"��LK�M/+102�L0wZx+ª{�8%M/0�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+10w"³! {k�� ��0�+Y"%!L&'� 8%0IZu� .�Z?M/0VZQ+D��+'"%!L��K~&'�L"�"��L��!L:/ty! {�0I�LKNM�! {�8%M/02= +Y"�±7.r+D8%0L�:9;RN<���7Q��#N YvX^��! �L0F8%M7� 8�+ {^�F�*�}@��^+'"��vK~!L./0�"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�9v�L"�"%!kK~+'� 8%0IZ�8%!P��B?SA8%M ��0>��!L.r0w"%0C02=P��0wZ�SZQ+1./� � �

� ��� � 8%M/02.u8%M/0�K2� ./!L.r+'K2� &iZQ+D��+'"%!L��+Y"�0I¨®:7� &i8�!A����B FWO����i(FM/02��0��i+'"C�v&1+D./0�{|��!L= 8%M/0��:/&1+D.r�v! {³8%M/0vK~!L./0L�:9;RN<���7Q��#N YE�«0>8�7,��03�V"%=�!#!L8%M�K~:/���L03� .�Z � � .?� =�t/&10�&D+1./0��/:/.�ZQ&D0�!L.�7 "%:�K�Mv8%M7� 8 � � !�� � @(FMr0>��08!�+Y"^���E� 8%+1!L.7� &Q.k:r=P��0>�I��X^��! �L0�8�M�� 8�8%M/03K2� ./!L.r+'K2� &/ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L�^! {�8%M/0�K~!L./03"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+18�91��� � �+Y"��PS {[�LK~8�!L��+Y� &A�:9;RN<���7Q��#N Yx�6K � {��k3 £F02+YZ 9 t�� ¤ �LR�� �i028

� \���� ���#67�"!"!"!"�}�   ��) �  �� � \$%«� � 6g�"!"!"!8�$�   �'� Rx/��0��yMQ9#t�02�E"%:/�%{[�LK~0§ZQ0~±7.r0wZ �Q9<��{|:/.�KE8%+1!L. %��y�#:/trt7!#"%0v8%M7� 8 � % > � � 6 Z�!#0I"�.r!L8��d� ./+Y"%M<02�L02��9#S(FMr0>��0L� =�!L.7"%+'Z�0>��8%M/0V02�#t/��0I"�"%+1!L.

� � og��� � !"!8! � og�  � % > � � 6 !X���!d�L0�8%M7� 8�� .k9K��� M/&10>�:��S {|!L��=}! �L0>�C8�Mr0§"%=�!#!L8%My&D!QKE:�"�! {'�²+Y"��v=P:r&D8%+Dtr&D0�! { � � .7Z�8�MQ:7"

�C- � � � ; - !:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y��#:/t/t�!#"%0�8%M7� 8 ����� ���������P�F+Y"��?"%=?� &D&�"%:/�/�L��!L:/ty(F+18�Mz��¨L:/!L8%+D02.Q8�� � �   > �§�X���!d�L0v8%M7� 8V8�M/0�{|!L��= og��� � !"!8! � og�   +'" �3SA+1.Q�d� ��+'� .Q8�� .7ZzZQ0I"�KE02.Q8�"�8�!���./!L./SA�d� ./+Y"%M/+1./�x{|!L��=ZQ0~±7./0IZ�!L.u8%M/0v"%=�!#!L8%Mu&1!kK~:7"�! {k�G��s�M/02.�@/�L"C� �7! �L0L@/K~!L./&D:�ZQ0�8�M7� 8��,- +'"(=m� ��8%+D02�I�

*z0�(F� .k8�8%!��L"�"%:/=�0��,- 8%!P��0 �PS/=m� ��8%+D02����0IK>� :�"%038%M/02.?(�0�K2� .?t/:/&1&�+D8��7�LK�4��L"�+ {�+D8�(F�L"��=m� ��8%+10>��ZQ+D��+'"%!L�I��;�!L��0Ct/��0IK~+'"%02&19a@L"%:/trt7!#"%0�8%M7� 81B��,- +'"���=�� ��8�+102�mZQ+1�#+Y"%!L��� .7Z�&D028 )z\���� ���

¤ O

Page 34: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

��0§��=�!L��t/Mr+'"%= �[0L� �/�7�x��0I"%!L&D:/8%+1!L.u! {m"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+18�+10I"�! {C�z���Fs�M/02.�(�0§K2� .<ZQ0~±7./0�8�M/0vtr:/&D&1SA�7�LK�4) �I��B��,-V����5A.yt7� ��8�+YK~:/&Y� �I@#+ª{ )�+Y"�8%M/0���0I"%!L&1:/8%+D!L.?! {�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+10w"�8%M/02.�(�0�K2� .�(F��+18�0

�,- �� �B ) � � B �,-v��F � � � �|�(FMr0>��0��|� � "�� ��0�0>�QK~0>tr8�+1!L.7� &3Z�+D��+'"%!L�x! { ) �A+[� 0L�^8%M/029�� ��0<K~!L.Q8��E�LK~8%0IZ¯8�!z�d� ��+1028�+10I"�! {§"%=?� &D&102�ZQ+1=�0>.�"%+D!L.i�^� .7Z x� � "F� ��0({"wga?^i]#_Xw#yn_�v7e xl${ c2��s�M/0�.Q:/=x�702�� ��+'"CK2� &D&10IZ�m7^Wc"�f{"lf[Rw#_R� �?! { �|���:9;RN<���7Q��#N Y �«0>81)\��� ; � � ��B ��� � ��� ; � � � B �%�3��0�8�M/0x��0I"%!L&D:/8%+1!L.<! {F�uK~!L./0x!d�L02� �^02��!L./0I"%002=P��0IZ/ZQ+1./� � � ��� � �^X���! �L038%M7� 8�8%M/0�ZQ+Y"�K~��02t7� .7K~9v! {�8%M/0�:/./+Y¨L:/0�02�kK~02t/8%+D!L.�� &�ZQ+D��+'"%!L��! { ) +'"0I¨L:7� &i8%!*���"F°O > B<�

MAN7O�PRQTSUQWVXP'Y h�lGcf^`_ �nv7yiw#{$^Fa?^il cJ]#j'� w#{"l���w#yTyil#m*��w#_�]#_�^F��w#y �?{"l c [kl#�"ai^ ��l$y ��a l}{$e,^T_�w#y%�:^Tj1w#y`y�m7^Wc ��f{"lf[Rw#_R�f^il c ��w#{"l:_X]#_ �W_�lf��wgai^ ��l �i{"l c [�lU�"a?^ ��l$y����[�] cf^<a?^ ��l�� ��i028V:7"�./!L8%0�8�M�� 8�8�Mr0�K~!L.7Z�+D8%+D!L.�!L.zt7!#"%+18�+1�#+18�9z�A./!L./SA./02�#� 8%+D��+D8�9r�3! {FZQ+Y"�K~��0>t�� .7K~9¡ZQ!�0I"�./!L8

