2. TVC Research & Testing Report, Paddy Boylan 6.11.13

7/22/2019 2. TVC Research & Testing Report, Paddy Boylan 6.11.13

1/33

"

-PDV Research Services-

!"#"$!%& !"()!*

+,-,./

%01"2*3 #$%&' ()*+

(!)4"%* &"$53 ,$--. /0.1$)

(!)4"%* 2678"!3 "2"34


2/33

5

678 9:;;:? @8A:@B A@8C8>BC D E:FG :9 DFH8@B=C8I8>B A@8JB8CB=>? @8C8D@K7 D>F

9=>F=>?C 9:@ #D@CLC ):@B7 $I8@=KD> B8;8H=C=:> K:II8@K=D; !"#$%"& ()#"% *+,&-678 A@=ID@G D=I :9 B7=C @8C8D@K7 9:@I B78 K@8DB=:> :9 D> DFDAB8F H8@C=:> :9B7=C K:II8@K=D; 9:@ B78 $MCB@D;=D> ID@N8B+ 678 DFDAB8F K:II8@K=D; ? :> B78 2PQ CD;8C =>K@8DC8 :9 K:>98KB=:>D@G :H8@ B78 MAK:I=>?RD;;: A8@=:F+S8 F8B8@I=>8F B78 :A=>=:>C :9 D CA8K=9=K C8B :9 $MCB@D;=D> K:>CMI8@C B:?

B7DB =B 8F A8@9:@ID>K8 =>F=KDB:@ BD@?8BC :> D;; I8DCM@8FDCA8KBC+(> DFF=B=:>' B78 $MCB@D;=D> ID@N8B+


3/33

2

%)2*"2*#(>B@:FMKB=:> Y++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 4+

RGA:B78C8C+++++++++ Y+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Z+

#8B7:F +++++++++++++++++++++++Y+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ W+

%8CM;BC ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++Y+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ [+,8@9:@I=>? DCA8KBC ++Y++++++++++++++++++++++ [+

\>F8@A8@9:@I=>? DCA8KBC Y++++++++ ""+

0B78@ @8CM;BC ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++"4+*:>K;MC=:> ] @8K:II8>FDB=:>C ++++++++++++++ "^+

&MIID@G :9 @8K:II8>FDB=:>C+++ "3+

/=E;=:?@DA7G ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 5P+$AA8>F=T +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 5"+


4/33

4

12*!)56%*1)2

678 @8C8D@K7 F8CK@=E8F => B7=C @8A:@B FMKB8F B: =>9:@I B78 A@:CA8KB=H8

DFDABDB=:> :9 #D@CLC ):@B7 $I8@=KD> 6_* !"#$%"& ()#"% *+,& 9:@ D> $MCB@D;=D>

DMF=8>K8+ 67=C DFDAB8F H8@C=:> B@D; A=8K8 B: D >DB=:>D; A@8JRD;;:

CD;8C E::CB=>? KDIAD=?> C88 B78 @8;DB8F I8F=D CK78FM;8 9:@ F8BD=;Ca+

67=C @8C8D@K7 7DF B78 9:;;:? :EX8KB=H8Cb

"+ 6: A@:H=F8 VMD;=BDB=H8 D>F VMD>B=BDB=H8 :A=>=:> FDBD :> !"#$%"& ()#"% *+,&'EDC8F :> D E@:DF DMF=8>K8 8TDI=>=>? C=T N8G DCA8KBC :9 B78 K:II8@K=D;+ 678

K:;;DB8F FDBD E8 K:IAD@8F D?D=>CB A@8F8B8@I=>8F A8@9:@ID>K8

=>F=KDB:@C B: @8H8D; D@8DC :9 CB@8>?B7 :@ 8CC+

5+ -8B8@I=>=>? B7:C8 DI:>? :M@ B8CB8F DMF=8>K8 B: B78 N8G .+//#0%%1$#1234%"KDB8?:@G' @8A@8C8>B=>? :M@ BD@?8B DMF=8>K8 B78 CK:A8 :9 B7=C@8C8D@K7"+ .+//#0%%1 $#1234%"=C F89=>8F B7=C @8A:@B DC K:>9:@I=>? B:

8=B78@ :@ E:B7 :9 B78 9:;;:? VMD;=9=8@Cb

$+ 678 K:>CMI8@ 7DC E:M?7B K:>98KB=:> ;:;;=8C' KD>FG' :@ C:B78@cC RD;;: DKB=H=B=8C B78 ;DCB 54 I:>B7C+

+1,6#"

/+ 678 K:>CMI8@ A;D>C B: AD@B=K=ADB8 => cB@=KNJ:@JB@8DB=>?c F89=>8F 78@8 DC B78?=H=>? :@ @8K8=H=>? :9 K:>98KB=:> :> RD;;:a B7=C MAK:I=>? RD;;:+

2+ 6: A@:H=F8 =>9:@IDB=:> H=D C8K:>FD@G C:M@K8C :> A:B8>B=D; ;8?D; D>F 8B7=KD;=CCM8C @8?D@F=>? DFH8@B=C=>? D>F B78 $MCB@D;=D> 9::F =>FMCB@G' A@=ID@=;G B7:C8@8;DB=>? B: B78 ID@N8B=>? :9 K:>98KB=:> B: K7=;F@8> D>F DF:;8CK8>BC+

/DC8F MA:> B78 @8CM;BC :9 B7=C @8C8D@K7' D C8B :9 @8K:II8>FDB=:>C =C A@:H=F8F B: DFH=C8

B78 K@8DB=:> :9 D> $MCB@D;=DJCA8K=9=K DFDABDB=:> :9 !"#$%"& ()#"% *+,&+

678 ?:D; :9 E:B7 B78 I:F=9=8F K:II8@K=D; D>F =BLC :@=?=>D; =C B: A:C=B=:> &>=KN8@C DB B78

B:A :9 B78 K:>98KB=:> ID@N8B 9:@ B78 MAK:I=>? RD;;: C8DC:>+ 67=C =C C8B D?D=>CB DEDKN?@:M>F :9 D 2PQ =>K@8DC8 => K:>98KB=:>D@G CD;8C => B78 $MCB@D;=D> ID@N8B FM@=>?

