25

1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    6

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

��� � ���������� ������� �������� � ����������� ���

� �"!"!$#�%'&"()!"*'�)+-,/.1032546("26+87-26+"+)25!-,:9;�"+=<12�7/>)!?03+=>A@B,�)+"C�9;2526+�D >)!E26+EFHGJIK260

L:MONQPSRUTWVXPZY:[]\H^`_baWcedefhgW^`d6iXaj_XfkiX^Qlm\onpcKgW^hqjdKqWird1s1tvuAwyx'z�w${}|�~O�6��qW\^`_baWcedefkgW^`dK��_ba]_X�?dKqW��cA_XfkiX^Qlm\�iXaWce��\Qfkc3i/l�_ba��/cedKiXaW�W��a���_X��\�a]��g�\�cKdK�m_ba��}fkcKd��_bcK\��������6\�l�lm\QfS�5iXaW� gWaWcKg}^Q^`\�cKce��gWl�lm��irdedKiX^K�X\�� �=iXa��¡dK���H\�c�ck��aW^`\X�£¢�_XfdKq�\j�}fkced;^`_baWcedefkg}^`dK�m_ba¤_X�EdKq�\�_XfkiX^Qlm\X�6�$\��Wfk\�ce\�aZd�i¥a�\Q��d¦����\�_X�"��aU§Kg�fK�irfK�bgW�H\�a�d?dKqWird��$\3^QiXl�l�¨©fk\�ce_bg�fk^`\ª��_bgWaW�W\��«��aU§Kg�fK�X�­¬j®©a�dKq�\3ce��\�^Q��iXl�^QiXce\ª_X�dKq�\E^`_baWcedefhgW^`dK�m_ba�_X�¯dKqW��c?_XfhiX^Qlm\X�°iHdefk\Q\E�H\QdKq�_��/^QiXa/��\3gWcK\���de_=defkiXaWcK�±_Xfk�gWaZ��_bgWa}��\��/ce\�irfk^hq]��a�de_:\`²���_ba�\�aZdK��iXl�lm�;��_bgWaW��\��³�°q�\�aW^`\)fK\�^Qg�fkcK��´X\X��cK\�irfk^kq³���qW��cJdefhiXaWce�µ_Xfk�=irdK�m_ba«_X��dKqW\6^`_baWcedefhgW^`dK�m_ba«^QiXa:��\5��a�de\Qfklm\�iS´X\��«�5��dKq=iXa�_XdKq�\Qf^`_baWcedefkgW^`dK��_ba:ce_"dKqWirdyfk\�l�irdK�m´X\1de_EdKq�\1a�\Q�¤^`_b�"�}��aW\��=_XfkiX^Qlm\AiXl�ce_)w'z ¶1w'zs6w¸·�^`_bs1w6�1��q}��c5lm\�iX�}c5de_;dKq�\o^Qg�fk�m_bg}c5cK�mdKg}irdK�m_ba-�6q�\QfK\"¹¯º�[p»�s1w?¼�z½w5��}g�d¾¹Oº�[¿»�wy{°|�¼yz s6tyu1w5�UiXa}�ªdKq�\y^`_b�H�°lm\Qde\�ÀyÁ Â�æ�W\Q�XfK\Q\y�µ_XfÄw${}|)^`_bl�l�ir�}ce\�cde_«i=cK��aW�blm\�ÅWæ��ce_b�H_Xfk�}qW��cK�Æd¦����\X�Ç-È�ɳÊ)Ë RÍÌONXY3Î�\�l�irdK�m´���Ï�irdK�m_ba³�WÐ�_b�H�}lm\`²��mdÑ�:Ð?l�iXcKce\�c���wO_blm��a�_b�=��iXl°�1�m\Qfkirfk^hqZ�X�tJ²���_baW\�aZdK��iXl³�1�m\Qfkirfh^kq��X�}wvfk��_Xfk�md¦��Ò5fk�bgW�H\�a�dKcQ�}ÓA��ir�X_baWiXl���Ï�irdK�m_baÔ³ÕÄM³Ö È VXP«VZ×µTWN�NÍØ�Ù¯VbT�PUØ Ë�Ú YoÛXÜbÝAÞbß���ÛXÜbÝHàQÞ���ÛXÜbÝoà�ß

á5â�ãWä1å�æ³ç3è=éoêOå�ëkç6äìeí¥îXï�ð�ñ�ò°ó°ôUõ�ö÷ôUøúù�ûUò°ü�õµûhýQþ�ôUø6ù�í�ÿ�� ô���ôUø��Ñó�ü��¥ð�ñ���ûhþ��1ôÍÿ¸ù� �ôÍø�� û��úø��í�:ûúô��³ù�ø`ù��`õ��í�`þ�ô��øhô�� ö��ø]í�í�ÿ�ô��úôUø�� õ±í�õµû��`õµý��úõ��-ô�� ü��ø��úõ��-ô�ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ� !±ô#"%$���&'�]ù�í�ÿ("*)+��&'�Sòõ±ö,"%$���&�-�î+�/.102��"*)��3&'���4�`þ�ôÍí65,7ªì��98:�;"%$��3&<���;ÿ}ôUû/í��-ý��í=�`ù�õµí>5,7ªì��98:�;"*)��3&'���@?7ªþ=��ûA�6ô¡þ³ùB �ô ù þ=���ôC��ù��D Äô@�E�1ôÍôUí í�í�ÿ�ô��úôUø�� õ±í�õµû��`õµýF�G�!H�°íI�� õµù�!J�`õ��-ô>�K5MLN�ù�í�ÿ�í�í�ÿ�ô��`ôÍø��-õµí�õ±û��úõµý�ô@O2�G�í�ôÍí=�úõ�ù�!��úõ��-ôP5M8RQSLJ?UT¤ôV�W��!µÿ¤ù�!µû� ôXO2�ÄôÍý��4�úþ�ôUí ùûúô��³ù�øúùY�`õZ�í# Äô@�E�1ôÍôUí[L {°| ù�í�ÿ\L {^]�_�| ?/ìeí�ÿ�ôÍôUÿ¯ò`�1ô-þ³ùB �ô-û��� ô/ô� }õ±ÿ�ôUí�ýÍô-ö��ø:�`þ³ùY�ÿ�õ±øúôUý@�`õZ�í<���a°ýUù�ûS�K�A°ýUï�bc��ò°õZ�P��ø�� °õ±í����d�íU�N�ø�ef�öyü��¯òIgJõÄù�í�ÿ/hOþI�í���¦üRgih¯ï�jc�ûúþI+�6ôUÿF�úþ³ùY�oö��ø"ù�íc�9k2O�ôÍÿ#lZòm5n8RQSL¿õµû"í��oý��íc�Qù�õ±í�ôUÿ�õ±í�L {°| õ±öR�úþ�ôo�G�!Z�}í�� õµù�!� ù�ýQþ�õµí�ôHýrù�íA�í!Z��ù�û�e�&dpWq=��ôÍøúõ±ôUûJ�%V�`þ�ô�5nLr�ø`ù�ý�!µô�?tsEôUøJ�`ôÍýQþ�í�õ�q=��ô«ýrù�í þ��6ô� �ôUøí��J ô=ô@O^�`ôÍí�ÿ�ôÍÿA�%V��ø�� �ôS�`þ³ù��n5M8RQSL½õ±ûªí��3ý��í=�`ù�õµí�ôUÿ¸õµíaL {°| ��í�ý��í�ÿ�õZ�úõ��í³ùY!�!Z��?ìeí�ÿ�ôÍôUÿu�úþ�ô���øhôUûúôÍíc�V�³ù�� ôUø�ûhþ��3û4�`þ�ùY�;í'øúô�!µùY�`õH }õ�vUõ±í���`ôÍýQþ�í�õ�q=��ô]ýUù�í ûhþ��w�úþ�õµû��í�ý��í�ÿ�õH�`õZ�í³ù�!Z!Z��?

Page 2: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

� � gWq�fh�=iXa��������

�A}ýrù�û ��øúôÍû��!H�Aþ��6ô� �ôÍø"ÿI°ôÍû ��I�3ù:øúôUû��`øhõµý��úõ��íU�í��`þ�ô)ûúõ��f�!±õµýUõH�E� �öi���øW�ø`ù�ý�!µôý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õ��í<? ì �/õµû �6ô�!Z!�� e}íI+�3í[�úþ³ùY�VL {°|�� !������� L {°|��� �3s"ô��jñ�ï��@?�ó°õµí�ýUô�&dp�� ù��� �øhõ�vUôÍûn!Z��jö��ø"ù�íc��lbòm�A°ýUù�û��ÄøúôÍû��!H�Hù�!±û�jûhþ��3û:�`þ³ù��:5M8�Q:L��� L {°|��� ?��:��øM�ø`ù�ý�!µôý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õ��íP��ø�°ýÍôUôÍÿ�ûN c�/ôUí�ý�}ÿ�õµí���`þ�ôEû��Qù�í�ÿ³ù�øúÿ ý���f�!±ô��`ôªûhô��! õ±í=����úþ�ôJ�ø`ù�ý�!µô" û���ýQþa�úþ³ùY�Eù4kIO°ôÍÿAL {}| �ø`ù�ý�!µôn�jù�ýQþ�õµí�ôoýUù�í]ÿ�ôÍýUõµÿ�ôS� ô��o ÄôÍøúûhþ�õ��]õ±í# x c�]ù�û�e$�õµíI� q^��ôUøúõ±ôUû �ö " ?N�a°ýUù�û���øhôUû��!Z�úûªûúþ��3û �`þ³ù�� �`þ�õ±û �ø`ù�ý�!µôn�jù�ýQþ�õµí�ôoýUù�í¸í�ôUõH�`þ�ôÍø ôí�í%�Kù�ÿ³ùY�I�`õH �ôoí�øN!µõ±í�ôrù�ø�!Z�V G���í�ÿ�ôUÿ<?�ìeí�� ù�íc�U�ø`ù�ý�!µô:�³ùY�ÄôÍøúûUò2�`þ�ôoý��í�û��`ø���ý��`õZ�í]õµûû���ýQþ��`þ³ùY�M�`þ�ô��`ôÍû��S!µù�í���³ùY��ô �í!Z�¸øhô�q=��õµøhôUûHùf d���í�ÿ�ôÍÿ�í^�I�o ÄôÍøn�ötq=��ôÍøúõ±ôUûV���ö;�`ôÍíô� �ôUíA�í�ô��X?

7ªþ�ôUøhô½ù�øúô ù�!±û�pû��� ô[��úþ�ôUøF� �û��`ù�ý�!±ôUû��`þ�ùY�#���ø�ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�í �o��û���ùB ��õµÿ¯òù�í�ÿ#�`þ�ùY��� õZ��þc�=ô@O2�!�ù�õµí#�3þ=�F�úþ�õµû���ø�� !±ô��8þ³ù�û=øhô�� ù�õµí�ôÍÿ ��ÄôÍí¡ö��ø=û���ýQþ ù/!��í��`õZ� ôY?'&N°ÿ�õ±í�[5M8�Q:L x õµíc��uL {°| x õZ�P�I!µõµôÍû �`þ³ùY��8RQSL x � 5n8RQSL x ?Æì ��õ±ûjí��eWí��3íC�3þ�ô��`þ�ôUøS�`þ�ôf8 O2�d�í�ôUíc�`õµù�!R7ªõZ� ô sEõµôÍø`ù�øhýQþ=�[�K8RQSLtsn�SòJÿ�ô@k³í�ôUÿC ô�!���=òJþ³ù�û�`þ�ôHÿ��3í=�1ù�øhÿ ûhô��³ù�øúùY�`õZ�í���ø���ÄôÍø��E�$(¿ù�ûhô��³ù�øúùY�`õZ�í��ö`�E�W ù�ÿ � ù�ýUôÍíc�J!µô� �ô�!±ûªõ��f�!Z�)�õµíI� ûúô��³ù�ø`ù��`õ��í�û¸ùY�]ùY!�!n!Z��1ôÍø�!µô@ �ô�!±û*(£ù�û�ÿ}ôUû��úþ�ô#L �!H�}í��-õ�ù�!J7ªõ��-ôFsEõµôUøúù�øúýQþc��KLtsn�@?oü��ø9Lts:òM�úþ�õµû9��ø��� ôUø��E� øhô�!µùY�`õH °õZvUôÍû�?�ì©öf8RQSLts�ûhþ��!±ÿ þ³ùB �ôu�`þ�õµû9��ø���+�ôUø��E��ò��`þ�ôÍí õZ� ö��!�!Z��3û ö÷ø��� ù½øúô�!�ùY�úõZ }õ�vUùY�`õZ�í(�öo�`þ�ô ÿ�ô��úôUø�� õ±í�õµû��`õµýF�úõ��-ô�þ�õ±ôUøúù�ø,�ýQþc� �Ks)óIb)-��V�`þ³ùY��L {}| �� 5n8RQSL3ò"ûhõµí�ýÍô#L {°| �� 8RQSL {°| ?1s"ù�ø����jù�í�õµûUò3ìE�f� ôÍø,�� ù�í¥ù�í�ÿ ó°ô��6ô�!±û��í[�Ks"ìkó°ñ)-��,� �ûúôÍø� �ôÍÿF�`þ³ùY�"õ±öR8RQSLts�ûúþI��!µÿ'þ³ùB �ô4�úþ�õµû,��ø���ÄôÍø��E��ò�`þ�ôUí �`þ�õ±û���ø���ÄôÍø��E�½ÿ°ôÍû]í��]øhô�!µùY�`õH °õZvUôY? 7ªþ�ô��pý��í�û��úø���ý@�`ôÍÿ ù�í �ø`ù�ý�!µô " û���ýQþ�`þ�ùY�S8RQSL.� 5n8RQSL3òd��ô��:�úþ�ô;ûhôUý��í�ÿ#!µô� �ô�! �ö 8RQSLts�õµûM��ø���ÄôÍø�?�/ �4��ýQþ��1ôUù�e�ôÍø��ø���ÄôÍø��E��ö��øJ8�Q:Lts:ò�eWí��3í¥ù�û"ó°ô@�1ô�!µû��í�� û�&N�í � ôUý�����øúôU� ó}ô��Eñ$0c��ò³õµûN�úþ�ôHö��!�!Z��3õµí�û��`ùY�`ô�� ôÍíc�B�o8RQ:L1� 5n8RQSL ��2 5M8RQSL3� 8RQSL {°| ?�ìeí¤ùa�W�ø�!±ÿC�3þ�ôÍøúô�ó°ô��6ô�!4�û��í�� ûHý��í � ôÍý��%��øúô;þ�!µÿ�ûÍò<L {°| �� 5M8RQSL3ò¯ûúõ±í�ýUô L {}| ��18RQSL {°| ?5�:��ø)ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�íþ³ù�û �%�ù� ��õµÿP�`þ�õ±ûW��ø�� !±ô�� ò}õK? ôY?±ò}õµíf�`þ�ô,�N�ø�!µÿf�1ô"ý��í�û��`ø���ý��3ó°ô��6ô�!±û��í�� ûAý��í � ôUý@�%��øhô�o��û��5í���þ�!±ÿ<?�ìeíjó°ôÍý��`õZ�í60S�6ôJ�3õ�!�!�õµíc�`ø�°ÿ��ýUô3ù�!�ù�í���³ù���ô1ö��ø�ôUí�ý�°ÿ�õ±í���`þ�ô3ý���7��!±ô��`ô:ûúô@�5 x ù�í�ÿ��`þ�ô;øhôUû����øúýÍô d���í�ÿ�ôÍÿ�õµí � ��ø��a� ô@�`þ}ÿ¯òd�3þ�õµýQþF� �ôÍøúý��� ô4�úþ�ôUûhôÿ�õ�8 ý��!Z�úõµôÍû�?�ìeí �úþ³ùY��ûúôÍý��úõ��í¯ò��6ô �3õ�!Z!�ù�!±û�S��õH �ô �`þ�ôJk�øúû���ý��í�û��`ø���ý��`õZ�íV�öG�`þ�ô �øúù�ý�!±ô�?ìeí�ó°ôÍý��úõ��í/jV�1ô��3õ�!Z!d�`øúù�í�ûkö��ø�� �úþ�ô«ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��í/�%-ù/øúôUý���øúûhõZ �ô:ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�í

��ûhõµí��ù��`øúôÍô9� ³ù�ûúôÍÿ/� ô@�`þ}ÿ#�¦ûhôUôf�Ñó2�ù�ñ�ðY�Sò:&1þ³ù��I�úôUøNQ)ì<;�� �3þ�ôÍøúô�ò�õ±ö'�6ôoýrù�í���ô��3ù�íõµí � ��ø���ö÷ø��� �í�ôn!±ôrù�ö¯õµí�ù��`øúôÍôM�6ôoýrù�íU�`þ�ôÍíU�`þ�ø���Æù��1ùB�P�úþ³ùY�W!µôUù�övù�í�ÿjû��Qù�ø�� ��ûúõµíI��`þ�ô;í�ô@O^���í�ô�?ST¤ô;ù�øúøúù�í��ô4�úþ�ô4�úøúôUô�û���`þ�ùY�:�6ô�þ³ùB �ô �f�øúôo!±ôrùB �ôÍûn�`þ�ù�í�õµí � ��øúõµôÍû�?/n!±û��ò'�úþ�õµû«í��BøúôÍý���øhûúõH �ôU�-ô��úþ}ÿ�ýUù�í ô-ý���o �õµí�ôÍÿC�3õH�`þ#�`ôUýQþ�í�õ�q=��ôÍû;ÿ�ô� �ô�!Z��ÄôÍÿ c�>="ù�ý eY�?r�@=Eù�ýrñ � �SòGs)ù�ø��%� ù�í�õ±û"ù�í�ÿ�sEô�� ù�ýQþ³ù�í�ÿ�ø`ùF�3sns)ï°î+�Eù�í�ÿBAN!Z���ù�í�ÿ'ìE�7��³ù���!µõ�ùYv�v�U�@A6ìKñ�ð��R�%4��ô�� LC�EDnLF�D5nLHG/ý�c5nL3ò2�3þ�õZ!µô3û��úõ�!Z! þ�ù� }õ±í�oL {°| � 5n8RQSLøúô�!�ùY�úõZ �ôn�%/ù�øúôÍý���øhûúõH �ô��ø`ù�ý�!µôY? T�ô«ô�!µõZ� õ±í³ùY�`ôJ� ù�ýQþ�õ±í�ôUû �úþ³ùY�3ÿ�íY�3ýrùY�úô����øhõµýUù�!�!H�ù�ýÍýUô��2���í ùY�S�f�û��:�í�ô �³ùY�úþF c�'ö��øhýUõµíI���`þ�ô�ù�ýUýUô��I�Qù�í�ýUôV�íF�í�ô �öt�`þ�ô !±ôrùB �ôÍûS�ö���ø �úøúôÍô:ù�í�ÿa�úþ�ôUía��ûhõµí� ù;ö��I�%��øhô�!µôrùZöyö��øªôUí�ý�°ÿ�õ±í�?

7ªþ�ô«øúô�!µùY�`õH }õ�vUôÍÿ��N�ø�!µÿ/�1ô:ýUøhôrùY�úô«þ�ù�û,�E�Wjõ±íc�`ôUøhôUû��`õµíI�P��ø��� ôUø��úõµôÍû�? 7ªþ�ô�k�øúû��"õµû

Page 3: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

���$_;º1fkiX^Qlm\�c�dKq}ird5¢�_Xfk^`\)i � ����Ð�fkgWa}^kq 0

ù� G��I�,!��� ûúô��úû�? 7ªþ�ô�!��� ûúô��úûn�ö?ù-ý�!�ù�ûhû��¤ý��í�ûúõ±û��`û,�ö �`þ�ûhô �ø`ù�ý�!µôUû " û���ýQþA�`þ³ùY�� x ����? 8�ûúûhôUíc�`õµù�!�!H��òI�úþ�ô�!��� ûhô��úûM�ö�ù/ý�!�ù�ûúû�� ��õZ �ô=í/þ�ô�!Z�/��f�úþ�ô=ý�!µù�ûúû��R?

=Eô�!�ùY�úõZ �ôJ�� ���øW�ø`ù�ý�!µô�ò��6ôn��ô��1ù«û���ø���øhõµûhõµí�«øúô�!�ùY�úõ��í�ûhþ�õ��V ô��E�6ôUôÍíU�`þ�ô,!���½ûúô��úûö��øM5nL£ù�í�ÿa�`þ�ô !��� ûhô��`ûEö��øML {}| ? 7ªþ�ô k³øúû��oý��í�ûúõ±û��M�ö�ô@O�ù�ý@�%!H�a�úþ�ô4!µù�í����ù���ôUû3õ±íLªò�3þ�ôUøhôrù�ûJ�`þ�ô«ûhôUý��í�ÿ'ý��í�ûhõµû��úûJ�ö �úþ�ô�!�ù�íI���³ù���ôÍûªõµía5n8RQ:L,?

7ªþ�ô1ûhôUý��í�ÿ ��ø���ÄôÍø��E���öI���øyøúô�!µùY�`õH }õ�vUôÍÿ��W�ø�!µÿ�õ±û'�`þ³ùY�i�`þ�ô1ý���P�!±ô��úô�� Á  �eÿ�ô���øúôÍôö��ø4L {}| ý��!�!µù���ûúôÍû ���ù¥ûúõ±í��!µô�� �©õµû���P�ø���þ�õ±û�� �E�^�ÄôY?#7ªþ³ùY��õ±ûUò�ù�!Z! L {}| �©ý���f�!µô@�`ôûúô@�`û:��í�ÿ�ôUøn�d�!H�}í��-õ�ù�!4� �`õZ� ôM�jù�í=�)� �í�ô�øhôUÿ��ý��`õZ�í�û)ù�øúô �d�!H�}í��-õ�ù�!4� �`õZ� ô"õµû���P�ø,���þ�õ±ý�?(7ªþ�õ±û�ù�ÿI �ù�í�ýUôUûjù ��ø����øúù���ö��øf��ô����`õµíI�¤ý���P�!±ô��úô ÿ�ô���øhôUôUûP�%¤ý��!�!µù���ûhô��¥õ�ö� � 5M8�Q:L õ±û;ù'ý�!�ù�ûhû4�3õZ�úþ ý���f�!±ô��`ôjûúô��úûUò��`þ�ôUí[�í�ôjýrù�í[� ù�e�ô�ù�!�!�� �©ý���f�!µô@�`ôûúô@�`û� �eõ±û���f�ø���þ�õµý�õ±í�ù øúô�!�ùY�úõZ }õ�vÍôUÿ �N�ø�!µÿ> c� ûhô����`õµíI�uL � DnLBù�í�ÿ� � 8RQ:L,?sM�� ôÍø:ù�í�ÿ ó}ô�!�� ù�í �Ks)ó�ï � �n�6ôUøhô�ù� !±ô �% ÿa�úþ�õµûHö��ø�� � � Á ) òyù�í�ÿ\���ø���øhôUûhôUíc��øúù�ý�!±ôV�W�ø�e}û«ö��ø�� � L {°| ? /)í �ø`ù�ý�!µô�ö��ø�� � 5nL �W��!±ÿ�ý��íIk³ø�� �`þ�ô-õµû���P�ø,���þ�õ±û���ý��í � ôUý@�%��øhôV�@A s)ð�ð��X?�8R �ôUí��úþ����þU�ø`ù�ý�!µôÍûW� ù�eWõµí���`þ�ô"ý��í � ôUý�����øúôM�`ø���ôHù�øúôeWí��3í �Ñü�ü��=ï ��� A A1ü?ï�ñc��ò³õZ�Eõµû3û��úõ�!Z!Jù�í õµíc�`ôÍøúôUû��`õ±í�P��ÄôÍí9q=��ôUû��`õZ�íA�3þ�ô@�`þ�ôÍøM�úþ�ôUøhôõµû3ù�íA�øúù�ý�!±ôoøúô�!�ùY�úõZ �ô:�% �3þ�õµýQþ9LF�'DML�ù�í�ÿA5nLC� 8RQSL ?

�Aâ���æ����kë�� ëhä���æ¾ë����T�ô:ù�ûúû��I� ôS�`þ�ô«øhôrù�ÿ�ôUøªö¦ù��-õ�!µõµù�øt�3õZ�`þ¸û��Qù�í�ÿ�ù�øúÿ í��úõ��í�ûªõ±í¸û��`ø���ý�����ø`ùY!Jý���f�!µôXO°õZ�E��`þ�ô��ø���ò?ù�û:ù�øúô-ÿ�ô�k³í�ôUÿ¯ò$ô�? �?±ò$õµí6�@A ��!=ñ�ñY�@?U5M�í�ô@�`þ�ô�!µôÍûúûUò �1ôV�3õ�!Z!�õµíF�`þ�õ±û=ûúôUý@�`õZ�íøúôÍýrù�!Z!�û��� ô�íI��`õZ�í�ûM�úþ³ùY�S�6ô;ö÷ôUô�!�ù�øúô;íI��=ý���f�f�í�eWí��J!µôÍÿ��ô�òvù�í�ÿFkIOF�í û��� ôí��`ùY�`õZ�í<?ó°ô��úûEù�øúôHÿ�ôÍí��úôUÿ/ c�]ýrù���õZ�QùY!m!µô@���úôUøúû3ù�í�ÿ¸ù�øúôHû�� �ûhô��`û,�ö#"�$ròI�3þ�ôÍøúô"B�&%('*)rî,+=?

