英国 IPA Investigatory Powers Act 2016 - 情報セ lab.iisec.ac.jp/~hayashi/170612 2016 は、条文だけでもA4 で300 ページ以上に及ぶ大部であるため、調査結果

IPAInvestigatory Powers Act2016

2017 6 12

Executive Summary ............................................................................................... 3

1 ................................................................................ 5

2IPA 2016 .................................................................................. 6

3IPA 2016 ................................................................................................ 8

4 ........................................................... 9

5 ........................................................................... 11

6 ..................................................... 14

7. oversight arrangements8 ......................................... 14

89 ...................................................................................... 15

9 ..................... 17

10. ............................................. 18

11. ........................................................ 23

12. ........................... 24

13. ............................................. 27

14IPA 2016 Brexit ........................................................................................ 30

....................................................................................................................... 33

1Additionalsafeguards and restriction on use and disclosures ...... 34

2 ........................................................... 36

[email protected]

[email protected]

mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]

3

Executive Summary

1. IPA 2016

IPA 2016 A4 300

2

IPA 2016

1

safeguards

double lock

(ICRsInternet Connections Records)

BPDbulk personal dataset 4

3 GCHQ

3 1

4

National security notice Technical capability notice

2IPA 2016

IPA

2016

GCHQ MI5 GCHQ

BPD MI6

GCHQ 50 5

20

3.

IPA 2016 11

EU Brexit EU

3

5

1

2012 2013

ISPInternet Service Provider

2

( 1

2013 6

( 2

2014 5

http://lab.iisec.ac.jp/~hayashi/

2013 6 NSA

National Security Agency1

SIGINT :SIGnals INTelligence)

2

NSA

GCHQGovernment Communications

HeadQuarters

2 IS

EU

EU

1 NSANational Security Agency

(SIGINTSignals Intelligencedata transmission

[2014]

[]p.4p.94 2 SIGINT COMINTCOMmunications

INTelligence18 U.S.C. 798

http://lab.iisec.ac.jp/~hayashi/

6

IPAInvestigatory Powers Act2016

EU

2

2

2

2IPA 2016

(1) 3

Security ServiceSS MI5

Secret Intelligence ServiceSIS MI6 1908

Security Services Act 1989 GCHQ

Government Communications HeadquartersIntelligence Services Act 1994

Interception of Communications Act1985

Regulation of Investigatory Powers ActRIPA2000

(2) IPA 2016

NSA 2014 4 EU

2014 7 DRIPAData Retention

3 [2015]() [2015]

pp.180~185

7

and Investigatory Powers Act2014 4

2016 12

2016 3

Investigatory Powers Bill

(3) IPA 2016

12015 3 5

22015 11 Draft Bill

pre-legislative scrutiny6

3 2016 3

Investigatory Powers Bill7

4) EU Brexit6 23 6 7

444 69

ping pong8 11 17

5) 2016 8

6) 11 29 royal assent

regulation

(Schedule) 9 DRIPA

IPA 2016 RIPA 2000

(HUMINT

HUMan INTelligence)9 RIPA 2000

4 DRIPA 2014

EU 2642015.6 5 Privacy and Trust

A Question of TrustQueens Counsel David Anderson A Democratic

License to OperateRoyal United Services Institute (RUSI) 6 3

2016 3 Investigatory Powers Bill ( HL BILL

40 of 2016-27 House of Lords Library Note, 21 June 2016

http://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/LLN-2016-0032/LLN-2016-0032.pdf

7 A response to pre-legislative scrutinyAn operational case for bulk powers

Operational case for the retention of internet connection recordsCodes of practice: retention and

use of bulk personal datasets, National Security Notices, Interception of Communications 8

9

1 p.9

http://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/LLN-2016-0032/LLN-2016-0032.pdf

8

3IPA 2016 10

272 1 9 10

1 2

2 11

3 12

4

5 13Equipment Interference

6 14 1 2

3

7 15

8 16Oversight Arrangements

9 17

110

10 the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland 2011

6500 84.1 8.3%

4.8 2.8%

Countries of the United Kingdom by population, Wikipedia 11 261 (6) 12 261 (5) entity data events data

EU communications data meta

data 13 5

2020

-

247 (2011.3) 14 2 3 5 6

IPA 2016

NSA 2014 1 PPDPresidential Policy

Directive28

without the use of discriminants (e.g. specific identifiers, selection terms, etc.) 15 7

health records

16 Intelligence Service

CommissionerInterception of Communications CommissionerChief Surveillance Commissioner

IPA 2016 6

Investigatory Powers Commissioner

240 4

Information Commissioner 244 17 9National Security NoticeTechnical Capability

Notice

9

2 7 9

2 3

4 5

6

7 National security noticesTechnical capability notices9

418

EU-

11.(3)

(1)

19 IPA 2016

(2)

1 2

(safeguards)

(3)

(ICRsInternet Connection Records) 20

capability

18 6 19 Operational Case for Bulk Powersp.8 20 3 62 (7)

62

p.13 3)

10

(4)

(Investigatory Power

commissioner) Judiciary Commissioner

16

double lock

(5)

1

2

3

(6)

double lock

national security noticetechnical capability notice

(7)

1

2

11

5

BPD

bulk personal dataset 4

(1) 4

GCHQ 3 21 Intelligence

BPD BPD

99

economic well-being

specified

operational purpose22

21 Intelligence Service8 263 Security Service()

Secret Intelligence Service()or GCHQ 22 Operational Case for Bulk Powers

12

3

1

6

(2)

1)

2 6 1

3 1

MI5MI6GCHQ 3

Scottish Ministers

1

2

31

1)~3)

(specified

operational purpose)

6 30 6 30

2)

5 6 3

pp.24~25

13

2 1

6 12

Scottish Ministers

1

2

31

1)~3)

6 30 6 30

3) ICR

3

6 2

ICR

4

1

2

31

10

1)~3)

1 1 6 30

14

4

retention notice

12

4) BPDbulk personal dataset

BPD BPD 2 23

BPD

6 30

6

IPA 2016

1

(1)

(2)

(3)

2

7. oversight arrangements8

4 IPA 2016

(1)

(high judicial office24)

23 BPD BPD 202 (1)(3) 24 high judiciary office 2005 3 3 25 2

high judiciary office

15

3

(2)

oversight

8 1

229

2 1 6 1

auditinspection

investigationreview

252 national security notice

230

89

(1) 248

combination of warrants and

authorisations 8

16

8 9

(2)

249

(3) National security notice (252 )

National security notice

National security notice IPA 2016

Civil Contingencies Act 2004 1

25

(4) Technical capability notice 235

National security notice IPA 2016

Technical capability notice IPA 2016

capability

2 5 6 3

National security notice

Technical capability notice

245

25 1 1 emergencies

human welfare

17

(5) National security notice Technical capability notice

notice

injunction

2 5

9

(1)

1)

home-grown terrorist

NSA 3

OTT

26

GCHQ

2)

[2007]27