B7=C A8@=:F5+

$>G F8H8;:AI8>B :@ I8F=D CK78FM;=>? :9 B7=C K:II8@K=D; IMCB D;C: BDN8 =>B: DKK:M>B

B78 :>?:=>? 899:@BC EG ?:H8@>I8>B D>F =>FMCB@G B: @8?M;DB8 K:>98KB=:>D@G DFH8@B=C=>?+S7=;8 D I:@8 K:IA;8B8 E@8DNF: :9 DAA;=KDE;8 K:F8C D>F @8?M;DB=:>C KD> E8 9:M>F =>

@898@8>K8 :9 B7=C @8A:@BLC DAA8>F=T' B78 9:;;:? 9DKB:@C IMCB E8 K:>C=F8@8Fb

"

678 DKBMD; BD@?8B DMF=8>K8 9:@ !"#$%"& ()#"% *+,&=C F8CK@=E8F DC ID;8C D>F 98ID;8C D?8F "4J"3' ;=H=>?=> M@ED> :@ CMEM@ED> @8?=:>C+ 678 BD@?8B DMF=8>K8 @898@@8F B: => B7=C @8A:@BLC E:FG @8A@8C8>BC B78A@=ID@G ID@N8BDE;8 K:>CMI8@ ?@:MA DC 8TDI=>8F B7=C @8C8D@K7+5)DB7D> U@=;;C+ `5P"2a+ 7#18%$)9#1%"& 2+/%2 + .+//#0%%1 :#""#" 2)#"&- $HD=;DE;8b7BBAbddI:>DC7+8FMd>88@GJCD;8CJDJ7D;;:J7:@@:@JCB:@G+ 1DCB DKK8CC8F 5^+"P+"2+


5/33

^

J $MCB@D;=D> K:F8C2CA8K=9G B7DB 9::FJID@N8B=>? I8CCD?8C :> B8;8H=C=:> B7DB F:

>:B @8A@8C8>B D e78D;B7G K7:=K8L KD>>:B E8 DFH8@B=C8F FM@=>?b

J *7=;F@8>cC *a A@:?@DIC+J U8>8@D; Ua A@:?@DIC F=@8KB8F A@=ID@=;G B: K7=;F@8>+J $>G A@:?@DII=>? ^PQ :9 B78 DMF=8>K8 =C K7=;F@8>+

J #D@N8B=>? I8CCD?8C IMCB >:B e>:B A@:I:B8 D> =>DKB=H8 ;=98CBG;8L :@

e8>K:M@D?8+++ M>78D;B7G 8DB=>? :@ F@=>N=>? 7DE=BC+c4

J #D@C &>DKN9::F $MCB@D;=DLC : AME;=C78F CBD>FD@FC^CBDB8C B7DB =B :B

8>?D?8 =>b

fYDFH8@B=C=>? F=@8KB8F B: K7=;F@8> M>F8@ "5' @8?D@F;8CC :9 >MB@=B=:>

A@:9=;8+f

S7=;8 ID>G :9 B78C8 K:F8C D@8 C8;9J@8?M;DB:@G D>F H:;M>BD@G' =B =C :M@ M>F8@CBD>F=>?

B7DB =B =C #D@CLC KM@@8>B A:;=KG B: H:;M>BD@=;G K:IA;G C+

678 =IA;=KDB=:>C B78C8 @8?M;DB=:> A:C8 9:@ B78 DFDAB8F !"#$%"& ()#"% *+,&D@8

F=CKMCC8F I:@8 => B7=C ADA8@LC @8K:II8>FDB=:>C+

;/%+2% 1#)% ):+) +// 291+/3%2 91 ):92 "%?#") +"% "#31,%, 3? )# ):% 1%+"%2)

291+/3%2 91 ):92 "%?#") +"% "#31,%, 3? )# ):% 1%+"%2) )0# ,%$94+/ ?/+$%2-

2$$)$+ `5PP[a+@@B@ 7#,% 8#" @,>%")9291< C D+"E%)91< 7#44319$+)9#12 )# 7:9/,"%1- $HD=;DE;8b

7BBAbdd?g*:IICgB:g*7=;F@8>g*:F8JP35PP[+AF9+

1DCB DKK8CC8F 54+"P+"2+4$*#$+ `5PP[a+@7D@ 7:9/,"%1F2 G%/%>929#1 ()+1,+",2 HIIJ-$HD=;DE;8b

7BBAbddCgBHgCBD>FD@FCg5PP[+AF9+ 1DCB DKK8CC8F 5W+"P+"2+^&MCD>>D7 6GIIC+ `5P"5a+ %8CA:>C=E;8 DFH8@B=C=>? B: K7=;F@8>b D> =>F8A8>F8>B @8H=8< :9 B78 $MCB@D;=D>9::F D>F E8H8@D?8 =>FMCB@G C8;9JJJ@8?M;DB:@G K:F8C+ &MCD>>D7 6GIIC' =>F8A8>F8>B 9::F D>F D?@=KM;BM@8K:>CM;BD>B' *D>E8@@D+ A?55+


6/33

Z

&9()*&"#"#

S8 E8?=> $MCB@D;=D> .+//#0%%1 $#1234%"DMF=8>K8' DK7=8H=>? DB;8DCB B78 EDC8;=>8 A:C=B=H8 A8@9:@ID>K8 =>F=KDB:@ CK:@8 `DC F89=>8F => B7=C

@8A:@BLC I8B7:F E8;:? I=;F D>F CBDB=CB=KD;;G =>C=?>=9=KD>B 8TK8AB=:>C+

67=C F B78@8;8HD>K8 :9 =BC I8CCD?8 B: RD;;: EMG=>? DKB=H=B=8C+


7/33

W

7"*&)5

%8C8D@K7 FMKB8F => BF

A:AM;DB=:>J@89;8KB=H8 VMD>B=BDB=H8 FDBD C8B' 8G8 B:B=9G=>? B7:C8 => :M@C8?I8>B B8F DC .+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2+ .+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2K8 9:@ B78 AM@A:C8C :9 B7=C @8A:@B' D>F 8F B7@:M?7 DVMD;=9G=>? VM8CB=:>+