ZQ02t�0>.�Z�!L.���0I"%!L&1:/8%+D!L.���s�M7� 8i+Y"2@I+ª{�"%!L=�0���0I"%!L&D:/8%+1!L.�)<\�� � ����M��L"�� &1& � � "it�!#"%+18�+1�L0��A��0w"%t��E./!L.rS./02�#� 8%+D�L0 ��8�M/02.°� .Q9�!L8�M/02�V��0I"%!L&D:/8%+1!L. )���\R��� � � � M7�L"V8%M/+'"�t/��!Lt�02��8�9<�L"V(�02&D&A�?5A.7ZQ020IZi@��Q9¢C+D��!L.�� 4d�V��0I"%:/&D8�8�M/02��0�02�#+Y"%8n"��v"%0I¨L:/02.7K~0�! {��/&1!d(CSA:/t7"��z\�� ������"%:7K�M�8%M7� 8�8�M/0�K~!L=�t7!#"%+18%+D!L.) �� \���� � � � � {[�LK~8�!L�E"x8%M/��!L:/�LM )��V\���� � � �G� �#+1.7K~0u�z"%+D=�t/&10?�/&1! (FSA:/tGM7�L"�t7!#"%+18%+D�L0ZQ+Y"�K~��0>t�� .7K~9��6KNM/0IK�4~¡ � )� ��GM��L"Ft�!#"%+18�+1�L0PZQ+Y"�KE��02t7� .�KE+10I"��L"�(�02&D&A��J�:/8�8%M/0PZQ+Y"�KE��02t7� .�KE+10I"�! { ) �K2� .u��0vKE!L=�t/:r8�0IZ�!L.H��� � ��"%!P(�0�� ��0VZQ!L./0L�

5A.ZQ+1=�02.7"%+1!L.GO�8�M/0yKE&Y�L"�"v! {�t7!L+1.Q8n"�(F+18�M¯8%0>��=�+1.7� &F"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"VK~!L+D.7K~+YZQ0I"V(F+18�M,"%=�!�!L8�Mt�!L+D.Q8�"v�A8�Mr+'"V=?�)9��70?(C+D&1&^./!L8V02.7K~!L:/�E� �L0P9L!L:z8%!�"%8%:7ZQ9�8%M/02=y�n��5A.7Z�0>0IZi@�(�0P=?�)9�K~!L.7"%+YZQ02���=�+D.r+D=?� &���0I"%!L&1:/8%+D!L. ),\~� � � � ! {F��8�02��=�+D.�� &�"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18�9?!L.G�y"%:/�%{[�LK~0L��s�M7� 8�+Y"2@�(�0x=��)9�L"�"%:/=�0^8%M7� 8-)?ZQ!�0w"³./!L8^KE!L.Q8%�E�LK~8�� .Q9v�$��� �AS�KE:r���L0F�A(�0FZQ!�./!L8�(F� .Q8�8%!��L"�"%:/=�0�� .Q9#8%M/+1./��� �7!L:/88%M/0v02�kK~02t/8�+1!L.7� &^"%028 � �(��´ ./02+D8%M/02��8��E� .7"%�L02�E"�� &1+D8 9�.r!L��­ =�02028�+1./�?+1.<!L.r0�t�!L+D.Q8�­?K~!L.7ZQ+18�+1!L.i����#+1.7K~03� &1&7ZQ+Y"�K~��0>t�� .7K~+D0I"�� ��0�t7!#"%+18%+D�L0�� .7Zx8�M/0C+D.Q8%02�E"%0wK~8%+D!L.x=?� 8���+1��� �|��� �J�)��+Y"�./02�#� 8%+D�L0�ZQ0~±7./+18�0+18�{|!L&1&D! (3"�8%M7� 8F8%M/02��0V0>��+'"%8�"F��K~:/���L0 � , "%:7K�M?8%M7� 8

� , � �,- � � , � 1 � � x� �|� 2 4Rx!¢C!d(�02�L02�I@/"%+1.7K~0 ��s, 4,RQ@r8�M/+Y"C+D=�t/&1+10w"��Q9��LZa��:/.7K~8�+1!L.�8%M7� 8�� , +'"C��"%=�!�!L8�M�� � � .7Z ��s, � �V�L@� , � �,- ���V�L�^s�MQ:7" � , +'"^���$��� �AS�KE:r���L0a@�KE!L.Q8%�E� ��9�8%!v!L:/���L"�"%:/=�t/8%+D!L.������C!L8�0�8�M7� 8�8�M/0�"�� =�0� ���L:/=�02.Q8n"�t/��! �L0I"i8%M7� 8^� .Q9���02�L:/&'� �i�r+D�E� 8%+D!L.�� &L=�!L��trM/+'"%= ! {7"%=�!#!L8%MP"%:/�%{[�LK~0I"i+Y"���K~!L=�t7!#"%+18%+D!L.! {^�/&1!d(CS[:rt7"�´ 8�Mr0�{[�LK~8F(CM/+YK�My+'"CKE&10I� ��&D9x{[� &Y"%0�+1.yM/+D�LMr0>�FZ�+D=�02.7"%+1!L.7"2� �

 �"�{|!L��8%M/0�K2� ./!L./+YK2� &�"%+D�L:/&Y� ��+18�+10I"�(�0�M7�)�L0�8�Mr0�{|!L&1&D! (F+1./�

¤L¤

Page 35: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

��N56 6 ��Y��nv�[�[�] c�lpa?h�wgaJ� h�w c,��w#_�]#_�^F��w#y�cf^T_x�nv7y?w#{$^<a?^il c w#_ m �,- ^dc ��w#{#ai^?l${ � h�l$_�jF]#{,w#_&�{"l c�]#y<v ai^?]#_ )�\7��� � �) � �C- �� �C-�!

