Wong,"RazeofGlory"JournalofLateAntiquity9.1©2016JohnsHopkinsUniversityPress-1

Appendix: The Table of Hack Marks

Roman numerals in brackets indicate the order of individual figures in each scene, starting from the left.

No. Image Plate Number Description Also Found

a1

Dendera

78(ii)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Small, somewhat

rounded blows.

Dendera

64(i), 112(i)

a2

Dendera

97(ii)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Well-rounded ovoid

marks made in a

downward motion.

Edfu 345(i),

Dendera

90(i, ii)

a3

Dendera

642(ii)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Deep, well-rounded,

overlapping

incisions. Large in

diameter.

Dendera

146(vi), 655

(i, iii)

ab4

Edfu 344(i)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Deep, oblong cuts

with rounded edges. Edfu 346

Wong,"RazeofGlory"JournalofLateAntiquity9.1©2016JohnsHopkinsUniversityPress-2

No. Image Plate Number Description Also Found

ab5

Edfu: Chapel

of the Spread

Wings, North

Wall, Register

1

Large, deep hack

marks with

somewhat

rectangular shape.

N/A

ab6

Edfu 344(i)

Copyright

©IFAO

Irregular marks

made by chipping

off the relief surface.

The result is a

‘flaked off’

appearance.

Edfu 346

ab7

Edfu 347(ii)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Deep, ragged and

irregular lacerations. Edfu 492(iv)

b8

Edfu 563(v)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Deep, triangular

chippings. N/A

Wong,"RazeofGlory"JournalofLateAntiquity9.1©2016JohnsHopkinsUniversityPress-3

No. Image Plate Number Description Also Found

b9

Dendera

78(ii)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Fine, shallow

strokes made in a

downward motion.

Edfu 403(ii),

Dendera

78(i)

b10

Dendera 97(i)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Long, fine

lacerations made in

a downward motion.

N/A

b11

Dendera

286(ii)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Long, thick cut

marks. N/A

b12

Dendera

112(ii)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Deep, narrow

scratches of varying

lengths.

Edfu 347(i)

Wong,"RazeofGlory"JournalofLateAntiquity9.1©2016JohnsHopkinsUniversityPress-4

No. Image Plate Number Description Also Found

b13

Edfu 532

Copyright ©

IFAO

Teardrop-shaped

incisions.

Edfu 521,

527, 571

b14

Edfu 337(ii)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Fine, sharp slashes

made diagonally. N/A

b15

Edfu 347(ii)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Deep, thick and very

long slashes. Edfu 405(i)

b16

Edfu 403(i)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Sharp, sparse and

extremely long

lacerations.

N/A

˝˝

Wong,"RazeofGlory"JournalofLateAntiquity9.1©2016JohnsHopkinsUniversityPress-5

No. Image Plate Number Description Also Found

b17

Edfu 532

Copyright ©

IFAO

Deep, delicate marks

made diagonally.

Similar to b14.

Edfu 541

b18

Edfu 252(iv)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Diagonal, medium-

length scratches in

two downward

perpendicular

directions.

Edfu 252(i)

b19

Edfu 252(v)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Similar to b18, the

cut marks go in

horizontal and

vertical directions.

N/A

b20

Dendera

282(ii)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Thin and deep

vertical scratches.

Dendera

281(i),

282(ii)

Wong,"RazeofGlory"JournalofLateAntiquity9.1©2016JohnsHopkinsUniversityPress-6

No. Image Plate Number Description Also Found

b21

Dendera

597(ii)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Long and ragged

vertical cut marks.

Dendera

608(ii)

b22

Dendera

597(iii)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Ragged horizontal

slashes.

Dendera

607(ii)

b23

Edfu: Sun

Court,

Register 1,

North Wall

Rectangular,

straight-edged

lacerations.

N/A

bc24

Edfu 252(iii)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Long, rugged

gashes. N/A

Wong,"RazeofGlory"JournalofLateAntiquity9.1©2016JohnsHopkinsUniversityPress-7

No. Image Plate Number Description Also Found

bc25

Edfu 227(i)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Rough, irregular

lacerations. Edfu 233(i)

c26

Edfu 339(i)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Deep, pointy gashes. Edfu 492(iii)

c27

Edfu 576(iii)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Rough, uneven

surface created by

deep and irregular

blows.

Dendera

611(ii)

c28

Dendera

282(i)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Deep and thick

incisions.

Dendera

281(ii),

E500(iii)

Wong,"RazeofGlory"JournalofLateAntiquity9.1©2016JohnsHopkinsUniversityPress-8

No. Image Plate Number Description Also Found

c29

Edfu 327(i)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Erasure using a

‘roughening’ method

similar to that

described by Roth1.

The result is similar

to the defaced

Hathor heads of the

columns at Dendera.

Edfu 327(ii)

d30

Dendera

281(iv, v)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Irregular chipped

surface.

Dendera

65(ii)

d31

Dendera 148

Copyright ©

IFAO

Fine, highly-

concentrated marks

producing a gritty

surface. A common

pattern, especially at

Dendera.

Edfu

215(iii),

Edfu 354(ii)

d32

Edfu 518(iii)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Deep, fine incisions

creating an uneven

surface.

Edfu 519(i),

Edfu 546

1 Roth 2005: 278

Wong,"RazeofGlory"JournalofLateAntiquity9.1©2016JohnsHopkinsUniversityPress-9

No. Image Plate Number Description Also Found

bd33

Dendera

99(ii)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Long and very

shallow scratches.

Dendera

614(i)

bd34

Dendera

286(i)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Shallow, irregular

lacerations.

Edfu 604(i,

ii)

ad35

Edfu 492(i)

Copyright ©

IFAO

Irregular punctures,

very small in

diameter. Similar to

d32.

Dendera

182, Edfu

404(i)

ad36

Dendera 598

Copyright ©

IFAO

Wave-like

lacerations with

irregular punctures

distributed

throughout.

N/A