678 CM@H8G F=H=FMD;C 9@:I :M@ ID=;=>? ;=CB :H8@ hDK8E::ND>F 8ID=;+

678 CM@H8G DCN8F @8CA:>F8>BC B: H=8< B78 DF EG 9:;;:? D> 8TB8@>D; ;=>N B: =BC.:MBME8 A:CB=>?+ S8 DCN8F "P VM8CB=:>C => B:BD;' K:H8@=>? B78 9:;;:?b

J -8B8@I=>=>? D?8 ] ?8>F8@ IM;B=A;8dE=>D@G K7:=K8 @8CA8KB=H8;GaJ $ VMD;=9G=>? VM8CB=:> F8B8@I=>=>? :B B78 @8CA:>F8>B =:> HD;M8C :9 8DK7 DCA8KB `8DK7 HD;M8 @D>?=>? 9@:I " B: ^a E8 E@:N8> F: =>B: B78=@ I8D>' I:F8 D>F I8F=D> HD;M8C D>F K:IAD@8F 8F >=?@A?B;CD= ECFED;GA?


8/33

3

5+ h:@ DCA8KBC +/3%:MBK:I8' D I8D> :9 DB I:CB 5+2 D>F DI:F8 D>F I8F=D> :9 DB I:CB 2 DK@:CC D BD@?8B C8?I8>B F=KDB8

A:C=B=H8 A8@9:@ID>K8 B+

2+ h:@ eA@:FMKBdE@D>F =F8>B=9=KDB=:>L' D CMKK8CC9M; =F8>B=9=KDB=:> @DB8 :9 3^QF=KDB8 A:C=B=H8 A8@9:@ID>K8+

$ K:AG D>F E@8DNF: :9 B7=C CM@H8G' =>K;MF=>? C @8;DB8 B: F C=F8@8F B: 7DH8 F8C=@DE;8 7=?7 :@ ;:< HD;M8C' KD> E8

9:M>F M>F8@ @898@8>K8 Z => B78 DAA8>F=T+

S8 :B8 B7DB FM8 B: B78 >DBM@8 :9 :M@ ID=;=>? ;=CB B78 IDX:@=BG :9

=>F=H=FMD;C BD@?8B8F F=H=FMD;C' =>? :9 B78 DF+ $C F BC K:M;F E8 =IA;8I8>B8F B: 8998KB=H8;GDFDAB =B+ 678 VM8CB=:>C 8F B=BDB=H8 FDBD => I=>F => :@F8@ B:

A@:H=F8 =B ? VMD;=BDB=H8 =>C=?7BC+

678 9:KMC ?@:MA K:>C=CB8F :9 ID;8C D>F 98ID;8C DK@:CC D @D>?8 :9 D?8 D>F 8B7>=K

EDKN?@:M>FC' D;;:? A:B8>B=D; 9:@ D HD@=8BG :9 =>C=?7BC DK@:CC D E@:DF K:>CMI8@ EDC8+

R:F =C F=CKMCC8F 9M@B78@ => B78 @8CM;BC+


9/33

[

!"#60*#

2 :MB :9 Z :9 !"#$%"& ()#"% *+,&LC CM@H8GJB8CB8F DCA8KBCI8B A8@9:@ID>K8 =>F=KDB:@

BD@?8BC K;MC=:> D>F @8K:II8>FDB=:>C 9:@F8BD=;C+

/89:@8 A@:K88F=>?' K:M>B8@8F =>

:M@ @8C8D@K7' D>F B78=@ A:B8>B=D; =IADKB :> @8CM;BCb

J 678 9:KMC ?@:MA 7DF :>;G :>8 DMF=8>K8 I8IE8@ B: B78KDB8?:@G :9 .+//#0%%1 $#1234%"+ -8CA=B8 B7=C' :M@ @8C8D@K7 K:>K;MF8CB7DB D> =>F=H=FMD;LC CBDBMC DC RD;;: :@ >:>JRD;;: K:>CMI8@

7DC ;=BB;8 :EH=:MC 8998KB :> :A=>=:>C B:DBM@8 :9 :M@ ID=;=>? ;=CB B78 IDX:@=BG :9 =>F=H=FMD;CBD@?8B8F


10/33

"P

.+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2F "%2?#12%2 )# KL ):91E ):92 +, 92 4%4#"+A/%!M

e#8I:@DE=;=BGL A8@9:@ID>K8 CK:@8Cb

#8D>b NO.Z

#8F=D>b NW#:F8b N3

$MF=8>K8 @8CA:>C8C B: E:B7 eI8CCD?8 K;D@=BGL D>F eA@:FMKBdE@D>F =F8>B=9=KDB=:>L :@ XMCB DE:H8 B78 B7@8C7:;F :9 B78=@ @8CA8KB=H8 A8@9:@ID>K8 BD@?8BC+

/+I(?AFPDG,J?;CF EF=CGE@ED;GEACMCK:@8F QRS`"" :MB :9 "2 @8CA:>F8>BC CMKK8CC9M;;G

=F8>B=9=8F B78 E@D>F[a K8 BD@?8B :9 QRS' DC ?@DA78F E8;: KD;KM;DB8F DCb `2n2n4n4n4n4n4n4n4n4n^n^n^a o "2 T NO.W#8F=D> KD;KM;DB8F DCb `"2n"a o 5 p W' q I8F=D> p WB7F=?=B => C8VM8>K8' q I8F=D> p N3#:F8 KD;KM;DB8F DCb 2' 2' NU NU NU NU NU NU NU N' ^' ^' ^' q I:F8 p N`3 HC 2 HC 5 :KKM@@8>K8Ca[,8@K8>BD?8 KD;KM;DB8F DCb ""o"2 T "PP p 3^Q


11/33

""