�5� V V $Y�5 {^� &D&iZQ+Y"�KE��02t7� .�KE+10I"^� ��0�RV8�Mr0>.�!L:/�FK~&'� +1=�+Y"�� �Q�#+1!L:7"2� � 8%M/02��(F+Y"%038%M/0�ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L� � x� �|�+Y"�0 � 0IK~8%+D�L0v� .7Z�8�MQ:7"�(�0�=?�I9?K~!L.7"%+YZQ02��8�M/0V02�k�LK~8�"%0I¨L:/02.7K~0�! {�"%M/0I�)�L0w"�!L.A��� \

R�� � ; -! � ) � �,-V��� � ; -! � �,-! 6��� � ; ��� � � � �p- A��� � Rx!s�Mr+'"�9#+10>&YZ/"C�P"%0I¨L:/02.7K~0V! {³ZQ+1��0IK~8F+1=�� �L0I"

R�� � ; -V� �p-§����� ) � ; - � �,-! 6��� � ) � ; ����� � � �,-! 6��� �� � �� ) � ; - + ; -§� �,-V��� � �

� ) � ; - � �,- � � �L�

5A.yt7� ��8%+'K~:/&Y� ��(�0§� .y02=P��0IZ/ZQ+1./�� - � ) � � -

! {§� .+1.Q�L0>��8%+1�/&D0y"%M/0I�){�+D.Q8%!G�<8%!L�E"%+1!L.Q{|��020¡"%M/0I�){�(FMr+'KNM+'"x+Y"%!L=�!L��trM/+'"%=?"�+D.,K~!QZQ+D=�02.7"%+1!L. �L�s�MQ:7"2@Q"%+1.7K~0(� +'"�./!L��=?� &[@5) � �'-! X� �C-v� C&D8%02��.7� 8%+D�L02&19a@Q+1.�8%M/0�� ��!d�L0Vt/��!#! {�@Q+1.�ZQ+D=�02.7"%+1!L.?OP(�0�=��)9?� &'"%!x./!L8%0�8%M7� 8F"%+1.7K~0

; ��� � � � �,-! A��� ; ��� � � � � � x� �|�A�� .7Z�8�Mr0�=?� 8%��+D�y� �(�D� �J�I��+'"�./02�#� 8�+1�L0vZQ0~±7./+18�0�8%M/02��0~{|!L��0

) � ; ��� � � � �p- A�'� � 6 ��� �(��� � x� �|�|��� Rx!*,Mr+'KNMvt/&D:r�L�L0wZV+1.?� �L�i�L+D�L0I"�8%M/0FZQ0I"%+1��0IZ�+Y"%!L=�!L��t/M/+Y"%=¡� � .v8�Mr0F!L8%M/02��M�� .7Zi@L���L02./02�E� &#8%M/02!L��02=! { � �E� :r0>��8%S�£C+D02=?� .7"�K�MQ./02+YZQ02�^+1=�tr&D+10I"�8�M7� 8

�� ) � ; - � �,- ���,R {|!L� q-4 Rx!

s�Mr+'"�+D=�t/&1+D0I"�8�Mr0��d� .r+'"%M/+1./�v! { �� ) � ; - �� .7Z�8%Mk:�"2@Q+D.?��+D02(�! {�� �L��t/��! �L0I"^+1.�ZQ+D=�02.7"%+1!L.uOv8%M/0

{|!L&1&D! (F+1./���� NgV � N 6 Y � ��y &^ � ��yil$_�_Xl}{�� �~v�[�[�] c�l�aihXwgan� h�w c���w#_�]#_�^F��w#ygcf^`_ �nv7yiw#{$^Fa?^il c w#_Rm �,- ^Wc���w#{#ai^?l${ � hXl}_AjF]#{(w#_&�{"l c�]#y<v ai^?]#_,)�\���� ���

�� ) � ; - � R jF]#{ q-4,Rx!

� h�wga�^dc �Ra?h�l(cf^`_x�nv�yiw#{$^Fa�l ct]#j�� w#{"lJ{"wgai^?]#_�w#y � �*z0�./!L8�0IZ�8%M7� 8��E� 8%+D!L.�� &7"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18%+D0I"^� ��0�K~!L.Q�L0>.r+D02.Q8^��0wK2� :7"%0�K~!LM/!L=�!L&1!L�L9v! {³�v"%M/0I�){�! �L0>�

��� � ��+D028�9 � (F+18�M¯�E� 8%+D!L.7� &�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"VK2� .°��0uK~!L=�t/:/8%0wZW!d�L02�P����0I"%!L&D:/8%+1!L. ) \���� � �¤ �

Page 36: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

! {�8�M/+Y"��d� ��+D028�9L� =�� ./!L./+YK2� &³"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+18�+10I"3� ��0x02�L0>.z./+YK~02���70IK2� :7"%0L@�+ {��,-�+Y"0=m� ��8%+D02��� .7Z B �t�!#"%+D8%+D�L0�+D.Q8%0>�L02�C8�M/02.

�6 �<� � �$B �,- �'� � 6 �<�*� ) � � B �,- �%�'� � 6 �<�*�$B��,-V�

� .7Z¯8%MQ:7"x8�M/0���0I"%!L&D:/8%+1!L.°M7�L"x8%M/0�"�� =�0yt/&1:/��+D�L02.7�Q� ;�!L��02!d�L02�I@�+ª{�9L!L:,M7�)�L0y8�(�!G�/+1�E� 8�+1!L.7� &�d� ��+1028�+10I"F(C+D8%M<K2� ./!L./+YK2� &�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"�8%M/02.�9L!L:<K2� .y±7.7Z�8�M/02+1��KE!L=�=�!L.y��0w"%!L&1:/8%+D!L.y� .7Zy8�MQ:7"8%M/029uM7�)�L0�8%M/0P"�� =�0�t/&1:/��+1�L0>.��Q��s�M�� 8F+Y"F(CMQ9?8�Mr0§K~&Y�L"�"F! {�K2� ./!L./+YK2� &�"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18%+D0I"�� t/t�0I� �E"F"%!.7� 8%:/�E� &19<+1.G8�Mr0uK~&'�L"�"%+ª±�K2� 8�+1!L.G! {��/+D�E� 8%+1!L.7� &^0I¨L:/+1�d� &102.7K~0uK~&'�L"�"%0I"V! {3tr��!L��0IKE8%+1�L0�� � ��+D028%+D0I"2@�"%0203 £F02+YZ 9 {|!L�F=�!L��0�Z�0>8�� +1&'"2�

�C!d( (�0u(C+D&1&3K~&Y�L"�"%+ {|9°O S�ZQ+1=�02.7"%+D!L.�� &mK2� ./!L./+YK2� &F"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18%+D0I"2���:/t/t�!#"%0?8�M�� 8u�F�*�$@��P+Y"��zO SZQ+1=�0>.�"%+D!L.7� &iK2� ./!L./+YK2� &�"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8�9�� .7Z �,- +'" =�� ��8�+102�I�:�C!d(�(�0v4�./! (�8�M�� 83��=�+1./+D=?� &���0I"%!LS&1:/8�+1!L.<! {�@�M7�L"�8%M/0P02�kK~02t/8%+D!L.�� &�"%028*� �|�^(FM/+YK�M�+'"V�?8%��020P! {F"%=�!#!L8%M��E� 8%+1!L.7� &^KE:r���L0w"�(FM/+YK�M=�020>8C8��E� .�"%�L0>�E"�� &19x´ 0I�LK�M�8 (�!�� 8�!L./0Vt7!L+1.Q8F� 8F=�!#"%8>��; !L��0>! �L02�I@L{|��!L= 8%M/0§� ���L:r=�02.Q8�(FM/+YK�M(�0yM7�I�L0yM7�LZ��(FMr+D&10¡� �L!/@�(�0y4#./! ( 8%M7� 8?� &D&�ZQ+Y"�KE��02t7� .�KE+10I"v� ��0¡R��[��0IK>� :�"%0u!L8%M/02��(F+Y"%0u8%M/0��0I"%!L&D:r8�+1!L.<(�!L:/&YZ�.r!L8���0�=�+1./+1=?� &|���Ps�MQ:7"3{|��!L= �LZ ��:/.�KE8%+1!L.�(�0�"%020�8%M7� 8 � � � +'"v�LK~8%:7� &D&19<�8%��0>0�! {��E� 8%+D!L.�� &�K~:/���L0I"�� .7Zx0I�LK�M�!L./0�! {�8%M/02=}M7�L"�"%0>&ª{|SA+D.Q8%02�E"%0wK~8%+D!L.A�3OQ�^s�MQ:7"�8%!PKE&Y�L"�"%+ª{|9P"%:7K�M"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"�(�0§� ��0V"%:/t/t�!#"%0wZ�8�!x:/.7ZQ02�E"%8�� .7Z?K~&'�L"�"%+ª±�K2� 8%+D!L.?! {�+D.Q8%02��0wK~8%+D!L.y=?� 8���+YK~0I"�� �(�D� �J�I�"%:7KNM?8�M�� 8>\ 8%M/0�02&102=�02.Q8�"�!L.u8%M/0vZQ+'� �L!L.�� &�� ��0V0I¨L:7� &i8%!*�3OQ@ !L:/8�"%+'Z�0�! {�8%M/0vZQ+'� �L!L.�� &7(�0VM7�)�L0�Rv!L�V�L@ 8%M/0�=?� 8%��+D��+Y"�./02�#� 8%+D�L0VZQ0~±7./+18�0L�

�#:7KNM?=?� 8���+YK~0I"FK2� .u��0�{|:/&D&19?K~&'�L"�"%+ª±70IZ�+1.�8�02��=?"�! {^8�M/02+1�F+1.7K~+'Z�0>.�KE0��L�E� t/M7"2�s�Mr0mK~!L=P�r+D.7� 8%!L��+Y� &Lt/��!L�/&10>= ! {�K~&'�L"�"%+ª{|9#+1./��"%:7K�MV=?� 8���+YK~0I"�� .�ZV��0>&Y� 8%0wZx��K~!L././0IK~8�0IZ�¡ª���L�E� trM7"

&10w�LZr"F8%!�8�Mr0P"%!L&D:/8%+1!L.u(CM/+'KNM¡K2� .��70Vt/+YKE8%:/��0IZ��L"C!L./0V! {³8%M/0V{|!L&1&D! (F+1./����9#./4�+D.<Z�+'� �L�E� =?"2\ �  (FMr0>��0 ��� �L@ �   (CM/02��0G����/@�� � @ � � � .7Z ���3´ 02�Q�LKE8%&19u�L"F� 8C!L:/�3��+1�L:/��0��Q�

s�Mr+'"^Z�0E±�./0I"�:r./+'¨®:/02&D9v8%M/0�{|:/.7Z/� =�02.Q8n� &��L��!L:/t3) D � .7ZPK~!L.7"%0I¨L:r0>.Q8%&D9L@#Z�0E±�./0I"^�F�*�$@����L"�!L./0! {^8�Mr0 � ��� ��� ¨®:/!L8%+D02.Q8F"%+D.r�L:/&'� ��+18%+D0I"2�

=�!L.Q�L02�E"%02&D9L@Q"%:/t/t�!#"%0�8�M7� 8��F�*�$@��F+Y"�� . � � � ����"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8�9L��B�"%+D./�v8%M/0V02=P��0wZrZQ0IZ���0I"%S!L&1:/8�+1!L.�@®{|��!L= �LZ ��:/.7K~8%+D!L.�{|!L��=x:/&Y�Q@d(�0VK>� .yKE!L=�t/:r8�0�8%M/0�K2� ./!L./+YK2� &�ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L��!L.u8%M/0���0I"%!L&1:/8�+1!L.��s�Mr0vt/��!#! {�+Y"C+D.�ZQ:7K~8�+1�L0L\F(�0V(F+1&1&³K~!L=�t7� ��0V8�Mr0PK>� .r!L./+'K2� &�ZQ+D��+'"%!L��! {�8%M/0�.#SA8�M��/&1! (FSA:/ty! {:� CL@&10>8x:7"PZ�0>.r!L8�0?+18P�Q9 � , @�(F+18%M°8%M/0�"%8���+YK~8v8��E� .7" {|!L��= ! {�� �b� CL@�(�0uK2� &1&�+D8�� , �G*z0�KE&Y� +1=8%M7� 8F+1.�8�Mr0§X�+'K2� �EZ��L��!L:/ty! { � , (�0VM7�)�L0 � � � � �J� , � .7Z?8%M/+Y"2@/�Q9?�LZ ��:/.7K~8%+D!L.�@Q+D=�t/&1+D0I"�8�M7� 8� - � � RQ�

�i028 �z\ � , � � , � �3��0�8%M/0v­ t/��02�#+1!L:7"�­V�/&1!d(CSA:/t���s�M/02.

� � � � � � � � � � � F°O� ,¤ �

Page 37: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

(FMr0>��0 � , +Y"i8%M/0�0>�QK~0>tr8�+1!L.7� &kZ�+D��+'"%!L�I� � .V8�M/0�!L8%M/02��M7� .7Z«@I(�0^4�./!d( 8�M7� 8 � , � ��M7�L"�=P:r&D8%+Dtr&D+YK~+D8�9O�� .7Z�8%M/0vKE02.Q8%0>�C! { ��"%!�8%M7� 8

� � �F� , � �I��� � , F°O� , !�C!d(V@iKE!L=�t7� ��+1./�x8�M/0�� �7! �L0V8�(�!?0I¨L:7� &1+18�+10I"�� .7Zy:7"%+1./��8�Mr0v+D.7Z�:7K~8�+1�L0§�L"�"%:r=�tr8�+1!L.u(�0v�L028�8%M/0ZQ0I"%+1��0wZ�0w¨®:7� &1+D8�9L�

s�MQ:7"2@�(�0�M7�)�L0�"%4L028�K�M/0IZ�8�M/0Vt/��!�! {�! {^8�Mr0�&'�L"%8C��0I"%:/&D8�! {�8�Mr0w"%0V&10wK~8%:/��0I"2���� NgV � N 6 Y���l#a��<�*�$@��� l(wG_�]#{$eAw#y�c"v7{$jFwg��l:cf^`_x�nv�yiw#{$^FaT� �� hXl}_ a?h�l:jF]#yTyi]7�'^T_x�Ha���]���]#_Rm7^Fa?^i]#_ncw#{"l(l#ugv�^ �"w#y?l$_�a ��i^%� �,- ^dc �'w#{#a?^il${�w#_Rm,@A^Wc(��w#_�]#_�^F��w#y ��?^`^%�z�F� �$@��1^Wc��^Th�]#y?]#eA]#{f[nh�^F�:a ]pw#_ � ��� ��� cf^T_x�nv7y?w#{$^<ad� �

¤L¦

Page 38: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

�� ( v����V��������Q��/���r�k���«�7���� �� ���3� �E�'�������5x8�Mr+'"y"%0IKE8%+1!L. 5x&1+'"%8y"%!L=�0�:7"%0~{|:/&���0I"%:/&D8�"�!L. "%:/�%{[�LK~0I"?(CM/+YK�M � ��0�:7"%0IZ¯{|��0I¨L:r0>.Q8%&D9(C+D8%M/!L:/8��0~{|02��0>.�KE0�8�M/��!L:r�LM/!L:/8�8�M/+Y"�K~!L:/�E"%0L�

��P�S#N����#N���S#QWVXP � ��V�� ���S7Y �«028:�²��0v�P"%=�!#!L8%MuK~!L=�t/&D028%0v�A0a� �/�Qt/��!L��0IK~8%+D�L0 �m"%:r�%{[�LKE0L�^s�M/02.?!L.� q ��� 8�M/02��0V02�#+Y"%8n"C� " SA�/+1&1+D./0I� �F"%9�=�=�028%��+'KCt/��!QZQ:7K~8

� q � � � � q ��� � � �,� � � s ���� � �,� � � s ��) " !s�Mr+'"x=�0I� .7"x8�M7� 8�8%M/0�+1.k8%02�E"%0IKE8%+1!L.°+Y"x(�0>&1&�ZQ0~±7./0IZ !L.,8%M/0�&D+1./0I� �P0I¨®:/+D� � &D02.7K~0<K~&'�L"�"%0I"2@�+18�+'""%9#=�=�028���+YK�� .7Z��L"�"%!kK~+'� 8%+1�L0a��;�!L��02! �L0>��+18FM��L"�8%M/0�{|!L&1&D! (F+1./�Ptr��!Lt702��8%+D0I"2\

+ { �,��� .7Z � s � ��0�8 (�! =m� ��8%+10>�FZ�+D��+'"%!L�E"�(CM/+'KNMuM��I�L0�.r!�K~!L=�=�!L.yKE!L=�t�!L./02.Q8�8�M/02.

�,� � � s � �D ��� �� � � ZQ+1=pr ; -JI D > ��% �D �}% sD �(FM/02��0�% �D +Y"�8%M/0�&1!kK2� &�0I¨L:�� 8�+1!L.u! { �4�³� 8�@i@

+ {.7 +Y"F� .y+1����0wZ�:7K~+D�/&10V�6� .�Z?��0IZQ:7K~0IZ���K~:/���L0�8%M/02.�{|!L��� .Q9?ZQ+1�#+Y"%!L�!�

� ��72� o5 ��� � � � ���

(FM/02��0 �z\ �7 � 7 � � +Y"�8%M/0V./!L��=?� &D+1HI� 8�+1!L.?! { 7P�

*z0z:7"%0�{|��0I¨L:r0>.Q8%&D9 8�Mr0�+1.Q8�02�E"%0IK~8�+1!L.{|!L�<� ±��702�y! {P��0w"%!L&1:/8%+D!L.�) \(� � � �G@�(C+D8%M/!L:/8�L"�"%:/=�+1./�<8%M7� 8����+Y"�t/��!®��0wK~8%+D�L0L� s�M7� 8�+Y"?� &D&���+1�LMQ8>@F"%+1.7K~0�8%M/0�±7��02�?+Y"�t/��!L��0IK~8�+1�L0�(�0<K2� .02=P��0IZ/Z����Q+D.Q8%!P��tr��!L��0IKE8%+1�L03"%:/�%{[�LK~03� .�ZP:�"%038%M/0�+1.k8%02�E"%0IKE8%+1!L.�K~!L=�+D./��{|��!L=�8%M/+Y"^02=x�70IZ/ZQ+1./�/�

s�Mr0�{|!L&D&1! (F+1./�v8�(�!�8�Mr0>!L��02=?"�� ��0�:7"%0IZ�{|��0I¨L:/02.Q8�&19�8�Mr��!L:/�LM/!L:/8�8%M/0�8%02�#8

��� NgV � N 6 Y ����w c"a�l$yT_�]gv-��]H��]#_�ai{"wg�"a?^i]#_ �f{$^<a l${$^i]#_-� �ClUa 7 �2� l�w#_ ^`{${"l#m�v��f^!�y?l��"v7{���l�]#_�wcfeA]g]ga?h�c"v7{$jFwg��l:� c"v�� hLa?h�wga��,-7��7 4 R w#_Rm�7Gs 4 R �� hXl}_ 7 ^dc|w�cfeA]g]ga?h*{"wgai^?]#_�w#y��8v�{���l^ � l � 7 � � � w#_Rm�eH]#{"l"]���l${(aih�l${"l l��g^Wc"a<c|w�eAw"[ � \7� � ��]#_.a ]�w�cfeA]g]ga?h�c"v7{$jFwg��l � ���'h�^F��h��]#_�ai{"wg�"aFc 7ba�]w,cfeH]&]gaihA[�]#^T_.aJ]#_�� � h�wga�^Wc � � � � -�� � � ^dc w#_*^Wc�]#eA]#{f[nh�^Wcfe � �³� 7v�1� A*) �w#_Rm���^dc|aih�l��y?]�����v�[*]#j � wga A ���� NgV � N 6 Y���l#a )�\7��� � � xlJw.�^`{"wga?^?]#_�w#y&[n{"]"[kl${'eA]#{f[nh ^dcfe ]#j.c"v�{$jFwg� l c � Z�c$c"v7eAl:a?h�wgaR���^Wc:cfeA]g]ga?h w#_Rm���^Wc1_X]#{$eHw#y � �~v�[�[�] c�l a?h�wga.) � � ��@��1� � ������� , �(� ^dc w4m lU��]#e�[�] cf^<a?^i]#_ ]#j�w � �m7^TeAl}_~cf^i]#_�w#y � xl${ ^`_�a ]�^T{${"lUm v��f^�y?lk��]#e�[�]#_�l$_.aFc �� h�l$_pa?h�l�^`_�a l}{ c�l#�"a?^i]#_(eAwga?{$^ �V� �|�'� �J�I�f�����WI ��� ,^Wc1_�lf��wga?^ ��l�mxl ��_�^Fa�l �

�i028C:7"�./!L8%0V8�M7� 8C8�Mr0�&'� 8%8%0>��8%M/02!L��02= K2� .u��0�+1.Q�L02�E"%0wZ

