36
!

! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

!

Page 2: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

!

Page 3: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRASOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA

WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRASOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA

!Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen

Lund Observatory, Sweden

Cool Stars 13, Hamburg, July 2004

Page 4: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

WAVELENGTH SHIFTS !WAVELENGTH SHIFTS !WAVELENGTH SHIFTS !WAVELENGTH SHIFTS !

Usually interpreted as “Radial

velocity”

Page 5: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

"Definition" of radial velocity"Definition" of radial velocity"Definition" of radial velocity"Definition" of radial velocity

"The radial component is stellar movementtoward or away from us. This motion

mustbe measured from a star's spectrum."

C.De Pree & A.Axelrod: The Complete Idiot's

Guide to Astronomy, p.258 (1999)

Page 6: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

Astrometric radial velocities IAstrometric radial velocities I

Dravins, Lindegren & Madsen, A&A 348, 1040

Page 7: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

Astrometric radial velocities IIAstrometric radial velocities II

Dravins, Lindegren & Madsen, A&A 348, 1040

Page 8: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

Astrometric radial velocities IIIAstrometric radial velocities III

Dravins, Lindegren & Madsen, A&A 348, 1040

Page 9: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

Pleiades from Hipparcos Proper motions over 120,000 years

Page 10: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

STARPATHS (200,000 y)STARPATHS (200,000 y)

Madsen, Dravins & Lindegren, A&A 381, 446

Page 11: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

Hyades from Hipparcos D. Dravins, IAU Symp. 215 (2004)

Page 12: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

Hyades lineshifts Madsen, Dravins & Lindegren, A&A 381, 446

Page 13: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

Gravitational

redshifts

D. Dravins

IAU Symp. 210

Page 14: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

STELLAR GRANULATIONSTELLAR GRANULATION

Hans-Günter Ludwig (Lund)

Page 15: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

“Beta Hydri” [G2 IV] Synthetic Fe I line & mirror

profileDravins, Lindegren, Nordlund & VandenBerg, ApJ 403, 385

Page 16: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

Lineshift & stellar rotation

Madsen, Dravins & Lindegren, A&A 381, 446 & Dravins, IAU Symp. 215

Page 17: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

Atmospheric shockwaves (Hartmut Holweger,

Kiel)

Page 18: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

PROGRESS IN SCIENCEPROGRESS IN SCIENCEPROGRESS IN SCIENCEPROGRESS IN SCIENCE

is driven by ...

Confrontation between theory and observation

Falsification of theoretical hypotheses

New observational measures requiring explanation

Page 19: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

PROGRESS IN SCIENCEPROGRESS IN SCIENCEPROGRESS IN SCIENCEPROGRESS IN SCIENCE

is not driven by ...

Agreement between theory and observation

(when they agree, not much new can be learned)

Page 20: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

PROGRESSPROGRESS ININ STELLARSTELLAR PHYSICSPHYSICSPROGRESSPROGRESS ININ STELLARSTELLAR PHYSICSPHYSICS

Requires disagreement between

theory and observation !

Page 21: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

Non-LTE in convective lineshifts

Dravins & Nordlund,

A&A 228, 184

Dravins, IAU Symp. 210

Page 22: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

Fe II lineshifts at solar

disk center

Dravins, IAU Symp. 210

Solar data:

Allende Prieto & García López, A&AS

131, 341

Laboratory wavelengths:

S. Johansson (Lund)

Page 23: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

Fe II lineshifts at solar

disk center

2-D models by Aleksey Aleksey

GadunGadun, Kyiv, Ukraine

Dravins, IAU Symp. 210

Page 24: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

Ni I lineshifts at solar

disk center

Dravins, IAU Symp. 210

Solar data:

Allende Prieto & García López, A&AS

131, 341

Laboratory wavelengths:

U. Litzén, J.W.Brault, A.P.Thorne, Phys.Scr.

47, 628

Page 25: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

429 Ti I bisectors at solar

disk center

Solar data:

“Hamburg photosphere” H.

Neckel, Solar Phys. 184, 421

Kurucz et al.: Solar Flux Atlas from 296 to

1300 nm

Laboratory wavelengths:

P. Forsberg, Phys.Scr. 44, 446

U. Litzén (Lund)

Page 26: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

Same spectral line in

different stars

Dravins, IAU Symp. 210

Adapted from

Dravins & Nordlund, A&A 228, 203

Page 27: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

IMAGING STELLAR SURFACESIMAGING STELLAR SURFACESIMAGING STELLAR SURFACESIMAGING STELLAR SURFACES

ESO VLTI : AT1 and domes of the 8.2 m unit telescopes

Page 28: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

Same spectral line in

different stars

Adapted from

Dravins & Nordlund, A&A 228, 203

Page 29: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

IMAGING STELLAR SURFACESIMAGING STELLAR SURFACESIMAGING STELLAR SURFACESIMAGING STELLAR SURFACES

Page 30: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

IMAGING STELLAR SURFACESIMAGING STELLAR SURFACESIMAGING STELLAR SURFACESIMAGING STELLAR SURFACES

Optical VLA

Antoine Labeyrie (Laboratoire d'Interférométrie Stellaire et Exo-planétaire)

Page 31: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

WAVELENGTH SHIFTS !WAVELENGTH SHIFTS !WAVELENGTH SHIFTS !WAVELENGTH SHIFTS !

A new diagnostic tool for stellar physicsenabled by ...

Astrometric radial velocities throughout the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram

High-resolution spectrometers with accurate wavelength calibration

Accurate laboratory wavelengths for several atomic species

Page 32: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

The End

Page 33: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

...

Page 34: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

Astrometric radial

velocities from

perspective

acceleration

Dravins, Lindegren & Madsen, A&A

348, 1040

Page 35: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars

UNDERSTANDINGUNDERSTANDING STELLARSTELLAR

SURFACESSURFACESUNDERSTANDINGUNDERSTANDING STELLARSTELLAR

SURFACESSURFACES

theory and observations interact about...

Spectral-line strengths

Spectral-line widths Line-profile shapes

Line asymmetries and bisector patterns Time variability in irradiance and

spectrum

Stellar surface imaging Relative & absolute wavelength shifts

Page 36: ! WAVELENGTH SHIFTS IN SOLAR-TYPE SPECTRA  ! Dainis Dravins, Lennart Lindegren, Hans-Günter Ludwig, Søren Madsen Lund Observatory, Sweden Cool Stars