.+//#0%%1 7#1234%"2F "%2?#12%2 )# K+"% +A/% )# 9,%1)98&

):% A"+1, #" ?"#,3$) 91 ):92 $#44%"$9+/NM

*+I7=F I8F=D>dI:F8 :9 4' K8

BD@?8BC :9 2+W D>F 2 @8CA8KB=H8;G+ &88 BDE;8 " => B78 DAA8>F=T+

-+ %8CA:>C8C 9@:I :MB 9:KMC ?@:MA @8=>9:@K8F B78C8 VMD>B=BDB=H8 9=>F=>?C :>eI8I:@DE=;=BGL' eA@:FMKBdE@D>F =F8>B=9=KDB=:>L D>F eI8CCD?8 K;D@=BG'L F+J ): I8IE8@C => B78 ?@:MA 7DF F=99=KM;BG K:IA@878>F=>? B78 >D@@DB=H8

:@ I8CCD?8 => B78 DF+

6CF=?>=?@A?BECH $=DG? DI8D> :9 :>;G 5+Z D?D=>CB D BD@?8B :9 2+W' dI:F8 CK:@=>? 2+ 67=C =C

A@8C8>B8F E8;:B=r=8F

3^Q

*:M;F >:B

=F8>B=9G

"^Q


12/33

"5

.+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2F "%2?#12%2 )#K@8)%" >9%091< ):% +,5 L +4 4#"% 91$/91%, )# A3& ):92

?"#,3$)OM

e(IADKBL A8@9:@ID>K8 CK:@8Cb#8D>b +OV

#8F=D>b /#:F8b /

09 AD@B=KM;D@ >:B8 =C B78 9DKB B7DB B7=C CK:@8 =C =F8>B=KD; B: B78 e=IADKBL CK:@8 9:@ >:>J.+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2' DB 5+Zd2d2 `C88 BDE;8 2+2 => B78 DAA8>F=Ta+

h+ 67=C ;:< CM@H8G CK:@8 H8CB=?DB8F :M@ 9:KMC ?@:MA' D>F B78 e=IADKBL

VM8CB=:> D I:@8 CA8K=9=K ID>>8@ => :@F8@ B: C88 =9 B78 :MBK:I8 9:@IDB=:> DC A@8C8>B8F => B78 VM8CB=:>+ 678 ?@:MA N B7DB B7=C `DFa ? &>=KN8@C ED@C 9:@

RD;;:kl

678 @8CA:>C8 D;I:CB M>D>=I:MC D>F CB@:>?&%2' C?VM=KN;G D>F DCCM@8F;G+ 6: 9M@B78@ K:>9=@I' B78G DCN8Fb


13/33

"2

j-:8C D>GE:FG B7=>N B7DB B78G B78IC8;H8C I=?7B E8 I:@8 A8@CMDF8F B: EMG

&>=KN8@C `D9B8@ H=8? B7=C DFakl

%:M?7;G 7D;9 :9 B78 ?@:MA D?@88F' >:BDE;G 8H8> =>K;MF=>? D ;D@?8 A:@B=:> :9 B78 >:>J

.+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2D>F =>K;MF=>? B78 C=>?;8 .+//#0%%1 $#1234%"+ ):E:FG => B78

?@:MA F=CD?@88F +

U+ e$>>=;KMD;C: @DB8F E8;:< BD@?8B :9 2+5 D>F D I8F=D>dI:F8 :9 2 `BD@?8BCb2+Wd2a+ &88 BDE;8 5 :9 B78 DAA8>F=T+

&BDB8I8>BC EG B78 9:KMC ?@:MA A@:H=F8F B78 9:;;:? =>C=?7BC :> B78 DFLC DAA8D;b

J j(BLC XMCB D;@=?7B+ (BLC >:B EDF+lJ j(B >G+ (B LB :+:+:+ 9M>>GY =B BC CMC B7DB B78 I:I8>B >=C:>L @M>CD>=8@ I:I8>BC => B78 K:II8@K=D;+

R+ e%PKGP?;K ;DD=>G;JEKEGLMF @8CA8KB=H8

I8DCM@8I8>BC+

678 9=@CB' jL929#1 +,2 )# @4%"9$+1 #1%2'l =C =>B8>F8F B:

?DM?8 ?8>8@D; :A=>=:> B: H8@CMC $MCB@D;=D> B8;8H=C=:>DFH8@B=C=>?' D>F =C >:B D CA8K=9=K @89;8KB=:> :9 !"#$%"& ()#"% *+,&5 IDN=>? B78 DAA;=KDB=:>

:9 D A8@9:@ID>K8 =>F=KDB:@ I8D>=>?;8CC+

(B CK:@8F :B 7=B =BC BD@?8B :9 5+2d2d2+

R: HD;M8+ &88 K:>K;MC=:> D>F @8K:II8>FDB=:>+


14/33

"4

678C8 :A=>=:>C 8@D;;G 8K7:8F EG B78 9:KMC ?@:MAb

J 678@8 K8 B: DFC+J 67:C8 9:@ B7=C

AD@B=KM;D@ DF+

J 678 A@8HD=;=>? 988;=>? K8@>8FDE:MB K:II8@K=D; =C $MCB@D;=D> :@ $I8@=KD>+

)G:=? ?= B78 9:KMC ?@:MA G 8B7=KD; :@ A8@C:>D; =CCM8 ? :9 K:>98KB=:> :9 $MCB@D;=D> B8;8H=C=:>' =>K;MF=>? B: K7=;F@8>' B78 M>D>=I:MC@8CA:>C8 :B+

$ E@8DNF: :9 D;; A8@9:@ID>K8 9=?M@8C 9:@ .+//#0%%1D>F >:>J.+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2

KD> E8 9:M>F => B78 DAA8>F=T M>F8@ BDE;8C 4+" D>F 4+5+


15/33

"^

%)2%06#1)2 $25 !"%)7"25$*1)2#

&L>AG:=B8>B :9 B78 ):@B7 $I8@=KD> !"#$%"& ()#"% /+,& 8@D;;G CM=BDE;8 9:@ D> $MCB@D;=D> .+//#0%%1 $#1234%"DMF=8>K8' DK7=8H=>? DB;8DCB B78 EDC8;=>8 A:C=B=H8 A8@9:@ID>K8 =>F=KDB:@ CK:@8 9:@ D;; N8G DCA8KBC' D>F