7ªþ�ô5ýrù�øhÿ�õµí�ù�!µõH�E�n�ö�ùªûúô@� " õµûJÿ�ôUí��úôUÿ�ù�û.- " -+?�ó^�`øhõµí��û$ù�øúô�ÿ�ôUíI��`ôÍÿ�ù�ûvû��jù�!Z!�!µô@���úôUøúû/ )102)13�)145)767676 ?RT¤ôoû���-ô��`õZ� ôÍû1õ±ÿ�ôUíc�`õ�ö;� ù�ûúô@� �3õZ�`þjõZ�`û1ýQþ³ù�ø`ù�ý��`ôÍøúõ±û��`õ±ý"ö���í�ý��`õZ�í¯ò^�`þ³ùY�õµûÍò " � / � � î=õ±ö / . " ò³ù�í�ÿ " � / � �8'VY�`þ�ôÍø��3õµûhô�?

7ªþ�ôa!µôUíI���`þ>�ö)ù¡û��`øúõ±í� / õµû�ÿ�ôUí��úôUÿ =�:9 / 9 ? ü��ø/ù¡ûhô�� " ù�í�ÿ>& .<;Eòt�6ô!µô@���`þ�ô�í��Qù��`õ��í "�=?> û��Qù�í�ÿ£ö��øU�`þ�ô�ûhô��¸ý��í�ûúõ±û��úõµí�[�ö:ù�!Z!,�úþ�ô�û��úøúõ±í��û]õµí " �ö!µôÍí���úþ�& ?�T¤ô:�3øhõZ�úô@" > ö��ø��A"�$%� =?> ?5ó^�`øhõµí��ûAù�øúôS�øhÿ�ôUøhôUÿ�k³øhû��J c��!µôÍí���úþ¸ù�í�ÿ��`þ�ôÍí!µôXO°õµý����ø`ù���þ�õµýUù�!�!H��?FAW� ÿ�ô�k³í�õZ�`õZ�í õZ�/þ�!µÿ�û�ö��ø-ù�íc� û��úøúõ±í�CBC�`þ�ùY�DB�E � ù�O.F¡õ±í�`þ�õµûJ�øúÿ�ôUøúõ±í�? 7ªþ�õµûJ�øúÿ�ôUøúõ±í� ù�!µû�P!±ô��`û,��ûEõµÿ�ôÍíc�`õ±ö;��û��`øhõµí��û,�3õH�`þ í³ùY�%��ø`ù�!ví=��o ôUøhû'?)rî,) � )7676G6 ?

T¤ô�ù�ûhû���-ô¡ù¿îIH¾î�ò:�íc�%�òoôrù�û��)� �%��eý���P��2�`ô#�³ù�õ±øúõµíI� ö���í�ý��úõ��í1���úþ�ô�ö���í�ý@�`õ��íJ / )10?K �80�- � / -L0��� / -M0S-£î+�ON � �3õZ!�!OÿI=�@?1ó°ô��úû"ýUù�í ù�!µû� ùY��ÄôUù�øEù�ûEù�ø����� ôÍíc�`ûUòô�? �?�ò J / )1PQK �R% J / )O0SKV��0 .TPD+c?/T�ôjù�ûhû���-ôjû��Qù�í�ÿ³ù�øúÿ¤ôUí=��-ôUø`ù��`õ��í�û �öªøúôÍý���ø*�ûúõH �ô�!Z�#��øhôUûúôÍíc�Qù� !±ô ý�!�ù�ûhûúôÍû4 c�6�3�øúù�ý�!±ô��n7i��øúõ±í�A� ù�ýQþ�õ±í�ôUû�? /)íVU(W�XZYI[]\f�jù�ýQþ�õµí�ô/õµûùP�4�!Z�úõ�� �`ù�� ô:7 ��øúõµíI�P� ù�ýQþ�õ±í�ôS�3õZ�`þ'ù�í'õ±í��I�J�`ù��Äô�ò ù�í9��2�%��I�,�QùY�Äô�ò �W�ø�e/�`ù�� ôUûUòù�í�ÿ½ù�^G_�\IWa`u�Qù�� ô�?.�oøúù�ý�!±ôa� ù�ýQþ�õ±í�ôUû-þ³ùB �ôA�`þ�øhôUô ÿ�õµû��`õµíI����õµûhþ�ôUÿ�û��`ùY�`ôÍûcb#d�e5fhg6ò

Page 4: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

j � gWq�fh�=iXa��������

g e � ù�í�ÿ����5ò`�3þ�õµýQþ¤ù�øúô/ô@O2�!µù�õµí�ôUÿ ù�û=ö��!�!���3û��:ù��:û���-ô-û��Qù���ôc�¦û%�=õ±íC�úþ�ô/ý���f��+��Qù��`õ��í>�úþ�ôA� ù�ýQþ�õ±í�ôa�jùB� ôUíc�úôUøP�úþ�ô'û��QùY�úô b#d�e5fhg6òAù�í�ÿ6�úþ�ôUí ��°ôÍûP�� �`þ�ô û��QùY�úôg e � ò �øJ��}ôUûJ�%f�`þ�ô«û��`ùY�`ô����5ò ÿ�ô�� ôUí�ÿ�õµí�P�íA�úþ�ô �-ô��4 ÄôÍøúûúþ�õ��a�öR�`þ�ô:û��`øúõ±í�jý���ø,�øúôÍíc�%!Z�A�3øúõH���`ôÍíF�íF�`þ�ô q=��ôÍø����`ù�� ô�õµí ùUkIO°ôUÿ U(W�XZYI[]\�ûhô��B? &N��P�I�I�QùY�úõ��í9�³ùY�`þ�ûS�öù'í�í�ÿ�ô��úôUø�� õ±í�õµû��`õµýV� ù�ýQþ�õ±í�ôjýUù�íu ô��øúÿ�ôUøúôÍÿ[ c�\�øhÿ�ôUøhõµí�a�`þ�ôjû��Qù��`ôjûhô�� �ö �`þ³ùY�� ù�ýQþ�õµí�ô�? /"í�ù�ýÍýUô��I�`õ±í�¤ý���P�I�I�QùY�úõ��í[�úþ³ùY�-õµûf� õ±í�õ�� ù�!5õµí �`þ�õ±û/ûúôUí�ûúô¥ýUù�í �úþ^��û ôjÿ�ô@k³í�ôUÿm?�ó2��ýQþ ù ý���f��I�`ùY�`õZ�í¡õµû�ýUù�!�!±ôUÿ#�`þ�ô []\���� U� �=ý���P�I�I�QùY�úõ��íC�ö�� �íõµíI��I� / ?Hì©ö�íI]ù�ýUýÍô��I�úõµí�]ý���f��I�Qù��`õ��í'ô@O°õ±û��`ûM�`þ�ôÍí��`þ�ôo!±ôÍö;���P�û��)ý���f��I�Qù��`õ��í'õµû��í�ÿ�ô�k³í�ôÍÿ<?�ì©öd�úþ�ôJ�jù�ýQþ�õµí�ôªõ±û�ÿ�ô��úôUø�� õ±í�õµû��`õµý �`þ�ôÍíf�úþ�ôJ!µôSö;�%�f�û���ý���f��I�Qù��`õ��í�õµûR�`þ�ô��í�õZq=��ôAý���P��2�QùY�úõ��í:õ±ö�úþ�ô � ù�ýQþ�õµí�ôAù�ýÍýUô��2�`û�?RT�ô !±ô����1� / �$û��Qù�í�ÿ;ö��ø �`þ�ô !µôSö;�%�f�û��ý���P��2�QùY�úõ��íF�öW� ù�ýQþ�õµí�ô�� �í õ±í��I� / ?oT�ôV��ûúô �`þ�ô-ûúù��-ô-íI��QùY�úõ��í¥ö��ø:�ø`ù�ý�!µô� ù�ýQþ�õµí�ôUû���� x � / ���@?�T�ôS!µô@���P��� x � / ���N ô:�`þ�ôHûúô��J�ö q=��ôÍøúõ±ôUû �`þ³ù��ªõµûªù�û�e�ôÍÿ'ùY!��í�� x � / �oõ±ö�� x ù�ýUýÍô��I�úû / ò$ù�í�ÿ FA��úþ�ôUø��3õµûhô�?�7ªþ�ô []\�������C�öªù¸ý���f��I�`ùY�`õZ�í¯òJõK? ôY?±ò�`þ�ô�í^�I�o ÄôÍøS�ö5û��úô���ûÍò$õ±ûoÿ�ôUíI��`ôÍÿ c� 9�� x � / � 9 ?;ü��øHù�í�í�ÿ�ô��úôUø�� õ±í�õµû��`õµý �jù�ýQþ�õµí�ô�`þ�õµû5û��Qù�í�ÿ�û�ö��ø �úþ�ô,!µôUíI���`þP�ö¯õH�`ût!µôSö;�%�f�û��6ù�ýÍýUô��2�`õµíI��ý���P��2�QùY�úõ��í/õ±öOõZ�5ô@O°õ±û��`ûÍò�ù�í�ÿ'AY�`þ�ôÍø��3õµûhô�?�AW� ö�°ý���ûúõ±í�9�í ùA�³ù�ø��`õ±ý��!µù�ø=ý���f��I�`ùY�`õZ�í\�³ù��`þ �6ô�� ùB��ûhôUô�� ����ô@�Hùjí�í�û��`ù�í�ÿ³ù�øhÿ�õµíc�`ôÍø���øhô��`ùY�`õZ�í��ö��úõ��-ô� G���í�ÿ�ûHþ�ôUøhô�?Ss,��1ô@ �ôUøÍòvûúõµí�ýUô �6ô�õ�� ��!±õµýUõH�%!H�U��ûhô:ý�!�}ý e�ôÍÿ9� ù�ýQþ�õµí�ôUûUò�úþ�õµû3õ±ûEíIP� � ôUý��úõ��ím?N7ªþ�ô«ûúô@�n�ö�û��úøúõµíI��ûEù�ýUýÍô��I�úôUÿ c�¥ù�7i��øhõµí�#���ø`ù�ý�!µôB�J� ù�ýQþ�õ±í�ô�� �;�3õZ�`þ9�ø`ù�ý�!µô " �SòÄõµû"ýrù�!Z!µôUÿA�`þ�ô [ X����,_?X��Z\4�ö ��¦øhô�!µùY�`õH �ôU�� " �;ù�í�ÿ õ±û;ÿ�ôUíI��`ôÍÿ> c�"!,��� �/��!,��� x ���X? /�øhô�!�ù��`õZ }õZvUôUÿ¤ý���f�!µôXO°õZ�E�ý�!µù�ûúûEõµû3ÿ�ôÍí��úôUÿ9 c�/�3øúõH�`õ±í� �`þ�ô��øúù�ý�!±ô:ù�û)ù/û��� ôUøhûúýÍøúõ��2�rò ô�? �?±òGL x ? / ý���f�!µôXO°õZ�E�ý�!µù�ûúû�� ù��¡ùY!µû� ù��� ôrù�ø�ù�û:ù û��� ôUøúûhýUøhõ��I���%'ù�í��úþ�ôUø«ý���f�!±ô@O°õZ�E��ý�!�ù�ûhûUò$ÿ�ôUíY�`õµíI��`þ�ô'ý�!µù�ûúûU�öS!�ù�í���³ù���ôUûjô�� ôÍø���õ±í� ö÷ø��� �`þ�ô��� ôUø`ù��`õ��í �ö=ô�q=��õ����õµí�¤ù\�jù�ýQþ�õµí�ôö÷ø��� �úþ�ôHý�!µù�ûúû �3õZ�úþ¸ù�í��øúù�ý�!±ô"ö÷ø���w�úþ�ôoû��I�ÄôÍøúûúýÍøúõZ�I�3ý�!µù�ûúûÍò�ô�? �?�òL {°| �<%#!M���%$J� �� õµû3ù/ÿ�ô��úôUø��-õµí�õµû��úõµýM�d�!H�}í��-õ�ù�! �`õZ� ôS�øúù�ý�!±ô:� ù�ýQþ�õµí�ô:ù�í�ÿ'& .F5ML +=?

7ªþ�ô�� ù�õµí�ý���f�!µôXO°õZ�E��ý�!�ù�ûúûúôÍû�õµí\�úþ�õµû �³ù�� ôUø/ù�øhô�Lªò 5nLªò 8RQSLªò5ù�í�ÿ 5n8RQ:LEò�3þ�ôÍøúô�ôXO2�d�í�ôUíc�`õµù�!'�`õ��-ôHõµû �`ù�e�ôÍíA�%P ÄôS�E�WU�%V�`þ�ô �G��1ôÍøM�G�!Z�}í�� õµù�!�� � >)(+*-, ò³ö��ø. . ;N�@? 7ªþ�ôUûhô«ý�!�ù�ûhûúôÍûªù�øúôn� ô��o ÄôÍøúûW�ö`�`þ�ôoû� �eýUù�!�!±ôUÿUL �!H�°íI�� õµù�! 7ªõ��-ô:sEõµôUøúù�øúýQþc�ù�í�ÿ/�`þ�ô 8 O2�G�í�ôUíc�úõ�ù�!'7ªõZ� ôSsEõµôÍø`ù�øhýQþ=�¸øhôUû��ÄôÍý��`õH �ô�!Z��ò�3þ�õµýQþ/�1ô«ÿ�ô�k�í�ô ô�!Z���?

7ªþ�ôJL �!Z�}í��-õ�ù�!c7ªõZ� ôNs"õ±ôUø`ù�øúýQþc� �1ù�û�õ±í=�úø�}ÿ��ýÍôUÿo c�/ó=�%}ý e^�-ô���ôUø,�Ñó^�%WðYb���ù�í�ÿý��í�ûúõ±û��`û��öW�`þ�ô/õµí2k³í�õZ�úô�ý��!Z!µôÍý��`õZ�í#�ö6ý�!�ù�ûúûúôÍûQ� Á , ò0/ Á , ù�í�ÿ21 Á , ò'�3þ�õ±ýQþ ù�øhô/ÿ�ô�k³í�ôUÿõµí�ÿ��ý��úõZ �ô�!Z��ù�ûªö��!�!Z��3û��� Á 3 �%1 Á 3 �4/ Á 3 �5/ Á $ � L� Á ,6* $ � 5nL�798(1 Á ,:* $ � &Nh� Á ,6* $/ Á ,6* $ � L 7 8 (

7ªþ�ôu8 O2�G�í�ôUíc�úõ�ù�!�7ªõ��-ôCs"õ±ôUø`ù�øúýQþc�Æù�û'ù�í ù�í³ùY!��� �ö �`þ�ô L �!H�}í��-õ�ù�!:7ªõZ� ôs"õ±ôUøúù�øúýQþc�]õ±ûªÿ�ô�k³í�ôUÿ¥ù�û3ö��!�!���3û���<;�= Á3 �51�;�= Á3 �4/>;�= Á3 �5/>;�= Á$ � 8RQSL

Page 5: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

���$_;º1fkiX^Qlm\�c�dKq}ird5¢�_Xfk^`\)i � ����Ð�fkgWa}^kq -

� ;�= Á,6* $ � 5n8RQ:L 798(1 ; = Á,:* $ � &Nh�<;�= Á,6* $/ ;�= Á,6* $ � 8RQSL 7 8 (

=Eô�!�ùY�úõZ }õ�vUùY�`õZ�í�û:�öN�`þ�ôUûúô-þ�õ±ôUø`ù�øúýQþ�õ±ôUû��3õ�!�! Äô/ÿ�ôÍí��`ôÍÿu c��òyô�? �?�ò��<; = Á � x, ò'�3þ�ôUøhô�`þ�ô«õ±íc�`ôUø���øúô@�QùY�úõ��í]õ±û �`þ³ùY� �úþ�ô=þ�õ���þ�ôUû��J!µô� �ô�!`�øúù�ý�!±ôoõµû3ýQþ³ù�íI��ôUÿ¸ö÷ø��� 5nL ��P5ML x ?

�ªâ�������� ����ç6éoæ³ê ��ç6éHäoè@�vè�ãWä��°éoæ� �� �¯å��oçEè��������������� �"!$#%�'&(� �*),+,��+.-/)10��,!32�� / k³øúû��]û��!Z�I�`õZ�í �%[Li�û���� û���ø�� !±ô�� �Aù�û� I�`ù�õµí�ôUÿD =�pü¾øhõµôÍÿ ÄôÍø�� �Ñü³øúõ -�ð��¸ù�í�ÿÆõ±í�ÿ�ô��ÄôÍí�ÿ�ôUíc��!Z� �A��ýQþ�í�õ�e �K�A��ý -Ybc�@?w7ªþ�ô����øhôUûúôÍíc�`ôUÿ¥ùV�-ôrù�í�ûJ�ö?ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�ía�úþ³ùY�J!µùY�`ôÍø ÄôÍýrù��-ô�e}íI+�3í'ù�û �`þ�ô54úü$õµí�õH�`ôoìeí+�� ��ø�� L�øúõZ�øúõH�E�o� ô��`þI°ÿ<?76 D"û��³ù�!�!H��ò�ù�í�ø�? ô�?�ûhô����`þ�ùY��þ³ù�û�û���-ô ��ø���ÄôÍø��E�4�3õH�`þ�øhôUû�� ôUý@��%jù�!�!vøhôUý���øúûúõH �ôo�ø`ù�ý�!µô��jù�ýQþ�õµí�ôÍû)õµûEý��í�û��úø���ý@�`ôUÿF c� û��`ù���ôUû�?M7ªþ�ô;ûúô@�S�ö�ù�!Z!'�ø`ù�ý�!µô� ù�ýQþ�õµí�ôUûAö��ø�� û3ù�í¸õ±íIk³í�õH�`ôHûúô@�,�öyøúô�q=��õ±øúô�� ôÍí=�úû,�úþ³ùY�3þ³ùB �ô���f ôHû`ù��`õµû�k³ôUÿa c���`þ�ôý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õ��í<? / �=ôUù�ýQþ�û��Qù���ôo�í�ô �ö �`þ�ôUûúô/øhô�q=��õµøhô��-ôUíc�`ûHõ±ûoû`ù��`õµû�k³ôUÿOò$ù�í�ÿ�û���`þ�ô��ø�°ýÍôUûúûP���³ù�øúù�íc�`ôÍôUûU�úþ³ùY� õµí �`þ�ôA!µõ��-õZ��ù�!�! �úþ�ô øhô�q=��õ±øúô��-ôUíc�úû�ù�øhô'û`ù��`õµû�k³ôUÿm?D7ªþ�ôÿ�õ�?OôÍøúôUí�ýUôf Äô@�E�1ôÍôUí ôrù�ø�!µõ±ôUøHý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�í�û:ù�í�ÿ �úþ�ôVk³í�õZ�úô/õµí � ��ø��F��øhõ��øhõZ�E���-ô��úþ}ÿõµûM�`þ³ùY�)øúô�q^��õµøúô�� ôÍíc�`û:�`þ�ùY�=ù�øhô;û`ùY�úõµû�k³ôUÿ¡ùY�Hû���-ô;û��`ù���ô�òm�jùB�A ÄôÍý���-ôo��í�ûúùY�`õ±û�k³ôÍÿù���ù�õµí�ù��ªû���-ô:!µùY�`ôÍø6û��Qù���ôY?t7ªþ�õµûAõ±û1ýUù�!�!±ôUÿ98��;:a_ZW<8����jù�û`ù��`õµû�k³ôUÿ¸øhô�q=��õµøhô��-ôUíc�B?tsEôUøhôõµí�ÿ�ô@O°õµíI�U�`þ�ô:øúô�q^��õµøúô�� ôÍíc�`û: ôUý��� ôÍû:�öt� ù � �øEõ��f�d�ø��Qù�í�ýUôY?�/ øúô�q=��õ±øúô�� ôÍí=�:�jùB� ôoõµí � ��øúôUÿ¸ù��Aû��� ôoû��Qù���ô:�í!H�jõ�ö'�`þ�õ±ûAù�ý@�`õ��í�õµûN�`ù�e�ôÍí��%;ûúùY�`õ±ûhö;�jù;øúô�q=��õ±øúô�� ôÍí=� �öþ�õZ��þ�ôUøi��øhõ��øhõZ�E�P�¦õK? ôY?±ò��3õZ�úþ;û�� ù�!�!±ôUøJõ±í�ÿ�ô@O�X?�ü��ø�ù,��õZ �ôUí;øhô�q=��õ±øúô��-ôUíc�R�úþ�ôUøhôAù�øhôN�íI!Z�k³í�õH�`ô�!Z��� ù�íc��øhô�q=��õ±øúô��-ôUíc�úû,�ö�þ�õZ��þ�ôÍø ��øúõZ�øúõH�E�#�¦õ±í�ÿ�ôXO�õ±í��û��`ù�ø��úû �3õZ�`þ 'c�X?�ì©ö �úþ�ôUøhôù�øhôEõ±íIk³í�õH�`ô�!Z�o� ù�íc�/û��`ù���ôÍû1ùY�t�3þ�õ±ýQþ�ù���õZ �ôUí øúô�q=��õ±øúô�� ôÍí=� � ùB�V Äô3û`ù��`õµû�k³ôUÿOò°õH��ö��!��!���3û �`þ�ùY�Eô� �ôÍø�� øúô�q=��õµøhô��-ôUíc�)ô@ �ôÍí=���³ù�!Z!Z���3õ�!Z!< ô«ûúùY�`õ±û�k³ôÍÿ9� ôUø��jù�í�ôUíc�%!H�C�¦õK? ôY?±ò�3õZ!�!í��� ô�õµí � ��øúôÍÿ�ùZö;�`ôUøS ôUõ±í�]û`ù��`õµû�k³ôUÿ��@?/ó2�ù�øúô � û� G2�e\� ó^�ù�ñ�ð��Eý��íc�Qù�õµí�û«ù�í ô@O°ýÍô�!��!µôÍíc�6ôXO2�d�û�=ôn�öOÿ�õ ?ÄôUøhôUíc�W� ô@�`þ}ÿ�ût�ö¯ý��í�û��`ø���ý��`õ±í�«ø�? ô�?Wûúô@�`û�?�ìeí-ý���f�!±ô@O°õZ�E�o�úþ�ô��ø���òôUû��ÄôÍýUõµù�!�!H�jõ±í��ø`ù�ý�!µôoý��í�û��`ø���ý��`õZ�í¯ò�õH�ªõµû1ûúô�!±ÿ���í�ôUýÍôUûúûúù�ø�����/øúôUû��ø�� ��V�P�øhôoý���7��!±õµýrù��`ôUÿ\� ô@�`þ}ÿ�ûo�öEý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�íu�`þ³ù�í�û��Qù�í�ÿ³ù�øúÿOò5û�!���=ò�û���eýrùY!�!µôÍÿ?> X@8��A X�� B@A� \ \ù�ø�����-ôUíc�`û�?:7ªþ�ôo�-ô��úþ°ÿOòOùY�)û��`ù���ôDC�òG�Qù�e�ôUûHõµíc��jý��í�ûúõ±ÿ�ôUøúùY�`õZ�í�ù�!Z!yøhô�q=��õ±øúô��-ôUíc�úû�3õZ�úþjõ±í�ÿ�ô@OU!µôÍûúû �`þ³ù�íEC�ò°ù�í�ÿjû`ùY�úõµû�k�ôUû1ö÷ø��� �`þ�ô"û�� �ûhô�� �ö'�`þ�ôÍûúôoøhô�q=��õµøhô��-ôUíc�`ûW�`þ³ùY�ýrù�íA ô=û`ùY�úõµû�k�ôUÿ/�`þ�ô��í�ô:�3õH�`þ/�`þ�ô=û��jù�!Z!µôÍû��ªõ±í�ÿ�ô@Od?ó�ùY�úõµûhö;�}õ±í��ù:øúô�q=��õ±øúô�� ôÍí=�W��û��³ù�!�!H�V� ôUù�í�û6ù�ÿ�ÿ�õ±í�;ù«ûúô@� �öJû��`øhõµí��ût�% �`þ�ô,�ø`ù�ý�!µô

