Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
2
2
Webinar 5 Issue BriefPowerPoint File
• An email with links to these documents was sent to all registered participants
• Check your inbox for an email from the “California Hospital Association”
• For assistance, call CHA Education at (916) 552-7637
3
Anne McLeodSenior Vice President, Health Policy & InnovationCalifornia Hospital Association
Anne McLeod provides leadership in the development of CHA’s public policy objectives and develops innovative policy solutions for CHA’s members. Using her experience and extensive knowledge of federal and state health policies, Ms. McLeod represents hospitals’ interests and supports their future growth and success as they respond to the challenges they face going forward.
Staff
3
4
Ken KaufmanChairKaufman Hall
Since 1976, Mr. Kaufman has provided healthcare organizations with expert counsel and guidance in areas including strategy, finance, financial and capital planning, and mergers, acquisitions and partnerships. Recognized as a leading authority and committed to industry education, Mr. Kaufman has given more than 400 presentations at meetings of leading industry groups. He has authored or coauthored six books, and his articles regularly appear in major healthcare publications. Mr. Kaufman has an MBA with a concentration in hospital administration from the University of Chicago Graduate School of Business..
Speakers
5
Mark E. GrubeManaging DirectorKaufman Hall
Mark Grube leads Kaufman Hall’s Strategic Advisory practice. Mr. Grube has more than 25 years of experience in the healthcare industry as a consultant and as a planning executive with one of the nation’s largest healthcare systems. Mr. Grube is a frequent speaker and author, and he is a three-time winner of the Healthcare Financial Management Association Best Article Award. He has presented at meetings of the American College of Healthcare Executives, The Governance Institute, The Healthcare Roundtable, HFMA and many other organizations.
Speakers
4
6
Dr. Lambert has more than 40 years of experience as a physician, healthcare executive and board member. As a member of Kaufman Hall’s Strategy practice, he assists hospitals and health systems with integrated strategic and financial planning, service line planning/distribution across systems and medical staff planning/physician alignment strategy. Previously, Dr. Lambert held senior executive positions at several Chicago area hospitals. He also has provided consultation in physician relations and continuity of care.
Matthew J. Lambert III, MDSenior Vice PresidentKaufman Hall
Speakers
7
Today’s Topics
1. The Changing Healthcare Business Model
2. Leadership Mindset
3. Leadership Competencies
4. Leadership Structure and Metrics
5. Examples of Leadership for Population Health Management
6. Concluding Comments
5
8
The Changing Healthcare Business Model
Ken Kaufman
9
B-School, DisruptedIn moving into online education, Harvard discovered that it wasn’t so easy to practice what it teaches.
MINH UONG/THE NEW YORK TIMES
SundayBusiness SUNDAY, JUNE 1, 2014
“A company must stay the course even in times of
upheaval while constantly improving and extending its
distinctive position.”
Michael Porter
“The only way that market leaders like Harvard Business School can survive “disruptive
innovation” is by disrupting their existing business
themselves.”
Clayton Christensen
6
10Source: Congressional Budget Office: Extended Alternative Fiscal Scenario. Extrapolated by Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, as illustrated in Blinder, A.S.: After the Music Stopped: The Financial Crisis, the Response, and the Work Ahead. New York: The Penguin Press, 2013.
The Dominant Role of Healthcare Spending (Congressional Budget Office Long-Term Budget Projection)
The Driving Force Behind the Change to America’s Healthcare System
11
The Numbers Send a Clear and Present Message
“The implication for budgeteers is clear: If we can somehow solve the health care cost problem, we will also solve the long-run deficit
problem. But if we can’t control health care costs, the long-run deficit problem is insoluble.”
Alan S. Blinder
Source: Blinder, A.S.: After the Music Stopped: The Financial Crisis, the Response, and the Work Ahead. New York: The Penguin Press, 2013.
7
12
Since 2010, Hospitals Have Absorbed $144B in Payment Cuts
Source: American Hospital Association
13
Hospitals
Doctors
Patients
Fee-for-Service Model
8
14
Fee-for-Value Model
Patients
Healthcare Company
Hospital Outpatient ServicesDoctors Continuum
of Care
Content of Care
• Commodity • Make vs. buy • Low-cost provider• Contract to specifications
Select Contract(?)
Who is This?
Employers Medicare and Medicaid
15
Leadership Mindset
Mark Grube
9
16
Are you trying to make the old model work in the new
world?
Are you learning to use a new model based on the
new world?OR
A New View of Healthcare
17
A New View of Patients
“For healthcare executives, the challenge is to think about their delivery networks and their healthcare services with
this new, multifaceted patient in mind — a patient who may be healthy or sick, who values nurturing but wants
independence, who craves information and flexibility, and who will make choices based on perceptions of value that
vary depending on each situation.”