¤ U

Page 39: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

��� NgV � N 6 Y ����{"wgvxl${#a���]#_.a?{"wg�"ai^?]#_ �f{$^Fa�l${$^?]#_-����l#a � � � � �(�� lHw ��]#_�_�l#�"a�l#m �8v�e ]#j:^T{${"l��m�v��f^!�y?l��"v7{���l c�]#_ wA� ]#e�[ny?l��Hc"v7{$jFwg��l�� � �nv�[�[k] c�l aih�wga�a?h�l(^T_.a l${ c�l#�8a?^?]#_*eHwga?{$^ ��� �|� � �J�I�1^dc_�lf��wga?^ ��l�mxl ��_�^Fa�l �� h�l$_Ha?h�l${"l:l��&^dc"aFc�w�h�]#yi]#eA]#{f[nh ^<�'��]#_�a?{"wg�8a?^?]#_]#j�� � a?h�wga�^Wc ��w:hX]#yi]#eA]#{f[nh�^F�eAw"[�]#_�a�]�w#_�w#_Xw#y ��ai^F� �"w#{$^?l#aT�L�'h ^<� h^dct^dc�]#eA]#{f[nh ^dcfe ]gv�aFcf^Fmxl!� w#_RmA�'h�^F��h � ]#_�a?{"wg�"a<c � a ]�w[�]#^`_�a ��� ( v����V����:��������� ���z�^���������������5A.y8�Mr+'"C� t/t702.7Z�+D��5^��0IK2� &D&i���L"%+'K�ZQ0~±7./+18%+D!L.7"�� .�Z?K~!L.7"%8���:�KE8%+1!L.7"���02&'� 8%0IZ?8%!P8%!L��+'K��d� ��+D028%+D0I"2��s�M/0��0I�LZQ02��+'"C��0~{|02����0IZ�8�!�3 �/:r&D8%!L. 9 � .7ZL3 � Z/� 9 {|!L��ZQ028�� +D&Y"2�� �xS#QWVXP��D�9�7V�PRN���Y s�M/0P"%028%SA:/t�\:� +'"���&Y� 8%8�+YK~0P+A� 0L�(� � "   @�2 \ � � #�B � �*� " �F(C+D8%M�Z�:7� &t7� +1��+D.r�

�1� ��\ 2 �H� � " !*z0?KE!L.�"%+'ZQ02��K~!L./0I"�+1.z�L0IKE8%!L�v"%t7�LK~0w" � \ � � � � � +�� � � .7Z � �,� 2 � � 2 +�� �����Q9� �/:7"%0�(�0�(F+1&D&�"��)9�8�M�� 8F8%M/0§K~!L./0I"C� ��0�+D.*� � .7Z�2 @/��0I"%t�0wK~8%+D�L02&19L�����V 6 �7VXPRN��,S#V �� PRN*S#V ��Q���D�D��QWN7S#QWN<�7Y s�!?� .Q9u�LZ/ZQ+18%+D�L0�"%02=�+1�L��!L:/t �°(�0vK2� .<�L"�"%!kK~+Y� 8�0��S�� &1�L02�/�E�A�43 � 9 \�(C+D8%M ��SA�7�L"%+Y" ���I@ � ) � � .�Z�=P:r&D8%+Dtr&D+YK2� 8�+1!L.���� ����� \ �����3��� �6�LZrZQ8�+1�L0P8%!=P:r&D8%+Dtr&D+YK2� 8�+1�L0 �n�

s�!P� .Q9v±7./+18%0>&19P�L02./02�E� 8%0IZA��S�� &1�L0>�r�E� � (�0��L"%!kK~+'� 8%0�� .u�)©?./0C�d� ��+10>8 9u�A!L�I@Q=�!L��0Ft/��0IK~+Y"%0>&19L@�)©?./0�"�KNM/02=�0d��(CM/+'KNM<(�0�K>� &1& ��� �[!L� ��� � � ���p¢C02��0P+Y"�8�M/0?K~!L.7"%8%��:7K~8�+1!L.�\�&1028G@~� �"!"!"!#�$@   �70�L02./02�E� 8�!L�E"�! { � !d�L02�|��@/8%M/02.y8�M/02��0�02��+'"%8�"��P"%:/�A��0IK~8�+1�L0V=�� t

�z\x�3 � � �8!"!"!"���  g9 � � "%:7KNM?8�M�� 8 ��� � � ���\@ � !�i028�+�70V8%M/0�4L02��./02&i! {^8%M/0�=?� t ����*z0vZQ0~±7./0����¯�L"�8%M/0�H202��!�&D!QK~:7"�! {^t�!L&D9�./!L=�+'� &Y"�{|��!L= +F@8%M7� 8F+Y"

� � \ �2� � � � !"!"!"���   ��) �   \g%«� � � �8!"!"! �   �'� R {|!L�3� .Q9%�),+J/MAN7O�PRQTSUQWVXP'Y �X]#{�w#_&�4{"wga?^?]#_�w#yRc"ai{$^F�"aiy��L��]#_ ��l���[�]#y���h�l#m7{"w#y���]#_�l � ^T_ � � ��l�mxl ��_�l�i^%� w�c�l$e,^��g{"]gv�[9� � \���� � � 2 ��h�^<� h^Wc ��_�^Fa l}y����l$_�l${"wga lUm��?^`^%� w�c�l$e,^��g{"]gv�[�w#y���l �{"w �

�\ � �43 �

� 9 � �3 � � � 2 9 � ��_�^Fa l}y����l$_�l${"wga lUm w#y���l �{"w�����?^`^T^ � w�,_�lGa ]#{$^<� �"w#{$^il#aT� � � \�� �����)� � � �� �D� ��V ���� PRN�S#V � Q���D�D��QWN7S#QWN�� ��8n� 4L0y�yM/!L=�!L=�!L��trM/+'" = ! {F&'� 8%8�+YK~0I"*� \R��� � � (FM/+YK�M=?� t7"���K~!L./0 ���i+1.*���i+1.k8%!���K~!L./0 ��+1. � �r8�Mr+'"CZQ0~±7./0I"F��=�� t � � � � � �

�r:/.7Z/� =�02.Q8n� &�0>�Q� =�t/&D0L\V5 { ��+'"V��{[�LK~0�! { �¯8%M/02.z(�0�M7�I�L0P� .¯�L"�"%!kK~+'� 8%0IZ�=�� t ��� � � �(FMr+'KNMu+Y"F� .y02=P��0wZrZQ+D.r�/�

¤�1

Page 40: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

��V ��V �����D�8��Y ����l${f�*w�p_XlGa�]#{$^F� �"w#{$^?l#aT�L��]#_�a�w#^T_ncJw ���^�� a ]#{#vgc �� � \�� ��� 6�� � �f� � � � �   , � � �

a?h�l �^��Ha�]#{#v&c�^dc w#_*]"[kl$_ mxl$_nc�l:c�l#a�^`_-� � c�]�a?h�wga'^Fa�^WcJ]#j�m7^TeAl}_~cf^i]#_Al#ugvxw#y�a ]4a?h�l:{"w#_ ]#j�a?h�ly?wga a?^<��l(� ����.P�� �~P�� S#V � Q�� D�D��QWN7S#QWN���YMAN7O�PRQTSUQWVXP'YHZ\jFw#_�� ^`_��^dctw(c�lUaC]#j)�i{"wga?^i]#_Xw#y c"a?{$^F�8a?y��H� ]#_ ��l�� [�]#y �xh�l#m7{"w#y �1��]#_�l c�^`_�bc"v���ha?h�wga ��i^%� l"wg��hAjFwg��lG]#j�wp��]#_�l�^T_ � ^Wc�w#yWc�]G^T_ � ��?^`^%��a?h�l�^T_�a�l${ c�l#�"ai^?]#_*]#j1a���],� ]#_Xl ct^`_ � ^Wc�w�jFwg��lG]#j�l"wg��h � hXlGc"v�[�[�]#{#a1]#j:a?h�lGjFw#_ ^dc|l#ugv w#y�a ]*aih�l�v�_�^i]#_ ]#jJw#yTy���]#_�l c�^T_ a?h�l(jFw#_ � Z jFw#_ ^dc0� ]#e�[ny?l#a�l(^Tj^Fa<cJc"v�[�[�]#{#a�^dcJ� �

*z03ZQ0I"�K~��+1�70C8�M/0�K~!L.7"%8���:�KE8%+1!L.P! {���8�!L��+YK��d� ��+1028�9��z� ���i{|��!L= ��{[� . �y\�*z0��L&D:r03�)©?./0�8%!L��+'K�d� ��+1028�+10I"v�L"�"%!kK~+'� 8%0IZz8%!<KE!L.r0w"�{|��!L= � � &D!L./�y8%M/02+D�v!Lt�02.W"%:r�7"%028n"V�L"�"%!kK~+Y� 8�0IZz8%!<K~!L./0I"V(FM/+YK�M� ��0�8%M/02+D�C+D.Q8%02�E"%0wK~8%+D!L.�"2�^s�M/0���0I"%:/&18�+Y"F��"%02t7� �E� �/&103� � ��+D028�9L�

�RQ?P�������D��QTS#QWN��7Y �i028 � �70��zK~!L./0�! {�=�� ��+D=?� &FZQ+1=�02.7"%+D!L. +D. � � @�8%M/0y�d� ��+10>8 9 � � M��L"P�ZQ+Y"%8�+1./�L:/+Y"%M/0IZ¯t�!L+D.Q8 � � �A8%M/0z:/./+Y¨L:/0 ±7�#0IZ t7!L+1.Q8?! {v8�M/0G�LK~8%+D!L. ! {v8�M/0z�/+1�¯8�!L��:7"~��� � � +'"�L"�"%!kK~+Y� 8�0IZ 8�!G8%M/0�+'ZQ0I� &"6 +1.��43 � � 9 � �3 � � �/2 9 �L02./02�E� 8%0IZ¯�k9¯02&D02=�02.Q8n"?K~!L=�+1./��{|��!L=� � � �IRx/L�

s�Mr0��f�7� ��+Y"%4#+ ��KE!L8�� ./�L02.Q8F"%t7�LK~0�! { � � � 8�� � +'"�Z�0E±�./0IZ?�L"�6 > 6�sF� .�Z�+D8�"����L"%+'"�K~!L.7"%+'"%8�"�! {02&D02=�02.Q8n"m{|��!L= � � � �IRx/�(FM/+YK�M�� ��0�./!L8F"%:r=�"�! {^8�(�!�"%:7K�My02&D02=�02.Q8n"2�

 C.��)©?./0�8�!L��+YK��d� ��+1028�9 � � +'"V.r!L.7"%+D.r�L:/&'� �V+ � �,+Y"v�L02./02�E� 8%0IZG�Q9G��t7� ��8v! {��7�L"%+Y"V! {�8%M/0&Y� 8�8%+'K~0��z@/+1.u(CM/+YK�M�K>�L"%0

����� , ���f� � �  ���, @r(FM/02��0G�A��! g��.�� � .7Z-.�� ogqFB�� ���$!

�r!L�P�<K~!L./0 � 8�M/0y��+1./� � � � �3 � � 9 +Y"V+1.k8%02�L�E� &D&19GK~&D!#"%0IZi�zs�M/02��0~{|!L��0�8�!L��+YK��d� ��+1028�+10I"P� ��0./!L��=?� &�M/02.7K~0�"%=�!#!L8%Mu+1.¡K~!QZQ+D=�02.7"%+1!L.<�L�

¤ T

Page 41: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

�,��� �V��3�����J�02&D! (5�(�!L:r&'ZV&1+D4L0C8�!V&1+'"%8�=?� .Q:7"�K~��+Dt/8�"i(CM/+YK�M�5«:7"%0IZv(CM/+D&10�t/��02t7� ��+1./��8�Mr0w"%0�&10IK~8�:/��0I"��A+1.�=?� .Q9+1.7"%8n� .�KE0I"�8�M/0V��0I�LZQ02��+'"C�L"%4L0IZ?8%!?KE!L.�"%:/&D8�8%M/02=}{|!L��ZQ028�� +D&Y"�! {^t/��!�! {["~�n�^5�� &Y"%!P&1+'"%8�8%M/0I"%0V(FM/+YK�M5v(�!L:r&'Z¯"%:/�L�L0I"%8P8%!G��0I�LZ¯+D. !L�EZQ02�P8%!G02�#8%02.7Z8%M/0�:/.7Z�0>�E"%8�� .7ZQ+1./��! {�8%M/0<K~!L.Q8�02.Q8�"P! {V8�M/0I"%0&10wK~8%:/��0I"2���N���S��� N��nY�i!�!L+ ��02./�#�Q@�5�"%!L&Y� 8�0IZ��#+1./�L:/&Y� �FX�!L+1.k8�"�!L. =�!L=�t/&D028%0§56.k8%02�E"%0IKE8%+1!L.7"2@D�i!L.7Z�!L.¡;�� 8�M/02=?� 8%+'K2� &^��!LSK~+D028�9��i0IK~8�:/��0��C!L8�0I"��#02��+10w"CULU#@«�6KNM7� t/8%02��� ���¢�� ��8n"%Mr!L��./0L@k C&1�L0>�r�E� +'K��L02!L=�028���9L@��#tr��+D./�L02��S �^02��&Y� ���IT�ULU#@���K�M7� tr8�02�3�������N���S��� N��.Y35¢3� ��8�"%M/!L��./0 9 � .7Zy� &'"%!;�:r=P{|!L�EZ«@� C&D�L02�/�E� +YK �L0>!L=�028%��9 5N��=�!L=�t/&102� t/��!L��0IK~8�+1�L0°� � ��+D028%+D0I"2� �#t/��+1./�L02��S �^02��&'� � �IT�U ¦ @��K�M7� t/8%02� 1 ������ :�{|0>�I@��C!L��=�� &L8 (�!LS6Z�+D=�02.7"%+1!L.7� &L�#+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+10w"2@2 C./.7� &Y"i! {7;<� 8%M/02=?� 8�+YK2� &/�#8%:7ZQ+10I"�./!VU#�L@dX���+D.rSK~02.k8%!L.z�IT�U#�L���N���S��� N��RY;�+1&1./!L�I@/��+D./�L:r&'� ��t�!L+D.Q8�"�! {�K~!L=�t/&D02��MQ9#t�02�E"%:/�%{[�LK~0w"2@Q C./.7� &Y"�! {�;<� 8%M/02=?� 8�+YK2� &��#8%:7ZQ+10w"�./! ¦ �L@X���+D.7K~028%!L.¡X���0I"�"��IT�UI�/�;�:r=P{|!L�EZ«@/s�M/0vs�!Lt7!L&1!L�L9?! {��C!L��=?� &��#+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8%+D0I"�! {�� .z C�L0>�r�E� +'K��#:/�%{[�LK~0I"F� .7Z���=���+D8%02��+D!L.{|!L����+D=�t/&1+'K~+18�9L@kX�:/�/&1+YK>� 8%+1!L.¡;�� 8�M/02=?� 8%+'¨®0�5�¢�¢��?T ���n�IT ¦ � �����N���S��� N��RYJ���+10w"%4L!L��.�@a£�� 8%+D!L.�� &D0C�#+1./�L:/&Y� ��+D8 �� 8�02.v4L!L=�t/&102�#02����& ��LK�M/02.�@L5A.Q�L02.Q8�+1!L./0I"�;�� 8�Mr0>=?� 8%+'K2� 0���@ ¤L¤L¦¤ � 1 ���IT ¦�1 ���X���+D&1&[@��i!QK>� &QK~&'�L"�"%+ª±�K2� 8�+1!L.V! {r¨®:/!L8%+D02.Q8n"�! {7K~!L=�t/&D02��=?� ./+ª{|!L&YZ/"��Q9�ZQ+Y"�KE!L:r.k8%+1.k:r!L:7"/�L��!L:rt7"2@I��:/4L0;<� 8%M/02=?� 8�+YK2� &��L!L:/��.�� &��������IT ¦ UL��@ ¤ Ud� k¤�1L¦ ��r:/&D8%!L.�@Q5A.Q8���!QZQ:7K~8%+D!L.y8�!x8�!L��+YK��d� ��+D028%+D0I"2�� Z/�Q@�=�!L.k�L02�?��!kZ�+D0I"�� .7Z�� &1�L0>�r�E� +'K��L02!L=�028���9L�� C.�+D.Q8%��!kZQ:7K~8%+D!L.�8%!�8�Mr0v8�M/02!L��9y! {^8�!L��+YKV�d� ��+1S028�+10I"2���#tr��+D./�L02��S �^02��&Y� ���IT 1�1 �J�� ��8%M�@^X�028�02�E"2@ ��� .ZQ0 ��0>.�@ =�!L=�t7�LK~8 =�!L=�t/&102�G�#:/�%{[�LK~0I"2@��#t/��+1./�L02��S ��0>��&Y� �<�IT 1 �/@��6KNM7� t/8%0>�5%5�5�@�"%0IKE8%+1!L.7"�� UL�����N���S��� N� ��3 J���+D0I"%4L!L��. 9 @.3 J�� ��8%M�@/X�028�02�E"2@ ��� .<ZQ0 ��0>. 9 � .7Z?� &Y"%! C��8�+1.�@��#!L=�0v.Q:/=�02��+'K2� &�K~��+D8%02��+'��{|!L��K~!L.k8%�E�LK~8�+1�/+1&D+18�9?! {�KE:r���L0w"�!L.�� &1�L0>�r�E� +'KV"%:/�%{[�LK~0I"2@ � .<+Y"%!LS&Y� 8�0IZ��E� 8�+1!L.7� &i"%+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�+10I"^! {�"%:/�%{[�LK~0I"2@Q F=�02��+YK>� .y�L!L:/��.7� &r! {³;<� 8%M/02=?� 8�+YK2"2@���� ���IT ¦ O��n@r� 1 � S�#T ¦ � .�Z������n�IT ¦L¦ ��@��IOLT � ¤L¦ �

�#R

Page 42: «7 - mimuwjarekw/talks/sing.pdf · «7 / 3 V ° 3 ^ s ! 702 L+1.G(F+18%MG&D028v:7"VZQ+Y" K~:7" " "%!L= 0 "%8n .7Zr EZ

K�0>=�tQ{�@7K�.Q:7Z/"%02.�@d; :/=x{|!L�EZi@L�Q� +D.Q8%S6��!L.7� 8>\�s�!L��!L+YZ/� &#¢�=P��0IZ/ZQ+1./�#"2@d5�@��#tr��+D./�L02� �i0IK~8�:/��0��C!L8�0I"+1.¡;�� 8�M/02=?� 8%+'K2" ��� � ���IT�U ¤ �n@«�6KNM7� t/8%02�35�@�"%0wK~82� ¤ �n���02=?� H2:/��0L@dX�+D./4�M7� =�@ds�02+'"�"%+102�I\��#02=�+1.7� +1��0^"%:/��&10I"^��+D./�L:r&'� ��+18�0I"iZQ0I"��#:/�%{[�LK~0I"2@L��t/��+D.r�L0>���«0IKE8%:/��0�C!L8�0I"C+1.¡;�� 8�M/02=?� 8%+'K2"������u���IT 1 R��n���N���S��� N��RY��:/�%{|020L@L��+ª{|8�0202.?K�M7� �E�LK~8%0>��+1HI� 8�+1!L.7"«! {7�E� 8�+1!L.7� &QZQ!L:/�/&10�t7!L+1.Q8n"�� .7Zv"%+1=�t/&10mK~��+18�+YK2� &kt�!L+1.k8�"2@ � � ¢^.rS"%02+D�L.r0>=�02.Q8m;�� 8�Mr0>=?� 8%+'¨®:/0 �� ��n�IT�UdT���@�� ¤ O � ¦L¤ �£C02+'Zi@ >^!L:r./�<t�02�E"%!L.7"v�L:/+YZQ0?8%!GK2� ./!L./+YK>� &F"%+1./�L:/&Y� ��+18�+10I"2@^X^��!QKE020IZQ+1./�#"v! {v�#9�=�t7!#"%+Y��+1.,X^:r��0;<� 8%M/02=?� 8�+YK2" ����@Q C&D�L02�/�E� +YK � 02!L=�028%��9�´ J�! (3Z�!L+D.z�IT 1 �Q@ ¤ �#� �/�I�Q�

�/