��í�ÿ�ôUøoý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�í<?n7ªþ�ô�øúô�q=��õ±øúô�� ôÍí=�úûoõµíA���ø"ý�}ÿ�õµí� ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��í ù�øúô�õ±í�ÿ�ôXO�ôÍÿ�3õZ�úþ �`þ�ôJ!µôÍí���úþP�öÄû��úøúõ±í��û�? =Eô�q^��õµøúô�� ôÍíc�GFIH = H�ù�û�eWû��`þ³ùY�5û��`øúõ±í��û / �öm!±ôUí���úþ 9 / 9+ ôý��øúøúôÍý���!Z� ôUí�ý�°ÿ�ôUÿ õµía�`þ�ôo�ø`ù�ý�!µô�?,7ªþ³ùY�oõµû)õ�ö / .F x �úþ�ôUí��úþ�ôUøhô;þ³ù�û,�%� ô;û��� ôý�}ÿ�ôN�úþ³ùY��ûúùB�°ûR�úþ³ùY��õH�?õ±û?ù�í�ÿ�õ�ö / �. x �`þ³ù�ío�`þ�ôÍøúôªþ³ù�û �%: ôªû���-ô1ý�°ÿ�ôN�`þ³ù���û`ùB�}ûõZ�3õ±ûúí�� �B?�ìeí øúôÍý���øhûúõ��ía�úþ�ô��øhô��úõµýrùY!¯ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��í�ûJ�úþ�õµû3ý�°ÿ�ô=ýUù�í¯ò� ôUýrùY��ûúô«øúôÍý���øhûúõZ �ô� ù�ýQþ�õµí�ôUû�þ�ù� �ô���í= G���í�ÿ�ôÍÿu�`õZ� ô�ò ôjû���øúôrù�ÿ[��I���`þ�ø�����þ\�úþ�ô�ôÍí=�úõµøhôU�øúù�ý�!±ô�?¸ìeí

Page 6: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

b � gWq�fh�=iXa��������

���ø=ýUù�ûúô/þ��6ô� �ôÍøUò �6ô-í�ôUôÍÿ �%/ ô-ù� !µô �� øhô��úøúõµô@ �ôV�`þ�ô/ôÍí�ý�}ÿ�õµíI�a c�¡ù¸øúôÍû����øhýUô�� G���í�ÿ�ôÍÿU� ù�ýQþ�õ±í�ô�??ìeíf�³ù�ø��`õ±ý��!µù�øUòWù��d�!Z�}í��-õ�ù�!=�`õZ� ô �ø`ù�ý�!µôJ�jù�ýQþ�õµí�ôY? 7ªþ�ôÍøúôSö��øúô�òù�!Z! �ö �`þ�ô ôUí�ý�°ÿ�õ±í��� ôUø��`õµí�ôUíc�4�� / þ³ù�û4��9 ô�ÿ�í�ô 4hý�!��ûhôP�%@6 / ?97ªþ³ù���õµûÍò �`þ�ô!µôÍí���úþF�öt�`þ�ô�ôÍí�ý�}ÿ�õµíI�]û��`øhõµí��û:�jùB�'í��S ô ��øúôUùY�`ôÍøn�`þ�ù�í¡ùUkIO°ôUÿ#�d�!Z�}í��-õ�ù�!võ±í�`þ�ô�!±ôUí�Y�`þ/�ö / ?!�oí ù �õµí�ù�ø���ù�!���þ�ù� Äô@� �`þ�ôÍøúô«ù�øhôS�í!Z� � Á � H = H � û��úøúõµíI��û3ùB �ù�õ�!�ùY !µôM�ö!µôÍí���úþ �`�a9 / 9 �@?�7ªþ�ôÍøúôSö��øúô:ù � ô@�`þ}ÿ��`þ³ùY�J� ôUø�� õH�`ûAõ±í � ��øhõµôUûÍòI�`þ�ùY�3õµûªøhô9�eôÍí�ý�}ÿ�õ±í�V�ö/ òJûúþI��!µÿ¡ù�!±û�]þ³ùB �ô ù�í¡õZ�P�I!µõµýÍõZ�J G���í�ÿ#�íF�úþ�ô�í=��o ôUø��öt�`õZ� ôÍûn�`þ³ù��=ù�í õµí � ��ø��õµûM�ÄôÍø��-õZ���`ôUÿm? �n�`þ�ôÍø��3õµûhô�òm�úþ�ô;û��³ù�ýUô �ö�ôUí�ý�°ÿ�õ±í���W��!µÿ'ûúõ��f�!H�ak!�!i��<? A1ôÍýrù���ûhô���ø �-ô��`þI°ÿ þ³ù�û5û���ýQþ¸ù� ��õ�!H�5õµí-ûúôUý���øúõH�E��ò^�1ôoýUù�!�!�úþ�ôn�-ô��úþ}ÿ�4høhôUû����øúýÍô: G���í�ÿ�ôÍÿõµí � ��ø���? 6

����� ��� ),#%� +�� )�� ),+ ���� 3!�� ������� � gJô@� � $I) � )7)7676G6G ô«û���-ô:û��Qù�í�ÿ³ù�øúÿ'ôUí=��-ôUø,�ùY�úõ��í �ö íI�í�ÿ�ô@�`ôUø�� õ±í�õµû��`õ±ý\�øúù�ý�!±ô\� ù�ýQþ�õµí�ôUûUò�ù�í�ÿ !µô@� x � % J . ) / )%& K � / .!,��� x, ���C9 � x, � / � 9Z� &#+Wò2 Äô,�`þ�ôoû��Qù�í�ÿ³ù�øúÿjý���f�!µô@�`ô"ûúô��1ö��øN5M8RQSL x ?RT�ô:�!µù�íP��ôUí�ý�}ÿ�ô x õ±íc�% " û���ýQþ��`þ�ùY�AõH�1ýUù�í� Äô"øúô@�`øúõ±ô� �ôUÿ/ c��ù4�G�!H�°íI�� õµù�!�`õZ� ô, G���í�ÿ�ôÍÿ� ù�ýQþ�õµí�ôN�3õZ�úþo�`þ�ôªþ�ô�!�� �öÄù�íV5ML x �ø`ù�ý�!µôY? 7ªþ�ôªôÍí�ý�}ÿ�õ±í�S�öÄùHû��`øhõµí� / �3õZ!�!}ý��í�ûhõµû���ö�û��`øhõµí��û J / ) B KUòG�3þ�ôÍøúô 9 B 9%� 9 / 9

) - � 9 B 9�- -2?��oí'õµíI��I� / òd�`þ�ô4�G�!Z�}í��-õ�ùY!m�`õZ� ô�øúù�ý�!±ôn� ù�ýQþ�õµí�ôn�3õ�!Z!Äøhô��`øhõµô@ �ô:�`þ�ôS�jù�O°õZ�o�� �¦õ±í��`þ�ôn!µô@O°õ±ý����øúù���þ�õ±ýrù�!G�øhÿ�ôUø%�6û��úøúõµíI�B/û���ýQþa�`þ³ùY� J / ) BhK,. " ò¾ù�í�ÿ��3õZ!�!¯ù�ýUýUô��I�"õ ?9�úþ�õµû�B/õµû }ÿ�ÿ<?ó°õµí�ýUôªö��øt��õZ �ôUí / ù�í�ÿ BS�`þ�ôJq=��ôÍø��9���SB�� E�B�� � 9 B�� 9 � 9 B 9�� J / )1BhKJ. " �¾õµû�ù�íU5ML x

q=��ôUø���òvù�L(�jù�ýQþ�õµí�ô��3õZ�úþ ù�í#5nL�x\�ø`ù�ý�!µô�ýUù�í�k³í�ÿ J / ) BhK�. " �3õZ�`þ9�jù�O°õZ�o�� B c�� �õ±í³ù�ø���ûúôrù�øúýQþ¥ù�í�ÿ��`þ�ôÍí ÿ�ôÍýUõ±ÿ�ôS�3þ�ô��úþ�ôUøJ�`þ�õ±û�B-õ±û °ÿ�ÿm?

��� � ���I� )*�� ;!$�,#� �� � ) � T¤ô�k³øhû��V��õH �ô¸ù�í õ±í�ö��ø��jù�!5ÿ�ôÍûúýUøhõ��I�úõ��í[�ö,�úþ�ô]ý��í�û��úø���ý���`õZ�í<?,7ªþ�ô;ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�íF�öR�úþ�ôo�øúù�ý�!±ô ��ø�°ýÍôUôÍÿ�ûS c�'û��Qù���ôÍû�?SgJô@� " � ô4�`þ�ô �ø`ù�ý�!µôù�ö;�úôUøEû��QùY��ôDC�?,gJô�� � $! ô;ù�íA�ø`ù�ý�!µô�� ù�ýQþ�õµí�ô:ý���P�I�I�`õ±í�H $)òOù�í�ÿ9!±ô�� �%$" ù�í�ÿ# $ Äô �G�!Z�}í�� õµù�!<�`õZ� ô �ø`ù�ý�!µôo� ù�ýQþ�õ±í�ôUû �¦ÿ�ô@�`ôUø�� õ±í�õµû��`õ±ý;ù�í�ÿ�íI�í�ÿ�ô@�`ôUø�� õ±í�õµû��`õ±ý�òøúôÍû�� ôUý@�`õZ �ô�!H��/û���ýQþ �`þ³ùY� �%$ �'& ~ �" ý���P�I�I�`ôÍûf�úþ�ô�L {°|�~ �õ±í³ù�ø�� ûúôrù�øúýQþpù�!Z���øhõZ�`þI�ÿ�ôÍûúýUøhõ� ôUÿjù� d� �ô�?tgJô��)( $ �%!,���%$ �'&* �" �X?R7ªþ�ôM���ù�!�ö¯û��`ù���ô C'-¤î3õµû��%����³ù�øúù�íc�`ôÍô�`þ�ùY�HùY�M�`þ�ô�ôUí�ÿF�ö �`þ�õ±û)û��`ù���ô+( x-,/.�0 G " > � x-,/.�0 G " > ò ö��ø)û��� ô &¤ÿ�ô��ÄôÍí�ÿ�õ±í��íV�`þ�ô3û��Qù���ôY?�7 :ù�ýQþ�õ±ô� �ô,�úþ�õµût���ùY!I�`þ�ôEý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õ��íP ��õ�!µÿ�û�ù«ûhô���P ùY�5û��Qù���ô C<-¡î�3þ�õ±ýQþ¥õµûEõµí�õH�`õµù�!�!H� ô��P�2�E��?J7ªþ�ôUí'õZ�"øúô�� ôrù��`ôUÿI!Z�¸ûúô�!µôÍý��`ûoù û��úøúõ±í� / �ö�!µôÍí���`þA& ù�í�ÿù � õ±í�õ�� ù�! Bf�ö !±ôUí���úþ/& ) - � &f- j-û���ýQþA�úþ³ùY�

1/ . x ,�2�354 ( x ,62�3 ò¾ù�í�ÿ

1 % J / ) B 'hKG) J / ) B�î K + G �P��� x ,72�3! �A3d��� � F�ö��ø3ù�íc�c3a�3õZ�úþL9 3�9�� 9 / 9 ?

7ªþ�ô¸ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õ��í ��ø�°ýÍôUôÍÿ�ûV =� !±ô����`õµíI�98 � x ,62�3 � / ��ò �úþ�ôUí�ûúô@���`õ±í�CP �%CP;:% J / ) B�8 K +=?Eó=�Qù���ô C -Æî:ôUí�ÿ�û,�3þ�ôUí�íIU�f�øúô / õµíu�@ x ,62�3 4 ( x ,62�3 � G " > ýrù�í9 ô

Page 7: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

���$_;º1fkiX^Qlm\�c�dKq}ird5¢�_Xfk^`\)i � ����Ð�fkgWa}^kq ð

ö����í�ÿ¯ò°õK? ôY?±ò=�3þ�ôÍí¸ù�!�!³û��`øúõ±í��û �ö'!±ôUí���úþU&'ù�øúô"ý��øhøúôUý@�%!H�/ôUí�ý�°ÿ�ôÍÿ]õµíf�`þ�ô,�ø`ù�ý�!µôY? T�ô�3õ�!Z!m��ø�� �ô��`þ³ùY�3õ±í�ÿ�ôÍôUÿ ôrù�ýQþ û��QùY��ô=ôUí�ÿ�ûEù�ö;�úôUøEù !µõZ� õH�`ôUÿjí^�I�o ÄôÍøJ�ö�û��`ô���û�?

T¤ô6ýrù�!Z!c�`þ�ô5í�ôUôÍÿ;ö��ø`�`þ�ô5ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��í �%)ý��øúøhôUý@�%!Z�«ôÍí�ý�}ÿ�ôAùY!�!�û��úøúõ±í��ûi�ö�!µôÍí���úþ&¡ùcW \O^G_�8 W1\�� \�� �F > ?�T�ô��úþ�ôUí û`ùB���úþ³ùY�Eøúô�q^��õµøúô�� ôÍíc� F > õµû GX��8 �� \ B X�� � X��Z\ C:õ�ö( x , G " > �1 x , G " > ? /�øúô�q=��õµøhô��-ôUíc� W1\O^G_�8 W \ QX� �\�� �8 U#� ùY�"û��`ù���ô(C�õ�ö�õZ�Eõ±û)í��û`ù��`õµû�k³ôUÿm? / øhô�q=��õµøhô��-ôUíc�,�`þ³ùY� �1ù�ûEû`ùY�úõµû�k³ôUÿ ùY�3û��`ù���ôIC � ùB�]øúô�q^��õµøúô«ùY���`ôÍí=�úõ��í ùY�û��� ô:û��QùY��ô4" E�C�òOÿ��ô4�%�ýQþ�ù�í��ôÍûHõµí9�úþ�ô4�øúù�ý�!±ô�?,T¤ô;ûúùB�A�úþ³ùY�n�úþ�õµû"øúô�q^��õµøúô�� ôÍíc�õµû 8��;:a_ZW1\ B�?

/"ö;�úôUø«û��QùY��ô�CV�`þ�ô ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��í�ù�ý��úû4��G�í#�`þ�ô-þ�õZ��þ�ôUû��4��øúõ��øúõZ�E�'øúô�q^��õµøúô�� ôÍíc��`þ�ùY�=øúô�q^��õµøúôÍû�ù����`ôÍíc�`õ��íC c� ûhô����úõµí�/&[�%��úþ�ôV� õ±í�õ�� ù�!�� û���ýQþ �`þ�ùY�=øúô�q^��õµøúô�� ôÍíc�F  õµû:í��:û`ùY�úõµû�k³ôUÿ<?a7ªþ�õ±û�ýrù�íu Äô øúôÍý����í�õ�vUôÍÿu c� �úþ�ô ö¦ù�ý����`þ³ùY� "  Gr� x-, . 0 4( x-, . 0 � �� F?w5MY�`ô��`þ�ùY� ûúõµí�ýUô - " � * $ -���� û���ýQþ ù�í�� �Q_ ��ôXO�õ±û��¸ö��ø¸ù�íc���õH �ôUí C�òJö��øS��`þ�ôUø��3õ±ûúôfL {°| � 5n8RQ:L �3õZ�úþC�úþ�ô/ô��f�I�E�F�øúù�ý�!±ô/ù�í�ÿ#�1ô-ù�øhô-ÿI�í�ô�?T�ôU�3õ�!Z!W��ø�� �ô��`þ³ù���ôrù�ýQþ øhô�q=��õµøhô��-ôUíc� F > �3õ�!Z!W ô]û`ùY�úõµû�k³ôUÿ ù�í�ÿ õµí � ��øhôUÿ[�íI!Z�¤ù!µõZ� õH�`ôÍÿ]í^�I�o ÄôÍøM�ö �`õZ� ôÍû �¦õ ? ô�?�ò�`þ�ô�ôUí�ý�}ÿ�õµí�Vk�úû"õ±ía�úþ�ô�ôÍí�ý�}ÿ�õµíI� û��³ù�ýUôB�@? /"û F >õµûªûúùY�`õ±û�k³ôÍÿ9�íI!Z��õ�ö?ùY!�!¯û��`øúõ±í��ûJ�ö !µôUíI���`þ/&¡ù�øúô=ý��øúøhôUý���!Z�]ôÍí�ý�}ÿ�ôÍÿ¯òG�úþ�õµû ��ø�� �ôÍûM�`þ�ôý��øúøúôÍý��úí�ôUûhû:�ö �úþ�ô«ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��í<?3ü$õµøúû�� �1ô��3õ�!Z!'��øúôÍûúôUíc�M�`þ�ô«ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��í û�!±õ���þc�%!H��f�øúôoö��ø��jùY!�!Z��?

�I� ),�� 3! �,#� �� � ) ���� î�� " 3 � FS6 ���� C��V'2�& � �D�-õµí % � E ' �G� ( x , 4 x , � G " Á ��TF?+ �� � �(& ) � - � & � - - �" �8' � P � � 3 �TF � �� ��� � � / . �@ x ,72�3 ,�� � 4 ( x ,62�3 ,�� � � G " > ,� �L�õµý e��`þ�ô�!±ôrù�û��3û���ýQþ / �gJô�� Bf ô�� õ±í�õ��4���û���ýQþa�`þ³ùY�9 B 9���� � òJ / )1BhK5�.�� H � H � > , �U��� x ,72�3 ,�� �! � 3d���SòB Er� ù�O5% 39� 9 3 9 ��� � � J / )O3 K . " � +Wò�ù�í�ÿB � B � î�� / . x ,62�3 ,�� ���

ì©ö?í/û���ýQþ B-ô@O°õµû��`ûUò�úþ�ôUí/�`þ�ô«ý��í�û��`ø���ý��`õZ�í ôUí�ÿ�û ��n�`þ�ôÍø��3õµûhô�ò !µô@��P � � � * $ � P � � � :C% J / )1BhK + � N�� / õµû \�� Y U�BZ\ B��3õZ�`þ B�� Nó°ô��J" �D"'-£î �

� ),+ � � � ���" � * $ � " � : P � � � �� ),+*�� ���� C

� ),+?�"! �I� )*� 3! �*#� �� � )

Page 8: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

ñ � gWq�fh�=iXa��������

�����,���I��! ! ��#� )"���;�@� 7ªþ�ô�ý��øúøhôUý��úí�ôUûhû ��ø�^�ö}ý��í�ûhõµû��`û`�ö�ù3ûhôUøhõµôUû'�öI!±ô��f�jù�û�?i�A�û��õ��f�G�ø��`ù�íc�%!Z��ò��1ôo�4��û��Hûhþ�� �úþ³ùY�M�`þ�ô;ý��í�û��`ø���ý��`õZ�í���}ôUûn�í'ö��øhô� �ôÍøUò<�úþ³ùY�oõ±ûUòOù Bõµûªö����í�ÿ'ôUù�ýQþ9�`õZ� ôHõ±ía�úþ�ô�!�^��<?N7ªþ�ô:ö��!Z!���3õµí� !±ô��f�jù4�3õZ!�!Jûhþ�� �`þ³ùY�J�úþ�ô�ûhô��M�ö� ! q=��ôUøhõµôÍû"õ±ûªôrù�û����% ùB ��õ±ÿ<?

��e��������V� � & � " $ ��� �d&#. ;N� � - � H � H � > �P��� $! �A3d��� -�� � ) >�* $ �K?� W1U U ���>�oí¤õ±í��I� 3u�ö !µôUíI���`þ� & �`þ�ô í=��o ôUø �öAû��`ô���ûo�ö�� $! õ±û G���í�ÿ�ôUÿu c�� > ?oì �)ö��!�!���3û,�`þ³ùY�M�`þ�ô�í^�I�o ÄôÍø:�ötq=��ôÍøúõµôÍûoõµíA�`þ�ôo!±ôÍö;���P�û��)ý���f��I�Qù��`õ��í9�í9�úþ�õµûõµíI��I�Aõ±ûN G���í�ÿ�ôUÿ� c� � > ? /"ûN�`þ�ôÍøúô=ù�øhôoùY�N�P�û�� � >�* $ û��`øúõ±í��û 3/�ö`!±ôUí�Y�`þ � &$ò2�`þ�ô!µô��P� ù�õ±û ��ø�� �ôÍÿ<? �

5"ôXO2�4�1ô�ûhþ�� �`þ³ùY���`þ�ô�ôUí�ý�°ÿ�õµí� ÿ�í�ô]ù��;ù'ûhõµí��!µôV!µô@ �ô�!6ÿ}ôUû�íI��4�`ù�e�ôf�%^� ù�íc�;ôUí�ý�}ÿ�õµí�Hû��`øhõµí��û�?�ü��ø?ôUù�ýQþ û��Qù���ô C"ù�í�ÿ/ôUù�ýQþ/û��`øhõµí� / �öG!µôÍí���`þV& � ò��6ôJ�jùB�k³í�ÿ�k³øhû�� �úþ³ùY� / õµû1í��ªõ±í# x , 2�3 ,�� � ùY�Aû���-ô:�G�õµíc�rò�ù�í�ÿ��úþ�ôUí¸þ³ùB �ôS���ôUí�ý�°ÿ�ô:�úþ�õµûö¦ù�ý@�Aõµí P � � � * $ ?t5"ô@O^� �6ô:� ùB�fk�í�ÿ�ö��ø5û���-ôM" � E6"��úþ³ùY� / . x ,62�3 ,�� ��� ù�í�ÿ]þ³ùB �ôn��ôUí�ý�}ÿ�ô4�`þ�õµû3ö¦ù�ý��)õµí P � � � � * $X?oó}õµí�ýÍô�õµí û�� �ûúô�q=��ôÍíc�:õH�`ôÍø`ùY�úõ��í�û "7� � � "7�<�ö��úþ�ô T£þ�õZ!µô!�^��/�`þ�ô B � ûoù�øhô4��õ±ý e�ôUÿ'û���ýQþ��úþ³ùY�n�úþ�ô«í�ô�� û��úøúõ±í��ûEõµí P � � � � � * $Eù�øhô:íI��nq=��ôÍøúõ±ôUÿ¥õ±í�`þ�ôS!µôÍö;���P�û��Aý���f��I�Qù��`õ��í��ö � x , 2�3 ,�� � �! � / ��òI�`þ�õµûªõµûW�`þ�ôS!µù�û�� �úõ��-ôM�úþ³ùY� �6ôHí�ôUôÍÿa��ôUí�ý�}ÿ�ô / ?tT�ôS�`þ�ôÍøúôSö��øúô=þ³ùB �ô��`þ�ô=ö��!�!���3õ±í�o!µô��P� ùI�

��e���������Hü �øEô@ �ôÍø�� Co. ;pù�í�ÿ / . " > , ò / õ±û3ôUí�ý�°ÿ�ôÍÿ�ùY�,�f�û��J�E�3õµýÍô:õ±í û��Qù���ôC�?

7ªþ�ô�ö��!Z!���3õµí�/!±ô��f�jù¸õµû:ýUôUíc�úø`ù�!N��9�`þ�ôjý��øúøúôÍý��úí�ôUûhûf�ö �`þ�ô ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��í<?�ì �û��`ùY�`ôÍû �`þ³ùY�J�úþ�ô=í^�I�o ÄôÍøJ�ö �úõ��-ôUû �úþ³ùY� �`þ�ô«û��`øhõµí��ûJ�ö�ù ��õZ �ôUía!µôÍí���`þ ù�øhô=ôUí�ý�°ÿ�ôÍÿõµí��úþ�ô��ø`ù�ý�!µôHõ±û !µõ��-õZ�úôUÿ<? /)í�ÿa�úþ�ôUøhôÍö��øhô��úþ³ùY�J�`þ�ô«ø�2�� �%/ý�°ÿ�ô=õ±û ��øúôÍûúôUíc��?

��e���������V� � �a� � - %$C ��& � � � +�- � � Â�� * $ �K?� W1U U ��� T¤ôF��ø�� �ôF�`þ�õµû� c��õ±í�ÿ��ý@�`õZ�í �í �F? gvô@���  � %$C 3 � CY$ � ����� +C ô�`þ�ôa� ù�O°õ�� ù�!6ûúô�� û���ýQþ6�`þ³ù��P& �

(� � ö��ø C , . �  ? 7ªþ=��ûC- % C �W& � � � +�-��

-��  -,- - %$C �t& � � � +�-+? ü��ø � ��î�ò5ûhõµí�ýÍô��`þ�ôÍøúô ù�øhô]í û��QùY��ôUû C]û���ýQþ>�`þ³ùY�& � � î�ò'�6ô þ�ù� �ôC-G%$Ca�m& � �î,+�- � -��i$ -+?fgJô�� . Äô-ù�ø� �õZ�úø`ù�ø��¥û���ýQþ �`þ�ùY� C , ù�í�ÿC ,6* $N d��úþ¸ô@O°õµû��"õ±í��i$X?5ü¾ø��� �úþ�ô=ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��í¸õH�ªö��!�!Z+�3ûW�`þ³ùY�

x , ( GL"$ � x , ( .�0 G"

$ � ( x , ( . 0 GL"$ � ( x , ( . 0 GL"

$"! x , ( . 0 G"$ ?