—Ken Kaufman, “Patients as People”
10
18
A New View of Scale
• Network strength• Physician/clinical alignment• Operational efficiency• Infrastructure• Expertise
Hospital systems with more than $1 billion in revenue have experienced higher revenue growth, better
balance sheet ratios, and higher operating and
operating cash flow margins than smaller health systems
Need Benefit
Source: Analysis by Kaufman, Hall & Associates, LLC, of proprietary medians data from Moody’s Investors Service, 2013
19
A New View of Volume
• Non-strategic volume such as emergency department, cash customers and patient-preference decisions
• Fixed revenue per person or member (PMPM)
• Organized under accountable care model
• Organization receives portion of revenue depending on arrangement
• Contractual relationships with payers, employers and providers
• Preferred-provider status for select tertiary/quaternary services
Managed/Attributed Lives
Influenced Lives
Incidental Volume
11
20
• Partnerships focused on acquiring selected PHM/value-based capabilities
• Partnerships for broad collaboration on network and care management
• Partnerships for focused network development
• Partnerships between large employers and provider networks to manage defined populations
• Partnerships designed to achieve full population health manager capabilities
A New View of Partnerships
21
Leadership Capabilities
Matt Lambert, MD
12
22
New Leadership Expertise
• Fostering clinician leadership• Network development and management• PHM and associated risk• Clinical, business and consumer intelligence• Innovation and transformation• Technology
23
Which leadership capabilities do you view as most important for success in a PHM environment? (Select all that apply)
1. Fostering clinical leadership
2. Network development and management
3. Population health management and associated risk
4. Clinical, business and consumer intelligence
5. Innovation and transformation
6. Technology
Polling Question #1
13
24
Clinical leadership needed for care redesign:
Fostering Clinical Leadership
Population Segmentation & Stratification
Program/ Intervention
Development
Program Evaluation & Refinement
1 2 3
25
Physician Leadership Competencies in a PHM World
• Systems theory and analysis
• Use of information technology
• Cross-disciplinary training and multidisciplinary teams
• Expanded knowledge areas
• Interpersonal and communication skills
Physician Core Competencies Next-Generation Core Competencies
• Medical knowledge
• Patient care
• Practice-based learning and improvement
• System-based practice
• Professionalism
• Interpersonal and communication skills
• Use of informatics
From Top Doctor to Physician
Leader
The competencies that make an individual a good physician are not the same competencies that make a physician a great leader. However, the heart of being a
good physician leader is being a good physician.
Source: Combes, J.R., Arespacochaga, E.: Lifelong Learning: Physician Competency Development. American Hospital Association’s Physician Leadership Forum, Chicago, IL, June 2012.
14
26
Network Development and Management
• Familiarity with full continuum of care• Contract negotiation• Performance monitoring and management• Technology integration
27
PHM and Associated Risk
Risk Expertise:
1. Assessing, managing, mitigating risk
2. Actuarial services
3. Predictive/risk modeling
PHM Expertise:
1. PHM strategic direction
2. Development of PHM services
3. Coordination of PHM initiatives
15
28
Clinical, Business and Consumer Intelligence
Clinical Intelligence Business IntelligenceConsumer
Intelligence
• Identify, stratify and prioritize the patientpopulation
• Design and evaluate interventions
• Network performance
• Risk contracting• Operational
efficiency
• Demographic, socioeconomic,behavioral, attitudinal information
• Consumer engagement
29
Innovation and Transformation
Transformation
• Change management
• Project/results management
Innovation
• Linking strategy and innovation
• Creating structure for innovation
• Cultivating new ideas
• Developing and testing
16
30
Technology
Source: Arlotto, P.: “Technology for Population Health Management,” California Hospital Association and Kaufman Hall, Aug. 25, 2015.
• Understand consumer needs and preferences
• Develop connected healthcare ecosystem integrating medical, social and community services
• Use advanced population analytics to help predict care requirements for population segments and assess performance of individual providers, sites and entities
• Incorporate disruptive innovations that drive redesign of business and care-delivery models
31
• Chief Transformation Officer
• Chief Medical Informatics Officer
• Chief Innovation Officer
• Senior Healthcare Economist
• SVP, Pharmaceutical Management
• SVP, Managed Care Pricing
• SVP, Health Plan and Managed Care
• SVP, Actuarial Services and Predictive/Risk Modeling
• SVP, Product and Benefit Design
• EVP, Consumer Solutions
• EVP, Advanced Analytics
• EVP, Network Partnerships and Management
• COO, Network Operations and Development
• Endless physician and clinical leadership and councils in key areas such as primary care, ED, hospitalist and post acute
• University, research institutes and other partnerships
New Roles
17
32
Press *1 to enter the queuePress *2 to remove yourself from the queue
Phone questions:
Questions?