8F :MB B: E8 =>K:@@8KB+ 0>;G 2 :MB :9 Z N8G DCA8KB A8@9:@I8F' ?8C >8K8CCD@G B: :AB=I=O8 !"#$%"& ()#"% *+,&+ 678C8 N8G DCA8KBC D@8 ;=CB8F

=> :@F8@ :9 7=?78CB A8@9:@ID>K8b

.O 7=BA?;JEKEGL

/8=>? B78 :>;G CK:@8 B: 8TK88F =BC A8@9:@ID>K8 =>F=KDB:@ EDC8;=>8' K;MF8 B7DB!"#$%"& ()#"% *+,&=C D H8@G I8I:@DE;8 K:II8@K=D;' DC CMAA:@B8F EG @8CM;BC $ D>F -+

(> B7=C D@8D' B78 K:II8@K=D; >88FC >: I:F=9=KDB=:>+

+O (?AFPDG,J?;CF EF=CGE@ED;GEAC

I,@:FMKBdE@D>F =F8>B=9=KDB=:>L IDF8 =BC A8@9:@ID>K8 BD@?8B EG D ID@?=> :9 P+ &88 @8CM;BC/ D>F -+

S8 E8;=8H8 B7DB B78 K:II8@K=D; A8@9:@IC => B7=C D@8D' D>F B

K:M;F A:B8>B=D;;G =>K@8DC8 B7=C CK:@8 =B M>>8K8CCD@G CB8A+

/O 7=B=9=KDB=:>L' eI8CCD?8 K;D@=BGL IDF8 =BC BD@?8B' D;B7:M?7 EGD ID@?=> :9 P+ &88 @8CM;BC * D>F -+

S7=;8 =IA@:H8I8>B K:M;F A:B8>B=D;;G =>K@8DC8 B7=C CK:@8' >8K8CCD@G+

NO $>>=;K

!"#$%"& ()#"% *+,& F=F >:B @8DK7 =BC eDAA8D;L BD@?8B' D> D@8D F=KDB8F EG@8CM;B U' Bb

"+ 0M@ 9:KMC ?@:MA @8H8D;8F B7DB B78 K:I=K 8998KB :9 B78 B@:;;8G 9=;;=>?=KN8@C B >=C:>L @M>C D? B@:;;8G 9@:I :M@ e:;F ;DFGL' K;8D@;G M>C8BB;8FEG 78@ K@88AG DAA8D@D>K8' H:=K8 D>F E87DH=:M@' F B: :>8 :9B78 K:II8@K=D;LC 9M>>=8CB I:I8>BC+


16/33

"Z

S8 E8;=8H8 B7DB 8>7D>K=>? B78 A@:I=>8>K8 :9 B78 DE:H8 BBC => B78

K:II8@K=D; 8@D;;G DAA8D;=>? 9:@ :M@

BD@?8B DMF=8>K8+

RO %PKGP?;K ;DD=>G;JEKEGL

S7=;8 .+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2 C88I8F B: A@898@ B7=C $I8@=KD> K:II8@K=D; B: I:CB' D>F

K:II8@K=D;C => ?8>8@D;' B7=C DCA8KB =B CB=;; F=F >:B I88B =BCVMD>B=BDB=H8 A8@9:@ID>K8 BD@?8B+ &88 @8CM;B R+

/DC8F :> :M@ @8CM;BC' F B78 9:;;:?b

2+ %8H:=K8 !"#$%"& ()#"% *+,& DKB:@C+ $MCB@D;=D> H:=K8CB => =>K@8DC=>? KM;BM@D; 9DI=;=D@=BG ?=>? B78 K:>K8AB :9

B78 e:;F ;DFGLCL 9DN8 H:=K8 D>F DKK8>B+ 678C8 D@8 D N8G AD@B :9 B78K:II8@K=D;LC DAA8D;' D>F =9 @8J@8K:@F8F C7:M;F @8ID=> B78 CDI8 =>

B:>8' `9DN8a DKK8>B D>F K:I=K =>B8>B=:>+

$C D> D;B8@>DB=H8 :AB=:>' C=IA;G @8J@8K:@F D;; H:=K8C 8TK8AB B78 e:;F

;DFGLCL B: A@8C8@H8 =BC K:I=K 8998KB+

VO 1B>;DG

!"#$%"& ()#"% *+,&F2 e(IADKBL =C A8@7DAC =BC I:CB 8CC8>B=D; K:IA:>8>B => B8@IC :9

I88B=>? =BLC DFH8@B=C=>? :EX8KB=H8 :9 KDA=BD;=O=>? :> B78 RD;;: K:>98KB=:>D@G CD;8C

CA=N8+ S8 K:M;F K:>C=F8@ B78> B7DB B78 K:II8@K=D;LC =IADKB E8=>? C: 9D@ M>F8@ BD@?8B'DC C88> => @8CM;B i' E:F8C A::@;G+

R: @8CM;B h' F B78 9:;;:?b

4+ S8 @8K:II8>F @8C8D@K7 8TB8>F =>B: =BC D;;:BB8F A8@=:F :9 @8JB8CB+ S8E8;=8H8 D>:B78@ CM@H8G C7:M;F E8 K:>FMKB8F :> D >8< DMF=8>K8' DCF8I:?@DA7=KD;;G C=I=;D@ DC A:CC=E;8 B: B78 :@=?=>D; DMF=8>K8+ 678 >8B=KD; B: B78 :@=?=>D; :9

VM8CB=:> 3' H=>K=>? DC D CM??8CB=:> B: EMG &>=KN8@C 9:@

RD;;:+l

678 ^ @D>N D>C8D@ =F8>B=KD; VM8CB=:> B: B78 :>8 A:C8F => :M@ 9:KMC ?@:MA' EG @8;8DC=>? =B D

CM@H8G 78;A F8B8@I=>8 =9 B78 9:KMC ?@:MALC @8CA:>C8 :ID;:MC :@ K8 @8CA:>C8C DKBMD;;G F: K7D>?8 K;MC=:> :9 B78 RD;;: K:>B8TB B:

B78 VM8CB=:>+

):B8 B7DB 8< CM@H8G @8CM;BC D@8 A:C=B=H8 :@ >8?DB=H8' e=IADKBLCL :@=?=>D;

CM@H8G CK:@8 =C >:B


17/33

"W

(> DFF=B=:>' K@8DC8 !"#$%"& ()#"% *+,&LC =IADKB+ 678@89:@8' F B7DB FM@=>? B78 D;;:BB8F @8JB8CB B=I8' D>:B78@ 9:KMC?@:MA =C A8@9:@I8F+ 67=C ?@:MA F E8BB8@ B7D> :B78@ ?@:MAC DK@:CC D;;

A8@9:@ID>K8 =>F=KDB:@C' DKK8AB=>? I=;F D>F CBDB=CB=KD;;G =>C=?>=9=KD>B 8TK8AB=:>C+

67=C F B78@8;8HD>K8 :9 =BC I8CCD?8 B: RD;;: EMG=>? DKB=H=B=8C+l

/DC8F :> :M@ @8CM;BC' K;MF8 B7DB 7GA:B78C=C 5 7DC >:B E88> HD;=FDB8F+ *:;;DB8F?@DA7C :9 E:B7 .+//#0%%1D>F >:>J.+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2 KD> E8 9:M>F => B78 DAA8>F=T

M>F8@ BDE;8 4+" D>F 4+5+

S78B78@ :@ >:B D> =>F=H=FMD; ? B: =BC BD@?8B ID@N8B B7D> =B 8@D;

AME;=K+ S8 E8;=8H8 B7DB B7=C K:M;F @89;8KB e=IADKBL D>F eDAA8D;L FM8 B: D A:CC=E;8 =>DE=;=BG B: K:IIM>=KDB8 D> 8998KB=H8 RD;;:

EDC8F I8CCD?8+

7=FE; KED;GEAC @8JB8CB=>? !"#$%"& ()#"% *+,& CB=;; 7DC >:B DK7=8H8F DB ;8DCB B78 I=>=IMIA8@9:@ID>K8 CK:@8C 9:@ D;; Z :9 =BLC N8G DCA8KBC' B78 9:;;:? C7:M;F E8 K:>C=F8@8Fb

Z+ 68;8H=C=:> I8F=D EMG C7:M;F E8 C;=?7B;G B: I:F8@DB8;G @8FMK8F'DKK:@F=>? B: B78 8TB8>B B: F8@A8@9:@IC+ $C

!"#$%"& ()#"% *+,&6_* 9:@IC B78 K8>B@D; K:IA:>8>B :9 B7=CKDIAD=?>' D;; CDB8;;=B8 DFH8@B=C8I8>BC :> :B78@ I8F=MIC C7:M;F E8

@8FMK8F EG B7=C CDI8 A8@K8>BD?8+

$C F=CKMCC8F => B7=C ADA8@LC =>B@:FMKB=:>' @8;8HD>B ;DF @8?M;DB=:>C => A;DK8 ? :> !"#$%"& ()#"% *+,&LC I8F=D CK78FM;=>?+ S8 @8K:II8>F B78 9:;;:?


18/33

"3

B=I8CdDMF=8>K8 IDN8MAC E8 DEC:;MB8;G DH:=F8F 9:@ K:IA;=D>K8 FMCB@G D>F ;8?D;

CBD>FD@FCb

W+ -: >:B DFH8@B=C8 FM@=>? K7=;F@8>LC `*a A@:?@DII=>?+-: >:B DFH8@B=C8 FM@=>? ?8>8@D; Ua A@:?@DIC F=@8KB8F A@=ID@=;G B:

K7=;F@8>+

-: >:B DFH8@B=C8 FM@=>? D>G A@:?@DII=>? PQ :9B78 DMF=8>K8 =C K7=;F@8>+

*7=;F@8> D@8 K:>C=F8@8F D>G A8@C:> MA B: D>F =>K;MF=>? "5 G8D@C :9 D?8+

#PBB;?L A@ ?=DABB=CF;GEAC H:=K8CB => =>K@8DC=>? KM;BM@D; 9DI=;=D@=BG ?=>? B78 K:>K8AB :9B78 e:;F ;DFGLCL 9DN8 H:=K8 D>F DKK8>B+ 678C8 D@8 D N8G AD@B :9 B78

K:II8@K=D;LC DAA8D;' D>F =9 @8J@8K:@F8F C7:M;F @8ID=> B78 CDI8 =>B:>8' `9DN8a DKK8>B D>F K:I=K =>B8>B=:>+

$C D> D;B8@>DB=H8 :AB=:>' C=IA;G @8J@8K:@F D;; H:=K8C 8TK8AB B78 e:;F;DFGLCL B: A@8C8@H8 =BC K:I=K 8998KB+

4+ S8 @8K:II8>F @8C8D@K7 8TB8>F =>B: =BC D;;:BB8F A8@=:F :9 @8JB8CB+ S8E8;=8H8 D>:B78@ CM@H8G C7:M;F E8 K:>FMKB8F :> D >8< DMF=8>K8' DC

F8I:?@DA7=KD;;G C=I=;D@ DC A:CC=E;8 B: B78 :@=?=>D; DMF=8>K8+ 678 >8B=KD; B: B78 :@=?=>D; :9VM8CB=:> 3' H=>K=>? DC D CM??8CB=:> B: EMG &>=KN8@C 9:@

RD;;:+l

678 ^ @D>N D>CF B7DB FM@=>? B78 D;;:BB8F @8JB8CB B=I8' D>:B78@ 9:KMC?@:MA =C A8@9:@I8F+ 67=C ?@:MA


19/33

"[

E+ (>K;MC=:> :9 D CK8>8 :9 DKBMD; AM@K7DC8K+ (9 =>K@8DC=>? :B78@ 8;8I8>BC' CMK7 DC =BLC 7MI:M@ :@ KM;BM@D;

9DI=;=D@=BG' K:M;F A:B8>B=D;;G =>K@8DC8 e=IADKBL+

Z+ (9 !"#$%"& ()#"% *+,&CB=;; M>F8@A8@9:@IC MA:> @8B8CB=>?' 68;8H=C=:>I8F=D EMG C7:M;F E8 C;=?7B;G B: I:F8@DB8;G @8FMK8F' DKK:@F=>? B: B788TB8>B B: F8@A8@9:@IC+ $C !"#$%"& ()#"% *+,&