� ó}õµí�ýÍô=ù�ýUýÍô��I�úõµí�V�³ùY�úþ�û �ö � ! ù�øhôS��øúôÍûúôUø� �ôÍÿ¯ò x , G "$ ýrù�í¸í�ô@ �ôUø,!��ûúôoô�!µô��-ôUíc�úû

ùY�:ù�íc��û��Qù���ô�ò�ù�í�ÿC�úþ�ôVk³í³ù�!���ø��� ôUø=ý��íc�`ù�õµí�-ôUíc�=ö��!Z!���3ûoö÷ø��� �`þ�ô/ö¦ù�ý@���úþ³ùY���6ôù�øhô }õµûhõZ�`õ±í�U!±ôUí�Y�`þ î�ù��oû��`ù���ô C ,6* $ ? ��ó°õ±í�ýUô��`þ�ôÍøúô/ù�øhô4�íI!Z�/�E�N]û��`øhõµí��ûM�öt!µôÍí���úþî�ò -��i$ - �.0I?

5M��1k2O�� EBî-ù�í�ÿ û���I�d�ûhô-ù�ûHõµí�ÿI��ý��úõ��í�þc�^�dY�`þ�ôÍûúõµûP�#�%$ � �a� � - %$C��d& � �$�+S- � �'& � * $ î��K?7�: �ûhôUø� �ô �`þ³ùY�P�#� . ����� C+� � C , � C � C ,6* ))( * $ �F& � � � � ?o7ªþ�õµûHõµû

Page 9: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

���$_;º1fkiX^Qlm\�c�dKq}ird5¢�_Xfk^`\)i � ����Ð�fkgWa}^kq ï

ÿ��ôV�%��úþ�ô�ö¦ù�ý����`þ�ùY�ròJö��ø«ù�íc� . û���ýQþ\�`þ³ù��(C , ù�í�ÿ C ,6* $)ô@O°õµû��:õ±í �  òvõ±ö:� ��C+� � C , �C��?C ,:* $ ��2 & � � � � �`þ�ôUí x , ( G " ! x , ( . 0 G "  ù�û6õ±íf�úþ�ô�� � î"ýrù�ûhô�� /"û

!��í��ù�ûn& � � ��òJùY!�!yù�ýUýÍô��I�úõµí�]ý���f��I�Qù��`õ��í�ûM�ö � ! ùY�n!µôUíI���`þ � ù�øhô4��øhôUûhôUø� �ôUÿ c�\�úþ�ô]ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��ím?us"ôÍí�ýUô��úþ�ô]ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��í ýUù�í �í!H��ö¦ù�!Z!N ³ù�ý e �%F!±ôUí�Y�`þ ��% ôÍí�ý�}ÿ�ô ù¡í�ô@��ù�ýÍýUô��2�`õµíI�¡ý���f��I�Qù��`õ��í<?�ó°õµí�ýUô��`þ�ôÍøúô ù�øúô/�íI!Z� �  û��úøúõµíI��ûV�ö!µôÍí���úþ ��ò% x , ( . 0 G "  ýUù�í�í�� ôM��ø��� ôUø�!Z� !µù�ø���ôÍøR�`þ³ù�í x , ( G "

 ö��øt�P�øúô �`þ³ù�í�  ý��í�ûhôUý��I�`õH �ô . ? 7ªþ�ô/õµí�ÿ��ý��úõ��í�þc�^�G��`þ�ôÍûúõ±û���õZ �ôÍûS��û«ù�í#��� ôUø� G���í�ÿ#�í þ���ö;�úôUíu& � � �F?9T¤ôfk³í�ÿu�úþ³ùY� -��  - � -7%$CF� & � � � +�-�� � �  - î+��- î�?�ó}õµí�ýÍô- %$C �=& � � � +�-�� � �  � $�� � * $ î�ò³õZ�ªö��!Z!���3û �`þ�ùY� - %$C �=& � ��� +2-�� � � �  � $�� � * $ î+��-C� � �  � $�� � * $ î+���R� �  - î���- � �  - î+� �1� � �  � $�� � * $ î+� ��� �  - � ��- � �  -�î+� �� �  � $�� � * $ � �  - � ��� � �  � $�� � * $ * �  * $�� � � Â�� �  * � ?5ó°õ±í�ýUô � � � ò2�`þ�õ±ûªõµûJ!µôÍûúû �`þ³ù�í�øªô�q^��ù�!'�% �  � * $ ? �

T¤ô«ù�øhô=í�� øúôUù�ÿI����P��ø�� �ô

��e�������� S5M/û��`ù���ô=ôUí�ÿ�ûEö��ø !µù�ý eU�ö�ý�°ÿ�õ±í�/û��úøúõµíI��û�?� W1U U ���5ü�õ O/ù�íP& � î�ò}ù�í�ÿU!±ô��GCY$ �?CB) � ����� � C��, ôEù�!�!�úþ�ôEû��QùY��ôUûGCM�3õZ�úþP& � �D& ?AW�PgJô��f�jù50�ò=�1ô)þ³ùB �ô��c� � > � * $ ? T�ô)ûúþI+�(�úþ³ùY�6õ±öm�úþ�ô)ý��í�û��`ø���ý��`õZ�í�øhôrù�ýQþ�ôÍûN�`þ�ôû��`ù�ø��,�ö�ù�û��`ù���ôIC , ò�`þ�ôUí õZ�ªý��íc�`õµí=��ôÍûM ô����í�ÿ9C , ?ü�õHO¥ù�íc� / �ö !±ôUí���úþF&�òvù�í�ÿF!µô�� � �1& ) - � &U-.-2? / �S�`þ�ô�û��Qù�ø��S�ö5û��`ù���ô CY$Sò�6ôjþ³ùB �ô J / ) "  K � F? ó2�I��d�ûúô / k³øúû��;í�ôÍôUÿ�û4��A ôjôÍí�ý�}ÿ�ôÍÿ ùY�:û���-ô õH�`ôÍø`ùY�úõ��í"%$ �öJ�`þ�ô�!Z2��<? 7ªþ�ôUøúô¸ù�øúô �  � $ �³ù�õµøhû %(B � '*) B � î,+ � "  ò5ù�í�ÿ> c� gJô��P� ù¤î�ò��6ôþ³ùB �ô"ùY�t!±ôrù�û�� �  � $ � ) >)* $ �öm�`þ�ôUûúôJ�³ù�õµøúû�ùB �ù�õZ!�ù� !±ô1ö��ø�ôÍí�ý�}ÿ�õµíI� / �3þ�õ�!±ô3ùB ��õ±ÿ�õµí�� H � H � > �U��� x , 0 2�3 , 0 � � 0! �A3d���X?i7ªþ=��û / ýrù�í� ô5ôÍí�ý�}ÿ�ôÍÿ��3õH�`þ«ù � õ±í�õ�� ù�!bû��úøúõ±í��BY$ . " Â!µôUùB °õ±í�=ùY�t!±ôrù�û�� �  � $ � ) >�* $ î,�³ù�õ±øúû��öÄû��úøúõµíI��û:E BY$?ù� �ù�õZ!�ù� I!µô�ö��ø�ôUí�ý�°ÿ�õµí� /õµíS�úþ�ô�ö��I�%��øhô�?yìeí��úþ�ô��N�øúû��$ýrù�ûúô�ò / í�ôUôUÿ�ûi��, ô�ôUí�ý�°ÿ�ôUÿ4�í�ýUôt�f�øúô�õ±í«û��Qù���ôGCY$�òZû`ùB�ùY�5û��� ô3õZ�úôUøúùY�`õZ�ío"*) E "%$ �3õH�`þ ù��-õµí�õZ�jùY!°û��`øúõ±í�BB)�? /n�f�í�S�úþ�ô �  � $ � ) >�* $ îùB �ù�õ�!µù� !µô���ù�õµøhû �ö¾ý�°ÿ�õµí�Eû��úøúõµíI��ûUò��6ô1íI+��þ³ùB �ôªùY� !µôrù�û�� �  � $ � � � ) >�* $ îN�`þ³ù�� �6ôýrù�í���ûúô:�3þ�õZ!µô)ù� ��õµÿ�õµí� � H � H � > �P��� x , 0 2�3 , 0 � � �! �A3d���n�ÑùY��ù�õµíU��ûúõ±í� gJô��f�jù î+�@? /Eö;�`ôUøôUí�ý�}ÿ�õµí� / �`þ�ô ûhôUý��í�ÿ\�`õZ� ô�ò'�1ôf�`þ�ôÍí þ³ùB �ôjùY��!µôrù�û�� �  � $ � ) >�* ) � �³ù�õµøhû��öý�}ÿ�õ±í�/û��`øhõµí��û�:E BB)Eö��øªôUí�ý�°ÿ�õ±í� / õ±í¸ö��2�%��øhô«û��Qù���ôUû�?

&N�íc�`õ±í^��õµí�U�úþ�ô�û`ùY� ô�ù�ø����I� ôÍí=�M�`þ�ø�����þ�û��Qù���ôUû CB)7)<C � )76G676�òm�1ô�ûhôUô4�úþ³ùY�=ùZö;�`ôUøû��`ù���ô C , �1ô5þ³ùB �ô1ùY�`!µôUù�û�� �Â�$ . � � ) >)* ) - � �m�³ù�õ±øúû`�ö°û��`øhõµí��û$ùB �ù�õZ!�ù� !±ô�ö��øJôÍí�ý�}ÿ�õµíI�

/ ùY�Eö��I�%��øúô«û��QùY��ôUû�?oó°õ±í�ýUô . ��� � � > � * $ òG�6ô;þ³ùB �ô;ùY�M!µôUù�û�� �  � $ � > � * ) >�*� �<'�³ù�õ±øúû �ö"ý�}ÿ�õ±í� û��`øhõµí��û !µôÍö;��ö��ø / ù�ö;�úôUø�ô� �ôUø�� û��Qù���ô C��3õZ�úþ>& � � & ?[7ªþ^��ûP�6ôù�!H�AùB�}û3þ³ùB �ô«ôUí��I��þ ý�°ÿ�õµí�/û��úøúõ±í��û �%/ý���P�I!µô��úôHô� �ôUø�� û��Qù���ôY?

�ü³ø��� �úþ�õµû,gJô��f�jù/õZ�3ö��!Z!���3ûªõ��f�-ôUÿ�õµùY�`ô�!Z�f�`þ³ùY�"õµí�ÿ�ôUôÍÿ'ôrù�ýQþ¥û��`ù���ô«ôUí�ÿ�û,�3õZ�úþ

�`þ�ô�!±ô� �ô�!Jý��øúøúôÍý���!Z�]ôÍí�ý�}ÿ�ôUÿ õµí��úþ�ô=ô@O^�`ôÍí�ûúõZ�í9�öi�`þ�ô��ø`ù�ý�!µô�?�7ªþ�ùY�3õµûÍò

Page 10: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

î ' � gWq�fh�=iXa��������

� �#f ����� ��f�g���V�#��C�����( x-, . 0 4 x-, . 0 � G " > , � F?

� �#f ����� ��f�g���:!±õ�� ��� & � � � ?� W1U U ��� 7ªþ�õ±û3ö��!�!���3ûAÿ�õµøúôÍý���!Z�jö÷ø��� gJô��P� ù 0I? �ü³ø��� �úþ�ôUûhô4!±ô��f�jù�û �úþ�ô«ý��øhøúôUý@�`í�ôÍûúû:�ö �`þ�ô:ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�í ö��!Z!���3û�? 7ªþ�ô��ø`ù�ý�!µô

õµû«ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`ôUÿ[�úþ�ø���I��þ ù'øhôUý���øúûhõZ �ôU��ø�}ýUôÍÿ��øúô�ò�þ�ôUí�ýUô�õH�:õ±û�øhôUý���øúûúõH �ô�!Z��ôUí=��-ôUø,�ù� !±ô�? /)ûo�úþ�ô]ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õ��í�ýUù�í4kö¦ù�!Z!W �ù�ý e 6#�� ù�!µôÍí���`þ[&£ù��/ù�íc�u�G�õµíc��õ±í\�`þ�ôý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õ��í ���úþ�ø�����þ ù�ýQþ³ù�õ±í �öoýQþ³ù�íI��ôUû õµí �`þ�ôa�ø`ù�ý�!µôB�4�1ô ýrù�í�í�� ý��í�ý�!���ÿ�ôøúôÍý���øhûúõH �ôUí�ôUûúû�?

�� e � f e����%:7ªþ�ôUøhô6ôXO�õ±û��úû?ù3øúôUý���øúûhõZ �ô�!Z�«ôÍí^�I� ôÍø`ù� !±ôt�ø`ù�ý�!µô " û���ýQþ4�úþ³ùY��� {}|�~ �5n8RQ:L x ?

����� ���I� )*�������"��)*#%���@� 7ªþ�ô�ö��!Z!���3õµíI��ý��ø��!�!µù�ø��a�1ù�û��úþ�ô/õµí�õH�`õµù�! �f��úõZ �ùY�`õZ�í'ö��ø�`þ�ô«ý��í�û��`ø���ý��`õZ�ía�ö �úþ�ô��ø`ù�ý�!µôY?

� �#f ����� ��f�g���:7ªþ�ôÍøúô«ô@O°õµû��`ûEù�í/�øúù�ý�!±ô " û���ýQþA�úþ³ùY�,L {°|�� � L {2]�_°|�� ?� W1U U ���f7ªþ�ôf�ø`ù�ý�!µô�ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úôUÿ õ±íC7ªþ�ô��øhô�� ð��jùYe�ôUû�L {°| � �w5M8RQSL��R?�ì �«í��ö��!Z!���3ûN�`þ�ùY�ML {}| � � L {^]�_�| � ? �

&N�ø��!�!�ù�ø�� ñ û������ôÍû��úû:�`þ³ùY�M�`þ�ôÍøúô;õ±û"íIU�`õZ��þc�oþ�õ±ôUø`ù�øúýQþc�A�úþ�ô��øúô�� �¦ùY�:!±ôrù�û��oí���í�ôC�`þ³ù��¥øúô�!�ùY�úõZ }õ�vÍôUû%�]ö��øAL {����! R] �#" � > ��� �`õZ� ô ý�!µù�ûúûhôUûÍò:ö��ø û���õH�Qù� I!µô ö���í�ý��úõ��í�û%$ ?T£þ�ôÍøúôrù�û û���ýQþ ù\�úþ�ô��øúô�� õµû��`ø���ô ù�í�ÿ£øhô�!�ù��`õZ }õZvUôUû ö��ø/5M7ªì��98M�&$ �3&'���F� ó�üR�¥ð�ñ �h =ù�e}ñ$0��@? /"íjô� �ôUí-ö���ø��úþ�ôUø�ý��!�!�ùY��ûúôªö��!Z!���3û?ÿ�õ±øúôUý@�%!H�;ö÷ø��� �`þ�ô,� �ûhôUø� �ù��`õ��íV�úþ³ùY�t�`þ�ô�`ôÍýQþ�í�õZq^��ôUûEõµí �KsEô�� ñ�ï��Aøúô�!�ùY�úõZ }õ�vÍô�?

� �#f ����� ��f�g�'�:7ªþ�ôÍøúô«ô@O°õµû��`ûEù�í/�øúù�ý�!±ô " û���ýQþA�úþ³ùY�,L {°|�� � 5nL {2]Y_�|�� ?/)í ô�q=��õH �ù�!µôÍí=�3û��QùY�úô��-ôUíc�Eõµû �úþ�ôHö��!�!Z+�3õ±í�?

� �#f ����� ��f�g �)(�:7ªþ�ôÍøúô«ô@O°õµû��`ûEù�ía�ø`ù�ý�!µô " û���ýQþA�úþ³ùY�,8RQSL {°|�~ � � 0+* 0 � � L {°|�~ ?� W1U U ��� /n��ù�õ±íF��ûúôo�úþ�ôo�`ôÍýQþ�í�õZq^��ôUû«õµí>�KsEô�� ñ�ï��M�����ô@�`þ�ôÍø:�3õZ�`þF�ø`ù�ý�!µô " õ±íF7ªþ�ô���øúô���ð2? �

/n��ù�õµíA�úþ�õµûEõµû"ù û��`øúù�í��ô �I�oíI��)ý��íc�`øúù�ÿ�õµý@�%�ø�� ý��í�ûhô�q=��ôÍí�ýUôY?nT¤ô eWí�� ö÷ø����`þ�ô¡ÿ�ô��`ôÍø��-õµí�õ±û��úõµý¥þ�õ±ôUøúù�øúýQþc�r�úþ�ô��øhô�� �úþ³ùY�A8RQSL �� Lù�í�ÿ �`þ³ùY�/�úþ�õµû��úþ�ô��øhô��øúô�!�ùY�úõZ }õ�vÍôUû�?�7ªþ�ô���øhô� }õ����û;ý��ø��!�!µù�ø�� ûhþ��3ûo�`þ³ù���õ±ö �úþ�ô�ô@O2�G�í�ôÍí=�úõ�ù�! �`õZ� ôf�ø`ù�ý�!µô� ù�ýQþ�õµí�ôUû5ù�øúôªøhôUû��`øúõ±ý��úôUÿP���q^��ôUø��}õ±í� �í!Z� �G�!H�°íI�� õµù�!�!H�S� ù�íc� q=��ôUøhõµôUûn�Ñù�û�ù�øúô �`þ�ô�G�!Z�}í��-õ�ùY!d�`õZ� ôS�ø`ù�ý�!µô��jù�ýQþ�õµí�ôÍû ��ò �úþ�ôUía�`þ�ô��E�W�ý�!µù�ûúûhôUûEý��õ±í�ýUõ±ÿ�ô=øúô�!µùY�`õH �ôS�% " ?7ªþ�ôHö��!Z!���3õµí��ý��ø��!�!µù�øúõ±ôUûªù�øhô=ù�!µû�V� ôÍí=�úõ��í�ôUÿ ù�ûJ�� ôUí/��ø�� !µô�� ûªõ±í\�3s"ô�!�ñ�j��@?

Page 11: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

���$_;º1fkiX^Qlm\�c�dKq}ird5¢�_Xfk^`\)i � ����Ð�fkgWa}^kq î�î

� �#f ����� ��f�g ����:7ªþ�ôÍøúô�õµû¯ù�í��ø`ù�ý�!µô " û���ýQþ��`þ³ùY�'8�Q:L x �D5n8RQSL x ! 8RQSL {°|�~ �� ;�= Á � x) ?� W1U U ��� 7�ùYe�ô ù���ù�õ±í �ø`ù�ý�!µô " õµí �úþ�ô ��ø�^�öU�öU7ªþ�ô��øúô�� ð2? ì � ö��!�!Z+�3û¥ö÷ø����`þ�ô ö¦ù�ý@� �úþ³ùY���`þ�ôPL �!H�}í��-õ�ù�!�7ªõZ� ôfs"õ±ôUøúù�øúýQþc�¡ý��!Z!�ù���ûúôUû��%9L {°|�~ ò c�C�³ù�ÿ�ÿ�õ±í��ò�`þ�ùY�n�úþ�ôo8 O2�d�í�ôUíc�`õµù�!i7ªõ��-ô4sEõµôUøúù�øúýQþc� ý��!Z!�ù���ûúôUûJ�%�8�Q:L {}|�~ ?"ü���ø��úþ�ôUø��P�øúô�ò �`þ�ôøúô�!�ùY�úõZ }õ�vÍôUÿ �`õZ� ô¸þ�õ±ôUø`ù�øúýQþc� �`þ�ô��øúô�� ö��ø ÿ�ô@�`ôÍø��-õµí�õ±û��`õ±ý��ø`ù�ý�!µôa� ù�ýQþ�õµí�ôUû-õ��f�!µõ±ôUûL {°| ~ �� 8RQ:L {}|�~ ? �7ªþ�õ±ûEý��ø��!�!�ù�ø��-õ��f�!µõ±ôUûN�úþ�ôHö��!�!Z��3õµí� ��ø��� ôUø��E��?� �#f ����� ��f�g � ��V�÷ìE73ñ�ïc�@?

7ªþ�ôUøhôoô@O°õ±û��`ûAù�íU�øúù�ý�!±ô " û���ýQþ��úþ³ùY�Aó°ô��6ô�!±û��í � ûªý��í � ôUý@�%��øhô"ö¦ù�õZ!µû�øúô�!�ùY�úõZ �ô,�� " ?/)íI��`þ�ôÍø3ý��í�ûhô�q=��ôÍí�ýUô;õ±û �`þ�ôHö��!Z!���3õµíI�?� �#f ����� ��f�g � ��V� A s)ï�î��@?

7ªþ�ôUøhô:ôXO°õµû��úûEù�íA�ø`ù�ý�!µôHûúô@� " û���ýQþA�úþ³ùY�,L {°| � �� L {}| ���� ?

� â������ � æ���� � �¯å��oç3èT�ô í�� ��ø�}ýUôÍôUÿ6 c��ô@O2�!µù�õµí�õµí���úþ�ôa�úøúôÍôa�-ô��úþ}ÿ>�úþ³ùY�V�3õ�!Z!Aþ�ô�!Z� ��ûP� 2�Qù�õ±í ù�íõµí � ��ø��)�©ö÷øhôUôN �ôUøhûúõ��íf�ö��`þ�ôªý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�í/õµí/ó°ôÍý��úõ��í70I? 7ªþ�ô � ù�õµí;øhôrù�û��í �1ôªí�ôUôUÿ�ôUÿõµí � ��øúõ±ôUû3ù�û �6ô�ù�ø�����ôÍÿ õ±í ó°ôUý@�`õ��í>0o�1ù�ûJ�`þ�ôHö��!Z!���3õµí�I?

�oí�ù�í õµí�ÿ�õH }õµÿ�³ùY!�³ùY�úþP�í õµí�I�I� / ò�ù«í�í�ÿ�ô@�`ôÍø��-õµí�õ±û��`õ±ýªô@O2�G�í�ôUíc�úõ�ù�!��`õZ� ô � ù��ýQþ�õ±í�ô �jùB� q=��ôUø�� �í!H��ôXOI�G�í�ôÍíc�`õ�ùY!�!Z��� ù�íc�;û��`øúõ±í��û�?RsM��6ô� �ôUø �ío�`þ�ôªý���o �õ±í³ùY�úõ��í�öAù�!�!R�G�ûhûúõ� I!µô �³ùY�úþ�ûUò$ô� �ôUí ù/!µõ±í�ôrù�ø)ô@O2�d�í�ôUíc�`õµù�!�!H�� G���í�ÿ�ôUÿ\� ù�ýQþ�õ±í�ôV�jùB��þ�ù� �ô� )�� ÿ�õ±û��`õ±í�ý���q=��ôÍøúõµôÍû�? /"û �`þ�ô ý�°ÿ�õ±í� øúô���õ��í ö��ø / �¦õK? ôY?±òi�`þ�ô-øúô���õ��íC�öªû��`øhõµí��û=õ±í�3þ�õ±ýQþ]û���-ô)û��`øúõ±í�;õ±íP�`þ�ô:�ø`ù�ý�!µô"ý�}ÿ�ôUûW�3þ�ô��úþ�ôUø / õ±û1õµíP�`þ�ôn�úôUû�� !�ù�íI���³ù���ô,�ø6í��X�õµûV!±õ��-õZ�`ôÍÿ\�%¡û��úøúõ±í��ûV�ö:!±ôUí�Y�`þ & � ö��ø/û��� ô�kIO°ôUÿ �Äò1õ±í�ÿ�ôUôÍÿ X,[ [ � >�� û��`øhõµí��û/õ±í�`þ�õµûAøhô���õZ�í�� ù��jù��� ôrù�øN�í]û��� ôn�³ùY�`þm?�7ªþ�ôUøhôÍö��øhô�ò > �?X� \��,\IW:ý�°ÿ�õ±í�;û��`ø`ù��`ô��Y�U�6ôÿ�ôÍýUõµÿ�ô��í¯ò��`þ�ô�í�í�ÿ�ô��`ôÍø��-õµí�õ±û��úõµýf�jù�ýQþ�õµí�ô�� ùB� ����øúí[��I�o�%'þ³ùB �ô ù�í ù�ýÍýUô��2�`õµíI��³ùY�úþ õ�ö$ù�í�ÿa�í!Z�jõ±ö`�`þ�ô«ôÍí�ý�}ÿ�õ±í�/û`ùB�}û,�úþ³ùY� / õ±ûªí��3õµí��úþ�ôS�`ôUû��,!�ù�í���³ù���ôY?