Online questions:
Type your question in the Q & A box, hit enter
33
Leadership Structure and Metrics
Mark Grube
18
34
PHM “NewCo”Ownership OwnershipEntity 1 Entity 2
Board of Managers
Entity 1 % Representation
Entity 2 % Representation
Care Coordination
Managed Care Contracting HIT/IT
Network Development and Provider Engagement
Proposed PHM Governance Structure
35
PHM Division Leadership
Local PHM Network 1
Local PHM Network 2
Population 1
Local PHM Network 3
Care Model Coordination/ Integration
Value-Based and Risk Contracting/Products
PHM Analytics and Information Systems
Service Delivery and Network Operations
PHM Innovation, Training and Education
Financial Risk Management and Modeling
PHM Operations
Primary Care Physicians
Other Providers
PHM Division Governance and Executive Leadership
Population 2 Population 3
Primary CarePhysicians
Other Providers
Primary Care Physicians
Other Providers
New View of Organizational Structure
The PHM-centralized
operations and talent infrastructure
– build, buy and partner options
The PHM delivery hubs – physician orgs, employers,
purchasers, medical neighborhoods, etc.
Overall strategy; integration with
broader healthcare company
19
36
KeyInitiative
AreaPotential Performance Metric
• Primary care base as % of total physicians• % employed physicians• # of physicians in leadership roles• Loss per physician
• Commercial rates as a % of Medicare• PMPM cost for employees• % of revenue in non-fee-for-service relationships• Performance relative to target credit medians
• # of patient-centered medical home sites• % well, % at risk, % chronically ill for employee population• Core measures, % readmissions, % mortality• # of innovation center projects and impact
• Attributed primary care lives• Utilization rates• Market share• % of revenue inpatient vs. % of revenue outpatient
• Successful initiative execution (on time, on budget)• Overall organization performance against metrics defined above
Physician Platform
Development
1
Pricing and Competitive
Cost Strategy
2
Care Coordination
and PHM
3
Efficient Service Delivery
4
Organizational Structure and
Goal Alignment
5
Leadership Accountability Metrics
37
Clinical Outcomes/Patient Satisfaction Measures
Covered Lives in Value-Based Arrangements 50,000
18% 52% 30%
0% 50% 100%
Population by Risk Level
High risk Medium risk Low risk
100 125 148
350 300400
850
1000
750
Hospital 1 Hospital 2 Hospital 3
Inpatient admits per thousandED visits per thousandPhysician office visits per thousand
Observed/expected risk-adjusted all-cause mortality rate 0.75
Risk-adjusted all-cause readmission 13.8%
Hospital-acquired conditions 6%
Core measures sets, composite 88%
HCAHPS composite 95%
Physician Measures
Midlevel provider wRVUs / total practice wRVUs 25%
PMPM cost efficiency score 0.90
Revenue from value-based contracts 35%
Physicians qualifying for EHR incentives 82%
Referral leakage rate 18%
Average wait time to PCP appointment 1 day
Utilization Rates
Positive/negative trends over previous year
Payer Mix
Commercial
Medicare Advantage
Medicaid
Sample Value-Based Dashboard
20
38
Examples of Leadership for PHM
Matt Lambert, MD
39
Cedars-Sinai Medical CenterMovement to Value-Based Care Arrangements
• Vivity Partnership • Three Medicare Advantage Plans• Three ACO Arrangements
• Proactively engage and educate network physicians about issues related to value-based care
• Use data to highlight the performance of each clinician • Use a dual-reporting structure in some instances; encourages a system-
centric approach
~70K lives for all of these arrangements
“… developing local clinician champions and leaders for PHM has been and will continue to be critical to our success with PHM.”
Dr. Scott Weingarten, MD, MPHSenior Vice President and Chief Clinical Transformation Officer
21
40
Community Hospital of the Monterey Peninsula
• New leadership mindset
• PHM governance and leadership structure
• Partnerships to support PHM
• Leadership accountability
41
Talent
Training
Technology
Trustees
Time
“It is really, really hard work. But it can be done through successfully involving your stakeholders in advancing the process.”
Elizabeth A. Lorenzi, Vice President and Chief Operating OfficerCommunity Health Innovations
Community Hospital of the Monterey Peninsula
22
42
Concluding Comments
Mark Grube
43
• How high a priority does your leadership place on preparing for PHM?
• What gaps in expertise for PHM are most pressing in your organization?
• What would be the key value proposition your organization can and should deliver in a PHM environment?
• How can you ensure that physicians and other clinicians play a leading role in preparing for and managing under PHM?
• What metrics will you use to evaluate your progress toward effective and efficient PHM?
• How might your leadership/organizational structure and decision-making process need to change to drive the major strategic shifts required for PHM?
Key Questions
23
44
Financing/Distribution System Competencies
Delivery System Competencies
Care Management
Care Management
Technology/Infrastructure (Claims-focused)
Technology/Infrastructure(Medical records-focused)
Webinar 3
Webinar 4
Population Health Management Framework
Webinar 2
Webinar 1
Leadership and Talent for Population Health Management
Webinar 5
45
PHM requires levels of leadership, and organizational sophistication and nimbleness
never before required in healthcare.
Bottom Line
24
46
Press *1 to enter the queuePress *2 to remove yourself from the queue
Phone questions:
Questions?
Online questions:
Type your question in the Q & A box, hit enter
47
25
48
Thank youAnne [email protected]
Ken Kaufman [email protected]
Mark [email protected]
Matt Lambert, [email protected]