6_* 9:@IC B78 K8>B@D; K:IA:>8>B :9 B7=C KDIAD=?>' D;; CDB8;;=B8DFH8@B=C8I8>BC :> :B78@ I8F=MIC C7:M;F E8 @8FMK8F EG B7=C CDI8

A8@K8>BD?8+

W+ -: >:B DFH8@B=C8 FM@=>? K7=;F@8>LC `*a A@:?@DII=>?+-: >:B DFH8@B=C8 FM@=>? ?8>8@D; Ua A@:?@DIC F=@8KB8F A@=ID@=;G B:

K7=;F@8>+

-: >:B DFH8@B=C8 FM@=>? D>G A@:?@DII=>? PQ :9

B78 DMF=8>K8 =C K7=;F@8>+

*7=;F@8> D@8 K:>C=F8@8F DMF=8>K8C "5 G8D@C D>F M>F8@+


20/33

5P

81801)W!$(&9

"+ )DB7D> U@=;;C+ 5P"2a+ 7#18%$)9#1%"& 2+/%2 + .+//#0%%1 :#""#" 2)#"&- $HD=;DE;8b

7BBAbddI:>DC7+8FMd>88@GJCD;8CJDJ7D;;:J7:@@:@JCB:@G+ 1DCB

DKK8CC8F 5^+"P+"2+

5+ sM;=D> ,:@BD D>F )DB7D> U@=;;C+ 5P"2a+ G:% ,+"E 29,% )# .+//#0%%1O 4+"E%)91929#1 ()+1,+",2 HIIJ-$HD=;DE;8b7BBAbddCgBHgCBD>FD@FCg5PP[+AF9+ 1DCB DKK8CC8F 5W+"P+"2+

$FF=B=:>D; IDB8@=D;b

!"#$%"& ()#"% *+,&6_* DHD=;DE;8 9:@ H=8? DBb

7BBAbdd


21/33

5"

$(("251X

R* @898@C B: .+//#0%%1 $#1234%")R* @898@C B: >:>J.+//#0%%1 $#1234%"

6DE;8 "b.+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2F "%2?#12%2 )# RG:% +,S2 2)#"&/91% 0+2 %+2& )# 8#//#05 +1, L

31,%"2)##, 0:+) 0+2 :+??%191


22/33

55

6DE;8 5b

.+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2F "%2?#12%2 )# RL /9E% ):92 +,OM T.//$&)U

R* e$AA8D;L A8@9:@ID>K8 CK:@8Cb

#8D>b 2+5#8F=D>b 2

#:F8b 2


23/33

52

6DE;8 2+Pb

B#1=.+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2F "%2?#12%2 )# KL /9E% ):92 +,OM T.//$&)U

)R* e$AA8D;L A8@9:@ID>K8 CK:@8Cb

#8D>b 2+4#8F=D>b 4#:F8b 4


24/33

54

6DE;8 2+"b

B#1=.+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2F "%2?#12%2 )# KL ):91E ):92 +, 92 4%4#"+A/%OM T#$01*&2+)+,-U

)R* eI8I:@DE=;=BGL A8@9:@ID>K8 CK:@8Cb

#8D>b 2+W#8F=D>b 4

#:F8b 4


25/33

5^

6DE;8 2+5b

B#1=.+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2F "%2?#12%2 )# KG:% +,F2 2)#"&/91% 0+2 %+2& )# 8#//#05 +1, L

31,%"2)##, 0:+) 0+2 :+??%191


26/33

5Z

6DE;8 2+2b

B#1=.+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2F "%2?#12%2 )# K+8)%" >9%091< ):% +,5 L +4 4#"% 91$/91%, )# A3&

):92 ?"#,3$)OM T30/&(,U

)R* e=IADKBL A8@9:@ID>K8 CK:@8Cb#8D>b 5+Z

#8F=D>b 2#:F8b 2


27/33

5W

6DE;8 2+4b

B#1=.+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2F "%2?#12%2 )# KL 929#1 +,2 )#

@4%"9$+1 #1%2OM T45),5*&) .(($/,&2+)+,-6 &7% +8 '$8$*&)U

)R* eKM;BM@D; DKK8ABDE=;=BGL DFC => ?8>8@D;a A8@9:@ID>K8 CK:@8Cb#8D>b 2+2

#8F=D>b 2#:F8b 2


28/33

53

6DE;8 2+^b

B#1=.+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2F "%2?#12%2 )# KL 0#3/, ?"%8%" ):92 +, 98 9) 0+21F) @4%"9$+1OM

T45),5*&) .(($/,&2+)+,-6 9*1($*- %,1*$ )&7- %/$(+:+(&))-U

)R* eKM;BM@D; DKK8ABDE=;=BGL B7=C DF CA8K=9=KD;;Ga A8@9:@ID>K8 CK:@8Cb#8D>b 4+"#8F=D>b 2

#:F8b 2

6DE;8 2+Zb

B#1=.+//#0%%1 $#1234%"2F "%2?#12%2 )# K+"% +A/% )# 9,%1)98& ):% A"+1, #" ?"#,3$) 91):92 $#44%"$9+/NM

"4 :MB "Z )R*C CMKK8CC9M;;G =F8>B=9=8F B78 E@D>F 3W+^Qa

*:@@8KB;G

=F8>B=r=8F

3W+^Q

*:M;F >:B

=F8>B=9G

"5+^Q


29/33

5[

6DE;8 4+"

.+//#0%%1 $#1234%" #?919#1 "+1E91F =F8>B=9=KDB=:>' >:B F=CA;DG8F' =C 3^Q+

6DE;8 4+5

B#1=.+//#0%%1 $#1234%" #?919#1 "+1E91F =F8>B=9=KDB=:>' >:B F=CA;DG8F' =C 3W+^Q+

4+"

5+3

2+W

5+Z

2+5

4

2

4

2 2

4

2

4

2 2

P

P+^

"