7ªþ�ô��N�ø�eZù�ø����í�ÿ þ�ôUøúô�ò� d�øúø���6ôUÿ ö÷ø����øúôUý���øúûhõ��í/�`þ�ô��ø���ò³õµû3ùY��ù�õµí��úþ³ùY���î�? �úþ�ôUøhô:ù�øúô=í�� ��2V� ù�íc��û��úøúõ±í��ûJ�ö !µôUíI���`þ 9 / 9 ?� ?Eù�í-ù�ýÍýUô��I�`õ±í�=ý���f��I�`ùY�`õZ�ío�í/õµíI��I� / ýrù�íf Äô�4Kö÷ø��vÍôUí�6���ûhõµí�=í�� �%^�� ù�íc�û��`øúõ±í��û�?

0I? õ�öo G���í�ÿ�ôÍÿ ûúôUù�øúýQþ ûhþ��3û��`þ³ùY�'í�í�ô �ö ���ø'ý���øúøúôÍíc��ýrù�í�ÿ�õµÿ³ù��`ô\�ø`ù�ý�!µôUûýUù�í¤ö��øhýUô]ù�í ù�ýUýÍô��I�úõµí�¥ý���f��I�Qù��`õ��í¯ò �úþ�ôUíu�6ô�ýrù�í û`ù�ö÷ô�!Z�¡ý�}ÿ�ô�õ±í ù�ýÍýUô��%��`ù�í�ýUô�øúô � ôUý@�`õ��íA�ö / ?

Page 12: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

î � � gWq�fh�=iXa��������

7ªþ�ôSe�ô@�U�ö'�`þ�ôn�W�ø�e�ù�ø����í�ÿ]õµû1õH�`ô�� 02?�8�ù�ýQþ��`õ��-ôEõµíP�úþ�ôoý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�í��1ôoù�û�e�3þ�ô@�`þ�ôÍø�û��`øhõµí��û?ýrù�í4 Äôªù�ÿ�ÿ�ôUÿ ��n�`þ�ôN�ø`ù�ý�!µô ( 8�� X Y \IW X@8��DW \��@8 U#�:( ��"ö��øhýUôªùoí�ô��ù�ýÍýUô��2�`õµíI� ý���P�I�I�QùY�úõ��ím?6ì©ö�û��ò��6ô«ö��øhýUô:ù�í�ÿ/kIO/�`þ�ô�ù�ýÍýUô��I�`õ±í�jý���P�I�I�QùY�úõ��í ù�í�ÿ�f+ �ôo�í9��P�úþ�ô;í�ôXO2�oøúô���õ��í<?Eì©ö�í��Uòd�úþ�ôUíX,[ [ �a_� _ZW1\ �AW 8����# QX B BZ\ B'�U ���\ U(W�XZYI[]\> 8 [ [��I\ ���8 W1\��@8 U#��?ts"ôUí�ýUô«øúô � ôÍý��úõ��í õµû3ù�!±û�V��øhôUûúôÍø� �ôUÿ<?NT�ô��jùYe�ô=û���øhôS�`þ³ùY�J�úþ�ôUøhôù�øhôM�f�øúôEøúô���õ��í�û �úþ³ù�íU�úþ�ôUøhôoù�øhô)ý���P�I�I�QùY�úõ��í�ût��4 ôn��øhôUûhôUø� �ôUÿ ùY�1ù4��õH �ôUí û��`ù���ô�òû�V�`þ�ùY� �1ô:ù�!H�AùB�}û3þ³ùB �ô«ø�^�� ôÍí����þ/�%/ôÍí�ý�}ÿ�ô�?

7ªþ�ô=øúô���õ��í�ûªù�øúôHÿ�ô�k³í�ôÍÿ'ù�ûAö��!�!Z+�3û�? !HõZ �ôÍí¸ù;û��úøúõµíI� ÿ�ôUíI��`ô� c� �"�$ �úþ�ôHûúô@��ö?ù�!�!¯û��`øhõµí��û3õ±í "�$J�`þ³ùY�3ôXO^�`ôUí�ÿ 4?5ìeí û���-ô���ù��ÄôÍøúûEûúô@�`û,!µõ�e�ôS�`þ�õ±û3ù�øúô:ù�!µû�/ýrù�!Z!µôUÿYI`([ 8�� BZ\IW @?A5M���ù'ûhô�q=��ôUí�ýUô/�öªý@�2!±õµí�ÿ�ôUøúû�ýrù�íu ôU��õZ �ôÍí ù�û n$�"�$�� ) "�$�� 676G6±ò�3þ�ôÍøúô , þ³ù�û , � $�ù�û ùC��øhô�kIOd? 7ªþ�ô , ýrù�í½ù�!µû� ôa�úþ����þ=�f�öHù�û/í°ÿ�ôUûU�íù9k³í�õH�`ô�!Z� �ø`ù�í�ýQþ�õµí�F�úøúôUôY? /øhô���õZ�íu�3õ�!Z!W ô¸ù¥ûúô@�V�öJ�`þ�ô�ö��ø�� J "�$7) �"�$ )1"�$ ) "�Kö��ø]û��� ô . "�$�? 7ªþ�ô ôUíc�`õ±øúôF�øúù�ý�!±ô9�3õ�!Z!n ô�ý��í�û��`øúù�õµí�ôUÿ(�%[ ô�ù û�� �ûhô��A�öJ "�$G) "�$G)1"�$ ) "�K�?ü��ø:��õH �ôUí / �ö !±ôUí���úþ�&E<'U�`þ�ôÍøúôo�3õ�!Z!` Äô�û��`øúõ±í��ûoõ±í9�`þ�ôo�ø`ù�ý�!µô4�ö��`þ�ô;ö��ø��

J / ) ) > )102) 8IKW�3þ�ôUøhô ) > � �9$ ��) ����� ��) >

õµûªû���ýQþ9�úþ³ùY�Q9 ��) , 9 � 9 ��) , � $ 9�� . -¿î=ö��ø"ùY!�!�î� . �D&$òM9 0�9�� � &P- � ò¾ù�í�ÿ 8:. "�?gJô��V��û�ÿ�ôUí��úô��`þ�ô]ûhô��V�ö"ù�!Z!1û���ýQþ û��`øúõ±í��ûo c� ( = ? 7ªþ�ô 8-ý���f�d�í�ôUíc�`û �ö,�úþ�ôUûhôû��úøúõ±í��û)ôÍí�ý�}ÿ�ô4�3þ�ô��`þ�ôUø / .F x ?n8�ù�ýQþ������3õZ!�!` ô�õµÿ�ôUíc�`õHk³ôUÿ9�3õH�`þ�ù í^�I�o ÄôÍø)õ±í�`þ�ô«øúù�í��ô'o�% ��� �� )� * $ î=õµí��`þ�ô���û��³ù�!<�1ùB��?

7ªþ�ôA�úôUû��U!µù�í���³ùY��ô ! 3 ö��øV�ø`ù�ý�!µô P õµû/ÿ�ô�k�í�ôUÿpù�û/ö��!�!���3û�� / . ! 3 õ�öHù�í�ÿ�í!H�jõ�ö<�`þ�ôS!µô@O°õ±ý����øúù���þ�õ±ýrù�!Z!Z� � ù�O°õ��4���ô�!µô�� ôÍíc�ªõµí�( = G P �¦õ�övõZ�AôXO°õµû��úû �1õ±û �ö'�`þ�ôö��ø�� J / ) )102)rî K ?�sEôUøúô�ò���øW!µôXO�õ±ý����ø`ù���þ�õµýrùY!G�øúÿ�ôÍøúõµíI�o�íU�úþ�ôoô�!±ô��-ôUíc�`û J / ) )10 ) 8 K�ö ( = õ±û���k³øúû��4!±ô@O°õµý����ø`ùY��þ�õµýUù�!�!H�a�øúÿ�ôÍø c� �ò'�úþ�ôUí =�C0 ò'�`þ�ôÍí\ c� 8�?�8R °õ±ÿ�ôUíc��!Z��ò! 3 .CL {}| � ö��øEù�!Z!<�øúù�ý�!±ôUû�PU?WT�ô��3õ�!�!Oý��í�û��`ø���ý��où-øhôUý���øúûúõH �ô �ø`ù�ý�!µô " û���ýQþA�`þ³ùY�! x �E x ?

�:��ø"ý��í�û��`ø���ý��`õZ�íA�3õZ!�!' ��õ�!µÿ��úþ�ô �ø`ù�ý�!µô� c�'ù�ÿ�ÿ�õµíI� û��`øúõ±í��ûJ�`þ³ù��n ô�!Z�í� �% øúô9���õZ�í�û?ù�û?ÿ�ô�k�í�ôUÿ-ù� G� �ô�? &N�íc�`ø`ù�ø��4��:�`þ�ô1ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��í�õ±í/ó°ôUý@�`õZ�í70�ò��úþ�ôAý��í�û��úø���ý���`õZ�íjþ�ôUøúô:�3õZ!�! ��øhôUûúôÍø� �ô:ù�ûN�1ô�!�!Äù�û � ��û��3ùB ��õ±ÿ]ù�ýÍýUô��2�`õµíI��ý���f��I�`ùY�`õZ�í�û�? 7ªþ�ôUøhôÍö��øhôí��W�í!H�o�3õ�!Z!�û��úøúõ±í��û Äô,��I� 8�� �U��úþ�ô,�ø`ù�ý�!µô3ÿ��øhõµí���`þ�ôEý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õ��í¯ò2 I�I�1û��`øhõµí��û�3õ�!Z! ô øhôUûhôUø� �ôUÿ½ö��øV�úþ�ô¸ý���f�!±ô��-ôUíc�V�ön�úþ�ô/�ø`ù�ý�!µô ù�û �6ô�!Z! ?�ü��øo�`þ�õ±ûV���ø��G�ûhô�6ôP� ù�õµíc�`ù�õµí�ù¸û�� ôUýÍõ�ù�!�ûúô��Uòi�úþ�ô-øúôUû��`øúù�õµíc�=ûúô@�B? ü��øHôrù�ýQþ�C � î�ò'�1ôV�3õ�!Z!?þ³ùB �ô " � ôU�`þ�ôjûúô��o�ö3û��úøúõµíI��ûo��I��õµíc�%A�`þ�ô��ø`ù�ý�!µôU ôÍö��øúô�û��Qù���ôECc?AT¤ôU�3õZ!�!5ù�!±û�¥þ³ùB �ô¸ùøúôÍû��úø`ù�õ±í=�)ûúô@� F � �3þ�õµýQþ'ý��íc�Qù�õµí�û)ù�!�!<�úþ�ô�û��`øúõ±í��û,�`þ³ùY�,�6ô;þ³ùB �ô � U#3ý���P�-õZ���`ôÍÿa���`þ�ô Y U#���2[]\�� \�� W�ö �úþ�ô��ø`ù�ý�!µôS ôÍö��øhô=û��QùY��ô(C�?tT¤ôS�3õZ!�!Jù�!H�AùB�}ûEþ³ùB �ô " � � F � ò¾ù�û�6ô�!�! ù�û " � � " � * $?ù�í�ÿ F ��� F � * $X?R7ªþ=��ûW�úþ�ôJ�ø`ù�ý�!µô �3õZ!�! ô"ûúù�í�ÿI�3õ±ýQþ�ôUÿU Äô@�E�1ôÍôUí" � ù�í�ÿ9F � ? T£õZ�úþ�õµí ôrù�ýQþ'û��QùY��ô(CQE î�ò��1ô��3õ�!Z!vù�!µû�P��ûhô4!Z°ýUù�!< �ù�øúõµù� !µôÍû��" ù�í�ÿ��F�%�õµíc�`ôÍø��G�!�ùY�úôM ô��E�6ôUôÍí " � ù�í�ÿ " � * $5ù�í�ÿU Äô@�E�1ôÍôUí5F � ù�í�ÿEF � * $5øúôUû��ÄôÍý��úõZ �ô�!Z��? / �

Page 13: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

���$_;º1fkiX^Qlm\�c�dKq}ird5¢�_Xfk^`\)i � ����Ð�fkgWa}^kq î0

ù�íc�C�d�õµíc�«õµí �úþ�ô-ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��í¯òi�1ôf�3õ�!Z!�û`ùB�#�`þ³ùY��ù�í �ø`ù�ý�!µôDP õ±û�ù YOX�� B@8� X� \ õ ?�" � P � �Fo?

�oí�ônk³í³ùY!ÄíY�`ôn ôÍö��øúôM�6ôoû��Qù�ø��B� �6ôn�3õ�!Z!¾û���-ô��úõ��-ôUû5û`ùB��ò 4�gJô��.P Äô:!±ôrù�û��1û���ýQþ�`þ�ùY��?�?�?Uò76#�ø 4�!�^�e'ö��ø��`þ�ôP� õ±í�õ��4�� P�û���ýQþu�`þ³ù���?�?�?Uò76#�ø�û��� ô-û���ýQþ¯òR�3þ�ôUøhôP � "�$�??ìeí/û���ýQþ-ýrù�ûhôUûÍò=�6ôEù�ûúû���-ô �`þ�ôJ��û��³ù�!!±ô@O°õµý����ø`ùY��þ�õµýUù�!^�øúÿ�ôÍøúõ±í�S�í/û�� �ûúô��úû�öS"�$i c���úþ�ôUõ±øvõµíIk³í�õZ�`ô�ýQþ³ù�ø`ù�ý@�`ôUøhõµû��`õµý�ûhô�q=��ôUí�ýUôUû�? 85ù�ýQþ�ý��í�ÿ�õZ�úõ��í��í PD�3õZ!�!�ÿ�ô��ÄôÍí�ÿ�í��íI!Z� ù4k³í�õH�`ôoûhô��J�ö` �õH�`û �ö�PH� ûªýQþ�ù�ø`ù�ý@�`ôÍøúõµû��`õ±ýoûúô�q^��ôUí�ýÍô�ò¾û�/ùo�-õµí�õZ�o�� P1�3õZ!�!ù�!H�AùB�}û3ô@O°õµû��"õ�ö`�`þ�ô=ý��í�ÿ�õZ�úõ��í¸ýUù�í/ Äô=û`ù��`õµû�k³ôUÿ ùY�Eù�!Z! ?

5M�� �6ô�ù�øúô«øúôUù�ÿI�/�%P��øúôÍûúôÍí=�n�`þ�ô:ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��í<?"ó^�`ù���ôÍû)ù�øhô�í=��o ôUøhôUÿ���ûúõµíI�&�ö��ø &>� î ) � )767676@?

�I� ),�� 3! �,#� �� � ) ���� î � �9$ � ' . " ) � n$ ���9$ � " $ �TF � F�$ � J "�$G) n$ "�$7) "�$G) "�K � ���� � & �3& � î+�N�� � � ����� ü��øúýÍõµí�/ù�ýÍýUô��I�`õ±í� ý���f��I�Qù��`õ��í�û� �8'V. " >�* $ � �C�T" > � �" � " ) > � $ � �FE� Fn) > � $ ������ � �- � ) > � $ � ��F��>� �" : � �F G J "�$G) �"�$ ) "�$G) "�K�� �(3�&% / . �>�G���SPo� � �" � P � �F��;� / . 3 �A+- ! ( ��8F�� � ��)/ � � õ±í ( �P1�D�-õµí2%(P �G� �" � P � � �F��;� / .B 3 � + ��" � �" : ���P��� 3! � / ��� G P � ��FE� �F ���P��� 3! � / ��� P � �� � � % / + �� ��� -£î �

� ),+ ��!� ) �� � (3� F ���) > � � � ) > � � �F � �F��

� � � ���9� &N°ÿ�õµí� ��! � � # � / . " > � �N�� ìeíc �ù�øúõµù�íc�B� �" G J / ) ) > ) "�$G)1"#K � F �,N07� �-õµí5% 0 � . " ) >)* ) � J / ) ) > )O0 � ) "�K � �F + �- ! / .B �x � � �1) 8 � î � � �/� 8 �T' ��" � �" :C% J / ) ) > )102) 8IKa+ N�� / õµû \�� Y U�BZ\ B� =� J / ) ) > )10 ) 8 K �,N

� ),+ ! ��!

Page 14: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

îBj � gWq�fh�=iXa��������

� � � ��� � &N!µôUù�í=��" ) > � �" � Fn) > � ���F J " > ) "�$G)1"�$ ) "�K%� : �"

� ),+ �- � � & ���� � &f-¿î����) >)* $ � ' . " >)* ) � ) >)* $ � ) > ��) >)* $ �" ) >�* $ � " ) > � Fn) >�* $ � Fn) > G � J "�$7) ) >)* $�"�$7) "�$G) "�K : " ) > �

� ),+ �- � � &f-¿î� ),+?�"! �I� )*� 3! �*#� �� � )

��e������� � Hü �ø3ù�!�!�C E�'�ò�6ô=þ³ùB �ô " � � " � * $�ò5F � � F � * $�ò'ù�í�ÿ " � � F � ?

� W1U U ���pó^�`øúù�õ���þc�hö��ø��1ù�øúÿ�õµí�ÿ��ý��úõ��í �í C�?r5,��`ô��`þ�ùY� � ��û��P ÄôSö��øúô �F�õ±û/ýQþ³ù�í��ôÍÿùY�V�`þ�ô ôÍí�ÿ6�öM�`þ�ô ü��øhýUõµíI�C��þ³ù�ûúôa�ö)û��QùY��ô9C � � &�òW ÄôÍýrù���ûhô �" � �F;òW�6ô þ�ù� �ô�F�� � �" :u� �F G J "�$7) ) > "�$7) "�$G) "�K�� � �F G � �" : J "�$G) ) > "�$G) "�$G)1"#K�� � �Fo? �

��e����������Hü �ø"ôUù�ýQþ�& ��î;ù�í�ÿ / . " > òOùf �ùY!���ô=ö��ø�0 õ±ûEö����í�ÿ'õ±íA�úþ�ô &N}ÿ�õµíI���þ³ù�ûúô��ö�ó=�Qù���ô � & ?� W1U U ���]ì �«û�� 8-ýUôUû �% ûúþ�� �úþ³ùY��ùY���`þ�ô-û��`ù�ø����öW�`þ�ôH&N°ÿ�õµí�a��þ³ù�ûhôP�ö3ó^�`ù���ô � &�ò- J / ) ) > ) "

) >�* ) ) "�K �F - � � ) >)* ) ?jì �«õµû=ý�!µôrù�ø� c�F�úþ�ô ý��í�û��`ø���ý��`õZ�í#�`þ³ùY�=ö��ø«ù�íc�Br. J / ) ) > ) "

) >�* ) )1"#K�ò6õ�ö�BF�1ù�û ô@ �ôÍø øhô��f+ �ôUÿ ö÷ø��� �F ôÍö��øhô��`þ�ô¸û��`ù�ø��f�ö,�`þ�ô&N}ÿ�õµí����þ³ù�ûúôn�övó^�`ù���ô � &�òc�`þ�ôUíU�úþ�õµût�o��û��1þ�ù� �ô)þ³ùY��ÄôÍí�ôUÿjõµíV�`þ�ô�=Eô��ÄôUùY�W!�^��V�ö�`þ�ô�ü��øhýUõµíI�P��þ�ù�ûúô �ö?û��� ô«û��`ù���ô C � � & ? 7ªþ�õ±û"þ³ùY��ÄôÍí�û"ö��ø)ùY�,�f�û�� � > � ù�íc� B�3q=��ôÍøúõ±ôUû�ù�í�û��1ôÍøúôÍÿ�4híI%6=ù�!��í�Hù)ûhõµí��!±ô �³ùY�úþ �ö � ! � / �H���vö��ø?ôrù�ýQþ / �c�3õH�`þ 9 / � 9�� &�òù�í�ÿ/�`þ=��ûQ- J / ) ) > ) "

) >)* ) ) "�K �F -�� � > � � >�* $ î+� � � ) >�* $ ? �T¤ô=ÿ�ô@k³í�ô " � � ��� 3 " � ?

��e�������)��Hü �ø?ôrù�ýQþf&¸ù�í�ÿ;ö��ø�ù�!�! / �öG!±ôUí���úþ &�ò " ý��íc�`ù�õµí�û�ôXO�ù�ý���!Z�o�í�ôªû��úøúõµíI��ö<�úþ�ô3ö��ø�� J / ) ) > )102) 8IK?ö��ø 0U. "

) >�* ) ù�í�ÿ�8n. "�ò=�3þ�õµýQþ õµût�`þ�ôM!µôXO�õ±ý����ø`ù���þ�õµýrùY!�!Z�� ù�O°õ��o�� ô�!±ô��-ôUíc�,�ö ( = G " ?� W1U U ��� AW�/gJô��P� ù�ûHîBj-ù�í�ÿ î -}ò " ý��íc�Qù�õµí�ûEùY�J!±ôrù�û��J�í�ô=û���ýQþ û��úøúõµíI�?

gJô�� �" ) � 3 )76G676G) ��) > ò,0«ù�í�ÿ 8� Äô6ù�û$õµí��`þ�ô &N°ÿ�õ±í�,��þ³ù�ûhôN�ö³û��Qù���ô � & � ��û�� ÄôSö��øúô/ õµû6ôUí�ý�°ÿ�ôUÿ<? &N�í�ûhõµÿ�ôÍøAù�íc� û��úøúõµíI� BV. ( = �3þ�ôÍøúô@B>�� J / ) ) > )102) 8IK@?�7ªþ�ô)û��`øhõµí� Býrù�í��í!H�¸ôUíc�`ôÍø " ôÍõZ�`þ�ôUø �÷õ;�Aÿ��øhõµí�P�`þ�ô &N°ÿ�õ±í�U��þ³ù�ûúô4�ö�û��� ô:û��QùY��ô4��úþ�ôUø,�`þ³ù�í� &$ò �¦õ±õ;�oÿ��øhõµí�a�`þ�ôjü��øúýÍõµí�a��þ³ù�ûhôU�ö3û���-ô û��Qù���ô � & ��E � &�ò �ø��÷õµõ±õ;�"ÿ��øúõµíI�A�`þ�ôü��øúýÍõµí� ��þ³ù�ûhô:�övû��� ô"û��`ù���ô � & �2� � & ? &Aù�ûúôV�÷õ;��ýrù�í�í�ô� �ôÍøªþ³ù��� ôUíOòI ôUýrùY��ûúô=ù�íc�û��úøúõ±í��û3ôUíc�`ôÍøúõ±í�P�úþ�ôUía�N��I!µÿa Äô��ö �`þ�ô=ö��ø�� J / � ) �])10 � ) 8 � K �3õH�`þ / � �� / ? &Aù�ûúô��¦õ±õ;�ýrù�í�í��)þ³ù��� ôUí� c�AgJô��f�jù îBj�ù�í�ÿA�úþ�ô:ö¦ù�ý@�n�úþ³ùY��BjõµûEøúô��P� �ôÍÿ¥ö÷ø����FM) > ÿ��øúõµíI��`þ�ô &N!±ôrù�í=��a��þ³ù�ûúô��ö�ó=�Qù���ô � &6�÷õ±öyõZ� �1ù�ûhí�� �"ù�!±øúôUù�ÿI�]øhô��f+ �ôUÿ ôrù�ø�!µõ±ôUø �X?

Page 15: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

���$_;º1fkiX^Qlm\�c�dKq}ird5¢�_Xfk^`\)i � ����Ð�fkgWa}^kq î -

ìeí�ýrù�ûhô/�¦õ±õµõ �Sò2B��o��û��S Äô�ùUq=��ôUø����ö��úþ�ô�ö��ø�� J / ) �9$������ ��) > � � $ �c3�)10 �]) 8 � Ko�÷ö��øû��� ô ��ò 3vò�0 ��ù�í�ÿ 8 �H���jù�ÿ�ô��í û��� ô]ù�ýUýUô��I�`õ±í�F�³ùY�úþ[�ö � ! � / � �«ö��ø�û���-ô / �;?7ªþ�õ±ûjõµûf ôUýrùY��ûúô9�3þ�ôUíVB¤ôÍí=�úôUøhû " ò BD. �U��� 3! � / �H���!GLP � �F��$òN�3þ�ôÍøúô ��9$%����� ��) > � � $ �F?�ó°õµí�ýÍô�� õ±û�û��I �ûúô�q^��ôUíc�%!H�Æõ±í�ýUøhô��-ôUíc�`ôÍÿ¯òJ�1ô þ³ùB �ô � � ��) > � òù�í�ÿ-û� �9$������ ��) > � � $ �c3 õµû�!µôXO°õµý����ø`ù���þ�õµýUù�!�!H�=û��`øhõµý@�%!Z�4!µôÍûúû��`þ³ù�í �9$%����� ��) > � ) > ?7ªþ=��ûUò?B:õ±û6ùY!µû��!±ô@O°õµý����ø`ùY��þ�õµýUù�!�!H��û��`øhõµý���!Z�4!µôUûhû �úþ³ù�í J / ) ) > )10 ) 8 K ?R7ªþ�õ±ûW��ø�� �ôÍûW�`þ�ô!µô��P� ùI? �

��e���������% ! x � x ?� W1U U ���)ü�õHO ù�í�& E ' ù�í�ÿ�ù�í / . " > ?MgJô�� �" ò��F;ò (/òOù�í�ÿ"�6 Äô�ù�û)õ±íA�úþ�ô &N}ÿ�õµíI���þ³ù�ûúô��ö"ó=�Qù���ô � & � ��û�� ôÍö��øhô / õµû:ôUí�ý�°ÿ�ôÍÿ¯ò5ù�í�ÿu!±ô�� �" 3 ôU�`þ�ôP �ùY!���ôf�ö �" ùY��`þ�ô�û��`ù�ø�� �ö �`þ�ô�ûúù��-ô &N}ÿ�õµí�9��þ³ù�ûhô�? AW�\gJô��f�jù¤îBb�ò?õZ�:û��+8 ýÍôUû �%'ûúþ��w�`þ³ùY�/ . x�� 2 / .C x òG�úþ³ùY�)õµûUò / û��`ùB�°û)ý��øhøúôUý@�%!H� ôÍí�ý�}ÿ�ôÍÿ¥õµía�`þ�ô �ø`ù�ý�!µôY?)ó}õµí�ýÍô(3�8F�ò�6ô=þ³ùB �ô

/ ."� ��2 �#� P � � �" 3 � P � �F�� / �. 3 � 6

ó2���G�ûhô / . � ?47ªþ�ôUí¯ò` ôUýrùY��ûúô �" 3 � �" � " � �F c�#gJô��f�jù'î�j�ò<�1ô�þ�ù� �ô/ �.B �x ù�í�ÿ / �. x ?

5M���û��I��d�ûúô / �. � ? 7ªþ�ôUí / �1ù�û øúô��f� �ôÍÿ½ö÷ø��� ��õ±í½û��� ô õZ�úôUøúùY�`õZ�í �ö�`þ�ô =Eô��ÄôUùY��!Z2��¯òªùY�P�3þ�õµýQþ6�úõ��-ô'ù�ípù�ýUýÍô��I�úõµí�\�³ùY�`þ �ö � ! � / �V�1ù�û�ô@O2�!±õµýÍõZ�%!H���øhôUûúôÍø� �ôUÿ¯ò ôUí�û���øúõ±í�V�`þ³ùY� �#� P � � �" 3 � P � �F�� / . 3 � ?ó2-õµí��`þ�õ±ûªýrù�ûhôS�1ô«þ³ùB �ô / . x ù�í�ÿ / . x ? �

��e�������)�� " õ±ûªøúôÍý���øhûúõZ �ô�?� W1U U ��� /M!�!�ûhôrù�øhýQþ�ôUû6ÿ�í�ô3õ±íV�úþ�ôEý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��í-ù�øhôEøhôUý���øúûhõZ �ô�!Z�V G���í�ÿ�ôUÿ¯òWõµí�ý�!���ÿ�õµí��`þ�ô;ýrù�!±ý��!µùY�`õZ�í9�ö Põµí9�úþ�ô =3ô�� ôrùY�S!Z2��<?oü���ø��`þ�ôÍøUò¯ô@ �ôUø���û��úøúõ±í�cB � J / ) )10 ) 8 K�3õZ�úþM9 / 9+� &�õµûEý���f� õH���úôUÿa =�a�`þ�ô�ôUí�ÿF�ö5ó^�`ù���ô � &\ c�9 ôUõ±í�U��I�n�ö Fn) > " ) > ?�

�"�������E�� � )���� ! ��� ��� � ������ 7ªþ�ô�ù�û����I�`ô:øúôrù�ÿ�ôUøM�jùB� þ³ùB �ô;íI��`õ±ýUôUÿa�`þ³ù��)õ±í�`þ�ô�ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õ��í¥õµí'ó°ôUý@�`õZ�í�jP�6ô�øhôrù�!Z!Z����ûúôUÿF�í!Z���úþ�ô�ô@ �ôUí�û��Qù���ôUûM���ý��í�û��úø���ý@��`þ�ô �øúù�ý�!±ô�? 5,�� �`þ�ô��`õZ� ô=þ³ù�û"ý��� ôS��U��ûhô��úþ�ô4}ÿ�ÿ û��QùY��ôUû"õµí/�`þ³ùY�Eý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�í�%U��ô��=ù�í¥ô@O^�`øúù�õµíc�`ôÍøúôÍû��`õ±í����ø��� ôUø��E�A�ö��úþ�ôo�øúù�ý�!±ô�?nT�ô4�3õ�!Z!`��ûúôo�úþ�ôo}ÿ�ÿ¥û��`ù���ôÍû�öi�`þ�ô=ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�ía���ö��øúýÍô��úþ³ùY�

�3jI?±î+� L�x �EDnL�x � 5ML�x G ý�c5ML�x

õµí ù�ÿ�ÿ�õZ�úõ��í���PL {}|�~ � 5n8RQSL�xi?

Page 16: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

î�b � gWq�fh�=iXa��������

/)ý@�%�³ù�!Z!Z��òt�úþ�õµû�õµû�í��oq^��õZ�`ô]ý��øúøhôUý@�B?uT�ô]ýrù�í ��ø�+ �ô��`þ³ùY� �úþ�ô/�ø`ù�ý�!µô " �`þ³ùY��6ô�ý��í�û��`ø���ý��;þ³ù�û �úþ�ôU��ø��� ôUø��E� ���3j?�î+���=ù� G� �ôU�í!Z�C��í�ÿ�ôUø �úþ�ô]ù�ûhû���f�I�úõ��íC�`þ³ùY�LF� L5óIL / & 8 �3��í�øúô�!µùY�`õH }õ�vUôÍÿ �@?�7ªþ�ùY�3õµûÍò�1ôS�3õ�!Z!Oõ±í�û��úôrù�ÿ ûúþ�� �úþ�ôHö��!�!Z��3õµí��

�3jI? � � LF� L5óIL / & 8 ��2 �3L�x �'DnL x � 5ML x G ý�c5ML x � L {°|�~ � 5M8�Q:L x �I)

�3þ�ôÍøúô " õµû �`þ�ô��øúù�ý�!±ôn�6ô�ù�øhô=ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõµí�?RT�ô=ýrù�í/�`þ�ôUíCW \ A W1\I[ X��8 �38��(\S�%f� I�`ù�õµíù�í��ø`ù�ý�!µô " �³û���ýQþ��`þ³ù�� L x � �'DnL x � � 5nL x � G/ý�c5ML x � � L {}|�~ � � 5M8RQSL x � �3õZ�úþí-ù�ûhû���f�I�`õZ�í�û�?

=Eô��eøhô�!�ù��`õZ }õZvrùY�úõ��í¥õ±û=ù/�úôUýQþ�í�õ�q=��ôV�`þ³ùY�«þ³ù�û ôUôÍí ��ûhôUÿu ôÍö��øúô/õµí¡ù¸í^�I�o ÄôÍø��ö�!µù�ýUôÍûU�÷ûúôÍô9�¦ü?ü���gvï$0���òJö��øoô@O�ù��f�!±ô��Sò` �2�:õH�Hÿ�ôÍûúôUø� �ôÍû;ù/ �øúõ±ôÍö5ô@O2�!µù�í³ùY�úõ��í þ�ôÍøúô�?T�ô:ýUù�í ýUù�û��M���ø3ôÍí=�úõµøhô«ý��í�û��`ø���ý��`õZ�í øúô�!µùY�`õH �ôS�%-ù�íc�/�øúù�ý�!±ô & c�/!µô@���úõµí�/ù�!Z!m�`þ�ô� ù�ýQþ�õµí�ôUû�õµíc ��!Z �ôÍÿ þ�ù� �ô)ù�ýUýUôÍûúû �%��ø`ù�ý�!µô�&[?�AW�/ÿ�õ±í�=û��òc�6ôM I��õ�!±ÿ/ù�íP�ø`ù�ý�!µô " $û���ýQþA�`þ�ùY��3jI? 0c�

L $ � L5óIL / & 8 $ ��2 �3L $J� x * � � DnL $ � x * � �35nL $ � x * Gu�¦ý�c5nL $ � x *� �KL {}| * � x * � �K5M8�Q:L $ � x *

ôUýrùY��ûúôf���øS��ø�2�öW�öS���3j? � ���n ô�!Z���ýUù�í ý�!µôUù�ø�!H�� ô�øúô�!�ùY�úõZ }õ�vÍôUÿ��%'&[?�ìeí ���3j? 0c���ù� G� �ô�ò³ôUù�ýQþ ý�!�ù�ûúû �öi�`þ�ôoö��ø�� � � $ � x * õµû � ��û��3ô�q^��ù�!<�% � $�� x * =��ý���o �õµí�õ±í�4�`þ�ô�E�W9�øúù�ý�!±ôUû=õµíc�%a�í�ôY?�5M�� !±ô���� Äô ù�íC�ø`ù�ý�!µô/û���ýQþ\�`þ�ùY� L�� �wL6ó2L / & 8 � �¦ùL5óIL / & 8 �eý���P� ô��úôHûúô@�rò�ö��øªõ±í�û��`ù�í�ýUôB�@?6ó°ô@���`õ±í�>& ���8õµí ����j? 0����N��õH �ôUû

L x � �'DnL x � � 5nL x � G ý��5nL x � � L {}|�~ � � 5n8RQSL x � )

�3þ�ôÍøúô " � � � "�? 7ªþ�ô L � L5óIL / & 8�ù�ûúû���f�I�`õZ�ípþ³ù�û� ôUôÍí¿ô9?OôÍý��úõZ �ô�!Z�

ÿ�õ±ûúýQþ³ù�ø���ôUÿF c�Ak³øúû��=øúô�!µùY�`õH }õ�vUõ±í�V�%��¤òd�`þ�ôÍí��% "�?=ì �:�`þ�ôUøúôSö��øúô�û�� 8-ýUôÍûHö��ø:���ø

ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õ��í/��/ôUí�û���øúôU����j? � ���1ù� G� �ô�ò }õµù�ùV��ø�^�ö �úþ³ùY�3øhô�!�ù��`õZ }õZvUôUû�?�ó2�ö÷ø��� í���í¯ò�6ôS�3õ�!Z!Äö÷øúôÍô�!H�¸ù�ûúû���-ô��úþ³ùY�,LF� L6ó2L / & 8 ��í�øhô�!�ù��`õZ }õZvUôUÿm?ü��øªûúõZ�P�!±õµýÍõZ�E�V�ö ��øúôÍûúôÍí=�`ùY�`õZ�í¯ò�úþ�ôoö��!�!Z��3õµí�;ý��í�û��`ø���ý��`õZ�í/�í!H��ôUí�û���øhôUûJ�`þ³ùY�

L {°|�~ � 5n8RQSL x ù�í�ÿ L x � DML x ?C!Hô����úõµí��L x � 5nL x G�ý�c5nL x ��ûúôUû�ûhõ��-õ�!µù�ø�`ôÍýQþ�í�õZq^��ôUû ù�í�ÿ ýrù�í�ôrù�ûúõ�!H�\ ô¸õµíc�`ôÍø�!±ôrùB �ôÍÿ õ±í=����`þ�ô¸ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�í<?F/)ûo�úþ�ô¸ô� �ôUíû��`ù���ôÍû=ù�øúô�õ±ÿ�ôUíc�`õ±ýrù�!i�%��úþ�ô�ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��í õ±í ó°ôUý@�`õZ�í#j�òm�6ôf�í!Z�A��øúôÍûúôÍí=���úþ�ô °ÿ�ÿû��`ù���ôÍûEþ�ôUøúôY?ü��ø . � J � ) �SK � î ) � ) 0?)767676mòI!µô�� # , ôn�`þ�ôS�jù�ýQþ�õµí�ô � �"ô�q=��õZ�� ôUÿ��3õZ�úþ¸ù;ý�!�}ý eû�V�`þ�ùY�3õZ�3ø���í�û3õµí��`õZ� ôn& , ?

Page 17: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

���$_;º1fkiX^Qlm\�c�dKq}ird5¢�_Xfk^`\)i � ����Ð�fkgWa}^kq îXð

���� � &f-¿îU�3& � î+�N�� �8'V. " >�* ) � �C�:%Wî )767676 )%&#+ � �" � " ) > � �F � Fn) > ������ � �- � ) > � ��F��>� �" : � �F G J "�$G) �"�$ ) "�$G) "�K�� �(3�&% . ."� �G���SP � � �" � P � �F�� �r���?0I� � 9 0�9 � � > � , � # 3, þ³ù�ûEùY�J!µôUù�û���E�N ù�ýÍýUô��2�`õµíI�f��ùY�`þ�û,�í¸õµíI��I��0 � �A+- ! ( ��8F�� � ��). �D�-õµí ( �P1�D�-õµí2%(P � � �" � P � � �F�� �r���?0I� � 9 0�9h� � > � , � # 3 �, þ³ù�û"ù��M!±ôrù�û���E�W�ù�ýÍýUô��2�`õµíI�f��ùY�`þ�ûJ�í õµíI��I��0 � +L�õµý eP�`þ�ô�!µôUù�û��3û���ýQþ 0�ù�í�ÿ/�`þ�ô�!µôUù�û�� �E�W-ÿ�õµû��`õµí�ý��Eù�ýÍýUô��2�`õµíI�f��ùY�`þ�û� ù�í�ÿ��o�ö # 3, �í õ±í��I��0 �gJô�� �1 ôS�`þ�ô=ûhô��M�ö?ùY!�!mq=��ôÍøúõ±ôUû,�jù�ÿ�ô=ù�!��íI� �³ùY�`þ�û � ù�í�ÿ�� ��" � �" : ��� G Po� ��FE� �F ��� P � �N�� # , õµûªíf!��í��ôUø3ù7DML 3 � � ù�ýQþ�õ±í�ôoö��ø3ù�íc�]ýUù�í�ÿ�õ±ÿ³ùY�`ôP � �,N� � � % . + �� ��� -£î �

� ),+ ��!� ) �� � (3� F ���) >)* $ � � � ) >�* $ � � " ) >�* $ � �" � FM) >�* $ � �F��

� ),+?�"! ���� � &P-£î7ªþ�ôn�ø`ù�ý�!µô " õµû�ÿ�ô�k�í�ôUÿ]ù�ûW ôÍö��øhô�ò}ù�í�ÿ õZ��õ±û6ý�!µôrù�ø�!Z��øúôÍý���øhûúõZ �ô�?t7ªþ�ô,��ø�^�öd�`þ³ùY�

L {°|�~ � 5M8RQSL x øúô�q^��õµøúôÍû�!µõZ���%!±ô:ýQþ³ù�í��ô�ö÷ø��� �`þ�ôV��øhô� }õ����ûS��ø�^�ö*�SgJô��P� ù¥îBj]õµûû��úõ�!Z!�ý�!±ôrù�ø�!Z�a�`ø���ô�?VgJô��f� ù'îbð�õµû:�úø���ô c��ôXO�ù�ý��%!H���`þ�ô�û`ù��-ô ��ø�^�ö*? gJô��P� ù'î -�õµûû��úõ�!Z!i�úø���ô�òi I�I�S�1ôV�o��û��=øúô@ }õµûúô ���øS��� ôUø� G���í�ÿ#�í�- J / ) ) > ) "

) >)* ) ) "�K �F - ��ù�ýÍý����íc�3ö��øªû��`øúõ±í��ûJ ôUõµíI�-øhô��f� �ôUÿ¸ö÷ø��� �F ÿI��øúõ±í�V°ÿ�ÿ¸û��Qù���ôÍû�?W8�ù�ýQþ

°ÿ�ÿ]û��QùY��ô � & � -�î � � &'øhô��f+ �ôUûAö÷ø��� �F (¿ùY�N�P�û��,( q^��ôUøúõ±ôUû � ù�ÿ�ô)ù�!��í� �E�W�³ùY�úþ�ûJ�ö # , � 0 , �Aö��øªôrù�ýQþ . . %Wî )7676G6G)%& �]+Wò

�3þ�ôUøhô 0 , õ±û�ù¥û��úøúõµíI���3õZ�`þ[!±ôUí�Y�`þ � � > � � , ? 7ªþ�ô]í=��4 ÄôÍø �ö,q^��ôUøúõ±ôUû �í ôUù�ýQþ�³ùY�úþ õ±û3ùY�J�f�û�� � � > � � , � , � � > ?5ó2V�`þ�ô

�%��`ù�!?í=��o ôUøS�ö1û��`øúõ±í��ûoøhô��f� �ôUÿ ö÷ø��� �F�õµí ù�!Z! �`þ�ô °ÿ�ÿ û��Qù���ôÍû � � C � � &õµû"ùY�M�P�û��:& ) � > � � ) >�* $ ?�/"ÿ�ÿ�õµíI�P�%f�`þ�õ±ûM�úþ�ô�í=��o ôUøM�ö�û��`øúõ±í��ûEý����í=�úôUÿ�õ±íA�`þ�ôô� �ôUí�û��`ù���ôUû ��õZ �ôÍû/ù��%��`ù�!1û��`øúõ±ý���!Z�C!µôÍûúûo�`þ�ù�í � ) >�* $ - � ) >�* $ � � ) >)* ) ù�û�ÿ�ôÍûúõµøhôUÿ<?gJô��f�jù�îBb-õ±û �`ø���ô��3þ�ôUíA�úþ�ô���ø�^�ö$õµû �f°ÿ�õHk³ôUÿ��� ù�ýUý����íc�"ö��øªû��`øhõµí��û�B-ôUíc�`ôÍøúõµíI�" ùY�:°ÿ�ÿ'û��QùY��ôUû�? 7ªþ�õ±ûoýrù�ûúô�õµû"ôUíc�`õ±øúô�!Z� ûúõ��-õ�!µù�ø �%�ýUù�ûúôa�÷õµõ±õ;�Aõµí9�úþ³ùY�S��ø�^�öKòOûhõµí�ýÍô�`þ�ô�}ÿ�ÿ¸û��`ù���ôÍû"ý�!��ûhô�!Z�jøúôÍûúô��4 !µôS�`þ�ô:ü��øhýUõ±í� ��þ³ù�ûhôUû,�öi�`þ�ô=ô� �ôUí û��QùY��ôUû�?

Page 18: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

îXñ � gWq�fh�=iXa��������

5M��úô��`þ³ù����`þ�ô#L � L5óIL / & 8�ù�ûhû���f�I�úõ��ír�1ù�û¸í��¸í�ôÍôUÿ�ôÍÿÆõ±í£ù�íc� �ö��`þ�ôý��í�ûúõ±ÿ�ôUøúùY�`õZ�í�ûHù� G� �ôY?�ó^]õµí'ö¦ù�ý@�rò'L {}|�~ � 5n8RQSL x ò¯ù�í�ÿ��`þ�õµûHù�!±û��ý�!µôUù�ø�!H� þI�!µÿ�û�3þ�ôÍíA�6ô«øhô�!µùY�`õH °õZvUôn�úþ�ô=ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��í/�%-ù�íc�/��øhõ��øN�ø`ù�ý�!µô &[?ì �?øhô�� ù�õµí�û`�%)ûúþ�� �`þ³ù��RL x �'DML x ?�ü$õHO�ù�í . û���ýQþ �úþ³ùY� # , õ±û�ù�DML x � ù�ýQþ�õ±í�ô�?T�ôo�3õ�!�!$ÿ�ôUûhýUøhõ� ô ù�L x /M!����øhõZ�úþ� �%]ý���P��2�`ô�!,��# x, �@?;ü�õHO¥ù�í õµí�I�I�@0¥ù�í�ÿ#!µô��&>� .�� !��� 9 0�9 �c? T�ô k³øúû��1ø���íP�úþ�ô3ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��íf�`þ�ø�����þ-û��`ù���ô � &M-�î�? /Eö;�`ôÍø6ù�!µõH����!µô

�`þI����þc�rò�õZ�ªýUù�í/ ÄôHûhôUôUí/�`þ�ùY� ) >�* $6ù�í�ÿ " ) >�* $:�Ñù�û3ùV!±õµû�� �öyû��úøúõ±í��û �1ýUù�í/ dY�`þ� ôý���P��2�`ôUÿ]õ±í]û��³ù�ýUôS!µõ±í�ôrù�ø�!Z�-ôXOI�G�í�ôÍíc�`õ�ùY!Oõµí�&¥ù�í�ÿ��`þ=��û �G�!Z�}í�� õµù�!¾õµí 9 0�9h� � > � , ?ìeíV�³ù�ø��`õµý��!�ù�øUò��úþ�ôªûúôUù�øúýQþ�ôÍÿU�³ù��`þ�û��öG�`þ�ô �jù�ýQþ�õµí�ôÍû � ! ù�í�ÿ�# , ù�øhôªôrù�ýQþf�öG!µôÍí���úþ� � > ù�í�ÿu�í!Z�Fq=��ôÍø���û��úøúõµíI��û �ö !µôÍí���`þ� � > ?]ìeí�ûúõZ�o�!�ù��`õµíI�/�úþ�ô-ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��í¯ò ôUûúõ±ÿ�ôUû�� ù�õ±í=�`ù�õµí�õµí�Eù:!µõ±û�� �ö��`þ�ôªû��`øhõµí��û$õµí �" ò��1ô �4��û���ùY!µû�n�jù�õ±íc�Qù�õ±í;ù ��� � > � �eûhõ�vUô!µõ±û����

� �ö��`þ�ôªû��`øhõµí��û?øúô��P� �ôÍÿ�ö÷ø��� �Fpÿ��øhõµí�S}ÿ�ÿ;û��Qù���ôÍû�ù�í�ÿ�õ±í4�`þ�ô =3ô�� ôrù���!�^���û�ö1ô� �ôÍí û��`ù���ôUû�? !=õH �ôUíC�`þ�ôÍûúôP!µõµû��`û«ù�í�ÿC�`þ�ô � ò �-ô��o ôUøhûúþ�õZ�\�öAù�íc�¡û��`øhõµí� õµí �Fýrù�í ôUù�ûúõZ!Z�� ôHý���P��2�`ôUÿ ùY�Eù�íc���úõ��-ô 4��í��`þ�ô�I�16 ù�û3í�ôÍôUÿ�ôÍÿ<?��oô@k³í�ô

lY�A0I� � J ) >)* $a) " ) >)* $a)� � � � .�0 Kù�û/ù� G� �ôY?\7ªþ�ô�ö���í�ý��`õZ�í l ýUù�í Äô]ý���f��I�`ôÍÿD���3õH�`þ��2�/ù�ýUýÍôUûhûV�� ù�í �ø`ù�ý�!µôB�«õ±í�G�!Z�}í��-õ�ùY!�û���ù�ýUô4�¦õ±íC9 0�9 �Sò�ù�í�ÿjõZ�úû���I����I�6õµût�d�!Z�}í��-õ�ù�!}ûúõZvUôY?�ì �5ö��!�!���3û?ö÷ø���1�`þ�ôLF� L5óIL / & 8pù�ûúû���f�I�`õZ�í��`þ³ùY�,loýUù�ía Äô=ý���P��2�`ôUÿ¸õ±ía�G�!H�°íI�� õµù�! �`õ��-ô�?

AW�U�úþ�ôoý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�í¸ù�í�ÿ��úþ�ôoö¦ù�ý��N�`þ³ùY� # x, õ±ûAù DML5xA�jù�ýQþ�õµí�ô�ò-# 3, � 0��þ³ù�ûªùY��f�û��W�í�ô"ù�ýUýÍô��I�úõµí� �³ùY�úþU�í õµí��2��0;ö��ø5ô� �ôUø�� P û���ýQþ��úþ³ùY� " ) >�* $ � P � Fn) >�* $@?T�ô�ýrù�í íI+� øhôUý�� �ôUøo�`þ�ô]ù�ýUýÍô��I�úõµí�9�³ùY�`þ[�ö # x, �A0I�Sò?õ�ö �`þ�ôÍøúô]õ±û4�í�ô�ò �`þ�ø�����þ ùÿ�ô@�`ôUø�� õ±í�õµû��`õ±ý��G�!H�°íI�� õµù�!<�`õZ� ô� G���í�ÿ�ôUÿF��ø�°ýÍôUÿ��øhôo��ûhõµí���ø`ù�ý�!µô " ò¯ù�ûM�6ô;ûúþ��í�ôXO2��?�T¤ô=ù�ÿ�ù��I�3ù;û��Qù�í�ÿ�ù�øúÿ��`ôÍýQþ�í�õZq^��ô«ÿ�ô� �ô�!��� ôUÿ ù�í�ÿ���ûúôUÿa c� =Eù�ý e� ?>�@=Eù�ýrñ � �Sò7$ù�øúÿ�û:� !V? 73ñ�ï���ò^s)ù�ø��%� ù�í�õµû�ù�í�ÿ�sEô�� ù�ýQþ³ù�í�ÿ�ø`ùP�Ksns"ï�î+��ù�í�ÿ6AN!Z��Bù�í�ÿ ìE�P��ù���!µõ4�ù�v�v�9�@A1ìKñ�ð��W�%-ý���f��I�úô # x, � 0�X? �:��ø /n!Z���øúõH�`þ�w��ûhôUû"ù/ö���í�ý��`õZ�í��jù�ûEù�û��I �ø���%��`õ±í�ô�ò2�3þ�ôUøhô

�d� 0 ) ) >�* $O) �" )� � � �� �U� # 3, �A0I����õ�ö ��� ùV!µôUù�û��3ýUù�í�ÿ�õ±ÿ³ùY�`ô�Po� � # 3, �A0I� � î��Ñò4hí%6 ��úþ�ôUø��3õµûhô�?