"+^

5

5+^

2

2+^

4

4+^

#8I:@DE=;=BG *M;BM@D;$KK8ABDE=;=BG

`DF CA8K=r=Ka

#8CCD?8 K;D@=BG (IADKB $AA8D;

#8D>

#:F8

#8F=D>

2+W

4+"

2+3

5+Z

2+4

4

2

4

2 2

4

2

4

2 2

P

P+^

"

"+^

5

5+^

2

2+^

4

4+^

#8I:@DE=;=BG *M;BM@D;

$KK8ABDE=;=BG

`DF CA8K=r=Ka

#8CCD?8 K;D@=BG (IADKB $AA8D;

#8D>

#:F8

#8F=D>


30/33

2P

%898@8>K8 b

678 ID>FDB:@G CBD>FD@FC => A;DK8 D@8 C8B EG E:B7 B78@32)"+/9+1 7#44319$+)9#12 +1,

D%,9+ @3):#"9)&S2 7:9/,"%1S2 G%/%>929#1 ()+1,+",2 HIIJVI' @8;DB=>? B: B78 B=I=>? D>F

K:>B8>BC :9 I8F=D I8CCD?8C :> D;; K:II8@K=D; B8;8H=C=:>+

\>F8@ B78C8 K:F8C' DFH8@B=C8I8>BC E@:DFKDCBC IMCB >:B e>:B A@:I:B8 D> =>DKB=H8

;=98CBG;8L :@ e8>K:M@D?8+++ M>78D;B7G 8DB=>? :@ F@=>N=>? 7DE=BC+c

678 $MCB@D;=D> $CC:K=DB=:> :9 )DB=:>D; $FH8@B=C8@C ID=>BD=>C B78 C8;9J@8?M;DB:@G@@B@

7#,% 8#" D+"E%)91< +1, @,>%")9291< 7#44319$+)9#12 )# 7:9/,"%1-VV\>F8@ B78C8 K:F8C'

DFH8@B=C8I8>BC IMCB >:B cM>F8@I=>8 B78 =IA:@BD>K8 :9 78D;B7G :@ DKB=H8 ;=98CBG;8C :@

B78 A@:I:B=:> :9 78D;B7G ED;D>K8F F=8BC+c

678C8 K:F8C D;C: CBDB8 B7DB :>;G 9::FC D>F E8H8@D?8C B7DB I88B K:IAD>G CBDB8F D>F

K:IAD>G F8B8@I=>8Fa CBD>FD@FC 9:@ D c78D;B7G K7:=K8c IDG E8 DFH8@B=C8F F=@8KB;G B:

K7=;F@8>+ 67=C DAA;=8C B78 DFH8@B=C=>? BDN8C A;DK8 FM@=>?b

J *7=;F@8>cC va A@:?@DIC

J U8>8@D; Ua A@:?@DIC F=@8KB8F A@=ID@=;G B: K7=;F@8>

J $;; A@:?@DII=>? ^PQ :9 B78 DMF=8>K8 =C K7=;F@8>+

#D@C &>DKN9::F $MCB@D;=D K:IA;=8C B: B78C8 @8?M;DB:@G D>F C8;9J@8?M;DB:@G CBD>FD@FC'

D>F => DFF=B=:> 7DC =BcC : AME;=C78F CBD>FD@FC"5' =>K;MF=>? B78 9:;;:?b

f): DFH8@B=C=>? B: F=@8KB8F B: K7=;F@8> M>F8@ "5' @8?D@F;8CC :9 >MB@=B=:> A@:9=;8+f

S=B7 B7=C => I=>F' B7=C @8A:@B DFH=C8C B7DB U@:K8@G &B:@8 1DFG' A@:I:B=>? &>=KN8@C

*D>FG /D@' 8C @8?D@F=>? B8;8H=C=:> ID@N8B=>? B: K7=;F@8> DC =B;=N8;G =C >:B K:>C=F8@8F D c78D;B7G K7:=K8c 9::F+ 678@89:@8' #D@C C7:M;F DH:=F D>G

DFH8@B=C=>? C;:BC B: K:>9;=KB 929#1 ()+1,+",2 HIIJ-$HD=;DE;8b7BBAbddCgBHgCBD>FD@FC

g5PP[+AF9+ 1DCB DKK8CC8F 5W+"P+"2+""$$)$+ `5PP[a+@@B@ 7#,% 8#" @,>%")9291< C D+"E%)91< 7#44319$+)9#12 )# 7:9/,"%1- $HD=;DE;8b7BBAbdd?g*:IICgB:g*7=;F@8>g*:F8JP35PP[+AF9+1DCB DKK8CC8F 54+"P+"2+"5&MCD>>D7 6GIIC+ `5P"5a+ %8CA:>C=E;8 DFH8@B=C=>? B: K7=;F@8>b D> =>F8A8>F8>B @8H=8< :9 B78$MCB@D;=D> 9::F D>F E8H8@D?8 =>FMCB@G C8;9JJJ@8?M;DB:@G K:F8C+ &MCD>>D7 6GIIC' =>F8A8>F8>B 9::F D>F

D?@=KM;BM@8 K:>CM;BD>B' *D>E8@@D+ A?55+


31/33

2"

%898@8>K8 Zb

678 9:;;:? =C D K:AG :9 B78 ? CM@H8GI:>N8G+K:I

!" $%&'(& )'*+, *,& -.%%.)/01 2/3&." 4* /( ' (,.5* *&%&2/(/.0 +.66&5+/'% *,'* -/5(* '/5&3 /0

76&5/+'"

,**89::)))";.


32/33

25

O" E.)F 8%&'(& 5'*& ;.


33/33

22

!" A*5.01%; T/('15&&

K" T/('15&&

P" E&/*,&5 715&& 0.5 T/('15&&

N" 715&&

O" A*5.01%; 715&&

):B8 t B78 9:;;:? =C D E@8DNF: :9 8DK7 CM@H8G VM8CB=:> =>B: =BLC @8;8HD>B eN8GDCA8KBL D>F

Documents

2. TVC Research & Testing Report, Paddy Boylan 6.11.13