�3þ�ôÍøúô �" ù�í�ÿ��� ù�øhô�!µõ±û��úûo�öEû��úøúõµíI��ûUò�ù�í�ÿ �F�õ±û;ÿ�ô�k�í�ôUÿ ö÷ø�����

� ù�í�ÿ ) >)* $4 c��`þ�ô ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�í �úþ�ø���I��þ¤û��Qù���ô � &a- îjù�û:ÿ�ôÍûúýÍøúõ� ôUÿ ù� d� �ô�? &N!µôUù�ø�!H��ò��'ýrù�í\ ôý���P��2�`ôUÿ�õµíC�d�!Z�}í��-õ�ù�!$û��³ù�ýUôP�3õH�`þ��I�;ù�ýUýUôÍûúû��%¥ù�í �øúù�ý�!±ô�ò$ù�í�ÿ�õZ�`û���2�%��I�:õµû�G�!Z�}í��-õ�ùY!Äûhõ�vUôY?6ó°õµí�ýÍô�LF� L5óIL / & 8"ò�� õ±ûªý���f��I�`ù� !±ôHõµí��G�!Z�}í��-õ�ùY!G�úõ��-ô�?

Page 19: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

���$_;º1fkiX^Qlm\�c�dKq}ird5¢�_Xfk^`\)i � ����Ð�fkgWa}^kq îrï

/:g�!5� =3ìE7Js:� ü � = # x, �A0I�&N��f��I�`ô �" � " ) >�* $Sò � � � � � � � . 0 �;�3þ�õµýQþ ÿ�ô�k�í�ôUû �F��Sòù�í�ÿ � ) >�* $Aù�ûEù� d� �ô� }õµùflY�A0I� ��3� F ������ � �- 9 0�9 , �`õZ� ôÍû- ! �d� 0 ) )��" )� � � �� 4hí%6�� � ��)�3�5� : �G� 0 ) ) �" )�

� � ��" � �" :u��� G " � ��F � �F ��� " � �

� ),+���!� ),+?����� � � /)ýÍýUô��2�)õ�? # x, �A0I� � î:ù�í�ÿ �P��# x, �A0I��� � � �8t5��7ªþ�ôH/M!����øúõZ�úþ��ýUù�íu ô ø���í¤õ±íC�úõ��-ôV�d�!H�}í��-õ�ù�!?õ±íT9 0�9¾øhô�!µùY�`õH �ôV�%a�ø`ù�ý�!µô " �

�ò �" ò �� òAù�í�ÿ � ù�øúô ù�!�! �öoûúõZvUôA�d�!H�}í��-õ�ù�!6õµí<9 0�9 ò6ù�í�ÿ �6ô9�í!Z�[q=��ôÍø�� " �í

û��úøúõ±í��ûjõ±í �/ò �3þ�õµýQþpù�øúô�ù�!Z!J�öHûúõZvUô�ù��U�f�û�� 9 0�9 , ? �;T¤ôA��Äÿ�ùY�`ô �� �% ù�ýUý����íc�

ö��øJ�`þ�ô«û��úøúõ±í��ûEøúô��f� �ôÍÿ¥ö÷ø��� �F�ù�ûM ôÍö��øhô�? �/7ªþ�ô k³í³ùY!$ô@ �ùY!��³ùY�úõ��í/�ö # x, �A0I�Eù�í�ÿ�P��# x, �A0I���ªýrù�í9 Äô;ÿI�í�ô;õ±í9�G�!Z�}í��-õ�ùY!Jû��³ù�ýÍô4�3õZ�úþ��I�n�ø`ù�ý�!µô�ù�ýUýÍôUûhûUòJù�í�ÿ�û��ýUù�í ô«ÿI�í�ô=õµí/�G�!Z�}í��-õ�ùY!G�úõ��-ô�?

T¤ô]ÿ�ô�k³í�ô¸ù�í=�\�ø`ù�ý�!µôP�%F ô]ù¥ýrù�í�ÿ�õµÿ³ù��`ô � ��û��-ù�û ôÍö��øhô�?C5M��úô��`þ³ù�� " õµû;ùýrù�í�ÿ�õµÿ�ùY�`ô �`þ�ø�����þ��I���`þ�ô /M!����øúõZ�úþ� òJù�í�ÿ �" í�ô� �ôUø4!Z�ûúôÍû=ô�!µô�� ôÍíc�`û=í�ø=ÿ}ôUû��F��ù�õ±í;ù�íc��??ì©ö �`þ�ô /M!����øúõZ�úþ� ù�ýÍýUô��2�`ûUò��úþ�ôUí/ùZö;�`ôUø �`þ�ôªü��ø !�^�� �úþ�ôUøhôAõµû�ù�í/ù�ýÍýUô��2�`õµíI��³ùY�úþ �ö # x, �A0I�`�3þ�õ±ýQþV�í!Z� � ù�e�ôÍûRq=��ôUøhõµôUû�õ±í��f?�AN�I�R�úþ�õµû�õ��f�!µõ±ôUû # x, �A0I� � îªù�!±û��ò ôUýrùY��ûúô �" ò �F;ò³ù�í�ÿ þ�ôUí�ýÍô " ù�!Z!¯ù���øhôUôS�3õZ�úþ�õµí �V?

&N�íc �ôÍøúûúô�!Z��òJû����G�ûhô # x, � 0�!��î�òÄù�í�ÿF!µô@� � 3 � �U� # x, �A0I���@?�&N!µôUù�ø�!H��ò �¸í�ô� �ôÍøøúô@�%��øhí�û 4híI? 6>T¤ô:ý�!µù�õ�� �úþ³ùY� � 3 � � ù�ö;�úôUøJ�`þ�ô !�^��ak�í�õµûhþ�ôUû�?)ì �)ö��!�!���3û3õ��f�-ô9�ÿ�õµùY�`ô�!Z�f�`þ³ùY� �" G'� 3 � �F G � 3 � " G � 3 ò�ù�í�ÿ]û��# x, �A0I� � î=ù�í�ÿ��`þ�ô /M!����øhõZ�úþ�ù�ýÍýUô��2�`û�?

T¤ôf��ø�+ �ôP�úþ�ô ý�!�ù�õZ�A��gJô@��� � 9 0�9 , ?]ü��ø � � î ) � )767676 ) ��ò !±ô��P �o ôV�`þ�ô-ûúô@�ö����í�ÿf c� �:ù�í�ÿV!µô@� � �N ô �`þ�ôJq=��ôÍø���ûhô��5øúô@�%��øhí�ôUÿP =� � �íV�`þ�ô � �úþ õH�`ôUøúùY�`õZ�ío�öG�`þ�ô!�^��<?�ó2���G�ûúô:k�øúû�� �úþ³ùY� �úþ�ôUøhô=õµûªù � û���ýQþ/�`þ�ùY��P �)ù�í�ÿ " ù���øhôUôn�3õH�`þ�õ±í � 3 G � �Zò�`þ�ùY�1õ±ûUò*P � G�� 3 G�� � � " G�� 3 G�� �+?R7ªþ�ôUí��6ôn�4��û��1þ³ùB �ô � 3 �%� �+�?ì©öJíI��rò=�`þ�ôÍí!µô@�

( � �" :u�AP � G � ��� :\� " G � 3 �a6&N!µôUù�ø�!H��ò)(�õµû ù¡ýUù�í�ÿ�õ±ÿ³ùY�`ô�òN �2� # ", �A0I��þ�ù�ûf�E�W¤ÿ�õµû��úõµí�ý@� ù�ýUýÍô��I�úõµí� �³ùY�`þ�ûUò �í�ô� ù�eWõµí�aq=��ôUøhõµôUû:õµí � �/ù�í�ÿ �`þ�ôU��úþ�ôUø��jùYe}õ±í�aq^��ôUøúõ±ôUû:õµí � 3 ?�7ªþ�õ±û� }õZ�!�ùY�úôUûS�`þ�ôý��í�ÿ�õZ�úõ��í]ôÍí�ö��øhýUôUÿA c���`þ�ô=ôÍí�ÿA�ö�ó^�`ù���ô � &f-£î�ò¾ù�í�ÿ¸û�V�`þ�ô«ý�!�ù�õZ��þI�!µÿ�û�?

5M�� û��I��d�ûúô �úþ³ùY��P � G � 3 G � �6�� " G � 3 G � �oö��øEù�!�! � òÄù�í�ÿ9!±ô�� B �S Äô��`þ�ô

Page 20: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

� ' � gWq�fh�=iXa��������

�-õµí�õZ�o���û��úøúõ±í�]õµí �AP � 4 " � G � 3 G � ��?�7ªþ�ôUí ûhõµí�ýÍô " � B ���7�� P ��� B ���,�1ô eWí���`þ�ùY��B��. � � � $� = $ � ��ò� ôUýrùY��ûúô P �où�í�ÿ " ù���øúôUôS�3õH�`þ�õ±í �

��$

� = $ � ��?�7ªþ�õ±û,�-ôrù�í�û �`þ³ùY��� 3

��� = $

� ��� ��� 3

��$�

� = $� ���T6

7ªþ³ùY�=õ±ûUò�� 3 � !Z�ûúôÍû=ùY��!µôUù�û��:�í�ô/ô�!±ô��-ôUíc�f� B ���n�í ôrù�ýQþ�õH�`ôUøúùY�`õZ�í��ö �`þ�ô !�^��<?A1ôSö��øúôS�`þ�ôS!�^��]û��`ù�ø��úûUò�6ô:þ³ùB �ô -�� 3 � - � -�� 3 -�� 9 0�9 , ò�ù�í�ÿ û�-ù�ö;�`ôÍø �`þ�ô�!Z2��k³í�õ±ûúþ�ôÍûUòI�6ôHþ³ùB �ô � 3 �3�TF?�7ªþ�õµûW��ø�� �ôUû �`þ�ô)ý�!�ù�õ���ù�í�ÿP�`þ�ôoý��øúøhôUý@�`í�ôÍûúûJ�ö'�`þ�ô/n!Z���øhõZ�`þI�A? �

7 a��ô@�4L x � 5nL x G¡ý��5nL x ò'�6ô ýUù�í¡ôrù�ûhõ�!Z�'õµíc�`ôÍø�!±ôrùB �ôfL x � 5ML x G�ý�c5ML xû��`ù���ôÍûu���ö4�úþ�ô¡ö��ø�� j�& -�î+�U�3õH�`þ(�`þ�ô L x � DnL x û��`ù���ôÍû[�¦íI+� �ö4�úþ�ô¡ö��ø��j�& î+�X?�ü��ø �`þ�ôHö��ø�� ôÍøªû��`ù���ôUûÍò�3þ�õµýQþ'ù�øúôHþ�ù�í�ÿ!±ôUÿ ûúõ��-õ�!µù�ø�!H� �% �`þ�ô�!µùY���úôUø �í�ôUûUò�6ô�ý��í�ûúõ±ÿ�ôUøEôrù�ýQþ # $, ù�û"ùP��ø���ÄôÍøn5ML $ G'ý�c5ML $ � ù�ýQþ�õµí�ô«õ�öKò�ö��ø3ôrù�ýQþ'õµí��2�rò¾õZ�þ³ù�û1ùY� !±ôrù�û�� �í�ôoù�ýÍýUô��2�`õµíI�o�³ùY�úþ¯ò�ù�í�ÿ�ôUõH�`þ�ôÍøAù�!Z!Äù�ýUýUô��I�`õ±í�o�³ù��`þ�ûAû��Qù�ø��N�3õH�`þ]ù�!µôÍö;� �øúù�í�ýQþU�øR�`þ�ô@�/ù�!�!�û��Qù�ø��t�3õZ�úþ ùHøhõ���þc�t �øúù�í�ýQþ<? # $, ù�ýUýÍô��I�úûAù�í/õµíI��I��õ±öOù�í�ÿf�í!H�;õ�öõZ��þ�ù�û5ù�í-ù�ýUýÍô��I�úõµí���³ùY�úþ-û��Qù�ø��`õ±í�S�3õZ�`þ-ù�!µôSö;�t �ø`ù�í�ýQþ<??ìeíV�`þ�ô,L x � 5nL x G=ý�c5ML xû��`ù���ôÍûn�1ô !Z2�e�ö��øoù Pw�3õZ�`þ �" � P � �F�� �`þ³ù��)ö��øhýUôUûn d��úþ9�E�^�ÄôÍûS�ö5ù�ýÍýUô��2�`õµíI��³ùY�úþ�ö��øU�úþ�ô¥û`ùY� ô¥õ±í��I� 0d? 7ªþ�ô�ý��øúøhôUû��d�í�ÿ�õµí� L x /n!����øúõH�`þ� õ±û�ôUûhûúôUíc�úõ�ù�!Z!Z���í�ýQþ�ù�í��ôÍÿ¯ò³ô@O°ýUô��I�J�`þ³ù�� � í��ÆûúôUù�øúýQþ�ôÍûªö��øN�E�W-ýUù�í�ÿ�õ±ÿ³ùY�úôUû�P�ù�í�ÿ P � û���ýQþ/�`þ³ùY�# 3, � 0��ù�í�ÿ # 3 �, � 0�=ôrù�ýQþ þ³ùB �ô ù�í ù�ýUýUô��I�`õ±í�F�³ùY�úþ�ù�í�ÿu�`þ�ô��E�N#�³ùY�úþ�û�û��`ù�ø��V�í���G�ûhõZ�`ôP �ø`ù�í�ýQþ�ôUû�?�ì©öEû���ýÍýUôUûhûhö��!Ñò � øhô�����øúí�û �`þ�ô���í�õ��í\�ö �`þ�ô øúôÍû�� ôUý��úõZ �ô�q^��ôUø��ûúô@�`û�?97ªþ�ôP��ø�^�ö �öAô 8-ýUõ±ôUí�ý@� ù�í�ÿ ý��øhøúôÍý��`í�ôUûúû4��ø�}ýUôÍôUÿ�ûo!µù�ø���ô�!Z��ù�û4 ôÍö��øhô�?¸ì©ö �ô� �ôUø"øúô�����øúí�ûE4hí�ò 6f�`þ�ôÍí9�1ô:ûúôUù�øúýQþ'ö��ø"ù�í=� 8����,[]\�ù�ýÍýUô��2�`õµíI�U�³ùY�úþ9�ö # 3, �A0I���÷ö��øù�íc�/ýrù�í�ÿ�õµÿ�ùY�`ô�P �X?R7ªþ�ôJk³øúû��N �øúù�í�ýQþP�öd�úþ�ô,�³ùY�`þV�6ô,k³í�ÿU�o��û��6ù���øúôÍô �3õZ�`þV�`þ�ùY� �öù�íc��ù�ýUýUô��I�`õ±í���³ù��`þF�ö # x, �A0I�@?S7ªþ�ô�ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��íF��ø���-õµûúôÍûM�úþ³ùY�ròÄö��øoù�!Z! ( �3õZ�úþ" >)* $ � ( � F >)* $�ò?ù�í=�#�E�W�ù�ýÍýUô��2�`õµíI�9�³ùY�úþ�û4�ö # ", � 0�oû��`ù�ø����3õZ�úþ �úþ�ôjûúù�� ô �øúù�í�ýQþ<?=ó^�õ±ö �]í�ô@ �ôÍøHøúô�����øúí�û 4hí�ò76��`þ�ôUí�ùY�n!µôUù�û��n�í�ô4�ö��`þ�ôoq=��ôÍøúõ±ôUûoõ±íA�`þ�ô;ûúô@�øúô@�%��øhí�ôUÿ9 =� ���o��û��HùY!µû�f ô�õµí � 3 ù�í�ÿ þ³ùB �ôo ôUôÍí�ù�í�û��1ôÍøúôUÿ�ÿ�õ ?ÄôUøúôÍíc�%!Z�]ö÷ø��� " ?ó2�� 3 �1�3õZ!�!Oûhþ�øúõ±íe]ù�ûJ ôÍö��øhô�?RT�ôS�`þ=��ûEþ³ùB �ô��`þ�ôHö��!Z!���3õµí� �`þ�ô��øúô��A��� e � f e�� �)'�:7ªþ�ôUøhô�õµû:ù øhôUý���øúûúõH �ô��ø`ù�ý�!µô " û���ýQþu�`þ³ùY�oL {°|�~ � 5M8RQSL x ù�í�ÿL x �EDnL x �D5nL x G ý�c5nL x ?

�"��� ��� � � ),���;� � )*+ �I� ��� � �*� ��)� � � �! � �1�$� ü��øHù�íc� øúô�!�ùY�úõZ }õ�vUù� !±ô�ý�!µù�ûúû��>�6ô!µô@�,g �JT � �i�Aÿ�ôÍí��úô��úþ�ô=ý�!�ù�ûúûJ�ö�ùY!�! � �E!���Æûúô@�`ûUò õ ? ô�?�òI�úþ�ô:ý�!�ù�ûhûJ�ö?ùY!�! P�û���ýQþA�`þ³ùY�� 3 � �R?P7ªþ�õ±û=ý��í�ýÍô��I�:õZ�úûúô�!±ö6øúô�!µùY�`õH }õ�vUôÍûUòvõ ? ô�?�ò'�1ô-û`ùB�F�úþ³ùY�:ù ûhô�� P õ±ûS!����ö��ø��øúô�!�ùY�úõZ �ô:�%-ù�ía�ø`ù�ý�!µô " õ�ö�� x � 3 ��� x ?ó°õµí�ýUô4�úþ�ô;ý�!µù�ûúûhôUûS5MLÆù�í�ÿFL {°| ù�øúô94hý�!Z�ûúô/6U�%�ôUù�ýQþF��úþ�ôUøÍò<�í�ô � õZ��þc�)ôXOI� ôUý@�

�`þ�ùY�Jg �JT �K5MLW�5ûúþ��I!µÿ�!µõZe�ô@�3õµûúôn Äôoý�!��ûhôn�%Vg � T �3L {}| ��òI �2�3õµí�û��`ôrù�ÿ��1ôS��ô@� �`þ�ô

Page 21: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

���$_;º1fkiX^Qlm\�c�dKq}ird5¢�_Xfk^`\)i � ����Ð�fkgWa}^kq � î

ö��!Z!���3õµí��ý���øhõ����û !Z��3í�ôUûhûM��ø��� ôUø��E��øúô�!µùY�`õH �ô:��f�ø`ù�ý�!µô " �ö 7ªþ�ô��øhô��8îXï2?

� �#f ����� ��f�g � (� =3ô�!µùY�`õH �ôU����`þ�ô¸ûúô@� " �öM7ªþ�ô��øhô�� îrï�òtg �JT �K5nLW�7� L�ù�í�ÿg �JT �KL {°| � � 5M8�Q:L,?

� W1U U ���]ì �:õµûS�6ô�!Z!��EeWí��3í6�¦ûhôUôF�Ñó°ô�!�ð�ï����n�`þ³ùY�4g �JT1�K5MLN� �w5nLCG ý�c5MLªò?ù�í�ÿ#�`þ�ô��ø�2�ö6øúô�!�ùY�úõZ }õ�vÍôUû � �úþ^��û4g �JT �K5MLN� �wL øúô�!�ùY�úõZ �ôV�� " ?��a�øúô�+ �ôUøÍò�øúô�!�ùY�úõZ �ôV�� "�6ô:þ³ùB �ô

�3L {}| � {2]�_°| � �3L {}| � |���� � Lts � 5M8RQSL � L {°|ù�í�ÿ/�`þ=��û,5M8�Q:L � � �Pg � T �KL {°| � � L {°| � 5M8�Q:L �

sM��-ôUø1ù�í�ÿ¸ó}ô�!�� ù�í#�3soó�ï � �6ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`ôÍÿ¸ù�í��ø`ù�ý�!µôEøúô�!�ùY�úõZ �ôM�% �3þ�õµýQþ/LF� DnLù�í�ÿM� Á ) � 8RQSLªò5ù�í�ÿ[�`þ=��û �`þ�ô]ý���f�!µô@�`ô � Á  �eÿ�ô���øúôÍô�ö��ø � Á ) � 8�Q:L ý��!�!µù���ûúôÍû�?7ªþ�ôJ�øúù�ý�!±ô " �öG7ªþ�ô��øúô���îrï: �øúõ±í��û �úþ�ô3ý��!Z!�ù���ûhô1ö���ø��`þ�ôÍø�ÿ��3í õ±ío�`þ�ô �G�!Z�}í�� õµù�!þ�õ±ôUø`ù�øúýQþc��?

� �#f ����� ��f�g ���� =3ô�!µùY�`õH �ôV�%A�úþ�ôjûhô�� " �ö 7ªþ�ô��øúô�� îrï�ò?ù�!Z!�� Á  �eý���P�I!µô��úô/ûúô��úûö��øJL {°| ù�øúôS�G�!Z�}í��-õ�ùY!G�úõ��-ôHõµû���P�ø���þ�õ±ý�?� W1U U ��� A1ôUø��jù�í �@A1ôÍøQð�ð��jûhþ��1ôÍÿD }õµù ù øúô�!µùY�`õH }õ�vrùY !µôa��ø�^�öS�úþ³ùY���úþ�ô�ý���f�!±ô��`ô� Á  �©ÿ�ô���øhôUôHö��ø,8RQSL½ý��!�!µù���ûhôUû �%-ù¸î �E!±õ��eÿ�ô���øhôUôV���í�ô9� �% � �í�ôS!±ôUí���úþ+�eõ±í�ýUøhôrù�ûhõµí� �H�øúôÍÿ��ý@�`õ��í�û �X? AW�jøhôUû��!Z�úûAõµí#� !:ó°ñ�ñ��1ù�í�ÿ#� ��g��Hñ�ðY�Sò�ùY!�!yî �E!±õ��eÿ�ô���øhôUôUû�ý��!�!µù���ûúô"õ±öyù�í�ÿ�í!H��õ�ö LC�EDnLªò¾ù���ù�õµí� c� ù�øúô�!µùY�`õH }õ�vrùY !µôM��ø�^�ö*? =3ô�!�ù��`õZ �ôn�% " �6ô:þ³ùB �ô4LF� DnLù�í�ÿAL {°| �D8�Q:L,? �

�ªâ��¤ç6äoê��hé���ëkç6ä��s)ùB }õµíI��ý���-ô4��U�`þ�õ±û:�G�õµíc�ròG�`þ�ô�øúôrù�ÿ�ôUø:� ùB�A�W�í�ÿ�ôUøn�3þc��õ±í9�`þ�õ±ûn�³ùY�ÄôÍøn�1ô ��øúô9�ûúôÍíc�`ôUÿu�E�W¥ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�í�û4�öªôUûhûúôUíc�úõ�ù�!Z!Z�F�`þ�ôjû`ùY� ôf�ø`ù�ý�!µôY?�7ªþ�ôjøhôrù�û��í�û«ö��ø��úþ�õµûù�øhôEþ�õµû����øúõ±ýrù�!Ñò�ù�ôÍû��`þ�ô��`õ±ý)ù�í�ÿf�úôUýQþ�í�õµýrùY! ?�sEõµû����øúõ±ýrù�!Z!Z��òY�`þ�ôEõ±í � ��ø���ý��í�û��`ø���ý��úõ��íf�Aù�û�`þ�ô/k�øúû��f�%# ô/��øúôÍûúôUíc�úôUÿpùY� ù ý��í°ö÷ôUøúôÍí�ýUô\�@AW73ï�j=�@? /)ûV�ö;�úôUí> ÄôSö��øúô�òW�úþ�ô¸ý��í+�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�í��Aù�ûAû�^�í�� ù�ÿ�ô)øhôUý���øúûhõZ �ôS c� ö��øúýÍô:�ö'�`þ�ôn�`øhôUôS�-ô��`þI°ÿU�6ô:��øhôUûhôUíc�`ôÍÿ õ±íó°ôÍý��`õZ�í�j/�¦ü?ü?ï)-��@? AW��`þ��-ô��úþ}ÿ�û1þ³ùB �ôn�`þ�ôÍõµøW+�3íjõµíc�`øhõµí�ûhõµý, ÄôUù��I�E�jù�í�ÿU�úþ�ôUøhôÍö��øhô G��`þ ÿ�ôUûhôUø� �ôn�`þ�ôUõµø �!µù�ýUô3õµíf�`þ�ô,!µõH�`ôÍø`ùY����øúôY?�ìeíUY�`þ�ôÍø6ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�í�ûN G��úþU�-ô��`þI°ÿ�û� ù��V��ø�� �ô,�`þ�ôÍõµø5ûúô���ù�ø`ùY�úôM��ûúô�?t7yôUýQþ�í�õµýrùY!�!Z��òWõZ�5ûúôÍô��-ôUÿU�úþ³ùY� �`þ�ôÍøúôM�6ôUøhôM �ôUø��P��^°ÿù�ø�����-ôUíc�`û5þ�ôUøhô,�3þc�-õµí�ÿ�ôUôÍÿ�ù�í õµí � ��ø�� �-ô��`þI°ÿ-õµû�í�ôÍýUôUûhû`ù�ø�� ö��øt�úþ�õµû�ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õZ�íù�û��1ô�ôXO2�!�ù�õ±í�ôUÿ ÄôSö��øúôY?9s,��1ô@ �ôUøÍò5ù���ù�õ±í�õH� ����øúí�ôÍÿu��I� �`þ³ù���õ±í � ��ø��¡ù�ø�����-ôUíc�úûý���!µÿC Äô/øhô��!µù�ýUôÍÿ c�# G���í�ÿ�ôÍÿ¤ûhôrù�øhýQþ<?U7ªþ�ôÍøúô-õµû«ù�í#�!±ÿ#�úþ�ôUûhõµû��`þ³ù�� X���`A�ø`ù�ý�!µôý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õ��íjõµí-ý���P�!±ô@O°õZ�E�4�`þ�ô��ø��/ýUù�íU ôM� ù�ÿ�ô3øhôUý���øúûúõH �ôoûhõ��f�!Z�4 ÄôÍýrù���ûúôn�öm�`þ�ôö¦ù�ý@� �`þ³ù�� �`þ�ôHý��í�û��`ø���ý��`õZ�í¸ÿ�ôrùY!µûN�3õH�`þ]øúôÍû����øúýUô� G���í�ÿ�ôUÿ/�jù�ýQþ�õµí�ôÍû�?t7ªþ�ôS��øhôUûhôUíc�

Page 22: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

�$� � gWq�fh�=iXa��������

ý��í�û��úø���ý@�`õ��í�û«ö¦ù�õ�!µôÍÿF�%a��ø�� }õµÿ�ô ù¸ý����íc�úôUø�ôXO�ù��P�I!µô�( �øUòvô�q^��õZ �ù�!µôÍíc�%!Z��ò`��ø�� }õµÿ�ôÍÿ�f�øúôHû����G�ø��3ö��ø �úþ³ùY� �`þ�ôUûúõ±û�?

�)öªý����øúûúô�òR�1ôf�N��!µÿ !µõ�e�ôf��'ûhôUôP�úþ�ô�L {}| �ôUøúû���û 5M8�Q:L q=��ôÍû��úõ��í ù�í�û��6ôUøhôUÿõµíP�`þ�ôS��í�øúô�!µùY�`õH }õ�vUôÍÿU�W�ø�!±ÿ<?RT¤ôHý��í � ôÍý��%��øúô:�`þ�ùY� �`þ�ôHý�!�ù�ûúûúôÍûªõµí�ö¦ù�ý@�3ù�øhôoÿ�õ ?ÄôUøhôUíc�rò �I�Eû���ýQþ¥ù ��ø�2�öi�3õ�!Z!Oøhô�q=��õµøhôS �ù�û��%!H��í�ô@� �`ôÍýQþ�í�õZq^��ôUû�?ìeíC�úþ�ô�øúô�!�ùY�úõZ }õ�vÍôUÿ�ûhô����úõµí��ò<�1ô �W��!µÿ#!±õ�e�ô �%¸ûúôÍô ù�íC�ø`ù�ý�!µô;øhô�!�ù��`õZ �ô4�%��3þ�õ±ýQþ

L {°| � 5M8�Q:L �I�4L3� A LtLJ?�T�ôV�`þ�õ±íe ùA��ø�2�öAûúõZ� õZ!�ù�øM�%/�`þ�ôP��ø�^�ö �ö 7ªþ�ô���øhô�� îXïA�-õ���þ=���W�ø�e¾òR I�I� �úø��}õµíI�A�% ö��øúýÍô�ù�!Z! A LtL �jù�ýQþ�õµí�ôÍû �%A Äô-ýrù��`ô����øúõ±ýrù�!� ù��U��I�J�%^V�jù�í=�jû��úøúõµíI��û3õµí��`þ�ô��øúù�ý�!±ô�?

� ���I�væ��yäoê ���� ��� ¢��XÜ��:ÎE� � \����X\�l �$�"� � gWq�fk�=iXa¾�yiXaW��¹v�v¢W_XfKdKa�_S�E�¥s1w£�=���bqZd=a�_Xdo��\�iXcH\�iXce�¥iXc

��\Qde\�^`dK��a��ªgWaW����g�\vce_bl�gWdK�m_baWcQ��® a����� ���� �,�������������� ���$�! #"���%$'&)(+*-,/.�01�2�3��41.�/ ���$�657�)���/ 3,8���9&��/.�0:4)�;��#�X�}�°ir�X\�c�<rÞ>=@?#<rÞbÜ��³s5\Q�BAv_XfK�°�Oà����XÜ��°Ò5Ð�C �

� � Ó%DªÜXÜ��FEW� � iXl�^HGirÏ�irf��HE���Ó�GI irÏX�°iXaW�JE��KDªir�}irfKf-G_��L*+�; 34M���;41 ���&���.N0 ���PO�� �;,'�h��Q��Wfk��a��X\QfKÃR \Qfkl�ir���Äà��XÜXÜ��

� � \Qf3S�S@�«¹y� � \Qfh�=iXa³�T�!��U,/:�/.V� � �XW ����4Y���[Z\� �U� �;� �]�7��:�^&���.N0 ����� �6* � ���h��w$qWÓ dKqW\�cK��cQ�Ð�_Xfha�\�l�l³¶1aW�m´X\QfkcK��d¦�X�¾à��>S�S��

� � �LS�S@�«¹y� � \Qfk�«iXajiXa}� �"�³�6irfKdK�«iXaW��cQ�3ºAaj��ce_b�H_XfK�°qW��cK�=c6iXaW�j��\�aWcK�mdÑ�/_X�ys1w iXaW�_XdKq�\Qf1^`_b�H�}lm\Qde\"ce\QdKcQ�_*1��$`(ba$_&���.N0c4$� ���Û#de=rÞbß@?#=�<�<��Jà��>S�S��

� � �`��à3�FQ��­ÎE� � g}cKcAiXaW�]¹v���6iS�X�Hºªa defhg�dKq�Ã÷dKir�}lm\)fK\��Wg}^Q�m�}��l���d¦��de_fQ�ÒJ�ª�g���\�/ 3. � �;�;�/�/c�h&��/.�0:4)� � �;�;��W�K�rÞW»[<b¼d ÜXÛ@?°àQÞ><��Ä¢�\Q�WfkgWirfk�jà�����àr�

� � ®©Ü>S@�9C � � l�gW��iXaW� Î3��®©�H�}ir�bl���irÏQÏQ_��iD1\�a�\Qfk��^ _XfhiX^Qlm\�c/iXaW�¤_XfkiX^Qlm\¸^Ql�iXcKce\�cQ�£®©a�_ ���� �,�P�/��#�/�f��� ���$�8jlk ���m��nonpni*-,/.�01�2�3��41.q�/sr)�/41:��� �;�;��Y�f���t&��/.�0:4)� �] �\�\� �]:� �`���}ir�X\�cAàXà�Ü@?°à�<XÛ��°s6\Q�uAv_XfK�°�³à��XÜ>S���®©tyt$t¡Ð�_b�H�}g�de\Qf!Q�_�^Q�m\Qde\Q�«wyfK\�cKcQ�

� � �N�2v/� � gWq�fh�=iXa iXaW� �Ä_XfK\�aZ´�l��m\QdQ� ºAa dKq�\¸^Qg�dedK��a��¥\����X\]_X�"fk\�l�irdK�m´��mÏ�irdK�m_baHd¥��q�\fK\�cK_bg�fk^`\1��_bg}aW��\��=��ar§eg�fk�)�H\QdKqW_��³�³®©a6$`MM4 ��Y�%� �] 3+� �;�[�/+��o&�� � �w��x\41��41.y�/$`4)�z�/. � � �/{�| �����4 �����3���/:�'�_ ��P�� �/.V.�����b�°�}ir�X\�c`<XÛ�=@?#<>S/=��Jà����2v��

� ¢¯¢��Xß��}Q��r¢�\�aWaW\QfviXaW�o¹v�r¢�_XfKdKa�_Í�3� � \Q�X_baW��~ &p� z��f���f~H��®©a9*�5�$'&�*}�>�r�Z´X_bl�gW�H\�rÞXÞª_X�)| �P���;41 *�!��� � �3�_��t&��/.�0:4)� �\ _*c�\� �]c� �`�Z�}ir�X\�c$Û�à��@?�Û�<>S��MQ��Wfk��a��X\Qf���à����Xß��

� ¢¯¢�����<��FQ���¢W\�aWa�\Qf��ª¹v��¢W_XfKdKa�_S�E�3iXaW��Q��­Ò"�!�3g�fKdeÏX� ��qW\¸��ce_b�H_XfK�°qW��cK��^`_baU§e\�^`dKg�fK\q�_bl��Wc�fK\�l�irdK�m´X\"de_;iXa _XfkiX^Qlm\X�5®©ah�� ����9p > � �����npnon�*-,/.�01�2�3��41.�r7�/41:� � �;�[�/Y����F&��/.�0:4)� �] %*K�\� �]:� �`���}ir�X\�c`=rÞ�?#=����Oà�����<��

Page 23: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

���$_;º1fkiX^Qlm\�c�dKq}ird5¢�_Xfk^`\)i � ����Ð�fkgWa}^kq � 0

� ¢¯¢��3¹���=��FQ���¢�\�aWa�\Qf���¹v��¢�_XfKdKa�_Í�3�-Q��l�3g�fkdeÏX��iXaW�=¹y��¹Ä� ��Ò1a=_XfhiX^Qlm\��}gW��l���\Qf��­c¯de_�_blm���mdQ�°®©a�_ ���� �,�P�/��#�/�g��� ���$��k ���9��nonpnu*+�; 34M���;41 ���� &��/.�0+�4��O>� �;,h57�$���� ,f&����� �\ �\:� �Q��}ir�X\�c"à�<rÞ�?°à�=�àr�³s5\Q� Av_XfK�°�Äà�����=��}®©tytyt5�

� ¢¯¹��H�2v/� � �°¢}g³�}�"�}¹ � �WiXa}�6Ao����q�_ba����$Ò6a/ir�}�}l���^QirdK�m_ba/_X�ÄdKq�\EdefkiXaWcKl�irdK��_baWiXl¾�H\QdKq�_��³�( � ���$�]. � �;�[�,� �7*-,2� � �].��}57�$�P�/ ,r�K<>S�d�à�Ü�=@?°à�ÜXÛ��và����2v��

� ¢�fk��ß>S@�=ÎE� C �b¢�fh�m\�����\QfK���W����_ªfK\�^Qg�fkck�m´X\�lm�3\�a�gW�H\Qfkir�°lm\�ce\QdKcJ_X�°��aW^`_b�H�}irfkir�°lm\��W\Q�XfK\Q\�c_X��gWaWce_blm´rir�}��l��md¦�X��® a'�� ���� M� � � Y$��,�>��:*c�\� ��X´X_bl�gW�H\Xvl=��b�}ir�X\�c�<�=XÛ@?#<�=XÜ��³à��Xß>S��

� D%Q�ÜXÜ���EW�HD1fk_bl�l��=iXaWa-iXaW� Ò"�)Q�\�l��=iXa³�AÐ�_b�H�}lm\`²��mdÑ�/�H\�iXcKg�fK\�c6�µ_Xf1�°g��}l���^úÃ÷�X\Q��^`fK����Ãde_bce��cede\��=c��!*1��$`(ba$_&��/.�0:4)� �� àXàb»[<b¼de=rÞ>�@?#=�=Xß��ÄÒ6�Wfk��lOà��XÜXÜ��

� D)�­�5Ü����FD)�­�Oirfk��_bc���ÝAg�\QfK� ^`_b�H�}l�\`²��mdÑ�X�A_Xf/�5q��¤��c-�md/�W���:^Qg}lmd:de_�ce\Q�}irfkirde\ aW���)·^`_ a����3�µfK_b� ���E����fkiXaW�W_b� _XfkiX^Qlm\ �°�g&��/.9Z]��+� �z�� �[�,�r�H�#de=XÜXß@?#=���<��và��XÜ����

� �6\�l�Ü2v/�«�1iXaWcH�6\�l�lm\Qf�� ºAa'fK\�l�irdK��´��mÏQ\��'��_blm��a�_b�=��iXl$iXaW�'\`²���_ba�\�a�dK��iXl?^`_b�H�}gWdKirdK�m_baWcQ�*1��$`(ba$_&���.N0c4$� ��Äà�=�»�v�¼d S�à@S�?1S/<Xß��Äa�_S´X\��"��\Qf"à��XÜ2v��

� �6\��«Ü����«¹y�}�5\��«iX^kqWiXaW�Wfki��$��qW\3cedefK_ba��H\`²���_ba�\�aZdK��iXl¾qW�m\Qfkirfh^kq���^`_bl�l�ir�}ce\�cQ�!aY�/41 3+������&��/.�0:4)� �\ �/:��*:,�� � �].y*c�\� �]:� �3�ú�:=���»[=b¼de<����@?#=�<�<��yà��XÜ����

� �1�`��à3��EW�5�6irfkdK�=iXaW��c/iXa}� ¹v�5�6\��=iX^kq}iXaW��fki���ºªa�\`Ã÷��iS� �µgWa}^`dK�m_baWc�iXaW� dKqW\ a�_ba�Ã��cK_b�H_XfK�}qW��cK� _X��s1wJæ^`_b�H�°lm\Qde\Bce\QdKcQ� 57�)���/ *� �;�[�,�� &��/.�0:4)� �] y*c�\� �]:� �`�Ü�àb»©àS¼d�à�ßXß@?°à�Û�=��yà�����àr�

� �6®�Q�ÜXß��9EW�?�1irfKdK�=iXa}��cQ�6s"��®©�=�H\Qfk�=iXa¾�5iXaW� R �!Q�\Q�$\�l�cK_ba³�iQ��}irfhce\jcK\QdKc���a s6wvæw!dtyu1w$��® Cjt ´X\QfkcKgWc3s1tvuAwy��® Cjt��6���]�� . � �;�[�/ �/:�s&���%�; �� � �yÛXß�»[<��/=b¼d�à�ßXÜ@?à�Ü�àr�cC iS���/EZgWa�\«à��XÜXß��

� � Q�ÛXß���EW�°�1irfKdK�=iXaW��c1iXaW� Î3�KQ�de\�irfkaWcQ�6ºAa-dKq�\"^`_b�=�}g�dKirdK�m_baWiXlO^`_b�H�}l�\`²��mdÑ��_X�viXlm�X_rÃfk��dKqW�=cQ��5M <�/M� �$L. �\ )( � ���� *K���9��ÄàXà@S�de<XÜXß@?#=rÞbÛ��và��XÛXß��

� � QY��<��FQ����5_b�H\Qf?iXaW�:ÒE�­¹y�1Q�\�l��«iXa³�³ºAfkiX^Qlm\�cv�µ_Xf$cKdefkgW^`dKg�fkiXlW�WfK_X��\QfKdK�m\�c\dÄdKq�\6��ce_b�H_XfeÃ�}q}��cK�B�Wfk_X�}lm\���iXaW� �}g��}l���^úÃ÷�X\Q�]^`fK���}de_X�Xfkir�}q��X�ha1�/41 3+��_���J&���.N0c4$� �\ ��:�*-,2� � �].�*c�\� �]:� �3�ú�Yv�v}»[<b¼de<XÜ>S�?#=rÞ�àr�yà�����<��

� ® �5Ü����=ÎE��®©�H�}ir�bl���irÏQÏQ_oiXa}�}D)���Oirfk��_bcQ�ÄÓ6\�^Q��cK�m_ba�´X\QfkcKgWc�ce\�irfk^hq;�WfK_X�}l�\��=cy��a�cKg���\QfeÃ��_blm��a�_b�=��iXlbdK���H\X��® a��� ����9K #"���%��npnon *-,/.N0Y�2���41. �/Vr7�/41:� � �;�[�/Y����� &���.��0:4)� �\ *c�\� �]c� �`�}�}ir�X\�c�<�<�<@?#<�<>S��¯à��XÜ����

� �3¹ ÓªÜ>S@�9�H�1�ª_����ª��¹ _ba�����iXaW�«Ó)��ÓAg³�¾Ò a�_Xde\1_ba:_ba�\`Ã÷��iS�«��gWa�dK�m_baWcyiXa}�«��_blm��a�_b�=��iXlmÃdK���=\3��ce_b�H_XfK�°qW��cK�=c�� 57�$�P�/ *� �;�[�,��_&��/.�0:4)� �] �*c�\� �]:� �`�Mv�S�de<XÛ�=@?#<>SrÛ��Jà��XÜ>S��

Page 24: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

� j � gWq�fh�=iXa��������

� C-_�^��XÛ��}Q�irfhiXquC _�^QiXcQ�¿¶1cK��a��'��_bgWaW��\�����g�\Qfk�¡^Ql�iXcKce\�c�de_�ce\Q�}irfhirde\¸^Ql�iXcKce\�c;��a�dKq�\\`²���_ba�\�aZdK��iXlAdK���H\]qW�m\Qfkirfh^kq�� �±fk_b�8^Ql�iXcKce\�c���a w$�E� 57�$���/ *� �;�[�,� ��&��/.�0:4)� �] *c��� �\:� ���l��kX�Äà�ßXÜ#de<�<�à?#<�=�àr�và����XÛ��

� CjgW^�ßXÛ��«Ò"�­ÒE�:C gW^hqWaW�m���yºAa;dKq�\3gWa}ce_blm´rir�}��l��mdÑ�H_X�ÄdKqW\ª�WfK_X�}lm\�� _X�OfK\��WgW^Q���}��l��mdÑ�=��a�dKq�\dKq�\Q_Xfk��_X�JiXlm�X_Xfh�mdKqW�=cQ����������7$��,�l� 7���/4���*-*M*1W1� àQÞbÜ#d�à��2v2?°à��>S��$à��XßXÛ��

� Î5iX^�Ü�<��;Ð1�UÎ5iX^k�X_��O�WÎ5\�l�irdK�m´��mÏQ\��E��g�\�cedK�m_ba}cÄ��a�´X_blm´���a����}fK_X�}ir�}��l���cedK��^¯iXlm�X_Xfk��dKqW�=cQ�MaY�/41 �+� �K$ �P�]�@�9!&��/.�0:4)� 7( �>�]�$��:<��#de<XÛ�à?#<XÛXÜ��và��XÜ�<��

� Q�\�l�S/���=Ò"�KQ�\�l��=iXa³�ywvæce\�lm\�^`dK�m´X\)ce\QdKcQ�WdKiXl�l���l�iXaW�bgWir�X\�cQ�°iXa}��dKq�\E��\�qWiS´���_Xf�_X�¯��_bl���a�_rÃ�=��iXl�dK���H\ªfK\��Wg}^Q�m�}��l���dK�m\�cy_ba-s6w5�p(#� �����*-,2� � �].��}57�)���/ 3,r�Äà�=#d ßXß@?�ÛXß��Jà��>S/���

� Q�\Q�6Ü�=�� R � Q�\Q��\�l�ce_ba³�9$ � �;4M�/, ��� ���$�'*+�; 34M���;41 �}���g�����ow$qWÓ dKq�\�cK��c��ÄÐ�_Xfka�\�l�l¯¶1aW� ôX\Qfkck�md¦�X�°®ÑdKqWiX^Qi��°s5\Q� Av_XfK�]à]vZÜXß�=���Ò1g��bgWced3à��XÜ�=�����Î6Ü�=ÍÃÑß>Srß��

� Q�¢�C SrÜ���EW� ®h�cQ�\��m�±\QfhiXcQ�-C �eE��}¢¯��cK^hq�\Qf��}iXa}�/ÒE�­ÎE�:C \Q�X\Qf��!Q�\Q�}irfkirdK��aW�=a�_baW��\Qde\Qfk�«��aW��cedK��^dK���=\3^`_b�H�}lm\`²��md¦��^Ql�iXckce\�cQ�_a))$�&)(��-<Xß�»©àS¼d�à]vZÛ@?°à�Û>S���EZiXa�g}irfK�jà��>SrÜ��

� Q�_bibÜ>S@�«Î5_X��\Qfkd5®ú�HQ�_birfk\X�`W ����41 P�3� � �U,�n�M41.5�] �lZ �4��* � ��� �/c�����z�> � �3�h�6wÄ\Qfhce��\�^`dK�m´X\�c��a6CjirdKq�\��=irdK��^QiXlĹ _X�b��^r�cQ��Wfh��a��X\Qfeà R \Qfkl�ir����à��XÜ>S��

� Q�de_�SrÛ��«¹y��Q�de_�^K���H\Q�X\Qf�� ��qW\-��_blm��a�_b�=��iXl Ã÷dK���H\�qW�m\Qfkirfk^hqZ�X�y57�$�P�/ *� �;�[�,���&��/.�0:4)� �] *c��� �\:� �Q�:=#d�à?#<�<��¯à��>SrÛ��

� � Gir��Ü�=��FQ�� �LGir�°�BÒ�Og�fk��a�� �«iX^kqW��aW\ qW�m\Qfkirfh^kq��X� 57�$�P�/ *� �;�[�,��6&��/.�0:4)� �] m*c�\� �]:� �`�<XÛ#de=�<>S�?#=�=�=��và��XÜ�=��

CjiXa�gWck^`fk�m�Wd�fK\�^`\���´X\�� ����������������������������Ð�[¤®�ªfkg}��cKl�iXiXaFvWà�=àQÞ>�XÜ�QME=Ò1�=cede\Qfk�WiX�dKq�\Es6\QdKq�\Qfkl�iXaW�Wc���! #"�$&%('*)*+�,&-/.0'21

3&4&5*6 � 5 �87 5 �9� 5 �¶6aW��´X\QfkcK�mdÑ�:_X��Q�_bg�dKq Ð�irfK_bl���aWiÓ6\Q�°irfKdK�H\�a�d5_X�vÐ�_b�H�}g�de\QfLQ�^Q�m\�aW^`\Ð�_bl�gW�"�}��i��-QWÐ <���<rÞbÜ:�; '!' ; "<)*+�= ; .>=!+?. ;!@ �

A/�9�CB 5 7ED�� 4 �CD&Fs1t�Ð Î5\�ce\�irfk^kq-® a}cedK�mdKg�de\v=®©aW��\Q��\�aW��\�a}^`\6[¸iS�wvfh��aW^`\Qde_ba³�WsLE=ÞbÜXß2vbÞ:<G "�HI' G ,#)J" ; = ; %J"K+� L.0'KM�.N' ; +/.O+ G $

A 5*5 �8P�D�� 5 ��Q9RJS 5K4® ¹Ä¹Oж6aW��´X\QfkcK�mdÑ�:_X�¯Ò6�«cede\Qfk�WiX�<2v:wyl�iXaZdKir�X\�CjgW���W\QfK�XfkiX^kq�dàQÞ�à�Ü=� R Ò1�=cede\Qfk�WiX�dKq�\Es6\QdKq�\Qfkl�iXaW�}c1 ;�; 'K)K=J+�- ; 'T+ ; .0�#U#%�.N'K1

Page 25: 1032546(26+87-26++)25!-,:9; +=)!?03+=>A@B,fenner/papers/bigcrunch.pdfY ÄôÍøúûUò 2 `þ ôoý í û `ø ý Z í]õµû û ýQþ `þ³ù Y M `þ ô `ôÍû S! µù

���$_;º1fkiX^Qlm\�c�dKq}ird5¢�_Xfk^`\)i � ����Ð�fkgWa}^kq � -